Latest / The Sperrins: Mining, Power & Community in Northern Ireland / #No.35 When “Public” Isn’t Public . A conversation with Gerard Moyne and Sean Gallagher
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome, Sean and Gerard, and it's a great pleasure to have
- 0:03you on here today.
- 0:05And thanks very much.
- 0:11So Sean, can you tell me a little bit about yourself, your
- 0:16background and sort of how you've ended up being involved
- 0:21in this. But before we get into our main topic, a little bit
- 0:26from a short overview, I live in Lata Kenny.
- 0:32I've been living here since his late 70s,
- 0:36originally from the given area, so I have a very big interest in
- 0:41the spurn mountains, okay,
- 0:44because I grew up on them,
- 0:48but I here. And then for 30 years, I worked organic culture
- 0:55for supplying
- 0:57supply and vegetables and herbs to local restaurants, mainly.
- 1:01And then I taught organic gardening to on certain courses
- 1:06throughout Donegal.
- 1:08And therefore, when I got into my late into my 50s, I thought
- 1:16my organic garden was of an interest from the environment,
- 1:19trying to work with the environment, and showing people
- 1:21you can work, you know, you poison the land, etc, etc. So
- 1:25then I decided, then in the 50s, I wanted to
- 1:29go back and study law so I can use that as a law, as a resource
- 1:34to help to work for the environment. And so I did a law
- 1:38degree and Larry Kenny, and then I've done my master's in
- 1:41environmental law and UCC and cork.
- 1:46And from that, then
- 1:48I got, I was working, I got in touch with Tony Lowes. Well,
- 1:51actually, Tony Lowes got in touch with me through the
- 1:53lecture and UCC, and it kind of linked me in then with
- 1:57environmental campaigns. So it was, it was, I thought it was
- 2:00good to have a group here in Donegal. So I approached people
- 2:03like Jared and couple other people
- 2:08to get a wee group together to
- 2:11over to use our knowledge and legal knowledge to help to
- 2:17defend the environment. So we started a group called defend
- 2:20environmental wealth. And here we are. We've been successful in
- 2:25a few campaigns, but I suppose the sperm, sperm mining issue is
- 2:33probably the biggest thing we've got involved in. Positively,
- 2:37Jared, that's my overview. Thank you. Thank you, Sean, that's
- 2:40very interesting, and half of that I wasn't aware of. And I
- 2:44must come back to you, I have some parallel I have a parallel
- 2:47track in my life. You know?
- 2:51Yeah, I would have been an organic teacher as well and
- 2:55grew organically. I worked in the organic centre Leitrim for a
- 2:58number of years. You know that? Especially years ago. I visited
- 3:05a lot, you know, yeah, and I did a post grad in environmental
- 3:08decision making with the Open University,
- 3:12all many years ago, you know. So, yes, we're in the we're in
- 3:16the same chat about that again. Hi and I HR
- 3:22and Gerard, tell us a little about yourself.
- 3:26I'm the reluctant hero.
- 3:30Right myself, I only got into, I suppose, in academia circles. I
- 3:37only
- 3:39lifted that in my 50s and got a degree in Community Development,
- 3:46and then subsequently, recently, I did a diploma in science
- 3:50through the University of Galway. With regards to
- 3:53organics, I'm actually an agent for an organic supplier,
- 4:01an Ireland fruit Hill Farm in corks. Oh yes, I do. I know
- 4:06them. Of course, I've often bought off them. So I'm there.
- 4:09I'm their doone girl. Agent, pretty good. So myself and Sean
- 4:14were out yesterday delivering compost and seeds throughout
- 4:18Donegal. Anyway, how do I get into the environmental thing? I
- 4:22was dragged in it through the court,
- 4:26because in 1997
- 4:28and I worked in the coal industry for 30 years, and oil
- 4:34and we had a family business. And in 1997 I stupidly, I
- 4:41suppose, at that time, wrote to my local authority complaining
- 4:45bitterly of the dumping of toxic waste in Donegal.
- 4:49Long story short, I
- 4:53wrote the letter. About six weeks later, I was served with a
- 4:57planning infringement injunction.
- 5:01And then I spent 21 times in the High Court with my local
- 5:04authority, and it was
- 5:07basically the deliverance of a message, hold your tongue. We've
- 5:12beggar fish to fry. So
- 5:16that's where the brown envelope came. Thesis came in because I
- 5:21realised Weinstein might have been a local business person. I
- 5:25was a very small fish in a very large pool of complicity to
- 5:31commit criminal acts.
- 5:34And so
- 5:36I became very familiar with the law very quickly, because
- 5:41in my local authorities
- 5:45trial,
- 5:46I took on to educate myself because I figured this was going
- 5:50to cost me a fortune.
- 5:52So as a lay litigant, I represented myself in the High
- 5:56Court 21 times. So that was interesting,
- 6:01and you know,
- 6:04the tipping, the tipping, the cap to authority, didn't, I
- 6:08didn't read that chapter, but
- 6:14so anyway, you got a long story short in 2005
- 6:20because of this case, which is relating to the 13 acre dump
- 6:25just up the road, and it's now 29th year of non action.
- 6:31I was forced into voluntary liquidation by just basically
- 6:37the bullying of our local authority and other matters. So
- 6:45I've been fighting for the environment since even though I
- 6:50was always an environmentalist, but I didn't know it. Yeah, I
- 6:55wasn't aware of my role walking the rivers fishing, you know,
- 7:02and my great interest in protecting the environment by
- 7:05what I did was doing anyway, without the help of others or
- 7:08even knowledge. So that's, that's where I come from. Then,
- 7:13of course, we met Sean, and we've been, I was sure we've
- 7:18been doing great work since we've been. I we don't even get
- 7:21a Christmas card from the local authority anymore.
- 7:25Yeah, but Jared, you've got to mention your your famous
- 7:28beekeeper? Oh, yes. Well, yes, yes. Go on. Debbie. Well, I am a
- 7:33beekeeper, and that's where the science diploma came in, because
- 7:38through university of Galway, I did a diploma in science through
- 7:42the topic being beekeeping,
- 7:45which is very interesting, because I brought it up at the
- 7:48meeting last night.
- 7:50I said,
- 7:52I actually have a herd number imagine for your bees, for my
- 7:57bees, yes,
- 8:02because no, they don't individually have to have tags
- 8:07on their ears.
- 8:12I'll make you,
- 8:14make you laugh again in a few moments. So I've been at the
- 8:17bees since 2016 so I'm very much an infant in this, but I'm not a
- 8:23great believer in this ideology of I've got 30 years experience.
- 8:29A colleague of mine once, once said, is it 30 years or one
- 8:33year? 30 times?
- 8:36So anyway,
- 8:39so yes, I have to have a herd number. And this is very
- 8:42important, I suppose, because in Donegal, I think anyone that has
- 8:47gone through the roads here in Donegal, especially in an issue,
- 8:51have seen oysters and mussels been moved all over the place,
- 8:56one of the one without licence or concern moving problems from
- 9:04Lough foil to Los wolley Loch foil. None of the oysters coming
- 9:08out of Lough Foyle are actually allowed to be used for human
- 9:11consumption because there's no licencing. Yeah, yeah. Yet, yet,
- 9:16they're coming out onto the roads of any shown, and they've
- 9:19been moved to Los wolley and trebega Bay in cairndana and
- 9:24other places all over Ireland without either concern or
- 9:27licencing, or
- 9:30where myself, as a beekeeper, I sell honey in butcher shops
- 9:36locally,
- 9:38the local authorities go into the
- 9:42Environmental Health go into the butcher shop and look for my
- 9:45herd number on the jars.
- 9:49Now here and I have to be inspected every year, one, one,
- 9:53once a year, the environmental health inspector comes to my
- 9:56home to inspect, am I labelling correctly? Am.
- 10:00I doing all the and I think it's wonderful that this is done, you
- 10:04know, that I'm doing the correct thing, but yet here we have
- 10:09100,000
- 10:10trestles of oysters in Lough Foyle been moved all over
- 10:15Ireland without a will. Narrowway. It's
- 10:19incredible, isn't it? It's incredible. So the very people
- 10:22whom, like the sea protection authority based in Greencastle,
- 10:28are, I call it, what if you could call the conspiracy of
- 10:33anonymity. They cannot be seen to be doing their job. And
- 10:39that's from yourself and Sean come in, we have, I liken it to
- 10:44becoming the barking dog. So every corner they go round,
- 10:48we're standing there chained to the ground.
- 10:55But anyway, I'll
- 10:57finish on this note
- 10:59the So October last year, my my wife's she's not my doctor, but
- 11:04she has a doctor, a medical doctor, and I rang her one
- 11:07morning, and I says, Hello, love. How you doing? I said, I'm
- 11:10coming in to see you.
- 11:13I'm only 10 minutes away, because I just got stung with a
- 11:16B. And she went, Oh, shit.
- 11:20So anyway, I was right in the midst of anaphylaxis, and it's
- 11:25not funny, and I've been strong hundreds of times. So since last
- 11:30year, I've been going to for immunotherapy
- 11:35for three months. I had to go down every Sunday to Galway,
- 11:39and now I'm going down every six weeks. And for anyone out there
- 11:43that has bees and knows someone that has become allergic, it's
- 11:48really, really important to know that there are as a cure out
- 11:52there. And I'm loving it. I didn't give up my bees. I still
- 11:57have them. And, yeah, all good. Oh, that's really interesting,
- 12:00because my other half had bees here, and that happened to him,
- 12:05and he gave them up. He gave them up 20 years ago. You know,
- 12:07it was getting too dangerous. So that's that's interesting. And I
- 12:13have someone else here connected through one of my kids, who's
- 12:17doing a beekeeping course at the minute and is looking forward to
- 12:21putting hives on the place here this summer, so I must connect
- 12:25them up to you at some point.
- 12:32Me,
- 12:36me, yeah, how about 20? No, you're more than that. Well,
- 12:42there's a podcast. You've got 20
- 12:46Sean. Those are the legal ones.
- 12:51Does each hive have a herd number, or does No? No, just me?
- 12:55All right, okay, and that's interesting. And so honey on the
- 13:01back, on the labels, on the honey, should have heard number
- 13:04on the label, if it's real honey, and if it's if it's any
- 13:08concern, I would please, please, please, even though it's
- 13:12expensive, buy from your local beekeeper. Oh, yeah, and do not
- 13:16touch that sugar syrup. That's yeah, past this honey. Yeah, I
- 13:21know. I know that for years, but I just see other honey around
- 13:26for sale, around the place, and I'm suspicious of it. Let's put
- 13:29it like that, totally, totally
- 13:32okay. Let's get to the point of this conversation. So
- 13:37last year, June, January, 2020
- 13:4025
- 13:42our public inquiry for the gold mine planning application was
- 13:48suspended due to lack of a trans boundary consultation. Now I
- 13:53want to
- 13:55sort of drag you back to that time and
- 14:01so I kind of know now why you got involved. But was there any
- 14:04other reason you particularly got involved in relation to the
- 14:07trans boundary
- 14:10issue at that time? Had you been aware of it before you were
- 14:14approached by one of us, or just tell the story the circumstances
- 14:19around it? Sean, if you want to go ahead or Well,
- 14:24I've always, I've been involved with Ken, oh yes, yeah, for for
- 14:30years now, yeah, good number of years since the foundation of
- 14:32it, you know, yeah. And so I was very aware of what's happening
- 14:39in Tyrone. Visited the place a couple of times and and then,
- 14:44with my
- 14:46knowledge and law, it's just, I mean, there's been no proper
- 14:50transboundary consultation here. You know,
- 14:54when
- 14:57Ireland and Britain are both sick.
- 15:00Just to the Espoo, which is the
- 15:03which
- 15:05is 45 countries in Europe are signed up to that
- 15:10too, and that's basically to to prevent and reduce and control
- 15:13significant adverse transboundary environmental from
- 15:18proposed activities. And that has to be done, and as a legal
- 15:22stand. So I noticed that this wasn't happening, so obviously
- 15:28I pointed that out in our submission, but obviously
- 15:32Donegal county council was trying to evade the issue. And
- 15:36can I just stop you there from
- 15:39can you remember when Donegal county council actually put out
- 15:44the public consultation? Was it in December, or was it earlier?
- 15:48Was it december two? It was before Christmas. And obviously,
- 15:52it's a holiday period, yeah, and it was, it was very close to
- 15:58Christmas, like it was, like within a day or two of
- 16:00Christmas, wasn't it? Yeah, exactly. And they published it
- 16:04on the fifth of December, I believe, which
- 16:08giving the 30 days it ran up and included the Christmas,
- 16:14Christmas holiday break. But that was, that was
- 16:18a contrived event. Yes, I know, I know that, but I just wanted
- 16:23for people who will be listening to from the outside and know
- 16:26nothing about it. So it was, was it about two weeks or three
- 16:30weeks was given, in total, something like that for the
- 16:33public consultation? Yes, yeah, yeah. I was trying to look it
- 16:37up, and I just couldn't see when it actually went out, you know,
- 16:41so taking it from there. Then Sean,
- 16:47so the the
- 16:49public inquiry open. Can you hear me? Sean, oh, yes, I hear
- 16:53you. The Public Inquiry opens, and day one,
- 16:59and Sean and Gerard pier,
- 17:05we sent another submission and pointed out transboundary
- 17:09aspects of it, you know, which are obvious from land soil,
- 17:13every part of the FX drones could be, in fact, done August
- 17:17were, were hydrological linked.
- 17:23We're conscious beside each house, obviously would have
- 17:26taken so I'd want to interesting material myself and Jared went
- 17:31over to Omer to the opening, and I went up and just to put
- 17:39another copy of because I had suspicions that Donegal County
- 17:42Council wasn't going to get this and in time, actually, I knew
- 17:45the one could get
- 17:47sold it. Yeah, I went up to the table and slapped down on the
- 17:51table big brown envelope of their submissions, and that, I
- 17:56think, annoyed them, so they asked how it started. Maybe
- 17:59Jared you can mention
- 18:03what happened there? Yeah,
- 18:07what
- 18:09you just mentioned the late submission the Donegal credit
- 18:13Council. This is how,
- 18:16how inept they are. They sent it into the king's Council. That's
- 18:21the DFI at 10 past Friday, 10 past five on the Friday night
- 18:28before the public inquiry.
- 18:3110 past five, yeah, so they didn't have time to even look at
- 18:35it. It had supposed to have been in with them in the October of
- 18:41the previous year, and they just didn't bother their ass because
- 18:44they felt it's this is insignificant. So the Friday
- 18:47morning the previous night, I printed five copies of our
- 18:50submission, and that, by the way, I don't carry round brown
- 18:55envelopes,
- 18:57really,
- 18:59but I had to say we made an exception in this case. So and
- 19:05so we took five copies of our submission up, and Sean had
- 19:08written on the outside of it our, I think our, D, E, W,
- 19:12submission to the public inquiry. My recollection is
- 19:17correct. So Sean put it up on the table, and then I seen a
- 19:21member of security go immediately up and lift it off
- 19:25the table and then wander around the hall with it, not knowing
- 19:28what to do with this and and so then the fun began. I thought,
- 19:35so, right, what's going to happen here? So security looked
- 19:41at it. Everybody looked at it, but they sat it back up on the
- 19:44table, then they took it off the table. So then the the chair of
- 19:49the commission, the commissioners, came in, and they
- 19:51greeted everybody, and she then said, Who put this envelope on
- 19:57my table? You know? And.
- 20:00Member as well, and I and so everybody was looking around. So
- 20:06we looked around as well,
- 20:12you know, more or less. And, you know, Oh, it wasn't us.
- 20:16So, so that that came. Then she said it again, and I thought,
- 20:23then that point, I stood up and I said, you know, it was myself
- 20:28and Sean and that, that that began the nightmare for Fyffe,
- 20:37because I truly believe they they honestly believe nobody was
- 20:43going to show and they weren't, and because of the lack of
- 20:48interest by the Irish government, Irish state, not
- 20:52just, yeah, not Council,
- 20:56the Irish state, because of their lack of interest and their
- 20:59lack of knowledge of their
- 21:03need to comply with legislation. You know, as a friend of mine
- 21:07once said, He says, The great thing about the Republic of
- 21:10Ireland, he says, When the European Union
- 21:14bring in new directives, new legislation, Ireland is quite
- 21:17unique in the fact that it generally is very quick on the
- 21:22ball to bring that into Irish law. But the other side of it is
- 21:27they are also unique, and they enforce none of it,
- 21:36you know. So, so anyway, that's where the
- 21:42chairperson asked myself and Sean to come down and others
- 21:47people of interest, to come down to the blank tables, to sit with
- 21:52the elite, you know,
- 21:55or beside the elite of all the legal teams. And that's why,
- 22:00getting back to my original case, is that when you've got
- 22:04people who are legal kings council or solicitors firms,
- 22:11they don't know what to do with you. That's right, they have no
- 22:15idea, because you you, they have no idea. And you know the the
- 22:22because they show deference to each other, because they know
- 22:27that. You know, as a friend of mine, I've got two friends, but
- 22:32the other friend, the other friend, says to me at one time,
- 22:36it was a case held in the court in letter Kenny, and a man went
- 22:39to the solicitors firm, and he said, I can't represent you, but
- 22:42here's a note for a guy down the down the street. He'd represent
- 22:47you. And on the way down, he went, open the note and it and
- 22:50it read two fat geese, one for you and one for me. And that's a
- 22:56true story that was a customer of mine, an old man and never
- 23:01came in. And that's what that son of a gun wrote on that bed
- 23:05of paper. He should have been struck off. And he turned
- 23:07around, and he went back up the road, and he sorted the thing
- 23:10out with his neighbour, which he should have done in the first
- 23:13place, but that's but that's what they treat each other. The
- 23:18we are the geese. Yeah, yeah, treat us with a certain level of
- 23:24contempt. Contempt, absolutely. And look, you've seen
- 23:29the Council for deradian talking about his trousers down around
- 23:35his ass. You know, he made that comment to me,
- 23:39and I thought, how rude can you get you know? But anyway, so the
- 23:46we only learned them. We went home. We went there on the
- 23:50Tuesday while they were arguing, and we went there we were, oh
- 23:54no, that's right, we decided not to go back on the Wednesday. And
- 23:58I was sitting in the pub at nine o'clock on the Tuesday night.
- 24:01And RTE rang me and said, Are you going to the the tribunal
- 24:06tomorrow, the inquiry? And I said, Well, I have no intentions
- 24:09of good. You better go. I says, why? He says they've admitted
- 24:14what Jews have said that they broke the law. Yeah, yeah. And I
- 24:19went, wow.
- 24:25Sean heard this more than the RTE guy. I can't remember his
- 24:29name. When we were walking up the steps into the choir
- 24:32inquiry, he made the comment, there's the two ball records
- 24:36from Donegal.
- 24:40I thought,
- 24:44but if I had any thing to say is,
- 24:50this has been a learning experience, and this is what
- 24:55it's so important for lay people, you have a voice and
- 24:59always.
- 25:00Believe that,
- 25:01and you can be heard, but there are others right there who will
- 25:05help you be heard. Yeah, that's so true,
- 25:10and it's using the law to break the law. Exactly.
- 25:18Sean, how did you feel when you heard the news, yeah, well,
- 25:24I was quite confident that we were on the right, you know,
- 25:29I was the only person myself and Jared, mean that there was
- 25:32report. I've talked to a few people at the beginning, and
- 25:36they said, This can't work. You know, they've totally ignored
- 25:40the transboundary issue, but I didn't expect it to all happen
- 25:43so quick, yeah, within, basically within 24 hours, you
- 25:48know? Yeah. And so that was,
- 25:53I say, as Jared alluded to, that was
- 25:58we felt, it was a we kind of felt we we done a good job, one
- 26:03for a better word, that we managed to
- 26:07put a spoken there in the procedure of trying to harm your
- 26:12environment, you know, because that's where I look at it, you
- 26:15know. So
- 26:17and after necessary measures to establish proper procedure with
- 26:22the public
- 26:24and
- 26:26prepare possibility and potential impacts on their
- 26:29environment and not carried out. And I felt I'd a good day's
- 26:33work. And both Jared and I felt we've done a good day's work.
- 26:36You know what it comes down to? Yeah, absolutely, from the point
- 26:41of save our sperms. Was a fantastic day's work. You know
- 26:44what it for all of us? You know the years we've spent on this,
- 26:49and the years that you guys have spent accumulating knowledge how
- 26:55to how to work around procedure and in relation to the
- 26:59environment, and boom, there. Does it works? As you were
- 27:02saying, George, you know, yeah. So my question is, then,
- 27:07so the trans boundary issue still exists. We're about to,
- 27:11we're start, we're about to start another public inquiry.
- 27:15And recently, I had on the podcast an expert from Dr
- 27:20Stephen emmerman from the yes, yeah, Utah in the USA. And his
- 27:26point was that
- 27:29that in relation to, say, a mine tailings dam, and the collapse
- 27:34of a mine tailings dam, one it's uninsurable,
- 27:39and there are none of them insured anywhere around the
- 27:41world, so it's a known risk, and it's not a matter of if, but
- 27:45when the mine tailings dam will collapse. And two, as part of
- 27:51the their application, dalradian ought to have had in a
- 27:55downstream
- 27:58plan for alerting communities such as yourselves and Donegal,
- 28:02but also the communities here, which are five miles, 10 miles,
- 28:061520, doesn't exist. It's not in the planning application at all.
- 28:10You know, yes. So I just wonder how,
- 28:14how do you, how do you think it's going to go forward from
- 28:17here in relation to the trans boundary aspect of it? Well, I
- 28:21just want to point
- 28:23out, only in the last few weeks we had rainstorms, downpours and
- 28:28unprotected downpours, and South East Ireland, you know, done
- 28:35massive damage. And this is now happening if they want to. So
- 28:39it's we have to follow a precautionary, Precautionary
- 28:42Principle within environmental law. And when someone cannot be
- 28:47predicted, or is uncertainty, you cannot go ahead with that.
- 28:51Now, the sperm mining application, it is, it is in
- 28:57raised ground, and we do not know when we're going to get
- 29:01that amount of rain would fall, and what damage it can do to
- 29:05terrains, for example, and what damage it can do to a water
- 29:10weighs, you know, so it's uncertain that cannot be even
- 29:16mitigated against, which is completely uncertain. So the
- 29:20project on that basis cannot go on. That's way I look at it, you
- 29:24know.
- 29:26So the
- 29:29hammered home come any inquiry,
- 29:32and April is April, I think it's to begin. That's right, yeah,
- 29:35and that uncertainty around the precautionary principle
- 29:41has to be hammered home. And that just not does not affect
- 29:44just the waterways and environment, the biodiversity in
- 29:48Toronto, born County Derry. It also affects the foil Donegal so
- 29:56trans boundary issue
- 29:58and F.
- 30:00If it doesn't meet the standard of
- 30:07impact, mitigate it can't mitigate against
- 30:10unpredictability, and we're living in an age of
- 30:14unpredictability as far as the environment.
- 30:19The other thing is which I think is important and and it relates
- 30:24to the trans boundary issue, it would appear that
- 30:29we, the people on the other side of this boundary, have been
- 30:35isolated in the fact that the people of Donegal will
- 30:41not know what's going on with this tribunal until it's over,
- 30:45because we have no access to it unless we wish to travel to
- 30:50Oman. So all those that have concerns have no
- 30:56there's going to, from what I can gather, that there will be
- 30:59no cameras. There will be no recording. It'll be all you know
- 31:06second hand knowledge. So how does the people of Donegal
- 31:11and further afield? Because this will relate, especially with
- 31:15air,
- 31:18the foil goes out and goes out into the Atlantic, and it goes
- 31:23right across the Donegal,
- 31:25North Donegal coast, and the north coast of Derry. But how do
- 31:30the people of Donegal
- 31:33are how are they going to get be informed?
- 31:37That is of concern to me personally, if there's no access
- 31:41to any information other than we go, we sit, we listen and we
- 31:46say, well, but we can't record it. So
- 31:50this is very strange to me. Very strange. Yeah, it seems to put a
- 31:55shot across the bowels of the art house convention, really,
- 31:58doesn't it? Totally, people are entitled to have access to
- 32:02information, right to know? Yeah, I believe we have. We're
- 32:08working on that. At the minute. We're making creating a case for
- 32:12that,
- 32:13which,
- 32:15in the short term, it takes them a long time to come back to when
- 32:20you're putting together an argument for the convention so
- 32:24it, you know, it may not be, it may not be quick enough for what
- 32:28we're dealing with right now. In your opinion,
- 32:33could the public inquiry be stopped again at this point
- 32:37because of that lack of Yes, yes, and I think, I think
- 32:40there's President on this. I do not know, right? Okay, I don't
- 32:44think I can't on the top of my head, but I won't look into it.
- 32:47I think there's been cases where it was compulsory to have it
- 32:52open to the public, like, you know, technology now it's very
- 32:54easily do. So, yeah, yeah. From zoom, etc, etc. And, okay,
- 33:00people can,
- 33:02can look on and see what's happening, maybe, and obviously
- 33:06not partake, but they can then delegate, or whatever. It's kind
- 33:11of, it's kind of an oxymoron, really, when you're using the
- 33:14term public inquiry, where you're holding it in camera, it
- 33:21is an oxymoron. Yes, absolutely correct. So I think that we're
- 33:27we should be quite confident and be stalwart to the public
- 33:32inquiry team. Is that, how can you you know there's a bloody
- 33:36subtle difference between public consultation and public
- 33:41participation, and this they are saying to us, oh, well, you can
- 33:47send in and I will say at this point, I am shamed beyond Shame,
- 33:55the
- 33:56submission by our local authority. It's dreadful yet
- 34:03again, thrown again at the 11th Hour. You know, appealing,
- 34:08appealing to the locks agency for a copy of their submission
- 34:12so they could
- 34:14take little bits and pieces out to make our submission look
- 34:17really nice and good when
- 34:21there was no concern, no interest in this whatsoever,
- 34:26probably left to the office intern or something. Well,
- 34:29whatever. I don't know, you know,
- 34:33like a senior planner, and I'm not denigrating the person that
- 34:39signed it off, but it doesn't appear to have been a team
- 34:42effort. It appeared to be, could you please send me some
- 34:45information so that I can copy and paste and that's what it
- 34:49was. And it's a dreadful, well, not overly dreadful, but it's an
- 34:54unthought out submission without and the consultation.
- 35:00Process as it was, again, last minute.com, throw it in, yeah,
- 35:05highly unprofessional as well. And it makes me actually wonder,
- 35:10you know, was, was it planned to be that way? Absolutely,
- 35:16absolutely, yeah, coming back to your point about the access to
- 35:24information for people in Donegal and further field. And
- 35:27you know this because this impact, this actually impacts
- 35:31the whole of Ireland. This, this planned application, because
- 35:34there's 28% of the Republic and 25%
- 35:38of Northern Ireland
- 35:41have are out with mining exploratory licences. So you
- 35:46know, everyone is interested. Everyone is watching.
- 35:51Not too long ago, two, three years back, maybe three, maybe
- 35:54no, maybe about four years ago, there was a huge as I call them,
- 35:57wind factories now, rather than wind farms, because that's what
- 36:00they are. Wind factories planned for a place called Brock Derg
- 36:05here in the spurns and that
- 36:10the PAC at that point,
- 36:14made the point of allowing access online and being able to
- 36:19record at that consultation and at that inquiry. So it you know
- 36:26what wonders that the President had already been set. It's not
- 36:29as if it's a new precedent, absolutely, and now
- 36:33this time, they seem to be driving a Coach and Horses
- 36:36through it, and deliberately, as you say, not allowing
- 36:41participation of interested parties in it. And it really is
- 36:45a blow to democracy. You know, if they can, if they can stop it
- 36:49for something like this, well, what else are they going to do
- 36:52that? We saw it happen where, many times over the past three
- 36:56or four years, when Emmet was
- 37:01he was elected
- 37:03for on, on on one issue, the mining issue, to sit on our
- 37:07District Council, and his mic was often muted in discussions,
- 37:11particularly through when we were in lockdown and he couldn't
- 37:15participate in the conversation. Do you know that is it's
- 37:19absolutely scandalous. Of course it is,
- 37:23and that's why, that's why we need to be stalwart in our in
- 37:26our
- 37:28sort of approach with respect to the inquiry
- 37:33and the team, to say, the people of Donegal have a right to be
- 37:38there and then, and that doesn't necessarily been mean in the
- 37:42room, because if a what are they going to do? Let's put a
- 37:46scenario here. 34,000 people from Donegal show up at the
- 37:51meeting
- 37:53Exactly, exactly, you know, let's get a crowd here and say,
- 37:57because they're saying, well, the only way you can participate
- 38:00is to come into the room. So what have we gathered up about
- 38:0350 buses of people and say, an idea, not a bad idea. We have a
- 38:08right. Yes, we have a right to attend.
- 38:16You know, you can't, no, you can't have your cake and eat it.
- 38:25Yeah, go ahead. Sean, no, it's just, I mean, it's the name,
- 38:29it's a public inquiry, so the public, we have to have a right
- 38:31to hear the inquiry. Yes, exactly.
- 38:38So now my next question is little slightly broader.
- 38:44So as people who are protecting and defending our environment,
- 38:51and as I pointed out last week at another meeting, you know,
- 38:55our governments are not protecting our environment, our
- 38:57political parties are not protecting our environment, our
- 39:01district councils are not protecting our environments,
- 39:04least not where it counts. And then there's one line left, and
- 39:09that's us. We're the last. We're the last in line to
- 39:14to put value on the air that we breathe, the water we drink, and
- 39:19the earth that supports us, yeah,
- 39:22but we're always reacting. We're always reacting. We're react
- 39:27against this planning application, against that
- 39:31proposed, against this.
- 39:35So we're always catching up. We can never drive the horses. Do
- 39:40you understand what I mean? Yeah. And in your opinion,
- 39:47how do we change that? How do we
- 39:52how do we be in the room
- 39:55to change policy?
- 39:58Oh, God, I.
- 40:00Big question, I know, but it's what we have to be thinking of,
- 40:03because otherwise this is where we'll always stay, always
- 40:07reacting. I suppose
- 40:10my personal opinion is,
- 40:14you know, teach a man to fish. It'll do him no harm. So teach a
- 40:20man and
- 40:23include all genders. Teach people that they have a right to
- 40:28knowledge and their right to the landscape, and that these that
- 40:33these rights are all enshrined in legislation. We sometimes we
- 40:38take laws as being a negative, you know, as in regards to
- 40:42enforcement, and it's we're being forced, but, but if we can
- 40:48educate in some small way,
- 40:53the next generation and the next generation after before them, If
- 40:59we continue to educate and be responsible for saying, like we
- 41:03did last night at the meeting, you have rights, and your voice
- 41:10is important to everyone,
- 41:14and it's often we get angry with people you know, and
- 41:18someone I Know the other day says, I fundamentally disagree
- 41:22with this person and what they're saying totally disagree,
- 41:27but I keep reflecting that there's they're a human being,
- 41:33and it's my duty to
- 41:37tell them that
- 41:41their voice can be heard by everyone, but they have to
- 41:45understand my voice as well and the reasoning why so, so we
- 41:50can't just be angry at each other. We have to sit down and
- 41:52have a discussion as to why we we must respect each other.
- 41:57Yeah, I have a phone ringing here somewhere.
- 42:02Yeah. I know what you're asking.
- 42:07It's a difficult one for a simple reason that I think we're
- 42:10going through a phase with change, and you alluded to it
- 42:13earlier, that people are becoming more aware of their
- 42:18environment, and that's when it comes down to those people who
- 42:22are attacking or threatening the environment are a minority.
- 42:26They're usually, yes, we want to profit and and they're the main
- 42:32concern is making money, making profit, and the environment
- 42:38comes second. But we as defenders now, we call ourselves
- 42:41defend environmental wealth, and that's what it comes it comes
- 42:46down to, comes down to
- 42:48population and its health. It comes down to biodiversity. It
- 42:52comes down to our land or soil or water or air
- 42:57and our climate,
- 43:00whereas material assets to us is our cultural heritage, our
- 43:06material asset is our landscape. It is not
- 43:11how much money we have in the bank, the air would be breathe.
- 43:15And interaction between the volume things, as I've
- 43:17mentioned,
- 43:20are so important because they interact. Their health interacts
- 43:23with our biodiversity, etc, etc. So that awareness as an
- 43:28educational thing, and so awareness that it's so important
- 43:32that we
- 43:33defend our environment, because that is the real wealth. And
- 43:38once that gets across and to people's conscience, that's when
- 43:42things begin to move. Now we saw it. We saw it last night at our
- 43:46meeting. You see it in Toronto? No, 15,000 many applications.
- 43:54I think it's up on 50, 50,000
- 43:57Yeah, yeah, you know. And and through all that, people become
- 44:02more aware. They understand what's happening. So that's how
- 44:06change comes about. So I think in this last 10 years, there has
- 44:11been change and there's been awareness, and we have to keep
- 44:15the people on the people who wants to tackle their
- 44:18environment or destroy it, we have to keep them on the back
- 44:21foot.
- 44:23So, yeah, I think it's educated. That's basically what we have to
- 44:28do.
- 44:30Yeah, be aware and be diligent in their awareness and use
- 44:35whatever resources we have. They're not great, but they can
- 44:38be built upon ours. Ours convention can be built upon
- 44:42Espoo, etc,
- 44:46and lobby or politicians, because at the end of the day,
- 44:49they have the power. And obviously here in the Republic
- 44:53of Ireland, they're trying to undermine the Irish convention,
- 44:57trying to undermine judicial review. That's right.
- 45:00I have to be diligent and don't let it happen. And does. And as
- 45:03we proved categorically, you don't have to be a king's
- 45:07counsel or a politician to bring down a public inquiry. Yeah.
- 45:12What a fantastic example. Okay? And probably my final question
- 45:19ask you, each of the individual what gives you hope?
- 45:25My hope is exactly what I'm after.
- 45:28Leading to is awareness, making people aware, creating that
- 45:32awareness within the community and stamp out reaction,
- 45:38reaction. It may not yet there's a rise of the right and Irish
- 45:43politics, European politics, and politics throughout the world,
- 45:47like you know, we see the election of people like Trump
- 45:49etc in America who even deny climate change. They can, they
- 45:55can dampen your hope. But I think it's a blip. I think that
- 45:59will resolve and we'll move into an area, I hope
- 46:06we move into a period of
- 46:09a heightened awareness.
- 46:12Fingers crossed, you know, but at the present time, you can,
- 46:16you can. You can't blame people being
- 46:19up against it. You know, there's a local awareness. You know, the
- 46:22reactionary governments are in power, especially in Europe and
- 46:26America. And of course, war is a big problem in the world at
- 46:30moment too, and puts puts the environment back in the
- 46:34back stove, off the stove altogether. You know, so.
- 46:39But I am still hopeful, and being an activist is the most
- 46:44important thing, because if you're an activist, you always
- 46:47hold on to hope, but if you stop acting and stop fighting for
- 46:50your community, you'll lose hope and you'll become depressed.
- 46:54That's my message out to the community.
- 46:57Lovely, well done. Sean, thank you for me. For me. I suppose
- 47:03what gives me great hope is the despair that we share amongst
- 47:09those that threaten our environment, because they do
- 47:12despair, because their question is, and this is always the
- 47:16question in the room, what's in it for them, and then they can't
- 47:21deal with the concept of the word nothing.
- 47:25There's not nothing materially there, but there's but if only
- 47:30they knew there's every everything, and there's just so
- 47:34much. I couldn't even begin to go through the alphabet of all
- 47:39the things that are there for us, and the goodness and the
- 47:42wonder and the protection. And you sit, you know, I remember
- 47:46sitting at dunnery fort
- 47:48with an American and it was very inspiring, because she sat
- 47:52beside me, and I said, after we just sat in silence for a few
- 47:56minutes, and I turned to her and I says, What do you hear? And
- 48:00she started crying because she says nothing,
- 48:06and that concept, but there wasn't nothing. She hadn't heard
- 48:12all the other things that there is to hear. And I'd never
- 48:16experienced that before, because we become so
- 48:21burdened with noise. Noise is surrounds us, and this is what
- 48:28gives me hope, is that we're taking the noise and we're doing
- 48:33something about it.
- 48:36And on that note,
- 48:38I think we'll leave it at that. Thank you so much. Thanks both
- 48:41for a great conversation. Good. Thank you. Sure. We'll see you
- 48:46soon. A great host. I hope this doesn't put somebody off their
- 48:52beer on Saturday night, you can turn it up in the pub and they
- 48:56can all listen to you.
- 48:59Excellent, thank you very much. Thanks a million, folks. Thank
- 49:03you so much.
- 49:05You.