Latest / Onramp Bitcoin Media / The Last Trade E017: Tipping Points of Institutional Adoption with Fidelity's Chris Kuiper
Transcript
- 0:00What you're telling me is that music is about to stop, and
- 0:04we're going to be left holding the biggest bag of bodarous
- 0:07extras ever assembled in the history.
- 0:11Of doubtless 1974198792972000. Whatever we want to call this,
- 0:19it's all just the same thing over and over.
- 0:21We can't. Help ourselves.
- 0:23I say when we sell, hey, I say when we sell, welcome back to
- 0:31the last trade, exciting week, Bitcoins pushing towards 27,000.
- 0:37Again, we've got a lot of news. We were mentioning Deutsche Bank
- 0:41just announced today that they're going to begin custody
- 0:44and crypto assets for their clients.
- 0:47So I think that's the first big bank mover into the Custody
- 0:51game, and we're joined by Chris Kiper, the director of research
- 0:57at Fidelity Digital Assets. I paused there cuz Chris, I
- 1:01asked how to pronounce your name before and he said it's Kuiper
- 1:03like diaper. And I almost said Chris diaper.
- 1:06I'm sorry. You got it.
- 1:08My pneumatic almost failed. It's supposed to put it in your
- 1:12brain how to say it, but you almost said the wrong thing.
- 1:14That's the right thing. Well, thank you for joining us
- 1:17today. Thank you.
- 1:19It's my pleasure to be here. Well, we had a great intro call
- 1:24yesterday. And I think the big theme that
- 1:28we pulled from that was I think just the admiration that
- 1:32Michael, myself and Jesse have for the work that Fidelity has
- 1:36done in the space for some time now, coming up on a decade, I
- 1:39believe. So your annual research pieces
- 1:42are incredible. Obviously, you're the Director
- 1:45of research, so you have a lot of say over what goes into those
- 1:49pieces. So before we jump into the
- 1:51broader discussion, I think just an introduction to yourself, how
- 1:56you got into the position of Director of Research at Fidelity
- 2:00Digital Assets and yeah, I guess we can start there.
- 2:06Yeah, sure. Well, thanks again for having
- 2:07me. Chris Kiper, Director of
- 2:09Research at Fidelity Digital Assets.
- 2:11For those who don't know, Fidelity Digital Assets is a
- 2:14subsidiary of Fidelity Investments.
- 2:17So it is a separate fidelity entity dedicated to the digital
- 2:21asset space. We'll talk more about it, I'm
- 2:23sure, but our core products that we started with and we continue
- 2:27to use today is our custody services.
- 2:30So we offer cold storage custody for digital assets for our
- 2:33institutional clients as well as a platform and execution to help
- 2:38them buy, sell and hold digital assets.
- 2:40My journey or kind of origin story, I did the traditional.
- 2:45Financial tradfi world kind of stuff.
- 2:48I I got out of College in 2009. I want to go to capital markets.
- 2:51Worst time ever, of course. So I started in banking as a
- 2:55credit analyst for a couple years.
- 2:57Then I got to make the jump to a money manager in Chicago.
- 3:00We had about 30 billion under management there and I was
- 3:03analyzing tech stocks. I I love technology.
- 3:06I'm not a computer programmer or anything like that or developer,
- 3:09but I've always built my own computers and just wanted to
- 3:11experiment with stuff. So.
- 3:13It was actually through the tech side, believe it or not.
- 3:16Not the finance side that I first heard about Bitcoin.
- 3:19I heard about it in some tech magazine or blog and I was
- 3:25interested like what is this from a technological
- 3:27perspective? I read about it, researched it.
- 3:30I made my first Bitcoin purchase in 2012 or early 2013.
- 3:34I think it was whenever it was trading at around $4045.
- 3:39I just bought a couple and said I got a.
- 3:41Experiment with this. I got to trade it, sell it,
- 3:45moved around, and of course I did all the stupid stuff.
- 3:47You know, I bought stuff with it.
- 3:48I lost it. I, I, I, you know, basically
- 3:50traded and gambled with it. So lest anyone thinks I'm a
- 3:53Bitcoin billionaire sitting on $40 Bitcoin, I did all the
- 3:57things that everyone does with it.
- 3:58It wasn't until later where I did this deep dive into it,
- 4:02especially the economic side of it.
- 4:04My other passion is economics, and I was just talking to Marty,
- 4:07you know, recognizing a lot of the books behind him on the
- 4:10bookshelf there. Studied that in grad school and
- 4:13was this nerd that loved monetary theory and history.
- 4:17I went to George Mason University for my master's, and
- 4:19there's a professor there that I said I have to take a class with
- 4:22him. Doctor Larry White, he's the
- 4:24foremost expert on free banking, so he he knows a lot about
- 4:27private currencies and competing currencies and all of that.
- 4:30So that's when it really started to to click with me on the Econ
- 4:34side of what Bitcoin is as an asset and this, this aspiring
- 4:38money. And so I kept working in the
- 4:40finance world after that. And then eventually, these two
- 4:43paths kind of merged and I had the opportunity to come over to
- 4:46Fidelity, and I've been absolutely loving it ever since.
- 4:51Yeah, I'm jealous you got the study under Larry White.
- 4:55I saw him do a Soho forum debate with I forget his name, but he
- 5:01was one of the biggest proponents of nerp, essentially.
- 5:06It's bugging me that I can't think of his name, but it was an
- 5:10incredible debate. Larry Professor White won won
- 5:13the debate pretty handedly, but the whole I know we have a whole
- 5:17list of topics to to go on, but the whole idea of free banking
- 5:21on Bitcoin has always fascinated me because of the infamous Hal
- 5:24Finny post to bitcointalk.org. I believe it was in December of
- 5:282011 where he essentially said that we may be able to create
- 5:32like a free banking system on Bitcoin, having a bunch of
- 5:35private banks use Bitcoin as a reserve currency and then issue
- 5:40money's on top of that. And it's not the most popular
- 5:43idea of Bitcoin, but it's one that has always stuck with me
- 5:46and sat in the back of my mind like it seems like it could be
- 5:48possible. Well, are we, are we kind of
- 5:50already in the Bitcoin free ranking where, you know, you
- 5:53mentioned Fidelity's been around for a while They're they seem to
- 5:55be doing OK and there's some others that aren't, aren't,
- 5:59aren't around. And the market has decided who
- 6:01who stays around and who kind of maybe goes a little further on
- 6:04the risk curve than they should. Ken Rogoff was the man he he
- 6:09debated. Oh, sure.
- 6:11Yep, he buried the famous Rogoff and Reinhart paper and book.
- 6:15Sure, yeah. Do you think free banking is
- 6:18possible with Bitcoin? Personally, I I'm not sure.
- 6:23I mean, I think it is, but I haven't studied it enough yet to
- 6:27say. But I guess I don't see why not.
- 6:31You know, studying under Dr. White, he's.
- 6:34Basically documented all the places throughout history where
- 6:37free banking was in existence and where it was actually very
- 6:39successful. I think it was like Ireland and
- 6:43and Scotland, if I'm remembering correctly, you know, when one of
- 6:45those periods was well over 100 years.
- 6:47So if it can work back then with, you know, their relative
- 6:51rudimentary accounting and paper, how much more so could it
- 6:55work today? I guess it's kind of my theory,
- 6:57yeah. And from like a scaling Bitcoin
- 6:59perspective, when you think about the limitations of the
- 7:02protocol level and the fact that not every human on earth is
- 7:06going to be able to actually own a UTXO, the concept of free
- 7:10banking is an interesting way to attempt to scale Bitcoin to
- 7:15billions of people in the future.
- 7:20Yeah, there's some practical realities about Bitcoin that
- 7:23are, I suppose, some of the like, uncomfortable topics where
- 7:29it's a source of FUD. For a lot of people, you know,
- 7:33especially alt coiners, about how there's only 7 transactions
- 7:37per second. And so how could the world
- 7:39possibly, you know, adopt Bitcoin as a as a practical
- 7:44medium of exchange currency. And well, the the answer to that
- 7:49is it's not going to happen on on the base layer, it's not
- 7:52going to happen on on chain. The seven transactions per
- 7:55second limitation is only at the base layer.
- 7:58But of course it's going to, you know, we're scaling on the
- 8:00second layer with Lightning and other solutions.
- 8:03And the reality with those implementations is that you kind
- 8:08of end up with, you know, a third party that you're using as
- 8:12a service to use their infrastructure to, you know,
- 8:16lightning channels to transact. You know your value on the
- 8:21lightning network and then you're you know you have, you
- 8:25don't have total. About autonomy and control of
- 8:31your payment infrastructure at that point, because you're sort
- 8:36of piggybacking, you're paying as a service for somebody else
- 8:40to provide part of the the, the infrastructure that you need in
- 8:44order to transact. And now you're starting to
- 8:47approach banking in in that sense.
- 8:49And so you know that there's a path for that to continue to
- 8:53develop and. So long as you have a honest and
- 8:57true measuring stick that nobody controls, I don't see why not,
- 9:02you know, why free banking can't continue to naturally
- 9:06organically develop in the free market.
- 9:09And and I think the Lightning Network is sort of an indication
- 9:13of the early stages of that process playing out.
- 9:17Yeah. And then on top of that, things
- 9:18like Fetty Mints, these Charmian mints, which can act like
- 9:21individual private banks, Federated banks on top of the
- 9:24protocol level that are interoperable with Lightning.
- 9:27It seems like the experiment is being played out in real time.
- 9:31But we're not here to talk about free banking, even though it is
- 9:34an interesting concept. We're here to talk about what
- 9:37you're doing at Fidelity. And again, like going back to
- 9:40what we said earlier, Fidelity has been a staunch supporter of
- 9:45Bitcoin for, for almost a decade now.
- 9:47And I think Abby really sticking her neck out there in 2014 and
- 9:53saying, hey, we're going to begin transacting a Bitcoin in
- 9:57our in our cafeteria. We're going to really dig into
- 10:00mining. We're going to support people
- 10:01like Bob Mcilrath and others to really dive into what's going on
- 10:06here and try to figure out the custody side of of this Bitcoin
- 10:10thing. They did it early, A prestigious
- 10:1475 year old institution handling over a trillion dollars of
- 10:19assets. What in your mind Chris really
- 10:24sets Fidelity up to, to make a move like that pretty early on a
- 10:28bitcoins life cycle? Yeah, sure.
- 10:30So this was one of the things that attracted me to Fidelity
- 10:34and I did not know. So I love telling the story to
- 10:36people because I think they should know about it.
- 10:38But they always say how did fella to get into to Bitcoin and
- 10:41digital assets did you just jump in when and the last bull run
- 10:45and. And it's like, no, absolutely
- 10:46not. They were very methodical.
- 10:48They thought about this. And then, as you said, they
- 10:49invested a lot of time and and resources.
- 10:52So really the story goes back all the way to 1999, you know, a
- 10:56decade before Bitcoin even existed, with the creation of
- 11:00this internal group of business in Fidelity called the Fidelity
- 11:04Center for Applied Technology. And of course, we love acronyms.
- 11:08We're big company, so we call it F Cat, but this group.
- 11:12Mandate was to say, hey, Fidelity's been around for now
- 11:16over 75 years, Let's make sure we don't get disrupted or that
- 11:20we're looking out for the next big thing so we don't miss it,
- 11:23right. So they started this in 1999 and
- 11:26their whole model is scan, try and scale.
- 11:33And so they're scanning the horizon for these potential
- 11:35disruptors or things that might help us or or.
- 11:39Created efficiencies in the company, so of course they they
- 11:41found Bitcoin. I'm not exactly sure which which
- 11:44year they it popped up on their radar.
- 11:46Obviously this happened long before I was there, but a lot of
- 11:49this has been well documented and and passed down so hopefully
- 11:52I'm getting all the details right.
- 11:53But 2014, I know they had a pretty good group set up
- 11:57already. Researching it trying to find
- 12:01out as much as they could and remember back and forth. 2014
- 12:03There weren't near as many resources around, so they were
- 12:06already. Putting in the legwork to try to
- 12:09understand this, a year or so later, 20 by 2015, this gets to
- 12:14that try part. They get their hands dirty.
- 12:16This group F cat, they don't just sit in their ivory tower,
- 12:19read about it and and talk about it, they actually do it.
- 12:23So they said, well if we're going to understand this, we
- 12:25need to mine some Bitcoin ourselves.
- 12:26So they actually set up a unit to start mining Bitcoin and of
- 12:31course they said we got to purchase a miner from from China
- 12:34at the time. And so they put in an order for
- 12:37$200,000 worth of mining equipment.
- 12:40And this is kind of a famous story.
- 12:42Now that order was rejected by a procurement team.
- 12:45Whether it was on the cost basis or maybe some legal or risk
- 12:48issues, I don't know. But Abby Johnson, our CEO and
- 12:53Chairman, she, as you said she believed in this.
- 12:56She was a strong supporter. And she's told the story many
- 13:00times where she had to kind of walk down to people's office and
- 13:02say look. It's 200 grand.
- 13:04We're doing this. And for those who don't know, a
- 13:06big company like Fidelity, obviously 200 grand is not
- 13:08nothing, but in the in the relative basis of a company like
- 13:11this, that's not the biggest expense ever, right?
- 13:15And so she said, come on, just approve it, right?
- 13:16And so they got to work. They got mining Bitcoin.
- 13:21Marty, you mentioned also they experimented with using it as a
- 13:24payment mechanism. So they rolled out a little
- 13:26pilot where some employees were given a wallet and some Bitcoin
- 13:30and they paid for their lunch down at the cafeteria in
- 13:33Bitcoin. This was 2017, I think, So you
- 13:36can imagine how that went when you didn't have lightning where
- 13:38it is today. There was at least waiting of 10
- 13:42minutes or more when people wanted to return something that
- 13:45caused a ton of issues. So that didn't go as well.
- 13:48And there's still a lot of people at Fidelity today that
- 13:51you can see them calculating like how much that salad would
- 13:53be worth today if they still held that Bitcoin in 2017.
- 13:57But back to the mining they're they're mining Bitcoin and then
- 14:00the next thing they encountered was, well, we've got this mined
- 14:04Bitcoin, we want to hold it, but there's no institutional grade,
- 14:08enterprise grade. Custody solution out there, well
- 14:11of course Fidelity custody's and record keeps a lot of financial
- 14:15assets. So they said why don't we just
- 14:16build our own and that gets to the scale part of F Cats
- 14:20mission, right. If there is a possibility to
- 14:23turn this into a product or just scale it out over Fidelity then
- 14:26they're going to look to do that.
- 14:27And so in 2018, Fidelity Digital Assets was born and our first
- 14:32product and still our main core product today is custody, so
- 14:35cold storage of digital assets. And then we've added services on
- 14:39top of that since then. So again, like you said, the
- 14:42whole point of the story is we're not just, you know,
- 14:45joining the bandwagon. We've been here a long, long
- 14:48time. I joined this role two years
- 14:51ago. I think Philly Digital Assets
- 14:53was around 100 employees, maybe maybe getting close to 150 at
- 14:56the most. Now today, two years later,
- 14:59we've got over 600 associates here.
- 15:02So there's been a lot of investment.
- 15:04There there's so many different ways to to take this but I think
- 15:07one of the thoughts or questions as you navigated that story and
- 15:11journey is and my understanding was it was the greatest sense of
- 15:14like or example of innovators dilemma of sitting in a room.
- 15:18And at least the story is I understand it like what can
- 15:23disrupt us or how can we disrupt ourselves.
- 15:25And it was this technology and it would love to hear kind of
- 15:28like how you think about it right now.
- 15:32As far as integrating into the traditional financial system,
- 15:37because I would imagine we're still very early and
- 15:39understanding how this, you know could potentially disrupt
- 15:42financial services. But there's this world where
- 15:45you're starting to see it. You're seeing the interest and
- 15:47you have an existing, you know whole book of business across
- 15:52you know equities bonds across the board.
- 15:55But how Bitcoin starting to like seep into that and then if you
- 16:00can you know. How you see it potentially
- 16:02disrupting some of that. If you have any theory or any
- 16:05like stance on the side of fidelity, of like where Bitcoin
- 16:09starts to insert itself in the fidelity stack and then other,
- 16:12you know, large institutions. Yeah, great question.
- 16:16I mean, I know back when they were researching it, they made a
- 16:21list of all the ways. This could potentially either
- 16:24integrate with the business, whether it's record keeping or
- 16:27stock transfers, all that kind of stuff, or whether it could
- 16:30disrupt it. So they they've made that list
- 16:32and I'm glad to see now at this stage the the focus, or at least
- 16:37what they've ended up doing by our actions you can tell, is to
- 16:411st focus on Bitcoin, the asset right of getting.
- 16:45People exposure to it and of course it started with Fidelity
- 16:47Digital assets. The the institutional side, now
- 16:50you've seen us expand on the retail side with Fidelity
- 16:52Crypto. So any retail person, any of our
- 16:55millions of retail users who have a Fidelity account can can
- 16:58get access as well. We custody the Bitcoin for them
- 17:02and other digital assets. Now where it goes in the future,
- 17:06you know, who knows, who's to say.
- 17:08Obviously we're still looking at a lot of potential things, but
- 17:12at this point. I think it was the right call to
- 17:161st get the custody thing figured out because that is just
- 17:19so core. It's like a a primitive to the
- 17:22whole financial system. And then from there, that's
- 17:25where you can build all these other things, you know, even
- 17:27just like adding a service that we've added, that we added
- 17:31later, like lending, lending capabilities, like all that
- 17:34stuff has to come after these these really core fundamental
- 17:37things you're touching on. An idea that I feel very
- 17:41strongly about and it seems like Fidelity really grok this early
- 17:45on is that there's an order of operations to how Bitcoin will
- 17:48succeed and ultimately be integrated into our financial
- 17:52system. Like starting out with mining
- 17:54first, like I actually think that is the 1st order of
- 17:56operation, like mining in full nodes, making sure that that's
- 18:00sufficiently geographically distributed as the first thing.
- 18:02And then it's like, OK, we've plugged our miners in.
- 18:05We've received our Bitcoin for participating in global
- 18:08consensus. Now what do we do?
- 18:09We have to custody it. And then you just mentioned
- 18:12lending. I think that's the the logical
- 18:14next step after that is this order of operations.
- 18:17And now sitting in 2023, there's robust mining, there's robust
- 18:23full node distribution, there's robust custody products.
- 18:25Lending products are becoming more popular.
- 18:27We discussed lightning and fediments.
- 18:29They're further down the order of operations, but that's one
- 18:33thing that I believe strongly is that there's this order of
- 18:36operations, the thing and it seems like at fidelity you guys
- 18:40have honed in on that and really prioritize like focusing on the
- 18:44first set of order of operations, perfecting that and
- 18:47moving from there. Yeah, absolutely.
- 18:51I'd agree. And from a research perspective,
- 18:53we try to do the same thing. It's like when I first came on,
- 18:56it's it's here's what we have so far in our research library.
- 18:59Where are the holes for someone going on this journey of?
- 19:03Understanding what it is. Understanding the basic
- 19:05technical things, at least up to a level that an investor needs
- 19:09to. Understanding the value
- 19:11proposition. Understanding how it might fit
- 19:13to your portfolio. Understanding how to manage the
- 19:16risk. That has an order of operations
- 19:18too. So we try to mirror that as well
- 19:21on the investment and education side.
- 19:29And so I just can't help but think about how it's it's the
- 19:34fidelity is the only example that I can think of of an
- 19:37institution that has gotten this far down the learning curve
- 19:41already with regard to Bitcoin and and building products around
- 19:46it. You know as Michael mentioned
- 19:48like with the innovators dilemma in mind here of of some of these
- 19:53products are are changes for how traditional finance does things.
- 19:57Some of them might disrupt existing products and I I would
- 20:03love to hear it, you know, if you can share a little bit about
- 20:08what you see as like the the institutional learning process.
- 20:13And I know that you've been, you know, only been a part of it for
- 20:17a couple years here. But clearly there's success
- 20:20because if you go from 150 on the team to to 600 over the two
- 20:25years that you've been there, that's. 4X growth and and
- 20:29Fidelity must see this as a a major growth area and would love
- 20:35to hear like what has that institutional learning process
- 20:41looked like specifically in in terms of how, you know what's
- 20:45ahead for other institutions, institutions that are only right
- 20:49now, you know, maybe they're a couple years into their learning
- 20:52process with regard to how they incorporate Bitcoin into their
- 20:55business models. And So what has that like
- 20:59institutional learning and then processes and teaming.
- 21:04And you know, you talked about the experimental model, but what
- 21:08do you think have been some of the major lessons that Fidelity
- 21:11has has gleaned and and with respect to like what's coming
- 21:16for other major financial institutions as they learn?
- 21:21Yeah, I mean a lot of things there.
- 21:23So even just. In the two years I've been here,
- 21:26I've noticed with client conversations or prospective
- 21:30client conversations, their questions are getting a lot more
- 21:33sophisticated. So whether from our material or
- 21:36other material material out there like that you and others
- 21:39have put out, they're getting, they're getting the message,
- 21:42they're they're getting up the learning curve.
- 21:44And so it used to be a lot of what we'd call Bitcoin 101
- 21:48stuff. You know, what's Bitcoin?
- 21:49What's the difference between Bitcoin the Network, Bitcoin the
- 21:51asset? Why is it, you know, most people
- 21:54didn't even know there was I love to cap 21 million,
- 21:57certainly didn't know about things like difficulty
- 21:59adjustment, all that kind of one-on-one stuff.
- 22:01And now it's become a lot more sophisticated.
- 22:04So the challenge is still people are all over the place and even
- 22:08if you do like a group call or or or interview with someone,
- 22:12it's if you have more than one person, they're all on different
- 22:15levels. So that's always a challenge to
- 22:17try to speak to everyone in the audience.
- 22:19But overall I think. There is progress there, right.
- 22:22And so that's that's encouraging to see.
- 22:25And so people are taking a lot more seriously and we can talk
- 22:31about this as well, one of my theories, but the the excuses
- 22:35are the roadblocks for people not doing it are also getting a
- 22:39little more sophisticated as well for for better or worse,
- 22:42right. And then for what's coming, I I
- 22:45think a lot of institutions are realizing that.
- 22:48This is different and you can't just jump in here.
- 22:50It takes years and years of preparation and work.
- 22:53And that's why Fidelity recognized this early and why
- 22:56they've grown the team so much is because they obviously
- 22:58believe in the space. They obviously believe it's
- 23:00going to grow and we want to be ready if or when it does right.
- 23:04And so you can't, you can't turn on all this stuff in the next
- 23:08bull market when people are asking for exposure.
- 23:10You've got to have it all your ducks in a row ready to go once
- 23:13that happens just to to round that out like I was thinking
- 23:19about how Fidelity stands in in a in a small small group in my
- 23:26mind of like kind of innovators first through the door sort of
- 23:34idea here of like it's it's fidelity it's it's Paul Tudor
- 23:37Jones for for big name investors micro strategy and El Salvador
- 23:43You know like those are those are the the people who were like
- 23:47clearly ahead and and 1st through the door through the
- 23:50door and are their experience is modeling for others whether or
- 23:58not it was a good idea first of all and and then secondly how
- 24:03others can can follow that path. And I think it's notable that
- 24:07for each of those four categories they they've all had
- 24:13a good experience. You know, like every, you know,
- 24:17big name investors. El Salvador is doing great
- 24:19because in large part because of their adoption of Bitcoin,
- 24:24MicroStrategy is outperformed everybody on the stock market
- 24:27and Fidelity is investing heavily in this, in this new
- 24:31product area. And I think that, you know,
- 24:36that's part of connecting the dots for everyone else as
- 24:39they're evaluating is it a good idea to touch Bitcoin, to get
- 24:42involved in Bitcoin And it's proof positive when these
- 24:46leaders have a good experience and and double down on on their
- 24:51involvement in Bitcoin. So yeah, Michael, you go ahead
- 24:55now. Yeah, I was thinking it would be
- 24:57good maybe to take a step back because I think it'll help in
- 25:00two parts because it's fascinating.
- 25:03You walk through Chris like the the not trajectory, but like
- 25:07starting from mining or even before mining and thinking
- 25:10about, you know, how do we disrupt ourselves before we're
- 25:13disrupted. And thinking through that and
- 25:14having that like from a cultural lens and then the mining and
- 25:17then using it in the lunch room and where you're at now and and
- 25:19all the things that are planned for as Bitcoin grows.
- 25:24You guys manage close to $12 trillion in assets like to have
- 25:28that culture and go through that is is insanely impressive.
- 25:31I've the only company I've I've been at that has had some of
- 25:34that embodied is is Google 100,000 plus person company and
- 25:37you can get up and pick up and do things and and you expect.
- 25:40I don't know if it's still like that but I think it's important
- 25:43to understand the ethos of fidelity and how like that was
- 25:46even possible because to Jesse's point I think.
- 25:49That there's probably and there's different different
- 25:51areas of the market whether it's the Michael Michael Sailors, the
- 25:55El Salvadors, they all have their own overlap with something
- 25:59that exists at Fidelity. And then they also have their
- 26:01own like particular instance that we're going to start seeing
- 26:03with other countries, with other financial institutions, with
- 26:06other Fortune 500 companies. And so I think my understanding
- 26:09more just because it's fascinating what made Fidelity
- 26:12do this, but then also we can start to look at who will be the
- 26:14incumbents that also adopt this. And then who will be the ones
- 26:17that don't because we've seen this the past couple of years in
- 26:19the cycles is like people touch it and then the cycle the market
- 26:23falls and it's like all I'm done with it like they're you know
- 26:25you keep you keep hearing. I think the latest was I don't
- 26:27know if it was TD but there there was one firm that was like
- 26:30God, we're going to scrap our digital asset strategy and then
- 26:32if they didn't really have that confidence and conviction of
- 26:34understanding what's happening here.
- 26:36So I would love to just hear about the culture of fidelity
- 26:38and like how you know you see it from coming in of like it was in
- 26:43the ethos to look at this. If you don't mind sharing.
- 26:47Yeah, no, that's a great question.
- 26:49One that attracted me again to fidelity in this position, which
- 26:53it was very clear that people truly believed in it.
- 26:56And on the research side, I like to tell my my team, it's a
- 26:59little cliche of course, but we have a missionary mindset, not a
- 27:02mercenary mindset, right? So our research is stuff we
- 27:05truly believe in and not to say we we get it all right or
- 27:09anything like that, but we're not here to to try to to make a
- 27:12quick sale or something like that and.
- 27:15Our business model is aligned with that right as as a
- 27:17custodian you make money off of the fees of custodying the
- 27:21assets. So our goal is for people to
- 27:24understand the core value propositions of Bitcoin and
- 27:27digital assets and to have an allocation and an exposure to it
- 27:31and have a very long term allocation and time horizon.
- 27:34So that aligns everything right. It aligns, it aligns what we
- 27:38think is the best way to play this, and and.
- 27:40And to get exposure to it, we it aligns what we think is the
- 27:44highest chance of probability of access the longer you you hold
- 27:47this a longterm view. And then it aligns with our
- 27:49business model of how we make money, right?
- 27:52So we we don't make money off of tons of trades like other
- 27:56companies out there. And we're not only crypto, we're
- 27:59we're Fidelity. So even if people come in
- 28:03through the digital assets side, then they might, you know,
- 28:06access or want other services from Fidelity.
- 28:09In terms of the culture, I mean I'm not I'm not sure exactly
- 28:11where that came from other than you know some certain people
- 28:14that really believed it and carried the torch.
- 28:17But to your point of of of such a large company being able to do
- 28:21this, I I credit that with the structure that they set up with
- 28:24us as being a a subsidiary. So people have likened it to
- 28:29more of a startup feel or or late startup feel, yet we have
- 28:33kind of the. The guard rails or the safety
- 28:36net of the Fidelity parent company above us, which is a
- 28:39really unique and nice structure to have, quite frankly.
- 28:43Yep. Yeah.
- 28:44There's this term I didn't necessarily had heard before,
- 28:46but I kind of recognized it over the years and being this space
- 28:49is like an educated client is a great client because we're still
- 28:53so early in this whole. Period of understanding Bitcoin
- 28:56and custody and it's like if they understand fundamentally
- 28:59what's happening, they can think about it from a long term time
- 29:01horizon. You can provide the right
- 29:02products and they can be long term clients.
- 29:04But we've seen you know again over the cycles coming in it's
- 29:08it's there's only so many people available to educate to really
- 29:11break things down to first principles and embody these like
- 29:15or be able to facilitate that. You mentioned Jesse's content
- 29:19and the and for the research. It's like over these years the
- 29:23the signal is getting tighter and tighter and the education
- 29:25information becomes quicker and quicker to go from well, what is
- 29:29this to oh maybe this is something that I want long term
- 29:32exposure to. But we've just gone through
- 29:35these phases year after year of there are some entities or or
- 29:42people that come into the space that don't aren't able to pick
- 29:46all that up. And so that's where we see a lot
- 29:48of the, you know, I think the past 24 months have been very
- 29:51volatile and they've been you know, great for certain aspects.
- 29:54I imagine they've been great for fidelity because they anchor
- 29:56back to fundamentals and to the type of clients you're looking
- 29:59at track. But on the other side of that, a
- 30:01lot of people, I think the past few years have gotten burned
- 30:03because they weren't educated properly and the businesses that
- 30:07didn't educate them as well weren't able to really kind of
- 30:09reap the rewards long term because the client didn't
- 30:12fundamentally have an anchor into what's happening.
- 30:14And and ultimately this is, you know.
- 30:16I don't know if you agree, but we kind of joke around.
- 30:18It's like alien technology. This stuff is not easy,
- 30:20especially when you come from a traditional finance background
- 30:23to look at it and understand, fix supply and something that
- 30:26could have value. So it really isn't easy to
- 30:29educate. Well, and to piggyback on that,
- 30:32I guess a good topic to dive into is having written these
- 30:37research reports over the course of many years.
- 30:40What have you found has connected with your clients and
- 30:44really help them rock? What's going on here with
- 30:46Bitcoin? What type of information do you
- 30:49find is the most high leverage and having the the light switch
- 30:52go off for for your clients? Yeah, great question.
- 30:55So in terms of the the type of content, you know, really the
- 31:00educational stuff and knowing that we talked to institutional
- 31:04investors anytime I can bridge. This digital asset world back to
- 31:08the traditional finance world is usually helpful or a win.
- 31:12You know, I was in that world, got my CFA, all that kind of
- 31:15stuff. So I can speak their language,
- 31:16right. And so if you can put things,
- 31:18even though they're not always great analogies or ways of
- 31:21putting it, sometimes if you put things in their terms like what
- 31:24this is kind of like APE ratio or whatever the example might
- 31:27be, then you might see them pick that up, right.
- 31:31The other thing I found is whenever we talked to.
- 31:36Client or prospective client especially is I try to feel
- 31:40where they are on the macro thesis, right, because that kind
- 31:43of then determines which path to go with them.
- 31:45And what I mean by that is are they already on board with some
- 31:49of the big macro themes that we've identified in our research
- 31:51And and you obviously talk lots about just the the basic idea of
- 31:55currency to basement. You know, I, MF and others have
- 31:59papers out there saying this is the playbook, like this is how
- 32:02you take care of high debt loads.
- 32:04The fact that our our debt to GDP is very high, we've got huge
- 32:08structural deficits right now. If they're on board with that
- 32:12macro thesis and they already hold that, then it's a lot
- 32:15easier in many ways as you can imagine.
- 32:17Then it's more talking about the intricacies of the
- 32:21technicalities of Bitcoin and and some of the unique
- 32:23investment characteristics. But they're on board with the
- 32:26big picture. If they're not on board with
- 32:28that, if they they just see it as you're a gold bug or
- 32:32something like that and they're. You know, just vehemently
- 32:35against gold for whatever reason, good or bad.
- 32:39Then it's a different approach. Then you got to try to say okay.
- 32:44Is there a chance you could could be wrong here or wouldn't
- 32:48you even just want to hold kind of a market neutral position of
- 32:52Bitcoin as a percent of the total global investment
- 32:55universe? Or maybe you can do the
- 32:59technology, play with them like kind of.
- 33:01Owning the next piece of the the infrastructure of the Internet.
- 33:03Sometimes that narrative or thesis works as well but that's
- 33:08what that's a different conversation if that makes
- 33:10sense. Yeah you're you're hitting on
- 33:12how it, you know in our conversations with folks and and
- 33:16on the podcast last week, this was a major theme is it's hard
- 33:19to put this asset in any particular bucket.
- 33:23It it doesn't fit in portfolios the way that portfolios have
- 33:26traditionally been constructed. And so I think you're sort of
- 33:30speaking to that but but I I guess where do you tend to to
- 33:35see folks fitting Bitcoin into their portfolios?
- 33:40Do they in your experience, do they tend to carve it out as
- 33:43like part of a hard asset bucket sitting alongside gold or is it
- 33:49like a technology play in order to hold a part of the Internet
- 33:53of value? How do you see that playing out?
- 33:58Yeah, great question because this is actually a question we
- 34:00ask on our annual survey every year.
- 34:02So we are now in our fifth survey in process institutional
- 34:06investor survey of digital assets.
- 34:08So this is one of the largest surveys done out there over 1000
- 34:12participants and everyone's always looking forward to to
- 34:15next year's results. So stay tuned for for that one.
- 34:17We're almost done. Or finishing up this year's.
- 34:20But one of the question is what what do you consider it?
- 34:23Do you do you consider it as part of your real asset sleeve
- 34:26or your your equity kind of risk one or do you take it out of
- 34:29bonds? And I don't have the numbers in
- 34:32front of me right now, but I I think if I'm remembering
- 34:34correctly, most people carve it out out as separate or as part
- 34:39of their real assets, right, which makes sense because it's
- 34:42it's commodity like it's scarce. I think that that resonates the
- 34:46most with them and so we've also done.
- 34:50A lot of studies showing if you had just say a 6040 portfolio
- 34:54and you took it out of your risk bucket or you're not off off
- 34:59risk bucket, your say your bonds, it's what you would
- 35:02expect, right? You're going to, you're going to
- 35:04lower your volatility and returns if you or you won't
- 35:07lower your returns, but you're going to lower your volatility
- 35:09if you take it out of your your risk bucket and then you're
- 35:12going to increase if you take it out of your bond bucket.
- 35:14So it doesn't really matter or people could just go halfandhalf
- 35:19if they wanted to. But it really depends on kind of
- 35:22their mandate and how they they view risk to begin with, if that
- 35:26makes sense. And it's part of that.
- 35:29It doesn't really matter which bucket you take it from
- 35:32ultimately, because Bitcoin dwarfs either of those buckets.
- 35:38And so whichever bucket it's coming from is a good bucket to
- 35:43be taken from. Yeah, exactly.
- 35:45I mean, if you're purely looking at historical numbers, which
- 35:48have of course have been through the roof on almost every time
- 35:50frame, then yeah, it trounces everything.
- 35:52So I mean theoretically if you if you have no risk limit, then
- 35:56it's like you would just allocate everything to it.
- 35:59Purely on a backwards looking historical basis but but yes
- 36:03you're I'm sure you I'm sure you found that that Black Rock
- 36:06report rather eyebrow raising when they what was it they they
- 36:10concluded the optimum allocation was 87% or something.
- 36:14Yeah, I wanted to say 90%. I read that paper as well.
- 36:18It's funny because I actually got dinner with somebody on
- 36:20Monday night who's in the space and is.
- 36:24Working on a credit credit related Bitcoin product and
- 36:27their team has ran the numbers on the worst four year Kagger
- 36:32return of Bitcoin. It just so happened to be April
- 36:352019 to April 2023. So recently in the Kagger in
- 36:39that time period was 23.4% or something that which is unheard
- 36:45of and any other. Is US.
- 36:48Right to do a shameless plug for one of our pieces.
- 36:51This is the exact problem we tried to tackle in one of them.
- 36:55It's something called Bitcoin using machine learning to to
- 36:58model Bitcoin in a portfolio. And so here we tapped another
- 37:01team at Fidelity that works with these machine learning a I
- 37:05driven models and they looked at this problem just from a quant
- 37:09perspective, saying the history of Bitcoin is short, especially
- 37:13if you only go back to like when you have some, you know.
- 37:16Pretty solid trading data, not it's very early days and
- 37:20furthermore not only is the history short, but it's, it's
- 37:23crazy good, right. So if you don't think it's going
- 37:27to repeat that, how can we, how can we really model that
- 37:30forward. And so they they use some
- 37:32sophisticated techniques which I'll be honest some of them are
- 37:34over my head to try to create some synthetic returns or or
- 37:38data looking forward. But basically they they model it
- 37:41like a very high. Growth, high tech stock, high
- 37:45beta stock where it has, you know, huge skews in terms of
- 37:51their return distributions, it's and it's highly skewed to the
- 37:54right. And so they say if we can do
- 37:56this with some stocks, why don't we just say Bitcoin is going to
- 38:00be similar to that and then work off of that.
- 38:03And not surprisingly, it all depends on your inputs.
- 38:06But if you think bitcoin's going to return more than your current
- 38:10asset class buckets. Then it makes sense to put a
- 38:13little bit in your portfolio and how much you put in is of course
- 38:16just dependent then on on how much you're willing to lose.
- 38:19And kind of the unique thing they did with this is instead of
- 38:24the efficient frontier, which the nerds listening will will
- 38:27know what I'm talking about, the efficient portfolio, efficient
- 38:30frontier, they did something called an efficient loss
- 38:33frontier or something like that. Basically saying how much are
- 38:36you willing to stomach and as a drawdown.
- 38:39And then from there, you can decide your allocation of
- 38:41Bitcoin, right? Because that's the true measure.
- 38:44A lot of people care about how much can I, how much loss can I
- 38:48get, Not necessarily how much gain can I get.
- 38:51So yeah, we can put a link to that in the show notes or
- 38:54whatever, but that that was one of the ways we tried to tackle
- 38:56this. But it's it's a sticky problem
- 38:58for sure. Does that come up in the in the
- 39:01conversation like the fundamentals because I think
- 39:03that like you're kind of alluding to I think.
- 39:06You know, for certain people interested, they've kind of
- 39:09jumped the gap that there might be some value here.
- 39:11But for others and I think the majority, it's like there's a
- 39:14lot of error between zero and $26,000 or wherever you're at
- 39:17and obviously on on this call and folks listening know about,
- 39:20you know, hash rate addresses, all the things that are the
- 39:23fundamental under underpinnings of what's happening.
- 39:26But does that come up? And have you guys constructed
- 39:28anything around that to show like there's fundamental growth
- 39:31across every, almost every metric in the ecosystem when it
- 39:35comes to Bitcoin? Yeah, that's a big one.
- 39:37We like to hit in our, our recaps and roundups and updates.
- 39:41We like to say, look, if you removed price and you didn't
- 39:44know what the price was and we just gave you the network
- 39:47fundamentals, you'd be surprised.
- 39:49We're in a sixty 7080% bear market or whatever it is because
- 39:53all of these metrics keep going up.
- 39:56Another research product we did this year is something called
- 39:58the Signals Report, where there's all these signals out
- 40:01there, there's your traditional price signals, and then there's
- 40:05all these. Specific on chain signals to
- 40:08Bitcoin as you know and institutional investors, they
- 40:11they might know about it but they don't know how to correctly
- 40:13interpret it or place it. And So what we did with this
- 40:16report is we we put them in buckets.
- 40:18We said identify whether you're a short term, medium term or
- 40:21long term investor and then depending on that here's the
- 40:24signals you should be watching. And so for the long term, the
- 40:27investor persona for that one we say is I'm a long term investor,
- 40:3010 plus years maybe I'm DCA ING every month or quarter, whatever
- 40:34it is. All I care is about the absolute
- 40:38fundamental thesis. And the absolute fundamental
- 40:40thesis is, is this thing going to survive or is it going to die
- 40:44or or people going to become apathetic about it.
- 40:46And so really the only signals you should care about are these
- 40:48longterm things like hash rate, address growth, transactions,
- 40:51all that stuff that you guys know.
- 40:53So that's one way we've tried to also approach this this problem
- 40:57with people. That's such incredible framing
- 41:00and positioning of like, let's just put the price aside and
- 41:03let's look at this over the course of X number of time
- 41:05frames and say like you wouldn't know what the price, you
- 41:08wouldn't know that we're sitting at $27,000 right now.
- 41:11And and ultimately, you're right, it's a binary, it's a
- 41:14binary question and outcome. This thing either works and
- 41:19becomes digital gold and more or it doesn't work and it goes to 0
- 41:24so. You know digital gold would be
- 41:27500,000 per Bitcoin and so a 20X from where we're at.
- 41:32Everyone's very happy if that happens over the over 2 decades
- 41:36even that that's a fantastic outcome or it goes to zero and
- 41:40and you know we are all wrong for some reason that after years
- 41:44of digging into it and and lots and lots of brain cycles spent
- 41:49looking at this thing we are missing something.
- 41:53And and so you're right, they're like on the long time scale,
- 41:56that's all that matters is, is, is adoption increasing because
- 42:00adoption increasing interacts with the finite supply of this
- 42:05thing to cause each unit of supply to become more valued
- 42:10over time because more people are competing for it.
- 42:13It really is that binary in the end, isn't it?
- 42:18And what you've hit on here is, is another approach we use
- 42:20within investors, institutional investors which is they
- 42:23understand things with asymmetric payoffs, right.
- 42:27And so that's one we we hit just like you said I I'm in, I'm in
- 42:30your camp personally I I think this is pretty binary especially
- 42:34over the long term. It's either going way up or it's
- 42:36going to to basically nothing or staying kind of nowhere, right.
- 42:41And so if you believe that, then why not have exposure to
- 42:45something so asymmetric like that is the big, the big Holy
- 42:50Grail in finance finding asymmetric bets like that is how
- 42:52alpha is created. And so that really resonates
- 42:54with institutional clients as well.
- 42:57Yeah. And on this note too, I think
- 42:59the topic we should bring into this, bringing the price back
- 43:02into it, I think that's one thing that the Bitcoin price
- 43:05volatility has really proven out over the 1st 15 years of
- 43:09Bitcoins existence is that time in the market is way more
- 43:13important than timing the market.
- 43:15And trying to articulate that to new investors is kind of hard
- 43:21because when we go through these bull cycles, it's typically like
- 43:23two to three months where we run up pretty crazy and then it
- 43:26crashes back down and that's all they say.
- 43:28They're like how this is way too volatile for me.
- 43:30But you can run the numbers historically if you spend a lot
- 43:34of time in this market, your portfolio is going to benefit
- 43:37massively and just trying to articulate to that to people
- 43:41gets a bit muddied with. The high volatility rate that's
- 43:44existed historically, yeah, the volatility keeps coming up.
- 43:48If if you look at our survey, it's usually the number one
- 43:52reason listed why people don't invest.
- 43:54And frankly I don't quite understand that from
- 43:58institutional investors because these investors should know
- 44:01volatility is never a reason to just not invest at all.
- 44:05It's a reason to make sure you're appropriately sizing your
- 44:08position, right. That's, that's the key.
- 44:11And and they should really know that I'm so I always push back
- 44:14and say, oh, it's too volatile. So do you own any Netflix in
- 44:17your accounts? Because Netflix has had
- 44:20drawdowns of 80% or more three or four Times Now as well in its
- 44:23history. And I'm not picking on Netflix,
- 44:25it's just an example. But that's that's what you can
- 44:28experience with other assets you already invest in.
- 44:31So are those completely off the table?
- 44:34No, you just make sure you're appropriately sizing your
- 44:37position and your risk. Yeah.
- 44:39And it goes back to framing like volatility is opportunity.
- 44:44And you you alluded to earlier how there are increasingly
- 44:49sophisticated objections to to Bitcoin because change is
- 44:55difficult I think is really what it comes comes back to you right
- 44:58and and for Trad 5 to have to reckon with like why is this
- 45:03thing that on, you know based on my mental model of how the world
- 45:07works and how finance works. This thing shouldn't exist or or
- 45:10shouldn't go anywhere. It should be a bubble.
- 45:13Why is it continuing to to have little mini bubbles with higher
- 45:18highs and higher lows every four years and not going away and in
- 45:23fact continuing further into an adoption curve that creates the
- 45:29basis for people wanting to find sophisticated reasons to to?
- 45:35Not have to incorporate this into their portfolios and into
- 45:39their models about where the world and where finances is
- 45:43tracking currently. And so I, I I want to go back to
- 45:50I can't resist asking if Fidelity has you know you when
- 45:55you when you went to the quant team and they modeled out you
- 46:01know their perspectives of of. Volatility going forward with
- 46:06Bitcoin does, does Fidelity subscribe to the idea that the
- 46:14havings matter or is it a liquidity driven price chart or
- 46:23you know what can you, what can you talk about there?
- 46:26Sure. So I just just a quick note,
- 46:29when we say like Fidelity, we're not talking Fidelity as a whole.
- 46:32We don't have a house view on these things.
- 46:35I'll I'll speak from Fidelity digital assets in our research
- 46:38team in particular. But we certainly think that
- 46:41having is worth watching and it has to have some effect because
- 46:47you're changing the two most important things in economic
- 46:49supply, the other one being demand, right.
- 46:52So my colleague on the team, Danielle Gray actually has a a
- 46:56piece out not too long ago, a couple months ago going into the
- 47:00having and and you know basics of what it is, but then also
- 47:04doing analysis of well if if past is prelude to the future,
- 47:08what could we see or how could this play out.
- 47:10So we're still debating internally as well though the
- 47:15jury's still out because we haven't test.
- 47:17You know we haven't had a real world example of whether the
- 47:19having is the primary driver or whether it's just happened to
- 47:23match up with these four year liquidity cycles and and Fed
- 47:26cycles as you know. Or maybe it's both.
- 47:29Maybe we'll we'll see these two things happen differently this
- 47:33time or maybe it'll happen together again in the world may
- 47:35never know which one's the the primary driver.
- 47:38But I think just from a first principles perspective, if you
- 47:41if you go through the economics of the supply and the and the
- 47:45demand and and what happens with having, it has to have some
- 47:48effect. But of course, you know, people
- 47:49can debate how much of an effect it has, but it's definitely
- 47:53something that people should not be not aware, ignorant of, and
- 47:57and should be should be watching carefully.
- 48:01Yeah, we'll be really interesting to see if the Fed is
- 48:04able to keep rates elevated for another year and what the
- 48:09Bitcoin price does in that type of environment, post having next
- 48:12year. Yeah, yeah, I I have the luxury
- 48:16of being able to fly off the handle and say I don't think
- 48:19it's gonna happen. I don't think that's too far off
- 48:23the handle, Jesse. No, that's true.
- 48:27But with all that in my I mean. Because there's a social aspect
- 48:33to it here as well, obviously at the supply and demand with the
- 48:36havings and then you have the liquidity of the incumbent
- 48:40system driven by Fed policy. That's always something that's
- 48:45lingered in my head, like if Fidelity is successful in
- 48:49convincing other institutions and doesn't have to be fidelity
- 48:53by themselves, but other institutions had the light
- 48:55switch go off. And then there's a
- 48:57psychological, social aspect of it.
- 48:59That could happen at some point in the future as well, Where,
- 49:02yes, the having may have somewhat of an effect, liquidity
- 49:06profile of the monetary system may have some effect.
- 49:09But is that psychological light switch going off for a bunch of
- 49:12institutions at the same time? Does that have like a more
- 49:15profound effect at some point in the future?
- 49:18People just, yeah, absolutely. I think, I think as much as we
- 49:23like to paint the finance world as quant driven, and it's
- 49:27obviously gotten a lot more quant driven in the past few
- 49:30years, I personally believe, and I've been in the space long
- 49:34enough to know that it's still humans and it's still people
- 49:37making these decisions and pulling these triggers.
- 49:39So don't don't underestimate that.
- 49:43And don't underestimate the reflexivity of something like
- 49:45that. Yeah.
- 49:47And let's let's dig deeper in that because I know Marty when
- 49:50you kicked off the show you you referenced Deutsche Bank, but
- 49:54reading like ink backwards from Deutsche Bank was I think today,
- 49:57a few days ago, Franklin Templeton.
- 49:59You know, I think a 1.2 trillion plus in a UM filing for ETF,
- 50:05we've had this drum beat of institutional kind of activity
- 50:09happening this year. And it in, in my opinion, it
- 50:11feels like it's the first year that institutions are trying to
- 50:14frontrun. The having like to your point
- 50:15that we had the cycle and everybody went into hibernation
- 50:18but they were working on stuff. It wasn't like they were like,
- 50:20oh, this isn't coming back and now we have, there's a lot of
- 50:23stuff happening in the quote UN quote digital asset space, but I
- 50:26think preparing for but. Staying on Bitcoin, how are you
- 50:31kind of seeing the market as far as just like institutions
- 50:35building infrastructure, thinking about this next wave of
- 50:37adoption? Because I think it's probably
- 50:39for anybody that's paying attention in the space, it's not
- 50:43going away and there's probably another happening.
- 50:47And so now they're again from again from this vantage point
- 50:50like preparing to absorb that flow.
- 50:52And I don't know if we've seen that in previous cycles ahead of
- 50:56having thinking back even just like 2019.
- 50:59Hey. I mean, I think people initially
- 51:01still thought that like having didn't matter.
- 51:04I think most people would would come in.
- 51:05I think the reasons why they having matters is still up for
- 51:07debate and there's efficient market hypothesis and a bunch of
- 51:10other things that people will discuss.
- 51:13But yeah, just curious, Chris, like how you're seeing it and
- 51:15how you guys are preparing. I know there's some products you
- 51:17guys are working on the fact it whatever you can share.
- 51:20But then also just from the external market and what you're
- 51:21hearing and seeing feels like a lot of institutions are getting
- 51:24suited or prepared for whatever's to come the next
- 51:27couple years. Yeah, absolutely.
- 51:29I mean, I don't know if institutions are internalizing
- 51:33the having as that much. I guess I just haven't heard it
- 51:37anecdotally. But whether or not they are
- 51:41doing that or just subconsciously or through other
- 51:44means and and signals and data, I do agree with you that they
- 51:52are now fully on board of thinking this is not going away.
- 51:54And so that's why you see all these announcements of
- 51:56institutions with coming out with this product or or or
- 52:00preparing with this or ramping up that.
- 52:01And so they're coming along and they're they're incentivized to
- 52:04do it right if if there's potential for money to be made
- 52:08and to serve their customers, they're going to do it.
- 52:10And so they don't even have to necessarily fully believe in the
- 52:14having or Bitcoin itself. And not to take take this on a
- 52:19different note, but it just because it reminded me right now
- 52:21I was listening to your previous episode with I think it was
- 52:24Lauren and he was saying something like, well that the
- 52:28institutions are coming but it's just slow and gradual and I
- 52:31would agree it's currently slow and gradual.
- 52:32But he seemed to say not to put words in his mouth that it's it
- 52:36might just keep going slowly and gradually.
- 52:38And my experience in the industry, I personally think
- 52:42there's going to be a gradually then suddenly kind of event, a
- 52:46turning point. And the reason I I think that is
- 52:49because of two things. One, in the institutional money
- 52:53space, you're if you're a money manager, whether it's of a
- 52:57family office or or hedge fund or big endowment or pension,
- 53:01whatever it is, almost all of these people have a benchmark
- 53:05that they're measured against, right.
- 53:06And so Bitcoin, just Bitcoin itself today, if you, I mean,
- 53:12Jesse, you've run the numbers probably more recently than me
- 53:15on this and and I saw one of your articles, but out of the
- 53:18global investable universe, it's we've come up with like .2 to
- 53:22.5%, right? So it's hardly enough to warrant
- 53:26being in one of these benchmarks.
- 53:28But if or when it gets big enough or when it's just added
- 53:31because it's a different asset class and these index providers
- 53:35add it, that gets added to all these money managers scorecards.
- 53:39And so I used to be at a money manager in Chicago.
- 53:41It was a $10 billion growth fund.
- 53:43I worked on a team and I would have to.
- 53:45I was the the low man on the totem pole early in my career.
- 53:48And one of the things I had to do was prepare these attribution
- 53:50reports. So every month and every quarter
- 53:52I'd give my manager this attribution report and it said
- 53:55here's how much you outperformed your your benchmark and here's
- 54:00why you under or outperformed it.
- 54:01And it would go by sector and by even industry and specific
- 54:04stock. So you were underweight this
- 54:07stock or this sector compared to the benchmark and it did really
- 54:10well. So that hurt you.
- 54:12So what happens when all these managers start getting their
- 54:14attribution reports saying you underperformed your benchmark by
- 54:18200 basis points, 2%, which in the in finance world is a lot
- 54:22for people who don't know because you were underweight
- 54:25Bitcoin. And the other thing this reminds
- 54:28me of too is early in my career we're on the growth fund and
- 54:32there was some stock. It doesn't matter the actual
- 54:34name. If it was Apple or something, it
- 54:35was doing really well and it got to be a big position like 5% of
- 54:38the benchmark and some of these managers are like well, 5%.
- 54:41That's that's a big position for a fund like that's where our our
- 54:45upper risk limits are. So we have to own 5% just to be
- 54:49neutral. And it's like, yeah, if you, if
- 54:52you own anything less than 5%, you don't even have to have an
- 54:55opinion on it. But if you own 0% of something
- 54:58and the benchmarks at 5, you're effectively underweight that
- 55:03thing by 5% and if it does well, it's going to hurt you.
- 55:05So if you have no, no opinion whatsoever, if you're completely
- 55:09neutral on Bitcoin and let's say it's in your benchmark at 2%,
- 55:14then you have to own 2% of it. Otherwise you're taking an
- 55:17active bet for or against it. And then of course all the
- 55:20passive managers out there will just have to own it as well,
- 55:22right? So that's one of my personal
- 55:24reasons why I think you could see a flip it like a a a big
- 55:28turning point. And the other big thing is just
- 55:30the whole idea of career risk. So in the finance world, career
- 55:33risk is everything. If you underperform due to
- 55:38something, but all your peers underperform because they were
- 55:41also getting it wrong, it doesn't hurt you as much as if
- 55:45you stick your neck out on something and it turns out to be
- 55:48wrong, right? It's career suicide.
- 55:50So as soon as that career risk goes away and everybody is kind
- 55:54of owning it and doing it, then that's also where when you'll
- 55:57see a big acceleration. Yeah, I think it's so
- 56:02interesting how a big element of the adoption curve is.
- 56:07Human psychology and and that manifests in a variety of layers
- 56:12and and career risk is a big part of it particularly with
- 56:17regard to institutional capital allocators or or or money
- 56:21managers. And you're right that like
- 56:25bitcoin's entire history to date has been as an asset that
- 56:28doesn't move the needle. It doesn't matter in terms of.
- 56:34The global asset landscape, it it is by my estimations half a
- 56:39percent as you said so 1-2 thousandth of the world's value
- 56:43is in Bitcoin. So you can you can ignore that
- 56:46and that bucket that tiny little thimble and and you're fine in
- 56:50terms of like tracking the overall asset landscape and and
- 56:56you know on a on a weighted basis that you're going to be
- 57:00fine if you ignore that but there's some threshold where.
- 57:04That's no longer true. And then that introduces this
- 57:08this issue of of career risk, which is really a kind of like
- 57:14pressurized version of of social proofing.
- 57:17You know that Paul Tudor Jones says it's a good idea.
- 57:21Bill Miller's on board Strand, Stan Druckenmiller, now Larry
- 57:25Fink, Ray Dalio is sort of opening up to it.
- 57:30So why aren't you hedge fund manager?
- 57:34Participating in this thing, are you going to, are you going to
- 57:37miss out on another year of Bitcoin being the top performing
- 57:41asset in the global asset landscape which is happened like
- 57:4510 times at or 11 times out of the last 14 years and and we're
- 57:51due for another three-year run in my opinion.
- 57:55And so that that element of human psychology is really what
- 58:02drives. The adoption curve, because the
- 58:05next incremental slice of adopters is motivated by all of
- 58:10the inputs that they're gathering and how their
- 58:13psychology processes, whether or not it's time to make the jump.
- 58:17And that's a that's a push and a pull system, right, where you're
- 58:21you're pulled in because you find the the potential upside
- 58:27very attractive or you're compelled by the fact that, you
- 58:30know, bonds are probably going to lose.
- 58:34Are going to be a losing proposition on a on a real real
- 58:38return basis over the coming decade or or two.
- 58:41You know, you might be pulled into Bitcoin, but you can also
- 58:44be pushed into Bitcoin because you have to.
- 58:47You have to include it in your portfolio because you might fall
- 58:50behind versus your, you know, your cohort that you're being
- 58:53compared to if you're managing money.
- 58:56Or you might fall behind your neighbor or your friend who has
- 58:59a little bit of Bitcoin and you're sick of them
- 59:01outperforming you. And so, like the adoption curve
- 59:05is really this, this manifestation of human
- 59:08psychology. And that's why ultimately it's a
- 59:10bell curve, because that's how human psychology plays out in
- 59:14the in a smooth distribution of of how each of us with our
- 59:18individual circumstances and faculties process reality and
- 59:23change our behavior in a distribution manner.
- 59:27And yet we are still at the very early stages of that.
- 59:31And we're going into an increasing towards the middle of
- 59:35the bell curve where all of the crazy action happens.
- 59:39Chris, that topic you went to is insanely fascinating on the
- 59:44benchmarks and underperforming. Can you talk about how you see
- 59:47and it isn't to be relative and it can be if you guys if you
- 59:50feel comfortable discussing plans on the wealth management
- 59:52side, but I feel like. Is there something very similar
- 59:55with RIAS and financial advisors?
- 59:57And I think I was listening to one of the, I think it was a
- 1:00:03webinar podcast that Jack on your team did with Tyrone Ross
- 1:00:07and a few other folks about. I I forget the number but I
- 1:00:10think it's like anywhere between 70 to 80% of like Bitcoin crypto
- 1:00:14sits outside of FAA wealth managers platforms because of.
- 1:00:20A number of things whether it's like you know career risk the
- 1:00:23tooling and all the things associated.
- 1:00:25But how do you see that playing out?
- 1:00:27Because it feels like a very similar dynamic of there's going
- 1:00:29to be certain benchmarks that are going to become more and
- 1:00:32more visible and that individual, as you know, we know
- 1:00:36inflation runs and and Justice point about bonds that it's
- 1:00:39getting harder and harder to keep pace on that store storing
- 1:00:42value long term in a in a world where the cost of goods is
- 1:00:46increasing. How you see that playing cuz
- 1:00:48there's trillions and trillions sitting in those accounts as
- 1:00:50well outside of traditional kind of, you know, pensions, hedge
- 1:00:53funds, endowments. Yeah, absolutely.
- 1:00:58Yeah. On the wealth side, the Rea that
- 1:01:00sort of side it's, it gets to Jesse's point about the the push
- 1:01:04versus the pull. And in that segment, it's the
- 1:01:07end clients who are doing this and trying to usually push the
- 1:01:11advisor. To either accept it or help them
- 1:01:15custody it or manage it. It's not the advisor pushing
- 1:01:19them saying you should own a certain percentage.
- 1:01:21So that hasn't that hasn't flipped yet and maybe it will in
- 1:01:24the future. I could see that as a
- 1:01:26possibility. Of course, when they.
- 1:01:28When advisors all kind of get on board and get the message and
- 1:01:31become believers. But so far it's still the
- 1:01:33individual torchbearers who's who have their coins somewhere
- 1:01:37off of their advisors platform. They've done it on their own and
- 1:01:40that's why you have that big number that you just mentioned.
- 1:01:42And so you know that's one thing Fidelity's focused on with
- 1:01:46you've seen some news around our wealth Escape offering for
- 1:01:49example this is a a platform for RIA's and and similar broker
- 1:01:57dealers or. Or you know, family institutions
- 1:02:03allowing them to get exposure through this workflow in this
- 1:02:06platform that they already have, right.
- 1:02:08So that allows the the advisor to to handle it directly.
- 1:02:13And then of course the services are done on our end on the
- 1:02:15fidelity digital assets side of the actual execution and
- 1:02:18custoding of the of the assets. And then of course it's all
- 1:02:21built into the workflow with tax reporting and performance
- 1:02:24reporting and all that. So it's coming.
- 1:02:26It's very. You know this is very small at
- 1:02:28first, just just a few people and then we'll see where it goes
- 1:02:32from here. But I I think that's a big a, a
- 1:02:37big deal in terms of of normalizing it, right It's or
- 1:02:42maybe normalizing this is the right word but like building the
- 1:02:44the normal infrastructure around it like the infrastructure that
- 1:02:47people are already comfortable in the traditional finance world
- 1:02:50then it comes here rather than a client saying hey I've got.
- 1:02:55Bitcoin and cold storage. I have the private key.
- 1:02:57What should I do? Should I give my advisor one key
- 1:03:00of a multi cig or or you know that it gets a little.
- 1:03:03You can do that, of course, as you know, but it gets a little
- 1:03:06more complicated and beyond what a lot of people are comfortable
- 1:03:12with, especially advisors, if they're not trained or or well
- 1:03:15versed in the technical aspects of all of this, it can be really
- 1:03:18scary. So yeah, it's definitely coming,
- 1:03:21but it's still, it's still being pushed from the other end, not
- 1:03:24from the advisor end. But in the future, you know
- 1:03:27maybe if that becomes kind of the standard recommended, you
- 1:03:31know how advisors already kind of have these these broad
- 1:03:34guidelines that a lot of them agree on whether they come from
- 1:03:37their own companies or from CFA Institute or you know all these
- 1:03:40other kind of things. I could see that happening in
- 1:03:43the future for sure. Well and that's what it's like
- 1:03:46just one thing to on that grounding as you mentioned the
- 1:03:50gradual and suddenly and Jesse was referencing the human
- 1:03:53psychology and that is where I would double down on the gradual
- 1:03:57and suddenly on the advisor side when they start because we know
- 1:04:01this whole system is all about aligning incentives and I don't
- 1:04:04know the exact numbers but it's you know let's call it roughly
- 1:04:0650% of advisors are tied to percentage based fees to the a
- 1:04:10UM and what better asset to to juice AUM than Bitcoin once you
- 1:04:14catch it. And so now that you go in from,
- 1:04:16oh, I need to be, you know pull it's like pulling teeth to let
- 1:04:19my advisor hold this to like, Oh no, you should have a 2%
- 1:04:21allocation because I know this thing, what this thing actually
- 1:04:23does. And that's another gradual and
- 1:04:26suddenly of like one that flips because that's money directly in
- 1:04:29the pocketbook of the the advisor wealth manager RA firm.
- 1:04:33Yeah, and before we get too far ahead of ourselves here, because
- 1:04:36I agree with all this, these these switches are gonna go off.
- 1:04:39We're gonna have to gradually. Soon suddenly moment.
- 1:04:42But I think to have a sober conversation about the state of
- 1:04:46the literal onboarding, the on ramping infrastructure that
- 1:04:50exists today. We've seen that historically
- 1:04:52particularly during the peak of bull runs where many people are
- 1:04:57trying to get in the Bitcoin but the literal infrastructure that
- 1:05:00is getting people access to Bitcoin begins to break down.
- 1:05:02Coinbase most notably just breaks during during these bull
- 1:05:08markets when the prices. Is running.
- 1:05:10And Chris, you mentioned you guys have grown your team on the
- 1:05:13research side 4 fold over the last two years.
- 1:05:16But just looking at the landscape of literal onboarding
- 1:05:20infrastructure, whether it be custody, OTC desk, liquidity
- 1:05:24providers like, what is the state of that part of the
- 1:05:27industry and can it actually handle a massive inflow like the
- 1:05:31one that we're describing here? Yeah, I mean, I can't speak for
- 1:05:36the rest of the industry. I mean, I can say from what I
- 1:05:38see at Fidelity. Would certainly think so and
- 1:05:41hope so. And this is where, you know, the
- 1:05:43benefit of a fidelity comes into play.
- 1:05:45A lot of times we get asked, well, why should we go with
- 1:05:47fidelity? Or what's your competitive
- 1:05:49advantage when you're this firm that's over 75 years old and
- 1:05:54there's other crypto native firms who know the space inside
- 1:05:56and out because that's all they do.
- 1:05:58And there's some truth to that, of course.
- 1:06:00But the flip side is, yeah, we've been in the financial
- 1:06:04space for over 75 years. So we've got down pat things
- 1:06:07like risk onboarding. Operational controls site, we've
- 1:06:12got a whole cybersecurity team. So this is where the big parent
- 1:06:16Fidelity company can leverage a lot of the stuff that we've
- 1:06:20honed and perfected over the years and just apply it to the
- 1:06:23space. So some things are the same, you
- 1:06:25know bitcoins very different as an asset in many ways, but as a
- 1:06:29financial asset and something to custody and on board people,
- 1:06:32there's a lot of similarities. And so that's where things get
- 1:06:35leveraged across the entire organization.
- 1:06:38Yeah. And I'd go as far as to say as
- 1:06:39we'll we'll never really get that one down pat until we get
- 1:06:43we reach a stabilization just being you know building like
- 1:06:46infrastructure in the middle of these bull runs it's they're so
- 1:06:49reflexive that I remember like on the hardware device
- 1:06:52manufacturer is one example. They just like run out right
- 1:06:55because the the capacity and we talked about like Coinbase being
- 1:06:57able to support on the onboarding you know managing
- 1:07:00consultations setups like there's just all it's it's a lot
- 1:07:04because you basically it's just so reflexive that you then you
- 1:07:07expand and then it contracts. So I think we're we're probably
- 1:07:10a cycle or two and you know some kind of volatility being muted
- 1:07:14where you can have a better baseline or model for the growth
- 1:07:18trajectory. But yes, I think just to your
- 1:07:21direct question, Mark, I think we particularly end up in this
- 1:07:24push pool for the next like decade as an adoption.
- 1:07:29And I I think that continues until we've.
- 1:07:33You know, I think this is an S curve and and it continues until
- 1:07:36we've gotten to the the middle of the bell curve which would be
- 1:07:39the mid inflection point there in the middle of the S curve,
- 1:07:43which is to say it's on the way there, it's gradually, but it's
- 1:07:48exponentially. So you know, rather than
- 1:07:49gradually, then suddenly or gradually overall, as as Lauren
- 1:07:54last week sort of advocated, I think it's gradually but in
- 1:07:58exponentially, you know, in an exponential fashion.
- 1:08:01So. And and I think that the way
- 1:08:04that this manifests is, you know, I've I've used the analogy
- 1:08:07before of like Bitcoin, the infrastructure for the Bitcoin
- 1:08:10network grows the way that a tree grows where you know in the
- 1:08:17summertime when things are good in the bull markets it, you know
- 1:08:23the the tree ring expands and then in the bear market it, it
- 1:08:27hardens, right. You go through that hardening
- 1:08:29process and. And on to the next cycle, but
- 1:08:32through that that cyclical process of expansion and then
- 1:08:39hardening and expansion again it's not a smooth process, but
- 1:08:44it's it's an incremental layered process of of becoming a more
- 1:08:50robust infrastructure and the network can on board an
- 1:08:54increasing amount of capital and people because of the
- 1:08:58investments that happen. During the bear markets, frankly
- 1:09:01the hardening that happens then in order to support the
- 1:09:06expansion cycle that's coming in the next bull market and it's to
- 1:09:11get meta like I don't think it. Needs to get meta, yeah, so
- 1:09:16maybe we both get meta. It's like it's not really
- 1:09:18anything unique. We're just seeing those
- 1:09:19accelerated, right. You think Bitcoin is just a
- 1:09:21micro calls and we talk about the asset being the Canary in
- 1:09:25the coal mine with global markets and with Lakota get
- 1:09:27sucked. It's the first thing down.
- 1:09:29We we chatted last week, you know the railroads fiber
- 1:09:33probably like Internet server infrastructure like you just
- 1:09:36always over expand but it's just over a longer period.
- 1:09:39So you don't feel it And then you kind of build in that
- 1:09:41contraction when it's quieter and you have all this like
- 1:09:43oversupply over capital in the space and then you come back and
- 1:09:46it's ready for that next wave when it's prepared.
- 1:09:48So I feel like what we're talking about here, we're just
- 1:09:50seeing it in like real time because of the value and the
- 1:09:53prices like tracking it and all the things and the people going
- 1:09:55to 0 or happening faster. But it's probably the same we've
- 1:09:59seen over the past hundreds of years.
- 1:10:00Yeah, and I was gonna say it sort of works on a fractal.
- 1:10:04Like you see it not only with the industry, with the
- 1:10:07onboarding infrastructure. We see it at the protocol level
- 1:10:09too, like when the price runs, everybody wants Bitcoin, you
- 1:10:12have fees go up. It gets.
- 1:10:15You have to wait longer and longer for your transaction to
- 1:10:17get confirmed at the protocol level.
- 1:10:20We hit that limit and people say this doesn't work and that
- 1:10:23provides a data point like, all right, here's where the outer
- 1:10:26edges of the network are and here's what we need to fix on.
- 1:10:29That's why we get things like Segwitch nor Taproot lightning
- 1:10:33fediments like there's just. It's like bitcoins as living
- 1:10:36Organism in these adoption waves, it gets pushed to its
- 1:10:39limits. We figure out where the limits
- 1:10:41are at the protocol level and the layers above.
- 1:10:43And we're like, all right, here's where we hit the limits
- 1:10:45this time around. Let's make sure that we can go
- 1:10:47beyond those limits during the next cycle.
- 1:10:50And then you see that happening in parallel with the industry
- 1:10:52too, with the businesses that are servicing the new Bitcoin
- 1:10:56users. Yeah, this is a really great
- 1:10:58topic to discuss because I think it helps in a in a way provide
- 1:11:03you talked about the layer between 0 and 26,000.
- 1:11:06But we're actually discussing real time like for individuals
- 1:11:09looking at this well why is there that volatility and we're
- 1:11:12describing real time in the the one of the other analogies
- 1:11:14that's used in the industry is like gold monetizing.
- 1:11:17We're watching it from somebody picking up that as a like rock
- 1:11:20and dust it off and shave it and keep pull it out of the earth
- 1:11:22and put it in a coinage and stamping it and turning it into
- 1:11:25something that's used for for food or whatever it is needed.
- 1:11:29We're just seeing that play out in real time and we're somewhere
- 1:11:31in in on that curve of it being something somebody's pulling out
- 1:11:35of the earth and then it being used as a unit of account to buy
- 1:11:39a building or whatever that might be.
- 1:11:41And so that period in between is very volatile and we just happen
- 1:11:45to be watching it. Yeah, and on the research side,
- 1:11:48we actually have mapped that out before, and other people have
- 1:11:52done this too, and I'm usually not a fan of Mapping different.
- 1:11:56Time frames, axes over each other, but just as I think a
- 1:12:01illustrative example is, you can look at when we went off the
- 1:12:04gold standard and then it was legal once again for people to
- 1:12:07invest in gold. Gold had to go through its own
- 1:12:10monetization phase, right? And people had to recognize what
- 1:12:14it was, that it was an investable asset class.
- 1:12:16Now, it wasn't just fixed at $32 or $34 an ounce.
- 1:12:21It went through this massive boom up to 800, which in
- 1:12:24percentage terms was was crazy. It had a big crash down once
- 1:12:27again and now you know it's kind of going through another big,
- 1:12:31big adoption phase. So that's one proxy we've looked
- 1:12:35at. We had someone on our, not on
- 1:12:38our research team, but within Fidelity digital assets, he had
- 1:12:42a lot of experience in the commodity markets when they kind
- 1:12:44of became an investable asset class.
- 1:12:46And so there's a piece out on our website of.
- 1:12:49How that went through the financialization and the
- 1:12:51productization of people being able to invest in commodities as
- 1:12:55an investable asset class. And we we've seen the same thing
- 1:12:57with Bitcoin. There's similar markers there
- 1:12:59too. Michael, one thing you said
- 1:13:02earlier reminded me, you said how railroads or fiber optic
- 1:13:06went through these big booms and over expansions.
- 1:13:08And I don't know if any of you have read that Perez book, The
- 1:13:12Economist, Carlotta. I think it's her first name,
- 1:13:16Financial capital. And technological booms and
- 1:13:20financial capital or something like that, if I'm getting that
- 1:13:22right, do you guys know which one I'm talking about?
- 1:13:24I haven't read it, but I'm familiar with it, yes.
- 1:13:26Yeah, she has a few, right. There's another one that's like
- 1:13:29like the innovation cycles. That's I think was before it.
- 1:13:33Yeah, so she wrote this many years ago and a lot of people in
- 1:13:37the space have picked it up and and that's how I heard about it,
- 1:13:41saying, look, this is kind of like what's happening with
- 1:13:43Bitcoin, where she. Takes really broad stretches of
- 1:13:45history like the the railroad boom or microprocessors or
- 1:13:50something like that. And she shows through her
- 1:13:52academic it's an academic book that financial capital and
- 1:13:56technological capital have to go together and they they feed off
- 1:14:00of each other. At least this is what I've
- 1:14:02gained from the book. The whole our whole research
- 1:14:04team read it together and and discussed it was a lot of fun to
- 1:14:07see the similarities. But her her point was.
- 1:14:10There's definite phases of speculative financial boom where
- 1:14:14everyone piles in and and the finance side gets ahead of
- 1:14:17everything. But then that's what also funds
- 1:14:20a lot of the stuff for the real tech or the real productivity
- 1:14:25enhancing stuff like railroads or microprocessors.
- 1:14:27And so you need both of these things to feed off of each
- 1:14:31other, but they kind of move in different phases.
- 1:14:34And so we also tried to match where we might be in the current
- 1:14:37cycle and we. It's easy to say like, oh, we
- 1:14:39already had the big frenzy, the boom, like the ICO boom.
- 1:14:42Oh, and then the the recent boom to 69 and and I.
- 1:14:44My point, but from the book was these things are so large that
- 1:14:49they permeate almost everything in society.
- 1:14:51Like if you think of how railroads drop the price of so
- 1:14:53many goods, or how microprocessors affected
- 1:14:56everything to me if I read the book and I try to match it up to
- 1:15:00our current cycle. We're not anywhere near there
- 1:15:03yet because Bitcoin and digital assets have not permeated all
- 1:15:06other industries. They have not shaped and changed
- 1:15:09all other industries in in the whole capital production cycle
- 1:15:13yet. And so it's an interesting read.
- 1:15:15She's actually been on Twitter saying don't apply my book to
- 1:15:18Bitcoin, which I think is funny, but.
- 1:15:21We did amazing. So it's such a good point.
- 1:15:25Yeah, it's such a good point. I think it's also where this
- 1:15:28like pod comes in. It's because there's a lot of,
- 1:15:31you know, value and and I don't know if money to be made, but I
- 1:15:35guess money to be made if you're if you're right about some of
- 1:15:38the stuff and there's a lot of money that will be lost.
- 1:15:41And then I think, you know when you reference some of these
- 1:15:44technological cycles, you know somebody has to go through the
- 1:15:46door and you know that's their their capital that went out.
- 1:15:50I think it just doesn't We talk about being a microcosm, being
- 1:15:54faster. There's just a lot more money to
- 1:15:55be lost faster in this environment because it's
- 1:15:59basically you're spinning up units that are tied potentially
- 1:16:04to money and people are putting their money or investing.
- 1:16:06And so I think basically saying like there's there's a lot of
- 1:16:12information out there and finding the right anchor points
- 1:16:15to get through the fundamentals is paramount more than anything
- 1:16:19I could probably imagine because it's just so easy to put the
- 1:16:23dollars to waste in something like this.
- 1:16:26And we've seen this in the past 15 years versus kind of
- 1:16:29something that's hard infrastructure.
- 1:16:30There's still scammers out there and there's still noise.
- 1:16:33But I feel like this is the tightest version of that.
- 1:16:37These are basically taking your dollars for something that can
- 1:16:39basically go to zero and is a click of a button away.
- 1:16:46So there's no, there's no question.
- 1:16:47There is more of just like it was, it was dancing around the
- 1:16:50topic. It was just like do your
- 1:16:52diligence and do your research when you know if you're coming
- 1:16:54into space and looking at like what could be the next big boom
- 1:16:56or how can you, you know, create value.
- 1:16:58It's that it's a little bit different in that way that
- 1:17:01there's not a lot of opportunity, there's not a lot
- 1:17:04of cost, fixed cost to creating a cryptocurrency.
- 1:17:07And so it's really important to understand the under underline
- 1:17:10and why there's value around Bitcoin.
- 1:17:13Yeah, it comes back to that like for these previous.
- 1:17:19Technology waves, the railroads or or maybe it's
- 1:17:22microprocessors. There's hard assets there.
- 1:17:25There's tangible assets that you're investing in.
- 1:17:28When you're when you're providing capital for something
- 1:17:31like that, you're investing in a railroad and there's proof of
- 1:17:34work because there's either a railroad built or not.
- 1:17:38Same for like a a chip manufacturing plant.
- 1:17:42You you know what? You're what you're getting.
- 1:17:45But when it comes to money, there's this.
- 1:17:50It's ephemeral. It's it's an idea.
- 1:17:53Ultimately, it is. It is what everybody structures
- 1:17:59their decides to structure their finances around.
- 1:18:03And that is a shifting target. It's it's an intangible target.
- 1:18:08And so it's easy to be misled. And it's easy to to fall into
- 1:18:12the traps. There's always been snake oil
- 1:18:14you know in in like the American West is a great example of like
- 1:18:18that's where the term comes from because snake oil would pop up
- 1:18:21as the the hot new product that you had to invest in and you
- 1:18:24don't want to miss out on the next Cocacola or whatever.
- 1:18:29And next thing you know you've purchased a stake in a in a
- 1:18:34business that is hot air and. That's even more possible with
- 1:18:40Crypto because these things, you know, because there's no
- 1:18:46manufacturing plant to to point at or any specific sales to, to
- 1:18:53show as proof of of adoption or attraction for a product.
- 1:18:57And so people will make big mistakes in terms of how they.
- 1:19:04They engage with what is you know we are speed running the
- 1:19:11monetization that bootstrapping of gold which was a 6000 year
- 1:19:15process and we are doing it in the space of a generation in our
- 1:19:21lifetimes at least and that is unprecedented and and it's it's
- 1:19:27only possible because technology moves so much faster you know we
- 1:19:32every. Every generation really
- 1:19:37technology has. Over the last 200 years,
- 1:19:40technology has seen a market uptick in speed of adoption.
- 1:19:46You know, whether that's going from radio, how, how long it
- 1:19:48took radio to go through the S curve of adoption, how how long
- 1:19:52it took to get into half of the homes in the US took took quite
- 1:19:59a bit of time. It took decades.
- 1:20:01How long did it take smartphones to get into the pockets of half
- 1:20:05the population? Not very long.
- 1:20:08And Bitcoin is a little bit different because it is such a
- 1:20:12base layer of civilization. And you know this is it's harder
- 1:20:18to adopt than buying the latest tech gadget because it it
- 1:20:23requires a great deal of conviction or or a burning
- 1:20:26platform to to to effect change in in your portfolio.
- 1:20:32But it is happening much, much, much faster than the 6000 year
- 1:20:35process of gold monetizing. And what's tricky about that is
- 1:20:41that, you know, if this is a process that has only just
- 1:20:44begun, and I think, I think Chris is right here, that we
- 1:20:50are, we are not yet in the era of Bitcoin permeating
- 1:20:54everything. So for, for that matter, like as
- 1:20:57annoying as it was in 2021 when it felt like Bitcoin and crypto
- 1:21:01was being talked about everywhere, that's only going to
- 1:21:04get worse every bull market. I think, you know we're going to
- 1:21:07go from Katy Perry throwing off crypto logos on her nails to it
- 1:21:12being in absolutely every business that you walk into.
- 1:21:17There's going to be we accept Bitcoin or you know, set up your
- 1:21:21crypto savings account with us, etcetera.
- 1:21:26And you know, because of that, because of how fast this trend
- 1:21:30is playing out, how early it is in it, the fact that we're going
- 1:21:34to speed run the monetization of gold in the span of a lifetime,
- 1:21:41People need to be very careful that they're not making the
- 1:21:44mistake of their lifetimes by buying in on snake oil, on
- 1:21:50crypto snake oil of whatever form, and instead taking care to
- 1:21:57understand and have conviction around what is lasting here and
- 1:22:04placing their portfolio accordingly when they have the
- 1:22:08sufficient understanding to be able to withstand the volatility
- 1:22:12along the way. I think this gets.
- 1:22:17Into an interesting topic we could cover and bringing it back
- 1:22:20to Fidelity. Been around for 75 plus years
- 1:22:24and in arguably the 1st 32 years of my life.
- 1:22:27Like I remember when we got caller ID then we got a OL and
- 1:22:31then fast where we had high speed Internet at smartphone
- 1:22:34we've got Bitcoin like that was a massive step function
- 1:22:38improvement in the technology that we leverage as humans like
- 1:22:42literally the the pace of change is.
- 1:22:45People would argue so fast that it's really hard at a chemical
- 1:22:48level for us to even process it. And so Fidelity weathered that
- 1:22:52storm and provided their clients extreme value throughout all
- 1:22:57that. And so like moving from the
- 1:22:59analog world of the industrial revolution now into the the the
- 1:23:04hyper automated world of the digital revolution that we're
- 1:23:08living through right now and arguably bitcoins sort of the
- 1:23:10last piece of that revolution, you get digital money.
- 1:23:13After the Internet and all these consumer applications and it's
- 1:23:16really the charity on top that that brings everything together
- 1:23:19like navigating those hyper volatile transitions.
- 1:23:25How humans actually leverage tools and the types of tools
- 1:23:27that they're they're leveraging. Like, how have you guys
- 1:23:31weathered that storm and moving forward things get more crazy,
- 1:23:36which I think they will, particularly with Bitcoin and
- 1:23:38things like AI. Like it's it's only going to get
- 1:23:40weirder from here. Yeah, definitely.
- 1:23:44On the acceleration .1 of the things I like to reference in
- 1:23:48talks that I do or when, you know, especially if it's to a
- 1:23:51big group or on stage, but also with clients too, it kind of can
- 1:23:54resonate with them is everything you're talking about here.
- 1:23:57And Jesse was talking about the acceleration of of all of this.
- 1:24:01Jeff Booth talks about this a lot.
- 1:24:02We we we as humans are terrible extrapolating things.
- 1:24:05Exponentially in our minds, right.
- 1:24:07We're linear thinkers. And he always uses the example.
- 1:24:10If you fold the paper 4045 times, you know, provided you
- 1:24:14could do it on an atomic level or you have the strength to how
- 1:24:17high would it be. Most people guess oh a few
- 1:24:20stories maybe as tall as the Empire State Building if they're
- 1:24:23really aggressive. And the correct answer is from
- 1:24:26here to the moon 250,000 miles, right.
- 1:24:29And. The other illustration I like to
- 1:24:31give is one I've seen before, where I'll put up two pictures.
- 1:24:34I'll show one picture first, which is the Wright brothers in
- 1:24:38Kitty Hawk, NC, showing the first demonstrated flight right
- 1:24:441903. They flew their plane a few 100
- 1:24:46yards or something like that. The second picture is Neil
- 1:24:49Armstrong on the moon. And guess how many years those
- 1:24:53two pictures are apart? They're only 6566 years apart.
- 1:24:58And so I say, if you were a young person on that December
- 1:25:01day in Kitty Hawk, NC, and you just witnessed this first flight
- 1:25:06ever, they proved that it could be done and they said, okay, you
- 1:25:09now know it can be done. Where do you think this goes?
- 1:25:12In 65 years? Not a single person on that
- 1:25:15field would guess we'll have someone on the moon, let alone
- 1:25:19we'll have Boeing 740 Sevens shuttling millions of people
- 1:25:22around the world every day like it's nothing, right?
- 1:25:25We're just so bad at predicting technological change like that
- 1:25:28at that exponential rate. And so I mean that's our job at
- 1:25:33Fidelity to to try to navigate this.
- 1:25:35It's it's why Fidelity built Fidelity Center for Applied
- 1:25:38Technology, which I talked about earlier.
- 1:25:40It's why they continue to experiment with things like a I
- 1:25:44and quantum computing and all this stuff to see how it could
- 1:25:47fit into our financial world. You know you're talking about
- 1:25:52the. The first caller ID and someone
- 1:25:55else said, yeah, Fidelity's history, how did they navigate
- 1:25:57it before 1 Funny thing in their history that I remember seeing
- 1:26:01when I first started was they were I think the first to
- 1:26:06implement being able to buy mutual funds over the phone.
- 1:26:11Like either first with a person and then actually like a touch
- 1:26:13tone phone. Like one of those automated
- 1:26:15things which just seems so funny and archaic now, but of course
- 1:26:18was revolutionary at the time. So it's those kinds of things
- 1:26:21where you know you just have to keep, keep innovating, keep
- 1:26:23taking advantage of what's coming out there to serve your
- 1:26:27clients. Yeah, that's like going back to
- 1:26:31the the Jeff Booth line. We're very linear thinkers.
- 1:26:35We can't think exponentially, but human history has showed
- 1:26:38that we've had these exponential step.
- 1:26:41Function improvement. So when it comes to Bitcoin,
- 1:26:43like that's the one thing I personally try to get through to
- 1:26:47people is like, hey, yeah, looks stupid.
- 1:26:49It's slow, it's really far, and there's a bunch of crazy people
- 1:26:53that are into it. But if you really dig into it
- 1:26:55and look at the fundamentals and how everything works, like
- 1:26:58there's something there. And it is undeniable that it
- 1:27:01provides utility that has never existed before.
- 1:27:04And if you can grok that, you may not be able to fathom the.
- 1:27:08The changes that will bring to the world at this current
- 1:27:12moment, but you have to at least accept that human history have
- 1:27:15shown like when something like this is dropped on humans, we we
- 1:27:18take it and run to the highest extent that we can take it.
- 1:27:24The other thing that works on institutions is drop a Charlie
- 1:27:27Munger or Warren Buffett ID on them they'll they'll usually
- 1:27:30registrate, which is invert, always invert.
- 1:27:33So to invert this is to say. Do you think that in in the, I
- 1:27:39don't know how many years it'll take, but in the future it will
- 1:27:43be normal to think that we couldn't send money to whoever
- 1:27:47we wanted with a click of the button, Like we do an e-mail
- 1:27:50that it took three to five business banking days or that
- 1:27:54international wires got stuck. Like that's just going to seem
- 1:27:57so silly that anyone ever put up with that and that we had that
- 1:28:00right. So if you flip it around and
- 1:28:01invert it, you think, Oh yeah, we are living in this kind of
- 1:28:04weird. Era that we just take all these
- 1:28:07things as normal, but we've been like fish in the water where,
- 1:28:10well, that's just how it is, right?
- 1:28:12Email's such a good parallel like e-mail when you reference
- 1:28:15public and private key cryptography and you have a
- 1:28:17public address that anybody can send.
- 1:28:18Or David Marcus yesterday I think was referring to I never
- 1:28:22heard it in that form and it's probably it's pretty simple.
- 1:28:24It's just like if I go outside. I think the studio he was
- 1:28:26recording, Squawk Box in front of New York, was like, if I went
- 1:28:28out there I could send an e-mail to anybody, but if they asked
- 1:28:31for like, money. I know I'm trying to figure out
- 1:28:33what app and if they're in a different country now I've got
- 1:28:35like intermediary banks and I've got to send a wire like just
- 1:28:38that inversion of like, should it be this hard?
- 1:28:41Can we imagine it's gonna be that hard in 10 years Is a nice
- 1:28:44framing. I think we're all coalescing
- 1:28:47around this. It's all about framing and
- 1:28:48positioning and meeting people where they're at, because
- 1:28:51ultimately everybody's coming at this from a different
- 1:28:53perspective. Yeah.
- 1:28:56And on that note, I know I think we only have 10 minutes left,
- 1:29:00but I think. Another big underlying theme
- 1:29:04with Bitcoin, it's adoption. And where it is now,
- 1:29:07particularly at the institutional level, is the the
- 1:29:10generational aspect of it. Like the the people in control
- 1:29:14of large swaths of money at the institutional level are a bit
- 1:29:17older. You have your crusty CIO who
- 1:29:20really doesn't want to make too many.
- 1:29:24Not. Crusty out there, Mr. CIO.
- 1:29:26You. You.
- 1:29:27No, but there is this generational aspect where you
- 1:29:30have. Somewhat of I don't want to call
- 1:29:33them Luddites, but there's this barrier, this mental barrier
- 1:29:36that exists at the institutional level, where there's plenty of
- 1:29:39people our age in these institutions that get it and
- 1:29:43grok it and have a lot of trouble trying to get it past
- 1:29:47the the investment committee. Because it's just something they
- 1:29:50can't rock from a generational perspective for some reason.
- 1:29:55And just insert one additional cuz I know with limited time is
- 1:29:58where that Black Rock, B&Y melon and let's call it Franklin
- 1:30:03Temple. And there there's been a few in
- 1:30:04the past 12 months. How that can potentially help or
- 1:30:06how you're thinking about it from your side like in that
- 1:30:10supporting that case for the CIO that would have naturally been a
- 1:30:15little bit less or apprehensive to this whole ecosystem and how
- 1:30:19you see that helping in their journey.
- 1:30:24Yeah, I mean, I think that gets back to the point of career
- 1:30:26risk, right? If you're the only one doing it,
- 1:30:28that's really risky for your career, especially if you're
- 1:30:31someone who's a high level see something, you know who's who's
- 1:30:35towards the end of their career. You don't really want to rock
- 1:30:37the boat at the end, right? You want to coast?
- 1:30:40Coast out maybe, but. This is something we've seen in
- 1:30:44our survey data as well, not not necessarily the age thing
- 1:30:47because we don't, we don't measure that, but more the
- 1:30:50structure, right? So the highest adopters, seventy
- 1:30:548085% or more are high net worth individuals and family offices
- 1:31:02and some RIA firms, right? And that makes sense because
- 1:31:05those are individuals driving the decision, so they get bitten
- 1:31:07by the Bitcoin bug or whatever it is.
- 1:31:09And they're the ones that carry the torch in their small family
- 1:31:12office. There tends to be less red tape,
- 1:31:14less bureaucracy, so they can pull people along or it's just
- 1:31:17their own individual decision. They have sole discretion,
- 1:31:20right. So that brings true.
- 1:31:22Whereas it's really this, this absolutely, extremely see family
- 1:31:26offices are kind of in the middle.
- 1:31:28I think there were 37% last year saying that they already invest
- 1:31:31in digital assets. And then on the other end of the
- 1:31:34extreme is pensions, endowments, foundations, exactly who you
- 1:31:38would think where they have large investment committee
- 1:31:41boards and a lot of bureaucracy and red tape, and for good
- 1:31:44reason. Obviously they're they're trying
- 1:31:46to preserve wealth for in perpetuity, for generations and
- 1:31:50generations. And so they have these things
- 1:31:53for a reason. But that means that it's a long,
- 1:31:56long process for them and if even if there's one person
- 1:31:59there, they have to try to get everyone else.
- 1:32:02Involved and and convinced of it.
- 1:32:04So that's why we see that change in our our results.
- 1:32:08And if if I can take this a little bit in a different
- 1:32:11direction again with the, the last podcast you had, you talked
- 1:32:15about the institutions that they're coming and maybe they're
- 1:32:17already here. Our last survey, our numbers
- 1:32:20went up again where 6 out of 10 of our institutional survey
- 1:32:24participants said they already invested in digital assets and
- 1:32:28and we said wow, that went up again, That's great, but. 6 out
- 1:32:31of 10, that's that's a pretty big chunk.
- 1:32:33Why is this still such a small asset class.
- 1:32:36So we went back to our data set and Matt on our team, Matt
- 1:32:40Hogan, he worked with our our data provider and our survey
- 1:32:44provider with this, the people who are doing it and really dug
- 1:32:47deep into the data and we had some theories and then the data
- 1:32:50confirmed it that the reason we have such high participation yet
- 1:32:55it's which says the investors are here, the institutional
- 1:32:58investors are here, but. The asset class market cap does
- 1:33:03not reflect that is because the people who are here are the ones
- 1:33:06with the relatively smaller a UM, right.
- 1:33:09So the individual investors, the family office, the high net
- 1:33:12worth and the big gorilla pools of capital, the pensions, the
- 1:33:15endowments, they're at like mid single digit adoption, right.
- 1:33:20And so it depends on who you say institutional investors are
- 1:33:23here, who you're talking about, right.
- 1:33:26And the other thing is that the people who are invested.
- 1:33:30They're almost all invested at very small amounts, which isn't
- 1:33:33a criticism. I mean Bitcoin digital assets
- 1:33:36are a small asset class. So you know, I question your
- 1:33:38risk strategy if you were 100%. But again, you have a smaller
- 1:33:43pool of capital, there may be 1 or 2% allocations.
- 1:33:47And so that's really what's driving kind of this head
- 1:33:50scratch at first, where on one hand you hear the institutions
- 1:33:53are here. On the other hand, you look at
- 1:33:55the, the price charts and it's like there's no way that's just
- 1:33:57the math doesn't check out. Yeah.
- 1:34:00And. And and that brings it back to
- 1:34:02the point you were making earlier about like when Bitcoin
- 1:34:05is 1% of the global asset landscape, then those big
- 1:34:10players need to step up to a 1% allocation in order to preserve
- 1:34:15capital. Like in order to preserve
- 1:34:17wealth, which is kind of their mandate, they have to have that
- 1:34:21slice. So then you have this reflexive
- 1:34:25structural bid for Bitcoin. And at the same time Bitcoin
- 1:34:31issuance becomes increasingly scarce, as we know every four
- 1:34:34years and and those two factors combined to create like this,
- 1:34:38this lift as institutional as Bitcoin grows that it's a
- 1:34:44positive flywheel. As Bitcoin grows in value, more
- 1:34:47institutional allocators need to bid for Bitcoin in order to have
- 1:34:53a representative slice of it in their portfolio in order to
- 1:34:57preserve wealth through time and not miss out.
- 1:35:00And and the cycle continues. You know, given that there's
- 1:35:06less and less Bitcoin being created and it all just sets up
- 1:35:10for, you know, it's it's a it's a scenario that the gold can
- 1:35:15only dream of really, because it's gold with a finite cap on
- 1:35:19on how much gold there is. Yeah, and when you put it like
- 1:35:24that, Jesse, it just made me think of.
- 1:35:27Once that becomes ingrained and really internalized at the
- 1:35:32institutional level, like the the amount of thinking that's
- 1:35:36going to go into like actually getting exposure and not moving
- 1:35:39the price too far too much higher than it is when they want
- 1:35:44to get in. And because that that creates
- 1:35:45the feedback loop too. It's like I need to get 1%
- 1:35:48allocation, which means I need this much Bitcoin.
- 1:35:50I can't signal to my competitors and I'm doing this right now
- 1:35:52because they'll be like. That whole psychological battle
- 1:35:56that that awaits us in the future is going to be
- 1:35:58fascinating to play out because once that happens and they're
- 1:36:03fighting for the 1% exposure and they find out like what they
- 1:36:05thought was 1%, it's only half a percent now.
- 1:36:07They got to get more. It's it's an interesting
- 1:36:11debacle, but. Chris, is there, is there
- 1:36:15anything that excites you? I know between half of Fidelity
- 1:36:19yourself, like Fidelity being around and looking at this.
- 1:36:22Ecosystem you, you touched on all the things that most
- 1:36:24institutions haven't even like thought of yet, let alone have
- 1:36:27tried. So you're already ahead of the
- 1:36:29curve. Is there anything that you guys
- 1:36:31are looking at that you can share that is kind of like just
- 1:36:34interesting you're exploring and even if it's not from UNBAF,
- 1:36:37fidelity digital assets on yourself, yourself being a, you
- 1:36:39know, a Bitcoin advocate and looking at this space that
- 1:36:43you're excited to see over the course of the next couple years
- 1:36:45or for this cycle? Yeah, so I'll mention one.
- 1:36:50Data point that I find interesting as a follow up to
- 1:36:53what Marty just said at the reflexivity, we keep watching
- 1:36:57the exchange balances go down in in the data and I think this is
- 1:37:03the first time we've ever had a declining exchange balance
- 1:37:07potentially going into the next cycle.
- 1:37:10If we do, obviously this is speculation, but if that were to
- 1:37:13happen, it's going to be really interesting to see how that
- 1:37:16plays out. You know, is that going to be?
- 1:37:19Kind of this this musical chairs that people realize there aren't
- 1:37:21as many coins at the ready to absorb extra demand this time
- 1:37:26around versus the other cycle. So that's one thing we're
- 1:37:28watching on the the investment team, The other data point and
- 1:37:32and we briefly mentioned this and another part of the
- 1:37:34conversation was I put together two data sets of showing M2
- 1:37:38money supply going back to the the late 1800s and this is the
- 1:37:41first time we have a contracting M2 money supply since the Great
- 1:37:45Depression and. We talked about this in our
- 1:37:48latest video we did. And I said it's not surprising
- 1:37:52because since the Great Depression, all these central
- 1:37:55bankers said we will never forget the lessons of the Great
- 1:37:59Depression. And to them the lessons were
- 1:38:00don't ever let the money supply contract, right.
- 1:38:03And that's what they did it. They'd never let it contract
- 1:38:06until today. And so it's not surprising that
- 1:38:10we've got headwinds because we've found in our research that
- 1:38:13Bitcoin is highly, highly correlated or.
- 1:38:17Reactive to changes in the money supply, not necessarily changes
- 1:38:20in inflation, but the money supply first and foremost.
- 1:38:23And so it'll be interesting to see once once that, excuse me,
- 1:38:29once that changes or or if or when that changes in the money
- 1:38:32supply goes back up again. Might not be immediate, but
- 1:38:36that's one of the things we're looking at too.
- 1:38:37On the research side, yeah, it sure seems like there might be a
- 1:38:42convergence of timelines here of the halving is coming in seven
- 1:38:48months and we'll see when you know because of the the nature
- 1:38:55of the financial system they they have to expand the money
- 1:38:58supply and that could begin mid next year.
- 1:39:04Again that that's sort of my rough estimation of of timing
- 1:39:08and and I could very easily be be wrong there.
- 1:39:14But if those two forces were to converge it it it creates the
- 1:39:19sort of the opposite dynamic of what happened in the tail end of
- 1:39:23the of the 2021 bull market where the bull market forces
- 1:39:27were playing out. But we switched from a QE
- 1:39:31quantitative easing position to quantitative tightening right at
- 1:39:34the, you know, Q4 and 2021. And that just just blue cold air
- 1:39:40on on the party that was happening and snuffed it out
- 1:39:45entirely. And we could have the opposite
- 1:39:47effect of switching from that regime of quantitative
- 1:39:51tightening which we've had since Q 4/20/21 back to QE at the same
- 1:39:57time that Bitcoin becomes twice as scarce in terms of new
- 1:40:01issuance. Don't bet on it.
- 1:40:05Nothing's a sure thing, but this has been a fascinating
- 1:40:09discussion. Chris, I wanna thank you for
- 1:40:12taking time to do this. We were very excited for this
- 1:40:15conversation. Again, the work that Fidelity
- 1:40:17has done and that your research team has done over the years has
- 1:40:21been extremely valuable for the Bitcoin space at large.
- 1:40:24I think the annual report, like you said, is something that
- 1:40:27everybody in the industry looks out for and looks forward to
- 1:40:31because you guys are out there on the front lines interfacing
- 1:40:35with large pools of capital that are trying to understand this
- 1:40:38and you guys are actually providing them good genuine data
- 1:40:42that that is needed. You're not you're you're not
- 1:40:44selling them the snake oil you're you're explaining to them
- 1:40:47exactly what's going on here. So just want to commend you,
- 1:40:51your team in Fidelity, Abby, Shout out to Abby for really
- 1:40:56being the tip of the spear on the institutional side of things
- 1:40:59on for Bitcoin over the last decade.
- 1:41:03Yeah, absolutely. This has been my pleasure.
- 1:41:06And you can go find all of our research at
- 1:41:08fidelitydigitalassets.com. We'll have that survey coming
- 1:41:12out hopefully this year yet. And then we also have a piece
- 1:41:15coming out on understanding proof of work.
- 1:41:18So this is a piece that I think is sorely needed in the space to
- 1:41:23help investors understand why we have proof of work and.
- 1:41:28What it actually does and the implications for Bitcoin as an
- 1:41:32investment. So it it pushes aside all the
- 1:41:34environmental stuff and it just says, let's understand what this
- 1:41:37actually does, why it's a very big deal and what it actually
- 1:41:41means for your investment, yeah. That's awesome.
- 1:41:45Yeah. Just want to commend Chris again
- 1:41:47for doing this well while having a brief call.
- 1:41:52It's been great. Michael, Jesse, anything to add
- 1:41:55here? Just thanks for for coming on.
- 1:41:57We're excited to have this and it showed up.
- 1:42:01So we're looking forward to that and the research piece and then
- 1:42:05also we we guys know that you're working on a lot of stuff.
- 1:42:08So excited to see you continue to pave the way.
- 1:42:12Yeah, fully agree. All right.
- 1:42:16That's all we got today. We'll see you guys next week.