Latest / The WallBuilders Show / A Bold Move on Border Security and Subsequent Legal Challenges
Transcript
- 0:07Rick Green: Welcome to the Intersection of Faith and the Culture.
- 0:09Rick Green: This is The WallBuilders Show.
- 0:10Rick Green: I'm Rick Green here with David and Tim Barton.
- 0:12Rick Green: You can find out more about us and the program and you can also listen to some of the past programs over the last few months right there at wallbuilderslive.
- 0:18Rick Green: com.
- 0:20Rick Green: That's our website for the radio program.
- 0:21Rick Green: You can get a list of our stations.
- 0:23Rick Green: A lot of other great information there, and then over at wallbuilders.
- 0:25Rick Green: com you can get some great tools for your family, whether it's DVDs or watching videos online or getting some of the books or just reading some of the articles right there on the website.
- 0:34Rick Green: All of it is designed to equip and inspire you to be a part of the solution, to be a good citizen and live out your freedom in a way that will preserve it for future generations.
- 0:45Rick Green: We've got your questions to get to today.
- 0:47Rick Green: Thanks for sending those in.
- 0:48Rick Green: It is Foundations of Freedom Thursday.
- 0:50Rick Green: Alright, guys, jump into those questions and folks, if you haven't sent yours in and you've got a question about the Constitution or history or application of biblical worldview to some of the issues going on out there, whatever you got, send it in to us.
- 1:00Rick Green: We'd love to air your question and talk about it.
- 1:03Rick Green: So radio@ wallbuilders.
- 1:04Rick Green: com.
- 1:05Rick Green: That's the email.
- 1:06Rick Green: Radio@ wallbuilders.
- 1:07Rick Green: com Nothing off the table.
- 1:09Rick Green: We love hearing from you, so send them in.
- 1:11Rick Green: This one comes from David, not David Barton, here on the program.
- 1:14Rick Green: Another David, he said, howdy David, Rick and Tim have questions related to Texas Governor Abbott's battle with President Biden over the continued influx of illegal immigrants coming across the border.
- 1:23Rick Green: Number one are Governor Abbott's actions to use Texas DPS and Texas National Guard to secure the border and protect the state constitutional?
- 1:31Rick Green: Two if so, what was the basis for the US Supreme Court decision allowing the Department of Homeland Security to remove border security provisions placed by Texas agencies?
- 1:40Rick Green: And he's talking about, you know, cutting the razor wire, thereby countering the actions of the Texas agencies.
- 1:45Rick Green: And three I've heard that some Texas Democrat members of Congress are calling for President Biden to take control of the Texas National Guard.
- 1:52Rick Green: Does the Constitution allow for President to take command of a state's National Guard for domestic duties within the state without some declaration of war or insurrection?
- 2:00Rick Green: Thanks for all you do to educate and inform people about the truth.
- 2:02Rick Green: God bless you.
- 2:03Rick Green: Alri ght, that's David at Out in League City, Texas.
- 2:05Rick Green: David, thanks for sending that in.
- 2:06Rick Green: We're going to need about five programs to answer all three of these questions.
- 2:10Rick Green: So, fellas, our schedule is full for the next five Thursdays.
- 2:14Rick Green: What is it they say when you're, when somebody's wanting to in Top Gun, when he wanted to buzz the tower and he says something is full?
- 2:20Rick Green: Well, I can't remember the line now.
- 2:21Rick Green: The pattern is full.
- 2:23Rick Green: That's it, the pattern is full.
- 2:25Rick Green: Thank you, David, for filling the pattern.
- 2:28Rick Green: All right, guys, let's take the first one.
- 2:29Rick Green: Our governor have its actions, using our DPS and National Guard to secure the border.
- 2:33Rick Green: Is that constitutional?
- 2:35David Barton: That's going to be one of the things that will be a huge decision in the coming months, and that's going to be,
- 2:40David Barton: are we going to use the progressive interpretation of the Constitution or do we go back to original intent?
- 2:45David Barton: Because original intent the founding fathers dealt with immigration extensively back in their day.
- 2:50David Barton: We had so many people coming to America from all across the world for the same kind of reasons they wanted freedom, they wanted to be here, they wanted out from under tyranny of their own government, and so they were coming here and the founding fathers had extensive, extensive discussions immigration, including when they were writing the Constitution and putting clauses in there about immigration.
- 3:10David Barton: As a matter of fact, the guys who signed the Constitution nearly one-fifth of them were themselves immigrants.
- 3:16David Barton: They were not even born in America, so they as immigrant and they probably took the strongest position on how important immigration is and how important you control the borders and how important is that you have high standards for those who are coming in.
- 3:28David Barton: The immigrants themselves who were signers of the Constitution probably raised the bar much higher than those who had lived here, but nonetheless, all that to say that hey, David, think about it.
- 3:38Rick Green: That's the Hispanic community in America that came here illegally.
- 3:42Rick Green: They're the ones standing up the most to say we don't want illegal immigration, we want it to be legal.
- 3:47Rick Green: So it's very similar, right.
- 3:49David Barton: It is exactly similar.
- 3:50David Barton: And those who came here illegally and went through the process.
- 3:53David Barton: They now understand why that's so important.
- 3:56David Barton: And the founding fathers talked about it.
- 3:57David Barton: They said you know, we came here thinking we were coming to another nation and we would have voted and acted as if we'd been in our home nation, which would have turned America into our home nation.
- 4:07David Barton: But because it required-
- 4:10David Barton: Well, some of those at the Constitutional Convention said you ought to wait 14 years before you allow an immigrant to vote, because it'll take about that long to learn how to think like an American and understand American institutions.
- 4:20David Barton: Some said nine years.
- 4:21David Barton: They settled basically on five years.
- 4:23David Barton: But they said if you come from a nation, it'll take you five years to learn how different America is, how different philosophy is, how different the government is, how it serves the people, and not vice versa.
- 4:33David Barton: You need five years of inculcation of the American culture, otherwise you'll destroy it by voting the way you voted in Mexico or Brazil or Russia or China or wherever.
- 4:43David Barton: So that's why they were so adamant on that and that timeframe.
- 4:46David Barton: Now, who enforces that?
- 4:47David Barton: Back in the founding era, this was a shared responsibility.
- 4:51David Barton: Thomas Jefferson, I think it was 1803, said look, the real purpose of the federal government with immigration is to make sure that everyone who arrives on the shore is healthy, you don't have tuberculosis or some big disease.
- 5:02David Barton: But then it's up to the states on what you do with immigration.
- 5:05Tim Barton: Hey, wait a second, wasn't that what they were doing at Ellis Island back then?
- 5:08Tim Barton: I mean, George Washington established Ellis Island, Alexander Hamilton came right through there, except no, Ellis Island was the 1890s.
- 5:18Rick Green: And this is one of the-.
- 5:19Rick Green: Just a few years later, right, just a couple years off here.
- 5:21Tim Barton: This is one of the ones we have pointed out as one of the very easy things that, if you just understood the basic concept, it shoots so many holes in this idea that only the federal government can, does or should.
- 5:35Tim Barton: There was no like this unilateral idea of federal immigration.
- 5:39Tim Barton: Where did that happen?
- 5:41Tim Barton: Because, again, Ellis Island was the 1890s.
- 5:45Tim Barton: So who was doing immigration before that?
- 5:48Tim Barton: And to make your point, this is when very clearly it goes back it was the States, and I'm trying to give this as a really silly but the most simplified example possible.
- 6:00Tim Barton: The federal government was not the ones doing this, they were working with the States.
- 6:04Tim Barton: The States were the ones doing the operation of this.
- 6:06Tim Barton: The federal government was working with the States.
- 6:08Tim Barton: The federal government was not usurping the States.
- 6:10Tim Barton: The States were the ones processing this and they were working with the federal government and vice versa as this happened.
- 6:17David Barton: To go to your point, Tim, 1892 when Ellis Island open when George Washington did the ribbon cutting there with Thomas Jefferson at Ellis Island and they had the Statue of Liberty there when they erected the Statue of Liberty with George and John and all the yeah right, 1892 is when Ellis Island opens and that was based on the fact that the year before Congress had passed really its first national immigration law, first really federal law on immigration that was purely federal, and so it was the year before that Congress started passing federal immigration laws in that sense.
- 6:48David Barton: And that goes back to two Supreme Court cases, 1875, 1876, where the Supreme Court said, hey, we think that immigration probably should be a federal issue, not a state issue.
- 7:00David Barton: And so, starting 1875, 1876, you have I think you could argue it's an activist Supreme Court, because they're overturning what previous Supreme Courts had done, because they had a different view.
- 7:11David Barton: And at that time you had all the Irish immigration, you had the Catholic immigration, Chinese immigration, you had all this immigration floods coming in and they're saying, just let the federal government take care of all this.
- 7:21David Barton: And so that's 1892 when Ellis Island opens.
- 7:24David Barton: That's the first federal immigration facility.
- 7:27David Barton: So what did you do for the first 100 years?
- 7:28David Barton: Well, you let the states be involved with it.
- 7:31David Barton: So it really was a shared responsibility and to that extent what Abbott did is consistent with what the founding fathers would have been doing back in their day.
- 7:42David Barton: It's not consistent with what would have been in 1892.
- 7:46David Barton: So, to answer David's question on whether it was right for Abbott to use the Texas forces to do this, it depends on whether you're interpreting it under original intent for the first century or under the courts reinterpretation of the last century.
- 7:59David Barton: But under original intent, this is a shared responsibility.
- 8:03Tim Barton: Well, and Dad, even along those lines, this is one of the very unique times when the federal government is not upholding the actual laws of the nation, intentionally, and then they're preventing states from upholding federal immigration laws that the federal government is abandoning.
- 8:22Tim Barton: So, generally speaking, that this never would have been considered unconstitutional because the states would have been working with the federal government to uphold the same standard, enforcing the same laws.
- 8:33Tim Barton: And it's this really kind of interesting quandary when the federal government is refusing to uphold the actual laws of the nation and then a state decides to step in to uphold a moral and ethical standard, and really even the legal standard that the federal government has optionally, arbitrarily, chosen not to do, and then the federal government is coming after the state for following the laws of the nation.
- 8:59Tim Barton: It's so ridiculous, but it's, I think, one of the very few times that we can look at any kind of immigration situation where the federal government and the states were diametrically opposed in the outcome of the application of following the law.
- 9:17Rick Green: Well, you know, what's interesting, guys, is the intellectual dishonesty which is not shocking, of course, but the intellectual dishonesty of the Biden administration and the arguments they made to the court to get this decision where they can now go cut the razor wire.
- 9:30Rick Green: They literally argue I just gotta read this to you.
- 9:33Rick Green: They literally argue that they're enforcing the statutes right, that they're there for a purpose.
- 9:37Rick Green: Now they only use the words like if I remember right, it was interrogate, process, possibly apprehend.
- 9:45Rick Green: The statute actually says that the reason they have the ability to come within 25 miles of the border and enter these areas is "for the purpose of patrolling the border to prevent the illegal entry of aliens into the United States.
- 10:01Rick Green: And they're standing before the court saying you know what?
- 10:05Rick Green: We need to move those evil Texans out of the way and cut the razor wire out of the way so that we can do our job.
- 10:11Rick Green: And then, instead of preventing the illegal entry of aliens into the United States, the whole case is around this September 20th day where they literally threw a rope, they literally put a ladder rope down and helped the illegal aliens, cut the razor wire through the rope down, helped 4,555 illegal aliens that day.
- 10:31Rick Green: And then they did not apprehend them, they did not interrogate them, they did not detain them or any of those things.
- 10:36Rick Green: They literally said hey, walk that way, it's gonna be a mile.
- 10:40Rick Green: And then you know, would you please stop at the processing center there and guess what?
- 10:45Rick Green: Half about half, little more than half showed up for processing a mile down the road.
- 10:50Rick Green: Where'd the rest go?
- 10:51Rick Green: We have no idea.
- 10:52Rick Green: So my whole point is they're literally standing in front of the court saying the Texans are not letting us fulfill the law, and then they're turning around and on camera not fulfilling the law.
- 11:01Rick Green: They're doing the opposite of fulfilling the law and that's why Texas, I think, has such a good argument for saying nope, you do not have the right to cut our razor wire and go in there and aid in a bet the breaking of the law.
- 11:14David Barton: And going with that, I'll remind people that when Governor Abbott took his oath of office, it was not an oath just to uphold the state laws of Texas and the Constitution of Texas.
- 11:23David Barton: It was the laws and the Constitution of the federal government in the United States.
- 11:26David Barton: His oath of office was to uphold all those laws state and federal and so if the government's not going to uphold his federal laws, he's simply doing what he took an oath to do, and that was uphold federal laws.
- 11:36David Barton: But I've heard a whole lot of discussion on this and I think most people have missed a really key point here.
- 11:42David Barton: The Supreme Court did not order that Abbott has to take that razor wire down and say razor wire is unconstitutional.
- 11:49David Barton: They did not.
- 11:49David Barton: They had a 5-4 decision and there is no written explanation by any justice.
- 11:55David Barton: It's just a 5-4 procedural decision that said, hey, we're going to vacate what the Fifth Circuit did.
- 12:00David Barton: We're going to let that trial go all the way through.
- 12:03David Barton: We'll weigh in on this later.
- 12:04David Barton: So all we're doing is we're simply saying the Fifth Circuit, we're going to vacate it and they need to go through with the trial.
- 12:10David Barton: So the Supreme Court did not do anything in the sense of saying, hey, you have to tear down that razor wire that Texas illegally put up.
- 12:18David Barton: That's not it.
- 12:19David Barton: Media's been covering it wrong.
- 12:20David Barton: So all it is is an unsigned opinion 5-4, that they're vacating the Fifth Circuit decision and the Fifth Circuit is over Texas, Louisiana and Mississippi.
- 12:31David Barton: So that's the federal court that said, hey, there's going to be a trial on this, and they simply vacated the early part of that decision.
- 12:37David Barton: There's no decision about the Supreme Court on this yet at all.
- 12:41Tim Barton: Well, the part they vacated was that Biden and his team could not cut down a razor wire.
- 12:48Tim Barton: So, vacating, it then says, okay, Biden and his team can cut down a razor wire.
- 12:51Tim Barton: What it doesn't mean and what it did not say is that Abbott and Texas can't put up razor wire.
- 12:58Tim Barton: What's super interesting is now you have this weird kind of dichotomy of, well, somebody can put it up and somebody can take it down, and neither one has been declared the winner and neither one has been declared right or wrong.
- 13:12Tim Barton: And so, even as Biden has been saying, Texas, get out of the way and whatever kind of threat and force they're going to try to use and leverage and we're seeing that unfold even this week.
- 13:21Tim Barton: We're seeing that happen where Abbott doesn't want to back down, Biden doesn't want to back down.
- 13:26Tim Barton: But this is where even seeing how this plays out in the lower courts and I'm sure it's going to be appealed, no matter who does what going up and now you have so many states that are siding with Texas on this and are encouraging Texas on this.
- 13:40Tim Barton: This is something that is also going to be interesting to see how it plays out in the polls.
- 13:44Tim Barton: It's something that will be interesting to see what Trump does, which guys, on the break we were talking about, or I guess, before we got started, even kind of alluding to some of this, it'll be interesting if this is something that positions Governor Abbott.
- 14:02Tim Barton: Maybe that Trump says you know a guy that's willing to fight this fight maybe should be a vice president.
- 14:06Tim Barton: We would have other reasons that you know, maybe we're not a fan of Abbott in some areas because what happened early on in COVID.
- 14:11Tim Barton: Maybe he's learned his lesson, I'm not sure.
- 14:13Tim Barton: Nonetheless, it'll be very interesting to see how this plays out in the landscape of the presidential election and other things going forward.
- 14:23Rick Green: Yeah, you know you talked about the other states supporting, I think, one of my favorite quotes.
- 14:27Rick Green: Well, of course, DeSantis had a great quote where he was saying do you really think the founding fathers would have ratified the Constitution if it meant that they could not protect their own borders?
- 14:38Rick Green: And then, do you really think Texas would have joined the union if it meant they can't protect their own borders?
- 14:43Rick Green: I thought that was great.
- 14:44Rick Green: And then there was this really fun when Christy Noem said if Texas needs more, she's a governor of South Dakota there.
- 14:49Rick Green: She said if Texas needs more razor wire, I'll load it up in my pickup truck and bring it to you.
- 14:54Rick Green: I thought that was great, too.
- 14:55Rick Green: All right, guys, quick break.
- 14:57Rick Green: We got the last part of David's question.
- 14:59Rick Green: When we come back has to do with essentially federalizing the Texas National Guard.
- 15:05Rick Green: Stay with us folks.
- 15:06Rick Green: You're listening to The Wall Builders Show.
- 15:11Tim Barton: Hi friends! This is Tim Barton of Wall Builders.
- 15:13Tim Barton: This is a time when most Americans don't know much about American history or even heroes of the faith, and I know oftentimes for parents we're trying to find good content for our kids to read and if you remember, back to the Bible, the book of Hebrews, it has the faith hall of fame where they outlined the leaders of faith that had gone before them.
- 15:28Tim Barton: Well, this is something that, as Americans, we really want to go back and outline some of these heroes, not just of American history, but heroes of Christianity and our faith as well.
- 15:36Tim Barton: I want to let you know about some biographical sketches we have available on our website.
- 15:39Tim Barton: One is called the Courageous Leaders Collection and this collection includes people like Abigail Adams, Abraham Lincoln, Francis Scott Key, George Washington Carver, Susanna Wesley, even the Wright brothers, and there's a second collection called Heroes of History.
- 15:51Tim Barton: In this collection you'll read about people like Benjamin Franklin or Christopher Columbus, Daniel Boone, George Washington, Harriet Tubman.
- 15:58Tim Barton: Friends, the list goes on and on.
- 15:59Tim Barton: This is a great collection for your young person to have and read and it's a providential view of American and Christian history.
- 16:05Tim Barton: This is available at wallbuilders.
- 16:06Tim Barton: com.
- 16:07Tim Barton: This is www.
- 16:09Tim Barton: wallbuilders.
- 16:09Tim Barton: com.
- 16:11Rick Green: We're back here on WallBuilders.
- 16:15Rick Green: Thanks for staying with us and we're in the middle of a three-part question from David in League City.
- 16:20Rick Green: David, thanks for the question.
- 16:21Rick Green: We sort of covered the whole, can Governor Abbott use the Texas National Guard and the DPS to protect the border?
- 16:28Rick Green: And we didn't really get into the Constitutional provisions,
- 16:31Rick Green: but of course Governor Abbott is now stating exactly what we've said for years Article IV, section IV it's the federal government's responsibility to repel an invasion and protect against an invasion.
- 16:40Rick Green: It's the guarantee clause.
- 16:41Rick Green: And then Article I, section X if the federal government's not doing its job and there's imminent danger, can do what it needs to do, and I think it's still going to have to do more.
- 16:50Rick Green: You've got to take those folks and place them back across the border.
- 16:52Rick Green: But this is still a big step.
- 16:55Rick Green: And even the language in his statement last week was really strong, stronger than he's ever said.
- 17:00Rick Green: He literally said that the federal government broke the compact with the states.
- 17:05Rick Green: So that's the first two and kind, of the battle, over this decision.
- 17:09Rick Green: By the way, the court case is all about property and whether or not you can destroy the chattel of the state, whether or not the feds can do that.
- 17:15Rick Green: So it's not even technically the Constitutional question of securing the border, but it's being used for that particular question.
- 17:21Rick Green: Okay, now guys, to the third question, can?
- 17:24Rick Green: So yeah, this is a great question.
- 17:26Rick Green: So what happens if President Biden says well, you're using the Texas National Guard to secure the border, I'm just going to nationalize, I'm going to call up the National Guard and then I have control! Interesting question,
- 17:40David Barton: You know, this is one of those shared responses and, by the way, David asked here.
- 17:44David Barton: He said I've heard that some Texas Democrat members of Congress are calling for President Biden to take control of the Texas National Guard.
- 17:49David Barton: I would say that if you eliminate those last five words, he's got it really right.
- 17:55David Barton: If you said I've heard that some Democrat, Texas Democrat members of Congress are calling for President Biden to take control, that's it.
- 18:02David Barton: They want to take control of everything.
- 18:03David Barton: They want to take control of climate, they want to take control of everything.
- 18:07David Barton: So it doesn't have much to do with the Texas National Guard.
- 18:09David Barton: That's just the excuse.
- 18:10David Barton: But going back to that, the Texas National Guard, people need to understand that the guard can be called up by the President, but you have to have a declaration of some kind of emergency, so you can call them up for, hurricane Katrina, we need help with law and order and we need help with rescues and the floods and we need to keep looters out of the stores.
- 18:30David Barton: Whatever, it doesn't have to be an act of war or insurrection, just some kind of national emergency where you've got to have some kind of help.
- 18:38David Barton: And that's been done a number of times.
- 18:40Rick Green: You know, David, this is a great point you're making because, hey, the border's fine, there's no emergency down there, it's all secure,
- 18:47David Barton: That's
- 18:49Rick Green: Yeah, how does he say, on one hand, hey, there's an emergency, I got to call the Texas National Guard, and then, on the other hand, you just play the clips of he and Kamala saying, oh, there's no problem at the border, everything's great, Mayorkas saying everything's great at the border, it's perfectly secure.
- 19:02Rick Green: Well then, what's the emergency?
- 19:04David Barton: Yeah, and why are you calling up the Texas Guard if there is no emergency?
- 19:08David Barton: Because you can't just take it over.
- 19:10David Barton: Now, Texas is one of 23 states that also have organized state militias.
- 19:15David Barton: So we have not only the Texas National Guard, we've got the Texas State Guard, but the National Guard what happens is Governor Abbott is over the National Guard.
- 19:25David Barton: That is a Texas force.
- 19:26David Barton: It can be called into federal service, but he's also got the Texas State Guard, which can be called in the state service.
- 19:32David Barton: 23 states have that.
- 19:33David Barton: Other states ought to develop it, by the way, if you're a state, you ought to get your own state guard.
- 19:38David Barton: You need your own organized militias and extra forces for emergencies and whatever crisis comes along.
- 19:44David Barton: So Abbott is still in charge of the Texas National Guard and I firmly believe that if Biden were to say, hey, I'm taking the Texas National Guard and we're going to keep Texas from tearing down razor wire, I think that Abbott would directly counterman that order and you would have a good fight in court and I think the state would win on that.
- 20:04David Barton: I think the state would win on that particular issue because if there's not an emergency, you can't just call them up and federalize them just because you want to.
- 20:11David Barton: This is one of those shared responsibilities that goes all the way back to the American War for Independence.
- 20:16Rick Green: I have a question for you then, and I may be wrong on this.
- 20:19Rick Green: Guys correct my memory, but when they did the whole calling up the National Guard and had all the fences and everything around the Capitol and Washington DC look like a war zone for a while there with the overreaction, didn't some governors actually call their National Guard back?
- 20:38Rick Green: So wouldn't that be kind of the same tug of war there, or give and take?
- 20:45David Barton: They did.
- 20:45David Barton: Absolutely and it would be.
- 20:46David Barton: And there was a number of states that said we refuse to participate in this and a number of governors called their National Guard home because that National Guard is under the control of the governor.
- 20:57David Barton: Now you know it can't be federalized in the right situation, but that sure wasn't J6.
- 21:01David Barton: J6 wasn't the right situation and there's no way they were going to win that in court.
- 21:06David Barton: And so there were a number of those guards that did come home right, you're exactly right.
- 21:11David Barton: And on the other hand you did have the riots back in Little Rock in 1954 and segregation, where Eisenhower federalized the Arkansas National Guard and moved them away from enforcing segregation.
- 21:24David Barton: They moved in the 101st Airborne to take the place of the Arkansas National Guard.
- 21:28David Barton: So there's there's times and places where you've seen it go kind of both ways.
- 21:32David Barton: But I don't think Biden would have a leg to stand on in a court, at least in a Constitutional court.
- 21:38David Barton: He might in the San Francisco court, although I've got to say we've seen some really interesting rulings coming out of the Ninth Circuit in the last couple of years that really do appear that they're reading the Constitution again, which is good news as well.
- 21:51Tim Barton: We know guys, it would be interesting too, we know a lot of people in the National Guard and if they got such an order it would be quite fascinating to see if there'd be pushback.
- 22:02Tim Barton: One of the things that we recognize every member supposed to be, of Congress, of public service, but certainly the military.
- 22:09Tim Barton: They take an oath to uphold the Constitution, to defend against all enemies, foreign and domestic, and I think there'd be people recognizing there's an invasion.
- 22:17Tim Barton: And if the president is doing things to the detriment l of America, I would be very curious what level of pushback or reticence or resistance there would be, because I suspect there would be some.
- 22:29Tim Barton: Now I think it probably would be more vocal retired people speaking out explaining that some of their friends still involved.
- 22:34Tim Barton: They're not excited, they don't wanna do it.
- 22:36Tim Barton: But when you talk about a really difficult position with the potential of resistance from inside your own National Guard, it certainly could be over this kind of issue and I'm not sure if Biden sees it or not, I'm not sure what people are telling him or advising him.
- 22:57Tim Barton: But I know a lot of people in active military and National Guard on reserves and I mean the people I know they would certainly want to defer to obedience to the commander in chief, but they also recognize and especially after COVID, this became a much stronger reality for many of them.
- 23:17Tim Barton: They also recognize that they have responsibility to not follow unconstitutional orders to a certain extent, and this certainly could be a situation that could raise some questions for many people.
- 23:30David Barton: And I think there's another factor here that is worth remembering and that is that before Abbott became governor he was the attorney general and he argued and won a number of cases at the US Supreme Court over Constitutional issues, over original intent kind of issues.
- 23:46David Barton: And so I think he is one guy that if he felt like that he was being pushed or the president was stepping in to do something that was not within constitutional bounds, I think Abbott would mount a very aggressive resistance.
- 24:01David Barton: Now I don't mean physical armed resistance, I mean a legal resistance in the sense of he's not gonna go along with that.
- 24:07David Barton: So, Tim, to go to where you are, not only would there be internal pressure from the guard members, I think there would be external pressure from the governor and from the staff and from most of the Texas leaders, right down through the attorney general himself, to fight that.
- 24:21David Barton: I think it'd be very, very difficult for Biden to be able to pull that off.
- 24:25David Barton: So, David, great question, lots of stuff talked about, but bottom line is don't let how that decision, the Supreme Court decision of last week, is being portrayed now suggests that the Supreme Court has taken a position that what Texas is doing on the border is unconstitutional, illegal and has to stop, cause that was not the decision at all.
- 24:45David Barton: That was not it in any way, shape, fashion or form.
- 24:47David Barton: I think this is gonna move probably toward the right constitutional conclusion by the time this Fifth Circuit trial is over.
- 24:55David Barton: I think you'll get a really strong constitutional decision out of the Fifth Circuit and I think the Supreme Court will probably defer to that once it's gone through the circuit.
- 25:03David Barton: But we'll see.
- 25:04David Barton: I don't think the Supreme Court has enough.
- 25:06David Barton: And, by the way, Rick, you and I and Tim were talking about this earlier.
- 25:11David Barton: It appeared that two of the more conservative justices, although not the most conservative, that's Roberts and Amy Coney Barrett.
- 25:17David Barton: It appeared that they went with the liberals on this thing, and I would say that no, it's not really going with the liberals.
- 25:24David Barton: I think that they have a view that it's the federal government that's to be in charge of immigration, not the states.
- 25:29David Barton: And I don't think they took a position on the razor wire.
- 25:32David Barton: I think they took a position on no, no, no.
- 25:34David Barton: This is really more of a federal issue than a state issue, and so I think that's where they came down, not ruling at all in the merits of what was going on, of that thing.
- 25:42David Barton: So even when you see that Roberts and Amy Coney Barrett were on the other side of the liberals, that doesn't mean that they've gone liberal.
- 25:49David Barton: It means that there is a federalism argument that they are probably having in their mind that says, hey, the feds do have a role in this and let it work out the Fifth Circuit.
- 25:58David Barton: So still a lot to go on this.
- 26:00David Barton: I don't think it'll end up the way the media has been portraying this thing, and I think they've really mis-portrayed it badly over the last eight to 10 days on this thing.
- 26:08Rick Green: And with there being no opinions written and it just being a decision, there's no way for us to know.
- 26:12Rick Green: I mean, it could be as simple as them thinking you know this is too big of an issue for the injunction to stay in place.
- 26:17Rick Green: We want to wait until we see the full merits of the case.
- 26:20Rick Green: It could be as simple as that.
- 26:22Rick Green: Maybe they just wanted the injunction to go away.
- 26:23Rick Green: Again, nothing decided on the merits at this point, so it's going to be really interesting to watch.
- 26:27Rick Green: Well, David from League City, thank you for sending this in.
- 26:29Rick Green: You have the rare distinction of the entire program being devoted to your set of questions.
- 26:34Rick Green: So great job sending those in.
- 26:36Rick Green: Folks, send more to us at radio@ wallbuilderscom, and we'll hit those next week.
- 26:41Rick Green: Thanks so much for listening.
- 26:42Rick Green: You've been listening to Wall Builders.