Latest / When Killers Get Caught with Brittany Ransom / The Osage Nation Serial Murders that legitimized the FBI
Transcript
- 0:20Everybody in serial killer country.
- 0:22My name is Brittany. Ransom, my name is Brian Joyner.
- 0:24And this is when Killers get caught a podcast of a deep dives
- 0:27into the lives. And psyches of the Killer's, we
- 0:29love to learn about Out each week.
- 0:30Brian, I will find a True Crime Story that resonated with us.
- 0:33Then I'll discuss one well-known or lesser known killer, and go
- 0:36deep into their childhood lives methodology.
- 0:38And most importantly how they got caught and then we'll get a
- 0:42little spooky. We'll learn something about
- 0:43Cryptids or the supernatural with Brian.
- 0:46Yeah. Before we start, I just want to
- 0:48remind you all that our patreon is live.
- 0:51There are four tiers from five to fifty dollars.
- 0:53That offer you loads of fun things like a special extra
- 0:58podcast where Brian and I discussed.
- 1:00Spear see, theories, or you could even have a Groupon to
- 1:05chat. But not one on one, but you get
- 1:08to talk to us. Ask us any questions you want.
- 1:10Its private. It's on the Discord.
- 1:12It's just a fun. You know, ask us anything kind
- 1:15of thing that you can do every month.
- 1:18Yeah, if you're interested in March, our website is
- 1:20www.pevs.com and that's where you can find links to pretty
- 1:25much everything we do. So, starting out this week in
- 1:28True Crime, I I have been following a case.
- 1:34I'm just the, the headline in itself is just interesting but
- 1:38I'm telling you, is that a 17 year old boy has been charged
- 1:41with the murder of his twin sister.
- 1:43His name is Benjamin Elliot and her name is Megan.
- 1:47He stabbed her in the next several times on Wednesday of
- 1:50this week. Oh, now Benjamin claims that he
- 1:54woke up between 2:30 and three in the morning, standing in his
- 1:57sister's bedroom with a knife and that he didn't realize he
- 2:02was in there. In fact, he thought he I was
- 2:04dreaming, he removed the knife and sat down beside her and
- 2:08called 911 according to claims, he's meeting Court.
- 2:13Megan Elliott was pronounced dead at the scene.
- 2:16The 911 operator and instructed Benjamin on how to perform CPR,
- 2:20which he was in the process of doing when the deputies arrived
- 2:23at his house. Mmm, Moments after the call, the
- 2:27parents woke up. There's audio of them screaming
- 2:32after discovering that their daughter was dead.
- 2:35And so now, this is popping up in a bunch of my True Crime
- 2:38groups that I'm a member of them, Facebook and other forums
- 2:41with people. I'll just going, do we really
- 2:44think that he was sleepwalking? Hey, there are cases where, you
- 2:50know, the sleepwalking is a, you know, it plays a big role in it,
- 2:54so There have been some news reports that said though that
- 2:57the parents initially didn't want to allow the police in
- 3:00like, this is still something that is in the process of
- 3:04happening on interesting. So we shall see what's going on.
- 3:09Yeah. It's just very interesting and I
- 3:11mean, has he have you reported history of him at sleepwalking
- 3:15or anything like that? Like in an appearance on winning
- 3:18the police and I mean, I would like it depends what time in the
- 3:21morning that he called the cops and the cops came.
- 3:23So he's saying that he Discovered that he was awake
- 3:27like he woke up and was like, oh no, this isn't a dream at about
- 3:293 a.m. but the police only got there at 4:45 which is a big gap
- 3:36from when he says he realized that he did it and when they
- 3:41called hmm they had they detain him.
- 3:46You know there's been now at this point like an initial like
- 3:48hearing and what. Yeah, yeah, but yeah.
- 3:54They, they have the knife, they have everything, they had to get
- 3:57search, warrants to go, look in the house.
- 4:03It's just it's really interesting.
- 4:04This happened in Georgia by the way, of course Georgia.
- 4:08Mmm. So yeah.
- 4:12The police are officially charging him with murder
- 4:15regardless. As to what the family said,
- 4:16they're like listen the y'all can work that out in court with
- 4:19the lawyers but this is a clear cut and dry murder case.
- 4:23So he's already been like arraigned on the base charges
- 4:29His bond set at 100 thousand dollars.
- 4:32Oh, wow. Yeah.
- 4:36But like, we don't know anything about that.
- 4:37So I'm guessing that's going to come up as a proper
- 4:40investigation happens, right? Because you have a history of
- 4:42sleepwalking, does he do strange things?
- 4:44I mean some Sleepwalkers just kind of walk through the house.
- 4:48There's actually a lady I fell in Tick.
- 4:49Tock she's a delightful woman but like her husband set up what
- 4:54it's like Sabrina spooky and she's one of those Jet Dad jokes
- 4:58and all the freaking puns I don't remember that she like
- 5:01she's a writer. Okay not there's another one
- 5:03that just sleepwalking through the blonde lady.
- 5:05She said Herbal. She also writes like spooky
- 5:08spooky books, too, but her They just set up cameras all over the
- 5:13house and there have been times that her husband has been like
- 5:18outside. Like you need to come inside the
- 5:20house and she's just like, but it's knowing some paranormal.
- 5:26Only one hundred percent of sleep activity stuff.
- 5:29And she has what's it's more than just sleepwalking.
- 5:33It's another issue. Where There's a complete
- 5:38disconnect with her brain and rest, but yeah, she's cool,
- 5:43she's cool and he's very funny. I would like she just will post
- 5:47clips of her W like of the the footage, like the cameras in her
- 5:51house or just walking back and forth around the house like all
- 5:54sorts of interesting stuff. So there's things like that, but
- 5:56that's more than just your basic, right?
- 5:58Right. Sleepwalking 7.
- 6:01What he did? Well what he did if he was,
- 6:04sleepwalking is more than your basic sleepwalking, right?
- 6:09So like if he doesn't have any history of this, then it's just
- 6:13like okay then was right was it something that was that came up
- 6:16in the hour? It took you to call the police?
- 6:18Yeah. Like did you just make this up?
- 6:23But yeah, I'm looking at right here to give the kid the benefit
- 6:26of the doubt for right now and then he killed his sister.
- 6:31I mean, okay, do it by accident, he probably feels terrible.
- 6:34If it was accident, I would assume you felt terrible but uh,
- 6:40So anyway onto my thing. So this one's a little bit
- 6:46funnier than Britney's. So apparently the streets of New
- 6:51York. Apparently just Queens is being
- 6:55terrorized by a rooster A rooster.
- 7:03Rooster, it's very Rising. I was looking up the lady with
- 7:07the sleepwalking and then my brain just connected.
- 7:10Rooster. Yeah, yeah.
- 7:13So apparently, there's a, these are rooster apparently well
- 7:19known in the neighborhood as well and it just is attacking
- 7:25people. One person says that, I was
- 7:30just, you know, usually just casually walking, you know, the
- 7:34hedge, my bus to go to work. When I felt a peck, oh my left
- 7:39hand. And if that this thing kept
- 7:42coming is so vicious, almost evil is like Magpie levels of of
- 7:49bird violent. Blood was gushing.
- 7:52Oh my God. I was trying to apply pressure
- 7:54to it and it kept charging at v-0.
- 7:58Oh man. Okay.
- 8:02And like I said, the Rusev's does have a reputation in the
- 8:05neighborhood and people who live in the area told me if you see
- 8:10that they've been terrorized for years by this rooster.
- 8:15So I'm not sure if this is just a random wild rooster to has
- 8:19just set up shop in Queens, but does this belong to somebody
- 8:24because there's lots of people. Yeah, up there who have chickens
- 8:27and roosters out in their yards because they like eating the
- 8:30eggs. It's very, you know, gentrified
- 8:34neighborhood. Ask this is true.
- 8:37It could be just like a blow, the country white people show
- 8:41called a chickens. I was going to say is just that
- 8:43a bad thing. I mean, fresh eggs.
- 8:46I was going to say, Escape cockfight, horrible plan was so
- 8:52violent. Yes, he's like I'm ready to
- 8:53fight. Come on now.
- 8:54Where's my other was my opponents?
- 8:57And this person is like, I didn't sign up for this sir, and
- 9:00then I guess when the other neighbors they were laughing
- 9:03about it, like, kids can ride your scooters.
- 9:05You people can't walk in peace without being attacked by.
- 9:09What is Rooster is Rooster is terrorizing In neighborhoods and
- 9:12queens. Someone go out there catches
- 9:15rooster and fry it up. Wow, what if that's somebody's
- 9:20friend someone's violent friend I need to talk to her friend.
- 9:25You can't talk to a rooster family.
- 9:26That's what it wasn't. You need to sit that Rusev
- 9:29jammed, talk to a cat. They only understand spray
- 9:31bottles. This is true.
- 9:34This is true. But yeah, no, you sit down to
- 9:36this rooster down, tell them like hey I heard you out there.
- 9:38Terrorizing everybody you need to stop order going to Cook you?
- 9:43You're gonna get it? That's that's this is we're
- 9:45right? This is funny.
- 9:48Look, I like to bring the levity up in here.
- 9:51You always ring the bell today, I'm bringing the conspiracy but
- 9:56not in the way that we handle like conspiracy Crypt.
- 10:00This is more of a well. So,
- 10:17Sometimes I get to looking into things.
- 10:18Uh-huh. And you fall down into a rabbit
- 10:20hole and you can't get out of the rabbit hole until you've
- 10:22read everything. You can about the subject.
- 10:24I don't know if other people feel that way, but that's how I
- 10:26am. And so, what started me looking
- 10:28into this was that I was just looking up the FBI.
- 10:31And so, I was tracking back backwards to, like, when I
- 10:33started, you know, and, like J Edgar Hoover, and all that
- 10:37stuff. And imagine my surprise, when
- 10:40one of the FBI's first major cases involved a massive
- 10:44conspiracy, where members of the Osage Nation were murdered
- 10:48shortly after becoming the richest people in the world.
- 10:51After oil was discovered, beneath their reservation
- 10:55imagine that it's called the reign of terror and it lasted
- 10:59from 1921 to 1926. Now, according to Osage Nation
- 11:04history, there are still roughly 60 unsolved murders from this
- 11:07time, but ultimately the F be able the FBI was able to solve
- 11:11all about 24 of them. Not only is this story, just
- 11:15incredible. General.
- 11:17There's actually a movie that's supposed to come out about it in
- 11:20like the next couple of months. Oh, nice.
- 11:22It's a Scorsese film to even better.
- 11:24So I figured before any of us go and see this movie.
- 11:27I'm going to feel everybody on what happened in dosage, Hills
- 11:31in Oklahoma, because, boy, was it, a wild ride and I've let
- 11:36everybody know listening. I've been hyping this up to
- 11:38Brian. Now, for a little while, I was
- 11:40like, oh, you don't even understand it's going to blow
- 11:43your mind, I'm having a consistent.
- 11:45But before we even start anything, let's learn a little
- 11:47bit about the Osage Nation. So they are an indigenous tribe
- 11:52in America who live in Oklahoma for a pretty long time.
- 11:55But we have found remnants of the tribe as far east as the
- 11:58Ohio River and the Mississippi River dating back to 700 BC.
- 12:02Their name is a French version of their indigenous name which
- 12:05is was that shush which means mid Waters and the Dougie
- 12:10han-soo language. They migrated West after the
- 12:1317th century and archaeologists have found evidence That there
- 12:16were three different routes that they took.
- 12:17During this immigration, period, one group, followed the
- 12:20Missouri. Osage River to Western Central
- 12:23Missouri and Eastern Oklahoma. Another groom took that same
- 12:27river to West Central Missouri. Then another cluster of about
- 12:31six different groups, followed the only Ottawa River and Iowa,
- 12:35and they ended at the Osage River, this happened because the
- 12:39Iroquois invaded, the Ohio Valley, where they had been
- 12:42living. And there were a lot of battles.
- 12:47And I have to explain this because my family is linked to
- 12:53the Confederacy, it's referred to as the Iroquois Confederacy.
- 12:58It's the initial name for the five tribes, the name that we
- 13:02refer to is holding the shown a, those tribes are Mohawk, Oneida,
- 13:07that's my family. Onondaga Cayuga and Seneca later
- 13:10on. There was another trial, another
- 13:12tribe that was added. But at this time, there's only
- 13:15five So, when I say they were invading, this was five
- 13:22different tribes, invading an area.
- 13:26So I totally understand why the Osage people just said, I am a,
- 13:31yeah, yeah. Like, you know, I'm a head out,
- 13:34a SpongeBob style. This is too much.
- 13:37I'm not you, and I didn't want this, okay?
- 13:38Like they had a whole series of bloody battles through Kentucky,
- 13:41Virginia. Like they were just like, you
- 13:43know what, we got. Good.
- 13:47So from the 1700s to the 1900s, they were taking over territory.
- 13:51In the midwest, they were raiding their Santa Fe New
- 13:54Mexico. They explored Palos Verdes
- 13:56Peninsula on the coast of California, just before the
- 13:591800s, the largest group headed up towards Oklahoma and Kansas,
- 14:03and there were hostilities between the Osage Nation and the
- 14:06Cherokee Nation that in 1839, the US government stepped in and
- 14:10forced all of the different dosage bands of the tribe to
- 14:13leave Arkansas and Oklahoma. ah, and they move them into Kansas,
- 14:18which is where the tribe had agreed to settle in 1825 but
- 14:22like, you know, Part of that time period was we conquer him?
- 14:31So, but the other issue was that didn't last?
- 14:34Because even though they had been forced into can't into
- 14:37Kansas, they got forced back into Oklahoma and 1871, this was
- 14:42actually their third and most terrible displacement, it was
- 14:45pretty traumatic for the tribe and there are tombstones across
- 14:49the entire area that show that the majority of the people who
- 14:52died during that third transition.
- 14:55We're Young mothers and infants. Wow.
- 14:57So it's pretty hard on the tribe in general.
- 15:01Now, solidly in Oklahoma, they settled in and then in 1894,
- 15:06large, quantities of oil, were discovered underneath a large
- 15:10Prairie that was owned by the tribe.
- 15:13The Osage - they negotiated with the US and retained the rights
- 15:17for the minerals, under their land. this was called the Osage
- 15:22allotment Act of 1906 and it said that any subsurface
- 15:26minerals within the Osage Nation reservation were held in a trust
- 15:29by the US government, but we're still tribally owned and they
- 15:33were paid mineral lease royalties to the tribe and this
- 15:37started out as like, Tribal members is called Head rights
- 15:45actually but those people who were a lot he's in the tribe and
- 15:48had that head rate would get like $100 every couple months
- 15:52and then all of a sudden it was a thousand dollars every couple
- 15:54months and then by the early like the late like nineteen
- 15:59teens the tribe, I received millions of dollars at this
- 16:03point so they were at that moment, the richest people in
- 16:07the entire world. Oh nice.
- 16:09Okay. Well, some awesome.
- 16:12Unfortunately, this isn't the only time that the the Osage
- 16:16tribe is going to have issues with this.
- 16:19There's a lot of really jacked up stuff that happens with that.
- 16:22The acts that were passed during that time period.
- 16:25But also recently they sued the US government for mismanagement
- 16:29of the trust Assets in the year 2000 and they settled for 380
- 16:33million dollars in 2011. So it's been 100 Years of drama
- 16:38with this. Yeah.
- 16:39But we are specifically talking about the time period.
- 16:42It before the reign of terror, so we're back in 1921.
- 16:46The US government is in all that happy about how the Osage Nation
- 16:50is using their wealth. We are a, we're very racist,
- 16:54National Nation. Now, with a very racist past and
- 16:56there is nothing that makes broke white folks, more upset
- 16:58and seeing brown people drive rolls royces and building big
- 17:02old beautiful houses. In fact, the Press was obsessed
- 17:05with stories of the rich Redskins and they took delight
- 17:09and trying to cast the osich. Tribe as Savage spendthrift,
- 17:14everybody wanted to know how these people were spending their
- 17:16money. So Congress, passes a law,
- 17:20requiring, any member of the Osage Nation, who is at least
- 17:23half to be appointed a guardian until they can prove that they
- 17:28are competent enough to spend their own money.
- 17:32Excuse me. Hmm.
- 17:36Now they, they, they set this up originally going well, a lot of
- 17:39these people who are getting this money, are minors their
- 17:42children. Who are, you know, full-blood?
- 17:46This is just one of the ways that the u.s. government has
- 17:48screwed indigenous people over using blood Quantum, but that's
- 17:51another conversation for another day.
- 17:55And the thing is, even if these miners had Parents, it didn't
- 17:58matter. The government was like, no, no.
- 17:59Everybody needs to have someone to help them with their money.
- 18:03No, it down to thank you. And this wasn't handled by the
- 18:05feds, but by local lawyers and businessmen and it was
- 18:08completely taken advantage of, in fact, So guys, tell you
- 18:13there's so much money here. The Osage Nation began
- 18:16auctioning off development rights to parts of their
- 18:20reservation for people who were hunting for oil.
- 18:24And according to the commissioner of Indian Affairs
- 18:26in 1924 alone, their revenue was 30 million dollars in 1920.
- 18:32That's about 400 million dollars now.
- 18:35So, a family of four who were all a lot, he's who had had
- 18:38right? Could be collecting, roughly
- 18:41600,000. U.s. dollars today just to
- 18:44exist. Wow, there's a lot of money and
- 18:47that guardianship was very corrupt.
- 18:54So this all really starts, the reign of terror May 27th, 1921
- 19:01local Hunters, find a badly, decomposed body of 33, year old
- 19:05and a brown in a Ravine and Osage County.
- 19:09Anna was known to go on sprees as her family called them where
- 19:12she got dancing and drinking with her friends until dawn.
- 19:15Also reminding you, we are still in the prohibition era.
- 19:18Mmm. So there's a lot of bootleggers
- 19:20and a lot of crime happening. She gone out on one of those
- 19:24fries on May 21st and her sister Molly Burkhart hadn't heard from
- 19:28her by May 24th and she was pretty alarmed there.
- 19:32They had a previous sister who had died in 1918 and Molly
- 19:37wasn't entirely sure. That one made sense, either
- 19:41Molly and her sisters and their parents were all on something
- 19:44referred to as the Osage role, which meant that they were
- 19:47registered tribal members and that they were all allottees who
- 19:50had head rate. This family all lived in his
- 19:54area called gray horse, which was one of the reservations
- 19:57older settlements. Also all the sisters were
- 20:00married to white man. That's going to matter later on.
- 20:05Now the last time the Anna had been seen was a luncheon on the
- 20:0821st that Molly had been the. What do you call that when you
- 20:12have a party host? Yeah, she was hosting a luncheon
- 20:15and I showed up drunk, she caused a scene with pretty much
- 20:18everybody there. Molly had to stop her sober up
- 20:22and Molly's husband's younger brother, Brian spelt with a.
- 20:26Why said he dropped her off at her house?
- 20:30Bryan, insisted that he had dropped her off at like 5:00. 30
- 20:34in the afternoon before going to see a show that was called
- 20:38bringing up father with another man in town named William Hale,
- 20:42who was his uncle and also one of the most powerful people in
- 20:46Osage County but we will also talk about William a little
- 20:49more. Now after three nights of not
- 20:52hearing from her sister Molly slack.
- 20:54All right y'all, let's get this going and she's like she sends
- 20:58people to go check on Anna's house.
- 21:00Nobody's been there and as servants or like she didn't come
- 21:04home. That's also when they learned
- 21:07that another Resident in on the tribe Charles Whitehorn had also
- 21:13vanished a week before, Anna. So, a week after an has been
- 21:19gone. Now, a different body is found
- 21:21on a hill, north of downtown Pawhuska.
- 21:25It had two bullets in its head, execution style, the body was so
- 21:30rotten, they couldn't identify it.
- 21:32And the only way, they figured out who it was was because the
- 21:35oil workers who found him checked his pockets and
- 21:38discovered a letter that someone had written to Charles Whitehorn
- 21:44Charles wife is white and Cheyenne Indian when within 24
- 21:50hours, they also find Anna's body in the mud in a ravine
- 21:54partially submerged bloated. We didn't really do autopsies,
- 21:58then like we do now. Instead what they had was called
- 22:01a Coroner's inquest a group of people show up led by a justice
- 22:05of the peace and they have kind of a conversation over the body
- 22:08at the location where they find it.
- 22:11So they do this with Hannah Brown.
- 22:13The reason why we had it like this is because after the
- 22:15American Revolution Americans were kind of not interested in
- 22:18cops citizens were afraid that they would become a symbol of
- 22:22Oppression America, how funny. Whoa.
- 22:28It's like history like repeats itself or something.
- 22:31Yeah. So these inquest were regular
- 22:33people from the town who were doing, they were filling the Gap
- 22:38that cops would do today. And to be fair, When these
- 22:44regular people found that an injustice had been done, it
- 22:47usually got real violent so like they would take their job, very
- 22:51seriously. Okay.
- 22:52Cool. And Anna's inquest, they
- 22:56realized they like put her body on like a slab and they were
- 22:59just checking and stuff and they were like, oh yeah, no.
- 23:01She got shot in the back of the head.
- 23:04This definitely a murder. Because originally when they
- 23:06first found her body, there was like well when she just got
- 23:09drunk and like fell over in the woods and like exposure, But
- 23:13there was definitely a bullet hole.
- 23:17So the information about both these murders.
- 23:19Now falls on the local sheriff and Osage County.
- 23:22He's a 50 year old, former Frontiersman named harf Reyes
- 23:26who took his job, pretty seriously.
- 23:27But he also liked to get a little money on the side from
- 23:30his favorite criminals. Pretty much.
- 23:33If you were like a moonshine Bootlegger, you knew that all
- 23:35you had to do was pay Harvard a little booze and he'd let you
- 23:38out. One harv learned about Anna.
- 23:41He was already knee-deep in investigating Charles white
- 23:43horns, murder. So, he was like, I need somebody
- 23:46else to focus on this, so he passed it off to the town
- 23:49Marshal, the Marshall shows up, and it's just like, okay.
- 23:53She was drinking at some point. Somebody definitely shot her in
- 23:57the back of the head. He did note that there were two
- 23:59sets of car tracks at the crime scene that were not from the
- 24:03people who had showed up, but we didn't know how to trace.
- 24:06The killer from just try to tracks and At best, like the
- 24:11best area where there was forensics, were like the major
- 24:14cities, your Philadelphia, your DC, Houston La New York middle.
- 24:21Oklahoma didn't have really any forensic knowledge at that
- 24:24point, they didn't even photograph the crime scene back.
- 24:27Oh, come on. Yeah.
- 24:30And even if they had, it was already incredibly contaminated
- 24:34by roughly a dozen people. So, I traipse through this true,
- 24:38this caused a bit of a media frenzy, they recovered a bullet,
- 24:42from Charles white horns body. And it was roughly the same size
- 24:46as the whole and Anna's. Had they thought it was a 33.
- 24:51The theories are rampant. They're like two Indians dying
- 24:55in the same week. They're both wealthy ocid
- 24:59residence. And so people are like, well is
- 25:01this like HH Holmes in Chicago? Or is this just a coincidence?
- 25:07Because that was the only like International serial type murder
- 25:12that we had any reference for at the time, right?
- 25:15Which was HH Holmes at the end of the 19th century.
- 25:19Some of the elders actually said that, they felt like finding
- 25:23that oil under the reservation was a curse on the Osage people
- 25:28and there was one quote from a newspaper that said after the
- 25:32fat checks from the great white father and I know My people will
- 25:38be happier. Hmm.
- 25:40Yes, they did refer to kind of how we say, like, Daddy Biden
- 25:44and we're being kind of facetious.
- 25:47That's kind of how they talked about checks from the government
- 25:50that chicks At that point. Local police were just kind of
- 25:56ready to be done with Anna's case, but Molly didn't wasn't
- 25:58having that. She reached out to William hail
- 26:01rich, man. Lot of land.
- 26:03That he purchased a lot of it from the Osage people.
- 26:05He had worked his way up from just being a poor cow boy to a
- 26:09man who now walked around town in a bow tie and recited poetry
- 26:12like, he thought he was that guy.
- 26:15He was this yet. Okay.
- 26:16He even had a diamond-studded pain from the Masonic Lodge so
- 26:19you know, yeah. Those kind of connection, okay?
- 26:23Hale was also a reservation, Deputy in Fairfax.
- 26:27Now, that was mainly an honorary title, but a lot of the people
- 26:30in the Osage Nation, trusted him.
- 26:32And so, when he talked to Molly, he was just like, I got you, IMA
- 26:36get Justice for your sister. There was a small hearing after
- 26:41this and they went over all the details of the last day of
- 26:44Anna's life. They interviewed everybody who
- 26:46had anything to do with her servants, everybody, especially
- 26:50brianburkhardt His responses were a little weird, but they
- 26:58really couldn't prove anything from the fact that like, maybe,
- 27:00this guy was just a little nervous on the stand.
- 27:02Mmm. The other issue we came into
- 27:07when this discussion at this hearing, was that, this area had
- 27:11a big issue with Outlaws because of prohibition, and the Osa
- 27:15chills were really nice place to hide if you were on the run
- 27:17because it was big, beautiful Wilderness.
- 27:20The other Theory though, was maybe it was somebody on the
- 27:23reservation and that made sense because the only people who
- 27:27would know, all of Anna's patterns, were people who knew
- 27:31her Molly was suspicious of Anna's.
- 27:35Urban Oda Brown and when he was questioned after Anna's death,
- 27:39he sobbed and put on a total show and everybody was like,
- 27:43yeah, he's lying. It also didn't help that.
- 27:49After Anna's death Brown, got a lawyer and tried to get her
- 27:52share of the Osage allotment, but before, after they had
- 27:57gotten divorced, and I had changed her will so that all of
- 28:00her money will go back to her mom.
- 28:03Lizzie. Okay, cool.
- 28:05Aw So Brown didn't have any legal right to get that money
- 28:11and at this point, the only way you could get in a lot meant was
- 28:15either through an inheritance or a will.
- 28:18So or the natural way that money flowed if you like die.
- 28:22So if a spouse dies, goes to the next person.
- 28:24Who knows the family members right?
- 28:26A few weeks after Anna's Funeral, a man who was in jail
- 28:30for forgery, sent a letter to sheriff harv and was like, I
- 28:34know about the murder. So, both harv and hail rush to
- 28:38meet this man, and he claims that Anna's ex-husband Oda.
- 28:41Brown paid him, eight thousand dollars to murder her.
- 28:44He told them, he shot her in the head and carried her body to the
- 28:47creek afterward which is why they hadn't been able to find
- 28:50the bullet because they've been looking in the wrong place.
- 28:53Hmm. OTA Brown was arrested, but
- 28:55there was no evidence that the forger had even been in Osage
- 28:59County, so, they just released Oda Brown.
- 29:01And officially, and his murder was listed.
- 29:04She was listed as Murdered by parties, unknown.
- 29:10Two months after her daughter's. Death, Lissie died as well.
- 29:14She had been ill for years, but it got like exponentially worse
- 29:18after Anna died. Okay, in fact, Molly's
- 29:24brother-in-law, Bill Smith was like this feels weird.
- 29:30And so, he started digging into the idea that Lizzy had been
- 29:33poisoned. This made sense because now
- 29:36Lizzie would have had to allotment checks, she'd be
- 29:39getting after Anna passed, right?
- 29:40It was a lot of money, unfortunately, the local police
- 29:44showed absolutely no interest in pursuing Lizzy as a case, an
- 29:48elderly ill woman died of her illness and they were not going
- 29:52to do an autopsy or an inquest over it.
- 29:55Somali puts out a two thousand dollar reward for anybody who
- 29:58can give her information about the murder of her sister Anna.
- 30:01And the Whitehorn family goes bet you.
- 30:03We will also put out two thousand five hundred dollars
- 30:06for any reward on Charles body. So now, we're looking at almost
- 30:09five grand for help on these two murders that were discovered on
- 30:13virtually the same day. Hm, it seems like it'd be a good
- 30:18motivator, but then har Frey has got himself charged with failing
- 30:24to enforce the law. Law because he'd been accepted
- 30:27all those bribes from bootleggers and the Oklahoma
- 30:30attorney general was aimin to put him in jail, so he was kind
- 30:33of busy. He didn't have any time to look
- 30:38into the crimes because he was too busy.
- 30:40Trying not to go to jail himself too.
- 30:42Busy the Oklahoma attorney general was like, Yeah, Sohail
- 30:48decides, I'm going to hire a private detective.
- 30:51Now in the early 20th century, detective agencies definitely
- 30:55filled the void where corrupt or underfunded or just downright
- 30:59inept police weren't doing their job.
- 31:05Just like now private detectives are very unwieldy.
- 31:10You never knew if you were getting somebody like Virgil
- 31:13vandagriff who helped capture her bone Meister, or if you were
- 31:16going to get a scammer who was going to take your money and
- 31:18run. So it was all over the place.
- 31:21So hail chooses the detector from Kansas City who went by the
- 31:24name. Pike, first name only Anna
- 31:29estate was like, screw it. We're going to hire detective to
- 31:32and then the Guardians for both Anna and Lizzie.
- 31:35The his name was Scott Mathis. He put together a team of
- 31:37privatized and so did the white whore nasty.
- 31:40So, at this point now the three of these people have organized
- 31:42roughly, 50, different detectives who are all over
- 31:49those. Its reservation.
- 31:51Wow. Trying to find information and
- 31:53the thing is these weren't your average attack devs.
- 31:57These are all people who had previously worked for the Secret
- 31:59Service. They were considered to be
- 32:01better than Pinkerton detectives.
- 32:03Really one of them was William J Burns who was referred to as
- 32:09America's Sherlock Holmes and he had a whole team of people under
- 32:13him. The information about them, like
- 32:16none of their names are listed in any of the information that
- 32:18you look up and the FBI. Actually just let you go on to
- 32:23their website and pull up all the data they have on us.
- 32:27So it's a lot of reading and it's very interesting but like
- 32:31so they were only know by code numbers and all of, if T of
- 32:36these code number people, kind of descended on the town and
- 32:40they began looking in. Every one, they were a lot of
- 32:41dead ends. A lot of false leads, but they
- 32:44did learn that Anna. Had been seen with two men from
- 32:46the oil fields before her death. Now while the detectives were
- 32:50out following every lead, a man, by the name of aw, Comstock
- 32:54showed up and gray horse to help as well.
- 32:57William Burns had investigated him in the past for trying to
- 33:00help an oil company trick, the Osage Tribal Council into a
- 33:03badly and deal. Those charges couldn't be proven
- 33:07but Burns decided Comstock might be a good Ally to have.
- 33:11Hmm. Everybody was a sub-sect, but
- 33:14none of them were good enough suspects.
- 33:17They ended up finding out that Anna was pregnant and nobody
- 33:20knew who the dad was. And so then, that caused a whole
- 33:23series of rumors that Anna could have been sleeping with other
- 33:27people's boyfriends or husbands. And that's why she was murdered.
- 33:31It was all kinds of crazy. Well, okay, so February, 1922,
- 33:36nine months after both Anna and Whitehorn our dad, They don't
- 33:43know what to hails. Detective Pike, had abandoned
- 33:45the case entirely, Sheriff Harvey couldn't lead, any
- 33:48investigation? Because he had been officially
- 33:50kicked out of office. They had no more leads to
- 33:52follow. It was looking like, they didn't
- 33:54have any idea who it killed Anna or Charles, and then in late
- 33:58February, William steps in left his house.
- 34:01And when he came home, a few hours later, he was visibly ill.
- 34:05He died before Dawn, unlike Lizzie William was only 29 and
- 34:12Considered to be in pretty good shape.
- 34:14So his death was very suspicious and when they decided to do an
- 34:17inquest in him they determined that he was poisoned the poison
- 34:22was assumed to be strychnine and even though we had the forensic
- 34:25ability to test for strychnine poisoning nobody did it.
- 34:31Why they just decide all you do is take like a flash sample.
- 34:37Yeah. Where I'm looking for is not
- 34:38flash but you know what I mean? Yeah.
- 34:42You see it was like just a little bit of Flesh that flesh
- 34:46to go March 2016. 22, another Osage woman dies of poisoning,
- 34:53no toxicology done on her remains either.
- 34:56What's going on July 28th, 1922 Joe Bates, gets whiskey, from a
- 35:04stranger. And after a sip of it later, he
- 35:07begins frothing at the mouth and collapses.
- 35:10He's only in his mid-30s when he He dies.
- 35:15At this point. The Osage Nation is dropping
- 35:19like flies and they all are people who coincidentally are
- 35:24over that. 50% threshold, meaning, they get checks There
- 35:31were so many cases by August that the Osage Nation reached
- 35:36out to Barney McBride. Who was a wealthy Oil, Man.
- 35:39And they were like, listen, you have connections to DC.
- 35:42We need help. Please go get, help.
- 35:46Someone is killing us, please. Right.
- 35:49So McBride was married to an indigenous woman and she had
- 35:52passed and he was trusted by the Osage people.
- 35:55He was actually raising their daughter within like the tribe
- 36:00trying to help her, you know, know her people.
- 36:01Right? Right.
- 36:03So he agreed to do it. When Barney gets to d.c.,
- 36:08there's a telegram waiting for him in his rooming house.
- 36:11From a friend of his that just says Be careful.
- 36:17That night when McBride went out to play Billiards, somebody
- 36:20kidnapped him. And in the morning they found
- 36:22his body. He had been stabbed over 20
- 36:25times been bludgeoned in the head, until his skull had
- 36:28collapsed and stripped naked, except for his shoes.
- 36:33And socks had, they not been for a business card, which had been
- 36:36tucked in his shoe. They wouldn't have been able to
- 36:39ID him, which lets me know that the people who did this wanted
- 36:43him to be found. This was a warning The local
- 36:47police in Washington were like he was probably followed from
- 36:51Oklahoma. And they wanted to kill him
- 36:57before he could talk to anybody official was.
- 37:03I'm sorry, there was actually an article in the Washington Post
- 37:05that was just like conspiracy. Like, you know, borrow, you
- 37:09know, oil men murdered due to conspiracy to kill Rich, Indians
- 37:14like, major news. And then it goes quiet, there's
- 37:20no suspicious deaths, there's nothing.
- 37:23Hmm, until February of 1923 This time, it started again, Henry
- 37:29Rowan, 40 years old found in his car Frozen, but he definitely
- 37:35didn't die from freezing, because there were two bullets
- 37:39in the back of his head just like, with Charles Whitehorn,
- 37:43there's making this stuff. Obvious, like, what we're gonna
- 37:46just like with, Anna, the deputies and Marshall show up at
- 37:49the Ravine. They look at the body.
- 37:51They noticed there are trademarks and the frozen mud
- 37:55from that moment on every OCT. As had electric lights put
- 37:58outside of their houses, and thing is, this would have been
- 38:01seen as like a really bougie thing to do.
- 38:06Because everybody didn't have light like that in the nineteen
- 38:10a time, like, everybody didn't have the ability to drown your
- 38:13house and light like we do now, it was expensive but they got
- 38:16the money to do that, right? Well, that's what they're like,
- 38:18oh, these people, they have lights on all night long outside
- 38:20their houses, but they had that so that if they heard something
- 38:23outside their house, they could look and be like, yep.
- 38:28Play it. Safe.
- 38:30Molly and her family were still looking for a killer.
- 38:34Bill Smith is like I know this is okay, I'm on to something
- 38:39here, he's doing his own separate that's Molly's
- 38:42brother-in-law. Married to her sister Rita and
- 38:46he's just like I'm some is going on here.
- 38:49I'm a follow this lead. He's doing this all on his own
- 38:51on a stick tape. Hmm.
- 38:54And Bill realized he must have been onto something because they
- 38:57started hearing people skulking around the house at night so
- 39:01much so that he and Rita had trouble sleeping.
- 39:05So they moved a month after Romans death this time.
- 39:10That was the house closer to the center of Fairfax where they had
- 39:12a lot of neighbors, whereas, before they were out more in the
- 39:15countryside in March, a Man shows up at their door and as
- 39:23like, I heard you So and farmland and bills.
- 39:26Like you are mistaken, sir, and Bill told his friends at the
- 39:30man, looked like he was casing the place.
- 39:33Then all the neighbors. Dogs started, dying, one by one.
- 39:36All poisoned, come on. Bill Tells A friend of his, I'm
- 39:39pretty sure I'm gonna die soon. Hmm.
- 39:42So on March 9th, Bill drives a friend to a Bootleggers Ranch on
- 39:46the western side of the reservation.
- 39:48This Bootlegger is Henry grammar, he owned a ranch, and
- 39:51he was a well-known outlaw. With connections to the Kansas
- 39:54mob. So bill, and his friend got to
- 39:57the ranch grammar is not there. So they just grab a couple jars
- 39:59of whiskey. Have a couple of swigs, they
- 40:02drop, bill off back at home Rita's there.
- 40:04And so is one of their cermets named Nettie, Brookshire, who,
- 40:07sometimes would stay there overnight.
- 40:09Like if she was working late and about 3 a.m. everyone in town
- 40:14heard a loud explosion that radiated through the
- 40:17neighborhood, it bent trees, blew out windows people down the
- 40:22street, At the Fairfax Motel were thrown out of their
- 40:25ballads, like was there a bomb? Yes.
- 40:29Molly and Earnest were over on the other side of the
- 40:31reservation and Molly looked out the window and went there's a
- 40:35fire. She thought it was Thunder at
- 40:38first but it was Bill Smith house and the entire house was
- 40:43gone. This was such a massive
- 40:45explosion that like it was just destroyed the town rushed out
- 40:52and they're like, we got to look for any survivors, anybody
- 40:54survive and they began moving rubble and after forever, they
- 40:58started hearing Bill screaming. Mmm, Rita was beside him in bed.
- 41:02They said it looked like she was peacefully sleeping, but when
- 41:04they moved her, they saw that she had been Hit by something in
- 41:07the back of her head, she was killed immediately.
- 41:11They couldn't even find Nettie. A Justice of the Peace.
- 41:15Simply like looked at it and determined that she had been
- 41:19blown to pieces that he was only 19 years old.
- 41:22She was married and had a small child.
- 41:25There weren't enough remains for them to even do an inquest.
- 41:28And in fact, they sell, they found part of Nettie's, remains
- 41:31roughly 300 feet away burned into the side of a house.
- 41:35Wow, And all I could think of here was like damn poor Molly.
- 41:40She is literally now the only person left alive in her family.
- 41:44Yeah. Okay.
- 41:45The carry Bill to an ambulance, they took him to a hospital on
- 41:49the way to the hospital. He passed out originally when
- 41:52they found him, he was awake and screaming and when he found out
- 41:54read, it was gone. He asked one of the people to
- 41:57save him for their gun so he could kill himself to.
- 42:00He was sad. Poor guy.
- 42:04They realized as they were taking him to the hospital that
- 42:07this had been planned. Specifically.
- 42:08Because roughly every like justice of the peace, all those
- 42:13people. Hmm.
- 42:15We're out of town for a court case.
- 42:16Oh, how convenient? They had to rush back in the
- 42:20middle of the night. Cops set up flood.
- 42:22Lights at all the access and actresses to the hospital.
- 42:26They posted an armed guard outside of his hospital room.
- 42:30Everybody was like if Bill was if this was because he said he
- 42:34knew something. He's got to tell us something
- 42:36now. Yeah.
- 42:37Yeah. Because he has time to take him
- 42:41for it, right. His friends say that like well
- 42:44he rambled on and on about stuff.
- 42:46Sometimes he like woke up and he was like did I say something?
- 42:49Yeah. And they were like no no he's
- 42:51trying to stop himself or so worried that maybe he would say
- 42:54something that would call it. Like it was weird and then four
- 42:59days later he died. He never told anybody anything,
- 43:05huh? At least at this point.
- 43:07How did he die? It was just my explosion from
- 43:09his injuries. Okay I was about to say, what do
- 43:12I miss my games I was worried. Okay, question for you real
- 43:14quick so I don't, I'm not sure how reservations are set up.
- 43:18Uh-huh. Is there some type of security
- 43:22they have? There is a lot of them are big.
- 43:25Open areas. There are generally reservation,
- 43:29police, and they did have like hail was one of their
- 43:32reservation chair, right? Right.
- 43:34Right. It's we're like right now we
- 43:36come. We run into issues in the u.s.
- 43:38when there's like a missing woman like the case that I
- 43:40talked about on Tick Tock last week.
- 43:43They don't know where she died or where this lady went missing.
- 43:47So they're not Sure who's in charge.
- 43:51Is it the reservation police? Is it the state?
- 43:53That's why a lot of times when there are reservation like
- 43:56people who go missing or die on reservations, it's handled by
- 43:59the feds because well, we least know that they're the ones in
- 44:02charge right. True.
- 44:03But as far as this was, it was just it was a massive area
- 44:06enemy. The thing is, they had people
- 44:07coming and going nonstop because they had boil Barons coming in.
- 44:11They were auctioning off land to make money.
- 44:13There were people, you know, digging, they just ran wheel.
- 44:17There were loads of random people coming off and It's
- 44:19reservation today we might not have that, right?
- 44:23But at this point in history with the Osage Nation, they did
- 44:26have too many people on there which is also contributed to the
- 44:30confusion with whether this was an internal conflict or sore,
- 44:36somebody criminals on the outside trying to kill people,
- 44:39right? Okay.
- 44:41It's just like, is okay, kids. I told you.
- 44:45This is a tail. It's a tale, isn't it?
- 44:48That is for me and I like You like it so, April 23rd.
- 44:52Sorry, got April 23rd. But April of 1923 the Governor
- 44:57of Oklahoma, Jacksy Walton sends his top investigator Herman, Fox
- 45:01Davis, 2006 County because people and O's the chills were
- 45:04saying that the reason why they hadn't found the killers because
- 45:07it must be somebody in the local police department, or either
- 45:11someone in bed with the local police department.
- 45:14Now Davis was also a former member of the burns detective
- 45:17agency and the governor Like bat listen.
- 45:20I hired the best man to protect me.
- 45:22He's got that within a few days though Davis was hanging out at
- 45:28the Bootleggers houses and in the gambling Den said he was no
- 45:32help. In fact by June, he ended up
- 45:35pleading guilty to bribery and got a two-year sentence.
- 45:39Oh my God, the governor pardoned him.
- 45:41Then when he got released, he killed it attorney and got life.
- 45:45What present do, yeah. That One didn't work out and
- 45:51following that Governor Walton got impeached in November of
- 45:531923 seems he had pardoned a lot of people including some of the
- 45:58oilmen. He was a getting that money to
- 46:03build a nicer house from sorry. Of course, of course, one day in
- 46:07June of 1923 though, George big heart called up his friend, an
- 46:13attorney WW1, he was sick, and he was being taken to Oklahoma
- 46:18City Hospital, George big heart. Said that he had information
- 46:22about the murders, and he was only going to speak to Vaughn in
- 46:24person. So, before Vaughn went to go to
- 46:27that meeting. See his friend, he goes and he
- 46:30says, his wife. Listen, I've been collecting
- 46:32evidence about this on my own. I have hit it at this location.
- 46:39When van gets their big card is still alive.
- 46:42He shares the information with his friend.
- 46:44Apparently, it's very incriminating.
- 46:46Then Vaughn sits with his friend.
- 46:48As big heart dies Vaughn calls, the new Osage County, sheriff,
- 46:54and he's like, listen, I'm coming back tomorrow.
- 46:57I know everything about everything.
- 46:59You don't even got to worry about it.
- 47:00The sheriff's just like, well, do you know who killed Baker and
- 47:04he's like, not only do I know who killed my friend.
- 47:06I know more. Oh man.
- 47:08Let's go. Go.
- 47:09He was last seen boarding the overnight train and when the
- 47:12train pulled into the station, he wasn't on the train anymore.
- 47:15What know what They found his body about 36 hours later.
- 47:23It was about 30 miles north of Oklahoma City on off the train
- 47:27tracks, he had been thrown off the train, his neck was broken.
- 47:31He had also been stripped naked, just like McBride so everything
- 47:35he had written down in that meeting and then when Vaughn's
- 47:40Widow went to that special hiding spot it was cleaned out
- 47:44to what the fuck. Okay, look, I know this isn't
- 47:48passed but guys, you gotta be quiet.
- 47:50Keep walking at this point, the reign of terror had claimed 24
- 47:55people from just the Osage Nation, but it was also killing
- 47:59a bunch of people outside of an Asian to the Rancher who was
- 48:06trying to help the investigation, they found his
- 48:09body at the bottom of a flight of steps, and they were able to
- 48:11determine that he was drugged. Another guy was in a different
- 48:15city, he was an Oklahoma City and he got shot.
- 48:19In broad daylight on his way to go talk to State officials about
- 48:24the case, my God. So now it's not just people with
- 48:27a head, right? It's anybody who's trying to get
- 48:30help for the tribe. Yeah.
- 48:34The justice of the peace was receiving Anonymous threats.
- 48:37Like at this point, he was just like, I don't even want to do
- 48:40inquests on the new bodies that are being found, the new County.
- 48:44Sheriff was just like, listen, you know, we don't gotta worry
- 48:49about this. It's just some Indians dying.
- 48:52What are you talking about? He was scared.
- 48:57And after the bombing of the Smith house, the Osage tribe
- 49:01began asking the federal government to send
- 49:03investigators. But specifically investigators
- 49:06who had no ties to Oklahoma at all because there was obviously
- 49:10a leak here, the tribal council actually sent a formal
- 49:14resolution to DC and I'm going to read you part of it, which
- 49:16says, whereas and no case have the criminals been apprehended
- 49:19and brought to Justice. Whereas the Osage Tribal Council
- 49:22deemed essential for the preservation of the lives and
- 49:25property. Of the members of the tribe that
- 49:27prompt and strenuous action. Be taken to capture and punish
- 49:31the criminals. Be it further resolved.
- 49:33That The Honorable Secretary of the Interior be requested to
- 49:36obtain the services of the Department of Justice in
- 49:40capturing and Prosecuting the murderers of the members of the
- 49:43Osage tribe. Letters were also sent to the
- 49:46Kansas to Kansas Senator Charles Curtis who was part call and
- 49:51part dosage. And at the time, the highest
- 49:53elected official with an e and e, An ancestry like he was the
- 49:58highest you have been ever elected.
- 50:02While the tribe is waiting for a federal response, Molly is just
- 50:06living in fear. She's like, I'm definitely the
- 50:09next Target she heard people breaking into their car one
- 50:13night and Earnest was just like, just lay still, I don't do
- 50:16anything, let them take the car, who cares?
- 50:18It's just a car. When her brother-in-law and
- 50:23sister had been killed, hail was in Texas.
- 50:28Hail shows up at Molly's house. In is like listen I'm gonna get
- 50:32you your Vengeance. I promise part of Hale's pasture
- 50:35is set on fire acres of land damaged.
- 50:39Hundreds of cattle dead. Molly just decided she wasn't
- 50:42going to leave the house anymore.
- 50:44She didn't let anybody visit. She stopped going to church.
- 50:49Molly's Faith was gone at this point, Her Health deteriorated.
- 50:54She ended up actually giving her third child with Ernest to other
- 50:59family members to raise because she was like, well, if I'm going
- 51:03to die, maybe one of us can live, so sad.
- 51:09That was a her little two year old Anna at the time.
- 51:12Mmm, also she named the baby after this.
- 51:16Yeah, anyway, we don't hear a whole lot about Molly after
- 51:21this, the local Physicians, the shown Brothers began showing up
- 51:24and giving her injections for her health.
- 51:27That they told her was insulin would should have helped since
- 51:30her her health issue was diabetes raw.
- 51:34But it wasn't, it was not helping at all.
- 51:36And in fact, in 1925, Molly sent a secret message to a priest
- 51:41saying that she was in danger, and she was being poisoned.
- 51:46Yeah, yeah, yeah. You were now at the same time,
- 51:51Tom white is a special agent at the Bureau of Investigation as
- 51:56it was called. He was working in Houston and he
- 51:58received an urgent order from DC.
- 52:01His new boss, J Edgar Hoover was like, I need to talk to you and
- 52:04I need to talk to you in person. Whitehead joined the bureau in
- 52:081917 after he had been barred from joining World War one due
- 52:12to a recent surgery, he still wanted to serve his country but
- 52:16there was also another issue. Tom white was not like a regular
- 52:20Lawman he was a cowboy hmm. He had been raised in the
- 52:24wilderness but he was noticing that the need for Cowboys was
- 52:29slowly shrinking in the u.s. we were moving away from the wild
- 52:32west era and so he was like maybe if I if I Don't get what
- 52:37the new times. I'm going to be left behind you.
- 52:40Yeah, unfortunately, now President Theodore Roosevelt had
- 52:44created The Bureau as a way to fill the void in law enforcement
- 52:47in 1908, it was so new that they only had a couple hundred agents
- 52:50in a few field offices Across America.
- 52:53They hadn't really figured out exactly what they were doing
- 52:55yet. Sometimes they worked on bank
- 52:56fraud or antitrust cases, other times.
- 52:59It was shipments of stolen, cars films, smut all sorts of random
- 53:03stuff being stolen Across America.
- 53:05Other times, they hunted. Escaped prisoner and sometimes
- 53:08they were called in to deal with crimes on Indian reservations.
- 53:11Kind of like now because they're the only ones with jurisdiction
- 53:15because their federal agent They didn't really have any power to
- 53:21arrest, anybody back then, but they were very good at figuring
- 53:25things out. This was like, this was so new
- 53:28that ages didn't even carry weapons.
- 53:30As a part of being an agent Back, Then They Carried weapons
- 53:34because they knew that they were about to be about that business,
- 53:36right? But it wasn't like you have a
- 53:37special issued weapon, right? Okay.
- 53:40So Tom white arrives at the bureau.
- 53:42He here, learns about the case in Osage County, and it had been
- 53:47two years since since the nation had sent, That letter and they
- 53:55had sent other agents to check it out.
- 54:00And all the other agents that said the same thing.
- 54:04There's nothing we can do here. The tribe.
- 54:08It actually sold part of their land to help fund the
- 54:12investigation, which is unheard of and messed up.
- 54:17They ended up selling about 20 thousand dollars worth of lamb
- 54:20which is about three hundred thousand dollars.
- 54:22Now to be told that there was nothing that could be done.
- 54:26Wow. They were just going to drop it
- 54:30back into the locals hands and Hoover was like we need to do
- 54:35this and we need to do it differently.
- 54:37So he convinced the Governor of Oklahoma to release this guy who
- 54:41was known as Blackie Thompson and that's a super racist name
- 54:44because Blackie was literally just like a native man who was
- 54:47like a quarter Indian. He couldn't have been that dark
- 54:50for y'all to name him Blackie. I'm just saying I looked at
- 54:54pictures of him and he was probably a hair darker than I
- 54:57am. Oh wow.
- 54:58Well You know, they used to call I know, but you just go mad
- 55:02about it. So when I talk about him, I just
- 55:04end up writing about him as Thompson, do nothing.
- 55:12Thank you. Like what?
- 55:15I was when I heard his name, I was like oh, he was probably a
- 55:17dark-skinned man. Know they was just racist.
- 55:20Yeah. Okay.
- 55:25Thompson was going to gather evidence working for the bureau.
- 55:30Because they were like listen, No One's Gonna question this
- 55:32convicted bank robber for navigating Osage County.
- 55:35This is where a lot of bank, robbers hide out in the Hills.
- 55:38Unfortunately, the agents had been said to keep an eye on him,
- 55:40lost track of him and it was a chills and he robbed another
- 55:43bank and killed a police officer, and it took them a long
- 55:45time to find them again. So that's kind of why there was
- 55:49that two-year Gap because literally everybody was Trying
- 55:54to deal with the Scandal that they had messed up.
- 55:58In fact, like I said, Hoover had just gotten his job.
- 56:00So he was like, crap, we can't do this before.
- 56:03There was also a whole nother, like Federal Scandal that
- 56:05happened during that time period.
- 56:08So they were really worried about losing Federal funding and
- 56:11proving that the Bureau of Investigation was vital to the
- 56:15Department of Justice. So Hoover brings in Tom.
- 56:21Wait, a cowboy see, there were still.
- 56:24There were a couple of cowboys who worked for the feds at this
- 56:27point but all the new guys who were coming in were what Tom
- 56:30Wright referred to as the college boys.
- 56:33Oh these are people who are going to college and then
- 56:35joining the bureau which is how it works.
- 56:38Now, usually But Tom Wayne understood the assignment.
- 56:44He's like you're not bringing in the military, former military,
- 56:48any former cops, you're calling in somebody who's a friend.
- 56:51Here is a man who has experience dealing with the wild west and
- 56:56osich Hills is the wild west. So they sat white to the
- 57:00Oklahoma field office and the field office, there was in
- 57:03desperate. Need of somebody who knew what
- 57:04they were doing, because they were inundated with crime.
- 57:08Just constant crime. The bootleggers.
- 57:11Is the gambling dens. Like, they were just like,
- 57:13there's so much crime, we can't keep up with it.
- 57:15Help us please. This was both an opportunity and
- 57:19if he messed up, this was going to be a death sentence to his
- 57:22career, other agents who have been sent to Osa chills and who
- 57:26had not done anything. Had either been sent to distant
- 57:29far away, field offices, or outright fired.
- 57:34White was also aware that every single person who had gotten
- 57:36close to the truth here had been murdered, so he knew that he was
- 57:41going to have to operate differently, right?
- 57:43He spent the first part of the summer of 1925 cinch simply
- 57:47catching up on four years of murders and Mayhem in Osage
- 57:50County. He felt that there were had to
- 57:53have been clues in the original files that would like lead him
- 57:56to some answers. And he was surprised to learn
- 57:59that despite Molly Burkhart being the only surviving member
- 58:02of her family. Nobody had decided to interview
- 58:05her. So weird.
- 58:08Yeah, people dropping the ball laughter, right?
- 58:11He noted that Osage murders were definitely not that of a serial
- 58:15killer. We didn't call it a serial
- 58:17killer at the time, but he was just like it's not following any
- 58:19pattern. We had people shot stabbed
- 58:21poisoned, drugged bombs. It was random forms of murder
- 58:26but he noted in his writings that these were very planned out
- 58:32execution. Yes, they every single detail.
- 58:34Nothing left to chance. White knew he couldn't trust
- 58:39anything from the local Lawman or the private detectives.
- 58:43Honestly, the giant file of stuff at the detectives wrote
- 58:47was just a lot of personal opinion just a bullshit
- 58:50basically like they were following stuff but like it was
- 58:53just they wrote down everything. There was no discernment.
- 58:56Oh okay, I got you like she talked about this in the sky was
- 59:00blue. That day.
- 59:01Yeah details I was just like this is so much.
- 59:05No wonder people were overwhelmed by it before.
- 59:09It wasn't an issue like we're sometimes.
- 59:11There were no leads, there were too many leads and they hadn't
- 59:14followed them down and figure them out.
- 59:16Right? So he assumed he was like I need
- 59:19a team and he knew they were going to have a rough time
- 59:23because Witnesses at this point were terrified that they were
- 59:26going to be murdered. Why decided that he was going to
- 59:30be the face of the investigation along with two other regular
- 59:33members of The Bureau and everybody else who was involved
- 59:38will go undercover. He decided the only other people
- 59:43he was going to bring onto the team, we're Cowboys.
- 59:46So he brought in a 56 year. Old Sheriff from New Mexico with
- 59:49a talent for Assuming New identities.
- 59:51Also, a former Texas Ranger who was very well, versed in danger,
- 59:57He brought in a deep-cover agent who looked like an insurance
- 59:59salesman because he had been an insurance salesman, huh?
- 1:00:04He kept one of the previous agents who had gone into Osage
- 1:00:08County before John Berger, John knew the case and had a list of
- 1:00:13criminal informants in Oklahoma. And he also brought in Frank
- 1:00:17Smith, Smith was also older and he was also a cowboy.
- 1:00:21The three of them were going to be like the front people who
- 1:00:24were doing the visible. Esta, gatien that everybody in
- 1:00:28town can see, right? Then they also their last member
- 1:00:31was a man by the name of John Ren.
- 1:00:36John ran is a former spy for revolutionary leaders in Mexico
- 1:00:42and he was also India. Mm-hmm.
- 1:00:45Cool. Smart Ute, which is a tribe that
- 1:00:47lived in what is now Colorado and Utah.
- 1:00:50Ryan was it, incredible investigator but he had been
- 1:00:54fired because he hated to do paperwork.
- 1:00:57I feel that Hoover had actually only reinstated him, roughly a
- 1:01:01few months beforehand and was just like, you got to do what
- 1:01:04you're supposed to do. Man, I dunno supposed to, but
- 1:01:08paperwork is just like, it's above my pay grade, you know I'm
- 1:01:11saying, give me a raise, maybe white needed ran because in
- 1:01:16reading the old investigation papers, There was a lot of
- 1:01:20casual racism in the report and then also a little bit of
- 1:01:24jealousy just because little that casual Reese's one of the
- 1:01:27bits. I read said that the OCH people
- 1:01:30were lazy pathetic, and the only way to get make them talk was to
- 1:01:34cut off their allowance. Wow, that's the person.
- 1:01:37Who's your tribe is. Paying you to be here and fix
- 1:01:40this? Yeah.
- 1:01:41Wow, fuck you. And here's the thing because the
- 1:01:45Osage tribe members could tell that these investigators didn't
- 1:01:47like them. Why would you feel Pell to go
- 1:01:50out on a limb to talk to these people.
- 1:01:52When anybody who talks the law enforcement is literally getting
- 1:01:55murdered like the next Market day.
- 1:01:58But you imagine you have paid three hundred thousand dollars
- 1:02:01for these people do an investigation about and they're
- 1:02:03calling you lazy and entitled. I like okay you can go right?
- 1:02:11Give me my money back. White tells Hoover these are who
- 1:02:13I want and everybody said was that a coded message that said
- 1:02:18proceed under cover immediately reporting to agent in charge.
- 1:02:21Tom white the group, all slipped into town separately and under
- 1:02:26the radar with assumed identities.
- 1:02:28Two of them showed up at will actually want.
- 1:02:30He was one of like a quiet elderly Cattleman from Texas who
- 1:02:35was going to become friends with William hail The man who looks
- 1:02:39like an insurance agent. Open up an insurance business
- 1:02:41in. Downtown Fairfax.
- 1:02:43And he'd go door-to-door specifically, two suspects house
- 1:02:46has to go. Meet them agent Reynolds arrived
- 1:02:49as a medicine, man searching for his long-lost Osage relative.
- 1:02:53Yeah, Ryan attended tribal, Gatherings made friends with
- 1:02:57locals who told him things that they definitely were never going
- 1:03:00to tell white man. When white arrived with the
- 1:03:04other two, this was also the beginning of the FBI wearing the
- 1:03:10black soot Black, Tie, shiny shoes.
- 1:03:13So that's how so white Smith and burger show up to town.
- 1:03:19So they they come with this appearance.
- 1:03:22So everybody knows where you guys investigating.
- 1:03:26Yeah, the four other guys show up working in the oil fields and
- 1:03:29I just looked in the regular Ranch in and I just like Other
- 1:03:33guys, they re set up their shops there before these guys even
- 1:03:36came there and they got they got their information already.
- 1:03:41Okay, cool. I mean this was done very well.
- 1:03:44Yeah, yeah, it's awesome. Okay.
- 1:03:45I like it. So, the first thing that White
- 1:03:50and the other two agents, we're like go there.
- 1:03:53Like where do we start? Well, first thing is they go
- 1:03:56check the justice of the peace. Anna's inquest records are gone,
- 1:03:59stolen. None of Anna's evidence had been
- 1:04:02saved. Saved.
- 1:04:03Literally, the only thing that was left was that the Undertaker
- 1:04:07had kept her skull because they had exhumed her body at one
- 1:04:10point. And the showing Brothers, the
- 1:04:15two medical doctors in town had like, literally chopped up her
- 1:04:20brain to try and find a tiny bullet in it.
- 1:04:25So the Undertaker was like, I'm just gonna keep this skull here.
- 1:04:28Yeah, they entered the rest of her.
- 1:04:30This was useful though because he was able to See what had
- 1:04:33happened. And he came to the same.
- 1:04:37Conclusion as the initial inquest her, there was no exit
- 1:04:40wound. That bullet should have been in
- 1:04:42there, so we do something. Find the hammer, found the
- 1:04:45bullet from Anna. So they stopped at the bring for
- 1:04:47no reason less. What they went back and looked
- 1:04:49at it again, but he was just like, no this what you like, he
- 1:04:55spoke to the Justice. He was like what you said
- 1:04:57originally was right there. Should have been a bullet in her
- 1:04:59brain, mmm. And that meant that one of the
- 1:05:03first people who were there at that inquest.
- 1:05:06Probably took it. In fact, they went and they
- 1:05:11spoke to the show and brothers and they were like, we do know.
- 1:05:15We don't like you. Yeah.
- 1:05:19It's very obvious that they're involved at this point.
- 1:05:21Yeah, there was so much hearsay and that original those 50
- 1:05:25privatized. That wiped is just like, you
- 1:05:27know what? I'm gonna interview everybody on
- 1:05:29my own your guys are going to help me.
- 1:05:32We're going to check out all their Alibis one by one agent
- 1:05:34Burger helped him with this together.
- 1:05:36They ruled out. Most all of the people that the
- 1:05:40Eyes left as Witnesses, including Anna's ex-husband,
- 1:05:43when they looked into the situation was that, oh, Des
- 1:05:49Browne was with a woman in another city.
- 1:05:51And that was accurate. They were divorced.
- 1:05:55He was allowed to be out there. Slut right.
- 1:05:56Right. Right, right.
- 1:05:57Yeah. Do you think he was out there?
- 1:06:01You know, meet ladies, if living is best?
- 1:06:04Like, they looked into the rumor that and I had been killed by
- 1:06:06the girlfriend of someone. She was having an affair with
- 1:06:10what they realized through doing that investigation was that the
- 1:06:13private eyes had written down everything that everybody told
- 1:06:16them and white determined. Oh some of this is just straight
- 1:06:21lies. This is manufactured to
- 1:06:23specifically throw people off. Hmm.
- 1:06:27J. Edgar Hoover also helped a
- 1:06:29little bit from DC. He actually demanded daily
- 1:06:31reports. So they descent daily coated
- 1:06:34telegrams to him to DC, but he was just like, there's a white
- 1:06:39woman you have listed here. Her name is Nisha, Kenny and
- 1:06:42she's married to an Osage, man. And I think she's part of this
- 1:06:45conspiracy Kenny had a history of mental illness issues and she
- 1:06:49believes she was possessed and had tried to kill a local
- 1:06:52attorney, but Hoover had interviewed her twice and even
- 1:06:55had a government expert on Mental Health.
- 1:06:57Evaluate her. They realize they were like,
- 1:07:00she's a bit paranoid, but she's very perceptive.
- 1:07:03So while she'll make a terrible witness, she will be able to
- 1:07:06help us with the leads, hmm? Okay, Hoover also pointed out
- 1:07:10that aw Comstock that Guardian. Was not the worst person, he had
- 1:07:20an issue like they had real beef because Comstock had criticized
- 1:07:25him to the bureau and threatened to turn Senator Curtis against
- 1:07:29Hoover. So initially Hoover was not on
- 1:07:35board with Comstock being a part of this, right, right.
- 1:07:38White was just like he was showing up giving us a little
- 1:07:41bit of information then hiding again because Comstock realized
- 1:07:45that this was real. Real deal.
- 1:07:48People are still Dying by the end of July.
- 1:07:50White begins looking into brianburkhardt Molly's
- 1:07:53brother-in-law. The last person who'd seen
- 1:07:55alive. Anybody need a refresher.
- 1:07:59He swore that he took Ana home between 4:30 and 5:00 p.m. and
- 1:08:04then gone into Fairfax to see a show with William Hale and his
- 1:08:07brother Ernest and two, other family members, and aunt, and
- 1:08:10uncle. This seemed like a solid Alibi.
- 1:08:13So agent Burger traveled to Brian's family's house in
- 1:08:17Northern Texas, which is Campbell, Texas, and lo and
- 1:08:21behold, William Hale had also grown up near Campbell Texas to
- 1:08:25oh wow, honey. When they got when Burger got to
- 1:08:30Campbells family's house, sorry to the house.
- 1:08:34And in Campbell Ryan's Uncle wasn't there but his aunt was
- 1:08:38there and she launched into an entire tirade about how Earnest
- 1:08:43had married. One of those red Millionaires
- 1:08:45and she didn't like it, she was in the middle of this crazy
- 1:08:49conversation with agent burger and Brian's.
- 1:08:54Uncle comes in. And is like Brian was with us.
- 1:08:58Y'all need to leave. Uh-huh.
- 1:09:03Excuse me sir. But how the hell you know, how
- 1:09:06do you know what I'm here for? Yep, he was just like, listen
- 1:09:08stop. He was like Brian was with us.
- 1:09:10You'll need to look into this. He has an alibi.
- 1:09:13Y'all need to get out of my house.
- 1:09:15Hmm, I don't trust, his Alibi is not very trustworthy.
- 1:09:18I don't think so either. So it's August of 1925, white
- 1:09:22undercover agents. Go into the town of Ralston.
- 1:09:26There was an old lead that Anna had been spotted by a group of
- 1:09:29white. Men who have been sitting
- 1:09:31outside of a hotel in Ralston on Main Street, previous detectives
- 1:09:35had spoken to the group of men and they were like, we have no
- 1:09:37idea what you're talking about. they track down an old man, who
- 1:09:41was originally kind of worried at them first, but once he
- 1:09:45realized that they were legit, he was like, oh yeah bat he was
- 1:09:48like I was there and I definitely did talk to Anna.
- 1:09:53In fact, I know I talked to her because I was like, hey, Annie
- 1:09:59And he said that she wasn't slumped over drunk and she was
- 1:10:03in the car with brianburkhardt and Bryant was driving.
- 1:10:06He was definitely not in Fairfax because he was in Ralston at
- 1:10:09like midnight. Hmm interesting.
- 1:10:13There were other Witnesses who confirmed that Brian was driving
- 1:10:16the car too and this was the first kind of crack and
- 1:10:20brianburkhardt sli's there was no way he was both in Fairfax
- 1:10:24and Ralston at the same time. No you're not a time traveler
- 1:10:27sir. So It follows this lead and he
- 1:10:30follows agent Burgers. Network of informants and be
- 1:10:33they kind of create a timeline. So Brian and Anna had stopped at
- 1:10:37a speakeasy in Ralston and stayed there until 10 p.m. then
- 1:10:40they headed to another underground bar.
- 1:10:42A couple miles north of Fairfax Brian's Uncle from Campbell was
- 1:10:46spotted with them that night but he left before they left that
- 1:10:51bar at 1 a.m. then they kind of disappear for about two hours
- 1:10:57and other People who he interviewed him.
- 1:11:00Ralston said that they saw Brian Anna and a third man.
- 1:11:04They didn't know at about 3 a.m. In fact, someone who knew Brian
- 1:11:11said that she heard him get out of a car.
- 1:11:16They were a like in Fairfax and he was yelling at Anna to get
- 1:11:20back in the car. That's the last time.
- 1:11:23They anybody in Ralston or Fairfax are hurt Anna, huh?
- 1:11:29And actually he found out from these witnesses that after they
- 1:11:32initially had, told that stuff to the private eyes.
- 1:11:36Someone had come around and paid everybody off.
- 1:11:40Interesting. So at the end of the summer now,
- 1:11:44White's like there's definitely a mole in this investigation.
- 1:11:48One of his agents have been questioning a local like crappy
- 1:11:52attorney and the attorney knew a lot about the case, the attorney
- 1:11:55was like, oh, I've seen part of the Bureau reports and I can see
- 1:11:59more of them if I want to. This wasn't really anything new
- 1:12:02in the bureau's past breach has happened a lot, but the problem
- 1:12:06is this kind of a breach had was going to get a lot of people
- 1:12:09killed. Yeah.
- 1:12:09Like Literally as soon as someone says they have
- 1:12:12information, about this case, they go dying in the next day.
- 1:12:17On top of that, two of the previous Burns detectives, try
- 1:12:21to expose one of burgers, informants, Kelsey Morrison and
- 1:12:28they lied and told local PD that Kelsey Morrison had committed a
- 1:12:35robbery and he hadn't. So, Kelsey gets pulled into
- 1:12:39local PD. Ancient Burger reports that the
- 1:12:43local law men are trying to mess up their investigation.
- 1:12:46After Morrison is released, he super freaked out and is like
- 1:12:50can you get these guys before they kill me?
- 1:12:52No agent Burgers. Like, you need to lay low, watch
- 1:12:56out for traps. Like if this was so like, when I
- 1:13:00say that the, the identities of those four men who were
- 1:13:04undercover were so important, white never met with them
- 1:13:08anywhere near Fairfax, and it was never during the day, they
- 1:13:12met in the middle of the countryside at night to exchange
- 1:13:17information. They all were told to always
- 1:13:19carry their weapons. Make sure you aren't being
- 1:13:21followed. In case your cover gets blown,
- 1:13:24you need to be able to defend yourself, right?
- 1:13:26Right. So that white looks into the
- 1:13:29private eye who hail hired in 1921 our boy.
- 1:13:32Pike, the one who you know said that he just quit and left town.
- 1:13:36Yeah, right. Well, Why it's walking around
- 1:13:40town one. They're all like kind of just
- 1:13:42doing the regular thing. Agent Burger is just a random
- 1:13:47guy walks up to him and it's just like Pike and I work
- 1:13:50together. Pike has something he wants to
- 1:13:52tell you, but he's not going to tell you about it.
- 1:13:56Unless you pay him very well. Pike.
- 1:13:59He says Pike knows the identity of the third man who was with
- 1:14:05Anna at 3:00 before she died. Of course, Asian Burgers.
- 1:14:12Like I do want to let you know, you are attempting to extort the
- 1:14:16federal government right now. Yeah.
- 1:14:19You should just have him come to us and talk to us.
- 1:14:21We could protect him and the guys like yeah, no.
- 1:14:27So they launched their own investigation to find Pike and
- 1:14:30they do of course he did because he gets arrested commit and
- 1:14:33highway robbery and Tulsa Oklahoma, dude.
- 1:14:36Come on. So when to attempt to get like a
- 1:14:40lesser, Sentence. Hike tells them that there was a
- 1:14:46local Gambler who had been with the three of them, but the
- 1:14:50Gambler had gone home before the third man arrived.
- 1:14:54So this was a useless lead from Pike.
- 1:14:57Go to jail, don't collect $200. Yeah, but he was so pretty much
- 1:15:02Pike. Gave them another person they
- 1:15:04hung out with but not the one they wanted.
- 1:15:06Then why did he say that? He had information?
- 1:15:08You just want the money, these won the money.
- 1:15:10He was just trying to Extort them dumbass.
- 1:15:13Okay now they did learn something from Pike though.
- 1:15:16The three of them. Put a lot of pressure on Pike
- 1:15:18and he went I wasn't hired to find, Anna's killer.
- 1:15:23I was hired to conceal. Where Brian was that night?
- 1:15:27I was hired to falsify evidence. I was hired to create for fake
- 1:15:31Witnesses and to manufacture an alibi for brianburkhardt.
- 1:15:36Ha ha ha ha. And he said This all came from
- 1:15:41William hail. Fuck you.
- 1:15:44Okay. Now he'll head and said,
- 1:15:47directly that Brian was the killer just that he needed.
- 1:15:50Brian to be clean. Mmm.
- 1:15:52That's his nephew. He's looking out for his family.
- 1:15:56It was a big deal though because literally everybody in this
- 1:15:58town, trusted. William hail.
- 1:16:01And now, Tom white has evidence that William Hale is big bad
- 1:16:06guy. So yeah he'll had well Not only
- 1:16:10that he'd been lying to Molly for four years.
- 1:16:15So, they asked him. Is Hale involved?
- 1:16:20Or is he just covering for his family?
- 1:16:24Pike isn't sure, but he's just like Sometimes when I would meet
- 1:16:28with hail Brian was there and so was Ernest, Molly's husband?
- 1:16:38Ernest Burkhart was in on this from the jump.
- 1:16:41So he must have been a third person that was there.
- 1:16:43Then we'll see at this point. It's very obvious to the
- 1:16:47investigators that the Burkhart family is part of this
- 1:16:49conspiracy and he's like. Did Bill Smith figured this out?
- 1:16:53Is that why he got blown up? Because that was his
- 1:16:56brother-in-law, you know, they were related through marriage,
- 1:16:59right? Smith hadn't, covered that lizzi
- 1:17:01had been poisoned and he was following the trail related to
- 1:17:04the Head Right money. Remember, I told you that bill
- 1:17:09would wake up and start panicking that like he said
- 1:17:11something. Yeah.
- 1:17:13Shortly before build died, James and David shown.
- 1:17:18Thus doctors called bills attorney and had him come to the
- 1:17:25hospital. Why way specifically met with
- 1:17:31Bill and made? Sure.
- 1:17:32There were no nurses around. Tom white is very suspicious of
- 1:17:37the shown Brothers. At this point, you should be, he
- 1:17:40was already suspicious because of that missing bullet.
- 1:17:44And he questioned, everybody who'd been in the room.
- 1:17:47The doctor said they called those lawyer hoping that he
- 1:17:49would tell them who was attacked.
- 1:17:51But Tom was like why don't you call Justice of the Peace or
- 1:17:53somebody who could have arrested somebody?
- 1:17:55Yeah, they like it didn't matter.
- 1:17:56Bill didn't say anything. He didn't name his Killers but
- 1:18:03what he did tell us attorney was that he only had two enemies in
- 1:18:06this world. William K hail the king of Osa
- 1:18:10chills and his nephew Ernest. Becker.
- 1:18:15Okay. Now, Tom, wait, Tom and his
- 1:18:19agents determined that the shown Brothers had orchestrated that
- 1:18:21kneeling for their own purposes. The lawyer had been called in to
- 1:18:26bring paperwork and that paperwork.
- 1:18:29They got built a sign when he was just Lucid enough.
- 1:18:33Allowing his brother to be appointed to his wife's estate.
- 1:18:38So Rita Rita's had right money. They had Bill sign it away. but
- 1:18:46the problem was Well, okay, so this is obviously the first
- 1:18:50direct connection to these murders being super tied to the
- 1:18:54Head, Right? Mm-hmm.
- 1:18:55White, look more into it and it was just corruption on top of
- 1:18:57corruption. Some of the Guardians had been
- 1:19:00appointed to the Osage tribe were decent, but most of them
- 1:19:02were just straight up robbing people of their money.
- 1:19:05Like, he would find out that like a person be like, hey, I
- 1:19:08want to use my money to buy a car and the guardian be like,
- 1:19:10bet I'll go get you a car and he buy the car for about $250 and
- 1:19:14then sell it to his client for 1012 $250.
- 1:19:18Wow. Eating the thousand dollars
- 1:19:19himself Guardians were getting kickbacks from the banks that
- 1:19:23held the money stores that they, that the people shopped at,
- 1:19:27sometimes they would just outright buy land in the name of
- 1:19:32their clients but it was for them.
- 1:19:35Hmm. Even worse the US government was
- 1:19:39looking at these purchases and going, the Osage people are
- 1:19:42really spending frivolously and the O's is people are begging
- 1:19:47for like to use their money. To like bite to build schools,
- 1:19:50right? They want to do good for a
- 1:19:52community, a government study actually was launched after this
- 1:19:56whole thing happen and it showed that those Guardians stole eight
- 1:20:00million dollars from the Osage people, just in the early 1920s.
- 1:20:05What the fuck? And all those Guardians were the
- 1:20:10most prominent men in town, local judges lawyers
- 1:20:13prosecutors. There was one judge who
- 1:20:15legitimately was telling people, if you vote for me, I'll make
- 1:20:19sure you get on this Guardian action, that's sickening.
- 1:20:26Some of the Guardians would clean out the account and then
- 1:20:28tell their client, you don't have any more money.
- 1:20:32And just leave the person to just live in poverty.
- 1:20:35There was one instance where a guardian let a child die instead
- 1:20:39of giving them money from the account, what the fuck.
- 1:20:43And the thing is, it wasn't that the Osage people weren't aware
- 1:20:45of what was happening. It was just that they were like,
- 1:20:47this is just another way that the u.s. government is screwing
- 1:20:50us over. It like that again they couldn't
- 1:20:52do anything about this either because they were appointed,
- 1:20:55Guardian government Guardians. Yeah.
- 1:20:58Goes was like this. This is Christ startling for
- 1:21:01white because He had read a lot of the same newspaper stories
- 1:21:05and other Americans read was that the Osage people all had 11
- 1:21:08cars and they all lived in fancy money and they were all stupid.
- 1:21:11Wealthy. Yeah.
- 1:21:12Beloved car is not all my name. Well, they all right.
- 1:21:15Yeah, they're all my name but guess what?
- 1:21:17I don't drive any and his cousin and uncle.
- 1:21:19Yeah. Everybody else has a car.
- 1:21:21I don't have a car. Exactly.
- 1:21:23God. So what we learned was that
- 1:21:29people felt helpless and that they had nobody on their side
- 1:21:31which was why they fell. Ain't no real desire to talk to
- 1:21:36anybody who came to help him about this.
- 1:21:39So, in September of 1925, the undercover insurance agent stops
- 1:21:43at a gas station in Fairfax and starts talking to a woman who
- 1:21:46worked there. He's like, hey, I've been here
- 1:21:48for a couple months and I think I want to buy a house and the
- 1:21:52lady is just like, oh yeah. Well you got to talk to Bill
- 1:21:54hail. He owns everything here.
- 1:21:56She said that she had brought her home from Hale and she lived
- 1:21:59pretty close to him. And that one night, thousands of
- 1:22:02Acres of Bill's land had been set on fire and it was meant to
- 1:22:06seem like it was for other reasons but she knew the real
- 1:22:09reason and the real reason was that bill hail wanted insurance
- 1:22:13money. And in fact he had collected 30
- 1:22:15thousand dollars from that stretch of land being burned.
- 1:22:22White's going to look in the helm or remember Henry Rowan.
- 1:22:27Yeah. Who'd been shot in the head
- 1:22:30twice and found in his car. He's Frozen.
- 1:22:32Yep. Well Bill.
- 1:22:34Hail made this big to-do about how he and Henry Rowan were best
- 1:22:38friends and that Rowan had been kind of cheated by his guardian
- 1:22:43and didn't have any money. And so, Bill Hale had given him
- 1:22:49over twelve thousand dollars because they were such good
- 1:22:52friends. I don't give that kind of money
- 1:22:55to my friends. Anyway, well just before Rowan
- 1:23:00died. There was an insurance policy
- 1:23:03that was taken out on his life 25,000 dollars.
- 1:23:08And Bill was the beneficiary, of course you was, and, of course,
- 1:23:12right after that, Ron ended up with a bullet in his head.
- 1:23:15But no one had even interviewed bill as a suspect.
- 1:23:18And so, white track down the insurance agent, who told a very
- 1:23:22different story than Hale had tone of hounds book.
- 1:23:24Remember because bills, like, we're such good friends.
- 1:23:27He listed me because I was the last person, you know, they were
- 1:23:30like, well, why not? His wife was like, oh, that's
- 1:23:32because his wife was cheating on him with somebody else of
- 1:23:35course, which was true, but he was like he just didn't want her
- 1:23:40to have any of the money but beside the point what the
- 1:23:43insurance agent said was that Hale had pushed for the policy
- 1:23:48and the insurance agent was like well most people only need about
- 1:23:5110,000 dollars Max especially indigenous people because once
- 1:23:56the town got wind of all that money, it became very expensive
- 1:24:04to bury indigenous people and the area of course and they I
- 1:24:07jacked up the price of funerals for the Osage tribes members to
- 1:24:12the tune of roughly 8,000 dollars.
- 1:24:14That's a lot of money. Now, that's way too much money
- 1:24:19back then for a funeral. Yeah, yeah.
- 1:24:23So, the typical amount that they would give for something like
- 1:24:26that was about 10 grand for an indigenous person to pay for
- 1:24:29their funeral, things of that nature, you know, help the
- 1:24:32family out a little bit. I mean, they would have been
- 1:24:34fine because eventually the head right money would come in the
- 1:24:36next couple of months, and the family would be able to do what
- 1:24:38they need to do. Right, right.
- 1:24:40Hale says, he'll pushes the policy from 10,000 to 25,000
- 1:24:45saying that Rowan owned him money white, didn't think that,
- 1:24:48that was real. Because if it was real all Hill
- 1:24:52would have had, Do was present proof of that debt to the Rowan
- 1:24:57estate, and it would have been paid back because that money is
- 1:25:00still dropping into an account. It's possible that Rowan never
- 1:25:08even knew that this policy was taken out on his life.
- 1:25:11I'm Imagine and after Rowan's funeral, they tried to pin the
- 1:25:17murder on the man who had been sleeping with his wife.
- 1:25:21And in fact, hail like was like you need to lead run and
- 1:25:26actually the guy was like, know if I run people are going to
- 1:25:29think. I did it.
- 1:25:30He was right. Yeah.
- 1:25:32I mean yeah. You were going to you did it
- 1:25:34real. He'll also visited Rowan's Widow
- 1:25:37and left a bottle of whiskey for her and she need to supposed to
- 1:25:42have it because she was Like think that's poison.
- 1:25:45Yes, it was. I guarantee you, it was fucking
- 1:25:49poison white discovered that Hale had even tried to buy
- 1:25:53Rowan's head right previously, but that literally went against
- 1:25:58the government's ruling, there was no way you could sell your
- 1:26:02own head, right? But the only way it could Pat be
- 1:26:03passed down. Was through inheritance or like
- 1:26:05dual will white followed the head rates and realized that
- 1:26:09these were all being slowly trickling back to Molly
- 1:26:12Burkhardt and if she It would go to her children and her husband,
- 1:26:16Ernest Burkhart, ours. Just get the fuck out of here.
- 1:26:20You get hers out of this man has money went to Lizzie.
- 1:26:24Lizzie's money was dispersed back to her kids when she died
- 1:26:27Rita's. Money was actually supposed to
- 1:26:29go to Mali to the killer hadn't intended for Bill, to outlive
- 1:26:34Rita, which is why they had to go and have him have Bill filed
- 1:26:38that document before he died. Right.
- 1:26:40Right. But the bulk of all of these had
- 1:26:43rights Now, belong to Molly. Burkhardt she's received be
- 1:26:46receiving roughly four or five times her normal allotment girl.
- 1:26:53Watch out, they looked into, it's got Mathis.
- 1:26:56Who was the guardian of both Anna Brown and Lizzie in the
- 1:26:59back pocket of hail every bit of corruption that agent, white
- 1:27:04found in Fairfax had a connection to William hail, and
- 1:27:07that made it very hard to get any justice.
- 1:27:10So, in the fall of 25 white told who Hoover.
- 1:27:14I have to get evidence to put hail away and his accomplices,
- 1:27:18there was pressure from White's bosses but also presage pressure
- 1:27:23from the Osage people who were, like we really appreciate what
- 1:27:27you're doing but we're still scared.
- 1:27:28Hmm. White was finally kind of on the
- 1:27:32same line with usage people, which was that there is no way.
- 1:27:37Any of the corrupt, white citizens of osich hills were
- 1:27:40going to implicate one of their own people and murdering
- 1:27:42Indians. So he turned to The Outlaws
- 1:27:46instead, these men were any less racist but some of them wanted
- 1:27:49Hale gone too. He specifically talk to Dick.
- 1:27:53Greg, a well-known Outlaw who had information, but he didn't
- 1:27:57want to tell it all white met with him.
- 1:27:59And realized that dick Greg would easily backstabbed roughly
- 1:28:02anybody, he knew but not William.
- 1:28:05Hail Greg did however let agent white know that Hale had met
- 1:28:10with the outlaw out Spencer and his gang which Greg had been a
- 1:28:14part of in 1922 and that Hale had offered them two thousand
- 1:28:20dollars to kill Rita and Bill Smith.
- 1:28:22Al Spencer had declined saying we're criminals but we're not
- 1:28:26hit men and we're not just going to murder some innocent lady.
- 1:28:29Yep in her bag. So white ended up then going to
- 1:28:32Henry grammar the Bootleggers who Bill visited Just like every
- 1:28:37other witness against Hale, grammar have been killed shortly
- 1:28:40after Bill died in 1923, there was a clear sign that if you
- 1:28:44were a business, if you were a criminal who did business with
- 1:28:46William hail you were going to die after your business was
- 1:28:49concluded, oof they still had their other informant Kelsey
- 1:28:53Morrison, who told white really bad news Beal?
- 1:28:58Hell knows you're onto him. One of the undercover agents had
- 1:29:03gotten close to Hale. And when they talked about the
- 1:29:07case, he'll was like, it's all good.
- 1:29:10I'm bulletproof. Oh really now sir?
- 1:29:15So at that white was like, okay we're safe for now, they don't
- 1:29:17think we're a real threat, they just know that we know about it.
- 1:29:22October of 25 agent white gets a tip, a prisoner named Bert
- 1:29:26Lawson knew a lot about the Osage murders.
- 1:29:29So white and Frank Smith go to Macalester, prison to talk to
- 1:29:33him, Lawson had been a ranch hand for Bill Smith, and threw
- 1:29:37him had met the rest of the Hale family, all the brothers and all
- 1:29:40that. So when Bill Smith and Lawson
- 1:29:43had a falling out, Ernest Burkhart had gone to Lawson and
- 1:29:47was like, listen, I need you to kill my brother-in-law, Bill
- 1:29:50Smith. I'll give you five grand and
- 1:29:53lost them was like listen, it's not really what I do.
- 1:29:59But then lost and got arrested and he needed lawyers.
- 1:30:02So he said that he agreed to do it out of desperation and that
- 1:30:05Ernest, provided him with nitroglycerin and it even
- 1:30:08dropped him off at Bill's house to do the deed.
- 1:30:10And then they snuck him back into the local jail while the
- 1:30:12cops were at the explosion. On October 24th. 1925 white
- 1:30:18sends a telegram to Hoover saying, they have a confession
- 1:30:20of the person who set the bomb Hoover was like bet.
- 1:30:24Congratulations. This is when Comstock starts
- 1:30:28receiving threats for helping with the investigation and have
- 1:30:31even found Dynamite planted in like his windows at his house.
- 1:30:35Like it opened the windows. Yeah.
- 1:30:37To let the air in and he was just like there is there's a but
- 1:30:41I know might hear this not good because a boom stick in my
- 1:30:44window. So John ran, the UK Jack had
- 1:30:48spoken to Molly's priest and Molly's priest was like, yeah
- 1:30:52she hasn't been to church in like a long time but she did
- 1:30:55send me a message saying She was poisoned.
- 1:30:58And so the priest was told Ren. I told her don't drink any
- 1:31:03alcohol under any circumstances. Wasn't alcohol.
- 1:31:07That's the thing. They didn't realize that it was
- 1:31:09the insulin injections that were being poisoned and Molly was
- 1:31:12100%, right? It was just happening, very
- 1:31:15slowly, as to present itself as an a slow ending illness, just
- 1:31:19like her mother. Yeah.
- 1:31:23Finally, it was December 1925. Agent.
- 1:31:25White couldn't wait any longer. He sent out warrants to arrest,
- 1:31:28will help William Hale and his nephew Ernest Burkhart Earnest
- 1:31:32got picked up right away and they took him to a jail and got
- 1:31:35three which was a roughly like Southwest like 80 miles.
- 1:31:39He'll actually couldn't be found and they had learned that he
- 1:31:43liked bought a fancy new outfit and then he strolled into the
- 1:31:46Sheriff's Office and was like understand.
- 1:31:48I'm wanted oh my God. And so they took him to jail and
- 1:31:51Guthrie to they were held separately and they actually put
- 1:31:56our In this area of the prison that was hot as hell like.
- 1:32:00So he would be super uncomfortable.
- 1:32:04They in fact, all the police in Guthrie were like Earnest is
- 1:32:09gonna break first. He he just seems like he would
- 1:32:13no one breaks in the first 24 hours, Ernest, just sit there
- 1:32:16saying over and over your informant is lying.
- 1:32:20Hales like I have an alibi. I was I literally got a telegram
- 1:32:24in Texas and signed for it. How was I there for bills
- 1:32:27assassination? White goes out in a lamb and he
- 1:32:33decides I need to bring Blackie Thompson it.
- 1:32:36Forgot all about Blackie got you will remember.
- 1:32:39They had originally used him and then had to put him back in
- 1:32:42prison because he was a little too rowdy.
- 1:32:43Yeah, so he didn't even. So here's the thing.
- 1:32:46White didn't even like talk to Hoover about this because had he
- 1:32:50asked for permission Hoover would have said, no, because
- 1:32:52that had been a big scandal at had gotten him in trouble.
- 1:32:58But what he did do was Whitehead Thompson.
- 1:33:03Always under an armed guard. They he legitimately had a
- 1:33:08Rifleman on a nearby building. Always with his rifle on
- 1:33:15Thompson the entire time. He was there.
- 1:33:18Like they took every attempt to make sure Thompson did not
- 1:33:24Escape So they bring in Thompson, he's initially kind of
- 1:33:30hostile and rude. But when agent white goes,
- 1:33:34listen, I don't want to know about anything else you're
- 1:33:35doing. I want to know about, Bill Hale
- 1:33:38and your connections to him and osich else.
- 1:33:41And that's when they noticed that Thompson was like no longer
- 1:33:45as aggressive. He told white, told him.
- 1:33:51Listen, I can't shorten your sentence.
- 1:33:53You're literally in jail for life.
- 1:33:56But eventually Thompson began talking and he said that he had
- 1:33:59also been offered money to Kill Bill and Rita Smith.
- 1:34:04So they took that back to Burkhardt and they said listen
- 1:34:09we have a second witness willing to testify that you conspired to
- 1:34:13Kill Bill and Rita Smith and so Earnest is like nah nah you
- 1:34:18don't and he's like who recommend?
- 1:34:21So they bring in Thompson into the same room with Earnest and
- 1:34:26Earnest Burkhart is shook. Circus Thompson.
- 1:34:31Looks at Earnest and goes listener and eat.
- 1:34:33I told him everything. Burkhart is almost like he wants
- 1:34:39to talk but he's too scared multiple times, he liked starts
- 1:34:42the conversation and discuss I can't They take Thompson back to
- 1:34:48his cell white goes home. A little bit defeated.
- 1:34:52He's like, maybe the whole that Hale has on his nephews is just
- 1:34:56too much. In the middle of night though,
- 1:34:58he gets a phone call and he's worried, he's like, oh God it's
- 1:35:01a phone call like midnight. Does that mean Tom said escaped
- 1:35:05or somebody killed himself or something like that?
- 1:35:08No, it was the prison aren't. His Burkhart is ready to talk.
- 1:35:12Oh, okay. Brock Holt was told his rights,
- 1:35:16he And a paper saying he waved them and he made a statement
- 1:35:19implicating not just his uncle in the bomb plot but connecting
- 1:35:23hail to a lot of the criminals that agent Smith had learned
- 1:35:26about Burkhardt told them that Lawson actually had lied and the
- 1:35:31bomber was not Lawson. It was a demolition expert that
- 1:35:34they had found named ASA Kirby. ASA, Kirby had been eliminated,
- 1:35:40just like all the other criminals, that's why you
- 1:35:42haven't heard of them, right? That's why loss of the still
- 1:35:45alive. If he had been the one who done
- 1:35:46it, he dead very true. He said that bill Hills.
- 1:35:51Alibi was real. He had just paid Kirby to do the
- 1:35:54murder Burke her. Turned out on a lot of people.
- 1:36:00He implicated a man named John Ramsey, unknown cow Thief for
- 1:36:03killing Henry Rowan. Ramsey initially played dumb
- 1:36:07until they brought Burkhart signed confession to him and he
- 1:36:09went I guess it's on my neck now.
- 1:36:12Get your pencils. The only person that Ernest
- 1:36:16dimming implicating, his confession was his brother
- 1:36:19brianburkhardt. Why not?
- 1:36:21And Brian was the Prime is this Brother?
- 1:36:23Come on, man, his uncle but honest to give them the name of
- 1:36:29the third man who was with Brian and Anna was in Earnest now who
- 1:36:34was Is it Kelsey Morrison the informant that they'd had the
- 1:36:40entire time. He didn't want to implicate
- 1:36:42himself what, in fact, Kelsey Morrison is the person that
- 1:36:46killed Anna. Wow.
- 1:36:49Okay. So they went to go gather
- 1:36:52Morrison and they decide to check on Molly Burkhardt.
- 1:36:56He was near death. And coincidentally, as soon as
- 1:37:00her husband was locked up and the injection stopped, Molly got
- 1:37:04better. To the damn Brothers, what we're
- 1:37:07brothers at Hearn has never admitted to poisoning his wife,
- 1:37:11the show and brothers were brought in and they were asked
- 1:37:14about what they were using to treat Molly, they never gave a
- 1:37:18straight answer. Like I read the interviews
- 1:37:23there. So kg like, like I said, like,
- 1:37:27explain to you the answers that the show and brothers gave were
- 1:37:30the same, but also very cagey. Like, at one point he was just
- 1:37:33like, Well, why'd you ask the nurse to leave?
- 1:37:36He was like, I don't remember asking the nurse to leave.
- 1:37:38He was like, well, did she lie? And he's like, no.
- 1:37:39If she said, I asked her to leave I did, but there's lots of
- 1:37:42reasons why I could ask a nurse to leave, okay?
- 1:37:45It was that kind of stuff. Like it was so cyclical.
- 1:37:48And honestly, I think that I would white was just like, I'm
- 1:37:52fed up with y'all. I want to choke that unlike you
- 1:37:55better answer my questions correctly.
- 1:37:58No, it was always, it was really kg.
- 1:38:00It was very cyclical every time. Like they were like, oh, you
- 1:38:04know, are you sure it was insulin that you were giving
- 1:38:06Molly Burkhart? Well, we thought it was insulin,
- 1:38:09we don't know. We just get the syringes, we're
- 1:38:11not putting it in there, you are putting it in her.
- 1:38:16So you should know what you're giving a patient.
- 1:38:20Paige I hate. Yeah, there they are.
- 1:38:23The two. I hate In This Very Room of all
- 1:38:26the people. You're mad at your mad at David
- 1:38:28show at these two people you're pissing me off.
- 1:38:32Okay. Anyway, on this, though, Molly's
- 1:38:35like I really want the people who killed my family to go to
- 1:38:39prison and they're like everybody.
- 1:38:41And she's like, yeah, everybody. And they're like Ernest, she's
- 1:38:43like, I love Earnest, she's really struggling.
- 1:38:46She's just like, no, it's not him.
- 1:38:50It was Earnest to with all the other confessions agent white
- 1:38:55goes back to hail. He's like, listen, we have all
- 1:38:59this evidence against you. An it's going to be so messy.
- 1:39:03Your family is going to be implicated.
- 1:39:05It's going to be a big shame to your family.
- 1:39:08Do you really want to do all this?
- 1:39:12He'll was like I'll fight it. Oh okay.
- 1:39:19So, I went to court hail and the co-conspirators were tried in
- 1:39:23both state and federal court between 1926 and 1929.
- 1:39:27It was state and federal court because some of the murders were
- 1:39:30done off the reservation. So those were tried in local
- 1:39:33Court, whereas the ones on the reservation, we're done.
- 1:39:37We're heading federally, I'm going to save you.
- 1:39:40A lot of the sort of details, there were a lot of Deadlock
- 1:39:42juries there were appeals overturned verdicts. halfway
- 1:39:48through Earnest trial, like he was messed up like he was just
- 1:39:53He's described during his trial as just looking Haggard at one
- 1:39:58point Hale and him have the same attorney and they bring him in
- 1:40:02too. Like he walks in and he was like
- 1:40:07wait. He's on our side and so they
- 1:40:13make him go talk to that attorney.
- 1:40:15And when he comes back, he starts recanting, all of his
- 1:40:18confession on the stand. That gets everything.
- 1:40:21Shut down. It's a big craziness.
- 1:40:24And finally, that night, after Earnest was put back in prison,
- 1:40:27he actually requested the judge and he was just like, I don't
- 1:40:29want to do this anymore. The judges like what do you
- 1:40:32mean? He's like why aren't you talking
- 1:40:33to your attorney? He's like, they won't let me do
- 1:40:35what I want to do and judges like what do you want to do?
- 1:40:37He's like, can I just go to prison for life?
- 1:40:41Can we just be done with us? This is really stressful and so
- 1:40:43the judge was like okay he's like no death penalty, you just
- 1:40:48go to jail forever. Hmm.
- 1:40:52He turned State's evidence and told the police that Hale had.
- 1:40:58Also gotten George big heart killed as well.
- 1:41:02George big heart has been to see hail And then come home and I'd
- 1:41:09he implicated his uncle in the poisoning of Joe Bates.
- 1:41:13The trials were pretty heated, Kelsey Morrison finally admitted
- 1:41:18to killing Anna Brown at the request of hail and he said that
- 1:41:22Brian was his. Accomplice Brian also turns
- 1:41:25State's evidence, it took four separate Charles to get hail
- 1:41:29convicted. Wow.
- 1:41:30October 29th 1929, he was only convicted for one murder.
- 1:41:36Come on, huh? We didn't rear Owen?
- 1:41:40Okay. Well, how long is he put away
- 1:41:42for Or he was given life in prison and sent to Leavenworth
- 1:41:46Prison in Kansas, okay? Unfortunately.
- 1:41:49He was paroled on July, 31st 1947 after serving 17 years in
- 1:41:54prison, he moved to Montana because he literally lost
- 1:41:57everything in Oklahoma good where he became a ranch hand.
- 1:42:01He died in Arizona and 1962 and was buried in Wichita, Kansas,
- 1:42:06what'd he, die of natural causes, damn it cools old by
- 1:42:11then he was in his 80s. Despite all the setbacks this
- 1:42:16was seen as a major win for the bureau, which would become the
- 1:42:19FBI in 1935, that's awesome and become its own.
- 1:42:24It wasn't just a part of the Department of Justice anymore.
- 1:42:26It was its own Federal Bureau of Investigation Bernie's Burkhart
- 1:42:30received life in prison and got a full pardon from Oklahoma,
- 1:42:36governor Henry bellmon in 1965, he wanted to go to jail, I know.
- 1:42:43Molly divorced, her husband. Got remarried to a man named
- 1:42:46John Cobb. They were very happy.
- 1:42:48Actually, during Ernest trial. Their daughter Anna died.
- 1:42:52She was 40. It was really just devastating
- 1:42:57for her because she was like, damn, I sent her to go live with
- 1:43:01her other family and be safe. And now she's gone.
- 1:43:05Yeah. Molly died of natural causes in
- 1:43:091937. Her head right went to her.
- 1:43:12Surviving older children, Tom on Tom white went on to have an
- 1:43:16illustrious career in the FBI. He actually ended up becoming
- 1:43:20one of those college boys that he never liked.
- 1:43:23He had a stroke in 1971 at 90 years old and died.
- 1:43:27December twenty. First two months later after
- 1:43:30this was all exposed, the US government changed the head
- 1:43:33right law saying that the allotment could be passed.
- 1:43:37Down to two. Nobody other than other postage
- 1:43:41tribe members yes in an attempt to make sure the reign of terror
- 1:43:45never happened again. No more white men coming in.
- 1:43:49Pretty much didn't matter if you married into the family.
- 1:43:52If you weren't, if you, you had to be at least 50% blood-quantum
- 1:43:57for you to have this head, right?
- 1:43:59That's like I said, they do still have the treaty.
- 1:44:02Mmm, not the treaty. I'm sorry, they do still have
- 1:44:05had Ray and they do still get That allotment but there has
- 1:44:08been continuous issues with. The guardianship it's not the
- 1:44:14same as it was then but there was still major mismanagement on
- 1:44:19a bigger level Kimberly is still going on.
- 1:44:23Hey Miss, it's not the guardianship.
- 1:44:26Oh my God if we Brittany free free days, right?
- 1:44:30Well anything is pointed to a lot of people that
- 1:44:34conservatorships and guardianships and things of that
- 1:44:36nature are very easily. Get manipulated, manipulated and
- 1:44:41taking advantage of Lily. I'm sure some of the, the
- 1:44:45children of the Osage tribe, where some of the people who
- 1:44:48were just straight robbed because they would have never
- 1:44:50even looked at their accounts. Yeah, no they were kids, there
- 1:44:56is more to this story. That was recovered.
- 1:45:01It was discovered later when reporters looked into the cases,
- 1:45:05I'm gonna leave that up to the people listening.
- 1:45:08The majority of this podcast today was sourced from the Book
- 1:45:12killers of the flower Moon, by David Graham, it is totally
- 1:45:17worth reading. You should get yourself a copy.
- 1:45:19There is a whole third section that discusses the newer
- 1:45:23information that has discovered been discovered.
- 1:45:24Recently, there's also another book that I read called the
- 1:45:28deaths of Sybil Bolton by Dennis make Olive who learned way later
- 1:45:34in life, that his grandmother Sybil Bolton was poisoned during
- 1:45:38the reign of terror. That's what the movies called
- 1:45:41to. Yes, the Is called Killers, the
- 1:45:43flower moon. It's called the Osage murders in
- 1:45:46the birth of the FBI together. It is one hell of a story.
- 1:45:50I totally understand why it's a movie now.
- 1:45:52Yeah, Leonardo playing Ernest. Yeah.
- 1:45:55Well, I mean ours was a white guy.
- 1:45:56So I know it's interested in who's gonna play the indigenous
- 1:45:59women because like, who's playing Rita and Lizzie and
- 1:46:04yeah, are they first Nations actresses?
- 1:46:07Because I would really like that.
- 1:46:08Yeah, Lily Gladstone, playing Molly.
- 1:46:12Is that but yeah, I don't know. But it was like I said, one hell
- 1:46:19of a story. I got it and this just happened.
- 1:46:23Yeah, in our history. Holy cow.
- 1:46:26Goodness gracious. That was a story.
- 1:46:30I told you like, I was so hype. That's like, this went way
- 1:46:33longer. I looked at my notes and was
- 1:46:34like, oh dear, we're at like 17 pages, but totally, absolutely
- 1:46:41incredibly worth. And if you listen to, thank you
- 1:46:43so much, mmm-hmm. So, we got some spook in to talk
- 1:46:48about. Now, we got some scrutiny to
- 1:46:50talk about. Well, not spookin, okay.
- 1:46:53People who investigates broken though?
- 1:46:56Oh okay, okay, so about talk about our boy Zak Bagans.
- 1:47:00Again, I never talk about I will never there would never be an
- 1:47:06episode where I talk about him, maybe definitely not.
- 1:47:10Maybe he gets a rest of my for doing it.
- 1:47:12Douchebag stuff. Anyway.
- 1:47:14No today I'm going to start this off by apologizing, okay,
- 1:47:19recanting, I guess whatever. Oh Lily Gladstone as a First
- 1:47:22Nations actress knew ye I just didn't know she was I looked her
- 1:47:26up. I've heard her name before it is
- 1:47:28in no way. I'm gonna start it off by
- 1:47:31apologizing to anybody who's listened or who is listening
- 1:47:36goes back and listens to any of our earlier episodes when I
- 1:47:41first started talking when I was talking, I mentioned Harry,
- 1:47:43Houdini and then and then I hear.
- 1:47:45I mentioned Harry price as well. Okay.
- 1:47:48And I got Harry price next up with Vincent Price.
- 1:47:53Oh dear. Because of the same last name,
- 1:47:56right? But Vincent Price.
- 1:47:58Yeah. So I'd even Pete that the day
- 1:48:01you started. Yeah.
- 1:48:02It's okay. Like it was earlier episodes,
- 1:48:05but I'd confuse Harry price of admission price in the
- 1:48:08Scooby-Doo. It's appraised price is like
- 1:48:12Like awesome. Awesome people.
- 1:48:14Yeah, I know Harry price is awesome people to okay but I
- 1:48:19just wanted to go back and correct that it was Vincent huh.
- 1:48:25Are we talking about Vincent? No but maybe I should one day
- 1:48:28because whole dude Adventure price is.
- 1:48:30Yeah. He's one of those pillars that I
- 1:48:32like to think about because when I think of is the price, I go.
- 1:48:35I know, right? Yes.
- 1:48:38You know, weird eyebrow thing. Oh my God.
- 1:48:40Yeah, he did. Well, ya know, the animated him
- 1:48:43in the Scooby-Doo movies, but oh wow.
- 1:48:46Yeah, he was in. That is fucking awesome.
- 1:48:48Anyway. No, I'm talking about the other
- 1:48:50price today. Okay, Harry price.
- 1:48:53Okay. So do you know who Harry price
- 1:48:57was cat-like? Offhand name him. okay, well,
- 1:49:05Since I already talked about Harry Houdini, yes I'm gonna
- 1:49:08talk about her price. Also, Harry price was basically
- 1:49:11was he also a magic man. He did sleight of hand.
- 1:49:15Oh but here your price was basically the.
- 1:49:19Yeah, the UK version of Harry Houdini.
- 1:49:21Okay? Okay, so what did he do?
- 1:49:24The things like that? I'm locked up inside of a big
- 1:49:26old giant case of water situation like those ones.
- 1:49:28No, no, no. I feel so anxious.
- 1:49:32When I watch this, nothing like that.
- 1:49:35I'm watching a murder because look, what Houdini, he kind of
- 1:49:38like, started out as a magician, right, and like stage magic and
- 1:49:42stuff like that. And he became, you know, but
- 1:49:45then he was into like the defrauding of the mediums of
- 1:49:50stuff like that. But even then after that he did
- 1:49:52stuff that was he did The Escape of rotting mediums.
- 1:49:54Yeah. So like his whole career wasn't
- 1:49:58like the medium thing is who's kid.
- 1:50:00That was towards the. Yeah.
- 1:50:02And mainly that was because he got mad about the mediums and
- 1:50:04his Look look, understandable. Yeah, listen, I don't want you
- 1:50:09to mention anybody. Who I know who has died, fam,
- 1:50:15tell me about some stranger's, but if the person mentioned
- 1:50:18somebody, I know me. Mad too.
- 1:50:20Yeah. Especially if you get it wrong
- 1:50:22because like he's like, yeah, your mom learned English and the
- 1:50:26afterlife get out of here. Oh, mama is Hungarian how she
- 1:50:31won't learn English. She ain't speak English dies.
- 1:50:34Oh my God. Yeah, but did okay, so what
- 1:50:37Harry price do? Something similar here plays,
- 1:50:39did you something similar? So, here, price, he started his
- 1:50:43career out, basically with the Supernatural and then what a
- 1:50:49paranormal, and then he learned sleight-of-hand magic and stuff
- 1:50:53like that on his on his way. So this is a story.
- 1:50:56I'm going to tell this it's going to be like a multi-part
- 1:50:59because I got another your other cases from Harry price.
- 1:51:02I want to talk about. Oh, so you're talking about one
- 1:51:04particular A price case. I'm going to I'm going to do
- 1:51:06like a little sure what to say because I do I did tell you that
- 1:51:10I wrote too much and I was like, okay well let me just stop right
- 1:51:14now. You could have gone with no
- 1:51:17three-hour episode. We can have a three hour episode
- 1:51:19like next week. Okay.
- 1:51:21No it probably won't be as long bet.
- 1:51:26Are you know I'm going to talk about next week.
- 1:51:28I already planned it. So there you go.
- 1:51:30Won't be as bad also. I got a I got stuff to do after
- 1:51:34we record next week. That's right.
- 1:51:35You do hit me. Never mind not 3 hours. 3 hours
- 1:51:42anyway. Maybe episode 50.
- 1:51:49So in London I don't think this was cool on his part but he kind
- 1:52:01of wanted to change some details about his early childhood.
- 1:52:05Oh dear. Basically, mainly where he was
- 1:52:07born, people always to do that, though.
- 1:52:11So he wanted people. Like, if you read, I read one of
- 1:52:14his books when I was writing this up Confessions of a ghost
- 1:52:19hunter, okay? I think that's what it was
- 1:52:21called and he States in her, he was born.
- 1:52:26In. Oh, so fry shove cephalic.
- 1:52:32No, not so folk, it's sh ROP. Shi re it's something sure.
- 1:52:45Yeah. Yeah I'm not getting all the
- 1:52:47letters you're saying. But literally somebody on my
- 1:52:50timeline the other day was just like rope, she likes to sure.
- 1:52:54They literally were like, if I have nothing to tell Americans
- 1:52:57it's was sure. It is what?
- 1:53:00Yes, it's Schroeder. Shire is sure.
- 1:53:04It's that I know for sure is Shropshire, that's not sure.
- 1:53:08All right. And not where he was born,
- 1:53:10that's not where he was born, but he did study there and it's
- 1:53:14a really nice place. I guess it's a lot of wealthy
- 1:53:16people live there at that time. So he wanted people to think I
- 1:53:20got wealthy parents and stuff like that.
- 1:53:22Why was that something he worried about?
- 1:53:23I don't know. Sure, he was actually born in
- 1:53:26New cross and his father was a traveling salesman.
- 1:53:31Nobody liked traveling salesman. We stay still.
- 1:53:33Don't, it's a weird one of those jobs that like was necessary,
- 1:53:38but people hated that, The same way that people hate when people
- 1:53:41come to your door now. Yeah that's why I had that.
- 1:53:43I have that nice. No soliciting sign that says no
- 1:53:46soliciting don't render Bill, don't knock, don't make it
- 1:53:50weird. I have received so much, Mormon
- 1:53:53stuff in the last, like, two months crazy.
- 1:53:55Someone Mormon must be moved into this apartment.
- 1:53:58I was like, am I just don't even want to talk to you?
- 1:54:00Please don't talk to me. Oh my God.
- 1:54:03I got a thing. Do you have a church?
- 1:54:06Leave me alone. Leave me alone.
- 1:54:10Anyway, at the age of 15, he found it.
- 1:54:13The Carlton dramatic society, which is now called the carton
- 1:54:18theater group, okay? It's place where amateur actors,
- 1:54:21they go us, nice, play rates and stuff like that.
- 1:54:25And this is where he wrote his first play, the skeptic, which
- 1:54:29was an account of his first ghost experience while he was
- 1:54:33investigating his first haunted house.
- 1:54:36So as at age 15 like there was a haunted house in there and you
- 1:54:39know people Oil, they were reporting Poltergeist type
- 1:54:42activity. So, you know, he goes there, he
- 1:54:45checks it out and he writes this play about it and this is
- 1:54:49basically the only reason why he founded this kolchin Dramatic
- 1:54:54Society is so he could write this play about him.
- 1:54:58Going to investigate this haunted house.
- 1:55:00Okay, yeah. But yeah, he goes into great
- 1:55:05detail about this in his book, The confession of a girl's ghost
- 1:55:09hunter, okay? You can find on arxiv.org.
- 1:55:13It's the whole thing is there. I've looked for other books that
- 1:55:17he has other books are but they're like.
- 1:55:19That one's actually really good. So he was also interested in our
- 1:55:23College archaeology, which is really cool.
- 1:55:26It was a coin collector to and you know, just small little
- 1:55:30tidbits of things that you know make him awesome.
- 1:55:35An early influence to his life's work was the great.
- 1:55:44I cannot pronounce his name. I tried it so many times is it's
- 1:55:49like, okay, so it's basically, I'm not saying it.
- 1:55:54I'm not seeing any, but it's a traveling Merchant basically.
- 1:56:01Yeah, right? Yeah, it did SSE cue, You ch.
- 1:56:10The any EQ? Yeah uch uch.
- 1:56:17Are you eh? Yeah yet?
- 1:56:20Even spell it. You I forgot you hate your
- 1:56:22writing. So anyway we're not talking
- 1:56:25about the right now. Sequitur.
- 1:56:27Yeah, there you go. So it's like that, that word.
- 1:56:33So basically, this person is like a traveling Merchant or
- 1:56:36they like a traveling Medicine, Man.
- 1:56:38Okay? Like, oh, that makes sense like
- 1:56:40a. It sounds a digital.
- 1:56:42Yeah. Like, a flim-flam man sort of
- 1:56:44that sale snake oil and stuff like that too.
- 1:56:47So I looked up the name, snake oil salesman and it's like,
- 1:56:53there's a whiskey neat after his to, or some type of alcohol, is
- 1:56:56really cool looking. But yeah, so they did like magic
- 1:56:59and stuff like that. So, Hee hee.
- 1:57:07After you know, after he devotes his life to like this stuff he
- 1:57:11goes into the society is called a magic circle.
- 1:57:14Okay. It's a British organisation made
- 1:57:18for promoting the Arts of magic. So, here is where he learns his
- 1:57:27sleight-of-hand and some like little parlor tricks.
- 1:57:33So he's in the society about magic and in the society amount
- 1:57:37of magic he's also learning about like, Conjuring things,
- 1:57:41you know, I magicians, they conjure, I don't know, rabbits
- 1:57:44out of hats or, you know, doves out of her arms and stuff like
- 1:57:47that. So that counts is Conjuring and
- 1:57:51I mean, that's probably not the kind of conjuring, he was
- 1:57:53learning but that's what I'm thinking.
- 1:57:58Yeah. So this gives them like a leg up
- 1:58:05on wanting to learn more about paranormal.
- 1:58:09So he after you know, he's in this magic circle, he joins the
- 1:58:12society for physical research in 1920, okay?
- 1:58:19And he was interested in mediums like Houdini but unlike Houdini
- 1:58:25Price, He endorsed, who did, he endorse mediums that he actually
- 1:58:31believed were like, correct? Yeah.
- 1:58:34So unlike Houdini, who was just like, I'm not going to believe
- 1:58:38anything. I like what the meetings.
- 1:58:43Yeah. Hmm.
- 1:58:44I'm more like Houdini well, trust your dad files.
- 1:58:47Okay, her name is Amy. I forget her last name, but I
- 1:58:51like her show. It's corroborated by a police
- 1:58:55officer. Oh wow.
- 1:58:56Okay. Well, former police officer who
- 1:58:58seems like a nice guy, you know, that means something to me.
- 1:59:01Okay, yeah. Okay.
- 1:59:03Okay. Your benefit of the doubt.
- 1:59:06Hmm, But yeah. So he endures mediums that you
- 1:59:10don't want a real deal. So here is one of his earlier
- 1:59:15cases. All right?
- 1:59:16Like one of his very first cases so this is interesting because
- 1:59:19this guy Started out amateur Ghost, Hunter at 15, grows up,
- 1:59:26he's an immature, Willis Hunter archaeologist coin collector.
- 1:59:29He wrote plays starting to feel very much Jack of all trades,
- 1:59:33master of none. Just say, So February 1922 price
- 1:59:43in a group of some magicians that were in his group.
- 1:59:49They go, they're investigating one of the most famous spiritual
- 1:59:54photographers of the time. His name was William hope, okay?
- 1:59:58And hope so hope was a member of the crew Circle.
- 2:00:06So this is a group of people who Were basically just all spare
- 2:00:10photographers, okay? And what hope would do, you
- 2:00:17know, he would offer his services to people.
- 2:00:20Of course, he gets pure Spirit, photographs taken.
- 2:00:23And the way he would do this is that he would get people that
- 2:00:28hold plates, I guess, and their pictures.
- 2:00:31And after, you know, pictures were developed, they develop and
- 2:00:35have a spirit behind them. Yeah.
- 2:00:37Yeah. I've seen these.
- 2:00:38Yeah. Yeah, they're actually some
- 2:00:40really beautiful ones from him. There's the one with the two
- 2:00:44people in the front and then there's a lady with a veil right
- 2:00:47behind them. Super cool.
- 2:00:50Yeah, fake as hell. Very cool though.
- 2:00:52That's a creepy picture, but yeah, like it's really hard for
- 2:00:55me because I went to school for photography.
- 2:00:58So and I got to use old timey cameras.
- 2:01:03Literally, all you have to do to make a spirit.
- 2:01:05Photographed is while the camera is just sitting there with the
- 2:01:10silver exposure, right? And past, it's because it took
- 2:01:14so long for the exposures to saddle that it anything that
- 2:01:20just darted by. So, there are pictures of like
- 2:01:22bugs zoom in by that like cause people to fix this with
- 2:01:25superiors. If it was from the 1920s, I
- 2:01:28don't trust it. As far as the spirit photography
- 2:01:30goes like, I said, he did some Oppressive thing, you know, they
- 2:01:34didn't look blurry, they looked cool.
- 2:01:36Ya know, some of his pictures. They were like I looked at them.
- 2:01:39They're actually really, really nice.
- 2:01:41Really good. As I just know.
- 2:01:42The one, the one, with the lady in the veil.
- 2:01:44That's the one that I've seen that, I think is incredible.
- 2:01:46There's another one, there's one of Richard Price.
- 2:01:49He got one taken not Richard. Got Richard Harry Potter Harry
- 2:01:53price. God, I want to see that one
- 2:01:56here. You prior Richard Pryor hold on,
- 2:01:59Richard Pryor the comedian Ryan. Hold on here.
- 2:02:06Um, it's picture. The picture one Harry price.
- 2:02:13This one right here. Now look at this picture and
- 2:02:16tell me that's not a fucking. Just look at it.
- 2:02:18It's another lady with a veil but look at that lady's face.
- 2:02:23you can tell it's like a It's not.
- 2:02:28Oh yeah she looks like a mask. Yeah it looks like a freaking
- 2:02:30statue or also fun fact. Yes.
- 2:02:34So the way so you've used Photoshop, you are, you know,
- 2:02:39that the different things on Photoshop or referred to as
- 2:02:42layers layers? Yeah.
- 2:02:43That goes back to stuff that you had to do in Dark rooms, which I
- 2:02:46also learned how to do in college when we had a whole dark
- 2:02:50room year. Where you physically layered
- 2:02:56things on top of your, like exposure.
- 2:03:02And that's when you like, turn the light to expose it.
- 2:03:04So there were actually ways that you could, it's very plausible,
- 2:03:07he did that here. Yes, said of catching it in
- 2:03:11picture because like I said, when people walked onto the
- 2:03:15exposure, it showed us blurry. This looks almost like two
- 2:03:19separate pictures next to each other.
- 2:03:21Yep, which he very well could Could have merge those together
- 2:03:24in the dark room. It's really intriguing.
- 2:03:27I didn't know any of that stuff and tie.
- 2:03:29I did it officially in school. It's just recourse, you know, I
- 2:03:32grew up on digital cameras. So we spend the whole first year
- 2:03:35just learning the old ways. Goodness pain-in-the-ass
- 2:03:39carrying around that big old Honker I believe it and setting
- 2:03:42it up in Philadelphia. so, another person got their picture
- 2:03:50taken is Sir. Arthur Conan Doyle really love
- 2:03:55it. Do you remember him from Houdini
- 2:03:59episode? No, Sir.
- 2:04:01Arthur Conan Doyle. Oh yeah, of course.
- 2:04:03He's loves his, he loves the spiritualism.
- 2:04:06He's and he's, you know, he's in that scene.
- 2:04:09So I'm not gonna lie, Sir, Arthur Conan Doyle Spirit
- 2:04:13picture. So yeah, the picture you got was
- 2:04:15of his dead sister. and oh, his looks way more janky, but
- 2:04:29Pricing price had this whole group his magicians.
- 2:04:33They had this plan to see if they could prove this this
- 2:04:40disproved. I love it.
- 2:04:43This is so funny. Look at this one.
- 2:04:45This proof hope. Yeah this looks so bad.
- 2:04:49Yeah. It's just it's like a picture
- 2:04:51just plopped on top of another picture freaking terrible.
- 2:04:54Who are these people being the ghosts for?
- 2:04:56Haven't, you know, I need to find a book about Mm hope
- 2:04:59because I'm like, I'm sure Lord, who was, who are these actors?
- 2:05:02Who are like, bat. I'm gonna get my like five
- 2:05:05dollars for the day to be a ghost verbally.
- 2:05:09Him hope. I know.
- 2:05:11I think it's could you use anybody else at that point?
- 2:05:13Once you were in one picture, he couldn't use you again.
- 2:05:15Yeah, probably not. Oh, it's beautiful.
- 2:05:20It's just super funny when you put this on YouTube, you just
- 2:05:22have to show all these pictures that I'm laughing.
- 2:05:28This is the good one. Okay, there is the mask.
- 2:05:31Isn't it? Looks it looks a little bit like
- 2:05:33a mass, but she also looks kind of real.
- 2:05:35It's just a weird Veil. And I just like chilling.
- 2:05:37They're like okay, we're taking a picture.
- 2:05:39Okay, okay but my thing is, when you think it was like a little
- 2:05:43bit Suspicious that he was able to get all of these Spirit
- 2:05:48photos and show many of them are in just such good detail and
- 2:05:52it's 1922, that's why he had investigators coming to check
- 2:05:56him out. Okay, so like I said Harry price
- 2:06:00and his crew magicians they have this they have this method
- 2:06:03worked out and so What it was, is it consistent of presenting,
- 2:06:10hope, with a set of glass negatives that had been secretly
- 2:06:15marked with x-rays. So it's trap worked.
- 2:06:22So when hope return the plates, the one, the one continue the
- 2:06:26extra Spirit image. Yeah, showed no sign of the
- 2:06:30markings he used his own. Yep.
- 2:06:32So you switched out the ones that the X-ray ones with his
- 2:06:36own, gotcha. So yeah, like I said, but you
- 2:06:42could very easily just been like, oh, I like to use my own
- 2:06:44supplies but he let people bring their own plates in the stuff
- 2:06:47too. Okay.
- 2:06:49So it was just weird that he would switch it out, you know?
- 2:06:52They're mean if you have people bring us up.
- 2:06:56Okay, so he's called they're like okay dude we know you
- 2:07:01switched out, this is this this is what happened and you know so
- 2:07:05he was doing this during the the - process.
- 2:07:07Yeah. So, after, you know, they find
- 2:07:11him guilty of this spiritualist spiritualism was like, no, no,
- 2:07:16you guys just out here. You're trying to frame our boy
- 2:07:19for. Okay, you guys little medium
- 2:07:23buddies to show. Ya trim.
- 2:07:25Frame of really hope like the community.
- 2:07:29They are supportive but for the wrong.
- 2:07:33Oh, no. He's better wrong.
- 2:07:35They're wrong for supporting him because he definitely picked it
- 2:07:38and they were Faking it to they were if you mess it, if you mess
- 2:07:42him up, you mess us up. So yeah, they're like you're
- 2:07:46wrong for trying to like expose him as a fraud.
- 2:07:48Like even Conan Doyle he was like, he came to the, you know,
- 2:07:52Harry price and screws like hey guys, could you like recant what
- 2:07:56you said about Hope? Because I believe he's.
- 2:08:00All right. And there we else's, and we
- 2:08:02don't want to see anything. Like, let's see, him going down
- 2:08:05the time, basically, we just want to believe in ghosts, but
- 2:08:10there are people out there who believe in this, and they're
- 2:08:13being hurt by this. You know, like what the Houdini
- 2:08:17thing, people are going to these mediums like, expecting an
- 2:08:20actual real experience, and they're going to be putting
- 2:08:22their entire life savings on these mediums.
- 2:08:26They spent all of their money chasing after this idea that
- 2:08:30they could see or hear, or talk to their dead relatives again,
- 2:08:34it was real bad. Yes.
- 2:08:39So I do feel bad about that. Yeah, that sucks.
- 2:08:44Yeah, so once Okay so When when Conan goes to price and he's
- 2:08:58like can you do this in prices like nah?
- 2:09:01Brah. Like this is this is what I do
- 2:09:08so. So he goes and writes his
- 2:09:11pamphlet about his side of the story and how you know it's
- 2:09:17serious when there's a pamphlet. Oh yeah.
- 2:09:18Definitely in about you know how hoped William hope is like this?
- 2:09:22He's right about this stuff. I'll remind you guys Conan
- 2:09:28Doyle. He was a believer of all things,
- 2:09:30paranormal and spiritual and he didn't like being wrong.
- 2:09:35So he even went as far as the contacting his good buddy.
- 2:09:39Harry Houdini at this time to. I think they're still friends at
- 2:09:43this time. He's before they like completely
- 2:09:45had that following. Yeah, I believe so.
- 2:09:49Can you get your fellow magic buddy and tell him to leave me
- 2:09:52alone and Houdini was kind of like conflicted, right?
- 2:09:58When because at this time, he was also on his way to go
- 2:10:01investigate. Hope this like this man is just
- 2:10:13lying. That wasn't really your sister.
- 2:10:18Oh my God. L write another book so I have
- 2:10:22what he wrote to Houdini. So he wrote this letter to ready
- 2:10:25on April 13th. 1922 and he writes I've written a book on
- 2:10:31Psychic photography with special reference to the crew.
- 2:10:34Circle the evidence in their favour is overwhelming though.
- 2:10:40What happened on a special occasion with two, amateur
- 2:10:43conjurer's out of his stunts in a third dingwall behind them?
- 2:10:49What it is, is more than I can say.
- 2:10:53We found that another test was in dependably carried out about
- 2:10:59the same time. Well, I guess my other is
- 2:11:02situation. So they're talking about the,
- 2:11:04the silver plates, right? The ones that they that means is
- 2:11:08how you did photos back that. Yeah.
- 2:11:11And so, they're saying that they had little bits in the, the
- 2:11:14silver plates. I don't think what they got.
- 2:11:19I think Hope was a total fraud, but I don't think what they got
- 2:11:22was really enough to say. He was a complete and total
- 2:11:24fraud, I guess, since he switched the plates out, Could
- 2:11:29he could have come up with an E lot.
- 2:11:30Like it'll come up with loads of logical reasons why you may be a
- 2:11:33broke. You know, the array.
- 2:11:35I'm so sorry. Your Originals got messed up.
- 2:11:37I had to use my own instead, like I feel like you was just a
- 2:11:41bad shyster because I'm come up with a good lie as to why he
- 2:11:46used a different one. Well, you probably wasn't caught
- 2:11:47before either church and so he's like, oh yeah, little that we
- 2:11:50call that. Like, they think that they're
- 2:11:52like, you know, a humorous. Yeah, he had a little bit of
- 2:11:55that hubris. And that's like, really, what
- 2:11:57messed him up. Up them, like I can think of a
- 2:11:58million reasons why I would be like nah, I use my own stuff.
- 2:12:03Yep. So after he writes this letter
- 2:12:06to, you know, Houdini Houdini's like, hmm, not really impressed
- 2:12:09by this sir. So, like I said, yeah, well I
- 2:12:13love his reasoning. Listen, I wrote a book and like
- 2:12:16if you release this information, my books going to be wrong.
- 2:12:20He thinks ticklish. So like can you know, I can you
- 2:12:26like comment down over there with Your and I get it but like
- 2:12:30I have a book to sell sir. So like doesn't matter because
- 2:12:35after where they're no longer friends anymore?
- 2:12:37Yeah. So like I said, burn that
- 2:12:40bridge, right? He really did, he really did it
- 2:12:44was bad Houdini was already on his way?
- 2:12:47Well, he was yeah, he was planning on going to investigate
- 2:12:50William hope, but they got there first.
- 2:12:53Okay, what do scheduling Houdini couldn't go?
- 2:12:55So he had someone else it in on and get a picture taken for him.
- 2:12:59He did the same thing. That that price did.
- 2:13:03What do you know the plates? And I will say, it's It shows
- 2:13:09some level of skill, we're talking mid-1920s being able to
- 2:13:14to do that and make it look like oh, yeah, absolutely Sir, Arthur
- 2:13:19Conan Conan. Doyle's, actual sister.
- 2:13:22Yeah, that's skill. That means that he had to
- 2:13:25manufacture a lot of drawing and adjustments, which also explains
- 2:13:31why he couldn't use, just that one play here because he was
- 2:13:35probably using multiple layers of to get that image.
- 2:13:39You could tell like that one. You just showed me what the big
- 2:13:41face and like the middle. You can tell it's like different
- 2:13:44plates on top of. Yeah, yeah.
- 2:13:46So I mean that would explain why he didn't have.
- 2:13:49It wasn't done with just one. Yeah.
- 2:13:51It was done with multiple layers, you still very
- 2:13:53interesting. It really is like you, you put
- 2:13:55in the work for this. I like you're still faking a
- 2:13:58fraud, but you put into words what an impressive way of using
- 2:14:02your skill set? Oh, goodness.
- 2:14:08There's, there's important things you can do in post like
- 2:14:11the whole concept of like dodging photos and things of
- 2:14:14that nature, that's done in post, when you're, you know,
- 2:14:17making something darker, making something lighter, that that
- 2:14:19process is useful and can make the picture look better.
- 2:14:23Yeah, he just did all that stuff.
- 2:14:25Just to lie to make a quick buck.
- 2:14:30So after, you know, Houdini does this thing.
- 2:14:35Sir, Sir Arthur Conan Doyle? Okay, he writes another letter
- 2:14:40to Houdini. Oh no, basically saying that.
- 2:14:44Okay, so we're not friends anymore.
- 2:14:48No nothing. He writes and says, hey, those
- 2:14:54place, I had those x-ray markings on them.
- 2:14:57Those x-ray markings they disappear after a while.
- 2:14:59So, obviously he wasn't used. He did use their place at the
- 2:15:05They did that, they brought but the X-ray markings disappeared.
- 2:15:09Hmm. So, after you get this letter,
- 2:15:12Houdini was like all right, sometimes I'm tired of being
- 2:15:15like the middleman. So he goes and he contacts
- 2:15:18price. So Harry price in Houdini Dirk
- 2:15:21under buddy, buddy. So they're kind of cool guys
- 2:15:24together. And he tells price about the,
- 2:15:29you know, the X-ray, your stuff in prices.
- 2:15:30Like dude, I'm all right. On top of this because I know
- 2:15:34for a fact, he's x-ray markings, don't disappear.
- 2:15:37Yeah. When you said that my face did a
- 2:15:40what? Yeah that's not how that works
- 2:15:43at all. I'm like whatever sir the whale.
- 2:15:51Yeah and who do you like all right cool.
- 2:15:55Cool long as you know All right. So I like that, though.
- 2:16:00I'm not a professional courtesy for people uncovering fraud.
- 2:16:04Absolutely, just letting you know, he's saying that you gave
- 2:16:07him bad plates. It disappeared.
- 2:16:10It was your fault. He's like, no.
- 2:16:12No, don't worry. I got this.
- 2:16:13Yeah, there's there's this whole back and forth between these
- 2:16:18three guys. Okay, the Houdini just being the
- 2:16:20middleman with Nicole. You couldn't do it.
- 2:16:23You just coming to him and saying, hey, your body price is
- 2:16:27wrong about this and this is why it would be so annoyed.
- 2:16:31Yeah, and phrases like, yo, get your boy Conan Doyle out of here
- 2:16:34because he's, he's harassing the hell out of me and my group.
- 2:16:40We're just trying to take pictures of ghosts.
- 2:16:42God. Oh my God.
- 2:16:48I tell ya, I only want to see a picture of a ghost somewhere
- 2:16:50that I'm never coming back to. Because if his ones in my house
- 2:16:53like this yellow house now, fam, Guess you live here?
- 2:16:57Yeah but soon years later. Okay Conan Doyle he admits
- 2:17:03defeat. After years years of harassing
- 2:17:06Harry price about just this one thing.
- 2:17:10Like I mean they didn't ever released the book though.
- 2:17:13The pamphlet? Yeah.
- 2:17:14Yeah, I'm pretty sure you did well.
- 2:17:16Did he release the book about how he had studied ghosts
- 2:17:20photography and all that stuff? I'm pretty sure he did.
- 2:17:22We look up. If you look him up, I'm pretty
- 2:17:25sure you'll find it. But I want to know he's like I'm
- 2:17:28just gonna release this book anyway.
- 2:17:29Screw it. But yeah, that's funny but like
- 2:17:39I said they dropped their whole career Harry price in Sir Arthur
- 2:17:44Arthur Conan Doyle. They never saw eye-to-eye to
- 2:17:47fight. They just stopped to fight each
- 2:17:50other. It's crazy.
- 2:17:51It was crazy. And like paraphrase, he was like
- 2:17:54the nicer version of Houdini. Like, he gave me was a benefit
- 2:17:58of the doubt and Houdini was like, all right.
- 2:18:01I know you're faking from. Neither thing.
- 2:18:02Is that Houdini's? Just like, I'm just gonna have
- 2:18:04some He crawled under this fucking tape.
- 2:18:09Watch your legs. Oh my God.
- 2:18:14So after exposing after this whole situation, whole thing is
- 2:18:18blown over now. And after exposed like this is
- 2:18:21his first case I mind you. So after exposing a few more
- 2:18:26people at the spr Harry price, he starts his own organizations
- 2:18:31called the National Laboratory of physical research.
- 2:18:36He gets a little bit of flak from the spr that he was in,
- 2:18:40because he actually paid his median, the mediums that he came
- 2:18:43that came in to his test. He paid them for a time and
- 2:18:48they're like, don't don't be paying these mediums.
- 2:18:51Like, they might be frauds, how are you paying these frogs?
- 2:18:54You know what I mean? You're just giving money to
- 2:18:58frogs. I'm just saying because that's
- 2:19:02like, yeah, but like, they're there.
- 2:19:06Spr whole thing was, you know, we're going to find out these,
- 2:19:09you know, or find these mediums that are, you know, doing
- 2:19:11fraudulent readings and stuff like that.
- 2:19:14But here prizes like well yeah, but they're coming to me to do
- 2:19:20the readings and stuff. So I'm gonna give him the
- 2:19:23painting for the time and you know, it's only fair and I agree
- 2:19:27with you like what he did there. so, there are many more cases
- 2:19:36like I said in the beginning that your price was involved in
- 2:19:39this was this one was just like the tip of the iceberg, like his
- 2:19:43starting point, and I will be covering One or two more, maybe
- 2:19:49like there's a big one. I'm going to cover it like next
- 2:19:51week's. Okay.
- 2:19:53But either way, Price was praised for his work at, you
- 2:19:59know, the bunking, fake mediums and his paranormal investigation
- 2:20:03skills. Okay, there have been several
- 2:20:06biographies written about Harry price, some critical some
- 2:20:11sympathetic so very, very critical.
- 2:20:15There was one that was released in 2006.
- 2:20:18I about how he was a con man in stuff like that.
- 2:20:23It was like, dude. Dude, I'm pretty sure know that
- 2:20:26that he was exposing the con people, true.
- 2:20:32I mean, yeah, we're out here to bunking things and mediums.
- 2:20:36There are people out there who are writers and who don't like
- 2:20:40you even write bad things about you.
- 2:20:43Yeah no I understood. Yeah so price would later died
- 2:20:50at his home or March 29th. 1948 from a massive heart attack and
- 2:20:59that's what I got for this week. It's not as long as I should
- 2:21:07just wait until next week. I got some stuff for you.
- 2:21:09It's going to make you laugh and it's going to be funny.
- 2:21:12So we interesting, it's gonna be compelling All right.
- 2:21:20Well, I'm interested more stories.
- 2:21:22Good, you're getting more, you're going to get more.
- 2:21:26What do you like it or not? Goodness.
- 2:21:31Well, I just interesting path we've taken today.
- 2:21:35Yeah, I just, I don't know. I just like, I like the game of
- 2:21:37telephone between these grown-ass, man.
- 2:21:42I just like how you got here your price or just know.
- 2:21:46They're they're doing the same thing.
- 2:21:48So they're buddies, they have their own community, and then
- 2:21:53you have Conan Doyle out here with his group of spiritualist.
- 2:21:57And they're just like, look, we're gonna curse you and you
- 2:22:01all this stuff, if you don't stop telling the truth.
- 2:22:05Oh, I just love. I just love to debunking and
- 2:22:10just invasive investigation into the stuff.
- 2:22:12It's really awesome. But yeah, that's it for me.
- 2:22:18Hope you guys enjoyed the episode this week.
- 2:22:20Yeah, I think we had a good time.
- 2:22:23Yeah, always. Have a good time.
- 2:22:24Is always fun. And then your story is always.
- 2:22:28They always throw me for a loop. That's because the the shortened
- 2:22:33version of what we know. Like, there's always so much
- 2:22:36more to it, so there's always a backstory to something.
- 2:22:43Yeah, somebody told me that they listen to last week's podcast
- 2:22:46three times. What?
- 2:22:48Yeah, I was like, oh well. Thank you.
- 2:22:54Oh, my God. Why why did you do that?
- 2:22:56I guess they were really into You mad at me?
- 2:23:02Were you also mad that you learned?
- 2:23:04What was as Catherine night? Yeah, you learned that her first
- 2:23:08husband or whatever was cheating on her when she was accusing him
- 2:23:11of cheating on her and I was like, no, he was cheating on
- 2:23:13her, but he's actually cheating on her.
- 2:23:15Yeah, you were really upset when I brought that point out.
- 2:23:17You were like, wait, no, like, how dare you sir?
- 2:23:22Oh my God, dang it for being a scoundrel.
- 2:23:25He still didn't deserve to be like beat with a frying pan.
- 2:23:29No fan. Okay, no, he did not but he
- 2:23:31also, but regardless, thank you for listening to the 30-some
- 2:23:36percent of people who stay till the very end do.
- 2:23:39Yeah, you're also do stay in the end.
- 2:23:41I actually just would love to invite you to be a part of this
- 2:23:46with us. We have so many ways that you
- 2:23:48can talk to us more. Some of those are through
- 2:23:50patreon, you can send messages, we respond through patreon.
- 2:23:54Ryan talks to people on there. Like I said, for people who do
- 2:23:58do the 50, Dollar tear, you get to have a Q&A with us once a
- 2:24:03month. You can talk about whatever you
- 2:24:04like. You can give us any sort of
- 2:24:07criticism that you want. We have our own little like I am
- 2:24:12a once a month you have access to the extra podcast.
- 2:24:17Yep which is gonna get spooky this October.
- 2:24:20Oh goodness, working on it along with a lot of other things.
- 2:24:29So, thank you for listening. Yeah, we appreciate it a night.