Latest / Legally Speaking with Michael Mulligan / Indigenous Title vs. Private Property: The Cowichan Tribes Decision Explained
Transcript
- 0:00Adam Stirling: It's time for Legally Speaking.
- 0:01Adam Stirling: Hey Michael, are you with us?
- 0:03Michael Mulligan: I certainly am.
- 0:04Michael Mulligan: I'm direct from Pompeii, italy, and it looks like we've managed to get a good connection going through the miracle of the cell phone network.
- 0:11Adam Stirling: That's a solid connection.
- 0:13Adam Stirling: Anyway, interesting story on our agenda today because I know that you and I have talked in the past about various complicated, lengthy legal issues involving Indigenous rights and title, and the Cowichan Tribes issue is in the news, as you well know, the province is already announcing they're going to appeal.
- 0:29Adam Stirling: Can you help us understand exactly what's happening here?
- 0:35Michael Mulligan: and how it relates to the idea of private property.
- 0:36Michael Mulligan: Sure Well, first of all it's a huge decision.
- 0:38Michael Mulligan: I mean I think the case may have set a Canadian record for the longest trial it was some 500 plus days of trial and this enormous 800 page decision that came out of that.
- 0:49Michael Mulligan: And the case involved a claim for a whole bunch of property over in Richmond and interestingly, as with many of these things, there's a conflict in part between different Indigenous groups claiming the same territory.
- 1:08Michael Mulligan: So that's a broad background to it.
- 1:11Michael Mulligan: But part of what's in this case has caused some very serious concern about what implications it could have more broadly in terms of property ownership in British Columbia.
- 1:22Michael Mulligan: And to appreciate all that, it has to start with an explanation for why it is you own property in British Columbia, right?
- 1:29Michael Mulligan: Why do you own your house, if you own a house?
- 1:32Michael Mulligan: And the answer to that in BC and most Canadian provinces not all but most is that we have a version of what's called the Torrens system, and the Torrens system is a government registry which lists who owns real property.
- 1:49Michael Mulligan: And the core concept with the Torrens system is it grants what's referred to as indefeasible title to property.
- 1:57Michael Mulligan: It's conclusive ownership of the property, and what's different about that is that in places where you don't have that sort of a system, your claim to ownership of property would depend on the claim of ownership the last person had and the person before them and the person before them right.
- 2:16Michael Mulligan: And so you would need to go back and look and say, look, can I purchase this property from you?
- 2:22Michael Mulligan: You would need to be assured that that person has legal title to it.
- 2:25Michael Mulligan: And how did they get that?
- 2:27Michael Mulligan: And so you'd have to go back through the chain to try and figure it out.
- 2:30Michael Mulligan: The touring system does away with that completely, and it says that if you're listed as the owner of property in British Columbia or other places that have that, that is conclusive proof.
- 2:43Michael Mulligan: You own the property.
- 2:45Michael Mulligan: Now that matters both in terms of the complications of transferring property, but it also has real implications for things like let's imagine you want to get a mortgage to purchase property or build a home or do something.
- 2:57Michael Mulligan: The person lending money on the strength of the mortgage needs to be assured that you in fact own the property, so that they could, if you didn't pay them back, collect right.
- 3:09Michael Mulligan: And if that's uncertain, you're also not only would you have trouble potentially selling something, but you may have trouble borrowing against it, or your cost of borrowing will be higher because the lender will be uncertain about whether you know.
- 3:21Michael Mulligan: Can you really be sure you own this thing?
- 3:22Michael Mulligan: And so that's the Turing system.
- 3:25Michael Mulligan: And so this is how it interferes with this Cowichan decision.
- 3:31Michael Mulligan: We have in Canada since 1982, provision section 35 of the Constitution Act, and it says this the existing Aboriginal and treaty rights of the Aboriginal peoples of Canada are hereby recognized and affirmed.
- 3:48Michael Mulligan: There's some more detail below that, but that's really what it says.
- 3:51Michael Mulligan: What does that mean?
- 3:52Michael Mulligan: Right?
- 3:53Adam Stirling: Yeah.
- 3:54Michael Mulligan: It's really very ambiguous.
- 3:55Michael Mulligan: And so since 1982, courts have been going on and trying to interpret well, what all does that mean?
- 4:03Michael Mulligan: On in trying to interpret, well, what all does that mean?
- 4:07Michael Mulligan: And I should say, as somebody who works in the sausage factory, at the courthouse, that sort of thing goes on all the time in terms of judges trying to, you know, specify what the law is.
- 4:16Michael Mulligan: And there are some areas, for example in civil law, where much of the law is that it's sort of the common law built up over hundreds of years with things like well, what do you need to have a contract and what do you do in this particular circumstance?
- 4:28Michael Mulligan: Or what are the elements of the court?
- 4:30Michael Mulligan: All these things have been developed slowly over time and that's how the common law works.
- 4:36Michael Mulligan: And one of the, I should say, sort of beauties of the law is that generally, the law conforms with what most reasonable people who would think carefully about an issue would think yeah, that's probably how that should work out.
- 4:50Michael Mulligan: Right, that seems like a fair thing, right, it's sort of how contract law works.
- 4:55Michael Mulligan: Or, you know, tort law, in terms of putting somebody right if you cause them some harm or damage.
- 4:59Michael Mulligan: It all sort of generally conforms with.
- 5:01Michael Mulligan: Yeah, that seems like a fair outcome and how people expect their lives to be ordered.
- 5:07Michael Mulligan: Now this particular case has raised real concerns.
- 5:10Michael Mulligan: Now that you know that background, the Torrance system, why you own your property and that provision, and here's the heart of it, the judge in this case says I agree that Aboriginal title is a prior and senior right to land.
- 5:24Michael Mulligan: It is not an estate granted by the crown but rooted in prior occupation.
- 5:28Michael Mulligan: And then it goes on reversed.
- 5:30Michael Mulligan: The proper question is what remains a fee?
- 5:33Michael Mulligan: Simple title after aboriginal title is recognized in the same lands.
- 5:47Michael Mulligan: And then it goes on and essentially what the judge finds is the fact that the person, a person, may be a registered owner of land and the fact that the touring system says that's conclusive proof you own it.
- 5:59Michael Mulligan: You can't go behind that.
- 6:01Michael Mulligan: The judge found that no Aboriginal title can still exist for that same land.
- 6:08Michael Mulligan: Now one of the great uncertainties about that is what is Aboriginal title?
- 6:13Michael Mulligan: That hasn't been clearly defined.
- 6:15Michael Mulligan: Many of the concepts here have just been judicially invented since 1982, because the provision we're dealing with says the existing Aboriginal treaty rights of the Aboriginal peoples of Canada are hereby recognized and affirmed.
- 6:32Michael Mulligan: So all of the law that's developed since then.
- 6:35Michael Mulligan: All this concept of Aboriginal title, concepts of the honour of the crown, all these things which have been found in the law since then, are all judge-created, all of it.
- 6:50Michael Mulligan: And one of the worries here is that this outcome and each judge when they get one of these cases, is looking at the prior decisions and trying to come up with a rational decision that fits within the previous decisions.
- 7:01Michael Mulligan: And it's all fine as far as all that goes.
- 7:04Michael Mulligan: That's what they're, of course, trying to do.
- 7:06Michael Mulligan: But the challenge here is that the outcome of that accretion of sort of principles and ideas and things that have been built up since 1982, if this case remains the law, what that may effectively mean is you don't own your house anymore because you've got Aboriginal claims that virtually cover the entire province several times over.
- 7:30Michael Mulligan: And either Aboriginal title means nothing right.
- 7:33Michael Mulligan: If it means nothing, the Aboriginal groups couldn't use the land or do anything with it.
- 7:39Michael Mulligan: Probably that's not what's intended.
- 7:42Michael Mulligan: Eventually it means nothingness.
- 7:43Michael Mulligan: So if it means something and you've got this conclusion that it takes priority over the simple ownership of land, it doesn't matter that you bought it for value, that the chain of people that have owned it for a very long time it could simply be rendered meaningless, and that's the natural conclusion of this decision.
- 8:09Michael Mulligan: And while the grievance of this particular case we're careful not to try to actually give this area claim includes things like farms and houses and so on.
- 8:20Michael Mulligan: And so they were.
- 8:22Michael Mulligan: Because the conclusion of that would be, I think, probably completely contrary to what most people would think of as a sort of the expected outcome of this sort of dispute.
- 8:34Michael Mulligan: Right and unlike you know many areas where you say, yeah, that's the answer to how a contract worked, that's sort of what accord with how you think that would work if you were buying yourself a car or doing something.
- 8:44Michael Mulligan: Right.
- 8:44Michael Mulligan: If the outcome of all of this, the judicial interpretation of that terminology or that general phraseology in Section 35, results in a conclusion that that house you worked your whole life to pay for is not yours, somebody else is free to come in and set up in the backyard or move into your living room.
- 9:07Michael Mulligan: If that's the outcome and that seems to be what the judge has found here by putting together these sort of principles and these other cases since 1982.
- 9:17Michael Mulligan: That is a very problematic outcome, because not only would it undermine sort of the economic functioning of the province as a whole, because, first of all, people wouldn't be able to reliably own property, people that have worked and paid for things would no longer get the benefit of them.
- 9:35Michael Mulligan: And furthermore, going forward, if you are a lender, are you going to lend somebody money on the strength of title, which could be meaningless, because three or four or more Indigenous groups are claiming that they have title to that land?
- 9:50Michael Mulligan: Whatever that means, probably not.
- 9:52Michael Mulligan: And so it is potentially very broad-reaching implications, potentially seriously destabilizing implications, and it is exactly that.
- 10:05Michael Mulligan: It's just sort of the next accretion of sort of the well, these are the principles that Bud Springford attended this case.
- 10:11Michael Mulligan: You put those together.
- 10:12Michael Mulligan: It must mean this, it can't mean that, it can't mean that, and then you wind up with this result which, unfortunately, in my view, is not one of those results that would generally accord with what people would think.
- 10:24Michael Mulligan: Yeah, that's about how that should work.
- 10:35Michael Mulligan: It's a result, again, working in a sausage factory is that the justice system works because people generally, you know, agree with the outcomes.
- 10:44Michael Mulligan: Right, in a broad sense.
- 10:45Michael Mulligan: Right, you might not agree with a particular case, but you know, okay, fair enough, that's how that works.
- 10:49Michael Mulligan: This is the sort of decision which, if it was not reversed on appeal and it was carried to its logical conclusion would not be that, and that's very troublesome from the perspective of the rule of law and respect for judicial decisions, because I would imagine that this would not be something that's likely to be generally accepted by the population.
- 11:13Michael Mulligan: If I tell you that that house you worked for and paid for is no longer yours, I don't know that that's generally going to be accepted, and so that's really the heart of it.
- 11:23Michael Mulligan: That's what the torrent system is, and the judge in this case has found that, despite the fact that that legislation says that's yours and no looking behind that, has found that, oh, there's a way to look behind that.
- 11:35Michael Mulligan: Has found that, oh, there's a way to look behind that.
- 11:38Michael Mulligan: And we'll have to wait and see, of course, what happens with the appeal to the Court of Appeal and eventually probably to the Supreme Court of Canada.
- 11:46Michael Mulligan: But everyone involved there, I think, should also just be aware that you know, even if something might make logical sense or fit together with other previous decisions of the court, if the eventual result is a result that would not be broadly accepted by the public, it's not going to work Because at the end of the day, we're just people up there in robes and ties and stuff.
- 12:10Michael Mulligan: It's not going to work unless you have a decision which is going to be broadly accepted.
- 12:15Michael Mulligan: I don't know that this outcome is likely to be that, so that's why there's been concern about it.
- 12:21Michael Mulligan: That's what's happened in this case, and we'll have to wait and see what happens, of course, with the one or two levels of appeal, whether this gets reversed in some fashion or whether they, of course, decide to proceed in this way.
- 12:35Michael Mulligan: So that's what's going on in that decision.
- 12:39Adam Stirling: All right.
- 12:39Adam Stirling: Couch and Tribes decision under appeal according to the province of British Columbia.
- 12:44Adam Stirling: Quick break.
- 12:44Adam Stirling: Legally Speaking continues.
- 12:45Adam Stirling: After this, Legally Speaking continues.
- 12:47Adam Stirling: Michael Mulligan from Mulligan Defense Lawyers.
- 12:49Adam Stirling: We've got just over four minutes left in today's segment, Michael.
- 12:53Adam Stirling: How shall we spend them?
- 12:55Michael Mulligan: Sure, I think there's another case.
- 12:57Michael Mulligan: People may have some interest in rising out of a door dasher and how that fits in with arbitration, and the case involved a fellow who was a dasher not dashing, but a dasher which you can sign up for on an app and then you do deliveries and get paid for that work.
- 13:16Michael Mulligan: And this fellow had signed up in 2022 to do that and had done it for a couple of years and then, for reasons unknown, or at least not specified in his decision, doordash decided to cancel his account, so he could no longer be a DoorDasher, and that prompted the fellow to sue DoorDash for a variety of things, including, for some reason, he was asking for 12,960 hours of work at $50 an hour, for he wanted $648,000, along with plus wear and tear in his car, various other things Wow.
- 13:51Michael Mulligan: And he specified that he was suing for as a result of breaches of the charter rules against discrimination, hate and defamation.
- 13:59Michael Mulligan: So, anyways, that's what he was suing for as a result of breaches of the charter rules against discrimination, hate and defamation.
- 14:03Michael Mulligan: So, anyways, that's what he was suing for.
- 14:04Michael Mulligan: But the particular decision dealt with the applicability of an arbitration provision and the way that worked.
- 14:08Michael Mulligan: In this case, as in many cases where you'd agree to use software, an app or something, you have to scroll through and say I agree, I agree, I agree to a bunch of things if you wish to be able to continue to sign up to do anything.
- 14:20Michael Mulligan: And this particular agreement had in it an arbitration clause which said that both parties agreed to, if they had any disputes, settle it by way of arbitration rather than going to court.
- 14:32Michael Mulligan: One of the interesting things here in that clause and it probably has to do with DoorDash being sensitive to their position that people who do that work are not employees.
- 14:42Michael Mulligan: They're independent contractors and free to negotiate things.
- 14:46Michael Mulligan: They actually say in here you can opt out of the arbitration provision.
- 14:50Michael Mulligan: There's a way you can do that if you want to write in.
- 14:52Michael Mulligan: As he wished to opt out of it.
- 14:53Michael Mulligan: This fellow hadn't done that, and so DoorDash applied to have the court claim struck out on the basis of how the Arbitration Act works.
- 15:04Michael Mulligan: And that act essentially says that if you establish some basic things, like there was an arbitration agreement, one of the parties has started an action, the other party hasn't taken steps in the action, like you can't get into day five of the trial, realize it's not going well and then say you't taken steps in the action, like you can't get into day five of the trial, realize it's not going well and then say you wish to go to arbitration.
- 15:22Michael Mulligan: Right, you haven't done anything, you can apply for the court action to be stayed and discontinued.
- 15:29Michael Mulligan: So the matter would be sent to arbitration.
- 15:31Michael Mulligan: And that's exactly what happened here.
- 15:35Michael Mulligan: The digital treasury, yeah, appears to be an arbitration agreement.
- 15:38Michael Mulligan: It wasn't opted and opted out of it.
- 15:39Michael Mulligan: They both appear to be parties to it.
- 15:41Michael Mulligan: Doordash hasn't taken any steps in the litigation and so they're applying to have it struck out.
- 15:48Michael Mulligan: That is to say, the court claim and that was the outcome.
- 15:54Michael Mulligan: And so people should be aware of this when they're scrolling through those contract provisions, clicking yes, yes, yes.
- 16:03Michael Mulligan: In some cases you may actually have a remedy at the time to say I wish to be out of this, but if you don't, you may wind up agreeing to all sorts of things that could have implications for you later.
- 16:14Michael Mulligan: Remember Seinfeld used to joke that people scrolled.
- 16:17Michael Mulligan: You could insert the entire text of Mein Kampf into the agreement.
- 16:21Michael Mulligan: The person would start tapping I agree, I agree, I agree, and that's probably not too far from the truth.
- 16:26Michael Mulligan: So that's something to be aware of how that arbitration act works in British Columbia.
- 16:31Michael Mulligan: Be careful about what you're clicking and signing on, because the result could be you won't be able to advance your charter claim for 12,000 hours of work for DoorDash.
- 16:41Michael Mulligan: If you've clicked, I accept.
- 16:44Adam Stirling: Michael Mulligan, with Mulligan Defense Lawyers, legally speaking, second half of our second hour every Thursday.
- 16:48Adam Stirling: Thank you so much.
- 16:49Adam Stirling: Pleasure as always.
- 16:50Adam Stirling: Thanks so much.
- 16:51Adam Stirling: It's always great to be here.