Latest / Science Behind the Glass: illuminating the human side / Why the Human Brain Evolves Best Together with Dr Mark Williams
Transcript
- 0:01Who are the characters behind science? This is
- 0:04Science Behind the Glass, illuminating the human
- 0:07side. In this podcast, we unveil the human side
- 0:11of laboratories and science. Scientists share
- 0:14personal experiences and we discuss their meanings
- 0:17from different perspectives and fields of research.
- 0:31Welcome to Science Behind the Glass, where we
- 0:33explore the profound intersection of science
- 0:35and humanity. Today, We are joined by a revolutionary
- 0:39thinker, Dr. Mark Williams, whose life and work
- 0:43break long -held myths about the human brain
- 0:46and will offer a blueprint for a kinder, more
- 0:48connected future. Dr. Mark is an international
- 0:52neuroscientist with over 25 years of experience
- 0:55in behavioral and brain imaging research focusing
- 0:58on social skills. He has published more than
- 1:0270 scientific papers and work at MIT in the USA
- 1:07and multiple universities in Australia. He is
- 1:10co -director of BrainCamp, a neuroscience program
- 1:14for kids where he translates complex science
- 1:16into transformative action, providing educators
- 1:21with tools to replace outdated practices like
- 1:24ranking students. He's also the author of the
- 1:27bestseller book, The Connected Species, How the
- 1:31Evolution of the Brain Can Save the World. Today,
- 1:35we are diving into one of the most complex organs
- 1:38in the animal kingdom, the human brain. But to
- 1:42truly understand it, we have to go behind physiology
- 1:45and anatomy. We need to ask what this organ has
- 1:50made possible, from brain -baking technological
- 1:52advances to deep social risks we are still trying
- 1:56to heal. Mark, it's a pleasure having you here.
- 1:59Thank you for accepting this invitation. Thank
- 2:03you for having me, Linda. It's great to be here.
- 2:04So, can you tell us a little bit how your background
- 2:08shaped the person that you are today and how
- 2:12this has influenced your neuroscience studies
- 2:15and the path that you have taken? That's a very
- 2:20big question to start off with. I actually grew
- 2:24up in a fairly small country town in Victoria,
- 2:28in Australia. and I wasn't very academic at all
- 2:32actually to begin with. My mother had mental
- 2:34health issues and I avoided school. The town
- 2:38had very high unemployment and so I and back
- 2:42then we had corporal punishment so you'd get
- 2:43the strap or the cane if you did anything wrong.
- 2:46So myself and my friends used to try and avoid
- 2:48that by going down to the lake and fishing and
- 2:51smoking pot most of the time. So when I was 15
- 2:55I was told by my principal I'd be dead or in
- 2:57prison by the time I was 25. and I should leave
- 3:01school and get an apprenticeship at the local
- 3:03abattoir. And so I didn't really like school
- 3:06at all and didn't think I was very intelligent.
- 3:09Until I was 25 and two of my friends had drug
- 3:13overdoses and I decided I needed to go back to
- 3:16school and do something different with my life.
- 3:19And so I did, and there was a physics teacher
- 3:21there at the TAFE, basically the college that
- 3:24I went to, to do my HSC, to do my final year.
- 3:27and he convinced me that I should go to university.
- 3:31We sort of bonded over records, you know, back
- 3:34then we had records, black vinyl records and
- 3:37I used to collect them and so did he and we sort
- 3:39of bonded over that and then he, yeah, convinced
- 3:42me that I was more intelligent than I was. So
- 3:44I went back, I did a Bachelor of Science and
- 3:46I majored in psychology because I wanted to learn
- 3:50why I was as messed up as I was and members of
- 3:53my family were as messed up as they were and
- 3:55I... I also did a major in physiology because
- 3:58I was really interested in who we are as humans.
- 4:04And so I was lucky enough, I got into a special
- 4:07strain, which was that neurophysiology strain,
- 4:09which was a select group of students and sort
- 4:13of took off from there. I then did a PhD in medicine
- 4:16and ended up getting a fancy fellowship to go
- 4:19to MIT and work at MIT for a number of years,
- 4:22which was amazing. But yeah, I really just fell
- 4:24in love with. understanding who we are as humans
- 4:27and how our brains have evolved. Wow, that's
- 4:31amazing. You have collective experiences and
- 4:35mentors and it's so important to highlight that,
- 4:38like the mentors in life. I think that for me
- 4:40it was important that my school teacher that
- 4:43was a biologist, actually he was living like
- 4:46breadcrumbs to try to understand biology and
- 4:51cosmos. that serious at that time. But it's amazing
- 4:56what you have done, Mark, and all the decisions
- 4:59that you have taken. And especially understand
- 5:02the brain and why we take decisions and how we
- 5:05get influenced by others, especially. And something
- 5:09that has been very interesting, well, at least
- 5:11for me, is that we always oversimplify the concept
- 5:14of natural selection. And then there's like harshest
- 5:19phrases that says like a... people only associate
- 5:23Darwin with only the strongest survive or life
- 5:27is brutal competition or the weak should be left
- 5:30behind but this is not natural selection and
- 5:34and this is not what natural selection is it
- 5:37about it's not about the strength or domination
- 5:40but about adaptability and the evolution doesn't
- 5:43aim for progress It is simply a response to changing
- 5:46environments. And in fact, traits like cooperation,
- 5:50caregiving, and empathy can be just as important
- 5:53as a physical strength or speed. And human evolution,
- 5:57in particular, has been deeply shaped by our
- 6:01ability to live in groups and share together
- 6:04and have this communication and help and care
- 6:08for each other. In your book, The Connected Species,
- 6:12you argue that our brain didn't evolve through
- 6:15competition, but through connection. Could you
- 6:19please explain how that works neurologically
- 6:23in beautiful and simple words? Which one are
- 6:26those brain structures that work? How is the
- 6:28network? How the changes that support this idea?
- 6:32Yeah, so when you think about it, like us as
- 6:37humans, we became the alpha species on this planet
- 6:40Earth. I don't think there's any argument about
- 6:42that. We've taken over. every continent on planet
- 6:46Earth, which no other animals managed to do,
- 6:48and we're now changing the environment, doing
- 6:50all sorts of things. But we weren't actually
- 6:53the most likely species to do that, when you
- 6:56think about it, because we're not the strongest
- 6:58species on this planet Earth. Lots of species
- 7:01are much stronger than us. We're not the fastest
- 7:03species. There's lots of fast, you know, much
- 7:06faster animals out there that would take us down.
- 7:08We couldn't outrun a lion or a tiger or anything.
- 7:10And we don't actually have the largest brain.
- 7:12There's lots of animals that have much larger
- 7:14brains than ours and much more complex brains
- 7:16than ours. So, you know, you have to ask, why
- 7:19did we become the species that we became, the
- 7:22selfish species? And it was through collaboration.
- 7:24It was through our ability to actually communicate
- 7:27with each other and to support each other. to
- 7:30empathize with each other and to want to help
- 7:33each other that we ended up where we actually
- 7:36are. And so we selected for empathy. We selected
- 7:40for, you know, we as humans, there's areas of
- 7:42our brain that activate just to touch, for example.
- 7:47So when we get touch on our skin, there's C fibers
- 7:50that only activate the touch. and they they release,
- 7:53activate an area of our brain that releases oxytocin
- 7:56that makes us feel more connected to the person
- 7:59that we to just touched us and that's the only
- 8:01reason they're there is to actually connect us
- 8:04with other people and to make us feel as though
- 8:06we're part of the group and then we have face
- 8:09perception abilities which allow us to recognize
- 8:11faces and thousands of faces and faces across
- 8:15long periods of time right you can run into someone
- 8:17who you haven't seen for 20 years 30 years 40
- 8:19years and still recognize them even though their
- 8:22hair's changed and they're you know they've got
- 8:24more wrinkles or they've got fat or they've got
- 8:26skinny or you know all these different changes
- 8:28that are good you'll still recognize them which
- 8:29is quite amazing that we're able to do that and
- 8:32again there's these dedicated areas in our in
- 8:34our cheesy form gyros that they're just for us
- 8:38to be able to recognize who's who and so we know
- 8:41who is somebody who we can trust and somebody
- 8:43who maybe we can't trust and then and then we
- 8:47We thrive on connection, right? We get all these
- 8:50really happy endorphins and neurotransmitters,
- 8:53serotonin, oxytocin, when we're actually with
- 8:55other people. And when we're lonely, we don't
- 8:57get those neurotransmitters and we find ourselves
- 9:02really fearful. So we now know based on the Harvard
- 9:05study, which has been going for 75 years, that
- 9:08the number one way to actually increase your
- 9:11lifespan by 10 to 15 years, decrease likelihood
- 9:14of having neurodegenerative diseases later on,
- 9:16improve your cardiovascular system, decrease
- 9:19likelihood of having mental health issues, increase
- 9:22your IQ, is just to spend time with people that
- 9:26you trust and chat to them on a regular basis.
- 9:29I mean, that's what our brains have actually
- 9:31set up for. And that's how we've become this
- 9:34alpha species through that collaboration. And
- 9:37it's only really in the last couple of thousand
- 9:39years that we've been setting up society in a
- 9:41way which is in competition. And that's a fairly
- 9:44recent thing, something that I think we need
- 9:46to think about it from a societal point of view
- 9:49because our brains haven't changed in the last
- 9:5135 000 years in actual fact they got a little
- 9:54bit smaller when we when we moved from hunter
- 9:56-gatherers because we actually had better diets
- 9:58when we're hunter -gatherers so they got a little
- 9:59bit smaller but otherwise they haven't really
- 10:01changed and so most of that evolution has been
- 10:04around us being friendly to each other not competing
- 10:06with each other yeah and we have done so many
- 10:09changes in like our technological advances but
- 10:13then we go i would say forwards and backwards
- 10:17many times and then I think that I don't know
- 10:21like in your opinion it would be more like the
- 10:24lack of connection that we are having not only
- 10:27now or these like a disparities or biases that
- 10:30we are having or we take one party or the other
- 10:33one in extreme cases so how we can find a middle
- 10:38term to like a you know of discussion what is
- 10:41the like a good advice to get a middle kind of
- 10:45discussion when everything is so biased or like
- 10:48when we have completely different opinions but
- 10:51then he says like oh you just listen what the
- 10:54other has to say but how to get there? Yeah well
- 10:58we need to do it face to face I think that's
- 11:00the biggest problem is that most people try and
- 11:02communicate over the internet and when we do
- 11:05that we don't connect with the other person and
- 11:08we feel just dividing being nasty over the internet
- 11:12because it's not natural right the other person
- 11:14doesn't feel real because they're not actually
- 11:16there right in your face whereas when you actually
- 11:18meet up with when you're on the internet you
- 11:20don't get all important neurotransmitters released
- 11:22because you're not face -to -face with them when
- 11:24we meet someone in person First thing we do is
- 11:26we touch each other appropriately and with consent,
- 11:29but all societies have some way of touching each
- 11:31other when we meet each other. So we shake hands
- 11:33or kiss each other on the cheek or even the Inuits
- 11:36who are fully clothed will rub noses because
- 11:39it's only part of their skin that's actually
- 11:40showing. And that releases oxytocin so we feel
- 11:43more connected to the other person and more likely
- 11:45to trust the other person. And then serotonin
- 11:47is released because of body language and because
- 11:49of our closeness to the other person at times.
- 11:53and then lots of endorphins as well, because
- 11:55we're actually interacting with someone face
- 11:57to face. And then we also are less likely to
- 11:59be nasty to a person because they're actually
- 12:01there. They can actually harm us if we are nasty
- 12:04to them. So we're more likely to actually speak
- 12:07to them in polite ways and actually be willing
- 12:10to actually listen to what they have to say.
- 12:12So we need to stop trying to solve our problems
- 12:15online. We need to actually be spending time
- 12:17face to face with people when we actually want
- 12:20to connect with people. Because that's so important
- 12:22for us and that's how our brain actually involved
- 12:25evolved and on the internet Of course, you have
- 12:28all these algorithms which are driving the information
- 12:30to us and are forcing us into groups that is
- 12:34really taking advantage of the way our brains
- 12:37have evolved but taking advantage of it in a
- 12:39really negative way and I think we need to realize
- 12:42that that these algorithms need to stop when
- 12:45governments need to legislate against them so
- 12:47that we're not being driven normally into groups
- 12:50that we're going to isolate us from the general
- 12:54population. Yeah I completely agree and something
- 12:59that is really that you mentioned the these algorithms
- 13:02that are behind all the scenes for example in
- 13:05social media or Instagram or there's a I remember
- 13:09in a program that they were mentioning, for example,
- 13:12how, depending on the colors of the lights, or
- 13:15they are all the time observing how many clicks
- 13:17to give. What are they similar? It sounds crazy,
- 13:22but it's true. Like a profile in the person.
- 13:26So that kind of thing that is very biased. And
- 13:30then also, we have a guest. She works for a privacy.
- 13:36and she's very good in blockchain and privacy
- 13:41and she was mentioning that they are developing
- 13:44actually their company the way to just block
- 13:48creating noise when you are using a channel or
- 13:51talking with someone because actually are the
- 13:54patterns when are the patterns that the machine
- 13:58learning is using to get all that information
- 14:01from you. Not the regular conversations or the
- 14:03slang that you use with your friends but like
- 14:06these really focused patterns that you use and
- 14:10the punks use and then... So she was saying that,
- 14:13like, yeah, I asked her, like, I should be interested
- 14:16to see if criminality goes up because they are
- 14:20going to mask. This is like a word, but it should
- 14:22be like water, not because some of them, you
- 14:24know, they are misusing the word that we have
- 14:28the right to privacy. And I think that I agree
- 14:30with you in the sense that we have to control
- 14:33more, at least, or the government had to be put
- 14:36like a boundary in these companies getting everything.
- 14:40affecting our brains and affecting teenagers
- 14:43and the way that we are connecting and thinking.
- 14:46And having said that, how our brains are different
- 14:51nowadays compared to the pre -internet times.
- 14:54You mentioned before that it hasn't been changing
- 14:57too much, but then how this has influenced our
- 15:01brain, like all these technological advancements.
- 15:03Yeah, it's pretty concerning. We know that there's
- 15:07a lot of evidence now that when kids are given
- 15:09screens at a young age, at preschool age, that
- 15:13they are white matter tracks. So the areas that
- 15:16connect, the corpus callosum connects the left
- 15:18hemisphere and the right hemisphere. And then
- 15:20we have a whole bunch of other tracks that connect
- 15:22the frontal areas to the rear and all over the
- 15:24brain. And it's sort of like the highways in
- 15:27a city, right? And they connect all the suburbs
- 15:29together. We know they're abnormally developed
- 15:32in kids who are using devices. from a young age
- 15:35so those areas aren't developing properly and
- 15:38we don't really know what the outcome of that
- 15:40will be later on. We do know the younger a child
- 15:43is given a device or the more time a child spends
- 15:45on a device the more likely they'll be diagnosed
- 15:47with ADHD or with autism which is a real concern.
- 15:51We know that our intelligence levels for the
- 15:54first time have dropped. There used to be what
- 15:57we called the Flynn effect where our intelligence
- 15:59levels were getting higher and higher and higher
- 16:01because people were becoming more and more educated.
- 16:03The trend has now gone the opposite way and we're
- 16:06actually getting dumber than we were before because
- 16:09we're not actually learning. We're not holding
- 16:10the information anymore. Reading, for example,
- 16:13has gone down dramatically in the last 10 years,
- 16:16which is really concerning because that also
- 16:18impacts our emotional intelligence. So we actually
- 16:21learn a lot. of our emotional intelligence by
- 16:23reading fiction books because we get into other
- 16:26people's lives and we experience what other people
- 16:28are doing and you can have imagination and you
- 16:31can put yourself in other people's places and
- 16:33all those sorts of things especially as a teenager
- 16:35but we know emotional intelligence is now dropping
- 16:38and a lot of that has to do with the fact that
- 16:41teenagers are no longer reading books the way
- 16:43they used to read books. So they're not actually
- 16:45having those experiences that they really need
- 16:47to be having so that they can understand how
- 16:49other people feel in different situations and
- 16:52so on. And we all need to be reading more. And
- 16:55then, of course, our attentional networks have
- 16:57been affected as well. We can't attend to things
- 17:00for as long as we used to be able to attend to
- 17:02things because we're constantly being distracted
- 17:05by devices. And then the notifications are always
- 17:08beeping and buzzing out as we capture our attention
- 17:10as well, which again affects our attentional
- 17:13networks, which is a big concern. We think that
- 17:16our working memories also dropped. So we used
- 17:18to talk about magic number seven in relation
- 17:21to our working memories, which is sort of like
- 17:23a consciousness, what you're aware of in one
- 17:25moment in time, which is why phone numbers used
- 17:27to be limited to six numbers because you can
- 17:29only hold six numbers at a time and then dial
- 17:32a phone number. And we believe that that's now
- 17:34dropped down to about four rather than seven
- 17:37so it used to be seven and we think it's gone
- 17:39down to four now with most teenagers. So yeah
- 17:42there are a huge number of changes that are occurring
- 17:44not because our brain's changing but because
- 17:47we're not using our brain and so therefore those
- 17:50things aren't developing and what really concerns
- 17:52me is that we um whether you get Alzheimer's
- 17:55disease for example or other dementias depends
- 17:57very much on whether or not you have extra capacity,
- 18:01extra cognitive capacity that is your brain really
- 18:04strong. And if it's really strong, you're much
- 18:06less likely to get Alzheimer's disease and other
- 18:09neurodegenerative diseases. And that's on the
- 18:12rise. Neurodegenerative diseases are increasing
- 18:15significantly, and especially early onset neurodegenerative
- 18:19diseases in two years. So the last report came
- 18:22out two years ago, and the previous two years
- 18:25there was a 400 % increase. in neurodegenerative
- 18:28diseases for young onset, which is between 25
- 18:32and 35 year olds getting dementia. The 400 %
- 18:35increase for 25 to 35 year olds getting dementia,
- 18:38which again, it's specific to that age group
- 18:41because they grew up with the devices, right?
- 18:44They went through their teen years through those
- 18:45really formative years with the devices. And
- 18:47now we're seeing that they're getting dementia
- 18:49at a really young age. And early onset dementia
- 18:52is very Acute so those those individuals will
- 18:57die very very quickly, which is very sad Wow,
- 19:00that's very scary Yeah Yeah, because you might
- 19:06think that like at these neurodegenerative diseases
- 19:09are more related with the age or aging people,
- 19:12right? But then now like in 20s and 30s Yeah,
- 19:16for the first time we've had a 19 year old being
- 19:19diagnosed with early onset dementia. So he's
- 19:2219 he will probably have to live a couple of
- 19:25years now that he's been told. And actually that
- 19:28leads to my question to one study, actually the
- 19:32MIT study that Jorain on CharGDP found that using
- 19:36AI tools like CharGDP can make students think
- 19:39less and remember less. How can educators use
- 19:43these tools in a way that helps a student learn
- 19:46without hurting their brain development and actually
- 19:49cheating and thinking, critically thinking, because
- 19:53it's not happening anymore? No, it's not. And
- 19:57that's really sad. I mean, in universities, we've
- 20:00always had trouble with cheating and getting
- 20:03around it. In the old days, students used to
- 20:05pay other students to write their reports. And
- 20:07now they're using ChatGPT rather than paying
- 20:10other students. which you could argue it's not
- 20:12very fair on those students that used to make
- 20:14money out of it, but they don't have an income
- 20:16anymore because of ChatGPT. But the real problem,
- 20:19yeah, is that they're not thinking, right? Learning
- 20:22is about thinking. It's about putting the information
- 20:24into your long -term memory. And innovation and
- 20:27creativity comes from information in your long
- 20:30-term memory. So you need to get the information
- 20:31into your long -term memory so that you can then
- 20:34put different ideas together and actually come
- 20:36up with something new. And we know artificial
- 20:39intelligence is It's artificial, right? Artificial
- 20:41means that it's fake, it's not real. It's a fake
- 20:44intelligence and we've just been tricked into
- 20:45thinking that it's intelligent. And it can't
- 20:48come up with new ideas. It's incapable of coming
- 20:51up with a new concept or a new idea or be innovative
- 20:53or creative. It is just regurgitating the information
- 20:56that's actually out there and putting it in different
- 20:59ways so that it looks as though it's intelligent.
- 21:01And so to come up with the next great idea and
- 21:04the next innovative... idea, the new technology
- 21:06or whatever, we have to have that information
- 21:08in our long -term memory and we're not putting
- 21:10it, we're not analyzing into our long -term memory
- 21:12because we're not concentrating on things for
- 21:15long enough to put it into our long -term memory
- 21:17which is because our attention mechanisms aren't
- 21:22as good as they used to be which means the information
- 21:24is not going into our working memory and our
- 21:27working memory is not as long as it used to be
- 21:28because we're not using it in the same way and
- 21:30then that information is not being downloaded
- 21:32into our long -term memory. So those are the
- 21:35issues with it and that's why if you use CHAT
- 21:37GPT, you won't know the information because you're
- 21:40not actually attending to it, whereas students
- 21:42who actually do the thinking themselves, that
- 21:45information gets downloaded into their long -term
- 21:48memory so that they'll actually know it better.
- 21:51They'll be able to pass exams and do all the
- 21:53rest of it and come up with innovative and creative
- 21:55ideas later on, be great entrepreneurs and all
- 21:58great scientists. be able to solve all the problems
- 22:01that are coming down the line. And what would
- 22:03be the suggestion or the advice for the educators
- 22:08to try to handle this? Because I think that AI
- 22:11is here to stay. It's not going anywhere and
- 22:14it's like moving super fast. And I would say
- 22:17that it's a good tool if you know and understand
- 22:20the basics and you use it as a tool. But as you
- 22:24mentioned, because we have this fake perception
- 22:26that because with our we take pictures with our
- 22:30phone, for example, and that picture is in your
- 22:33memory. It's getting stored in your phone. So
- 22:36it's something similar what happened with these
- 22:38AI tools. So what would be the suggestion to
- 22:42lead or deal with these issues with AI or child
- 22:46GDP? Yeah, I think we just need to be a little
- 22:48bit more clever about giving students. In old
- 22:52days, we used to often ask students to write
- 22:56drafts first right that you'd write an overall
- 22:58summary of what you were going to write for example
- 23:01and that would be handed in and then the teacher
- 23:03would give it back based on you know some notes
- 23:05and so on and then they'd have to write the next
- 23:07stage and then that would be looked at and so
- 23:09on or getting the kids to write down each stage
- 23:13as they go through those stages and so you've
- 23:15actually got a map of how they came up with these
- 23:18ideas and and how they evolved and how they ended
- 23:21up in the in the way they were by the end. and
- 23:24having the teachers look at all of those stages
- 23:27and mark all of those stages as part of the process
- 23:29and so you're actually helping the kids or the
- 23:32students actually learn how to learn and learn
- 23:35how to go through that whole process rather than
- 23:38having a situation which we have now which is
- 23:40you you get given an assignment and then you
- 23:43get the details as to what is expected for each
- 23:46stage of it and then they just hand in the final
- 23:49report which could have just been written by
- 23:51chapter gbt whereas those other stages will be
- 23:55different for each individual. And if they're
- 23:57not different for each individual, then you know
- 23:58that they've actually achieved it rather than
- 24:00actually done it properly. Yeah. So I think that
- 24:03one of the lectures we're doing here is like
- 24:06a, they were giving up. It's like a, we can avoid
- 24:09that you use CiaoGTP, but we are going to offer
- 24:12you like the tools. You can use this as a tool,
- 24:15but you have to present to us without any resource.
- 24:19Here you come. I personally come here, write
- 24:23down everything. Like you use all the tools,
- 24:27but you have to understand the context and the
- 24:29basis, because that's the big issue that, as
- 24:33you say, we have it, right? Like we just put
- 24:36it there and it's done. Yeah, it's done. Paint
- 24:39it in, get a mark and then forget about it. And
- 24:42how can we understand the brain's mechanisms
- 24:47for forming memories and habits? and that is
- 24:51going to transform our approach to education
- 24:53and personal development. What approaches have
- 24:58you seen, for example, with your brain camp,
- 25:02that make bigger changes in our education system?
- 25:08For example, I read that you work a lot with
- 25:12kids that are very distracted or they can't...
- 25:16focus or they are not interested. So what are
- 25:20the best approaches to educational skills or
- 25:24tools? Yeah, one of them is to give them a little
- 25:29bit more freedom in what they're expected to
- 25:33do. So, for example, reading, I think, is the
- 25:36number one thing that we should be teaching all
- 25:38kids and kids should be spending all our time
- 25:40learning how to read. Because, A, it's really,
- 25:42really difficult because our brains never evolved
- 25:44to read. And most, the majority of people have
- 25:47only started reading in the last one or two generations.
- 25:50It's a really, really new skill that's really,
- 25:52really difficult to actually do. And what amazes
- 25:55me is that so many people learn to read, not
- 25:58that we have problems with kids. learning to
- 26:01read. So they've got to spend a lot of time actually
- 26:03doing it and so giving the school having the
- 26:06first half an hour where all the kids read that's
- 26:10all they do they just read and and in fact all
- 26:12of the staff also read because adults aren't
- 26:15reading enough today either so everyone just
- 26:17spends the first 30 minutes reading but the kids
- 26:20are allowed to choose whatever they want to read
- 26:22so they're actually reading stuff that they're
- 26:24interested in so if they want to read a surfing
- 26:26magazine they can read a surfing magazine. they
- 26:29want to read whatever it has to be on paper it
- 26:31has to be a real thing book or whatever but they
- 26:34can read whatever they want to and then you you
- 26:36end up creating an environment where they're
- 26:40all interested in reading because they're doing
- 26:43something they're reading something they're interested
- 26:45in so they're willing to do it but also they'll
- 26:48start talking to each other about what they're
- 26:50actually reading so then they it becomes that
- 26:55the whole community reads rather than what we've
- 26:57got at the moment when nobody basically reads
- 27:00anymore for pleasure. And so it becomes a pleasure,
- 27:02it becomes a habit, right? It becomes something
- 27:04that they just do naturally and the teachers
- 27:06do naturally as well. And that, I think, is a
- 27:09number one. We know that reading ability is the
- 27:13best indication of how successful someone will
- 27:16be later in life, whether or not someone will
- 27:17go to university and whether or not someone will
- 27:19do well at university and whether someone will
- 27:21actually end up. being successful in whatever
- 27:25area they go into. And it doesn't matter what
- 27:27subject you do. The number one thing you've got
- 27:29to be able to do is be able to read because reading
- 27:32is where we get the information and how we transfer
- 27:35information from one person. That's very interesting.
- 27:38And what do you think about the test and ranking
- 27:41based on the knowledge? Yeah, we should get rid
- 27:44of it completely. There's no reason to have tests
- 27:47at all because tests don't actually test what
- 27:51a student knows. Tests actually just examine
- 27:55what a student can retrieve from their work,
- 27:58their long -term memory, when they're in that
- 28:01testing situation. And some kids learn how to
- 28:04do tests, how to be good at doing tests, and
- 28:07they get good marks. Not because they have more
- 28:09information in their long -term memory or know
- 28:11the information or have more intelligence than
- 28:14the other kids, just because they learn how to
- 28:17manipulate the system. And so... We should trust
- 28:20teachers to be professionals, and we should do
- 28:23what a lot of the Scandinavian countries do,
- 28:25which is not have any testing until they go to
- 28:29university, because that's when we actually need,
- 28:32right? You don't need to be able to rank someone
- 28:36in their history test, or their history. thing
- 28:40in year nine or year seven. It's completely meaningless.
- 28:44I have no idea what my marks were back then.
- 28:46I'm sure you probably don't either, right? It
- 28:48doesn't impact whether or not they're going to
- 28:50be successful at university. The students that
- 28:53do really well in their HSC or in their final
- 28:55year and get into university aren't the kids
- 28:57that actually do really well at university or
- 29:00are amazing PhD students or amazing postdocs
- 29:03or very successful CEOs or whatever. They're
- 29:06the kids that... Love to learn and then the kids
- 29:09that love to think and that's very different
- 29:11to being able to just pass the test That's true.
- 29:14And actually something that you mentioned also
- 29:17is that anxiety plays an important role? How
- 29:20do you feel like a related with tests, which
- 29:23I'm one of those I feel really nervous and those
- 29:26like a multiple choices was just so horrendous
- 29:31like i think i was like i know the topic but
- 29:34i don't know maybe it's a b c or maybe that's
- 29:38wrong and then you just erase the previous question
- 29:40that's horrendous and it's not like i want one
- 29:44size fits everyone i did That's very wrong. Yeah.
- 29:47And it teaches kids that school and learning
- 29:50is anxiety provoking, right? It teaches kids
- 29:53that this is what learning is all about, is doing
- 29:56these tests under these exam conditions. And
- 29:59that's not what learning is about. Learning is
- 30:01about becoming better, right? Becoming thriving
- 30:04and being able to have conversations with people
- 30:08and to think and to do all those really cool
- 30:10things. Not about... where you rank in your class
- 30:13compared to everybody else which is yeah it's
- 30:15really sad that we set kids up like that and
- 30:17some of the best school systems in the world
- 30:19don't have testing because they trust their teachers
- 30:21because teachers know how well students are doing
- 30:24right that they know all these students are doing
- 30:27really well because they're happy and these kids
- 30:31are struggling because they're messing up and
- 30:33they're doing all the rest and so we need to
- 30:36focus on these kids and help them and we don't
- 30:38need to focus on these kids. They don't need
- 30:40to give them a test, and a good teacher does.
- 30:43Yeah, I agree. It should be just demolished.
- 30:47And also, why does punishment often fail to change
- 30:54behavior? And what does neuroscience suggest
- 30:57we should be doing instead in classrooms, homes,
- 31:01and even in the justice system? Yeah, punishment
- 31:04makes the person who's giving the punishment
- 31:09Feel better right because they're like I've done
- 31:11something about this But it doesn't actually
- 31:13help the person who's actually been punished
- 31:14all the research shows that it only stops them
- 31:17from doing it when they think they're gonna get
- 31:18caught So if they think they're gonna get caught
- 31:20they won't do it And then if they don't think
- 31:22they're gonna get caught then they'll continue
- 31:23doing whatever the behavior actually is so it's
- 31:26not about changing that we also know you know
- 31:29the a lot of schools use dojos and all sorts
- 31:32of things where they give kids little merit badges
- 31:36and all sorts of things. We know none of that
- 31:37actually works either. It's been shown that one
- 31:41study which was really interesting is that they
- 31:43got students to do a really difficult project
- 31:46that took a couple of weeks to complete and they
- 31:49either got the teachers to walk around the classroom
- 31:51and talk to each student and tell them that they
- 31:55were doing really well and you know all this
- 31:57positive reinforcement or they got the teachers
- 31:59just to walk around and give all the students
- 32:01high fives. Well randomly give students high
- 32:04fives and they found that when they did the positive
- 32:07reinforcement the kids often Gave up fairly quickly
- 32:11when they weren't getting the positive reinforcement
- 32:13So they needed the positive reinforcement to
- 32:15keep going and they were soon as that went away
- 32:18They gave up when they got the high fives. They
- 32:20were much more motivated to actually do it And
- 32:23they they pursued they continued doing it even
- 32:26though that when they weren't getting the high
- 32:28five So, you know just giving them that positive
- 32:30reinforcement where you're touching them through
- 32:33the high five which gives them the oxytocin and
- 32:35makes them trust you more and makes you actually
- 32:37feel involved but not actually positively reinforcing
- 32:41their behavior. So yeah, we should be doing things
- 32:44like that. I mean, coaches I think are great,
- 32:46right? Sports coaches, a lot of sports coaches
- 32:48are amazing because they know, they use those
- 32:51sorts of things, high fives, you know, pat on
- 32:54the back, all that stuff, which is really important
- 32:55for us as humans and that's what we should be
- 32:57doing. And we actually don't use as much in the
- 33:01classroom. It's like a positive reinforcement.
- 33:05And related to the justice system that is very
- 33:09criticized, especially now that in Australia
- 33:11there's a new law, the brain of the kids or teenagers
- 33:15develop properly until the 25th. You are the
- 33:19expert in this. What do you think, why is failing
- 33:22the justice system? Do you think that just putting
- 33:25them in a place confined? punish them what has
- 33:29to be changed or done because it's easy to criticize
- 33:33from one party with one point of view like well
- 33:36they're recurring doing this over and over and
- 33:40it's getting worse and the other ones is like
- 33:42yeah but it doesn't work just putting them there
- 33:45so what would be a good suggestion or not like
- 33:49a one extreme to the other one what has worked
- 33:52previously or like what studies have shown that
- 33:56actually this is not going to work, it's just
- 34:01going to keep them there for a while. Yeah, we
- 34:05know that we behave based on the people around
- 34:10us, right? We mimic what other people are doing
- 34:12and that's because we want to be part of the
- 34:15group and so the group is so important to us
- 34:17as a species because that helps us survive and
- 34:21we don't for hundreds of thousands of years we
- 34:25relied on the group. for survival as we talked
- 34:27about before we weren't the fastest or the strongest
- 34:29or anything like that so if we didn't have our
- 34:31group if we got rejected from that group then
- 34:34we would die and so we needed to work within
- 34:36that group and and our brains are still set up
- 34:39for that and through the mirror neuron system
- 34:41which mimics what other people are doing which
- 34:43is why you know you'll see teenagers they're
- 34:45all mates and they'll all walk the same and they'll
- 34:47all have their jeans hanging down or whatever
- 34:49it was saying and all the rest of it they'll
- 34:51talk in similar ways and they'll have similar
- 34:53mannerisms and all the rest of it because of
- 34:55this automatic processing through the mirror
- 34:57neuron system which is to bond us to make us
- 35:00more connected with each other if you take a
- 35:02child who's done who's made a mistake and then
- 35:06stick them in amongst a whole bunch of other
- 35:09kids who have also made mistakes and are constantly
- 35:12making mistakes they're all just going to learn
- 35:15from each other and they're going to bond with
- 35:17each other and they're going to continue making
- 35:19those mistakes, right? What you need to do is
- 35:22take a kid who's made a mistake and put them
- 35:24with kids who haven't made mistakes so that they
- 35:27learn a different way of doing things, rather
- 35:29than sticking with a whole bunch of other kids
- 35:32who are making the same mistakes so they continue
- 35:34to make the same mistakes. And I think that's
- 35:36a mistake we make, is that we're training these
- 35:41kids to be criminals, right? Because we're sticking
- 35:43with kids who are making mistakes. They're making
- 35:46mistakes, right? They're young kids. They're
- 35:48not doing it because they want to. There's something
- 35:50in their lives which meant that they didn't have
- 35:53the right support that they needed to make the
- 35:55right decisions at that point in their life.
- 35:57And then we go and stick them in amongst with
- 36:00a bunch of other kids who are also in the same
- 36:02situation so that they just feed off each other
- 36:05and all become worse and become criminals. rather
- 36:09than giving them the support and help that they
- 36:11actually need. So this is more, and it's really
- 36:13important what you said, because it's like people
- 36:15say like, oh, nature versus nurture. When they
- 36:20say like, oh, well, they grew up under these
- 36:22conditions, have horrendous experiences. There's
- 36:24nothing else to be done, which I actually disagree.
- 36:29But then a lot of people say like, oh, no, there's
- 36:31so many cases that it doesn't work. Like the
- 36:34family structure is done. It's terrible. the
- 36:38kid is not going to behave in this way. But as
- 36:41you say, if we put it outside, what the chances
- 36:44are that these kids recover? Have you seen it
- 36:47in other examples, like for example, in other
- 36:50countries? Yeah, I mean, there's lots of mentoring
- 36:54programs that get set up and work really, really
- 36:58well, where rather than putting them, there's
- 37:00a great guy in Frankston in Melbourne, who he
- 37:04was an Olympic wrestler. from the Eastern Bloc
- 37:07and then he came to Australia and he actually
- 37:09went over and worked in Mongolia as their their
- 37:13main coach and then he came back to Australia
- 37:15and saw that there was really high youth crime
- 37:18in Frankston and so he set up a gym and he talked
- 37:21to the police and he gets kids who are having
- 37:24a rough time and on being on that track to go
- 37:28to youth detention and so on and gets them into
- 37:30the gym and gives them something to work for
- 37:34right gives them that the wrestling which gives
- 37:36them lots of touch and also lets them vent all
- 37:39their anger and gives them somewhere to go but
- 37:41also puts them in amongst a whole bunch of other
- 37:43kids who are learning how to wrestle and are
- 37:47aiming for something and they're getting fit
- 37:49and they're getting healthy and then they have
- 37:51programs they have you know some counselors there
- 37:53as well for them to talk to but they also talk
- 37:56about nutrition and how important food is all
- 37:59the things that we know as educated people are
- 38:02really important for us that they don't really
- 38:04know and the information they don't really get
- 38:05in their homes and so they can also take that
- 38:09back to their homes and that program is doing
- 38:12great stuff because again it's giving them the
- 38:16information that they need and giving them a
- 38:18community of people who are trying to better
- 38:22themselves rather than just you know being punished
- 38:25for something that they've done because of the
- 38:27situation, the sad situation they're in. Yeah,
- 38:31I agree. I think that the justice system needs
- 38:33to ask first instead of taking decisions. Yeah,
- 38:39a big problem, whether you'll talk about a justice
- 38:41system or the political system, that both of
- 38:44them are set up as competitions rather than being
- 38:47about collaboration, right? Our justice system
- 38:50is set up as the prosecution and the defense
- 38:53actually fighting against each other and one
- 38:55of them trying to win. whereas what we should
- 38:58do is we should have a justice system which is
- 39:00about finding justice and so everyone goes in
- 39:03there looking for how do we what's what's actually
- 39:06happened and how do we actually remedy this situation
- 39:09in a just way rather than let's put these two
- 39:12groups together and get them to fight each other
- 39:14and a similar politics is the same right we have
- 39:17two or three different groups that are actually
- 39:19fighting against each other which is a ridiculous
- 39:21way to run a country what we should be doing
- 39:23is having a system where they all work together
- 39:25to better our country and better everybody. Because
- 39:29it's the way our brains evolved. Yeah, exactly.
- 39:32We get the best ideas of both parties and try
- 39:34to work together to produce a solution instead
- 39:37of competition. Yeah, let's hope. Let's hope.
- 39:41Not only this country, I think, but worldwide.
- 39:43No, no. Yeah, it's not as... And so much of your
- 39:48work points to the idea that empathy and connection
- 39:51are not just emotional experiences, but neurological
- 39:55necessities. What do you think happens to a society
- 39:59neurologically and socially when empathy starts
- 40:03to fade? Oh, yeah. Oh, that's... You only have
- 40:08to look at what's happening in America at the
- 40:10moment, right? I shouldn't say that, but... Oh,
- 40:13you can. I agree. Yeah, it's really sad. We are
- 40:20empathic, right? And you see a child crying,
- 40:24you want to put your arm around the child, right?
- 40:25That's an automatic response. We are empathic
- 40:28people, and we want to actually help each other.
- 40:31And we got to this point because of that. It
- 40:34really frustrates me. I hear, you know, these
- 40:36entrepreneurs who say, you know, empathy is weak
- 40:39and all these sorts of things, when they're actually
- 40:41only got to where they are because of the support
- 40:44of all these millions of people around them,
- 40:46right? They're using technology that was designed
- 40:49by millions of people who all worked together
- 40:51and collaborated and generated these amazing
- 40:53ideas. And then they're using that to make lots
- 40:55of money. And it's like, well, you are benefiting
- 40:59from all the empathy that's out there and all
- 41:02the collaboration and all the goodwill of society.
- 41:06And now you're saying, no, I'm not empathic and
- 41:08we shouldn't be empathic. That's just nasty.
- 41:11We as a race or species got to where we are because
- 41:16we're empathic, because we help each other, we
- 41:18collaborate, we do all those things. And without
- 41:20it, I think we're in a lot of trouble. And we
- 41:22do die, right? Loneliness kills us. We die. 10,
- 41:2515 years earlier, if we're lonely, if we don't
- 41:27have people around us, we're more likely to have
- 41:29cardiovascular problems. We're more likely to
- 41:32get dementia. It's bad for us. We're more likely
- 41:34to have psychosis, mental health issues. So we
- 41:37need to be amongst other people. And it's really
- 41:41sad that we have this epidemic of loneliness
- 41:44in our society these days. And especially because
- 41:48it's amongst young kids, right? It's the 15 to
- 41:4925 year olds now are amongst the loneliest people.
- 41:53Whereas they used to be the opposite. It used
- 41:55to be the opposite. It used to be all the people
- 41:57who were the loneriest. So I don't know where
- 42:00that's going to go, but we really need to turn
- 42:02it around and really do it really quickly because
- 42:04it's not healthy and it's not good for us. We
- 42:07need to realize that, you know, these ideas like.
- 42:49Yeah, and you point out something really important
- 42:51because we always like we have close relatives
- 42:55that are the chimpanzees. And they say, like,
- 42:58oh, look at the chimpanzees. They are just like
- 43:00the way that we are, very violent. And I said,
- 43:03like, yeah, but look at the bonobos and these
- 43:06over -closed relatives. And they actually solve
- 43:10every problem with love and sex. Makes love no
- 43:15more. Yeah, no, it's true. And we're actually
- 43:17closer to them than we are to the chimpanzees.
- 43:20But even if you argue that, right, the chimpanzees,
- 43:23we are... we separated from the cheap pansies
- 43:26millions and millions of years ago, right? We've,
- 43:28we've, we've changed a lot since then. Yeah.
- 43:31So it's a, yeah. So it's a pitiful excuse to
- 43:34just pretend that we are just like a selfish
- 43:37and the selfish gene I have. Um, and well, I
- 43:46want to know, like your knowledge is about how
- 43:49the brain works, including stress, attention,
- 43:52connection. How do you apply this in your own
- 43:55daily life and with your family? Are there specific
- 43:59habits that you can or practices that you follow
- 44:02because you have learned through neuroscience,
- 44:05your life, your experience that you can give
- 44:07us some amazing tips? Cool yeah so we're very
- 44:11careful with devices neither of my I have two
- 44:14teenagers neither of them are on social media
- 44:17because so there's nothing social about social
- 44:19media and the damages it causes to kids and to
- 44:22teenagers is quite, it's awful. I mean, there's
- 44:24a huge amount of research now showing that does
- 44:26significant damage to them. And social media,
- 44:29we've got to remember that social media is about
- 44:31advertising. And so you're either advertising
- 44:33a company or you're advertising a beat or you're
- 44:36advertising a podcast or whatever you're advertising,
- 44:38or you're advertising yourself. And so if kids
- 44:41or teenagers are on social media, they're advertising
- 44:44themselves and they're being taught that to get
- 44:46friends and to have people like you, you have
- 44:49to advertise yourself. And that's an awful way
- 44:51to grow up. And that's why we see a strong correlation
- 44:56between social media use and mental health disorders,
- 45:00mental health issues and anorexia nervosa and
- 45:02bulimia nervosa and all of these things. So neither
- 45:05of my kids have social media and won't have social
- 45:07media until they turn 18. We have our devices
- 45:10so that they turn on to sleep mode at nine o
- 45:13'clock. All the devices go on sleep mode at nine
- 45:15o 'clock and don't turn on again until six a
- 45:17.m. so that we have a period of time when we
- 45:19don't have access to them and then when we come
- 45:21home we have an area that we put all our phones
- 45:24so that we don't have our phones on us when we're
- 45:27at home because we're at home right why would
- 45:28you need your phone in your back pocket when
- 45:30you're sitting on the couch or whatever right
- 45:32so we have an area that they go and they go there
- 45:34and they never go into the bathroom and they
- 45:36never go into the bedrooms because we know that
- 45:38that is harmful as well and then I work at home
- 45:43a lot these days as you can probably see i'm
- 45:44working my office yeah And so I regularly organize
- 45:49to meet up with friends for coffee so that I'm
- 45:51not isolated. So I do a lot of speaking gigs.
- 45:54When I'm doing speaking gigs, I'm obviously around
- 45:56people, but if I'm, if I'm having a bit of time
- 45:58at home, I make sure that I catch up with friends
- 46:01and so on over coffee, um, at lunchtime or in
- 46:03the morning before I start work so that I'm actually
- 46:06doing something with other people and interacting
- 46:09with other people. And then I walk a lot. So
- 46:11I have a dog and he needs a lot of walk. So I
- 46:14walk a lot. with my dog, which is always important.
- 46:19Yeah. Those are some of my tips. Oh, yeah. How
- 46:22do you convince your teenagers? Because sometimes
- 46:26they are rebellious. How do you convince them
- 46:28to get on board with, like, stop using social
- 46:32media when they have a big influence or their
- 46:34friends that have social media? How do you manage?
- 46:38They never had social media. So I've always,
- 46:41with what we wrote from the beginning, said,
- 46:42no, I was at MIT when... Facebook started and
- 46:45I saw how it started and where it went. So we've
- 46:50always said no social media and they have no
- 46:53problem with it. I mean they don't, you don't,
- 46:55kids don't actually connect on social media right.
- 46:58I often hear parents that will come to me when
- 47:00I do presentations on this and then they'll say
- 47:03you know but my kids need social media because
- 47:05they need to connect with their friends and it's
- 47:08not actually true because on social media you
- 47:11post stuff after you do it. So they're missing
- 47:14out. What social media is about is really about
- 47:18advertising yourself. So what they do is they
- 47:20go to a party, they take lots of photos and then
- 47:23they post those photos to tease the kids who
- 47:26are at the party. Those kids were never invited
- 47:28to the party and so they're just missing out
- 47:31on going to the party and they get to see that
- 47:33they're missing out. which is really nasty and
- 47:35all how they actually organize parties is actually
- 47:37just to text each other and say hey I'm having
- 47:39a party or hey meet me here or whatever and that's
- 47:42how you actually get invited to parties and do
- 47:44all those sorts of things and so there's no reason
- 47:47to have social media from a group point of view
- 47:51for teenagers at all and my kids are yeah always
- 47:55going to different things and meeting up and
- 47:57they're both involved in sport all the rest of
- 47:59it I mean there's no and then they just don't
- 48:02get to see when their friends go to things and
- 48:05then Skype about the fact that they've been to
- 48:07things that they weren't invited to, which is
- 48:09good, because they don't need to know about that,
- 48:11because that's just mean and nasty. And so they
- 48:14miss out on all the mean and nasty stuff and
- 48:16don't see that. Yeah, and then they've heard
- 48:20me speak so many times. They know the damages
- 48:25it causes. And they also talk about some of their
- 48:27friends that they go, oh, Alonso is really addicted
- 48:29to social media. It's really sad, right? They
- 48:32find it sad. that these kids need to do that
- 48:36to get validation for themselves and it's similar
- 48:40with video games like the process of like addiction
- 48:43is similar with video games in long term yeah
- 48:46absolutely yeah it is a problem um it depends
- 48:49on the video games so my son loves playing he's
- 48:52he's a huge basketball fan um and he plays basketball
- 48:56for real in a real game and goes down the basketball
- 48:59courts regularly to play pick -up games and all
- 49:02the rest of it and then he plays basketball on
- 49:05a video game which isn't addictive because it
- 49:08ends right and just you play a game and then
- 49:10it ends and then it's you can play another game
- 49:12but whatever the addictive aspect to video games
- 49:16is the ones that continue on and that there's
- 49:18no about any end to it and you've got to get
- 49:20to the end of yeah whatever years to actually
- 49:23get to the end of it We have a guest that he
- 49:28developed a video game that is for learning science
- 49:32and adaptation and all this crazy stuff in biology.
- 49:36And it's very cool because we asked them how
- 49:38long does it take to complete the video game.
- 49:42And it's actually personalized for girls and
- 49:44boys, also age, and also tells them all the stats
- 49:48afterwards. But it has to be very short, like
- 49:5210 to 15 minutes, and that's it. That's it. You
- 49:55learn there, you do the task, in what part do
- 49:59you fail, or what do you have to improve, and
- 50:03it's no more than that. Because, as you said,
- 50:07the continuous ones are the ones causing this
- 50:11addiction. Tell us today, is it scary at the
- 50:15same time? We're wonderful humans, right? And
- 50:22we're going to solve the problems that we have.
- 50:25Yeah, I have faith. I still have faith in our
- 50:30humanity. Sometimes it's tricky. But that's the
- 50:33idea, connecting. Thank you very much, Mark.
- 50:38This has been amazing. Thank you for accepting
- 50:40this invitation, for sharing your knowledge and
- 50:43your amazing experience. Thank you, Linda. It
- 50:45was great to meet you. This episode was inspired
- 50:48by the courage to challenge deeply rooted assumptions
- 50:52about human nature, about how we learn, how we
- 50:55grow, and how we build a society that truly supports
- 50:59connection. Dr. Mark Williams reminds us that
- 51:06science is reimagining the system we live in.
- 51:10It's about seeing empathy as an evolutionary
- 51:13strength. and it's about asking ourselves what
- 51:17kind of future we are requiring our brains to
- 51:19live in. Science Behind the Glass is an independent
- 51:23podcast created and produced by your host Linda
- 51:26Hernandez and Daniel Esguerra. With the invaluable
- 51:29support of our technical director Rafael Giordano
- 51:33and the original music by our colleague and friend
- 51:36Bernardo Aguila. Follow us on Instagram, X, Facebook,
- 51:40TikTok. and linking, and visit our website for
- 51:43more stories, resources, and upcoming episodes.
- 51:46If you enjoyed this conversation, we invite you
- 51:49to support our work or contribute through PayPal.
- 51:53Just go to our website, click into the support
- 51:57us button to continue with these narratives and
- 52:00supporting this project. Don't forget about critical
- 52:04thinking, about empathy, and about your own choices
- 52:08and decisions. Thank you for listening. Keep
- 52:11asking, keep connecting. Until next time.