Latest / The Vegan Report / Ridglan Farms: Behind the Smokescreen.
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to The Vegan Report, my name is Ryan,
- 0:03and today you will hear the unfiltered truth
- 0:06about the Ridgeland Farm protests. By now, you
- 0:10have surely heard about this so -called Beagle
- 0:13Rescue. It has attracted immense media attention
- 0:17and sympathy from the animal rights movement.
- 0:21And my suspicion is that if you ask any vegan
- 0:24about it, They will tell you that it is the story
- 0:28of a triumphant group of activists closing down
- 0:32one of the worst dog breeding facility in the
- 0:35US and rescuing thousands of dogs from a terrible
- 0:39fate. But what if everyone had it wrong? What
- 0:44if the story and reporting you heard on this
- 0:47issue missed the mark and by a mile? And the
- 0:51Richland Farm protests did not save dogs, they
- 0:55actually harmed dogs, harmed activists, and harmed
- 0:59this movement as well. To expose the truth on
- 1:03this issue, I have with me Dr. Crystal Heath,
- 1:06founder of Our Honor, the only organization empowering
- 1:10veterinarians to oppose the abuse of the animal
- 1:14agriculture industry. She has been on the front
- 1:18line of covering this story and she joins me
- 1:21now for an exclusive conversation discussing
- 1:23what happened at Ridgeland Farm, why this event
- 1:28has taken the proportions it has, the hate against
- 1:32animal lab researchers and meat eaters we see
- 1:36being legitimized, and how could that hate lead
- 1:41to mass violence? the chances of the arrested
- 1:45protesters to escape prison, and much, much more.
- 1:50Visit the episode notes to find her contact info
- 1:53and the link to her organization. Your support
- 1:56to our honor would do a lot of good. Lastly,
- 2:01do not forget to share this episode with the
- 2:04vegans you know. Let's spark reflection and conversations
- 2:07on what we should accept as good activism. Follow
- 2:12the show and don't miss out on part two of this
- 2:16whole saga When it is released and make sure
- 2:19to leave a five -star review Thank you crystal.
- 2:23Welcome to the vegan reports. Thank you so much
- 2:25for being here Thank you so much for having me
- 2:28back again. Once again your favorite of this
- 2:31show Okay, I'll use some favorites somewhere
- 2:35I'm hated by many other places Okay, so Let's
- 2:42start by talking about how important this event,
- 2:49this protest has become in the animal rights
- 2:52community. I've seen people in group conversations
- 2:58bringing this up when introducing themselves
- 3:00like, and I was part of the original farm protest.
- 3:06And then people clapping with admiration. I've
- 3:11listened to people bring this up during job interviews
- 3:14and making social media posts about it. Quite
- 3:19a lot of social media posts around this activism
- 3:25stunt. And then when you think about all of the
- 3:28media coverage around it, it does feel like one
- 3:33of those pivotal moments in the animal rights
- 3:38movement. Yeah. I mean, it's It's wild. I've
- 3:42been working on the Ridgeland thing with a variety
- 3:45of different animal advocacy organizations. There's
- 3:48just not one group involved. There's many. And
- 3:52I've been working on this since 2019. I spoke
- 3:55about it at the University of Wisconsin. And
- 3:59I've grown increasingly concerned about the way
- 4:02things have been portrayed, I actually examined
- 4:06hundreds of those dogs as they came out of Ridgeland.
- 4:10I saw firsthand how these were the most shut
- 4:14down dogs I've ever seen in my life. It was awful.
- 4:19And I've seen Ridgeland Farms dogs who were released
- 4:22from labs, Marshall Farms dogs who were released
- 4:25from labs. The Marshall Farms dogs, I'm not saying
- 4:28any of this is right, but the Marshall Farms
- 4:32dogs when they're released are so much better
- 4:34adjusted than the Ridgeland dogs because they
- 4:37get like 90 seconds of enrichment a day versus
- 4:40like the, I forget the exact number, but Ridgeland
- 4:44Farms dogs get less socialization than the Marshall
- 4:47Farms dogs get. It was astonishing examining
- 4:51those dogs after they were released. They had
- 4:54dermatitis, dental disease. I was forbidden from
- 4:58saying anything about the health conditions of
- 5:01the dogs. I signed a thing, but now that they're
- 5:04all out and Ridgeland's closed down, I feel like
- 5:06I have some liberty to finally say what was going
- 5:09on. I know, speaking to other veterinarians who
- 5:12worked in labs on Ridgeland dogs, many of them
- 5:15have a congenital seizure problem as well. So
- 5:17that's something that I hope adopters are aware
- 5:20of. There's a huge problem with Giardia in these
- 5:23commercial dog breeding facilities. I've also
- 5:26publicly I have this need to set the record straight.
- 5:31I see so many activists. It's weird how everybody
- 5:35is saying like, oh, they were a part of this.
- 5:38And everybody kind of the outsiders say like,
- 5:41oh, animal rights is a cult. You're starting
- 5:46to act culty with the way that you're talking
- 5:49about this. And I'm like, don't do that. And
- 5:53now, especially me saying, actually, trying to
- 5:56correct people about events, about things that
- 5:59happened, about what Ridglin was doing, and getting
- 6:02such backlash for a commitment to the truth.
- 6:07I have this need to make sure people are accurate
- 6:11in what they say. And that's important with trials
- 6:13coming up and with people who were involved in
- 6:17this action. There should be some informed consent.
- 6:21And part of informed consent means that you're
- 6:24aware of all of the perspectives, the facts of
- 6:28the case before you do something that involves
- 6:31high legal risk. So yeah, I look forward to diving
- 6:34in on what all of those are. And it was interesting
- 6:36before I came onto this podcast today, I was
- 6:40listening to your previous episode with Gary
- 6:42Yourofsky and Paul Watson. And they were talking
- 6:46about the Ridgeland thing and Gary was talking
- 6:49about the April action that had not happened
- 6:52yet. and kind of what was motivating him to take
- 6:58part in that. And he really felt like, oh, if
- 7:00we get 2 ,000 people there, this is one thing
- 7:02he said. I don't want to portray this as a complete
- 7:05inaccurate version of what he said. But one of
- 7:08his points he made for wanting to take part in
- 7:11that was you're forcing the police's hand to
- 7:15take action now. it became clear to me he was
- 7:18thinking that the police were going to rescue
- 7:21those dogs or help them in some way because there
- 7:23were so many people there and a lot of people
- 7:26got into that action. I spoke to many people
- 7:28who were involved in that for a variety of different
- 7:32reasons and people were given this fire hose
- 7:34of information and they grabbed onto something
- 7:38that they could hold on to. as their reason for
- 7:42being there and what was going to work. And for
- 7:45some people, it was, I'm going to walk out of
- 7:47there with a dog. And that's why I'm there. I'm
- 7:49going to be one of those people to walk out of
- 7:51there with a dog. We are definitely going to
- 7:52get 2000 dogs out on April 18th. The date was
- 7:55going to be April 19th, but they did it a day
- 7:57early. Another reason was the press attention
- 8:01that it's going to get shining a light on the
- 8:04violence, bringing the violence out into the
- 8:06open. But a lot of people were misled too. They
- 8:11were led to believe the police wouldn't really
- 8:14do anything because they were nonviolent protesters.
- 8:17There wasn't going to be this risk of tear gas.
- 8:20And if you are worried, wear swim goggles and
- 8:22a mask and all of this stuff, which we can go
- 8:25into. Given all of the information that's come
- 8:27out, it didn't quite come out how a lot of people
- 8:31expected. Of course, I kind of I was messaging
- 8:37you. I'm like looking back onto my messages from
- 8:40April before the action telling you what was
- 8:43happening behind the scenes. I feel vindicated
- 8:46a little bit. I was right. And many people were
- 8:49like, man, I was texting all the people before
- 8:52this happened. And I'm like, this is how it's
- 8:53going to go down. They're not going to get any
- 8:55dogs out. There's going to be tear gas. And I
- 8:56feel vindicated. And it's like, why don't people
- 8:59listen to me? Yeah, I'm so lucky. to have you
- 9:03in my network to have had your voice in, in all
- 9:08of this, because if it wasn't for you, I think
- 9:11I would have just accepted the dominant narrative
- 9:15around this story, which is that rigid and farm
- 9:18this place decided to shut down or something
- 9:23and then they were going to get rid of the dogs
- 9:27and then protesters appeared and they changed
- 9:31the fate of those dogs. for the best. And yeah,
- 9:36that's about it. It's a triumphant story of protesters
- 9:40coming to the rescue of dogs that were experimented
- 9:45upon. And I never heard of Ritual and Farm before.
- 9:50And I did not follow that story as closely as
- 9:55I should have because I did not think that it
- 9:59would grow into the monster it has become. Yeah,
- 10:03the monster. That's a good way to put it. Okay.
- 10:06But Richland Farm, you said appeared on your
- 10:08radar back in 2019. What was the context behind
- 10:13that? I actually had a YouTube channel taken
- 10:15down because of sharing footage that the activists
- 10:19gathered from inside. Breaking into that facility,
- 10:24rescuing dogs, I know some of the dogs who were
- 10:27rescued in that first action. I'm not critical
- 10:30of open rescue as a tactic or covert rescue by
- 10:34any means. I think sometimes that is necessary,
- 10:36but I think people need to go into it with their
- 10:39eyes wide open, fully understanding. the risks,
- 10:43fully understanding what could possibly happen
- 10:46and not relying on, oh, because in the past,
- 10:50people haven't gone to jail for very long. People
- 10:53haven't suffered that much. A lot of the times
- 10:56the charges are dropped. Last time, the activists
- 10:59from the 2018 rescue and open rescue, those activists,
- 11:04their charges were dropped. And so I think a
- 11:07lot of people are assuming, oh, the charges are
- 11:09going to be dropped again. But it's a different
- 11:12environment now. And I do have to bring up, I
- 11:15think a lot of people think, oh, one group is
- 11:18responsible for Ridgeland. It was that 2018 action
- 11:22that really put Ridgeland on everybody's radar.
- 11:25And I would argue that's not the case. It was
- 11:28actually back in 2015. Beagle Freedom Project
- 11:33was the group that put this on all of our radar.
- 11:36And they were the first one to bring a story.
- 11:40There's this March 5, 2015 story that they did.
- 11:44And at that time, Ridgeland had 3 ,733 beagles.
- 11:50622 were experimented on in some fashion. and
- 11:54they had this breeding colony of 750 female dogs
- 11:57and 70 studs. And Dr. Burns, who was now like
- 12:0190 plus years old, he was the guy who is in charge
- 12:04of it, owns it. It was so interesting to read
- 12:07what he said. back then. After this article,
- 12:10I think they got a PR team because they're not
- 12:13as forthcoming as they used to be. But he says,
- 12:15you don't love doing it, but that's the business.
- 12:18He says how they average 1 .7 litters per year
- 12:23per dog, about four to five puppies. And these
- 12:27customers, they only want dogs who are perfect
- 12:29with no defects. And he joined Ridgeland in 1968.
- 12:34This was two years after they started. And he
- 12:37was interested in getting into this beagle breeding
- 12:39business because he saw there was this huge need
- 12:43because the need for standardized dog research
- 12:47subjects came after the passage of the Animal
- 12:50Welfare Act back in the 1960s. They had more
- 12:54than a dozen competitors back then, but now Ridgeland
- 12:57is about 10 % of the market share. He even said,
- 13:01hey, I think this is going away. these new things
- 13:05that are coming up, non -animal models and computer
- 13:09and AI and stuff, that is going to take over.
- 13:12So even back in 2015, Ridgeon was seeing the
- 13:16writing on the wall. He's like, the public doesn't
- 13:18like this. This is going away. The pressure led
- 13:22to a special prosecutor. A whistleblower pointed
- 13:26out like, hey, they were removing the third eyelid
- 13:29glands of these dogs with no anesthesia. the
- 13:33cherry eye surgery, they were just using prepare
- 13:36cane, which is a very old way of doing things.
- 13:40And ultimately, Ridgeland gave up its breed or
- 13:43sell a permit pretty easily, which I think was
- 13:45a sign that they were done. Back then, last year,
- 13:49they were done doing this. They were done fighting.
- 13:53Richard van Dommelen had his license suspended.
- 13:57He voluntarily gave up his veterinary license.
- 14:02He voluntarily gave it up. I think he was done
- 14:04too. So then, back in February of this year,
- 14:10Center for Humane Economy, seeing the writing
- 14:12on the wall, and Ridglin was not able to sell
- 14:14very many dogs during this time, I think because
- 14:17of all of this pressure, they decided to purchase
- 14:21the dogs. And miraculously, they started a conversation
- 14:25with Ridglin to release the dogs. And From what
- 14:29I'm told by people closely involved in this,
- 14:32Ridgeland was ready to release the dogs. And
- 14:36then this March action happened. And yay, 22
- 14:41dogs were rescued. I can't be against 22 dogs
- 14:45getting rescued. But this also led to many dogs.
- 14:51than being purchased by biosciences companies.
- 14:55These biosciences companies like Merck, Bo Ringer
- 14:59Engelheim, Comparative Biosciences, they saw
- 15:02all the press attention too and were hoping for
- 15:08maybe a good deal on these dogs. And from what
- 15:11I'm being told, it seems they were close to a
- 15:15deal. And then Laura Trump goes online and says,
- 15:21she offered a million dollars for the dogs which
- 15:24is more than what they were going to sell the
- 15:28dogs for. A lot of people might say like oh you're
- 15:32retelling the story after it all happens but
- 15:35I sent a message to you on April 4th and what
- 15:39did I say? I said a group did raise the funds
- 15:42to buy the Ridglin dogs and was negotiating that
- 15:44deal with Ridglin. when the second open rescue
- 15:47was announced, that deal fell apart. I was hearing
- 15:50wild things that they were going to do ventilation
- 15:54shutdown, one group said. And I'm like, that's
- 15:57completely illegal. They wouldn't do that. I
- 16:00was worried a more feasible thing would be that
- 16:05they would euthanize the dogs and sell them as
- 16:07cadavers, which is something that they would
- 16:09do. I was told all sorts of things that Some
- 16:12prominent activists departed and then they came
- 16:15back. But yeah, there was this negotiation happening
- 16:21well before the April 18 action is the point
- 16:26I want to make. And this these actions led these
- 16:31dogs to be sold. I want to get my numbers right.
- 16:35So on April 22nd. Merck Animal Health purchased
- 16:4054 of the dogs. On April 29th, Boehringer Ingelheim
- 16:45purchased 17 of the dogs. April 29th, also East
- 16:49Tennessee Clinical Research got two of the dogs.
- 16:52And in June of 2026, Comparative Biosciences
- 16:55got 33 of the dogs. So it's sad all of these
- 16:58dogs could have been released, but the March
- 17:02action. delayed everything. And it's not just
- 17:06me saying this. There are many prominent people
- 17:11out there who are saying the exact same things.
- 17:15But it's so interesting how I've been bullied
- 17:18and attacked for just screenshotting their comments
- 17:22on social media, sharing it to my social media.
- 17:25And then I've had people affiliated with the
- 17:28open rescue campaign reach out to me and say,
- 17:30do you have any proof of this? And I ask, well,
- 17:32why don't you ask this person who I screenshotted
- 17:35their comment for that? Did you ask them why
- 17:38they're saying this? And it's like, no, they're
- 17:41not. They're not reaching out to them. They're
- 17:43just harassing me. But I really think all of
- 17:46these news reports that. These actions led to
- 17:51the release of the dogs are completely false.
- 17:54Yeah, they got a lot of media attention. But
- 17:58what also got a lot of media attention was the
- 18:00release, the dogs and the stories of them being
- 18:02adopted and all of the footage of them playing
- 18:05and everything. And the sad part is now activists
- 18:08are facing felony charges and activists got injured.
- 18:13Teeth got knocked out. They got tear gassed when
- 18:18the dogs were going to be released anyway. And
- 18:21they're claiming this necessity defense. The
- 18:24necessity defense means that there's no other
- 18:27way to get these dogs out. But there was. And
- 18:32the fact that there was a legal avenue to get
- 18:35these dogs out and originally was negotiating
- 18:37will ultimately harm their case, I think. And
- 18:42in Wisconsin, I think the necessity defense is
- 18:44specifically related to weather, like some sort
- 18:47of weather threat. You can't do it. based on
- 18:51just they're in danger because of other reasons.
- 18:56What a mess. Yeah, it's a mess. It's messy. And
- 19:00few people want to dig into it because it's they're
- 19:04like, oh, you know, the dogs are out. So isn't
- 19:07that can't you just be happy that the dogs are
- 19:10out? It's like, no, because people are hurt.
- 19:13People are facing legal charges. People didn't
- 19:16know what they're getting into. There was a lack
- 19:18of informed consent. And it harms our movement
- 19:21when we're not accurate, when we're not honest,
- 19:23when we're not transparent. And it makes our
- 19:24movement stronger when we're freely able to talk
- 19:27about these things. All of those reasons are
- 19:30good reasons to speak up about this. But also
- 19:33I don't want to see a repeat of this whole operation
- 19:39and are already whispers of people wanting to
- 19:42organize something similar with other operations
- 19:46out there. And it scares me because this You
- 19:50know you we have to be have courage whenever
- 19:53I hear somebody say I'm scared I'm like I know
- 19:56that's going to register in the activists mind
- 19:59of like we have to be courageous They're taught
- 20:01this mantra be brave. We have to be courageous
- 20:04and it's like, okay instead of saying I'm scared
- 20:07it's like Mmm, I have concerns That need to be
- 20:13addressed here. So I don't use fear just because
- 20:17I know It's almost like a brainwashing. It's
- 20:21giving brainwashing, you guys, the way that you've
- 20:25created these mantras. It's getting a little
- 20:30coercive. I invite people to read the book, The
- 20:35Gift of Fear, because fear is actually your friend.
- 20:39It should not be afraid of fear itself. But yeah,
- 20:43I'll be afraid for both of us. It's scary to
- 20:47think about. this becoming the norm in this movement.
- 20:53You know, I'm thinking, why this issue? I thought
- 20:57we had evolved beyond that in the sense that
- 21:00we were now focusing on farm animals. That was
- 21:04the big thing in the animal rights movement.
- 21:09And experiments and denouncing labs and all of
- 21:12that. It was at the center stage of our movement,
- 21:16maybe back in the 1960s or something that belongs
- 21:20to an older generation of activists. So how come
- 21:26there was this appeal for this issue? This is
- 21:29so interesting because I've seen the evolution
- 21:32of this within the group that was involved in
- 21:36the March and April actions, having conversations
- 21:39with them about this back in 2020. And I remember
- 21:42a sort of side group who was very passionate
- 21:46about the animal experimentation thing, had ideas
- 21:49for legislation. We're going to name it after
- 21:51one of the dogs. Of course, There's a great activist
- 21:55who drafted the FDA Modernization Act, which
- 21:59was passed and now working on the next iteration
- 22:02of the FDA Modernization Act. But I was told,
- 22:06back in 2020, animal experimentation just isn't
- 22:11where it's at because everybody feels like animal
- 22:15experimentation is necessary. But there was this
- 22:18thing of like, But the dogs, everybody loves
- 22:21dogs. And this footage from inside Ridgeland
- 22:23and the cages of dogs is pretty horrifying. And
- 22:26that's where my YouTube got taken down because
- 22:29I was trying to share this footage in Facebook
- 22:33chats. with veterinarians. And I just got brutally
- 22:38attacked by my colleagues by veterinarians for
- 22:41sharing this footage. And I'm like, I'm seeing
- 22:43this footage all around everywhere. And it's
- 22:45not being taken down. But yeah, like I lost my
- 22:47YouTube channel because of bullying for merely
- 22:50just posting this footage. So people are horrified
- 22:54by it by the fact that dogs are being used in
- 22:57this. But I think there was like a lack of the
- 23:01activists really didn't think it's going to work
- 23:04because people are continuing to justify animal
- 23:09experimentation. But White Coat Waste Project
- 23:12did such a great job with their messaging that
- 23:15this is actually very wasteful and foushy and
- 23:19those beagles with the nets over their heads
- 23:22that were experimented on. And that sort of was
- 23:26a jumping off point. Let's revive this Ridgeland
- 23:29thing. And the charges were dropped against the
- 23:32activists. And it's like, oh, Now we're licensed
- 23:34to do whatever we want around this and it gets
- 23:37a ton of media attention. And I think there is
- 23:40this belief that we bring people in to our sphere
- 23:43on the dog issue, then we'll be able to talk
- 23:48about other animals too. And I'm seeing a missed
- 23:52opportunity here. Now that Big Dog Ranch Rescue
- 23:55got involved and they ended up actually outbidding
- 23:58Center for Humane Economy on the last release
- 24:01of the dogs. They do these Birkins for Beagles
- 24:05thing where they're having people buy raffle
- 24:09tickets to potentially win a Hermes Birkin bag
- 24:14made of, you know, the skin of dead cows. And
- 24:18everybody is taking their Ridgeland Beagles to
- 24:21get their Starbucks pup cups. And there's these
- 24:25whole conversations about feeding your Ridgeland
- 24:28dog raw meat. And it's like, oh, we're missing
- 24:33out. Now we're like, yay, the activists, like
- 24:36we have to support the activists who are facing
- 24:38felony charges and nobody's pushing back on this
- 24:42like feeding dogs, raw food, this Birkin for
- 24:45Beagles thing. It's so funny how Laurie Simmons
- 24:48is not being criticized at all for the Birkins
- 24:51for Beagles thing, but I am being criticized
- 24:55so severely for trying to set the record straight
- 25:00on What actually led to the release of the dogs,
- 25:03which wasn't the March and April actions. Those
- 25:06got media attention. Yay. People fundraised off
- 25:12of that and got a lot of money. Yay. We love
- 25:15this successful fundraising and the media attention.
- 25:18But. That's not what led to the release of the
- 25:22dogs. And if we want to be honest and what actually
- 25:25works to get these places closed down, what worked
- 25:28in the case of high quality research, which was
- 25:31a place that closed down around the same time
- 25:33as Ridgeland. And I got to visit all of those
- 25:35Marshall farms and Ridgeland dogs who were released
- 25:37from that. It was whistleblowers. It was USDA
- 25:42complaints and veterinarians speaking out about.
- 25:46this place and PETA's actions that led to this
- 25:50closure. It was an open rescue. And the same
- 25:54thing with Invego. It was diligent collecting
- 25:57of information, whistleblowers and the diligent
- 26:01reporting, getting the USD on board, getting
- 26:04politicians on board, getting the politicians,
- 26:07the news media, educating them about this. That's
- 26:10what really works. But what these huge actions
- 26:14do do is emboldened activists, which is what
- 26:18we're seeing now. These emboldened activists
- 26:21who feel motivated to finally post about this
- 26:23on social media relentlessly, but unfortunately
- 26:27they are saying things that are not true. And
- 26:29there is now this us versus them vilification
- 26:34of lab workers, this idea that lab workers are
- 26:37evil. We need to get lab workers on our side.
- 26:41They are the whistleblowers. They are the ones
- 26:43who have the data that we need. to shut these
- 26:47places down and to move away from animal research.
- 26:50And the vilification of them, the us versus them
- 26:53stuff is really harming our ability to do work.
- 26:59And I know Madeleine Krasno, who's a friend of
- 27:01the show, a friend of you and everybody, Justify
- 27:05is doing amazing work reaching out to lab workers
- 27:10and getting them on their side and telling their
- 27:13stories. She is getting relentlessly inundated
- 27:17with bullies who are saying the most awful things
- 27:21to her. And when you go on the social media,
- 27:23all of them say save the dogs. What's the hashtag
- 27:26save the dogs thing. They're the most vicious
- 27:30people who are actually harming the ability to
- 27:33get the evidence we need to move away from this
- 27:37model of research. There's this opposition to
- 27:40what you're saying because people's reputations
- 27:43are or in peril. There are lots of activists
- 27:47that went to those protests, were invited to
- 27:50go there and actually purchased plane tickets
- 27:54and traveled sometimes from very far away to
- 27:58get there and then post about it or associate
- 28:01themselves with it. And now they have to face
- 28:05the reality that this protest was not a force
- 28:09for good and it actually harmed those dogs. But
- 28:14from what you just said, I think, no, it's more
- 28:18than that. There's like a visualization of this
- 28:22event. It's like, you know, I don't have a great
- 28:29analogy, but maybe people who went and served
- 28:32their country in some war zone and now they have
- 28:35this bond, you know, between themselves, this
- 28:41you know, friendship, trauma bond, something
- 28:45like that. Yes. And it is powerful. And we see
- 28:51how powerful this is this bond, but we get we
- 28:56need to go over this, you know, we can't allow
- 29:00this to root itself in the movement and spread.
- 29:04Have any solution in mind? Yeah, I think a huge
- 29:08problem that we're seeing here is not only just
- 29:10groupthink, which groupthink is if you're not
- 29:14aware of what this is, some of the warning signs
- 29:17of groupthink are this like perceived invulnerability,
- 29:20this overconfidence that leads groups to take.
- 29:23dangerous and reckless actions, rationalization
- 29:26and denial, and they dismiss warnings and avoid
- 29:31reevaluating things. There's this strong moral
- 29:34justification. The group assumes that its actions
- 29:37are inherently good and ignores any possible
- 29:41ethical issues. The stereotype views of others
- 29:44and enemies are overly simplistic. So lab workers,
- 29:49of course, anybody who works in those systems
- 29:50are evil. And we don't understand what leads
- 29:53people to do that sort of work. Of course, they
- 29:56view animal rights activists as evil. We are
- 29:59unhinged and we are not rational and dangerous
- 30:04even. And of course, these when these groups,
- 30:06they're silencing dissent and Members who disagree
- 30:09are pressured to conform and not speak out, which
- 30:12I've seen a ton of people keep trying to silence
- 30:15me. And I know many people have been silenced.
- 30:17I so resonated with what Paul Watson said on
- 30:19your podcast where he was like, see shepherd
- 30:21wanted to give me $350 ,000 to just be a figurehead
- 30:25and shut up. And I would not take it. I'm like
- 30:28the same. I make enough money. If they gave me
- 30:31$350 ,000 to just shut up, I would not take it.
- 30:34I want to get the truth out there. What I've
- 30:36seen in this group chat is this false consensus.
- 30:40All of these group chats, people have sent me
- 30:42these transcripts of the planning chats and the
- 30:46way that anybody who voices concerns, they're
- 30:50kind of... assuaged and everybody's like, no,
- 30:54you have to be brave and tear gas is in a risk
- 30:56and the legal risk is low and we're going to
- 30:59get those dogs out. Whatever people need to hear
- 31:02to keep motivated and keep going is what they
- 31:05will continue to hear. And there's all of these
- 31:08myths of if we shut down, now it's Marshall Farms.
- 31:11If we shut down Marshall Farms, that will end
- 31:13animal testing. And it's like, no, it won't.
- 31:17It will not, it will move to other countries
- 31:20and not even animal testing. Martial farms maybe
- 31:23would strike a blow to the dog experimentation
- 31:27industry, but it wouldn't even do much to affect
- 31:31the pigs, the primates. the mice and the rats
- 31:35that are used in animal experimentation. And
- 31:38there's already a shift because of the closure
- 31:40of Rugelland and all of the attention on dogs.
- 31:42There's a shift towards pigs and primates now
- 31:46for a lot of this research. So it's very concerning
- 31:51what I'm seeing here. And what's the answer?
- 31:54I think encouraging more people to speak out
- 31:57about these things and speak the truth. I've
- 32:00struggled with this, though, honestly, with the
- 32:03veterinary profession. I'm like, how do we get
- 32:06the veterinarians to speak out and share their
- 32:09stories? And it's really hard when there's so
- 32:13many people. And now when veterinarians do speak
- 32:16out and say like, yeah, I used to be part of
- 32:19the lab. And I think it's bad. People go, how
- 32:23dare you? How could you possibly work in a lab?
- 32:25You must be evil to the core. No forgiving, but
- 32:30of course we forgive Laurie Simmons for selling
- 32:32Birkin, Hermes Birkin bags. We forgive all of
- 32:36the male animal activist leaders who pursued
- 32:39young activists, but we don't dare forgive anybody
- 32:44who worked in a lab and now speaks out about
- 32:46it. Those are the very people that we need who
- 32:50can explain why people do this. It's almost like...
- 32:54If you don't virtue signal hard enough, and if
- 32:58you're not posting on social media saying that
- 33:00lab workers are evil and experimentation is wrong,
- 33:04and if you're not hardcore in that language,
- 33:08you're on the bad side. You're not one of us.
- 33:12You're one of them. Because I mean, like, well,
- 33:15how are we going to develop medications for our
- 33:18dogs, for our companion animals? How are we going
- 33:21to develop animal free foods that we can feed
- 33:24to millions of animals and not worry about potentially
- 33:28poisoning them or having a nutrient deficiency?
- 33:31We have to do some sort of research. And I think
- 33:35that there's a way to do that consensually. on
- 33:39animals who have an advocate the same way, with
- 33:42the same consideration that we give human infants
- 33:45and children who we experiment on. Because we
- 33:48have to try new drugs on infants and children
- 33:52whose bodies are different than adults for the
- 33:56first time. We have to do that. There's one point
- 33:59where we have to put it in a child or an infant.
- 34:02And we do it with the utmost caution and consideration.
- 34:06Of course, sometimes It's not done right at all.
- 34:11And there are institutional review boards and
- 34:13there are people who sit on those review boards
- 34:16and who voice concerns about a study and who
- 34:18are retaliated against and kicked out. This is
- 34:22a huge problem in any field. It's the same thing
- 34:25that happens in animal rights activism when you're
- 34:27like, oh, actually, the March and April actions
- 34:29didn't lead to the release of the dogs. The same
- 34:32way that I'm getting pushed out and bullied and
- 34:35retaliated against for saying that is the same
- 34:38thing that happens to people who sit on institution
- 34:40review boards and was like, actually, the study
- 34:42is overly dangerous and we shouldn't do it. They
- 34:46are kicked out. You're harming this very important
- 34:48work that we're doing to save children's lives.
- 34:51How dare you? You are slowing things down or
- 34:53kicking you out. And that's the fundamental problem
- 34:56that we need to address and raise awareness about.
- 35:00And I think just talking about it for the start
- 35:02will help. There's an organization called Center
- 35:05for Institutional Courage. Because we're all
- 35:08about the bravery and courage that kind of gives
- 35:09a framework for how to do this. What do you think
- 35:12animal activists need to become aware of? How
- 35:15do institutions act courageously and they protect
- 35:19whistleblowers? They have systems in place to
- 35:22protect people who are whistleblowers and they
- 35:24don't retaliate against. people who voice concerns.
- 35:28And that's the start. This is, this is a lot.
- 35:32Yeah. I want to bring this conversation for a
- 35:35moment to a dark place. I recently watched an
- 35:39anime called the Darwin incident. And it's about,
- 35:43well, one of the team of that is animal experimentation.
- 35:47And in there, there's this portrayal of an animal
- 35:51rights activist. who gets radicalized and decides
- 35:56to shoot people. That person considers those
- 36:01people as, you know, animal abusers, carnists
- 36:04put the labels you want to put on over them.
- 36:07And I was looking at that and I felt horrified
- 36:11because I thought this is a possibility. This
- 36:14is truly a possibility. I do see potentially
- 36:18an animal rights activist out there who decides
- 36:21to resorts to violence against people in a mass
- 36:29terrorist attack, maybe in the name of animal
- 36:32rights. Why not? Again, if we look at all of
- 36:36the rhetoric that we see out there on social
- 36:39media, and you mentioned a few of those things,
- 36:42and I've seen the same level of vitriol against
- 36:45not just lab workers, but everyday people who
- 36:48are not vegan. If you eat meat, you're a murderer.
- 36:52Murder, wow. What do we do to murderers? We give
- 36:56them the electric chair. And it's wild to meet
- 36:59animal rights activists advocating for killing
- 37:01people. Of course, nobody has been killed yet
- 37:04by animal rights activists. But the language
- 37:08is getting there. And I've heard some people
- 37:10argue, oh, it's just a release valve for this
- 37:13anger if they don't mean it. And I'm like, there's
- 37:16not a good look for activists who are currently
- 37:19standing trial and trying to portray themselves
- 37:21as nonviolent activists when everybody around
- 37:23you is saying violent things. And I don't think
- 37:27it's a release valve for some because I have
- 37:28run into some pretty unhinged people. So I got
- 37:31this wonderful apartment and I was planning on
- 37:33having community events here because we have
- 37:35a giant community space. But because of all of
- 37:39the vitriol I have gotten from animal rights
- 37:42activists, I will not host an event at my place
- 37:46because I don't want animal rights activists
- 37:47to know where I live. I used to be fearful of
- 37:49the industry, like the animal ag people are out
- 37:52to get. No. I'm more afraid of animal rights
- 37:55activists as a vegan, veterinarian, animal rights
- 37:58activist than I am of the industry at this point.
- 38:03Yeah. I mean, when I look at t -shirts sold by
- 38:07sanctuaries or ticks of the sort and I get the
- 38:10urge of shopping and getting one of those t -shirts,
- 38:14I stop myself because that would mean giving
- 38:16them my address and I actually don't trust them.
- 38:19I've seen too many animal rights activists with
- 38:21crazy ideas in their head that I can trust them
- 38:25with that information. Just can't. But yeah,
- 38:28it is a chilling scenario potential. And I would
- 38:32hate to think that I somewhat contributed to
- 38:35that, but it doesn't seem to worry most leaders
- 38:39of this movement because again, there's this
- 38:42tolerance and silence around what just happened
- 38:45in Richard and farm and all of the conversation
- 38:49around it and a tolerance. for the attacks that
- 38:53you've been the victim of for so long now. So
- 38:56yeah, how do we make leaders of this movement
- 38:59understand that this is more than what it looks
- 39:05like? You know, this is not just a quarrel between,
- 39:11you know, an insider in fighting thing. Yeah,
- 39:14in fighting. It's always dismissed as I'm like,
- 39:18No, what's worse in fighting or group think is
- 39:22far worse than in fighting. And I think it's
- 39:27even so the last time I was on your podcast,
- 39:30I shared my own personal story of what happened
- 39:34with me. And I didn't mention anyone's name on
- 39:39that. podcast. And I haven't mentioned anyone's
- 39:41name on this one as well, because it's not about
- 39:43individual people. It's about groups and what
- 39:46they did and patterns. But when somebody shared
- 39:49your episode that you did of me, the person was
- 39:55immediately messaged with somebody who felt I
- 39:58was talking about a specific person. And this
- 40:01person messaged and said, Crystal, repeatedly
- 40:05speaks on behalf of other women without their
- 40:07consent. She does this to me multiple times where
- 40:10she has talked about my story and said I was
- 40:12being abused by blank, which is not true. She
- 40:15does not have my consent to speak about my experiences
- 40:18with him. And that's been really upsetting from
- 40:20what I've seen. She has done this with other
- 40:22women as well. Did I talk about other women on
- 40:25that podcast? I talked about in general. people
- 40:28being romantically pursued. And then she says
- 40:30the last time this came up was during our court
- 40:32case where Crystal was supporting the very people
- 40:36who called the cops on activists, telling them
- 40:38about an open rescue, which was honestly really
- 40:41scary and ended up causing a lot of issues for
- 40:43our court case. So here I am a snitch. And this
- 40:48is we know there are other women, one woman who
- 40:53had her defense funding revoked on an open rescue
- 40:58trial. She faced felony charges, had her defense
- 41:02funding revoked, and attorneys went on Twitter
- 41:05and said when the National Lawyers Guild started
- 41:08raising money for her defense. said next level
- 41:12embarrassing that a National Lawyers Guild would
- 41:14raise money for a snitch and other animal rights
- 41:17attorneys liked that tweet. This is back in the
- 41:20day when you could see who would like a tweet
- 41:22and very prominent animal rights attorneys like
- 41:24that tweet. And I'm like, oh my gosh, this is
- 41:26definitely like a bros before hoes situation.
- 41:29It's all of the bros banding together to attack
- 41:33this one sheet. I used to think like Kind of
- 41:37there's this hierarchy of activists and those
- 41:39activists who are willing to face felony charges
- 41:41are like the pinnacle of the activists, right?
- 41:45And once you do that, you can clearly do no wrong.
- 41:48You can romantically pursue whoever you want.
- 41:50You can have harems. It's fine. You'll get forgiven.
- 41:54But you're a woman who voices concerns about
- 41:56another. You're called a snitch. And people repeatedly
- 41:59told me she snitched to the prosecutors. For
- 42:03one, this is open rescue. How do you snitch on
- 42:07an open rescue? It's all out in the open, right?
- 42:11Isn't that the point? But if you'd put that label
- 42:14on somebody that they're a snitch, you're done.
- 42:17You're ostracized from the movement. And there's
- 42:21no critical thinking. And that's what they do
- 42:23to everybody who is like, hey, actually, this
- 42:25is what happened. So that's concerning. And I
- 42:29think what do we do? We just tell our stories.
- 42:32Every time I talk about this, more and more people
- 42:35say, oh my gosh, thank you so much for sharing
- 42:37your story. That resonated with me. And now I
- 42:40know I recognize the red flags and I know what's
- 42:44going on. They'll get other people out of it
- 42:47and people be warned. And, you know, we can't
- 42:49get everybody, but at least we tried, you know,
- 42:53and that's all we can do. Well, I think it has
- 42:55to do with the fact that we don't have human
- 42:58resources in this movement. I need ARHR, animal
- 43:03rights human resources. Yeah. I mean, it's because
- 43:06in the corporate world, they detect people with
- 43:10narcissistic personalities, psychopaths, all
- 43:12of that. They have personalities. Wow. I mean,
- 43:14for the record, like a lot of these animal research
- 43:17facilities are run by narcissistic sociopaths,
- 43:21in my experience. Not the workers, do not attack
- 43:24the workers with this or the veterinarians, but
- 43:27the CEOs and huge problem in HR. If you feel
- 43:32you have to report somebody into HR, HR is there
- 43:35to protect the company, not you. So HR isn't
- 43:43perfect either, but we need something. We need
- 43:46something to protect activists. Well, maybe they
- 43:49do it on purpose. They know very well that this
- 43:52person has certain personality traits that make
- 43:56them bad friends or lovers, but certainly good
- 44:00CEOs. And so we are actually looking for that
- 44:03in a person and we'll give you power if we detect
- 44:07that in you. But in the nonprofits world and
- 44:11in contact with vulnerable populations, whether
- 44:13we're talking about animals or humans, we should
- 44:19be thinking the opposite way. We should detect
- 44:22them first of all, and then we should have systems
- 44:26to keep them far away from us and from those
- 44:30vulnerable populations. But there is none of
- 44:33that. And we actually pretend that psychopaths
- 44:36and narcissists and malignant this and that,
- 44:40that doesn't exist. The decades of psychiatric
- 44:45and psychological research that have been done
- 44:47on that, that's nothing. That's just, you know,
- 44:51those people are not walking among us and the
- 44:54chances that those people are in our movement,
- 44:58zero. We delude ourselves with that and our allies
- 45:02do not protect us. They are actually making us
- 45:05even more vulnerable to... the predation of those
- 45:08people. Yeah. And I think we have this sort of
- 45:11transcendent mission like to help animals. And
- 45:14animals are the most vulnerable. So whatever
- 45:16you've gone through personally, tear gas, had
- 45:19your teeth kicked out, you're in prison now for
- 45:22an action that wasn't needed because the dogs
- 45:24would have been released anyway. That doesn't
- 45:26matter because the dogs are the most important
- 45:29thing. And this is the same thing that we see
- 45:32in religious institutions as well. This person,
- 45:35the leader, of the FLDS is such a good, holy
- 45:40person, God -like, and you can't criticize him
- 45:43at all because he's doing such good, important
- 45:47work. We see this with NXIVM and Scientology,
- 45:52and I'm not saying any group's a cult, but when
- 45:54you start doing cult things, maybe we need to
- 45:58put the brakes on that. Don't do culty things,
- 46:02and people maybe won't accuse you of being a
- 46:04cult, but not having open dialogue and discussion
- 46:08about facts and bullying and retaliating against
- 46:12people who are posting their thoughts about an
- 46:14action. That's kind of culty, this like giant
- 46:19pile on and disbelief that some people are morally
- 46:22superior to others. Aren't we? as activists supposed
- 46:26to be dismantling hierarchies of moral worth?
- 46:29Don't we understand that that's what leads to
- 46:32all problems in society, the view that some are
- 46:34more important than others? So why are we perpetuating
- 46:39these hierarchies of moral worth and believing
- 46:42that some people can be harmed more than other
- 46:46people and more than other animals? This is just
- 46:49an example of something that was said to me when
- 46:52I shared on April 18th my thoughts and my concerns,
- 46:56warning people about there's going to be tear
- 46:58gas. People aren't heeding my warnings at all.
- 47:02People didn't prepare. Nobody bought gas masks
- 47:05or very few people did. Somebody wrote, sticking
- 47:08to facts of people giving their opinions and
- 47:12probably ones who did not do their due diligence
- 47:15to be informed and prepared for what could possibly
- 47:18happen and lack of knowledge on preparing for
- 47:20repression from law enforcement, corruption of
- 47:23law enforcement, I should say. Those are not
- 47:25facts. Those are opinions. It seems you are leveraging
- 47:28the initial results of the first day of a very
- 47:30difficult and historic action and the fact that
- 47:33activists were confronted with unprecedented
- 47:35brutal force in the animal rights movement to
- 47:37gain power, to feed your ego, to feel better
- 47:41about yourself, to show you no better. I'm not
- 47:44surprised. This has become a pattern coming from
- 47:46you, just like you did when you intervene with
- 47:49Miami's Aquarium actions in Miami and the hypocrite
- 47:53of Phil Demers. This person just goes on and
- 47:56criticizes my Miami's Aquarium stuff. Miami's
- 47:59Aquarium stuff, I was not trying to get any attention
- 48:02on me, but the vet staff reached out to me because
- 48:05they were telling me their experiences and needed
- 48:11somebody to share that with the media. And so
- 48:13I did. And this person has been nonstop on my
- 48:16social media harassing me and discrediting me
- 48:19and harming my ability to do good work, just
- 48:21shedding seeds of doubt in people's minds that
- 48:25I'm really just out there to get personal attention
- 48:28for myself, which is a bit of projection, I think.
- 48:31Why do we celebrate those who do get lots of
- 48:35media attention? But then if I get media attention,
- 48:39I'm out to put the spotlight on myself. It's
- 48:42interesting. The paradox of why some people are
- 48:45rewarded for getting press attention and other
- 48:47people like me are punished for it. But also
- 48:49you're not getting press attention, not in the
- 48:54same scale or kind than the organizers of those
- 49:00protests. I remember listening to a podcast and
- 49:02the host of the podcast. kind of an obscure podcast
- 49:05and started talking about Ridgeland farm. And
- 49:09I thought, wow, this, yeah, they are getting
- 49:12what they wanted, which is media attention, which
- 49:16brings me to this question. What should we call
- 49:18this brand of activism? Because I don't feel
- 49:23comfortable associating that with what the animal
- 49:28liberation front are doing or used to do much
- 49:32more in the past, which is much more, you know,
- 49:35covert, try actively to hide their identity and
- 49:41avoid harming their fellow activists and so on.
- 49:45Although I'm sure there are some sort of stories
- 49:47around that. So it's not that it's not like we
- 49:51said before, this focus on farm animals and veganism
- 49:56and all of the rest. It's like in my mind, I
- 49:59call it social media activism. Yeah, it's kind
- 50:05of a weird strain of actions and philosophy that
- 50:09feels very foreign to this movement, actually.
- 50:12Do you feel that way? Yeah, it's so interesting
- 50:15how they refer to the April activists as the
- 50:20rescuers when they didn't rescue a single dog
- 50:22that day. So how can you call it open rescue
- 50:25and people who were convicted? of open rescuing.
- 50:28They weren't convicted of open rescue. They were
- 50:31convicted of trespassing, conspiracy, all of
- 50:35these other things. They're never convicted of
- 50:40rescuing animals or theft even. Usually theft
- 50:43charges are dropped. So it's interesting how
- 50:46these things get conflated. And it's anything
- 50:49you do related to potentially the release of
- 50:53animals is considered rescue, which rescue in
- 50:57itself is a very strange word that I stay away
- 51:01from saying rescue because it has a lot of weight
- 51:04and judgment to it. You think of an animal who's
- 51:08stuck in a flood or something and you're risking
- 51:11your life to conquer the elements and take a
- 51:15animal to safety. When they're in these institutions,
- 51:19yes, at any moment some person working in the
- 51:23lab can decide to euthanize those animals. or
- 51:25on factory farm floors, there are animals who
- 51:28are dying who are not able to reach food and
- 51:31water. And yes, we would love to see them rescued,
- 51:34but most of the times those animals who are rescued
- 51:37are not in imminent peril. Yes, they want to
- 51:40make their necessity defense for that case, but
- 51:43it's a challenging defense to make. And I don't
- 51:47want to discourage that. It is this weird, it's
- 51:51the use of the court system too. That's the main
- 51:54thing to get this in front of a court of law
- 51:56because court cases are compelling. I'm watching
- 51:59the Lindsay Clancy trial right now. I love a
- 52:02true crime. I've sat through three open rescue
- 52:04trials. I know how they go, but I also know why
- 52:08some were won and why some were lost. And for
- 52:12the most part, They're one, because the prosecution
- 52:16makes some severe mistake. And you have thankfully
- 52:20one or two jurors who are very committed to turning
- 52:24the tide and convincing the other jurors on this.
- 52:27But it's very, very hard to get a good jury.
- 52:31If you're up against a good prosecutor, it's
- 52:35very, very hard. So you have to bank on a somewhat
- 52:39inept prosecutor and some good jurors. I see
- 52:45all of these people posting on social media saying
- 52:47like, oh, I put this dog in the front of my Tesla.
- 52:52I'm like, do not make it easy for the prosecutors.
- 52:55That's the thing that has gotten activists is
- 52:59posting on social media the video evidence. Jurors
- 53:03need something to latch onto to make the case
- 53:07that there's some doubt here. But when you post
- 53:10on social media, I know it's open rescue, but
- 53:13you have to either bank on they're going to drop
- 53:15all the charges or something. But if that goes
- 53:18to trial, it's not going to be good. It's like
- 53:20a court. court activism. It's not necessarily
- 53:25open rescue, which I'm in favor of it, but I
- 53:27think we need informed consent. Activists need
- 53:30to know what they're involved with and we can't
- 53:33retaliate against those who are just talking
- 53:35about it and sharing their own opinions and perspectives
- 53:38about this. We can't be ostracizing people and
- 53:41character assassinating people who are talking
- 53:43about this. Some tough questions. Do you believe
- 53:46the organizers of these protests were aware of
- 53:50the negotiations? taking place. I know for a
- 53:54fact the leaders were aware and they did not
- 53:58inform the rest of the activists about this because
- 54:01a very prominent activists brother was involved
- 54:05from the start and her brother believes that
- 54:10the activist actions delayed the release of the
- 54:12dogs by more than a month and has posted about
- 54:15that on social media. So that person was aware,
- 54:20I don't know how many people that person shared
- 54:22that with, but I do know also the leaders themselves
- 54:26were informed. After the fact, did those leaders
- 54:30confess to being informed of the negotiations
- 54:34or did they do PR for their actions and basically
- 54:39continue with the lie? It seems like the version
- 54:44of the truth has continued. I've seen people
- 54:47with t -shirts that said, I got tear gas and
- 54:49prepper sprayed and all I got was 2000 beagles
- 54:51out. Here's actually what I'm worried about.
- 54:54Somebody one day is going to engage in self -immolation,
- 54:58setting themselves on fire for the dogs. And
- 55:00if somebody did that for Ridgeland, not necessary.
- 55:04somebody harming themselves for the original
- 55:07Beagles I saw in the planning chats. One person
- 55:10in particular said, I was ready to die for those
- 55:12dogs. That's scary. You didn't need to because
- 55:17they were all going to be released anyway. And
- 55:19there's this belief of like, oh, the pressure
- 55:22was needed to secure the deal. No, it wasn't.
- 55:26And it actually slowed the deal at the key moment
- 55:30when there needed to be trust. they harmed that
- 55:34and delayed the release. Did they confess or
- 55:37did they continue with the lie? I've seen it
- 55:41continued and perpetuated even in the media recently
- 55:44that those actions led to the release of the
- 55:48dogs. There's no acknowledgement that the negotiations
- 55:51started in February. If anybody is out there
- 55:55who wants to correct me on that, let me know.
- 55:57But it seems whenever I bring this up, they're
- 55:59doubling down on the fact that activist pressure
- 56:01was needed to secure the release of the dogs.
- 56:06Are you optimistic about the fate of the activists
- 56:10being prosecuted right now? Do you think they'll
- 56:12get a good deal? Are we talking about prison
- 56:16sentence maybe even if people don't face prison
- 56:19time facing felony charges being convicted of
- 56:22felonies is not great your rights are limited
- 56:26i was even just applying for a new apartment
- 56:28recently and it's like have you ever been a convicted
- 56:31of a property crime a felony property crime and
- 56:34i'm like no thank god i can say no i haven't
- 56:37to that You're limited in what professions you
- 56:41can pursue. Yeah, good luck being a veterinarian
- 56:43as a felony convict. It's going to be really
- 56:47hard. Every time they've been somewhat overly
- 56:53optimistic about things, they were overly optimistic
- 56:55about the use of tear gas. They were overly optimistic
- 56:59that the police were going to help them on April
- 57:0118th. They're overly optimistic that charges
- 57:04wouldn't be filed for the March action. and the
- 57:07charges were filed. They were optimistic that
- 57:09the charges would not be filed previously and
- 57:12charges were filed. This will go to trial. I
- 57:15don't know how many activists will end up facing
- 57:18charges. In all of the previous open rescue cases,
- 57:21many of the activists pled out, had deals or
- 57:27their charges were dropped. But I don't think
- 57:30that's going to be the case here, especially
- 57:32given that they're so intent on Marshall Farms.
- 57:35The agriculture industry interests want to make
- 57:39sure that this is prosecuted. They want their
- 57:43property protected. So this will go to trial.
- 57:47I have to look into who the prosecutor is because
- 57:49it has to be a prosecutor who's down with being
- 57:52public and going through the public scrutiny.
- 57:56in harassment and all of this. It was so interesting
- 57:59to see the change in social media. After the
- 58:01March action, people were kind of like, yay,
- 58:04everybody was on board. And then after the April
- 58:06action, a lot of the Dane County people are like,
- 58:10no, these activists are hooligans. Like they
- 58:12broke the law. There is more of that. I expect
- 58:15to see more of that. I expect to see that the
- 58:18corporate interests will want to see this prosecuted.
- 58:22Unless, is there a chance that the Trump administration
- 58:25is going to put the pressure on to say no? I
- 58:29don't know. I think the Trump administration
- 58:31is going to look into these guys and be like,
- 58:32this is a bunch of blue haired liberals. And
- 58:35the beef industry, they're all about protecting
- 58:37the beef and dairy industry. And the beef and
- 58:39dairy industry want to see these guys prosecuted.
- 58:42it's going to be a harder battle than they anticipate,
- 58:45which I think it's been all along. It's kind
- 58:48of the philosophy of we didn't do this because
- 58:50it was easy. We did this because we thought it
- 58:53was going to be easy sort of thing. Again, another
- 58:55tough question. Should we sort of shed light
- 58:59and cover this prosecution of those activists?
- 59:03Or do you think it would be better for the whole
- 59:06movement to maybe relegate that to the margins?
- 59:10And hopefully they get support for their defense
- 59:14and all of that, but not to make it a story.
- 59:18It is such a thing. It's going to be in the media
- 59:22and we have to make sure that there's accurate
- 59:26reporting on this because if activists are thrown
- 59:29in prison, activists are convicted. We have to
- 59:32interpret that. What does that mean for the movement
- 59:35as a whole? Does this mean that animal rights
- 59:38is under oppression? Does this mean animal rights
- 59:41is taking a step? back. Animal rights is losing.
- 59:44No, it's not. These activists did things in a
- 59:47way that was less than strategic. Group think
- 59:50took over. This is the story we have to explain
- 59:55to activists that this doesn't mean that the
- 59:58animal rights movement is losing. It means that
- 1:00:02we need to fight hard against groupthink and
- 1:00:06unnecessary use of resources and legal risk.
- 1:00:10And that's the whole thing. It's a waste of resources,
- 1:00:14what they did. All for the release of the 22
- 1:00:17dogs. If you're going to do an open rescue, get
- 1:00:20animals out. But the April thing, I knew they
- 1:00:23weren't going to get any animals out. and they're
- 1:00:26going to face tear gas. It was a waste of resources.
- 1:00:29And we have to think critically going forward.
- 1:00:33And we have to learn. And we're not learning.
- 1:00:36So there's a group of us talking about this.
- 1:00:38But it's also diverting attention away from important
- 1:00:41work that is needed to be done. And that's what
- 1:00:44I worry about, too. All of this attention and
- 1:00:47use of resources is going to go through these
- 1:00:49trials instead of what's actually needed is gathering
- 1:00:52evidence. accurate explanation, an investigation
- 1:00:56into the psychology of what keeps people in labs.
- 1:00:59Simply shaming lab workers and assuming that
- 1:01:02they are evil is not going to be how we end animal
- 1:01:05experimentation because everybody is part of
- 1:01:09harmful systems and we have to understand what
- 1:01:12leads people to be part of harmful systems and
- 1:01:15what's the best way to extract them from it.
- 1:01:18If we figure out how to communicate to activists
- 1:01:21about the harmful systems they're part of and
- 1:01:24extracting them from that, we can use that to
- 1:01:28understand how lab workers and veterinarians
- 1:01:32are part of harmful systems and what empowering
- 1:01:35them to take action to dismantle those systems.
- 1:01:38That's a great answer. Yeah, if I was a Richland
- 1:01:41farm and looking to take a nice retirement, I
- 1:01:46think I would just contact the tip line of those
- 1:01:49groups. organize the protests and anonymously
- 1:01:54invite them in to help me sell whatever animals
- 1:01:58I keep to the highest bidder. If we look at it
- 1:02:03like this, we understand that this has not been
- 1:02:06beneficial. Do you know how much they ended up
- 1:02:09making Richland Farm from selling their dogs?
- 1:02:13It's all confidential. I don't know with all
- 1:02:16these series of deals. And I know Big Dog Ranch
- 1:02:19Rescue outbid CHE. So what was the final amount?
- 1:02:24I'm not sure. But Beagle Freedom Project, Kindness
- 1:02:27Ranch, these groups regularly get animals out
- 1:02:32of labs after they're done with their experimentation.
- 1:02:38Regularly, Kindness Ranch says to me, sends a
- 1:02:40message, we got another 30 out, we closed down
- 1:02:43this lab, they're out there doing the work. And
- 1:02:46so is Beagle Freedom Project. Keep supporting
- 1:02:49those groups because they're doing this literally
- 1:02:52every day, getting animals out of labs. We have
- 1:02:54to understand that unless we change the culture,
- 1:02:57it's just gonna move to China. And that's the
- 1:02:59conversation that I've had. with veterinarians
- 1:03:02at conferences. I just went to the American College
- 1:03:05of Animal Welfare short course and the entire
- 1:03:08thing was all a lab animal. And the very first
- 1:03:10talk was ALAC. This is the organization that
- 1:03:15accredits labs and they had accredited Ridgeland
- 1:03:18Farms. She was talking about the high standards
- 1:03:21they have and their transparency. They list all
- 1:03:24of the labs that they accredit on their website.
- 1:03:26So I looked, Ridgeland Farms is there along with
- 1:03:28AlphaGenesis. All these labs who I'm like, problematic.
- 1:03:33So I'm the very first person to raise my hand.
- 1:03:35And I say, so I see one lab whose I didn't mention
- 1:03:40their names received unprecedented media attention
- 1:03:43as of late is still listed. This was in June,
- 1:03:47still listed as accredited on your website. Are
- 1:03:50you worried this harms your reputation as an
- 1:03:53accredited body to still have this place? listed,
- 1:03:57they've been accused of removing cherry eyes
- 1:04:00without any anesthesia. This person said, yes,
- 1:04:04we're very worried about this and anytime a place
- 1:04:08gets media attention, they have an obligation
- 1:04:10to report that to us. We're very worried about
- 1:04:14this and we're keeping an eye on it and they're
- 1:04:17under probation. And then somebody else raises
- 1:04:20their hand after that and we're like, we would
- 1:04:21like to know if a place is under probation because
- 1:04:26we sponsor research and we would like to be made
- 1:04:30aware that a facility that we're working with
- 1:04:33is under probation. And the person said, well,
- 1:04:36it's up to you to do your due diligence about
- 1:04:39that. And it's like, what's your point? What's
- 1:04:42your purpose, Alak? It seems like it's more to
- 1:04:45put a shroud of legitimacy around it rather than
- 1:04:50actually protect the animals because they were
- 1:04:53all we do site visits we don't regulate we work
- 1:04:57with facilities to make things better so if they
- 1:04:59do notice a violation or something they won't
- 1:05:02do anything that point they'll tell them you
- 1:05:05got to get better by the time we do the next
- 1:05:07site visit you got to get your act together we
- 1:05:09really got to do better of course i want to end
- 1:05:12it all i envision a future where we don't have
- 1:05:15colonies of animals in labs to do research. But
- 1:05:19I do want animal research to continue for the
- 1:05:22benefit of animals. And I want it done with the
- 1:05:25same consideration that we give to humans and
- 1:05:29infants and children who are undergoing research.
- 1:05:32I think we can do this better. And it's an access
- 1:05:34to care model because right now people, dogs,
- 1:05:36cats, all animals are dying of conditions we
- 1:05:39already have cures for. And it's wild that we're
- 1:05:42spending billions of dollars to build new cures
- 1:05:44when many people and animals do not have access
- 1:05:48to existing cures. And that's what we need to
- 1:05:51focus on. How did you feel when all of this was
- 1:05:55over when the dogs were basically all freed?
- 1:06:00Oh, so free. Now I can talk about it. It's like,
- 1:06:04I was holding my tongue for so long, because
- 1:06:06it's like, I don't want to do anything that would
- 1:06:08threaten the dogs that would make Ridgeland back
- 1:06:12out of releasing more dogs. I'm still a little
- 1:06:15bit worried about Merck and Boehringer -Engelheim
- 1:06:17and comparative biosciences and these other places.
- 1:06:21We still have to get those dogs out of those
- 1:06:23places, but it is very freeing to now be able
- 1:06:27to talk about it. libraries full of footage of
- 1:06:32these dogs that I examined and I'm looking forward
- 1:06:35to posting them on social media and explaining
- 1:06:37what I saw and explaining the inherent problems
- 1:06:41with animal research that's not limited to just
- 1:06:44Ridgeland. This is systemic problems. The Giardia.
- 1:06:48All of these commercial dog breeding facilities
- 1:06:51have Giardia. There's no way around it. There's
- 1:06:53no way to provide these animals with the adequate
- 1:06:56socialization. things that they need, this volume
- 1:06:59of animals, not in a colony setting. I call it
- 1:07:02vivarium based research. We have to move away
- 1:07:05from saying and animal experimentation and animal
- 1:07:09research and animal testing. There's different
- 1:07:11things we're talking about when people, for the
- 1:07:14most part, the normies think that animal research
- 1:07:19is feeding dogs, Drano, and that it's completely
- 1:07:22unnecessary and we need to. move away from it.
- 1:07:26Yeah, that sort of thing. Easy. Don't buy products
- 1:07:28that test on animals. Small percentage of what
- 1:07:32animal research actually is. And a lot of it
- 1:07:35is things like pharmacokinetic studies on animals
- 1:07:40who actually will benefit from new drugs like
- 1:07:43Serenia and things like that. But how do we do
- 1:07:46that in a way that is not relying on caging dogs
- 1:07:50who don't have a person advocating for their
- 1:07:53best interest? And when we say end animal experimentation,
- 1:07:57end animal research, the people who are involved
- 1:08:00in animal research roll their eyes at us. And
- 1:08:02they're the ones who hold power, no matter how
- 1:08:04much social media attention and following. they
- 1:08:08get. When the politicians are explained, oh,
- 1:08:10actually, we need this in order to develop cures
- 1:08:14for your dog and develop new heartworm medications
- 1:08:17or whatever, people are going to go, oh, OK.
- 1:08:20There's lots of people causing a fuss about all
- 1:08:22sorts of things on social media. That doesn't
- 1:08:25mean that it actually translates into good policy
- 1:08:28that changes things. We have to educate activists,
- 1:08:33change our language and our asks. to make it
- 1:08:36very clear what we want, and it's actually feasible.
- 1:08:41And it's doable and don't rely on these slogans
- 1:08:45that aren't actually going to change the minds
- 1:08:47of people who do have the power to change things.
- 1:08:50And I think the responsibility of informing activists
- 1:08:55rests on this podcast and others who should be
- 1:09:00doing the job of hard hitting journalists or
- 1:09:04at least curious investigative journalists. But
- 1:09:08sadly, I don't see that much. I see a lot of
- 1:09:11back rubbing and you know, you're my friend,
- 1:09:14so come on in on my show or something. But where
- 1:09:18are the interesting perspectives? There are so
- 1:09:20many guests that I welcome on this show and I
- 1:09:23absolutely do not agree on their positions. our
- 1:09:26perspectives, but I think it's interesting to
- 1:09:29explore and present that to the world and inform
- 1:09:33people on their existence and give them somewhat
- 1:09:37difficult questions to answer. Yeah, do see my
- 1:09:41role in that. And I hope people take this episode
- 1:09:44and share it with their friends and the vegans
- 1:09:47they know, the activists they know who have been
- 1:09:51brainwashed or got caught in the web of lies
- 1:09:57that sprung from this. No, I haven't said I haven't
- 1:10:00said lies. I think it's hard to you cannot say
- 1:10:05what anybody's intent is, I think people have
- 1:10:09convinced themselves of a narrative that isn't
- 1:10:13fully accurate because so many who have access
- 1:10:17to other facts aren't allowed into the conversation.
- 1:10:20And so there's this spun narrative about things
- 1:10:25and how they went down. I don't like to accuse
- 1:10:28anybody of lying, but there's not providing the
- 1:10:32whole truth. And I think it's really hard when
- 1:10:35you're in that environment. I was there when
- 1:10:37you're getting fed this narrative and it's being
- 1:10:40reinforced. And then there's this one voice who
- 1:10:43says, actually, this is true. And then it's just
- 1:10:47dismissed. There's this phenomenon called betrayal
- 1:10:50blindness. It's this tendency not to fully recognize
- 1:10:54that this betrayal is happening because it could
- 1:10:58threaten this. relationship that you have in
- 1:11:01this group identity that you had. And that's
- 1:11:05what I see is rampant in the animal rights movement,
- 1:11:08just this betrayal blindness. You don't see how
- 1:11:10you're not getting adequate informed consent
- 1:11:13about the things that you're participating in.
- 1:11:16Yes, it's a wiser perspective. But yeah, still,
- 1:11:23I wish people share this. I know I have a list
- 1:11:25of people I will share this episode with because
- 1:11:28it's of hard, you know, I, I think I was telling
- 1:11:32you that, but it's kind of hard hearing activists,
- 1:11:35you know, being caught in that narrative. And
- 1:11:41you don't know where to start in presenting the
- 1:11:44truth or the alternative version of what's happening.
- 1:11:49And you sound like that meme of the guy with
- 1:11:53the conspiracy thing. Yeah. So I'm so happy that
- 1:12:00now I have this episode, this reference that
- 1:12:03I can share with people and say, here, take a
- 1:12:06listen to this, you might be surprised what you're
- 1:12:09going to hear. I kind of want to put together
- 1:12:12an hour long lecture with screenshots and documents
- 1:12:17showing exactly what I know, because this was
- 1:12:20a very just kind of free flowing conversation.
- 1:12:23I'm not relying on this date, this person said
- 1:12:26this. and this happened, but I have screenshots.
- 1:12:29I have a dossier of documents I could provide.
- 1:12:33I have a whole thing. This was a very free flowing
- 1:12:37overview. You're getting a very narrative assessment
- 1:12:41of what happened. not a highly referenced version
- 1:12:46of what happened, but I do have that too, which
- 1:12:49I will publish at some point for sure so that
- 1:12:52people have that because you do need facts and
- 1:12:55what was actually said and when and what did
- 1:12:58people believe going in because that's all important
- 1:13:01to know too. Yes, I agree. And I'm looking forward
- 1:13:04to that expose. And also, I think that the alternative
- 1:13:09narrative that you're presenting, it makes sense.
- 1:13:11I think it will appeal to people's logic and
- 1:13:14maybe wake them out of that hysteria that is
- 1:13:19going on around Richland farm. And they might
- 1:13:21start thinking they might start having doubts.
- 1:13:24And I think that's what we want from anyone,
- 1:13:28a level of skepticism, not to be a fanatic about
- 1:13:32anything. And yeah, I think this conversation
- 1:13:35can offer that to people. I hope so. Yeah, and
- 1:13:38I know a lot of people won't and may the bridges
- 1:13:41I burn light my way. I can say to that. Yeah,
- 1:13:46that's we burn. That's okay. Crystal, did you
- 1:13:53want to add something before we stop the recording?
- 1:13:57Anybody who has any questions, please reach out
- 1:14:00and ask me directly and join our group chat and
- 1:14:03we can discuss this further. I'm an open book.
- 1:14:06I'm down to talk with anybody no matter what
- 1:14:08people say. So please do reach out. There's a
- 1:14:11lot of documentation to this. There's a lot more
- 1:14:15to this story that is just too time consuming
- 1:14:19to share on this hour and a half long podcast.
- 1:14:23It's literally a book. I could write on this
- 1:14:26and I might write the book on this. So please
- 1:14:29do reach out. See Heath at our honor dot org
- 1:14:32info on our honor dot org and find me on social
- 1:14:36media. I'm down to talk to anybody who wants
- 1:14:39to seek the truth. I am not down to answer questions
- 1:14:43by people who will use my answers out of context
- 1:14:47in order to paint me as an evil person who is
- 1:14:50out to harm the movement and out to harm individuals.
- 1:14:53If you're asking me questions. in ways that intend
- 1:14:56to trap me, that intend to prosecute me. I am
- 1:15:01not going to do that. I am not a snitch. I'm
- 1:15:03not going to talk to law enforcement. I'm not
- 1:15:04going to talk to prosecutors. I'm not going to
- 1:15:06talk to the FBI, even though this was an open
- 1:15:08rescue. So there should be nothing to snitch
- 1:15:11about. Right. But anyway, yeah, down to talk
- 1:15:15to anybody. Please, please reach out. Amazing.
- 1:15:17Thank you so much, Crystal. Thank you so much
- 1:15:20for sharing this with us. I hope you write this
- 1:15:24book. I really hope I would devour this book.
- 1:15:27This is such a great story with amazing characters,
- 1:15:32crazy, interesting, entertaining characters.
- 1:15:35I could see a movie being done around this book
- 1:15:39and you're the best person to write this book.
- 1:15:43You really have all the facts and you know, all
- 1:15:45of the people. So that's amazing. Yeah. Thank
- 1:15:49you so much for speaking up as always. you're
- 1:15:52never disappointing, I have to say. So thank
- 1:15:55you. Thank you for having me on and literally
- 1:15:57probably being the only podcaster willing to
- 1:15:59talk about this story. Animal rights podcaster.
- 1:16:02I'm sure I can go on to some true crime podcasts
- 1:16:05and share my story, but they might not be very
- 1:16:08charitable to the animal rights movement. So
- 1:16:11I thank you. You're the only one who will probably
- 1:16:13have me on and hear me out. I mean, this is crazy
- 1:16:16to hear because this is the most important story
- 1:16:18out there. And if I have the scoop, thank you.
- 1:16:22This is yeah, you have the scoop. Thank you.
- 1:16:25And thank you to you, of course. Thank you, everyone
- 1:16:28for listening. I kindly invite you to share this
- 1:16:31podcast with the vegans you know, let's encourage
- 1:16:34more people to take action. Again, thank you
- 1:16:38so much for caring. And I will see you next Tuesday
- 1:16:41for a new episode.