Latest / Office Hours with Fexingo: Daily Career Q&A, Workplace Questions, and Professional Advice / How to Ask for a Raise When Your Company Is Hiring
Transcript
- Lucas: So you open the company Slack, and there it is — three new job postings in your department alone. Sales is hiring, engineering is hiring, and your own team just got approval for a second manager. But your last raise was two years ago, and it was three percent. That's the setup for today's question. Luna: That's such a specific frustration. It feels like the company has money for everyone but you. Lucas: Exactly. And if today's episode helps you think through that conversation, that's great. If it does, the way we keep this show ad-free is listener support — you can buy me a coffee at buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. It's a small way to keep these career conversations going. Luna: Yeah, every bit helps. So Lucas, what's the smart way to approach a raise when your company is clearly in hiring mode? Lucas: First, understand the psychology. When a company is hiring, managers are often more focused on filling seats than on adjusting existing salaries. There's a budget for new heads, but pay bumps for current staff come from a different line item. That's why you can't just assume the hiring momentum will carry your raise through. Luna: So it's not automatic. But doesn't the hiring spree give you some leverage? Lucas: It can, but you have to use it carefully. The key is to frame your request around market data and internal equity, not around 'you're spending money on new people, so why not me?' That comes off as whiny. Instead, you want to say, 'Given that we're hiring for roles at this level, I want to make sure my compensation reflects the market rate for my position.' Luna: That makes sense. But what if your manager says, 'We don't have budget for raises right now, we're investing in growth'? Lucas: That's a common pushback. And the way to counter it is with data. Look at the salary bands for your role — if your company posts them internally, great. If not, use sites like Glassdoor or Levels dot fyi to get a range. Also, calculate the cost of replacing you. Recruiting fees, training time, lost productivity — that can easily be fifty to one hundred percent of your annual salary. Bringing that number to the table shows you understand the business case. Luna: So you're saying, show them it's cheaper to give you a raise than to hire your replacement. Lucas: Right. And that's especially powerful when they're already hiring for similar roles. If they're posting your job at a higher salary than you're making, that's your opening. You can say, 'I see we're hiring for a senior analyst at ninety thousand. I've been in this role for two years and I'm at seventy-five. I'd like to discuss aligning my pay with that market range.' Luna: That's a concrete move. But what if they say the new hire is more experienced than you? Lucas: Then you pivot to your institutional knowledge. You've been there, you know the systems, the clients, the internal politics. That's worth something. New hires take months to ramp up. You can say, 'I understand they bring different experience, but I also bring two years of context that would take someone else six months to absorb.' Luna: That's a good point. So timing matters too, right? Lucas: Absolutely. Don't ask the week after they announce the hiring freeze — that's terrible. But if they're actively recruiting, that's a sign of confidence. The best time is right after a successful quarter or a big client win, when the company feels good about momentum. Luna: And what about the meeting itself? Should you schedule a formal sit-down or just bring it up casually? Lucas: Formal, always. You want a scheduled conversation, not a drive-by at the coffee machine. Send a calendar invite with a subject line like 'Discussion about my role and compensation.' That sets the tone that this is a business conversation, not a casual ask. Luna: Okay, and when you're in that meeting, what's the one thing you should avoid doing? Lucas: Don't threaten to leave. Even if you have another offer, that's a last resort. Once you play that card, you can't unplay it. Instead, focus on your performance and the market. You want to make it easy for them to say yes, not feel cornered. Luna: So let's talk about a real example. I remember a friend of mine — she was a marketing coordinator at a tech company that was doubling its sales team. She saw the job postings and felt undervalued. She did exactly what you're describing: she researched salaries, found the range for her role, and scheduled a meeting with her manager. She asked for a fifteen percent raise and got it. Lucas: That's a great story. What made it work? Was it the data, or the timing? Luna: Both, honestly. She timed it right after the company announced a big funding round, so there was a sense of abundance. And she came prepared with numbers — she showed the salary band for her role, noted that they were hiring a senior coordinator at a higher rate, and highlighted her own contributions to the marketing campaigns that drove some of that growth. Lucas: That's the perfect combination: timing, data, and performance. And she didn't make it about 'you're spending money on new people.' She made it about fairness and market alignment. Luna: Exactly. And her manager didn't even hesitate. She had the numbers, so it was easy to justify to higher-ups. Lucas: Now, one thing to be careful about: if your company is hiring but also has a pay freeze, that's a different situation. You might have to ask for a title change or additional benefits instead. But if there's no freeze, the hiring spree is actually a green light. Luna: So the takeaway is: don't assume the hiring spree means you're forgotten. Use it as a signal that the company has money and is investing in talent. Then make your case with data and timing. Lucas: Right. And one more tip: practice your conversation out loud. It sounds silly, but it helps. You want to sound confident, not apologetic. Rehearse your key points until they feel natural. Luna: That's a good point. It's like they say, 'Luck is what happens when preparation meets opportunity.' Lucas: Exactly. And the opportunity here is your company's growth. Don't let it pass you by. Luna: So if you're listening and you're in this situation, what's the first step you'd recommend? Lucas: Start by gathering your data. Look at salary bands, your own performance reviews, and any industry benchmarks. Then, before you schedule the meeting, think about what you'd do if they say no. What's your plan? That way you're not caught off guard. Luna: And if they do say no, but they offer a smaller raise or a promise to revisit in six months, is that a win? Lucas: It's a partial win. You've opened the conversation. And if you get a commitment to revisit, make sure it's in writing — an email or a note in your HR system. That way you have a follow-up point. Luna: That's smart. And if they say no and give no reason, that's a red flag. Maybe it's time to update your resume. Lucas: Right. But don't jump to that immediately. Sometimes it's just a bad quarter. But if they're hiring and still won't adjust your pay, that sends a message about how they value you. Luna: Okay, so to wrap up: when your company is hiring, you have leverage. Use it wisely. Do your research, time it right, and present a solid case. Lucas: And remember, the goal isn't to demand — it's to align your pay with the market and your contributions. If you do that, you're more likely to get a yes. Luna: Thanks, Lucas. That was really helpful. For our listeners, if you've got a career question, send it our way. And if this episode was useful, consider supporting us at buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. Lucas: That's it for today. We'll catch you next time.