Latest / The Psychology Undergrad Podcast / Self-Esteem & Self-Concept: How You Build Your Sense of Self
Transcript
- 0:00Have you ever noticed how you act completely
- 0:03differently when you catch your own reflection
- 0:06in a window or a mirror or something? Oh yeah,
- 0:08like instantly. Stand up straight or check your
- 0:10hair. Right, exactly. But it turns out that reflection
- 0:14doesn't just show your face. It literally forces
- 0:18you to act more morally, which is wild. Anyway.
- 0:21Welcome to the Psychology Undergrad. Pull up
- 0:23your chair, guys. We've got our iced coffees,
- 0:26our highlighters, and we are like elbow deep
- 0:29in the assigned reading for today. Yeah, if you
- 0:31are sitting here in the campus library with us
- 0:33right now, you definitely know the struggle.
- 0:36Today, we are doing a deep dive into chapter
- 0:39three of our textbook, which is all about the
- 0:42self. A super light and easy topic, obviously.
- 0:44Oh, yeah. Incredibly simple. But I mean, trying
- 0:46to figure out your self -concept is basically
- 0:48like trying to pick a major, you know, but for
- 0:50your entire personality. That is honestly the
- 0:52best way to put it. Right. It is just so overwhelming.
- 0:55It's constantly shifting based on who you hang
- 0:57out with. And like, everybody else seems to have
- 0:59an appa - on what you should do with it. It really
- 1:02is a massive undertaking for a single chapter.
- 1:06So to make sense of it without getting completely
- 1:08lost in the weeds, we're going to look at three
- 1:10core dimensions today. Okay, break it down for
- 1:12us. So first, how we cognitively map out who
- 1:16we are. Second, how we evaluate our worth. And
- 1:19finally, how the people around us literally construct
- 1:23our identities. So let's start at the foundation
- 1:25with the cognitive map. We all remember that
- 1:28classic Gallup mirror test from Psych 101, right?
- 1:31Oh, a chimp one. Yeah. Where the researchers
- 1:33anesthetize chimpanzees, paint a red dot on their
- 1:36foreheads, and just put a mirror in the cage.
- 1:38Right. And when the chimps wake up and look in
- 1:40the glass, they immediately touch their own forehead.
- 1:44Exactly. They have that baseline realization
- 1:45of, like, I am me. Whereas dogs and cats just
- 1:49think there's a really good -looking rival living
- 1:50in the glass. True. But chapter three takes that
- 1:54baseline. and ask a much harder question. Which
- 1:56is? Like, once we know we exist, how do we organize
- 2:00all the messy, totally contradictory information
- 2:02about who we actually are? Yeah, and that organization
- 2:05system is what the text calls the self -concept.
- 2:08Right. It's the entire overarching belief system
- 2:11you hold about your traits, your physical features,
- 2:14your goals, and your social roles. But your brain
- 2:20doesn't just throw all that into one giant pile,
- 2:22thankfully. It organizes it into self -schemas.
- 2:26Yeah, so you have a highly specific schema for
- 2:28your academic abilities. Yeah. And then a completely
- 2:31different one for your physical appearance, and
- 2:33another one for how you act at a party. The textbook
- 2:35uses a pretty standard analogy here. It suggests
- 2:38thinking of the self -concept as this giant mental
- 2:40filing cabinet located right behind your forehead.
- 2:43Like in the prefrontal cortex. Exactly. And the
- 2:46self -chemas are the individual manila folders
- 2:48inside. You've got a folder labeled student,
- 2:50another labeled athlete, maybe one labeled loyal
- 2:53friend. But honestly, that feels a bit too static
- 2:55to me. Really? How so? Given how fast we switch
- 2:59between personalities, it feels more like a social
- 3:01media recommendation algorithm. Oh, that's a
- 3:04good way to think about it. Yeah, like the brain
- 3:06constantly monitors the environment and dynamically
- 3:09pulls up whichever folder is most relevant to
- 3:11help us survive the moment. That algorithm analogy
- 3:14actually tracks perfectly with how the brain
- 3:16filters reality. I mean your brain is bombarded
- 3:19with millions of bits of data every single day.
- 3:21It really is. It needs a brutal, highly efficient
- 3:25sorting mechanism to decide what to keep. Right,
- 3:28and the text highlights a study by Rogers demonstrating
- 3:31the self -reference effect, which shows exactly
- 3:34how this sorting works. Oh, that one perfectly
- 3:36shows the filter in action. Yeah, so they gave
- 3:38college students a list of 40 adjectives. Some
- 3:41were asked to process the word structurally,
- 3:44like checking if the word was written in uppercase
- 3:46letters. And others just checked to see if it
- 3:48rhymed with another word. Right, and the final
- 3:51group was simply asked to decide if the adjective
- 3:53described them personally. Wait, let me guess
- 3:55the outcome. The students who related the words
- 3:58to themselves remembered vastly more adjectives
- 4:00than anyone else. Way more. Significantly more.
- 4:04When you process information in relation to yourself,
- 4:07it gets deeply embedded in your memory network.
- 4:10Because the self folder is the most robust, highly
- 4:13accessible schema you possess. But like here
- 4:16is where it gets really interesting and honestly
- 4:19a little unsettling. Okay, hit me. If our memory
- 4:22is so heavily biased by the self -reference effect,
- 4:25does that mean we are all inherently selfish
- 4:27learners who only care about a subject if it's
- 4:29about us? I see what you're saying. It definitely
- 4:32looks like narcissism, but it's really just about
- 4:35evolutionary survival. Survival. How does remembering
- 4:39adjectives help us survive? Well, for our hunter
- 4:42-gatherer ancestors, cognitive resources were
- 4:45scarce. If a piece of information connects to
- 4:48your self -schema, the brain assumes it directly
- 4:50impacts your survival. Oh, so it flags it as
- 4:53critical for your resources or your standing
- 4:55in the tribe. Exactly. If it doesn't relate to
- 4:58you, the brain just discards it to save energy.
- 5:00Okay, so we have this powerful algorithmic filing
- 5:03cabinet that prioritizes our own survival. But
- 5:07does that cabinet look the same for everyone
- 5:09across the globe? Definitely not. The textbook
- 5:12brings up the 20 statements test, or the TST.
- 5:15to show how culture completely rewrites the code
- 5:18for these folders. I love that test. It's incredibly
- 5:21simple. It really is. It's literally just a piece
- 5:24of paper that says, I am, followed by a blank
- 5:27line repeated 20 times. And the TST is just a
- 5:30brilliant window into cultural psychology. Yeah,
- 5:33when researchers give this test to people from
- 5:36Western individualistic cultures like the US
- 5:38or Canada, they answer in a very specific way.
- 5:42Right, they almost exclusively fill in the blanks
- 5:44with internal, unique traits. They write, I am
- 5:47friendly, I am ambitious, or I am athletic. Because
- 5:51their self -concept is built on how they stand
- 5:53apart from the crowd. But when you give the exact
- 5:56same test to people from Eastern, collectivistic
- 5:59cultures, the entire framework shifts. Yeah,
- 6:02they focus heavily on social roles and relationships
- 6:05instead. Exactly. They write, I am a sister,
- 6:07or I am a student of this university. Their identity
- 6:10doesn't exist in a vacuum. Right. It is fundamentally
- 6:13intertwined with their community. And this cultural
- 6:15programming drives actual measurable behavior.
- 6:19Oh, like that Penn study by Kim and Marcus. Yes.
- 6:22They went to the San Francisco Airport waiting
- 6:23area and asked people of different cultural backgrounds
- 6:26to fill out a quick survey. And as a thank you
- 6:28for their time, the researcher offered them a
- 6:31pen. Right, they would hold out a handful of
- 6:34five pens. Four of them were green, and one was
- 6:37orange. Let me predict this based on the TST
- 6:40results. Go for it. The European Americans intentionally
- 6:43grabbed the orange pen to assert their uniqueness,
- 6:46while the Asian Americans grabbed the green pen
- 6:49to blend in. That was exactly what the data showed.
- 6:51Wow, that is wild. Yeah, European Americans...
- 6:54overwhelmingly chose the rare pen color. Their
- 6:58cultural self -concept rewards standing out.
- 7:00While the Asian Americans significantly preferred
- 7:03the common pen color because their culture prioritizes
- 7:06harmony. Exactly. At a neural level, choosing
- 7:10the unique pen might actually trigger a sense
- 7:12of being abrasive or antisocial for someone whose
- 7:15self -schema is built around group cohesion.
- 7:18So, since we are building these complex filing
- 7:20cabinets filled with cultural programming, what
- 7:23happens when the system gets messy? Or when you
- 7:25open too many folders at once, right? Exactly.
- 7:27The text introduces self -complexity and self
- 7:30-concept clarity here. Let's try another tech
- 7:32analogy to make sense of it. I am all about the
- 7:35tech analogies today. Think of self -complexity
- 7:37like having multiple browser tabs open on your
- 7:39laptop. OK, I can visualize that. If your identity
- 7:42is 100 % tied up in being a soccer player, meaning
- 7:47you only have one single tab open and you tear
- 7:50your ACL, your whole browser crashes. Oh, wow.
- 7:53Yeah, you lose your entire sense of self. Right.
- 7:56But if you have high self -complexity of 20 tabs
- 7:59open, you're a soccer player, but you're also
- 8:01a musician, a sibling. a debate team member.
- 8:05So an injury just closes one tab. Exactly. It
- 8:08hurts, but the rest of your identity is fine.
- 8:10The operating system keeps running. That makes
- 8:13so much sense. High self -complexity acts as
- 8:16a profound cognitive buffer against depression
- 8:18and stress. Because you aren't putting all your
- 8:21psychological eggs in one basket. Exactly. Self
- 8:24-concept clarity, however, is a slightly different
- 8:26metric. How so? That is about how clearly and
- 8:29consistently those tabs are defined over time.
- 8:31You might only have three tabs open, but if you
- 8:34know exactly what they are and they never contradict
- 8:35each other, you have high clarity. And I'm assuming
- 8:38both high complexity and high clarity are strongly
- 8:41linked to better mental health. Yeah, absolutely.
- 8:43But even with a perfectly organized browser,
- 8:46there are moments you are forced to look at all
- 8:49your tabs at once. Right, which the text calls
- 8:52self -awareness. And it introduces a rather painful
- 8:55idea called self -discrepancy theory. Oh, this
- 8:57one is brutal. It posits that we all carry around
- 9:00an actual self, who we currently are, and an
- 9:04ideal self, who we wish we were. And most of
- 9:06the time, we avoid thinking about the gap between
- 9:09the two. Naturally. But when we become cutely
- 9:12self -aware, like when we catch a reflection
- 9:14in a mirror or hear our own voice on a recording,
- 9:17we are forced to compare them. Right, and when
- 9:19the actual self doesn't match the ideal self,
- 9:21it triggers genuine psychological distress. We
- 9:24feel anxiety, guilt, or just profound disappointment.
- 9:28And because the human brain completely disguises
- 9:30psychological distress, it aggressively looks
- 9:33for escape hatches. Which brings us to self -affirmation
- 9:36theory. Let's say you completely bomb a statistics
- 9:39midterm, and your ideal self is a straight A
- 9:42student. That's a massive discrepancy right there.
- 9:45Yeah, so you will naturally try to reduce that
- 9:47distress by affirming your worth in a totally
- 9:50unrelated area. You tell yourself, well, I might
- 9:53be terrible at math, but I am an incredibly loyal
- 9:56friend and a talented artist. Why does that actually
- 9:59work? Like, how does being a good friend magically
- 10:01fix a failing grade? It helps to view your ego
- 10:05or your self -worth as a finite bank account.
- 10:08Okay, tracking. When you fail the math test,
- 10:10you take a massive emotional withdrawal. You
- 10:13are suddenly in danger of your overall psychological
- 10:16state going bankrupt. Ah, so self -affirmation
- 10:19acts as an emergency transfer of funds from a
- 10:21different account. Precisely. You remind yourself
- 10:24of your high value in an unrelated area to get
- 10:27your total network back into the positive, staving
- 10:29off that psychological distress. So we balance
- 10:31the emotional books, but what happens when that
- 10:34self -awareness is forced upon us physically?
- 10:36You mean the mirror studies? Yeah, the studies
- 10:38showing that people act more morally when simply
- 10:41priced in front of a mirror. They are absolutely
- 10:43fascinating. It really is wild. If a piece of
- 10:45glass makes us eat healthier and cheat less on
- 10:47tests, does that imply our morality is just like
- 10:50performance art? It raises a pretty heavy philosophical
- 10:53question about human nature, honestly. For real.
- 10:56Psychologically, the mirror triggers acute, unavoidable
- 11:00self -awareness. It makes your ideal self, which
- 11:05presumably includes being an honest, upstanding
- 11:08person, highly accessible in your working memory.
- 11:11Because you are literally watching yourself.
- 11:13So you hold yourself to a higher standard to
- 11:15avoid the distress of discrepancy. Exactly. You
- 11:17don't want to watch yourself be a bad person.
- 11:19But the dark inverse of this phenomenon is what
- 11:22sociologists call de -individuation. Which is
- 11:26the complete loss of individual self -awareness
- 11:28and individual accountability. Right. Usually
- 11:30because you are submerged in a crowd or your
- 11:33identity is physically hidden somehow. Yep. When
- 11:36you remove the mirror and blur the individual
- 11:38into the anonymous group, that psychological
- 11:40distress of self -discrepancy completely vanishes.
- 11:43And the textbook provides several purely sociological
- 11:46and psychological examples of how this dissolves
- 11:49our moral standards. It does. A very common example
- 11:53is children wearing masks on Halloween. Studies
- 11:56show they're far more likely to break rules and
- 11:58steal extra candy simply because their identity
- 12:01is concealed. The text also examines the behaviors
- 12:04of the Ku Klux Klan as an extreme historical
- 12:07example of this. Right, noting objectively how
- 12:10members hid their identities under white hoods.
- 12:12Yeah, it strategically stripped away individual
- 12:15accountability, which allowed them to commit
- 12:17acts they might not commit if their faces were
- 12:19visible and their self -awareness was active.
- 12:22The book also references Gustave Le Bon's early
- 12:25theories on crowd psychology, explaining how
- 12:27individuals in a riot become submerged in the
- 12:30group identity. Exactly. They lose their self
- 12:32-control and engage in antisocial behaviors because
- 12:35they are anonymous. Even something as common
- 12:38as leaving a massive pile of garbage at a music
- 12:40festival is a form of de -individuation. Yeah.
- 12:43Looking at this objectively through the lens
- 12:45of psychological data, the mechanism is identical
- 12:48across all these scenarios. When you are just
- 12:50an anonymous part of the crowd, the rules of
- 12:52the actual self just don't feel like they apply
- 12:55anymore. The ego is no longer monitoring its
- 12:58bank account, the gap between actual and ideal
- 13:01self dissolves, and people become highly willing
- 13:05to violate mainstream social norms without feeling
- 13:08a shred of guilt. So we desperately need the
- 13:12mirror to keep us in check. and maintain our
- 13:15moral compass. But most of the time, we don't
- 13:17have a literal mirror in front of us. Right.
- 13:19So we use the people around us instead. Which
- 13:22brings us to the concept of the looking glass
- 13:24self. This was proposed by Charles Cooley way
- 13:27back in 1902. The fundamental idea. is that a
- 13:31massive portion of how we see ourselves comes
- 13:33directly from our perception of how others see
- 13:36us. We basically rely on our social environment
- 13:39to construct our internal reality. The Baldwin
- 13:41and Holmes study is a perfect illustration of
- 13:44this. Oh, the one with the fiction reading. Yeah,
- 13:46because it proves we don't even need the people
- 13:47to actually be in the room to feel their judgment.
- 13:50Right. They had women read a piece of fiction
- 13:52with heavy sexual content and then rate how enjoyable
- 13:55it was. But before they read it, they were primed
- 13:57to visualize specific people. Okay, how so? Half
- 14:00the women were asked to vividly picture the faces
- 14:03of two older family members, like their grandparents,
- 14:06and the other half visualized two college acquaintances.
- 14:10The results were striking, weren't they? Yeah.
- 14:13The women who visualized their older family members
- 14:15rated the story as significantly less enjoyable
- 14:18than the women who visualized their college friends.
- 14:21Wow. So just the imagined presence of a specific
- 14:24social audience fundamentally changed how they
- 14:27evaluated their own internal feelings. Exactly.
- 14:30They were looking at themselves through the imagined
- 14:33looking glass of their grandparents versus their
- 14:36peers. Evolutionarily, this is just another survival
- 14:39mechanism, right? To stay safe in a tribe, you
- 14:41constantly need to anticipate how the group evaluates
- 14:44your behavior, even when they aren't looking.
- 14:47Precisely. We don't just imagine what they think.
- 14:49We actively and aggressively compare ourselves
- 14:51to them. Right, which the text breaks down into
- 14:54downward and upward social comparison. Do you
- 14:56have a good undergrad analogy for this one? Oh,
- 14:58definitely. Downward comparison is glancing at
- 15:01the kid in the back of the lecture hall who slept
- 15:03through the entire midterm, so you feel like
- 15:06an absolute genius for pulling off a C -. It
- 15:08is painfully accurate. It is a calculated strategy
- 15:11to boost your own self -esteem by finding someone
- 15:14worse off. And upward comparison. That is looking
- 15:17at the curve breaker, who finished the test in
- 15:1920 minutes, and suddenly you're staring at your
- 15:22desk feeling like you need to rethink your entire
- 15:24major. Yeah, upward comparison almost always
- 15:27causes negative emotions, like envy or feeling
- 15:30profoundly inadequate. Though occasionally it
- 15:32can motivate us to improve, right? Sometimes,
- 15:35yeah. But the textbook brings this concept crashing
- 15:37into our modern reality with social media. Oh,
- 15:40man. With billions of users on platforms like
- 15:44Facebook and Instagram, we are now living our
- 15:46social lives entirely online. We are constantly
- 15:49exposed to the highly curated, perfectly edited
- 15:52highlight reels of everyone else's lives. Which
- 15:54triggers this relentless, exhausting cycle of
- 15:57upward social comparison. The book also dives
- 16:00into MMOs, massively multiplayer online games
- 16:04like World of Warcraft. Right, where players
- 16:07get to design avatars to represent themselves
- 16:10in these virtual worlds. And research shows that
- 16:12gamers almost universally design avatars that
- 16:16match their ideal selves, not their actual selves.
- 16:19So they make them taller, stronger, and more
- 16:21conventionally attractive. Exactly. And this
- 16:24phenomenon is especially prevalent among players
- 16:27who struggle with low actual self -esteem in
- 16:30the real world. Because the virtual world offers
- 16:32a frictionless space freed from physical constraints
- 16:35where the looking glass reflects back exactly
- 16:38what they want to see. But the psychological
- 16:40toll can be heavy. You are essentially outsourcing
- 16:43your self -esteem to an environment that isn't
- 16:45real. widening the discrepancy when you finally
- 16:48have to log off. Which means we aren't just looking
- 16:50in the mirror, we are actively manipulating what
- 16:53it reflects. Because we care so deeply about
- 16:55how we compare to others, we actively manage
- 16:58our image, which the text calls self -presentation.
- 17:01It is pure reputation management aimed at increasing
- 17:04our social status. But we aren't all equally
- 17:06good at it, nor are we equally motivated to do
- 17:09it. Right, which introduces a fascinating individual
- 17:12difference variable known as self -monitoring.
- 17:14High self -monitors are like the ultimate social
- 17:17chameleons. They really are. They walk into a
- 17:19room, instantly read the social cues, figure
- 17:22out what people want, and themelessly adjust
- 17:24their behavior to fit in and be liked. And low
- 17:27self -monitors are the exact opposite. They act
- 17:30on their internal convictions regardless of the
- 17:32audience. Yeah. If they hate the music playing
- 17:34at a party, They're going to say it loudly, even
- 17:37if everyone else is having a great time dancing.
- 17:39There is a brilliant study on this by Chang and
- 17:42Chartrand focusing on unconscious mimicry. Oh,
- 17:45I remember this one. Yeah, they had college students
- 17:47interact one -on -one with an actor working for
- 17:50the researchers. During the interaction, the
- 17:52actor would subtly touch her own face. Because
- 17:55the researchers wanted to observe if the student
- 17:57would unconsciously mimic the behavior. Exactly.
- 18:01The twist in the methodology was that before
- 18:03the meeting, some students were told the actor
- 18:06was going to be the leader of an upcoming task.
- 18:09And others were told she was just a worker. Right.
- 18:12The researchers found that high self -monitors
- 18:14unconsciously mimicked the face -touching behavior
- 18:17much more frequently but specifically when they
- 18:20believed the actor was the leader. They were
- 18:22subconsciously aligning themselves with the person
- 18:25holding the power to gain social approval. While
- 18:28low self -monitors didn't show this variation,
- 18:31they barely mimicked the actor regardless of
- 18:34her supposed status. So what do you make of that?
- 18:37Well, it makes me wonder, like, does this mean
- 18:39high self -monitors are just being fake and manipulative,
- 18:42essentially lying to the people around them?
- 18:44What's her question? Or is this a necessary evolutionary
- 18:47survival skill for navigating something as complex
- 18:50as a college campus or a corporate office? It
- 18:53is very easy to judge high self -monitors as
- 18:56fake. But from a psychological standpoint, the
- 18:59textbook suggests it is a highly adaptive form
- 19:01of social intelligence. That makes sense. Humans
- 19:04survive by maintaining group harmony and securing
- 19:07their place in the social hierarchy. Exactly.
- 19:10Being able to fluidly read cues and adjust your
- 19:12behavior isn't inherently malicious, it's social
- 19:15glue. It only becomes dangerous if the discrepancy
- 19:19between the chameleon behavior and the true internal
- 19:22self becomes too massive. Right, which leads
- 19:25straight back to the severe psychological distress
- 19:28we talked about earlier. Well, as we wrap up
- 19:30our review of this chapter, the text offers a
- 19:33genuinely comforting concept for anyone who spends
- 19:36too much time stressing over their self -presentation.
- 19:39Oh, the illusion of transparency. I love this
- 19:41one. It is the psychological finding that we
- 19:44vastly overestimate how much people are paying
- 19:47attention to us. And how accurately they can
- 19:50read our internal emotional states. Because our
- 19:53own self -concept is so highly accessible to
- 19:56us, like, we are literally always in our own
- 19:58heads. We egocentrically assume everyone else
- 20:01is hyper -focused on us too. But they aren't.
- 20:03They're entirely too busy digging through their
- 20:06own mental filing cabinets worrying about their
- 20:08own discrepancies. Exactly. When you make an
- 20:11awkward comment in a group, you might agonize
- 20:13over it for a week, but research shows nobody
- 20:15else really noticed and they definitely aren't
- 20:17thinking about it later. The overarching theme
- 20:19of Chapter 3 is really that the self is never
- 20:22created in isolation. It is a constant ongoing
- 20:25negotiation between your internal cognition,
- 20:28your emotional evaluations, and the complex social
- 20:31situations you find yourself in. So let's summarize
- 20:34the ultimate psychology undergrad study guide
- 20:37for this chapter. Right. We started with the
- 20:39cognitive filing cabinet, learning how the self
- 20:42-concept organizes our world and how deeply culture
- 20:45dictates the folders inside. Then we weighed
- 20:48the heavy moral implications of self -awareness.
- 20:51Seeing how mirrors keep us honest and how the
- 20:53anonymity of crowds can make us lose our compass
- 20:56entirely. And finally, we saw how the social
- 20:59looking glass, through comparisons and self -monitoring,
- 21:02shapes our daily interactions. It is a lot of
- 21:04material, but it all connects back to that central
- 21:07drive to understand who we are in relation to
- 21:09the pack. The most practical takeaway for your
- 21:11daily life on campus is definitely this. The
- 21:14next time you trip on the stairs in the library
- 21:17or spill your iced coffee in the middle of a
- 21:19crowded dining hall, rely on the illusion of
- 21:22transparency. Exactly. Take a deep breath. Nobody
- 21:24is watching you as closely as you are watching
- 21:26yourself. That is a very scientifically backed
- 21:28reason to finally relax. But before we pack up
- 21:31our highlighters and head out, I want to leave
- 21:33you with a final, lingering question to ponder.
- 21:36Oh, a thought experiment. Yeah. We talked about
- 21:39MMO gamers and social media users meticulously
- 21:42curating these ideal, flawless digital avatars.
- 21:46Right. If we spend all our time cultivating these
- 21:49frictionless, perfectly edited digital versions
- 21:52of ourselves... What happens to our tolerance
- 21:55for the messy, flawed, highly complex actual
- 21:58selves we have to live with offline? There's
- 22:00a deep one. Will we eventually prefer the mirror
- 22:02of the screen to the reality of the looking glass?
- 22:05Definitely something to ponder before the midterm.
- 22:07Good luck with your studying.