Latest / Consumerpedia / 99 - How Marketers Target & Sometimes Trick Kids
Transcript
- 0:02Wherever you go, whatever you do, you're being targeted with
- 0:05advertising. Marketers are also bombarding
- 0:08our kids with TV commercials, digital ads, product placements,
- 0:11brand logos and even kid influencers on social media.
- 0:15And this is perfect because it's a lip oil mixed with a lip
- 0:19plumper. It's almost like skin care on
- 0:21your lips. It feels so nice and it gives
- 0:24that amazing glossy finish that you're always.
- 0:26Reaching for That's because American children have enormous
- 0:30spending power. Most have cash or access to
- 0:32their parents credit cards and plenty of influence over what
- 0:35the family buys through their pester power.
- 0:38If your parents. Will let you have.
- 0:39Any real puppies? Then just collect little live
- 0:42pics like these. Check the link in the
- 0:44description box below. Marketing to minors is
- 0:47challenging. Advertising can easily exploit a
- 0:49child's limited ability to distinguish between
- 0:52entertainment and selling. AI and digital animation make it
- 0:55easier than ever for advertisers to cross that line, and the
- 0:58growth of online marketing to children raises serious concerns
- 1:02about privacy and data collection.
- 1:04I'm Herb Weisbaum, the consumer Man, a contributing editor at
- 1:07checkbook.org. Welcome to
- 1:09consumerpedia@checkbook.org. We're the nonprofit that helps
- 1:13consumers select services, avoid trouble, and save money.
- 1:17Because we don't accept any advertising or take money from
- 1:20any business, we recommend you can rely on checkbook.org to be
- 1:23completely independent and objective.
- 1:26Now here's the host of Consumer Pedia America's consumer expert,
- 1:30the consumer man, Herb Weissbaum.
- 1:33In this episode, what's being done to protect our kids from
- 1:36the pervasive and persuasive marketing they're exposed to
- 1:39every day? What are the rules regarding
- 1:42marketing to minors and is anyone enforcing them?
- 1:45And most importantly, how parents should talk to their
- 1:47kids about advertising. We have two great guests to
- 1:50discuss all of this. Bonnie Patton is executive
- 1:53director and Co founder of truthinadvertising.org,
- 1:56tina.org, a nonprofit dedicated to protecting you and your kids
- 2:00from false advertising and deceptive marketing.
- 2:03Hi, Bonnie, good to talk again. So glad to be here.
- 2:06Thanks for having me. And Donna Frazier, senior vice
- 2:08president at BBB National Programs, an independent
- 2:11nonprofit organization that overseas more than a dozen
- 2:14national industry self regulatory programs, including
- 2:17the Children's Advertising Review Unit or Cairo.
- 2:20Hi, Donna. Hi, thanks for having me.
- 2:23So let's start by looking at the landscape.
- 2:24Bonnie, tell us the various ways that companies market to minors
- 2:28and some of your concerns about what's going on.
- 2:30Wow. That's that's a big question to
- 2:33start. You know, children are on social
- 2:37media platforms and on the Internet all day every day and
- 2:41marketing dollars are following them.
- 2:43And not only are we seeing companies that are complying
- 2:48with the law and caring for the kids, but unfortunately we're
- 2:52also seeing a lot of bad actors in deceptive marketing that has
- 2:57followed these kids to the Internet and social media
- 3:00platforms. And they're trying to make sales
- 3:02in some cases by using deception.
- 3:04Not trying. They're absolutely doing it in a
- 3:07number of ways. Brands are providing kid
- 3:12influencers with their products that are inappropriate for
- 3:16children such as energy drinks, alcohol mixers, anti aging
- 3:21products, weight loss products, supplements, you name it.
- 3:25And then, you know, there are a lot of just ads that the kids
- 3:29don't understand are ads and they're not appropriately
- 3:33disclosed for these minors. So Donna, we're going to dive
- 3:36into the specifics of what KEDU actually does, the children's
- 3:39advertising, reviewing it and just, but based on the
- 3:42complaints you're getting, what are the biggest problems you're
- 3:45seeing with marketing to kids right now?
- 3:47The inability for brands to effectively advise to both
- 3:51parents and children exactly what they're seeing, right?
- 3:54I mean, the guidance is labeling an ad an ad.
- 3:57I would argue that possibly a child under 13 doesn't
- 4:00understand what even hashtag ad means.
- 4:03There is a problem with regards to the types of disclosures that
- 4:07need to be made and how they're being made.
- 4:10And what children actually understand, which I think is an
- 4:12ongoing debate, will be a forever debate about exactly
- 4:16what children understand and at what age they understand things.
- 4:19But what we are seeing, again, I agree with Bonnie, is the use of
- 4:22influencers. And a lot of brands will say to
- 4:25us, you know, we have no control over the influencers, while some
- 4:28influencers are hired by the brands.
- 4:30And then there are independent influencers who are are touting
- 4:34certain brands that they can get income and revenue and things
- 4:37like that. But some of these influencers
- 4:40are children, some of them are teenagers, but have a very young
- 4:45audience that follows them. Influencers are exactly what
- 4:49they say they are influencers and brands are fully aware of
- 4:53the power of influencers. And I think the digital space,
- 4:57not necessarily the mobile apps and all that sort of thing, but
- 5:00the digital space I think is where we're seeing great
- 5:02vulnerability for we're. Going to talk a lot more about
- 5:05these influencers later in the podcast, but right now I want to
- 5:08get back to that concept about advertising to kids.
- 5:10I mean, there have always been concerns about this.
- 5:13I remember TV commercials when I was a child during the Jurassic
- 5:15period where the toy did something it couldn't do and
- 5:17there was a little tiny disclaimer flash to the bottom
- 5:19of the screen for a few seconds and I couldn't read.
- 5:22Saying something like this toy airplane really doesn't fly by
- 5:24itself. However, with computer generated
- 5:26images and now AI, the tools to deceive or misleader
- 5:30significantly more powerful and accessible.
- 5:32Bonnie, what worries about this the most?
- 5:34Are you seeing this going on? Absolutely.
- 5:36And I think, you know, to your point, this isn't just simply
- 5:39affecting, you know, families or kids pocketbooks, the deceptive
- 5:44ads and manipulative ads we're seeing can influence kids
- 5:48behavior. It can encourage them to engage
- 5:51in risky or in healthy, you know, or even at times dangerous
- 5:55behavior as a result of, of what they're seeing.
- 5:59Don, am I correct? You've been talking to the
- 6:00advertising industry about the need for guidelines and need for
- 6:03some guardrails when they're using stuff like AI and computer
- 6:06generated images, correct? Cairo has been hosting since
- 6:09last year in AI working group with a lot of the leading brands
- 6:13talking about the challenges that they are having in the AI
- 6:16space. What we're discovering and
- 6:17talking to these larger brands is that they're actually
- 6:20reluctant to really embrace and engage in the AI space.
- 6:24Some are, some are moving ahead, a lot of them are not.
- 6:27They're being very careful. They're being very cautious,
- 6:29especially in the children's space.
- 6:31I think some companies are being very cautious.
- 6:33Some have a higher risk tolerance than others.
- 6:36But a lot of these brands are trying to be as thoughtful as
- 6:40possible when it comes to AI because it is moving so fast.
- 6:44When we started the conversations in our working
- 6:46group, we were just talking about just generative AI.
- 6:50Now we have a gentic AI. We have all these different
- 6:52types of AI. And this is just, you know,
- 6:54within 6 to 9 months that things are evolving so quickly.
- 6:58So we are working on creating some guidance, some guardrails.
- 7:03We did this for the metaverse. We are working on doing this for
- 7:05AI, both for industry as well as parents.
- 7:09Parents need as much guidance as industry does.
- 7:11You know, there's a lot of ways that an advertiser can get to a
- 7:14kid. You can do something simple like
- 7:15have product placement or have characters in the the storyline,
- 7:19make a commercial. But there's a lot of ways to do
- 7:21this kind of thing if you really want to get the message out.
- 7:23That's not really an advertisement.
- 7:25Exactly. I mean, there are advocating
- 7:28there are virtual worlds, right? Roblox and Minecraft, Fortnite,
- 7:32those are all virtual worlds. Adver games have become very
- 7:36popular. Using licensed characters and
- 7:40mascots to deliver a message is something that we're seeing.
- 7:44You have interactive storytelling and experiences
- 7:48that are story based apps using AR filters, choose your own type
- 7:52of adventure, sweepstakes, think contests.
- 7:55So there's so many different ways to reach a child with these
- 7:59marketing messages. Pawnitina.org has created a
- 8:02series of in depth reports called Monetizing Kids.
- 8:05It looks at the growth of social media influencers.
- 8:08We were talking about a minute ago, kids marketing in some
- 8:10cases to other kids. One case study you conducted
- 8:13focused on Piper Raquel, a 17 year old kid fluencer.
- 8:16That's a name kid fluencer who has more than 35,000,000
- 8:19followers on social media, 35,000,000.
- 8:22She mostly sells nutritional supplements and weight loss
- 8:25products and I want to give a quick listen.
- 8:27I always get complimented on my hair and I do have to say I'm so
- 8:31flattered. Literally without my hair I
- 8:33probably wouldn't get many compliments but there is always
- 8:36room for improvement. I've been having some hair
- 8:38problems so I kind of want to try something new when I want to
- 8:41bring you guys along with me. I saw these Sugar Bear Pro
- 8:44Vitamin gummies and I was like I need to get these right now so I
- 8:48got them because I have to keep this hair looking luscious.
- 8:52Bonnie, what is going on here? It's a true disaster.
- 8:56This is brands, I think, exploiting minors to get to
- 8:59other kids and get their products out there.
- 9:02But the problem is that a lot of these products are not meant for
- 9:06children. There are supplements where if
- 9:09you look at the bottle, it says keep out of the reach of kids.
- 9:14And here this dietary supplement has hired this kid influencer to
- 9:20basically promote their product to a bunch of other children.
- 9:24To me that's just wrong. It's more than wrong, it can
- 9:27absolutely be dangerous and harm kids.
- 9:31I totally agree. I think that, you know, I just
- 9:33said to my team earlier this morning, I was in a beauty
- 9:38makeup shops where I always thought that these places were
- 9:41intended for adults. I could not walk down an aisle
- 9:44without tripping over a child. The beauty industry in
- 9:46particular has become fraught with influencers, kid
- 9:51influencers, influencers who are really talking a lot about
- 9:55beauty products that are nowhere intended for the use of
- 9:59children. I don't want a child to be using
- 10:02retinol products. They're not safe for children.
- 10:04They're barely safe for adults. There are a lot of products out
- 10:07there that kids are using. There aren't proper disclosures.
- 10:10Whether or not the brand, this is what the brand intended.
- 10:13We're beyond intent at this point, right?
- 10:16I think brands have to really understand that your marketing
- 10:20team may never have intended this to be their, but now it is.
- 10:24And what are you going to do about it?
- 10:25That's a really good point. You know, when it comes to
- 10:27advertising targeted at children, there are federal
- 10:30rules and industry guidelines, and we're going to discuss those
- 10:32next. I'm her Weissman, the consumer
- 10:34man, and you're listening to Consumer Pedia powered by
- 10:37checkbook.org. At checkbook.org, we have the
- 10:41answers to your consumer questions 24/7.
- 10:44That's checkbook.org. We're a unique nonprofit that
- 10:48can help you with select local service providers, avoid
- 10:50trouble, and save money. Because we don't accept any
- 10:53advertising or take money from any business, we recommend, you
- 10:57can rely on Checkbook to be completely independent and
- 10:59objective. Our advice is always free.
- 11:02Ratings of local services are available with a subscription.
- 11:06If you live in one of these seven metro areas and haven't
- 11:08joined Checkbook yet, check us out Boston, Chicago,
- 11:12Philadelphia, Seattle, San Francisco, Minneapolis, Saint
- 11:15Paul, and Washington DC Get your free 30 day subscription by
- 11:20going to checkbook.org/consumer Pedia.
- 11:24This is not an unregulated marketplace.
- 11:26There are laws and rules in place, a voluntary system, the
- 11:29Children's Advertising Review Unit, which was created in 1974.
- 11:33Cairo tries to promote responsible advertising to
- 11:36children and work with companies that cross the line from
- 11:38creative to deceptive. Donna, could you explain how
- 11:41Cairo works? Cairo, as you said, was founded
- 11:43in 1974 by industry, by the stakeholders who realized that
- 11:48OK, if they don't do something, Congress will.
- 11:51So industry came together and developed guidelines that over
- 11:54the years since 1974, we have continued to update based on
- 11:59technology, based on trends. The last update to the
- 12:02guidelines was in 2022. So we included in app purchases,
- 12:06we included more about deceptive practices and obligations that
- 12:11brands have in app games, advertisement, things like that.
- 12:15We have that arm, which is our advertising arm, and we have our
- 12:19KRU guidelines and we monitor the space, the children's space,
- 12:23to determine whether or not companies are in compliance.
- 12:25And when they're not in compliance, we send an inquiry
- 12:28letter to them. We may ask for a product,
- 12:30physical product to be sent to us that we can look at it. 99%
- 12:34of companies when we send an inquiry letter either didn't
- 12:37know that they were not in compliance with the rules
- 12:39because they weren't aware of the rules, they weren't aware of
- 12:41Cairo, and they want to do the right thing.
- 12:44I think companies like people, when they find out what the
- 12:47right thing is to do, they'll do it.
- 12:49The very few instances where companies don't agree with our
- 12:53findings or don't want to imply K room has the ability and we
- 12:56have done this to forward our case decisions to a state AG and
- 13:01or the Federal Trade Commission. The last referral that we made
- 13:04to the Federal Trade Commission was in 2018, which was against
- 13:07Musically, which is now known as TikTok and the FTCA year later
- 13:12agreed with our findings found additional evidence that deemed
- 13:15them to be not in compliance with COPPA, the Children's
- 13:18Online Privacy Protection Act and find them.
- 13:20I believe it was $5 million in 2019.
- 13:22The fact that we have COPPA here, the Children's Online
- 13:25Privacy Protection Act that was enacted in 2000, and we again
- 13:29help companies who want to adhere to the law and the rules
- 13:33and manage their online experiences for children and
- 13:36engage with them in the right way.
- 13:38In addition, companies who believe that they're not
- 13:41engaging with children, but want to make sure that they're not
- 13:43engaging with children the right way.
- 13:45There's a right way and a wrong way to do it.
- 13:46So that is another arm. And then our third arm is our
- 13:50pre screen service, which we provide to companies.
- 13:52They can send us an ad at any stage of the advertisement,
- 13:56whether it's a script, whether it's a final beta roll or AB
- 13:59roll, we can review it and ensure that they are in
- 14:02compliance with our advertising and privacy guidelines.
- 14:05Donna, give me one or two absolute no no's, absolute red
- 14:09lines you can't cross. One is not making the proper
- 14:12disclosure that this is an actual ad.
- 14:15You must disclose that this is an advertisement, and there are
- 14:19different ways to do that when it's directed to a child, right?
- 14:21So if you have, especially if there's a character, a character
- 14:25can be in an ad, but you need to be specific and say this is a
- 14:29toy that this character is playing with.
- 14:32I think having children understand what an actual ad is,
- 14:36There's a whole education piece around this, right, with regards
- 14:38to parents and schools and how children are informed about what
- 14:41an ad is. They have to be able to
- 14:44understand the language. The language has to be child
- 14:47appropriate. And that is probably one of the
- 14:49biggest red flags is talking to children like they're not
- 14:52children. This is one of the times where
- 14:53you want to talk to a child like they're a child when it comes to
- 14:55advertising. Good point.
- 14:57So years ago, Congress recognized the significant
- 14:59potential for harm the Internet could pose, and in 1988,
- 15:03lawmakers passed the Children's Online Privacy Protection Act,
- 15:06COPPA, which required the Federal Trade Commission to
- 15:08issue and enforce regulations concerning children's online
- 15:11policy. The primary goal is to place
- 15:14parents in control over what the information which is collected
- 15:16and it was designed to protect kids under the age of 13 while
- 15:19accounting for the dynamic nature of the Internet.
- 15:21Bonnie, is this working? Wow, I think we can say yes and
- 15:25no. I mean recently we've seen the
- 15:27FTC go after Disney and 3rd party software apps for
- 15:33violating COPPA. So we know that companies as
- 15:37established as Disney are not following the rules of the road
- 15:41and should know better. At the same time, there are
- 15:44checks and balance like the help of KRU or the FTC taking these
- 15:49actions that show to some extent it is working.
- 15:54But I think the problem is the Internet is just such a massive
- 15:59domain and there's nowhere near the resources to police it in a
- 16:04way where we can say COPPA is being followed well for kids.
- 16:10By the way, as we're recording this episode, news broke today
- 16:13that Disney is going to pay, you mentioned Disney, $10 million to
- 16:16settle allegations by the FTC that it facilitated the, quote,
- 16:20unlawful collection of children's personal data.
- 16:23The FTC takes this data collection pretty seriously.
- 16:25Donna, could you give us the nuts and bolts of the primary
- 16:29stuff that's in place with COPPA?
- 16:31Basically, what are the rules that COPPA sets up?
- 16:33So COPPA applies to websites, mobile apps, online services
- 16:38that are directed to children under 13, requires mental
- 16:41consent before you can collect the data of a child and personal
- 16:45date of a child, which includes name, e-mail, location.
- 16:50Location alone is considered personally identifiable
- 16:53information. Device ID is considered
- 16:55personally identifiable information alone.
- 16:58So I think one of the changes that the rule, the Copper Rule
- 17:01made in 2013 really clarified actually what personal data is
- 17:06because for years everyone was operating under the premise that
- 17:09first name, last name, date of birth was all that personally
- 17:12identifiable information covered.
- 17:13Now it covers all these other things standalone.
- 17:16COPPA also requires that there's a clear disclosure about what
- 17:20data is collected, how it's used, and who it's shared with.
- 17:24And I would argue those are the three things that people really
- 17:27want to understand, right? What information you collected
- 17:29by my kid, who's using it, How are you using it, and who are
- 17:32you sharing it with? And I think it's that sharing
- 17:34piece that actually connects the docs.
- 17:36And it also prohibits conditioning participation in
- 17:41games or contests or activities without giving more information,
- 17:46right? So if all you need from me is my
- 17:49first name and for me to create a password to enjoy a game or
- 17:53log in, you should not need more personal data from me in order
- 17:57for me to engage in that actual game or activity.
- 18:00And then there's also heightened security practices in the rule
- 18:04that was just amended last year. There's additional security
- 18:08practices put in place because obviously we know that there are
- 18:12bad actors out there who are trying every which way to hack
- 18:16into companies like a Disney, like some of these other folks
- 18:19who they believe have a lot of personal identifiable
- 18:22information, which they do. There have to be increased
- 18:25security around the data of children.
- 18:27So that's kind of the the big picture of Kaba.
- 18:30Thank you. Well, rules and guidelines are a
- 18:32start, but parents need to take steps to protect their kids from
- 18:35intrusive advertising and improper data collection.
- 18:37And we're going to have some tips for you straight ahead.
- 18:39I'm her Weissbaugh consumer man, and this is Consumer Pedia
- 18:43powered by checkbook.org. Consumer Pedia Fast Facts
- 18:49According to a recent report by DKCA New York public relations
- 18:53firm, 42% of all household spending in this country is
- 18:56influenced by 8 to 14 year olds. These so-called Gen.
- 19:00Alpha children directly spend $101 billion per year.
- 19:04In addition to the influence they have over their parents
- 19:07wallets, the report found 95% of all apps designed for
- 19:11preschoolers contain at least one kind of advertising,
- 19:13according to a report from the Institute of Digital Media and
- 19:16Child Development. The average teenager sees one ad
- 19:19every 10 seconds while scrolling through their feeds, the report
- 19:22noted. That's equivalent to 420
- 19:24advertisements per hour. You know, it's clear that
- 19:29parents play a significant role in protecting their children
- 19:32from deceptive advertising and intrusive data collection.
- 19:35Bonnie, your group Truth and advertising.org, recommends
- 19:37discussing ads with your kids. What do you tell them?
- 19:40What's the conversation going to be about?
- 19:41That's right. I think you know, media literacy
- 19:44is just as important as you know these days learning to read and
- 19:49doing arithmetic. Children need to understand
- 19:53about marketing, and obviously it depends on the age of the
- 19:57child. And you know, as kids
- 19:59cognitively develop, they can learn more and more about this.
- 20:03But they need to know that when they hear marketing messages,
- 20:08when they can even understand that an ad is an ad, that they
- 20:12need to be skeptical. They need to not just take it
- 20:17that everything that's being saying is absolutely true, that
- 20:20they have to use some critical skills to evaluate what they're
- 20:24hearing and seeing. I assume it for the appropriate
- 20:27age group. You go to some specifics, such
- 20:29as tricks that advertisers use or explain these endorsements
- 20:32and testimonials they're going to see.
- 20:33Absolutely. I mean the goal is for kids once
- 20:36they're old enough to understand that the mode of bias and
- 20:40interest of marketers is to get them to part with their hard
- 20:44earned cash or to behave in in some way that they might not
- 20:49otherwise behave, that it's to motivate them or in the case of
- 20:54bad ads to manipulate them. And so it's important
- 20:58conversations to have that said, you know, yes, parents and
- 21:02guardians are primarily responsible, you know, for the
- 21:05upbringing and development of their kids.
- 21:07But in this area, with regard to advertising and deceptive
- 21:12advertising, I don't think that parents should be expected to go
- 21:16it alone. It's very complicated.
- 21:19The Internet's a big place. There's no way parents can
- 21:22understand everything. And that's why I think that
- 21:25there is a responsibility for brands and companies and
- 21:29marketers to be very cautious when they're dealing with
- 21:33children and we're just not seeing enough of that.
- 21:36I would assume Bonnie for teens. You should tell them why they
- 21:39never fill out online forms based on an advertisement they
- 21:41see. Among other things,
- 21:44unfortunately, I think anytime anyone is on the Internet, and
- 21:48this especially includes minors, they should not be sharing any
- 21:53personal data. They should not be going off of
- 21:57games they're playing to engage with others on other more risky
- 22:02platforms. You know, unfortunately, when
- 22:05you get old enough, you've got to read the terms and conditions
- 22:08and privacy policies. That's either a parent or, you
- 22:11know, maybe a team, but it can be a dangerous place and I think
- 22:16caution is recommended at all turns.
- 22:18Agree with you 100%. Donna, do you think parents
- 22:21should be watching what their kids are watching to know what
- 22:23marketing messages are saying? Absolutely.
- 22:26I think parental participation is key, depending of course, on
- 22:30the age of the child, right? If you're dealing with young
- 22:32children, right, explaining, as Bonnie said, very simply that an
- 22:35ad is, is a message of trying to get you to want something or do
- 22:39something. And I don't think it's too early
- 22:41to start teaching critical thinking by talking to your kids
- 22:44about what this ad is trying to get you to do, talking about
- 22:48exaggeration, comparing claims with reality, all those sorts of
- 22:51things. I think that there's a
- 22:53responsibility the entire ecosystem here with regards to
- 22:57how ads are being directed to kids.
- 22:59And I think look, we have to also, let's be real about this,
- 23:02this is a business and brand loyalty is starting at a younger
- 23:07and younger age and advertisers know that and parents need to
- 23:11understand that as well. So watching what their kids are
- 23:14watching, being familiar with the content that their kids are
- 23:17watching, the platforms that they're on, but also
- 23:19understanding that they actually have the ability to have some
- 23:22control setting rules regarding in app purchases, you know,
- 23:26using parental controls on the platforms.
- 23:29The more that they can make themselves aware and avail
- 23:33themselves of the tools that are out there specifically for our
- 23:35parents, I think can help. I agree with Bonnie.
- 23:39There's no silver bullet. There's no panacea in here.
- 23:41The entire ecosystem needs to do better here and brands actually
- 23:46will do better. Their bottom line will actually,
- 23:49I think my opinion only, that their bottom line will likely
- 23:53increase when they show parents who may also be purchasing their
- 23:58brands that they actually want to do the right thing by their
- 24:00kids. Brand loyalty is a real thing,
- 24:03and when you have so much competition in the marketplace,
- 24:06I think it only behooves brands to really pay attention to how
- 24:09they're evolving that brand loyalty with young kids and
- 24:13being responsible to them. My take is so many companies
- 24:16today actually cross the line to do whatever they want to do, say
- 24:19they're sorry they didn't realize it, which is one thing
- 24:22if you maybe you'd have a little deceptive advertising.
- 24:24It's quite another if you're collecting sensitive data from a
- 24:26child, then it gets breached and it's out there and does some
- 24:29real harm. So I think you're right that the
- 24:30industry really does need to clean up its act in this country
- 24:33today. Absolutely.
- 24:34Final question, what does a parent do if they see an ad?
- 24:36They believe it's deceptive or harmful?
- 24:38Can they complain personally to Keru?
- 24:40They file complaint with tina.org.
- 24:42Go to the FTC. What do you folks recommend?
- 24:44All of the above. Right.
- 24:46Exactly. They go to Tina, they go to
- 24:48Keru, they go to the FTC, they go to the company.
- 24:50Good point. You know, they actually complain
- 24:52to the company as well. They have to make their voice
- 24:55known. And sometimes, you know, also
- 24:57parents talking with other parents say, hey, did you see
- 24:59this? When they receive multiple
- 25:01complaints about the same ad, about the same practice, that
- 25:04may move a company and actually do something.
- 25:06Yeah, I think we should also add that parents can go to their
- 25:10state Attorney general or consumer protection bureaus in
- 25:13the state and that's also a very good Ave. for them.
- 25:16Well, it truly is a minefield out there and we just scratched
- 25:19the surface. I put more links to information
- 25:22in the show notes and I want to thank our great guests for
- 25:24making us so much smarter. Bonnie Patton, executive
- 25:26director of truth and advertising.
- 25:28You can find them online at Tina T ina.org.
- 25:31Thank you, Bonnie. It's been my pleasure.
- 25:33Thank you. And Donna Frazier, senior vice
- 25:35president at bbb.nationalprogramsyoucanfindthechildrenadvertisingreviewunit@bbbprograms.org/program/children
- 25:44slash Cairo Don't worry, I put the link in the show notes.
- 25:47Thanks for being with us. Thank you so much.
- 25:50Before we go a few other consumer pedia episodes you
- 25:52might want to check out #53 smart toys, the privacy and
- 25:57security risks 85 too much. How we're encouraged to buy,
- 26:01buy, buy and #26 sale prices are rarely deals.
- 26:06And with that, we're out of time.
- 26:08I hope you'll rate this episode. It's really helpful.
- 26:10And follow us on Apple podcast, Spotify, or wherever you listen
- 26:14to your podcasts. Remember, we release new
- 26:17episodes every other Thursday. Another way you can support for
- 26:20this show is to follow us at Consumer Pedia on Facebook and
- 26:23Instagram, at consumerpedia.org on Blue Sky, and at My Consumer
- 26:28Pedia on X. You can find me at
- 26:31consumerman.com. I'm her Weissbaum, always
- 26:34looking out for you. Until next time, be smart and
- 26:37shop wisely. Consumerpedia is a public
- 26:40service of checkbook.org. We're a unique nonprofit that
- 26:43helps you save money and make smarter choices.
- 26:46You can count on Checkbook to help you find the best services
- 26:49and avoid the worst with local ratings that are accurate and
- 26:52unbiased. If you live in or around these
- 26:55seven cities and haven't joined Checkbook yet, check us out
- 26:58Boston, Chicago, Philadelphia, Minneapolis, Saint Paul,
- 27:02Seattle, San Francisco, and Washington DC.
- 27:05To get your free 30 day subscription, go to
- 27:07checkbook.org slash Consumer Pedia Consumer Pedia.
- 27:11Empowering consumers to save money and make smarter choices.