Latest / Office Hours with Fexingo: Daily Career Q&A, Workplace Questions, and Professional Advice / How to Ask for a Mentor When Youre a Junior Employee
Transcript
- Lucas: So we got a question this week from a listener named Priya, who's about two years into her first job out of college. She says she knows she needs a mentor but has no idea how to ask someone without it being weird or presumptuous. Luna: Yeah, that's a really common one. It's one of those things everyone says you should do but nobody teaches you how to actually do it. Lucas: Exactly. And the default advice is usually 'just ask someone you admire' or 'network more,' which is basically useless. So let's get specific about what actually works. Luna: Let's do it. What's the first thing Priya should avoid? Lucas: I'd say the biggest mistake is sending a message that says, 'Will you be my mentor?' to someone very senior you've never spoken to. That puts the other person in an awkward spot. They don't know you, they don't know how much time you'll need, and it feels like a big yes or no commitment. Luna: Right. So you want to lower the stakes. I've heard of something called the 'two-ask framework' — you ask for a small thing first, and only after that do you ask for the bigger thing. Lucas: That's exactly the approach. Step one: ask for a twenty-minute informational interview. Make it easy for them to say yes. You say something like, 'I'm early in my career and I really admire your work on X. Would you be open to a brief chat next week about how you got started?' That's not a big ask. Luna: And do you mention the word 'mentor' at all in that first message? Lucas: No. You don't. The word 'mentor' carries weight. Instead, you frame it as seeking advice. There's a really interesting study from Harvard Business Review a few years ago showing that people are significantly more likely to help someone who asks for advice than someone who asks for mentorship. 'Advice' feels one-off and low-pressure. Luna: So after the informational interview, then what? How does Priya transition to an ongoing relationship? Lucas: That's the second ask. At the end of the twenty-minute call, she says something like, 'This was incredibly helpful. Would it be okay if I reached out again in a month or two with a quick question?' That's still low commitment. Most people will say yes. Luna: And then after a couple of those follow-ups, it's basically a mentorship without ever having to use the word. Lucas: Exactly. You're building the relationship naturally. And if at some point you want to formalize it, you can say, 'I've really valued your guidance these past few months. Would you be open to being a more formal mentor?' But by then it's just naming something that's already happening. Luna: I think who Priya asks matters a lot too. The instinct is to go for the most senior person in the department — the VP or the director. But that person is probably overloaded and may not have the bandwidth. Lucas: Great point. A Korn Ferry study from 2023 found that employees with mentors are promoted five times more often, but the study also noted that the most effective mentors are often just one or two levels above you. They remember what your challenges are like, and they have more time. Luna: Yeah. A senior manager or a director is usually a better bet than the SVP. And don't forget peers who are a few years ahead — they can be just as valuable. Lucas: And one more thing: Priya should look outside her direct reporting line. If her boss mentors her, there can be a conflict when she wants to talk about career moves that might not align with the team's needs. A mentor in a different department or even a different company can be more objective. Luna: Okay, but let's say Priya sends the first email — what if she gets no reply? Or what if the person says no? Lucas: That's going to happen sometimes, and it's not personal. Senior people get dozens of these requests. If she doesn't hear back after a week, a polite follow-up is fine. If she gets a no, she thanks them and moves on. The key is to have a list of five to ten potential mentors so no single rejection feels like a dead end. Luna: And when she does get a yes, she needs to come prepared to that first meeting. Have specific questions. Show that she's done her homework. That's how you signal that you're worth investing in. Lucas: Absolutely. And here's the other side: she should think about what she can give back. Even a junior person can offer value — sharing what she's learning about new tools, offering to help with a small project, or just being a fresh pair of eyes on something. Mentorship works best when it's reciprocal. Luna: That's a good point. And it's also a good reminder that if this episode helped you think through a career move or a decision, the way to keep this show ad-free and independent is really simple. If today's episode was worth a coffee to you, you can find us at buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. Lucas: Yeah, we don't have sponsors or ads, and that's intentional. Listener support is what makes that possible. So if you can, link is in the show notes. Luna: Alright, back to mentorship. Lucas, what about the actual ask itself — is there a template Priya could use? Lucas: Sure. For the first email, keep it short. Subject line: 'Quick question about your career path in ' — that's it. Then three sentences: introduce yourself, mention something specific you admire about their work, and ask for twenty minutes. No attachments, no long bio. Luna: And for the second ask, after the informational interview, what does that look like? Lucas: Something like: 'Thank you again for your time last week. Your advice on X was really helpful. I was wondering if I could follow up with a quick question in a month or so? No pressure at all.' That keeps the door open. Luna: I love that it's low pressure on both sides. Priya doesn't feel like she's imposing, and the mentor doesn't feel trapped. Lucas: Right. And if the mentor says yes to that follow-up, then a month later Priya sends a specific question — not 'how do I grow in my career,' but something like 'I'm working on a project with a tight deadline and I'm struggling to prioritize. How would you approach it?' That shows she's applying the advice. Luna: That also makes the mentor feel like their time was well spent. People like to know they made a difference. Lucas: Exactly. And after a couple of those exchanges, the relationship is basically a mentorship. At that point, Priya can ask for a quarterly check-in, or the mentor might offer it unprompted. Luna: One thing we haven't touched on: what if Priya's company has a formal mentorship program? Should she use that instead? Lucas: Use it if it exists, but don't rely on it exclusively. Formal programs often assign you someone who may not be the best fit. It's a starting point. But the organic relationships you build yourself are usually stronger and more durable. Luna: Okay, final piece of advice for Priya? Lucas: Start today. Pick three people — one in your department, one in a different department, and one outside your company. Send the first email this week. The worst that happens is you get a no, and you're no worse off than you are now. Luna: And if you're on the other side — a senior person listening — consider saying yes to that first informational interview. You never know who you might help. Lucas: That's it for this episode. Next time we'll tackle another listener question. Thanks for being here.