Latest / Once Upon a Time at the Oscars / All Quiet on the Western Front (1930) - featuring Jordan Ghastly
Transcript
- 0:00Good evening ladies and gentlemen and welcome
- 0:03to once upon a time at the Oscars Hello everyone,
- 0:38and welcome to Once Upon a Time at the Oscars.
- 0:41The show where we take you through every Best
- 0:43Picture nominee from 1927 to today. I'm Kyle.
- 0:46And I'm Ryan. And here we are again in the third
- 0:49Academy year, talking, what is this, the fourth
- 0:52movie? Yes. Yes. This will be the fourth movie
- 0:55this year. Yeah. Without giving away too much,
- 0:58probably the biggest... most impactful movie
- 1:01we've covered so far on the show? I think that's
- 1:02fair to say. I think that when we first talked
- 1:05about, I think we actually mentioned on the pod
- 1:07that when I was purchasing movies for this, one
- 1:10of the first ones that I actually purchased purposely
- 1:13for this podcast was I found this movie on Blu
- 1:17-ray, part of the 100 -year celebration of Universal
- 1:20specifically. So, I mean, how do you want to
- 1:23reveal? I mean, I guess they already know the
- 1:25title because they've clicked on the episode.
- 1:27Right, yeah. Hey, let's reveal our guest first.
- 1:30Hey, that's a great idea. So, who do we have
- 1:31with us today? So, the first guest of this iteration
- 1:35is our very good friend, my personal very good
- 1:38friend as well, Jordan Gastly. Yeah. Hello. Hey,
- 1:43buddy. How's it going, buddy? It's going well.
- 1:46Hey. Very happy to have you on here. Hi, buddy.
- 1:49Kyle's here, too. Hi, also, buddy. Drop an S
- 1:53on that, please. Hey, buddies. So, Jordan is
- 1:57a very close friend of mine. Anyone who has listened
- 1:59to any, I mean, literally any of the podcasts
- 2:02I've been on previously, Jordan has been involved.
- 2:04Cinema Showdown, we were co -hosts, co -hosts
- 2:07of, well, I guess, yeah, co -hosts of Mickey
- 2:09Mutineers, It's All in My Head podcast. We've
- 2:12done it all together. You've been on an episode
- 2:14or two of my long -famed... Commentary Men. We
- 2:19did the Monster Squad episode. You know what's
- 2:21really funny is I was doom -scrolling on the
- 2:25couch the other day. As one does. Yeah, yeah.
- 2:28Well, you know. Let me just gesture broadly.
- 2:31My Facebook memories came up, and it was a memory
- 2:35of us recording an episode of Commentary Men.
- 2:39The giant stripe plush was there, wasn't it?
- 2:43I think so. Yeah. But I think that that was for...
- 2:46an episode of all in it's all in my head uh i
- 2:49think he lived there for a while he was definitely
- 2:51there for a commentary men episode i had a giant
- 2:53plush of stripe the gremlin um and i don't know
- 2:57where it went now i'm sure one of the animals
- 2:59that has lived either at his place or my place
- 3:02have torn into it and it's gone you hope losing
- 3:05a gremlin is like the worst thing we didn't get
- 3:08it wet all right like it's fine like it just
- 3:10we destroyed it we He didn't feed it after midnight
- 3:13or anything, so it should be fine. I do have
- 3:17a question. After you feed a gremlin, like, you
- 3:19feed a mogwai after midnight, it turns into a
- 3:21gremlin, right? But then if you feed a gremlin
- 3:23after midnight, does that even matter? It doesn't
- 3:26matter anymore, right? It's just a gremlin. I
- 3:28don't... Yeah, I guess you're right. I guess,
- 3:30yeah. We could feed it after midnight. We just
- 3:31can't get it wet. And I think the most impressive
- 3:35thing about that film is that all mogwais know
- 3:37about time zones. Damn. That is true. And they
- 3:43love James Dean movies. It's true. Yeah, they
- 3:47really do. Also, I want to apologize to all the
- 3:49listeners. I had a little bit of a cold earlier
- 3:52this week, so I'm kind of dealing with the leftovers
- 3:55right now. So if I'm a little hoarse, that is
- 3:58why. Give yourself some credit, man. You're at
- 4:00least like a medium -sized horse. Okay, thank
- 4:02you. Centaur level. thank you medium -sized pretty
- 4:06big uh so jordan is on the podcast today because
- 4:10specifically uh well you know we don't really
- 4:12need a reason but specifically for this one uh
- 4:14we are covering all quiet on the western front
- 4:17and uh jordan you want to tell us a little bit
- 4:19about your background and why you might be a
- 4:21good speaker for this episode uh well i'm might
- 4:23be an okay speaker for this episode you guys
- 4:26are putting a lot of trust better than us no
- 4:28um just Professionally and academically, my background
- 4:31is in history. I have a degree in world history
- 4:34and cultures. I have a certificate in public
- 4:36history. My minor was in classical studies. I
- 4:39do currently work in museum education. And it
- 4:43is just very serendipitous that we are recording
- 4:45this this week because my team and I are actually
- 4:48currently updating our World War I field trip
- 4:52at the museum right now. I personally find World
- 4:57War I a more fascinating world war between World
- 5:01War I and World War II. I know a lot of World
- 5:03War II diehards will call that blasphemy, but
- 5:06I personally just find that World War I is more
- 5:10fascinating just because it is literally the
- 5:12first modern war in the world. And at the beginning
- 5:16of this war... We were marching in on horseback,
- 5:19and just a short four years later, we're flying
- 5:22planes and driving tanks. And it's also the war
- 5:26that created our map right now. All of the little
- 5:30conflicts that are going on in Eastern Europe
- 5:33and the Near East and everything, all of this
- 5:35is fallout from what happened at the end of World
- 5:38War I. So it is the first modern war, and it's
- 5:42the war that created our current world map, so
- 5:45to speak. It's really good to have you on here,
- 5:48because I think that what Kyle and I talk about
- 5:51is a lot of the impact of this movie. But obviously,
- 5:55this is one of the first movies that we can cover
- 5:57on this iteration that talks about the real -life
- 6:00impact that these events have had on where we
- 6:03are today. So it was important that we brought
- 6:05in someone who can speak a little bit more to
- 6:08the events that the movie depicts. So we're very
- 6:11happy to have you on the pod to kind of cut up
- 6:13a little bit and talk a little bit about this
- 6:15movie. Thanks, man. Thanks for having me. I'm
- 6:17really excited. Yeah, I'm excited, too. Thank
- 6:19you so much for laying out your credentials,
- 6:21too, because all Ryan said was, yeah, he's a
- 6:24big history guy. And I was like, yeah, that sounds
- 6:26great. I do think I said historian. I said he's
- 6:29a historian. So hearing all the actual qualifications,
- 6:33I'm like, oh, my God. Ryan. There's a reason
- 6:37I asked him to introduce it and not myself. Oh,
- 6:40I'm glad I didn't do it. I would have been like,
- 6:42this is Jordan. He likes history. He likes history.
- 6:45He knows a thing or two. I think he watched the
- 6:47movie. I did, actually. I rewatched it last night
- 6:50and I finished it this morning. Nice. Because
- 6:54I had seen it and I was actually texting Ryan
- 6:57yesterday about it. And we were actually joking
- 7:01because I picked up that same Blu -ray copy,
- 7:05the 100 years, that nice book. The hardback,
- 7:08yeah. And then, you know, the director's name
- 7:11is his last name is Milestone. And whenever I
- 7:14bought it, like the big the big tagline on the
- 7:16back of the Blu -ray that was put on there by
- 7:18the studio to celebrate 100 years of film was
- 7:21a milestone in filmmaking. And it was just it
- 7:26was one of those like perfectly timed like puns.
- 7:28Like the studio probably didn't even know that
- 7:31the. The director's last name was Milestone.
- 7:34But I saw that and I'm like, oh, that's pretty
- 7:36funny. I love that because I want to believe
- 7:38that they did know that. And they're like, hey,
- 7:40what if we said this in 1930? So then either
- 7:43way, we're right. Like, technically, it is a
- 7:46milestone in filmmaking. So you can't be mad
- 7:48at us. It just happened to be true on the back
- 7:50end as well. So, Kyle, let's talk a little bit
- 7:54about the movie specifically. You want to give
- 7:56us a rundown of... The cast and crew. As we said,
- 8:00All Quiet on the Western Front. Jeez, put some
- 8:03respect on its name. Came out in 1930. It was
- 8:06a Universal Pictures film directed by Lewis Milestone.
- 8:11Starring Lewis Woolheim, you mentioned from the
- 8:13Racket episode we covered. Also, Lewis Milestone
- 8:16directed that movie. He did. Yeah. Lou Ayers
- 8:19as Paul, John Ray as Himmelstoss. Those are the...
- 8:24Big names I have listed here. Yes. And then this
- 8:27was nominated for four Academy Awards, including
- 8:30writing for George Abbott, Maxwell Anderson,
- 8:32and Del Andrews, cinematography for Arthur Edison,
- 8:36directing for our boy Lewis Milestone, and then,
- 8:38of course, outstanding production or best picture.
- 8:41So with all quiet on the Western front, you're
- 8:44right that this was the first movie that we've
- 8:46come across that even before signing up for the
- 8:49podcast, I have heard of, right? This was the
- 8:51big one that kind of came out. Why was that at
- 8:55the time? Why do you think this has had the longevity
- 8:57that it has? Definitely because of its subject
- 9:01matter and its context. I think that this is
- 9:04the most well -shot, well -acted movie that we've
- 9:09covered thus far. It's incredible. There are
- 9:13so many reviews I saw on Letterboxd of people
- 9:15that I follow that usually have very, they throw
- 9:19out the one -line comedic review. Of modern movies.
- 9:24And I see many people who are like in their 20s
- 9:27that watch this movie, gave it five stars and
- 9:29are just like, oh, my God, this is incredible.
- 9:31Yeah. There's no, you know, tee hee ha ha with
- 9:35this movie. It's just great. It's so well done.
- 9:37And I think that speaks to the longevity of its
- 9:40legacy, really. Before I go into that, Jordan,
- 9:43how did the movie land for you when you watched
- 9:45it last night and today? Oh, no, it's it's it's.
- 9:49Definitely a heavy film. And I don't know if
- 9:51I'm getting ahead of you guys or not. So if I
- 9:53am, please, you know, rein me back in. But this
- 9:56is based off of a book. It came out like 10,
- 10:0011, 12 years prior. Oh, you got it. Okay, excellent.
- 10:03And, you know, the book comes out, I think, like
- 10:061928, maybe. So maybe roughly a decade after
- 10:11the end of the war. This book, because of the
- 10:15said subject matter that we're going to dive
- 10:17into, eventually gets banned by the Nazi regime
- 10:21as the Nazi regime is coming up in the 1930s
- 10:26in Germany, strictly because it is such an anti
- 10:31-war story. It's allegedly semi -autobiographical.
- 10:36I can't remember the author's name. You have
- 10:38the book in front of you. I actually don't have
- 10:40the book in front of me. Eric Maria Remarque.
- 10:44Remarque, yeah. if I'm not mistaken, did a follow
- 10:48-up book called something like Down the Road
- 10:51or On the Road or something with the road. And
- 10:55I've not read that. This book becomes highly
- 10:59controversial within the next decade that it
- 11:02gets banned. And then when the movie comes out
- 11:05in 1930, the film also gets banned from a lot
- 11:09of places in Europe. And some of these places
- 11:12don't lift the ban until like the 1970s or the
- 11:161980s. which is pretty crazy. It is wild. It's
- 11:19always so fascinating that, obviously, censorship
- 11:23is always for a bigger purpose than just, hey,
- 11:25we don't like that movie. But an anti -war film
- 11:29just ever being banned is so wild. But I guess
- 11:32if your goal is to use war for your own purposes,
- 11:35you want to promote war. Say it with me now.
- 11:39Propaganda. There you go. Well, and that's a
- 11:44perfect segue into the plot of the film. So we're
- 11:47introduced to Paul. Paul is the lead here, but
- 11:51we're introduced to Paul via his classmates as
- 11:53well in a class. And the class is happening.
- 11:57In kind of an unbelievable shot to me. I mean,
- 12:00Kyle, you brought this up earlier. Even watching
- 12:02this with our movie that we'll talk about next
- 12:05week, too. The difference in quality is staggering.
- 12:09It just looks, sounds, and feels like a completely
- 12:13different, not just type of movie, but a different
- 12:15time that it's filmed. And there's an incredible
- 12:18shot. It's not the first shot of the movie, but
- 12:20the first real narrative establishment is when
- 12:23the professor is speaking. And specifically,
- 12:26it's Professor... Kantorik? Kantorik? Yeah. So
- 12:30the professor is speaking, and while he's speaking
- 12:33to his class, we've actually kind of panned out
- 12:35from a window shot of soldiers marching in the
- 12:39street in Germany, and everyone celebrating their,
- 12:42you know, I guess sending them off, so to speak.
- 12:45And in this maybe four to five minute speech
- 12:49that he's given, the crowd never stops. And that
- 12:53shot in the background... it must be at least
- 12:56a thousand extras. Yeah. Like, it's just the
- 12:58scale of this movie, right from the very beginning,
- 13:01is unreal. And not like something we've seen
- 13:04before. You know, we've talked before about how
- 13:06two people will try and share a microphone. I
- 13:09mean, this was filmed in 1930, 1929. So there
- 13:13are very real instances. We talked about in old
- 13:16Arizona, where if you weren't standing right
- 13:18underneath a microphone, you weren't getting
- 13:20picked up. Right. And now we have, like, you
- 13:22know, thousands, well, not thousands, but hundreds
- 13:25easily of extras on set. And, like, we're picking
- 13:28voice up of one person completely fine. Yeah.
- 13:31So the quality really is staggering. The incredible
- 13:33thing about that shot, too, is that you're starting
- 13:35out in the streets and then pulling into the
- 13:37classroom through the window, like you said.
- 13:38Right. And you get this shift in the sound itself
- 13:42of everybody cheering on the streets. That all
- 13:45fades away once you get into the classroom so
- 13:47that you can hear the professor's speech. What
- 13:49an incredible shift in the capabilities of sound
- 13:52from movies we talked about a week or two ago.
- 13:55It's wild how far they've advanced and how much
- 13:59they're showcasing the technology in this film.
- 14:01It is. And I think specifically what impressed
- 14:05me the most about this is, I'm getting slightly
- 14:07ahead of myself, is how the tone of the movie
- 14:10matches the journey for the hero, right? Or I
- 14:15should say not even the hero, but in this case,
- 14:17our case study, which is Paul. So it matches
- 14:20the environment of what Paul is feeling in that
- 14:22moment. And Paul is surrounded by his classmates
- 14:24and friends, and they're a little more eager
- 14:27for the war than he is. And he ultimately accepts
- 14:31because the camaraderie of it, so to speak. And
- 14:35the movie has a joyful tone. It is very, like,
- 14:38kind of upbeat and joyful, and you see, you know,
- 14:40we're introduced to Himmelsdoss, who was the
- 14:42mailman at the time, and he's just very, you
- 14:45know, happy -go -lucky. Hey, you know what? This
- 14:47is actually my last run. I'm about to ship off,
- 14:50head off to war. Yeah. And even his introduction
- 14:53as a general, was a general? He's a sergeant
- 14:56in the reserves. A sergeant, thank you. Yeah.
- 14:58So his sergeant in the reserves role, he takes
- 15:01it a little more seriously. Right? He's kind
- 15:04of no longer the happy -go -lucky postman. He
- 15:07takes it very seriously. And even in him changing
- 15:10that tone, we still follow the boys, and the
- 15:13boys are like, let's get this guy. We can't stand
- 15:15this guy. Let's take care of him. And they do.
- 15:18And it doesn't feel violent. It feels kind of
- 15:21fun and exciting. Very jovial. Very jovial. And
- 15:25that was what caught me off guard the most with
- 15:27this movie was, for a subject matter like it
- 15:30was, you're not anticipating kind of like a joyful
- 15:33tone throughout. And I won't lie to you and tell
- 15:37you that there's a joyful tone throughout the
- 15:38entire runtime of this movie. But the very beginning,
- 15:41like first third, it does. And I thought that
- 15:45was very interesting. Because especially in 1930,
- 15:49I think it kind of had to be, that was the standard,
- 15:51right? We expected that. We didn't quite see
- 15:54that happen. Jordan, do you agree with that?
- 15:56Do you feel like there's a different tone? Yeah,
- 15:58and I think, I mean, you know, it's purposeful
- 16:01too, right? Like, it's the entire point of that
- 16:05opening scene with the professor is he's giving
- 16:09this very impassioned speech about what it is
- 16:12to love your country. Like, he's the hype man
- 16:15for Germany. And, you know, which I'm sure we'll
- 16:18talk about whenever we get to some of the closing
- 16:20scenes of the film. So I won't mention it now,
- 16:23but he's the one that's building them up, right?
- 16:26And this really does tie into a lot of how they
- 16:32really did get a lot of young soldiers to join
- 16:34the war, which very quickly becomes a war of
- 16:38nationalism. A lot of people go to war and join
- 16:42the armies because, well, why join the German
- 16:45army? Well, because we're German and we love
- 16:47Germany. Not really knowing. the causes of the
- 16:51war which again is a scene that happens later
- 16:54on down the line which i'm sure we'll talk about
- 16:56and i can definitely get into some detail on
- 16:58that um when we get there um but i think that
- 17:01that's you know that i think that that's purposeful
- 17:04to not only hype up the the students to go and
- 17:07join the war but you're also hyping up the audience
- 17:10of like hey no these these guys are going to
- 17:12do it like these guys are going to go they're
- 17:14going to be great great soldiers uh spoiler alert
- 17:17germany does lose the war i don't know if you
- 17:20guys knew that uh fun fact last night when jordan
- 17:22was telling me he was watching the movie i said
- 17:24i'll try not to spoil it for you yeah uh and
- 17:28what did you say jordan i hope the allies win
- 17:30Yeah, I said, I hope the allies win. And then
- 17:32you went, uh. I said a gif of a guy being like,
- 17:35oh, no. Uh -oh. So, but yeah, because that's
- 17:40as quickly as you're hyped up, and as we'll see,
- 17:44that hype and joy quickly goes away because these
- 17:48kids, literal kids, teenagers, get to see firsthand
- 17:54what warfare is like, modern warfare is like.
- 17:59And the reason I bring up Himmelsdorf in that
- 18:01tone is that his departure afterwards when the
- 18:04kids, I won't say mercilessly beat him, but you
- 18:08do leave him in a puddle of mud, he's replaced
- 18:11by the previously mentioned Louis Wilhelm, who
- 18:15is Cat. Yeah. And Cat, as a sergeant, prepares
- 18:20them more for this idea of war, not in a iron
- 18:24fist rule or iron thumb, but more so just...
- 18:28preparing them of, like, do you know what's to
- 18:30come? Like, are you ready for what's to come?
- 18:33And that's really where I think the tone starts
- 18:36settling in, where there is a camaraderie, and
- 18:39they are very much still brothers, but Cat prepares
- 18:42them a little bit more. I gotta tell you right
- 18:44now, all cards on the table, I think that I have
- 18:48a substantial crush on Lewis Woolheim. I don't
- 18:52know what it is. He's so good as Nick Scarcy
- 18:55in The Racket. And then as Cat here, I mean,
- 18:59I know this is the whole point of the movie,
- 19:00I'd follow that man anywhere. Yes. What on earth?
- 19:04He is just the most dynamic actor and character
- 19:08that I think we've seen in the past three years
- 19:11that we've been covering so far, Kyle. I mean,
- 19:12what do you think? Absolutely. I think it helps
- 19:16that he's such a likable character in this movie.
- 19:19One of my favorite moments is when one of the
- 19:22first bombs drop with the new, not new recruits,
- 19:26but you know, the kids and one of them drops
- 19:28to his knees and is grabbing Kat's jacket and
- 19:31just pressing his face into his legs for cover.
- 19:35Kat's character could, could be like Himmelsdorf
- 19:37and be like, get up. What are you doing? Himmelsdorf
- 19:39probably would have ran. Yeah. But Kat picks
- 19:42him up and he's like, they're there. son or whatever
- 19:45like it's okay you'll you'll do better the next
- 19:48one or like you'll be ready for the next one
- 19:49and everything you say go ahead i'm sorry i didn't
- 19:52mean didn't he say something like it's happened
- 19:53to better men than you yes it's happened to me
- 19:56yeah yes and i has anyone else did anyone else
- 20:00read this book ever at any point i haven't i've
- 20:02not read the book you've not read it i i didn't
- 20:04finish it but i wanted to read it um mostly to
- 20:08get a sense of like this was nominated for writing
- 20:11let me see how it was adapted Kind of thing.
- 20:13And so reading the book, that specific moment
- 20:16in the book occurs. And it's because that soldier
- 20:19ends up soiling himself out of fear. And Kat
- 20:23sees that and he's like, it's okay. So that's
- 20:26kind of implied in the movie. And it just showcases
- 20:29the level of just compassion Kat has for these
- 20:34young soldiers. And he's such a great character.
- 20:36And Wolheim portrays him incredibly. that scene
- 20:41they even say something about getting like new
- 20:44changes of underwear too so it's i i i would
- 20:47probably even say that it's a little bit more
- 20:49than implied oh yeah for sure then yeah well
- 20:51there's also a level of informed there right
- 20:54like he doesn't just like kind of console them
- 20:56and like help them prepare but he also tells
- 20:58them like you know you really got to listen for
- 21:00the whistle like the whistle specifically dictates
- 21:02what kind of like bomb is being dropped then
- 21:04he mentions like you know specifically the high
- 21:06-pitched one is the one you really have to look
- 21:07out for so and you know there's a bit of foreshadowing
- 21:10there but specifically that to me showed like
- 21:14you said he's he's tough but he cares about these
- 21:17kids and he wants to help them by like not just
- 21:20getting them to fight in this war but to survive
- 21:23it as best they can We could talk through what
- 21:25happens in this, and I think that it's more there's
- 21:27set pieces. We don't have to reestablish this
- 21:31too much for the audience. I mean, this very
- 21:32much is World War I, right? The events that we're
- 21:35seeing. But I have a question for Kyle. Kyle,
- 21:39you said you've read the book, not in totality,
- 21:41but you have read a good bit of it. Is it from
- 21:44Paul's perspective? Yes. Yeah, it is. And one
- 21:48thing that I think is interesting, and this is
- 21:50telling of the tone at the beginning of the movie,
- 21:53I'm sorry, did you want to go somewhere? No,
- 21:56no, I was just wondering. Yeah, it is from Paul's.
- 21:58At the beginning of the book, it kind of goes
- 22:00directly into the war. And there is no setting
- 22:03up the, okay, we're recruiting the kids and everybody's
- 22:06happy and it has that positive tone. Even the
- 22:09scene where they attack Himmelsdorf for being
- 22:11just awful. All of that takes place. during the
- 22:14heart of the war itself. So it is all very bleak
- 22:18and very dark, and there's not a whole lot of
- 22:20joy in the book. And I think that that speaks
- 22:23to what movies were supposed to be or expected
- 22:26to be during the time. You had to have that kind
- 22:29of false lead into what the movie actually was
- 22:33going to be just to bring in audiences. I don't
- 22:36know how this was marketed in 1930. If it was
- 22:39when it first came out, if it was like the war
- 22:41spectacle to to end all war spectacles, blah,
- 22:44blah, blah. Or if it was very much promoted as
- 22:47a anti -war piece. Do you have any knowledge
- 22:50of that at all, Jordan? No, I don't know exactly
- 22:54how it was marketed. But, you know, the film
- 22:59being 12 years removed from from Armistice. There
- 23:03was there was a lot of thoughts that people people's
- 23:07idea or just like thoughts on the world. Well,
- 23:10at that point, it was just the Great War because
- 23:12it wasn't called World War One until World War
- 23:14Two happened. A lot of people's thoughts on the
- 23:18war or people thought that other people's thoughts
- 23:21were waning on the war and they didn't know how
- 23:23well this film was going to do at the time. You're
- 23:26also less than a year removed from. Black Friday
- 23:31and the beginning of the Great Depression and
- 23:34the stock market crashing, too. So I think there
- 23:38were a lot of things up in the air. But also,
- 23:40there are still a lot of World War I veterans
- 23:43that are looking at this. And I know a lot of
- 23:48World War I veterans were on set with the director
- 23:51to help with stage direction for this. Some of
- 23:56those, whenever I was re -watching it, because
- 23:58I'd watch this. Years and years and years and
- 24:00years ago. And a quick refresher, some of those
- 24:04battle scenes, like when they first enter No
- 24:07Man's Land and they're starting the ground infantry
- 24:10to go towards the other trenches in the front
- 24:13lines, there were a lot of scenes that would
- 24:17change very quickly. And I'm like, there's no
- 24:19way that that was an acting scene. That had to
- 24:20have been like archived footage from World War
- 24:23I. Sure. No, everything was shot for the movie.
- 24:27No archive footage whatsoever was spliced into
- 24:31this. Incredible. Which I thought was pretty
- 24:33amazing. Yeah. You know, like you said, you were
- 24:35talking about set pieces here. Yeah, unless like
- 24:38it was an outdoor shot that they needed to be
- 24:41specifically outdoor. A lot of these were internal
- 24:43studio shots. That's wild to think about. It's
- 24:47unbelievable. I mean, you know, the prep that
- 24:48we've done for these movies and these seasons
- 24:51that we've covered. we don't have very loud films
- 24:54right like it's just been most i mean for the
- 24:57first year it's just uh music essentially right
- 25:00so this was the first one then you know it's
- 25:03anticipated with the the subject matter of the
- 25:05movie but especially this is the first one i
- 25:08watched on blu -ray right everything else we've
- 25:10watched on youtube and 2b as it's accessible
- 25:11but this is the first one that i was blessed
- 25:14enough to have a physical copy of and watch it
- 25:16on blu -ray and uh It was just jarring how, I
- 25:20think there's almost like a 10, 15 minute sequence
- 25:22in this movie that bombs are going off in the
- 25:24background. And it's just a very loud film. And
- 25:28I don't really have anything too amazing to say
- 25:30about that, but it was just such a jarring difference
- 25:33from what we've experienced so far. And I don't
- 25:36think that that, look at that, I do have something
- 25:38to say about that. I don't think that that's...
- 25:40that coincidental just because specifically i
- 25:42don't know if it's the first and jordan maybe
- 25:43you can speak to this but it is recognized as
- 25:46the first significant anti -war film that was
- 25:48made yeah yeah you're absolutely right and it's
- 25:51still regarded as one of the top war films ever
- 25:54made just in general um i mean it's been remade
- 25:57twice so it's got to be doing something right
- 26:00you know most recently Just real quick, since
- 26:04we're talking about Oscars, most recently remade
- 26:07by Edward Berger, who went on to do Conclave,
- 26:09which was recognized last year in the Oscars.
- 26:11Sorry, Jordan, go ahead. Oh, no, it was 2022,
- 26:14I think? It was. Yeah, yeah, yeah. I haven't
- 26:17seen any, because there was one that was made
- 26:19in the 70s that I haven't, I haven't seen any
- 26:21of the remakes. But I do think it's interesting
- 26:23that this one was made by an American director
- 26:26about German. you know this this narrative is
- 26:31all of these german soldiers who are on the you
- 26:33know go go to the western front obviously it's
- 26:36in the title um the next one i believe was a
- 26:39british director and then the third one is a
- 26:43german director it's finally if i'm not mistaken
- 26:46so it's it's interesting that in in 1930 that
- 26:50this this book is being adapted by an american
- 26:53director about somebody that the Americans were
- 26:57fighting against not but a decade earlier. And
- 27:00I think that, one, that goes to how strong the
- 27:04anti -war narrative is. You know, this is very
- 27:08much a cautionary tale. And it still is. I mean,
- 27:12kids sign up to go to, you know, enlist in the
- 27:14Army all the time. Not probably not knowing what
- 27:17they're getting themselves into. Definitely not
- 27:20then because they didn't have an iPhone to pull
- 27:22out of their pocket and be like, what's war like
- 27:24Google? Yeah. Right. So it's you see that when
- 27:27they get to that front, like we've been discussing
- 27:29when they actually see those bombs drop in the
- 27:32artillery fire and they're like, oh, this is
- 27:34nothing like we were told. It's a completely
- 27:37different experience than what we've seen in
- 27:39Oscar contenders previously. I mean, two years
- 27:41ago, Wings. was out and wings had a very you
- 27:45know like the first third of this movie a very
- 27:47jovial sense yeah there's the war comedy elements
- 27:51to it right even uh like physical comedy yeah
- 27:54kind of making light of that scenario and you
- 27:57know it's not making fun of it but it is more
- 27:59so kind of embracing like hey this is just where
- 28:01we are and this is the setting yeah we talked
- 28:02about how war was less the plot and more the
- 28:05setting in that moment so this had to have been
- 28:08extremely jarring difference because with its
- 28:11anti -war stance and where you know the next
- 28:14two -thirds of the movie go it really is even
- 28:18now in 2025 watching like the final scene of
- 28:20this movie it is just absolutely breathtaking
- 28:23what they were able to do because this just wasn't
- 28:26what movies were at the time right and so uh
- 28:30jordan in terms of reception um do you have any
- 28:34stories or knowledge of how this movie was received
- 28:37at the time whether it was you know hey what
- 28:39is this or wow this is incredible um not like
- 28:43like film reviews or or you know just personal
- 28:46opinions i mean it obviously did something right
- 28:49because didn't it win like x amount of awards
- 28:51look at you jordan that way we're here talking
- 28:53about it it's true it did it's clearly resonated
- 28:57with somebody somewhere or a group of people
- 29:00somewhere because in the year 2025 Almost 100
- 29:04years later, we're talking about this film and
- 29:08the impact that it had. Well, the reception is,
- 29:11you're correct. Obviously, it was a big part
- 29:14of the Academy Awards, hence why we're discussing
- 29:17it here. I'm interested in the reception of the
- 29:20audience overall, but not a big surprise. It
- 29:23wasn't received super well all over, right? Germany
- 29:27was not the most receptive to this. The reason
- 29:31I wanted to bring this up was that there's something
- 29:32that I thought was kind of interesting in Alcoyne
- 29:36on the Western Front. About halfway through the
- 29:38movie, Cat and his platoon find themselves marooned
- 29:43in a room because of all the warfare going on.
- 29:46And they're trapped from some gunfire. And they
- 29:49are in this room for, I think they mentioned
- 29:51it could be a week. And at one point, rats are
- 29:54released into the room. And they try to like...
- 29:58kill them as they can so they're not like trapped
- 30:00in there with them. I had read that actually
- 30:03when this movie came out that Hitler and his
- 30:05team and other soldiers actually went to theaters
- 30:09and they would throw stink bombs, but they'd
- 30:13also release white mice into the theater to evacuate
- 30:16people from there. And I thought that was an
- 30:19interesting, I mean, obviously there's a reason,
- 30:21but I thought that was an interesting dynamic
- 30:23of how that was happening in real time. And it's
- 30:27depicted on screen. So it's not even, hey, this
- 30:29isn't correct. Well, that is correct, and we
- 30:31just don't want you to see it. Wow. And I thought
- 30:33that was really, really remarkable, reading that
- 30:36on the back end after watching this. But Jordan,
- 30:38you were nodding throughout all that. So was
- 30:40this a calming tactic, or was this like a one
- 30:42-off for them? No. Again, this movie gets banned
- 30:46in Germany. The Nazi regime officially bans not
- 30:50only the book, but the film. Whenever it did
- 30:55get released in Germany, you know, Adolf Hitler
- 30:59is in his rise to power and he's taking all of
- 31:02these animosities from the end of World War I
- 31:06and he's turning it into his Nazi propaganda
- 31:08machine. And this movie is very, is essentially
- 31:14like doing the opposite of what he's trying to
- 31:16do, right? He's, when Adolf Hitler comes to power.
- 31:20He's really trying to be very charismatic and,
- 31:23you know, hype up the masses to, you know, buy
- 31:26into the German ideology again. This is now the
- 31:29new German ideology. All of this stuff happened
- 31:31because of A, B, and C. But then this film comes
- 31:35along, or excuse me, all these things happen
- 31:37from A, B, and C. So join the Nazi army, Nazi
- 31:40party in the Nazi army, and we can, you know,
- 31:43make Germany what it was. Again, if you want
- 31:47to go with a very current tagline that you might
- 31:50see in American politics. But anyway, this film
- 31:53comes along and it shows the dangers of all of
- 31:57that, right? It shows that a character who bought
- 32:01into the hype actually goes on these front lines
- 32:04and it literally changes him mentally. And the
- 32:09entire film is just the precaution of that or
- 32:12a cautionary tale of that. This is very counterproductive
- 32:16to what was Hitler was wanting to happen in the
- 32:18early 1930s in Germany and in Austria. But that's
- 32:21why over there it gets they they drop the kibosh.
- 32:25They sabotage a lot of these viewings until they
- 32:27actually get a chance to ban these films for
- 32:30this film rather. Man. And, you know, with this
- 32:32being an anti -war film, it's it's wild to see
- 32:35how it does not pull any of its punches. This
- 32:39is a very violent film in a way that we certainly
- 32:42have not seen. thus far, you're seeing gore.
- 32:46You're seeing people lose limbs on screen. There's
- 32:50that iconic shot where there's a soldier running
- 32:53across a no man's land and he goes down and his
- 32:56hands grab. towards whatever he can find and
- 32:59it happens to be barbed wire and he gets hit
- 33:02with a bomb at the same time and all that is
- 33:04left are his hands clinging to the wire. Yes!
- 33:07That was a crazy scene. Is it not wild? That
- 33:10was insane. Almost a hundred years old and you're
- 33:12seeing that type of graphic violence on screen.
- 33:16It's so shocking and just really effective in
- 33:20a way that I almost feel I don't know about you
- 33:22guys but I get numb sometimes when I watch action
- 33:25movies, and you're watching John Wick, and people
- 33:28are getting blasted left and right, and you're
- 33:30like, yeah, whatever, cool. But in this almost
- 33:32100 -year film, when I saw that, because of when
- 33:35it came out and the implications of the message
- 33:38it's pushing and just what they're able to show
- 33:40in this time period, I was really taken aback
- 33:44by it. No, absolutely. I mean, there's a couple
- 33:46moments in this, and one of the last things we'll
- 33:48talk about will be the other moment. There's
- 33:50a couple moments in this where it just kind of
- 33:52leaves you breathless, because you didn't see
- 33:54this, right? Let alone now, back then. Like,
- 33:58in the 1930s, this wasn't a thing. We talked
- 34:00last week, we talked about the love parade. And
- 34:03we talked about how, you know, it's essentially
- 34:05a sex comedy. And all this was possible from
- 34:08pre -code. So a question that I have for both
- 34:11of you, but Kyle, for you to start, is we talk
- 34:14about pre -code. Do you think that Alquine on
- 34:16the Western Front and that graphic violence that
- 34:18it depicts was leading the path for what would
- 34:21eventually be the code that's introduced to Hollywood?
- 34:23Yeah, I imagine that this isn't the main thing
- 34:27the Hays Code was eventually trying to tone down.
- 34:31Sure. It was a lot of the things that made Hollywood
- 34:34itself look... just like this evil, vicious entity
- 34:39of corruption and things. But I do think that
- 34:42the violence in this, and even just the anti
- 34:44-war aspect of it, especially as we move into
- 34:47the Code era and then World War II requiring
- 34:51so much American war propaganda as well, this
- 34:54movie wouldn't fly. I'd be curious to know what
- 34:57that was like during the 40s as far as speaking
- 35:01about this film at that point, because everything
- 35:03was pushing, you know, sign up. Uncle Sam needs
- 35:07you and all of that. This movie must have done
- 35:09terribly during its re -release in the 40s, you
- 35:13know, which didn't happen, of course. But, Jordan,
- 35:17as far as the code and everything, do you have
- 35:21historical knowledge of the Hollywood code at
- 35:25all? Not really. You know, I know of the code,
- 35:30but I'm sure, like you said, it was more... More
- 35:33than just something like this. Like, I'm sure
- 35:36that there were a lot of other factors that just
- 35:38went into censorship. And then the ideas of,
- 35:42you know, what is morally good at the time, right?
- 35:48Sex bad. Yeah, yeah, pretty much, right. But
- 35:51beyond how graphic it is, you mentioned earlier
- 35:54there's the great scene where everybody's talking
- 35:58about the cause of the war. And why are we even
- 36:01out here? Do you want to talk a little bit about
- 36:04that scene? Right. So remember, they're on a
- 36:08break and they go to get food. And remember,
- 36:11like half their battalion has been killed. So
- 36:14that chef is like, you're not eating until everybody
- 36:18gets here. It's like, buddy, this is everybody.
- 36:20It's like, how many of you? We were 150. Now
- 36:23we're 80. So like they, you know, they got double
- 36:25portions. And, you know, of course, like the
- 36:27what's his what's his face? Starts with the H.
- 36:31Was that him? Himmelsdoss. Yeah, that was Himmelsdoss,
- 36:34right? Correct. Where he said, like, you know,
- 36:36feed them double portions. The men could use
- 36:38it. Oh, I think that was a different character,
- 36:42just to be clear. I think his name was Marquis.
- 36:45Okay. Something like that. It was the mustache
- 36:48that threw me off, because I don't know if you've
- 36:50noticed, World War I was fantastic for mustaches.
- 36:54Yeah. Everywhere. Everybody in every army. Fantastic
- 36:58mustache. But they're sitting by that tree eating
- 37:02and they're like, oh, I've never seen a Frenchman
- 37:05before. Like, why are we here? Well, they didn't.
- 37:07They were attacking us. And so, like, nobody
- 37:09knows why everybody is in this war. They just
- 37:13know that they're fighting for their country.
- 37:15Right. That's why it's kind of looked at as like
- 37:17a war of nationalism. And the actual what people
- 37:21now, you know, historians now label the quote
- 37:23unquote official cause of the war is still up
- 37:27for debate. 100 years later um so i'm gonna i'm
- 37:30gonna do this as much as i can with like cliff
- 37:32notes for for a cliff notes version of this so
- 37:35um austria -hungary is isn't you know a joint
- 37:39empire and it has um basically has political
- 37:43power over balkans sarajevo um i believe it's
- 37:47sarajevo and there's this uh terrorist group
- 37:50on the black hand that doesn't like the austria
- 37:53-hungarian empire and their leader franz joseph
- 37:56um franz joseph has a nephew uh named franz ferdinand
- 38:01who uh had a fantastic indie band in the 2000s
- 38:06what is a big fan right yes um uh but no uh he
- 38:10has this nephew named franz ferdinand and franz
- 38:14ferdinand is he's the heir apparent to the austria
- 38:17hungarian empire and he's for lack of a better
- 38:20phrase he's much less conservative than his than
- 38:24his uncle. And I feel like everybody realizes
- 38:28that once Franz Ferdinand takes the throne, he's
- 38:32going to loosen up on a lot of countries to give
- 38:36them their own autonomy back. And this was 100
- 38:40% what was going on in the Balkans. And at one
- 38:45point, Franz Ferdinand and His wife, Chloe, I
- 38:51believe her name is. They were going to make
- 38:54an appearance in Sarajevo. And they were going
- 38:57to go into this motorcade. They were going to
- 38:59have the top down. And it was more like, to them,
- 39:03it was like trying to be a gesture of goodwill
- 39:07towards a lot of people in the Balkans. And Black
- 39:11Hand finds out about this. And so they plan an
- 39:14assassination attempt on Franz Ferdinand. And
- 39:19so there's a bunch of as the motorcades coming
- 39:23through. Also, like, as Ferdinand was warned
- 39:25multiple times, this isn't a good idea. There's
- 39:27like there's a national day going on right now.
- 39:30You know, you don't you don't want this to happen.
- 39:34And he's like, nah, nonsense. It'll be fine.
- 39:37So he didn't listen. And a lot of these members
- 39:40of the Black Hand disguised themselves as just
- 39:43civilians. And as the motorcade comes through,
- 39:46somebody throws a bomb and it misses and it explodes
- 39:50by them, but it doesn't kill them. They take
- 39:53cover into a nearby building after everything
- 39:56settles down. For whatever reason, they made
- 39:58the decision to continue the motorcade the way
- 40:00it was going. And as the motorcade was going
- 40:03down the road, it takes a wrong turn into a dead
- 40:06end alley. Well, it just so happened that. A
- 40:09member of the Black Hand by the name of Gavrilo
- 40:11Princep was standing in line to get a sandwich.
- 40:16And he turns around and sees Franz Ferdinand's
- 40:20motor coach backing out of the alleyway that
- 40:23it took a wrong turn in. So what does he do?
- 40:25He drops his sandwich and he picks out his gun
- 40:28and he assassinates Franz Ferdinand and Chloe.
- 40:32This happens, I think it's June, I believe June
- 40:3528th, 1914. For an entire month. Nothing happens.
- 40:39For the entire month of July, all of these monarchs
- 40:43of all of these kingdoms are on vacation. Kaiser
- 40:46Wilhelm is actually on like a Norwegian cruise
- 40:48at this point. And for an entire month, there's
- 40:52this whole back and forth of, will there be war?
- 40:55Is there not going to be war? Will there be war?
- 40:57I don't know. Until Kaiser Wilhelm kind of starts
- 41:00to elbow Franz Josef and was like, hey, you should
- 41:03really go to war with these guys. And if you
- 41:05go to war. will help you. But there's like, and
- 41:09I actually have, I pulled this book right here.
- 41:11It's called Dance of the Furies. This author
- 41:14actually goes through a lot of newspapers in
- 41:18July 1914. And all these newspapers of civilians
- 41:21are just like, yeah, nothing's going to come
- 41:22of this. Like, no one's going to go to war. Like,
- 41:24no, nothing will happen. And eventually they
- 41:27do go to war. But largely the minds of people
- 41:31in Europe at that time were like, no, war will
- 41:33not happen. Nothing is going to happen. until
- 41:36Wellhelm started to nudge the Austria -Hungarian,
- 41:39the Austria -Hungarian army, or Austria -Hungary
- 41:43rather. And, you know, and then an ultimatum
- 41:45was given, but this ultimatum that was given
- 41:47by Franz Josef, they couldn't, you know, the
- 41:50opposition couldn't, they couldn't make it happen.
- 41:53Like it was, they went in knowing it wasn't going
- 41:55to happen and therefore war was going to happen.
- 41:58And then it did. And then that's when all the
- 42:00dominoes fell. So, you know, Austria -Hungary,
- 42:04invaded the balkans then russia went to asia
- 42:08hungary then germany to russia and then france
- 42:11to germany so it was it was crazy how all the
- 42:14dominoes fell very quickly when for about four
- 42:17and a half weeks everyone was like war is war
- 42:20is more than likely not going to happen yeah
- 42:22would you say that this is this is such a broad
- 42:26question but is this like the first time in history
- 42:31that A country is just like, hey, guys, we need
- 42:35you to fight this war. Don't worry about what
- 42:38it's about. If you go back to medieval Europe,
- 42:42all of these knights and all of these soldiers
- 42:45that are fighting in king's armies, they're fighting
- 42:48for their king. And what is it, for king and
- 42:50country, is what a lot of these people would
- 42:53say. So I don't think it's... I don't think it's
- 42:56an uncommon mindset, but I do think that this
- 43:00is kind of the last of that late Victorian idea
- 43:04of the European. Because even Franz Joseph, before
- 43:09Franz Ferdinand died, he had gone on record,
- 43:13and I'm paraphrasing, so forgive me if I don't
- 43:16get it 100 % correct. He tells another... I believe
- 43:20like an American politician or maybe the American
- 43:22president, I can't remember. He tells another
- 43:24world leader, you see in me the last of the original
- 43:29European monarchs. Meaning that once he's gone,
- 43:32the idea of the monarchy and the idea of whatever
- 43:36political power these monarchs held is going
- 43:39to vastly change just because the world is changing.
- 43:43So I do think that that mindset is still very...
- 43:47present in like the soldiers fighting the war
- 43:49and and therefore present in the characters whenever
- 43:52they're you know they're uh talking about this
- 43:54um but this also goes to show that even a lot
- 43:58of the the soldiers like the infantry the boots
- 44:01on the ground don't really know why they're fighting
- 44:04outside of oh well well we're german and germany
- 44:08needs us to protect germany so let's go protect
- 44:10germany so it becomes a very very nationalistic
- 44:13uh mindset Well, I think that scene that we were
- 44:16just talking about, there is the moment where
- 44:18you start to see the soldiers kind of be like,
- 44:20listen, I don't really care why it started. I
- 44:24don't like that we're here. So maybe it was our
- 44:28fault, I think one of them says. And there's
- 44:30the one guy who's like, hey, keep my Fuhrer's
- 44:32name out of your mouth kind of thing. Yeah. And
- 44:35I think that's a good example of just the nationalism
- 44:39kind of taking hold of at least some of these
- 44:42soldiers. at some point during their time in
- 44:45the service. I mean, absolutely. Like, you know,
- 44:48a significant part of the movie is Paul's kind
- 44:52of disbelief at how much that nationalism can
- 44:54go. I mean, we're skipping forward here a little
- 44:57bit, but he's injured and he's watching his friends
- 45:01die and he's able to go back home and visit his
- 45:03family. And his immediate reaction is that he's
- 45:07shocked that everyone is in still support of
- 45:10the war. And in support of him being a soldier
- 45:14in that nationalism that you mentioned, to a
- 45:16point where he even goes back to the professor
- 45:17into that same room where he was recruited. And
- 45:20almost like a time travel scene, he's watching
- 45:23the same thing happen with a new group of younger
- 45:25recruits. And it's that realization for him of
- 45:30that exact nationalism you're talking about,
- 45:32where it's like, well, it doesn't really matter,
- 45:34the point of this. It's that I'm standing up
- 45:36for my country, and that's the highest honor
- 45:38I can have. It's that sympathy that we get from
- 45:42Paul, or for Paul, rather, that really kind of
- 45:45solidifies the anti -war tone of this, of Paul
- 45:48realizing what he's currently involved in. I
- 45:52mean, that was, for me, that was kind of the
- 45:55first gut punch of the movie. I mean, he's watching
- 45:57friends die, but it was that realization of the
- 46:00nonstop, right? Like, this is going to continue
- 46:03forever. Yeah. Of how this is just the same thing
- 46:06over time with new people. And I think that's
- 46:10what's so cool is you have the violent aspect
- 46:13of war and seeing all of these horrible atrocities
- 46:17occur, and that serves as very anti -war in itself.
- 46:21But I think that a lot of time that violence
- 46:24and all of that can still be kind of perceived
- 46:28by its audience as like, oh, well, those are
- 46:31heroics. Like, yes, that's terrifying, but boy,
- 46:34to be a hero in that war and come out on the
- 46:37other side as someone that fought for my country,
- 46:39there's that. This movie, in a way that a lot
- 46:42of other very powerful war films don't do, has
- 46:47those scenes where the soldiers are talking,
- 46:50you know, what are we doing here? Whose fault
- 46:52is this? Why are we doing this? I've never seen
- 46:54a Frenchman. Or Paul being in the classroom and
- 46:57being just shocked that I can't promote this.
- 47:01For these kids here? That's awful. And later,
- 47:04when he's out having a drink with all of the
- 47:07old wealthy figures in his town or whatever,
- 47:10and they have their battle strategy laid out
- 47:13and they're arguing, and he's just like, you
- 47:15guys don't know what it's like out there. He's
- 47:17like, no, you don't know what it's like. I mean,
- 47:20you know the details of it, but that's not important.
- 47:23And to immediately get pushed aside as just,
- 47:27oh, well, you're a soldier, but, you know. Let
- 47:30let the big boys talk. Right. You know, it's
- 47:32it's it's glad you brought this this entire like
- 47:36scene up because that you now see the detachment
- 47:40that Paul has from civilian life. Right. He has
- 47:43been he has been rocked by the war. He's been
- 47:47in it for years at this point. Right. And like
- 47:50you said, he's. He's seen all of his comrades
- 47:52and his friends die one by one. Even mentors
- 47:55die one by one. People that he fought with and
- 47:59some of them he even grew up with and went to
- 48:02school with. And specifically that scene, the
- 48:06two scenes you're talking about of how he is
- 48:09walking by the school and the professor sees
- 48:11him. He's like, oh. Tell him what it's all about.
- 48:14He's automatically going to be on the professor's
- 48:17side. And the professor is somebody who wasn't
- 48:21boots on the ground. He wasn't in the trenches,
- 48:23which trench warfare is insane, man. I'm going
- 48:28to go on a slight tangent on trench warfare,
- 48:30but a scene after this, you see one of the soldiers
- 48:33in a trench that's flooded, and he's trying to
- 48:36dig out the water from the trench with a shovel.
- 48:41Because if they don't do that, there's a lot
- 48:43of stuff that's going to happen, man. Like, standing
- 48:45water attracts bugs. Bugs attract rats, and rats
- 48:49have diseases. And on top of that, if you stand,
- 48:53like, trench foot is not fun. Like, if you stand
- 48:57in water for so long, it is going to, and you
- 49:00try to take off a boot or a sock, your skin's
- 49:03coming with it. Like, it's not fun. Awful. But,
- 49:09you know, back to the classroom scene, it's this
- 49:14disconnect from the people who are promoting
- 49:17it and saying, no, this is a great thing to do.
- 49:20And the people who were actually there going,
- 49:23this is horrifying. We live in a constant bombardment
- 49:27of artillery. We have to learn how to sleep with
- 49:30all of the explosions going on. We maybe get
- 49:34a little bit of sleep. We hardly have any food.
- 49:37And we're fighting for this country. Like, what
- 49:39for, right? And I think Paul even says something
- 49:41along the lines of, it's better to be alive than
- 49:44to die from one's country or something along,
- 49:47you know, something like that. Because he realizes
- 49:50on these, like, this is meaningless. Because
- 49:54we, the soldiers didn't do anything. The soldiers
- 49:57are just following orders. It's all of these
- 49:59higher up politicians and like the king's men
- 50:01who are egging this war on. And that's what you
- 50:04kind of like see in that. scene in the pub where
- 50:08it's like all of these what looks to be rich
- 50:10white men in suits who have never seen that hardship
- 50:15on the front line and paul's like oh man this
- 50:19you it's easy to talk about it but when you are
- 50:22literally boots on the ground it is a completely
- 50:24different story um and then of course all these
- 50:28old white men are like nah you're just a kid
- 50:31you don't you know like I've literally lived
- 50:33through this war. It's weird how he's like being
- 50:35gaslit into, it's not that bad. He's like, I
- 50:39literally had friends die. Yeah. I don't know
- 50:42what to tell you. Well, it shows the disconnect
- 50:44too. And in the people who are causing these
- 50:49wars and sending people out and their disconnect,
- 50:53right? This isn't a system that they know is
- 50:56flawed and they're feeding it. They believe in
- 50:58it. And that belief. Then bleeds into what is
- 51:02nationalism for, you know, the teachers and the
- 51:05students. And it's this disillusionment. It's
- 51:09how you keep feeding the war machine. Exactly.
- 51:11Like, those people think that they're doing the
- 51:14right thing. Or they know that they're not doing
- 51:19the right thing and they still do it anyway,
- 51:21which is even worse. Right? It's one thing to
- 51:24be completely, what's the word I'm looking for?
- 51:27Ambivalence, not the word. Complicent? Complicit
- 51:30or just like just not knowing, like you think
- 51:32you're doing the right thing, but you're really
- 51:34not. And or they know what they're doing. And
- 51:39it's like, well, if these kids don't go to war,
- 51:41I'm going to have to go to war and I don't want
- 51:42to go to war. So I'm going to send these kids
- 51:43to war. Oh, oblivious. Oblivious. Yeah. Thank
- 51:46you. So I don't know. Like, I have a degree.
- 51:50I don't know why I couldn't. But it's it's kind
- 51:56of shows like the. moral disconnection but also
- 51:58like the class disconnection too right like paul
- 52:02even says he leaves his leave early because he's
- 52:05like i can't stand this like it's too quiet like
- 52:07whenever he's having that heart -to -heart with
- 52:09cat and he's like you're all i got left man like
- 52:12i can't live life anymore like this is all i
- 52:16know like that's how rough not just any war but
- 52:19this war specifically affected paul um and and
- 52:23unfortunately in that same scene he loses cat
- 52:26Right. Like the artillery starts to come down
- 52:30and he breaks his shin by the time he gets back
- 52:32to camp. That's dead. So like Paul literally
- 52:35has he literally just said, you're all I have
- 52:38left. So after that, there's no wonder why he
- 52:41spiraled into depression, because everybody that
- 52:43he came up with in the war is gone. And he sees
- 52:47he, you know, walks into the building and he
- 52:50sees all of these new recruits at the end of
- 52:51the film. And they're even younger than he and
- 52:54his crew. And he talks to that one soldier. He's
- 52:57like, how old are you? He's like, I'm 16. 16?
- 52:59I didn't even have my license at 16. Yeah. Can
- 53:02you imagine giving a child a rifle and a bayonet
- 53:08and said, go kill some allies? That's nuts. You
- 53:11know, in October, I work at a haunted house,
- 53:15and a lot of our actors are high school students.
- 53:17And I've gotten very close with some of these
- 53:20kids, and I'm always just like. Oh, I'm so proud
- 53:23of these kids. Watching this movie the other
- 53:26day and, like, putting that alongside that context
- 53:29and imagining any of them having to go off to
- 53:32war, I got very emotional in that scene where
- 53:35the kids are like, well, I'm 16. Like, I think
- 53:38people forget, like, what war means. And, you
- 53:42know, it's less prevalent, I'm sure, today, but,
- 53:44like, there are still recruiters going to high
- 53:47school. Oh, yeah. High schools. It's crazy. They
- 53:51are children. Yes, yes, they are children. And,
- 53:54you know, we can get into discussions about like
- 53:56how they're preying on on high school children
- 53:58and said, you know, that's a whole different
- 53:59podcast episode. But it's still yeah, it still
- 54:02does happen today. Just a side note, whenever
- 54:05we're done recording, I do want to talk to you
- 54:07about working at a haunted house, though. But
- 54:11yeah, it's, you know, in. Are you guys cool if
- 54:15I kind of go to the ending scene of the film?
- 54:18Yeah, right before you do, I do want to point
- 54:20out the scene that I liked. I don't know if I
- 54:23say I like it, but you mentioned how Cat had
- 54:26his shin destroyed in that explosion. I really
- 54:31liked the callback of Cat. I mentioned earlier
- 54:34in the podcast, Cat told them, you really want
- 54:36to listen for the high pitch. Because when you
- 54:38hear the high pitch of a missile or a bomb, that's
- 54:42when you want to hit the floor. And you notice
- 54:44in that shot that while they're talking and you
- 54:46hear that little pitch, Cat is the first one
- 54:48on the floor. And Cat's taking that exact precaution
- 54:51that he gave them. And he's still injured. And
- 54:55he still dies because of this. So even with that,
- 54:58I really liked that idea of how they included
- 55:01a wide shot of Paul and Cat. But noticeably,
- 55:04Cat is down faster than Paul is. And even still
- 55:08taking that awareness into consideration, it's
- 55:11futile. yeah you're still going to be affected
- 55:14by this war so it's uh to even to that extent
- 55:18though you know the entire film once you're introduced
- 55:21to cat is built up as like the strongest of the
- 55:24bunch he's indestructible he's the guy he's yeah
- 55:26he's indestructible like they even made that
- 55:29uh this war is over whenever whenever i die this
- 55:31war is over yeah um which you know You could
- 55:36probably make the argument was or wasn't the
- 55:37case in the context of when he dies and when
- 55:39the war ends or when armistice happens. But,
- 55:41you know, it goes to show that no one is safe.
- 55:46You can be the biggest and the baddest. It doesn't
- 55:48matter. Yeah. I think that lends itself perfectly
- 55:51to that final sequence you're talking about,
- 55:54Jordan, if you want to take it. Yeah. So, you
- 55:56know, Paul has now literally lost everything.
- 55:59He's lost all of his buddies. He's lost Kat.
- 56:02The last scene is him in the bunker, you know,
- 56:04and he's he's manning an automatic rifle, not
- 56:09automatic rifle, but like, you know, like a railgun.
- 56:12And he's looking through his little bunker hole
- 56:14and he sees this butterfly and he's he's compelled.
- 56:17And, you know, to me, this was my interpretation
- 56:20of it. So if anybody has a different interpretation
- 56:22of it, you know, please jump in. But, you know,
- 56:25I he's. He's very intrigued and distracted by
- 56:28the butterfly, like this beautiful creature in
- 56:31the midst of no man's land. This literally war
- 56:34-ridden piece of land is destroyed. To me, the
- 56:39butterfly was almost like representing life.
- 56:41Like he was reaching for meaning or reaching
- 56:44for life or reaching for something. And then
- 56:46in the midst of that, somebody had got him. And
- 56:49the film ends with the death of Paul. And they
- 56:52have that really awesome final shot the cemetery
- 56:57with all the, the crucifix headstones or, you
- 57:00know, the makeshift headstones. And they superimpose
- 57:03that shot of all of him and his buddies marching
- 57:06whenever they first were, you know, enlisted
- 57:08in, into the army. And they're all kind of like
- 57:10looking back. So it's, uh, I, I, it's again,
- 57:15just this, uh, very powerful ending. Where, you
- 57:19know, maybe Paul did want to live, but again,
- 57:21it wasn't in the cards. You know, war doesn't
- 57:24care if you want to live or not. The war machine
- 57:26is literally going to keep going. Yeah, absolutely.
- 57:29I think an interesting thing here in this movie
- 57:32as well is a lot of times in these successful
- 57:37war films like Saving Private Ryan, a lot of
- 57:40the deaths of these main characters are stretched
- 57:44out and kind of treated as heroic deaths. In
- 57:48other films, that doesn't happen in this movie.
- 57:51It doesn't really happen with Cat. He dies on
- 57:53the way to making it back to camp. All of his
- 57:57friends that die, it's very bleak and sad. And
- 58:02there's the one kid that has his leg amputated
- 58:06and he doesn't know. And he ends up giving up
- 58:08his prize boots to another soldier. And there's
- 58:10more emphasis put on this journey of the boots
- 58:13after he passes away. amazing sequence but there's
- 58:19never really any heroics placed on the death
- 58:23of these characters no and i think that adds
- 58:25support to to how awful and just this war isn't
- 58:31giving credit to any of these soldiers it's it's
- 58:33not praising them it's not triumphant at all
- 58:36and you don't get a moment of Kind of remembering
- 58:41or giving these soldiers their due until that
- 58:45final shot where they are superimposed over the
- 58:48frame and they're marching away over that cemetery.
- 58:52And I think that goes to show like war is awful.
- 58:55People die and nobody will care. They will celebrate
- 58:59you when you're gone, though. That is when you
- 59:02will get your praises because you will have died,
- 59:04quote unquote, a hero. And that's so terrifying.
- 59:08To me, in a way, I like that there are no heroics,
- 59:12I guess, in this movie. No, and then, you know,
- 59:16I know that we, as we talk about the characters
- 59:19of the film, like, when we say hero, we really
- 59:23mean the main character, right? Like, it's, you
- 59:25know, kind of going back to, like, what was it,
- 59:27the Joseph Campbell, like, the hero's journey,
- 59:28which is why we keep saying the hero, right?
- 59:30Right. It's, yeah, it's, he might have people
- 59:37that, I think he's a hero because of what he
- 59:40was doing. And in some kind of mindsets, he might
- 59:43be seen as a hero. But really, it's, you know,
- 59:46and I think I said this earlier in the pod, it's
- 59:48a cautionary character in very cautionary situations
- 59:53where it's like, don't think that war is great
- 59:57because it's not, right? Even though it was called
- 1:00:00a great war, it wasn't a great war. Well, I think
- 1:00:05back to Kantorek, the professor, and he heralds
- 1:00:10Paul as a hero, and everyone does. But it's not
- 1:00:14until Paul speaks up against the war that he
- 1:00:17kind of suggests that he isn't really the hero,
- 1:00:19right? So it's this status that they put on them
- 1:00:22until they say something they don't like. And
- 1:00:24then they take that away from you. So it's almost
- 1:00:27like an expectation of you or like a title given
- 1:00:30to you because of your placement and not what
- 1:00:32you've done. Right. Or your thoughts. Well, I
- 1:00:35think the same people in that classroom who call
- 1:00:37him a coward at one point, they once he gives
- 1:00:42his life for his country and he dies and he's
- 1:00:44gone. Now they will all see him as a hero of
- 1:00:48the country. And that's what's so awful. Because
- 1:00:50it helps them feel better. Yeah. Right. Right.
- 1:00:53So I and go ahead. I mean, no, no. The more things
- 1:00:56change, the more they say stay the same. Right.
- 1:00:59Like if that happened today and it does like
- 1:01:02there are a lot of veterans that speak out today
- 1:01:04that are like, yo, this is war is war, man. War
- 1:01:08in my I had a professor whenever I was taken.
- 1:01:11I actually took a really cool World War One class
- 1:01:13with with my history professor and he would come
- 1:01:16in and every day he would just look at us and
- 1:01:18say and he was he was a veteran as well. And
- 1:01:21he would say war is hell. War is hell. And my
- 1:01:25grandfather served in World War II, so he and
- 1:01:29I would kind of chat stories about relatives
- 1:01:31that fought in this war or that war. And he always
- 1:01:35pushed us, and he would say, war is not kind,
- 1:01:40war is hell. And I think that, especially in
- 1:01:45this day and age, people who don't serve don't
- 1:01:49realize that and use that as another propaganda
- 1:01:52crutch to push one one political agenda or another
- 1:01:57you know not trying to get into you know current
- 1:01:59politics or anything but it's it's always happened
- 1:02:02and it's always going to happen unfortunately
- 1:02:04sure that's the relentless of the war machine
- 1:02:07that you talked about so yeah it's turning it's
- 1:02:10uh it was a devastating movie to watch right
- 1:02:14i mean even obviously more devastating to experience
- 1:02:17but it was just extremely jarring for me to watch
- 1:02:23because, I mean, you know, personally speaking,
- 1:02:25we've talked a lot about how the movies we've
- 1:02:26watched outside of the research for this don't
- 1:02:30really relate to these movies. But this was the
- 1:02:32first time, I think, in watching these movies
- 1:02:34in chronological order from 1927 to today. Hey,
- 1:02:38look at that. Sorry, that was the tagline for
- 1:02:41the podcast. No, you're good. So this was the
- 1:02:46first one where it really was just like... It
- 1:02:48sounds like I'm oversimplifying it, but it was
- 1:02:52just so different than everything else we've
- 1:02:54watched, right? Not just in quality, but also
- 1:02:56just in the messaging. You never really had a
- 1:03:00director kind of putting something in front of
- 1:03:01you and just like almost like clockwork orange,
- 1:03:03just holding your eyelids open to being like,
- 1:03:06you need to see this. Like you need to see what's
- 1:03:08happening right now. And it's just an extremely
- 1:03:11special and important film. And just so, so good.
- 1:03:16I guess to oversimplify it again, just incredibly
- 1:03:18emotional. Truly, truly. What is it? I'm sure
- 1:03:23we've all seen our share of war films. What is
- 1:03:26it about this movie in particular you think that
- 1:03:29it makes it so successful as an anti -war film
- 1:03:33that other movies aren't able to capture? Even
- 1:03:37the remake that came out in 2022, I think. Well,
- 1:03:40I mean, for me, I think it's the Paul of movies,
- 1:03:42right? I mean, Paul was the first person. of
- 1:03:45his class to actually stand out and be like,
- 1:03:47what's going on here? Like, what are we actually
- 1:03:50doing? And it's not lost on me that Paul kind
- 1:03:53of serves as, I don't want to say just Lewis
- 1:03:56milestone, but the movie itself to kind of just
- 1:04:00like stand up and like not support, you know,
- 1:04:02not to say Wings is complicit in this, but like
- 1:04:04there are movies that are kind of feeding into
- 1:04:07the propaganda intentionally or not. this being
- 1:04:11the first of its kind to kind of stand out and
- 1:04:13just like question why these things are happening
- 1:04:15despite what's going to happen you know theaters
- 1:04:17being filled with mice and stink bombs and murder
- 1:04:21is happening because of it like it was the first
- 1:04:24to stand up so for me that's the significance
- 1:04:26is it was the first one brave enough to kind
- 1:04:29of like ask those questions regardless of what
- 1:04:31it was going to mean yeah what about no i i i
- 1:04:34can't really disagree or add too much to that
- 1:04:38because I agree with everything that Ryan said.
- 1:04:42First of its kind, very cautionary. And like
- 1:04:46I said earlier, there's a reason why we're still
- 1:04:47talking, why we're recording a podcast about
- 1:04:50it right here, right now in the year 2025, the
- 1:04:52year of our Lord Dolly Parton. Especially in
- 1:04:58what we will see coming up. The events of the
- 1:05:04end of World War I, once the armistice hits,
- 1:05:07which I'm looking for the date, was five days
- 1:05:13ago. So it was the 11th hour of the 11th day
- 1:05:16of the 11th month is when armistice happened
- 1:05:19and all the fighting stopped. And it's now Veterans
- 1:05:24Day here in the States, but everywhere else it's
- 1:05:27either Armistice Day or Remembrance Day. And,
- 1:05:32you know, we see post -World War II, whenever
- 1:05:36that ends, America enters this huge economic
- 1:05:39boom. Everybody's having babies. That's why they're
- 1:05:42called the baby boomers. And then we see a lot
- 1:05:45of war films, right? And they keep this idea
- 1:05:49of America, rah, rah, sis, boom, bah. Or, you
- 1:05:52know, especially here in the States. But we take
- 1:05:56that big tonal shift of... We like war isn't
- 1:06:00what you think it is to where the good guys,
- 1:06:02we got to run in and save the day. Right. So
- 1:06:04it's, I think it's still stands the test of time
- 1:06:07because not only is it one of the first, but
- 1:06:10it, it, I mean, well, essentially because it's
- 1:06:13the first actually, like it's, it still holds
- 1:06:14up because of that. Yeah. The thing that kind
- 1:06:17of like stands out to me is I think we've done
- 1:06:19so much of our research that I was ready to watch
- 1:06:23this knowing that it was the director and star.
- 1:06:27of the racket and it's just such an absolute
- 1:06:30left turn yeah i think there's an interesting
- 1:06:33dynamic and similarity in the ending of the racket
- 1:06:38and the ending of all quiet on the western front
- 1:06:41of this like uncontrollable result like we can
- 1:06:46try and do what's right and we can try and like
- 1:06:48fix the world but the world's going to keep happening
- 1:06:51And I think that there's a little bit of that
- 1:06:52in the racket and then obviously a much larger
- 1:06:54global scale of that in Wall Quiet in the Western
- 1:06:57front of just this relentless machine that regardless
- 1:07:00of you trying to be the fix of it, it's going
- 1:07:02to happen with or without you. And that's such
- 1:07:05an incredible, if it's intentional, and I think
- 1:07:09it is, an incredibly global view of it. Like
- 1:07:13that's just an incredible concept to put into
- 1:07:15a movie from 1928 to like... 1930 now i mean
- 1:07:19did you see any kind of correlation between those
- 1:07:21two yeah some of some of that is like context
- 1:07:26from the book i think that sure you know regardless
- 1:07:30of what milestone wanted to put in as his own
- 1:07:32personal decisions the the book itself just has
- 1:07:35that like this it is what it is it was what it
- 1:07:38was kind of thing yeah um but i i can see milestone
- 1:07:42being like this is what i'm about like i'm all
- 1:07:45for this that's probably why he was chosen to
- 1:07:47direct this film. Yeah. Jordan's back. Sorry.
- 1:07:52No, you're good. Do you mind if I kind of backtrack
- 1:07:54and add something? Of course. Well, of course
- 1:07:57not. Go ahead. As I was running down the stairs,
- 1:08:01we were talking about the end of the film, right?
- 1:08:03And how a lot of people who aren't in the war
- 1:08:08machine, right? The boots on the ground are still
- 1:08:12very pro -war. At this point in time, The writing
- 1:08:17is on the wall that Germany is going down. Like,
- 1:08:20they're not winning the war. They're losing a
- 1:08:22lot of traction on the battlefield. Sorry, I'm
- 1:08:25out of breath. I ran up those stairs really fast.
- 1:08:27Good, no worries. And a lot of Germans are actually
- 1:08:31very disillusioned with the Kaiser at this point.
- 1:08:34So they are losing a lot of that nationalism,
- 1:08:37too. So that's not to say that there weren't
- 1:08:41people still, like, clinging on to it. But with
- 1:08:43what ends up happening at the end of the war.
- 1:08:46Whenever, you know, armistices made, the Treaty
- 1:08:49of Versailles, which ends the war, doesn't get
- 1:08:51signed until July of 1919. And one of the terms
- 1:08:56of ending the war was that Germany had to take
- 1:09:00the blame for the war and pay reparations. And
- 1:09:05while the treaty was signed, it was not so much
- 1:09:09peace, but there was a French general by the
- 1:09:12name of Ferdinand Fauch. He's very famous for
- 1:09:17saying, this isn't peace, this is armistice for
- 1:09:2220 years. And he was very true because, you know,
- 1:09:26what we know about Hitler's rise to power and
- 1:09:29his charisma in creating the Nazi party and the
- 1:09:33Nazi army, that's essentially what ends up happening,
- 1:09:36which leads us into World War II. But it is interesting
- 1:09:41because Germans were becoming very disillusioned
- 1:09:43with... the Kaiser at that point. And then, you
- 1:09:46know, once the war ends, he's deposed. To backtrack
- 1:09:50one more time, when I was talking about what
- 1:09:52makes this film hold up and do things that other
- 1:09:55anti -war films are able or capable of doing,
- 1:09:59I do want to pull the quote that occurs at the
- 1:10:01beginning of the movie. It's also the start of
- 1:10:04the book. And to me, this movie is fascinating
- 1:10:08because I am not knowledgeable in history. obviously,
- 1:10:13the way that you are, Jordan. So if they're not
- 1:10:16dropping country names or, you know, I can't
- 1:10:22recognize patches and badges on uniforms and
- 1:10:24things. Right, right. This movie doesn't really
- 1:10:27showcase who you're following. And it being an
- 1:10:30American -made movie, if you're really not paying
- 1:10:33attention, you kind of could make the assumption
- 1:10:35that these are United States soldiers that you're
- 1:10:38following. Everybody's speaking perfect English.
- 1:10:41Exactly. Yeah. There's like one or two mentions
- 1:10:44of the Fuhrer. And unless you're really paying
- 1:10:47attention, you know, I'm not going to recognize
- 1:10:49like a German, a small town in Germany or that
- 1:10:52they're drinking out of Steins or whatever. There's
- 1:10:55a couple of names given that. That's true. The
- 1:10:59Spiked Helmets were. were the giveaway for me,
- 1:11:02at least just because that was a common German
- 1:11:05helmet for World War I. But I think you're absolutely
- 1:11:09right. Even me, I have to go back and be like,
- 1:11:12oh, is this a British uniform? Is this an American
- 1:11:15doughboy? Is this a French soldier? And like
- 1:11:19you said, they only allude to it a couple of
- 1:11:21times. That scene where we were talking about
- 1:11:23when they're eating and sitting under the trees,
- 1:11:24I've never even seen a guy from France before,
- 1:11:26and I'm sure he's never even seen a guy from
- 1:11:28Germany before. What was that quote? The quote,
- 1:11:32it's the beginning of the movie and also how
- 1:11:35the book starts. It said, this book, or in this
- 1:11:37case, this movie, is to be neither an accusation
- 1:11:41nor a confession and least of all an adventure.
- 1:11:44For death is not an adventure to those who stand
- 1:11:46face to face with it. It will try simply to tell
- 1:11:49of a generation of men who, even though they
- 1:11:52may have escaped shells, were destroyed by the
- 1:11:55war. And I think that is one of the biggest reasons
- 1:11:58this movie is able to withstand the test of time
- 1:12:03of its anti -war message because you're really
- 1:12:08not following a nation in this. I mean, you are
- 1:12:11obviously German soldiers, but you can replace
- 1:12:14them with any side of this war or any war, I
- 1:12:18think, and kind of just simplify it down and
- 1:12:23equate it to this is what war is like. Regardless
- 1:12:27of national. Regardless of nationality. It could
- 1:12:30have been any soldier for any army. It could
- 1:12:33have been any soldier for any army. It would
- 1:12:34have been the same story. And that's what's so
- 1:12:38incredible about this film to me and just this
- 1:12:40story in general. It's mind -blowing to think
- 1:12:44that in 1930, American directors and studios
- 1:12:48didn't change this to be an American army and
- 1:12:53tell it from their perspective so that there
- 1:12:55was any bit of... you know, I don't know, nationalism
- 1:12:58promoted through the film. And I love that they
- 1:13:02decided not to do that. They told a story from
- 1:13:06the perspective of our enemy, you know, as an
- 1:13:09anti -war film. That's a huge thing that I don't
- 1:13:13know that we would be able to do now. I think
- 1:13:16there's a reason that the remake for this was
- 1:13:19made by a German filmmaker in 2022 and not remade
- 1:13:23by an American. Yeah. Jordan, we end every episode
- 1:13:28with talking about double features. Okay. And
- 1:13:31I'm interested in what you would, I should clarify,
- 1:13:37with double features, we just talk about a movie
- 1:13:39that we would pair this with, right? It could
- 1:13:42be for the literal themes. It could be for more
- 1:13:44of a distant theme, tones that came out of it
- 1:13:48for you. What movie would you pair with All Quiet
- 1:13:52on the Western Front? Or do you need a moment?
- 1:13:55No, I think I've got a good one. Well, before
- 1:13:59we started recording, I joked like 1917 would
- 1:14:04be the obvious one, right? Which is a fantastic
- 1:14:08film in and of itself. There's like, what, three
- 1:14:10camera shots in that entire film? That was crazy.
- 1:14:12So good. Very good. Sam Mendes. It was very good.
- 1:14:16But I am actually going to go with Stanley Kubrick's
- 1:14:19Paths of Glory. If you've not seen that one.
- 1:14:22That's Kirk Douglas. It's another World War I
- 1:14:25film. And it's about Kirk Douglas. I forget his
- 1:14:29rank, but he plays some kind of superior officer.
- 1:14:32And he gets the order to send his men into, you
- 1:14:37know, no man's land. It's essentially a suicide
- 1:14:39mission. And he knows it's a suicide mission.
- 1:14:42And he's like, I'm not doing it. And he... Essentially,
- 1:14:47like, defends his stance and, you know, he gets
- 1:14:50court -martialed and et cetera, et cetera. But
- 1:14:52it was a really good World War I era film. So
- 1:14:56I would probably go with Paths of Glory. I think
- 1:14:58it actually got a Criterion release. It did.
- 1:15:01Nice. Very cool. Kyle, what about you? I'm going
- 1:15:04to go with the other anti -war film that I hear
- 1:15:08spoken about probably more than All Quiet. I'm
- 1:15:13going to go with Come and See. Yeah. Ellen Klimov
- 1:15:15from 1985. And I don't know if you've ever seen
- 1:15:20that movie, but there's nothing glorious about
- 1:15:23anything that happens in that movie. It is incredibly
- 1:15:26depressing. I honestly wouldn't recommend that
- 1:15:29double feature because it would just be so heartbreaking.
- 1:15:32But that's a movie, I think, that really, really
- 1:15:35serves that anti -war message in just, I don't
- 1:15:39know, astounding ways. It is interesting. I do...
- 1:15:42completely agree uh that that's kind of heralded
- 1:15:45as like the anti -war film but i definitely think
- 1:15:48of now having watched uh in my adult age all
- 1:15:51quite on the western front i definitely think
- 1:15:52of it as the anti -war film i have two and this
- 1:15:55is the leftist of left fields and i promise i'm
- 1:15:59not saying this in jest i thought about this
- 1:16:01pretty heavily uh i'm kind of thinking of um
- 1:16:04it petty wise and the reason why i know no i
- 1:16:08understand here's why The idea, and specifically
- 1:16:11it's Paul coming back home. Paul coming back
- 1:16:14home and seeing how absolutely unaffected everyone
- 1:16:17is. And the idea of his friends are missing and
- 1:16:21he's going through actual hell. And the public
- 1:16:24perception is, you know, this happens. This isn't
- 1:16:27a big deal. And watching that hell that they
- 1:16:29go through and still having to kind of like go
- 1:16:31through everyday life. I thought there was a
- 1:16:34similarity there. Jordan, you have your finger
- 1:16:36up. Yeah, if I could interject. Please. You know,
- 1:16:40talking about a horror film that you're going
- 1:16:43to pair this with or double feature this with.
- 1:16:45This war inspired all of the horror cinema of
- 1:16:49the 1920s. 100%. Fields of dead bodies. You know,
- 1:16:53the vampire, the German expressionism of Nosferatu
- 1:16:56in 1922. There's a book out there by a guy named
- 1:17:01Scott Poole called Wasteland. And it talks about
- 1:17:04all of the 1920s cinema and how World War I.
- 1:17:08influenced it not only like mentally but uh aesthetically
- 1:17:12you know you look at the world war one gas era
- 1:17:15gas masks those things are terrifying to look
- 1:17:18at right but then you fields of dead bodies is
- 1:17:22just you know another you know just a bunch of
- 1:17:25zombie corpses out there right so it's there's
- 1:17:27a lot of that uh the horror of the war that works
- 1:17:30its way into horror of the 1920s absolutely you
- 1:17:34know another aspect for me was the time paul
- 1:17:37coming in this class and seeing the younger kids
- 1:17:39uh that just are replacing and even going back
- 1:17:42to the fields or to the front lines and seeing
- 1:17:45the younger soldiers that have taken the place
- 1:17:47of his friends i think that reminds me a little
- 1:17:50bit of like now um Georgie, well, not Georgie,
- 1:17:54but how all of the kids grow up, and they're
- 1:17:57still seeing this happen again. It's just this
- 1:17:59relentless machine that's going to continue regardless
- 1:18:01of what they do. The second thing is kind of
- 1:18:04the cat of it all, and it reminded me a lot of
- 1:18:07Dead Poets Society, and the idea of raising these
- 1:18:10men to be what they need to be to prepare themselves
- 1:18:12for the real world. Granted, it's not so much
- 1:18:15for war. But it is very much that. And even the
- 1:18:18idea of being yourself and being at home and
- 1:18:21not being able to be yourself and taking your
- 1:18:23own life. And some of the men that he's with
- 1:18:27on these fields have those decisions to make
- 1:18:29of whether it is something they want to die or
- 1:18:32take their own life. Should it be at someone
- 1:18:33else's hands or at mine? And that's something
- 1:18:35that's heavily prevalent in Dead Poets Society.
- 1:18:38It's a movie that has lived with me for a very
- 1:18:39long time. And the idea of seeing any kind of
- 1:18:42figure trying to mold boys to be like the men
- 1:18:46that they need to be and not just to be men but
- 1:18:48to live in this world yeah uh that's dead poets
- 1:18:51aside in me and i think that's one reason i love
- 1:18:53the cat character so much also on top of lewis
- 1:18:55mulheim so those two are very different but like
- 1:18:59the themes of those and the time especially and
- 1:19:02how this is like a relentless machine and that
- 1:19:04stood out to me for all quite on the western
- 1:19:06front so i did think about janice films come
- 1:19:09and see but to your point I don't wish that double
- 1:19:12feature on anyone. That sounds like a death sentence,
- 1:19:18and I don't want that for anyone. Yeah, totally.
- 1:19:21Yeah, no, I think the Dead Poets Society definitely
- 1:19:24has some more uplifting, at least heartwarming,
- 1:19:28maybe. Yeah, I mean, that's the thing, is that
- 1:19:30Dead Poets Society has this note, or this legacy
- 1:19:33of being a very happy... I guess film or like
- 1:19:37not happy, but like people see it and just have
- 1:19:40good feelings about it. It's not a happy movie,
- 1:19:42but it is inspiring. I think absolutely it is.
- 1:19:46And that's a, that's a better feeling than I
- 1:19:48think walking away from a double feature of all
- 1:19:50quiet and come and see, but fair, but very effective.
- 1:19:54How about ratings? Ratings. Let's, let's talk
- 1:19:58that. So we go by the letterboxd format of ratings
- 1:20:02where it is from. half a star to five stars,
- 1:20:05five stars being the perfect film for you. Jordan,
- 1:20:09you're the guest. Oh, geez. Don't, don't. Do
- 1:20:12you need a minute? I'm sorry. Do you need a minute?
- 1:20:14Yeah, you go first. Yeah, you go first. Cause,
- 1:20:16uh, I mean, I, I feel like I would give it five
- 1:20:19stars, but maybe I want to think about that for
- 1:20:21a second. Yeah. Well, Hey, you think about it,
- 1:20:23buddy. I don't need to five stars. Yeah. Um,
- 1:20:25I think it's a five star. I think that. Kyle
- 1:20:29and I have talked about previous movies on this
- 1:20:30iteration and how we would differ from like 0
- 1:20:33.5 and 3. And there's just not a thing I would
- 1:20:36change about this movie. I think that the issues
- 1:20:40that I've had with other movies that I've given,
- 1:20:42you know, 3 .5, 2 .5, aren't present in this.
- 1:20:46This is not a movie that is of its time in the
- 1:20:48sense that you can tell, oh, you know what? This
- 1:20:50definitely looks like it was a year or feels
- 1:20:51like a year after they got the technology to
- 1:20:54record sound. This looks like it could have been
- 1:20:57made in 1950. Like, in terms of the technology
- 1:21:00that they had with both video and audio, it's
- 1:21:03unbelievable. The shots that they can get in
- 1:21:05this, the amount of extras that they had, to
- 1:21:07Jordan's point, they filmed a lot of this in
- 1:21:09lots. And how did they do that? How is some of
- 1:21:12this not stock footage? It's insane. So, no,
- 1:21:14it's a five star for me very easily. Yeah, I
- 1:21:17agree. It's five stars all the way. There are
- 1:21:19no limitations in this movie, technical or otherwise.
- 1:21:23I think you can see the support. that so many
- 1:21:27people in Hollywood had for the making of this
- 1:21:30movie. There are stories of some of the extras
- 1:21:33being directors of the time that just showed
- 1:21:36up and they were like, I want to be a part of
- 1:21:37this. Fred Zinneman, notorious director that
- 1:21:40we'll speak about later on the podcast, he was
- 1:21:43one of them that showed up and said, this is
- 1:21:46important, I want to be a part of this. And all
- 1:21:48of that passion and desire to tell this story
- 1:21:52is present. paired with the story itself, is
- 1:21:56a five -star film. You know, my gut reaction
- 1:22:00was to give it five stars, and I was second -guessing
- 1:22:03myself, but you know what? I'm going with my
- 1:22:05gut reaction. Five stars, man. Even though you've
- 1:22:10remade, or this film has been remade, I don't
- 1:22:14know if you can make this kind of film like this
- 1:22:17these days, right? It's a great message. It was...
- 1:22:23acted very well it you know i i watched the the
- 1:22:26version on tubi um so i i did have a little bit
- 1:22:29of tape hiss in my audio but whenever whenever
- 1:22:32i'm watching a film like that like i i think
- 1:22:35that adds to the film's character right kind
- 1:22:38of gives me a an idea of when and how it was
- 1:22:42made um but it um yeah i got reaction is five
- 1:22:48stars so yeah i'm with you guys Well, you know,
- 1:22:51the other part of this is we talked a little
- 1:22:55bit about preservation. Last season, we talked
- 1:22:57about lost media and kudos to Universal. I mean,
- 1:23:02obviously, you know, it says right on the back,
- 1:23:04as you mentioned earlier, Jordan, it says on
- 1:23:06the film, a milestone in filmmaking. Studio saving
- 1:23:08picture as well. We'll throw that out. 100%.
- 1:23:11I mean, so it saved Universal in that sense.
- 1:23:14So Universal has done its due diligence in honoring
- 1:23:18that. And there are plenty of physical copies
- 1:23:21available of this. We mentioned the 100 -year
- 1:23:23anniversary of Universal, them releasing a hardback
- 1:23:26edition of this with some special features. And
- 1:23:29I'm very excited to go and watch on the back
- 1:23:32end now. And a booklet inside with descriptions
- 1:23:35of the movie in a little more detail. If you
- 1:23:39can get your hands on it, I would absolutely
- 1:23:42recommend it. I believe it's available online.
- 1:23:44There's plenty of ways to watch this. Jordan
- 1:23:46mentioned to be it's available. So 100 % recommend.
- 1:23:51Yeah. This was also added to the library of Congress
- 1:23:56films, films worth saving list too. I don't know.
- 1:24:01So I think it was like 1980. I might be off on
- 1:24:04my time on that, but. Can somebody fact check
- 1:24:07me on that? I got you. Isn't it crazy too, that
- 1:24:10there's like only some movies that should be
- 1:24:12considered worth saving and not just like, Hey,
- 1:24:14it's a movie. It's worth saving. Right. Right.
- 1:24:16Maybe not. Disraeli. I wasn't going to say Disraeli.
- 1:24:21I was going to say, what was the trauma film?
- 1:24:24Poultry Geist. Oh God. Poultry. Where they built
- 1:24:28the KFC on a burial ground. Yeah. Man, we were
- 1:24:32sitting here talking about the peak cinema making
- 1:24:35and here comes trauma. Well, you know what? That
- 1:24:40would be a hell of a double feature. You know
- 1:24:42what? Can I change? So with the public library.
- 1:24:49You said the public library, Jordan? Library
- 1:24:52of Congress. Nope, I didn't say that. The public
- 1:24:54library. Right up the street. They were like,
- 1:24:56this is important. The one down the road. Yeah.
- 1:24:59My Google was like, yeah, lots of public libraries
- 1:25:03have this. I was like, okay, thank you. It is.
- 1:25:06Okay. Yeah. Cosigned. Thanks. Perfect. Worth
- 1:25:11it. So if anybody has anything else, we're getting
- 1:25:16close to sign off. If not, I do have one more
- 1:25:19fact that I think will kind of send off this
- 1:25:22movie and its importance. Yeah, take us home.
- 1:25:23We can talk where to find you and things, Jordan.
- 1:25:28Lou Ayers, who played Paul in this film, he was
- 1:25:31discovered at the Coconut Grove nightclub. So
- 1:25:34he wasn't an actor. They found him and they said,
- 1:25:36you're perfect for this film. This movie had
- 1:25:40such a tremendous effect on his views of war
- 1:25:44in general. that he became a huge conscientious,
- 1:25:48I can never say this word, conscientious, yeah,
- 1:25:53objector of World War II. And it kind of got
- 1:25:57him blacklisted a little bit in Hollywood for
- 1:26:00speaking out against the war. This movie has
- 1:26:04a lot to say. I think if you're not here for
- 1:26:07the historical aspect of like the Academy and
- 1:26:11these movies and what they've built, for our
- 1:26:14modern era of filmmaking, this movie, above everything
- 1:26:17we've watched so far, should be seen by everybody.
- 1:26:21It's relevant in every moment that it has existed
- 1:26:26since its release. Give it a watch above anything
- 1:26:29else that we've talked about. Heavy recommend.
- 1:26:32Yeah. More so than anything we've watched so
- 1:26:34far. I do think it can change the way you view
- 1:26:38just war in general, and it might help you show
- 1:26:42a little more compassion. Just even to your neighbor,
- 1:26:46your neighbor right next door or your neighbor
- 1:26:49halfway across the globe. And speaking of our
- 1:26:52neighbors right next door, Jordan, thank you
- 1:26:54so much for joining us for this episode. Thanks
- 1:26:57for having me, man. You do a lot of great work.
- 1:26:59And then there's the mutineers. Yeah, that's
- 1:27:03true. So where can everyone find you to learn
- 1:27:07more about you and what you do? As far as like
- 1:27:11my history stuff, I do have a TikTok and an Instagram
- 1:27:15page. They don't get updated as much as I would
- 1:27:19like to update them. I'm going to try to start
- 1:27:21doing better. But for history related content,
- 1:27:24you can follow me on TikTok and Instagram at
- 1:27:28JDHistoria, H -I -S -T -O -R -I -A. And then
- 1:27:34just for my fun stuff, you can find me Jordan
- 1:27:39Gaskley. G -H -A -S -T -L -Y on Instagram, TikTok,
- 1:27:44YouTube. I'm a big action figure collector. I
- 1:27:48know that you guys can see me through the camera.
- 1:27:50Is that true? That's so interesting. Yeah, so
- 1:27:53I've got a bunch of, like, I'm a big action figure
- 1:27:55collector, so a lot of that content on those
- 1:27:57Jordan Gastly channels is more of, like, pop
- 1:28:00culture and fun type stuff. Every once in a while,
- 1:28:03some history gets tossed in. And then Ryan and
- 1:28:06I do this other podcast called The Mickey Mutineers.
- 1:28:10It's kind of, you know, it's... It's a podcast
- 1:28:15that exists. That is true, and that's something
- 1:28:17that Jake, who runs Mickey McNeers, likes to
- 1:28:21say, is this has been a podcast. It has been
- 1:28:25truly surreal to have this conversation with
- 1:28:27you, Jordan, and discuss World War I while watching
- 1:28:30Castle Grey's skull be wrapped in Christmas lights
- 1:28:32behind you. Thank you. There's a reason every
- 1:28:38podcast we have done has included you at some
- 1:28:41point, so I'm very grateful that you have joined
- 1:28:43us to talk a little bit about this. Thanks, buddy.
- 1:28:45I appreciate it. Yeah, it really has been awesome.
- 1:28:47Thank you so much for having me. Anytime. Nice
- 1:28:50to finally meet you. kind of face -to -face.
- 1:28:53Yeah, you too. I do appreciate all of the film
- 1:28:56picks that you guys gave me on the Cinema Showdown
- 1:28:58episode I couldn't make. It should be noted that
- 1:29:03the one that got you the most money was picked
- 1:29:04by me. Yes, it's true. And Kyle, I think you
- 1:29:08gave him Witch Board. You're welcome. Thank you.
- 1:29:13I want to see the remake of that one. I have
- 1:29:16seen the original one. What was really cool about
- 1:29:20the DVD is that it did come with a little cardboard
- 1:29:23Ouija board with pop -out planchettes. Oh, man.
- 1:29:27Yeah. I would actually love a physical copy of
- 1:29:29that. That's my new goal for collection. I would
- 1:29:32love that. Yeah, that sounds awesome. But one
- 1:29:35more time, thank you so much for being a guest
- 1:29:38on the show. Our first guest. It's incredible
- 1:29:40to be able to talk to someone that knows the
- 1:29:42history of... The lore of this film, I guess.
- 1:29:47No, it was fun. Like I said, I think a lot of
- 1:29:51people really lean heavy into World War II. And
- 1:29:53yes, it is fascinating. And also quite topical,
- 1:29:57depending on things. But World War I, I think
- 1:30:01people pass up. And it's just incredibly fascinating.
- 1:30:05The first modern artillery and everything just
- 1:30:10came from this war. I think people overlook that
- 1:30:15a lot. Yeah, absolutely. Jordan, we'll put all
- 1:30:17of the links you mentioned in the show notes.
- 1:30:20And guys, if you want to support the show, you
- 1:30:23can reach out to us via email, outaopodcast at
- 1:30:27gmail .com. Give us your thoughts on All Quiet
- 1:30:30on the Western Front or any of the other films
- 1:30:32we're covering this Academy year. We are approaching
- 1:30:35the end of season one. We've got just two more
- 1:30:38episodes left before we take a... Little break
- 1:30:42until mid -January, and then we'll be coming
- 1:30:44back strong talking about the 2026 Academy Awards.
- 1:30:49I'm so excited. It's going to be wild talking
- 1:30:50about movies that are not like 96 years old.
- 1:30:54Yeah. Also, check us out on Patreon, patreon
- 1:30:56.com slash O -U -T -A -O podcast. Everything
- 1:30:59that we mentioned now is going to be listed in
- 1:31:01the show notes. That's going to do it for this
- 1:31:04episode of the podcast. As always, I'm your host,
- 1:31:06Kyle. And I'm Ryan. And we'll see you at the
- 1:31:09movies.