Latest / Once Upon a Time at the Oscars / The Life of Emile Zola (1937)
Transcript
- 0:00Hello everyone and welcome to Once Upon a Time
- 0:15at the Oscars. The show that takes you through
- 0:17every Best Picture nominee from 1927 to today.
- 0:20I'm Kyle. I'm Ryan. And I, we were talking about
- 0:23Pop -Tarts before this started and how to weave
- 0:25that into our show because we're looking to make
- 0:26it to the big leagues, baby. That's right. We're
- 0:29trying to get out there and we're trying to make
- 0:31sure that we're hosting, uh, maybe not Marvel
- 0:33stuff. I think we could though. We could, why
- 0:35not? But I feel like if the Academy ever needed
- 0:38like, uh, you know. Two guys to, you know, hype
- 0:42up the Oscars. Like, you know, coming into the
- 0:45Oscars. Yeah. If they needed that. I think we
- 0:47could do it. I think we could do it, too. And
- 0:49what better way than to boldly claim on here
- 0:53that the best Pop -Tart is the cherry Pop -Tart?
- 0:57Well, that's funny, because I think I agree with
- 0:58you, so... Damn. Never run out of controversy.
- 1:01Oh, damn it. No. I do feel that way. I think
- 1:05that cherry is the... Well, and cherry's my favorite
- 1:07flavor, so, like, that's... Cherry's pretty good.
- 1:10It's my favorite fruit. It's a fruit. What else
- 1:14would it be, Ryan? Well, no, it has a seed. So
- 1:17pit is the correct terminology. So look, I'm
- 1:21just saying ever since the tomato controversy
- 1:23entered, this is the controversy we can use to
- 1:25get onto the prom time. Yeah, hit me with it.
- 1:27Tomatoes. Gotcha. What's the controversy? Not
- 1:29really a vegetable. Yeah. Kind of a fruit. It
- 1:33is a fruit. Yeah. But it has been seen as a vegetable.
- 1:36Yeah. I want to ask you a question right now.
- 1:38I told you about this, or I think I've mentioned
- 1:40it to you before. VeggieTales. Oh, yeah. Are
- 1:43you familiar? By name? Yeah. Yes. The two lead
- 1:46characters are Larry the Cucumber and Bob the
- 1:51Tomato. Well, that's not... What is it called?
- 1:54Alliteration? Are you going to look me in the
- 1:55eyes and say the Christians are wrong? Right
- 1:59now, on the podcast, in front of me and God?
- 2:02Yes. Bob the Tomato is a prominent... He is second
- 2:06lead to Larry the Cube. He probably thinks he's
- 2:09first. Oh, wait. Neither one of them are in alliteration.
- 2:11What was I getting at? Nothing. What? You know
- 2:14what you need to do? Uh -huh. Catch up. Oh, the
- 2:17old Pulp Fiction joke there. I got you on that.
- 2:19Yeah. So I'm just saying that VeggieTales told
- 2:23me early on, and by early on, I was probably
- 2:25introduced to them when I was 13, so it's not
- 2:27a big deal, that tomatoes were vegetables. Are
- 2:32there no... Other foods in VeggieTales? Oh, there's
- 2:35plenty. Broccoli. No, no, no. Other than vegetables.
- 2:38I'm trying to think if there's an apple. Because
- 2:40that would be, I feel like that enters like a
- 2:42whole new theming into the show. You're right.
- 2:45There were other fruit foods that weren't vegetables.
- 2:49Yeah. There are fruits. They're fruits. They're
- 2:52healthy. You remember that from Hey Arnold? Hey
- 2:54Arnold. Yeah, yeah, yeah. Such a good episode.
- 2:56I know where it's going. What a good show. So
- 2:59Chase, who's going to be on the podcast in the
- 3:02future. In a few years. Yeah. We just, you know,
- 3:05did some research for it. No big deal. He loves
- 3:08Hey Arnold so much that he talked about dressing
- 3:10up as a banana and a strawberry. Oh, that's good.
- 3:13Which are definitely fruits. Both of them are.
- 3:16Both berries, actually. Look at that. More controversy.
- 3:20People are going to be like, banana's not a berry.
- 3:22What can I say? You're not even going to defend
- 3:25it. You're just going to be like, what can I
- 3:26say? Yeah. Cool. We're not talking about fruits
- 3:29or vegetables. Nope. Hey, make us go viral. That
- 3:32was it. Good luck. Share that clip. I like how
- 3:34you said good luck because that's like, hey,
- 3:37that's all we have. Good luck trying to get that
- 3:39to go viral. That's it. It's never going to get
- 3:41better than that. So thank you for your patronage.
- 3:45Today, we're not talking about either of those
- 3:47things. We are talking about the importance of
- 3:50journalism. And Publicated Truth. Okay, yeah.
- 3:54And Courtroom Dramas. Yeah. And a little bit
- 3:57of both. And today we're talking about The Life
- 3:59of Emile Zola. So, peeling the curtain back a
- 4:03little bit, I had been aware of this. A, you
- 4:06mentioned Off -Pod. I picked up the DVD of this.
- 4:08But I was also aware because Bryce kind of was
- 4:11like, I think when we covered 1931, he was like,
- 4:14yeah, good luck getting to The Life of Emile
- 4:16Zola. Yeah, that sounds familiar. Ever since
- 4:19then, I was like, oh, God. I gotta do this movie.
- 4:23And Bryce warned me about it. And I don't know
- 4:24why he never elaborated. I just know he warned
- 4:27me about it. Typical Bryce. And, uh, the day
- 4:30came and I watched it and I was kind of waiting
- 4:32for it to be like, you know, not so much in the
- 4:35quality of the movie, but the quality of my experience,
- 4:37like a good earth too, of like, this movie is
- 4:40just like, uh, snail's pace. It is sluggish and
- 4:44it's not going anywhere. And instead, I did not
- 4:48expect, you know, a courtroom drama from this.
- 4:51I didn't expect, with a movie like the title,
- 4:54like The Life of Emile Zola, I think I expected
- 4:56it to be the beginning and end of his life. Yeah.
- 4:59And not just, kind of not that, but more like
- 5:01his lasting impression, I guess is the best way
- 5:04to put it. Right. So it's an interesting one
- 5:06to cover. Yeah. Is that the, do you feel comfortable
- 5:09agreeing with that? No, but. You can go ahead
- 5:14and go off king. Yeah. Yeah, so I forgot that
- 5:18Bryce said that about this movie completely.
- 5:21Do you wish you would have remembered? I wish
- 5:23I would have remembered. Yeah. Look, I sat here
- 5:26and I watched this and I was like... It's...
- 5:30I mean, we'll get into it. It's another Paul
- 5:32Muni movie where he is playing a man with a beard.
- 5:38And I think anytime Paul Muni... dons a beard
- 5:41and it's not like the stubble of a fugitive from
- 5:44a chain gang i'm just like i'll take a nap now
- 5:47so do you agree then with was it david selznick
- 5:50who was like whenever paul muni puts on glasses
- 5:54and has a telescope or um microscope microscope
- 5:57thank you uh i lose a hundred million dollars
- 5:59or something like that i think i'm david selznick
- 6:02yeah uh can i quote you Let me do some research
- 6:06on David Selznick again. Okay. Just in case.
- 6:09Never mind. I don't want to do it anymore then.
- 6:12Life of Emile Zola has 10 nominations. That's
- 6:17so many. Which is a big deal, man. Is that the
- 6:19most? I think that might be the most that we've
- 6:22had so far. It is the first film to be nominated
- 6:25for double digit nominations. This movie? This
- 6:29movie. This one? Yeah. This one. And listen,
- 6:33I don't even think it's worthy. Go down the nominations
- 6:35and I will tell you when I go. Now, wait a minute.
- 6:38So let's do a check system of sure and now wait
- 6:43a minute. Okay. Okay. Ready. All right. So here's
- 6:45your 10 nominations. Music score was for Max
- 6:49Steiner. Sure. Of course. Yeah. You would feel
- 6:51that way. Max Steiner is your boy. We love Max
- 6:52Steiner. We love Max Steiner in this house. That's
- 6:54true. Sound recording, Nathan Levinson. Yeah,
- 6:57sure. Yeah. I'm all right. Yeah. It's fine. Production
- 7:00design, Anton Grott. Sure. Now, I want to point
- 7:04out that your hand did come down just a little
- 7:06bit to be like, sure. The nomination I get. Yeah.
- 7:10Like, am I going to, you know, write his name
- 7:14down on the ballot? Probably not. Yeah. But like,
- 7:17yeah, I get you, man. Well, you can't do that
- 7:18this year. Right. You know what I mean. Like,
- 7:20check, check, put a check next to his name on
- 7:23the old ballot there. Okay. I hear you. Assistant
- 7:26director, Russell Saunders. I guess. This is
- 7:30a nomination I've never understood. I don't think
- 7:32anyone died on set, so I don't really understand.
- 7:35Did they film this on location in Africa? Maybe
- 7:39they just built the sets in Africa. They were
- 7:43like, let's put up a sound studio. Zimbabwe.
- 7:46I think this movie takes place in New York. So
- 7:48for anyone who's not familiar with this movie,
- 7:50that joke went over their heads. I'm so sorry.
- 7:51It was not filmed in Africa. It was not. Nor
- 7:53is it set. Writing original story. This was for
- 7:56Heinz Herold and Giza Herxig. Maybe. I guess.
- 8:02I have thoughts. Actor in a leading role. This
- 8:05was Paul Muni as Emile Zola. Sure. So far, we're
- 8:09doing pretty good. A lot of shers. Supporting
- 8:12actor Joseph Schildkraut as Alfred Dreyfus. Wait
- 8:17a minute. Oh! Wait a minute. Wow, okay. He's
- 8:21hardly in the movie. He doesn't do a whole lot.
- 8:23He's really not. He's got like one scene, really,
- 8:25where he's just kind of panicked. And by that
- 8:28measure, give a nomination to every actor in
- 8:31a horror movie ever. Yeah, I mean, I've been
- 8:33panicked all my life. I'm panicking right now.
- 8:37You asked me to say something about the Christians
- 8:39earlier, Ryan. Hey, they are VeggieTales, right?
- 8:44They embrace that. It's one community. That's
- 8:46true. Sweet and sour, half an hour, cauliflower.
- 8:50I said that wrong. It's sweet and sour, cauliflower,
- 8:52half an hour. That's the theme song. That's the
- 8:55theme song? Yeah. Sweet and sour, cauliflower,
- 8:58half an hour, VeggieTales. I missed out on so
- 9:01much. So much. And you know what? If you cast
- 9:04out the Christians with your thought, I just
- 9:06want them back by singing that theme song. We
- 9:08need to stop saying that I'm casting out the
- 9:10Christians. Bible Man? Have you heard of Bible
- 9:12Man? Everybody is welcome. No, I haven't. Bible
- 9:14Man is also another Christian television character.
- 9:19He's like Superman, but for the Bible. Wow. Yeah.
- 9:22I know Gumby. Was he a Christian icon? I don't
- 9:26know, man. He probably prayed. Why would you
- 9:28jump to Gumby is my question. I don't know. Gumby
- 9:31sounds like the same era as Bible Man. I think
- 9:34Gumby was like 1960s. Sure. And I think Bible
- 9:37Man was like 1990 something. The next nomination
- 9:40is writing screenplay. This was for, as mentioned,
- 9:43Heinz Harold, Geza Herxig, but also Norman Riley
- 9:46Rain. Wait a minute. So hold on. The original
- 9:50story, no issue. But the screenplay, wait a minute.
- 9:54You get one or the other. What are we doing here?
- 9:56It is about the same thing, right? Yeah. You
- 9:58just got two nominations for the same thing.
- 10:00That's like, oh, let's give Paul Muni best. actor
- 10:03but also best lead actress well we'll get there
- 10:06but they didn't win both good so hopefully that
- 10:09makes you feel better good it does but if anything
- 10:11i would probably say that the one that you would
- 10:13prefer them not win they won so sorry about that
- 10:15oh uh director this is for william deterlay who
- 10:19we've talked about previously on this podcast
- 10:20really yeah man i he i think he he has a very
- 10:25specific skill set and i don't know that it's
- 10:27this interesting You know, I really like this
- 10:30segment. I think we should do this for most episodes.
- 10:33You think so? Yeah, with a, sure, wait a minute.
- 10:35It's about 12 minutes into the podcast. Probably
- 10:37helps you out with talking about this movie,
- 10:39so you're welcome. And then, of course, outstanding
- 10:42production. This was on behalf of Warner Brothers.
- 10:44Yeah. So, this film directed... Oh, go ahead.
- 10:48Go ahead. Sure. Wait a minute. You know, like...
- 10:53That feels very subjective. I think, given how
- 10:56many sure's you gave versus now, sure, wait a
- 10:59minute. I think you have to give that best, or
- 11:02the nomination. I think they should have knocked
- 11:04this down to five movies nominated this year,
- 11:07and then we wouldn't have this problem. You know
- 11:09what's funny? This kind of has the this problem,
- 11:12where you have different, what's the word I'm
- 11:16looking for? The way that you pronounce it, or
- 11:19the inflection that you provide on this is different.
- 11:21Okay. For Sinners, getting, what was it, 17,
- 11:2514 nominations? Oh, I think it was like 13. Okay,
- 11:2813. So 13 nominations. 17 was just a lot. I was
- 11:32like, you're making up awards. Best documentary
- 11:37short. Sinners. At this point. No, so 13 nominations
- 11:42for Sinners, which was a record -breaking achievement.
- 11:46Yeah. You'd be like, oh, this. Really excited.
- 11:51And then Life of Emile Zola getting 10 nominations,
- 11:53you're like, this? It's all in inflections. So
- 11:57we'll get to Sinners in five, six years? A long
- 12:02time. It was 16 nominations. I thought it was
- 12:05more than 13. It's a lot. What did I say, 13,
- 12:0817? I stand corrected. You said 13, 17. Well,
- 12:11right in between is 15, but I digress. Anyway,
- 12:14let's really get into this movie, okay? So as
- 12:16you said, this was directed by William Deterly.
- 12:19Right. And we've seen him. He worked on A Midsummer
- 12:22Night's Dream. He did another movie as well.
- 12:25It was right after Midsummer Night's Dream. It
- 12:27was. It was the following year. And this film
- 12:30also stars nominated here. We had Paul Muni,
- 12:32who we've seen a number of times, who I think
- 12:34for me is just. dropping in my enjoyment of his
- 12:38performances as we go on. Joseph Shieldkraut
- 12:41as Captain Alfred Dreyfuss, who was also nominated
- 12:44in this film as a supporting actor. But then
- 12:47we have Gloria Holden and Gail Sondergaard, who
- 12:50we've seen both of them as well. So we have returning
- 12:53cast members here that we're familiar with and
- 12:56that we have enjoyed in the past. But boy, howdy
- 12:59for me. This is just like such a drag, man. Such
- 13:03a drag. So you just determined that the previous
- 13:07movie that we had talked about of William de
- 13:09Turley was The Story of Louis Pasteur. Yes. Also
- 13:12a Paul Muni film. Also a Paul Muni film, and
- 13:14also a biopic of sorts of an individual. So I
- 13:20wonder if he's just kind of in his bag now. He's
- 13:23like, hey, this is what the Academy does. I'm
- 13:25going to roll with it. Even the name, Story of
- 13:28Louis Pasteur, and The Life of Emile Zola. Yeah.
- 13:31Now, I will say this. The story of Louis Pasteur
- 13:35is correct. Beginning to end, you feel like it
- 13:38should be called The Story of Louis Pasteur.
- 13:39Sure. Watching this movie in full, it should
- 13:42not be called The Life of Emile Zola. Yeah, it's
- 13:44not his complete life. It's definitely a segment.
- 13:47It should be called, like, I Accuse, or... I
- 13:51saw there was multiple names out there. Justice
- 13:53is the name of one of his books that he released.
- 13:55Right. Justice works better here. I Accuse, one
- 13:58of my favorite scenes in this movie. That is...
- 14:01probably a better name for this. Like, this is
- 14:03much more about Alfred Dreyfuss than it is, like,
- 14:07Emile Zola and what he brought to this world.
- 14:10Yeah. I mean, it's definitely, like, his story
- 14:13because he's the one that, I don't know, changed
- 14:15things. It's his story in the way that, like,
- 14:18Hercule Poirot is, like, the main character of,
- 14:21like, an Agatha Christie movie. Yeah. But it's
- 14:24not called, like, The Adventures of Hercule Poirot.
- 14:26It's, like, The Murder on the Orient Express.
- 14:28I mean, it is in the books. Is it? Yeah, like,
- 14:31those are Perot mysteries. Oh, see, the movies
- 14:34and everything have different names. Sure. Well,
- 14:37the books do, too. They're just part of the collection
- 14:39of Perot mysteries. I don't want a collection
- 14:43of Emile mysteries. Emile courtroom dramas. Yeah.
- 14:47Well, this movie sees an end to that, quite literally.
- 14:50That's very true. Yeah, I mean, let's get into
- 14:52just general thoughts. I mean, so I think we're
- 14:56on the same, we're in the same coin, but two
- 14:58different sides of it. Yeah. I think we both
- 15:01agree this movie is overlong. It's very long.
- 15:05It's uneven. Yeah. And at times it doesn't have
- 15:10a focus of what it's focusing on. Very true.
- 15:13It's also, I don't think it's very well made
- 15:16in the, I mean, just in the flow of it. You just
- 15:21said yourself, like. Uneven. Uneven. But also
- 15:25in like. the storytelling, the visual storytelling
- 15:27and all of that. I think I've said this multiple
- 15:29times, actually, that's kind of what I'm looking
- 15:32for in movies. Like I don't want to see directors
- 15:35and cinematographers who have fallen into their,
- 15:38their groove and their systems and just kind
- 15:41of do that over and over again. Like I want people
- 15:45to get creative and show a reason for these films
- 15:48being nominated for best picture. And I think
- 15:51the ones that are nominated for story and acting,
- 15:55That's when I'm like, this probably should have
- 15:57just been a stage play because you're not doing
- 15:59anything visually striking on the screen. No,
- 16:03that's correct. I mean, it's more just kind of
- 16:05capturing it in real time than it is. I mean,
- 16:09the pacing is not great. The framing isn't really
- 16:12spectacular. It's more just, okay, I guess we
- 16:14put the camera here. We've talked about this
- 16:16with plays where it's just kind of like, where
- 16:19do I put the camera? Cool, keep it here. We see
- 16:21a bit of that here. I think the reason I say
- 16:23that the accused scene is my favorite is that's
- 16:25the best direction for me, where it's who do
- 16:27we show in this moment? Who do we cut to? What's
- 16:31the importance of this? And also, it's just a
- 16:33good monologue from Muni. That is kind of the
- 16:37beginning and end of interesting direction for
- 16:39me in this movie, and it's not even worth mentioning
- 16:41outside of this episode. Well, that becomes an
- 16:44editing. Yes. As well. Jeez. Correct. I got the
- 16:48words. Very hard for you to think of the word
- 16:50praise when talking about this movie. Yeah, yeah.
- 16:52You know, it's just not sitting in my vocabulary.
- 16:55That's understandable. I want to run something
- 16:57by you real quick. A couple things. We just talked
- 16:59about all the nominations. This is the first
- 17:01Warner Brothers movie to be nominated, or sorry,
- 17:05well, to be nominated and win Best Picture. That's
- 17:08pretty crazy. Right. Because we are now in the
- 17:1110th, technically 11th, when you look at it a
- 17:13certain way. the ceremony the 10th ceremony of
- 17:17the academy awards yeah it's the 10th great so
- 17:20we're in the the years threw me off uh we're
- 17:23now in the decade and it took the end of the
- 17:26decade for warner brothers to be on the map wow
- 17:29crazy yeah that is wild warner brothers to me
- 17:31is like one of the i mean to everybody it's a
- 17:34giant studio it's crazy it took 10 years yeah
- 17:36there's a couple of reasons for that and we'll
- 17:38get into it here but probably because their movies
- 17:40weren't as good hey there it is right Let's remember,
- 17:43they're also the people behind Sinners that also
- 17:47got the record -breaking nominations. Sure, yeah.
- 17:49So we're continuing the trend. But I'm talking
- 17:52about Magnet. Yeah, of course. So let's talk
- 17:55about the story, though, so people know who Emil
- 17:58Zola is. Yes. I guess we should get into the
- 18:01brief synopsis. Yeah, a little bit. So Emil Zola
- 18:04is a writer. In Paris in like the 1860s, right?
- 18:10Right around that era? Correct. And he's kind
- 18:14of a penniless writer. And there is political
- 18:17uprisings going on in France at the time. And
- 18:21by, I don't know, a stroke of luck, misfortune,
- 18:25or a mix of the two, there is a gentleman in
- 18:30the military named Captain Alfred Dreyfus who
- 18:33is accused of being a traitor. And a lot of this
- 18:37stems, this is never really said in the movie,
- 18:39and this is a big problem I have with it. Yeah.
- 18:42A lot of this stems from him being Jewish. He
- 18:45is accused of being a traitor and he is sentenced
- 18:48to prison and like solitary confinement on an
- 18:51island called Devil's Island, which is wild to
- 18:54me. Emil Zola decides reluctantly, I will add,
- 19:00to do his best to like free him and prove his
- 19:04innocence. kind of bring down the corrupt military
- 19:07of this era of France as well. Yes. There's a
- 19:14couple of intricacies in between there. Sure,
- 19:17of course. Obviously, he becomes a well -established,
- 19:20publicized author for his truth pieces. And writing
- 19:24smut, basically. And writing smut, yeah, true.
- 19:27So he becomes extremely popular. We see through
- 19:30a scene of almost like a Lazy Susan. like these
- 19:35books being produced. And there were many books,
- 19:39many, many books. So we then fast forward in
- 19:42time to where he has slowed down on everything.
- 19:45He's really not publishing much. He's enjoying
- 19:46the fruits of his labor. And he is in a very
- 19:49different position now than he was before, where
- 19:51he was burning pages of books saying that may
- 19:55the warmth of burning these pages provide warmth
- 19:58to the men who tell truth. I'm paraphrasing,
- 20:02but like, you know. Trying to benefit from those
- 20:06lies to men who provide the truth. And that's
- 20:09what he wants to be. So then when everything
- 20:13happens with Alfred Dreyfuss, we see him, you're
- 20:17right, reluctantly taking on this case because
- 20:19that's not who he is. But he's been challenged
- 20:20by his old friend to be like, you've gotten old
- 20:23and comfortable. And what does that do for you?
- 20:26And it really starts ringing in his ears. So
- 20:29when he hears about this case. Originally, he's
- 20:31not interested. You know, hey, I don't really
- 20:33do that anymore. I'm just kind of enjoying my
- 20:34life. But then, when she starts providing more
- 20:37evidence, I say she, Alfred Dreyfuss' wife, starts
- 20:40providing more information of the misjustice,
- 20:43of the mishandling of this, he becomes more interested.
- 20:46And that sets off the events. But that being
- 20:49said, that's like 50 minutes into the movie.
- 20:52right? Because this is really a story of two
- 20:54halves. One is really kind of three. One is the
- 20:58story of Emile Zola. Two is the story of Alfred
- 21:02Dreyfus and how he even came to be convicted.
- 21:05And three is the actual courtroom, the hearing
- 21:08of Alfred Dreyfus. So you mentioned this up top.
- 21:12And I think we should talk about this pretty
- 21:14heavily. There is a lot of, in the story of this,
- 21:18or sorry, not the story, but the actual, this
- 21:20is a real thing that happened. Right. Right.
- 21:22In the real life event of this, there was a lot
- 21:24of antisemitism in this case. And that has been
- 21:28completely erased from this. Right. And this
- 21:32is something that we've seen many times. Hollywood
- 21:35has a reluctance to show. the effects of anti
- 21:40-semitism in their movies but they'll make plenty
- 21:42of movies about it uh the house of rothschild
- 21:47with um boy howdy what's his name you got it
- 21:50if i say disraeli does that help really george
- 21:53arliss yes there it is uh house of rothschild
- 21:56with george arliss very much a story about a
- 21:59jewish banker uh and and like the effects he
- 22:03had on history while overcoming anti -semitism
- 22:07But that is such a vague part of that story in
- 22:11Hollywood, the way that Hollywood has told it.
- 22:13It also kind of feels like Hollywood leaning
- 22:15too far into it to where it's like parody. Right.
- 22:18Yeah, there is that as well, where it almost
- 22:21feels like they're committing the crime instead
- 22:24of trying to speak about it. I don't know. They
- 22:26went so far in trying to solve racism that they
- 22:28were racist. Yes. And that's not what happens
- 22:32here. They kind of just don't really deal with
- 22:34it at all. They take that element out of it for
- 22:37the most part. And I think that this movie feels
- 22:40really, really sanitized and just sterile. And
- 22:44it lacks a lot of heart and meaning to me because
- 22:47you don't have those elements of it. Like, you
- 22:51have to really, really dig deep to have them
- 22:53implied on the movie. And all of the big beats,
- 22:57like the I accuse scene and all of that, or even
- 23:01Alfred Dreyfuss, like him. panicking when they're
- 23:05arresting him and and just screaming like i'm
- 23:09innocent i didn't do anything wrong like all
- 23:11of that lacks the bite that i think is necessary
- 23:13for this story because you're leaving out the
- 23:16most important part of the story what are we
- 23:19doing we just keep doing this yeah and we're
- 23:22gonna keep doing it and it's backwards um i'll
- 23:25say that that requires some context to really
- 23:28know and feel those uh To feel the emptiness
- 23:31of those things, right? I will say that I read
- 23:33this afterwards. I didn't know this going into
- 23:36the movie. So I read everything in the movie
- 23:39as is. Now, they do try, and I'm not giving the
- 23:43movie a compliment. I think this is actually
- 23:44kind of a mark against them. But they try to
- 23:48provide a little bit of context for this, where
- 23:51when they are accusing Alfred Dreyfuss, they
- 23:54do say, some people in the military say, well,
- 23:58he is from a different country. So there is a
- 24:00dialect difference here. So they are specifically
- 24:03pointing out that he is not of America. And I
- 24:07think they're trying to kind of do that thing
- 24:09where Hollywood is at least saying, well, maybe
- 24:12this is targeting just a little bit. But that's
- 24:14really the only time they mention it. Not of
- 24:16America? They say he's from a different country.
- 24:19Yeah. But you mean, like, why did you say America,
- 24:23though? They're in France? Is that what you meant?
- 24:25It is what I meant. Okay, that's fine if that's
- 24:27what you meant. I just was like. I completely
- 24:29forgot this is in France. It is France. I was
- 24:31like, when did they go to America? No. You watched
- 24:33the wrong movie. Yeah. No, so this, you're right.
- 24:36Thank you for calling me on that. It is in France.
- 24:40So they mentioned that he is not of the country.
- 24:42I see. And that he would then bring in some different
- 24:46thoughts. Right. Which even that is silly because,
- 24:50you know, obviously being Jewish doesn't mean
- 24:52you're from a specific country. Yeah. So I don't
- 24:55know. Any little bit that they tried, it was
- 24:58so lackluster and just ineffective. Yeah. I don't
- 25:03know. I'm tired of it, Ryan. It just doesn't
- 25:07make for a good movie, I don't think. I understand.
- 25:09And, you know, the unfortunate thing is I think
- 25:11sometimes when we talk about problems with movies
- 25:13at this time period, we can say, well, thankfully,
- 25:15this isn't going to be a problem for much longer.
- 25:17And that is not the case here. This is something
- 25:20that's going to continue for a while, unfortunately.
- 25:22So I think we're going to run into this a couple
- 25:26of times, and it's just going to have to be a
- 25:28mark against the movie. And there's really not
- 25:30much that we can do about it. The only way I
- 25:32can grade it beyond that is how effective it
- 25:35was, how effective the decisions they made were
- 25:37to the movie. And in this, it's fine. It's not
- 25:42like, to your point, it's not as impactful, but
- 25:44it's fine. And I get services as an okay. This
- 25:48is a distasteful comparison probably. Okay. But
- 25:51I almost look at it like when you go to watch
- 25:54a slasher horror movie and you sit down, you're
- 25:57watching it, a kill happens off screen. Yes.
- 26:01And you're just like, well, what was the point?
- 26:03Like if you're going to make your slasher horror
- 26:06movie, then you got to show the kill, you know?
- 26:08Like you've got to have the bite. You've got
- 26:10to have the attitude and the willingness to commit.
- 26:13So you're saying it's got to show its work. Yeah,
- 26:16like, exactly. Okay. And the answer is, well,
- 26:20I think that's the problem as well. It's not
- 26:21showing its work, but it's also not giving you
- 26:24the answer to the math problem at the end as
- 26:26well. How much of it do you think is the code?
- 26:29I don't think it's the code, really. I think
- 26:32it is Hollywood. Just, like, and politics of
- 26:36the time. Like, I think the politics of America.
- 26:41And the world at the time, we're talking 1937,
- 26:43you know, like the Nazi party is just coming
- 26:46into power. And like anti -Semitism is rampant
- 26:50throughout the entire world. Yeah. So I don't
- 26:54think that it's the code. I think it's just everything.
- 26:58See, the reason I asked if it's the code is maybe
- 27:00there's like a, we can't offend the French. or
- 27:05the French government. Yeah. We can't offend
- 27:09these things. And for this movie to play, we
- 27:11have to do these things and make these changes.
- 27:14I wonder how much of it is that. Because House
- 27:16of Rothschild, I think, was just on the edge
- 27:19of the code. So they could do a bit more with
- 27:22that. Yeah. So I wonder how much of that factors
- 27:25in here. I mean, all of the stuff where they
- 27:28do mock the military is left in this movie. That's
- 27:31true. It's all the anti -Semitism stuff that
- 27:33has taken out. No, you're right. It's just bizarre.
- 27:36And like, again, it's something that we've dealt
- 27:39with before. So it's not surprising. I think
- 27:41it just gets a little tiresome after you see
- 27:44it over and over again. Right. And this is a
- 27:48story that I feel like I could be interested
- 27:50in, you know, but the way that it's presented
- 27:52and leaving out like the important part. being
- 27:56the anti -Semitism. That's one element of why
- 27:59I don't think this is a very engaging story,
- 28:01but I also don't think that it's presented in
- 28:03an interesting way. The way you spend so much
- 28:06time with Emile Zola at the beginning of this
- 28:08movie, while he's going through his writing and
- 28:11his rise as a prominent author, it's boring,
- 28:15is what it is. I don't think Paul Muni is doing
- 28:19anything spectacular in the first 50 minutes
- 28:22of this movie. No, he's just good. Yeah, he's
- 28:25just kind of pretending to be this guy. And it
- 28:28doesn't even really feel like acting. It feels
- 28:29like he's just doing his thing. Because his only
- 28:31emotion being portrayed is, I'm a writer, and
- 28:35I'm going to keep writing. See, I'll push back
- 28:39a little bit. I think Paul Muni is good in this.
- 28:41I don't think he's great. I think he gets too
- 28:43good, is what it is. Sure, yeah. And I think
- 28:46he gets too good. That's a good point to put.
- 28:48But I think that he plays the... version of emil
- 28:53zola who is struggling and burning uh pages to
- 28:56keep warm which is a nice um a nice comparison
- 29:00a bookend to the story here of where we begin
- 29:03and where we end yeah and we'll get there but
- 29:05you see him struggling to stay warm and then
- 29:08you see him successful and you see him struggle
- 29:11to get successful this is where i think the movie
- 29:13really can cut some pages of how he started working
- 29:17how he became a publicized author or published
- 29:20author and Then we see him being successful and
- 29:24we see him, his friend, his longtime confidant,
- 29:26criticizing that and letting him know that he's
- 29:29gotten comfortable and that's not what he stood
- 29:31for before. So you see him kind of like combating
- 29:34that thought. But I agree when I think he really
- 29:37hits his stride is in the courtroom scenes when
- 29:39he starts like, you know, really defending the
- 29:41truth. So I appreciated his performance. I thought
- 29:45he had good range. Him being nominated feels
- 29:47more like a formality than like a... A really
- 29:51important thing. Paul Muni, to me, almost feels
- 29:54like his name just escaped me. Daniel Day -Lewis.
- 29:58Sure. Okay. Yeah. Where he's in very select roles,
- 30:03you know? Like, you don't see Daniel Day -Lewis
- 30:05just showing up in, like, a Marvel movie to play
- 30:08the villain. Sadly, that's true. Yeah. Yeah.
- 30:10God, I'd love to see him as Gore the God Butcher.
- 30:13I mean, I think he could do great stuff. Yeah.
- 30:15But, like, I'm okay with him choosing those roles,
- 30:19you know? Things that he's really passionate
- 30:21about. And we've talked about how Paul Muni has
- 30:23had like the ability with the studio, with Warner
- 30:26Brothers to choose what he wants to be. And he's
- 30:28had movies made because he said, well, I want
- 30:31to do that. So let's make it happen. Right. And
- 30:34I think, I think that those types of roles don't
- 30:38always work for me. It feels a lot like George
- 30:41Arliss where he, he's so into the role and not
- 30:46even just the role, but like. wants the project
- 30:49to be made so badly and has so many of his fingers
- 30:53in the pot, in the pie, in whatever, that it's
- 30:57just, I don't know, it feels misguided or like
- 31:01it didn't have enough of a collaborative effort.
- 31:05And that, you know, this isn't like Disraeli
- 31:07where George Arliss just led the charge throughout
- 31:10the entire movie. That's not what Paul Muni is
- 31:12doing here. But... I think just the type of actor
- 31:16he is, like that's the vibe I get. And then the
- 31:18movie, it almost feels claustrophobic to me.
- 31:21It doesn't feel like it has any legs to it. There's
- 31:24no room to breathe. You're just stuck in this
- 31:27story, watching it kind of drag on. And I don't
- 31:32know if there's any connective tissue to any
- 31:33of the negatives that I'm spouting out, or it's
- 31:35just like, this is how I felt when I was watching
- 31:37it. And I don't know why. Well, I think that...
- 31:41I'm glad that you said this is not Disraeli,
- 31:43because I agree. When you were making that comparison,
- 31:45my first thought is there are some moments in
- 31:47this that I think that Joseph Schildkraut does
- 31:51some incredible work as Alfred Dreyfus. There's
- 31:54one scene in particular that I'm really excited
- 31:56to talk about. And I feel like in Disraeli, they
- 31:59wouldn't even cut to that. They would just cut
- 32:02that part out because it doesn't involve George
- 32:04Artless. So in this, it feels a little more balanced.
- 32:08Balance is not a word that I want to give this
- 32:10movie easily, because I agree with what you said
- 32:14before, where when it shows the beginning of
- 32:17the authorship of Emile Zola, and then goes all
- 32:23the way up to, yeah, he's gotten really comfortable.
- 32:25Now, let's go to the Alfred Dreyfuss portion
- 32:29of the story. There was a moment. And I told
- 32:32you my DVD kind of like caused problems when
- 32:35I was watching this. Yeah, it did. There was
- 32:36a moment where I legitimately thought, is this
- 32:39a different movie? Like, we are just now completely
- 32:42in the French military. Yeah. Thank you. And
- 32:45we are now completely like away from Miozola.
- 32:48And we're not talking about him at all. And it's
- 32:50not until like maybe 20, 25 minutes into this
- 32:52story that we find, to provide some context,
- 32:56that there has been a traitor. within the French
- 33:00military, there's been some documents that went
- 33:02out, and they convicted Alfred Dreyfus because
- 33:06they thought he was guilty. But of course, they
- 33:09thought he was guilty for other reasons. In real
- 33:12life, the anti -Semitism played a big part of
- 33:14this. In the movie, they thought his handwriting
- 33:17looked similar, and he's of a different country,
- 33:19so they just said it's him. When it comes out
- 33:22that that's not the case, to the higher -ups
- 33:25in the military, They are now in panic because
- 33:28they say specifically, with people like Emile
- 33:30Zola, we cannot give them the benefit of being
- 33:34true and factual about this. We can't give them
- 33:36the benefit of being right. So we need to cover
- 33:39this up. And that's what they do. They cover
- 33:42it up and they exonerate some people. They try
- 33:45to make it look like, hey, this is 100 % what
- 33:47it is and button it up. And they can't hide the
- 33:49truth. So instead, that's where Emile Zola comes
- 33:52in. By the time that the courtroom scene actually
- 33:55happens, there's a scene that kind of, I think,
- 33:57marries the before and the after of the movie.
- 34:00And that is the IQ scene, where Miozola has been
- 34:04confronted by Mrs. Dreyfus and asked to represent
- 34:08her husband. And he said that he won't. But he
- 34:11reads a bit more about the case, thinks about
- 34:13those stinging words that his old friend has
- 34:15told him, and then decides to show up, coordinate,
- 34:19you know, Mrs. Dreyfus being there. He coordinates
- 34:23the lawyer, coordinate the publisher, a number
- 34:28of people in a room. And he stands there and
- 34:30gives a speech. And it's what I'm calling the
- 34:33IQ speech. And I'm calling it that. I think it's
- 34:37named that. Are you saying I accuse? Yes. Okay.
- 34:40I thought you were saying IQ. And I was like,
- 34:43no. Yeah. Jacuzzi. We'll say. I see. Jacuzzi.
- 34:47Jacuzzi. The IQs. I accuse. There you go. Scene.
- 34:53And this is the scene that I think marries the
- 34:55before and the after. And it's really them trying
- 34:58to like now say, OK, here's what the movie is.
- 35:00And from then on, I dug it. I thought this was
- 35:04great. Before that, I was just so confused as
- 35:07to what we were actually doing. And it's a lot
- 35:09of setup to get to this part. But I think that
- 35:11the courtroom scene and him representing Dreyfus.
- 35:15is really good, is really effective. It's fantastic
- 35:18courtroom scenes. It's not really something we've
- 35:21seen before this. We've talked about Mr. Deeds
- 35:23Goes to Town and how that has a pretty substantial
- 35:26courtroom scene. But I think it's mostly the
- 35:29Frank Capra version of it. In this one, it's
- 35:32a little bit more about the truth and not just
- 35:34how you see one person. Kind of that, but not
- 35:38really. I think there's a lot more to it than
- 35:40this. The corrupt nature of a military, I think,
- 35:44is completely on question and on trial in this.
- 35:47And I really enjoyed that. I think that it's,
- 35:50I'm going to say something unpopular so I can
- 35:53tell you something behind the scenes, but it's
- 35:55a good thing that de Terlay was behind this instead
- 35:58of the original director. Do you know who was
- 36:01supposed to direct this first? I do not. Ernst
- 36:05Lubitsch. You know, I gotta say, Ernst Lubitsch
- 36:10directed The Patriot, which nobody has seen.
- 36:13That's true. And that was a drama. So it's possible
- 36:16that he could do it. That's true. However, when
- 36:18we think of Ernst Lubitsch, that is not at all
- 36:20what I imagine him doing. The life of Emile Zola
- 36:23starring... Maurice Chevalier. Yeah, that's kind
- 36:29of what I was thinking, is him being like, no,
- 36:30no, no, on trial. I just imagine the sex worker
- 36:34that he comes into contact with. That would then
- 36:38be the movie. He'd be like, please, Emil, we
- 36:41need help getting my husband out of prison. And
- 36:43he's like, give me one moment. So I want to give
- 36:48credit where it's due with Ernst Lubitsch. He
- 36:50originally was given the screenplay for this
- 36:51movie. And he knew that Paul Muni was the best
- 36:54actor for the part. And he was like, it's got
- 36:55to be Paul playing the role of Emil Zola. So
- 36:58Muni was under contract to Warner Brothers. Lubitsch
- 37:03couldn't do that, so instead he actually sold
- 37:06the project to Warner Brothers. Wow. So they
- 37:08could film it with Paul Muni. See, and that's
- 37:11what I'm talking about with Paul Muni, where
- 37:13Ernst Lubitsch is like, you know what, Paul's
- 37:16the man. That's crazy. That's crazy to me. It's
- 37:19nuts. Yeah. But credit where it's due, he sold
- 37:24it instead of just holding on to it, which I
- 37:26think... Is cool, but it does, unfortunately,
- 37:29completely give in to your theory of how Paul
- 37:32Muni is just—he needs to be the— He's that guy.
- 37:35Yeah. Yeah. What kind of award do you think there
- 37:38is for selling the property that wins 10—or gets
- 37:43nominated 10 times? Producer. Yeah? But he didn't
- 37:46even produce. He gave up the rights to produce.
- 37:49But I think they should have given him, like—
- 37:52a co -producer or something like hey thanks for
- 37:54selling us this script we got you in the producer
- 37:56like if it won outstanding picture which it did
- 37:59or production rather like he gets a producer
- 38:01award that's what i think should happen and probably
- 38:04does happen now yeah they're probably like hey
- 38:06we gave you a producer award thanks for your
- 38:09help here uh otherwise they just are given a
- 38:11special thanks at the end of the credits he gets
- 38:13one of those pocket oscars it's just Like you
- 38:16put it on a lapel pin kind of thing? Yeah. He
- 38:19probably got that. He got a little pin. Or maybe
- 38:22he got a fruit basket that was like, hey, thanks.
- 38:24So this courtroom that I'm talking about, this
- 38:28is where Muni has a six -minute courtroom speech
- 38:31that's really effective. I don't think it's his
- 38:35best work. It's good. But I do think the I accuse
- 38:39scene is better work from Muni. I think that
- 38:43it ties a little bit more of... It's more interesting
- 38:46is the best way I'll put it. But also it's kind
- 38:48of the transformation of Zola. It's a transformation
- 38:51from I've been comfortable and I do this because
- 38:55it helps me make money. And now I actually have
- 38:57to use this to spread the gospel of the truth.
- 39:01I also skipped over this. There's a really funny
- 39:03scene to me. Maybe it's not intended to be funny.
- 39:06Where earlier on. When everything is coming out
- 39:09about Dreyfus, there's a newsboy outside waving
- 39:13the newspaper around, read all about it. Dreyfus
- 39:15convicted. And you just see Zola riding on the
- 39:18bike with his wife. And she's like, hey, did
- 39:21you hear about this Dreyfus thing? He's like,
- 39:22I don't want to hear anything about it. Is that
- 39:24fresh fish? And he just, like, pulls over, and
- 39:27he's, like, picking through the fish, and he's
- 39:29like, no, no, this one is dry and very old. This
- 39:33one is fresh. It's a good thing I'm here. I'm
- 39:36like, this is rocks. Because this is just fully
- 39:38leaning into, like, yeah, the truth, who cares?
- 39:41Check this fish out. Yeah. Rocks. I thought it
- 39:44was kind of, like, a damning thing for his character,
- 39:46so I really liked that. But also, you know, he's
- 39:49put on, I mean, a fat suit at this point, I'm
- 39:52guessing. He's completely transformed in the
- 39:56years that he's become that. I want to point
- 39:58something out to you, and I want to ask your
- 40:00thoughts. The cover of this movie is a completely
- 40:03clean -shaven Emile Zola that we do not see in
- 40:09this movie. We never see him. He is wearing a
- 40:11beard the entire time, hiding behind it almost.
- 40:13He doesn't even look like Paul Muni on the cover.
- 40:15Do we think that this was Hollywood being like,
- 40:19we cannot advertise a bearded Paul Muni? Isn't
- 40:22he... Bearded on the cover of the story of Louis
- 40:24Pasteur. That's what I'm confused about. Yeah.
- 40:26I don't know. I don't know what that is. They're
- 40:29like, we got to get butts in seats. And the way
- 40:31we do that is have that jawline shut. Because
- 40:32we shave Paul Muni. That should have been the
- 40:36title of the movie. The shaving of Paul Muni.
- 40:39That's what it should have been. Yeah. Well,
- 40:41actually, it shouldn't because he doesn't shave
- 40:42this entire movie. Well, that's the thing. People
- 40:45show up and they're like, can't wait till it
- 40:47happens. And then they sit through the two hours
- 40:49and they're like, wait a minute. They didn't
- 40:51shave him once. Yeah. What's going on here? That's
- 40:54so weird. Speaking of blades, there is a scene
- 40:58where Alfred Dreyfuss, he gets accused, right?
- 41:01Yes. And they take him out to be publicly shamed,
- 41:05basically. And whoever the military member is
- 41:10that is, like, taking away his medals and badges
- 41:14and things like that, he takes his sword and
- 41:17he snaps it over his knee. Yeah. What are those
- 41:20swords made out of? Or, not well, what is that
- 41:23guy's knee made out of? That's crazy, man. Now,
- 41:27hold on. Because if we're going to say that this
- 41:29guy had a bionic knee, that's way more interesting
- 41:32than anything in this movie. This is how Daniel
- 41:34Day -Lewis ends up in a Marvel movie. Because
- 41:37if they remake this and he plays that guy, the
- 41:41whole time you're watching, you don't know. You
- 41:43don't know what's going on. And then he takes
- 41:45a steel sword and snaps it over his knee and
- 41:49you're like, wait a minute. What's going on?
- 41:51And then you find out he's Batrock the Leaper
- 41:53or something like that. You know? I gotta give
- 41:59you so much credit. To pull out... I was impressed
- 42:02with Gore the God Butcher. To pull out that reference?
- 42:06Yeah, man. What did you just say? Batrock the
- 42:08Leaper? Batrock the Leaper? Yeah. Kudos. He's
- 42:12in the Captain America movies. You know what
- 42:13you're not gonna get in your other Oscar podcasts?
- 42:17Batrock the Leaper? Batrock the Leaper reference.
- 42:20God bless you for that. Yeah, he kicks. I got
- 42:24from the name The Leaper. I had a feeling that
- 42:26he's jumping and kicking probably. Is he a frog?
- 42:29He's just a guy. He's just a guy. He's just a
- 42:32guy. And he kicks a lot. Loves to kick. Yeah.
- 42:34He's in Captain America. He's in the second one.
- 42:37When he fights him on the boat. He's in Winter
- 42:39Soldier? You remember when Captain America, like
- 42:41he's attacking on the ship? Yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 42:43It's in the beginning. And then there's that
- 42:45one guy and he's like, oh, okay, let's do this,
- 42:48Cap. And then he fights the one guy. And it's
- 42:51like a bigger fight? Yeah. That's Batrock the
- 42:52Leaper. Just to confirm, his last name isn't
- 42:55The Leaper. No, that's like his name. Okay. Yes.
- 42:58They don't call him Batrock the Leaper in the
- 43:00movie. Yeah, God Butcher is not his last name.
- 43:03Yes. I'm just making sure that it's not like
- 43:05his name is Batrock, like Mr. The Leaper. No.
- 43:08Okay. Just Batrock. His father was The Leaper.
- 43:12Unfortunately, I'm trying to do an LMFAO Batrock
- 43:15anthem reference. It can't work. I see what's
- 43:18happening. It can't work. We're so good at what
- 43:20we do. Something like that. We're so good at
- 43:24this. I want to go ahead and mention that Alfred
- 43:27Dreyfuss, two awards were won for this movie
- 43:31of the 10 nominations we talked about. We mentioned
- 43:34that writing screenplay was one of the winners.
- 43:36Wow. The other was supporting actor for Joseph
- 43:39Schilkraut as Alfred Dreyfuss. And watching this
- 43:44movie, writing this down, I was like, that's
- 43:47really interesting. Until. Because he has sidelined
- 43:51for most of this movie. Until we get to the end
- 43:53of this movie. And his innocence has been proven.
- 43:57They have noted, without a shadow of a doubt,
- 44:01that the military has covered this up. And they
- 44:03are going to exonerate Dreyfus. Yes. And when
- 44:08they let him out of prison, he has a scene where
- 44:11he can't believe that he's finally out. Because
- 44:13it's been years on this island that you mentioned.
- 44:15Devil's Island. Devil's Island. Which creates
- 44:17problems. We'll, you know, look over that for
- 44:20right now. He is freed and they open the door
- 44:24for the cell and they just walk away. And they
- 44:27talk to him for a little bit and they leave.
- 44:29And he's just kind of standing there. And there's
- 44:31a moment where he's standing right at the door
- 44:34that he goes to reach for the bars that he's
- 44:36been holding onto for years. And he, it's not
- 44:39there. And he just kind of like drops his hands.
- 44:41And then he walks out and he goes to the window
- 44:44to look at the sun. And he stops himself and
- 44:47then he turns around and he does it again. And
- 44:49just to feel like the feeling again of leaving
- 44:53this cell and leaving his like his prisonment.
- 44:57And then he does it again. And this is where
- 45:00I was like, oh, that's why you won. Like that
- 45:02is a great scene. It's the storytelling of no
- 45:05words. And it is communicating all these emotions
- 45:08and feelings and sentiments. In just your actions.
- 45:13Yeah. I thought this was incredible. And this
- 45:16is where the movie is super uneven. Because he
- 45:18deserves that win. He was fantastic in that part.
- 45:21Just that scene alone. And he's kind of dog walking
- 45:24a bit of what Paul Muni is doing in this movie.
- 45:28Yeah. Because Paul Muni is a part of many words.
- 45:30This is a man who's performing for the very back
- 45:33row of the crowd. And instead, we have such a
- 45:36subtle performance from Schildkraut. I really
- 45:41liked his performance. I liked that scene a lot.
- 45:43And I just thought this was interesting. That
- 45:46in that one scene, he just kind of overpowers
- 45:48anything that Paul Muni was doing. To a point
- 45:51where, yeah, Paul Muni got the nomination, but
- 45:53he didn't win. So I thought it's a really nice
- 45:56and interesting fact to look at this movie. Look
- 46:00at all those nominations. A record -breaking
- 46:02movie at the time for those nominations. And
- 46:05yet... It was only Schildkraut that got the win
- 46:09here and not Me. I think that's really interesting
- 46:11for this movie. Yeah. And telling, maybe, is
- 46:15what I'm trying to say. Definitely telling. Yeah,
- 46:17I think that's what it is. That's something that
- 46:19happens a lot now, especially. You'll get a movie
- 46:22that's nominated for tons of Academy Awards and
- 46:24won't take home anything. Like, True Grit, I
- 46:28believe, was nominated for like seven awards
- 46:30or something and took home nothing. And that's
- 46:33just one example of... many many movies that
- 46:36do that same thing um but here it's like that
- 46:41does make sense i think that that scene alone
- 46:44is probably the standout scene when it comes
- 46:47to acting performances um and i think again for
- 46:52me personally these stories that are based on
- 46:54just words after words after words without any
- 46:58like stylistic choices or anything these kind
- 47:01of weigh on me. They don't, they don't provide
- 47:03much enjoyment or entertainment or, or stuff
- 47:07to really chew on after the movie. So that scene,
- 47:10I will give you, uh, and, and shield crowd credit
- 47:13for, yeah, that that's solid. It's a good moment.
- 47:16Um, it is far too little too late though. That's
- 47:20fair for me. Um, like it doesn't win the movie
- 47:23for you. Right, right. And you know, we're already.
- 47:27like 52 minutes in so we won't go down every
- 47:30nomination but i gotta say like my sure sure
- 47:33not really uh at the beginning with like art
- 47:36direction and sound recording it's like yeah
- 47:38like if you look at the movie like the set designs
- 47:42and everything they look solid they look good
- 47:44uh devil's island looks like a place that i wouldn't
- 47:47want to go hang out in so that's pretty effective
- 47:50based on name alone right yeah but unless you're
- 47:53talking tasmanian devils Ooh, Tasmanian Devil's
- 47:56Island sounds pretty sick. Yeah, right? That's
- 47:59pretty cool. Inco... No, what's the word I'm
- 48:02looking for? Incomprehensible. That's true. I'm
- 48:04not going to understand a word that's said when
- 48:06I'm on it. Could you imagine if it's like you
- 48:10are in prison to Tasmanian Devil Island and then
- 48:13it's nice, but you're just like, hey, do you
- 48:17know where... What's the special today? Yeah.
- 48:20That sounds lovely. Yeah. Honestly, when you
- 48:23said, could you imagine, I did imagine The Life
- 48:25of Emile Zola starring Tasmanian Devil. Yeah.
- 48:28Where it's just the I accused scene, but blah,
- 48:31blah, blah. He says so many words and the whole
- 48:35movie would just be that. In other news, go see
- 48:37Coyote vs. Acme. Yeah. Which is eerily really
- 48:42similar to what we just made a joke about. Is
- 48:44it? Well, it's a courtroom movie, so. Oh, yeah,
- 48:47yeah. I should have double featured that. I still
- 48:49have time. But, yeah, I just think that, like,
- 48:53it's one of those movies where you're looking
- 48:56at the nominations and you say, yeah, okay, I
- 48:58can see that. But there's no way that this is
- 49:02the movie that deserves the win for all of these.
- 49:05And in a year where they were picking less than
- 49:08five movies for a lot of this stuff, like, I
- 49:11don't think it would have shown up. That being
- 49:13said, for whatever reason, this won Best Picture
- 49:16this year. uh, or outstanding production. And
- 49:19I, for the life of me will, this will be an example
- 49:22of, I don't get it. And I think that's fair.
- 49:25Uh, I, I want to say that like, while I enjoyed
- 49:28the movie, it's not a rigging endorsement of,
- 49:31you know, Ryan loves this movie. I enjoyed it.
- 49:34And there's a lot of complications behind it.
- 49:36It has difficult history, mostly the, um, eradication
- 49:39of any kind of mention of antisemitism, which
- 49:43is of course very important to the story. And
- 49:45it's a very uneven film. Yes. I enjoyed the courtroom
- 49:50scenes a lot. I thought that it was a really
- 49:52good base level for what's to come. It was a
- 49:56good foundation for the future films that...
- 49:59perfect what courtroom drama should be yeah um
- 50:02and it's not even the best version of like a
- 50:04courtroom drama it's just we haven't seen courtroom
- 50:06dramas to this level yet we've only seen some
- 50:08mentions of it i mentioned mr d's goes to town
- 50:11a few other examples but this is like prominently
- 50:14it becomes the entire movie is courtroom drama
- 50:16yeah it's just a lot of setup to get there that
- 50:19setup is very uneven and you just don't really
- 50:22you can't tell where the focus is And I agree
- 50:24with you that the great scene from Schildkraut
- 50:28that is very good is a little too late to sway
- 50:32my opinion on the movie overall. Sure. So with
- 50:35that said, I'm comfortable telling you that I
- 50:39gave this three stars. Did you? I did. This was
- 50:42three and a half, if you noticed that. I did
- 50:44knock it down from our conversation. Yeah. But
- 50:47three stars, I'll be honest, the half star that
- 50:50I gave it was because of Schildkraut's performance.
- 50:54I really wanted to honor that, that scene that
- 50:57I liked a lot. But looking back on it, I think
- 50:59that the three stars that I'm giving it now does
- 51:02encompass that. And it's just a matter of this
- 51:05movie felt uneven. Muni's doing a good job, but
- 51:08it does feel a bit like, you know, a focus issue
- 51:11is the main problem that I have with it. So three
- 51:14stars feels... Right. And probably the most generous
- 51:17thing I can give this. I think so, too. It's
- 51:20I see the vision. I see what they're going for,
- 51:23but it causes some problems. Yeah, I've I've
- 51:26definitely said my piece on the movie and the
- 51:28courtroom stuff that you really enjoyed. I did
- 51:31not enjoy at all. I thought overall this movie
- 51:34was pretty boring. Oh, and just to clarify the
- 51:37the gas stove lapel pin joke I made that is in.
- 51:44reference to emil zola's death in this movie
- 51:48he makes a comment very early on in the movie
- 51:50about well that's how people leave their their
- 51:53gas stove burning all night and then they suffocate
- 51:57in the night he's always afraid of a draft yeah
- 52:00so that is like the most blatant obvious foreshadowing
- 52:03ever put onto film because that is how he dies
- 52:07later on in the movie he's writing a book yeah
- 52:09and that's how he dies in this movie and i think
- 52:11that foreshadowing is so lazy and just uninspired.
- 52:15But I gave this movie two stars. I don't like
- 52:18it. I don't ever want to watch it again. If I
- 52:21did, I would give it less stars, I'm sure. I
- 52:23just don't think it's very good. Yeah, that's
- 52:25a good way to put it. So double feature, do you
- 52:29want me to go first so you have time, or do you
- 52:30have one? Nope, I'm going to go first. Here's
- 52:32what I've got. This is a man who reluctantly
- 52:34comes out of doing what he used to do for the
- 52:39betterment of something. So I went with Jason
- 52:41Statham's The Beekeeper. He was retired, Ryan.
- 52:46He was retired. But he knew he had to do what
- 52:50was right. And God bless you for this. We don't
- 52:53get an opportunity to talk about The Beekeeper
- 52:55enough on this podcast. I think this is the second
- 52:58time we've talked about The Beekeeper on this
- 52:59podcast. That's not enough. But it is so much
- 53:02more than most podcasts. Do you think this movie
- 53:05would be better if Paul Muni was to throw a bottle
- 53:08of honey at someone and then set them ablaze?
- 53:11Yes. Yeah. Yeah. Especially. If he left that
- 53:15gas stove running. Molotov cocktail. Jar of honey
- 53:20at somebody. Explosions everywhere. The guy,
- 53:24Dreyfus goes to use his sword. And then it just
- 53:26snaps in half. And you're like, don't worry.
- 53:28I'll take care of it. It's the bees. Incredible
- 53:34moment in film history for Jason Statham to have
- 53:37to be like, before he throws honey at someone
- 53:39at a gas station, he's like, did you know that
- 53:41honey is flammable? And then throws it. Also,
- 53:45incredible end to that movie. I won't give it
- 53:47away. But the final shot of it being like, yeah,
- 53:50by the way, here's how he escaped. Unbelievable.
- 53:53Yeah. I love The Beekeeper. Man. I can't wait
- 53:56for Beekeeper 2. I was gonna say The Meg, but
- 53:58I couldn't remember if Jason Statham was retired
- 54:00in that movie. From punching sharks? Or like
- 54:03what? From, I don't know. Deep sea diving? What's
- 54:06his name? Yeah, he was a diver or something.
- 54:07I don't remember. I don't dive anymore. I gave
- 54:10it up three years ago. It's either dive or dive.
- 54:15That's the tech line. Yeah. Damn. That's good.
- 54:18Do I do a good Statham? I didn't realize that.
- 54:20We've done this before as well. And I think we
- 54:22both do good Stathams. I think we both do good
- 54:24Stathams. Maybe we should be in the next Jason
- 54:26Statham movie as Jason Statham. Just both of
- 54:28us. Yeah. Each scene is different. And we're
- 54:31both like, I retired from Jason Statham impressions.
- 54:34And everyone's like, yeah, as you should have.
- 54:37And I'm like, but damn it, you brought me back
- 54:39in. What's your double feature? Damn, I wish
- 54:43it was Jason Statham something. Mine's Just Mercy.
- 54:47It's Destin Daniel Cretton's movie from 2019.
- 54:51This is, of course, the director who just broke
- 54:53some records for Spider -Man Brand New Day. And
- 54:57in 2019, he made a film called Just Mercy with
- 54:59Michael B. Jordan, Jamie Foxx, and Brie Larson
- 55:02about the, again, real -life story of Harvard
- 55:06-educated lawyer Bryan Stevenson, who was wrongly
- 55:12condemned and was brought down in a courtroom
- 55:17and was defended to try and save his life and
- 55:21save his innocence. And this to me felt like
- 55:24a good comp because of this is the best parts
- 55:26of the movie to me, I thought. And I think that's
- 55:30how the movie should be remembered. And I want
- 55:33to pair it with a movie that I think embraces
- 55:34that a bit more and evenly, which is Just Mercy.
- 55:37I can't believe that came out in 2019. I know.
- 55:40Well, that was before the pandemic. So it was
- 55:42somewhere between six. No, sorry. Somewhere between
- 55:46seven and 50 years ago. Right. Yeah. That's so
- 55:49wild. I feel like that trailer for that movie
- 55:52just came out and I was like, yeah, I'll probably
- 55:54catch that. And that was seven years ago. Do
- 55:58you ever play that game where you're like, yeah,
- 56:00it's that movie where Killmonger defends Electro
- 56:05in court with the help of Captain Marvel? Yeah.
- 56:07Yeah. I like doing that. Directed by the guy
- 56:10who does Spider -Man in a couple of years and
- 56:11Shang -Chi. Wow. Yeah. No, I have fun doing that
- 56:15a lot where, you know. This is the greatest show.
- 56:19And the blades come out. Yeah. So that's the
- 56:26life of Emile Zola. And honestly, that's about
- 56:29as coherent of the life of Emile Zola as the
- 56:31movie makes it. Yeah. I don't know. It's a story
- 56:34that I hope that I get an opportunity to learn
- 56:37about in a more educational way. Truthful. Yeah.
- 56:41And just impactful way. Because to me, this was
- 56:44just not it. And really. When I talk about it
- 56:48that way, I don't think it was it for you either.
- 56:51No, I definitely don't take it as a truthful
- 56:53thing. And honestly, it's very hypocritical of
- 56:55the movie to be preaching the power of truth
- 56:58and be eradicating or leaving out a very important
- 57:04detail of this. I agree. But if you have seen
- 57:07this movie and you have thoughts on it, and you
- 57:11want us to read those thoughts on the show. Not
- 57:14Bryce. Shoot us an email at OUTAOPodcast at gmail
- 57:18.com. We go over those every ceremony episode
- 57:22at the end of every month. And we are looking
- 57:25forward to reading more thoughts from you listeners.
- 57:28Also, if you would like to support the show financially,
- 57:30that does help us just do better, be better.
- 57:34You can check out patreon .com. O -U -T -A -O
- 57:38podcast. We have early episodes. We have movie
- 57:42reviews. We have access to the community discord.
- 57:45And we, of course, have our bonus podcast, Horror
- 57:48of the Overlooked, where we talk about all of
- 57:50the horror movies that were released the years
- 57:53we are covering. Beyond that, next episode, we
- 57:56will be covering, or beyond that, next episode,
- 58:00we will be speaking about Dead End, the William
- 58:03Wyler kind of sort of gangster movie. I'm looking
- 58:08forward to talking about that one. It should
- 58:09be a great time, and you are bearing the lead
- 58:11that Humphrey Bogart shows up in a pretty substantial
- 58:16moment. Yes, he does. So, until next time, I'm
- 58:21Kyle. I'm Ryan. And we'll see you at the movies.