Latest / Property Investment & Wealth Creation Australia | The Michael Yardney Podcast / Property Investors: Why Playing It Safe Could Cost You a Fortune
Transcript
- 0:00What are the decisions that you make as a property investor that feel
- 0:03the safest are actually the ones most likely to cost you a fortune?
- 0:07You know, like waiting for interest rates to settle.
- 0:09That sounds sensible. Keeping your money stashed in cash feels secure.
- 0:14Avoiding investment debt. That appears responsible,
- 0:17while buying in the same location everyone else is talking about provides
- 0:21the comfort of following the crowd.
- 0:23Yet each of these choices can carry hidden risks.
- 0:27In today's episode of the Michael Yardney podcast,
- 0:30I want to explore one of the most important psychological traps property investors
- 0:34face. And that's confusing familiarity with safety and discomfort with danger.
- 0:40Now, regular viewers and listeners know I usually have a guest on the show,
- 0:43but once a month or so, I like having a chat,
- 0:46just you and me, where I can give you my thoughts about an important topic.
- 0:50So by the end of today's show,
- 0:52I want to give you
- 0:53a practical way to distinguish genuine investment risk from emotional discomfort,
- 0:58and I want to help you make better decisions about property,
- 1:01money, and your financial future.
- 1:03So welcome to the Michael Yardney podcast,
- 1:05where twice a week I help you understand property investment,
- 1:08wealth creation, and the psychology of success,
- 1:11giving you perspectives I wish I'd had when I first started investing over
- 1:1650 years ago. These often have to do with the psychology of money.
- 1:20which is what we're going to be discussing today.
- 1:22So even though it's not about the next property hotspot or interest rates
- 1:25or the government, please stick with us, because I've got some great lessons
- 1:29to teach you. So let's get on with the show.
- 1:37Most of us like to believe we make rational decisions about money,
- 1:40about property investing and about our future,
- 1:42yet our choices are often guided by something much more powerful than logic,
- 1:47and that's the desire to stay safe.
- 1:49We gravitate towards familiar options,
- 1:52follow what others are doing, and avoid decisions that make us feel uncomfortable.
- 1:56Unfortunately, what feels safe today may quietly expose us
- 2:01to greater risks tomorrow.
- 2:03At the same time, some decisions that initially feel risky,
- 2:06such as investing when others are nervous,
- 2:08changing an outdated strategy,
- 2:11or seeking independent advice can ultimately make our financial position more
- 2:16secure. You see, our brains confuse familiarity with safety.
- 2:21Human beings are wired to seek certainty and to stay close to the group.
- 2:26If members of the herd strayed,
- 2:29they were easier for predators to pick off.
- 2:31Staying with a group has proven the best way to survive.
- 2:34Well, we're talking about, you know,
- 2:36in old caveman days, I guess, that for much of history that instinct
- 2:40did help keep us alive. So it's hardly surprising that it still influences
- 2:45how we behave today. The problem is that financial markets reward independent
- 2:49thinking rather than emotional comfort.
- 2:52If everyone around us is making the same decision,
- 2:54we tend to assume it must be sensible,
- 2:56even when few people have properly examined the risks.
- 3:00Now I see this in property markets all the time.
- 3:03When prices are rising strongly and optimistic forecasts dominate the headlines,
- 3:08buyers feel reassured because everyone else is doing it.
- 3:12Everyone else is confident. Yet this is often when people become careless.
- 3:16They stretch their borrowing capacity,
- 3:17they compromise on property quality,
- 3:19they justify almost any purchase because they fear missing out,
- 3:23you know, the old FOMO. When markets slow,
- 3:26as they are at the moment, and when the media turns pessimistic as it
- 3:30is at the moment, many of those same potential property buyers retreat.
- 3:34Competition eases, vendors become more negotiable,
- 3:37and investors actually have got more time to complete their due diligence,
- 3:41but buying suddenly feels dangerous, doesn't it?
- 3:44Interestingly, that asset may carry less market risk,
- 3:47yet the decision feels considerably riskier.
- 3:51You see, I've found over the years that following the crowd can be expensive.
- 3:55Sure, we feel comfort in doing what everyone else is doing because we feel if that decision
- 3:59is wrong at least we won't be wrong alone.
- 4:02But hey, do you really want to do what everyone else does?
- 4:04If you see the results most property investors get,
- 4:07we know most sell up in the first five years.
- 4:09And those who stay in the market,
- 4:11most property investors, 92% never get past their first or second property.
- 4:15So therefore doing what everyone else is doing may protect your ego,
- 4:19but it actually does very little to protect your wealth.
- 4:22Property investors regularly chase locations that have already
- 4:26experienced strong growth because recent performance makes them feel safe.
- 4:31But by the time a suburb becomes the latest hotspot,
- 4:34and you find out about it on social media or in the podcasts,
- 4:37or it's being promoted everywhere,
- 4:39much of the easy growth may have already occurred.
- 4:42Now, this doesn't mean investors should automatically move against the market,
- 4:46being contrarian for its own sake,
- 4:48can be every bit as dangerous as following the herd.
- 4:51The more sensible approach in my mind is to understand where the crowd could
- 4:56be mispricing risk and then make decisions based on research,
- 5:00on fundamentals, and on a clear strategy.
- 5:04This could mean buying an investment grade property in an established capital city
- 5:07market while others are being distracted by the short term headlines.
- 5:11It may also mean walking away from
- 5:13popular regional locations or that new apartment tower or the new house
- 5:18and land package in the outer suburbs,
- 5:20even though everyone seems to be talking about them at the moment.
- 5:23In other words, the greatest risk today may actually be not standing
- 5:28out from the crowd. In other words,
- 5:29simply doing what everyone else is doing.
- 5:32Now, let me give you another distinction.
- 5:35I think it's worth making here, because investors often use the words risk
- 5:39and volatility as if they mean the same thing.
- 5:42Volatility is the movement we can see.
- 5:44Property prices slow, auction clearance rates decline,
- 5:48interest rates shift, consumer confidence weakens.
- 5:51These developments attract plenty of media attention.
- 5:54So they feel immediate, they feel threatening.
- 5:58On the other hand, risk is often much quieter.
- 6:01Real risk is buying the wrong property,
- 6:04paying too much, borrowing without adequate financial buffers, relying on unrealistic
- 6:09growth assumptions or owning an asset with limited appeal to future owner occupiers.
- 6:15As I see it, those mistakes can erode your wealth for many years,
- 6:18yet they may not seem dangerous at the time you make them.
- 6:22For example, imagine the value of a well located investment grade property
- 6:26temporarily declining during a market downturn,
- 6:29like many are now. That may feel uncomfortable,
- 6:32but the property could still have strong
- 6:35long-term fundamentals, including scarcity, affluent owner-occupier demand,
- 6:40access to employment hubs, and a desirable lifestyle and maybe a walkable location.
- 6:46Provided the new owner, the new buyer has got sufficient cash flow
- 6:50and financial buffers, that temporary price movement may have little impact
- 6:55on the eventual long-term outcome.
- 6:58Now compare that with buying a cheap property in a location with weak economic growth, limited employment opportunities,
- 7:04an abundance of similar properties.
- 7:06Its price may remain stable for a while,
- 7:08giving the new owner a sense of security.
- 7:12Yet it could substantially underperform over the next decade.
- 7:17The short-term price movement's visible while
- 7:19the long-term underperformance develops quietly.
- 7:23That's why experienced investors learn to tolerate manageable volatility.
- 7:27while protecting themselves from permanent financial damage.
- 7:31Good investors, successful strategic investors understand that fluctuations
- 7:35are part of the property cycle.
- 7:37They see it as a fee for being involved in the market,
- 7:40not a fine for property investing.
- 7:43So smart investors prioritise owning the type of assets that
- 7:48are going to recover from these temporary setbacks and continue growing over
- 7:52the long term. Now, something interesting happens when
- 7:55we spend money. When we look around and see what everyone else is buying,
- 7:59we confuse the herd with safety.
- 8:01For example, simply because everyone else is using credit to buy
- 8:04the latest iPhone or even bigger things like I don't know,
- 8:07boats or cars, doesn't mean it's risk free.
- 8:10But we start to tell ourselves the story that because everyone else is doing it,
- 8:14hey, it must be okay. Also, we don't want to stick out and look frugal or stingy,
- 8:20do we? No one wants to be the person who says I
- 8:22I can't afford it when everyone else is buying.
- 8:25But in reality, safety comes from focusing on what we can actually afford compared
- 8:30rather than what our neighbours think they can afford.
- 8:34Cash is another thing I think we should have a quick talk about because sure
- 8:38it provides certainty because its value doesn't appear to jump from day to day.
- 8:42a balance of $100,000 will still show us a balance of $100,000.
- 8:47in next month's bank statement,
- 8:49well assuming you haven't spent any of it.
- 8:51However, the number on the statement only tells part of the story.
- 8:54Inflation steadily erodes what money can buy,
- 8:57while tax on your interest consumes a meaningful share of what you earn.
- 9:03In other words, having cash in the bank over a long period,
- 9:06your purchasing power falls significantly,
- 9:09even though the nominal value,
- 9:11the $100,000, still remains intact.
- 9:13That's one of the hassles or challenges with inflation,
- 9:15isn't it? Cash plays an important role in a sound wealth strategy,
- 9:19though. I'm not saying it shouldn't.
- 9:20Investors do need cash. They need financial buffers,
- 9:24but I often suggest you have them in an offset account where it actually means that
- 9:29you're not paying interest for the amount of cash that you've got there.
- 9:33And you have that sitting waiting,
- 9:35protecting you for vacancies, for repairs, for unexpected expenses.
- 9:40Or changes in interest rates, or changes in your income.
- 9:43So in my mind, the danger rises when temporary safety becomes permanent inaction,
- 9:48keeping every available dollar in the bank for years,
- 9:51because investing feels uncomfortable at the moment,
- 9:54can create a different kind of risk.
- 9:56The possibility that your wealth fails to keep pace with the rising cost of living.
- 10:01Another factor that stops many people is avoiding debt because that also carries a cost.
- 10:07Australians are often told that debt is dangerous.
- 10:09I know my parents were concerned about that,
- 10:12but they weren't good money managers.
- 10:14They didn't teach me good money lessons.
- 10:16But we're often taught to be debt free.
- 10:18I remember my mother saying to me,
- 10:20Michael, when will you ever own anything?
- 10:23Because she knew I had all these loans.
- 10:25But I used the leverage from the loans to grow my very substantial property
- 10:29portfolio. So again, Australians are
- 10:31often told that all debt is dangerous and becoming debt-free should be a top priority.
- 10:37The advice is appropriate for high interest rate consumer debt,
- 10:42which typically finances items that depreciate.
- 10:45However, it's less useful information,
- 10:48less useful advice when applied indiscriminately to productive investment debt.
- 10:53So I see three levels of debt:
- 10:55consumer debt, or non-productive debt,
- 10:58bad debt; necessary debt, non-interest deductible debt against your home,
- 11:03but your home's a great investment,
- 11:05and also productive debt, debt that you use when you leverage to
- 11:10buy growth assets like real estate.
- 11:12So in my mind, used carefully,
- 11:14debt will allow you to control a much larger asset and to benefit from capital
- 11:19and rental growth over time, because we are stuck in a period now of longer,
- 11:24higher inflation and slightly higher interest rates.
- 11:27So using leverage accelerates your wealth creation in ways that saving your money
- 11:32can't. I mean, you've heard me say it before.
- 11:35In the future, the majority of your assets when you retire won't be
- 11:39the money you've saved, the interest you've got,
- 11:41the rent that you've got. It'll be the tax- free capital growth that you've received
- 11:46on your property investments. So owning the most you can safely, by leveraging,
- 11:50makes sense to me. Of course, borrowing heavily without having the buffers
- 11:54or a reliable steady income, of course,
- 11:57of course that's risky. So is borrowing to buy poor quality assets simply because
- 12:01it's cheap or offering an attractive initial yield.
- 12:04So the real issue is the quality of your debt and I guess the quality
- 12:08of the assets, and the investor's capacity to hold through
- 12:12the inevitable ups and downs. For some people refusing to use any debt may feel
- 12:17smart to them, prudent to them,
- 12:19yet it could leave them approaching retirement with an insufficient asset base.
- 12:23Look, only last night I saw something on TV where a lady in
- 12:27her seventies was renting and still working,
- 12:30and they were talking about how it's not fair, and it isn't fair, that
- 12:33a lot of people retire and don't own their own home.
- 12:37So I guess I don't know what she was doing,
- 12:40how she invested, what she did with her money.
- 12:43But she'd been working for 50 years and hadn't actually put any aside to
- 12:47buy a home or buy assets that will protect her.
- 12:50So refusing to use debt prudently in my mind is a genuine risk,
- 12:55even though it develops gradually.
- 12:58So it's easy to overlook. I think another risk is waiting for certainty.
- 13:02That's rarely a safe strategy.
- 13:04I know many potential investors tell themselves,
- 13:07they're going to act, you know,
- 13:08when interest rates eventually fall,
- 13:10when I'm comfortable that they're not going to rise again,
- 13:12or maybe when economic conditions improve,
- 13:14or I know, you know, when the property market becomes clearer,
- 13:17there are so many mixed messages at the moment.
- 13:19Unfortunately, clarity generally arises after prices have already reacted
- 13:25to the improved conditions. You know,
- 13:26when you eventually read about the last couple of months,
- 13:30property values have kept rising,
- 13:31auction clearance rates are rising, that's all looking
- 13:34at the historic information. For our clients at Metropole
- 13:38and other investors, they've already done well.
- 13:41You see, there's always going to be a reason to delay.
- 13:44you know, there's an election coming up,
- 13:46inflation's annoying, scary. What about all those geopolitical risks overseas?
- 13:51maybe the government's going to change taxes.
- 13:53And of course there's regular economic forecasts continuously creating uncertainty.
- 13:59But the property markets currently are doing what they always do.
- 14:02They work through cycles. And when I first started investing over fifty years ago,
- 14:06they were doing the same. But because there wasn't the daily news,
- 14:10because you couldn't find out what was happening to property prices for
- 14:14up to a year later, the answer is I wasn't as concerned about the ups
- 14:20and downs of the market because I didn't even know they were happening.
- 14:23So basically I just invested.
- 14:26And that allowed me to build a very substantial portfolio I've got now.
- 14:30Today I can understand why many investors feel the uncertainty is making
- 14:36it harder for them to get into the market.
- 14:38I'm not suggesting anyone invest before you're financially prepared.
- 14:43Some people need to improve their cash flow,
- 14:45reduce their consumer debt, build a buffer,
- 14:47or strengthen their borrowing capacity before buying another property.
- 14:51What I am saying though is there's a difference between becoming properly prepared
- 14:55and waiting for every bit of uncertainty to disappear.
- 14:59The first is sensible risk management,
- 15:01the second can become an expensive habit.
- 15:04Look, let me illustrate this with two hypothetical investors.
- 15:08I don't know, let's call them David and Sarah.
- 15:10David's interested in buying another property,
- 15:12but the current market's making him feel uneasy.
- 15:15Economic news is mixed, interest rates remain a concern,
- 15:19and some commentators are warning property prices are going to keep falling,
- 15:23and he doesn't want to, you know,
- 15:24what they say, catch a falling knife.
- 15:25So David decides to wait until the outlook becomes clearer.
- 15:29On the other hand, Sarah's looking at exactly the same market and has many
- 15:33of the same concerns. She also understands that she can't predict what'll happen
- 15:38over the next six or twelve months.
- 15:40But she's preparing rather than attempting to forecast every market movement.
- 15:44She reviews her finances, improves her cash flow,
- 15:47builds a larger buffer, and obtains a clear understanding of her borrowing capacity.
- 15:51She then develops a strategic property plan.
- 15:54Hey, that's the sort of thing our wealth strategists at Metropole help
- 15:57our clients do. So she's got a plan and starts researching
- 16:01the locations and property types most likely to benefit from the long term economic and demographic changes.
- 16:07She doesn't rush out and buy the first property she sees.
- 16:10She uses the quieter market, though,
- 16:12that we're currently experiencing to complete her due diligence.
- 16:15And it's at a time when there's less competition and vendors are more willing
- 16:19to negotiate. Several months later,
- 16:21the economic headlines improve.
- 16:22Buyer confidence returns, auction clearance rates rise,
- 16:26and the media begins reporting the property market's turned.
- 16:28David finally feels comfortable enough to start,
- 16:30but at this stage, more buyers are attending inspections.
- 16:34Good properties are attracting multiple offers.
- 16:36Vendors are more confident about their asking prices.
- 16:38But Sarah's already bought the high quality property under more favorable
- 16:43conditions. Sarah didn't know with certainty that the market was about to improve.
- 16:47She simply recognized that preparation gave her the ability to act when
- 16:52the right opportunity appeared.
- 16:54David, he waited for greater certainty,
- 16:56but the price of that emotional comfort may have been greater competition and
- 17:00a clearly higher purchase price.
- 17:02Now, I think what I was trying to get at,
- 17:04I don't know if that story made sense to you.
- 17:06I hope it did. It highlights an important point.
- 17:09Successful investors are rarely fearless.
- 17:12They don't possess a crystal ball either,
- 17:15but they manage their uncertainty by becoming financially prepared,
- 17:19conducting careful research, and following a strategy.
- 17:23Now, another apparent form of safety that I've seen over the last couple of years
- 17:28is buying a cheaper property, as a lower purchase price seems to imply less risk.
- 17:34Now I can understand that appeal.
- 17:36A lower price usually means a smaller deposit,
- 17:38more manageable loan, less pressure on the household budget.
- 17:42However, price and risk are two very,
- 17:45very different things. There's usually a reason one property costs significantly
- 17:49less than the other. A cheap property may be located in an area with weaker
- 17:53employment growth, lower household incomes.
- 17:56Limited infrastructure and probably less demand from affluent owner-occupiers.
- 18:01It may also be one of hundreds of similar properties,
- 18:05meaning there's very little scarcity.
- 18:06Now, sure these properties can initially provide attractive rental yields,
- 18:12which make them appear financially sensible,
- 18:14yet a few thousand dollars of additional rent each year will rarely compensate
- 18:18the investor for missing hundreds of thousands of dollars worth
- 18:21of capital growth over various property cycles.
- 18:24Remember what I said a while ago,
- 18:25that when you eventually retire,
- 18:27most of your asset base, if you get it right,
- 18:30will be the tax free capital growth,
- 18:32not the extra rent you get that you pay tax on.
- 18:35A more expensive property in an established,
- 18:37tightly held suburb may initially feel like a riskier purchase.
- 18:41However, if it's got strong owner occupier appeal,
- 18:44access to employment, because you know,
- 18:46people move into areas because of jobs.
- 18:48So when we do our research at Metropole we look for areas where there's
- 18:53stronger jobs growth, which makes people move in,
- 18:56which means people can afford to buy more expensive properties. Often they rent there
- 19:00initially and then they eventually buy,
- 19:02and more affluent people keep moving in,
- 19:05and so the cycle moves on. So we look for areas with strong owner-occupier appeal,
- 19:10access to employment, good transport,
- 19:12attractive amenities, and also an element of scarcity.
- 19:16While it may seem a little riskier initially,
- 19:18because it costs more, actually
- 19:21It's a much more secure asset over the long term.
- 19:24Of course, this doesn't imply you should just buy the most expensive properties
- 19:28or the most expensive property you can afford.
- 19:30Far from that. An expensive property can still be a poor investment,
- 19:34particularly if it's overcapitalized,
- 19:35architecturally unusual, or situated in an oversupplied market.
- 19:39In fact, the top end of the market is always more volatile,
- 19:43as is happening at the moment,
- 19:44especially in the top end of Melbourne and Sydney,
- 19:47but the other capital cities as well.
- 19:49We like more the middle ring suburbs,
- 19:51the established affluent suburbs where owner occupiers have in many cases paid
- 19:56off their home. and where there's a balance of people who've been living there
- 20:01for a long time, others who've only moved in five or six years ago,
- 20:04and others moving in now. We want areas where there's a balance of demographics.
- 20:08And the quality of the asset matters more than whether the purchase price feels
- 20:13comfortable to you or not.
- 20:14Many investors reduce the immediate financial discomfort by choosing
- 20:18a cheaper property, yet unknowingly they accept a greater risk of long-term underperformance.
- 20:23Your borrowing capacity is a valuable and a limited resource.
- 20:27So every property in your portfolio must earn its place.
- 20:31I usually tell people I want them to own Mercedes or BMWs in their portfolio,
- 20:36not Kias or Ladas. So you've got to own the best assets you can,
- 20:40even if it's not as many.
- 20:42once you've used up your borrowing capacity,
- 20:43it'll be difficult to retrieve it if that particular property that
- 20:47you bought fails to grow. So you're wanting a property that's going
- 20:51to give you higher capital growth,
- 20:53which is going to give you the equity to get your next property.
- 20:57Now, there's also another area when we're talking about risks in property.
- 21:01I hope you're finding this chat useful.
- 21:03Again, normally in most of my podcasts I have a guest,
- 21:06and if you don't currently subscribe to the show,
- 21:08Click the subscribe button and go back and listen to all the various guests I've
- 21:13had who have valuable lessons about property investment.
- 21:16But today it's just you and me, as I'm talking about why some
- 21:20of the safest financial decisions can,
- 21:23in fact, for some people be the riskiest ones.
- 21:26And for generations, the principle of sticking with the herd was true
- 21:31and has worked well. As I said at the beginning,
- 21:34many of our grandparents
- 21:35had one job for many years and retired with the pension and lived happily ever
- 21:40after. Things have changed since then though.
- 21:43A regular salary's long been regarded though as one of the strongest forms
- 21:47of financial security. Yet today employment is changing rapidly as technology,
- 21:53artificial intelligence, automation and global competition reshapes Australia's
- 21:57workplaces. So in my mind, relying on one employer,
- 22:01one source of income may feel secure for you.
- 22:04Because it's familiar, but that dependence can leave your household financially
- 22:09exposed. So I believe you should be investing in your skills,
- 22:12building a professional network around you,
- 22:15and developing additional sources of income that can initially feel uncertain.
- 22:19If you've only got one source of income you're at risk,
- 22:22but over time making choices that give you a wider range of incomes,
- 22:27will make things more resilient than staying in the comfortable role
- 22:31as your industry will change around you.
- 22:33You've probably heard me say I want you to have two businesses.
- 22:36One is your cash flow business,
- 22:38which is your job, your profession,
- 22:40your income, that gives you your lifestyle,
- 22:42but also funds your second business,
- 22:44which is your capital growth business,
- 22:47your property business. And there could be shares in there or ETFs
- 22:50or other things so that eventually the capital growth business grows sufficiently to
- 22:55churn out sufficient income to replace your cash flow business.
- 22:59Now, again, I'm not necessarily talking about business owners,
- 23:04because to me, property investment is a business.
- 23:06It's supplying a service that's required by people and taking a financial risk
- 23:12to do that and expecting a reward.
- 23:14So I guess what I was saying in this little part of my chat with
- 23:18you is that you can't just rely on your job.
- 23:22especially in the future with AI coming around and I don't know what it's going
- 23:27to do. I've heard all the negative comments.
- 23:29I see some of the positive things as well.
- 23:31But whether you're in business or in a job,
- 23:34I think you've got to protect yourself by having a property business on the side.
- 23:38So again, I'm talking about how what seem like
- 23:45safe decisions may actually be risky.
- 23:47And real safety in my mind comes from resilience.
- 23:50Financial security doesn't come from eliminating every possible risk.
- 23:54That simply can't be done. It comes from ensuring that one setback won't derail your
- 23:59entire financial future. For property investors,
- 24:02this means owning the right assets, maintaining financial buffers,
- 24:05protecting your income, managing your debt responsibly,
- 24:09and avoiding excessive exposure to a single market or strategy.
- 24:13Now when you first start, you can't just diversify, that's hard.
- 24:17But over time, I'd like to see you have assets in various states.
- 24:21And over time, once you build a substantial portfolio,
- 24:24add maybe commercial properties to your portfolio as well.
- 24:27But it also means starting with a written strategic investment plan that accounts
- 24:33for the changing interest rates for periods of weak growth
- 24:36and unexpected life events. Because they are going to keep happening.
- 24:40A person with a well-selected portfolio, manageable loan-to-value ratios,
- 24:44Hey, appropriate insurance, that's a way of getting rid of risks,
- 24:46having sufficient cash buffers,
- 24:48may be safer than someone with no investments who depends entirely
- 24:52on the next paycheck. Now, what about diversification?
- 24:55I mentioned that a moment ago.
- 24:57it actually may create a false sense of security though,
- 25:00because it's an area where conventional advice sometimes needs
- 25:04a little more context. Investors are regularly told that diversification reduces risk.
- 25:10Now, in principle, that's correct.
- 25:12A portfolio that depends entirely upon one employer or one industry or
- 25:17one market or one type of asset can be vulnerable if circumstances change.
- 25:22However, diversification only helps when the underlying assets are sound.
- 25:27Owning several mediocre properties in different states doesn't automatically create
- 25:31a strong portfolio. It may simply spread poor asset selection across a larger area.
- 25:36Some investors buy in three or four states because they believe geographic diversity
- 25:40will protect them, yet each property may be located in an outer suburb with little
- 25:45scarcity, modest owner-occupier appeal,
- 25:47and a large supply of developable land nearby.
- 25:50In other words, not one that's going to grow.
- 25:53Sure the locations are different for this person,
- 25:55but the investment risks are remarkably similar,
- 25:58aren't they? Each property depends upon the same broad proposition.
- 26:02That affordability and population growth is eventually going
- 26:05to produce capital growth. If buyers can continue moving into one suburb further
- 26:09out and purchasing another brand new property,
- 26:12then the existing property that the investors bought may struggle
- 26:16to have genuine scarcity. So, as I see it,
- 26:19a carefully constructed portfolio should certainly avoid excessive concentration,
- 26:24but every asset must still satisfy sound financial investment fundamentals.
- 26:30Most of us have limited borrowing capacity,
- 26:33so owning fewer higher quality assets will create a more resilient portfolio
- 26:38in my mind than collecting a large number of inexpensive properties simply
- 26:42for the sake of diversification.
- 26:44The number of properties you own is far less important than the size
- 26:48and quality of your asset base that you control.
- 26:50Ultimately, diversification should protect a good strategy rather than compensate
- 26:55for a poor one.
- 26:57Now let me have a quick chat to you about what I call the comfort test.
- 27:00When a financial decision feels especially comfortable,
- 27:03it's actually worth asking why.
- 27:06Does it feel safe because the risks have been carefully assessed
- 27:09or because the decision is familiar?
- 27:11Because everyone else is doing the same thing.
- 27:14Similarly, when an opportunity feels uncomfortable,
- 27:17I think you should be determining whether this discomfort comes from
- 27:20a genuine danger or simply from uncertainty.
- 27:24or unfamiliarity. Successful investors learn to separate emotional discomfort from
- 27:29financial risk. They conduct their research,
- 27:31prepare for what could go wrong,
- 27:33and then make decisions based on where they want to be in 10 years,
- 27:3720 years' time. So in my mind, the goal is not to become fearless or reckless.
- 27:41It's to recognise that avoiding every uncomfortable decision can expose
- 27:45you to an even greater risk. The biggest risk of all,
- 27:48not reaching the financial future that you expected or you deserve.
- 27:51Now, there's a practical exercise you can use whenever you're facing
- 27:54an important property or financial decision.
- 27:57And I call this the risk reversal test.
- 27:59Most of us naturally begin by asking what could go wrong?
- 28:03if we act. What happens if property prices fall after I buy?
- 28:06What happens if interest rates go up?
- 28:08What happens if the property remains vacant for several weeks?
- 28:11Hey, what if my circumstances change?
- 28:13Now of course these are sensible questions, and they deserve careful consideration.
- 28:19However, they only examine one side of the decision.
- 28:23The risk reversal test asks you to consider what could go wrong if you do nothing.
- 28:28What could waiting another three or five years cost if property values and rents continue to increase,
- 28:34and they will over the long term.
- 28:35I accept that, well, rents are growing strongly at the moment,
- 28:39property values aren't, but this cycle will turn,
- 28:42it always does. So you've got to ask yourself what happens to
- 28:44the purchasing power of your deposit while it sits in the bank?
- 28:48What will your retirement look like if you never build a sufficiently large asset
- 28:52base? You should then determine whether each risk is likely to be
- 28:57temporary or permanent. The current market downturn is a temporary, normal phase
- 29:03of the property cycle. It's not permanent.
- 29:05A period of weak market conditions causes a temporary decline in the value
- 29:10of good property. Buying an inferior asset, paying substantially above
- 29:13its value or becoming a forced seller can cause much more lasting financial damage
- 29:18than buying a good asset in the current market.
- 29:21So the next step is of course to separate the risks you can control from those
- 29:25you can't. You can't control the economy.
- 29:28You're not going to control government policy or tax changes or inflation
- 29:33or the Reserve Bank's next interest rate decision.
- 29:35So spending too much time trying to predict these things can create
- 29:39an illusion of productive analysis,
- 29:41while it actually leads you no closer to making a decision, does it?
- 29:45You can though control the quality of the property you purchase,
- 29:48the location you choose, the price you pay,
- 29:50the amount you borrow, the size of your financial buffer.
- 29:53Now, of course, you can control your loan structure, insurance ownership structures,
- 29:58and the quality of professional advice you receive.
- 30:00So finally, I recommend you ask yourself whether you're rejecting
- 30:05the opportunity because your research has uncovered a genuine problem
- 30:08or because the decision feels unfamiliar.
- 30:11Now that can be a confronting question because fear often disguises itself
- 30:16as analysis. We keep looking for one more forecast.
- 30:19maybe another opinion. I'm looking for another piece of data.
- 30:22They see that, people see that as the real obstacle in our desire for certainty.
- 30:28The purpose of my test isn't to persuade you to proceed with every investment.
- 30:34Far from it. Sometimes analysis is going to confirm that walking away
- 30:37is the correct decision. But
- 30:39its value lies in helping you assess both sides of the decision,
- 30:43including the long-term cost of remaining where you are.
- 30:47Having invested through more than 50 years of property cycles,
- 30:50I can tell you there's never been a time
- 30:52when the outlook was completely clear.
- 30:54every cycle's brought its own reasons for caution.
- 30:57I've invested through periods of high inflation,
- 30:59double digit interest rates, recessions,
- 31:01credit restrictions, boy, changes in government.
- 31:04I've seen so many of those tax reforms.
- 31:07I remember the banking crisis and so many international conflicts.
- 31:11And during each of these periods,
- 31:13there were intelligent and persuasive commentators explaining to me why
- 31:18it was the wrong time to invest.
- 31:20Now some of those concerns were valid.
- 31:22The risks were real, and a number of investors who at that time made
- 31:26the wrong decision and went ahead and borrowed too much, or bought
- 31:29the wrong assets, or failed to maintain a proper
- 31:33financial buffer, experienced significant financial difficulty.
- 31:36Yet the Australian economy over all those cycles continued to expand.
- 31:40Our population continued to grow and the value of well-located properties increased
- 31:45substantially over the long term.
- 31:47So when you look back today, many of those periods appeared to have been excellent
- 31:51buying opportunities. But they certainly didn't feel that way while
- 31:55we were living through them. Boy,
- 31:57I remember that well. And that's one of the great
- 32:00tricks hindsight plays on you.
- 32:02It removes the uncertainty that surrounded those original decisions
- 32:06and makes the eventual outcome appear more obvious than it was at the time.
- 32:11I've also learned that successful investors rarely possess more certainty than
- 32:14anyone else. They generally have a clearer strategy,
- 32:17though, better financial buffers and a long term perspective.
- 32:21You've heard me say that over and over again in these podcasts, that
- 32:25successful investors don't worry where interest rates are going to be
- 32:28in six months, or where the property market's going to be in a year or two,
- 32:32but they have a long term, multi-decade approach.
- 32:35And they don't rely on their forecasting being correct.
- 32:38They prepare for a range of possible outcomes and ensure they
- 32:42can remain invested when conditions become uncomfortable.
- 32:46And these successful investors also recognise that time in the market
- 32:51is much more important than attempting
- 32:53to identify the perfect time to enter the market.
- 32:56Of course, this doesn't excuse poor asset selection.
- 32:59Time's not going to transform an inferior property into an investment grade one.
- 33:03And a rising market can sometimes conceal mistakes for a while.
- 33:08that happened over the last little while where people well overpaid
- 33:12in many regional areas, but because other investors ploughed in there too,
- 33:16pushed up values well above fundamentals and
- 33:19well above what the locals would be prepared to pay.
- 33:22So yes, sometimes time actually covers up in the short term mistakes.
- 33:29That's why I've always believed that property investment should begin with
- 33:32a strategic plan and finish with the selection of the right property rather than
- 33:35beginning with a property somebody wants to sell you.
- 33:38As I've often said, you know, the property you eventually buy should
- 33:41be the physical manifestation of a whole lot of decisions you make.
- 33:44So the most important lesson from
- 33:47All those decades of me investing is that uncertainty never disappears.
- 33:51It simply changes. At one point we worry about interest rates,
- 33:55at other times inflation, unemployment,
- 33:58government policies, geopolitical tensions.
- 34:00Once one concern recedes, another one takes its place.
- 34:04So if you require complete certainty before acting,
- 34:07you're going to spend your entire life waiting.
- 34:10Successful investors accept uncertainty as part of
- 34:13The price of participation. And as I keep saying,
- 34:16protecting themselves with a plan,
- 34:18quality assets, manageable debt.
- 34:20That allows them to remain focused on what where they want to be in ten years
- 34:24or in twenty years time, while much of the market's preoccupied with what might
- 34:28happen next month. Remember Warren Buffett,
- 34:31I quote him often he said it well when he advised us to be greedy when others
- 34:35are fearful and fearful when others are greedy.
- 34:38Of course doing so
- 34:39requires ignoring the herd and sticking out in a way that
- 34:42may feel wildly uncomfortable at first.
- 34:45Doing so requires ignoring the herd and sticking out in a way that may make
- 34:50you feel wildly uncomfortable at first.
- 34:53Suddenly sticking out doesn't seem like such a bad idea at all.
- 34:56We can learn a lot by watching people around us.
- 34:59By the way, that's how we've evolved and reached the top of the food chain.
- 35:02But just maybe we should think very carefully about doing the same thing
- 35:07as everyone else. Does it really keep us safer to stick with a herd,
- 35:11or are we risking everything by continuing to look at the world through an outdated lens?
- 35:16I hope my chat with you has given you some ideas about why what seem like safe financial
- 35:22decisions can sometimes be riskier.
- 35:24If you got some benefit from this and you haven't currently subscribed
- 35:28to or followed this show, whether you're watching or listening,
- 35:30please subscribe and listen. And why not send this to a friend as well,
- 35:34somebody who would get benefit from this lesson as well.
- 35:37Now I'll be back again in a couple of days with a guest.
- 35:41Every week, twice a week we have the
- 35:43episodes of the Michael Yardney podcast and as I said there's usually other experts.
- 35:47But I hope our one on one chat helped you.
- 35:49I just wanted to get some of these points across to you.
- 35:53In a moment, my popular trivia quiz and a mindset message.
- 36:02I hope the lessons I just shared with you gave you something to think about because
- 36:06if you've been listening to the headlines lately,
- 36:08you'd think the property market was falling apart.
- 36:11You know, values dropping, buyers panicking,
- 36:13experts predicting doom and gloom around every corner.
- 36:17The property bears have come out of their caves and they're telling
- 36:20us how terrible things are. Now I get it.
- 36:22The noise is loud and designed to grab your attention,
- 36:25but it's meant to do that rather than protect your interests.
- 36:29But as I think I explained in this
- 36:31chat we just had, history shows us what happens.
- 36:34Every downturn in Australia's property has eventually been followed
- 36:38by strong growth and investors who did well weren't the ones who panicked,
- 36:42they're the ones who had a strategy and stuck to it.
- 36:44And that's exactly what we do at Metropole.
- 36:47For decades we've been helping everyday Australians build substantial property
- 36:51portfolios by starting with a strategic plan and then focusing on helping them find investment grade assets.
- 36:58and ignoring the short-term chatter.
- 37:00So if you're wondering whether now is the right time for you to buy,
- 37:03hold or restructure your portfolio,
- 37:05don't guess. Why not book a wealth discovery chat with one of the team
- 37:09at Metropole and get a clear independent strategy based on your goals.
- 37:13Head to metropole.com.au, I'll leave a link in the show notes,
- 37:17metropole.com.au, and take the next steps towards
- 37:21the wealth you deserve. You'll find we don't have a one-size-fits-all strategy far from it.
- 37:26and we don't sell property, we start by planning out your future
- 37:31by organizing with you a strategic property plan.
- 37:34So while property is the vehicle,
- 37:36the strategy is the driver. At Metropole,
- 37:39we're big enough to tip the scales in your favour,
- 37:41but still small enough to care.
- 37:49Each week I give away three books everyone who answers the property trivia question
- 37:55gets a free report. Now today's a little bit more complicated but let's
- 38:00see if we can get the answer. If an investment falls by 20% by what percentage must
- 38:05it subsequently rise to reach its original value?
- 38:09If your million dollar property drops or $800,000
- 38:12How much does it have to rise to get back the original value?
- 38:15A. Up 20% B. Up 22.5% C.
- 38:2025% or D. 30% So how much extra does it need to rise?
- 38:25You don't even have to remember the ABCD.
- 38:27Just go to propertytrivia.com.au and leave your answer.
- 38:31If a property value drops 20% how much does it need to rise to get back
- 38:37to its original value? I think that's an interesting exercise even just to think about.
- 38:41but
- 38:41it would be great to leave your answer at propertytrivia.com.au get a report
- 38:46as well as a chance to win one of my books.
- 38:48Doesn't matter if you've listened to this a bit late,
- 38:50your answer will still count.
- 39:01One of the most valuable lessons I learned from one of my early mentors,
- 39:05Jim Rohn, was this your personal philosophy is the greatest determining factor
- 39:10in how your life works out. You see,
- 39:12he taught me your personal philosophy is a collection of your beliefs,
- 39:15your attitudes, and your ideas that guide the way you live.
- 39:18It influences how you respond to setbacks,
- 39:21recognize opportunities, manage your money,
- 39:23build relationships, and make decisions about your future.
- 39:27Jim often compared philosophy
- 39:29to the set of a sail. The same wind blows on all of us.
- 39:32We all experience winds of opportunity,
- 39:34of uncertainty, of disappointment and change.
- 39:37And while we can't control every circumstance,
- 39:40we can decide how we respond and which direction we take.
- 39:44Jim understood this lesson through personal experience.
- 39:47He often told the story about how at the age of twenty-five he was broke,
- 39:51frustrated, full of excuses, and he blamed the economy,
- 39:54his employer, the government.
- 39:56and almost everything around him for his lack of progress.
- 39:59And then he met his mentor, Earl Shoaff,
- 40:02the person who became his mentor.
- 40:04And after listening patiently to Jim's complaints,
- 40:06Mr Shoaff told him, Jim, if you want things to change,
- 40:10you have to change. If you want to have things better,
- 40:14you have to get better. And these words transformed Jim Rohn's philosophy.
- 40:19He gradually stopped asking why life was so difficult and began asking
- 40:23what he could do to become better.
- 40:25He read more, learned more from successful people,
- 40:27developed new disciplines, and accepted greater responsibility for his results.
- 40:32And his external circumstances didn't improve overnight,
- 40:35but his thinking began to change immediately.
- 40:38And over time his results followed.
- 40:42And that lesson has remained with me throughout my life.
- 40:45Whenever your progress is slow,
- 40:47it's worth examining the ideas behind your decisions.
- 40:50Are your beliefs helping you move forward?
- 40:52Or are some of them keeping you anchored to old habits and outdated assumptions?
- 40:57A better philosophy can begin with something as simple as reading a worthwhile book,
- 41:01listening to a sensible podcast,
- 41:04listening to somebody who's achieved what you hope to achieve, and asking yourself.
- 41:08a more useful question. Personal growth rarely comes from waiting
- 41:11for the outside world to become easier.
- 41:13It comes from developing the knowledge,
- 41:16skills and discipline to handle the world more effectively.
- 41:19The winds are going to keep changing throughout your life.
- 41:22Your responsibility is to keep learning,
- 41:24keep adjusting, keep setting your sails towards the future you want to create.