Latest / Once Upon a Time at the Oscars / One Hundred Men and a Girl (1937)
Transcript
- 0:00Hello everyone and welcome to Once Upon a Time
- 0:15at the Oscars. The show that takes you through
- 0:17every Best Picture nominee from 1927 to today.
- 0:20I'm Kyle. I'm Ryan. And today, oh this isn't
- 0:24the start of this, we just recorded the ceremony
- 0:26episode so I was like, we are starting a new
- 0:27year. No we're not. Nope. Nope. We're continuing.
- 0:30We are continuing. Hey, Henry Koster, remember
- 0:32him? I do. Do you remember Deanna Durbin? I do
- 0:35remember Deanna Durbin. I remember them both
- 0:38from the same thing. That's true. And if you
- 0:41loved a movie starring Deanna Durbin, directed
- 0:44by Henry Coster, in which they named a number
- 0:48of people. You're right. Yeah. Boy, do we have
- 0:51a movie for you. Boy, howdy. You know, it started
- 0:54with three. Three smart girls. Three smart girls.
- 0:57And you thought, wow, that's too many smart girls.
- 1:01I get three of them? I know. That is too many.
- 1:04What if we just went with one, you know? Well,
- 1:07how do you equal out three smart girls? Yeah,
- 1:10what could equal one smart girl? Well, I think
- 1:15what equals three smart girls is 100 men and
- 1:19a girl. Ah, I see. She doesn't have to be a smart
- 1:22girl. This is like the elementary school worksheets
- 1:26where it's like five apples equals one orange.
- 1:29Yes. The equivalent of three smart girls is 300
- 1:32men. Correct. But we got one girl. Yeah. Meaning
- 1:36we have 100 men and a girl. Which is, I don't
- 1:40know if you know this. It's very funny that you
- 1:41did this. That's the name of the movie we're
- 1:43covering today. Oh my goodness. Look at that.
- 1:46What a title, huh? I know. And honestly, when
- 1:48I saw the title of this, even before we saw anything,
- 1:51I was like, this is from that guy who did Three
- 1:53Smart Girls, isn't it? Yep. And not only that,
- 1:56but also Deanna Durbin, who was kind of the discovery
- 1:58of Three Smart Girls. Yes. Do you know the name
- 2:03of that Disney movie? where it's like... Yes,
- 2:06but continue. Is it Seven Brides for Seven Brothers?
- 2:10Seven Brides for Seven Brothers. Okay, I got
- 2:12that confused with this, and I thought it was
- 2:14going to be like a hundred guys trying to court
- 2:18one girl. One hundred men for a hundred women?
- 2:21No, just one woman. I thought it was going to
- 2:24be the whole thing. It was going to be like Princess
- 2:25Jasmine and Sultan sending in everybody. Souter
- 2:28kind of thing. That's what I thought the plot
- 2:31was going to be. Yeah. And when it said, like,
- 2:33starring Deanna Durbin, I was like, oh, I don't
- 2:35know if I love that. Yeah. But thankfully, that's
- 2:38not it. No. I will say this movie enters the
- 2:41lexicon of terribly named movies. Yeah. Yeah,
- 2:46I think so. There was many other names this could
- 2:48have been. We talked about this recently with
- 2:50another movie. Oh, what was it? It was, oh, it
- 2:52was The Life of Emile Zola. Yeah. And we thought
- 2:56it could have been called I Accused. right right
- 2:58which is much better but like this one could
- 3:01have just been called like my father's orchestra
- 3:04or you know something like that i'm gonna be
- 3:07so real with you 100 men and a girl is a much
- 3:10more interesting title than my father's orchestra
- 3:11so sorry man look i support you i'm just saying
- 3:15that it wasn't until like the 50 minute mark
- 3:18that i was like why on earth is this called 100
- 3:20men and a girl Right. Which, honestly, I take
- 3:23that back. Maybe the last 10 minutes is when
- 3:25it makes sense as to why it would be called that.
- 3:27Yeah. That's when it comes to fruition. Yeah.
- 3:30I guess so. We'll get there. But let's start
- 3:34at the beginning with this. And that starts with
- 3:36nominations. 100 Men and a Girl may have 100
- 3:39men and one girl, but it also had five nominations.
- 3:43Yeah. And those nominations are as follows. Film
- 3:46Editing for Bernard W. Burton. Original Score
- 3:49for Charles Previn. Sound recording, this is
- 3:53Universal Studio Sound Department, and this is
- 3:56Homer G. Tasker. Original story was from Hans
- 4:00Crawley. In outstanding production, this was
- 4:03on behalf of Universal Pictures. Mr. Crawley.
- 4:07Hey, that's K -R -A with an umlaut on the top?
- 4:12Yeah. L -Y. Oh, I forgot to write my umlaut in
- 4:14my notes. You fool. Ah, my regards to Hans. This
- 4:19was directed by Henry Koster. He's going to leave
- 4:21and it's going to be 99 men and girls. He's like,
- 4:24I'm through. Good luck. Directed by Henry Koster,
- 4:28as we said, the director of Three Smart Girls.
- 4:31Also, the founder of Abbott and Costello. Really?
- 4:35Yeah, yeah. Remember that was my double feature?
- 4:37Oh, that's right. That actually is going to paint
- 4:39a lot. Broader of a picture of my double feature.
- 4:42Oh, yeah? Cool. Let's talk about it. Sweet. Starring
- 4:45Deanna Durbin, the young actress star. She plays
- 4:48Patsy Cardwell, who is the daughter of a down
- 4:53-and -out musician. Her father, played by Adolph
- 4:56Menjoo, as John Cardwell. He's out there looking
- 5:00to make a buck by joining an orchestra. And when
- 5:03he has turned down and lied about... getting
- 5:07into this orchestra, she takes it into her own
- 5:09hands to have this group of musicians find a
- 5:15way to make some money. Yeah, when he's turned
- 5:18down from a well -known orchestra directed by
- 5:21Leopold Stokowski, portrayed by himself, then
- 5:27she and Patricia and John then find a way to
- 5:32fund their own. orchestra yeah and it's a little
- 5:35schemey it's a little little uh tricksy and honestly
- 5:39a lot of fun it is uh so this is what's interesting
- 5:44about this movie uh also written by bruce manning
- 5:48charles kenyon and james mulhauser um what's
- 5:52really interesting about this is the name was
- 5:55very confusing right when we first see the name
- 6:00i'm wondering what this could be what it could
- 6:01mean what's going on And what I did not expect
- 6:05is that this is basically a Little Rascals movie.
- 6:08Yeah. This is like a Little Rascals Three Stooges
- 6:11movie. And the general idea of this movie is
- 6:15that once Deanna Durbin finds out that her father,
- 6:18Adolph Menjoo, has lied about joining this orchestra,
- 6:22she tries to find a way to plead with Stokowski,
- 6:26the conductor, to let her father join. I could
- 6:32go through the plot on this and it's going to
- 6:33sound like, okay, yeah, there's a narrative to
- 6:35it. Cool. But the way that all these things happen,
- 6:37pretty much every scene then includes, well,
- 6:41I have to get around the security guard who's
- 6:43much too large to actually catch me. And her
- 6:47running from the security guard happens three
- 6:50separate times. And one of them, she's hiding
- 6:53in the rows and she's on all fours. And you could
- 6:56see like the feather in her cap sticking out
- 6:59from the seats. And they do the Scooby -Doo door
- 7:02thing, where she'll go to the left in row three,
- 7:06and then she'll disappear. And then you'll see
- 7:09her in row seven from the right. Right. You'll
- 7:11be like, well, there's no way you could have
- 7:12gotten there. Hold on. And it was funny, and
- 7:15I took it at the time, but I was like, what are
- 7:17we doing here? And at first, I said, this is
- 7:19Little Rascals, right? It's just Deanna Durbin
- 7:21being a little stinker, like you said, pulling
- 7:24a lot of tricks, trying to be a little comical,
- 7:27and everyone's going to love me, and that's why
- 7:29they're going to give my father a job. But then,
- 7:33the way that she gets funding for her father's
- 7:36orchestra, where he brings in 99 other men. is
- 7:41that she finds these elite individuals. Her father
- 7:45coming home, found a wallet on the floor, tried
- 7:48to return it to a woman. She drove off before
- 7:50he could, and he ended up taking the money that
- 7:53he needed, only the money he needed, from the
- 7:55wallet, and then turning it in. And when Deanna
- 7:59Derba finds out about this, she's like, well,
- 8:01no, we're going to return it to the person who
- 8:03it belongs to, and we're going to get that money
- 8:05back. Yeah. And that's what she does through
- 8:07a number of things. She finds the woman who it
- 8:09belongs to, and this ends up being Alice Brady,
- 8:11who is playing the Mrs. Frost. And she finds
- 8:15Mrs. Frost is very charming, gives her the money,
- 8:18asks for the money back, and then gives it to
- 8:21her immediately and says, well, that's how much
- 8:23I need from you as a reward, because I paid it.
- 8:25Or I already paid it and stole it from you. And
- 8:28Mrs. Frost finds this so charming that she brings
- 8:31her in and says, hey, I'm... I want to help you
- 8:33out. Like, I want to talk through this. What
- 8:35are you trying to do? And she promises her, I
- 8:37will fully fund you and your father's orchestra
- 8:40because of how charming you are. And once that
- 8:44plot is set up, I was like, cool, here's where
- 8:46the story kicks in. This is where we leave little
- 8:49rascals town. And this is the story. I was half
- 8:51right. We left little rascals town. And we then
- 8:55went into full -blown Three Stooges. Because
- 8:58Mr. Frost, her husband, then has a whole storyline
- 9:01where he and his best buddy are trying to get
- 9:05the best of each other. And always prank each
- 9:06other with their, like, you know, separate games.
- 9:09And the majority of this movie, man, is just,
- 9:11like, adults and children trying to trick each
- 9:14other. And, like, the folly, like, the physical
- 9:16folly of that. And I didn't expect it. That's
- 9:19not me saying, like, the movie is bad. It's just
- 9:22this is, we talked about Liable Lady. We talked
- 9:24about Thin Man and how these movies don't really
- 9:27like fit in to like the best picture register
- 9:30that we think of. Yeah. And A Hundred Men and
- 9:32a Girl for me just fell right into that category
- 9:35of like, hey, this isn't bad, but what is it
- 9:38doing here? Yeah, I can understand that. I think
- 9:41that more so than Three Smart Girls, this makes
- 9:45more sense. In my eyes. I would say so. I think
- 9:49there's some emotion to be had here, especially
- 9:52towards the finale of the movie. I think that
- 9:55the plot overall kind of feels warranted as far
- 10:01as like there's a little more prestige to the
- 10:04story than there was for Three Smart Girls. And
- 10:06I think that Henry Koster is really finding his
- 10:08footing with telling this type of comedic story.
- 10:12And kind of interweaving some drama. Maybe at
- 10:15this point he had worked with Abbott and Costello.
- 10:17So he was starting to understand effective comedy
- 10:20a little bit more. Maybe a little more slapstick
- 10:22as well that didn't exist in Three Smart Girls.
- 10:25Definitely more slapstick. Yeah. There's some
- 10:28silly stuff. And I think Deanna Durbin is a good
- 10:31lead here. In a way that she felt shoehorned
- 10:36into Three Smart Girls. Like they had to make
- 10:38it a musical. revolving around her. I would almost
- 10:41say she literally was shoehorned. Yeah. But with
- 10:44this, it feels like she is the lead and she's
- 10:48doing a good job. Kind of at the level and the
- 10:51caliber of some of the male lead children we've
- 10:54seen in the past. Granted, she's older than like
- 10:57a Freddie Bartholomew or a Jackie Cooper, but
- 11:00she's holding her own in a way that I think a
- 11:02child actress has not done yet on the podcast.
- 11:06I think that's right. I think that this is the
- 11:09closest we've seen to a actress getting close
- 11:12to the Freddie Bartholomew side of things in
- 11:15terms of deep acting in a young age. I will say
- 11:18that 100 Men and a Girl is more of Deanna Durbin
- 11:22fully realized. I think you're absolutely right
- 11:24that Three Smart Girls was more, hey, look what
- 11:27we have in the time that we... brought her in
- 11:30so we should try and build this movie around
- 11:32her as it's going rather than well we know what
- 11:35we have now and we're gonna build this movie
- 11:37around her from the get -go yeah and it feels
- 11:40that way i mean adolph menjoo is kind of in a
- 11:42different movie than uh than she is for the majority
- 11:45of this it's a lot of him being like i just don't
- 11:48know how we're gonna eat tonight or i don't know
- 11:50how we're gonna afford rent and she's like well
- 11:52don't worry dad i'm spunky and then she goes
- 11:54out there and just solves the problem immediately
- 11:56but she is a lot of fun in this. She's very charming.
- 12:02You can't help but be charmed in the same way
- 12:04that Mrs. Frost or Stokowski from time to time
- 12:07is charmed of her. But the other thing, too,
- 12:09is that she is this incredible singer. She's
- 12:12very talented. And this movie does suffer a little
- 12:15bit of what Three Smart Girls did, although it
- 12:17makes more sense, again, for a movie about setting
- 12:20up an orchestra, that there's just moments where
- 12:23they're like, today was a good day, huh? Time
- 12:25to rally around the piano. And then they just
- 12:28have like a moment where they just all play and
- 12:30sing a song. Sorry, I take that back. They all
- 12:32play and then Deanna Durbin sings a song. And
- 12:35it just felt like it was kind of more in that
- 12:38register of what we've seen with Three Smart
- 12:40Girls, but a little more elevated. Yeah. And
- 12:43Stokowski, Leopold Stokowski, the world famous
- 12:46composer being a part of this movie, is definitely
- 12:49kind of the biggest question mark. Not in a bad
- 12:51way, but just like, oh, how did you? How did
- 12:53this happen? Yeah. And him being involved, I
- 12:56think, makes it much more interesting. Are you
- 12:58familiar at all with Stokowski prior to this?
- 13:00No, not at all. Yeah. I can't say that I was
- 13:03aware of his name too much when this popped up.
- 13:07So seeing that he played himself, this seems
- 13:10to kind of be the thing. I did some reading up
- 13:12on this. He wanted to be a part of this. He signed
- 13:15up for it. He is a renowned conductor. So he
- 13:18recorded the music for this at the Philadelphia
- 13:21Academy of Music. Okay. And I think at the time
- 13:25it was a multi -channel system, multi -channel
- 13:27sound system. And it was the first time that
- 13:30they've actually done this to record music for
- 13:32a film, right? Okay. And this is what's interesting
- 13:35about the movie. With all the times that an orchestra
- 13:38is playing in this, which is probably like a
- 13:40fourth of the movie, none of that was live. That
- 13:43was all just recorded. So everything that you
- 13:45see on screen is them playing to the music that's
- 13:49actually playing over speakers. Right. which
- 13:51I thought was really well done, because at no
- 13:54point could you tell that, like, oh, they're
- 13:56not really playing this. Like, they actually
- 13:57are trying. And it seems like they got people
- 13:59who know what they're doing. It's like a really
- 14:01good Super Bowl performance. Yeah. I mean, you
- 14:04know, all the times that we're watching movies
- 14:06and there's a drummer that's playing, Taylor
- 14:07will lean over and be like, is he actually playing?
- 14:10Like, she'll be, like, kind of looking for me
- 14:11to be the determination of, you know, what happens.
- 14:13And you're like, yeah, he's really playing. Drum
- 14:16solo! But, like... It's always like a Disney
- 14:20Channel original movie where they're playing
- 14:22and they're not even trying. Right, right. Like,
- 14:25hey man, the acoustic guitar is the only thing
- 14:27I hear right now. Why are you playing a cymbal?
- 14:30That's just basic level. But in this, I was actively
- 14:34looking when I read this. I was actively looking.
- 14:36Pretty convincing. Yeah, they were great. So
- 14:38I think this worked out for them really well.
- 14:40And I don't know for sure, but I imagine maybe
- 14:43they're part of his orchestra. I know that he
- 14:47recorded in Philadelphia, so I'm not sure if
- 14:50it was his... The actors may have been, but the
- 14:53people who played in Philadelphia, different
- 14:55people, is my understanding. Okay. Yeah, I didn't
- 14:57know if they got members of his orchestra just
- 15:00to pan a mime. Not 100 % sure. Yeah, I don't
- 15:02know. But they look great either way. Stokowski,
- 15:05like, he must have been a draw for people in
- 15:08this movie. The movie opens up with him conducting
- 15:11an orchestra. And the credits are playing over
- 15:14his, I guess you'll call it a performance. I
- 15:18don't know if that's the appropriate term for
- 15:19watching somebody conduct. But it's kind of a
- 15:23unique opening sequence here. It's cool seeing
- 15:26the titles overlaid over actual footage. And
- 15:30this is, I guess, kind of a musical. You have
- 15:34Deanna Derb. You know, it's that type of 1930s
- 15:37musical where the songs don't... represent anything
- 15:41in the story they're just songs played in the
- 15:44movie yeah there's no performances like you know
- 15:47everyone kind of breaks out in song and dances
- 15:49around something there's no dancing uh it's just
- 15:52seeing and even that it's more like it to me
- 15:55and this is maybe what i should have said you
- 15:58know all those months ago and we talked about
- 15:59other movies of the early 1930s that really weren't
- 16:03musicals is what i said they're more variety
- 16:05hours yeah we're like hey here's where i sing
- 16:08a song But it's not like anyone else can join
- 16:11me in this. It's just more Deanna Durbin is going
- 16:13to sing a song. And that's how this comes across,
- 16:15too. Is there an orchestra playing? I might sing
- 16:18with them. Is there a piano? Someone go play
- 16:20that. I'll sing you a song. It's almost like
- 16:22these are less fantastical musicals. Yes. This
- 16:25feels like any time a song or somebody breaks
- 16:28out into a song, it's like, oh, I could see this
- 16:30happening in real life. This makes sense. Yeah,
- 16:32definitely. Yeah. It's not just like you're walking
- 16:35down the street and suddenly the entire mall.
- 16:39Well, I guess if you're walking down the street,
- 16:41it wouldn't matter what was happening. Outdoor
- 16:42mall. You know what I mean. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah,
- 16:44that one. Flash mob. Exactly. You understand
- 16:47what I'm trying to say. Yeah. I got lost halfway
- 16:50through that story. Because I watch musicals.
- 16:52Yes. And this is, I could see what they're saying,
- 16:56but I think there's maybe three, possibly four.
- 17:00Smart girls? Performances. Oh, okay. No, hey,
- 17:02whoa. There's definitely only three smart girls.
- 17:04Yeah. But there's one girl here. How do you think
- 17:07Deanna Durbin felt about that? She was labeled
- 17:08as a smart girl, and now she's just a girl. Yeah,
- 17:11I think that's a shift in the culture that we're
- 17:13still trying to recover from, honestly. It's
- 17:16true. I support a smart girl. Well, hey, you
- 17:20know what? I don't know what you're talking about.
- 17:21I support all women. That's true, yeah. Regardless
- 17:24of their intelligence, I support all women. When
- 17:26women speak, I sit down, I listen. This is, yeah.
- 17:29Wow, look at you. I feel like a couple times
- 17:31on this show, I've stumbled accidentally into
- 17:34things that are just like... Yeah, I'm going
- 17:36to say something kind of awful. Well, when I
- 17:38find a well that you're near, I just push you
- 17:40down it immediately. That's exactly what happens.
- 17:42I try my best on that. Kneecap. I do want to
- 17:46point out a few things here. So I mentioned all
- 17:48the nominations, film editing, original score,
- 17:51sound recording, original story, and of course,
- 17:52outstanding production. What I didn't mention
- 17:55were any acting nominations. Correct. So this
- 17:58is the only movie of this year, the 10th year
- 18:01of the Academy Awards. the only uh nominated
- 18:05film without any kind of acting nominations and
- 18:08when i first heard that i was like wow it's really
- 18:10interesting and then i watched the movie i think
- 18:12that's right yeah no it it makes sense um and
- 18:16you know we've talked about movies like that
- 18:18before where the the standouts aren't in the
- 18:22performances they're they're either in the visuals
- 18:26of the movie they're in the technical aspects
- 18:29of the movie or in this case i think it's kind
- 18:32of The story is probably the big seller here.
- 18:36Obviously, it's nominated for other things, some
- 18:38technical awards, the sound recording and the
- 18:40film editing. I don't know if those are the standouts,
- 18:43though. And the score itself is kind of confusing
- 18:47because you have actual musical pieces being
- 18:52conducted by Stokowski. But, you know, it's like
- 18:55your Mozart and your Chopin and all of that that
- 18:58already exists. Yeah, it's kind of it feels like
- 19:01a little bit of a cheat. Yeah. To have those
- 19:03in there. And I'm sure it's in reference to the
- 19:05songs that, like, Deanna Durbin sings. But the
- 19:08selling point here, to me, is the story. I would
- 19:13say the story. I do think the film editing does
- 19:16earn its spot here. I think having a prerecorded
- 19:19track that you're playing to, and then cutting
- 19:23to these different... musicians and their instruments
- 19:28and what they're playing at that time, that can
- 19:30get really dicey. That's true. There was a lot
- 19:32of this that I was very impressed by how well
- 19:35the editing was done. So huge credit given to
- 19:38Bernard Burton on this. Bernard W. Burton. But
- 19:41I agree. Original story, sound recording, that
- 19:43feels kind of like where the movie is most primed
- 19:46to succeed in this. Outstanding production, not
- 19:50so much. Just we've seen other movies just like
- 19:53what we've talked about so far of a higher caliber.
- 19:57I wrote down on this that it felt like an elongated
- 20:00Little Rascals Three Stooges episode. Yeah. And
- 20:04there's a whole sequence where there's a misunderstanding
- 20:07between Mr. Frost and Mrs. Frost. And then Patricia
- 20:11tries to alleviate this. And there's a driver
- 20:15that needs to get her from point A to point B
- 20:18to point C. she doesn't have money to pay for
- 20:22him so there's a lot of hey this guy will pay
- 20:23hey don't worry about this guy will take care
- 20:25of it well you'll know him because he's a large
- 20:27guy and a lot of the communication is very goofy
- 20:30and fun and he tries to identify mr frost as
- 20:33well she told me to look for a large guy and
- 20:36of course this is a problem for him and a lot
- 20:39of it just kind of felt like this slapstick the
- 20:42goofy nature of like you know one of those cartoons
- 20:45or um little rascal shorts that was just elongated
- 20:50to 90 minutes and even like a cameo and i'm using
- 20:54like quotes around that can you imagine people
- 20:56in 1937 watching 100 men and a girl and as soon
- 21:01as stokowski turns around they're like clapping
- 21:03i could see it i'm just imagining it's like the
- 21:07equivalent to like chris evans picking up mjolnir
- 21:10right yeah and they're just like maybe not maybe
- 21:14maybe when he picks up his uh baton You know,
- 21:18the baton just starts like shaking a little bit.
- 21:20And it's like, oh, yeah. Deanna Durbin goes,
- 21:22I knew it. And then Adolph Menjoo says, I am
- 21:27inevitable. Yeah. Which he kind of is. Okay.
- 21:31He's just showing up. Let's, I'll get back to
- 21:33my Stokowski thing in a second here. Adolph Menjoo,
- 21:36Adolph Menjoo is probably my favorite part of
- 21:38this movie because I love him so much. Every
- 21:40time I see him in something, even if he's not
- 21:43necessarily the nicest person in the movie, it's
- 21:45always like, I feel just comfortable. Around
- 21:47Adolph Minjoo. He's so charming in this, even
- 21:51though he is kind of playing like the dumb father
- 21:53to a more intelligent daughter. But what's interesting
- 21:57is that, and we'll get back to this, the way
- 22:00that Deanna Durbin plays Patricia is that she
- 22:04is smarter about some things, but still makes
- 22:07so many mistakes in this movie. Right. And there's
- 22:10even a point towards the end where all hundred
- 22:12of the men are like, what are we going to do?
- 22:1410 year old? I'm like, guys, she's 10. Like,
- 22:19give her a break. She can't solve all your problems
- 22:22for you. What I was going to say, though, is
- 22:24that with Stokowski, like, even his involvement
- 22:27in this feels kind of like a Three Stooges thing
- 22:29where it's like, hey, this is the one where that
- 22:31one conductor was in it. And he just kind of
- 22:33shows up. So I don't know if I mean that negatively
- 22:37or positively yet. It's just more of an observation
- 22:39that this just kind of felt like. I was watching
- 22:44three episodes of one series pushed together.
- 22:46Yeah, that makes sense. I think we talk a lot
- 22:50about Disney Channel original movies and how
- 22:53sometimes these will have that feel. This feels
- 22:56like a made -for -TV film. Wonderful World of
- 22:59Disney is exactly what this feels like. Yeah.
- 23:01Great call. Even if it's not Disney, it does
- 23:04feel like, oh, this is something that would be
- 23:06made for TV in the 90s. Yeah. That being said,
- 23:11though, I don't dislike it. No, I think it's
- 23:14doing a lot of really good things. There's some
- 23:16pretty impressive shots in here. And I kind of
- 23:19bashed the editing. Oh, I didn't bash it. I just
- 23:21didn't praise it. But there are a lot of cool
- 23:23dissolves that I noticed towards the end of the
- 23:25film where everybody's kind of playing phone
- 23:27tag at one point. And the editing there works
- 23:30really well. It helps keep the movie very fluid,
- 23:33which is something I don't think existed in Koster's
- 23:37previous film, Three Smart Girls. So I take back
- 23:40what I said on the editing. It's solid. But cool
- 23:43shots towards the end of the movie, not to spoil
- 23:46it, but you have Deanna Durbin kind of show up
- 23:50at outside of Stokowski's office or whatever.
- 23:54And they're in like this giant stairwell. It's
- 23:57like the balconies of a hotel room more so. I
- 24:00would think of like an atrium. Yeah. And how
- 24:02there's like at least three floors. Yes. So you
- 24:05have, you know. parts of these hundred men on
- 24:09all these different floors and you can see them
- 24:11all not parts uh you know what i mean like uh
- 24:14small sections of these yes group yeah and there's
- 24:19crane shot where Stokowski kind of walks out
- 24:21towards the balcony and the crane raises up above
- 24:24him so you can see all of the men on the different
- 24:27balconies and things all holding their instruments
- 24:30getting ready to perform for Stokowski and it's
- 24:33a really impactful shot and I think that's one
- 24:35of the moments that adds to the the drama and
- 24:38the emotion in the movie because it very much
- 24:40feels like a oh wow she did it Deanna Durbin
- 24:43did it she got everybody here and it's going
- 24:45to happen uh And I think that shot is what sells
- 24:49it. So you're getting some cool stuff. Yeah,
- 24:52I really like that shot. You know what it did
- 24:54for me is it reminded me a lot of like something
- 24:56we would see in a Capra movie. I'm going to say
- 24:59that the courtroom scene in Mr. Deeds goes to
- 25:02town, the final scene in it's a wonderful life.
- 25:06Like there is a lot of, we're going to put a
- 25:09lot of people in one room and we're going to
- 25:11frame this to where we can kind of pan through
- 25:13and see everyone. And it's almost a surprise,
- 25:16right? Like see how many people came to Mr. Deeds
- 25:19mansion or came to his defense in the courthouse.
- 25:22See how many people have come to the Bailey household
- 25:24to show their appreciation for him. And in this
- 25:27case, look at how many people we're able to fit
- 25:29in this atrium and the warmth that you feel in
- 25:32this and the music that they're playing is the
- 25:34same kind of warmth that you're supposed to experience
- 25:37or that you are meant to feel in the Capra movie.
- 25:40Yeah. Right? Like the, look how we've all come
- 25:43together and like we can go through it. We can
- 25:46make it if we are together. And one thing we
- 25:50haven't mentioned to this point is that while
- 25:52the orchestra is a very large part of it, the
- 25:54thing that kind of sells to Kowski and so many
- 25:56other people, is Deanna Durbin singing. So when
- 25:59he hears her sing, he kind of changes his tone
- 26:01about all of this. She's no longer this brat
- 26:03who's just trying to get his attention while
- 26:05he's trying to practice and rehearse. She is
- 26:07this unsolved or this unrealized talent. Yeah.
- 26:11And now he can have a orchestra and a singer
- 26:16behind it that he could really, really get into.
- 26:19But that shot specifically is, I thought even
- 26:22the movement of the camera felt very Capra -esque.
- 26:25Not to say it's a Capra shot, but it did remind
- 26:27me of more like it evolving into like that is
- 26:30the peak of the movie. And it is. Again, the
- 26:33editing of that is fantastic because there were
- 26:35multiple people playing at one time and they're
- 26:38playing to that track, which I thought, again,
- 26:40was very convincing. Yeah, I agree. I think that
- 26:44that shot itself. Really changed my perspective
- 26:48on the movie I'd been watching up to that point.
- 26:50I think it was a fun little comedic romp. And
- 26:53then adding that emotional moment kind of shifted
- 26:57the whole movie for me and just made me like
- 26:59it a little bit more. It is a tough movie to
- 27:02feel like, oh, we got to stretch a little bit
- 27:05to really talk about without just falling back
- 27:09into. And Deanna Durbin was this and that, you
- 27:12know? Yeah, but to be honest, I feel like that's
- 27:14the movie's problem, too. Yeah. I think the movie
- 27:16struggles to kind of keep, like, you know, the
- 27:18runtime there. Because so much of it is like,
- 27:21hey, here's where I trick that guy who's at Stokowski's.
- 27:24If I could tell you how many times Deanna Durbin,
- 27:27like, sneaks into Stokowski's rehearsal space
- 27:30and gets chased out by that guy. And her father.
- 27:34He's getting chased out of places, too. Like,
- 27:36it runs in the family. Well, they run. That family
- 27:39runs. That whole family does. Yes. Yeah. It's
- 27:42it's you brought up libeled lady before and how
- 27:46that's why is this an Oscar contender? It's a
- 27:49lot of fun, but it doesn't make sense. And I
- 27:52think with that, like we started pulling little
- 27:53scenes where we were like, that was really funny
- 27:55and that was really cute. And that's kind of
- 27:57how I feel about this. Like there's the scene
- 28:00where Deanna Durbin first. has good news for
- 28:04her father. Like, hey, I have an opportunity.
- 28:06Alice Brady's character is going to fund this
- 28:09thing. And she's trying to explain it to her
- 28:11father and his bandmates while they're playing
- 28:14cards. And she sits, like, on the seat of...
- 28:18I forget his name. It might be Max or Eric, her
- 28:22father's friend. Michael. Michael, thank you.
- 28:25And she, like, kind of pushes him halfway out
- 28:28of the seat when she sits down and she turns
- 28:30and she's like, sorry, Michael. And... It just
- 28:32reminded me so much of Judy Garland in a way.
- 28:37And I do wonder, based off her performance here,
- 28:41like how close was she to maybe landing the role
- 28:43of Dorothy? Oh, she might have just been a little
- 28:46too young. Too young or too old? Deanna Durbin?
- 28:50Yeah. Was Judy Garland like 13 in Wizard of Oz?
- 28:54She was very young. Because to me, Deanna Durbin's
- 28:57got to be like 10 in this movie. That's just
- 29:00two years prior. She's definitely older than
- 29:03that. If you want to talk about something else,
- 29:06I'm going to look up both of their ages. I will
- 29:08say that Alice Brady, we've talked about her
- 29:11previously. Gay divorcee in Old Chicago is where
- 29:14we've seen her and where we will see her again.
- 29:17But she was also in Three Smart Girls as well.
- 29:19So not only is Durbin returning, but also Alice
- 29:23Brady, who I liked a lot in Gay Divorcee. Excited
- 29:27to see her in Old Chicago. She does well here.
- 29:29I think it's just, it's kind of, a small part
- 29:33for her and she doesn't show up again. Her husband,
- 29:37Mr. Frost is really the one who I think gets
- 29:38the majority of the screen time after her initial
- 29:40appearance. Here we go. All right. She was considered
- 29:45for the role of, of Dorothy Gale, but was just
- 29:48unavailable. Interesting. She was, she was working.
- 29:50She, they were both, uh, with, well, she was
- 29:54under contract with Universal. So I think that's
- 29:56what it. boiled down to. We've seen some trades
- 29:59in there, but ultimately, yeah, they're going
- 30:01to stick pretty close to their contracts. Yeah,
- 30:03and her and Judy Garland had starred, from what
- 30:06I see, in a movie in 1936 as well. Every Sunday
- 30:10is what it's called. Short musical film. Interesting.
- 30:14Yeah, I don't know. She just gave a lot of Dorothy,
- 30:16and I wondered if that was a possibility. Well,
- 30:20clearly they thought about it too. One person
- 30:23we haven't talked much about, you mentioned Michael
- 30:25Bordoff. Um, that is her, uh, John's friend who
- 30:30at one point I thought maybe was her brother,
- 30:33his son, cause he's just kind of there, but now
- 30:36he's just a friend who hangs out. So, uh, is
- 30:39it Misha Auer? Oh, I don't know. You mentioned
- 30:41his name in the ceremony episode. Who was he?
- 30:44He was Michael. Oh, uh, yeah. I don't, I don't
- 30:48even know his name. I believe it's Misha Auer.
- 30:50We'll, we'll stick with that for now. So Misha,
- 30:52uh, playing Michael. He was great in this, and
- 30:56I think that whenever we talk about this kind
- 30:58of movie, and I think Gay Divorcee is a little
- 31:00different, but let's lump that in just for the
- 31:02sake of this comparison. Whenever we talk about
- 31:05a Three Smart Girls, or a Gay Divorcee, or a
- 31:09Libel Lady, I always anticipate that there will
- 31:12be someone who is a physical comedian, and it
- 31:15is solely in the faces they make. That is Misha
- 31:17Hauer. Misha in this movie is the king. He is
- 31:22going for the Georgie Stone. I know that Edward
- 31:25Everett Horton is another man like this who just
- 31:27is known for his facial reactions. I just want
- 31:31to go ahead and formally announce that Misha
- 31:33Auer is in the running for that. Because his
- 31:36facial reactions in this movie, 100 Men and a
- 31:39Girl, fantastic. Yeah. These types of characters
- 31:43feel like the... Oh, what's the word for like
- 31:47the beginning of something? The... No, precipice
- 31:52is like the... Trying to think of Jack and Daxter.
- 31:56Precedent? It's like the beginning. I just said
- 32:01that. The beginning. Yeah, the beginning. Like
- 32:03the dawn of the sidekick character. The comedic
- 32:08sidekick. Yes. We see a lot of those. And I think
- 32:12it's almost like... When you think about your
- 32:14Disney movies, like these are your Abu characters,
- 32:17and what's another good one? Miko in Pocahontas.
- 32:23Oh, yeah, the raccoon. Honestly, even the carpet,
- 32:26magic carpet in Aladdin. Yeah, yeah. Flounder's
- 32:30not my favorite, but something like that, you
- 32:32know? Maybe Scuttle. You pick Scuttle over Flounder?
- 32:36I don't really like Flounder. Like the character
- 32:39or the fish? he's both ryan no i know he's both
- 32:42i'm just saying do you not like the taste of
- 32:44like flounder oh no flounder's good the taste
- 32:47of flounder but i'm saying the character i'm
- 32:50not crazy about okay he's like boring piglet
- 32:53to me where he's like ariel i don't think we
- 32:55should do that but he doesn't oh did the deer
- 32:58kind of thing yeah okay i see what you're saying
- 33:01it's fine although i think it's really funny
- 33:02that like uh the crab is named sebastian yeah
- 33:07and the seagull is named scuttle And the flounder
- 33:11is just named Flounder. Right. They should have
- 33:13just called him Dinner. Freddy. Okay. Well, hold
- 33:15on. Rude. Yeah, you know, I think Alice Brady
- 33:20is doing this, too. I think Alice Brady is doing
- 33:22a pretty good job of, like, maybe not so much
- 33:24in this one, but at this time with Gay Divorcee.
- 33:28Like, she really is kind of getting into that
- 33:30same realm as Edward Everett Horton was. So I
- 33:35just wanted to point out, Misha Auer here is
- 33:38doing a really, really great, and great work
- 33:41as a sidekick in this, and I just thought his
- 33:43facial reactions in this were something that
- 33:45kept me coming back. Yeah, for sure. Trying to
- 33:48see what else he's been in. Lives of a Bengal
- 33:50Lancer. Yeah, I don't really remember him from
- 33:52anything else, but I liked him a lot in this,
- 33:54and it was very minor things of him just... Kind
- 33:58of being silly with Deanna Durbin. Yeah. I mean,
- 34:01this is extremely sweet of a movie. It's very
- 34:06short. It's only like 90 minutes, maybe 93. Yeah.
- 34:09I think you nailed it when you said this is like
- 34:11a TV movie. This is something that my mom would
- 34:14put on in Hallmark or would be on Wonderful World
- 34:18of Disney, and it would be completely fine. And
- 34:20it's long enough to justify a two -hour ad block.
- 34:25on the schedule and you watch it and you're fine.
- 34:27And then you're like, what else do I have to
- 34:29watch? Oh yeah, Citizen Kane. Like there's just
- 34:32very many different things that this is alongside
- 34:35that make it feel like the odd man out or the
- 34:38odd 100 man and a girl out. Right. Which again,
- 34:42you know, I don't want to say that negatively
- 34:44and then people are like, great, they didn't
- 34:46like it. It's good. It's fun. It's fun. We'll
- 34:49get into our ratings here in a minute, but it
- 34:51just, it feels so out of place. It does. It does.
- 34:55It's just another libeled lady. Um, maybe without
- 34:58the, the love that we gave it libel day. I mean,
- 35:02um, what do you think about like Shirley temple
- 35:05movies being thought of in the same conversation
- 35:09as like Oscar winners? I've never seen a Shirley
- 35:13temple movie in my life. So I don't even know
- 35:16if those are like cute little fun shorts or if
- 35:19they're feature length, like Oscar. worthy if
- 35:23they feel like made for tv i don't know anything
- 35:25about them really but even if we're not thinking
- 35:28about shirley temple if we're thinking about
- 35:29those kinds of movies okay right like um i'm
- 35:32trying to think of comps here but when i mean
- 35:37i guess the best way to put this is like think
- 35:39about the 90s like the little rascals yeah um
- 35:42a movie i'm about to talk here is actually a
- 35:44little similar about that in the double feature
- 35:46uh Jonathan Lipnicki in stuff like Stuart Little
- 35:50in The Little Vampire. Not The Littlest. Or like
- 35:55Harriet the Spy. Yeah, okay. Those kinds of movies
- 35:58that are like, they are a vehicle for this child
- 36:01actor to get their own project, and this is what's
- 36:05popular at the time. Those were never going to
- 36:07be movies that we consider to be Oscar -nominated.
- 36:11But because of the time, these Shirley Temple
- 36:13movies, Jackie Cooper, Freddie Bartholomew, although
- 36:17he kind of has more of an academic view behind
- 36:20it with something like Captain's Courageous now.
- 36:22Yeah. This kind of seems to be like the time.
- 36:25And the time is just that we are like, these
- 36:28movies are a big deal. And it's earlier on in
- 36:30the Academy. So my question to you is this. I
- 36:32don't have an answer for this. This is more of
- 36:34a discussion. Is it that at this time, they are
- 36:38looking at the movies that are... making the
- 36:41most impact and they are nominating that or is
- 36:45there just something we're missing with these
- 36:47kinds of movies i think that the academy just
- 36:49has like a different perspective on what is oscar
- 36:54worthy best picture worthy because these really
- 36:57are movies you you won't see nominated in the
- 37:00modern day um i'm sure a lot of it has to do
- 37:03with like the box office and things like that
- 37:06or just popularity overall but it's it's kind
- 37:09of hard to figure out like comedy doesn't even
- 37:12get that big of a recognition at the modern oscars
- 37:14no and honestly neither does cartoon now it's
- 37:18animated feature but like it's animated not cartoon
- 37:21right so like now i think there's a lot of um
- 37:24verbiage around it that tries to sell the importance
- 37:27and the what's the word i'm looking for not superiority
- 37:29but the elevated nature oh right of this so instead
- 37:33of cartoon it's animated yeah like i think that
- 37:37there's words like that so i i wonder if that's
- 37:40kind of now what you know a hundred years in
- 37:43to the academy that's what we're seeing versus
- 37:46the ninth year, which is what we're covering
- 37:49here. Or no, I'm sorry, this is the 10th. The
- 37:5110th year of the Academy, they're more so, well,
- 37:54yeah, I mean, you know, Deanna Durbin was a big
- 37:56find, and she's a great kid actress, and she's
- 37:59really fun in this, and it was a cute thing,
- 38:01so we're going to nominate it. Now, granted,
- 38:04we're not going to get any acting nominations.
- 38:06Adolph Menjoo is there to make sure that there's,
- 38:08like, you know, some interest in the acting overall.
- 38:11But otherwise, you're going to see Deanna Durbin
- 38:13getting into some hijinks. You know, I think
- 38:15Hollywood was different too. Sure. In the sense
- 38:18of like, there are producers out there looking
- 38:21for child actors to be the next big thing. Almost
- 38:25in the same way, I feel like the music industry
- 38:28is more this now than the film industry. Obviously,
- 38:32you have child actors, but like, what was the
- 38:36last modern movie you saw that introduced a child
- 38:41actor in like a really, really... Big role. You
- 38:45know, this doesn't count because she's not technically
- 38:47a child, but I was going to say one battle after
- 38:51another. Yeah. But teenager. Right? I mean, no,
- 38:54we would definitely say teenager. Yeah. Yeah,
- 38:56I think so. Okay, so let's think about this.
- 39:00This is not my answer, but let's just talk through
- 39:02it. Jonathan Lipnicki and Jerry Maguire, right?
- 39:07Okay. Haley Joel Osmond, Sixth Sense. Right.
- 39:11Dakota Fanning, I think, is a big one. Definitely.
- 39:14All of these are from a while ago. They are.
- 39:17There's not as much recently. Yeah. I think there
- 39:21was someone who I was really impressed with.
- 39:24You know, you're not going to like this answer,
- 39:26and we're just kind of talking through it. Buddy.
- 39:28The movie? The movie, yeah. Sorry, I should clarify.
- 39:31I guess there's a movie in the 90s about a giant
- 39:33gorilla named Buddy. That's not what I'm talking
- 39:35about. I'm talking about the horror film from
- 39:38this year with the giant orange unicorn. I think
- 39:41the children in that are fantastic. I don't think
- 39:44they're winning Oscars or anything. But in terms
- 39:47of an introduction, no, that just doesn't happen
- 39:49as often. I just can't even think of a movie
- 39:51that I've seen recently that has like a kid in
- 39:56it, you know, in a big role. Oh, I feel like
- 40:00I do, but I can't name it right now. Yeah, you've
- 40:02obviously seen more modern movies. Not only this
- 40:05year, but just in general. Right. But it feels
- 40:08like those are stories that have been kind of
- 40:11pushed aside. And they're not showing up the
- 40:13way they did even in like the early 2000s with
- 40:16stars like Dakota Fanning and Haley Joel Osment.
- 40:19What was it? If I had legs, I'd kick you? Yes.
- 40:22Like that's a story very much about a mother's
- 40:24relationship with their child. But that child
- 40:27doesn't even show up on screen. And that's kind
- 40:29of a creative decision. But I don't know. I feel
- 40:33like the modern Hollywood is shying away from
- 40:37kid actors. For the most part, you're probably
- 40:41right. Although, when you look at some of the
- 40:44bigger names in Gen Z right now, they started
- 40:47as children actors. Mechanic Race is kind of
- 40:51taking over right now. She is. Maybe not the
- 40:55first time, but one of the first times I saw
- 40:56her was in Gifted with Chris Evans. Okay. And
- 40:59she was phenomenal in that. She couldn't have
- 41:02been older than like, I don't know, eight maybe
- 41:04in that. She's always been great. She's been
- 41:07fantastic and she continues to be. Joey King
- 41:10is a similar person. Not quite as elevated, but
- 41:14still doing great work. I'll tell you the movie
- 41:16that I first thought of. And it's one that I
- 41:18saw a couple months ago and then just rewatched
- 41:20this week with Taylor. when we were at the hotel
- 41:23and we had some time to kill, I asked if she
- 41:26wanted to watch Rental Family, the Brendan Fraser
- 41:28movie from last year. And I love this movie.
- 41:32I really enjoyed my first time with it. I wanted
- 41:34to watch it again with her. She loved it as much
- 41:36as I did. But the reason I bring it up, there's
- 41:39a young character named Mia in the movie, and
- 41:41she's played by Shannon Mahina Gorman. And she
- 41:44was fantastic in that. She kind of has to play,
- 41:48like, you know, the child in the movie, but also,
- 41:51like, a young girl who hasn't had a father in
- 41:55her life, but also she strives for big things,
- 41:58but also she wants to be a little girl. Like,
- 42:01there's a lot that's in that part. And she does
- 42:03it really well. And it doesn't come across as,
- 42:05like, hey, this is where you're just supposed
- 42:07to cry and, like, lose your mind. Like, there's
- 42:09a real heartbreak in her. Yeah. So I thought
- 42:11she was fantastic in that movie. Don't know if
- 42:14it's an introduction, but when I look at her
- 42:16credits on Letterboxd, I'm not seeing any. But
- 42:19then again, it's not like she has seven movies
- 42:21lined up now because of this. So I see what you're
- 42:24saying, and this does happen, but just not nearly
- 42:27as much as it did in the 30s. Yeah, like, maybe
- 42:31it just hasn't happened in a while. And maybe
- 42:32that's kind of true with... The 30s as well,
- 42:38you know, like we weren't having back -to -back
- 42:40Jackie Cooper performances showing up at the
- 42:42Academy Awards. There was a little space in between
- 42:44there, and we hadn't seen Jackie Cooper in a
- 42:46while. Enter Freddie Bartholomew. You know, like
- 42:49there is a little bit of a gap. So maybe we're
- 42:52just missing, we haven't had one in the past
- 42:54couple years. Haley Steinfeld is one that I think
- 42:58of, you know, that was really, really big. What's
- 43:01her name? Abigail Bresnan? Yeah. Is that her
- 43:03name? Yeah, she was big, too. Little Miss Sunshine,
- 43:06right? That's her? Exactly. Yeah, so maybe we're
- 43:09just waiting for the next child star to show
- 43:12up in an Academy Award -nominated film. Definitely.
- 43:16But the other thing, too, and this can't be overlooked,
- 43:18is that in the 30s, there wasn't much of a spotlight
- 43:21on what this was doing to the children, right?
- 43:25That's true. And Hollywood does not go on and
- 43:30grow to be the... well -nurtured place for young
- 43:34adult actors right right so clearly there's a
- 43:37lot of controversies there's a lot of things
- 43:39that can happen to them so i'm sure there's also
- 43:42a good bit of hesitation on both the child and
- 43:45the adults or their parents side of putting them
- 43:49in that kind of environment yeah you would hope
- 43:50so right i mean i'm sure there's always still
- 43:53going to be some Abby Lee Miller's out there
- 43:55that are just kind of like thrusting children
- 43:56towards success in any way they can. But I'm
- 44:00sure there's a little more hesitancy around it
- 44:01with the more public cases of children not being
- 44:06treated well on set. Yeah. Or what it does to,
- 44:08you know, just fame in general, what that does
- 44:10to their mindset. Yeah. The Corey Feldman's,
- 44:12the, and this is a completely different situation,
- 44:16but Macaulay Culkin and like, you know, how he
- 44:18kind of shied away from acting for a while after
- 44:20that because of the way he felt he was being
- 44:21treated or saw himself. So there's just a lot
- 44:24of examples that I think have been brought to
- 44:27life that can question that a few times. Davy
- 44:29Chase. Davy Chase. But I do think that that just
- 44:34means that you have to be more intentional about
- 44:36what kind of situation you want to put your kids
- 44:38in and what kind of position you as a child want
- 44:40to be in. And I think that there is still a way
- 44:43to make that work. And I think things are getting
- 44:45better every day. Hopefully. That's the optimist
- 44:47in me. To where we can continue to see that.
- 44:51My guess is that's probably why we haven't seen
- 44:53as much recently. You know, I think also, this
- 44:56will be the last thing before ratings, TV. I
- 44:59think that's what it is. A lot of actors are
- 45:01making it on TV and not in the movies. Well,
- 45:03and with TV now, like it's just such a, especially
- 45:06with children, it's the same people you're working
- 45:09with. You don't have to meet a whole bunch of
- 45:10new people. When it comes to the creatives that
- 45:13you have to talk with on this, it's not a different
- 45:15group of people for every like. you know month
- 45:18that you're working on something you have like
- 45:20a lasting relationship and this is a new family
- 45:23and a lasting paycheck exactly so like modern
- 45:25family you look at something like that with those
- 45:27children yeah and how what they grew up to be
- 45:30and how they really are on tv and not really
- 45:32breaking out it's a great point tv is kind of
- 45:35replacing a big part of that yeah i think i think
- 45:38it's a mix of everything mentioned thus far That's
- 45:41right. And I think that's a really interesting
- 45:43conversation to have when we talk about Deanna
- 45:45Durbin, because this is the exact scenario that
- 45:48we fell or that is happening. Right. Three smart
- 45:50girls was, hey, look what we found. We need to
- 45:54incorporate her as much as possible in this.
- 45:56I think 100 men and a girl is slightly more realized
- 45:59because they kind of knew which. Not kind of.
- 46:02They knew what they had before with Deanna Durbin,
- 46:04so now they can build around her from the get
- 46:06-go. Yeah. But still, it doesn't change a Deanna
- 46:10Durbin movie. Right. Like, they are cementing
- 46:13what a Deanna Durbin movie is. Henry Costner's
- 46:15making sure of that. It's just not necessarily
- 46:18my cup of tea and very different than some of
- 46:20the other films we'll talk about this year. Yeah.
- 46:22I think there's less prestige in this movie.
- 46:24That's the best way to put it. So, that being
- 46:26said, I gave this movie... A very middle -of
- 46:29-the -road three stars. I did three and a half.
- 46:32Oh, wow. That feels high. I don't know why. Maybe
- 46:36you had fun. It might be three. I think that
- 46:39I didn't want to be too down on it. Like, it
- 46:42is Three Stooges, Three Little Rascals, like,
- 46:46you know, an elongated episode. But it still
- 46:49has its place. I just don't know if that place
- 46:51is, like, alongside these other movies. I'll
- 46:54be honest, I'm probably closer to a three on
- 46:56this. But three, three and a half doesn't seem
- 47:00unfair to this. It's probably three. Just because
- 47:04three and a half means I'm going to revisit a
- 47:05good bit. I don't know if I'd revisit this a
- 47:08ton. I would check this out much sooner than
- 47:11I did Three Smart Girls again. Easily. Yeah,
- 47:15this is cohesive. It has some emotional elements
- 47:18to it. It doesn't have any weird... distasteful
- 47:22jokes the way three smart girls did uh and i
- 47:24just liked it overall i think that this feels
- 47:27like everything they wanted to get from deanna
- 47:30durbin's first outgo outgo uh what's the word
- 47:35uh out uh outbreak adventure with henry coster
- 47:41you know i feel like that's what this this is
- 47:43definitely it's kind of one of those things where
- 47:45it's like hey it was better oh so it was good
- 47:46and you're like oh hold on it's like when you
- 47:48step up to the plate in baseball and you swing
- 47:51and you miss, but you do a full 360 and like
- 47:54the back of the bat hits the ball and you're
- 47:56like, oh, okay, that's 100 men and a girl. You're
- 47:58like, technically, I did it. Yeah. It's a bunt.
- 48:02So how about a double feature? I would love to
- 48:04do a double feature. So with my double feature,
- 48:07I wanted to go with a movie that also featured
- 48:10children actors. I don't know how we haven't
- 48:13talked about these two, actually. But kind of
- 48:16flipped the idea of 100 men and a girl on its
- 48:19head. 100 girl and a man? I knew you were going
- 48:21to do that. In that it is not the children that
- 48:25are pulling the pranks and being a little mischievous.
- 48:27It's the adults, and the children have to try
- 48:30and get rain back onto this. So I picked the
- 48:332002 movie by Sean Levy. Imagine my surprise
- 48:36when I saw his name attached to this. Big Fat
- 48:39Liar. This is Frankie Muniz, Amanda Bynes, and
- 48:43Paul Giamatti. Have you ever seen this? No. So
- 48:46Paul Giamatti is a Hollywood executive and Frankie
- 48:50Muniz and Amanda Bynes have an idea for a movie
- 48:54and they find a way, I forget exactly how, to
- 48:57pitch it to him. I think they wrote it down and
- 49:00left it or something and he found it. So then
- 49:02he makes the movie and Frankie Muniz is like,
- 49:04well, hey, that's my idea. And he goes to him
- 49:06and he's like, well, too bad, it's my idea now.
- 49:08So now the remainder of this movie is Frankie
- 49:10Muniz and Amanda Bynes punking. um paul giamatti
- 49:14and the ways that they punk him are numerous
- 49:17but the one that's most notable is they dye his
- 49:20pool blue so when he goes diving into the pool
- 49:23with like a g -string on he comes out and he's
- 49:25fully like tobias funke uh avatar pandora it
- 49:29out navi he's just fully blue and uh this is
- 49:34set to i don't know why this is so engraved in
- 49:36my head this is set to hungry like the wolf by
- 49:38duran duran okay And it's basically just like
- 49:42Mouse Hunt, but with Frankie Muniz and Paul Giamatti.
- 49:46That's fun. Crazy. But this is the kind of movie
- 49:49that I think 100 Men and a Girl is, where it's
- 49:51just, look at all the hijinks that these characters
- 49:54can get in. Don't we love a Frankie Muniz or
- 49:56an Amanda Bynes picture? And let's put them against
- 49:59someone like Paul Giamatti, who I think is actually
- 50:01a pretty good comp for someone like Adolph Menjoo
- 50:03in 1937. Yeah, that is great. So I thought of
- 50:07that dichotomy of those two things. And I think
- 50:09Big Fat Liar deserves to be in the Best Picture
- 50:12race as much as something like 100 Men and a
- 50:14Girl. Yeah. So that's my comp. That's great.
- 50:18I think the other dichotomy there is you have
- 50:20two child stars who both kind of went down different
- 50:24paths as they got older. Very. Frankie Muniz.
- 50:27Malcolm in the Middle, Agent Cody Banks. Yeah,
- 50:29and now he drives NASCAR, doesn't he? Or something?
- 50:33Does he? He does something with racing, but not
- 50:37Miracle in Lane 34 or whatever it's called. I
- 50:40believe you're referring to, was it Miracle in
- 50:44Mile? You're talking about the Disney Channel
- 50:46original movie. Yeah. Oh, yeah, yeah, yeah. But
- 50:49anyway. The boxcar movie. Exactly. He does something
- 50:52racing related now. And then Amanda Bynes, you
- 50:54know, who was a huge Nickelodeon star, she has
- 50:57had some trouble now. So I think those are like
- 51:01the two paths that it's very unfortunate that
- 51:04child stars can go down when they fall out of
- 51:07Hollywood in the limelight. Miracle in Lane 2.
- 51:10Ah, 2. Of course. The one after one. my best
- 51:15that's a great double feature thank you um my
- 51:18best my double feature here is this is your best
- 51:21work go ahead the best one this is about a young
- 51:24star uh who finds a group of kind of like down
- 51:30and out maybe not doing so great anymore they're
- 51:34past their prime group of individual performers
- 51:37and tries to help them get back Into the limelight
- 51:42and finding work. And that is going to be the,
- 51:45I forget what year, 2011 version of The Muppets.
- 51:49Hell yeah. Yeah. Let's go, brother. Yeah. I mean,
- 51:53I can't even remember the little guy's name.
- 51:55Walter. Walter. Thank you. Yeah. He's trying
- 51:58to get the band back together with The Muppets.
- 52:01Literally a line in the movie. I think we're
- 52:03getting the band back together. Yeah. I think
- 52:05that movie is funny. It has a lot of comedy,
- 52:09of course, because it's the Muppets. And then
- 52:11in true Muppet fashion, I think something that
- 52:14gets left out far too frequently with the Muppets
- 52:17is the heart. Yes. And the emotion. This is probably
- 52:21my second favorite Muppet movie. The original
- 52:24being my favorite. I love the original. But man,
- 52:28I've got everything I need right in front of
- 52:32me, whatever that song is called. I love it.
- 52:35I think it's fantastic. No, I'm a huge fan of
- 52:38that song. I'm just trying to think of what the
- 52:40line is. Life is like a song. And then there's
- 52:44someone else to make the comparison. And they're
- 52:46like, life's a fillet of fish. And they're like,
- 52:48yes, it is. Yeah, it's so good. Jason Segel has
- 52:52never been better. Well, he's really good in
- 52:54shrinking in the TV show. But I think he's never
- 52:57been better than this. This is the fully realized
- 52:59Jason Segel on big screens. And I wish there
- 53:03was like 10 more Jason Segel Muppet movies. I
- 53:06agree. I think that man understands the Muppets.
- 53:09He does. And I thought that movie was... God,
- 53:13I could have a whole essay about that. But Man
- 53:15or a Muppet. Am I a man or am I a Muppet? Yeah.
- 53:19It is legitimately a great song. It really is.
- 53:22And who did it nominate? Brett... No. I'm trying
- 53:26to think of the other half of Flight of the Conchords
- 53:28that isn't... Okay, yeah, never mind. Sorry.
- 53:30But he did the songs for the Muppets and Muppets
- 53:33Most Wanted. And I thought he was fantastic at
- 53:38that. He did all the songs in there. So Life
- 53:41is a Happy Song and Man or a Muppet. Yeah. Phenomenal.
- 53:46Great comp. I wish I would have thought of this.
- 53:48And Mickey Rooney's in it. Mickey Rooney is in
- 53:51it. Mickey Rooney almost looks like he's as surprised
- 53:54as we are that he's in it. That sounds right.
- 53:57He has like one scene where he just kind of like
- 53:58has his hands up like, hey, I'm in this movie.
- 54:00And that's it. It's great. Great double features.
- 54:03Thank you. Some of our best. No, I think they're
- 54:04both solid. So next episode, we will be covering
- 54:08Stage Door. That's right. Starring Katharine
- 54:12Hepburn and Ginger Rogers. Yeah. Ginger Rogers
- 54:15says, Fred who? Yeah. Give me Katharine. That's
- 54:19what she said. She wants to feel the Hepburn.
- 54:23Yeah, yeah, that's right. So stay tuned for that
- 54:26episode. Oh my gosh, you know what we accidentally
- 54:28did here? What did we do? A Menju double feature.
- 54:31Oh, we did, yeah. A Menju matinee. That's true.
- 54:34And about people trying to be performers again.
- 54:38Yeah, and, you know, the good side and the bad.
- 54:42Yeah, yeah, things about to get dark, guys. Yep.
- 54:45Things about to get real dark. So stay tuned
- 54:47for that episode. As always, I'm Kyle. I'm Ryan.
- 54:50And we'll see you at the movies.