Latest / Think Fast Talk Smart: Communication Techniques / 314. Rethinks: Turn Tension Into Trust
Transcript
- 0:02Matt Abrahams: The secret to mastering difficult conversations, delivering
- 0:06effective feedback, and resolving stubborn conflicts actually begins
- 0:10with a tough negotiation with yourself.
- 0:13My name is Matt Abrahams, and I teach Strategic Communication at
- 0:17Stanford Graduate School of Business.
- 0:19Welcome to this special Rethinks episode of Think Fast, Talk Smart, the podcast.
- 0:25We all struggle when having challenging conversations, be they arguments,
- 0:29negotiations, or constructive feedback.
- 0:32When I find myself in these difficult situations, I often return to the
- 0:36excellent advice of Sheila Heen.
- 0:39Sheila provided so many practical, useful tips that I wanted to provide you with
- 0:44an extended version of her insights.
- 0:47So you know, you can hear more extended episodes when you
- 0:50join our premium offering.
- 0:52So let's dive right in and learn from Sheila.
- 0:56Most advice on conflict resolution, negotiation, and feedback is
- 1:01to focus on the other person.
- 1:04And while important, it is more important to focus first on yourself.
- 1:10My name is Matt Abrahams, and I teach Strategic Communication at
- 1:13Stanford Graduate School of Business.
- 1:15Welcome to Think Fast, Talk Smart, the podcast.
- 1:21Today I look forward to speaking with Sheila Heen.
- 1:23Sheila is a lecturer at Harvard Law School and co-founder of Triad Consulting Group.
- 1:28She's also the co-author of the best-selling books Difficult
- 1:31Conversations and Thanks for the Feedback.
- 1:34Welcome, Sheila.
- 1:35Sheila Heen: I am delighted to be here.
- 1:37We're gonna have fun.
- 1:38Matt Abrahams: Shall we get started?
- 1:39Sheila Heen: Let's.
- 1:40Matt Abrahams: Many people avoid difficult conversations out of fear.
- 1:44What advice do you have for overcoming the anxiety that often accompanies
- 1:48these types of interactions?
- 1:50Sheila Heen: I think overcoming the anxiety is maybe better framed as getting
- 1:56honest with ourselves about the anxiety.
- 1:58Some of that anxiety is well-placed, particularly if my purpose in the
- 2:01conversation is to convince you that you're wrong or to convince you that
- 2:04I'm right, 'cause obviously I'm right.
- 2:06It is probably not going to go well.
- 2:08So when I'm negotiating with myself about having the courage to take the
- 2:13risk to have a conversation, the two things that help me are, number one,
- 2:17to remember that worrying about the potential costs of raising something
- 2:22important to me is only half the ledger.
- 2:25The other half of the ledger is what are the potential costs of
- 2:27avoiding it and letting it fester?
- 2:29And those are slower, they're less Technicolor in my imagination
- 2:33because they're not going to happen in the moment that I raise it, but
- 2:36they're still very real, and I think we discount the cost of avoiding.
- 2:42The second thing is to negotiate with myself about what am I trying
- 2:45to achieve in this conversation?
- 2:47And if I can shift my purpose from convincing you of something to instead
- 2:53just understanding how you see it and why we might see it differently,
- 2:59that actually is more likely to generate a good conversation with
- 3:03less defensiveness for both of us.
- 3:05And at the end, we don't have to agree.
- 3:07I can achieve my purpose simply by asking a lot of questions and then sharing how
- 3:13I think about it differently, and that'll push the conversation forward, and then
- 3:16we can go away and think about what we've heard and what might make sense next.
- 3:20Matt Abrahams: So this notion of reframing it as an opportunity to get understanding
- 3:23can take a lot of the pressure off.
- 3:25Sheila Heen: It can take a lot of the pressure off.
- 3:26When I invite you into a conversation about why I'm right, I'm basically
- 3:30saying, "Hi, I'm casting a play.
- 3:32In this play, I am the hero, and you are the problem.
- 3:35Would you like to be in my play?" And you're like, "No, I don't want to be in
- 3:38your play 'cause it's completely miscast." If I can shift my purposes, "Hey, I'm
- 3:42casting a play where two characters try to understand what's up," and you're like,
- 3:46"That sounds like an interesting play.
- 3:48Let's try it out."
- 3:49Matt Abrahams: So make it an invitation
- 3:51Sheila Heen: Make it an invitation that somebody would want to say yes to.
- 3:53Matt Abrahams: I like your analogy of the play.
- 3:56And thinking about the cost of avoiding is really important, because I know in my own
- 4:02life and in the lives of many I know, we focus on the other side of that equation,
- 4:07and not focus on what are the costs of avoiding the interaction, instead of
- 4:10just fixating on the interaction itself.
- 4:13In your book Difficult Conversations, you emphasize the importance of
- 4:16understanding the underlying emotions and assumptions in tough conversations.
- 4:21What tactics can we use to stay calm and focused as emotions escalate, and how can
- 4:27we reflect on those emotions in advance?
- 4:30Sheila Heen: One of the things that I've found really interesting
- 4:32about difficult conversations is that by the time something
- 4:35becomes a difficult conversation, we've got at least two problems.
- 4:38We've got whatever we're disagreeing about on the surface, should Mom stay
- 4:42in rehab, or is she ready to come home?
- 4:44Is this the right strategic decision and investment for us as a board?
- 4:48But if it's a difficult conversation, typically there's a deeper issue,
- 4:51which is how we each feel treated in how we're navigating this together.
- 4:56Because you never listen, because you always think you're
- 4:59right and need to get your way.
- 5:00And that's really a feelings question.
- 5:04Or, why am I never consulted about this?
- 5:06Or when I am consulted, you never take my advice.
- 5:09Part of the feelings piece is, let's talk about the real issues here.
- 5:15And if we can actually talk a little bit about those deeper issues, then we're
- 5:19actually addressing more of the root of the problem that's gonna make the surface
- 5:23issues easier for us now and over time.
- 5:26Ironically, the instinct for us is to try to keep feelings out of the conversation.
- 5:31Let's not open that whole can of worms.
- 5:33Stay calm, rational, business-focused.
- 5:35When we do that, we're not getting to the deeper issue.
- 5:38Part of what causes people to yell, cry, or get sarcastic when emotions burst into
- 5:45the conversation is because we're trying to tamp them down and keep them out.
- 5:48So they come out as being emotional.
- 5:51There's a big difference between being emotional and handling feelings well.
- 5:55Paradoxically, naming or describing the emotion I'm feeling can
- 5:59be a release valve for it.
- 6:01So if I say, "I feel confused, I just am frustrated 'cause I feel like we're going
- 6:05in circles," then my physiological feeling of being frustrated can ease a little bit.
- 6:11And if we can narrate and just name what we're feeling, it can help us acknowledge
- 6:17that this isn't easy, and then refocus on what we're trying to understand or unpack.
- 6:22Matt Abrahams: So it takes a moment to reflect on how we are feeling.
- 6:25And then once that happens, just sharing that can be a way of bringing
- 6:30them to the conversation without them just bursting onto the scene.
- 6:34They also lay the groundwork to have a discussion about them.
- 6:37Sheila Heen: I think that's right.
- 6:38And in doing so, I'm also inviting yours.
- 6:42One mistake it's easy to make is that I'm either so preoccupied with my
- 6:47own feelings that I forget that you often have many of the same feelings.
- 6:50You also feel frustrated and impatient and whatever.
- 6:53Or I'm so preoccupied with your reaction that I am neglecting thinking about how
- 6:58I'm gonna manage myself, and really, we need to be paying attention to both.
- 7:02Matt Abrahams: And you said something earlier that I think is really important.
- 7:04It's the story that we bring to the situation.
- 7:07So we have in our minds a story about this interaction that we're about to
- 7:12have that may or may not be accurate.
- 7:14Sheila Heen: So we have a story about what has happened, what is happening right
- 7:18now, and what we think should happen.
- 7:20In Difficult Conversations, we talk about that story itself
- 7:23having three key components.
- 7:25One is, I'm preoccupied with what I'm pretty sure I'm right about.
- 7:29The second is, whose fault is it that we're having this problem?
- 7:32And the third is, why are you acting this way?
- 7:34What are your intentions or motivations or character that are
- 7:37causing you to be so difficult?
- 7:40That story drives how I pretend to listen to you.
- 7:45The first negotiation is actually a negotiation I have to have
- 7:47with myself about my own story.
- 7:49To shift from being focused on what I'm right about to being curious about
- 7:52why it is, given it's so obvious that I'm right, that you see it differently.
- 7:56To shift from blame to thinking about what are we each contributing to the
- 7:59problem, and to shift from focusing on your intentions or character to,
- 8:04can I describe the impact on me?
- 8:05I don't know why you're doing what you're doing, but what's important to
- 8:08me is that you understand the impact it's having, either on me or on the team
- 8:11or on the business or the community.
- 8:13If I can make that shift in my own mind, then it's actually a more
- 8:17inviting conversation for both of us.
- 8:19Matt Abrahams: Teasing out those different components of
- 8:21the story is really important.
- 8:23I can imagine for myself in a situation where I have to have a difficult
- 8:26conversation, maybe with one of my kids or a coworker, I would have to damp
- 8:30down some of my emotions first to get to that place where I could actually
- 8:33do that introspection about my story.
- 8:35And then how do I actually kick off that conversation about the deeper level?
- 8:40I've invited you here to have a conversation about some topic,
- 8:44but really it's the underlying issue that's the challenge.
- 8:48How do I start that conversation about the underlying issue?
- 8:51Sheila Heen: The natural place to start is within my own story.
- 8:54In my story, you're the problem.
- 8:55The mistake we sometimes make is we think, "Well, I've been told, and I've
- 8:59heard on this podcast a lot, that I should listen and ask lots of questions,
- 9:03so now I'm gonna try to start by asking questions about your story." There's
- 9:08not something necessarily wrong with that, but if I'm not dealing with my
- 9:11own story and including it, it can feel false or forced, or I'm asking
- 9:17questions, but they're not real questions.
- 9:19So the key from our point of view is to try to step to the third story.
- 9:23As an observer who understood what we each think, how would they
- 9:28describe the difference between us?
- 9:30I can do that myself.
- 9:31So it might sound something like, "I'm guessing we have really different
- 9:35preferences for how this should be handled," or, "I'm guessing we
- 9:39have really different predictions about what the risks are here, and
- 9:42I'm curious to talk about that.
- 9:44I'm happy to share mine, and I'm particularly interested to hear what
- 9:47you're worried about." That is what we call starting the conversation from the
- 9:50third story, and it's one that includes both of our stories as part of the
- 9:55purpose of the conversation, and that's an invitation that they're likely to take.
- 9:59Matt Abrahams: You mentioned this notion of questions and how
- 10:02questions can actually be misused.
- 10:04But I know, and I've heard you speak about, the power of questions.
- 10:08Can you share with me a little bit about how questions can be helpful
- 10:12in managing conflict and negotiation?
- 10:14Sheila Heen: Yeah, a question should be an invitation to understand the other person.
- 10:19When you are the other person and someone wants to, genuinely, wants to understand
- 10:24you, that's a tough invitation to turn down because feeling understood by
- 10:29others is such a fundamental human need.
- 10:33So genuine curiosity is something that is hard for other people
- 10:37to resist being responsive to.
- 10:40And then because reciprocity is such a strong social norm, so if you
- 10:44attack me, I'm gonna attack you back.
- 10:46If you're genuinely curious about me, once I feel understood, I may be
- 10:51able to then turn to be more curious about why you would possibly disagree.
- 10:56So questions can move us toward understanding and finding some things
- 11:02that we have in common, even if it's just we both agree this is a problem,
- 11:05even if we disagree about what kind of problem it is, or who's causing
- 11:08it, or what we should do about it.
- 11:10But that common ground can help us think about, if we both agree it's
- 11:14a problem, where do we go from here?
- 11:16The other thing that questions can do, and I've both had this experience,
- 11:20and I periodically get asked about this experience, which is, how long
- 11:24do I have to listen to someone who just monologues the whole time?
- 11:27Because I don't want to ask them more questions.
- 11:29They're not listening.
- 11:30I can hardly get a word in edgewise, and they're not going to even pause.
- 11:34At the end of the conversation, they believe it went really
- 11:36successfully, and they leave the room.
- 11:38I think that questions can actually be really helpful because people will
- 11:42monologue about whatever comes into their head, and you can use questions
- 11:46to direct their monologue toward the things that actually would be
- 11:50helpful for you to hear more about.
- 11:52And I think we're taught not to interrupt people, but, and if I'm interrupting
- 11:57you to cut you off to say what I want to say, that gets a bad reaction.
- 12:00But if I'm interrupting you to better understand you,
- 12:03that is usually well-received.
- 12:05So saying, "Okay, hang on one second.
- 12:07Just, can I get a word in edgewise here?
- 12:09Because I just am not sure I'm tracking what you mean by this.
- 12:13Help me understand that first." I'm helping to shape the conversation
- 12:18about things that are helpful.
- 12:19And then I can paraphrase back, "Before we go too much further, I wonder whether
- 12:25it would be helpful for you to hear how I think about those things." So
- 12:29I can be more assertive about asking for reciprocity, that my perspective
- 12:34needs to be part of the conversation.
- 12:36Matt Abrahams: So questions can do a lot, especially when paired with paraphrasing,
- 12:39to move a conversation in the direction that you think it needs to go.
- 12:45And it's a way of asserting yourself without shutting the other person down.
- 12:51And questions, by their very nature, as you mentioned, are invitations,
- 12:54and reciprocity drives us to respond.
- 12:57So it's a way of bringing people to a conversation.
- 13:00I want to talk about when these types of interactions get stuck.
- 13:03Negotiations, conflict gets stuck.
- 13:05We're, we're cycling or circling on the same issue.
- 13:08We're not able to get out of our own worldview.
- 13:11How do you get unstuck without sacrificing your position or your self-worth?
- 13:20Sheila Heen: So I think the first question to ask is, why do I think we're stuck?
- 13:24To do some diagnosis.
- 13:26Is it because we're not understanding why we each feel so strongly about it?
- 13:31Is it because we're trading positions?
- 13:33This is the outcome that I need.
- 13:35In negotiation, people typically take positions and then say, "We must have
- 13:39X, Y, or Z," and, "We can't give you X, Y, or Z, but we can give you A, B,
- 13:43or C." If we're trading positions, then maybe we need to dig underneath for
- 13:47the underlying interests and concerns that we each think our solution will
- 13:53meet, and we need to talk about those deeper concerns that lead us to think
- 13:57that's the only thing we can accept.
- 13:59It might be that we're at impasse because we have the wrong people at the table.
- 14:04So every time we think of an idea that might move us forward,
- 14:09then, well, we can't do that.
- 14:11We would need higher-ups or collaborators or whatever.
- 14:15And we don't think they'd agree to that.
- 14:17Maybe we should find out.
- 14:18For me, the impasse question has 10 or 15 possible answers, and if you're
- 14:25not asking that question first, you're gonna misdirect your energies.
- 14:29And one thing you can do is just observe, name.
- 14:33It feels like we're going in circles and we feel stuck, and
- 14:36I wonder why that's happening.
- 14:38What's your sense of why it's happening?
- 14:39And then I'm happy to share what I'm noticing.
- 14:42And now I've made it a joint problem to do the diagnosis together, and
- 14:47that alone can help us come together to understand why we're stuck.
- 14:51I'll say one more thing, which is occasionally we're stuck
- 14:55because it doesn't make sense for me to move forward with this.
- 14:58I should say no, but a lot of people have trouble saying no and walking away 'cause
- 15:03they don't wanna let other people down.
- 15:04It's usually rooted in identity.
- 15:06I'm very loyal.
- 15:07I don't want to abandon you.
- 15:08I feel it might be rude, but that means I'm not being upfront about,
- 15:12I just am thinking this doesn't make sense for me to move forward with.
- 15:15I like you, and as things play out, if we check in in a month,
- 15:19we might be at a different place.
- 15:20But right now, I don't think it makes sense for us to move forward.
- 15:24Matt Abrahams: So it sounds like the way to manage an impasse or
- 15:27being stuck is to reflect in terms of what is causing that impasse.
- 15:33And in some cases, it might be your unwillingness to just cut
- 15:37bait and say, "We're done."
- 15:38Sheila Heen: Yes.
- 15:39Matt Abrahams: But much like you talked about when you were talking about
- 15:42emotion, we have to look deeper and understand what might be causing this
- 15:48and have the conversation at that level.
- 15:50Sheila Heen: I think that's right.
- 15:51Yeah.
- 15:51And we often skip that and just try a bunch of different things, or we
- 15:54try the same thing over and over, thinking we'll get a different response.
- 15:58Matt Abrahams: Again, it can be very hard to take that step back and reflect
- 16:02and see what's going on, but reminding ourselves that by getting to perhaps
- 16:06the root cause can remove, in this case, the impasse, in the case of
- 16:11emotions, can allow us to have the real conversation that needs to be had.
- 16:15I wanna highlight something I've noticed in many of your answers.
- 16:18When you give examples, you use words like wonder, curious.
- 16:23Those are very inviting words.
- 16:25Those are words that bring about connection and a, a
- 16:29sense of we're collaborating.
- 16:31Talk to me about your thoughts of, down to the linguistic level, what
- 16:35are your thoughts about the importance of language in conflict management?
- 16:40Sheila Heen: So I'm giving my internal voice a job.
- 16:42My internal voice believes that its job is to protect me and defend me and fight
- 16:47back on my behalf when someone says, "That makes no sense at all." But if
- 16:51I can give my internal voice the job, not turn it off, but the job of figure
- 16:56out why they see it in that way, which doesn't make sense, then my internal
- 17:00voice is actually on my own side.
- 17:02Needs to be curious in order to give me answers.
- 17:06And so I think some of it is just negotiating with your own internal
- 17:09voice to give it the right job.
- 17:12Matt Abrahams: I often think of conflict management, negotiation, feedback as
- 17:17things that are happening outside of myself with someone else, and they
- 17:20obviously are, but a lot of what you were talking about is the dialogue I have
- 17:24with myself, and that is really powerful.
- 17:27And a lot of us, I think, just jump right into the interactive piece
- 17:31without the self-reflection piece first.
- 17:33I want to switch to feedback because I know you have a
- 17:35lot of thoughts on feedback.
- 17:37What are some common mistakes people make when giving feedback,
- 17:41and how can we avoid them to ensure that our feedback is received as
- 17:45constructive rather than critical?
- 17:47Sheila Heen: Probably the first question is, does this person want my feedback?
- 17:51And unsolicited feedback can be some of the hardest feedback
- 17:56to be on the receiving end of.
- 17:58Now, that said, sometimes we are responsible for providing feedback.
- 18:01We're a manager, we're a parent, we're a colleague that sees that what's
- 18:05happening right now, actually, I have a responsibility to say something.
- 18:09One of the things that has helped me is just to understand that there
- 18:13are really three types of feedback.
- 18:14And often, as a giver, I'm not clear on which kind I'm offering, or my
- 18:20receiver is hoping for a different kind than what I am offering.
- 18:23So the three kinds, the easy way to remember them is ACE, A-C-E.
- 18:27So the first is appreciation.
- 18:29Just, "I see you, I get you, I'm noticing what's valuable about what you're doing,
- 18:33how hard you're working at it," et cetera.
- 18:35The C is coaching, and by coaching I mean anything that helps someone
- 18:39else become more effective or efficient or knowledgeable.
- 18:43If my goal is to help you get better, it counts as coaching So that's the
- 18:48engine for learning, but it bumps into the third type, which is evaluation.
- 18:52And evaluation rates or ranks you about whether you're meeting
- 18:56expectations, about whether you are exceeding or falling short.
- 19:01Part of what's hard, and from my point of view, the term constructive criticism
- 19:07comes from this cross transaction where, as a giver, I think I'm offering you
- 19:12coaching, but as a receiver, what you hear is judgment, evaluation, right?
- 19:18So I'm super clear that I give my kids, three of them, all kinds of
- 19:22brilliant coaching that is really helpful to them, and yet they hear
- 19:28that they're not measuring up.
- 19:30Part of it is just naming it and getting an alignment.
- 19:33So when someone says to me, "Hey, could you give me some feedback about this
- 19:36draft?" I've learned to ask, "What would be helpful to you right now?" Maybe
- 19:42it's just appreciation 'cause you're not sure there's even any value here,
- 19:45so do I see anything worth pursuing?
- 19:48Which is a combination of appreciation and evaluation.
- 19:51Or, "What do you like about this draft? What speaks to you about this
- 19:54draft?" Might be helpful at this stage.
- 19:56Another would be, "I can't figure out this story. I don't think it's
- 19:59working, and I'd love your input." So they're asking for coaching.
- 20:02And a third might be, "We think this is ready to send out. Do you think it's ready
- 20:06to go?" And that's an evaluation question.
- 20:08Does it meet expectations, or do we each think it's good enough?
- 20:12And so just getting aligned on that as a giver and a receiver can really
- 20:16straighten out what we're each hoping for.
- 20:18Matt Abrahams: It is important to delineate the type of feedback, and I
- 20:22appreciate the ACE, the appreciation, the coaching, the evaluation.
- 20:25It seems to me that we, as the person giving feedback, can ask,
- 20:31what is it that you're looking for?
- 20:32But it also, I believe, could be really helpful if those of us
- 20:35seeking feedback could be very clear.
- 20:38A lot of times we'll just say, "Can you give me feedback?" Or, "How'd that
- 20:40go?" Instead of being more specific.
- 20:43Do you have specific guidance around the actual phrasing of feedback that
- 20:47can actually help it be beneficial?
- 20:50Sheila Heen: As a receiver, one question that I've found useful is,
- 20:54what's one thing that if I changed it, you think would make this
- 20:57better or make this meeting more effective, or whatever the context is.
- 21:00The other thing that I try to keep in mind is that getting clear so that as
- 21:05a receiver, I can see what my giver is trying to say, or as a giver trying
- 21:08to help my receiver understand what I mean, is really a joint endeavor.
- 21:13And there's no avoiding the fact that you've got to start
- 21:16with a sort of label or topic.
- 21:19Like, I think one of the things that would be helpful is if you were more responsive
- 21:22or if, yeah, I think you're too nice.
- 21:25That's incredibly vague and frustrating.
- 21:28And because as a receiver, I have a reaction to it, I'm so like, "Okay,
- 21:31thanks for your feedback. Goodbye." Rather than saying, "Wow, I don't
- 21:37know what to think about that. Help me understand what you mean." And we can,
- 21:41as givers and receivers together, we can ask questions in a couple directions.
- 21:45One is backward-looking.
- 21:47Where is this coming from?
- 21:48You must have noticed some things that concerned you, or you had some
- 21:52expectations about how I would handle something, and I did something different.
- 21:55Like, there were a bunch of specific things that happened that have
- 21:58led you to offer me this feedback.
- 22:00So that's backward-looking.
- 22:01The other thing that we can do is ask questions forward-looking.
- 22:04If I were to take your advice, what would I do differently?
- 22:08What specifically would I do differently?
- 22:10Or it might be, look, if there was one thing you were going to do tomorrow
- 22:14or change to experiment with, it would be when you get an email, just send
- 22:18back a note that says, "On it. Back to you soon." 'Cause we can't tell
- 22:21whether you're getting our emails.
- 22:23That's a very specific thing that matches being more responsive, but is less global
- 22:30maybe than you thought it was before, and I'm getting clearer about what I
- 22:34actually am picturing you would change.
- 22:36More concrete.
- 22:38Matt Abrahams: It clearly seems that effective feedback is a dialogue
- 22:40where there's a communication and questioning and, and clarity
- 22:44that is sought and delivered.
- 22:46And as a feedback giver, I need to remind myself that I need to be specific.
- 22:52It seems to me that feedback, negotiation, and conflict management are all circling
- 22:59around some of the same key ideas.
- 23:02If you were to give one or two practical bits of advice to help people in
- 23:07each of those areas what would it be?
- 23:11Sheila Heen: For me, the thing that has made the biggest difference is
- 23:14to have a few analytical tools that just help me see beneath the surface.
- 23:18'Cause on the surface, whether it's conflict or difficult conversations or
- 23:23negotiation or feedback, on the surface it just feels like a mess, and why do
- 23:28I wanna get any closer to that mess?
- 23:29And if you look underneath the mess, there are a handful of things
- 23:35going on that if we can understand them, we have our first win.
- 23:38We don't know what to do about them yet, but we better understand them.
- 23:41So for me, thinking, what is this about for each of us?
- 23:47Often we're talking past each other.
- 23:49One of the things that happens is that what we each think this conflict is about
- 23:54is different, so we keep saying what's most important to me, and then you say
- 23:59what's most important to you, and we're not actually responding to each other.
- 24:03I think just as a first step, understanding what is this about, what's
- 24:07most important about it to each of us, can at least help us name the different
- 24:11topics that we should talk about and get aligned on which to talk about first.
- 24:15Matt Abrahams: Thank you.
- 24:15I think that's a very powerful starting place.
- 24:18And then I think the second step you already mentioned as well, which
- 24:20is to reflect what's the story I'm bringing, or what's my take on this.
- 24:24Very helpful.
- 24:25Sheila, this has been fantastic.
- 24:27Before we end, I'd like to ask three questions of all the guests.
- 24:31One I create just for you, and then the other two are similar.
- 24:33Are you up for that?
- 24:34Sheila Heen: Sure.
- 24:34Matt Abrahams: So my first question is quite self-serving.
- 24:37I find myself in several challenging situations, often in
- 24:42my personal life with my family.
- 24:44What advice do you give to people who have to negotiate and manage
- 24:49conflict in a situation where you know it will be continual?
- 24:53We're gonna have another family meal, we're going to
- 24:56take another family vacation.
- 24:58What advice and guidance do you have to help take some of the edge
- 25:01off and effect change in a way so we don't feel like we're having
- 25:04the same fight over and over again?
- 25:06Sheila Heen: We are having the same fight over and over again, aren't we?
- 25:09Matt Abrahams: Yes.
- 25:09Sheila Heen: And partly because we're each bringing such, I'll
- 25:13call it rich family experience with us into those relationships.
- 25:19And also the beauty of being in a family is that you hopefully have the sense that
- 25:26people accept me for who I am despite my flaws, and that means that we're
- 25:34less careful And we're more reactive.
- 25:38I think the thing that I regret looking back is early on not taking a beat to
- 25:46decide how I want to respond, and instead just reacting where my internal voice
- 25:51thinks, "Okay, that's ridiculous." So I just say, "That's ridiculous," and
- 25:55dismiss something that someone's trying to actually raise with me that's important.
- 26:01Matt Abrahams: That notion of reflexively responding and not taking a beat certainly
- 26:05plays out in my life, and I'm easily triggered to respond in the ways I have,
- 26:10and I think taking that beat will help.
- 26:13Question number two, who is a communicator that you admire and why?
- 26:18Sheila Heen: Oh boy, there are so many communicators that I admire for
- 26:20different reasons, but one of the ones I've been thinking about a lot lately
- 26:24is, oddly enough, Anderson Cooper.
- 26:27His new podcast series, All There Is, it's a podcast about grief.
- 26:32And one of the things I really have appreciated about it
- 26:35is how honest and raw it is.
- 26:39It's beautifully edited, but it also just invites us into his internal
- 26:45experience of grappling with grief, which then connects us all.
- 26:50And I also love the way that he invites others in.
- 26:54Matt Abrahams: Thank you for sharing that, and he's certainly a master communicator.
- 26:57I am not surprised that you would be drawn to a communicator who
- 27:02addresses emotion and who is all about inviting others to collaborate
- 27:07or experience something together.
- 27:08Those are two themes that came through in much of what you said.
- 27:12Final question, what are the first three ingredients that go into a
- 27:16successful communication recipe?
- 27:19Sheila Heen: Your guests have named just wise and insightful ingredients.
- 27:24So I found myself, in thinking about this question Thinking about what are the
- 27:30seasonings or spices you would add that other people might not be thinking about?
- 27:35Matt Abrahams: All right.
- 27:35Sheila Heen: So we're gonna assume that the cake is baked and, and is
- 27:38beautiful from your other guests.
- 27:40One of the things that I've been thinking a little bit about
- 27:43is just degrees of difficulty.
- 27:45Because I think we hear a lot these days especially about how, boy, disagreement
- 27:50is good, and disagreement should be out on the table, and that's where we
- 27:54really learn from each other, and that's where we can connect with each other.
- 27:57And I think what we're maybe not talking about enough is degrees of difficulty.
- 28:03So there are three things that I think increase the degree of difficulty.
- 28:07One is, is it about a topic that matters to me?
- 28:11So if I ask you what kind of ice cream is your favorite, do I care whether
- 28:15you eat different ice cream than I eat?
- 28:18But if it's about a topic that isn't near and dear to my heart, it's not that hard.
- 28:22And of course, disagreement is interesting and fun to talk about.
- 28:26Now let's take it to the next level, which is, is it about me in some way?
- 28:31If it's something that we disagree about and that has implications
- 28:35on who I am, well, now that ups the level of difficulty here.
- 28:39Or should you be here?
- 28:42Do you deserve to be here?
- 28:43Are people like you supposed to be here?
- 28:45Well, now we're upping the difficulty because it's about identity.
- 28:49And the third level of difficulty, is the outcome of this going to impact me?
- 28:54So if you and I have to share the ice cream and you get to decide because
- 28:58you have the decision rights and you're gonna dictate what kind of ice cream
- 29:01I eat for the rest of my life, well now something is on the line for me.
- 29:06And I think that's why when power comes into the picture, meaning who has what
- 29:12levers of influence over outcomes?
- 29:15And if the outcome of this is gonna have really important consequences
- 29:19for me, now that's the hardest place to feel, to step into a conversation
- 29:25where I know that we disagree.
- 29:27Now, you asked for three ingredients.
- 29:29Those are three levels of difficulty.
- 29:31They might be spices on the cake.
- 29:34As the degree of difficulty gets higher, it's more and more important
- 29:38that I develop the capacity to have those conversations because whether
- 29:41or not we talk about it, you will make a decision that will impact me or say
- 29:46something about me or matter to me.
- 29:48And so my opportunity to influence that decision and to understand it
- 29:53and fill in blanks where you maybe are missing something is lost if I don't
- 29:59develop the capacity to live in that space and to use the skills that I've
- 30:04spent time developing, but that can go out the window when I'm under stress.
- 30:09So that's the place where I think leadership goes from good to great, if
- 30:14we're gonna use an old phrase which is that not only can I have the conversations
- 30:19that matter, but as they get harder, I can stay in the place where I am showing up
- 30:25as my best self to have them and using all those skills that I've worked so hard at.
- 30:30Matt Abrahams: So insightful that while many people focus on macro
- 30:36ingredients, these are really micro ingredients that make a big difference.
- 30:40I love that they all start with the letter I, importance, identity, and impact.
- 30:46And this notion of being able to stay with this as you're having the conversation
- 30:52and being able to navigate through these degrees of difficulty, really
- 30:58important advice, and I'm gonna have to spend some time thinking about how I
- 31:02personally can help myself and help those I interact with navigate through these.
- 31:07Sheila, this has been absolutely fantastic.
- 31:09When we started the conversation, I thought it was going to be mostly
- 31:13best practices for how we engage others, and not only did we talk about
- 31:18that, but we really talked about how do we engage ourselves so that we
- 31:22can have these types of challenging conversations and negotiations.
- 31:26Thank you.
- 31:27Sheila Heen: Thank you.
- 31:30Matt Abrahams: Thank you for joining us for another episode of Think
- 31:32Fast, Talk Smart, the podcast.
- 31:35Among the many ideas Sheila shared, the one that stands out to me is
- 31:38miscommunication and hurt feelings occur when a person giving feedback
- 31:44and the person receiving it are not aligned on what is actually needed.
- 31:49To ensure feedback is constructive rather than critical, explicitly clarify which of
- 31:54the three types of feedback is expected, appreciation, coaching, or evaluation.
- 32:00This will help you ace your feedback.
- 32:03To learn more about managing conflict and difficult conversations,
- 32:07tune in to episode 250.
- 32:09This episode was produced by Katherine Reed, Ryan Campos, Alex
- 32:13McCarthy, and me, Matt Abrahams.
- 32:16Our music is from Floyd Wonder, with special thanks to Podium Podcast Company.
- 32:21Be sure to check out our full transcripts for each episode at fastersmarter.io.