Latest / The Psychology Undergrad Podcast / Solitary Confinement & Mental Illness: Rethinking Mass Incarceration
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to the Psychology Undergrad. Hey everyone,
- 0:02so glad you're joining us. Yeah, today we're
- 0:05embarking on a pretty intense deep dive into
- 0:09the source material. Specifically, we're looking
- 0:11at Chapter 7, Rethinking Incarceration. Right,
- 0:15which covers a massive... societal issue like
- 0:19a really profound one exactly our mission today
- 0:22is to unpack the psychological and honestly the
- 0:25moral implications of how America essentially
- 0:27treats its jails and prisons as the de facto
- 0:31mental health system yeah it's it's something
- 0:34I think a lot of people don't fully realize upwards
- 0:36of 40 % of people in jails and prisons have some
- 0:39kind of mental disorder 40 % I mean think about
- 0:42that that means if you as the listener really
- 0:44want to grasp the reality of the American and
- 0:46justice system right now, you absolutely have
- 0:49to understand this dynamic. You really do. And
- 0:51to kind of ground this in reality, the source
- 0:53material introduces us to the story of Seddliss
- 0:56Doughty. Right, yeah. That story really stuck
- 0:58with me. It's heartbreaking, really. So Doughty
- 1:01is a man with schizophrenia, and he started experiencing
- 1:04severe auditory hallucinations. Which is obviously
- 1:08a terrifying symptom to deal with. Extremely.
- 1:11And tragically, while dealing with this, he ended
- 1:13up shooting a stranger. OK, so when you hear
- 1:16that, right, the immediate thought is usually,
- 1:18well, this is exactly what the insanity defense
- 1:20is made for. You'd think so. But Doughty was
- 1:23actually terrified of the insanity defense. Really?
- 1:26Why? Because he was afraid it would lead to an
- 1:29open -ended, like, potentially lifetime stay
- 1:32in a psychiatric hospital. Oh, wow. So he essentially
- 1:36chose prison over a hospital. Exactly. He was
- 1:39convicted, went to prison, and once he was in
- 1:42there, he went off his medication. And without
- 1:44the meds, I'm guessing things deteriorated pretty
- 1:46fast? Yeah, he started acting out. Yeah. And
- 1:49because the system doesn't really have the tools
- 1:51to handle that, they just put him in solitary
- 1:53confinement for nine years. Wait, nine years?
- 1:56Nine years. Oh, my gosh. That is just, I mean,
- 1:59the psychological devastation of that is impossible
- 2:02to overstate. We are definitely going to get
- 2:04into solitary confinement in a minute. Oh, absolutely.
- 2:06But first. I want to give you all a mental model
- 2:09to hold on to. Think of our justice system as
- 2:12a house with a very specific moral architecture.
- 2:15I like that analogy. Right. So today, we're going
- 2:18to explore the basement, which is solitary confinement.
- 2:21We're going to look at the foundation, the legal
- 2:23rights. And then finally, a blueprint for remodeling,
- 2:27which is the APICUC framework. That's a great
- 2:29way to map it out. But before we get to the basement,
- 2:32We really need to understand the basic rooms
- 2:35of this house, like the physical and psychological
- 2:38spaces people are being placed in. Yeah, because
- 2:41there's a huge difference between jails and prisons,
- 2:43right? Completely. Structurally, they are very
- 2:46different. So jails hold over half a million
- 2:48people at any given moment. And those are mostly
- 2:50legally innocent people, right? Exactly. The
- 2:53vast majority are just awaiting trial, usually
- 2:55for low -level or non -violent offenses. So they
- 2:57haven't actually been convicted of anything yet.
- 2:59Right. Contrast that with prisons, which hold
- 3:01over a million people. And these are convicted
- 3:04individuals who are suring out longer sentences.
- 3:07OK, so to help you remember the difference, think
- 3:10of jail as this chaotic ER waiting room. People
- 3:14are constantly in flux, coming and going. And
- 3:17prison is more like the long -term care ward,
- 3:19where, you know, programming and rehabilitation
- 3:21are technically supposed to happen. That's a
- 3:24perfect way to visualize it, the ER waiting room
- 3:26versus the long -term ward. But OK, let's unpack
- 3:28this ER waiting room for a second, because the
- 3:31source material mentions that 75 % of unhoused
- 3:34people have mental disorders. And a massive portion
- 3:38of the jail population is only sitting there
- 3:40because they literally cannot afford to pay bail.
- 3:43Exactly, yeah. So aren't we essentially just
- 3:45criminalizing poverty and mental illness structurally?
- 3:49What's fascinating here is that the data totally
- 3:51supports that. I mean, look at the stats from
- 3:53Atlanta that the text highlights. Oh, right.
- 3:55The Atlanta numbers are wild. So in Atlanta,
- 3:58unhoused people make up only 0 .5 % of the overall
- 4:01population. Half a percent. Right. But they count
- 4:04for 12 .5 % of all jail bookings. That is just
- 4:08a massive over -representation. It really is.
- 4:11Yeah. The system just disproportionately traps
- 4:13marginalized groups. And it's particularly harsh
- 4:16on Black and Indigenous people. So these overwhelmed
- 4:20waiting rooms and underfunded long -term wards
- 4:22are just... And when they can't handle the behavioral
- 4:26symptoms of someone's mental illness, they default
- 4:29to their most extreme tool. Right. Which takes
- 4:31us down to the basement of the house, solitary
- 4:33confinement. Yeah. Or restrictive housing, as
- 4:37they sometimes call it. Which is a very sanitized
- 4:39term for what is actually a brutal reality. It
- 4:42really is. I mean, people are locked alone in
- 4:45a cell for up to 23 hours a day. Yeah. And think
- 4:48back to Sedlis Doughty. During his punishment,
- 4:51he was fed something called prison loaf. Ugh,
- 4:53I was reading about that. What even is that?
- 4:55It's basically this baked, dense brick of mashed
- 4:58up food. It technically hits all the nutritional
- 5:01requirements, but it's designed to be completely
- 5:04unappetizing. It's meant to be a punishment.
- 5:06That's just wild to me, and this isn't rare either.
- 5:09The sources point out that 8 % of the Federal
- 5:11Bureau of Prisons population is housed in these
- 5:14restrictive settings. Yeah, places like special
- 5:16housing units or the ADX Supermax out in Colorado.
- 5:20And the text included this quote from Pulitzer
- 5:24-winning journalist Ron Powers that really hit
- 5:26me. Oh, I know the one you mean. Yeah, he calls
- 5:28solitary confinement, sanctioned depravity. It's
- 5:32such a powerful phrase, because from a psychological
- 5:35standpoint, humans are built for social connection.
- 5:39We literally need it to keep our brains functioning
- 5:42normally. Exactly. Depriving someone of that
- 5:45is just a... profound moral failing. The stats
- 5:48in the text show that almost 40 % of homicides
- 5:51and half of all suicides in federal custody happen
- 5:54in solitary confinement. Half of all suicides.
- 5:56That's just staggering. Here's where it gets
- 5:59really interesting to me, though, from a psychology
- 6:01perspective. Using solitary confinement to fix
- 6:04a mental health behavioral issue. It's like locking
- 6:07a highly claustrophobic person in a dark closet
- 6:10to try and cure their panic attack. Yeah, that's
- 6:12exactly what it's like. It actively accelerates
- 6:14the psychosis. It doesn't treat anything. No,
- 6:16it makes it so much worse. But the question is,
- 6:19why do prisons resort to something so obviously
- 6:21harmful? Right. Like, if it doesn't work, why
- 6:23do they keep doing it? Well, the source material
- 6:25points directly to the root cause. systemic strain,
- 6:29and severe staffing shortages. Ah, right. They
- 6:31just don't have the people. Exactly. Three out
- 6:33of five people with mental illness receive absolutely
- 6:37no treatment in prison. None. That is just, I
- 6:40mean, three out of five. Yeah. And the text brings
- 6:42up this massive lawsuit in Illinois. The Assure
- 6:46Raw Showcase. Oh yeah, I remember reading about
- 6:47that. 12 ,000 inmates sued the state, right?
- 6:50Yes. Because suicidal individuals were being
- 6:53locked in solitary. It wasn't even for disciplinary
- 6:57reasons. They were locked up simply because the
- 7:00facility didn't have enough staff to let them
- 7:02out of their cell safely. Wait, really? So they
- 7:05were put in solitary just because there was no
- 7:06one to watch them in the general areas? Pretty
- 7:08much. The staffing reality is terrifying. Look
- 7:11at the Eastern Oregon Correctional Institution.
- 7:14They had a ratio of one officer per 80 adults
- 7:16in custody. One to 80? How is that even manageable?
- 7:20It's not. These officers are working mandated
- 7:24overtime. They're missing family events. They
- 7:26are chronically exhausted. And they are trying
- 7:29to manage a highly traumatized population, basically
- 7:33on their own. Which leads to that really striking
- 7:35quote from the Illinois DOC director. Right.
- 7:38They said, whether we want to be or not, we are
- 7:40the mental health system, and we have to start
- 7:43acting like it. OK, so pushback here. If the
- 7:47guards are completely burning out, and the inmates
- 7:49are actively suffering, isn't the system functionally
- 7:53failing its basic moral duty to both sides? I
- 7:56mean, yes, that's essentially what the sources
- 7:58are arguing. The system is structurally failing.
- 8:00So if it's failing that badly, what is the legal
- 8:03floor? Like, how does the law actually define
- 8:05society's moral obligation to the people it incarcerates?
- 8:08Well, that takes us to the foundation of our
- 8:10house model, the legal rights, and specifically,
- 8:13the Eighth Amendment. Right. The prohibition
- 8:15against cruel and unusual punishment. Exactly.
- 8:18And the defining case here, which the text highlights,
- 8:20is the 1976 Supreme Court ruling called Estelle
- 8:23versus Gamble. OK, break that down for us. What
- 8:25happened in Estelle? So the court ruled that
- 8:28failing to provide medical care can violate the
- 8:30Eighth Amendment, but only if it meets a very
- 8:34specific standard called deliberate indifference.
- 8:37Deliberate indifference. Yes. And then... Couple
- 8:40years later in 1978, a case called Bowering versus
- 8:44Godwin extended that exact same standard to cover
- 8:47mental health care. OK, so I want you all listening
- 8:50to picture the Constitution as the concrete floor
- 8:53of a building. It's the absolute bare minimum
- 8:56standard of living that you cannot legally drop
- 8:59beneath. Right, the absolute floor. But the issue
- 9:01is, it is incredibly hard to prove you actually
- 9:04hit it. I mean, think about the absurdity of
- 9:06this law. Yeah, it's a really high bar. So medical
- 9:08malpractice by a prison doctor isn't enough to
- 9:11violate the Constitution. No, malpractice or
- 9:13negligence isn't enough. You actually have to
- 9:15prove that the prison consciously, intentionally
- 9:18chose to ignore your suffering. That's almost
- 9:21impossible to prove in court. It really is an
- 9:23impossibly high bar. You have to prove your state
- 9:25of mind. But there's another side to this legal
- 9:28foundation, too. The right to refuse treatment.
- 9:31Oh, right. Because sometimes the prison wants
- 9:33to treat you, but you don't want it. Exactly.
- 9:35And the text points to the 14th Amendment and
- 9:38a 1990 case, Washington versus Harper. The court
- 9:41decided that inmates can be medicated against
- 9:43their will. but only if they are dangerous and
- 9:46the medication is in their best medical interest.
- 9:49Wow. I mean, on one hand, that is a total loss
- 9:51of bodily autonomy. Forcing medication into someone's
- 9:54body is incredibly invasive. It is. It's a huge
- 9:57ethical conflict. But on the other hand, you
- 9:59have to contrast that loss of autonomy with the
- 10:02dire need to prevent self -harm. Which is a massive
- 10:04issue. Huge. In 2019 alone, 30 % of all deaths
- 10:08in local jails were suicides. 30%. That just
- 10:11shows how desperate the situation is. So knowing
- 10:13that this legal floor is so incredibly low, the
- 10:16question becomes, how can behavioral health professionals
- 10:19actually build a system that heals people instead
- 10:22of just harming them? And that brings us to the
- 10:24blueprint for remodeling the house, the APIC
- 10:27framework. Yes. Sam, each has APIC framework,
- 10:31A -P -I -C. Right. It's a great mnemonic device.
- 10:33Let's walk through it. So the A stands for assess.
- 10:35Mm -hmm. Which means doing universal screening
- 10:38right at intake. Like utilizing things like the
- 10:41personality assessment inventory to figure out
- 10:43what's going on before it becomes a crisis. Exactly.
- 10:46Then the P is plan. You have to design the care.
- 10:50And since we already know there are massive staff
- 10:52shortages, the text notes how facilities are
- 10:55using telehealth to connect inmates with remote
- 10:58professionals. Which is super smart. OK, so assess.
- 11:01plan, then I is identify. Right. Identify and
- 11:05connect inmates to specific programs, both inside
- 11:08the jail and out in the community. And finally,
- 11:10C is coordinate. Yeah, coordinate the care, meaning
- 11:14you actually share the medical information so
- 11:16that when an inmate gets transferred, their care
- 11:19plan doesn't just vanish into thin air. Because
- 11:21that happens all the time, right? Oh, constantly.
- 11:23They get moved and they lose access to their
- 11:25heads for weeks. So AP is this great structural
- 11:28framework, but the sources also highlight this
- 11:31beautiful, almost spiritual alternative to the
- 11:33traditional punitive system. Oh, you mean the
- 11:35puhanoa in Hawaii? Yes. I loved reading about
- 11:38this. It's implemented at the Women's Community
- 11:40Correctional Center in Hawaii. It's such a radical
- 11:43shift in thinking. So a puhanoa is a native Hawaiian
- 11:47concept of a protected site for healing. And
- 11:50they apply this to the prison environment. They
- 11:52use cultural practices to provide actual trauma
- 11:56-informed care. Right, because they operate on
- 11:59the recognition that the vast majority of incarcerated
- 12:01women are victims of profound childhood and historical
- 12:05trauma. It's like, if you think of the traditional
- 12:08prison system, it operates like a quarantine
- 12:10zone. You know, just lock the sick people away
- 12:12so they don't bother anyone else. Yeah, out of
- 12:14sight, out of mind. Exactly. But the Kuhanua
- 12:17treats the prison as an incubator. It's a place
- 12:20completely focused on personal growth and restoring
- 12:22the community. Which is amazing. But as the source
- 12:25material makes clear, you really can't execute
- 12:28APEC or build a place of healing without addressing
- 12:31the elephant in the room. Ah, substance use.
- 12:33Yes. It is the missing piece of the puzzle. It's
- 12:36the most common co -occurring disorder. The numbers
- 12:38are pretty undeniable. Nearly 60 % of people
- 12:42in jails and prisons have a substance use disorder.
- 12:46Right. And just to give you some context, it's
- 12:48only about 10 % in the general public. 60 % versus
- 12:5010%. You literally cannot separate mental health
- 12:54from addiction in this population. You can't.
- 12:57Which is why the text introduces MAT, or medication
- 13:00-assisted treatment. Right. Things like MoUD
- 13:03and main use. Exactly. medications for opioid
- 13:06use disorder and alcohol use disorder. These
- 13:08are medical interventions that relieve withdrawal
- 13:10symptoms and cravings without producing any kind
- 13:13of euphoria. OK, so let me play devil's advocate
- 13:16for a second here, because this is a really common
- 13:18stigma. I can already hear people saying, wait,
- 13:20aren't you just substituting one drug for another?
- 13:23Why should my taxpayer dollars fund drugs for
- 13:25inmates? Yeah, that is the classic counter argument.
- 13:28But if we connect this to the bigger picture,
- 13:30that misconception totally falls apart. How so?
- 13:34Because MAT is a proven evidence -based medical
- 13:37intervention. It literally stops fatal overdoses.
- 13:41It stabilizes the brain chemistry. So they aren't
- 13:43just getting high? No, not at all. It just keeps
- 13:46them from going into severe withdrawal. And the
- 13:48data shows it significantly reduces future criminal
- 13:51activity and lowers probation revocations. It's
- 13:54basically an investment in public safety. That
- 13:56makes total sense. And the text mentions an innovative
- 13:59program in Oregon, right? The peer mentor program.
- 14:02Yes, it's brilliant. They use prison trained
- 14:05certified recovery mentors to treat their fellow
- 14:08inmates. That's incredible. So people who really
- 14:10understand the environment are the ones helping.
- 14:12Exactly. It builds trust in a way that an outside
- 14:15doctor sometimes can't. OK, so. To sort of review
- 14:19our journey today on this deep dive, America
- 14:21has essentially turned its jails and prisons
- 14:24into the largest psychiatric wards in the country.
- 14:27Without psychiatric resources. Right. And we've
- 14:29looked at the horrors of the basement solitary
- 14:31confinement. We've seen the systemic staffing
- 14:34shortages causing this. And we explored the incredibly
- 14:37low legal floor of the Eighth Amendment. Yeah.
- 14:40But we also saw that there is a way forward.
- 14:42Frameworks like AP and concepts like the Pew
- 14:45Hanawa show that healing is actually possible.
- 14:49Absolutely. And I think the real takeaway for
- 14:51you listening is this. Understanding this psychological
- 14:55landscape really empowers you to look past the
- 14:59stigma of a quote unquote criminal record. Yeah.
- 15:02To see the human being underneath. Exactly. To
- 15:04see the massive public health crisis operating
- 15:07right under the surface. Because true justice
- 15:10isn't just about punishment. It's about our moral
- 15:13duty of care. Well said. But as always, we want
- 15:17to leave you with a final lingering thought to
- 15:20ponder on your own. We've talked extensively
- 15:23today about the psychological devastation inflicted
- 15:26on the inmates, right? We have. But what happens
- 15:28to the psychology of the correctional officers?
- 15:32That's a dark but important question. Right.
- 15:34Because if a work environment is fundamentally
- 15:36built on sanctioned depravity and constant unending
- 15:39trauma, how does that chronic moral injury reshape
- 15:43the minds of the people holding the keys day
- 15:45after day? That's something that definitely needs
- 15:47more research. It really does. Something for
- 15:49you to think about until next time. Thanks for
- 15:51joining us on The Psychology Undergrad. Thanks
- 15:53for listening, everyone.