Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Making Civility Your Superhero Power
Transcript
- 0:03Welcome to Making Civility Your Superpower. I'm
- 0:07Lori Crip Martin, the past vice chair of the
- 0:09Beverly Hill Bar's litigation section and a certified
- 0:12family law specialist. I'm delighted to introduce
- 0:16our speakers, Joanne Rezzo and Judge Kenneth
- 0:19Maddell. Joanne Rezzo brings nearly 30 years
- 0:23of litigation experience and a dynamic, high
- 0:26energy personality to Signature Resolution's
- 0:29panel of neutrals. Known for her balanced approach,
- 0:32Joanne represented both defendants and plaintiffs
- 0:35at trial, giving her the advantage of being able
- 0:38to truly understand both sides of every case.
- 0:41Because her litigation career was split evenly
- 0:44between representing defendants and plaintiffs,
- 0:48she understands each side's unique perspective
- 0:51and knows how to unite parties to achieve a resolution.
- 0:54She brings the same level of detailed preparation
- 0:57to each of her mediations as she did to each
- 1:00of her cases that she took to trial, often preparing
- 1:04her own detailed chronologies, weaving together
- 1:07facts and evidence from each side. The Honorable
- 1:10Kenneth J. Modell brings 14 years of judicial
- 1:13experience and 23 years of civil litigation experience
- 1:17as a trial attorney to Signature Resolution's
- 1:20neutral panel. With this extensive involvement
- 1:23in civil law, and a virtue of empathic listening,
- 1:27enjoys an ability to effectively communicate
- 1:29with parties and attorneys to achieve meaningful
- 1:32resolutions to challenging disputes. His mediation
- 1:36philosophy is centered on a comprehensive understanding
- 1:39of the unique circumstances of each case and
- 1:42the importance of respecting the positions of
- 1:44the parties and attorneys with equal care and
- 1:47consideration. And now let's get started. Thank
- 1:51you very much, Lori, for the introduction. Judge
- 1:55Medel, do you want to start the? No, I just want
- 1:57to say it's a great honor to be speaking to the
- 2:00Beverly Hills Bar Association because every lawyer
- 2:03that ever came to me in San Diego who was from
- 2:05Beverly Hills had to say, I am from Jones and
- 2:08Smith from Beverly Hills. I always enjoyed and
- 2:11wondered why that happened. I always say, well,
- 2:13I'm Judge Medel from San Diego. It's good to
- 2:16meet you all today. I think we're going to just
- 2:18start with those introductions and that comment.
- 2:22We're going to start right into our program here.
- 2:26It's mostly on PowerPoint, so I hope you enjoy
- 2:29it. Here we go. This program is called Making
- 2:32Civility Your Superpower. Superhero power. Superhero
- 2:36power. Okay. So we're going to start off with
- 2:39some definitions so that we can put our presentation
- 2:41in context. for you. So the first one is? So,
- 2:45civility. It's formal politeness and courtesy
- 2:48or in behavior or speech. Generally, if you think
- 2:51of it this way, I hope we can treat each other
- 2:55with civility and respect. Now, some people think
- 2:57that you have to be an absolute bulldog at all
- 3:00times when you're litigating a case, but the
- 3:03reality is you can be an effective litigator
- 3:06and I would say even a more effective litigator
- 3:09and still be civil to the opposing parties and
- 3:11counsel. Civility ties in with professionalism
- 3:15and is an integral part of professionalism. Professionalism
- 3:18is the competence or skill expected of a professional.
- 3:23And a nice vignette of it is that competencies
- 3:27and learned behaviors that help you perform your
- 3:30job to the best of your ability. Professionalism
- 3:34encompasses how you conduct yourself in the workplace,
- 3:38your communication style, your integrity, your
- 3:42work ethic, or how you handle conflict. So you
- 3:46can see those elements of civility are deeply
- 3:49embedded into the very concept of us being professionals.
- 3:55So collegiality is defined as companionship or
- 3:58cooperation between colleagues who share responsibility.
- 4:02I'm reminded in this definition of an attorney
- 4:05that I was opposite on a case years ago now,
- 4:09but we took the case all the way through trial.
- 4:10And one of the things I'll remember very clearly
- 4:12from my relationship with her, she started every
- 4:15single email with good morning. I hope you had
- 4:19a nice weekend, that sort of thing. That set
- 4:22the tone for our relationship as opposing counsel
- 4:25throughout the case. And you can actually build
- 4:27good, constructive friendships with opposing
- 4:29counsel. Guys, with those three, and ladies,
- 4:33I always say guys includes men and women, so
- 4:37forgive me for that. But with those three definitions
- 4:40of mine, I want to ask you a critical question
- 4:43that's kind of the theme of our presentation
- 4:45is, how do you want to be remembered when your
- 4:48career as a professional is over? And so let's
- 4:52give a few vignettes. First of all, I had a case.
- 4:56I did primarily medical malpractice when I was
- 4:59a civil defense lawyer. But some things were
- 5:02sort of related to medical malpractice, and those
- 5:05were slip and falls in the hospital. I had a
- 5:07case where a young woman was hospitalized or
- 5:12admitted to the hospital for diabetic problems.
- 5:15And on the first night she was in a room, she
- 5:17went into the bathroom and saw that there was
- 5:20water on the floor. So she told the nurse, there's
- 5:22water on the floor of my bathroom. The nurse
- 5:25called up the maintenance man and said, can you
- 5:29come and fix water in the bathroom in room 336?
- 5:32The maintenance man came down, he did a repair
- 5:37and The next day, the lady went into her bathroom
- 5:43and there was water still on the floor and she
- 5:45slipped and fell and had a very serious back
- 5:48injury. Okay, so here's your first quiz. Once
- 5:53we got going with the case, the lady sued the
- 5:55hospital for negligence. Once we got going with
- 5:58the case, the plaintiff's lawyer, who was a young
- 6:01up and coming guy in the plaintiff's world, wanted
- 6:04to take the deposition of the maintenance man.
- 6:08Couple facts. The only thing that the maintenance
- 6:13man had in terms of a record for this thing that
- 6:17happened years ago was a log that said, water
- 6:21on floor in room 3102, tightened sink valve.
- 6:27That's all he had. And he had no recollection
- 6:33whatsoever of anything that had to do with this
- 6:35event. whatsoever. So that's all we had. So my
- 6:38first question to you is how long should this
- 6:42deposition take if he had no remembrance of this
- 6:45thing whatsoever and the only thing he had was
- 6:49tight and sink valve? One hour. I think one hour
- 6:52is reasonable. Well the answer is that it took
- 6:57eight hours. It took the entire day. Why did
- 7:00it take the entire day? It took the entire day
- 7:04because The plaintiff's lawyer kept asking the
- 7:07same questions over and over and over. No matter
- 7:11how many times the maintenance man said, you
- 7:13know, I really don't remember, he just persisted.
- 7:16He put words in the witness's mouth by misquoting
- 7:19the witness's prior testimony and asked so many
- 7:23questions that required utter speculation that
- 7:26it just consumed the whole day. Adam, here's
- 7:30the worst part. at a break in the deposition
- 7:33the plaintiff's lawyer stood up put his hand
- 7:35on my shoulder and said in a very patronizing
- 7:37way how am i doing ken as if to acknowledge that
- 7:42all of his improprieties were intentional and
- 7:45not just a lack of experience or or inadvertent
- 7:48so uh that that started uh oh and by the way
- 7:54when we got to the end of the depo he wanted
- 7:56another session which i said absolutely no we're
- 7:58not going we're not going to do that There's
- 8:01part two to this story, and that was the plaintiff's
- 8:03deposition. The plaintiff's deposition took place
- 8:07in a place called Escondido, north of San Diego,
- 8:12in a building that had buildings all around a
- 8:16square, but in the square, it was open to the
- 8:18elements. It was open outside. And it just happened
- 8:21to be the coldest, rainiest day of the year when
- 8:23I showed up with my briefcase to take the deposition.
- 8:26And I walked up to the door, which is a traditional
- 8:29door with a glass window in it. And I could see
- 8:33the plaintiff's lawyer and his client inside,
- 8:35and I knocked on the thing. And he put up his
- 8:38finger and said, wait. I got there 40 minutes
- 8:42early, because it's quite a drive from my house,
- 8:44and stood in the rain and the cold for about
- 8:4850 minutes, 10 minutes past the appointed starting
- 8:51time. waiting just to get in while he prepped
- 8:55his client. And the court reporter had to do
- 8:56the same thing when she arrived. When the deposition
- 9:00took place, when I came around to questions that
- 9:03were meaningful and substantive and maybe difficult
- 9:06for the plaintiff, he would obstruct the testimony.
- 9:13He would object and then say, Ken, did you mean
- 9:16to ask this? And he would re -characterize what
- 9:18I said to my question to something entirely different.
- 9:23He would change it into the answer or the question
- 9:27that he wanted and oftentimes he would include
- 9:29the answer that he wanted in the question that
- 9:31he made. He would whisper in her ear. She'd say
- 9:36before she answers that and he'd whisper in her
- 9:39ear and and then she would have her answer after
- 9:42that. So it just appeared to be he was telling
- 9:45her exactly what to say. At a certain point in
- 9:48the deposition Because I was kind of well into
- 9:52my career. I can think he knew who I was at least
- 9:55he said can I think you're getting mad Are you
- 9:57getting mad and I said I am I'm getting very
- 10:00I'm getting very annoyed at this and he goes
- 10:02Well, do you want to step outside now? He didn't
- 10:05say that like us men usually say that like let's
- 10:08go fight He said it like I want to know why you're
- 10:10so mad and here's what I told him I Told him
- 10:15do you watch professional basketball? And he
- 10:18goes, well, sometimes. And I go, well, I don't
- 10:20watch it anymore. And I don't watch it because
- 10:24every single time a guy is fouled, he has to
- 10:26argue with the ref. Every single time someone
- 10:29makes a mistake on the other team, they have
- 10:31to mock the other team or make fun of them. And
- 10:34they oftentimes get up in the, when they just
- 10:37do something routine, they get up in the face
- 10:38of the other player. They call themselves professional
- 10:43basketball players, but there's nothing professional
- 10:45about what they're doing. And you, Mr. X, you
- 10:50have behaved extremely unprofessionally today
- 10:53and at my client's deposition in contravention
- 10:58of our obligation to act professionally as one
- 11:01of the highest professions in the land. And that's
- 11:06story number one. That's a great story. And it's
- 11:10a lead right into the discussion I had with a
- 11:12judge that I worked for after my first year of
- 11:14law school. And I did go to law school in Los
- 11:16Angeles at USC. So I'm sorry if you're a UCLA
- 11:18grad out there. But I went to work after my first
- 11:21year of law school for a judge. I did an externship
- 11:24with Judge Rhodes in San Diego. And he taught
- 11:26a lot of wonderful things to me over the course
- 11:27of the summer. But one thing really stuck with
- 11:29me. And he said, your reputation is everything
- 11:33in this business. So your reputation is your
- 11:36stock and trade. And if you ever do anything
- 11:38to sully your reputation. You're never going
- 11:41to lose it down, especially in a town like San
- 11:44Diego, where everybody knows everybody. So you'll
- 11:46never remove the tarnish as, as judge Miss Dell
- 11:49story illustrates it. You know, he's going to
- 11:52always remember this attorney that was such a
- 11:54jerk to him. That was 25 years ago. Absolutely.
- 11:59And the other point that I make is you have to
- 12:02really consider how you treat the staff too.
- 12:04It's not just how you treat other lawyers, but
- 12:06how you treat the secretary's paralegals and
- 12:09other professionals in the opposing party's law
- 12:12firm or the judge's staff. Because as we'll talk
- 12:16about in a little while, they see it all and
- 12:18they hear it all. So aside from being the right
- 12:22thing to do, civility is actually really good
- 12:24for business. And one of the things that I found
- 12:29as a litigator, and again, Judge Mendel pointed
- 12:30out or Lori pointed out earlier, I actually represented
- 12:33plaintiffs for half of my career and defendants
- 12:35for half of my career. Sometimes for about 20
- 12:38years, I represented both plaintiffs and defendants
- 12:41throughout the course of those 20 years. But
- 12:45the one thing that I found out was I got referrals
- 12:48because I was civil, because I was professional,
- 12:51I actually got referrals from an unlikely source.
- 12:5350 % of my referrals came from lawyers I had
- 12:57litigated cases against. So a lawyer's mother,
- 13:01father, brother, sister -in -law got fired, they
- 13:03referred him over to me. 80 % of my good cases,
- 13:07the cases that we actually made real good money
- 13:09on, came from opposing counsel. When I transitioned
- 13:14to becoming a full -time mediator a few years
- 13:17ago, there was an attorney that I had had four
- 13:19cases against. He kept saying, I keep proposing
- 13:23you trying to get you hired on a case, but we're
- 13:25going to do it. We're going to work together.
- 13:26We finally had a case together about six months
- 13:28ago. I do pre -mediation phone calls in all of
- 13:31my cases. I had my phone call with him and he
- 13:34said, well, Joanne, does the name of this client
- 13:37sound familiar? I said, Sorry, it doesn't should
- 13:41it and he said this is the defendant where you
- 13:45represented the plaintiff in a lawsuit against
- 13:47this company about 10 years ago. And I defended
- 13:50the company in that case. And I was shocked.
- 13:52I was surprised. I said, wow, it must be a different
- 13:55in -house counsel. I'm surprised they were willing
- 13:56to hire me. And he said, no, it's the same in
- 13:58-house counsel. But because you comported yourself
- 14:01in a professional manner, they were fine using
- 14:05you as a mediator. I was actually hired recently
- 14:07to speak or requested, not hired, but asked to
- 14:11come and speak at an employment law summit again.
- 14:13different attorney, but it was an attorney here
- 14:15in San Diego that I'd have four cases against
- 14:17including a case that went all the way through
- 14:20trial. And literally just minutes ago, I got
- 14:23a retention notice for another mediation. Again,
- 14:27different attorney, an attorney I had litigated
- 14:29several cases against. And the defendant that
- 14:32he represents in that case is a defendant that
- 14:35I actually sued in a prior lawsuit. So again,
- 14:40All right, civility is good for business, but
- 14:42let's talk a little bit about the consequences
- 14:44of incivility. So if you comport yourself in
- 14:48a way that's uncivil, There's been a recent study
- 14:51that reported that 92 % of the people surveyed,
- 14:56attorneys surveyed, that it doesn't actually
- 14:58enhance the client result, that attorneys who
- 15:01engage in civility actually get a better result.
- 15:04It makes it more difficult to resolve matters
- 15:07and it's more expensive for clients. Think about
- 15:09all the time you spend dealing with issues that
- 15:12you wouldn't have had to deal with if you guys
- 15:14are getting on. There we go. So a little more
- 15:24on the consequences of incivility. The job that
- 15:28we have as lawyers is hard enough. And you can
- 15:31have a career. And one thing I always say, I
- 15:34do a speech every year for the University of
- 15:37San Diego pre -law students as they get ready
- 15:40to go out on their job to go off to law school.
- 15:44And one of the things I tell them is this job
- 15:46is hard enough. Being a lawyer, it's taxing,
- 15:49it's very demanding, but you can either do it
- 15:52the hard way or do it the easier way. The easier
- 15:55way is to be civil and have good relationships
- 15:58with people. But if you don't and you do it the
- 16:00hard way, studies have shown that you're twice
- 16:02as likely to suffer from mental illness and substance
- 16:05abuse than people in other professions, and 95
- 16:09percent of respondents in a recent study actually
- 16:11reported that incivility made the practice of
- 16:13law less rewarding and more stressful. Some of
- 16:17the materials you're going to get afterward include
- 16:19an ABA article about civility that talks about
- 16:22more of these issues. Okay, guys, I do not like
- 16:26to give bad examples of attorney conduct and
- 16:30not give good examples, complimentary good examples.
- 16:36You can see the very mean -spirited judicial
- 16:40officer or judge in this picture. You can also
- 16:44see the victim of the judge with his hand on
- 16:48his forehead in the other picture. Back in the
- 16:50day, we used to have all of our motions done
- 16:53in one courtroom in our old courthouse, and it
- 16:56was run by one judge. I walked into that courtroom
- 17:00one day to a very packed courtroom, tons of lawyers
- 17:04in there. And as I walked in, I heard this young
- 17:08lawyer pleading to the judge, to the court, for
- 17:14a continuance. The lawyer explained, I made a
- 17:18big, big, big mistake on the case, and it's going
- 17:22to prevent us going forward with the trial. I
- 17:25simply cannot go for the trial without repairing
- 17:28this mistake. And I asked the court for a continuance
- 17:31of the trial. The judge was on a rampage that
- 17:35day. And he took the opportunity, perhaps trying
- 17:39to educate or scare the other lawyers in the
- 17:43gallery, to torture this guy for about 10 or
- 17:4715 minutes. And how could you possibly make a
- 17:49mistake like this? And why should this court
- 17:52stop the world just because you made a mistake?
- 17:55And it went on. And the poor lawyer, when he
- 17:57had a chance, would break in and say, Your Honor,
- 17:59I know, I acknowledge I made the mistake, but
- 18:02I just can't move ahead with the trial at this
- 18:05point without addressing it. And you can see
- 18:08by this picture, that's not really him. But I
- 18:11chose a picture that captured his mood. He was
- 18:14almost in tears. And then you could cut the tension
- 18:18in the courtroom with a knife. And lo and behold,
- 18:24a lawyer stood up from the other table. This
- 18:29is sort of what Doug Reynolds looked like. He'd
- 18:32been in our community, legal community in San
- 18:34Diego for years. He was erudite. He was an icon
- 18:39of our legal community. He was intellectual,
- 18:43calm, and understated. This is a man who never
- 18:46used a note. He didn't bring notes to trial.
- 18:48He had it all on his brain. And here's what he
- 18:51said to the judge in this circumstance. He said,
- 18:55excuse me, Your Honor, I have been practicing,
- 18:58as you know, in this community for more than
- 19:0030 years now. And I can actually remember times
- 19:03when I find myself in the same predicament as
- 19:06opposing counsel. I mean, I've made similar errors
- 19:09and I've needed the court's help. I really think
- 19:14it would serve us all well if you granted his
- 19:17request for a continuance. Now, I've talked about
- 19:22this to other people before and usually I get
- 19:25all teary because it was such an unbelievably
- 19:27professional moment and civil and collegial moment
- 19:31that I've never forgotten. Rest in peace, Doug
- 19:34Reynolds recently passed away. But example number
- 19:38two about Who do you, how do you wanna be remembered?
- 19:43So civility actually can make you a better advocate
- 19:46too. It's not just the right thing to do. It's
- 19:50not just good for business, but it's actually
- 19:52gonna make you better at your job. you can be
- 19:57a better communicator and a better advocate.
- 19:59So it's easier to discuss and work over issues
- 20:03when you have a good civil relationship with
- 20:06opposing counsel. It gets much harder when there's
- 20:09a high level of tension. It's hard to get to
- 20:11the heart of the issues. when there's so much
- 20:15emotion involved. It also helps narrow the issues.
- 20:18If you're able to work collaboratively with opposing
- 20:21counsel on things like motions and limine, we
- 20:26actually, my former law partner and I actually
- 20:29had a meeting every time we had motions and limine
- 20:32filed in the case and we'd talk about number
- 20:34one, number two, number three. Okay, number one,
- 20:37you know what? Maybe they're right. Maybe we
- 20:38don't need to bring that issue up. Let's talk
- 20:40about it. So you can narrow the issues. You can
- 20:43focus on the core issues instead of hostilities.
- 20:46And you're more likely to get professional courtesies
- 20:51from the other side. We all have instances where
- 20:53things come up. And whether it's the kid gets
- 20:57sick or something happens in your personal life
- 21:00and you need to postpone something or whatnot,
- 21:03you're going to get a yes from imposing counsel
- 21:05when you have a good relationship with them and
- 21:07you've been nice to them. Judge Medel, can you
- 21:10talk a little bit about what the staff hears
- 21:13and sees? I just want to let you guys know that
- 21:16when the opposing lawyers come in on a case,
- 21:22and there is a lot of back and forth about how
- 21:24rotten the other side is and all the bad deeds
- 21:26that they've done, which many times has little
- 21:30to do with the court's business that day, that
- 21:33I sort of I do listen to it to screen as to whether
- 21:38there's anything that might involve me. But once
- 21:43I do that, it goes in one ear and out the other.
- 21:46I never remember what the issue was. I never
- 21:50remember that because it usually has nothing
- 21:54to do with the substance of the case. But what
- 21:57I do remember is kind of like when you meet someone
- 22:00that you think you might have met before. and
- 22:03you get a little rotten feeling in their stomach
- 22:05you know this wasn't whatever it was it was not
- 22:07a good interaction with this person that's kind
- 22:10of what happens when the lawyers return to my
- 22:12case in three or four weeks i don't remember
- 22:15what the issue was but i say oh no not these
- 22:18guys again and that's kind of an impression that
- 22:21you do not want to leave on the judge who's not
- 22:23happy to see you absolutely not And it's not
- 22:28just what happens in the courtroom in front of
- 22:30the judge, but what you do outside in the community
- 22:33when you're walking to lunch or having lunch
- 22:36or you're talking on the phone where other people
- 22:38can hear you, all of that matters. And the example
- 22:40that I give on that is that when I was ex turning
- 22:43for Judge Rhodes, the clerk that I worked with,
- 22:46she and I were going up the escalator. The federal
- 22:49courthouse in San Diego is right near a mall
- 22:51and the second or third level of the mall had
- 22:53restaurants. So we were going up in the escalator
- 22:55and there were two two male attorneys standing
- 22:58in front of us. I guess it could have been a
- 23:00man and a woman. I don't even remember exactly,
- 23:03but they were talking to each other about an
- 23:06opposing attorney and they mentioned the name
- 23:08of the opposing attorney and the clerk looked
- 23:11at me because that attorney was an attorney that
- 23:14was going to be in our courtroom that afternoon
- 23:16arguing a motion. in front of Judge Rhodes. And
- 23:20then so they go on to just bad mouth the other
- 23:23attorney. They were just talking smack. It was
- 23:25just it was embarrassing to listen to. It was
- 23:27so bad. And then they started making comments
- 23:30about the judge, our judge that we worked for.
- 23:34And you better believe that we remembered that.
- 23:37And you should have seen the look on their faces
- 23:39that afternoon when they came into the courtroom.
- 23:43The judge takes the bench. The clerk and I both
- 23:46walk out and sit at the little table next to
- 23:48the judges and their face just drained because
- 23:51they knew that we were the one standing right
- 23:53behind them on that escalator. Um, the other
- 23:56thing to think about, and I can say this because
- 23:58I'm not a retired judge, Judge Menell is, um,
- 24:01but you really have to think about the psychological
- 24:03effect that it's going to have on, um, on the
- 24:06judge. Um, if you're a combative, you're obstreperous,
- 24:10you're an absolute jerk to opposing counsel,
- 24:13they're going to know about it. And in my opinion,
- 24:15as a litigator, having tried a lot of cases,
- 24:17um, balls and strikes tend to go your way when
- 24:21you're nice. Of course, I consider myself a superhero
- 24:25judge, and none of that would ever affect my
- 24:27ability to be fair and impartial and to make
- 24:29the right call. Well, not all judges are like
- 24:31you. All right. So civility also makes you, I'm
- 24:38sorry, I think we're on the next. Okay, so let's
- 24:41talk about what your client thinks. So sometimes
- 24:43people think, lawyers think, well, I have to
- 24:45be a bulldog. I have to be, you know, constantly
- 24:48not agree to anything just in front of my client
- 24:51because my client is going to think I'm weak.
- 24:53Explain it to your client. Explain that it's
- 24:56important to have civility and professionalism
- 24:59in the practice of law. Explain to them that
- 25:03the studies actually show lawyers who are civil,
- 25:06courteous, professional, actually end up getting
- 25:08better results. And especially if it's a billable
- 25:12client. it costs less money to litigate a case
- 25:15when you're civil and you're courteous to opposing
- 25:18counsel. Let's talk, though, about what to do
- 25:21in front of the jury. Because those of us who
- 25:24not only litigate cases but try cases, you want
- 25:28to be really careful about what you do in front
- 25:30of the jury. So in my relationships with opposing
- 25:33counsel, we'd often spend time talking about
- 25:36what we did on the weekend, vacations we were
- 25:39taking, what our kids were doing, different sporting
- 25:41events that we'd gone to. We'd tell each other
- 25:44jokes. We'd just try to make things good and
- 25:47professional and collegial. Am I going to do
- 25:49that in front of the jury? No. Um, if I'm walking
- 25:52down the hallway and the jury's sitting on the
- 25:54benches outside the courtroom and opposing counsel
- 25:56is walking down the hallway too, I will nod.
- 25:59I will be polite. I will be courteous, but I'm
- 26:01not going to yuck it up. I'm not going to tell
- 26:03jokes in front of the jury with opposing counsel
- 26:05in front of the jury. Now, once we get into the
- 26:07courtroom, I'm still going to be friendly in
- 26:09my normal self with them. But in front of the
- 26:11jury, I always had a very sort of just professional,
- 26:14but not super, super overly friendly demeanor
- 26:17with opposing counsel. Even to the extent of
- 26:20It serves you well to help the other side out
- 26:22if they can't get their PowerPoint going or they
- 26:25left something. I just want to add something
- 26:27quickly. I remember in a criminal case, I was
- 26:30a prosecutor for seven years. I sat down after
- 26:33my closing argument and I left my yellow tab
- 26:38on the lectern and I saw that yellow tab come
- 26:41flying right in front of my eyes. The defense
- 26:44lawyer threw it. as a courtesy, of course, threw
- 26:48it at me and just about hit me in the head. And,
- 26:51you know, didn't say a word. I just put my head
- 26:53down and listened to what he had to say, just
- 26:55as an example of how you have to keep yourself
- 26:58under control in front of a jury. Absolutely.
- 27:02So we have the San Diego stability rules. I actually
- 27:04love them. They're very, I think they're kind
- 27:07of unique and interesting in terms of the presentation.
- 27:10But we will attach those as part of our packet
- 27:13that you'll have a chance to look at. So not
- 27:16only is stability the right thing to do, it's
- 27:19good for business, but it also promotes greater
- 27:22career satisfaction and attorney retention within
- 27:25law firms. So my first seven years of practice
- 27:32was in one of these big mega firms, right? Huge
- 27:34multinational law firm, and we had a lot of different
- 27:37attorneys. And what I learned as a young associate
- 27:39is you need to pick who it is that's gonna be
- 27:42your role model. because we had lawyers in our
- 27:45firm that would just be obstreperous and mean
- 27:49to opposing counsel. And when you ran into them
- 27:51in the hallway, the stories they told were typically,
- 27:55you won't believe what a jerk this guy was. I
- 27:58was talking to him today, da, da, da, da, da.
- 28:00And they go on and on about how terrible some
- 28:02opposing counsel is. Other lawyers would ...
- 28:06You pass them in the hallway and they say, oh,
- 28:08Joanne, hold on. I got to tell you the story.
- 28:10You won't believe the funniest story that opposing
- 28:12counsel told me during a phone call I had just
- 28:15yesterday or some crazy joke that his wife pulled
- 28:17on him for April Fool's Day. But the tone that
- 28:22that sets and the way that you feel about going
- 28:24to work every day is totally different when you
- 28:27work in an environment where people are friendly
- 28:30and people are courteous and it's a more joyful,
- 28:35happy experience. Happy attorneys actually means
- 28:38better retention of associates and staff as well.
- 28:42In every single one of my mediations, I do a
- 28:45pre -mediation phone call. I will two, one with
- 28:47each side. In that pre -mediation phone call,
- 28:52I ask a lot of questions, but one of the questions
- 28:54I ask is, how are you getting along or tell me
- 28:57about your relationship with opposing counsel?
- 29:00I do that for a number of reasons. One is that
- 29:05Sometimes in a mediation, you're mediating not
- 29:07just the dispute between the parties, but sometimes
- 29:09there's such bad blood between the lawyers and
- 29:12they're having such a hard time getting along
- 29:14that you almost have to mediate that or address
- 29:17that separately from the underlying dispute that
- 29:19the clients have. But there's one law firm in
- 29:23particular. It's a San Diego based law firm.
- 29:26It's a defense firm. Every single time I have
- 29:29a pre -mediation phone call that involves that
- 29:31firm, when I'm talking to their opposing counsel,
- 29:33they always say they have a great relationship
- 29:36with the lawyers in that firm. And the management
- 29:38of that firm has actually made a concentrated
- 29:41decision, a very intentional decision to promote
- 29:45civility within the firm, to promote an environment
- 29:48where they treat opposing counsel with respect
- 29:52and empathy, as opposed to being obstreperous
- 29:56all the time. And I actually had a phone call
- 29:59over the weekend with a managing partner because
- 30:01I wanted to learn a little bit more about their
- 30:04experience and the way they've cultivated a culture
- 30:06like that. And what she told me was that they
- 30:09had extremely high retention rates, not just
- 30:13for attorneys, but for staff members and paralegals
- 30:16as well, because it created a culture where people
- 30:20were happy going to work there and people enjoyed
- 30:22their time together. So civility also promotes
- 30:27good emotional health. I talked a little bit
- 30:30about what happens when you have attorneys around
- 30:34you that are positive, that are not telling downer
- 30:39stories about bad relationships with opposing
- 30:41counsel. So it creates a better environment in
- 30:45the office, but it also makes it less likely
- 30:47for you to take a bad day home from work to your
- 30:51family at the end of the day. Intentional civility,
- 30:55making a decision to be civil, to be courteous,
- 30:58to be friendly with opposing counsel also reduces
- 31:01stress and burnout among attorneys. I loved every
- 31:05minute of my career. Like I said, I worked for
- 31:09one of the mega firms for about seven years,
- 31:11and then I left there and I started a two -person
- 31:13firm with one of the other partners from that
- 31:15firm. I love the big firm. I love my small firm.
- 31:18I love what I'm doing now as a mediator. I know
- 31:20Judge Modell does too. But it reduces that. And
- 31:24I wanted to talk briefly about the concept of
- 31:27micro social interactions. So micro social interactions
- 31:30are interactions that are, by definition, last
- 31:34less than 10 minutes. Typically, it's anywhere
- 31:36from 30 seconds to two minutes. Um, and there
- 31:39was a study that came out recently and my husband
- 31:42and my son are always making fun of me because
- 31:43I can't, and I think you're the same way judgment.
- 31:46Can't get it into an elevator. Her son are always
- 31:48making fun of me. But we can't get in. Neither
- 31:54one of us can get into an elevator without striking
- 31:56up a conversation with someone. So, you know,
- 31:58I, you know, I've get into an elevator and I'll
- 32:00say, Oh, nice shoes or boy, that's a nice briefcase
- 32:03or something. And then we start a conversation.
- 32:05Otherwise you're just, just looking at your phone
- 32:07or you're looking up. the ceiling, but you start
- 32:09those conversations and here's what happens.
- 32:11It's a good way to start the day. You meet new
- 32:15people. And what I found is I oftentimes would
- 32:18meet attorneys that practice in the same field
- 32:21as me, but they were typically on the other side
- 32:23of the case. And then they'd say, oh, well, I
- 32:25need your card because I'm actually always looking
- 32:27for an attorney that does what you do. And I
- 32:29need someone to send referrals to. And I have
- 32:32a number of attorneys to this day. They're using
- 32:35me as a mediator now, but they would send cases
- 32:38to me. and those were people that I literally
- 32:41met in the elevator while I was going up to my
- 32:44office every day. I actually do that as a matter
- 32:49of personality, but I think I might do it to
- 32:52a fault because I've had my partner and others
- 32:55who were less social say, do you think you can
- 32:59get on this elevator without talking to someone?
- 33:05It might annoy a few people, but still, I think
- 33:08the general point of reaching out and being friendly
- 33:12to our people could mean good business. At least
- 33:14it means goodwill. You've made someone feel good
- 33:17in an elevator one day as well as yourself. Guys,
- 33:21I want to talk to you a little bit about this
- 33:26question. Turnabout is fair play when it comes
- 33:29to civility. I once again had a very serious
- 33:33case involving an injury or death of a baby,
- 33:36and it was a 10 -week medical malpractice case.
- 33:43The lawyers on the plaintiff's side were two
- 33:47women who were as prepared and more prepared
- 33:52than any lawyers I'd ever tried a case against
- 33:54even to this day or seen in my courtroom to this
- 33:57day. Incredibly. knew the medicine so well, knew
- 34:01every single medical reference to the subject
- 34:03matter of our case and really were like encyclopedias
- 34:07of the case, well beyond the actual facts of
- 34:10the case. But they were also highly charged and
- 34:15emotional. In the opinion of the three defense
- 34:20lawyers, my client was the least targeted of
- 34:24the three. We had the hospital, Doctor that delivered
- 34:30the baby and my doctor had seen the baby when
- 34:32I had seen the mom when she first came in To
- 34:35do the delivery. I was the least of the targeted
- 34:38defendants, but every single day for ten weeks
- 34:43There were a lot of things going on in that courtroom
- 34:46that shouldn't have been going on a judge would
- 34:49sustain an objection to the content of a question
- 34:53And the lawyer would simply reword it and ask
- 34:56it 10 times more. So we had to keep objecting,
- 34:59objecting, objecting. This is all in front of
- 35:01a jury. They would abuse what I believe the evidence
- 35:05code by reading for 10 minutes a medical text
- 35:09to the jury when that was not the way the evidence
- 35:13code was designed to have just someone do 10
- 35:16minutes of reading when they had a witness on
- 35:18the witness stand. The end of it was, do you
- 35:20agree with that paragraph? or do you agree with
- 35:22those four pages that I read to their expert
- 35:24or to on -cross examination? They would tell
- 35:28us the witnesses that were supposed to appear
- 35:30tomorrow morning from the plaintiffs, and then
- 35:32they would come the next day with four different
- 35:35witnesses. And daily, they would accuse one of
- 35:38the three of us of some ethical impropriety that
- 35:40we supposedly did. I was lucky because mine happened
- 35:43at the very end when they found, I think they
- 35:45must have said something like, we really haven't
- 35:47targeted a tent on this yet. And they came in
- 35:49and claimed that I had inappropriate contact
- 35:52with a treating physician. In short, it was 10
- 35:56of the most tense and miserable weeks that I've
- 36:00ever spent. And to their credit, they got a good
- 36:02verdict. At the very end of the case, one of
- 36:09my colleagues, my two defense lawyer colleagues,
- 36:12called me up on a Friday. In San Diego, as you
- 36:16guys might know, we have trial Monday through
- 36:19Thursday, but not on Friday. And this lawyer
- 36:22called me up and said, we told the defense, I
- 36:26mean, we told the plaintiffs that we were gonna
- 36:27call four witnesses, but I'm talking to the other
- 36:31lawyer and we decided just to call one and not
- 36:34tell the plaintiffs lawyer. Now the net effect
- 36:37of that would be that the, plaintiff's lawyer
- 36:39would be working on cross -examinations all weekend
- 36:41while we would be working on closing arguments.
- 36:44And we would show up on Monday and say we didn't
- 36:47call these three witnesses, we're ready to do
- 36:49closing arguments and catch the plaintiff's lawyer
- 36:52by surprise. But once again, we had a discussion.
- 36:56I said, you know, both of us were lucky to get
- 37:00into a boat and we've been in the American Board
- 37:03of Trial Advocates for many, many years. And
- 37:06one of the criterion, criteria that got us in
- 37:11was our commitment to being civil, collegial,
- 37:13which includes being open, honest, and not doing
- 37:17these kind of dirty tricks. And suffice it to
- 37:20say, by the end of that telephone conversation,
- 37:22we had said we need to distinguish ourselves
- 37:25from the dirty tricks that have been played against
- 37:27us by never doing that, by rising above that
- 37:30and doing the right thing. And so Upon that agreement,
- 37:34we called the plaintiff's lawyer and told them,
- 37:37wow, we're not going to call three other witnesses.
- 37:39And life went on. I'm not sure there was any
- 37:41specific reward. Maybe the dear Lord is looking
- 37:44down on that. But we felt better about ourselves,
- 37:48and we felt better about our commitment to the
- 37:50standards that aboda and just being a good lawyer
- 37:53imposed on us. And that is civility, collegiality,
- 37:57openness, and honesty. Speaking of aboda. Yes.
- 38:02Yeah. So civility can help with career advancement.
- 38:05You're a member of ABOTA, aren't you? Yes. I
- 38:08have to say I was on the membership committee
- 38:10for our chapter of ABOTA here in San Diego for
- 38:12many, many years. And I don't know why it happened,
- 38:15but I got the hardest cases to evaluate on new
- 38:20candidates. And here's why they were hard. Here's
- 38:24what it would sound like. I'm calling about this
- 38:28particular lawyer. You tried a case against them.
- 38:31What did you think about them? This is about
- 38:33their membership effort for ABOTA. I'll tell
- 38:36you what I think about them. I don't think I've
- 38:38ever seen anyone command a courtroom like this
- 38:41lawyer, like posing lawyer before. This person
- 38:44knew the evidence code back and forth. His cross
- 38:48examinations were amazing. He reduced my expert
- 38:50to a shriveling rubble on the witness stand.
- 38:54And to this day, As I lie in bed, even though
- 38:57that trial was three or four years ago, I can
- 38:59still hear the words of his closing argument
- 39:02ringing out. They were so powerful. He wiped
- 39:05me out. This guy is truly deserving, given his
- 39:09trial skills of being in a BOTA. I would say
- 39:12that's fantastic. Well, that's criterion number
- 39:15one. Let's go to criterion number two. What do
- 39:18you know and what did you experience about disability,
- 39:21professionalism, and collegiality? And typically
- 39:24that would be, do I have to answer that question?
- 39:32And I'd say, well, you don't have to, but it
- 39:34would really be helpful. And after a lot of resistance,
- 39:38I would finally get them to say what they were
- 39:41feeling, which is, no, this guy, he hid every
- 39:45bit of evidence that we possibly was produced.
- 39:48I had to do a motion to compel on every single
- 39:51routine piece of evidence. He actually had a
- 39:54one of my witnesses was an 89 year old woman.
- 39:57He made her cry. He was so brutal in terms of
- 40:00the cross examination. And there was just a lot
- 40:03of things that were dishonest about the way he
- 40:05approached the case. I cannot give him good marks
- 40:08for collegiality. And in a boda, that was enough.
- 40:12If we if two or three people said that during
- 40:14our investigation, you were done, at least for
- 40:18now. You could make efforts to correct that as
- 40:21time went on, but for this particular application
- 40:24process, you were done if you didn't get good
- 40:26marks on either one. I will ask you if any of
- 40:30you wish to become a judge, you know, you really,
- 40:33really need to behave in an appropriate way.
- 40:39I don't know if this sounds self -congratulatory
- 40:43or not. But I really think that legal skills
- 40:47and trial skills and all that stuff were not
- 40:50the propelling force to make me become a judge.
- 40:53I believe the fact that they send out 500 evaluations,
- 40:59many of them to my opposing lawyers on cases,
- 41:03and that people said, You know, one thing you
- 41:06can say about Kent, we really had a lot of fun
- 41:08with that case. We've really become close friends
- 41:12afterwards, and I think he's great. I think he'd
- 41:14be a great judge. I think those comments made
- 41:17me a judge more than any legal skill or acumen.
- 41:20And if you don't have those, if too many people
- 41:24say the wrong things during your judicial evaluation,
- 41:27you might as well say goodbye to that opportunity.
- 41:31Absolutely. And not only that, but also building
- 41:33a network for future jobs. You may love the position
- 41:37you're in right now, but you never know. The
- 41:39folks at Broback years and years ago probably
- 41:42all loved their job at Broback, but it's no more.
- 41:44And so if you have good relationships with opposing
- 41:48counsel, it's going to increase the likelihood
- 41:50that you can land on your feet if you have an
- 41:52adverse job situation come up. Why don't you
- 41:55talk about the dentist office case? Guys, I'm
- 41:58sitting, I was in a big firm, we had 50, well,
- 42:01for San Diego standards, we had 55 local lawyers
- 42:04in our firm, and it was an insurance defense
- 42:07firm, so we did every kind. I was lucky to do
- 42:09the medical malpractice stuff. I'm sitting in
- 42:11my office, minding my own business, when the
- 42:14receptionist said, Ken, there's a guy here to
- 42:19see you. He wants a lawyer here to see you. And
- 42:21I said, what's his name? And they told me his
- 42:23name, and I go, I don't know anyone by that name.
- 42:26And she says, well, he says he has a case with
- 42:28you. And I finally went, OK, you know, this is
- 42:32before telemarketers and people showing up. So
- 42:35I said, send him back. And he came back and he
- 42:38introduced himself. And he says, you may not
- 42:42have the materials for this case yet, but I am
- 42:46a plaintiff's lawyer and I have a case that's
- 42:48coming. And I've been told it's coming to you
- 42:51as one of. three or four different defense lawyers
- 42:54for different parties in the case. And I was
- 42:56in the audience, wanted to come by and introduce
- 42:58myself. He introduced himself. He told me about
- 43:01the case. He told me that his client was, I think
- 43:07she was like 23 or 24 year old woman who was
- 43:11born with a genetic disorder that made her look
- 43:13very tiny, very disfigured in terms of her orthopedics,
- 43:17as well as her face. and very, very reticent
- 43:21and shy. And at age 23, she asked her mother
- 43:25to take her to the dentist's office, having not
- 43:27been there for a long, long time. In the dentist's
- 43:31office, the judge looked at, I mean the judge,
- 43:34the dentist looked at the inside of her mouth
- 43:36and said, she has really, really, really bad
- 43:40collection of plaque all through her mouth, and
- 43:43she'll need for us to do the cleaning procedure.
- 43:46But he said, and this is the important part,
- 43:50for patients like this, it's best that we do
- 43:54it under general anesthesia. Knock her out. And
- 43:58what did he mean by patients like this? He thought
- 44:01she was mentally disabled, whereas she was not.
- 44:04She was completely normal. He puts her under
- 44:07the general anesthesia. As soon as he touches
- 44:11any one of her gums, blood just comes spurting
- 44:13out. The blood pooled in her throat. something
- 44:16called laryngeal spasm which is her throat just
- 44:19locking down happens and she begins to suffer
- 44:22hypoxia as they dial 911 to have an ambulance
- 44:24come in and take her to the hospital. At the
- 44:27hospital she's intubated and two days after that
- 44:32the nurse walks in and she had extubated herself
- 44:35so she'd removed the breathing tube. So now the
- 44:38hospital gets sued. I believe I represented a
- 44:41pulmonary doctor that was involved in that process.
- 44:44And he explained that this was the case to me.
- 44:47But more important than explaining the facts
- 44:49of the case, he said, here is what's going with
- 44:55her now. Here are all her treating doctors. Here
- 44:58is what her status is right now. Here is a list
- 45:02of the doctors if you want to start subpoenaing
- 45:05their records and the rehab places and that sort
- 45:07of thing. And by the way, in terms of prioritizing
- 45:11who I'm going to target, your guy is about three
- 45:15or four people down. You're not going to be the
- 45:18target. But if there's anything at all that you
- 45:20need from me to help you get acquainted with
- 45:24this case, just consider me a resource. I'd be
- 45:28happy to provide you the medical records, for
- 45:29example, just by sending those to you. I hadn't
- 45:34had the case yet. I knew there was something
- 45:37coming down, but I had nothing about the case
- 45:39at this point. And that was the first time ever
- 45:43that I'd have anyone come in and in such a calm,
- 45:47professional and ingratiating way introduce themselves
- 45:50and offer to work together with me in such an
- 45:53amazingly collegial way toward arriving at a
- 45:56just result in the case. I'd never forgotten
- 45:58that. Oh, by the way. Here he is. This is Charles
- 46:02LeMandry. We're going to name names now. Well,
- 46:06name names are the good examples, but he was
- 46:09the man who did that. I just want to give you
- 46:12that as an example. That's great. There you go.
- 46:15How do you build good relationship with the opposing
- 46:17council? Not all of us are going to be a Tom
- 46:19to walk into someone's office and say, hey, I'm
- 46:21here. I want to talk to Judge Meddiel or Ken
- 46:23at the time. Um, my practice was if I had a case
- 46:28with an attorney, I'd never been opposite before.
- 46:30The first thing I would do once I found out who
- 46:32the attorney was is I would give them a call
- 46:34and I would call with no agenda, no, you know,
- 46:37nothing I needed to, no extension, nothing like
- 46:39that, but just to introduce myself. Um, and I
- 46:42would say that I enjoyed having good collegial
- 46:44relationships with all of my, or almost all of
- 46:47my opposing counsel. Cause also we'll talk, as
- 46:49we'll talk about in a little while, you can't
- 46:52you can't control everyone. But I said, I have
- 46:55good relationships with opposing counsel. If
- 46:57I ever do anything that you think is just totally,
- 47:00you know, I've got off the deep end, what the
- 47:02heck is Joanne doing? Call me, let's talk about
- 47:05it. And I'm a big fan of picking up the phone
- 47:08or better yet meeting in person. I actually...
- 47:11did what I call discovery lunches. So when I
- 47:14had opposing counsel and I had a discovery dispute
- 47:17and I knew it was going to take us quite a while
- 47:18to go over stuff, I would actually call the other
- 47:20lawyer and say, hey, let's grab lunch. Bring
- 47:23your notes, I'll remind, but let's grab lunch
- 47:24together and my treat. So we would get together,
- 47:27we'd have lunch. And I intentionally didn't introduce
- 47:30the discovery issues or even the case at all
- 47:32until we were done with our meal. I would just
- 47:35talk about, you know, where'd you go for your
- 47:38last vacation, things like that, just to talk
- 47:41and to know each other. And then after we finished
- 47:43eating, I'd pull the papers out, they'd pull
- 47:45theirs out, we'd talk over discovery issues.
- 47:4799 % of the time when I had a discovery lunch
- 47:50like that, we were able to resolve the issues.
- 47:52And we know how much judges love discovery disputes.
- 47:55Yes, they're so much fun. Yes. Another thing
- 47:59I learned very, very young in my very early in
- 48:01my career was never attack opposing counsel.
- 48:03So when you have whether it's in writing or you're
- 48:06standing up in the courtroom in front of the
- 48:09judge, you don't attack the attorney. You don't
- 48:11say, well, attorney Joe says this or attorney
- 48:14Joe is doing this or whatever you say. the defendant,
- 48:17you know, Big Co or Jane Doe or whoever asserts
- 48:21this or whatever, as opposed to the lawyer, because
- 48:24what we're really doing is our clients are adverse
- 48:28to each other. We're not adverse to each other.
- 48:31Another idea is obviously join it in a court,
- 48:34you know, attend the bench bar mixers. I drove
- 48:36up a couple of weeks ago to the Beverly Hills
- 48:38Bar Association installation dinner, and it was
- 48:41just wonderful to see all of you guys interacting
- 48:44with each other, and even with opposing counsel,
- 48:48sharing a beverage together, sharing a meal together.
- 48:51But you can volunteer too. San Diego County Bar
- 48:53Association does beach cleanup days, where we
- 48:56go out and we pick up. We pick up trash on the
- 48:58beach. But do that sort of thing to build relationships
- 49:02with lawyers outside of your cases. So let's
- 49:05talk about, I mentioned that you can't, you know,
- 49:07you're going to have bad apples. You're going
- 49:09to obviously have people that are absolute jerks
- 49:12to you. And what do you do when you have someone
- 49:16in, for example, in a deposition that is just,
- 49:20it's strepharous, like the attorney that Ken
- 49:23mentioned earlier. So I would say take the superhero
- 49:27high road, first of all, moderate your tone.
- 49:30This works for lots of settings, not just legal
- 49:34settings. But there's an acronym, and I'm going
- 49:36to give credit where credit's due. There's a
- 49:38mediator trainer named Bill Eddy here in San
- 49:41Diego, who his specialty is high conflict personalities.
- 49:46And he developed this thing called SLIC. SLIC.
- 49:49And it basically is set limits and impose consequences.
- 49:53So for example, You have a deposition where they're
- 49:57poaching the witness, like Judge Modell explained,
- 49:59or they're interrupting your questions. And they're
- 50:03just that kind of lawyer, and you're not going
- 50:04to be able to retrain them in the moment. You
- 50:07need to just basically lay down the law by being
- 50:10firm, professional, not emotional. Being professional
- 50:14and basically saying, you keep interrupting me.
- 50:18I don't appreciate it. It's not appropriate.
- 50:21If you do it one more time, I'm going to have
- 50:24to suspend the deposition and seek a protective
- 50:27order. So that's the slick technique. Let's talk
- 50:31about what to do when you get a nasty ground.
- 50:33We've all gotten one of these. So let's say For
- 50:37example, a situation comes up and you have to
- 50:39postpone a deposition. Let's say your secretary
- 50:41sends an email to opposing counsel, says, we're
- 50:44really sorry, but that deposition scheduled for
- 50:45next week has to go off calendar. And opposing
- 50:49counsel immediately sends you a nasty ground.
- 50:53Two -page, single -space email that basically
- 50:56is going over and rehashing, ranting and raving,
- 51:00going over every perceived wrong that they think
- 51:02you've done wrong in the case. They demand at
- 51:05the end of the long ranting and rave, the demand
- 51:07that you reset the deposition. So your knee jerk
- 51:10reaction might be a point -for -point counterpoint
- 51:14letter or email, right? Going back and saying,
- 51:16no, you're the jerk and you're the one that did
- 51:18this and you're the one that did that. But what
- 51:20does that do, right? It ratchets up the dispute
- 51:23instead of calming things down. It solves no
- 51:27problems at all because you still got this deposition
- 51:30you got to take care of. And third, it costs
- 51:32a lot of money. You might spend two, maybe three
- 51:35hours working on that really nasty response to
- 51:38them that's really not going to do you any good
- 51:40for your client. So what you can do instead is
- 51:44use another Bill Eddy technique called the BIF
- 51:46technique. So what is BIF? It is a response in
- 51:50writing that is brief, informative, friendly,
- 51:56and firm. In the context of the example that
- 51:58I just gave you, what you would do instead of
- 52:02doing a two page single space ranting and raving
- 52:04email back to the other side. You send them an
- 52:07email that's one paragraph long. You start off,
- 52:10and this is the friendly part, good morning,
- 52:12or maybe even if you're willing to go there,
- 52:15I'm sorry. Explain the reason. I'm good morning,
- 52:20I'm sorry that I had to postpone the deposition.
- 52:22My wife had a surgery scheduled and that day
- 52:25was the only day the surgeon can do it, so I
- 52:28had no choice but to postpone it. Offer alternative
- 52:32dates. thank them for understanding, and tell
- 52:35them that you hope to enjoy a professional relationship
- 52:38going forward. So what's the effect of that email?
- 52:41You've completely diffused the situation. You
- 52:45took the high road. You didn't sink to their
- 52:48level. And you resolved the issue. You gave them
- 52:51alternative dates. So that was a perfect example
- 52:53of brief, informative, friendly, and firm. You're
- 52:57going to have a much better outcome if you do
- 53:00that. And they might start calling you Biff.
- 53:02Okay. They might start calling you Biff. What
- 53:05was the other one? The other acronym you had?
- 53:08Oh, uh, slick. Yeah. So either slick or Biff.
- 53:11You might have a whole new identity. Okay. I
- 53:15want to just, uh, since we have, uh, we're, we're
- 53:18almost done here. I just wanted to Add a few
- 53:21more comments to this particular subject matter
- 53:23we're talking about. If you've been in my courtroom,
- 53:26you may have heard me. I wouldn't call it a rant
- 53:29and rave, but it's a minor complaint by a judge
- 53:32about modern day meet and confer. Here is modern
- 53:36day meet and confer. Someone doesn't respond
- 53:41to your discovery properly. You immediately go
- 53:44to your computer. because you have an obligation
- 53:48under the CODESIL procedure to meet and confer.
- 53:52By the way, meet and confer means meet and confer
- 53:54and try to solve the problem, not just meet and
- 53:57confer. But you go to your computer and you put
- 54:01down not only all of your complaints in terms
- 54:06of the lack of discovery response, but you put
- 54:09down all your emotions too. This is like the
- 54:1110th time that you've done this, all the different
- 54:15things. And you don't realize what you're doing
- 54:18is very much like Moses coming down from the
- 54:21mountain with principles inscribed in tablets
- 54:26that cannot be removed. Here is my position.
- 54:30And you know what your opposing lawyer does?
- 54:32He goes, oh yeah? When he gets your letter, he
- 54:35gets on his or her computer and does the same
- 54:38thing and has his independent tablets, Moses's
- 54:42tablets. Both of them can't be changed because
- 54:45they're inscribed in there. And it's just the
- 54:48opposite of meeting and conferring and trying
- 54:50to solve the problem. So as Joanne mentioned,
- 54:55I really, really favor the old school way of
- 54:58doing it. I started doing civil in 1987 after
- 55:02seven years at the DA's office. And back in those
- 55:05days, you just called up the person or on occasions
- 55:09you'd meet them for lunch somewhere. and you
- 55:12would go over what it is exactly that you were
- 55:15shooting for in your discovery. And the opposing
- 55:19lawyer who was supposedly the bad player because
- 55:24they didn't answer it would say, oh, kind of
- 55:26like Pulp Fiction, oh, you didn't tell me you
- 55:29were set in the wolf. That's a whole different
- 55:31story. They say, oh, is that all you want? I
- 55:34can do that. You don't know how many times in
- 55:37informal discovery conferences in my courtroom
- 55:40where that happened, where they got all dressed
- 55:42up, they got their tie on, they came down with
- 55:44all these papers. And I just go, when you asked
- 55:47that question, what were you shooting for? And
- 55:49they tell them, and the defense lawyer says,
- 55:52oh, I can do that. And in 10 minutes, we've solved
- 55:55everything just because you guys couldn't communicate
- 55:58yourself in an old style communicative way and
- 56:01express that directly on the phone. or in person
- 56:04with the other side. That's meeting and conferring
- 56:07and solving the problem. Right. And I've actually
- 56:10experienced as a mediator sometimes, you wrap
- 56:13up a case, you get the case settled. I always
- 56:16tell people to circulate a draft settlement agreement
- 56:18in advance because if we have a resolution, I
- 56:21want to sign the agreement at the end of the
- 56:22day. That is absolutely the best thing to have.
- 56:26I mediated a case years ago now where the opposing
- 56:29counsel or the lawyers did not circulate a draft
- 56:32settlement They said, oh, don't worry about it.
- 56:34We'll get it done afterward. Literally eight
- 56:36months after we settled the case, I got a call
- 56:39from one of the attorneys saying, we still don't
- 56:41have a signed agreement because we're fighting
- 56:43over the terms of the settlement agreement. And
- 56:47what they were doing, the issues, I jumped back
- 56:49in to help them resolve it. And what it was was
- 56:51their emotions were getting in the way. They
- 56:53were fighting. It was just rashing it up to the
- 56:56point of being ridiculous. The actual substantive
- 56:58problems with the settlement agreement were tiny.
- 57:02Yeah, I would say that not only approaching a
- 57:05meet -and -confer in that sort of collegial way,
- 57:08calling up or meeting with someone, but also
- 57:11Joanne and I were talking about how it can lead
- 57:15to bigger accomplishments. I had a gentleman
- 57:20in my, a guy that I love that's in my building
- 57:22who's one of the few plaintiffs medical malpractice
- 57:25specialists in town. And we had a case, a big
- 57:28case against each other. And I called him up
- 57:30and I go, Bob, his name is Bob Vokey. I don't
- 57:33mind saying his names. I love the guy. But I
- 57:35said, Bob, I think we need to go to mediation
- 57:38on this because I know you have really strong
- 57:40opinions on this. I have really strong opinions.
- 57:42I don't know if we can do this on our own. He
- 57:44goes, Kenia, I'm three floors above you in this
- 57:48building. Come on up. Come on up and let's talk.
- 57:53We went up there and of course we talked about
- 57:55the thing that was most important, baseball for
- 57:59for 50 minutes. And in the last 10 minutes of
- 58:02our hour -long discussion, we solved the case.
- 58:05Same thing with a guy named Ben Bond, who was
- 58:07a very young man at the time, but is now the
- 58:11president of Aurobota. I called him up on a very
- 58:14serious case and told him, my client has no insurance.
- 58:17And at the end of this case, I will own everything
- 58:21that he has. You will get nothing, because he
- 58:23doesn't have anything. I think you should take
- 58:26action right now. and we met at a breakfast place
- 58:29called the Mission Hills or Mission Breakfast
- 58:31over in East Village and we settled that case.
- 58:35This is what face -to -face collegiality can
- 58:37accomplish and this is why we put on this presentation.
- 58:42This is why I will say to you, how do you want
- 58:47to be remembered for God's sakes? This person,
- 58:52the slip and fall in the hospital, that lawyer?
- 58:55Or do you want to be remembered more like Mr.
- 58:59LeMandry and Mr. Reynolds and have me look at
- 59:03you 30 or 40 years later and have such a good
- 59:07feeling and a warm remembrance of our interaction?
- 59:11And I think with that... I think we've done our...
- 59:13We have run out of our stuff, but we are here
- 59:16if you have any questions. Are there any questions?
- 59:20Maybe Min can help us with that. Yeah, so we
- 59:22do have a few questions. The first one is, any
- 59:25suggestions for managing the client expectation
- 59:28that bulldogging and being aggressive is not
- 59:31compatible with civility? Absolutely. And I've
- 59:37had clients who have said, it seems like you're
- 59:40best friends with the lawyer. You're really friendly
- 59:42with them. Shouldn't you be more aggressive?
- 59:44And what I tell them is, Advocacy is not the
- 59:48same thing as, you know, you don't have to be
- 59:51a jerk to be an advocate. And the reality is
- 59:54that if I have a good relationship with that
- 59:57opposing attorney, we're more likely to get what
- 1:00:00we need in the case, whether it's a postponement
- 1:00:03because your kid got sick and you can't make
- 1:00:05your deposition, or it might be uh you know we
- 1:00:10might get a better result at trial or we might
- 1:00:12get a better settlement because the attorney
- 1:00:14is willing to talk to his client about the fact
- 1:00:17that well you know miss rezo actually takes cases
- 1:00:20to trial and she's good at what she does and
- 1:00:22you know she the judges and the the jurors like
- 1:00:25her so it actually works to your benefit when
- 1:00:27i do that you know there's a certain number of
- 1:00:31uh defendants and that included my doctor defendants
- 1:00:33when i was doing medical malpractice who don't
- 1:00:36want you just to defend them They say, how can
- 1:00:39we get back at them? What can we do on the affirmative
- 1:00:44attack to get back at these people? And it does
- 1:00:47take a lot of patience, a lot of time you spend
- 1:00:49with your client, indicating what's possible
- 1:00:53and what's not possible. What would be the most
- 1:00:55effective way to defend you first? And then we
- 1:00:58can think about other things. But to explain
- 1:01:02who you are and what you intend to accomplish
- 1:01:04and how, and hope that they understand that that's
- 1:01:08why we are where we were. I think that that's
- 1:01:14the only thing you can do is explain it to them
- 1:01:18calmly. There will be a certain percentage of
- 1:01:22clients who just won't accept it, might think
- 1:01:25you're too weak, but hopefully you've built up
- 1:01:27a little bit of a reputation in town where you
- 1:01:29can say check with these other people and they'll
- 1:01:31say no. This guy wins everything by honey, not
- 1:01:35by, what's the other thing? I don't know, I only
- 1:01:39ever use honey. I don't know what the other one
- 1:01:40is. Ren, did you have any other questions for
- 1:01:43us? Yes. So this one attendee says, I have had
- 1:01:47good relations with some opposing counsel. Others
- 1:01:49have gone out of their way to be difficult. Others
- 1:01:51do not seem to think that civility is part of
- 1:01:53the role. What I was hoping to get from this
- 1:01:55course were some suggestions on how to deal with
- 1:01:57difficult opposing counsel, how to lower the
- 1:02:00temperature so you can discuss the facts and
- 1:02:02resolve the issues for your clients. Sure. So
- 1:02:05I think that question might have come in earlier
- 1:02:08in the in the presentation. But again, think
- 1:02:10back to the BIF and the slick techniques. If
- 1:02:15it's in writing, what you want to do is keep
- 1:02:18it short. Keep your response short and professional.
- 1:02:22Be like a duck. Let the water go off your back
- 1:02:25and just respond in a professional way. And that
- 1:02:29diffuses the situation instead of ratcheting
- 1:02:32it up. And then again, if it's a oral deposition
- 1:02:36or oral conversation, you just, you need to use
- 1:02:40the slick technique, right? Set limits and impose
- 1:02:42consequences and basically say, you're doing
- 1:02:45X, Y, and Z. I don't appreciate it. If you continue,
- 1:02:49here's the consequence. So this question is what
- 1:02:57can be done when the judges refuse to hold opposing
- 1:03:00counsel responsible for bad behavior including
- 1:03:02lying and refusing to follow court orders Do
- 1:03:06it does the judge have any responsibility to
- 1:03:08hold attorneys accountable for their behavior
- 1:03:09in a case? Well, it just depends on whether Let
- 1:03:15me give you examples something that I say to
- 1:03:17jurors all the time when I'm choosing a jury
- 1:03:19I try to explain to them what a cause of action
- 1:03:22is and I tell them You know, my court reporter
- 1:03:27could stand up right in front of all you people
- 1:03:29and say to me, Judge, I've never seen you looking
- 1:03:33so ugly and miserable today. And if she said
- 1:03:36that, that would be morally wrong because she's
- 1:03:40embarrassing me in front of all these strangers
- 1:03:41that are in my courtroom. And it's just mean
- 1:03:44-spirited and wrong. But I would tell the jurors,
- 1:03:48but there's no... a legal theory that covers
- 1:03:52that. It's not a bona fide cause of action. So
- 1:03:55we're not going to deal with all the wrongs.
- 1:03:56We're going to deal with only the ones that the
- 1:03:59law supports. Well, it's the same thing with
- 1:04:03lawyers misbehaving. 90 % of the time, it's a
- 1:04:07misbehavior that the court can address because
- 1:04:11it falls within the rough, unstructured categories
- 1:04:15of professionalism, civility, and collegiality.
- 1:04:18You violated those things and you say, well,
- 1:04:21I know, but you didn't violate anything that
- 1:04:23the court can really remedy. So the brief answer
- 1:04:27is, if it is something that's, for example, a
- 1:04:30bona fide discovery abuse, if it's a direct lying
- 1:04:35under oath or direct lying to the court, you
- 1:04:39know, I would hope that most judges would take
- 1:04:41that seriously. conduct a proper inquiry into
- 1:04:45it and sanction when sanctions are appropriate.
- 1:04:50But there's many, many, many complaints that
- 1:04:53the two lawyers have with one another that just
- 1:04:55doesn't fall under anything that I can deal with.
- 1:04:57I hope that's not a cop -out answer, but that
- 1:05:00is the answer. Well, and I think as a litigator,
- 1:05:03too, one thing to do is make a record of what's
- 1:05:07going on. If something's happening in a deposition,
- 1:05:10for example, that's not on the record, make a
- 1:05:14record when you go back into session in the deposition.
- 1:05:19Or if something is said to you that's unprofessional
- 1:05:22or uncivil, you can make some kind of a record
- 1:05:26of it to address it later if you need to. You
- 1:05:30know, as I was driving here today, I was thinking
- 1:05:33about that case where the lady slipped and fell
- 1:05:39in the hospital and thing. What could I have
- 1:05:40done? I mean, was I at fault in part for letting
- 1:05:44it go for eight hours when it shouldn't? And
- 1:05:46as you move through your career, you learn how
- 1:05:49to deal with these things. For example, in retrospect,
- 1:05:52I would have stopped the deposition at four hours
- 1:05:55or given him a good solid time to do what he
- 1:05:59wanted to do. And then I would have gone to court
- 1:06:02or asked him, I want to retake the deposition,
- 1:06:07but I want to videotape it this time, the rest
- 1:06:10of the deposition. Because I did have in that
- 1:06:14other case that I talked to you about, about
- 1:06:16the injured baby case, I got in late and I had
- 1:06:20to retake the plaintiff's deposition and so many
- 1:06:22bad things that were happening there that I did.
- 1:06:25terminate the deposition and go to court and
- 1:06:27say, here are the things that the interactions
- 1:06:30between the plaintiff and their client that are
- 1:06:33just totally inappropriate for the deposition.
- 1:06:35And you know what the judge said? Well, I can't
- 1:06:37see that. Same as what Joanne just said. I can't
- 1:06:40see that in the deposition transcript. So I recommend
- 1:06:43that you go back and you videotape it. And that's
- 1:06:47what we did. We videotaped it. And now you have
- 1:06:50hard evidence of impropriety captured on film.
- 1:06:52So that's going to help you a lot. Wren, did
- 1:06:56you have any other questions? Yes, just one final
- 1:06:59question. Is there ever a time or place to report
- 1:07:02an attorney to the state bar if the conduct gets
- 1:07:04so far beyond the line? Well, now you have to.
- 1:07:09If it goes to the line of true misconduct or
- 1:07:14criminal behavior or that sort of thing, I think
- 1:07:17there's a new statute. that requires you to report
- 1:07:21it even if it's a colleague even if they're on
- 1:07:23your same side or your same firm for god's sakes
- 1:07:27so um but uh Joanne you want to Well, no, you
- 1:07:31absolutely can report things to the state bar.
- 1:07:33And you don't want to go there with every kind
- 1:07:36of tit for tat that happens. And one of the things
- 1:07:40my former partner, Chip Edelson, was an amazing
- 1:07:45mentor. And I learned so many things from him,
- 1:07:48practicing law with him. But one of the biggest
- 1:07:50lessons I learned with him is pick your battles.
- 1:07:54Because not every dispute, not every fracas needs
- 1:07:57to continue. I mean, sometimes you just say,
- 1:08:00you know what? I'm gonna let that one go. It's
- 1:08:02the same thing when you're driving your car on
- 1:08:04the freeway, right? You know, someone cuts you
- 1:08:06off and you can get right on their bumper and
- 1:08:08you can honk your horn or you can salute them.
- 1:08:11Or you can just go, you know what? Karma's gonna
- 1:08:14get ya. I would say that piggybacking on what
- 1:08:18Joanne just said is... um you really it really
- 1:08:22would have to be something egregious to really
- 1:08:24warrant you contacting the state bar you know
- 1:08:27that that's my comment and that's just an opinion
- 1:08:30meaning not a judge's opinion just a human being's
- 1:08:33opinion so everyone's got to approach it in your
- 1:08:36own way well thank you all for attending and
- 1:08:40um rin we will let you uh sign us off how do
- 1:08:42you want to be remembered we'll see you guys