Latest / Crypto Coin Show / Layer 3 Modular Blockchain SKALE is the FUTURE? w/ Jack O’Holleran | Blockchain Interviews
Transcript
- 0:00I'm Ashon Addison from block West Capital for Investment Pitch Media, and today on
- 0:04the Cryptocorin Show we have Jack Ohaller and co founder and CEO of Scale Labs.
- 0:09Jack, Welcome to the show and thank you for taking the time today.
- 0:12Pleasure to be here. Thanks for having me likewise excited to dive into
- 0:16the world of blockchains and the intricacies of what makes a great blockchain. I
- 0:21know you and your team have been working on this for quite a while.
- 0:24Before we dive into Scale, I would love to start with a little bit
- 0:27on yourself, your background and blockchain and how that led to founding Scale.
- 0:32Yeah. So I started my career and enterprise software, started in mobile mobile
- 0:37security specifically, and there's a lot of deep cryptography integrated to the first product
- 0:43I was working on called good Technology. I'm actually coincidentally my co founder stand
- 0:48of Scale did our cryptography certification. We had the US government and CIA and
- 0:54US Senate and I think ninety of the Fortune one hundred using this product.
- 0:58So I learned a bit about cryptography and security. But this was, you
- 1:03know, before even bitcoin launched, and then I did. I started a
- 1:06machine learning company AI company that was a leading global, leading platform in the
- 1:11life science industry on commercial execution side of the life science AI world. And
- 1:17that was I like to say that was AI when AI was not intelligent yet
- 1:22it was dumb AI. And now we have smart AI and you know that
- 1:26that got me on a path to understand, you know, about building businesses,
- 1:30building communities, building technology. And I was looking to start my next
- 1:34company in twenty seventeen and it was a no brainer to do it around Ethereum,
- 1:38and that's really that was my path. People thought it was a bit
- 1:41crazy. They're like, you're leaving enterprise software to go work in crypto.
- 1:45Your nuts? And I think we all we all, well not all,
- 1:49I think, uh, you know, these things go in waves. But
- 1:51I think the people listening here today understand that there's real meat on the bone
- 1:55here. We're creating real applications. We're going to change the world and with
- 1:59programmable money and you know, business structures. So yeah, that was my
- 2:04path. Amazing. That's a great a breadth of experience being in cryptography before
- 2:09crypto and being an AI before most people, and now you were working on
- 2:15scale, which I know is very innovative as well. And I would love
- 2:19to dive into the Scale network. What makes it different, what you and
- 2:23your team have built there? In sort of a high level overview. Yeah,
- 2:27well, let me I'll take a step back before I get into the
- 2:29nuts and bolts of Scale and and just say I was actually trying to build
- 2:32decentralized applications in twenty seventeen, and so was Stan cloud co my co founder.
- 2:38One of the things we realized is that the infrastructure was not there at
- 2:42all. And this was before people use the word layer two, before they
- 2:45used you know, other you know, modular scaling and ZK proofs and layer
- 2:50three. All these terms didn't exist, and so we just thought of Scale
- 2:53as middleware. It was another blockchain that you build on Ethereum you can connect
- 2:57to Scale for fast execution. And and you know, for us, we
- 3:01were building always from this lens that we had to support you know, millions
- 3:06or hundreds of millions of users. And just if you're building an enterprise software
- 3:09product or uh, you know, consumer grade Web two product, you need
- 3:14to think about scaling user experience and performance with users. And back then there
- 3:20were only around ten thousand daily active users using Ethereum and Defy and all the
- 3:24applications that were there. It's a very small, small quantity of people.
- 3:30And then and then I say, I give that background because there's just a
- 3:34tremendous amount of group think and how we scale Ethereum, and unfortunately it keeps
- 3:38there's this dogmatic, almost religious perspective that guides guides us down a path that
- 3:45still does not cater well to to normal end users. You still have to
- 3:49know how to use you know, be pretty technical, use meta mask and
- 3:53your average DeFi user, yeah, no problem. But your average Web three
- 3:57user, your average gamer, it's just not And so we built Scale.
- 4:01We started this at the end of twenty seventeen. It took a long time
- 4:04to build. The main net launched October twenty twenty, and we built it
- 4:08to make Ethereum faster. We now have just crossed one hundred million transactions on
- 4:15chain in the network in the last year, and we've saved over about one
- 4:18point five billion dollars in gas fees in the last year. And that's really
- 4:24because the V two upgrade last June of twenty twenty two enabled Scale to support
- 4:30normal user workflows and really bring this gas free, fee free experience to end
- 4:38users. And you know, so we haven't always followed the idea the same
- 4:43path as everybody else building an ethereum. And but it's interesting now the roads
- 4:46are coalescing and a lot of our competitors strategies are folding into the scale strategy.
- 4:51Uh huh. That's really interesting background there, especially understanding you know,
- 4:58the scalability issues of ethereum. I think scale perfect name for a solution for
- 5:02that. But as you mentioned, they're about so the adopting of decentralized applications.
- 5:08It's easy for people that are deep in it and they understand all the
- 5:13technical part. But I feel like, you know, to actually scale not
- 5:16just in transactions, but scale the amount of users to hundreds of thousands to
- 5:21millions, it's going to require lowering the technical barriers to entry to make it
- 5:27easier for people to start getting into Web three. What do you think about
- 5:30that? Yeah, And you know, I'll first I'll say the challenge.
- 5:34The challenge with that is the easier Web three is to use, the harder
- 5:40it is to be you know, secure at the same time, So security,
- 5:45decentralization and kind of ease of use are all you know, just opposed
- 5:49there. You know, each one is diametrically opposed to the other and so
- 5:54that's what makes it hard. And so so for us, we were able
- 5:59to build a dynamic that shifts a lot of the you know, more power
- 6:03and more fees to developers who are running applications. Now, they still you
- 6:11can't impact somebody's money and base level securities there, but they can create a
- 6:16dynamic with this gas free experience to let people trigger on chain transactions in a
- 6:24seamless, behind the scenes way, and we call it an invisible Web three
- 6:28experience. So that is the key. But you can't do that unless you
- 6:30have a way to in a cost effective manner obfu skate gas fees away from
- 6:35the end user, abstract them from the end user. Great point. And
- 6:41now talking about the scalability, you mentioned that balance of having the security and
- 6:48also having functionality. How exactly does scale without getting too technical, you know,
- 6:55how exactly can you scale without sacrificing those other parts of the trilem?
- 7:00Yeah, well, so it all comes down to capacity and economics. Okay,
- 7:04so most blockchains are one finite database. If you add more servers,
- 7:11if you add more nodes, it doesn't add more capacity, You're just adding
- 7:14more security. Okay, blockchains are really you know, it's one database that
- 7:18can satisfy a certain amount of transactions. Now, each of these actors has
- 7:25to play a role and saying yes, this, you know this block is
- 7:28accurate, let's move to the next one. But adding more doesn't add more
- 7:31capacity, and so that's the problem with all blockchains. Now, this new
- 7:35layer three model or modul or multi chain model or multi chain network model,
- 7:41which I say new because it's getting so much you know, attention, and
- 7:45also you hear the word shared security and pulled security. These are all things
- 7:48Scales been doing for a very long time. So instead of having one blockchain
- 7:53with finite capacity, there are many block chains, and actually there's could be
- 7:57an infinite number of blockchains. The amount of chains can scale linearly in accordance
- 8:03to how many nodes are in the network. Okay, now there's two other
- 8:07core pieces that are important to make that work. One, you don't want
- 8:11to fragment your security. If you just have a bunch of completely separate blockchains,
- 8:16well you're not carrying and sharing any security across these different chains. Okay,
- 8:22so Scale has a way to have one unified validator set operating underneath all
- 8:28of these different chains so that they can also pull security with each other.
- 8:31They get this HERD dynamic, you know, HERD protection dynamic by all being
- 8:37there together. Number Two, the economics are important because you have to have
- 8:41an economic structure that will incentivize validators to set up more nodes and therefore create
- 8:46more chains. And that's why, you know, basically why I'm saying,
- 8:50you know, the economics are so critical to having actually limitless capacity, Otherwise
- 8:56you're going to run into bottlenecks with chains, and the same problem you experience
- 9:01with one chain, you can experience with ten when you get to that point.
- 9:05Okay, so does that make sense? Yeah, a little bit for
- 9:07sure. And one thing that I got out of that, which I think
- 9:11is important more people will begin to understand is the layer three aspect of it.
- 9:16And I'm talking about modularity. And I've seen across the twittersphere and across
- 9:22the crypto chasm in the past months starting to talk about mod modular blockchains versus
- 9:28monolithic blockchains. I feel like people overall understand layer two. Now as he's
- 9:35scaling networks. Layer three, not so many people are starting to understand.
- 9:39We're starting to add up with the layers. Is that layer three this modularity
- 9:43of blockchains specifically or is it more than that? Yeah, it is,
- 9:48and it isn't. I'll try. I'm going to try to take another step
- 9:52back and make this accessible to everybody. So the goal with layer three is
- 9:56to have an un limitless amount of blockchains to just increase supply while not fragmenting
- 10:05security. You still want to tie back your security, now there's different ways
- 10:09of doing that. Scale also is built on Ethereum, so a lot of
- 10:13the network security is hooked into a theory. Layer three models are you know,
- 10:20without getting two technical one. They incorporate lots of app chains or individual
- 10:26or specific multi chains like Scale has. Scale already has twenty chains in the
- 10:30network. But what layer threees can do. They also can plug in zero
- 10:33knowledge proofs or roll up techniques to connect the security of these smaller chains back
- 10:39to a bigger set and that could be back to ethereum, it could be
- 10:43back to a more centralized roll up that then rolls back to ethereum. And
- 10:48so what happens is people are getting experimental with layer three and layer four just
- 10:52because they're saying, well, if we can get more chains without splitting up
- 10:58our security. That's good, and that's the general premise of how scale functions
- 11:01scale. By the way, is launching a zero knowledge proof so it can
- 11:05have a what I would say a Ethereum pure layer three method because a lot
- 11:13of Ethereum maximalists don't want any consensus being finalized on another blockchain, whereas I
- 11:18feel like from a ux perspective, and for lots of use cases, for
- 11:22example within gaming, there's just tremendous opportunities for you know, to have fast
- 11:28finality and gas retransactions in app chain models. So again I'm getting in the
- 11:33weeds, but the point is everyone's trying to figure out how to have their
- 11:35cake and eat it too, have more supply without sacrificing security. Definitely,
- 11:41And you mentioned they're about app chains. I've been over a few discussions in
- 11:46the past week about app chains, and one of the main benefits from what
- 11:50I understand is the sort of as you're just talking about, having many block
- 11:54chains and almost a standalone app so that it's not like as you would see
- 12:00at ARC twenty token, it's sort of stuck with Ethereum. If anything happened
- 12:03to Ethereum that would it could take down the app is that one of the
- 12:09main benefits or maybe you can dive into more of the of the benefits of
- 12:13an app chain versus an app in that it's its own blockchain so it can't
- 12:18get hurt by the overlying ecosystem or what else is actually good about it.
- 12:22Yeah, so a big piece there's this noisy neighbor problem. So in blockchain.
- 12:28So let's say you've you know, everyone's happily using this chain and all
- 12:31of a sudden, this hugely you know, high volume transaction application comes in.
- 12:37It just starts chewing up all the bandwidth, right, And this happens
- 12:41a lot, and then people like, let's shut this thing down, and
- 12:43it's this noisy neighbor disrupts everybody else. So an app chain enables really noisy
- 12:50neighbors to you know, live in their own walled garden where they can have
- 12:54pay for as many transactions as they want. Now, the issue with that
- 12:58is if fragments liquidity, it creates ux issues for people to get assets over
- 13:01to those chains. And that's one of the reasons why Scale has created app
- 13:05hubs and I'm gonna be tweeting a lot about this in their future because I
- 13:09think we've we've been the first to market with a multi chain, a true
- 13:15multi chain pooled security environment. What we've found is that creates a lot of
- 13:20usability issues where if you just have one chain and you just show up without
- 13:24one chain and you put you know, everything's are, your money is there,
- 13:26I can go use that game that defy app. You know, there's
- 13:30no UX issue. You just plug your wallet in and for people who aren't
- 13:33familiar with this in it if you're in, if your money's in one chain
- 13:37and then you try to go to another chain, you can still use the
- 13:41same etherorum address, but you need to somehow bridge those assets. Over Scale
- 13:45actually has a zero transaction free UX product that lets you move assets instantly for
- 13:52free between all scale chains, and you know, even that can add some
- 13:56issues. So we have app pubs where lots of you know, similar products
- 14:00can use similar type chains, like there's a d FI hub, there's a
- 14:03gaminghib et cetera. Okay, that's great to know, and I think looking
- 14:09back through the start of gaming in blockchain, we saw one of the examples
- 14:15was Axie Infinity. There were so many transactions going on that all of a
- 14:18sudden, anybody else who was using ethereum. They were paying high gas fees
- 14:22because of this one app that they're not even using. And this is like,
- 14:24that's like the noisy neighbor. And I feel like as we get to
- 14:28more mainstream adoption of gaming with blockchain integrated, this is going to happen again.
- 14:33Because the gaming industry is so big, there's millions of players on specific
- 14:37games. One game comes in, if it's not on layer three, it's
- 14:41going to disrupt the home network and everyone's going to be paying more just because
- 14:45of these new people that come in. Is that right? And that's exactly
- 14:48why we built Scale the way we built Scale, and why the community behind
- 14:52Scale and you know, hey, we're just the core team getting things started.
- 14:56And you know there's you know, hundreds of people every day building on
- 15:00Scale across the gaming ecosystem and Web three ecosystem and you know, different open
- 15:05source contributors. And I say this because people realize, especially in gaming,
- 15:11and that's why Scale has If you go to dap Radar, we're typically in
- 15:15the top five every single day in terms of transaction volume. It's because we
- 15:18have a lot of games and games need a lot of transactions, so and
- 15:24guess what, they don't want to be in another chain where they're driving up
- 15:26their own price or other people's price. And so that's why we have a
- 15:30gas free model on scale. That's great to hear about the gaming and from
- 15:35what I understand, games are still very early on. There's only very few
- 15:39games that have millions of players that are going to drive new people into web
- 15:43three. I'm curious on your insights into you know, Web three gaming and
- 15:48where we're at right now as opposed to where we're going to be in the
- 15:50coming years. Yeah, and you know the thing about gaming gaming, I
- 15:54don't I'm forgetting the exact number. So instead of guessing trying to from I'm
- 16:00just gonna tell you to look at thee able to look it up. Gaming
- 16:03revenue dwarfs the rest of the entertainment industry, like it, absolutely dwarfs.
- 16:08It's like fifty x or something of movies for example, right, look how
- 16:14much actors get paid. And yeah, you know they're on strike right now,
- 16:18but you know, look how much revenue these businesses do. But gaming
- 16:21is just massive. But so gaming is a big, big category and there's
- 16:25lots of subcategories in gaming. Web three gaming specifically, I think will create
- 16:30its own niche in gaming. But the real growth in gaming will also be
- 16:34when there's this integration behind the scenes of Web three properties to traditional gaming,
- 16:42because traditional games don't need to change their culture, they don't need to change
- 16:47uh, you know, how they interact, but they can you know,
- 16:51the youth players can get a ton of value out of having seamless secondary marketplaces
- 16:55and owning their own assets with NFTs, having digital currencies that have transparent,
- 17:00open, you know, permanent properties. So these game companies can't just keep
- 17:06minting things and you know, kind of making revenue at their whim and kind
- 17:10of hurting users, which why is why Vitalli started Ethereum in the first place.
- 17:12If you go read about his World of Warcraft story. Definitely, and
- 17:18you know, gamers they when you're doing all these transactions or getting items,
- 17:25and you know, if everything's tokenized, all of that's going to be on
- 17:27the blockchain, but they don't necessarily want to see that. You know,
- 17:30hopefully it's all in the back end and they don't really have to worry about,
- 17:33you know, watching transaction confirming it should be instantaneous. For the most
- 17:37part, I was looking at one of the recent studies that I saw Scale
- 17:41was involved in. It said it was one of the fastest blockchains for confirming
- 17:47transactions. Maybe you can touch on that. Yeah, yeah, So Dartmouth
- 17:49Blockchain actually did a research study. They worked directly with core teams at Salona
- 17:56Avalanche, Polygone Scale and they literally validated their white paper technique to test time
- 18:03to finality, which is how much time does it take from when a user
- 18:06hits a button and then to get to finality on chain and Scale has instant
- 18:11finality, but there's still this kind of you know, networking piece and it
- 18:15was like one in some odd seconds. Scale skill is the fastest in time
- 18:19to finality and had the highest throughput, higher than Salana in real world throughput.
- 18:25So and a lot of these projects claim they have thousands per second and
- 18:29go look at the study. One of them claims thousands on their website and
- 18:32in reality it's only six when they're using a theory virtual machine. And and
- 18:37it's part Scale actually created a C plus plus etherorium. It didn't just fork
- 18:41yet like go etherium, which almost all of these ethereum killers, all their
- 18:45power and throughput just gets wasted because there's still a bottleneck and gath of how
- 18:52fast you can operate and whereas we you know, or the scale open source
- 18:56community created its own h C plus plus a theory which is super fast and
- 19:02it is shaken sensus. And does that help with being able to develop easily
- 19:06on the network. Yeah, So if you go play untitled platformer or zero
- 19:12X Battleground which is like just like this, you know Battle Royale game that's
- 19:17triple A style. If you go play one of these games, you grab
- 19:22a you know in zero spattle grab you grab a gun. Well, guess
- 19:25what you have that NFT you own that. Now you have the special weapon,
- 19:29the special tool, you do something. All these things are getting registered
- 19:32on the blockchain. The user doesn't have to hit met a mask and accept
- 19:36and do these things in game. And so these things are really you know,
- 19:41we thought of them in twenty eighteen as a pipe dream to be able
- 19:45to do and you actually you can do them now. So gaming is just
- 19:48I think cutting the frontier for what we're going to see in all these other
- 19:52Web three enabled Internet products. And you know, gaming is a great i'd
- 19:56say leader and pioneer and a lot of new tech and we're you know,
- 20:00same we'll be true with botching amazing to hear, and we don't have a
- 20:04lot of time left, but I want to touch on one more thing before
- 20:07we touch on the roadmap and what's next for you guys. You mentioned earlier
- 20:11about the ZK and zero knowledge proofs part of Scale. I'm curious on why
- 20:17is that important for maybe for the gamers or for people that are using the
- 20:21network, and you know, it doesn't really matter. Yeah, you know
- 20:26what, So if you think about zero knowledge proofs, it's added security.
- 20:30And so for Scale, Let's say I'm playing a game and I'm running around,
- 20:34I'm picking up things, I'm shooting things, I'm grabbing coins. You
- 20:38don't need to pay extra for zero knowledge proof to make, you know,
- 20:41validate that that happen. The Scale consensus is way more has more than enough
- 20:47security for that, and I believe to a whole world of dfive. But
- 20:51for people that say, hey, well I want an extra level of security
- 20:53because all of a sudden I got this NFT and it's worth ten thousand or
- 20:56a million bucks, what you can do is you can enter as zero knowledge
- 21:00proof into Scale. And for those high value use cases which the user is
- 21:04not going to see any of this. The user just you know, picks
- 21:07up buys this valuable thing. Well guess what that gets imprinted onto another blockchain
- 21:12back to the Etherium mainnet through a zero knowledge proof and it validates it and
- 21:17then that could never be taken without taking the overriding the security of the Etherium
- 21:21mainenet. And so what Scale Levitation protocol does is it enables zero knowledge proofs
- 21:26and scale consensus to operate in harmony. And we're actually going to be partnering
- 21:32with a zero knowledge proof builders as opposed to building our own our scales,
- 21:36own ZK tech. So scales, a network, and a community will be
- 21:40really this having this rapper that lets ZK techniques interact. And but it's all
- 21:45about use cases. It's all about you know, build developers building for the
- 21:51right ux in terms of costs, security, and experience. Very cool.
- 21:56Thank you for explaining that, Jack, And before we go, I'd love
- 21:59to know what the next steps and the growth and what do you think is
- 22:03going to happen in the industry and how is scale getting ready to grow for
- 22:07what's going to happen moving into twenty twenty four. Anything on the roadmap that's
- 22:10big that's coming up. Yeah, I mean, well so one launching levitation,
- 22:15the zero knowledge proof is going to be huge. There's also next government
- 22:21skills decentralize on Chaine. Governance is live. There's gonna be a lot of
- 22:23cool things happening with chain economics that we're going to see push forward. I'm
- 22:27excited to see, you know, community members and developers push forward these new
- 22:33initiatives. But in general, I think the main thing Scale needs to do
- 22:37well over the next year is just keep executing on the plan because the tech
- 22:42is there that other people are trying to build and enable through Layer three and
- 22:48you know, and that's I think there's a first mover advantage happening right now.
- 22:52And it's all happening behind the scenes, because you know, you go
- 22:55to the headlines, you're reading about the price of bitcoin and you know,
- 23:00chat, GPT and other things. But behind the scenes, there's just so
- 23:03much happening. And you know, that's really I think, you know my
- 23:07feeling. And when I talk to the core team and talk to people in
- 23:08the community and say hey, let's do the blocking and tackling, let's do
- 23:11the basics, Well, we have what other people are trying to build,
- 23:15let's just go support developers and you know, and help ethereum developers be successful
- 23:19and then you know, let the other stuff pan out that. Obviously you
- 23:22have to keep building for the future, but you also have to focus on
- 23:26what you have. Definitely good approach. I love it and I'm going to
- 23:30be following along for the updates and levitation protocol. Sounds like an amazing name.
- 23:34I'm gonna dive into the details of that as well. For the viewers
- 23:38that want to learn more about the network and also the games on it,
- 23:41or developers that want to try it out, what is the best way for
- 23:45them to learn more? Yeah, so Scale dot space Scale if you're looking
- 23:48at my hat there, Scale with a K is the website will guide you
- 23:53all the links you can go to at Scale network, on Twitter and at
- 23:59Jack o'haller and on Twitter you'll see just Twitter is one of the best places,
- 24:03as well as discord Scale dot chat will take you there. On Telegram,
- 24:07there's a Scale official Telegram channel. So kind of whatever your where you
- 24:12like to consume information, there's probably you can get on the newsletter. You
- 24:17know, whoever you are, you can you can keep up pretty easy.
- 24:21Amazing. Thank you so much Jack for all the information. I will leave
- 24:23all those links in the description box below as well to make it easy for
- 24:26the viewers. All the best with everything moving forward in gaming and with scale
- 24:30network and let's follow up in the near future. Thanks Ashon.