Latest / Forward | Better Athletes. Better People. / FWD | Private School vs. Public School: Making the Right Choice for Your Athlete
Transcript
- 0:10Welcome to Forward, a podcast from Hard Knock Press where we explore the ideas, stories, and conversations that help build better athletes and better people.
- 0:21I'm Kevin Mulhern alongside Joe Clemente.
- 0:24Let's get started
- 0:26Kevin T. Mulhearn: Welcome to FWD, a podcast for better athletes and better people I'm Kevin Mulhern.
- 0:32Kevin T. Mulhearn: My co-host is Coach Joe Clemente.
- 0:35Kevin T. Mulhearn: Welcome to episode four,"High School Baseball Today: What Parents Need to Know." A topic near and dear to your heart, I'm sure, Joe.
- 0:44Joe Clemente: Oh, yeah
- 0:45Kevin T. Mulhearn: So obviously y- you've been coaching for years in the Jersey baseball program and Don Bosco Prep.
- 0:50Kevin T. Mulhearn: We're not gonna focus exclusively on Jersey'cause hopefully this podcast will reach an audience, uh, beyond New Jersey and to other states in this country.
- 0:59Kevin T. Mulhearn: So we wanna just focus a little bit on, the difference between the threshold decisions that, that kids make.
- 1:06Kevin T. Mulhearn: I know in New Jersey it's a pretty, momentous decision as to whether or not to send your kid, to play baseball or other sports, at a private school, Catholic school, or, a public school.
- 1:19Kevin T. Mulhearn: And that's a threshold decision right off the bat that, you have to make, when your child is about in eighth grade.
- 1:26Kevin T. Mulhearn: and you really probably need to be thinking about it a lot sooner than that.
- 1:30Kevin T. Mulhearn: Probably in seventh grade you're seeing where his or her development is and making the decision as what's a good fit for this kid athletically, academically, and everything else, right?
- 1:40Kevin T. Mulhearn: what do you think parents need to think about, when they're making that decision?
- 1:44Kevin T. Mulhearn: What are the k- the key things that parents need to focus on?
- 1:48Joe Clemente: So most of the time, parents come up to me and they talk to me and they ask me that question, right?
- 1:53Joe Clemente: "How do I know what to choose?" Every individual, every athlete's different, okay?
- 1:58Joe Clemente: I would tell you that my answer to them is always pretty simple, okay?
- 2:03Joe Clemente: As you know me, I try to keep things simple.
- 2:06Joe Clemente: first and foremost is grades, right?
- 2:07Joe Clemente: Like, where are they academically?
- 2:10Joe Clemente: if they feel like that their, their academics is where they need to be and they're maturing in the right direction, that, that could be one of the factors.
- 2:21Joe Clemente: Most of the f- most of the time, the factors that parents come to me are always about athletics, right?
- 2:28Joe Clemente: "What do I need to do?
- 2:30Joe Clemente: h- is my kid good enough to play here?" Again, talking about what you just said, most of them start, I would say, in middle school.
- 2:38Joe Clemente: That's when they start to think about it, right?
- 2:40Joe Clemente: Because they get through that 11, 11U, 12U year, right?
- 2:44Joe Clemente: The 12U can actually-- you could actually be in seventh grade and starting to play middle school baseball, which is 60/90, which is on the big field, which you and I both know is a great equalizer.
- 2:56Joe Clemente: So that will determine athletically, and I'm just talking about baseball right now, of whether or not you start to see the growth physically, and the maturity in each athlete.
- 3:08Joe Clemente: that's really what it comes down to.
- 3:10Joe Clemente: again, the answer for the, for, the athlete or the parents, it's, it, it's different for each one because you have to take each case and say,"Hey, this is what I see.
- 3:21Joe Clemente: This is what we know." Add it all up, and figure out the equation, and then go from there.
- 3:27Joe Clemente: That's really what it comes down to.
- 3:30Kevin T. Mulhearn: And wouldn't you agree that th- there's also a matter of, what level of risk is acceptable for you?
- 3:34Kevin T. Mulhearn: 'Cause let's face it, it's a, a hell of a lot riskier sending your kid to play baseball i- in New Jersey at one of the, the top private schools, Don Bosco Prep, Delbarton, St.
- 3:44Kevin T. Mulhearn: Joe's, Bergen Catholic, DePaul.
- 3:47Kevin T. Mulhearn: Those schools are all powerhouses.
- 3:49Kevin T. Mulhearn: They have kids-- Many kids play in Division I baseball, many kids play in Division II and III baseball.
- 3:55Kevin T. Mulhearn: Those are really tough programs to play in, and there's a risk factor going in.
- 4:00Kevin T. Mulhearn: I could tell you it's, it's interesting when Dennis was 12, he was in sixth or seventh grade, I think, he played on the team, Clarkstown Stars Red team coached by Brian O'Hare, that was a, a, a very strong team, and that was w- when I first started even thinking about private school,'cause Mike Rooney, I was introduced to him by Brian and knew that he was the head coach of Don Bosco.
- 4:23Kevin T. Mulhearn: Brian also extolled the virtues of the Bosco baseball program, saying it was the best program in the area, and it's something that Dennis should think about as a possibility of playing.
- 4:33Kevin T. Mulhearn: So Mike actually had a chance to watch Dennis play.
- 4:35Kevin T. Mulhearn: at the end of the, the year, I came up to Mike a- and I said,"Mike, does my kid have a chance to play baseball at Don Bosco Prep for you, if he goes there?" And Mike gave me a really honest answer.
- 4:47Kevin T. Mulhearn: He said, Kevin, I can't tell you he's gonna be good enough to play or start on my varsity team.
- 4:52Kevin T. Mulhearn: I just can't predict that.
- 4:54Kevin T. Mulhearn: I don't know.
- 4:55Kevin T. Mulhearn: too early to say.
- 4:56Kevin T. Mulhearn: He's 13 years old, and I can't tell you what the future holds on that.
- 5:01Kevin T. Mulhearn: I can tell you that he's gonna be good enough to play on the freshman team.
- 5:04Kevin T. Mulhearn: he'll make the freshman team, and I'm sure he'll play, some." That was it.
- 5:09Kevin T. Mulhearn: That was the extent of the promise that he, he made.
- 5:12Kevin T. Mulhearn: And I have to tell you, I really appreciated that he was not blowing smoke up my ears, that he was telling me how it is.
- 5:19Kevin T. Mulhearn: "This is a tough program.
- 5:20Kevin T. Mulhearn: I got really good kids.
- 5:22Kevin T. Mulhearn: Your kid might play.
- 5:23Kevin T. Mulhearn: He might not play." and that was the challenge that we as a family faced to say,"Okay, you wanna roll the dice here and see what happens." there's no guarantees.
- 5:33Kevin T. Mulhearn: there's no guarantees in public school either.
- 5:35Kevin T. Mulhearn: you go to public school and you can sit in a public school and not make a team.
- 5:38Kevin T. Mulhearn: it's, it's very competitive.
- 5:40Kevin T. Mulhearn: Some of the public school teams, especially in Bergen County, are extremely strong.
- 5:43Kevin T. Mulhearn: the Catholic school decision, is one that you really have to have some level of, acceptance of risk.
- 5:50Kevin T. Mulhearn: and your kid could be a great player.
- 5:52Kevin T. Mulhearn: your, your kid could be all-state e- eventually and, and still not, n- not, be able to start right away or even at all for one of these private school powerhouses, just the way it is.
- 6:04Kevin T. Mulhearn: so, as I look at it, what do you tell a parent who's thinking about sending his kid to a private school when his kid is seventh and eighth grade and s- showing some talent for baseball?
- 6:15Joe Clemente: here's the thing, right?
- 6:16Joe Clemente: You were talking about New Jersey.
- 6:17Joe Clemente: let's just focus on Jersey.
- 6:19Joe Clemente: I'm in the mix, right?
- 6:20Joe Clemente: you and I have been-- your son played there, so let's talk about Jersey.
- 6:24Joe Clemente: The, the North J- the, the North Jersey area, whether it's private, right, parochial or public, okay?
- 6:32Joe Clemente: The baseball there, it's like a, it's like a small little mecca of...
- 6:35Joe Clemente: being in the Big North is, a huge deal.
- 6:38Joe Clemente: I'm a little biased, right?
- 6:39Joe Clemente: Maybe you are, too, but that's definitely one of the best conferences, in the country, okay?
- 6:44Joe Clemente: And I think that's proven, okay?
- 6:46Joe Clemente: And I'm talking about not just about, wins and losses, but I'm talking about the amount of kids that go to college, the amount of kids that are on the draft board that may get drafted, okay?
- 6:56Joe Clemente: first thing you gotta do is you gotta tip your cap to all the programs, all the coaches and be like, to set that standard, is hard.
- 7:02Joe Clemente: I know Runes, he...
- 7:03Joe Clemente: the standard is way up here, okay?
- 7:06Joe Clemente: And that's been set there for a long time, and that's been set.
- 7:10Joe Clemente: The, the bar has been set from the kids that continue to come into the program, right?
- 7:15Joe Clemente: So going to a seventh or an eighth grade parent, right?
- 7:19Joe Clemente: And saying, when they ask, again, coming back to, everybody always asks that question:"Is my kid gonna play there?"'Cause first of all, it comes down to money.
- 7:29Joe Clemente: Let's just, let's be honest, okay?
- 7:31Joe Clemente: The-- What you're investing in is not only, you're looking at this like, the education side is great, but my public school, some of these public schools are phenomenal, right?
- 7:41Joe Clemente: Ed- academically.
- 7:43Joe Clemente: So now you're sitting here going,"Okay, if I'm gonna sit here and I'm gonna spend 20, 30 grand a year, okay, maybe more," right?
- 7:50Joe Clemente: at this program, I need to make sure that my kid's gonna get an opportunity to play." But there are no guarantees like you said, okay?
- 7:58Joe Clemente: And, unfortunately, there's a risk, and that's what I tell these guys.
- 8:04Joe Clemente: Look, y- you might be the best player in your town.
- 8:09Joe Clemente: You might be the best player in the All-Stars.
- 8:12Joe Clemente: You might be the best player on your club team.
- 8:15Joe Clemente: But when you come to-- When you go to a parochial school or especially in the Big North, they're all the best players, right?
- 8:24Joe Clemente: And that's the hardest thing that parents have to deal with.
- 8:27Joe Clemente: Nobody wants to hear that, Kev?
- 8:29Joe Clemente: Nobody wants to hear that your kid, oh my God, he was the best for the last three years at 11U, 12U,
- 8:35Kevin T. Mulhearn: 12U
- 8:36Joe Clemente: 13, 14, and then all of a sudden you show up on campus, you're like,"Whoa." there's 70 kids trying out that are just as good if not better than I am.
- 8:51Kevin T. Mulhearn: 70 kids trying out that are just as good, if not better than him and honestly, it's sometimes it's a matter of luck.
- 8:52Kevin T. Mulhearn: if you are an outfielder and you have three stud outfielders who are there in your class or below, you're blocked.
- 8:59Kevin T. Mulhearn: That's it.
- 8:59Kevin T. Mulhearn: You're done.
- 9:00Kevin T. Mulhearn: and that could happen.
- 9:01Joe Clemente: But
- 9:01Kevin T. Mulhearn: what I'm saying, if you get bl-blocked behind three s- you know- Yeah super talented D1 caliber kids, you could be a really good player and n- and not be able to get on the field just because you're blocked.
- 9:13Kevin T. Mulhearn: I know that happened.
- 9:13Kevin T. Mulhearn: there was a, a kid who was a friend of, of m- his father's a friend of mine, played on Watika's team, for many, for a couple years.
- 9:21Kevin T. Mulhearn: Great kid, gr- super athlete, great soccer player as well as a baseball player.
- 9:25Kevin T. Mulhearn: And he was-- he went to Delbarton, and he had very sporadic playing time.
- 9:32Kevin T. Mulhearn: he got on the field a little bit.
- 9:33Kevin T. Mulhearn: He played some, but n- but only his senior year and only a little bit, not full time.
- 9:39Kevin T. Mulhearn: And he w- he was a good enough athlete that he got a Division I scholarship, at, at a Patriot League school, really good school, and, playing Division I baseball on scholarship and still had a tough time cracking the lineup at Delbarton.
- 9:53Kevin T. Mulhearn: It just shows you how crazy good Delbarton team is.
- 9:57Kevin T. Mulhearn: If that kid wasn't a two-year or three-year starter from the g- from the get-go, it's just not that easy.
- 10:02Kevin T. Mulhearn: and it has nothing to do with how hard he worked or how talented he was.
- 10:06Kevin T. Mulhearn: Sometimes you just, y-you get bad luck, and you get behind somebody who's better than you.
- 10:12Kevin T. Mulhearn: that's just how it is.
- 10:13Kevin T. Mulhearn: That's life.
- 10:15Kevin T. Mulhearn: but it's a reality that, that is difficult.
- 10:17Kevin T. Mulhearn: I know there-- We talked about this with Don Bosco.
- 10:20Kevin T. Mulhearn: There are so many good kids on that team who, who don't start, who get s- minimal playing time, and they're really good ballplayers.
- 10:27Kevin T. Mulhearn: And y- you know it, it hurts the coaches to see kids who are really good not get a full opportunity to play, but it's a zero-sum game.
- 10:36Kevin T. Mulhearn: You can only have nine guys play at a time.
- 10:38Kevin T. Mulhearn: It is what it is.
- 10:39Kevin T. Mulhearn: You gotta make your selections, have your nine starters, and run with it.
- 10:43Kevin T. Mulhearn: but the playing time issue for pr- for private schools is really a difficult one because it's a r- it's a really challenging thing for a, a kid to be able to go to one of these powerhouse schools and play.
- 10:55Kevin T. Mulhearn: and I think what a parent has to do is re- is realize, accept the fact that there's a possibility that as good as my k- my little Johnny is, that little Johnny's gonna be sitting behind, some, some other kid who's just maybe a tad better or who the coaches perceive as being a tad better.
- 11:12Kevin T. Mulhearn: He might not even be better.
- 11:13Kevin T. Mulhearn: He just might be someone who the coaches think is better, and that's the only opinion that counts, right?
- 11:18Kevin T. Mulhearn: you could watch your kid and say,"Oh man, th- my kid's the next Willie Mays." But if your kid sees him as a four...
- 11:23Kevin T. Mulhearn: but the coaches on the high school team see him as a fourth-best outfielder, he's not gonna play.
- 11:28Kevin T. Mulhearn: and you as a parent, when you send your kid to a private school, I think you have to send it with a mindset that there's a possibility that my kid's not gonna play as much as I want him to play.
- 11:37Joe Clemente: I tell everybody when they come up, right?
- 11:40Joe Clemente: if you're gonna go to Bosco, I'm j- I'm using Bosco, right?
- 11:43Joe Clemente: But any of the parochials, I'm sure they're in the same, they're in the same boat.
- 11:47Joe Clemente: If you're gonna go to Bosco, make sure you're going to the school because you love it academically, you love being there, you wanna be on campus, you love the brotherhood, all the extra stuff, because there is a chance you may not make a team, or you may make a team and not play
- 12:02Kevin T. Mulhearn: could interrupt for a second.
- 12:03Kevin T. Mulhearn: but isn't the case a, a lot of guys go to Bosco for the primary purpose of playing the sport they wanna play?
- 12:09Joe Clemente: 100%.
- 12:10Joe Clemente: But that's why- but that's us as coaches, like we have to let them know that, right?
- 12:15Joe Clemente: Like that's, I think that's me being nice saying,"Hey, listen, make sure you like this school because there is a chance that you may not make the team or you may not be happy with your role on the team."
- 12:25Kevin T. Mulhearn: And one thing that, that Bosco does, which I found fascinating and really interesting, was after tryouts, they have a, an actual piece of paper which outlines the role that they anticipate you having f- for that team.
- 12:40Kevin T. Mulhearn: the, I think the categories are, you're starting spot, fighting for a starting spot, m- minimal playing time, you're gonna be a backup or...
- 12:48Kevin T. Mulhearn: And then there's a last category, which is,"We don't see any role for you on this team.
- 12:51Kevin T. Mulhearn: You won't play." they actually say that.
- 12:54Kevin T. Mulhearn: I remember, Nick Bombaco got that letter as a junior.
- 12:58Kevin T. Mulhearn: He got the letter,"You're not gonna be playing at all." And, when Nick's father, Dean, got that, he was apoplectic'cause he wants his kid playing baseball.
- 13:06Kevin T. Mulhearn: Yeah.
- 13:06Kevin T. Mulhearn: And Nick is a damn good player.
- 13:07Kevin T. Mulhearn: Yep.
- 13:08Kevin T. Mulhearn: but what I'll say this, and I use that, that Bombaco story as fuel for Dennis when he was sitting at Union College this past year, the first 20 games.
- 13:18Kevin T. Mulhearn: Nick Bombaco, his dad kept that piece of paper in his pocket, and he kept telling his s- his c- his, his son,"Go out there and just work your butt off and get better and show the coaches that they're wrong and that you need to be playing." And wouldn't you know it, Nick, he, he started hitting the ball like crazy in practice.
- 13:38Kevin T. Mulhearn: He got the attention of the coaches.
- 13:39Kevin T. Mulhearn: They said,"Hey, this kid's a really good hitter." They put him in a game.
- 13:42Kevin T. Mulhearn: I remember he got a, a hit against a public school early in the season, came up with the bases loaded and got a triple to left center field.
- 13:50Kevin T. Mulhearn: All of a sudden, he started get- getting some opportunities.
- 13:53Kevin T. Mulhearn: They actually took him off the you're not gonna play list, paper that he got early in the season, and he started earning himself a role and a significant role.
- 14:03Joe Clemente: Well, think about that, right?
- 14:04Joe Clemente: if you're a player like that, that has talent but has just been told like,"Hey, there's really no role for you," like you only have one of two choices, right?
- 14:12Joe Clemente: You can either go hide in the corner, right?
- 14:15Joe Clemente: Or you can go out there and you can prove us wrong,
- 14:17Kevin T. Mulhearn: but I say it, it says a lot about a kid's character to-
- 14:20Joe Clemente: Oh,
- 14:20Kevin T. Mulhearn: a, a piece of paper that says,"You're not gonna play this year at all." That's what the letter said for all intents and purposes.
- 14:27Kevin T. Mulhearn: To get that letter and just to keep going out there and busting it and, and knocking through the door, it takes a lot of character.
- 14:34Kevin T. Mulhearn: 'cause I know tons of kids who would get that letter and said,"Okay, I'm gonna start, going fishing after my games.
- 14:39Kevin T. Mulhearn: I'm gonna just r-relax and not go for the extra batting practice, not go for the extra weight work.
- 14:44Kevin T. Mulhearn: Just it is what it is.
- 14:46Kevin T. Mulhearn: I'm gonna be a s- a substitute, and I'll, I'll deal with it.
- 14:49Kevin T. Mulhearn: Maybe next year I'll play a little bit."
- 14:50Joe Clemente: You want guys who wanna compete all the time, right?
- 14:54Joe Clemente: I'll tell you a funny story, about Rooney's real quick, just going back to about competitors, right?
- 14:59Joe Clemente: So Skip was...
- 15:00Joe Clemente: We were at summer camp, right?
- 15:01Joe Clemente: We had been doing summer camp.
- 15:02Joe Clemente: This actually was the first year that I didn't have a chance to do it because, Joey was out playing.
- 15:06Joe Clemente: he got all...
- 15:07Joe Clemente: He got invited to a bunch of, higher level stuff, 17U.
- 15:11Joe Clemente: So I was traveling, and I missed it.
- 15:13Joe Clemente: I missed the camp.
- 15:14Joe Clemente: But I remember...
- 15:16Joe Clemente: now you gotta think about this, like how clued in, Mike Rooney is to, baseball and kids and...
- 15:22Joe Clemente: So they would go to camp for like the first half, do all their skill work, stuff like that, and then we'd go to lunch.
- 15:29Joe Clemente: Everybody would eat, and kids would then come out afterwards, okay?
- 15:34Joe Clemente: And Skip would sit there, okay?
- 15:37Joe Clemente: Not saying anything.
- 15:37Joe Clemente: He'd eat his lunch, everybody would eat his lunch.
- 15:39Joe Clemente: and then you'd have a bunch of the kids who would, go into the dugout or go sit against the fence, or go up against the...
- 15:48Joe Clemente: go sit in the shade and stuff like that.
- 15:50Joe Clemente: And then you'd have, your handful of guys, like kids that would be, like, out on the field, like playing catch and running around.
- 15:56Joe Clemente: but we would never say anything.
- 15:58Joe Clemente: And there was a reason we would never say anything, because Skip would say to us, he's"I want the kids that wanna be on the field all the time.
- 16:05Joe Clemente: All the time." See, the kids...
- 16:06Joe Clemente: and it's not making them wrong.
- 16:08Joe Clemente: it's not saying, those kids are bad kids or anything, but there's just a, the...
- 16:11Joe Clemente: when you start to look at the type of athletes or the type of kids that you need to be in that program, you want kids that wanna compete.
- 16:20Joe Clemente: He wants kids, all these coaches want kids that wanna compete all the time, and that's the difference.
- 16:27Joe Clemente: That, those are some of the things that you asked me earlier about, talking to parents and kids about parochial and public, right?
- 16:34Joe Clemente: what, what is the difference?
- 16:36Joe Clemente: I'm telling you right now, if you're going to a parochial school, you be...
- 16:39Joe Clemente: You gotta be ready to compete every day, every pitch.
- 16:43Joe Clemente: E- everything that you do, you better be ready to compete because the guy next to you is, And some parents don't understand that.
- 16:50Joe Clemente: and I'm not trying to be rude about that, but they live in this bubble, right?
- 16:55Joe Clemente: And they live in this town that, they've always been the best, and they've never really had to compete like that all the time.
- 17:02Joe Clemente: I'm not saying they don't compete, I'm saying they don't do it all the time.
- 17:06Joe Clemente: That's the difference, right?
- 17:07Joe Clemente: C- think about it.
- 17:09Joe Clemente: Think about how many nights that Dennis came home, right?
- 17:12Joe Clemente: And you were like,"Hey, great job, but, you gotta keep pushing.
- 17:15Joe Clemente: You gotta keep pushing," right?
- 17:17Kevin T. Mulhearn: as a parent, honestly, I, I was worried about him being benched until ver- the very end of senior year.
- 17:22Kevin T. Mulhearn: I, I honestly, I never felt really solid or confident that he was gonna have a, a, a starting role, get his three at-bats a game every single game.
- 17:31Kevin T. Mulhearn: I was always worried that one, one bad spell, a bad play, an e- a bad error, an 0 for 10 s- spot is gonna put him on the bench.
- 17:39Kevin T. Mulhearn: it's hard to, A- and, that was me as parent thinking.
- 17:43Kevin T. Mulhearn: I, I don't know if Dennis felt that way himself, but I think I'm cer- certain that he had-- he knew he had pr- pressure on him, that there was some guys just chomping at the bit waiting to get in and take over his role if they could.
- 17:55Kevin T. Mulhearn: but it, it makes for a tenuous, tenuous season when you're not wor- when you're n- when you're not sure that your kid's gonna be playing and it's that competitive, that there's always a possibility that he's gonna wind up sitting on the bench.
- 18:08Kevin T. Mulhearn: and there are a lot of kids who are really good players who get benched or, or who don't crack the starting lineup, who will not see the field nearly as much as you would like them to as your, as, as, their parent, and that happens too.
- 18:21Kevin T. Mulhearn: sometimes, if, if you could, sometimes the best thing for the child is to leave the private school and go play at a public school, correct?
- 18:32Kevin T. Mulhearn: Yeah, 100%.
- 18:34Kevin T. Mulhearn: Not-
- 18:34Joe Clemente: every program, not every kid is built for every program, right?
- 18:38Joe Clemente: You as a parent, you try to do the best, try to make the best decision to help your kid out, and that's in any sport, right?
- 18:46Joe Clemente: We're not just talking about baseball now.
- 18:49Joe Clemente: and you wanna put them in an environment where they're gonna succeed, right?
- 18:52Joe Clemente: But ultimately, it doesn't make them any less of a, an athlete or a player if they go to a parochial school and they're like,"Hey, I just, this is just not for me," right?
- 19:03Joe Clemente: Doesn't make them a bad person, it's just not their thing, right?
- 19:06Joe Clemente: Like they didn't-- maybe they didn't feel like they fit in, maybe there was-- you were talking about a blockage, right?
- 19:12Joe Clemente: it's stacked so far, like they're looking for opportunity, whatever it might be, right?
- 19:17Joe Clemente: So again, there's a ton of public schools out there that are really good, and I was gonna say to you earlier, talking about these two, and, again, a little biased, right?
- 19:26Joe Clemente: Being in the Big North.
- 19:27Joe Clemente: I think that the baseball in the Big North or with all the parochial schools, even Delby, Pope John, all, all those schools in the area, okay?
- 19:37Joe Clemente: They, St.
- 19:38Joe Clemente: Peter's.
- 19:39Joe Clemente: The, the bottom line is they've made the public schools better.
- 19:44Joe Clemente: And what I mean by that is public schools that are going to play against the parochials, they know what they're up against, and there's no coach out there that wants to go out and get beaten up by one of these teams.
- 19:56Joe Clemente: So I gotta tip my cap to the coaches in the public schools in the area especially.
- 20:02Joe Clemente: Like they've done a tremendous job, raising the bar for their, for their players and their school, because there's no easy win.
- 20:11Joe Clemente: Like you remember back in the day when it was like,"Oh, I'm gonna go play,""Bosco's gonna go play so and Oh man, that's a stat day," right?
- 20:17Joe Clemente: Someone's going four for four with three homers and a double, right?
- 20:20Joe Clemente: there's no more of that.
- 20:22Joe Clemente: And like I said, that's, you gotta pay homage to the coaches in the local programs that, that I've seen that there is no easy win.
- 20:30Joe Clemente: There's a fight and every time that I would guess that this is the same not just for Bosco, but for Joe's, for any of the parochials, that every time that they go and play a public, they're getting their best.
- 20:43Joe Clemente: Like I, I'm gonna tell you right now that I know for a fact there is no easy win like, and every public school that we go play, like they are putting their ace on the bump as long as he's available or whatever their best is available and they're hunting for us.
- 20:59Joe Clemente: And I love it, And I tell my guys that.
- 21:02Joe Clemente: But ultimately, like there's no slouch, right?
- 21:07Joe Clemente: in the area anymore.
- 21:08Kevin T. Mulhearn: and that's, in, in my mind, the biggest difference between private schools and public schools as far as talent differentiation is pitching depth.
- 21:17Kevin T. Mulhearn: Don Bosco, had s- w- 2025 team, they had seven or eight kids who were all aces on a lot of public school teams.
- 21:26Kevin T. Mulhearn: the, the seventh or eighth k- kid on the depth chart could've been an ace in most public schools i- in the area.
- 21:31Kevin T. Mulhearn: they were that good pitching wise.
- 21:34Kevin T. Mulhearn: The public schools that I see, most of them have s- y- the really good programs have one standout pitcher.
- 21:41Kevin T. Mulhearn: Altapan had a Selden Kokubak kid this year who was tremendous.
- 21:44Kevin T. Mulhearn: Yeah.
- 21:45Joe Clemente: He was lights out
- 21:45Kevin T. Mulhearn: excellent a- as, as good as o- any pitcher in the state, really.
- 21:48Kevin T. Mulhearn: he was terrific.
- 21:50Kevin T. Mulhearn: but after that, the, there's a, there's usually a fall off in the depth of the pitching, which makes it interesting because you play a tournament like the Bergen County Tournament, especially when they space out the games like they have the last couple years.
- 22:01Kevin T. Mulhearn: If you can ride your ace, you can Public school teams can play with the big boys, they can play with the private schools if they're riding their ace, and they can pitch every game.
- 22:10Kevin T. Mulhearn: He pitched the quarterfinal, he pitched the semifinal, he pitched the finals.
- 22:13Kevin T. Mulhearn: You have three, three weeks of games, you could put your ace against the private schools at every game, it's gonna be very competitive games.
- 22:20Kevin T. Mulhearn: And p- and the public schools c- they've beaten the private schools a number of times the last couple years in those tournaments on the, that framework.
- 22:28Kevin T. Mulhearn: The difficulty is if you have to go deep into a tournament, if you're playing two or three games in a week, and you need to go four or five pitching deep.
- 22:36Kevin T. Mulhearn: That's where I think w- from my m- from my mindset, that was the differentiation that, that the private school pitching depth was so much more than the public school pitching depth.
- 22:47Kevin T. Mulhearn: usually the public schools, after the first two pitchers, there was a pretty significant drop-off at number three.
- 22:53Kevin T. Mulhearn: Bosco had, had a k- had a kid this year, Thomas Collins was all-state.
- 22:57Kevin T. Mulhearn: He wasn't even in, in, in, in the top three or four guys in the rotation, the year before.
- 23:03Kevin T. Mulhearn: now you could argue that.
- 23:04Kevin T. Mulhearn: maybe, he certainly had the talent to, to pitch a- at that level.
- 23:07Kevin T. Mulhearn: but he wasn't.
- 23:08Kevin T. Mulhearn: He just didn't pitch those kind of games as a junior.
- 23:12Kevin T. Mulhearn: he waited till his senior year to actually have, have that role.
- 23:15Kevin T. Mulhearn: But I'm sure when Tommy was a junior and if he was playing at a, at any public school, they would've been salivating having that kid take the mound e- every fifth day.
- 23:24Kevin T. Mulhearn: Every day.
- 23:24Kevin T. Mulhearn: So- Throw him out there as much as
- 23:25Joe Clemente: I throw him out there as much as I
- 23:27Kevin T. Mulhearn: So it just, it's the difference.
- 23:30Kevin T. Mulhearn: And there were kids, for pitchers, th- there were pitchers who I saw at, at Don Bosco Prep who were really outstanding pitchers, really good, and had a tough time getting more than seven, 10 innings, of work in the private school system.
- 23:44Kevin T. Mulhearn: It just- Couldn't find the innings because they were really good, but their other kids were really good too.
- 23:50Joe Clemente: I when you talk about that, I don't mean to jump in, but when you talk about, a- again, we keep talking about the differenti- what differentiates public, private, all that good stuff, okay?
- 24:01Joe Clemente: even though all the recruiting nowadays, especially with the NCAA rules and all that stuff with August 1st for the juniors, right?
- 24:09Joe Clemente: Almost all the recruiting is done in the summer, okay?
- 24:12Joe Clemente: that's fair to say.
- 24:13Joe Clemente: When you win, okay, in these county tournaments and the state tournaments, college coaches are going to see those teams because there's something there, right?
- 24:23Joe Clemente: they're going there to see somebody, okay?
- 24:26Joe Clemente: When you take a look at, and again, Bosco, and you go down the line, right?
- 24:32Joe Clemente: The job, again, what Mike Rooney and these guys, Jimmy and Dwyer, Jalil, all these guys have done is that there are kids that, like you said, that play minimally, on the field during the season, but they're playing in college.
- 24:49Joe Clemente: There's a reason for that.
- 24:50Joe Clemente: And I had the, I had the honor to be able to talk to a bunch of college coaches this summer because, again, Joey got invited to some of that stuff.
- 24:58Joe Clemente: And it was cool because they said to me, they were like,"When I see Don Bosco Prep, when I see St.
- 25:06Joe Clemente: Joe's, when I see Bergen," all of them, Delbarton, right?
- 25:10Joe Clemente: Again, we like to say all the names, but it's all the parochials in the area.
- 25:14Joe Clemente: When we see that, we know what type of program they're coming from.
- 25:18Joe Clemente: We know what we can expect
- 25:21Kevin T. Mulhearn: Type of program they're coming from.
- 25:21Kevin T. Mulhearn: We know what we can expect there's a lot of great p- private school teams, St.
- 25:22Kevin T. Mulhearn: Peter's Prep, Pope John.
- 25:25Kevin T. Mulhearn: Yeah.
- 25:25Kevin T. Mulhearn: th- these are all tough t- teams.
- 25:27Kevin T. Mulhearn: Every game against th- these teams are wars.
- 25:30Joe Clemente: they are battles for we know that going into it.
- 25:33Joe Clemente: but again, the college coaches, so like you're gonna know that, hey, if so-and-so is on the roster, if Mike Rooney chose them, chose this kid, there's a reason.
- 25:46Joe Clemente: you and I both know that.
- 25:47Joe Clemente: There's a reason, okay?
- 25:49Joe Clemente: and even though he didn't play a lot, there's, there's, As we always talk about, character is a huge, th- that's that's a huge component in how we choose kids, right?
- 26:00Joe Clemente: And like a lot of athletes, there's a misconception, right?
- 26:03Joe Clemente: It's always skill, skill, right?
- 26:05Joe Clemente: How good am I?
- 26:05Joe Clemente: How good am I?
- 26:06Joe Clemente: How fast can I run?
- 26:07Joe Clemente: but at our school, character, that pl- that's one of the largest things that, that we look at.
- 26:14Kevin T. Mulhearn: And, if you're thinking long term, I, I think you need to be patient.
- 26:20Kevin T. Mulhearn: Your kid's time is gonna come.
- 26:21Kevin T. Mulhearn: It might not come at the timetable that you want, but his time will come.
- 26:26Kevin T. Mulhearn: 'cause certainly the work that they do and the training and coaching and teaching that goes on there is extraordinary.
- 26:34Kevin T. Mulhearn: the funny thing is wh- when Don Bosco Prep is playing a playoff game, all the coaches are in the dugout, and, and Mike likes to stack his coaching staff.
- 26:42Kevin T. Mulhearn: So the freshman coaches are there, you know, Chevy's there, Brian Bankely's there, you're
- 26:46Joe Clemente: We're all there.
- 26:47Kevin T. Mulhearn: Vic Santos is there sometimes.
- 26:49Kevin T. Mulhearn: and there's five t- there's five coaches on the varsity team to begin with, so you look at that, there's almost more coaches than players in some of the games.
- 26:57Kevin T. Mulhearn: and it's funny to watch, but you realize, and I realize as a parent now with a little perspective with my kids over a year out, the commitment, the coaching commitment to those kids from that, from those private schools, and particularly Don Bosco, but I'm sure the same is true of some of the other private schools in the area, is extraordinary.
- 27:17Kevin T. Mulhearn: The commitment that these coaches, including you, give to these kids is remarkable.
- 27:23Kevin T. Mulhearn: And- That's a benefit, that goes beyond the scoreboard, beyond the playing time decisions, beyond the stats.
- 27:31Kevin T. Mulhearn: you're getting your kid to w- be worked on and developed by a really good group of guys who are looking to build, number one, his character, nu- number two, his performance.
- 27:42Kevin T. Mulhearn: But the character always is king, always.
- 27:46Kevin T. Mulhearn: And I love that about the private school, s- system, that these, these coaches are building men.
- 27:52Kevin T. Mulhearn: They are not just coaching boys.
- 27:56Kevin T. Mulhearn: And that's the one thing...
- 27:57Kevin T. Mulhearn: I'm writing my own book about, the 2025 Don Bosco Prep championship season.
- 28:02Joe Clemente: I can't wait.
- 28:03Joe Clemente: I can't wait, man.
- 28:04Joe Clemente: Let's get it done
- 28:05Kevin T. Mulhearn: Iron- Can't wait.
- 28:05Kevin T. Mulhearn: Iron Men is the name of the book.
- 28:06Kevin T. Mulhearn: eventually it'll be out there.
- 28:08Kevin T. Mulhearn: But, m- my, realization is that's what these guys were doing.
- 28:14Kevin T. Mulhearn: That's what you and, and the coaches at Don Bosco were doing.
- 28:17Kevin T. Mulhearn: They were building men.
- 28:19Kevin T. Mulhearn: They were taking boys and molding them and shaping them into str- and not just men, but strong men.
- 28:24Kevin T. Mulhearn: And we're a society that has put the boot on the strong men in a lot of areas and a lot of arenas.
- 28:30Kevin T. Mulhearn: It's h- harder and harder to be a boy today than I think it w- ever has been.
- 28:35Kevin T. Mulhearn: And th- this is one pocket of a group of men who are committed to these kids like they're their own sons.
- 28:44Kevin T. Mulhearn: and I can see it.
- 28:45Kevin T. Mulhearn: I can see how, how much...
- 28:47Kevin T. Mulhearn: when I sat down, I had three or four hour conversations with all the varsity coaches.
- 28:51Kevin T. Mulhearn: and I just saw the passion they have for what they do and how much they love it and how important it is to them.
- 28:56Kevin T. Mulhearn: and as, as a dad who's sitting back, again, with perspective, I really appreciate that'cause you just don't find that everywhere.
- 29:04Joe Clemente: I definitely think, it's a mutual respect, right?
- 29:07Joe Clemente: if the players are willing to put in the time and effort, then us as coaches, w- we wanna develop them and get them to be successful and get everything out of them, right?
- 29:16Joe Clemente: I am gonna turn around and talk about, the public school guys and, and not to harp on it, but, I have to...
- 29:24Joe Clemente: Again, we need to tip our cap to them because ultimately, most of the time going into a parochial school, we get some of the best talent in the area, okay?
- 29:33Joe Clemente: And unfortunately, that means that we're taking players from those public schools.
- 29:40Joe Clemente: Now, again, there's always situations, right?
- 29:43Joe Clemente: Mike has done a tremendous job building this program, and we should get the best players because we're the best, we're the best program.
- 29:51Joe Clemente: So ultimately, those public school coaches, they have to deal with a lot of adversity.
- 29:58Joe Clemente: So again, I don't want, as biased as we are about parochial just because we're in it, I want everybody out there to know, the, the public school coaches, they don't have it easy, right?
- 30:09Joe Clemente: And they try to do everything that they can.
- 30:11Joe Clemente: And think about this.
- 30:12Joe Clemente: You were talking about this earlier, right?
- 30:14Joe Clemente: They only got two arms, right?
- 30:16Joe Clemente: They have to manage the game, to the point of where, we gotta figure out how we're gonna go in and compete in the counties and the states, and we got two arms, right?
- 30:25Kevin T. Mulhearn: two premium arms.
- 30:25Joe Clemente: Two premium arms
- 30:27Kevin T. Mulhearn: all have more than two arms.
- 30:28Kevin T. Mulhearn: Yeah.
- 30:28Kevin T. Mulhearn: it's just that there's a drop-off often after the first two arms.
- 30:32Joe Clemente: Yeah, they're not gonna have, they're not gonna have the, they're not gonna have our guys as like their three, four, and five.
- 30:37Joe Clemente: Like you were just talking about O'Hare, right?
- 30:39Joe Clemente: if he's our three guy, four guy, like most public schools are not gonna have that.
- 30:43Joe Clemente: but again, I just want the public school coaches that are out there listening to this to know that, hey, like w- we have a ton of respect for you, right?
- 30:51Joe Clemente: And for what you do, and I tip my cap to you guys'cause it's not easy.
- 30:54Joe Clemente: And I have friends, I have a lot of friends that coach in the public school rank, in, in, in the realm, and it's not easy.
- 31:01Joe Clemente: And for what they've done, it's, it's nothing short of
- 31:06Kevin T. Mulhearn: And the, the Bergen County Public Schools are an outstanding group.
- 31:09Kevin T. Mulhearn: There's three of the, three of the state champions this year in public schools from the state of New Jersey come from Bergen County.
- 31:15Kevin T. Mulhearn: Yeah I think O- Altapan, Ramsey, I think, and I think Westwood maybe.
- 31:20Joe Clemente: Yeah, my bu- my buddy Chris Roof, I just saw, last weekend, haven't seen each other for quite a while because he's on a...
- 31:26Joe Clemente: he's the head coach at Governor Livingston.
- 31:28Joe Clemente: He's done a phenomenal job down there.
- 31:31Joe Clemente: and he's been there for a long time.
- 31:33Joe Clemente: And you know what?
- 31:34Joe Clemente: He...
- 31:34Joe Clemente: The culture there, like we talked about it for a while, like it's,
- 31:38Kevin T. Mulhearn: Is, is Governor Livingston a p- a public school or private?
- 31:41Joe Clemente: a public school, right?
- 31:42Joe Clemente: it's public.
- 31:42Kevin T. Mulhearn: yeah.
- 31:42Kevin T. Mulhearn: th- they were undefeated a couple years ago.
- 31:44Joe Clemente: they weren't...
- 31:44Joe Clemente: they were a win away from winning the whole thing.
- 31:46Joe Clemente: They won the section, I think, this year and...
- 31:49Joe Clemente: But but for the last couple of years, like they've continued to grow, but again, it's taken him a while.
- 31:54Joe Clemente: But again, it...
- 31:55Joe Clemente: He's relentless.
- 31:57Joe Clemente: he strives for his kids and, we had a really good conversation.
- 32:00Joe Clemente: He's an awesome coach, awesome dude, and, again, tipping my cap to these guys that, the kids are leaving their program to go to a parochial, right?
- 32:11Joe Clemente: So we're very fortunate.
- 32:12Joe Clemente: I'm a little biased.
- 32:13Joe Clemente: I'm good with that
- 32:13Kevin T. Mulhearn: but there's, remember a couple years ago we played Morris Knolls.
- 32:16Kevin T. Mulhearn: They had Luke Dickerson, who was one of the
- 32:19Joe Clemente: Oh, that kid was a stud, right?
- 32:21Joe Clemente: Stud.
- 32:22Kevin T. Mulhearn: a great hockey player, too.
- 32:23Kevin T. Mulhearn: Yeah.
- 32:23Kevin T. Mulhearn: and they also had a really strong pitching, staff.
- 32:26Kevin T. Mulhearn: I think, they had a kid, James Kahn, who played for complete performance.
- 32:30Kevin T. Mulhearn: Really good.
- 32:31Kevin T. Mulhearn: at, at-- That was one of the best games of the year.
- 32:33Kevin T. Mulhearn: We had a game against Morris Knolls where I think we won 2-1.
- 32:37Kevin T. Mulhearn: uh, Ryan Cavero pitched the game of his life that game.
- 32:40Kevin T. Mulhearn: But they had some lineup.
- 32:41Kevin T. Mulhearn: It's a public school.
- 32:43Kevin T. Mulhearn: And, and they were-- they gave us, everything we could w-we could take.
- 32:47Kevin T. Mulhearn: They were really good.
- 32:48Kevin T. Mulhearn: a lot of the public schools are really good.
- 32:49Kevin T. Mulhearn: A, a lot of the public schools in Bergen are really good.
- 32:52Kevin T. Mulhearn: Ram Pope's program is al-always good.
- 32:55Joe Clemente: a bunch of guys from Ridgewood.
- 32:56Joe Clemente: They play for us.
- 32:56Joe Clemente: They w- they won it this year.
- 32:58Kevin T. Mulhearn: Valley.
- 32:59Kevin T. Mulhearn: Yeah.
- 32:59Kevin T. Mulhearn: So Ri-Ridgewood is the third state champion, I think.
- 33:02Kevin T. Mulhearn: Ri-Ridgewood, Old Tappan, and, Old Tappan?
- 33:05Kevin T. Mulhearn: Yeah.
- 33:06Joe Clemente: he, look at the program he's got there.
- 33:07Joe Clemente: he works hard.
- 33:08Joe Clemente: he works hard
- 33:09Kevin T. Mulhearn: m- I used to sneak onto his field, with, with, with, with, with Dennis and, and Dylan Espinal and Elio.
- 33:15Kevin T. Mulhearn: We would go and-
- 33:16Joe Clemente: Oh, you're the reason why they have those signs out there now, right?
- 33:18Joe Clemente: trespassing?
- 33:19Kevin T. Mulhearn: are the reasons.
- 33:21Kevin T. Mulhearn: So a couple times he came there and Elio would say,"Hey, I pay taxes.
- 33:25Kevin T. Mulhearn: my, my-- I pay school taxes in this area." and he was pretty cool about it.
- 33:28Kevin T. Mulhearn: he knew
- 33:29Joe Clemente: Byron's cool, dude.
- 33:30Kevin T. Mulhearn: he knew who we were.
- 33:31Kevin T. Mulhearn: we, we weren't looking to desecrate the field.
- 33:33Kevin T. Mulhearn: We were just looking to take a little BP.
- 33:35Kevin T. Mulhearn: so but th-that was funny a couple times
- 33:37Joe Clemente: He's a true baseball guy.
- 33:38Joe Clemente: Like he's a, he's all in.
- 33:40Kevin T. Mulhearn: Old school.
- 33:40Joe Clemente: Yeah, old school for sure.
- 33:42Joe Clemente: That was last week, right?
- 33:44Kevin T. Mulhearn: old school, for sure.
- 33:44Kevin T. Mulhearn: Yeah.
- 33:44Kevin T. Mulhearn: that was last week.
- 33:44Kevin T. Mulhearn: Ri- La-la-last week's episode.
- 33:46Kevin T. Mulhearn: but, but, the interesting thing, too, if you look at s- at some point, if you're at a, a private school and you're there to play baseball, that's your primary goal, and you're not playing or you're blocked or you're told by the coaches you're not gonna be playing, at that point, i-is that something that, that you would recommend that you should seriously consider transferring to a public school?
- 34:08Joe Clemente: So listen, again, I think it comes-- I think every athlete or every, every kid is different, right?
- 34:14Joe Clemente: I think you need to take a look at the whole situation and say,"Okay, what's best for my kid?" and get their input, right?
- 34:20Joe Clemente: 'Cause they gotta feel comfortable too
- 34:21Kevin T. Mulhearn: and as, as part of it depends on the public school too.
- 34:23Kevin T. Mulhearn: if you're going to a public school that has a really strong program that where they're all good baseball players and your kid's gonna play in a competitive team, that's one thing.
- 34:30Kevin T. Mulhearn: You're going to a, a school where they were, two and 18 the previous year, it's quite another.
- 34:36Kevin T. Mulhearn: You gotta make that decision.
- 34:37Kevin T. Mulhearn: I guess that's part of the in- the impact is the where you're going.
- 34:41Kevin T. Mulhearn: And you also have the ability to transfer to another private school, from private school to private school.
- 34:45Kevin T. Mulhearn: That happens too, right?
- 34:46Joe Clemente: Yeah, you get, you get one, right?
- 34:48Joe Clemente: You get one free one as a varsity
- 34:49Kevin T. Mulhearn: one as a varsity guy.
- 34:49Kevin T. Mulhearn: and the rule changed from when Dennis started as a freshman.
- 34:52Kevin T. Mulhearn: It used to be, I think you had to sit out 30 days if you tr- if you transferred, to another pr- private school and that 30-day rule disappeared, right?
- 35:02Joe Clemente: that, between you and I think it wasn't just parochial to parochial.
- 35:06Joe Clemente: I think you got one transfer, and y- you could transfer whenever you wanted, but if you transferred, the old rule was 30-day sit.
- 35:13Joe Clemente: So what a lot of kids did was it was your first varsity, like whatever sport you played.
- 35:20Joe Clemente: So a lot of those kids, what they would do is they play baseball.
- 35:23Joe Clemente: They end up playing something in the fall or in the winter, which was varsity.
- 35:28Joe Clemente: They would sit the 30 days and be able to come back and play baseball.
- 35:32Joe Clemente: But what they ended up doing, I think, was whatever sport you played varsity was the 30-day sit or something like that, okay?
- 35:39Joe Clemente: So of course, there were different things that you could do to get around it.
- 35:43Joe Clemente: f- once they changed that, once they changed that, it's...
- 35:47Joe Clemente: You get one free, you get one free transfer
- 35:50Kevin T. Mulhearn: And this is just a couple years ago they
- 35:52Joe Clemente: Yeah.
- 35:52Joe Clemente: So you've seen, like people use this now as like a strategic move
- 35:58Kevin T. Mulhearn: there was a kid who transferred from Bosco to St.
- 36:01Kevin T. Mulhearn: Joe's as a ju- he was a junior in Bosco, and he transferred and played at St.
- 36:06Kevin T. Mulhearn: Joe's as a senior.
- 36:07Kevin T. Mulhearn: I saw that.
- 36:08Kevin T. Mulhearn: and there was no sit...
- 36:09Kevin T. Mulhearn: He didn't have to sit.
- 36:10Kevin T. Mulhearn: He didn't have to...
- 36:11Kevin T. Mulhearn: He went right into the s- into the season.
- 36:13Kevin T. Mulhearn: And any, any kid could transfer to any school.
- 36:16Kevin T. Mulhearn: you don't see it a lot though, do you?
- 36:17Joe Clemente: No.
- 36:18Joe Clemente: I, so I think you see more of the transfers from the sub-varsity guys, right?
- 36:22Joe Clemente: Because they kinda read the writing on the wall.
- 36:25Joe Clemente: And again, it doesn't make anybody a bad person, it's just when you look down the line, right?
- 36:30Joe Clemente: It's like, okay, you have kids that are p- that started as freshmen, JV, right?
- 36:36Joe Clemente: Or you have some guys that went from freshman to varsity, and you just start to look at the roster and you're saying,"Okay, does this work?""Am I the type of player that I'm okay with being here, practicing all the time, getting limited playing time, and then getting an opportunity in the summer to, to go to, to a college?
- 36:55Joe Clemente: Or am I the type of athlete that's like,'Hey, listen, I wanna work really hard, but I need to play.
- 37:00Joe Clemente: I wanna be on the field because I'll get bored if not.'"
- 37:02Kevin T. Mulhearn: it's fascinating.
- 37:03Kevin T. Mulhearn: everybody has a, their own decision to
- 37:05Joe Clemente: Yeah, tough
- 37:06Kevin T. Mulhearn: I know f- from our experience at, at, at Bosco, there was a g- a kid, I'm not gonna say his name, but he's a great kid.
- 37:12Kevin T. Mulhearn: L- love his family, too.
- 37:14Kevin T. Mulhearn: And he was a really good hitter on the team as a freshman and JV player.
- 37:19Kevin T. Mulhearn: Had a really rough junior year.
- 37:21Kevin T. Mulhearn: but he was beset with a significant injury to his shoulder, and once his shoulder healed, he just really couldn't crack the lineup.
- 37:27Kevin T. Mulhearn: And when he got his limited p- playing time, just didn't have a great season, just didn't perform at his level.
- 37:34Kevin T. Mulhearn: And it, it was really disappointing that this is a kid who may have been one of our best hitters, the first two years of the program, and as a junior, he had a really disappointing season.
- 37:44Kevin T. Mulhearn: And that kid had a decision h- to make.
- 37:46Kevin T. Mulhearn: He said,"Okay, I can go pretty much a- any- anywhere I want." I think St.
- 37:52Kevin T. Mulhearn: Joe's would love to have, ha- have him.
- 37:54Kevin T. Mulhearn: I know he knew the coaches from St.
- 37:55Kevin T. Mulhearn: Joe's, and I think they were salivating at the prospect of getting this kid.
- 37:59Kevin T. Mulhearn: And he just said,"No, these are where my friends are.
- 38:03Kevin T. Mulhearn: This is the program I'm in.
- 38:05Kevin T. Mulhearn: I wanna keep fighting and contribute to this program." And he wound up having a really good senior year, and he started off like a house on fire in the spring, hitting in Florida from day one, and had a really good season and played and contributed significantly to the state championship team.
- 38:22Kevin T. Mulhearn: but he had a decision-making after junior year,"Do I bail or do I stay?" And for him, it was stay, and I'm really happy that he made the decision.
- 38:31Kevin T. Mulhearn: I think he's happy about it, too.
- 38:32Kevin T. Mulhearn: But it wasn't an easy decision.
- 38:34Kevin T. Mulhearn: It was, there was a balancing.
- 38:36Kevin T. Mulhearn: It was the really,"What should I do here?"'Cause the junior year was so disappointing and s- so much less than what he wanted it to be.
- 38:44Kevin T. Mulhearn: and there are other kids who decide to leave, and sometimes for them, that's the right decision, too.
- 38:49Kevin T. Mulhearn: it's really a personal, decision that, that changes, w- this-- There's so many variables and circumstances that, that go into that.
- 38:57Kevin T. Mulhearn: But, they're hard decisions.
- 38:59Kevin T. Mulhearn: But one thing I say as a parent, it's good that your child starts learning how to make adult decisions at a young age.
- 39:06Kevin T. Mulhearn: the decision of what college to go to is a big decision in one's life.
- 39:10Kevin T. Mulhearn: To be able to, have input in that decision is great.
- 39:13Kevin T. Mulhearn: To be able to decide whether you're gonna go to one, one high school to play baseball or stay at another school or stay at, at the school that you're currently attending, these are big decisions.
- 39:23Kevin T. Mulhearn: and we as parents, we're trying to teach our kids, especially the boys, how to become independent, free-thinking men.
- 39:31Kevin T. Mulhearn: And it helps to...
- 39:34Kevin T. Mulhearn: It's not easy, but at the same time, it's really positive to be put in a position where you have to make these important decisions and, and reason your way through it and figure out what's important to you, what's not important to you, what, what level of risk you're willing to take or what level of risk you're not willing to take.
- 39:50Kevin T. Mulhearn: And I love the fact, I told you I love the fact that Mike Rooney, when Dennis was going to Bosco, did not promise anything.
- 39:57Kevin T. Mulhearn: He didn't promise a, a, a starting spot.
- 39:59Kevin T. Mulhearn: He didn't s- he didn't promise a spot on the varsity team.
- 40:01Kevin T. Mulhearn: He promised nothing except the chance to play on the freshman team.
- 40:05Kevin T. Mulhearn: That was it.
- 40:06Kevin T. Mulhearn: And I love that.
- 40:07Kevin T. Mulhearn: And I remember having a conversation with my kid about that and said, this is gonna be a challenge, and there's no guarantees here." I think if you were to ask me be- before freshman year, what's the chance that your kid's gonna be starting player at Bosco?
- 40:19Kevin T. Mulhearn: I probably would've said at best 50/50, at best.
- 40:23Kevin T. Mulhearn: there was a real good chance that he was not gonna be able to start at Don Bosco, and we were okay with that.
- 40:28Kevin T. Mulhearn: there was part of, part of the, the dynamic was this is a tough program and we know it, and we're pushing ourselves and we're challenging ourselves, and it may or may not work out.
- 40:40Kevin T. Mulhearn: And you have to be willing to accept that sometimes to take a challenge of one of these powerhouse private school programs.
- 40:47Joe Clemente: Yeah.
- 40:47Joe Clemente: when the ruling came out, you get one free transfer, right?
- 40:50Joe Clemente: on varsity.
- 40:51Joe Clemente: as a sub-varsity guy, you could go whenever you want, right?
- 40:54Joe Clemente: But, as being able to get that, it gives kids opportunities that feel like,"Hey, listen, I'm not gonna get a look." And some guys, some kids need to be on the field in order to get that opportunity to play at the next level, right?
- 41:08Joe Clemente: that's just the way it is.
- 41:09Joe Clemente: So again, I don't think it, it's, It's not a, it's not personal, from, our standpoint from Bosco.
- 41:17Joe Clemente: we just want you to do what's best for you.
- 41:19Joe Clemente: we're not gonna say,"Hey, listen, you need to leave," or,"You don't need to leave." That's a decision, like you said, tough decisions that are gonna have to be made by the athlete, the kid, and then the parents, of course.
- 41:28Joe Clemente: we stand by with whatever the kid, decides.
- 41:32Joe Clemente: but they are gonna know, like, where they're at.
- 41:34Joe Clemente: they need to know that because if we didn't tell them that, then it wouldn't be fair.
- 41:39Kevin T. Mulhearn: Tell them that, then it wouldn't be fair a- and you've seen, kids who, who have talked to Bosco coaches and were told,"We don't really see you having a huge role here playing time-wise," and they make a decision to go,"Okay, go to a different school," and have wildly s- wild success at the next school.
- 41:56Kevin T. Mulhearn: You've seen that too.
- 41:57Kevin T. Mulhearn: and to those kids, I tip my hat as well.
- 42:00Kevin T. Mulhearn: You realize that you're in a situation where you have to make an adjustment and, and ch- make a change, and you make it work for you.
- 42:06Kevin T. Mulhearn: Sometimes I think if you leave a, a private school,
- 42:09Joe Clemente: Hard, man
- 42:10Kevin T. Mulhearn: it's hard, but it also, I think, serves as fuel.
- 42:13Kevin T. Mulhearn: It's, I think you play with a chip on your shoulder the rest of your career that you wanna show everybody that you are good enough to play for this kind of program.
- 42:21Joe Clemente: Well, think about that.
- 42:22Joe Clemente: It takes a lot of courage to have to walk away also, right?
- 42:25Joe Clemente: Because if you're going back to your public school, you're gonna catch a ton of grief, right?
- 42:31Joe Clemente: "Oh, you couldn't hack it.
- 42:32Joe Clemente: You couldn't take it." So now you gotta wear-- You gotta have that chip because now I'm gonna go show you,"Hey, listen, the reason why I was there and the reason why I didn't play wasn't because I wasn't good enough.
- 42:41Joe Clemente: It's just where the clog was, and there was kids better than me or what coaches-"
- 42:45Kevin T. Mulhearn: again, kids who the coaches perceived were better than me.
- 42:48Kevin T. Mulhearn: Yeah.
- 42:48Kevin T. Mulhearn: That, that doesn't necessarily mean they were better than you.
- 42:50Kevin T. Mulhearn: It means that the coaches thought they were
- 42:52Joe Clemente: What they decided, exactly.
- 42:54Joe Clemente: So you-- again, it takes a lot of courage for kids to be able to walk away, get into a situation where they know there's gonna be a ton of pressure, right?
- 43:01Joe Clemente: Whether it's at a pr- at a public or they go to another parochial, okay?
- 43:04Joe Clemente: And those kids that are, that go there and are successful, tip our cap, right?
- 43:09Joe Clemente: "Hey, we love to see that, because you made the right decision." And again, that's why we say there's really no right and wrong until you get to a point where I think you become a junior, and you gotta pull the trigger one way or the other, right?
- 43:25Joe Clemente: and I think one of the things that you had said earlier that made a, that played a huge role is the friends thing, right?
- 43:32Joe Clemente: So I know that like, and, and I see it all the time, that my two boys that are gonna go, that are going to parochial school, right?
- 43:41Joe Clemente: In the summer, they're hanging out with their buddies in town, and they're all like,"Hey, why are you not with us?
- 43:48Joe Clemente: Why are you not coming to school with us?
- 43:50Joe Clemente: Why are you not coming to...
- 43:51Joe Clemente: this would be incredible.
- 43:52Joe Clemente: Like you, you're gonna be...
- 43:54Joe Clemente: you'll start on football varsity.
- 43:56Joe Clemente: You'll start on, you, on baseball varsity, and we need you." And they keep pulling them in, so it's not easy.
- 44:02Joe Clemente: And they're like, I've made that decision to walk away from you guys, not that I-- we're not friends, but I just have to do what's better for me, right?
- 44:10Joe Clemente: And what I feel like I need to do to better myself." These are not easy decisions.
- 44:16Kevin T. Mulhearn: are not easy decisions No, but they're adult decisions that kids are- They are starting to be making at an early age, and they're something that's a good training ground for making adult decisions when you're actually an adult.
- 44:25Joe Clemente: Builds character, right?
- 44:26Joe Clemente: Builds character, 100%
- 44:28Kevin T. Mulhearn: I wanted to talk to you for a little bit about the reclassing issue.
- 44:32Kevin T. Mulhearn: people who don't know, reclassing is getting pretty, popular in New Jersey, where, where a kid will take his eighth grade year and repeat it and don't-- and basically defer high school for a year and go to a, a reclassing school.
- 44:47Kevin T. Mulhearn: There's a bunch of good schools.
- 44:48Kevin T. Mulhearn: I'm not gonna say any of them, the names, but there are a bunch of good schools where they offer a program of one year kind of private tutorials, to bridge the gap between eighth grade and high school.
- 45:00Kevin T. Mulhearn: So basically what it does is it gives you a, a, a year of extra development before you start high school, which really helps at the private school powerhouse baseball programs, that extra year development.
- 45:14Kevin T. Mulhearn: And I wanna talk to you about something.
- 45:16Kevin T. Mulhearn: We were talking, a- about the, the, the need for reclassing and why it's being done.
- 45:22Kevin T. Mulhearn: There was a book by Malcolm Gladwell.
- 45:24Kevin T. Mulhearn: It was a bestseller, in 2008.
- 45:26Kevin T. Mulhearn: It was called"Outliers: The Story of Success." And he talked at length about- Canadian hockey programs, youth programs, where there was a disproportionately high level of success by kids who were born January, February, and March of a particular year.
- 45:44Kevin T. Mulhearn: Of course, the cutoff date in hockey in Ca- Canada is January 1st.
- 45:48Kevin T. Mulhearn: So he's saying when kids are nine to 10 years old, there's a huge gap between the kid who's born, say, in January 10th and the kid who's born December 15th.
- 45:58Kevin T. Mulhearn: There's a year development difference.
- 46:01Kevin T. Mulhearn: And what happens is that the coaches look at these nine, 10-year-old kids who are older and bigger, stronger, and they equate that as more talented.
- 46:10Kevin T. Mulhearn: So they pluck those kids out of the program, they put them into the all-stars, they start giving them better equipment, they start giving them m- more advanced training, and all of a sudden, the innate biological advantages they have from being older are enhanced even more by the additional training they get from that spot.
- 46:29Kevin T. Mulhearn: And he tracked it all the way to professional hockey that, that in the professional hockey ranks, there was a disproportionately high number of kids born the first three or four months of the year.
- 46:41Kevin T. Mulhearn: This was 2008, this book.
- 46:43Kevin T. Mulhearn: He did a follow-up study and, and they called that the RAE, relative age effect.
- 46:49Kevin T. Mulhearn: They did a follow-up study, Malcolm Gladwell did in 2022, and he checked the hockey stats, for birthdays in 2022, and he found that pretty much the same statistics applied.
- 47:01Kevin T. Mulhearn: So nothing had changed in the 15 or so years between the time he wrote his book,"Outliers," and 2022.
- 47:07Kevin T. Mulhearn: That's crazy.
- 47:08Joe Clemente: That's crazy
- 47:09Kevin T. Mulhearn: but it, but it's real.
- 47:11Kevin T. Mulhearn: There's a real advantage to being early on the cycle.
- 47:14Kevin T. Mulhearn: Totally.
- 47:14Kevin T. Mulhearn: and what the reclassing does, it takes away that disadvantage if you're born in the bottom half of the year.
- 47:20Kevin T. Mulhearn: My son was born October 28th, so if he went to Bosco in the class of 2024, he would have been giving up 10, 12, 14, 15 months to some, to a bunch of kids.
- 47:31Kevin T. Mulhearn: And that matters, and that's a big competitive disadvantage going in if you're giving up that kind of, that kind of- development and growth.
- 47:40Kevin T. Mulhearn: there's a, a, an 18-year-old kid is a, is usually a b- a lot stronger than a 17-year-old kid, and a 19-year-old kid is a lot stronger than an 18-year-old kid.
- 47:48Kevin T. Mulhearn: So that extra year really helps.
- 47:51Kevin T. Mulhearn: Dennis reclassed a lot of the kids on Bosco 2025 team reclassed.
- 47:57Kevin T. Mulhearn: I know your son Joey reclassed.
- 47:58Kevin T. Mulhearn: Yep.
- 47:59Kevin T. Mulhearn: th- these are things that, that p- that parents, sh- should think about.
- 48:03Kevin T. Mulhearn: And I have to tell you, when I first broached the subject with my wife, it w- it was, it was like f- come hell or high water, we're not gonna do this to our kid.
- 48:12Joe Clemente: That's everybody
- 48:13Kevin T. Mulhearn: and when I w- when I figured out what, what convinced Dennis' mom to say yes to the reclassing notion was COVID came and the whole year was a cluster.
- 48:23Kevin T. Mulhearn: It was just a
- 48:24Joe Clemente: That's what we ran into too
- 48:25Kevin T. Mulhearn: and we figured, you know what?
- 48:27Kevin T. Mulhearn: with, with the kids not even going to school in person, let's just reclass.
- 48:31Kevin T. Mulhearn: I- it makes more sense at that point.
- 48:33Kevin T. Mulhearn: but I'm telling you, I would've regretted not reclassing him.
- 48:37Kevin T. Mulhearn: and I'm really happy that I was able to convince Roxanne to do that because, it, it not only helps you from a, from a, a competitive standpoint as an athlete, but socially, especially boys.
- 48:50Kevin T. Mulhearn: Boys are, are slower developing emotionally, intellectually.
- 48:54Kevin T. Mulhearn: E- every, every metric, boys lag behind girls as far as development.
- 48:59Kevin T. Mulhearn: And that extra year, it, that gives the c- the, the kid that extra year to, to grow in all phases of life: emotional growth, intellectual growth, physical growth, confidence, all these things.
- 49:13Kevin T. Mulhearn: so I- I'm a big proponent of reclassing if circumstances are right, especially if your kid is born in the tail end of the academic year.
- 49:22Kevin T. Mulhearn: what's your view on that?
- 49:23Kevin T. Mulhearn: I know you're a reclassing p- proponent'cause you sent your own kid through the program of
- 49:27Joe Clemente: Yeah, it was the best thing that we ever did for him, for sure.
- 49:30Joe Clemente: He was always like,'cause-
- 49:34Kevin T. Mulhearn: about it, or was she on board?
- 49:36Joe Clemente: I think so, again, you talk about COVID, right?
- 49:40Joe Clemente: Joey was stuck in that COVID, that, that world too.
- 49:43Joe Clemente: And, like he missed so much, right?
- 49:46Joe Clemente: Like he missed so much that, that year and a half, that I think academically we were already on board, like we gotta figure this out.
- 49:55Joe Clemente: And then finding out, like figuring out like, hey, like I saw all the players at Bosco, right?
- 50:01Joe Clemente: That were reclassing and how successful they were.
- 50:05Joe Clemente: And it got to a point where, the...
- 50:07Joe Clemente: It was always about colleges.
- 50:10Joe Clemente: Okay, let me revisit this and you'll be like,"Oh, that makes sense." So everybody was always worried, about the draft and college coaches, always wanted the younger player, always wanted the younger player.
- 50:21Joe Clemente: That wasn't true.
- 50:22Joe Clemente: They wanted the best player, right?
- 50:25Joe Clemente: They always want the best player, the bigger, faster, stronger.
- 50:28Joe Clemente: So when reclassing started to come into play, we took a look at this, and I was like,"Listen, like we...
- 50:37Joe Clemente: It, I guess everybody calls it a gap year, if that makes sense, right?
- 50:40Joe Clemente: Because it's the gap.
- 50:41Joe Clemente: But, that was the best thing we ever did.
- 50:43Joe Clemente: He, he matured, not only, academically, athletically, physically, again, everything that you said, his confidence.
- 50:53Joe Clemente: And after what he had actually been through at a younger age with all this stuff, right?
- 50:57Joe Clemente: Of course, with the book, how the book started, it just did wonders for him.
- 51:00Joe Clemente: Like I would definitely say to people, if you're gonna go to a high-level, program and you have an opportunity to reclass, like especially in a parochial, like I would say that it's almost...
- 51:14Joe Clemente: I don't wanna say that everybody has to do it, but it's almost a necessity nowadays because the kids that you're up against are so much more physical, if that makes sense.
- 51:22Joe Clemente: And I'm just talking about sports-wise.
- 51:24Joe Clemente: Academically, it's gonna give you that extra year.
- 51:27Joe Clemente: Like what was cool about that for, I don't know if you've found this out with Dennis, but for Joey, like he already did almost his entire freshman year, so like in, in the gap year, like all the work and all that stuff.
- 51:40Joe Clemente: So when he got to Bosco and he was like,"Dad, this is awesome." He's like,"I already know all this stuff." I was like, And he did really well.
- 51:49Joe Clemente: So to me, I was like, that was worth it, just that, being able to do well academically.
- 51:56Joe Clemente: And then you got on the field and you saw how the physicality, shows up on the field, how hard he hits the baseball, throws, like all of the, all of those things that coaches are looking for.
- 52:09Joe Clemente: So I would 100% tell anybody that is thinking about it, especially, the...
- 52:16Joe Clemente: I don't mean to say it like this, but I know the moms sometimes, like,'cause of the academic side, I think that they, it's a necessity if you're almost, like if you're going to these schools and you're not, again,
- 52:28Kevin T. Mulhearn: Well, I don't think the moms, I don't think the moms are resisting, of course, the ac- academics.
- 52:32Kevin T. Mulhearn: I think the moms just see it like almost like a demotion, like you're being left back from school.
- 52:37Joe Clemente: I see that too.
- 52:39Joe Clemente: I see that too, but I, most of the questions I get, are from the moms.
- 52:43Joe Clemente: they'll always come to me and be like,"Hey coach, what do you think?
- 52:45Joe Clemente: What do you think?
- 52:45Joe Clemente: What
- 52:45Kevin T. Mulhearn: saying the fathers are usually gung-ho
- 52:47Joe Clemente: The fathers are usually like,"Yeah, let's do it.
- 52:49Joe Clemente: Let's do it.
- 52:50Joe Clemente: Let's do it." Because in their mind they're like,"Hey, bigger, faster, stronger." They-- I think, again, I'm not stereotyping anybody, please, but I'm gonna say that I think the men look more at the athletic side and the women look more at the academic side, and also the, the, the social, the, the social side, like their friends and all that good stuff, because that's what moms do, right?
- 53:15Joe Clemente: They wanna make sure that their kids are in an environment where they're gonna succeed,
- 53:18Kevin T. Mulhearn: Well, when you think about it, it is hard socially'cause you're basically getting ripped out of a class where your- Yeah your kids have been going to school for eight years, eight grade.
- 53:26Kevin T. Mulhearn: 100%.
- 53:27Joe Clemente: 100%.
- 53:27Kevin T. Mulhearn: so all of a sudden you're now in a different class with different kids.
- 53:32Joe Clemente: I know people that are going
- 53:34Kevin T. Mulhearn: I don't know if you want to go back- so for d- for Dennis, who was going to a different school anyway, that wasn't so much a factor because he's going to a different school, was gonna have to make friends from diff- different areas as well.
- 53:44Kevin T. Mulhearn: But if you're reclassing and going to, to the same school that, that you were pr- attending previously or public school- then you just, y- you just got jumped by everybody in your class.
- 53:53Kevin T. Mulhearn: So that is a hard thing from a social standpoint when you think about it.
- 53:55Joe Clemente: Yeah, it's very hard.
- 53:57Joe Clemente: but again, I think as you and I have both gone through this, it was the right move for us.
- 54:03Joe Clemente: that, that is definite.
- 54:04Joe Clemente: And if anybody were to ask me that, I tell them all the time, that was the best decision I made for my son
- 54:10Kevin T. Mulhearn: and remember, the private schools, a lot of people go to the private schools for the specific purpose of playing sports.
- 54:16Kevin T. Mulhearn: And, administrators don't wanna hear this'cause, it's always about the school first.
- 54:20Kevin T. Mulhearn: but reality is when you're going to high school to play sports, you're going to high school to play
- 54:25Joe Clemente: That's exactly what it is.
- 54:26Joe Clemente: You can't sugarcoat that
- 54:28Kevin T. Mulhearn: I have to tell you, I, I always fashioned myself a smart guy, and, I played football, basketball, and baseball at Poly Prep.
- 54:35Kevin T. Mulhearn: This sh- this year I, I-- My mom found my report card, my entire transcript from high school, and she gave it to me, and I brought it home and I showed Dennis.
- 54:43Kevin T. Mulhearn: I said, hey Dennis, wanna see something funny?
- 54:45Kevin T. Mulhearn: Take a look." He looked at my high school transcript.
- 54:49Kevin T. Mulhearn: He said,"Dad, I thought you were a smart guy." I said, I like to think I am." He said,"You did awful in high school.
- 54:54Kevin T. Mulhearn: all these C minuses.
- 54:55Kevin T. Mulhearn: What is this?
- 54:56Kevin T. Mulhearn: C mi- how you ever get a C minus, you'd have my head."
- 54:59Joe Clemente: You're like,"I'm playing
- 55:01Kevin T. Mulhearn: I said, I always thought I did really well in high school.
- 55:03Kevin T. Mulhearn: I was, a, a cut above." But, the reality was, I was playing football, basketball, and baseball.
- 55:08Kevin T. Mulhearn: Yeah.
- 55:08Kevin T. Mulhearn: And those were my- Sure.
- 55:09Kevin T. Mulhearn: what did I major in high school?
- 55:10Kevin T. Mulhearn: I majored in football, basketball, and baseball.
- 55:12Kevin T. Mulhearn: That's what it was.
- 55:14Kevin T. Mulhearn: but, but, it is interesting how, we do have different focuses, and Dennis is in college now and, I, I told him this year,"Dennis, I wanna tell you, your grade point average is a hell of a lot more important than your batting average." He says to me,"Dad, you've been telling me that for five years." I said,"Yeah, but Dennis, this time I actually mean it."
- 55:35Joe Clemente: Like it means something now, man
- 55:36Kevin T. Mulhearn: You mean something now.
- 55:37Kevin T. Mulhearn: and that's the truth.
- 55:38Kevin T. Mulhearn: h-h-in high school, the, the committed dads, the one thing about the Don Bosco dads, all like crazy committed
- 55:45Joe Clemente: Oh, yeah
- 55:46Kevin T. Mulhearn: guys.
- 55:47Kevin T. Mulhearn: That's what I loved about it, that I was not the only baseball nut in the group.
- 55:50Kevin T. Mulhearn: I was one of many.
- 55:51Kevin T. Mulhearn: it was mixed nuts.
- 55:53Kevin T. Mulhearn: s- and that's a fact.
- 55:54Kevin T. Mulhearn: there's o-one guy crazier than the next, which I loved.
- 55:57Kevin T. Mulhearn: They were all great guys, too.
- 55:59Kevin T. Mulhearn: Crazy.
- 55:59Kevin T. Mulhearn: so, but at the end of the day, you d- you do what you have to do to get your kid through it.
- 56:04Kevin T. Mulhearn: one last thing I wanna focus on for a second is recruiting.
- 56:08Kevin T. Mulhearn: the high school recruiting, what are the rules?
- 56:11Kevin T. Mulhearn: What should happen, and what does happen?
- 56:14Kevin T. Mulhearn: Can you speak about that for a little
- 56:15Joe Clemente: Yeah, absolutely.
- 56:16Joe Clemente: Let's keep it, again, let's keep it simple, right?
- 56:19Joe Clemente: so they changed the rules I think, two years ago.
- 56:23Joe Clemente: I think it was two years ago.
- 56:25Joe Clemente: So parochial schools are allowed to recruit, and public schools are doing it too, by the way.
- 56:33Joe Clemente: parochial s- coaches are allowed to recruit kids up to eighth grade.
- 56:38Joe Clemente: So as long as they have not entered a high school, everyone's fair game.
- 56:43Joe Clemente: So I can approach anybody.
- 56:44Joe Clemente: Most of the time we do things a little differently, just because we wanna make sure we're on the up and up, with the NJSIAA.
- 56:52Joe Clemente: We, especially at Bosco, we have a lot of people that reach out to us first, right?
- 56:57Joe Clemente: And then we go into it.
- 56:59Joe Clemente: But ultimately, we're allowed to go and recruit, watch games, do anything we wanna do up to, up to eighth grade, meaning like as long as they haven't entered a sc- a high school yet.
- 57:09Joe Clemente: Once they get into high school, the only way that you can talk to an athlete is they must reach out to you.
- 57:16Joe Clemente: So like as a coach, I could see a high school kid, I can't go talk to him.
- 57:22Joe Clemente: Okay?
- 57:23Joe Clemente: Which again, now the, the mayhem is all middle school
- 57:29Kevin T. Mulhearn: So you can't-- You, y-you're a coach at St.
- 57:31Kevin T. Mulhearn: Anne's, you can't go up to a kid who plays for St-St.
- 57:33Kevin T. Mulhearn: Thomas and says,"Hey, I really like the way you play." No way.
- 57:36Kevin T. Mulhearn: you come to my school, you're starting first baseman." No way.
- 57:38Kevin T. Mulhearn: that's ver- No way verboten.
- 57:40Joe Clemente: No.
- 57:40Joe Clemente: but if that kid, but if that kid, reaches out to the coaching staff, right?
- 57:46Joe Clemente: And says,"Hey, listen, I like your program.
- 57:48Joe Clemente: I'm interested.
- 57:49Joe Clemente: I'm looking at transferring," the, the next thing that would happen there immediately from our side is it goes to our admissions director, right?
- 57:58Joe Clemente: They handle it first.
- 57:59Joe Clemente: We got a-- Th- there's a big process for anybody from high school to high school, right?
- 58:04Joe Clemente: So we kinda focus on, up to eighth grade, and then anything over and above that, those kids reach out to us.
- 58:13Joe Clemente: But again, there's a huge process.
- 58:14Joe Clemente: and again, we- we're very good at that because, laws are laws and we wanna stick to it because we're not looking to break anything.
- 58:23Joe Clemente: and it's hard for a program like us because we get a lot of kids who inquire, right?
- 58:28Joe Clemente: Runes is probably-- He's stacked, a thousand emails deep about kids that wanna go to Bosco, Yeah Yeah.
- 58:44Joe Clemente: listen, when you show up at a, a state game and you got Timmy Corbin from Vanderbilt and, all, all these coaches from, Wake, everywhere, they're standing around.
- 58:54Joe Clemente: You got 30 scouts.
- 58:56Joe Clemente: you don't see that very often, right?
- 58:58Joe Clemente: I'm sure Delbarton, any of these teams, Josberger, any of these teams that are winning, at that point, coaches are showing up.
- 59:05Joe Clemente: But I'm gonna tell you right now, I will tell you right now as I sit here, I've been at Bosco for 15 years.
- 59:12Joe Clemente: W- It's taken us that long, Skip, to build this powerhouse, probably over the last 10 years.
- 59:18Joe Clemente: Every county game, every state game, even midweek games, there are college coaches there.
- 59:27Joe Clemente: think about that.
- 59:28Joe Clemente: they don't just show up anywhere, right?
- 59:30Joe Clemente: There's a reason for that,
- 59:31Kevin T. Mulhearn: And sometimes they see a kid who they, th-th-they're not spotlighting.
- 59:36Kevin T. Mulhearn: they see a kid and he just s-stands out, for a particular game or particular play, and that's how it works.
- 59:43Joe Clemente: Absolutely.
- 59:44Joe Clemente: There's a check.
- 59:44Joe Clemente: Let's go take a look at this guy or invite him to a camp, and that's how it works.
- 59:49Joe Clemente: It really, it's, that's how it works.
- 59:51Joe Clemente: but again, getting back to the rules, we can recruit to eighth grade.
- 59:55Joe Clemente: High school we stay away from unless they come to us.
- 59:57Joe Clemente: That's how it works
- 59:59Kevin T. Mulhearn: And if a coach, if you w- want a particular school as a parent, sh- should you go con- contact the s- the coach directly as a parent when your kid is-- If your kid is an eighth grade baseball player and he's good, and he wants to go to a school, do you go as a parent and talk to that coach?
- 1:00:17Joe Clemente: Yeah, so what I would do is all the schools offer open houses, right?
- 1:00:22Joe Clemente: And for us, like I know Skip's always there.
- 1:00:24Joe Clemente: Like one of us, like we're always there, right?
- 1:00:27Joe Clemente: Some of our players are there
- 1:00:28Kevin T. Mulhearn: One of us, like we're always there, right?
- 1:00:28Kevin T. Mulhearn: Some of our players and- There's open houses and all the coaches are present at those open houses.
- 1:00:31Kevin T. Mulhearn: so i- if they have the hockey coach, they have
- 1:00:34Joe Clemente: They got everybody.
- 1:00:35Kevin T. Mulhearn: basketball coach and the baseball
- 1:00:37Joe Clemente: And you can get information from the admin.
- 1:00:39Joe Clemente: And not only that, but usually f- like for our open house, there's clubs, like a bunch of clubs there, right?
- 1:00:44Joe Clemente: Fishing club, whatever.
- 1:00:46Joe Clemente: So like you, you really wanna get to know what you're getting into.
- 1:00:49Joe Clemente: again, same question everybody always shows up, what is it gonna take to start here?
- 1:00:53Joe Clemente: Is my kid gonna play?
- 1:00:55Joe Clemente: How good do you have to be?
- 1:00:57Kevin T. Mulhearn: But you realize that, that threshold question, w-, is my kid gonna be able to start here?
- 1:01:01Kevin T. Mulhearn: It's a question that cannot be answered when your kid- Cannot be answered when your kid is eighth grade.
- 1:01:05Joe Clemente: cannot be
- 1:01:06Kevin T. Mulhearn: answered.
- 1:01:06Kevin T. Mulhearn: and because the, the kid at 13 is not gonna be the kid at 17.
- 1:01:10Kevin T. Mulhearn: Nope.
- 1:01:10Kevin T. Mulhearn: And I valued Mike's candor when I asked that question.
- 1:01:15Kevin T. Mulhearn: I, I have to tell you, I wonder what I would've done if he had blown smoke out my ears.
- 1:01:20Kevin T. Mulhearn: I would've, I think, doubted the answer.
- 1:01:24Kevin T. Mulhearn: I liked the fact that he was candid and didn't s- and didn't make any promises.
- 1:01:28Kevin T. Mulhearn: but I assume, when you're making that commitment as a parent, dec- deciding whether or not to send your kid to a private school, there's a cost to it, too.
- 1:01:35Kevin T. Mulhearn: I mean, private schools are not free.
- 1:01:37Kevin T. Mulhearn: They, there's- No there's a value add that, you gotta d- dip into your pocket for quite a significant amount of money.
- 1:01:43Kevin T. Mulhearn: And you, and if you're doing it for your kid to play sports, and he goes there and winds up not playing, sometimes you wonder how much bang are you getting for your buck?
- 1:01:53Joe Clemente: But there, there's-- Again, it's like a big puzzle, right?
- 1:01:57Joe Clemente: and you gotta fill it in, and you gotta figure out which, what works for you and what doesn't.
- 1:02:01Joe Clemente: again, everything that you and I have talked about on this podcast, talking about kids and their sports, their sports life.
- 1:02:11Joe Clemente: As parents, we have to understand that there's an investment, right?
- 1:02:15Joe Clemente: Whether it's gonna be training, whether it's gonna be school, whatever we decide, right?
- 1:02:19Joe Clemente: 'Cause we make the decisions that are best for our kids.
- 1:02:22Joe Clemente: But the pressure that comes along with the investment on the parent side is always there, and that doesn't matter if you make, you know, 10 grand a year or you make a million dollars a year, right?
- 1:02:33Joe Clemente: There's always...
- 1:02:34Joe Clemente: Whenever you're laying out that kinda cash, you wanna know that you're getting the most bang for your buck, as you would say.
- 1:02:41Joe Clemente: the make- making the right decisions, and I understand why parents come to me at the open houses and ask these questions,'cause they, they're really, they're picking my brain, right?
- 1:02:51Joe Clemente: They'll be like, can I, can I just figure out if coach is like...
- 1:02:56Joe Clemente: Can he, hint if my kid..." no.
- 1:02:58Joe Clemente: you know what I'm saying?
- 1:02:59Kevin T. Mulhearn: just a little mini hint.
- 1:03:00Joe Clemente: what I'm saying?
- 1:03:01Joe Clemente: Like, like is...
- 1:03:02Joe Clemente: does he have a shot?
- 1:03:03Kevin T. Mulhearn: if he's gonna play, give me two winks a-and a clap.
- 1:03:07Kevin T. Mulhearn: So
- 1:03:07Joe Clemente: you know what I'm saying?
- 1:03:08Joe Clemente: "Oh, by the way, do you know who else is coming in?
- 1:03:10Joe Clemente: do you know, the roster?
- 1:03:12Joe Clemente: Do you know..." I'm like,"No, dude, I don't know." w- they're gonna show up.
- 1:03:15Joe Clemente: We're gonna see them like we see a lot of kids at summer camp, right?
- 1:03:18Joe Clemente: That are showing up on the field.
- 1:03:20Joe Clemente: but again, y- you have to do the research, you have to do your homework.
- 1:03:24Joe Clemente: And again, as a parent, I would just take a look at the...
- 1:03:27Joe Clemente: depending on where my kid is, like athletically, I would just look at what is in front of him
- 1:03:32Kevin T. Mulhearn: but Joe, that's the thing too.
- 1:03:34Kevin T. Mulhearn: Nothing is ever guaranteed.
- 1:03:35Kevin T. Mulhearn: You could have a really good shortstop and he co- he goes in and is rec- is recruited by Don Bosco, goes in to p- to play there, is dead set on playing shortstop, and all of a sudden-
- 1:03:47Joe Clemente: He's a center fielder.
- 1:03:48Kevin T. Mulhearn: fielder all of a sudden Nick- Nicky Becker signs up for Bosco and, your kid's not playing shortstop anymore.
- 1:03:54Kevin T. Mulhearn: That's it.
- 1:03:54Kevin T. Mulhearn: he played like the last-
- 1:03:54Joe Clemente: I'm saying.
- 1:03:54Joe Clemente: people ask us this, right?
- 1:03:56Joe Clemente: Cap, they ask us, and I'm like, I don't know what's coming in yet." You know what I'm saying?
- 1:04:00Joe Clemente: I've seen kids at camp, but I don't know the unknown, right?
- 1:04:03Joe Clemente: So But they-- but people all-- I get it.
- 1:04:06Joe Clemente: They want what's best for their kid, but
- 1:04:08Kevin T. Mulhearn: But they also want certainty.
- 1:04:10Joe Clemente: They also want certainty.
- 1:04:10Joe Clemente: Yeah.
- 1:04:11Kevin T. Mulhearn: and, and you're asking for s- for certainty and guarantees in a land of, of uncertainty.
- 1:04:16Joe Clemente: you get right
- 1:04:17Kevin T. Mulhearn: there's, there's...
- 1:04:18Kevin T. Mulhearn: Nothing is certain in life except death and
- 1:04:20Joe Clemente: That's it, man.
- 1:04:21Kevin T. Mulhearn: That's it.
- 1:04:21Kevin T. Mulhearn: So look
- 1:04:22Joe Clemente: That's it.
- 1:04:23Joe Clemente: So y- look, just do your homework.
- 1:04:25Joe Clemente: All right, tell the parents out there and the kids, do some homework.
- 1:04:29Joe Clemente: Make sure whatever program that you are looking at, like if they're not public, even if they are public, go watch them play.
- 1:04:36Joe Clemente: Go watch the coaches, right?
- 1:04:38Joe Clemente: Take a look at the atmosphere, the culture.
- 1:04:40Joe Clemente: The culture is crucial, right?
- 1:04:42Joe Clemente: is that what you wanna be a part of?
- 1:04:44Joe Clemente: Like we always talk about the brotherhood.
- 1:04:46Joe Clemente: That's important, do-- be educated before you make any decisions, because the only thing that happens is when you're not educated and you make the decision and it's not the right one, all you're gonna do is badmouth, the school and the coaching staff, and they had nothing to do with it.
- 1:05:03Joe Clemente: You ultimately made the decision, you were just unprepared, right?
- 1:05:08Joe Clemente: And then at the same time, you were probably unrealistic that, there are other kids that are gonna show up that are gonna be just as good as little Johnny or better.
- 1:05:17Joe Clemente: You just have to know that going into it.
- 1:05:20Kevin T. Mulhearn: just have to know that going into it.
- 1:05:20Kevin T. Mulhearn: Or perceived as such by
- 1:05:20Joe Clemente: Or perceive this...
- 1:05:21Joe Clemente: that's definitely what it comes down
- 1:05:23Kevin T. Mulhearn: definitely where it comes out.
- 1:05:24Kevin T. Mulhearn: That, and, and, baseball's a, it's a subjective game.
- 1:05:26Kevin T. Mulhearn: You might look at one kid, as a catcher behind the plate, and you're a former catcher say,"Hey, this kid's the best catcher I've seen in the area." The next coach could, could look at the kid and say,"Oh, he's okay, but I like this kid better." and, and- That's how it
- 1:05:37Joe Clemente: how it happens
- 1:05:38Kevin T. Mulhearn: and es- especially at a school, a, a prominent private school, in, in New Jersey, any of them really, Bosco, Delbarton, any of the- the top schools, you're gonna have that.
- 1:05:48Kevin T. Mulhearn: You're gonna have really good kids who have different skill sets, and they're all competing against each other, and one kid's gonna light up one coach, and another kid might light up another coach.
- 1:06:00Kevin T. Mulhearn: The question is: Who's the coach making the final decisions?
- 1:06:03Kevin T. Mulhearn: And that's really how it is.
- 1:06:05Kevin T. Mulhearn: it's a very uncertain game.
- 1:06:07Kevin T. Mulhearn: but, but like I said, we talked about this last week a little bit, the one thing I w- I will say is that the, the kids on that team, they all buy in.
- 1:06:16Kevin T. Mulhearn: the, the Don Bosco kids all bought in, and by the time that season was over in 2025, they were running on the field as state champions.
- 1:06:25Kevin T. Mulhearn: You could not tell from the faces who was the all-league player, who was the future Major League player, and who was the last guy on the bench.
- 1:06:34Kevin T. Mulhearn: They all had the same look on their faces.
- 1:06:37Kevin T. Mulhearn: It was-
- 1:06:37Joe Clemente: w- winning solves a lot of issues
- 1:06:39Kevin T. Mulhearn: saw the last guy it was re-re-remarkable.
- 1:06:41Kevin T. Mulhearn: and something I'll remember that.
- 1:06:42Kevin T. Mulhearn: I remember the look of 25 kids screaming out of the dugout with, pure joy on their faces, and that was a beautiful thing.
- 1:06:50Kevin T. Mulhearn: It
- 1:06:50Joe Clemente: It was incredible.
- 1:06:52Joe Clemente: It was incredible.
- 1:06:53Joe Clemente: I think I was screaming just as loud as everybody
- 1:06:55Kevin T. Mulhearn: sure.
- 1:06:55Kevin T. Mulhearn: I'm sure.
- 1:06:55Kevin T. Mulhearn: With y- with your voice, I, I have no doubt.
- 1:06:58Kevin T. Mulhearn: Oh no.
- 1:07:01Joe Clemente: funny.
- 1:07:01Joe Clemente: I keep hitting myself with this thing in the face.
- 1:07:03Joe Clemente: I gotta move it a
- 1:07:04Kevin T. Mulhearn: I don't know if you know that the, before, before that last game, I was there about an hour and a half before the game.
- 1:07:09Kevin T. Mulhearn: I was there before the bus came.
- 1:07:11Joe Clemente: you were sitting in the top right-hand corner of the bleacher.
- 1:07:14Kevin T. Mulhearn: were sitting in the top of the arena.
- 1:07:14Kevin T. Mulhearn: I was not gonna miss my seat, I remember.
- 1:07:14Kevin T. Mulhearn: We showed up.
- 1:07:14Kevin T. Mulhearn: We were watching the other games right
- 1:07:15Joe Clemente: I remember we showed up, we were watching the other games, right?
- 1:07:19Joe Clemente: I'm like,"Yo, is that Kev?
- 1:07:21Joe Clemente: He's sitting right there.
- 1:07:22Joe Clemente: He's, ready to go." And then everybody else started filing in, right?
- 1:07:25Joe Clemente: The other teams started going.
- 1:07:26Joe Clemente: I was like,"He's locked in, ready to go."
- 1:07:29Kevin T. Mulhearn: the blue, I had the blue and white shoes rolling.
- 1:07:31Kevin T. Mulhearn: I was re-ready to go.
- 1:07:32Kevin T. Mulhearn: That was awesome.
- 1:07:33Kevin T. Mulhearn: so-
- 1:07:33Joe Clemente: we'll let you control.
- 1:07:34Joe Clemente: Yes, you did.
- 1:07:34Joe Clemente: Different brand.
- 1:07:34Joe Clemente: That was awesome.
- 1:07:34Joe Clemente: That was tremendous
- 1:07:34Kevin T. Mulhearn: That was tremendous.
- 1:07:35Kevin T. Mulhearn: Too much fun.
- 1:07:35Kevin T. Mulhearn: But I hope, uh, for the audience that you've learned a little bit about the, the decisions being made regarding private school, public school, the difficult decisions making, the, the difficulty in making decisions regarding, what school your kid's gonna go to and what, where he's gonna play.
- 1:07:55Kevin T. Mulhearn: and the fact that l- life is uncertain, and certainly high school baseball and other high school sports are uncertain, too.
- 1:08:02Kevin T. Mulhearn: Nothing's guaranteed.
- 1:08:04Kevin T. Mulhearn: But the journey's well worth it if you persevere, in my mind.
- 1:08:08Kevin T. Mulhearn: this has been a fun episode.
- 1:08:09Kevin T. Mulhearn: I, I will tell the viewers that I'm not sure exactly when, but we're gonna have, Jim Wadica, from Wadica Baseball Club, pitching coach for Don Bosco Prep, is gonna be on to talk about the college recruiting process for high school baseball players.
- 1:08:25Kevin T. Mulhearn: And Jim is extraordinarily gifted and committed to k-kids and, really has helped doz- I think hundreds of kids, get good college positions and, roles in college programs, through sh-sheer effort, on his part.
- 1:08:41Kevin T. Mulhearn: and the fact that when Jim Wadica tells a coach about a kid, the coach credits his, his assessment,'cause,'cause Jim is a straight shooter and, and he touts kids who are good kids and good players and, his credibility is unmatched, I believe.
- 1:08:57Kevin T. Mulhearn: Joe, ag-again, this was a lot of fun.
- 1:09:00Kevin T. Mulhearn: Always enjoy this.
- 1:09:01Kevin T. Mulhearn: the viewers, I say keep moving forward.
- 1:09:05Kevin T. Mulhearn: Until next time, signing off.
- 1:09:07Kevin T. Mulhearn: Thank you.
- 1:09:09Thanks for joining us for another episode of FWrd.
- 1:09:11If today's conversation helped you, we'd love for you to subscribe and share it with someone who cares about developing better athletes and better people.
- 1:09:20FWrd is a Hard Knock Press publication where we're building books, conversations, and ideas that challenge conventional thinking and help people grow.
- 1:09:30Until next time, keep moving forward