Latest / Beyond The Horizon / The United States Governments Brief In Response To Ghislaine Maxwell's Appeal Request (Part 4)
Transcript
- 0:00Speaker 1: What's up everyone, and welcome back to the Epstein Chronicles.
- 0:04In this episode, we're going to pick up where we
- 0:05left off with the United States brief in response to
- 0:09Glaim Maxwell and her attempt at an appeal. Number three,
- 0:14the District Court did not abuse its discretion in declining
- 0:17to conduct a hearing. Finally, Maxwell argues that the District
- 0:21Court erd by denying emotions to dismiss without an evidentiary hearing.
- 0:26But as Judge Nathan explained, the cases cited by Maxwell
- 0:30in support of her request for a hearing mostly involved
- 0:32oral arguments where there was no written record of the
- 0:36full set of terms reached by the parties, and all
- 0:39of which involved defendants with first hand knowledge of the negotiations.
- 0:44This is no such case. The NPA's terms are clear. Furthermore,
- 0:48Maxwell had an unusually large amount of information about the
- 0:52NPA's negotiation history in the form of the OPR report,
- 0:56yet identifies no evidence that the Department of Justice made
- 1:00any promises not contained in the NPA here as below,
- 1:04Maxwell's further request for a hearing rests on mere conjecture.
- 1:09Judge Nathan did not abuse her discretion. Point number two.
- 1:13The District Court correctly concluded that the charges were timely.
- 1:17In two thousand and three, Congress extended the statue of
- 1:20limitations for offenses involving the sexual or physical abuse of
- 1:24a minor to allow prosecution so long as the victim
- 1:27remains alive. US Code eighteen, Section thirty two eighty three.
- 1:32Attempting to undermine the clear legislative intent, Maxwell argues that
- 1:36the amendment did not apply to her case because her
- 1:39crimes both predated the amendment and did not involve sexual abuse.
- 1:43These arguments fly in the face of the statutory text,
- 1:47legislative history, this Court's own decisions, and the persuasive authority
- 1:52of other circuits. The charges fell squarely within the amended
- 1:55statue of limitations, and this Court should affirm Judge Nathan's
- 1:59well reasoned decisions denying Maxwell's motions to dismiss the charges
- 2:04as untimely. A applicable law one standard of review. This Court
- 2:11reviews d novo both the denial of a motion to
- 2:14dismiss an indictment and the application of a statute of limitations.
- 2:19United States versus Sampson, eight ninety eight FT. Three d
- 2:22two seventy two seventy six two seventy eight second Circuit
- 2:26twenty eighteen two Statutes of limitations for offenses against children
- 2:32US Code eighteen, section thirty two eighty three and child
- 2:35abduction and sex offenses US Code eighteen, section thirty two,
- 2:39ninety nine. Most federal non capital offenses carry a five
- 2:44year statute of limitations see US Code eighteen, section thirty
- 2:48two eighty two A. In nineteen ninety, Congress enacted a
- 2:51provision titled Extension of Child Statute of Limitations, which provided
- 2:57that no statute of limitation that would otherwise preclude prosecution
- 3:01for an offense involving the sexual or physical abuse of
- 3:04a child under the age of eighteen shall preclude such
- 3:08a prosecution before the child reaches the age of twenty five.
- 3:12The Crime Control Act of nineteen ninety pub. Dot l.
- 3:15Number one zero one Dash six forty seven, Title II,
- 3:19Section two twenty five A one oh four stat four
- 3:23seven eight nine four seven nine eight, codified at US
- 3:26Code eighteen, Section thirty five oh nine K nineteen ninety.
- 3:31This provision extended the federal criminal limitation period for child
- 3:35sex abuse offenses, making it easier to prosecute offenders who
- 3:39commit sex crimes that may be difficult to detect quickly.
- 3:43Winingarten versus the United States eight sixty five Ft three
- 3:47d forty eight fifty four, Second Circuit twenty seventeen. In
- 3:51nineteen ninety four, Congress recodified this provision, moving it to
- 3:56US Code eighteen, section thirty two eighty three with identify language.
- 4:02Violent Crime Control and Law Enforcement Act of nineteen ninety four, pub.
- 4:06Dot l. Number one zero three Dash three two two,
- 4:09Title thirty three, Section thirty three zero zero one eight
- 4:14A Statute one oh eight seventeen ninety six two one
- 4:18four nine, codified at US Code eighteen, Section thirty two
- 4:22eighty three, nineteen ninety four. Within a decade, Congress began
- 4:26to view even the extended statute of limitations period in
- 4:30nineteen ninety four version of the thirty two eighty three
- 4:33as inadequate in many cases because they were released from
- 4:37criminal liabilities. Sex abusers whose crimes were not brought to
- 4:41the attention of federal authorities until after their victims turned
- 4:44twenty five Wingarten eight sixty five f dot three d
- 4:49at fifty four. Accordingly, in two thousand and three, Congress
- 4:52enacted a provision titled no Statute of Limitations for Child
- 4:56abduction and sex crimes, which amended section thirty two eighty
- 5:00three to read, no statute of limitations that would otherwise
- 5:04preclude prosecution for an offense involving the sexual or physical
- 5:08abuse or kidnapping of a child under the age of
- 5:11eighteen shall preclude such prosecution during the life of the child.
- 5:16Prosecutorial Remedies and Tools against the Exploitation of Children Today,
- 5:20Act of two thousand and three, The Protect Act pub L.
- 5:24Number one zero eight twenty one, Title two, Section two
- 5:28two one seventeen, Statute six fifty six sixty codified at
- 5:32US Code eighteen, Section thirty two eighty three, two thousand
- 5:36and three. In two thousand and six, Congress enacted a
- 5:40provision titled Longer Statute of Limitations for Human Trafficking related
- 5:44Offenses and subtitled Modification of Statute Applicable to Offense against Children,
- 5:50which further amended section thirty two eighty three to its
- 5:54current form to permit the prosecution of such offenses during
- 5:57the lifetime of the victim or ten years after the offense,
- 6:01whichever is longer. Violence against Women and Department of Justice
- 6:05Reauthorization Act of two thousand and six pub dot L
- 6:09Number one oh nine TOASH one sixty two, Title eleven,
- 6:13Section eleven eighty two, C one nineteen, Statute twenty nine
- 6:17sixty thirty one twenty six codified at US Code eighteen,
- 6:22Section thirty two eighty three, two thousand and six. Later,
- 6:26in two thousand and six, Congress enacted US Code eighteen,
- 6:29Section thirty two ninety nine in a provision titled no
- 6:32Limitation for Prosecution of Felony Sex Offenses, which provides that,
- 6:37notwithstanding any other law, an indictment may be found or
- 6:41any information instituted, at any time without limitation for any
- 6:45offense under Section twelve oh one involving a minor victim,
- 6:49and for any felony under Chapter one oh nine A
- 6:52and ten, except for Section twenty two fifty seven and
- 6:56twenty two fifty seven A or one seventeen or Section
- 7:00fifteen ninety one. The Adam Walsh Child Protection and Safety
- 7:05Act of two thousand six, pub. Dot L number one
- 7:08oh NINEASH two forty eight, Title two, Section two eleven
- 7:12one one twenty Statute five eighty seven six sixteen, codified
- 7:17at US Code eighteen, Section thirty two ninety nine, two
- 7:20thousand six three retroactivity under landgraph in Land Graph versus
- 7:27USI Film Products, five eleven US two forty four, nineteen
- 7:31ninety four, the Supreme Court set fourth to two part
- 7:34framework for determining whether a statute may be applied retroactively.
- 7:39At the first step, if Congress expressly prescribed that a
- 7:42statute applies retroactively to the antecedent conduct, the inquiry ends
- 7:47in the Court enforces the statute as it is written,
- 7:50save for constitutional concerns Winngarten, eight sixty five ft three
- 7:55d At fifty four and fifty five. If, however, the
- 7:58statute is ambiguous or it contains no express command regarding retroactivity,
- 8:03then the Court must turn to the second step, where
- 8:06a reviewing court must determine whether applying the statute to
- 8:10the antecedent conduct would create presumptively in permissible retroactive effects IDEA.
- 8:16Fifty five. If it would, then the Court shall not
- 8:19apply the statute retroactively absent clear congressional intent to the contrary.
- 8:24If it would not, then the Court shall apply the
- 8:26statute to antecedent conduct. Be the discussion one, there was
- 8:31no impermissible retroactivity in applying Section thirty two eighty three
- 8:36to Maxwell. Maxwell's claims that the District Court erd by
- 8:40applying Section thirty two eighty three's two thousand and three
- 8:43Amendment to her six counts of conviction ie Counts three, four,
- 8:48and six because they involve conduct that predated the amendment
- 8:52as an initial matter. This argument ignores the fact that
- 8:55counts three and six both charge continuing offenses that continued
- 8:59into two thousand four, thus post dating Section thirty two
- 9:03eighty three's amendment. Moreover, under the lang graph framework, in
- 9:08the two thousand and three amendment properly applies to pre
- 9:11enactment criminal conduct that still could have been timely prosecuted
- 9:15at the time of the enactment, As was the case
- 9:17here a, there was no retroactivity as to count three
- 9:22and six as an initial matter. Counts three and six
- 9:26both charge conduct that continued through two thousand and four,
- 9:30i e. After the two thousand and three Amendment to
- 9:32section thirty two eighty three, and thus present no retroactivity
- 9:37concerns for conspiracy charges requiring proof of an overt act,
- 9:42including US Code eighteen, Section three seventy one, the conspiracy
- 9:46statute at issue here, the Statute of Limitations runs from
- 9:50the date of the last overt act in furtherance of
- 9:53the conspiracy United States versus. Monaco one ninety four ft
- 9:57three d three eighty one three eighty seven and two,
- 10:00Second Circuit, nineteen ninety nine. According to the United States
- 10:04versus ben Zivi two forty two F dot three d
- 10:08eighty nine ninety seven, Second Circuit, two thousand and one. Similarly,
- 10:12for a continuing substantative offense, the statute of limitations only
- 10:16begins to run out when the crime is complete, meaning
- 10:19when the conduct has run its course United States versus
- 10:23Epulido five forty three f. Dot three d twenty five
- 10:27forty six, Second Circuit, two thousand and eight. Here, the
- 10:31indictment alleges the conspiracy charged and counts three and the
- 10:35sex trafficking offense charged in Count six continued through two
- 10:39thousand and four A one twenty seven through one thirty two.
- 10:43See also A one twenty three and one twenty four,
- 10:46one thirty one thirty two describing conduct through two thousand
- 10:50and four involving victim four. Thus, the statute of limitations
- 10:54for these two counts did not begin to run until
- 10:57two thousand and four, well after conco enacted the two
- 11:01thousand and three Amendment to section thirty two eighty three.
- 11:04Maxwell's arguments about retroactivity are therefore inapplicable to count three
- 11:09and six. All Right, folks, we're gonna wrap up this
- 11:11episode here and in the next episode discussing the topic,
- 11:14we're gonna pick up where we left off, and that's
- 11:17with applying section thirty two eighty three to Maxwell complies
- 11:22with land graph. All of the information that goes with
- 11:26this episode can be found in the description box.