Latest / The KAJ Masterclass LIVE / Explained: Beyond Reasonable Doubt
Transcript
- 0:32Welcome to this very special edition of the cage, a
- 0:35masterclass, the show, which ensures that you profit from
- 0:38your time. Spent here with experts, either
- 0:40through the industry, insights information, or simply learning
- 0:44from them. In today's episode of our
- 0:48special series called seven minutes with be awake soon,
- 0:50we'll be talking about what is meant by prosecution.
- 0:54Must prove, its case Beyond Reasonable Doubt for the accused
- 0:56to be convicted and punished Sosa.
- 1:00First question is the top it says, so if you can tell it for
- 1:04our viewers, Liberty of an individual is sacrosanct.
- 1:13And Liberty of a citizen. Who is accused of a crime?
- 1:21Can be taken away only by following the due process of
- 1:27law. As a part of the due process of
- 1:33law. we follow the fundamental principle of criminal,
- 1:41jurisprudence that is The prosecution must prove its case
- 1:51Beyond a reasonable doubt before an accused is convicted and
- 1:59punished. now, this implies that if there is a doubt in the case
- 2:10of the prosecution, The accused or to be acquitted.
- 2:17Because Liberty is sacrosanct. Only when the prosecution by
- 2:24evidence is able to prove Beyond Reasonable Doubt, which means
- 2:31there is no doubt that it is the accused and only the accused who
- 2:36has committed the crime only then will he be convicted and
- 2:41punished by law? Right now at investing Lee this
- 2:48principle is stated in different ways.
- 2:53For example, you have the Blackstone Ian principle, which
- 2:58says Ten guilty men, may go scot-free, but one innocent
- 3:06should not be incarcerated, convicted and punished for a
- 3:13crime. Then you know, this principle
- 3:18has been stated also in terms of hundred guilty men, we go
- 3:25scot-free but been fun, you know, st.
- 3:28Man should not be convicted and punished.
- 3:32Right? The Genesis of this principle.
- 3:37You know, goes back various centuries and where the priests,
- 3:43you know, from the church were part of the jewelry.
- 3:49And they were asked to try the accused and therefore this
- 3:56principle was evolved because you know they thought that it
- 4:01would be the greatest sin to punish an innocent man.
- 4:06So therefore this principle of Beyond Reasonable Doubt is
- 4:12embedded in our criminal justice system, I can say it is the
- 4:18back. Born of the Criminal Justice
- 4:21System. Right, right, so if you look at
- 4:25it that way, then prosecution has to prove Beyond Reasonable
- 4:29Doubt and the defense has to just create that the accused may
- 4:34not have done anything. And cures accuse need not prove
- 4:40his innocence, he has to only find the doubt, show a doubt in
- 4:46the case of the prosecution in the mind of the judge to slice
- 4:50your Twitter. Yes, sir.
- 4:53So applying this with this particular principle so that
- 4:56that means that some criminals both scot-free.
- 5:02Yes, yes. Some criminals do go, scot-free
- 5:09by applying this principle. But, you know, I am reminded of
- 5:15Famous words of John Adams, the famous John Adams.
- 5:20And he said that when an innocent man is punished He
- 5:29loses trust in the criminal justice system, right?
- 5:33You know, imagine and he knows him the man in jail.
- 5:37He says. What is good of honesty?
- 5:41What is good? Okay, no sense.
- 5:43If I am to be incarcerated and put behind bars and then John
- 5:49Adams, in the famous Boston Massacre case, Boston bombing
- 5:54case, he said that since time immemorial criminals Have have
- 6:03been laid off, that's fine, that's part.
- 6:08But for an innocent man to be in cancer, AJ and punished for a
- 6:13crime that he has not committed. it's a disgrace to the criminal
- 6:18justice system, you know, it is it it I would say it hits
- 6:25criminal jurisprudence, it hits at the edifice of criminal law,
- 6:31criminal justice, Right, sir? Right?
- 6:35With so much of care. That no innocent should be
- 6:38punished. What is your experience, sir?
- 6:40In our criminal justice system? Do you know sense also sometime
- 6:44get punished? That's a philosophical question.
- 6:50with my experience of three decades as a criminal side
- 6:54Council, as a defense counsel, I do find that in some cases.
- 7:02You know, sense to get convicted and punished.
- 7:07In our criminal justice system. we follow the principle of
- 7:13sheriff and grain, which means It is the judges Duty.
- 7:20Who separated the falsity is and truthfulness.
- 7:25From the evidence of witnesses. Now, this is not an easy task.
- 7:31It is almost a Divine function to separate falsities and route
- 7:37from the evidence of a witness. Therefore, there are times when
- 7:44judges do earth, and you know, sense, do get convicted at times
- 7:52judges are humans. After all, you know, they are
- 7:55not gods. So therefore while it is said
- 8:01that no innocent man should be incarcerated, it is also said
- 8:07that no criminal should go unpunished.
- 8:11So, when these twin objectives are sought to be fulfilled, and
- 8:16when, you know, there is wholesale, perjury, false
- 8:21evidence is part of the criminal justice system in India.
- 8:27The Supreme Court has said time and again we hardly come across
- 8:32a witness. Whose testimony does not contain
- 8:35falsity is embellishments exaggerations.
- 8:39So when the judge has to Separate the shape and the grain
- 8:43you know, sense sometimes to get punished and convicted,
- 8:49unfortunately, energy. I have delved into this topic in
- 8:53detail, in my upcoming book on the criminal justice system in
- 8:58India, right survive. Then we look forward towards
- 9:01that book and we'll talk separately on.
- 9:04Exactly what are the remedies for a person who feels that he
- 9:07has been wrongly. Convicted.
- 9:09Thank you very much sir.