Latest / Reformed Thinking / Blessed Are They Whose Iniquity is Forgiven | John Calvin

Transcript

Blessed Are They Whose Iniquity is Forgiven | John Calvin · Reformed Thinking

0:00
Brief audio intro Reformed thinking Welcome to Reformed
0:04
thinking. We're doing a deep dive today
0:06
that gets right to the heart of what it means to be a Christian,
0:09
specifically, the nature of forgiveness.
0:11
How does it work and how does that forgiveness by itself
0:15
create peace with God? That's the question we're
0:17
tackling, and our source material for this deep dive is
0:20
John Calvin's commentary on the Psalms.
0:23
We're going to see how he analyzes the doctrine of
0:25
justification by faith alone, but he does it through King
0:28
David's reflection in Psalm 32. And we're really focusing in,
0:32
aren't we, on just the first 2 verses of that Psalm?
0:34
We should also mention the translation, because the
0:36
specific wording matters. We're using the 1854 English
0:40
version from the Calvin Translation Society by Henry
0:43
Beveridge. Right.
0:44
That context is helpful. So our mission today is really
0:47
to unpack Calvin's argument that the free remission of sins isn't
0:50
just, you know, a step in the process.
0:51
He says it is the single gate of eternal salvation.
0:55
We want to understand what that actually means for a believer's
0:57
assurance, for their conscience, for their peace.
1:00
Because in Calvin's mind, this isn't just an interesting
1:02
thought on Psalm 32, he says this is the full definition of
1:05
the righteousness of faith. So not a piece of the
1:08
definition, but the whole thing, the mechanism that takes a
1:11
person from condemned to bless it.
1:13
So let's start with David starts.
1:15
Why are his words so layered? OK, so we begin with David's
1:19
decoration in Psalm 32, and what's immediately striking is
1:22
that he doesn't just say it once.
1:24
He repeats this idea of forgiveness and blessedness 3
1:28
times over. And this repetition isn't just
1:30
for poetic effect. It's theologically massive.
1:33
He really drives it home. The source points out these
1:35
three statements that all define what it means to be blessed.
1:38
First, blessed are they whose iniquity is forgiven, then whose
1:42
transgression is covered, And finally, blessed is the man to
1:45
whom Jehovah imputeth no sin. It's like he's layering these
1:49
ideas to make sure there's absolutely no misunderstanding.
1:53
Blessedness is all about God's action on sin.
1:56
Exactly. And Calvin takes that triple
1:58
statement and uses it to build his entire argument for sola
2:01
gratia grace alone. For him, this doctrine that we
2:05
are only accounted righteous before God by the free remission
2:08
of sins. He explicitly calls that the
2:11
gate of eternal salvation. That gate analogy is so
2:14
powerful. It's not a door, it's not a
2:16
path, it's a gate. If it's the gate, it means it's
2:18
the only way in. You can't climb the wall, you
2:20
can't dig under it. Any other approach, any
2:23
religious effort. It just doesn't work.
2:25
So what does Calvin mean by free remission being that single
2:29
entry point? Well, he means that the only way
2:31
God can actually accept people who you know, by all rights
2:34
deserve condemnation is if he performs this total act of, of,
2:39
of gratuitous reconciliation. It has to be free.
2:42
He's kind of paid for it. We have nothing to pay with.
2:44
If it required even a tiny piece of human merit or effort, the
2:48
gate would effectively be shut for good, because our best
2:50
efforts, as we'll get into are just fundamentally flawed.
2:53
Right, the gate isn't a turnstile where you put in your
2:56
coins of good deeds. It's it's just thrown open by
2:59
grace. And Calvin points out that the
3:01
apostle Paul confirms this interpretation.
3:04
He says Paul in Romans 4 is the assured interpreter and witness
3:09
of what David is saying here. And that's the link that
3:11
solidifies the whole thing. It gives us what you mentioned
3:13
earlier, the full definition of the righteousness of faith.
3:17
Paul's use of Psalm 32 means that faith is defined not by
3:20
something we do, but by the state of being.
3:23
You are only blessed when you are freely reconciled to God and
3:26
counted as righteous by Him. It's a status that's completely
3:28
external to your works. Let's go back to that repetition
3:31
for a second because David's threefold statement seems to be
3:34
the foundation for believers assurance.
3:37
Iniquity is forgiven, transgression is covered, and
3:39
sin is not imputed. Are these just synonyms or is
3:42
Calvin saying they each do something different?
3:45
Calvin sees them as three ways of confirming the absolute
3:48
certainty and the completeness of that remission.
3:52
So yes, they point to 1 great action, but each phrase kind of
3:56
pushes back against a different kind of guilt or fear we might
3:58
have forgiven means the debt is canceled.
4:02
The burden is literally lifted off.
4:04
OK, so that's the weight being removed.
4:05
What about covered? Covered means the offense is
4:09
hidden from God's judging eye. It's concealed.
4:12
It's not that it didn't happen, but it's no longer visible to
4:14
the judge. And then there's the third one,
4:16
which feels very legal. Blessed is the man to whom
4:19
Jehovah imputeth no sin. That's about imputation.
4:23
Right, that's exactly what it is.
4:25
Imputation is a legal reckoning. When God imputeth no sin, it
4:29
means he doesn't add it to your account.
4:31
He treats you for the purposes of judgement as if the sin never
4:34
happened. So forgiveness is removal,
4:37
covering is concealment, but non imputation.
4:41
That's the judicial act. That's the declaration that you
4:44
are righteous in his sight. And this is so central to
4:47
Reformed thinking, because if God just forgave you, you might
4:51
still lack the positive righteousness you need to stand
4:53
before Him. But by not imputing sin, the way
4:56
is cleared. That clarity on non imputation
5:00
is so helpful for the listener because you can see the Direct
5:03
Line from the Old Testament idea of blessedness to the New
5:06
Testament doctrine of salvation. Kelvin even brings in
5:09
Zacharias's song from Luke's Gospel, where the knowledge of
5:12
salvation is defined as knowing the remission of sins.
5:15
It is. Salvation is defined by this
5:17
change in legal status. And what's really striking in
5:20
Calvin's analysis is the fixed order this creates for anyone
5:23
who's looking for happiness or peace with God.
5:26
You can't come at it backwards. What do you mean?
5:28
You have to start by admitting that you are on your own,
5:30
completely worthy of destruction.
5:32
That's the zero point. And from there, the only way
5:35
forward is to accept that God can only be reconciled to you by
5:38
free pardoning you and bestowing His favor out of grace.
5:41
So if you're a listener seeking that kind of reconciliation, you
5:44
can't start by polishing up your spiritual resume.
5:46
No, you have to start with a full and honest acknowledgement
5:49
of your own inability, your complete dependence on God's
5:53
free favor. It seems the gate itself demands
5:57
that you leave all your own efforts behind.
5:59
That's a great way to put it. And that clarity on the free
6:02
part of remission leads to this huge theological consequence.
6:07
Calvin puts it in very stark terms.
6:09
The blessedness that David is talking about here, it utterly
6:13
destroys the righteousness of works.
6:15
Utterly destroys, not weakens, not diminishes, destroys.
6:18
That's so final. I think we need to spend some
6:20
time on why that destruction is so necessary.
6:22
Why can't our good works just, you know, coexist with God's
6:25
grace in the process of justification?
6:27
Why is it a 0 sum game? It has to be a 0 sum game
6:30
because of the standard God judges by.
6:32
The sources lay this out very clearly.
6:34
If God were to withhold mercy and just judge everyone
6:37
according to His perfect law, every single person would be, in
6:41
Calvin's words, utterly wretched and accursed.
6:44
This isn't about just making some mistakes.
6:46
It's about the very nature of who we are and what we do.
6:49
You're talking about the doctrine of total inability, the
6:51
idea that before God works in US, every part of us, our mind,
6:55
our will, our desires, is corrupted by sin.
6:58
That's right. And because of that, before
7:00
regeneration, a person's entire life is, from God's perspective,
7:04
hateful and loathsome. Every thought, every action,
7:07
every intention, it's all tainted by that original
7:11
corruption. There's just nothing left
7:12
untouched which makes any effort to clean ourselves up totally
7:15
futile. Which brings us back to what you
7:17
said earlier. We have to rely on the grace of
7:19
God alone. If everything we produce is
7:21
hateful and loathsome, then we literally have nothing to offer.
7:25
We show up at the gate empty handed.
7:26
And this is where Calvin directly confronts what he calls
7:29
the error of the papists, which really stands for any system
7:33
that tries to bring human merit into the picture.
7:36
Their objection was that, OK, you need pardon for your sins at
7:40
the beginning of your Christian life, right?
7:42
But once you're cleaned up, you can start earning merit.
7:44
You can start building up your own righteousness through your
7:46
works. Well, that sounds logical to the
7:48
natural mind. You get a fresh start and then
7:50
you get to work. Why is Calvin so insistent that
7:54
this view is completely wrong and actually destructive to the
7:59
whole idea of free pardon and assurance?
8:01
Because it completely misunderstands God's standard.
8:04
Calvin's counter is that we need mercy perpetually, even after
8:08
regeneration. This is the part people miss.
8:11
We don't just need justification to get started, we need it to
8:13
continue every single day. So even the good things a
8:16
Christian does, the works done after being made new in Christ,
8:20
even those aren't good enough to stand before God.
8:23
Not even close. He argues that no work done by a
8:26
person can please God unless he pardons the sin which mingles
8:30
with it. Think about that.
8:33
When a believer prays or shows charity or fights a temptation,
8:38
there is always some mixture of a wrong motive or pride or a
8:42
lack of perfect love mixed into that action.
8:45
Sin is still present in the believer.
8:47
That really forces you to reevaluate your own efforts.
8:50
Yeah, we tend to judge our good works by, you know, looking at
8:53
other people or maybe how we used to be.
8:55
But Calvin is saying the only standard that matters is God's
8:58
perfect law. Exactly.
8:59
The sources quote him saying that even the works of the
9:01
Saints are spotted with stains and are unworthy of reward when
9:04
judged by that perfect standard. We just failed to grasp how
9:07
absolute God's judgement is. It demands flawless perfection.
9:11
And to make that point, he uses that incredible, severe
9:14
metaphor. He says that in God's eyes, the
9:17
very brightness of the stars is but darkness.
9:20
Yeah, that metaphor tells you everything about God's holiness.
9:22
Just picture the brightest star you can imagine in the night
9:25
sky. It's radiating this pure,
9:27
intense light. That's the best righteousness we
9:29
can possibly conceive of. And yet, when you put it next to
9:32
the infinite, blazing perfection of God's own holiness, that
9:37
star's light just it's gone. It's rendered as darkness.
9:42
It's not just that there's a gap between US and God, it's that
9:44
the gap is unbridgeable by our efforts.
9:47
If the best works of the most devoted Saints are seen as
9:50
darkness in God's sight, then the whole idea of human merit
9:53
just evaporates. It's not a factor.
9:56
And that leads to this inescapable conclusion, since
9:59
perfection, like a perfect fear of the Lord, is simply not found
10:03
anywhere in human experience. Our salvation requires
10:06
continuous, free reconciliation. It's not just the door you walk
10:10
through at the beginning. It has to be the very path you
10:12
walk on every day. If that same grace doesn't
10:15
accompany them to the last step of their life, then assurance is
10:18
impossible. So this whole section just
10:20
dismantles the idea that once you become a Christian, you kind
10:23
of graduate from grace and start relying on your own performance.
10:26
If the brightest stars are darkness, than relying on your
10:29
own works even for a moment puts you right back outside that
10:32
gate. That is the point.
10:33
It's meant to constantly confront and crush our pride
10:37
because even the most mature believer, when they look at
10:40
their life against the perfect standard of the law, has to
10:43
admit that they're standing before God is only because of
10:46
Christ's righteousness and the free pardon that covers their
10:49
ongoing faults. OK, so since this doctrine is so
10:53
critical, but also so contrary to our human nature, which
10:58
always wants to contribute something, this brings us back
11:00
to David's repetition. Why did he say it three times?
11:03
Forgiven, Covered, not imputed? If it's one truth, why the
11:08
insistence? Calvin is very clear that this
11:10
is no vain repetition. He says it's divinely necessary
11:13
because it performs 2 completely different functions.
11:15
It's designed to address 2 opposite problems of the human
11:18
conscience. So the repetition is like a
11:20
medicine for two different illnesses, spiritual laziness in
11:23
one hand and crushing anxiety on the other.
11:26
Let's start with the first one to awaken the careless.
11:29
This is for the person who needs to hear about the destruction of
11:31
works we just talked about. The doctor is meant to raise up
11:34
those who are falling asleep and quicken the dull.
11:37
Absolutely. Calvin saw that most people,
11:40
whether they're religious or not, find ways to ignore their
11:42
conscience, he says. They use devices of their own.
11:46
They've explained away their sins.
11:47
They've become, in his words, intoxicated with deceitful
11:50
pleasures. And they operate under a
11:53
perverse carnal security. What does that carnal security
11:56
look like in real life? It's the person who has just
11:59
shut their eyes to the massive load of sin they're carrying.
12:02
They've convinced themselves that they're basically OK with
12:05
God. Maybe they compare themselves to
12:06
others, or they go through some religious motions.
12:09
They make light of their sins. They don't reflect on the real
12:12
danger they're in from God's judgment.
12:14
So it's a kind of self delusion. They might say, Oh yeah,
12:17
everyone sins, but they fail to look at the sheer volume and
12:21
weight of their own personal guilt before a perfectly holy
12:25
God. Precisely.
12:26
And Calvin basically challenges them.
12:28
He asks how can you continue to sleep so securely while you are
12:32
overwhelmed with an immense load of sins?
12:35
He's telling the listener that their feeling of security is
12:37
built on ignorance, not on reality.
12:40
That is really strong language. It's meant to shock the
12:43
complacent person into seeing their true condition, and the
12:47
repetition of the promise is what drives that hard truth
12:50
home. It takes a lot of divine effort
12:52
to get us to believe that our only blessedness is in free
12:55
forgiveness. It does, but then the repetition
12:59
is just as vital for the exact opposite problem.
13:02
And that's the second purpose, to tranquilize the anxious.
13:06
The goal here is to give fearful and anxious minds an assured and
13:09
steady confidence. And this speaks right to the
13:11
experience of a genuine believer, someone who has been
13:15
awakened, who sees their sin and is actively fighting it.
13:18
Once you realize the perfect standard of God's law, it's so
13:22
easy to swing from complacency right into terror and despair
13:25
because you know your best works are darkness.
13:27
That's the constant battle for a true believer.
13:30
Even the people who have tasted God's mercy, he says, are
13:32
constantly agitated and disquieted.
13:35
They're trying to hold onto grace, but they're frequently
13:37
abashed or made to stagger by all the assaults on their faith.
13:40
And that agitation comes from the remaining sin and the
13:42
accusations of the law and of the enemy.
13:44
So if a believer truly understands that their own works
13:47
are stained, how can only ever feel secure?
13:50
Doesn't Calvin's own high standard just add to that
13:53
anxiety? How does repeating the promise
13:56
fix that? It fixes it because the
13:58
repetition pulls the focus completely away from the quality
14:02
of the believers own performance and puts it back onto the
14:05
completeness of thoughts action. The believer knows they're
14:08
imperfect, and that makes them doubt, but the repetition
14:11
forgiven, covered, not imputed, acts as this threefold
14:15
confirmation that battles the internal war in their
14:18
conscience. So it's a constant reminder that
14:20
what God has done is complete and finished.
14:23
Since doubts are often coming upon them one after another,
14:26
just hearing it once isn't enough.
14:28
Not at all. That's why he says the Holy
14:29
Spirit confirmed and ratifies the remission of sins with many
14:32
declarations. This repetition gives incredible
14:35
comfort because it's an objective promise.
14:37
It stands outside of your feelings or your performance on
14:40
any given day. It's what keeps despair from
14:42
completely overwhelming you, and it's what gives you that assured
14:45
and steady confidence that is built on God's declaration, not
14:48
your own holiness. That double purpose is just
14:50
pastorally brilliant. It first crushes the pride of
14:53
the person who thinks they're righteous, and then it lists the
14:56
crushing weight off the person who knows they're not.
14:58
And the one thing both people need is to rely completely on
15:02
the freeness of the pardon. Right.
15:03
And to really feel the force of this doctrine of free remission,
15:07
we have to look at the specific contrast Calvin was drawing in
15:11
his own time. He directly targets any view
15:14
that tries to undermine the sufficiency of God's grace by
15:18
denying how complete that free pardon, really.
15:20
Is yeah, the source is named the Papists of his day, but we
15:23
should probably understand that as a critique of any system,
15:26
then or now, that tries to sneak human contribution back into
15:30
justification. His main complaint is that they
15:32
make light of the blessedness of forgiveness that David is
15:34
describing in Psalm 32. They do, he says.
15:37
They fail to penetrate the real meaning of the prophet.
15:40
They might read the verse, but they treat it like a common
15:43
saying and of little importance. They don't grasp the huge
15:46
doctrine of justification that Paul pulls from it.
15:49
They just assume blessedness comes from following a moral
15:52
code, not from a radical change in your legal standing before
15:56
God. And the root of that mistake,
15:58
according to Calvin, is what he calls the delusion of Satan.
16:02
That's incredibly strong language.
16:04
What exactly was the error that he felt was so dangerous?
16:08
The delusion is the idea that people are adorned with merits
16:11
that can get them God's favor. So instead of relying only on
16:14
grace, they obtrude their virtues upon God.
16:17
They essentially shove their good deeds in God's face, acting
16:20
as if they've earned a big part of their blessedness through
16:22
their own efforts. And that, of course, completely
16:25
contradicts the idea that blessedness utterly destroys the
16:28
righteousness of works. This desire to mix our effort
16:31
into justification seems to lead to all sorts of man made
16:34
religious practices, doesn't it? The human mind just wants to
16:37
make it a transaction. Yes, they fool themselves with
16:40
what he calls the device of a partial righteousness.
16:43
They invent these frivolous rituals to try to clear their
16:48
guilt and buy God's favor. You can see it in all kinds of
16:51
religious systems. Penances, pilgrimages, intense
16:54
self denial, all seen as ways to tip the scales back in your
16:57
favor. Let's get specific because
16:59
Calvin mentions 2 technical terms that our listeners might
17:01
not know. He talks about satisfactions and
17:05
works of super irrigation. What are those?
17:07
Good question. He says they thrust in their
17:10
satisfactions and works of super irrigation.
17:12
So satisfactions historically were acts of penance that a
17:15
person had to perform after confessing a sin.
17:18
The idea was that even though the eternal guilt was forgiven,
17:21
you still had to do something like fasting or giving alms to
17:24
satisfy God's justice for the temporal or earthly consequences
17:27
of that sin. OK, so your eternal destiny
17:29
might be secure, but you still owe a debt in this life that you
17:33
have to pay off through these acts of satisfaction.
17:35
Exactly. And then you have works of super
17:37
irrigation. This is the idea that you can do
17:40
good deeds that go above and beyond what God's law actually
17:43
requires. And in that system, these extra
17:46
merits could be stored up in a kind of treasury of merit, and
17:50
then they could be applied to other people who are falling
17:52
short. This whole system just creates a
17:54
massive problem for believers assurance because it denies them
17:58
the complete forgiveness David is talking about.
18:01
If you still have to perform a satisfaction, or if you're
18:04
relying on someone else's extra credit, then your standing is
18:07
still tied to this flawed human economy.
18:10
It results in what Calvin called a half pardon.
18:13
They might distinguish between the fault being forgiven and the
18:15
punishment being forgiven, but if you're still on the hook for
18:18
some kind of punishment, you haven't received a full pardon.
18:21
True remission, like David describes, forgiven, covered,
18:25
not imputed, has to be total and absolute.
18:28
And this all comes back to that fundamental mistake.
18:32
They believe that the pardon of sin is only necessary at the
18:35
beginning of righteousness. That's the error that keeps
18:38
repeating. It leads them to think their
18:40
later works are actually worthy of reward because they just
18:43
completely miscalculate God's perfect judgement.
18:46
They don't see the stain that's mixed in with everything they
18:48
do. And that destroys assurance.
18:51
How could it not? If you're standing with God,
18:53
depends even a little bit on your works of satisfaction or
18:56
merit, how could you ever know if you've done enough?
18:59
Your conscience would be in a constant state of terror, always
19:02
calculating your efforts against your failures.
19:04
Assurance becomes this fragile thing that depends on your
19:07
feelings and your performance. So Calvin's conclusion is really
19:11
clear. True blessedness demands that
19:13
you accept that God is reconciled to you, even though
19:16
he could justly treat you as an enemy.
19:18
It requires complete, ongoing reliance on that gratuitous
19:21
reconciliation. There's just no room for human
19:24
merit to gain favor, and that is the only foundation that can
19:27
possibly support an assured and steady confidence.
19:31
Right. So now that we've seen that free
19:32
remission is the gate and that it destroys our works, we have
19:36
to look at the completeness and the persistence of this grace
19:39
through the whole life of a believer.
19:41
And David's repetition really defines that completeness.
19:44
God's action is total. He performs remission by freely
19:48
pardoning, which means lifting off and taking away.
19:52
He's covering the sin and he's not imputing it.
19:54
These are all definitive acts of God that result in a complete
19:58
forgiveness, not some partial pardon that we have to top up
20:01
with our own efforts. And that complete action sets up
20:04
the final part of the argument, which is that this grace isn't
20:07
just for getting in the door. It has to accompany them to the
20:10
last step of their life. The believer is still involved
20:13
in faults, everyday sins of omission, sins of Commission,
20:17
failures and love. If they had to rely on their own
20:19
strength for justification, they would fail God's judgement every
20:22
single day. So justification is a
20:25
declaration that happens once, but our need for its covering
20:28
for its application to our daily sin, that's continuous.
20:30
It's the persistent reality for a justified person until the day
20:34
they die. It is, and we see the perfect
20:36
example in David himself. Here is a man who had made huge
20:39
advances in holiness, and yet he placed the alpha and Omega of
20:43
his salvation, the beginning and the end of it, in his gratuitous
20:47
reconciliation to God. If David, the man after God's
20:50
own heart, knew that his entire hope rested on mercy, well, how
20:54
much more should we? It seems like it's often the
20:57
people who are most advanced in holiness who are most aware of
21:00
their constant need for forgiveness.
21:01
Why is that? Kelvin says that the person who
21:04
excels most in holiness actually feels himself farther from
21:07
perfect righteousness. The closer you walk with God,
21:10
the brighter He lost. His perfect law shines on you,
21:13
and the more clearly you see your own remaining sin and just
21:16
how vast the distance is between your best efforts and God's
21:19
perfect standard. So, ironically, growing in
21:22
holiness actually increases your humility and makes you trust
21:25
only in God's mercy. That is a fascinating paradox.
21:28
The spiritual giants aren't the ones who think they've built up
21:30
a surplus of merit. They're the ones who see most
21:33
clearly that they are utterly dependent on free pardon for
21:35
their standing with God moment by moment.
21:38
Yes, the more you know the law's demands, the more you know your
21:41
own sin. So the greatest Saints are the
21:43
ones who most eagerly embrace the definition of blessedness
21:47
from Psalm 32, that their security rests entirely on God's
21:51
free favor. So the final implication for
21:54
you, the learner, is that knowing you are accounted
21:56
righteous before God solely by the free remission of sins, that
22:00
knowledge is the only refuge. It's the place where terror and
22:04
anxiety are traded for assured and steady confidence.
22:08
The repetition of that promise in Psalm 32 is exactly what's
22:12
needed to give that assurance and make peace possible even in
22:15
the middle of our daily struggle with sin.
22:17
It's the only solid ground there is.
22:19
Every statement in the Bible about blessedness is founded on
22:21
the free favor of God by which he reconciles us to Himself.
22:24
And that reconciliation which defines the righteousness of
22:27
faith, is the only source of eternal hope in our present
22:30
peace. This has been a really helpful
22:32
deep dive into Calvin's perspective on Psalm 32.
22:35
We've seen that the gate of eternal salvation isn't opened
22:38
by our striving or our merit, but only by fully embracing the
22:42
free remission of sins. And that same truth crushes the
22:46
pride of the careless and completely reassures the anxious
22:49
conscience. To sum it up, the blessedness
22:51
David celebrates destroys every claim to human merit.
22:55
It grounds our hope completely in God's free favor.
22:58
And that is why the knowledge of salvation is the same thing as
23:00
the knowledge of the remission of sins.
23:02
Now for a final thought to take with you.
23:05
Given Calvin's assertion the believers need this same grace
23:08
to the last step of their life, and that our sanctification, our
23:11
growth and holiness, never contributes one bit to our
23:14
justification, how does realizing the daily, hourly
23:19
necessity of forgiveness change our motivation for that growth
23:22
and holiness? If our good works can't earn us
23:24
anything, what new reason drives our obedience?
23:27
Think about how a continuous reliance on free pardon changes
23:30
the way we pursue holy life. Thank you for joining us on
23:33
Reformed Thinking. Until next time.