Latest / Manager Mondays with Fexingo: People Management, Team Leadership, and First-Time Managers / How to Mentor a High-Potential Employee Without Playing Favorites
Transcript
- Lucas: So you spot someone on your team who is clearly a future leader. Great instincts — you want to pour into them, give them stretch assignments, maybe even have some off-the-record career conversations. Luna: And then three weeks later, someone else comes to you and says, 'I noticed you've been spending a lot of time with Alex. What about the rest of us?' Lucas: Exactly. That's the tension. And it's one of the most common traps I see new managers fall into. You want to develop your best people, but if it looks like favoritism, you actually damage the whole team's trust. Luna: So what's the line between investing in a high-potential employee and creating a perception of unfairness? Lucas: Let me give you a concrete case. A VP of Engineering at a mid-sized software company — about 200 engineers — identified a senior developer who'd been delivering consistently for two years. Quiet, reliable, great code reviews. The VP started meeting with her weekly, giving her first crack at the most interesting projects, and even offered to sponsor her for an internal leadership program. Luna: I can already hear the other engineers grumbling. Lucas: Right. Within a month, three other senior devs asked for transfer to different teams. One told HR they felt the 'path to growth was blocked.' The VP was blindsided. He thought he was being a good manager, but he'd made three classic mistakes. Luna: What were they? Lucas: First, he never told the team what he was doing. He created this secret mentorship bubble. Second, he gave her access to opportunities that other team members didn't even know existed. And third, he never asked her to share what she was learning. Luna: So it wasn't the mentorship itself — it was the lack of transparency and sharing. Lucas: That's exactly right. And I think a lot of managers default to secrecy because they don't want to make the protégé feel awkward, or they worry that announcing it will seem like favoritism. But the secrecy is what creates the resentment. Luna: So what should he have done instead? Let's say you're that VP, and you want to mentor the senior dev without blowing up the team. Lucas: I'd break it into four steps. Step one: set group-level expectations. At a team meeting, announce something like, 'I'll be investing extra time in developing each of you over the coming months. For some, that might mean one-on-one coaching; for others, it might mean special projects or training. My door is open if you want to discuss your own development path.' Luna: That frames it as a team benefit, not a special favor. Lucas: Exactly. Step two: rotate the spotlight. If you're giving the high-potential employee a stretch assignment, also intentionally give a different team member a visible opportunity. It doesn't have to be equal in scope, but it has to be real. This signals that you're investing broadly, even if the depth varies. Luna: So you're not pretending everyone gets the same thing, but you're making sure no one feels invisible. Lucas: Right. Step three: create a 'no-fly zone' for special assignments. Meaning, if a particularly juicy project comes in, you don't automatically hand it to your protégé. You circulate the opportunity to the whole team, even if you privately hope they'll pick someone else. You can still guide the outcome, but the process is transparent. Luna: That takes discipline. You have to resist the urge to 'protect' the assignment for your star. Lucas: It's hard. But the payoff is huge — the team sees a fair system, and your protégé learns that they earn opportunities through competition, not favor. Luna: And step four? Lucas: Step four: ask the protégé to pay it forward. Once they've completed a stretch assignment or learned something from your coaching, have them present it to the team or mentor someone more junior. That turns a potentially isolating experience into a shared benefit. The team sees the value flowing back to everyone. Luna: I love that. It takes the 'why does she get all the attention' energy and replaces it with 'we're all learning from her growth.' Lucas: Exactly. And here's a subtle thing: when you ask the protégé to share, you're also teaching them a leadership skill — how to communicate and elevate others. It's a double win. Luna: So let's say I'm a manager who's already made the mistake. I've been secretly mentoring someone, and now I'm sensing resentment. Can I course-correct? Lucas: Absolutely. But you have to be honest and vulnerable. Call a team meeting and say something like, 'I've realized I've been investing a lot of one-on-one time with a few people without being transparent about why. I want to fix that. Going forward, here's how I'll handle development opportunities.' Then lay out a version of the four-step framework. Luna: And the protégé — do you have a conversation with them first? Lucas: You should. You say, 'I've been mentoring you, and I realize I've done it in a way that might have made others feel left out. I'm going to change how I do this, and I want you to be part of the solution. Would you be willing to share your recent project learnings with the team?' Most high-potential employees will be happy to help. Luna: I think the underlying principle here is that mentorship shouldn't be a secret handshake. It should be a visible, replicable process. Lucas: Exactly. And honestly, a lot of this comes down to a single question every manager should ask themselves before starting a mentorship: 'If another team member saw this interaction, would they think it was fair?' Luna: That's a powerful gut check. Lucas: If the answer is no, you need to change how you're doing it — not stop doing it, but do it more openly. Luna: I think we've given people a really practical playbook today. And you know, this kind of content is why a lot of listeners tell us they keep coming back to the show. Lucas: It's true. And it's also why a handful of listeners have started supporting us directly through buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. That's literally what keeps this show ad-free and allows us to keep drilling into these specific management challenges. Luna: Yeah, it's a small group, but it makes a real difference. If the show has helped you navigate a tricky management situation, that's where you can help keep it going. Lucas: No pressure, ever. But if you've been meaning to, that's the way. Back to the topic — I want to leave listeners with one more thought about high-potential employees. Luna: What's that? Lucas: Sometimes the best thing you can do for a future leader is to let them struggle a little without your direct intervention. That builds their own problem-solving muscles. So if you're tempted to hand them every answer, hold back. Let them come to you. Luna: Good note to end on. Thanks for the conversation, Lucas. Lucas: Thanks, Luna. See everyone next Monday.