Latest / Serial Killer Documentary Show / The Firefighter's Secret
Transcript
- 0:12Speaker 1: On November twenty fifth, twenty twenty. It was the day
- 0:15Speaker 1: before Thanksgiving. Received the phone call shortly after four o'clock
- 0:21Speaker 1: from the Mount Morris police chief and he asked me
- 0:28Speaker 1: of frantically, is anybody at my house? And I said,
- 0:31Speaker 1: my daughter Melissa is and said there's a fire and
- 0:38Speaker 1: it's bad.
- 0:43Speaker 2: My sister. She was nine months pregnant about to have
- 0:46Speaker 2: a baby in two days.
- 0:49Speaker 3: What do you remember from November twenty fifth, twenty twenty.
- 0:53Speaker 4: Who was my seventeenth birthday? My birthday is November twenty fifth.
- 0:57Speaker 4: Me and my mom were at a store. We're picking
- 1:00Speaker 4: out a cake and we finally got home and my
- 1:02Speaker 4: brother Carl frantically is calling the mom.
- 1:04Speaker 2: Have you heard from Melissa? Have you heard from Melissa?
- 1:07Speaker 5: And we're like no, why Carl said, the neighbor called
- 1:11Speaker 5: and he said the house is on fire. So at
- 1:15Speaker 5: that point my heart just sank because we were not
- 1:19Speaker 5: sure if Melissa was home or not. I just wanted
- 1:24Speaker 5: them both to be okay, and all I could think
- 1:27Speaker 5: was please just have one of them, at least one
- 1:32Speaker 5: of them make it through the night.
- 1:35Speaker 4: When everyone said they didn't know where she was and
- 1:38Speaker 4: they couldn't hear from her. I knew, I knew, just
- 1:40Speaker 4: had that gut feeling that she was gone.
- 1:44Speaker 5: For a huge tragedy like that to occur the day
- 1:47Speaker 5: before Thanksgiving, on Julia's birthday, right before the baby was
- 1:51Speaker 5: to be born, it was just so much.
- 1:56Speaker 6: When I arrived at the scene, I was told the
- 1:59Speaker 6: victim was found lying on the floor in front of
- 2:00Speaker 6: the stove. Melissa Lamish was a twenty seven year old
- 2:04Speaker 6: EMT We're trying to figure out why there's the fire
- 2:07Speaker 6: in the kitchen. We couldn't tell if it was intentional
- 2:11Speaker 6: or accidental. There was all kinds of possibilities running through
- 2:15Speaker 6: our heads, but we didn't know what happened to her.
- 2:22Speaker 1: My daughter, Melissa, she was very thoughtful and that's why
- 2:24Speaker 1: she got into being a paramedic. She wanted to help people.
- 2:33Speaker 2: When most of the first wilm she was pregnant. She
- 2:35Speaker 2: told me a couple things about the day. Matt Plodi
- 2:37Speaker 2: they on and off hung out for years and had
- 2:40Speaker 2: a similar click of friends.
- 2:41Speaker 7: Matt Plodi was a firefighter paramedic. He was a good firefighter.
- 2:45Speaker 7: Matt was somebody that was dependable on the fire scene.
- 2:48Speaker 7: He was just one of the guys.
- 2:50Speaker 8: He was keeping a secret the fact that he fathered
- 2:53Speaker 8: a baby in the hopes that the child wouldn't be born.
- 2:59Speaker 9: For matt he never had a child before. He didn't
- 3:05Speaker 9: want to make it known to other people because he
- 3:07Speaker 9: just wanted to keep that part of.
- 3:08Speaker 10: His life private.
- 3:11Speaker 8: Matthew Plodi was a person of interest on day one
- 3:15Speaker 8: simply because he was at the scene.
- 3:18Speaker 11: Matthew Plodi later told investigators that he was at the
- 3:21Speaker 11: house to see Melissa to talk about the baby.
- 3:28Speaker 12: He admitted he was there.
- 3:29Speaker 9: He told them everything that they would have needed to
- 3:33Speaker 9: know about his presence there, didn't have anything to die.
- 3:39Speaker 9: They discussed their finances, and then matt left as she
- 3:43Speaker 9: was making some lunch.
- 3:47Speaker 2: She waya I am zero.
- 3:53Speaker 11: I believe from the very beginning he was trying to
- 3:56Speaker 11: set up a story that there was an accidental house fire,
- 3:59Speaker 11: that she had been cooking something which would explain why
- 4:03Speaker 11: her body was found in the kitchen.
- 4:06Speaker 13: When you got the.
- 4:07Speaker 3: Call about Matthew Plode possibly being involved in a murder,
- 4:10Speaker 3: what did you.
- 4:11Speaker 14: Think, Uh?
- 4:13Speaker 7: Denial that it wasn't one of our people. It doesn't
- 4:17Speaker 7: chime with what a firefighter is. We put fires out,
- 4:23Speaker 7: we don't start fires. We help people. We don't hurt people.
- 4:29Speaker 7: It is unthinkable.
- 5:19Speaker 13: Before the fire that set Melissa Lamish's home a blaze
- 5:22Speaker 13: on November twenty fifth, twenty twenty, the day had started
- 5:26Speaker 13: with excited anticipation. Melissa was due to give birth to
- 5:30Speaker 13: a baby boy in just two days, and Thanksgiving was
- 5:34Speaker 13: a day away.
- 5:35Speaker 2: She was going to have a nice, private Thanksgiving with dad.
- 5:38Speaker 2: So I gave her a call the morning of the
- 5:40Speaker 2: twenty five and we talked for about two and a
- 5:43Speaker 2: half hours.
- 5:45Speaker 13: Cassie Ball and her sister Melissa had lots to chat about.
- 5:49Speaker 2: We talked a lot about the future. We talked about
- 5:51Speaker 2: what was gonna come with the baby. The conversation ended
- 5:54Speaker 2: because she looked outside the window. She said, you gotta
- 5:56Speaker 2: be kidding me. She's like, he's freaking here again. I
- 5:59Speaker 2: told him he's gotta stop doing this.
- 6:02Speaker 13: At the door was thirty three year old Matthew Plody,
- 6:05Speaker 13: the expectant father of Melissa's baby.
- 6:08Speaker 2: She said, I'll tell you what he wanted. I'll give
- 6:10Speaker 2: you a call right back.
- 6:11Speaker 13: Bye.
- 6:12Speaker 2: Hung up. Did she have a call back, No, my
- 6:14Speaker 2: sister never called back.
- 6:20Speaker 13: Melissa Lamish and Matthew Plody met and became friends seven
- 6:23Speaker 13: years earlier, while each was in college, they maintained a
- 6:27Speaker 13: casual relationship. The friendship, says the Lambish family cooled off
- 6:31Speaker 13: once Melissa let Matthew know about the pregnancy. Melissa told
- 6:35Speaker 13: her family he did not share her interest in becoming
- 6:38Speaker 13: a parent.
- 6:39Speaker 2: He wanted her to get an abortion. She didn't want that.
- 6:42Speaker 2: He blamed her, ghosted her. It did come to an
- 6:45Speaker 2: upset and Melissa. Because they were friends for so long,
- 6:48Speaker 2: she thought he'd at least want to be involved a
- 6:50Speaker 2: little bit yes, and also thought that he would want
- 6:53Speaker 2: something to do with the baby. To that point, she
- 6:56Speaker 2: thought he was a pretty nice guy. Then she saw
- 6:57Speaker 2: a different side of him, and that really upset her.
- 7:03Speaker 13: Deanna and Gus were fully prepared to help their daughter
- 7:06Speaker 13: with whatever she needed for the baby.
- 7:09Speaker 5: I had said, if he doesn't want to be a
- 7:11Speaker 5: part of the baby's life, you know, don't push The
- 7:14Speaker 5: baby is your child.
- 7:16Speaker 1: We'll tell her whatever you needed, I'll help you financially.
- 7:19Speaker 5: She knew she had plenty of family support, everything would
- 7:23Speaker 5: have been fine.
- 7:27Speaker 13: The Lammish family was a large one. Melissa had four siblings.
- 7:31Speaker 13: She was already an aunt and was known for following
- 7:35Speaker 13: her own path.
- 7:36Speaker 2: Melissa was unapologetically herself and that is what she was.
- 7:40Speaker 2: She's a perfect mix of sugar and spice. Not too spicy,
- 7:42Speaker 2: not too sugar, It's just perfect.
- 7:45Speaker 5: Melissa was strong, she was fierce. She was a go getter.
- 7:49Speaker 13: Melissa liked to reinvent herself through hairstyles and careers. Most recently,
- 7:55Speaker 13: the twenty seven year old had been working as an emt.
- 7:59Speaker 1: Melissa kind of fell into the line of work. She
- 8:02Speaker 1: had an experience in college that took her to an
- 8:05Speaker 1: emergency room, and she really appreciated how she was treated
- 8:09Speaker 1: and she wanted to do the same for other people.
- 8:12Speaker 5: You're proud.
- 8:13Speaker 1: Yes, it was her job and she took it seriously.
- 8:19Speaker 13: As her due date neared, Melissa had to stop working.
- 8:23Speaker 13: To make things easier, she moved into her childhood home
- 8:26Speaker 13: with her dad. Her parents had divorced several years earlier.
- 8:30Speaker 13: Melissa grew increasingly excited about becoming a mom. Even though
- 8:35Speaker 13: she and Matthew had little contact.
- 8:37Speaker 2: Melissa would continue to send him like sonograms or when
- 8:41Speaker 2: things would happen, because sometimes he would respond a little bit,
- 8:45Speaker 2: but she didn't know really where he stood exactly. But
- 8:49Speaker 2: Wilsa wanted her baby to have the option of having
- 8:51Speaker 2: the mother and the father, so she kept the communication
- 8:54Speaker 2: with him he often shut down.
- 8:58Speaker 13: Matthew wasn't just shutting out Melissa. He kept the fact
- 9:02Speaker 13: he was going to be a father a secret, including
- 9:05Speaker 13: from his coworkers and Chief Rob Schultz at the Carol
- 9:09Speaker 13: Stream Fire District, several counties away from Melissa's home.
- 9:15Speaker 7: We're here twenty four hours a day, and it's just
- 9:18Speaker 7: a normal course of being a firefighter, and that you
- 9:22Speaker 7: talk about your family, your personal life, and what's going on.
- 9:26Speaker 7: Good bad are indifferent? Well, I knew matt as a
- 9:28Speaker 7: single guy that didn't have any kids.
- 9:32Speaker 13: Even Matthew's own parents did not know about the pregnancy
- 9:35Speaker 13: until Melissa told them.
- 9:38Speaker 2: Melissa wanted them to have the opportunity to be part
- 9:42Speaker 2: of their grandchild's life.
- 9:43Speaker 3: How did Melissa say his parents responded to the news
- 9:46Speaker 3: of a grandson.
- 9:47Speaker 2: Melissa said that his parents were very nice, that they said,
- 9:51Speaker 2: let me know what you need. I'll help you any
- 9:53Speaker 2: way we can.
- 9:54Speaker 3: How did Matthew find out that Melissa had told his
- 9:57Speaker 3: parents they were having a baby.
- 9:58Speaker 5: I believe that the parents then approached him, but it
- 10:04Speaker 5: was not long after that that she had said he's
- 10:08Speaker 5: mad I told them.
- 10:09Speaker 3: Because he had kept it a secret.
- 10:12Speaker 13: Melissa celebrated the upcoming birth with family and friends at
- 10:16Speaker 13: a baby shower. She had let everyone know she was
- 10:19Speaker 13: having a boy. It was a happy time until nearly
- 10:23Speaker 13: two months later, on that fateful Thanksgiving Eve.
- 10:31Speaker 5: It was just all so surreal.
- 10:36Speaker 13: While Melissa's family tried to process their loss, investigators were
- 10:40Speaker 13: hoping to provide them with answers about what had happened.
- 10:44Speaker 6: The fire debris is everywhere.
- 10:50Speaker 13: Brian Ketter, then the lead detective at the Ogle County
- 10:53Speaker 13: Sheriff's Office, headed to the kitchen where Melissa had been found.
- 10:57Speaker 6: Everything's covered in smoke. Ceilings, walls had fallen down, and
- 11:03Speaker 6: everything's a mess.
- 11:04Speaker 13: Ketder and other investigators also headed outside to an ambulance
- 11:08Speaker 13: to view Melissa.
- 11:11Speaker 6: We've noticed that she didn't have a whole lot of
- 11:13Speaker 6: fire damage to her.
- 11:15Speaker 2: What does that say?
- 11:16Speaker 6: That's the fired and killer.
- 11:36Speaker 14: We need to identify the area of fire origin and
- 11:40Speaker 14: what may have caused that fire.
- 11:42Speaker 13: Michaelpoole, then a special agent with the Illinois State Fire
- 11:45Speaker 13: Marshall's Office, was trying to establish whether the fire at
- 11:49Speaker 13: Melissa Lammishes home was accidental or intentionally set. What are
- 11:55Speaker 13: you looking for.
- 11:56Speaker 14: We're the greatest damage is that where the fire patterns
- 11:58Speaker 14: are at. We're looking at every and everything in this
- 12:00Speaker 14: picture that may have something to do with the origin
- 12:03Speaker 14: of the fire.
- 12:04Speaker 3: Where do you think the fire started?
- 12:06Speaker 14: I believe the fires over here. Actually it's in these
- 12:09Speaker 14: cabinets where these cabinets used to be above the stove area.
- 12:15Speaker 13: But when Pool examined the stove, thinking that perhaps cooking
- 12:19Speaker 13: flames caused the cabinets to catch fire, he saw that
- 12:22Speaker 13: neither the oven nor the burners had been turned on, all.
- 12:27Speaker 14: The controls are in the off position, and there is
- 12:30Speaker 14: no fire damage in the interior of this oven to
- 12:33Speaker 14: show that this was some type of cooking fire.
- 12:36Speaker 13: They also did not find any electrical issues, So.
- 12:40Speaker 14: We're starting to run out of accidental causes, and we
- 12:45Speaker 14: could identify at least three very simple and easy ways
- 12:49Speaker 14: to exit this resident.
- 12:52Speaker 13: Much of the house besides the kitchen, remained accessible, so
- 12:56Speaker 13: Pool thought Melissa could have found a way out.
- 13:00Speaker 14: It was what I would call a survivable fire. This
- 13:02Speaker 14: young lady was a paramedic. She's used to dealing with emergencies.
- 13:07Speaker 14: For her to totally lose her perspective and stand there
- 13:12Speaker 14: and try and fight that fire. When you start putting
- 13:15Speaker 14: all these things together that you start coming up with Okay,
- 13:19Speaker 14: this makes no sense.
- 13:20Speaker 13: While Paul was inspecting the house, investigators talked with the
- 13:24Speaker 13: Lambish family. Ket Er learned about the phone call that
- 13:27Speaker 13: day between Melissa and Cassie that Melissa ended when Matthew
- 13:31Speaker 13: Plody arrived at the house.
- 13:34Speaker 6: We learned from the family that he was a fireman.
- 13:39Speaker 13: Melissa's brother, Carl, told investigators he had already spoken on
- 13:43Speaker 13: the phone to Plodi, telling him he knew he had
- 13:46Speaker 13: been at the house that day. Carl also told Plody
- 13:49Speaker 13: about the fire and that someone had died, but not
- 13:53Speaker 13: that it was Melissa. Investigators did that when they asked
- 13:57Speaker 13: Clody to come in for an interview that evening.
- 14:00Speaker 10: More than incation.
- 14:06Speaker 3: Yeah, as you watched his interview, what did you think
- 14:14Speaker 3: about his demeanor, his.
- 14:15Speaker 6: Responses emotionless, very soft spoken. Matthew said he went to
- 14:21Speaker 6: talk to Melissa. He wanted to talk about money, about
- 14:24Speaker 6: being allowed at the hospital when she was set to
- 14:26Speaker 6: be induced in two days, and that's why.
- 14:29Speaker 7: He was there.
- 14:30Speaker 13: In that interview, Matthew made a reference to a deadline
- 14:34Speaker 13: when explaining his decision to go to the house that day.
- 14:40Speaker 5: A deadline for that So we were.
- 14:44Speaker 3: The deadline for life or prayer leaders the deadline.
- 14:47Speaker 13: It was a phrase that investigators didn't quite know how
- 14:51Speaker 13: to interpret.
- 14:52Speaker 3: Was Matthew a suspect at that point?
- 14:54Speaker 6: No, he was not a suspect.
- 14:55Speaker 3: What are the next steps in the investigation.
- 14:58Speaker 6: We need to determine the cause of death. We don't
- 15:01Speaker 6: know if Melissa had a medical episode, or if somebody
- 15:05Speaker 6: did something to her, or if the carbon monoxide from
- 15:08Speaker 6: the fire killed her.
- 15:09Speaker 2: We don't know.
- 15:11Speaker 13: To get those answers, two autopsies would be performed, one
- 15:15Speaker 13: two days after Melissa's death, and then another about two
- 15:19Speaker 13: weeks later. While lab work was completed. The results normal
- 15:23Speaker 13: carbon monoxide levels and no soot was found in her system.
- 15:27Speaker 13: What was found was evidence of strangulation, including hemorrhages around
- 15:32Speaker 13: her neck. Melissa, it was determined, had been murdered.
- 15:37Speaker 5: We have to plan a funeral, and while we were
- 15:40Speaker 5: still waiting for things, it was nearly three weeks.
- 15:46Speaker 13: On December fourteenth, twenty twenty, the Lambish family held a
- 15:50Speaker 13: funeral for Melissa and her unborn baby, whom Melissa was
- 15:54Speaker 13: going to name Barrett.
- 15:57Speaker 5: We didn't get to kiss his forehead, touch his cheek.
- 16:03Speaker 5: The first time we got any kind of contact, they
- 16:09Speaker 5: were in a casket, and the first time I touched
- 16:13Speaker 5: his hand, I just remember gasping, just and I had
- 16:17Speaker 5: decided I was going to keep holding his hand, something
- 16:21Speaker 5: Melissa didn't get to do.
- 16:26Speaker 13: Melissa's family was convinced that Matthew Ploti was responsible for
- 16:30Speaker 13: their profound grief, that he killed Melissa simply because he
- 16:35Speaker 13: did not want to become a father. Matthew, investigators would learn,
- 16:40Speaker 13: had been juggling multiple women in his life.
- 16:43Speaker 1: I believe he did it because he's selfish and it
- 16:47Speaker 1: was going to change his life having a child.
- 16:50Speaker 3: Melissa wasn't asking him for anything, no money, nothing, He
- 16:54Speaker 3: could have walked away, so.
- 16:55Speaker 2: Why I think it was his pride. He wanted to
- 16:59Speaker 2: keep it as secret.
- 17:01Speaker 13: With no other suspects, and with Matthew admitting to being
- 17:04Speaker 13: at Melissa's home that day, investigators were also circling in
- 17:09Speaker 13: on Ploati. But we're still gathering evidence.
- 17:12Speaker 6: We had collected DNA evidence at the autopsy and we
- 17:16Speaker 6: sent that to the crime lab. We've got in search
- 17:18Speaker 6: warrants for phone records through in the process of getting
- 17:21Speaker 6: that information.
- 17:21Speaker 5: Back.
- 17:23Speaker 13: They were also waiting to get information back from Amazon
- 17:26Speaker 13: about possible recordings from an echo dot that Ketterer had
- 17:30Speaker 13: noticed and was retrieved from the fire damaged kitchen.
- 17:34Speaker 6: We were hoping it would record conversations or something from
- 17:37Speaker 6: the day between the two of them.
- 17:39Speaker 3: That Amazon Echo Dot could turn this case around.
- 17:42Speaker 6: Could have it could have recorded Melissa screaming for help,
- 17:45Speaker 6: galling out his name. We didn't know what it would be.
- 18:09Speaker 7: I was contacted by our police chief to give him
- 18:13Speaker 7: a call immediately that he had something very important, sensitive
- 18:17Speaker 7: to talk about.
- 18:18Speaker 13: When Carol streamed, fire Chief Rob Schultz returned the call,
- 18:22Speaker 13: he couldn't believe what he was hearing.
- 18:25Speaker 7: One of our firefighters was being investigated in a suspect
- 18:29Speaker 7: in a murder that occurred about two hours from our
- 18:33Speaker 7: fire district's boundaries.
- 18:38Speaker 13: It was now nine months since Melissa Lamish's death in
- 18:41Speaker 13: a house fire that had sent shockwaves through the community
- 18:44Speaker 13: in Mount Morris, where her home was located, but firefighters
- 18:49Speaker 13: where Matthew Plodi worked in Carol's stream about seventy five
- 18:53Speaker 13: miles away, were unaware of the fire. Ploti had said
- 18:57Speaker 13: nothing when you.
- 18:59Speaker 3: Heard the name Matthew in that call, what did you think?
- 19:02Speaker 7: I was, you know, there's no way this could be matt.
- 19:06Speaker 7: They have something wrong here.
- 19:08Speaker 13: But that disbelief started to change when Chief Schultz checked
- 19:12Speaker 13: to see if Clodie worked the day of the fire
- 19:14Speaker 13: and learned he had called out sick that.
- 19:18Speaker 7: Not in my stomach, like literally wanted to throw.
- 19:21Speaker 13: Up the fire. Chief sinking feeling only got worse when
- 19:26Speaker 13: he learned that investigators believed Matthew killed Melissa and their
- 19:30Speaker 13: unborn child because he did not want to be a father,
- 19:35Speaker 13: and then set the house on fire in hopes of
- 19:37Speaker 13: destroying evidence.
- 19:42Speaker 7: We had placed matt immediately on paid administrative lead. When
- 19:46Speaker 7: I called Matt in to tell him, I just said,
- 19:49Speaker 7: I'm being told that you're under investigation for a murder
- 19:53Speaker 7: of your estrange girlfriend and the baby that your father.
- 19:57Speaker 3: Did you ask him why he hadn't mentioned it.
- 20:00Speaker 7: Didn't feel that it was something that he wanted to
- 20:03Speaker 7: talk about, and he felt it was personal manner and
- 20:06Speaker 7: didn't want to disclose it.
- 20:09Speaker 13: While on leave. On August twenty eighth, twenty twenty one,
- 20:12Speaker 13: Matthew Plodi was called in again for questioning.
- 20:16Speaker 6: Remains Bryan, another time with the Shriff's office.
- 20:19Speaker 13: Clodi willingly appeared without an attorney.
- 20:23Speaker 9: I want to contribute to me in the life of
- 20:28Speaker 9: our child.
- 20:29Speaker 13: Over the course of the seven hour interview, he explained
- 20:33Speaker 13: to investigators why he was at Melissa's the day of
- 20:36Speaker 13: the fire.
- 20:37Speaker 12: It's we talked about your wagon payer and that we
- 20:44Speaker 12: we just said we work it out later to.
- 20:49Speaker 13: Visiting, he said. When he left that afternoon, Melissa was
- 20:55Speaker 13: talking about making lunch.
- 20:57Speaker 2: She talked about churning.
- 20:58Speaker 12: Supporting the back way.
- 21:00Speaker 5: Did I as fare out?
- 21:02Speaker 13: Most of the seven hours was filled with investigators asking
- 21:06Speaker 13: questions and Matthew Plody saying very little.
- 21:10Speaker 3: So did you go there to count her?
- 21:12Speaker 15: Or did you just go there and talk to her
- 21:14Speaker 15: and something happened?
- 21:15Speaker 6: We kept accusing him of things, and he never said
- 21:19Speaker 6: I didn't do it. He never said, you guys got
- 21:20Speaker 6: the wrong person. He was just emotionless and he wouldn't communicate,
- 21:24Speaker 6: not once in seven hours. Not once did he get upset.
- 21:26Speaker 6: Most people would have told us I'm done, but he
- 21:28Speaker 6: just sat and listened to us.
- 21:30Speaker 3: Had you ever experienced an interview like that before?
- 21:33Speaker 2: Never?
- 21:34Speaker 13: It wasn't just the lack of communication that made Lieutenant KETTERR.
- 21:38Speaker 13: Think Plody was guilty. But on the rare times Plody
- 21:41Speaker 13: did talk the unusual way. He frez things.
- 21:45Speaker 10: Did you attend the car?
- 21:52Speaker 6: During that seven hour interview, at one point Matthew did
- 21:55Speaker 6: say I had no intentions of hurting Melissa.
- 21:58Speaker 3: Did that make you do a double take?
- 21:59Speaker 6: Yes, because in our opinion that means I hurt Melissa,
- 22:02Speaker 6: but I didn't intend to do it.
- 22:05Speaker 13: But it was not an admission of guilt. So Keder
- 22:08Speaker 13: wanted to see if Cloti would say anything more and
- 22:11Speaker 13: made an unusual request of fire Chief Shultz.
- 22:15Speaker 6: Well, we asked Chief Schultz if he would wear a
- 22:17Speaker 6: listening device so that he would have a conversation with Matthew.
- 22:21Speaker 6: We would be able to hear it and record it
- 22:23Speaker 6: and try to gain some evidence that way.
- 22:25Speaker 7: When Brian asks this of me, I'm pre taken back,
- 22:30Speaker 7: and initially I had said no way, And I did
- 22:33Speaker 7: some thinking about it and called them back and said, yes, you.
- 22:36Speaker 3: Have a lot of responsibilities as a fire chief, but
- 22:39Speaker 3: I can't imagine you ever thought wearing a wiretap would
- 22:42Speaker 3: be one of them.
- 22:43Speaker 7: No, I don't freely talk about it. It's not something
- 22:47Speaker 7: that I'm proud of. It was something that needed to
- 22:50Speaker 7: be done in the hopes of helping the investigation. There's
- 22:54Speaker 7: a grieving family out there there that's looking for answers.
- 22:59Speaker 2: And so.
- 23:00Speaker 13: On September ninth, twenty twenty one, Chief Schultz called Matthew
- 23:04Speaker 13: Plodi and asked him to come in to talk.
- 23:08Speaker 10: And he agreed.
- 23:09Speaker 7: He says, I'd like to come talk to you.
- 23:12Speaker 13: Matthew came in later that day. The fire station was
- 23:15Speaker 13: quickly cleared of all other personnel and Brian Kett and
- 23:19Speaker 13: other investigators headed over. They were able to place a
- 23:23Speaker 13: device that just recorded audio on a phone on fire
- 23:26Speaker 13: Chief Schultz desk and listened in from outside the fire
- 23:31Speaker 13: station and from an adjoining office.
- 23:34Speaker 3: How are you feeling nervous?
- 23:36Speaker 7: Very nervous?
- 23:38Speaker 10: Fit scared?
- 23:40Speaker 13: Chief Schultz tried to learn what happened to Melissa by
- 23:43Speaker 13: appealing to Plody on a personal level.
- 23:46Speaker 7: I'm trying to find answers. I'm trying to help you,
- 23:49Speaker 7: help me walk through me would happened.
- 23:53Speaker 13: But the nearly two hour conversation yielded very little info
- 23:57Speaker 13: from Plody, with him again barely speaking about the day
- 24:00Speaker 13: Melissa died.
- 24:01Speaker 7: I remember saying fill in all the blanks for me,
- 24:04Speaker 7: And isn't it odd that no one here knows that
- 24:07Speaker 7: you're going to be a father, like that's that's something
- 24:10Speaker 7: we celebrate here.
- 24:11Speaker 2: What do you say? Nothing?
- 24:14Speaker 7: Head was down a lot of the conversation.
- 24:18Speaker 3: Did he ever say I didn't kill Melissa and my baby?
- 24:22Speaker 7: He did not.
- 24:23Speaker 13: With none of the interviews resulting in a confession, there
- 24:27Speaker 13: was still no arrest, something that exasperated the Lambish family.
- 24:32Speaker 1: Oh that was associating and I mean we were pastoring
- 24:35Speaker 1: the police constantly.
- 24:42Speaker 13: There were several reasons for the delay. There was the
- 24:44Speaker 13: wait for the fire, Marshall's report, which concluded that the
- 24:48Speaker 13: fire causes most likely incendiary and nature, possibly the result
- 24:52Speaker 13: of a fire being intentionally set in an effort to
- 24:55Speaker 13: conceal a potential homicide, and getting information from Ann Amazon
- 25:00Speaker 13: on whether Matthew's voice was recorded on that echo dot
- 25:03Speaker 13: they retrieved from the kitchen took time.
- 25:07Speaker 6: It did reveal voices, but nothing that proved helpful for
- 25:10Speaker 6: our case. It wasn't even on the day of the murder.
- 25:14Speaker 13: Investigators had also waited to obtain Matthew Plody's DNA until
- 25:19Speaker 13: after the August twenty twenty one interview, hoping he would
- 25:23Speaker 13: first confess to killing Melissa.
- 25:27Speaker 6: We got the results back, saying that it was his
- 25:29Speaker 6: DNA under her fingers.
- 25:32Speaker 10: Turned on the little chands by your back.
- 25:34Speaker 13: On March ninth, twenty twenty two, after a year and
- 25:37Speaker 13: a half of investigating Melissa Lamish's death with a police
- 25:41Speaker 13: bodycam rolling, Matthew Plody was arrested on charges including murder
- 25:46Speaker 13: the intentional homicide of an unborn child in Arson.
- 25:51Speaker 9: Technically, right now you are under arrest. The motive that
- 25:56Speaker 9: the state painted was just an inaccurate portrayal of matt
- 26:01Speaker 9: By the.
- 26:02Speaker 13: Time of Matthew Plodi's arrest, he had hired attorney John Copp.
- 26:07Speaker 9: They painted him to be this monster that, at the
- 26:09Speaker 9: drop of a hat, after a career of saving people,
- 26:12Speaker 9: decided to suddenly start killing people.
- 26:15Speaker 10: You were indicted by the grand jury.
- 26:16Speaker 9: The evidence doesn't show that Matthew Plodi murdered Melissa Lamish
- 26:20Speaker 9: or their unbone child.
- 26:45Speaker 3: Melissa Lambish was loved.
- 26:48Speaker 8: This is not someone who had enemies lined up around
- 26:52Speaker 8: the block who wanted.
- 26:53Speaker 3: To see her deceased.
- 26:55Speaker 8: Rather, there was one person and one person only, and
- 26:58Speaker 8: that was Matthew Plodi.
- 27:00Speaker 13: Yesterday, sixteen Assistant States Attorneys Alison Huntley and Heather Cruise
- 27:06Speaker 13: were part of the team prosecuting Matthew Plody.
- 27:09Speaker 11: All signs pointed toward Matthew Plody from the very beginning.
- 27:14Speaker 9: What we wanted to portray to the jury is that
- 27:16Speaker 9: he was a guide, saving lives for his entire career.
- 27:22Speaker 13: Defense attorneys John Cupp and Liam Dixon say their client
- 27:25Speaker 13: was misunderstood and as a firefighter, was a responsible person,
- 27:30Speaker 13: not a murderer.
- 27:31Speaker 9: Matt's plan was to financially support her. He had offered
- 27:34Speaker 9: her money before his plan was to be there.
- 27:37Speaker 13: Matthew Plody pleaded not guilty to all charges on March eighteenth,
- 27:42Speaker 13: twenty twenty four, more than three years since Melissa's murder.
- 27:46Speaker 13: His trial began in Ogle County, Illinois. The prosecution argued
- 27:51Speaker 13: that Ploti murdered Melissa and their unborn child because he
- 27:54Speaker 13: didn't want to be a father.
- 27:56Speaker 8: He was keeping a secret the fact that he fathered
- 27:59Speaker 8: a baby, in the hopes that the child wouldn't be born.
- 28:04Speaker 13: The defense told the jury there's no evidence Plody harmed
- 28:08Speaker 13: Melissa and that he had gone to see her that
- 28:10Speaker 13: day just to talk.
- 28:12Speaker 9: They discussed their finances, they discussed what would happen with
- 28:16Speaker 9: the birth of the child, and then Matt left as
- 28:19Speaker 9: she was making some lunch.
- 28:20Speaker 11: I believe from the very beginning he was trying to
- 28:22Speaker 11: set up a story that there was an accidental house fire,
- 28:26Speaker 11: that she had been cooking something. I believe that was
- 28:28Speaker 11: how he laid out the scene, which would explain why
- 28:32Speaker 11: her body was found in the kitchen.
- 28:36Speaker 13: Prosecutors called fire investigator Michael Poole to testify about his findings.
- 28:42Speaker 13: He told the court that he found no evidence of
- 28:44Speaker 13: an electrical or cooking fire.
- 28:47Speaker 10: And you certainly these these various certain things.
- 28:50Speaker 3: How how certain are you that this fire was intentionally set.
- 28:54Speaker 14: I'm certain that it was intentionally set.
- 28:56Speaker 13: No doubt, no doubt. During cross examination, the defense suggested
- 29:03Speaker 13: that Michael Poole was unsure of his findings, citing language
- 29:07Speaker 13: in his reports such as most likely and it is believed.
- 29:12Speaker 9: Use it to the phrase state is believe it is
- 29:14Speaker 9: as an uncertain of hitting correct, just fully I described it,
- 29:20Speaker 9: but that's.
- 29:20Speaker 10: An uncertain opinting correct.
- 29:23Speaker 13: Poole says he was just using standard terms used during
- 29:26Speaker 13: fire investigations.
- 29:28Speaker 3: I review information.
- 29:30Speaker 13: The state also called forensic pathologist doctor Amanda Humans, who
- 29:34Speaker 13: had performed one of the autopsies.
- 29:37Speaker 5: There was no soot in her airways and her measured
- 29:41Speaker 5: car of anoxide in the blood was within normal limits,
- 29:44Speaker 5: so she was to cease prior.
- 29:46Speaker 7: To the buyer.
- 29:47Speaker 13: Doctor Human's testified that Melissa's body showed evidence of a
- 29:51Speaker 13: violent struggle. The jury heard about the hemorrhages around Melissa's neck,
- 29:56Speaker 13: a specific type of broken blood vessels called petechial hemorrhages,
- 30:00Speaker 13: which according to Doctor Humans is a telltale sign of strangulation.
- 30:05Speaker 3: This is the most particulal henrygies I've ever seen in
- 30:09Speaker 3: a strangulation case.
- 30:10Speaker 5: To sit through trial was beyond devastating.
- 30:15Speaker 13: Deanna Lambish came to court every day.
- 30:18Speaker 5: I had been prepped by the victim's advocate. Things were
- 30:21Speaker 5: going to be gruesome. I was going to see a lot.
- 30:24Speaker 13: Deanna says she always kept Melissa and her baby Bearrett
- 30:28Speaker 13: in her thoughts.
- 30:30Speaker 5: She was so strong willed and had such pride that
- 30:33Speaker 5: baby was going to be a strong guy.
- 30:35Speaker 13: Matthew Plodi's parents also attended the trial.
- 30:38Speaker 3: They've been by his side throughout this yes.
- 30:41Speaker 9: I read courting.
- 30:44Speaker 13: One of the most important witnesses to testify was Melissa's
- 30:47Speaker 13: sister Cassie, talking about the day Melissa died and that call,
- 30:52Speaker 13: which Cassie says, was interrupted by Matthew Plodi.
- 30:56Speaker 8: What was the last thing your sister said to you
- 30:58Speaker 8: during that phone call?
- 31:01Speaker 2: Sorry, she said you'd make the conversation. Cler gets you
- 31:07Speaker 2: to call me right back to Melissa, call you back.
- 31:18Speaker 13: Jurors watch those recorded interviews with investigators where Matthew Plody
- 31:23Speaker 13: admitted he was at the house.
- 31:25Speaker 10: How long are the house?
- 31:28Speaker 4: More?
- 31:30Speaker 13: Prosecutors wanted jurors to hear that phrase. Plodi used deadline
- 31:36Speaker 13: for that, referring to the birth of his son as
- 31:39Speaker 13: a deadline.
- 31:41Speaker 8: He said, there's a deadline to these kinds of things.
- 31:46Speaker 8: That was his deadline to murder Melissa.
- 31:49Speaker 11: So if you think about it, logically, Thursday is Thanksgiving
- 31:52Speaker 11: and Friday is her due date. His deadline. The only
- 31:56Speaker 11: time to do this was Wednesday, so he took off
- 31:58Speaker 11: work and completed his goal.
- 32:03Speaker 13: The prosecutors found even more telling what Plodi didn't say,
- 32:07Speaker 13: especially during that seven hour interview, four hours of which
- 32:11Speaker 13: were played for the jury.
- 32:13Speaker 8: What is chilling is the fact that he never denied
- 32:16Speaker 8: murdering Melissa, and he never denied killing her baby boy,
- 32:21Speaker 8: not one time. It's chilling from a personal perspective, But
- 32:26Speaker 8: that's also excellent evidence that the defendant couldn't bring himself
- 32:30Speaker 8: to lie about that fact.
- 32:32Speaker 9: Over the course of multiple interviews for several hours, he
- 32:34Speaker 9: was calm and reserved.
- 32:38Speaker 13: His silence, defense says actually points to his innocence, not
- 32:42Speaker 13: his guilt.
- 32:43Speaker 9: He had a right to remain silent. But the police
- 32:46Speaker 9: are allowed to continue to poke and prod and try
- 32:49Speaker 9: to get him confused, and he just didn't buy into
- 32:52Speaker 9: any of that.
- 32:53Speaker 13: They say. Their client, when he did speak, was open
- 32:56Speaker 13: with investigators.
- 32:58Speaker 9: He told them everything about his presence there. He didn't
- 33:02Speaker 9: hide any of that. He just never admitted what they
- 33:04Speaker 9: wanted him to admit, which was that he killed Melissa
- 33:06Speaker 9: and his child, which he didn't do.
- 33:08Speaker 3: Do you think the fact that the fire didn't burn
- 33:11Speaker 3: down the whole house does that play in Matthew's favor
- 33:14Speaker 3: or not.
- 33:15Speaker 10: I believe it does. If he's a firefighter and he's
- 33:17Speaker 10: trying to destroy evidence, he would think he would have
- 33:20Speaker 10: the ability to set a fire to complete that goal.
- 33:25Speaker 13: But during three days of testimony, the state laid out
- 33:28Speaker 13: the case that it could have only been Matthew Plodi
- 33:31Speaker 13: who set that fire to conceal evidence of the murder
- 33:35Speaker 13: of Melissa and their unborn baby, something the defense was
- 33:39Speaker 13: about to contest. The state's fire expert deemed that this
- 33:43Speaker 13: was arson.
- 33:44Speaker 10: He did so, we had an expert who directly contradicted that.
- 33:51Speaker 10: What do you think of Matthew Plodi's interview with investigators
- 33:54Speaker 10: joined the conversation on Facebook and.
- 33:56Speaker 9: X The states expert didn't do a fraction of what
- 34:14Speaker 9: he should have done to properly determine the cause of
- 34:17Speaker 9: the fire. That should have been an undetermined fight.
- 34:20Speaker 13: To try to poke holes in the prosecution's case, the
- 34:23Speaker 13: defense called only one witness, retired firefighter and independent inspector
- 34:29Speaker 13: John Knapp. He was not at the scene of the fire,
- 34:32Speaker 13: but did study reports and photos.
- 34:35Speaker 6: I felt like there was probably more information than it
- 34:38Speaker 6: could have been gathered that wasn't there.
- 34:39Speaker 13: He disputed the prosecutions claimed that Plotie set the fire.
- 34:43Speaker 13: He testified that the evidence collected doesn't prove that the
- 34:47Speaker 13: fire was intentionally set by anyone.
- 34:50Speaker 2: I could invade that determination.
- 34:54Speaker 6: To whether or not what would cause of the fire
- 34:57Speaker 6: should be other.
- 34:57Speaker 14: Than determined when you're not there the scene, you don't
- 35:00Speaker 14: see what we've seen. Not always does every little tidbit
- 35:07Speaker 14: end up In a.
- 35:07Speaker 13: Report, Michael Poole says the defense is expert is wrong
- 35:11Speaker 13: and that his investigation was thorough.
- 35:14Speaker 14: We're looking for anything and everything that could have contributed
- 35:18Speaker 14: to the origins of this fire. They weren't there. You
- 35:21Speaker 14: needed to be there when we were doing the examination.
- 35:24Speaker 13: Matthew Ploti waved his right to testify. During closing arguments,
- 35:29Speaker 13: the defense accused investigators of having tunnel vision.
- 35:33Speaker 9: The complete lack of investigation of any other individual is shocking.
- 35:40Speaker 9: I've never seen such a poorly investigated case.
- 35:44Speaker 10: They didn't follow up on any other leads that may
- 35:46Speaker 10: have happened, any other boyfriends, any other anybody else.
- 35:49Speaker 8: If there had been another lead, investigators certainly would have
- 35:53Speaker 8: followed it. There simply wasn't.
- 35:55Speaker 13: Prosecutors told the jury that the evidence was clear Melissa
- 35:59Speaker 13: Lammish was strangled to death by the only person who
- 36:02Speaker 13: had a motive to kill her, Matthew Plody, who was
- 36:06Speaker 13: juggling multiple women and didn't want to change his lifestyle.
- 36:10Speaker 8: He clearly did not want to be involved in this
- 36:13Speaker 8: baby's life. This is someone who actively hid the fact
- 36:17Speaker 8: that a woman in the community was carrying his child.
- 36:20Speaker 9: He clearly had made some choices about having multiple relationships,
- 36:24Speaker 9: but did not make him a killer.
- 36:27Speaker 13: The trial lasted a week, and after two hours of deliberation,
- 36:31Speaker 13: the jury returned with a verdict. We the jury find
- 36:36Speaker 13: the decendant, Matthew Plody, guilty of first degree murdered, guilty
- 36:41Speaker 13: of all charges.
- 36:43Speaker 5: I could hear people sobbing and gasping, but like I
- 36:47Speaker 5: couldn't even lift my head.
- 36:49Speaker 3: What did you feel?
- 36:51Speaker 5: Shock?
- 36:52Speaker 4: Shock.
- 36:54Speaker 13: The verdict was a relief for Chief Robert Schultz. He
- 36:57Speaker 13: says the case had long wait on him and everyone
- 37:00Speaker 13: at the firehouse who had worked with Plody.
- 37:03Speaker 7: There was a huge closure here when pat was found guilty.
- 37:09Speaker 7: You still have the family out there that lost a daughter,
- 37:12Speaker 7: lost a grandson. You're never going to change that.
- 37:17Speaker 13: Three months later, on June twenty seventh, twenty twenty four,
- 37:21Speaker 13: Melissa's family and friends gathered at the courthouse for sentencing.
- 37:26Speaker 13: Matthew Plody listened with little reaction as a victim impact
- 37:29Speaker 13: statements were read.
- 37:31Speaker 1: We lost Melissa in the prime of her life. Melissa
- 37:33Speaker 1: and Barrett should still be alive and enjoying life with
- 37:36Speaker 1: their love and family.
- 37:37Speaker 2: I shouldn't have spent Thanksgiving that you're feeling like there
- 37:40Speaker 2: was nothing to be thankful for This shouldn't be real,
- 37:46Speaker 2: but it is real. It is all real because one
- 37:48Speaker 2: man decided to make the decision that Barrett and Melissa
- 37:52Speaker 2: weren't needed or wanted. No, no, this had to happen.
- 37:56Speaker 3: All he had to do was walk away.
- 38:03Speaker 13: Matthew Plodi also addressed the court with this brief statement.
- 38:08Speaker 10: Say anything other that I share that.
- 38:12Speaker 12: Sends also fair?
- 38:15Speaker 13: Do you believe him?
- 38:16Speaker 10: Oh?
- 38:17Speaker 1: No, definitely.
- 38:18Speaker 2: Not for him to say, I too have pain and
- 38:21Speaker 2: loss from Wilson Bart like that but a joke.
- 38:26Speaker 13: The judge imposed the maximum sentence.
- 38:29Speaker 9: Mister Clodie, you are sentenced to natural life.
- 38:32Speaker 13: Imprisonment, life behind bars.
- 38:35Speaker 3: Matthew Plodi will likely die in prison. Does that give
- 38:41Speaker 3: you any sort of peace?
- 38:44Speaker 7: No?
- 38:46Speaker 5: I know it's the justice system and we received our justice.
- 38:50Speaker 5: But nothing about this is just nothing about this is fair.
- 38:55Speaker 5: No punishment in the world brings them back. I miss
- 39:00Speaker 5: her person out. I think it's her sass.
- 39:04Speaker 13: Melissa's sister Julia Lynn tries to hold on to fond memories.
- 39:10Speaker 4: Malsa was I believe still is the best person that
- 39:15Speaker 4: I've ever met.
- 39:16Speaker 7: What are you?
- 39:16Speaker 3: Missus? Moosed about your daughter and there's a grandson you
- 39:19Speaker 3: never got to.
- 39:19Speaker 1: Meet before you start. I mean he was going to
- 39:23Speaker 1: come into my home. I was looking forward to raising him.
- 39:27Speaker 13: Through all of their grief, The Lambish family honors Melissa
- 39:31Speaker 13: in many ways.
- 39:32Speaker 16: We took toys to a local homeless shelter to honor Barrett.
- 39:37Speaker 16: To honor Barrett, we donated money to the No Kill
- 39:43Speaker 16: shelter that Melissa got her cat from.
- 39:47Speaker 13: They also sponsored a tree at a local arboretum that
- 39:50Speaker 13: Melissa loved.
- 39:51Speaker 5: Every year but the holidays. This tree will always be
- 39:55Speaker 5: lit as part of their.
- 39:57Speaker 13: Display, shining brightly like Melissa always did well.
- 40:02Speaker 2: So strong, she was fierce, she was powerful. Nothing was
- 40:06Speaker 2: going to stop her, and she was always going to
- 40:08Speaker 2: prove herself and she'd do whatever it takes to do it.
- 40:22Speaker 15: You've probably heard of the NCIS from the hit TV series,
- 40:25Speaker 15: but we're about to take you inside it's real life work.
- 40:29Speaker 15: Listen to forty eight hours NCIS early and ad free
- 40:32Speaker 15: on the forty eight hours plus subscription on Apple Podcasts.
- 40:37Speaker 12: As a kid grown up in Chicago, there was one
- 40:39Speaker 12: horror movie I was too scared to watch. It was
- 40:41Speaker 12: called Candy Man. But did you know that the movie
- 40:44Speaker 12: Candy Man was partly inspired by an actual murder. Listen
- 40:47Speaker 12: to Candy Man, the true story behind the bathroom mirror
- 40:50Speaker 12: Murder wherever you get your podcasts