Latest / Found in the Machine / Page Turner: Mary Jameson and the Optophone
Transcript
- 0:48Daina Bouquin: It is nineteen eighteen, and Mary Jameson is reading.
- 0:53Daina Bouquin: She was born blind, and she usually reads braille.
- 0:59Daina Bouquin: But the page in front of her is an ordinary printed page.
- 1:05Daina Bouquin: Black ink on white paper.
- 1:08Daina Bouquin: There is a machine between her and the page.
- 1:13Daina Bouquin: A delicate arrangement of lenses and wires, a spinning disc and a small piece of an element called Selenium.
- 1:22Daina Bouquin: As the mechanism moves slowly across the print, the machine sends a collection of musical notes into a pair of telephone receivers.
- 1:33Daina Bouquin: And Mary listens.
- 1:35Daina Bouquin: She hears in the sounds one letter, then another.
- 1:44Daina Bouquin: Eventually, a word.
- 1:47Daina Bouquin: It is slow work.
- 1:50Daina Bouquin: And the machine is temperamental.
- 1:53Daina Bouquin: Its focusing mechanism is so delicate that someone walking heavily across the room can knock it out of alignment.
- 2:02Daina Bouquin: But Mary has been practicing.
- 2:06Daina Bouquin: By the summer of 1918, she can read about one word per minute.
- 2:12Daina Bouquin: And that is enough to prove that it is possible.
- 2:17Daina Bouquin: I'm Daina Bouquin and this is Found in the Machine.
- 2:24Daina Bouquin: In June 1912, a physicist named Edmund Edward Fournier d'Albe arrives at an optical convention in London with an invention.
- 2:40Daina Bouquin: Fournier d'Albe is an unusual man.
- 2:44Daina Bouquin: A scientist and writer with interests ranging from electricity to spiritualism.
- 2:51Daina Bouquin: He knows some of the most prominent thinkers of the age.
- 2:55Daina Bouquin: He has befriended Harry Houdini.
- 2:58Daina Bouquin: And he has spent years studying the properties of a chemical element called selenium.
- 3:06Daina Bouquin: Selenium does something peculiar.
- 3:10Daina Bouquin: In darkness, it resists the passage of electricity.
- 3:14Daina Bouquin: But if you shine a light on it, that resistance changes.
- 3:20Daina Bouquin: Alexander Graham Bell had used it in an instrument that transmitted sound on a beam of light.
- 3:27Daina Bouquin: And in Poland, an ophthalmologist named Kazimierz Noiszewski had used it as an artificial eye to help blind people tell light from darkness.
- 3:38Daina Bouquin: And Fournier d'Albe is working on a very similar idea.
- 3:43Daina Bouquin: His instrument is housed in a slender wooden box.
- 3:48Daina Bouquin: Inside is a selenium cell that responds to light, producing changes in an electrical signal that a person can hear through telephone receivers.
- 4:00Daina Bouquin: Point it toward a window and the sound changes.
- 4:04Daina Bouquin: Move it toward a corner and it changes again.
- 4:08Daina Bouquin: He calls it the exploring optophone, and he imagines it helping blind people navigate the world.
- 4:16Daina Bouquin: The newspapers are delighted.
- 4:19Daina Bouquin: But among the people who learn about the invention is a blind solicitor named Washington Ranger.
- 4:26Daina Bouquin: Ranger writes to Fournier d'Albe.
- 4:29Daina Bouquin: What concerns him is how a blind person might earn a living.
- 4:40Daina Bouquin: A person who can detect a window has learned something about a room.
- 4:44Daina Bouquin: But a person who can read an ordinary printed page has access to an enormous part of the working world.
- 4:52Daina Bouquin: Letters, newspapers, documents, books.
- 4:56Daina Bouquin: So Fournier d'Albe begins working on another machine.
- 5:02Daina Bouquin: By 1913, he has an experimental reading optophone.
- 5:10Daina Bouquin: The First World War interrupts his work, but he returns to it, building an instrument that turns the shapes of printed letters into sounds.
- 5:20Daina Bouquin: To understand how this machine works, imagine a capital T.
- 5:26Daina Bouquin: One upright line topped with a horizontal stroke.
- 5:32Daina Bouquin: Now imagine a tiny vertical row of lights moving slowly across that letter from left to right.
- 5:41Daina Bouquin: Each of the little lights flickers at a different rate, corresponding to a different musical note.
- 5:48Daina Bouquin: The flickering comes from a spinning disc pierced with holes laid out in concentric rings passing in front of a lamp.
- 5:58Daina Bouquin: When the light falls on white paper, it reflects back toward a selenium cell.
- 6:05Daina Bouquin: And the listener hears a chord.
- 6:08Daina Bouquin: All of the notes are on.
- 6:10Daina Bouquin: But black ink reflects much less light.
- 6:15Daina Bouquin: So when the light passes over the ink, some notes disappear.
- 6:20Daina Bouquin: So as the row of lights moves across the T, the beginning of the top stroke interrupts a note.
- 6:27Daina Bouquin: Then the vertical line interrupts the whole chord.
- 6:32Daina Bouquin: The light continues past the vertical line with only the top stroke continuing to interrupt one note.
- 6:40Daina Bouquin: A person listening through the device has to recognize the letter T by the notes that disappear.
- 6:50Daina Bouquin: It's reading by absence.
- 6:53Daina Bouquin: In the spring of 1917, Fournier d'Albe demonstrates the instrument to representatives of the National Institute for the Blind.
- 7:03Daina Bouquin: He manages to read an unfamiliar newspaper passage, but the demonstration does little to convince them.
- 7:11Daina Bouquin: This machine is slow.
- 7:14Daina Bouquin: It takes extensive training, and its practical usefulness remains uncertain.
- 7:19Daina Bouquin: And these are reasonable objections.
- 7:22Daina Bouquin: But Fournier d'Albe keeps looking for people willing to learn.
- 7:27Daina Bouquin: That year he meets 18-year-old Mary Jameson and her twin sister Margaret.
- 7:35Daina Bouquin: The sisters already know Braille, and now they begin learning the strange new system of sounds.
- 7:42Daina Bouquin: And Mary takes to it.
- 7:45Daina Bouquin: Not immediately.
- 7:47Daina Bouquin: There is nothing immediate about learning the optophone.
- 7:51Daina Bouquin: She must memorize the musical patterns of printed letters.
- 7:56Daina Bouquin: She must distinguish sounds that can be maddeningly similar.
- 8:00Daina Bouquin: And she has to manage the machine itself.
- 8:03Daina Bouquin: Page must be positioned correctly, and the mechanism must be focused.
- 8:09Daina Bouquin: The scanner must be moving at the right speed.
- 8:12Daina Bouquin: Too quickly and the letters become an unintelligible stream.
- 8:17Daina Bouquin: But too slowly and she loses track of what came before.
- 8:22Daina Bouquin: But she practices.
- 8:24Daina Bouquin: And by August 1918, she gives a demonstration at King's College in London.
- 8:32Daina Bouquin: Someone in the audience has connections to Barr and Stroud, a Scottish company known for precision optical instruments.
- 8:40Daina Bouquin: And the company agrees to build a more practical optophone.
- 8:44Daina Bouquin: The machine is sturdier with a curved glass surface on which a book can rest.
- 8:52Daina Bouquin: Its scanning mechanism moves more reliably across the page.
- 8:57Daina Bouquin: And its designers add a second Selenium cell so the machine can sound the black ink itself.
- 9:05Daina Bouquin: Now, instead of listening for the notes that disappear, Mary can listen for the notes that are there.
- 9:12Daina Bouquin: But the signals are faint.
- 9:14Daina Bouquin: And after an hour or two, the selenium cells begin crackling.
- 9:20Daina Bouquin: In June 1920, Fournier d'Albe announces in the journal Nature that the problem of opening the world's literature to blind readers has been solved.
- 9:33Daina Bouquin: It is a remarkable claim and entirely premature.
- 9:40Daina Bouquin: The Optophone is expensive.
- 9:43Daina Bouquin: It remains difficult to operate, and it demands an enormous investment of time.
- 9:50Daina Bouquin: Mary knows this better than anyone.
- 9:54Daina Bouquin: By now she is its most accomplished reader.
- 9:57Daina Bouquin: She travels to demonstrations and exhibitions, showing audiences what the machine can do.
- 10:04Daina Bouquin: And she is also helping to design it.
- 10:07Daina Bouquin: At Bar and Stroud's London branch, she works with an engineer named A.
- 10:13Daina Bouquin: M.
- 10:13Daina Bouquin: Lundie.
- 10:14Daina Bouquin: She suggests changes to the musical notes so that certain letters are easier to tell apart.
- 10:20Daina Bouquin: She asks for stronger signals to hear over the noise of the mechanism itself.
- 10:26Daina Bouquin: She works with Lundie on a device that moves between lines and on a feature for reading italic type.
- 10:34Daina Bouquin: She teaches other blind people how to use it.
- 10:38Daina Bouquin: And her speed keeps climbing.
- 10:41Daina Bouquin: From one word per minute to 25, then 40, then 60.
- 10:49Daina Bouquin: She is doing the labor of a developer and a public ambassador, but she is doing it informally.
- 10:56Daina Bouquin: So her father, Thomas Jameson, writes to Barr and Stroud.
- 11:00Daina Bouquin: He wants the company to recognize her vital work with proper compensation and a formal place.
- 11:06Daina Bouquin: Barr and Stroud pays Mary for individual demonstrations, but never gives her regular employment.
- 11:14Daina Bouquin: Still, she keeps working.
- 11:18Daina Bouquin: And in 1921, Mary sits down to read a novel.
- 11:23Daina Bouquin: It is The Warden by Anthony Trollope.
- 11:27Daina Bouquin: Published in 1855, it tells the story of a kindly clergyman caught in a dispute over money at a charitable institution.
- 11:36Daina Bouquin: Mary places the book on the Optophone.
- 11:41Daina Bouquin: She finds the first line and she begins to read.
- 11:47Daina Bouquin: She no longer labors over individual sounds.
- 11:51Daina Bouquin: Familiar patterns begin to come together.
- 11:55Daina Bouquin: And she starts to notice something.
- 11:58Daina Bouquin: The more she reads a particular author, the easier it becomes to anticipate what comes next.
- 12:05Daina Bouquin: A writer has habits, certain turns of phrase.
- 12:10Daina Bouquin: But when she begins a book by someone new, the work becomes harder again.
- 12:15Daina Bouquin: So she deliberately decides to read writers who differ widely in style.
- 12:21Daina Bouquin: She reads Nathaniel Hawthorne's The Scarlet Letter, an autobiography by Herman Charles Merivale, and others.
- 12:31Daina Bouquin: And she finishes The Warden.
- 12:33Daina Bouquin: But even as Mary becomes more proficient, the future of the Optophone is becoming less certain.
- 12:40Daina Bouquin: Most people who try it never approach her speed, and few schools can afford one.
- 12:46Daina Bouquin: Braille is already established, reliable, and widely taught.
- 12:52Daina Bouquin: By 1922, Barr and Stroud is doubting whether there will ever be enough customers.
- 12:58Daina Bouquin: By 1928, the company has stopped pushing the machines.
- 13:03Daina Bouquin: Fournier d'Albe dies in 1933.
- 13:08Daina Bouquin: Only a small number of Optophones have been sold.
- 13:12Daina Bouquin: But Mary Jameson keeps reading.
- 13:17Daina Bouquin: In 1944, the organization St. Dunstan's takes up the British Optophone and replaces the old selenium cells with photoelectric cells that are much louder. In the 1950s, a man named W. K. Hill improves the focusing, making it easier to tell similar letters apart. Mary tests the changes. Meanwhile, across the Atlantic, engineers at RCA are building a machine that tries to identify the printed characters itself. The effort is led in part by Vladimir Zworykin, a man who had examined Fournier d'Albe's Optophones decades earlier. RCA's work is an early step toward what we now call optical character recognition.
- 14:11Daina Bouquin: The task of deciphering the page is beginning to move from the person into the machine.
- 14:19Daina Bouquin: It is 1966.
- 14:26Daina Bouquin: Nearly 50 years have passed since Mary first sat down with the Optophone.
- 14:35Daina Bouquin: She records a presentation for a conference on reading machines in the United States.
- 14:41Daina Bouquin: She remembers the delicate early machine.
- 14:46Daina Bouquin: But most of her talk concerns the machines being built now.
- 14:50Daina Bouquin: She's still asking questions to improve listening devices.
- 14:55Daina Bouquin: She wonders which notes are easier to distinguish and which letters are harder to recognize.
- 15:03Daina Bouquin: In the years that follow Mary's presentation, she exchanges letters and tape recordings with blind Americans working on newer machines.
- 15:12Daina Bouquin: One of them, Harvey Lauer of the United States Veterans Administration, sends her a device called a visotoner.
- 15:21Daina Bouquin: It's smaller and more portable than her old Optophone, but it is hard to keep aligned with the text and it struggles with certain colors of ink.
- 15:30Daina Bouquin: She weighs the two machines.
- 15:33Daina Bouquin: She knows what she likes about her old one and she knows what she wishes it could do.
- 15:38Daina Bouquin: She knows what it already does.
- 15:43Mary Jameson (archival audio): The Optophone is as much a part of my everyday life as the typewriter or telephone.
- 15:49Mary Jameson (archival audio): Sometimes the print is too big for the Optophone array.
- 15:54Mary Jameson (archival audio): At others, italics are too sloping.
- 15:57Mary Jameson (archival audio): While noting the shortcomings of the Optophone, I can use the valuable facilities it already gives.
- 16:06Mary Jameson (archival audio): I hope this situation makes me of use in solving vital print reading problems which remain.
- 16:16Daina Bouquin: Mary Jameson passes away in 1980.
- 16:20Daina Bouquin: By then the Optophone belongs to an earlier age.
- 16:25Daina Bouquin: Computers will soon recognize printed letters on their own and read them out loud.
- 16:30Daina Bouquin: But there is a photograph of Mary, taken decades earlier.
- 16:36Daina Bouquin: She is seated at an Optophone reading The Warden.
- 16:41Daina Bouquin: She wears a pair of telephone receivers over her ears.
- 16:46Daina Bouquin: The book rests on the machine in front of her.
- 16:50Daina Bouquin: Somewhere inside a disc is spinning and light is falling across the printed page.
- 16:58Daina Bouquin: And the machine is making its little collection of sounds.
- 17:02Daina Bouquin: Mary knows what they say.
- 17:06Daina Bouquin: I'm Daina Bouquin and this is Found in the Machine.
- 17:13Daina Bouquin: If you enjoy my stories, consider passing them along or leaving a rating or a review wherever you listen.
- 17:25Daina Bouquin: And if you'd like to support the show, you can go to found in the machine.com/ support, and you can find our Patreon and other ways to support the show.
- 17:36Daina Bouquin: The most recent bonus episode received by Patreon members was about the twenty thirty-eight problem.
- 17:42Daina Bouquin: Thanks for listening, guys.