Latest / The MaineHealth Podcast / Curbside Consult: Physician and APP Wellness with Ranjiv Advani, MD
Transcript
- 0:07From the MaineHealth ACO, this is Curbside Consult, the podcast that brings
- 0:11together specialists and primary care providers for informal clinical discussions.
- 0:17I'm Heather Ward, a family physician and participant in the MaineHealth ACO.
- 0:22My co-host, Mike Clark, he's off for this month.
- 0:26Today, we shift away from our usual clinical topics to talk about physician and APP wellness.
- 0:33It's a well-documented thing that around 40% of our physicians and APPs experience symptoms of burnout.
- 0:40That's a lot, but the good news is that rates are decreasing year over year.
- 0:46MaineHealth has put a big emphasis on wellness recently with some good results.
- 0:52Dr. Ranjiv Advani has been deeply involved in these wellness efforts,
- 0:57particularly in our community and rural hospitals.
- 1:01Ranjiv is a board-certified emergency medicine doctor who now works at the
- 1:05Franklin Hospital ED and is the Director of Provider Wellbeing for the Mountain
- 1:11and Coastal regions of MaineHealth.
- 1:14He is closely working with the Chief Wellness Officer, Christine Hine,
- 1:18and with his counterparts in the southern region, Stephanie Gray and Elizabeth Eisenhardt.
- 1:23Previously, he was the Medical Director of the Emergency Department at Mid Coast
- 1:28Hospital and has worked and practiced in Maine for about 26 years.
- 1:34And we have Rajiv with us now. Welcome.
- 1:37Thanks for having me. Really looking forward to this opportunity to just sit
- 1:41with you and talk about well-being and our medical staff and something that,
- 1:46we're passionate about.
- 1:47And we've learned a lot as we've gone out and talked to people on the front
- 1:51lines. And it's been great to get to know you over the last couple of years
- 1:54and a lot of other people in the regions.
- 1:56Yeah, well, I appreciate you being here and appreciate your time.
- 2:01So excited to have you here to talk about the super important topic.
- 2:05I wonder if we could just start with just hearing a little bit about your story,
- 2:11how you got into medicine, emergency medicine, and then maybe,
- 2:17why you transitioned into wellness.
- 2:21Emergency medicine to me, I think is something that was always in the back of my mind.
- 2:25I can remember distinctly playing youth soccer as a kid, and one of the kids
- 2:30on my team got hurt, and he's there, and they're holding his neck and all that.
- 2:34And then the EMTs showed up, and they kind of took charge of the scene, and they knew what to do.
- 2:39And the competence was on display, and the calmness was on display.
- 2:43And that was just, I was like, wow. And I think that just kind of stuck with me.
- 2:46I took a few years off after college and was a volunteer EMT in a small town in Colorado.
- 2:54And like many of us in the emergency department, I think we got our start in the MS.
- 2:58And I remember meeting some of the docs that did our medical director role and,
- 3:03getting to know them and just, again, seeing the level of knowledge that they
- 3:06had, the level of competence that they have, the calmness that they would bring
- 3:10to a difficult situation.
- 3:12And I think I was one of those guys in med school who kind of every rotation
- 3:17year on in third year, I thought, oh, I could probably do this or I could do that.
- 3:20But emergency medicine just kept appealing to me because of the,
- 3:24I think the breadth of what we do as well as the ability to kind of,
- 3:27like I said, to kind of take a oftentimes chaotic situation and put some calm
- 3:32into it. And that's been gratifying to me.
- 3:35In terms of wellness, you know, I think like many of us involved in the wellness
- 3:40movement, probably a lot of us got our start in that with our own burnout and
- 3:44our own trouble and looking into that more and trying to figure out how do I manage?
- 3:49How do I get through a career for 20, 30 or more years when it's really hard?
- 3:55And then as I became a leader in the ED at Mid Coast, it was also out of a sense
- 4:02of needing to take care of my staff and make sure that their well-being was looked after.
- 4:08And at that time, and always historically, rates of burnout for ED docs was always terrible.
- 4:1510 or 15 years ago, there wasn't much more to the wellness conversation than
- 4:19the resilience conversation and doing yoga and having a hobby and sleeping well and eating right.
- 4:26And if you wanted to talk more about that, there just wasn't much out there.
- 4:29And I think we're starting to put some meat on the bones of looking at this in a different way.
- 4:33I think that is so interesting. So maybe we just start with like,
- 4:37what are we looking at when we're talking about provider wellness?
- 4:42What is that exactly? Yeah, so there's lots of definitions of what wellness might be.
- 4:49We've brought this to some of the retreats that we've gone to to talk about
- 4:53just level setting the playing field about what are we talking about?
- 4:56And I guess there's a couple of concepts that I keep going back to.
- 5:00There's one really simple definition of well-being is the ability to see both
- 5:06the good and the bad across the situations that you're in.
- 5:09So it's specifically not just being optimistic and being positive all the time
- 5:16and sort of getting through something with grit that's going to,
- 5:19you know, we're going to make sure we're all positive here. Yeah.
- 5:24But it's also being realistic about what we're in with and being able to acknowledge
- 5:29the bad but not have that bad crowd out the good.
- 5:33And there was a really interesting episode of, have you ever listened to On
- 5:38Being by Krista Tippett? So she had a thing, a very short segment on hope.
- 5:44And what she said to me really rang true. She said something like,
- 5:48I want to talk about hope and not hope that we're just going to be optimistic
- 5:54and we know we're going to get through it.
- 5:57It's more just like a knowledge and a hope that we can make things better and
- 6:02that we want to try to do it.
- 6:04And that really rang true to me. And I, cause I often wonder why am I doing
- 6:07this kind of stuff? You know, why am I continuing to get involved in this?
- 6:10And I think that's the hope.
- 6:12The other thing I think is one of the other concepts is the difference between joy and happiness.
- 6:18And happiness is something where we've been inundated in society today to think
- 6:24that we just need to be happy all the time, or if it's not making you happy, don't do it.
- 6:28And joy is distinctly different than that you know joy is not always being happy
- 6:34but getting a real sense of fulfillment from what you're doing and you know
- 6:38for those of us who are parents we,
- 6:40acutely know the difference between joy and happiness you know being a parent
- 6:44doesn't always bring you happiness but it brings you great joy and i think a
- 6:47career in medicine affords you the same kind of opportunity yeah,
- 6:52i think of things in a very similar way and i think even just like here in my practice, how can we,
- 7:02increase the joy that's here to balance the suffering that's inevitably a part of life.
- 7:12As a primary care provider, we are responsible for essentially taking care of,
- 7:19the community, for taking care of everyone, knowing that there are thousands
- 7:24of people on a waiting list, like trying to get in.
- 7:27And so we're being asked to see more patients and more patients per day or per hour.
- 7:37Our specialty colleagues are being asked to see patients for more hours in a week.
- 7:42And I wonder, you know, how do we balance that demand for our services,
- 7:52and it is a service that we do, with, like, the other part of,
- 7:58like, being human and, like, needing that human connection and the time to make that connection?
- 8:03And does that play into wellness?
- 8:08We have to look to preserve that
- 8:10human connection. That's kind of the foundation of what we do every day.
- 8:15There's so much change that's been happening these days, operationally,
- 8:20clinically, systemization, that it's really easy to, again, look only to that
- 8:28and not see the good of your day.
- 8:30I used to talk to my docs in the ER a lot.
- 8:33You know, one bad patient encounter can ruin your day.
- 8:38And then you had a bad day. And I would say, oh, people say,
- 8:42I had a terrible day today. This is what happened. And I said,
- 8:44oh, did you have any good patient encounters? And they're like,
- 8:47no, no, I didn't. And then you push them and you're like, oh yeah,
- 8:50I guess I had a few people that, oh, that guy was nice.
- 8:53But you lose that. And I think in all of the operational change,
- 8:58we may have lost sight of the fact that inherently what we do every day is mission
- 9:02driven very good very valuable i tell this story a lot but i remember in residency i was at a,
- 9:07just at a friend's house who lived down in the boston area and these people
- 9:11were not in health care and you know at the time i was in residency i didn't feel particularly like,
- 9:17you know fortunate to be in medicine and the person who was not in medicine
- 9:21said oh you're really lucky to work in health care and i was like i don't know
- 9:25you know it's kind of a grind And she said, well, you get to help people every day.
- 9:30And it sort of made me step back and say, yeah, I guess you're right.
- 9:35And you take that for granted. It's really like the mission of what we do,
- 9:39the purpose, the meaning is really a layout for us.
- 9:44But we have to make sure we nurture that. And I think at some level that's been
- 9:48lost. You know, I was glad you brought that up because.
- 9:53This is a very high-level kind of thing, and then we could talk maybe a little
- 9:56bit more microscopic, but there's a great paper that just came out in JAMA just
- 10:01a couple months ago in February, and I've touched on it every time I talk to people now.
- 10:07May have even told you about this but the title of the paper is meaning and comfort in medicine and,
- 10:12the premise is is just like we were talking about that traditionally the the
- 10:18fulfillment that came in a health care career was from the meaning that you derive from,
- 10:24patient connection intellectual challenge doing something difficult,
- 10:29getting through difficult situations with families with patients.
- 10:34And that increasingly over the past many years, that level of fulfillment has
- 10:38become harder and harder to achieve because of administrative burden,
- 10:43administrative hassles, whatever,
- 10:46operational changes are happening, loss of autonomy,
- 10:50but also because we were overworked, literally, you know, we weren't getting
- 10:55our basic needs met, you know, going back to, you know.
- 11:00Why I got into medicine, you know, my father was a physician and he was cut
- 11:05from the cloth where he went to work at seven in the morning,
- 11:08got home at seven at night.
- 11:09And when I was thinking about a career in medicine, I was like,
- 11:12I don't know if I want that.
- 11:13When I was out in Colorado working ambulance, I worked with doctors who actually
- 11:16did have some semblance of work-life balance.
- 11:19In any case, we've started in healthcare to do some of the things to,
- 11:27to increase comfort, they call it hedonia in this article which is kind of an
- 11:32unfortunate choice of words I think but,
- 11:35We've done a lot of things to try to make sure that people are comfortable in their practice.
- 11:40It's that basic physiologic needs and the hierarchy of needs,
- 11:44making sure that work hours are reasonable for residents, making sure we're
- 11:48getting out on time, getting breaks during the day.
- 11:52You know, scribes are a great example of that.
- 11:56But really quickly, what happened was those became the endpoints in and of themselves.
- 12:02And so then when we talked about wellness all we were talking about was work-life
- 12:06balance, getting out on time do I have a scribe.
- 12:11And which is fine, I guess. But then you might lose out on the self-fulfillment
- 12:18and the self-actualization that comes from climbing the pyramid of self-actualization,
- 12:24and having true meaning in what we do.
- 12:28And so in a way, it's not surprising that when we're talking about these comfort
- 12:33level interventions, they're very transactional.
- 12:38You know, the relationship with the employer has become much more transactional
- 12:43and the relationship with our patients has been become more transactional.
- 12:47It doesn't need to be that way. And I think the premise of this paper is that.
- 12:52We don't want the pendulum to swing all the way back to where people were just,
- 12:56breaking themselves for a career in medicine and hopes that they would be fulfilled.
- 13:00But that we want to put these comfort interventions into place so that you actually
- 13:05have space of time to achieve meaning.
- 13:07And scribes is a great example, whether or not it's a person scribe or a bridge or whatever.
- 13:12But if we give you 5, 10, 15 more minutes back with using a scribe,
- 13:20it's not just so that you can walk out at 4, 59 or 5 p.m.
- 13:23It's 5 p.m. It's so that you actually have more time to spend with your patients.
- 13:27You have more time to cultivate those relationships.
- 13:30Or the other way to look at it is you might have more time to cultivate relationships
- 13:34with your staff and your team.
- 13:36Because those things have been really protective at maintaining wellness and
- 13:41protective against burnout in healthcare. here.
- 13:44Maybe we could talk about that a little bit more.
- 13:48And I think what I hear you saying is that once we have our basic needs met,
- 13:55so we're getting sleep as allowed based on our shift work and whatever. We're getting sleep.
- 14:01We have time to eat lunch.
- 14:04That's not just like a.
- 14:15All the other supports that we are working towards building that we have that
- 14:22time in our day to attend a huddle which I honestly like,
- 14:28personally I was just like oh my god how am I gonna fit a huddle into my morning
- 14:33and that's like one of the best times of my day like we get to throw out issues,
- 14:39talk for five minutes is kind of that really quick, like, let's all come together as a team. And
- 14:49I think that that's a really important part of surviving and,
- 14:56I guess, beyond surviving, thriving in this environment. Right.
- 15:01Absolutely right. And I think time is precious right now.
- 15:05You know that from being a leader. You try to get people together and no one has time.
- 15:11And it's crazy because we're actually, we theoretically should be way more efficient
- 15:16than we used to be in the past with all the systems that we have,
- 15:19the EMR, which of course gets beat up a lot. But can you imagine going back
- 15:23to a paper chart right now?
- 15:25Can you imagine going back to a world in which even if you had electronic charting,
- 15:29it was like years ago at Mid Coast, we had a module for the ED,
- 15:33a module for outpatient, a module for surgery, a module for OB-GYN, none of which talk.
- 15:39So, we spent a lot of time getting into records. We're maybe being blissfully
- 15:44ignorant about what was in the medical record.
- 15:47Right. Accepting that we're going to work with a lack of knowledge.
- 15:51Yeah, which maybe was okay. But we've theoretically gotten way more efficient,
- 15:55and yet seemingly time is at a higher premium than it was before.
- 15:58Now, some of that is probably because we're also personally putting a premium
- 16:03on our work-life balance, which, again, is not a bad thing, right?
- 16:07We don't want to say to you, we need you to be here 60 hours a week.
- 16:11We need you to be here for an early morning meeting. We need you to be here
- 16:14for an evening meeting every day.
- 16:17But at some level, we do want our clinicians, our medical staff to be able to
- 16:23lean into that stuff, find the time to get involved, and feel like it was worth it.
- 16:30You know, feel like that extra meeting I went to was actually worth it because
- 16:34I saw an outcome come from that.
- 16:35I'm seeing progress there. And I think a couple things are happening.
- 16:39Sometimes we're not providing a great forum for our people to get involved and
- 16:45be able to have that sense of agency and autonomy and so they might go to a
- 16:49meeting and just listen and they could have done that somehow else,
- 16:54but the the flip side of the coin and i think that what we have to own to some
- 16:58degree is we we need our medical staff to lean into this a little bit you You
- 17:04know, you can't hold your employment at an arm's length.
- 17:09And make sure you're always setting up boundaries and then kind of at the same
- 17:15time say, well, gee, why am I not fulfilled by this?
- 17:19I think there's something missing there. And some of that is,
- 17:23a lot of these buzzwords are agency, autonomy, decision-making capacity, teams.
- 17:29There was an interesting study that actually a highbrow reference to Harvard
- 17:34Business Review, but it just published and they did a study on ICU nurses and,
- 17:41they wondered what would keep ICU nurses on the job,
- 17:44and what was burning them out.
- 17:46And the premise, I think, going into that was, what if we can limit overtime
- 17:49and we can limit difficult situations, then they're going to be fine.
- 17:55And they didn't find that at all.
- 17:58Because inherent in a career in the ICU is difficult situations.
- 18:03And that's across the board in medicine. None of us got into this because it was easy.
- 18:08But what they found instead was that where those nurses had a sense that they
- 18:14had true autonomy and decision-making capacity,
- 18:18and where they felt that their team had their back and they could rely on one
- 18:23another that was greatly protective of staff well-being,
- 18:29and then therefore retention which is of course you know one of the ROIs on
- 18:33what we do is retention of staff,
- 18:36but we know we want to keep our staff around just for ourselves too because
- 18:39you spend a lot of time building your team.
- 18:41And if it's constantly changing, that's very disruptive. And,
- 18:45you know, we see that in primary care and in ambulatory practices,
- 18:48a lot of places where, you know, there's been a revolving door of MAs and RNs.
- 18:53It's really hard to have a cohesive team that's moving on, you know,
- 18:59hitting all cylinders, moving in the right direction when you're struggling for your support staff.
- 19:04And so it's so, there's so many levels of it, but inherent and a lot of this,
- 19:09is the relationship part. Yeah.
- 19:12And I think what you're saying is absolutely true.
- 19:17And at the same time, I also am responsible for my well-being.
- 19:26And for me, it's taken time just like for you.
- 19:30It's taken negative experience in order to figure it out.
- 19:35But like knowing what's important to me as an individual, how I can also be supportive to my team.
- 19:46So right now I'm thinking like my office staff and participate in community,
- 19:56so that like I have also the support beyond like being supportive to my office staff,
- 20:04the support of the broader community.
- 20:06Here locally Waldo community with other, being able to have conversations with other providers.
- 20:14And I mean, it's taken a while for me to figure that out, to figure out what
- 20:19is the mix that works well for me so that I can be responsible for my,
- 20:27wellness or my happiness or my joy at work or,
- 20:32however you want to define it.
- 20:35So I think, you know, and I think you touched on the meeting thing,
- 20:42and I'm just going to go there because, you know, pre-COVID and post-COVID, right?
- 20:48Like COVID changed everything.
- 20:51And one of the things is like it allowed us to have this kind of interaction.
- 20:55We're recording virtually and we're not in the same room. And so now we do all
- 21:00our meetings that way, but it just allows for a level of disconnection that,
- 21:05you know, where we have communication, but we don't have community.
- 21:11Right. And I don't know, how do we change that? Like, how do we get people back in the same room?
- 21:16I totally agree. And, you know, again, acknowledging the power of virtual meetings,
- 21:22that we're able to do this today.
- 21:24And we're not both driving an hour each, you know, way.
- 21:29But as you know, I work with seven different hospitals. I've tried to make it
- 21:34a priority of showing up in person as much as I can within reason, you know?
- 21:39And that one-on-one, or the time where you actually have to actually spend with
- 21:44people in a room as opposed to a talking head on a screen is hugely impactful.
- 21:49And you notice it, you know, I was at a pharmacy retreat last week that I helped,
- 21:54facilitate one section of it about wellness, and,
- 21:58This was a group of pharmacy leaders from throughout the system.
- 22:02And Brian, their leader, had made it a priority to bring them together twice
- 22:06a year in a forum. And they might not have ever interacted with one another.
- 22:12And yet they were still working together. And you look around the room in between
- 22:16sessions and people are just chatting. It's a loud room.
- 22:19People aren't just sitting there silent. And that time is valuable.
- 22:25There was the other thing that I go to and you might have heard me talk about this is,
- 22:31a speaker named Allison Pugh who spoke at the American Conference for Physician
- 22:36Health - Boston and she's a sociologist at Johns Hopkins and she wrote a
- 22:41book called The Last Human Job and it's about,
- 22:44this concept of connective labor,
- 22:47and connective labor is the ability to see and understand another human being.
- 22:53But also then communicate it back
- 22:54to them. So they feel seen and heard and understood and valued, moreover.
- 23:01And it's essentially at the essence of what we do every day in taking care of
- 23:05patients is you're cultivating a vision of some other person and creating dignity and creating value.
- 23:11And there's a couple things that are interesting about that.
- 23:14Number one is not only are you creating dignity in that person,
- 23:17but you feel some of that dignity, too.
- 23:20And it's a lot because of that human connection.
- 23:23It requires that you actually communicate back to the person that you see and
- 23:27cultivated that vision.
- 23:28And so if you just cultivate a vision and you keep it to yourself,
- 23:32who knows what's happening, right? And sometimes maybe that's what we're guilty
- 23:36of is as physicians and APPs of really not being able to communicate back to somebody.
- 23:42But the other thing that struck me was that we are also, as employees and people
- 23:48on the medical staff, recipients of connective labor.
- 23:51So we just as equally want to feel seen, heard, understood, and valued by the
- 23:57people that we're working for.
- 23:59And as we've gotten larger and larger and larger and the relationships have
- 24:04gotten further and further apart...
- 24:07That sense of being seen, valued, and understood has been whittled away a little bit and diluted.
- 24:13But the good thing is I think there's ways to recreate that.
- 24:17And, you know, as you know, one of the reasons I've always liked working in,
- 24:22small, rural, and community-sized hospitals is that ability to create a relationship,
- 24:28with your coworkers is very different than when you're at a really big place.
- 24:32And those relationships can be intimate. You know, I used to marvel at the medical
- 24:37staff meetings at Midcoast when I was there a few years ago.
- 24:40And every time there was a big retirement of someone who had been there a long
- 24:43time, you know, we would spend 20, 30 minutes at the beginning of a medical
- 24:48staff meeting with all kinds of speakers and stories of crazy stuff they used
- 24:52to do and stuff like that.
- 24:53And it's not that that's not happening anymore, it's just not quite the same
- 24:57maybe as it used to be, but it doesn't have to be that way. Yeah.
- 25:02And, you know, I point, the other interesting thing is we still can,
- 25:06you still can create relationships across the system,
- 25:10for those of us who've done the PLDF program almost universally,
- 25:15I would guess it might be 100%.
- 25:18When you ask people what was the best thing they got out of the PLDF,
- 25:21it's not like, oh, I really like that talk on finance that one day.
- 25:24I really like that crucial conversations concept.
- 25:27It's always the networking was amazing.
- 25:31Yeah. And so, 12, 15 years ago, I met Mark Egena and I still have a relationship
- 25:39with him that is based in that foundation of the PLDF.
- 25:43Several other people around the system.
- 25:45And so to whatever extent we continue to nurture those relationships,
- 25:49both near and far, I think it goes a long way.
- 25:52There was another paper that came out recently, and not that I'm an academic
- 25:57kind of guy, but there's a few papers that really kind of sum up this stuff.
- 26:00And this actually came out of the Mini-Z,
- 26:04cohort set that we were part of for the AMA, and it showed that,
- 26:08exactly that, that a sense of belonging and connectiveness with your coworkers
- 26:13and your peers really had a big impact on whether or not you were going to stick with your job.
- 26:18Yeah. We had a great conversation about this at Stephens the other day when I
- 26:23was presenting the Mini-Z because it was interesting because on the one hand,
- 26:27while burnout was still higher than we would want it to be, and we know that
- 26:30it has been for a long time,
- 26:33job satisfaction was still really high, amazingly high, considering the amount of burnout.
- 26:40But I think that's exactly what we're talking about, that.
- 26:44You can have a difficult time at work, either clinically or operationally,
- 26:50but if you feel a sense of belonging, feel a sense of connectedness with your team,
- 26:57with your people, that that can keep you coming back.
- 27:01And again, not that we should be striving to just make it easy for you.
- 27:09We want to make it easier for you to achieve that fulfillment connect with your
- 27:15patients but also connect with your team yeah,
- 27:18i can't you can't believe I've gotten this far in talking to you about not mentioning
- 27:22the Stanford model because it's like we always
- 27:25mention it in the first two minutes of when we talk but of course you heard this and again it's that
- 27:30three-legged stool of individual factors which again is the base which is your
- 27:34self-care yourself your reliance which is important but it's culture and processes
- 27:40and that's exactly what we've been talking about you know,
- 27:43culture is the way that patterns of human relationships the way that we interact
- 27:47with one another and culture sometimes seems,
- 27:51so big that you can't change it you know how do we change culture and then the
- 27:55processes or the workplace efficiencies are what many of our leaders are charged with doing.
- 28:01But seemingly have gotten harder to achieve process improvement because the
- 28:06system's got so much bigger that you've got so many more stakeholders to make things happen.
- 28:11One of the things that I really think is cool, like Nir Harish at PenBay is
- 28:15leading a local innovation center where they're soliciting ideas from the people,
- 28:21in the staff, not just medical staff -- anybody.
- 28:25And creating a vehicle to make local ideas come to fruition.
- 28:28Now, some of the ideas that people might have might be too big for that team
- 28:32to handle. And then if that's the case, they move it on to somebody else or advocate.
- 28:36But among the things that they're doing, they've been remarkably successful
- 28:41at instituting some really impressive changes.
- 28:44And I sat in on their meeting just last week and just listened to the,
- 28:47you know, how the sausage is made kind of thing. And they were,
- 28:51the list of things that they're working on is amazing.
- 28:54And a lot of these guys are just doing this because they just like doing it.
- 28:59And that sense of agency and autonomy is, again, greatly protective at feeling
- 29:06invested in what you're doing.
- 29:08You know, I guess I wonder how we can, or maybe how MaineHealth already is,
- 29:17promoting individuals' personal interest.
- 29:22So, like, within the context of our jobs and, like, what I do as a family physician,
- 29:28like, my personal interest isn't going and doing appendectomies, right?
- 29:32Like what my personal interest in medicine is just like the innovation group coming together.
- 29:41Like nobody, I don't actually know this, but I'm guessing nobody gave them permission
- 29:47to get together and chat, right? Like they're like, I'm going,
- 29:50like, I want to have this conversation.
- 29:53Let's start having this conversation.
- 29:55And we can each do that kind of on an individual basis too. Like,
- 29:59what is it that I'm really interested in? Whatever.
- 30:03Depression, hypertension, I
- 30:05don't know, diabetes. Like, can I do more of that in my own personal work?
- 30:10Because I really enjoy it. Like, what is MaineHealth doing to help promote,
- 30:17like, individuals being more empowered to just think about, like,
- 30:24I want to keep doing this.
- 30:25I want to do a lot more of this. This is fun. And this fills my cup.
- 30:29Yeah, I mean, I think the real answer is that's where we need to be aiming towards.
- 30:32You know, I don't know that we've done a fantastic job of that.
- 30:36You know, in particular in the community and rural hospitals where you're not
- 30:39in an academic career, you're not looking for academic achievement or climbing
- 30:44the ladder of academics, but you can still be very involved in the things that you want to do.
- 30:50And we need to work at creating time and space for you to do that and a vehicle.
- 30:56So you might have heard us talk about this, the gross programs that the AMA
- 31:01puts out. It's called Getting Rid of Stupid Stuff. Oh, yeah.
- 31:05And we all know that. The concept is that, and this is.
- 31:12A lean philosophy thing, is that the people at the front line know the work
- 31:15the best and that we should go to them for those solutions.
- 31:20We need to create a mechanism to do that you know and you know from
- 31:25being a leader very recently that there's so much coming from organizational changes,
- 31:33operational changes standardization and unification that's coming that has to
- 31:39go from the top down let's change it leaves very little time in your life as a leader,
- 31:45to do that kind of local change And it's almost like we have to remind ourselves
- 31:52and put on the scorecard for all of our leaders.
- 31:55Not only did you meet all these metrics, but tell me something that you did
- 31:59that was frontline driven, that was ground up.
- 32:02Maybe that could be on the scorecard too.
- 32:07I said this to Tim Fox the other day when we were chatting.
- 32:12One of the big achievements for our group at Mid Coast many years ago,
- 32:17and it was almost nine years ago, was to do an ED-initiated buprenorphine program,
- 32:24which back when we started talking about this in 2016-2017, people thought was nuts.
- 32:31And now of course it's very mainstream and we pulled that off by you know classic
- 32:38like project management we got the stakeholders together we,
- 32:41answered questions about what do we bring into this what do we want this to
- 32:44look like what's our vision and then we troubleshot the program we rolled it
- 32:49out not without resistance of course but then we refined it and whatnot,
- 32:53and it was wildly successful.
- 32:56And it really actually changed the way that people not only talked about Suboxone
- 33:01itself, but it was greatly successful in the way that people talked to patients
- 33:06with an opioid use disorder.
- 33:09That project would have been harder to do these days.
- 33:15Would have been maybe not impossible, but the barriers would have been higher.
- 33:19And so we need to think about what can we do to enable that kind of front-line
- 33:25autonomy, decision-making, innovation, ingenuity.
- 33:31And it doesn't have to be something big. It doesn't have to be changing the world.
- 33:36But the cool thing was, like I sat on this meeting that Nir had with his group,
- 33:40and I was just getting kind of excited and charged up because just listening
- 33:45to what these people were doing and that things were actually moving and things
- 33:48were actually happening was exciting.
- 33:50And I think if we can bring that back. And so what we're, what we're hoping
- 33:53to do is bring that kind of construct,
- 33:57to each local health system, whether or not it's in a specific unit or department
- 34:01or a hospital wide thing, you know, they have QR codes up that you can submit your, your idea to.
- 34:10And it's like the you know the i go to this too and when we talk to you know
- 34:15Encarta versus Wikipedia you know what Encarta was and Encarta was this online encyclopedia that,
- 34:23Microsoft was going to invent, and they were going to pay the best and the brightest
- 34:26to put this all together and of course you don't know who Encarta is because
- 34:30it fizzled and yet people spend a lot of time on Wikipedia for free,
- 34:36because of the purpose and the meaning and the autonomy that they feel from
- 34:40that not that we want people to be spending hours and hours of time.
- 34:45But if we can help you create and nurture and see to fruition a project that's of your conception,
- 34:54you might actually be willing to spend some time on the outside do that
- 34:58and then not only that I think that.
- 35:02That the people around you, even if they're not directly involved in that project,
- 35:06they feel that sense of autonomy and agency just transitively because they know
- 35:12that, oh yeah, we can do that.
- 35:15And then I think we may see true, true engagement, you know,
- 35:20so thinking about what do we want this to look like in the next five years,
- 35:2310 years is, you know, we want our medical staff to continue to be energized.
- 35:31And engaged with seeing their patients. But we want them to be just as much
- 35:35energized and engaged with their team and their local health system and their system,
- 35:42and that they feel supported by their system in doing so. Yeah.
- 35:47I'm wondering if you want to talk a little bit more. I mean,
- 35:50you've already mentioned some really important changes that are happening around
- 35:55MaineHealth to help support the wellness of our physicians and APPs.
- 36:01Because I'm wondering, because the recent survey came out and shows some significant
- 36:08improvement, especially with our APPs,
- 36:11I'm wondering if you want to talk about that a little bit or just,
- 36:17give us some insight in why you think we're seeing some of this improvement,
- 36:22which is great, but we got to know what it is and we can keep doing it, right?
- 36:26And that's what we're trying to get at with the Mini-Z, you know.
- 36:29And again, we're going to kind of acknowledge that the individual factors thing,
- 36:33the resilience thing, the self-care thing is wildly important.
- 36:38We're not going to focus on that. You know, in fact, that's too much where in
- 36:43the past we've gone to that. And then that sends a message that you and yourself
- 36:47are alone responsible for your well-being.
- 36:49Yeah. You know, we definitely have seen improvements in well-being and decreases
- 36:56in burnout throughout the system. Not where we would want them to be.
- 36:59We've talked a little bit about some of the things. So the agency,
- 37:04the autonomy part, which is kind of more of a culture thing.
- 37:08Interestingly, and you may not be surprised, we've seen improvements in the
- 37:14scores more for hospital-based providers than we have for ambulatory providers.
- 37:21I think primary care in particular is really in a difficult position right now.
- 37:25And you know that way more acutely than I do.
- 37:28So much coming at you operationally. I think there's a way through that though
- 37:32but going back you know I'll take the emergency department as one example because,
- 37:38as you also probably know like historically ER physicians were at the very
- 37:42top of the list when it came to burnout and that was just like seen as gospel
- 37:46and in the old days you'd talk about wellness and you'd be like oh we're the
- 37:50emergency physician we're the most burned out and it was a badge of honor and,
- 37:53we would talk about it like that and into our own detriment.
- 37:57But I think some things have happened. You know, the ER has always been a place
- 38:01of great teamwork and where our teams are functioning well, that's again, hugely protective.
- 38:07But also some things from the system have helped.
- 38:10For example, as I was thinking about this, you know, a few years ago only,
- 38:16we had a real problem with inter-facility transportation.
- 38:20So it's getting a little bit into the weeds here, but it's really a big,
- 38:24big issue in there. I can't tell you how...
- 38:27Frustrating and troubling and sometimes morally injured you were when you had
- 38:33a really sick patient in a small or community level ED,
- 38:38who needed to get to another place and you literally couldn't get an ambulance to come get them.
- 38:44And so we're calling around from ambulance to ambulance service and it just wasn't there.
- 38:51And it wasn't something that any one local health system could solve on its own.
- 38:56In fact, we were doing that and we were robbing Peter to pay Paul,
- 39:01you know, kind of thing. So like one hospital would shore up their EMS crews,
- 39:04but then everyone else was seeing a dearth of EMS providers.
- 39:09And so it really great example of something that the system can fix for us and
- 39:15a system level fix is really what it needed.
- 39:17And so now we actually have, and it's not probably fully mature,
- 39:22but we now have a MaineHealth owned and run inter-facility transport service
- 39:27that has changed that phenomenon.
- 39:30Again, not that it's solved 100% of the time, but that is a huge operational,
- 39:38improvement to the lives of the ER docs, especially in the outlying hospitals.
- 39:43And that's a great example of a workplace efficiency, a process of care that was broken.
- 39:52That the system identified as needing change and worked hard to make it
- 39:56happen and so that's just again an example of,
- 40:00those processes that are not working we need to identify those and hopefully,
- 40:05create some fixes you know we still board psychiatric patients in the ed we
- 40:10still are overcrowded we're still seeing people in the hallway,
- 40:14but even if you just see those system level fixes helping you,
- 40:17then you have a little faith that, yeah, we are moving in the right direction here.
- 40:22And I think, you know, we need to now start moving in the same direction for
- 40:26our primary care people.
- 40:28And, you know, it's something that I've talked to a lot of people,
- 40:31you and I have talked about it at length recently or a while ago,
- 40:34and Elizabeth and I have talked about it.
- 40:36And I don't work in an ambulatory setting. And so I've had to kind of understand that a little bit.
- 40:41But the pressures that you guys are under has been extraordinary,
- 40:44and particularly the operational change and a little bit of that loss of autonomy is there.
- 40:50And, you know, we really need to get to this freedom within a framework to create
- 40:55some guidelines, but then open it up.
- 40:57And essentially what we're talking about is trust, right?
- 41:01We want to trust you that you can, within certain parameters,
- 41:07create your practice the way that you need it to be and thrive and maybe even
- 41:12better than if it's prescriptive.
- 41:14Yeah and I mean that's certainly not an easy thing but i do think i think
- 41:20we're seeing that pendulum shift already a little bit even just with template,
- 41:26change discussions it went from like everybody's got to be exactly the same
- 41:31back to you choose between these,
- 41:34which is great. You know, it's great that we've,
- 41:38the technology is developed so that we can change and that it's been acknowledged that, you know,
- 41:47maybe we can do better if we have a little bit more autonomy and controlling
- 41:51our template within the framework that is established.
- 41:54Yeah, I mean, I think you have to, that there's going to be some guidelines
- 41:57and some influence and some standard way of doing things.
- 42:02And, but, and that's, but that's the conversation. And it's funny,
- 42:06years ago, when I was a new leader at Mid Coast and I would listen to the conversations,
- 42:11my kind of thought in the back of my mind was like, I don't know,
- 42:1550, 75% of the conversation that
- 42:17we were having was really about lack of interoperability of our systems.
- 42:24And we weren't talking about it that way explicitly, but the problem we were
- 42:27trying to solve had something to do with that.
- 42:29And now the conversation is that's the undertone of a lot of what we're doing
- 42:35is standardization versus customization, right?
- 42:38And we know we've moved, of course, because we were not standard in any way,
- 42:42shape, or form in the past. We've moved way towards standardization,
- 42:47but I think that's become the mode of our work, right?
- 42:49And that becomes the way things are happening now. and we've almost forgotten
- 42:53oh yeah, we do have autonomy and we probably need to,
- 42:56you know when we talk to Aileen about this like we do have autonomy at the front
- 43:01lines to do a lot of stuff and we just have to step into that world a little
- 43:05bit but we also have to be given some space for that and it's sort of like,
- 43:10it's the serenity prayer approach to this like what are the things that are
- 43:14you know good for standardization and what are the things that are not and
- 43:19the and the wisdom to know the difference.
- 43:21And so this inter-facility transportation thing is a fantastic example of a
- 43:25system that fixed something that wouldn't have been fixed any other way.
- 43:29Epic, of course, is a tool that
- 43:30we have that none of us would have if we weren't all part of a big system.
- 43:34But knowing where that line ends and where we need to give a little leeway is
- 43:40where we maybe need to be living a little bit. But that's a big gray area,
- 43:43and it's going to look different to different people.
- 43:47But I think ultimately, you know, the other, the other concept that we were
- 43:51moving into is leadership and leadership matters immensely at people's wellbeing.
- 43:56And we know that our staff's wellbeing is in large part due to their relationship
- 44:02and their behaviors of their immediate supervisor. So it's really not what's happening at the top.
- 44:08It's their immediate supervisor.
- 44:10And I think it's a, you know, it's a tough time to be a leader in healthcare
- 44:15right now, no matter if you're at MaineHealth or anywhere. I think you know that acutely.
- 44:20I know that acutely. We've actually done a pretty good job of humanizing our,
- 44:26medical staff over the last many years.
- 44:29You know, making sure we're not thinking of ourselves as robots or the thinker
- 44:33and we're detached and unemotional and that we actually can give ourselves some
- 44:38space and time to be human.
- 44:40I think we've done less good of a job for our leaders that way.
- 44:46And as you climb the pinnacle, like the air gets thinner and you look around,
- 44:50there's fewer and fewer peers, you know, and the peer support that you get can be few and far between.
- 44:57And then a lot of times you're on virtual meetings with a bunch of leaders and but in any case the,
- 45:02the leader leadership competencies that have to do with supporting wellness
- 45:08are you know it's the concept of servant leadership it's the concept of wellness centered leadership,
- 45:14which i think you know if you had to sum it up,
- 45:17invests in nurturing the aspirations of your staff.
- 45:23And trust again trusting that the results follow from that, as opposed to perhaps
- 45:29where we've been is emphasizing the metrics and the results and hoping the engagement
- 45:35follows from that, which may not happen.
- 45:39And if we can twist that a little bit, maybe we'll be on to something.
- 45:43And so, you know, there's a few things coming, you know, Stephanie Gray and
- 45:46Southern Region has done a lot of leadership stuff for their staff.
- 45:50We're changing the onboarding
- 45:53process which we you know again that was something that was seen,
- 45:57in surveys you would talk to medical directors who were onboarding people we
- 46:01were not doing a great job of bringing people into this organization and,
- 46:06that was identified and there's a new process and hopefully that's going to
- 46:11be a lot better than it was because we weren't doing a great job at giving a
- 46:15first impression sometimes.
- 46:17Yeah. It's one thing if someone was from Maine, within Maine,
- 46:20but someone came from away.
- 46:23It was really kind of scattered. And so hopefully that's going to be better.
- 46:26But so there are a lot of examples, I think, of places where we're moving in
- 46:30the right direction. We just have to continue to advocate for that.
- 46:34Advocate for, but also lean into agency on autonomy. You can't just be granted that.
- 46:40Yeah. And all of a sudden you're changed, right? It is going to require something from us too.
- 46:45And it's interesting because that I've always, this one, the paper I was talking
- 46:48about earlier came out and I was like, wow, that just really sums it up in a page and a half,
- 46:53about something that i've been thinking about a lot ever since i've been working
- 46:57in this space and it's counterintuitive to think that a wellness director would
- 47:02be saying hey i need more from you i need you to lean in i need you to go and be part of a project,
- 47:09as opposed to just let's protect our providers and let's protect our staff from anything extra.
- 47:16And it and it gets to that comfort and meaning balance and that you know it's the concept of,
- 47:23you get what you put into something or that nothing that is easy is worth doing
- 47:30or something like I can't remember exactly what I'm talking about.
- 47:34And this is a hard profession. The traditional stressors in healthcare of difficult
- 47:40cases, deaths, adverse events, mistakes aren't going away.
- 47:47That's not changing. But we've added on to that a whole level of,
- 47:53organizational challenges that now tend to be the places that people point to
- 47:58when they're burned out as opposed to the actual inherent stresses of what we're doing.
- 48:04Yeah, the nature of medicine. You know, you had mentioned earlier, and,
- 48:10we've been talking for a while, so maybe we'll lean into,
- 48:15kind of summing things up a little bit, but how important a sense of belonging
- 48:20and connectedness is in wellness and well-being.
- 48:25And I wonder, too, as Maine Health is, you know a newly forming like relatively
- 48:32newly forming system and the culture is developing like that sense of,
- 48:38belonging to something bigger you know if MaineHealth and
- 48:44our vision can be that or and does it also need to be that you know
- 48:53we as providers I think we do have a tendency to like separate,
- 48:59from our patients.
- 49:01But in reality, we're also part of the community that we're taking care of.
- 49:06And looking at us being part of that larger community or that larger vision
- 49:15of like, I'm taking care of you.
- 49:19You're taking care of me.
- 49:21So-and-so is taking care of my brother. You know, like all of that,
- 49:25it's important to remember, like.
- 49:28We're all part of that. And I, and I think that for me, just remembering that helps me,
- 49:37get really more meaning out of my work as opposed to really trying to separate
- 49:44and divide and be above, honestly.
- 49:46Yeah. Right. Oh yeah. I mean, definitely, you know, the hierarchy of medicine
- 49:50is flattened. It's not completely flat, of course.
- 49:52And, and people lament that a little bit, but it's a good thing, too.
- 49:56It's a good thing in moving towards just culture and psychologically safety
- 49:59to have a team that's able to answer to itself.
- 50:02If, again, we see ourselves as part of a larger team.
- 50:06My premise, I think, would be, and you talked about this, engagement with the
- 50:10system is certainly possible to achieve. But I think you have to start local
- 50:13and just work, build from there.
- 50:16I don't know that we can attempt to achieve system engagement and then drive
- 50:22local engagement from there.
- 50:24It might have to work in the other way. Totally agree. We talk a little bit
- 50:27about culture change and we talk about rituals and how do you do that.
- 50:30And Ainsley Price, who you work with, listened to one of my lectures and actually did it.
- 50:36And the idea is that if we want to change culture, we have to look at our values,
- 50:41and really identify what values are missing here and which ones we want to instill,
- 50:47which ones we want to reinforce.
- 50:48And you can use rituals to do that, as opposed to just saying,
- 50:50gee, we want culture change, and then sitting there and wondering,
- 50:53how do you do that? Because it seems impossible.
- 50:55And so, she created the Joy Duck Ritual, which is super simple, right?
- 50:59It's just a simple award for someone who exemplifies the values of what we're
- 51:04trying to do, and joy and work was the value.
- 51:06But the really cool thing that I didn't even know before she gave me the punchline
- 51:12was that this connected to the big rubber duck in the Belfast Harbor was...
- 51:17And connected you to the community. Yeah. It's like, again, so simple, but like ingenious.
- 51:23That was fantastic. And I'll tell you, I want to recognize as many people as
- 51:27I can, but like the other ritual that I witnessed, and it wasn't something that I have any credit for,
- 51:34or motivating, but Mary Vigent at Memorial has been hugely impactful at creating
- 51:39a sense of connectedness and belonging.
- 51:42One of the things that she did when she was the medical staff president,
- 51:44every single medical staff meeting would start with significant life events.
- 51:50And it was a picture of weddings. It was new babies. It was graduations.
- 51:54It was all those things that are hugely important to us that are happening in the background.
- 51:59That if you don't ask and you don't have time because we're so busy and we go
- 52:04through our lives connected from one another, disconnected from one another,
- 52:08and I'm not even going to talk about the phone that you stick in your face every
- 52:11time you have a free minute.
- 52:15But intentionally, every meeting started with that.
- 52:19And it was 10, 15 minutes sometimes.
- 52:24And it very specifically was not at the end of the meeting where it's just fit in, right?
- 52:30It was started. And the premise of every single meeting then was we are a community.
- 52:36And we've got each other's back, and we are aware of what's happening around us.
- 52:43And I think you know you don't have to be a leader to do that you could you
- 52:48can start those kinds of rituals and things,
- 52:51at your front line and whatever unit you work at and I think if we aim towards
- 52:55that it'll go a long way at developing the culture that we want to develop.
- 52:59Well I think on that positive note of something that we can each do individually
- 53:06or locally I'm gonna thank you for having this really great conversation.
- 53:11We could obviously go on probably for another hour.
- 53:14I really appreciate your time. And it's been fantastic to have you here. Thank you.
- 53:20Totally agreed. And I really appreciate the opportunity to come.
- 53:22And you and I have done this conversation before. We could probably go on forever.
- 53:27I really enjoyed having this conversation with you.
- 53:29Thank you so much. Thanks a lot.
- 53:33Thanks for listening to Curbside Consult. To continue the conversation,
- 53:37please visit the MaineHealth ACO's LinkedIn page at LinkedIn.com/company/MHACO.
- 53:46We welcome your reactions, thoughts, and suggestions for what specialties to
- 53:50cover in the months to come. We'll see you next time. We'll see you next time.