Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / The Song and Dance of Medicals in a Personal Injury Mediation
Transcript
- 0:03Welcome to the song and dance of medicals and
- 0:07a personal injury mediation. I'm Philip Vondra,
- 0:10Chair of the Beverly Hill Bar Association Personal
- 0:12Injury Law Section. I'm delighted to introduce
- 0:15our speaker, Joelle Barte. Joelle Barte is a
- 0:20mediator with Resolve Barte. bringing 30 years
- 0:23of experience in construction, real estate, business
- 0:27law, and personal injury. He is a licensed general
- 0:30contractor and licensed real estate broker. Mr.
- 0:34Berta began his legal career as a deputy district
- 0:37attorney in the Los Angeles District Attorney's
- 0:40Office. He has served as a legal business advisor
- 0:43with an emphasis in the international arena to
- 0:46business. businesses looking to break into the
- 0:49U .S. market or import from China. Throughout
- 0:53his career, Mr. Berta has worked on projects
- 0:56ranging from high -end residential developments
- 0:58to large -scale commercial properties, developing
- 1:01expertise in complex business and construction
- 1:04disputes. And now, let's get started. Hi. Good
- 1:10morning, everybody. First question is to ask
- 1:13ourselves, what are we doing here on a Friday
- 1:15morning listening to this guy? to talk about
- 1:18medicals. But that's what we do as lawyers, right?
- 1:21We like to talk about this kind of stuff. Thank
- 1:25you so much for that kind introduction. It's
- 1:26much appreciated. I will not bore you with the
- 1:30mediator talk, because us mediators tend to talk
- 1:32way too much. And you might be asking, what is
- 1:36this construction real estate mediator doing,
- 1:40working on personal injury? Well, it's. It's
- 1:44my way of keeping sane because in the world of
- 1:47construction defect and real estate, it can be
- 1:50very technical, very insurance driven, and it
- 1:54can be kind of boring sometimes because it's
- 1:56that technical. So I like to balance that to
- 2:00keep my sanity or to lose whatever's left in
- 2:03my sanity to do personal injury mediations, which
- 2:06I find very, very enjoyable. I love the people
- 2:09who practice in that arena. I find the adjusters
- 2:12very interesting and fun, as well as the plaintiff's
- 2:16attorneys working on the cases. So it's a nice
- 2:18balance and keeps me motivated to continue to
- 2:22do what I do as a mediator. With that, I thought
- 2:26I would set the stage for our discussion about
- 2:29personal injury and medicals and how they tend
- 2:31to really drive the mediation discussion and
- 2:35share with you what I do in my mediations with
- 2:39my personal injury clients, so to speak, and
- 2:42help them arrive at trying to get to a settlement,
- 2:46which hopefully makes everybody happy. So let's
- 2:50start the stage. At the stage, what's this song
- 2:53and dance all about? Well, let's start with our
- 2:56list of characters. Let's talk about a case.
- 3:02So we have a case. It's an auto accident. involving
- 3:06the following list of characters. So our plaintiff
- 3:11is Miss Steroid Injection. Our plaintiff's attorney
- 3:15is Leslie Pop the Policy Esquire. And the defendant
- 3:20party who hit her, sideswiped her, is Mrs. Agro,
- 3:24driver. Her attorney is Jill Defendum. And the
- 3:29insurance company is called Deny and Defend.
- 3:32And the adjuster who has shown up to mediate
- 3:35the matter is Froyline Fraud Finder and the mediator
- 3:41is Mr. Mouthful. So that's our list of characters.
- 3:45It's a classic somebody making a left turn at
- 3:49a light and they get sideswiped. Liability is
- 3:53not contested for purposes of our mediation,
- 3:56which is always how these mediations start. The
- 3:59insurance company will say We're not contesting
- 4:01liability for this purpose, but we're here in
- 4:04good faith to talk about a son. Wonderful. Which
- 4:07means they're willing to talk. The insurance
- 4:10policy with Deny and Defend is a $250 ,000 policy.
- 4:17And the medicals that comprise the plaintiff's
- 4:21injuries total of $185 ,000. Now I have a little
- 4:25spreadsheet I'll share with you a little bit
- 4:27later on, and I'm also happy to share that spreadsheet.
- 4:31And I wrote an article that is pending review
- 4:36by the Daily Journal, which kind of lays out
- 4:38this whole story that we're talking about. And
- 4:41I'm happy to send that off to everybody. If you'd
- 4:43like it, whether it's published or not in the
- 4:45Daily Journal, it'll kind of lay out our discussion
- 4:47for today. So what's going on? We show up in
- 4:51the mediation and how do these mediations typically
- 4:54go? Well, Mr. Mouthful mediator will talk about
- 4:57his wonderful past for 30 minutes. Hi, my name
- 5:01is, you know, Mr. Mouthful and I've been an attorney
- 5:04for 35 years and let me tell you about my experience
- 5:07and goes on forever. And then I'll spend about
- 5:0910 seconds talking about mediation confidentiality
- 5:12and talk about self -determination of the parties.
- 5:15Wonderful. I don't find that to be very useful.
- 5:19If they've chose you as a mediator, they know
- 5:21who you are. Just get into it. So I like to show
- 5:23up and say, hi, this is me. How can I help you?
- 5:27So let's just get into it. So it's going to start
- 5:33with the plaintiff. What's the demand? They get
- 5:36to go first. Fine. Plaintiff is going to say,
- 5:40in our scenario, policy is $250 ,000. We have
- 5:47$185 ,000 in meds. This is a no -brainer. Tender
- 5:51the policy. Simple, right? The numbers are just
- 5:55so high that you're going to have to tender.
- 5:58Or we're going to pop the policy, bad faith,
- 6:00all the wonderful things that our friends in
- 6:03the plaintiff bar like to say to the friends
- 6:06in the other side of the room, the adjusters
- 6:08and the defense bar. So how do you deal with
- 6:12this? Because When I go into the room with a
- 6:17four -line fraud finder and Jill defend them,
- 6:21the attorney, they have a quite different view
- 6:23of how they arrived at this astronomical number
- 6:26of $185 ,000 and they don't like it. And so what
- 6:32I find to be helpful is for us to dive into the
- 6:35medicals and to use that as a basis for us to
- 6:39try to arrive at some type of a settlement that
- 6:42might get it done, right? That could get it settled
- 6:44for us today. If we start in the vague world
- 6:47of just negotiating numbers without any kind
- 6:50of discussion of what's making up the case based
- 6:54on the numbers, you know, it's kind of a useless
- 6:57exercise. I want this, you want that. We're just,
- 7:00you know, I'm a used car salesman. I can't help
- 7:02anybody. I'm just going back and forth. Oh, you
- 7:05want 250? Look, I'll go tell them you want 250.
- 7:07Tell them 2 ,500 bucks. 2 ,500 bucks. Okay. Hey,
- 7:11they said 2 ,500 bucks. What do you want to do?
- 7:13It's useless, right? What are we talking about?
- 7:16So obviously, we can talk about the facts, the
- 7:18underlying issues of what happened in the case.
- 7:21They did this. They did that. OK, that's important.
- 7:23But from the defense's standpoint, they would
- 7:26like to get into the numbers and at least be
- 7:28convinced that it makes sense. So what I tried
- 7:31to do is after we talk about the case a little
- 7:34bit, depending on the plaintiff. And in this
- 7:37case, Mrs. Steroid injection was injured. She
- 7:40can't walk her pet peacock anymore. She can't
- 7:43have relations with her husband. Her life has
- 7:45been upended. All of this, obviously I'm exaggerating.
- 7:48But people can get a little bit bent out of shape
- 7:52when they're injured. And sometimes they got
- 7:54events. So we talk about that. Fine. But then
- 7:57what drives the numbers? And this is where I
- 7:59try to help Mrs. Steroid injection the parties
- 8:04involved in the case and sometimes their attorney
- 8:06because sometimes their attorney are having a
- 8:08hard time, you know The the old Larry Parker
- 8:12syndrome as I like to call her Larry Parker got
- 8:14me three point one million dollars So now everybody
- 8:17expects to get three point one million They failed
- 8:20to show you that the person who got that kind
- 8:22of a settlement is a quadriplegic But that's
- 8:24besides the point and his case is quite different
- 8:26than your Tesla rear -ender. So How do we manage
- 8:30this? How do we help the parties get to a place
- 8:33where they can try to negotiate something that
- 8:35could make them happy? So what I do is talk to
- 8:41the plaintiff and his client and say, look, we're
- 8:47going to play sort of a chess game here. After
- 8:50we've heard the case, and they've vented, and
- 8:52I've heard what happened to them, and they're
- 8:54quite satisfied that they've been heard, I say,
- 8:57OK, now here is what we have to understand. This
- 9:01is the worldview that's going on in the other
- 9:04room, and in order for you to best negotiate
- 9:07or achieve a settlement that you would find satisfactory,
- 9:11you have to sing a song, you know, dance the
- 9:15dance steps, if you will, that matches the music
- 9:18that they like to listen to in the other room.
- 9:21Because if you're playing Fly Me to the Moon,
- 9:23I want the 250, and they're playing, you know,
- 9:27David Guetta, Titanium, and they're dancing techno,
- 9:30we're not going to be synced. Dance ain't going
- 9:33to work so well. So I tried to explain to them
- 9:36is this is the worldview in the defense side.
- 9:40We may not like it. We may not agree with it.
- 9:43But this is how they like to run their discussions.
- 9:47So here's what they all do. They'll look at the
- 9:50meds. And of course, their general view of medicals
- 9:54is they're over -inflated, nonsense, bullshit,
- 9:58overcooked. you know, put together by crony doctors,
- 10:02all of the rest of it. And I try to share that
- 10:04with people, obviously, in a very delicate way,
- 10:08because if they're very sensitive, I don't, you
- 10:10know, I'm not so aggressive with the language.
- 10:12If they're not so offended, and I can be a little
- 10:15more direct with them, I'll paint that picture.
- 10:17But I try to get that, I try to make that point
- 10:22to them, look, this is how they view it. You
- 10:24know, that's their view. They deal with hundreds
- 10:26and hundreds of cases like this. And they think
- 10:29that everybody in the plaintiff's bar is a crook.
- 10:31They're mills. They're this or that. So OK, that's
- 10:35their view. We disagree. But that's how they
- 10:37see it. So what do they do? They're going to
- 10:39take the medicals. And then they're going to
- 10:43do something very interesting. And again, this
- 10:46is for the plaintiff and primarily the plaintiff's
- 10:49client. They're going to invite. a very interesting
- 10:52character to our movie that we're listening to
- 10:55or watching today called Thurston Howell III
- 10:57from Gilligan's Island. And I literally play
- 11:02the Gilligan's Island theme song, try to make
- 11:05things fun. Again, very sensitive to whether
- 11:07or not this is the kind of person that would
- 11:09be open to my craziness or somebody who may not
- 11:13be interested in that. So I'll temper it. But
- 11:16basically, I'll play the Gilligan's theme song.
- 11:19Obviously, if they're young, I'm 59. If they're
- 11:21much younger than me, they have no idea what
- 11:23the hell I'm talking about. I'll explain it to
- 11:25them. It's kind of fun. So who's this Thurston
- 11:28Howell, the third character? What the hell does
- 11:30this mean? Howell meds, right? So we have that
- 11:34famous case in California, which basically says,
- 11:37hey, plaintiffs bar, no fair, all your lean meds,
- 11:40we know what's going to happen. You're going
- 11:42to settle this case and pay pennies on the dollar.
- 11:44And that doctrine says, we're only going to have
- 11:48to pay what you're actually paying. after settlement.
- 11:50It's not fair for you to give us your inflated
- 11:53number and then make your back door deals with
- 11:55these doctors that are on leave and get the benefit
- 11:58of the savings. We need to get that benefit as
- 12:00well. So they're going to do one of two things,
- 12:03sometimes a combination of both things. They're
- 12:06going to take the medical procedures that you've
- 12:10claimed you've gone through in your case and
- 12:15go line by line in some cases and say, oh, $26
- 12:19,000 for PRP? That's crazy. You only get $16
- 12:23,000. And so on and so forth. And maybe this
- 12:26is where I should share with you this scenario
- 12:29that is quite common. Share my screen here. OK,
- 12:41great. So let's get rid of this. Give me a second
- 12:46here. All right. One second, guys. One second.
- 13:02I need to share the thing with you. Here we are.
- 13:07All right. Great. Here we go. Let's make this
- 13:10nice and large. OK. I assume we can all see the
- 13:15screen here. So here is. Here is how I walk the
- 13:23plaintiff and primarily their client through.
- 13:26Obviously, I talk to the attorney and discuss
- 13:30with them what I'm going to do. They're usually
- 13:32very cool with it. But I always like to ask permission.
- 13:35And everyone's fine with it. So here's what we
- 13:37have in our theoretical case. And this is what
- 13:41I do in my mediations. I'll take all the medicals.
- 13:44Yeah, I take them all item by item. And I add
- 13:47them up, obviously, with the help of AI. we can
- 13:51crunch the numbers quite easily. So that's very
- 13:54helpful. And I'll take all of the bills and add
- 13:58them up. And I'll create a couple columns here.
- 13:59So here's our case medicals. This is typically
- 14:02the name of the case. This is an auto accident.
- 14:04Here is the column of what the plaintiff is claiming
- 14:08as medicals. So we have Dr. Jim Joseph Family
- 14:12Care, November 18. That's the family doctor,
- 14:16$5 ,000. Then we have all these larger you know,
- 14:20procedures, PRP, on February 15th for 26 ,000.
- 14:24Again, on March for 26 ,000. Then again, on March
- 14:2916th for 26 ,000, which, you know, we can talk
- 14:33about later. Interestingly, that two days back
- 14:36to back, we have those kinds of procedures. And
- 14:39then April 15th, 26 ,000, so on and so forth.
- 14:42Sterile injections at 12 ,000. Chiro -care. and
- 14:47all the way down, MRI, and this all adds up to
- 14:50$185 ,000. Then what I do is I have another column
- 14:55here for the defendant. So we've shared, right?
- 15:00We've gone through discovery. The plaintiff attorney
- 15:03has shared these medical records with the defendant,
- 15:06the defense lawyer, and they have records of
- 15:08it as well. Sometimes they don't match. Oftentimes
- 15:13they don't match. Either they don't have a full
- 15:16file, they're missing information. And I like
- 15:20to do this in preparation for the mediation a
- 15:22good 7 to 10 days before if I get it, obviously,
- 15:25as soon as I get it. That way, if plaintiff is
- 15:29missing 30 or 40 or 50 ,000 in meds, I tell them,
- 15:33hey, you got to share this with the defense as
- 15:36soon as possible. Obviously, if they don't want
- 15:39to share, they don't want to share. But for mediation
- 15:42purposes, if they want that $185 ,000 number,
- 15:45They need to have all that sent over because
- 15:48nothing will upset an adjuster more than 24 hours
- 15:53before mediation, plaintiff sending over an additional
- 15:56$54 ,000 of meds. I get the call all the time.
- 16:00This is bullshit. I'm not doing a mediation in
- 16:0224 hours. They just sent over a bunch of additional
- 16:05meds. This is nonsense. And they don't like it.
- 16:08They want to be able to review it and see what's
- 16:10going on. So let's get all the meds exchanged
- 16:13well in advance of our mediation. That's going
- 16:17to be helpful. And as we go through here, we'll
- 16:21see that, oddly enough, we have 109 ,000 from
- 16:24the defense side versus 185. Well, what's happening
- 16:28here? Well, I didn't show the detail, but let's
- 16:30look at some of the Howell discount that the
- 16:35defendants are trying to point out. So in this
- 16:3926 ,000, What it comprises of is three separate
- 16:44charges. So each of these PRP $26 ,000 charges
- 16:48is made up of Dr. Cash, $12 ,000 for him, the
- 16:52shake and bake clinic of $10 ,000, and the actual
- 16:55procedure itself for $4 ,000. So they break it
- 16:58up three different ways. Defense lawyers hate
- 17:01this. The adjusters can't stand this. They consider
- 17:04it double, triple, dipping, whatever. That's
- 17:06their view. So then what they'll do is take this
- 17:09and say, no, no, no, no. we're not going to pay
- 17:11the shake and bake clinic $10 ,000. You get Dr.
- 17:15Cash is going to get his $12 ,000, the procedure
- 17:17for $4 ,000. That's $16 ,000. So that's all we're
- 17:19going to give you credit for in their mind. So
- 17:22they arrive at $16 ,000 for all those four procedures.
- 17:26$12 ,000 for a steroid injection is crazy. No
- 17:28one pays that. That's not their market rate.
- 17:30It's $6 ,000. And they kind of go down. you know,
- 17:34Cairo cares, 50 -250, nonsense. Our view is it's,
- 17:36you know, $25 a session. It adds up to $26 .25.
- 17:40I didn't break out all the visits here, but I
- 17:43often do if it looks like we're going to get
- 17:46into the nitty -gritty of the numbers. So this
- 17:48kind of ends up giving them their howl number.
- 17:52Now, this is their view, right? It has nothing
- 17:54to do with the plaintiff. They could say this
- 17:55is all nonsense. That's great for you, but this
- 17:58is how I like to explain it to the party. primarily
- 18:01the person who was injured in the plaintiff's
- 18:04room, that this is the view that they like to
- 18:06take in the defense side. The adjusters like,
- 18:10when I say this to the defendants, to the adjusters,
- 18:14yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, that's right, that's
- 18:15right. They love it. This is their language.
- 18:18They love this language. And I help them, we
- 18:20walk through it, because sometimes they just
- 18:22do a straight discount. They'll do, ah, it's
- 18:2430 % off the top, 40 % off the top, or it's a
- 18:28really good adjuster. They'll go into it like
- 18:30this and go item by item and discount it, discount
- 18:33it. You know, MRI bullshit, $4 ,800 is not what
- 18:35we pay. We pay $2 ,400. That's what Medicare
- 18:38pays. That's what this pays. That's what we pay.
- 18:41They substantiate it however they want. You know,
- 18:44they're billing practices. Then if there's a
- 18:49missing item, you know, like here we have an
- 18:51urgent care visit of $895. It's on the defense
- 18:53side. It's not on the plaintiff's side. I'll
- 18:56point it out to the plaintiff. Hey, by the way,
- 18:57you forgot to... put in your 895 urgent care,
- 19:00and we kind of get through the accounting. Now,
- 19:04what I'd like to do at this point is tell both
- 19:07sides, look, we may not agree on the way that
- 19:12we view the numbers, but we have to at least
- 19:14agree on what the numbers are. There's nothing
- 19:17harder to do in a mediation when they've got
- 19:20$275 ,000 in meds and the defendant has got $190
- 19:24,000, but they don't understand where that number
- 19:26comes from. We're not going to get anywhere.
- 19:29So the first place is to at least agree on what
- 19:31the numbers are. The defendant will agree that
- 19:33it's $185 ,000. They may not like it, but they
- 19:37see the bills, and we can all agree that it adds
- 19:39up, at least in the plaintiff's side, to $185
- 19:42,000. They discount it to $109 ,000. Plaintiff
- 19:45doesn't agree with this point of view, but it
- 19:47does add up to $109 ,000 based on their math.
- 19:50So at least now we have a starting point. And
- 19:53then this is where the next step. gets into what
- 19:56is the mediation value, as I like to call it,
- 19:59for today's discussion. I take that $109 ,000
- 20:04Howell discount, and I put it down here into
- 20:07a pain and suffering multiplier. And I'll put
- 20:10in two, three, sometimes four, but let's just
- 20:13use three for our discussions today, of a 1 .5
- 20:16multiplier, a 2 .0 multiplier, and a 2 .5 multiplier.
- 20:20So we take the 109 ,000 here. We multiply it
- 20:23by this 15. We arrive at 164, 219, and 274 ,925.
- 20:30What does that mean? This is the absolute highest
- 20:34amount of money that an adjuster would be willing
- 20:37to pay for this case, and they want to discount
- 20:41it down from there. So this would be like maximum
- 20:44authority in their view. We would never pay more
- 20:47than 164 for this case, and it's probably worth
- 20:5075 or 95 in our mind. This is their ceiling.
- 20:54So I take this information primarily for the
- 20:58plaintiff's side, and I explain it to them because
- 21:00the adjusters love this. They'll even be more
- 21:03aggressive sometimes. Oh, no, no, no. You didn't
- 21:05discount the 109. Let's take another 20 % off
- 21:08the top or whatever. Sometimes they do a combination
- 21:11of all the line items and take a discount off
- 21:13the top. Depends on what the route is that day.
- 21:17So we arrive at this. then we do this multiplier,
- 21:19and we arrive at an absolute maximum number that
- 21:22they'll ever pay, and it will play with the multipliers.
- 21:27That sort of resonates really well with the defendants.
- 21:31They love it. The adjusters are like, yeah, numbers.
- 21:33We like numbers. This makes sense. Sometimes
- 21:34they say to me, no way. It's not one five. It's
- 21:37one of a quart. So they'll never admit to this,
- 21:40right? I don't know for a fact that they're using
- 21:43this kind of a multiplier in the adjustment world
- 21:46or the insurance world. Nobody has ever said
- 21:47this to me. This may be very old school in the
- 21:50way we like to do PI cases. But it's some way
- 21:53of analyzing the numbers that we can talk about
- 21:56and get to a place. Now, that is a good way to
- 22:01explain to the plaintiff that they're not going
- 22:03to get $250, for example, or they may not get
- 22:05$250, or it may be hard to get policy. They're
- 22:08going to want to negotiate down from there. That's
- 22:13how I explain it to the plaintiffs. It helps
- 22:16them get a better understanding of what's going
- 22:18on in the mind of the people in the defendant's
- 22:20room. And then for plaintiff, I say to them,
- 22:26well, that's how they view it. Our challenge
- 22:29now is to explain to them why it's $26 ,000.
- 22:34why it's $12 ,000, why it's $52 ,500, why there
- 22:38shouldn't be a discount. Well, maybe Dr. Cash
- 22:40is the best doctor in town, and he charges that
- 22:42rate. And it's worth it, and that's why we went
- 22:46there, so we can start having more significant
- 22:49discussions. From there, we kind of get into
- 22:55it. Then we start talking with the plaintiff
- 23:00about what they want to do and how things proceed
- 23:04Sometimes and you know, I can stop sharing this
- 23:09now for now sometimes a Lot of times plaintiffs
- 23:14will say to me that's a beautiful explanation
- 23:16Joel Fantastic. What a wonderful view. It's all
- 23:19bullshit. I don't believe it That's not our point
- 23:22of view. That might be how you think it works.
- 23:24That might be how the defendant guy thinks. We're
- 23:27plaintiffs. If it wasn't for us, and I tell this
- 23:30to the defendants as well, I say, listen, guys,
- 23:32that might be your view. And you think that these
- 23:35guys are all ambulance chasers, and they're all
- 23:37mills and everything. But let's take the flip
- 23:38side for a minute. You've got to look at things.
- 23:41What's it look like in the plaintiff's side?
- 23:43Plaintiff's side is if it wasn't for them, none
- 23:46of these people could ever get recovered. None
- 23:48of them. I mean, if it wasn't for lean, big,
- 23:51bad, lean meds, nobody could get treatment. Nobody's
- 23:55going to get treatment. No one's going to get
- 23:57the kind of treatment that they need if they're
- 23:59with Kaiser or any of the other providers. No
- 24:01one's going to give them these kinds of advanced
- 24:02sterile injections and PRP and anything else
- 24:05that they need if it wasn't for the lawyers.
- 24:09Insurance companies don't ever pay people when
- 24:12they call up and say, I had an accident, give
- 24:14me $20 ,000 or $30 ,000, and we'll call it a
- 24:16day. You never pay it. You force people to go
- 24:19hire lawyers because you don't play ball. You
- 24:21don't you're not reasonable with them until the
- 24:23lawyer shows up So wasn't for the lawyers Most
- 24:28this is of course the plaintiff's bar and I believe
- 24:30this to a certain extent you have to be honest
- 24:32I mean if it wasn't for the plaintiff's bar a
- 24:35vast majority of people couldn't get recovery
- 24:38couldn't get help Who's gonna go out and spend
- 24:40a hundred grand of their own money? for medicals
- 24:42or try to fight Cedars -Sinai or Kaiser and the
- 24:45system. It's very hard, you know. So but for
- 24:49the plaintiff's bar, we'd have a lot of people
- 24:51hanging in the wind. So, you know, and that's
- 24:54because insurance companies play hardball and
- 24:56don't pay. So, look, this is the world we live
- 24:59in. It's not it's not one way. I mean, obviously,
- 25:01my cast of characters is kind of funny. I do
- 25:04it to make it amusing and interesting. But, you
- 25:06know, we can all talk about theory of plaintiffs
- 25:08and defendants, but that's that's I'd like to
- 25:11remind the defendants of it. So what I think
- 25:14is helpful for the defendants to take our plaintiffs,
- 25:19Leslie popped the policy very seriously, is now
- 25:22when we get into our discussion of what we could
- 25:24settle for, I tried to have a little more open
- 25:27discussion with our friends in the plaintiff
- 25:30side. I tried to get an understanding of where
- 25:32they want to end. Oftentimes, if it's somebody
- 25:36I have mediated with before, and they trust me,
- 25:38and they believe me when I tell them I'll keep
- 25:40things confidential, they give me their bottom
- 25:43line number. And I try to say this to both sides.
- 25:47Can you give me your bottom line number? And
- 25:49I know everybody wants a deal. So if the plaintiff
- 25:53says to me, listen, Joao, we've done a couple
- 25:56mediations before. I trust you. I know you're
- 25:58going to do me well. You're not going to screw
- 26:00me over. Let's do something. I'll take $125 ,000
- 26:05on this case. But I want to get to, if I can
- 26:08get $150 ,000 for my client, I mean, that's my
- 26:10job. So that's my bottom line. But try to get
- 26:13me more. Try to help me get something more reasonable
- 26:16for my clients. OK, great. So that's going to
- 26:20govern our discussions. Obviously, I'm not going
- 26:24over and say, hey, I'll take $125 ,000. Give
- 26:25it to him. No. I'm going to continue the discussions.
- 26:29We'll start with the numbers we have to start
- 26:31at. And I say the same thing to the defendants,
- 26:34that the adjusters are very reluctant to share
- 26:36any numbers at all, no matter how many times
- 26:39they've mediated with them. They just don't.
- 26:40It's just not their style. So I try to encourage
- 26:44them, though. to try to share. Look, especially
- 26:46if they have no authority. If they've only got
- 26:4825 ,000, like this case, for example, let's assume
- 26:51everything is legit. And it's on the up and up.
- 26:54There isn't anything fraudulent or horrible or
- 26:56the numbers are reasonable. And if they only
- 27:00have 25 ,000 in authority, we're not going to
- 27:06go anywhere. Let's have that conversation immediately
- 27:10so that I can tell the other side, look. whether
- 27:14we believe it or not, they're saying they've
- 27:16only got 25 ,000 in authority. Why don't we convince
- 27:20them that they're way off and come back and have
- 27:23a discussion in the future? Maybe they need to
- 27:26reevaluate the numbers and the medicals because
- 27:27they're just not seeing the case at all in the
- 27:31way that you guys are seeing it. Versus if they
- 27:34have money but they don't want to share and I...
- 27:36check them on this small amount. They said, no,
- 27:38we got money. Just continue on. OK, great. Then
- 27:41we'll continue the discussion. But that's how
- 27:45I like to explain to the plaintiffs. That's how
- 27:48I like to explain to everybody how the worldview
- 27:51is. And then we proceed with the case. And we
- 27:53go back and forth. And I try to get the plaintiff
- 27:55to open with a number that is seen as reasonable,
- 28:00at least in the eyes of the people in the other
- 28:02room. They never see it as reasonable as possible.
- 28:05So if they continue on the view of pop the policy,
- 28:09or I want policy limits, if it's warranted, absolutely.
- 28:15Let's do it. And let's go share that information.
- 28:19And let's go prove it to them, explain it to
- 28:22them so they can believe you. If it's not, or
- 28:27if they are willing to take something less, I
- 28:29always try to encourage the plaintiffs to come
- 28:33off that policy limit number as an opening demand.
- 28:37Because nothing does more to upset the other
- 28:40side to say, tender the policy, if it's not warranted
- 28:45in their mind, if it's really not warranted.
- 28:48Because then their view is, there you go. Another
- 28:51scum sucking, blood sucking, ambulance chaser.
- 28:54Another one. This is what it is. And it just
- 28:56sets the wrong tone. So I like to encourage people
- 29:00to not ask for the policy if it's not warranted.
- 29:04If you're doing it because you want to negotiate,
- 29:06that's not how I suggest you negotiate. My suggestion
- 29:09is if you need to end at 125, for example, Let's
- 29:14try to get to a number that's close to that or
- 29:16above, for sure. We're here for both sides. And
- 29:19I would suggest you open at a lower number than
- 29:22policy limits, perhaps sub 200. Nothing surprises
- 29:27people in the other room, in the defendant's
- 29:29room, more pleasantly as much as we can surprise
- 29:32them with anything pleasant, because they have
- 29:35a different view of the world, than to come in
- 29:37with a number that they were not expecting in
- 29:39the good way, much lower than they were expecting.
- 29:44I'm keeping a tally of my mediations. Obviously,
- 29:47they're all confidential. But I'm keeping a tally
- 29:49of the numbers to try to substantiate a theory
- 29:52that I have, which goes as follows. People end
- 29:55up getting more money when they start at a more
- 29:58reasonable number than if they started at an
- 30:01astronomical number. The view of start at $1
- 30:05million to end up $500 ,000. doesn't really work
- 30:09in my view, at least in the mediation side. And
- 30:12I find that people get better success rates numbers
- 30:15-wise when they start at a more reasonable number
- 30:19that obviously is connected to the facts and
- 30:22to the numbers of the case versus really just
- 30:25padding it. Because you think if you start high,
- 30:27you get a better end result. That tends to work
- 30:30really well. And it helps the negotiation go
- 30:34quite well. So that's how we do it. In my mediations,
- 30:41we really get into the meds. I ran through them
- 30:44quite fast. The other areas that we really, really
- 30:49get into, and I'll share the screen again as
- 30:52we discuss this so that we just can look at it
- 30:56again together, is dates are important, names
- 31:02are important, and tidiness in all of the medical
- 31:07records is very important. And I'll just make
- 31:10a couple of points here, which the defendants
- 31:13always point out. And this is an area where people
- 31:18start scratching their head in the other room
- 31:19and saying, this isn't so kosher or legitimate.
- 31:23So we have here a couple of dates. Let's just
- 31:25look at this date here. March 15, we have a PRP
- 31:29procedure at 26 ,000. And then on March 16, we've
- 31:32got another one for 26 ,000. How in the world
- 31:36is that possible? That's not usually the way
- 31:39medical procedures work, right? You don't have
- 31:42back -to -back procedures of that type the next
- 31:48day. What's going on? Either somebody is being
- 31:53very loose with their billing procedures or it's
- 31:58a mistake. Maybe the dates are wrong. So I always
- 32:01like to look at those types of things, catch
- 32:04them early if I can, and share it with the plaintiff.
- 32:06Say, look, this doesn't look so legit. What's
- 32:09going on here? What happened? Did it really require
- 32:12two days? I mean, if it did, it did. But if it
- 32:15doesn't look so good at face value, oftentimes,
- 32:18it's just a typo. The medical records have a
- 32:21wrong date on them, or something happened, or
- 32:23there's an explanation, or maybe it was a double
- 32:26billing. That was the procedure date. That was
- 32:29the billing date. Oh, we're double dipping, so
- 32:31to speak, here. Let's take that out. Great. Beautiful.
- 32:34Keep it clean. Keep it honest. That's important.
- 32:39And all of this numbers crunching, years ago,
- 32:44I'd literally take the bills one by one and type
- 32:47them in. With our friends in the AI world, you
- 32:52can do this very easily. And it takes seconds.
- 32:58Obviously, we all know about confidentiality
- 33:00and being careful to put information up there
- 33:02that shouldn't be out on the internet. But once
- 33:06you do it properly and take those safeguards,
- 33:09this can take, I'll give you an example. In construction
- 33:12defect cases where I might have 2 ,000 pages
- 33:15of documents, it can sift through those documents
- 33:19in minutes. and get outlines of dates and times
- 33:22and numbers that just make everything so much
- 33:26easier. So it's very easy to do. And you can
- 33:28be sure that the defendants are doing this. They're
- 33:31crunching everything and going through it. An
- 33:35additional point that I'd like to share with
- 33:38everybody is down below here. We didn't talk
- 33:40about it. But Dr. Cash has a report. about a
- 33:43future surgery that he believes is going to be
- 33:46warranted in the amount of $150 ,000, some type
- 33:49of a serious back surgery. Let's talk about future
- 33:53meds briefly because plaintiff attorneys often
- 33:58put that in there and say, it's $185 ,000. And
- 34:02by the way, she's going to have to have a future
- 34:05procedure of $150 ,000 or whatever that procedure
- 34:09is going to cost. I have very rarely found any
- 34:16instance in any mediation where the adjusters
- 34:20in the defendant's room will pay for any future
- 34:23medical procedures. Their response is, go under
- 34:28the knife, have the procedure done, send me the
- 34:31bill, and then we'll talk. Classic insurance
- 34:33talk, right? So that's what they always say.
- 34:39When I share that with the plaintiff or the person
- 34:43who was injured, I say to them, look, if that's
- 34:48definitely something you want to have done, that's
- 34:50a discussion between you and your doctor, you
- 34:53make that decision. And if it's going to have
- 34:56to be done, I would suggest that you might talk
- 34:59with your lawyer and maybe have that procedure
- 35:02done and then come back to mediate this matter
- 35:06because they're never going to pay for it. uh
- 35:09until it's done ever and if it's that kind of
- 35:11a number you know that's that's almost you know
- 35:14double what we have in medicals it's going to
- 35:16change the the value of the case for sure um
- 35:20so that's something that you know it's it's disappointing
- 35:23to to a lot of people because you know their
- 35:27view is if it's a it's a if it's some kind of
- 35:31a procedure they may have they're not sure if
- 35:33they want to i mean look people don't like to
- 35:34have surgeries and do things unless it's absolutely
- 35:38necessary. Sometimes they want to think about
- 35:40it. Sometimes it's something that's going to
- 35:42hopefully go away over time. And so they want
- 35:46some value for that, but it's it's very difficult
- 35:49to get insurance carriers very rarely pay for
- 35:51it unless. You know you got three doctors reports
- 35:54and they're like and they're. you know, pushing
- 35:57hard on it. That could be something to talk about.
- 36:00And it also depends on if it's going to push
- 36:02policy limits sometimes, and the carriers will
- 36:04say, fine, we'll just tender. But it's very rare.
- 36:07It's hard to make that case. That's maybe a discussion
- 36:09for another day, but it's a more difficult discussion.
- 36:14The other thing I think I would like to mention,
- 36:18as we talk about meds, so we talk about the numbers.
- 36:23I see we're starting to get some questions. we'll
- 36:27come back in a minute, is you're going to get
- 36:33into the medicals, not only by way of the numbers,
- 36:37but by way of the actual procedures themselves.
- 36:40And I am finding more and more that the adjusters
- 36:45and the defendant attorneys almost have like
- 36:49an MD. I mean, these guys are almost doctor level
- 36:52of understanding of what procedures are being
- 36:55claimed are needed. And we're getting into the
- 36:59nitty gritty of medical discussion a lot of times.
- 37:03So 2 .5 millimeter hernia at a certain place,
- 37:10C1, C3, or T1, they get into it. at a very technical
- 37:15level. And sometimes we're looking at x -rays
- 37:18together, we're looking at MRIs, and they're
- 37:20bringing in, interestingly, nurse practitioners
- 37:23now to talk about billing practices. Sometimes
- 37:25they'll bring a doctor in to start talking about
- 37:28how this was unnecessary, not required, not needed,
- 37:32you know, from a medical standpoint, and look
- 37:35at this and look at this and, you know, This
- 37:382 .5, you know at this place and the vertebrae
- 37:42is consistent with the same bulges This person's
- 37:45got and at this location in this location and
- 37:48that's just life. He's a 65 year old, you know
- 37:51plaintiff Those are typical from life. That's
- 37:56life experience. We all have that at 65 years
- 37:58old and and tough luck We're not paying for those
- 38:01injections because they weren't necessary. They
- 38:04weren't needed. You just poke them for money
- 38:06And we're getting into those kinds of very heavy
- 38:09discussions. So I would highly suggest that you
- 38:13get a lexicon or some medical, not training,
- 38:17but do some brush up on the medicals and be prepared
- 38:21to start arguing medical procedures. Because
- 38:24that's a fascinating area where it's really getting
- 38:26into the nitty gritty as we get into higher value
- 38:29cases where people are really arguing, we're
- 38:32talking half a million or a million dollars.
- 38:34We're deep in the weeds of playing doctor. Grey's
- 38:39Anatomy, if you will. And I found myself having
- 38:42to spend a lot of time understanding what those
- 38:44procedures mean. And we have literally doctor
- 38:48level discussions about what was necessary or
- 38:52not necessary or other procedures that could
- 38:54have taken care of it. So it's either going more
- 38:56and more into that level of discussion. So I
- 38:59would suggest that's something you should get
- 39:01into if it's your world. because they're going
- 39:04to start talking high -level technical doctor
- 39:08level stuff. So it's fascinating and requires
- 39:13a little bit of extra preparation and homework.
- 39:16And that's how it goes. And then we just talk.
- 39:20I tell people, let's just get it done. Let's
- 39:22have a conversation. I do the best I can to help
- 39:26people see what the mediation value for settlement
- 39:28is going to be. I always tell people, trial is
- 39:31trial. Mediation is mediation. It doesn't mean
- 39:34that this is what the case is worth. It just
- 39:36means what it's worth today. At this time, at
- 39:38this place, at this location and life of the
- 39:41case, this might be what it could settle for.
- 39:44It could settle for more. It could settle for
- 39:45less in the future. Who knows? But that's what
- 39:47you get today. And if you want it today, then
- 39:50we can get it done. And the other part that I
- 39:53really like to emphasize to the plaintiffs, if
- 39:57they can live with it, is there's a huge amount
- 39:59of value for peace of mind. and getting it behind
- 40:03you. So if that's worth something, then you should
- 40:07take that into consideration as well. For me
- 40:09personally, peace of mind is at high value. I
- 40:12would be willing to pay in the way of a discounted
- 40:16settlement so that I could get out of a lawsuit.
- 40:18That's me. I think it's important to have peace
- 40:20of mind and not have to deal with lawyers and
- 40:23depots and all the rest of it. That's why I became
- 40:25a mediator. I didn't like the practice of law
- 40:27in the way it's tough, it's hard. So that's something
- 40:32I try to explain to people, and that you may
- 40:34want to settle it for less than you were hoping
- 40:36for, but peace of mind. Money in the bank today,
- 40:39and you're done, and you move on with your life.
- 40:42So go on a vacation, have a cruise, enjoy yourself,
- 40:44go celebrate. That's worth a lot. And that's
- 40:48it, my friends. That's sort of how I use it.
- 40:52And then, obviously, the facts of the case definitely
- 40:57are not. We don't forget that. We don't just
- 41:01talk numbers. This is not a counting procedure.
- 41:04But if it's the more run of the mill, typical
- 41:06kind of a case where people are just injured
- 41:11in a normal manner, there's not terrible lifelong
- 41:16injuries here, then this can usually help get
- 41:19it done, which is the vast majority of the volume
- 41:21of mediations in the personal injury world that
- 41:24we see. The more traumatic ones, may be driven
- 41:30more by the facts and the injury of the case.
- 41:34If there's a traumatic brain injury and all these
- 41:36more traumatic events, medicals are important,
- 41:39but maybe less so important. What happened to
- 41:42this person is really going to drive the case.
- 41:44The narrative and the optics, of course, are
- 41:47going to be more important. in those kind of
- 41:49cases. So you have to balance it. This may work
- 41:52in some cases. I think it works in the vast majority
- 41:54of your typical type of a slip and fall or auto
- 41:57accident where we don't have traumatic injury.
- 42:00We have normal, more normal type of injury, the
- 42:03more typical type of a volume that we get. This
- 42:06is very helpful and very effective in the world
- 42:10of more dramatic. traumatic injury. This may
- 42:13not be as important. It may be 50 -50. Case facts
- 42:17are going to drive it much more than just talking
- 42:20meds. That's how it works. And I found it to
- 42:25be very, very effective. It has worked very well
- 42:28for most of the mediations that I do. And people
- 42:31find it helps them settle. And it helps the attorneys
- 42:36have open discussions with their clients. So
- 42:38that's the That's the song and dance of it. And
- 42:41with that, I guess we'll open it up to questions.
- 42:46All right. Let's see here. Shelly. Hi, Shelly.
- 42:49Shelly wants to know, what AI safeguards do you
- 42:52use when you submit documents or review by AI?
- 42:55Well, depending on which AI you use, there are
- 43:02privacy selections you can choose to make it
- 43:07confidential. You can tell it not to use your
- 43:09information to learn, which is telling it not
- 43:12to put it out there on the internet, and many
- 43:15others. I would suggest you do some research,
- 43:19because they all have different clod, and Gemini,
- 43:21and chat, and Brock. I mean, there's quite a
- 43:24few of them out there. Find the one that you
- 43:26like, and look, take a dive into it, and ask
- 43:29it, hey, I'm an attorney. I need confidentiality,
- 43:32so on and so on. And then we have quite a few
- 43:34of legal AI systems that have even higher levels
- 43:38of protection. The other simple way of doing
- 43:41it, you won't believe this. I go to AI and I
- 43:42say, I'd like to put this document in. I'd like
- 43:45it to be confidential. I want you to scrub the
- 43:47names. And then it'll give it to me and scrub
- 43:50the names. Obviously, it's out there. So you've
- 43:53got to be careful. So I would do a little bit
- 43:54more research on that. But it exists. You can
- 43:57toggle on and off confidentiality restrictions.
- 44:03You know, there's options you can find. I think
- 44:06that the world of, oh, confidentiality, AI, we
- 44:09can't use it, we're way beyond that. Way, way
- 44:12beyond that. I think find the one you like and
- 44:15make yourself comfortable with the safeguards
- 44:17and it'll be fine. It'll be fine. David Shraga,
- 44:21hey, Mr. Entertainment Mediator. What happens
- 44:25when the adjuster who's there is going through
- 44:26this process with you? And it seems clear there
- 44:29is a range that appears reasonable to you. And
- 44:32the adjuster says they don't have authority.
- 44:37They just didn't value it the same way beforehand.
- 44:42So I like to have that. So what do we do when
- 44:44the adjuster is just way off? They don't see
- 44:46the value or the numbers. Just great, beautiful
- 44:48multiplier, Berta. We're not giving you no 160.
- 44:52We've got 50 grand. That's what we value it at
- 44:54based on the meds. And that's what we're going
- 44:56to pay. I just get into it with them on the numbers.
- 44:59And we have that discussion. And I like to have
- 45:03them explain to me, well, why? What are you seeing
- 45:06that's not right here? You can say all day long,
- 45:08this is unnecessarily overly cooked. They overcooked
- 45:12the turkey. They didn't do it unreasonable. OK,
- 45:15fine. Let's go through it. And we'll go through
- 45:17it in great detail. If we're close, obviously,
- 45:21then I'll tell them to make that famous call.
- 45:23Pick up the red line and get authority. What
- 45:27about if the plaintiff's lawyer isn't sure how
- 45:29to price the Howell discount because they aren't
- 45:31sure what they can work out with the lien docs?
- 45:34OK, that's a great point. As we prepare, it's
- 45:40one of the points I like. So I'll have a pre
- 45:42-mediation call, and I'll tell the plaintiff
- 45:44exactly that. Did you do your math? Do you know
- 45:47how much you're going to get in all these different
- 45:49scenarios? And I have a calculator, by the way,
- 45:51that I also use to help the lawyers understand,
- 45:55because the clients want to know how much money
- 45:56am I getting at the end of the day? How much
- 45:59is in my pocket? That's a very confidential and
- 46:03sensitive discussion, because the lawyers take
- 46:05their cut, 30, 40, whatever the deal is that
- 46:09they did on contingency. And I tell the lawyers,
- 46:13have your calculator ready. Run your numbers.
- 46:16If they don't have one or they need some help,
- 46:19I give them one I have. Add up your expenses,
- 46:22take it off the top, take it off the bottom.
- 46:24Everybody runs it differently, but at the end
- 46:26of the day, they need to be able to tell their
- 46:28client, if we settle at 150, you're going to
- 46:31get $45 ,000. And then, well, clients like, I'm
- 46:36not taking 45, I need 65. Well, then they either
- 46:39have to discount their fee or they got to go
- 46:42prepare their doctors for what they can do. and
- 46:46they need to have that discussion as they prepare
- 46:48for mediation. This is what I tell people, talk
- 46:50to your medical providers, find out what they're
- 46:53willing to do, or at least you have a practice
- 46:55that they understand that they'll accept. So,
- 46:59you know, Dr. Cash, a $26 ,000 a pop, you know,
- 47:03I'll take 10 grand. Okay, fine. Okay, if that's
- 47:05your deal, that's your deal. If it's a normal
- 47:08case, I'll take 10 grand. If it's a loser, I'll
- 47:10take five. Whatever it is, however deal you've
- 47:13arranged, whatever arrangement you have, you
- 47:15need to know that so that when we're in mediation,
- 47:19you can talk to your client and say, look, this
- 47:20is how much you get at the end of the day. If
- 47:22we take that number, I think it's a good deal
- 47:24or I don't think it's a good deal. So you got
- 47:26to have your math prepared so that you understand
- 47:28what's happening. Nothing will destroy an attorney
- 47:33-client relationship in the plaintiff world when
- 47:36they get $175 ,000 settlement and clients getting
- 47:3920 grand. or whatever the number is, and they're
- 47:42so upset you can't believe it. Fire the lawyer,
- 47:46and then the lawyer's got to lean on the case,
- 47:48and it's horrible. So I tell the lawyers, do
- 47:51your homework. Prepare your client. Have this
- 47:53discussion with them. Take the spreadsheet. Explain
- 47:55the howl discussion with them. Have your personal
- 47:57calculator. Mrs. Steroid injection. We're going
- 48:01to have our mediation tomorrow. This is how they
- 48:04view it. I'm going to try and get you the policy.
- 48:06But if we end up settling at 125, here's what
- 48:09it looks like. If we settle at 100, here's what
- 48:11it looks like. And show them all the different
- 48:14numbers, high, medium, low. Pardon me, high,
- 48:17high, medium, best case, worst case, somewhere
- 48:20in the middle, so that the clients are able to
- 48:23make a decision. It's not a shock to them. when
- 48:25they see that it's $185 ,000 settlement, but
- 48:28I get $40 ,000? Well, what the hell, man? Where's
- 48:32my money? People get upset. You've got to show
- 48:34it to them in the numbers. And the numbers never
- 48:36lie. So that's how you've got to prepare them.
- 48:40Philip, how does a life care plan factor into
- 48:43the defense analysis? And what factors need to
- 48:46be presented so that they recognize the need
- 48:48for future care? Fascinating. Great, great question,
- 48:52Philip. That's a discussion for an entirely different
- 48:54day. It has huge bearing on it. And it goes back
- 48:59to the discussion of meds and numbers. The big
- 49:0630 ,000 foot answer is they need to believe it
- 49:10in the other room. Defendants need to believe
- 49:12it. The adjuster needs to believe it. If it's
- 49:15a very poorly put together life plan by a doctor
- 49:19who's under federal indictment, because he got
- 49:23nailed for lots of potential fraud, that's not
- 49:26going to go very far. if it's put together by
- 49:28a highly reputable doctor and a team of experts
- 49:33that has normal to high reputation, that goes
- 49:38very far in the other room. And then what happens
- 49:42then is a whole different discussion. But it's
- 49:44got to be legit. It's got to make sense. The
- 49:46numbers have to add up. It can't be a $50 million
- 49:49life care plan for somebody who was a welder
- 49:51making $40 ,000 a year. These things have to
- 49:54factor in. And of course, depends on their family
- 49:57and so many other factors. But it goes back to
- 49:59the numbers and reliability of the people putting
- 50:02together the reports, I think, is the short answer.
- 50:05What's the Howell discussion? Ralph, the Howell
- 50:08discussion. The Howell doctrine is based on a
- 50:13case called Howell versus something meatpackers
- 50:18of California. I forget the exact case citation.
- 50:22I can get that to you if you want. But basically,
- 50:24it was Howell versus, and it became this Howell
- 50:27doctrine, which says generally, hey, no fair,
- 50:31you plaintiff attorneys. You can't ask us for
- 50:34the full value, $185 ,000 in this case, when
- 50:37after we settle for $150 ,000, let's say, then
- 50:41you go back to those doctors. And instead of
- 50:44paying them $26 ,000 for each of those procedures,
- 50:46you're only paying them $10 ,000. And you're
- 50:48getting to pocket all of that additional money.
- 50:51That's not fair. The value of the med should
- 50:55be based on the after -discount lien because
- 50:58all these medical providers haven't been paid.
- 51:01They're in the deal. They're hoping to get money
- 51:04after it settles. So they do it on lien. The
- 51:08medical provider has a lien on the case. And
- 51:10after it settles, they get paid. So there's a
- 51:12negotiation after the fact. So Howell says, hey,
- 51:14no fair. You shouldn't get paid 100 % on these
- 51:17inflated numbers based on liens. You should be
- 51:20paid on what they're actually going to get paid
- 51:21for. So that's the Howell discussion. Philip,
- 51:26should the plaintiff's attorney present the reduction
- 51:28amounts with the various carriers? Yeah, possibly.
- 51:32Should the plaintiff take the step of going through
- 51:34the Howell calculation as we begin? Maybe not.
- 51:42Maybe you put it in as it's presented, I would
- 51:45suggest. And then I would be prepared to explain
- 51:48to my client as to why they're going to have
- 51:51this Howell discussion. And then you got to explain
- 51:53to the client, yeah, we're going to have to have
- 51:55this discount. It sort of makes sense because
- 51:57I'm going to get the discount for you. I mean,
- 51:59it's based on logic, right? They're saying I'm
- 52:02only going to pay. you know, 16 ,000 for the
- 52:05PRP procedure, and I'm probably only going to
- 52:07pay 16 ,000, or maybe we're only going to pay
- 52:0910 or 12. I mean, I have a special deal with
- 52:11Dr. Keshe, so I think you got to be transparent
- 52:14with that and explain it to them, and that's
- 52:16why we arrived at the discount. But I would tell
- 52:18the plaintiff to keep the full value number in
- 52:20there, not discount it themselves, but maybe
- 52:24use that as an opening instead of pop the policy
- 52:27number 250, say to the client, look, This is
- 52:31how they view the world. Let's try to get a good
- 52:34settlement here. Berte has always told me in
- 52:37my mediations with him that start with a reasonable
- 52:39number. We get a higher number. Let's trust him
- 52:42and see if we can get there. Start at 195 or
- 52:44something like that, and then have that discussion
- 52:47internally with your client about how it's going
- 52:48to go. Sharaga, another question. A lot of times
- 52:53plaintiff lawyers and adjusters know each other
- 52:56already from other cases due to the volume of
- 52:59cases. where they come across each other. How
- 53:02do they deal with the dynamic where the adjuster
- 53:04is thinking across multiple cases or has a history
- 53:07of distrust with the plaintiff's lawyer? This
- 53:11happens a lot, believe it or not. X, Y, or Z
- 53:15plaintiff lawyer shows up, and adjuster can't
- 53:20stand this guy. I'll give you a very high level
- 53:23dramatic example of it in a mediation that I
- 53:26did a couple of years ago. for a tragic private
- 53:29airplane crash. And six people lost their lives.
- 53:34Horrible accident, pilot error. It was a disaster.
- 53:38Insurance, most of the plaintiffs had settled
- 53:42out with the insurance company. There was one
- 53:45family left, the mom of the survivor. And the
- 53:51insurance company just wouldn't offer her a reasonable
- 53:54amount. a very high level person, high value,
- 53:59and life discussions that we had earlier. The
- 54:02numbers are very high. Policy limit on the underlying
- 54:06policy was $20 million. And I just didn't understand
- 54:10why the insurance carrier wouldn't tend to the
- 54:13policy. There was no question that it was going
- 54:17to be bigger than that number. So why not tender
- 54:20or get to a number close to, they were in the
- 54:23millions. when it should have been 10, 15, or
- 54:2520 million are really probably just tender. The
- 54:29insurance adjuster in that case had a grudge
- 54:33against this particular plaintiff's attorney
- 54:35who's world known for getting massive verdicts
- 54:38and it couldn't stand his guts and over his dead
- 54:41body he was going to settle the case. So that
- 54:43was just personal vendetta destroying the mediation.
- 54:47Guy wouldn't do it. Both super high level, I
- 54:50mean a very high level adjuster who's been in
- 54:52the game from 20 plus years who has settled very,
- 54:56very high value cases and deals with very high
- 54:59level insurance policies and couldn't stand this
- 55:02guy's face and said, F him. He's going to have
- 55:06to pull it out of me at trial and didn't have
- 55:09any concern about getting the policy popped and
- 55:13all that, which I think was a huge risk and bad
- 55:16faith. But that was it. So there's that dynamic.
- 55:19I can't stand that dude. Screw him. He's not
- 55:21going to get a dollar out of me. that happens
- 55:24and I just try to be more analytical with them
- 55:27and say great guys that's wonderful but what
- 55:29are you doing for your clients you know you guys
- 55:31want to fight it out on the playground and go
- 55:34to the sandbox go play some t -ball go beat each
- 55:37other up I don't care you don't forget you're
- 55:39here for your clients keep your vendettas for
- 55:43your own stuff but you have an obligation an
- 55:48ethical one let me remind you to help your clients
- 55:50so But when people are that emotional or that
- 55:54pissed, it's hard to get past it. The more interesting
- 55:57dynamic that David brings up is, what about if
- 55:59the adjuster and the defense attorney don't see
- 56:03eye to eye? Or perhaps, maybe they don't have
- 56:07animosity, but they just don't see eye to eye.
- 56:10Usually what happens is the adjuster is not interested
- 56:13in paying what the attorney is suggesting. And
- 56:17you have this fight between them. What I usually
- 56:22do is we just talk about it. Why? Why do we see
- 56:26a difference in the numbers? What is going on
- 56:29here? Why is it that your attorney is telling
- 56:31you you need to settle for $150, but for a line
- 56:36fraud finder, you're like at $50 ,000. What's
- 56:39the reason for it? That's all I got. Well, if
- 56:42that's all you got, maybe you need to pick up
- 56:44the phone. Let's help you get more. and we can
- 56:48get there, but usually it's driven by facts.
- 56:53There's something wrong in the case, right? There's
- 56:56something wrong with the facts or the numbers
- 56:58that drives that. It's not just a random, I don't
- 57:01think it's worth it kind of a thing. Something
- 57:03is driving it. If the adjuster doesn't see the
- 57:06value that the defense attorney is saying we
- 57:10need to pay, there's something missing in this
- 57:13story that they don't understand. So I need to
- 57:16have, I'd like to, they need to bring that out.
- 57:19Why do you think it's worth 100 ,000 and why
- 57:21do you think it's worth 50 adjuster? Have that
- 57:23discussion openly and let the documents sometimes
- 57:26solve it. A lot of times that helps. A lot of
- 57:29times that helps ferret it out and then we can
- 57:32get to the bottom line. Heather, why did they
- 57:35become, why did they come into paid mediation
- 57:38in the first place? That's if each council distressed
- 57:41each other to that extent. Well, sometimes they're
- 57:44ordered. into mediation. So in the general world
- 57:47of things, as a private mediator, people choose
- 57:50me. They agree to mediate. And they say, yeah,
- 57:54sure, let's mediate. We'll get together. Sometimes
- 57:56I get ordered by the court. So there are several
- 57:59court ordered mediation programs, such as Resolve
- 58:02Law LA and the Mediation Center of Los Angeles,
- 58:05which I should definitely. send a shout out and
- 58:08a plug to. They had their second annual dinner
- 58:11last night, a panel of which I am a part of.
- 58:14It's a pro bono mediation panel, pro bono. I
- 58:17mean, it's low cost. I think it's a $900 fee
- 58:22to mediate total, $450 each side. Those cases
- 58:25come in by order of the court. The judge will
- 58:29order it. You're going to mediate this case,
- 58:31and I'm ordering you to go to the Mediation Center
- 58:33of Los Angeles to do it, or the MVP. the panel,
- 58:37the Superior Court's ADR, No Cost Program, or
- 58:41Resolve Law. Those are three very big pro bono
- 58:44panels. So they'll come in sometimes not ready
- 58:47to mediate, oftentimes, because it's a court
- 58:50order. And oftentimes, I can get them to settle
- 58:53because, look, you came in here thinking you're
- 58:55not going to settle. Why don't we shift our mindset?
- 58:58What if we could settle? Sometimes it's PI, sometimes
- 59:02it's other cases because it's quite a broad range.
- 59:06But yeah, that's a good point, Heather. Why the
- 59:07hell are they showing up if they hate each other?
- 59:09Because they've been ordered by the court. Or
- 59:11sometimes they just do it because they want to
- 59:13see if they can get it done. I hate that guy.
- 59:16I don't want to see him in court anymore. So
- 59:17that's an impetus. Yeah, if they haven't paid,
- 59:23they have no skin in the game, Heather. You're
- 59:24right. That's correct. So if they're ordered,
- 59:26they don't have any skin in the game. However,
- 59:28they show up with their clients. This is an interesting
- 59:30thing about the court ordered mediation. They're
- 59:33ordered to mediate by a certain date. They're
- 59:35also ordered to have their clients show up. So
- 59:38they can't just show up lawyers only and say,
- 59:40this is bullshit. I'm checking off the box so
- 59:42the judge doesn't hold me in contempt. They have
- 59:45to bring their client. And so when they're upset
- 59:47with each other and they can't stand each other's
- 59:49faces and they show up without their clients,
- 59:53I tell them, we're not going to start until your
- 59:55clients show up. My client doesn't. I got him
- 59:59on speed. I said, that's great. He needs to show
- 1:00:01up. Why don't you read the order? It's technically
- 1:00:04an MSC, a mandatory settlement conference that's
- 1:00:07been ordered, not a mediation in the way that
- 1:00:09we see it. So get him on the phone, get him in
- 1:00:12the Zoom. And guess what happens? Lawyers hate
- 1:00:15each other. Clients want to settle cases. All
- 1:00:18of a sudden, I start talking to the clients.
- 1:00:20Obviously, with due respect to the attorneys
- 1:00:22and deference to them, we've got to be careful
- 1:00:25how you walk that line as a mediator. But now,
- 1:00:27all of a sudden, clients hear possible settlement.
- 1:00:30And they talk to their lawyer. And all of a sudden,
- 1:00:32the lawyer has to shift from, I hate that dude,
- 1:00:35to maybe I better settle this for my client.
- 1:00:37You hate him that much, then you don't need to
- 1:00:39see him at the CMC. You don't need to see him
- 1:00:40at the next hearing. You don't need to see him
- 1:00:42at the next ex parte. You don't need to see him
- 1:00:44at the depo. You don't want to see him. Get rid
- 1:00:46of the case. you know so I kind of flip it on
- 1:00:49and say if you hate him that much get rid of
- 1:00:51it now let's settle it so that's it everybody
- 1:00:55it looks like we run out of time I want to be
- 1:00:57very respectful of everybody's time you have
- 1:01:00my information and contact of course should you
- 1:01:04want to talk further you have my cell phone you
- 1:01:06have my email I love talking mediation and feel
- 1:01:11free to call me I'd love to talk with my friends
- 1:01:13at the in the bar and help them out of a mediation
- 1:01:16that's going to happen with another mediator
- 1:01:19in the world that we live in. And, you know,
- 1:01:21you've already booked him and you got here plenty
- 1:01:24of world. There's plenty of money going around
- 1:01:26for everybody to make money and mediation and
- 1:01:29law and everything. Let's help each other out.
- 1:01:31We're all colleagues. So I have a mediation with
- 1:01:34this dude. I've got an entertainment mediation
- 1:01:36with David Shraga. Right. Coming up. And here's
- 1:01:39the case. What do you think? How am I going to
- 1:01:41manage this? Call me up. Let's talk. Let's see
- 1:01:44about what we can do to help you out. I'll give
- 1:01:46you some insights as to how things might happen
- 1:01:48in the mediation and help you out. So with that,
- 1:01:52are there any other questions? Have a great weekend,
- 1:01:55everybody. And any questions or other concerns,
- 1:01:59I am here to answer, here to have a conversation.
- 1:02:03This concludes today's presentation. Thank you
- 1:02:05so much, Joel, for an excellent presentation
- 1:02:07today about mediation. And thank you so much
- 1:02:09to our audience. Have a great day, everybody.