Latest / Kentucky Tonight / Discussing the State Budget
Transcript
- 0:08Kentucky. Tonight I'm Renee
- 0:09Shaw and we thank you so much
- 0:11for joining us this evening.
- 0:13It's always the big ticket item
- 0:14during the even year 60 day
- 0:16session. And that's passing a
- 0:18two year budget. The Kentucky
- 0:20Senate voted for a plan last
- 0:21week that spends $34 million
- 0:23more than the House plan passed
- 0:25last month. So there are some
- 0:27differences. But both budgets
- 0:28give state workers 2% raises.
- 0:31Both would increase per pupil
- 0:32funding for education while
- 0:34still spending less than.
- 0:35Governor Andy Beshear had
- 0:37requested. A conference
- 0:38committee is now at work
- 0:39ironing out the differences the
- 0:40two budgets have. And tonight
- 0:42we'll talk about those
- 0:44differences and what kind of
- 0:45compromises are likely to
- 0:47emerge, what will end up in the
- 0:48budget and what's likely to be
- 0:50missing. We'll discuss all this.
- 0:52We have five guests in our
- 0:53Lexington studio. State Senator
- 0:55Amanda Mays Bledsoe, a
- 0:57Lexington Republican and vice
- 0:58chair of the Senate
- 1:00Appropriations and Revenue
- 1:01Committee. State Senator
- 1:02Reginald Thomas, a Lexington
- 1:04Democrat and Senate Minority
- 1:06caucus chair Kate Shanks senior
- 1:08vice president of public
- 1:09affairs for the Kentucky
- 1:11Chamber of Commerce. Jason
- 1:13Bailey, executive director of
- 1:14the Kentucky Center for
- 1:15Economic Policy and Andrew
- 1:18McNeill president and senior
- 1:19policy fellow at the Kentucky
- 1:21Forum for rights, Economics and
- 1:23Education, or Kentucky free and
- 1:26deputy state budget and policy
- 1:28Director and Governor Matt
- 1:29Bevin. Administration a few
- 1:30years ago. And in our
- 1:31Louisville studio, we have
- 1:33state Representative Tina
- 1:35Bojanowski, a Louisville
- 1:36Democrat and member of the
- 1:37House Appropriations and
- 1:39Revenue Committee. Certainly,
- 1:40we want to hear from you
- 1:41tonight. You can send your
- 1:42questions and comments by X,
- 1:44formerly known as Twitter, at
- 1:46Pub Affairs KET. You can send
- 1:47an email to KY Tonight at KET
- 1:49dot o r g, or use the web form
- 1:52at KET dot Johnny Nash KY
- 1:54tonight. Or you can simply give
- 1:56us a call at one (800) 494-7605.
- 2:00Welcome to all of our guests
- 2:02here in Lexington and in
- 2:03Louisville. We appreciate your
- 2:04time. So let's discuss first
- 2:06the proposed spending, and then
- 2:07we'll talk about what she
- 2:08proposed to save and maybe what
- 2:10you propose to give away
- 2:12separately. So, Senator Mays
- 2:13Bledsoe, I want to start with
- 2:15you, Senator. Senate Budget
- 2:16Chairman Chris McDaniel had
- 2:18called the Senate version of
- 2:20the budget, quote, it reflects
- 2:21a disciplined approach. I'm
- 2:23sure that you agree with that.
- 2:25What are the highlights of the
- 2:27Senate version of the budget
- 2:28that you would like to bring to
- 2:30attention that you did
- 2:31differently from the House?
- 2:32>> We largely kept many of the
- 2:33same things. I think we strive
- 2:35to be very structurally
- 2:36balanced, using one time money
- 2:38for one time expenses and not
- 2:39to do one time for reoccurring.
- 2:42We were very mindful to keep a
- 2:43healthy reserve in the Budget
- 2:44reserve trust fund. We also
- 2:46worked to reduce liabilities
- 2:47like pension and make sure
- 2:49we're investing in some of our
- 2:50health care and other issues.
- 2:51But most importantly, we took a
- 2:53very measured approach to
- 2:54government services and making
- 2:55sure providing them at a stable
- 2:57and consistent level.
- 2:57>> Yeah. So I also want to ask
- 2:59you, Senator Thomas, what are
- 3:01you pleased with in the Senate
- 3:02budget plan, or do you view
- 3:04anything as missed
- 3:06opportunities at this juncture?
- 3:07And this is still an early
- 3:08negotiating juncture. Correct.
- 3:10>> Well, we're certainly
- 3:12pleased with the fact that they
- 3:13did give state employees a
- 3:15raise. We had proposed the
- 3:17governor had proposed something
- 3:18in the area of 3 to 4%. They
- 3:21gave 2%. But that's still a
- 3:22step in the right direction.
- 3:24And it does continue our
- 3:28movement forward to fully fund
- 3:30our pensions. Get the Kentucky
- 3:33Teachers Retirement System
- 3:33fully funded by 2040. I think
- 3:35we can make that even earlier
- 3:37now, given some changes in the
- 3:38budget and then Chris and
- 3:41Kentucky Employees Retirement
- 3:43System funded by 2044. So we're
- 3:45making good progress there.
- 3:47>> So you're saying where the
- 3:48unfunded liability now that it
- 3:49would be fully funded by 2040.
- 3:51>> 20 teachers by 2040, Chris
- 3:53by 2044, maybe even 2042. So
- 3:57that's good. I do think Renee,
- 3:59and I have to say this because
- 4:01I strongly agree with Governor
- 4:02Beshear that that not
- 4:04addressing universal pre-K is a
- 4:06missed opportunity. That's only
- 4:07a $220 million expenditure.
- 4:11They're already 78 school
- 4:13superintendents, Renee 78. That
- 4:15said, they can start it to
- 4:16tomorrow and not even address
- 4:19that. It's a missed opportunity,
- 4:21particularly when over half the
- 4:22states now in this country,
- 4:24Renee, five of the seven who
- 4:25are neighbors have some form of
- 4:28universal pre-K. It's a missed
- 4:29opportunity.
- 4:30>> So I want to go to
- 4:31Representative Tina Bojanowski,
- 4:32who's in KET Louisville studio,
- 4:33to ask you about the House
- 4:34version of the budget. And as a
- 4:36public school educator in
- 4:38Jefferson County public schools,
- 4:39were you happy with what the
- 4:41House had appropriated for K
- 4:42through 12 education?
- 4:48>> So the SEEK number for the
- 4:51House is a little bit higher
- 4:52than what the Senate had. So I
- 4:54do prefer that. But if we look
- 4:57at SEEK, even since 2018, SEEK
- 5:00was $4,000 in 2018. And if you
- 5:03account for inflation in
- 5:05today's dollars, it's 5095. So
- 5:08the highest Senate year is 4774.
- 5:12And that's still where we're
- 5:15funding education at a lower
- 5:17level if you count for
- 5:19inflation. And then secondly, I
- 5:21think that both the Senate and
- 5:23the House have not fully funded
- 5:28transportation. So
- 5:29transportation is funded at
- 5:34$398 million. And we actually
- 5:35need another $93 million to
- 5:38fully fund transportation costs
- 5:41across the state. And then one
- 5:43more thing personally. So we
- 5:44have since 2010 paid into
- 5:47what's called the shared
- 5:49responsibility plan, where
- 5:513.75% of my paycheck every
- 5:53month, every every two weeks
- 5:56goes towards retired employees,
- 5:59health insurance. And our
- 6:01understanding in that agreement
- 6:02is that once that fund is fully
- 6:05funded, that we wouldn't have
- 6:06to pay that. And there is
- 6:08language in both bills, the
- 6:09House and the Senate, that says
- 6:11that amount won't change. So
- 6:13even if shared responsibility
- 6:15is fully funded, we as teachers
- 6:18will still be paying.
- 6:19>> Yeah. Any comment on that?
- 6:22Senator Thomas?
- 6:23>> Well, I will say this, Renee.
- 6:26What what that will do is get
- 6:29us faster to fully funding our
- 6:31pension, which is really
- 6:32important for teachers. You
- 6:35know, I understand his concern.
- 6:39You know, she has a she has a
- 6:41meritorious position, but I
- 6:43suspect with that additional
- 6:45money that's going to go now,
- 6:46all of it, all of it into the
- 6:48teachers retirement system that
- 6:50we'll probably see PDs
- 6:52retirement funded, fully funded
- 6:53by 2040, maybe 2038. Renee when
- 6:56you think about it, that's just
- 6:57ten years from now. We could be
- 6:59that fund could be fully funded
- 7:01ten years from now, 10 to 12
- 7:03years from now. That's a great
- 7:04thing given where we was ten
- 7:06years ago when we were talking
- 7:07about a 20% rate of fully
- 7:10funded, we didn't even know
- 7:11whether we meet our obligations
- 7:12at that point in time. We've
- 7:14come a long way, and we just
- 7:16got a few more years left to go
- 7:18to get to that fully funded
- 7:20point.
- 7:20>> Jason Bailey, I want to ask
- 7:22you, you said that the Senate
- 7:23budget makes modest
- 7:24improvements, but it doesn't go
- 7:25far enough. And you have even
- 7:27said that K through 12
- 7:28education remains in the Senate
- 7:29version woefully underfunded.
- 7:30Explain more.
- 7:31>> Well, for about 20 years now,
- 7:34we have not, as a state, kept
- 7:36up funding for K-12 education
- 7:39with the cost of providing that
- 7:41education. And we're losing
- 7:42ground in both versions of the
- 7:44budget. The State SEEK
- 7:47contribution that
- 7:48Representative Bujnowski
- 7:49mentioned, it would be 25% less
- 7:51than it was 20 years ago. So
- 7:54that's a problem for the
- 7:56quality of education we're able
- 7:57to provide for our ability to
- 7:59attract and retain qualified
- 8:01teachers to the to the to the
- 8:03positions. And it's, you know,
- 8:05even in the case of
- 8:06transportation that
- 8:08Representative Borkowski also
- 8:08mentioned, I mean, that's the
- 8:10legislature's own law that was
- 8:12created to create a formula to
- 8:14fund education in this budget.
- 8:16It would not be funded. And
- 8:17that would be 24 consecutive
- 8:19years of just not following
- 8:21their own law and suspending
- 8:23the law. So, you know, we've
- 8:25got billions in the budget
- 8:26reserve trust fund. We've we've
- 8:29passed tax cuts that cost now
- 8:31billions of dollars a year. It
- 8:32seems like education has is
- 8:34among the things that has not
- 8:36been prioritized. Even when
- 8:37more resources have been
- 8:39available these last few.
- 8:40>> Andrew McNeill do you feel
- 8:41that education. K through 12
- 8:42education in Kentucky has not
- 8:43been prioritized? Or do you
- 8:45believe enough money or more
- 8:46than enough money is going
- 8:47toward the public education
- 8:49system?
- 8:49>> Yeah. Thanks, Renee, for
- 8:50having us on tonight and for
- 8:52having a great group and panel
- 8:54with us. This question of
- 8:57adequacy. And this is going to
- 8:59be a little bit different
- 9:00direction than perhaps this
- 9:02conversation normally goes.
- 9:04This question of the amount of
- 9:06funding we need to begin
- 9:08changing it to look at what
- 9:10exactly funding is directed
- 9:12towards. There is a body of
- 9:15research coming out of Stanford
- 9:19University, national economists
- 9:22that look at this question that
- 9:23once you reach a certain level
- 9:26of funding, once you reach a
- 9:27certain level of funding. So
- 9:28I'm not going to sit here and
- 9:30try to suggest that funding
- 9:31doesn't matter for education,
- 9:34that additional funding in and
- 9:36of itself does not correlate
- 9:39with higher performance by
- 9:41students. What the money is
- 9:44directed towards and the
- 9:46strategies that they fund is
- 9:48what is far more important. So
- 9:50this question of, you know, $10
- 9:54here, $15 there, $20, even a
- 9:56couple of hundred dollars here
- 9:58on what the SEEK per pupil
- 10:00student appropriation is
- 10:02missing. The fundamental
- 10:04question. The question is, what
- 10:07exactly are those dollars going
- 10:08to do to improve student
- 10:10performance in the classroom?
- 10:11I'm going to make one quick
- 10:13point about this, because it's
- 10:14something that you've probably
- 10:15talked about on the show a
- 10:16number of times. Reading
- 10:18proficiency, you can throw
- 10:20millions of dollars, tens of
- 10:22millions of dollars at reading
- 10:24strategies that if it's not
- 10:26phonics, then you're not going
- 10:28to see the improvements that
- 10:30you could if you were funding
- 10:32the right strategy. And so I
- 10:34know that this is a traditional
- 10:36question that comes up adequacy
- 10:39of funding, amount of funding,
- 10:41I would suggest to the General
- 10:43Assembly and to the public out
- 10:44there where the money is going,
- 10:46is the question that we need to
- 10:48start asking going forward into
- 10:50the next biennium.
- 10:51>> So Kate Shanks, the Kentucky
- 10:52Chamber has always been very
- 10:54interested in making sure that
- 10:55there's a well trained, well
- 10:57educated workforce in order to
- 10:58recruit more businesses and
- 10:59have more economic development
- 11:01opportunities. How does the
- 11:02chamber view education funding
- 11:04in the K through 12 space and
- 11:06maybe even post-secondary
- 11:07education? Because we know
- 11:08there are differences there
- 11:09between the House and Senate
- 11:10versions.
- 11:10>> That's right, Renee. And so
- 11:12we look at it holistically. And
- 11:13absolutely, that's the K
- 11:14through 12 piece and the
- 11:15conversation around SEEK
- 11:16funding and other aspects. I'm
- 11:17glad that we brought up
- 11:19pensions already. This is
- 11:20something, you know, the
- 11:21Kentucky Chamber was very
- 11:22involved in when we did pension
- 11:23reform a few years ago, the
- 11:25leaky bucket, the leaky bucket,
- 11:26that is the report that we did,
- 11:28we did ten years ago, 15 years
- 11:30ago. It's been a repeating
- 11:31report that we put out there.
- 11:33And it's a very important topic.
- 11:35And I think when you think
- 11:36about the amount of money that
- 11:38has to go in to shoring up the
- 11:40pension system, that's a
- 11:41substantial amount of money
- 11:42that could be going towards all
- 11:43sorts of different needs that
- 11:45we have in the Commonwealth.
- 11:46And so I'm pleased to hear the
- 11:48Senator talking about when we
- 11:49might pay down that debt and
- 11:51get back on track. So I think
- 11:52that's a very important
- 11:55conversation. But regarding
- 11:56education, we do look at it
- 11:58holistically. And so we've seen
- 11:59some funding provided, I think,
- 12:00for higher ed, additional
- 12:02funding on performance based
- 12:03funding. We look at things like
- 12:04the work study scholarship
- 12:05program, where we continue to
- 12:07prioritize, prioritize that,
- 12:08provide funding for that. Those
- 12:10are scholarships for
- 12:11individuals who want to go work
- 12:13in some of those most in demand
- 12:15industries in Kentucky. And so
- 12:18we also look at, you know, to
- 12:21Andrew's point, accountability.
- 12:23And I think you're seeing the
- 12:24legislature take that up in a
- 12:26variety of bills. And I do want
- 12:28to mention one bill, and it's
- 12:29gotten a little complicated,
- 12:30but Senate Bill four is
- 12:32legislation that we worked with
- 12:33Senator West on, came out of
- 12:34the Senate, and it dealt with
- 12:36leadership programs for school
- 12:38principals. This is near and
- 12:39dear to our heart. At the
- 12:40Kentucky Chamber, we have been
- 12:41training school principals for
- 12:43years in recognizing that
- 12:45providing additional leadership
- 12:46training because they are like
- 12:47the CEOs of their school.
- 12:49What's really important for
- 12:51supporting the schools and what
- 12:53Senator West found when he did
- 12:55some research in this area, is
- 12:56that retention of teachers. Of
- 12:58course, you know, you think
- 12:59salaries and that's an
- 13:00important discussion, but
- 13:02really it's the leadership of
- 13:03the school and the principal.
- 13:04And so he took this on with
- 13:05Senate Bill four. We're big
- 13:07supporters of that work that
- 13:08he's doing and continuing to
- 13:09advocate for that because we
- 13:10think that that's important.
- 13:12But we look holistically at the
- 13:13budget when we focus on
- 13:15education in terms of
- 13:17post-secondary higher ed
- 13:19workforce training, so that we
- 13:21can be sure that people have
- 13:22the credentials they need to
- 13:23meet our workforce needs.
- 13:24>> I want to go to
- 13:26Representative Brzozowski real
- 13:27quick because on Senate before,
- 13:28even though this is not about
- 13:29that, but we knew that there
- 13:31was an amendment that was
- 13:32attached on. And I know that
- 13:34you want to go there too,
- 13:35Senator Thomas, that deals with
- 13:36the school boards of the two
- 13:38largest school districts in the
- 13:39state, Jefferson County and
- 13:40Fayette County, where there
- 13:41would be two appointed board
- 13:44members from the state
- 13:45treasurer. So talk to us. Do
- 13:47you agree with that approach or
- 13:48does that muddy the waters when
- 13:50it comes to principal
- 13:51leadership, should that be
- 13:53separated out in your view?
- 13:55>> Well, it definitely took a
- 13:59bill that had unanimous
- 14:01bipartisan support and made it
- 14:03much more contentious. So what
- 14:04Senate Bill four, as amended in
- 14:07the House will do, is it shifts
- 14:09us from having seven school
- 14:11board members in Jefferson
- 14:12County to five elected members
- 14:15and two appointed members. Now,
- 14:18with the the struggles that
- 14:20JCPS has had with budget in the
- 14:22last year or so, I think that
- 14:26it seems pretty rational to put
- 14:28individuals who have a a
- 14:32finance background onto the
- 14:34school boards. I think that
- 14:35that that can definitely be
- 14:37supported and it maintains,
- 14:40except for the two appointed
- 14:42positions, five elected
- 14:43positions. So there's other
- 14:45legislation, Senate Bill 114
- 14:47that would create an entirely
- 14:50appointed school board. And I
- 14:51find that highly problematic.
- 14:53So, you know, since I've come
- 14:55in the General Assembly, this
- 14:56is year eight, there's been
- 14:59angst about JCPS year after
- 15:01year. And we're we're worried.
- 15:02Are you going to break up the
- 15:04district? Are you going to just
- 15:05have appointed boards? And
- 15:07there are so many amazing
- 15:09things happening in the
- 15:10district. My hope is if this is
- 15:12the bill that goes through that,
- 15:14we can then move forward and we
- 15:15can figure out what kind of
- 15:17services and supports our
- 15:19students need to be successful
- 15:21and not just have, you know,
- 15:24that negative connotation about
- 15:25the district, the community and
- 15:28the General Assembly need to
- 15:29feel like JCPS is in a position
- 15:32to move forward. And even
- 15:34though it's highly contentious,
- 15:36I think that this amendment to
- 15:38Senate Bill four might help to
- 15:39do that.
- 15:40>> Do you agree, Senator Thomas,
- 15:42that this is one way to restore
- 15:43some public confidence,
- 15:44particularly in these two
- 15:45districts where there are
- 15:47significant budget deficits,
- 15:48more so with Jefferson County
- 15:49than Fayette County?
- 15:52>> Renee, I understand Senator
- 15:55Volkanovski's position, but but
- 15:56let me tell you this, okay.
- 15:59From the time we've had free
- 16:00public schools in this state,
- 16:02we've always had local school
- 16:04boards elected by local people.
- 16:06The school boards have always
- 16:07been accountable, Renee, to the
- 16:10public. And this radically
- 16:11changes this with the amendment
- 16:13to say, now that you have two
- 16:15members on that board who are
- 16:17accountable to no one, no one,
- 16:19I think it gives that authority
- 16:21to the state treasurer.
- 16:22>> Yes, but they have to have
- 16:24ten years of financial
- 16:25expertise.
- 16:26>> Renee. That doesn't matter.
- 16:27That doesn't matter.
- 16:28>> When you're dealing with $16
- 16:29million budget deficits or $187
- 16:31million budget deficits, that.
- 16:32>> Doesn't matter when you're
- 16:34talking about a a board that
- 16:37deals with free public schools
- 16:38where the public sends their
- 16:40children to that school, the
- 16:42people who are making policy
- 16:43decisions on that board should
- 16:45be accountable to that body.
- 16:47When you have anyone on that
- 16:49board, Renee, who are who are
- 16:51not accountable to the public,
- 16:53then you can influence
- 16:55decisions in a way that the
- 16:57public may not have wanted to.
- 16:59Anytime you have someone on the
- 17:00board who's in the, you know,
- 17:02in that decision making body
- 17:05and they're not accountable and
- 17:06you got a close vote, they can
- 17:08influence that decision and
- 17:09they're not accountable to the
- 17:11public for that decision.
- 17:11>> But they could not serve as
- 17:13chair or vice chair. Right. The
- 17:15two appointed.
- 17:15>> They have a vote, though.
- 17:17They're voting members. And
- 17:18let's not ignore that, Renee.
- 17:19They're not they they do have a
- 17:21vote on that board. And that's
- 17:22a dangerous precedent and one
- 17:24that I'm certainly opposed to.
- 17:26>> All right. So we're going to
- 17:27put a pin in that because that
- 17:29will probably come up again a
- 17:31little later. We've gotten
- 17:32several questions. And these
- 17:33are kind of non sequiturs right.
- 17:34So we're going to pivot from
- 17:36different areas here. Let's
- 17:37take this one from Patricia in
- 17:38Fayette County. Why do
- 17:40Christians in Kentucky not get
- 17:42to claim the 10% that they
- 17:43tithe to their churches when
- 17:44they're getting turned down for
- 17:46SNAP benefits, especially when
- 17:48many of our representatives are
- 17:49Christians and claim the 10% on
- 17:51their own income. That's a
- 17:55little stumper. I think of a
- 17:57question. Patricia Andrew can
- 17:59you make some?
- 18:02>> No, I'm sorry to that. It's
- 18:05always good to hear from the
- 18:06folks out in the public, but I
- 18:08don't know if anybody on the
- 18:09panel has any insight into that
- 18:11question.
- 18:11>> Right. Those are tax
- 18:13deductible contributions.
- 18:14>> They are if you itemize.
- 18:15>> If you. Yeah. Right. Okay.
- 18:17From Anthony and Louis County,
- 18:19why aren't legislators
- 18:20supporting a cost of living
- 18:22adjustment for Kentucky
- 18:23retirees? And Anthony, you are
- 18:24on to something because in the
- 18:26Senate version of the budget.
- 18:29Senator Mays Bledsoe, it's not
- 18:30necessarily a cost of living
- 18:32adjustment, but is there there
- 18:33is a 13th check. Explain what
- 18:35that is.
- 18:36>> So my understanding before I
- 18:38came to the General Assembly is
- 18:39that they weren't going to do
- 18:40Colas until we fully funded the
- 18:42liability, and that won't be, I
- 18:43believe, until 2036. Perhaps
- 18:45the way we're we're going. And
- 18:46so that's why they've not done
- 18:48in the past. Done Colas. I
- 18:50completely understand the
- 18:51frustration of people who have
- 18:52been without a cost of living
- 18:54increase, especially given how
- 18:55much costs have gone up. And so
- 18:57the 13th check is a way to one
- 18:59time to kind of infuse some
- 19:01resources into acknowledgment
- 19:02of those who have served,
- 19:03especially the longest, and
- 19:04have been waiting for that for
- 19:06a very long time.
- 19:07>> They get more than those who
- 19:09do.
- 19:09>> It's a scaled approach. If
- 19:10you serve more than 17, you get
- 19:12the full amount and then it's
- 19:14less as a way to encourage
- 19:15those who have worked for the
- 19:17state, to be honest.
- 19:18>> Yeah. Andrew.
- 19:18>> Yeah. This is one area of
- 19:20concern that I have with the
- 19:22state budget as it currently
- 19:23stands. And of course, we're
- 19:24talking about the Senate
- 19:25version there in the conference
- 19:26committee. They're going to
- 19:27hammer out a lot of differences.
- 19:29And it's not so much with the
- 19:31decision to provide this 13th
- 19:32check. But I think that we are
- 19:34stepping up to a structurally
- 19:35imbalanced budget. Again, the
- 19:37funding for that is coming from
- 19:40a state employee insurance
- 19:42trust fund. As I understand,
- 19:44it's not general fund.
- 19:45>> We're taking that from the
- 19:47DOI, the $350 million
- 19:49Department of Insurance fund.
- 19:50>> Yeah, but.
- 19:50>> That is one time cost money
- 19:52for one time use.
- 19:53>> I do understand that. But
- 19:54but it is a fund transfer in a
- 19:56sense to fund a one time
- 19:58expense. Most of the one time
- 20:00expenses have been moved into
- 20:01what was once House Bill one is
- 20:03now House Bill 900. Wright the
- 20:05other thing, and we'll get a
- 20:07little bit into the weeds here.
- 20:09I'm seeing the return of
- 20:11non-governmental expenses or
- 20:13expenditures. And that is
- 20:16something that was a very
- 20:20serious contributor to
- 20:21structural imbalance in the
- 20:23last decade. The money that is
- 20:26provided for the identification
- 20:30of nuclear ready sites, that
- 20:34may very well be a proper idea
- 20:36and something that could be a
- 20:38strong investment in the state
- 20:39going forward. But you got to
- 20:42dig in. There had the benefit
- 20:44of writing some budgets in my
- 20:46time in the state budget
- 20:47director's office. So I know
- 20:48where to look. You know, that
- 20:51$75 million is written as a
- 20:52non-governmental expenditure.
- 20:54And so I'm not suggesting that
- 20:57this budget is structurally
- 21:00imbalanced in the way that we
- 21:00have seen in the past, when it
- 21:02was really bad. There's a
- 21:03little bit of a slippery slope
- 21:05here. I know that times are a
- 21:07little bit tighter, but we've
- 21:08done better in the past. I
- 21:10commend the fiscal
- 21:11responsibility that both
- 21:13majorities have practiced,
- 21:15especially in this decade. But
- 21:16there's a couple of things in
- 21:17there that are concerning about
- 21:19where the source of funds is
- 21:20coming from. For some of the
- 21:23expenditures that the General
- 21:24Assembly is.
- 21:24>> Making. And Chairman
- 21:25McDaniel had said, Senator Mays
- 21:26Bledsoe, that this is a
- 21:28structural, balanced budget. I
- 21:30think that's what he said.
- 21:31Right. The Senate version. Yes.
- 21:33>> And I think that that has to
- 21:35go back to one time, use money
- 21:37for one time cost. And in this
- 21:39way, you know, the House
- 21:40version took that money to the
- 21:42budget Reserve trust fund. We
- 21:43could have sent it there and
- 21:44then written a one time expense
- 21:46from it. And so some of that is
- 21:48coming from an operating budget
- 21:49of DOI in that way. And we just
- 21:51allocated it differently for
- 21:52one time use. And I think what
- 21:54I would mention is that the
- 21:56governor did some very creative
- 21:57work trying to make his budget
- 21:59priorities, including using the
- 22:00DOI for Medicaid, including
- 22:02rolling back an MCO payment to
- 22:04to July instead of that current
- 22:06year that saved about $500
- 22:08million that he could then put
- 22:09to his initiatives. So some of
- 22:11this is creative budgeting.
- 22:12Sometimes it's tools. I think
- 22:13the structural balance that I
- 22:15think both of us are committed
- 22:17to out of the conference
- 22:18committee is ensuring that it
- 22:19makes sense that the one time
- 22:21operating expenses are in the
- 22:22operating budget and that one
- 22:23time capital investments are
- 22:24what time costs are in 900. To
- 22:26separate those two things and
- 22:27be wise about one time costs
- 22:29and recurring expenses.
- 22:30>> Yeah. So Jason Bailey, I
- 22:31want to go to you.
- 22:33>> Well, I think I think that
- 22:34is a, is, is a good approach
- 22:36when times are good. The issue
- 22:39is that, you know, the reason
- 22:41we used to call it the rainy
- 22:43day fund is that the main
- 22:44reason for budget reserve trust
- 22:45fund is rainy days. And it's
- 22:47actually to fund recurring
- 22:48expenses that have a temporary
- 22:49shortfall because the economy
- 22:50is down or, or the demand is up.
- 22:53We don't have that quite yet.
- 22:55Mostly we have a tight budget
- 22:57because of state policy
- 22:59decisions, state income tax
- 23:00cuts that are reducing the
- 23:01budget. But when, if and when
- 23:03the time comes that we hit a
- 23:04recession, I hope we will pull
- 23:06down that rainy day fund to
- 23:08fill recurring gaps that are
- 23:10temporarily created by
- 23:12shortfall. But, you know, I
- 23:13wanted to bring up, if I could,
- 23:15Renee, I think one of the
- 23:16biggest issues that remains in
- 23:17the budget to be decided and
- 23:19the biggest holes is in the
- 23:20Medicaid program, where both
- 23:22budgets are significantly
- 23:25underfunding Medicaid relative
- 23:27to what the the agency
- 23:29indicated was necessary to
- 23:30provide just a continuation
- 23:32budget. And in the when you
- 23:34once you count the federal
- 23:36money. The thing about Medicaid
- 23:37is that for every dollar we put
- 23:38in, we get three federal
- 23:40dollars. So the economic harm
- 23:41of of shorting Medicaid or
- 23:43cutting Medicaid is, is
- 23:45compounded. And we know that it
- 23:47hits, particularly in rural
- 23:49areas, in rural hospitals and
- 23:51rural providers and clinics
- 23:53that are already seeing cuts
- 23:55because of H.R. one that passed
- 23:56Congress last summer. So, you
- 23:58know, both budgets have a
- 23:59shortfall once you count the
- 24:01federal match of about $2.7
- 24:04billion in Medicaid. And that,
- 24:05I think, is the largest hole in
- 24:08what we're seeing. And, you
- 24:09know, in the last budget they
- 24:10did, the legislature did use
- 24:12budget reserve trust fund money
- 24:13to fully fund Medicaid. At the
- 24:15end of the at the end of the
- 24:17budget, they came in and
- 24:19provided that money because it
- 24:20needed to be provided. So I you
- 24:22know, I hope that that's one of
- 24:23the issues that is is addressed
- 24:25in the conference committee
- 24:27because we've already seen we
- 24:28saw a maternity center closed
- 24:30last two weeks ago in Lincoln
- 24:32County because of federal
- 24:34Medicaid cuts. You know, we're
- 24:36seeing we have 35 rural
- 24:38hospitals at risk of closure
- 24:40because of the federal cuts.
- 24:41And if the state is also
- 24:42cutting back and the governor
- 24:44indicated that they would have
- 24:45to cut payments to providers,
- 24:46they would have to eliminate
- 24:48services if the budget came in
- 24:50the way it is at this moment.
- 24:52That's a real problem.
- 24:54>> Any response on this side?
- 24:56>> I'll comment on it. I mean,
- 24:58the health care system, of
- 24:59course, is incredibly important.
- 25:00It has economic implications
- 25:02for our state. You know, the
- 25:03Chamber, we have members from
- 25:05all parts of the health care
- 25:07system, the managed care
- 25:08organizations, private insurers,
- 25:11pharmaceutical providers, the
- 25:12hospitals. And so we we keep in
- 25:14touch with our health care
- 25:15members constantly. And, you
- 25:18know, we are conveners. We can
- 25:20bring people together. And what
- 25:21I will say about Medicaid is
- 25:23you have to expect that the
- 25:24General Assembly is going to
- 25:26continue to study this issue
- 25:28thoroughly. It is a large chunk
- 25:30of our budget. It is important
- 25:32to a lot of Kentuckians that
- 25:33are served. It impacts
- 25:35providers. It impacts the
- 25:37economy as a whole, and it I
- 25:39think there's goals associated
- 25:41with it. And, you know, when we
- 25:42look at our work at the Chamber,
- 25:44we really focus on jobs,
- 25:47creating jobs and removing
- 25:48barriers that people face to
- 25:51reach their economic potential.
- 25:52And our goal ultimately, is
- 25:53that people who make use of
- 25:55public benefits, that it's
- 25:57temporary for most people and
- 25:58that they can move off of
- 25:59benefits and that they can be
- 26:01self-sustaining for themselves
- 26:02and their families. And so in
- 26:03addition to the work that we do
- 26:05with our directly with our
- 26:06health care members, we are
- 26:08fighting for jobs in Kentucky
- 26:09and we are fighting for workers
- 26:11and working families. And that
- 26:13means a lot of different things.
- 26:14And, you know, you'll see us
- 26:16this year and you did a whole
- 26:18session on this, Renee. It was
- 26:19wonderful fighting for
- 26:20childcare and private childcare
- 26:22facilities and childcare
- 26:23workers and those working
- 26:25families that are struggling
- 26:26with childcare, needing to find
- 26:29more childcare, more affordable
- 26:30childcare. That is one of our
- 26:32top issues because we want to
- 26:33support working families. And
- 26:34when you have a member of the
- 26:36family, a parent that takes
- 26:37themselves out of the workforce
- 26:38because they can't access it,
- 26:40that might mean the family is
- 26:41now dependent on public
- 26:44benefits. We are also working
- 26:45on housing this year. It's one
- 26:47of our top issues. We are
- 26:48supporting seven different
- 26:50bills across the Senate and the
- 26:51House. I expect there will be
- 26:54perhaps one big, beautiful
- 26:55housing bill or a couple of
- 26:56bills that are passed by the
- 26:58legislature, focusing on
- 26:59increasing supply of housing in
- 27:01Kentucky so that we can support
- 27:02working families. This is
- 27:04critical. We have a 200,000
- 27:06plus shortage of homes in
- 27:08Kentucky. And when you learn
- 27:10about supply and demand and
- 27:11price back in our economics 101
- 27:13days, if there's demand and
- 27:15there is demand in Kentucky,
- 27:16you got to increase supply. And
- 27:18so we see legislators, Senator
- 27:20Mills, Representative Witten,
- 27:23Representative White doing a
- 27:24lot of great work on housing.
- 27:25And so we'll be focusing on
- 27:27that. And so I think that, you
- 27:28know, in addition to working on
- 27:30the health care policy
- 27:31specifically and knowing that
- 27:32the legislature is going to
- 27:33study this in great detail, we
- 27:35have to continue to focus on
- 27:36economic growth, creating jobs,
- 27:38and making sure Kentuckians
- 27:40have what they need to fill
- 27:41those jobs, reach their
- 27:42economic potential, and support
- 27:44themselves and their families
- 27:46sustainably. In Kentucky, this
- 27:47will grow our population. This
- 27:49will grow our revenues, this
- 27:50will grow our economy. And that
- 27:52needs to be the focus. But
- 27:54undoubtedly, you will see the
- 27:55legislature continue to work on
- 27:56this through the budget,
- 27:57through the Medicaid Oversight
- 27:58and Advisory Board. And I think
- 28:00it's important topic for them
- 28:01to continue to work on.
- 28:02>> We know that the Kentucky
- 28:04Chamber also favors a continued
- 28:05gradual phasing out of the
- 28:07individual income tax. Do
- 28:09either one of the budgets,
- 28:10House or Senate version, try to
- 28:12rush that process to get to
- 28:14zero?
- 28:14>> No, I don't think so at all.
- 28:16I think it's a measured
- 28:17approach to reducing the
- 28:18individual personal income tax.
- 28:19We were one of the first
- 28:21advocates out of the gate for
- 28:22that. We advocated in 2018,
- 28:24when leader Rudy passed tax
- 28:25reforms. We advocated in 2022
- 28:27with the passage of House Bill
- 28:28eight, which created the
- 28:30personal income tax reduction
- 28:32process, especially for the
- 28:33legislature to take. And we
- 28:35advocated in 2025, last year,
- 28:36when they made reforms to that
- 28:38process where we might see
- 28:40incremental or smaller
- 28:41increments of reduction in the
- 28:42income tax. And this has been
- 28:45incredible for Kentucky. And
- 28:46it's very much important that
- 28:48as Kentuckians face inflation,
- 28:50affordability issues, that the
- 28:52legislature is putting more
- 28:53money back in the pocket of
- 28:54Kentuckians. That's what we're
- 28:55seeing. And then that money is
- 28:57getting spent in the economy.
- 28:58And you see that in sales tax
- 29:00and other revenues. And when
- 29:01you look at the reduction that
- 29:03we've seen in the income tax
- 29:04over the past couple of years,
- 29:06because of that, you haven't
- 29:07seen a dollar for dollar
- 29:08reduction in revenues. And in
- 29:10fact, our revenues are up
- 29:11relative to 2021. I think we
- 29:13had about a less than a $14
- 29:14billion budget. Now we're
- 29:15looking at a $1,516 billion.
- 29:18We've seen revenues grow even
- 29:19though we've been able to
- 29:20reduce the income tax. We also
- 29:22saw record employment to 2
- 29:24million jobs on record jobs
- 29:27actually on record in 2023. So
- 29:29we've seen growth in revenues
- 29:30in the economy and jobs since
- 29:33reducing the income tax. And
- 29:34we're seeing our competitor
- 29:36states do it as well. Lots of
- 29:37states post Covid reduce the
- 29:39income tax. So we are 100% on
- 29:41board with that. And we think
- 29:42it's important policy for the
- 29:43Commonwealth.
- 29:44>> If I can return Jason,
- 29:45unless you want to comment
- 29:46there, I want to return to SEEK
- 29:48real quickly. If you.
- 29:49>> Well, we're seeing cuts in
- 29:50this budget because of the
- 29:52income tax cuts. We're losing
- 29:53revenue $780 million for each
- 29:55half point. And we have a $2.7
- 29:58billion shortfall in Medicaid.
- 29:59In this budget, we have 7% cuts
- 30:01for many state agencies in this
- 30:03budget. So I do think the
- 30:05legislature is beginning to hit
- 30:06the wall on its on its ability
- 30:08to continue to reduce it. I
- 30:10don't see the Senate budget
- 30:11aiming to reduce the income tax
- 30:13further over the next two years.
- 30:15I don't see the House budget
- 30:16doing that very much. The
- 30:18original version of the House
- 30:20budget did aim to reduce income
- 30:22tax cuts or to have future
- 30:24income. Further income tax cuts.
- 30:26But there was an outpouring
- 30:27because it would require state
- 30:29employees and retirees to have
- 30:30a 78% increase in their health
- 30:32insurance. And people were like,
- 30:33no, we're not going to do that.
- 30:35And so the House came back and
- 30:37and put more money in the
- 30:38budget to prevent that. So it's
- 30:40very expensive. And I think the
- 30:41legislature is is really
- 30:42hitting the wall on this
- 30:43so-called march to zero,
- 30:45because the more you cut, the
- 30:47more you have to trade off in
- 30:49funding for schools, for health
- 30:50care, infrastructure and other
- 30:51things we need.
- 30:52>> So returning back to
- 30:53education, this questioner from
- 30:55Fayette County says, can the
- 30:56panelists please explain the
- 30:57State SEEK funding? Oh, boy.
- 30:59And how that's paid? Is it true
- 31:02that certain counties like
- 31:03Fayette pay more of the per
- 31:05student cost than others? If so,
- 31:07why doesn't each county get to
- 31:09keep the school taxes raised in
- 31:10their respective counties? This
- 31:11is an exceptional question, and
- 31:13it has an exceptional, probably
- 31:15complicated answer. Who wants
- 31:16to take a shot first?
- 31:17>> I'll go first. Okay, okay.
- 31:20The SEEK formula is designed to
- 31:23equalize payments to all
- 31:26schools across the state so
- 31:28that your wealthier counties
- 31:32don't receive more for their
- 31:35per pupil education than your
- 31:38less wealthy or your poorer
- 31:39counties. It equalizes it
- 31:41across all schools. And that's
- 31:43the beauty of the of Cara. Now,
- 31:47what I want to tell the the
- 31:49writer there is that what
- 31:51happens is if a, if a county is
- 31:55able to pay more in taxes
- 31:57toward their schools, then that
- 31:59money to the county from the
- 32:00SEEK formula, that will be
- 32:02reduced so that at the end of
- 32:04the day, the amount of money
- 32:06they're getting per pupil is
- 32:07equal to what other counties
- 32:08are getting. So that's what
- 32:10she's referring to, is that all
- 32:12schools will get the same, but
- 32:16some counties will receive less
- 32:18state dollars because they have
- 32:19more local tax dollars to pay,
- 32:21and sometimes will receive more
- 32:22state dollars because they have
- 32:24less taxes to pay. But at the
- 32:26end of the day, it's all equal.
- 32:28>> Representative Bozinovski,
- 32:29do you think if it's equal, is
- 32:31it fair?
- 32:36>> Well, I mean, I think it's
- 32:37fair that every child in
- 32:39Kentucky could have an
- 32:40equitable amount of funding
- 32:42applied to them. So in in
- 32:44response to the question, any
- 32:47local taxes that are raised are
- 32:49kept locally, but it's our
- 32:53state tax that is then
- 32:55appropriated across the state.
- 32:56So Jefferson County pays a good
- 32:58hunk of the state tax, and that
- 33:00is distributed statewide. So,
- 33:05yes, I think it's very
- 33:06important that every child has
- 33:09equitably funded education.
- 33:11>> And Jason Bailey Casey has
- 33:13done studies about this before,
- 33:15that the gap between more
- 33:17wealthy urban districts is not
- 33:20on par with poorer ones.
- 33:21>> Right? All the SEEK formula
- 33:23tells you is how to allocate
- 33:24the state money, how to
- 33:26apportion it among the
- 33:27districts. It doesn't. The
- 33:28legislature decides how much to
- 33:30put in it. You know, that's
- 33:31just a that's just a judgment
- 33:33call. And so the goal is
- 33:34equitable school funding. But
- 33:36if the state doesn't put in,
- 33:38you know, enough, it becomes
- 33:41unequal. And that's what's
- 33:42happened over over time. Is
- 33:44that the gap in funding between
- 33:45wealthier and poor school
- 33:47districts has grown. And it's
- 33:48actually we estimate it's
- 33:49bigger now than it was when
- 33:51when the state Supreme Court
- 33:53ruled that the funding was
- 33:54unconstitutional. So it's it's
- 33:58it is it is bozinovski. A lot
- 34:00of people have this impression
- 34:02that their their local school
- 34:03taxes are being taken from them.
- 34:04That's not true. But how much
- 34:06is being supplemented is is a
- 34:09decision of the General
- 34:10Assembly through the formula.
- 34:11>> Any response on this side
- 34:13before we move through this
- 34:15question from Woodford County,
- 34:17please explain why money set
- 34:19aside to address compression
- 34:21pay. This is, I guess, salary
- 34:23compression pay is only going
- 34:24to be given to two departments,
- 34:25and the rest of the money is
- 34:27going to the budget reserve
- 34:28trust fund, rainy day fund.
- 34:30This money was set aside to
- 34:31address this for all state
- 34:33employees affected.
- 34:35>> I believe we're talking to
- 34:36the Commonwealth attorneys and
- 34:38Commonwealth.
- 34:39>> We did in the county.
- 34:40>> Attorney, the county
- 34:41attorney's.
- 34:41>> I think they're talking
- 34:43about money in the permanent
- 34:44pension fund that the $67
- 34:45million that was for pay
- 34:46compression across the board.
- 34:47>> So we did two studies on
- 34:49that. And you'll have to ask
- 34:51Budget Director Hicks on why
- 34:52that was a recommendation to
- 34:53remove that funding. But the
- 34:55idea had been that it had been
- 34:56taken care of by the
- 34:57administration, and there was
- 34:59some disparities in the
- 35:00Commonwealth attorneys and
- 35:01Commonwealth that we did
- 35:03address, because that was done
- 35:04in the last budget to make that
- 35:06make that resources back up.
- 35:07But there was also a line item,
- 35:09I believe, in the House that
- 35:10referenced transportation and c
- 35:11h of the cabinet for Health and
- 35:13Human Services, and we took
- 35:14that out more for conversation
- 35:16of what we're really trying to
- 35:17do there. The compression is a
- 35:18very hard issue. It is a
- 35:20challenge, especially in
- 35:22government, when you continue
- 35:23to have people brought in at a
- 35:24higher pay. When you get people
- 35:26who have served for a long time,
- 35:28it is something that we have
- 35:29done some decent addressing of
- 35:30it, but it is not an issue that
- 35:32goes away quickly. So I think
- 35:34you'll see that come back.
- 35:36>> Up and have lawmakers gotten
- 35:37all the data that they need
- 35:39from the personnel cabinet to
- 35:40make an informed decision about
- 35:41how to address salary
- 35:42compression.
- 35:43>> That's debatable. And that's
- 35:45part of part of some of the
- 35:47challenge.
- 35:47>> I think Secretary Bailey
- 35:48will say that that she's given
- 35:51both chairs everything they've
- 35:53asked for regarding compression.
- 35:55She she will tell you that.
- 35:57>> All right. So moving back to
- 36:00education, because education is
- 36:01always the big topic. This from
- 36:03Billy Berry from Henry County
- 36:05says, quote, pre-K for all is
- 36:06highly supported in Kentucky by
- 36:0863 County judge executive's 35
- 36:11Kentucky mayors, the Kentucky
- 36:12Association of School
- 36:13Superintendents, and many
- 36:14others. How can this program be
- 36:16disregarded as not necessary in
- 36:17our state? How can we abandon
- 36:19our rural communities when they
- 36:21are, when there are funds for
- 36:22this program that will enrich
- 36:24our communities and state as a
- 36:25whole?
- 36:25>> Renee, I'll start with that,
- 36:27and I can go to Kate's point
- 36:29with regard to to what she said
- 36:31about wanting to get more
- 36:32people to work for universal
- 36:34pre-K will do. Renee. And I
- 36:36want to tell you, your
- 36:37listeners this is that at four
- 36:40years old, all children. No,
- 36:42not just those who are low
- 36:44income or those who come from
- 36:46parents who can afford private
- 36:47school, but all children can
- 36:49start school. This will free up
- 36:54couples so that they both can
- 36:55go to work. Kate, and have
- 36:58income bringing in from both
- 37:00families. It's the ultimate
- 37:02workforce benefit program for
- 37:05our state. In addition to that,
- 37:07Renee, it gets children in the
- 37:09school earlier, so they learn
- 37:10socialization skills they can
- 37:12start dealing with with reading
- 37:13and phonics, mathematics. And
- 37:17so they, they get a jump in
- 37:19their learning ability. And
- 37:20what we've seen, Renee, as I
- 37:22said, from a majority of states
- 37:23already, they already have it.
- 37:25It's the benefits are
- 37:27significant. More students
- 37:28graduate from high school. More
- 37:29students go on to college. They
- 37:31lead healthier lives. They're
- 37:32more productive in terms of
- 37:34income. Kate. So it's very
- 37:37beneficial for for our state to
- 37:39do this, why we're now in the
- 37:41bottom half of those states
- 37:42that don't have universal pre-K
- 37:44makes no sense. And our
- 37:46governor has been pushing this
- 37:47program since he came into
- 37:49office.
- 37:50>> And wasn't there Andrew back
- 37:51in, I can't remember during the
- 37:53seven years when there was an
- 37:55expansion of eligibility for
- 37:57pre-K, where it went from a
- 37:58certain level of poverty to a
- 38:00different level of poverty, and
- 38:02that that was voted on.
- 38:03>> Yeah, I think there have
- 38:05been some appropriate
- 38:05expansions of it, but I'm more
- 38:07of a policy person than a
- 38:08political person. But politics
- 38:09obviously plays a big role in
- 38:11this. And I went back to look
- 38:13at an article that was
- 38:16published December 11th of 2025.
- 38:19The governor was interviewed by
- 38:21FPL news, and the question was
- 38:23on universal pre-K, and I went
- 38:26back to read it to make sure
- 38:28that I was going to be accurate
- 38:30if this topic came up. And
- 38:31Governor Beshear said
- 38:32explicitly that he has the
- 38:33support to get universal pre-K
- 38:35through the legislature, it
- 38:36wasn't a question of if they're
- 38:38willing to work with me. It
- 38:39wasn't a question of, you know,
- 38:41is there enough funding for it?
- 38:43The governor has a 65%, 70%
- 38:46approval rating. We hear about
- 38:48it all the time. That is
- 38:51political capital. And so the
- 38:53question of why universal pre-K
- 38:57isn't got more momentum behind
- 38:59it. First of all, I think there
- 39:01are some real questions about
- 39:02whether or not it's the right
- 39:04policy, but the champion of it.
- 39:07And Reggie, you're right, he
- 39:08has spoken about it publicly.
- 39:11He's held forums about it. It
- 39:13seems to me that the people
- 39:14that he talks the least to
- 39:16about it are the members of the
- 39:18legislature. And so this idea
- 39:20of putting a sufficient or a
- 39:23vast sum of money into the
- 39:25budget for universal pre-K
- 39:26program without passing a bill,
- 39:28go do the work, put that
- 39:31approval rating to work,
- 39:33generate the support for it,
- 39:35work with the legislative
- 39:37branch. And I think that the
- 39:39question really needs to go
- 39:40back to the first floor, the
- 39:43executive branch of why this
- 39:45issue continues to just wither.
- 39:48>> So, Senator Mays Bledsoe,
- 39:49have you had conversations or
- 39:51your other members in
- 39:52leadership with the governor
- 39:53about the universal pre-K?
- 39:56>> I don't think the governor
- 39:57has had a conversation directly
- 39:58with any member of the majority
- 40:00in the legislature about pre-K.
- 40:02A members of his staff, I think,
- 40:03have reached out, and I've had
- 40:05one of those. But I think it's
- 40:06disingenuous for the governor
- 40:07to talk about it not being
- 40:09political and then use his
- 40:10Political action campaign
- 40:12committee to send a mailer out
- 40:13in my district. Julie Raque
- 40:14Adams then three women moms,
- 40:18Louisville Lexington. Without
- 40:19talking about the actual issue
- 40:21of childcare. So in pre-K,
- 40:23which we have right now, for
- 40:24those who are low income and
- 40:26have high need, we have pre-K
- 40:27for them that states assisted,
- 40:29but it's half day. What are the
- 40:31parents supposed to do after an
- 40:34afternoon or on the summertime?
- 40:35Like this isn't they don't all
- 40:37of a sudden have extra help if
- 40:39we're paying for extra pre-K or
- 40:41pre-K for a little bit, the
- 40:43four year olds without
- 40:44addressing the overall
- 40:45childcare system, which since
- 40:46Covid has been barely hanging
- 40:48on. And so I think the
- 40:50hesitancy with a $210 million
- 40:52recurring expense is to ensure
- 40:54that the actual childcare
- 40:56system is back to being solid,
- 40:58which I think House Bill six,
- 40:59which Knott the Chamber, but
- 41:01others have all been a part of
- 41:03that conversation, try to
- 41:04stabilize a very fragile
- 41:06environment because if your
- 41:07four year old goes, but your,
- 41:08your five month old who's in
- 41:10daycare now costs five times as
- 41:11much because you've removed the
- 41:12tuition paying members of the
- 41:14four and five year olds, that's
- 41:15a problem for sustainability.
- 41:17And so it's an overall concern.
- 41:19My kids went to pre-K. I'm for
- 41:21it. I don't think there's many
- 41:22members of the General Assembly
- 41:23who are anti early education
- 41:25investment. The question is how
- 41:26do we do it? Well, intentional
- 41:28with stability from the time a
- 41:30working parent may need it
- 41:31until the time they go to
- 41:32school.
- 41:33>> Representative Bujnowski,
- 41:34have you weigh in here?
- 41:39>> Yes. Thank you. So I did sit
- 41:41in on meetings with the
- 41:42governor and members of the
- 41:44majority party about this topic.
- 41:47I'm going to tell you, number
- 41:49one, the research is sound,
- 41:51that an investment in early
- 41:53childhood is the best
- 41:54investment we can we can make.
- 41:56I did have a bill that passed
- 41:57the House. Hopefully it will
- 41:59get through the Senate about
- 42:01class sizes and caseload caps
- 42:03for special education students,
- 42:05and it was only for K through
- 42:0712. And I've heard from
- 42:09multiple preschool teachers
- 42:11about a concern right now about
- 42:14caseloads and capsizes for our
- 42:17preschool program. So I fully
- 42:20support expanding preschool.
- 42:21But I think one part of it we
- 42:23need to look at is how is the
- 42:25program that we're providing
- 42:27right now going for children?
- 42:29If there are 20 children in a
- 42:31room with one teacher and one
- 42:33assistant, and 70 to 90% of
- 42:36them are special needs children,
- 42:38then maybe we need to put a
- 42:40little more effort into, I
- 42:42won't say effort, but address
- 42:45some concerns that we have in
- 42:47our current preschool program.
- 42:49And that's something I'll be
- 42:50working on over the next year.
- 42:52>> Any further comment about
- 42:54pre-K for me? Yes. Go ahead.
- 42:56>> I will say this, Kate and
- 43:01Amanda are not wrong when they
- 43:04say that you have to look at
- 43:06early childhood in total.
- 43:08They're not wrong about that.
- 43:11Yes, we we do the universal
- 43:13pre-K, but at the same time,
- 43:14we've got to look at our early
- 43:16childhood program and how to
- 43:19make that more affordable to
- 43:21parents as well. I do agree
- 43:23that that needs some some, some
- 43:25examination, because what
- 43:27happens is from a business
- 43:28model standpoint, Renee, your,
- 43:31your, your, your, your
- 43:33childcare centers get their
- 43:35money primarily from three and
- 43:36four year olds because the
- 43:38teacher to student ratio is a
- 43:40lot higher. So, so therefore
- 43:42there's more income coming to
- 43:43them. And, and we got to look
- 43:47at how are we going to pay them
- 43:49more because your childcare
- 43:50workers now, Renee, only make
- 43:51about 15, $17 an hour without
- 43:53any benefits. And that's got to
- 43:54change. So I don't I don't
- 43:56disagree with them that
- 43:57responsible leadership here
- 43:59requires that you also take
- 44:01into account how you deal with
- 44:03your early childhood education
- 44:05system. But but you can do both
- 44:07at the same time. You know, we
- 44:08do need universal pre-K.
- 44:11Absolutely. Everybody's doing
- 44:12it. Kentucky is falling behind
- 44:13every year, but we do need to
- 44:15look at our early childhood
- 44:16education system. So I will
- 44:18agree with Kate and Amanda on
- 44:19that point.
- 44:20>> Jason.
- 44:20>> Just add that the budget is
- 44:22the most important tool to deal
- 44:23with this entire early
- 44:25childhood issue, whether it's
- 44:26childcare, preschool, and it
- 44:28needs to be, you know, a
- 44:29combination. And there are some
- 44:32investments that we put in
- 44:33childcare post Covid to keep
- 44:35them up, propped up that are
- 44:36not in this version of the in
- 44:38the versions of the budget that
- 44:39are being negotiated. So, so
- 44:40the question apparently, you
- 44:43know, we talk about pre-K for
- 44:44all, but the question in this
- 44:45budget is whether we're going
- 44:47to be moving backwards on our
- 44:48funding levels for childcare.
- 44:50In terms of pre-K, both budgets
- 44:53put pre-K funding at in 2028 at
- 44:56the same dollar amount we put
- 44:57in in 2019, no increase. So so,
- 45:01you know, this is this is an
- 45:02expensive proposition. Early
- 45:04childhood education, it costs
- 45:05money and we can pass
- 45:07legislation. But ultimately, if
- 45:08we don't put dollars behind it,
- 45:10it won't it will not work. So I
- 45:12think I would love to see more
- 45:14attention given to the budget,
- 45:16you know, levels that are
- 45:17actually in the budget and, and
- 45:18what we risk by not just even
- 45:21continuing what we did last
- 45:22time.
- 45:23>> Renee can I make one
- 45:24clarification there or just.
- 45:26Jason makes a great point.
- 45:27Those funds that were in place
- 45:29during those budgets were
- 45:30federal funds. Those funds have
- 45:32been exhausted as they were
- 45:34intended to be. There has not
- 45:37been there was pressure to have
- 45:39the state step up and basically
- 45:41backfill or provide general
- 45:42fund to continue that subsidy.
- 45:46But again, the federal funds
- 45:48exhausted. It was a short term
- 45:50measure for a short term crisis.
- 45:52I'm not saying that it was not
- 45:54an important impact on being
- 45:56able to provide for those
- 45:59providers and those services
- 46:00for families. But given that
- 46:03those dollars have expired, I
- 46:05think it's a little bit
- 46:07misdirected to suggest that
- 46:11there is some big shortcoming
- 46:13within this budget, because we
- 46:15haven't backfilled those
- 46:16federal funds.
- 46:18>> Okay, shifting now to
- 46:19transportation. This is your
- 46:20jam Andrew and House Bill 502
- 46:23Lexington-Fayette only gets one
- 46:25sixth of transportation funding
- 46:26versus Louisville, yet the GDP
- 46:28of Lexington-Fayette County is
- 46:29only one third of Louisville.
- 46:31Jefferson. Why is there such a
- 46:33discrepancy between Jefferson
- 46:34to Fayette from Martin Rivers
- 46:36in Lexington? Thank you, Mr.
- 46:37Rivers.
- 46:38>> Yeah, and Senator Thomas may
- 46:41be able to help on the
- 46:42specifics and Senator Mays
- 46:43Bledsoe, on this question of of
- 46:45Fayette County's allocation.
- 46:46You know, the fact is, is that
- 46:49this is a work in progress.
- 46:50There is the funding bill,
- 46:52which I believe is House Bill
- 46:54501. House Bill 502 is the road
- 46:56plan. From what I've been able
- 46:59to discern, more attention has
- 47:03gone into 501 than is
- 47:06necessarily gone into 502 in
- 47:08terms of being able to hash out
- 47:09the differences or the details.
- 47:11I think it's a good question
- 47:13for anyone to ask if their
- 47:15elected representatives, you
- 47:16know, what can we see in terms
- 47:18of wanting to see some
- 47:20infrastructure improvements
- 47:21within our county? But I would
- 47:23also defer to our elected
- 47:25officials to discuss that
- 47:27particular question about
- 47:28Fayette County.
- 47:28>> Madam Vice Chair.
- 47:30>> I would just say, you know,
- 47:31be mindful that 50% of Fayette
- 47:33County's workforce comes in
- 47:34from outside Fayette County. So
- 47:35all the surrounding counties,
- 47:36their intersection, their their
- 47:38roadways that come in, all
- 47:40those improvements are very
- 47:41important to the workforce and
- 47:42actually do have kind of a
- 47:44holistic approach to
- 47:45transportation. You don't stop
- 47:46driving on 60 just because
- 47:48because it goes to Woodford or
- 47:50Fayette. And so I would be
- 47:51mindful of the whole region of
- 47:52that impact on the on the
- 47:54transportation budget. We are
- 47:55in the process of that. I think
- 47:57you will see more investments
- 47:58being made by the time it's all
- 48:00done.
- 48:00>> Senator Thomas.
- 48:01>> Senator Bledsoe and I have
- 48:02talked about this. One thing we
- 48:04do need from a transportation
- 48:06standpoint is we need a new
- 48:08intersection right there where
- 48:10the. New hospitals, new
- 48:14hospitals are being built. The
- 48:15UK hospital, the hospital that
- 48:19that's the old Central Baptist
- 48:20Hospital. They want a new
- 48:22intersection that feeds
- 48:23directly into I-75 right there.
- 48:27You know, everybody knows
- 48:28Hamburg is growing. That's
- 48:30that's not a surprise. And so
- 48:32that's that's one
- 48:33infrastructure need
- 48:34transportation need that we
- 48:35need sooner than later, later.
- 48:37And mayor, mayor Gordon is very
- 48:39supportive of this. So yes.
- 48:41>> In the out years plan.
- 48:42>> It it is. And what we're
- 48:44working on right now is trying
- 48:45to finalize some of the ways in
- 48:47which we fund that project. It
- 48:49is a massive underground tunnel
- 48:50under 75. As you can imagine,
- 48:51it wasn't ready to put in the
- 48:53house conversation yet. We are
- 48:54hoping to get to yes on that
- 48:56project, but it is. It's a very
- 48:58complicated project and it is
- 48:59very, very, very crucial to
- 49:01that side of Lexington.
- 49:02>> Yeah, Baptist Health, the
- 49:03hospital. I was thinking about
- 49:05Baptist Health, right?
- 49:06>> Yes. Okay. Thank you, Mr.
- 49:08Rivers, for for that
- 49:09conversation. We appreciate
- 49:10that. So we've talked a little
- 49:11bit about education. We've
- 49:12talked about social services,
- 49:14Medicaid. What is missing? We
- 49:16know that universal pre-K
- 49:18Senator Thomas is missing from
- 49:19the budget. But where do you
- 49:20hope at the end of the
- 49:21reconciliation process that it
- 49:23that the budget looks like the
- 49:25executive branch budget? Let's
- 49:26start there first.
- 49:26>> Well, I'll be brief because
- 49:28I want I want everybody to have,
- 49:30have, have a last some last
- 49:31words. So I'll just speak in
- 49:33like one minute. I want to go
- 49:34back to something that, that
- 49:36Jason said, and that's the
- 49:37Medicaid budget. And I think
- 49:38when we talk to your listeners
- 49:40and viewers, Renee, we need to
- 49:42talk about money. There is a
- 49:45$800 million State shortfall
- 49:47right now, the Medicaid budget.
- 49:49What's that translates to,
- 49:50Renee, when you talk about
- 49:51federal matching funds is a
- 49:54$2.7 billion shortfall. Okay.
- 49:56That will impact some of your
- 49:59rural hospitals. There's no
- 50:00question about that. And unless
- 50:04that's filled, you will see
- 50:06some of these clinics close.
- 50:08You'll see a few hospitals
- 50:11closed. You know, we've heard
- 50:13talk about how we have to have
- 50:15a healthy, healthy population
- 50:17to have a healthy workforce. No
- 50:18one's going to disagree with
- 50:20that. But if people can't get
- 50:21the kind of care they need
- 50:23because their Medicare has not
- 50:26been funded or they they've
- 50:27been ruled ineligible for
- 50:28Medicare, we're not going to
- 50:30get there. So that's that's the
- 50:31one thing we really haven't
- 50:33addressed yet. To answer your
- 50:34question that we need to
- 50:35address, we need to close that
- 50:37$2.7 billion gap.
- 50:38>> I want to go to
- 50:39Representative Bozinovski for
- 50:41closing thought before we get
- 50:42the rest of the table here in
- 50:44Lexington.
- 50:46>> Sure. Yes. So there are a
- 50:49couple of things that are high
- 50:50on my priority list. One is the
- 50:52Dolly Parton Imagination
- 50:54Library. In the Senate version
- 50:55of the bill, the local share
- 50:59has been increased, so the
- 51:01state share is no longer 50%.
- 51:03It's going down to 33%. And so
- 51:04there are some concerns that
- 51:06local programs will not be as
- 51:09able to get books into
- 51:11children's hands. A second
- 51:14concern is that there is in the
- 51:16budget for senior meals, it's
- 51:199.6 million and 9.3 million.
- 51:21I'm not certain if that is the
- 51:24entire budgeted amount, or if
- 51:26that allows for a base of last
- 51:28year's 10 million to get. The
- 51:31governor's proposal had close
- 51:33to a 20 million ask. So we
- 51:35don't want to cut senior meals.
- 51:36That's a priority. And then the
- 51:38third concern that's come up is
- 51:40in the Senate budget. Under the
- 51:42education, learning results and
- 51:45services, there's kind of a
- 51:46block grant where a certain
- 51:48amount of money can be spent as
- 51:51chosen as opposed to as
- 51:54designated. And I am concerned
- 51:55that that might have an impact
- 51:57on our very successful Reed to
- 51:59achieve Reed to succeed
- 52:01programs that the Kentucky
- 52:03Department of Education has
- 52:05implemented to help reading
- 52:06across the state. So those are
- 52:09those are my priorities that we
- 52:10haven't spoken about yet.
- 52:12>> Okay. And so I'm going to
- 52:13let Senator Amanda Mays Bledsoe
- 52:15just kind of chime in on that.
- 52:16You know, Dolly Parton's name
- 52:18is in the Imagination Library,
- 52:19but there's no slight against
- 52:20Dolly right at all.
- 52:21>> Against Dolly. I'm a big fan,
- 52:23and we did keep the amount of
- 52:25funding. They haven't spent all
- 52:26the money they were allocated
- 52:27in the last budget. They don't
- 52:29have. They have a reserve. And
- 52:30I think the idea was if local
- 52:32groups are doing a lot of
- 52:33fundraising, maybe if they have
- 52:35more impetus or more excitement
- 52:37around it, they would raise
- 52:38some more money and that would
- 52:39help get more people in the
- 52:40program.
- 52:41>> But we've also heard from
- 52:42counties like McCreary County
- 52:43who are very concerned about
- 52:45getting less money.
- 52:45>> That wasn't my favorite part
- 52:47of the structure. It's probably
- 52:48something that we'll continue
- 52:49to talk about, but I'm really
- 52:51glad she brought up to succeed.
- 52:52You know, one of the things we
- 52:54talk about in SEEK is what's
- 52:55not in SEEK. All the health
- 52:57care benefits for for teachers,
- 52:58all the pension benefits, all
- 52:59the Reed to succeed the math
- 53:01nation, Friskies, all the
- 53:02support services that are in
- 53:03the last funding, which you
- 53:05mentioned, which is over $200
- 53:07million, which is all education
- 53:09focused, every dollar of it,
- 53:11which doesn't show up in the
- 53:12SEEK formula, but actually
- 53:13shows up in that, not to
- 53:14mention our the charter
- 53:16programs like. And now I'm
- 53:19missing the names at EKU at the
- 53:22program there, as well as the
- 53:23ones the model. Thank you. And
- 53:25I'm thinking of the, the craft
- 53:27Academy and those which are all
- 53:29additional education programs
- 53:30that don't show up in SEEK and,
- 53:32and just on the Medicaid piece,
- 53:34just so we can hit on it a
- 53:35little bit, I hope we hit
- 53:37dental. That's an area that I
- 53:38know we've heard a lot of in
- 53:40the last couple of years that
- 53:41will not having those
- 53:42reimbursements is really having
- 53:43some difficulty with being able
- 53:45to provide dental services. But,
- 53:46you know, 1 in 3 Kentuckians on
- 53:48Medicaid, every 50% of every
- 53:49birth in the state is on
- 53:50Medicaid. It's unsustainable
- 53:51for us to continue on that path.
- 53:53Not to mention that many of the
- 53:55plans are actually better than
- 53:56private plans. And so it's an
- 53:57area that, to Kate's point, is
- 53:59not going away. We are going to
- 54:01have to figure out a way to
- 54:02provide services and health
- 54:03care the most effective,
- 54:04efficient way possible and
- 54:06providing really good care for
- 54:07Kentucky's most vulnerable.
- 54:08That has to be that's certainly
- 54:10the intent, I think, of the
- 54:11General Assembly is the most
- 54:12vulnerable to have that care
- 54:14and providing a balance and a
- 54:15structure that will continue to
- 54:16do government services well and
- 54:18allowing some to growth in the
- 54:19economy is really, really
- 54:20important.
- 54:21>> Kate.
- 54:21>> Child care, that's our top
- 54:23issue passed those bills.
- 54:24There's there's bills in the
- 54:25House. We support bills in the
- 54:27Senate. We support great
- 54:28legislation. So we want to see
- 54:29that get across the finish line.
- 54:31And of course, the budget
- 54:32funding those bills and the
- 54:33budget. It's also very
- 54:34important, including the Child
- 54:35Care Assistance Program and the
- 54:37Employee Childcare Assistance
- 54:38Program, which is a wonderful
- 54:39bridge to help people off of
- 54:41public assistance. It's a
- 54:42public private partnership, and
- 54:43we want to continue that
- 54:44program and see that funding in
- 54:46the budget. And then from there,
- 54:47of course, infrastructure,
- 54:48those one time spends
- 54:49potentially in House Bill 900,
- 54:51build more infrastructure. It's
- 54:52the foundation of our economy.
- 54:54>> Yeah, we didn't really talk
- 54:55about that. But we will. We'll
- 54:56get around to House Bill 900
- 54:58Jason. I'll give you about 45
- 54:59seconds, sir.
- 55:00>> The the $2.7 billion
- 55:02shortfall in Medicaid is the
- 55:04biggest is, I think, the single
- 55:05biggest issue. You know, we
- 55:07talked a little bit about the
- 55:08impact on on rural hospitals,
- 55:10but almost the entire job
- 55:12growth in the American economy
- 55:13and in Kentucky over the last
- 55:14year has been in health care.
- 55:16We have an aging population. We
- 55:18have more people going into
- 55:19nursing homes, more people
- 55:20going into home care services.
- 55:22That's one of the fastest
- 55:23growing types of jobs. We
- 55:27cannot cut this program and
- 55:29just give up federal money
- 55:31without severe consequences. So
- 55:33there's the economic impact,
- 55:34but there's also the impact on
- 55:36people. The governors, the
- 55:37administration will have to cut
- 55:38what's quote unquote optional
- 55:40services in Medicaid. Well,
- 55:41those optional services are
- 55:42things like waiver programs
- 55:44that serve people with
- 55:45disabilities. There are things
- 55:46like community mental health
- 55:47centers that provide drug
- 55:49treatment and and mental health
- 55:52services. Hospice is a optional
- 55:54program. Dialysis is an
- 55:55optional program, home
- 55:57delivered meals, certain types
- 55:58of drug treatment, etc. So that
- 56:01to me is is the single biggest
- 56:03issue that we face.
- 56:04>> Okay. Sorry, Andrew, we have
- 56:05to have you back so you can get
- 56:07the last word next time. Okay.
- 56:09>> Transparency. We need more
- 56:10transparency in the process.
- 56:11>> More transparency in the
- 56:12process. Okay. We'll have to
- 56:13have you back to follow up on
- 56:15that. And we thank you so much
- 56:17for being with us tonight on
- 56:18Kentucky. Tonight, we'll talk
- 56:19more about the General Assembly
- 56:21next Monday night as it wraps
- 56:22up and of course, Kentucky
- 56:23edition each weeknight at 630
- 56:25eastern, 530 central. We
- 56:26explore all that's happening in
- 56:27your state Capitol. I'm Renee
- 56:28Shaw. Take good care and I'll
- 56:30see you tomorrow night. Fast.
- 56:39>> High times are gonna come on
- 56:40the show.
- 56:43>> Well, see, we.