Latest / Automotive State of The Union / Steve Greenfield Reads The News w/ Paul and Kyle
Transcript
- 0:00[upbeat music] Hey, it is Thursday, November 3rd. We have a special guest. We're gonna have Steve Greenfield maybe read the news today.
- 0:07We're also gonna talk about the AutoVenture Intel Report and the virtual reality goggles that you keep on while you're driving the car. Everywhere I go, the people really wanna know- Watch it... who I is and who I ain't.
- 0:17While you're driving the car- Don't mess with the people. Don't mess with the people... No, we're gonna mess with the people. While you're driving the car? Don't, don't you mess- Well [laughs]...
- 0:25With someone else's- All right, while you're riding in the car. We're like, while I'm driving the car, this is gonna be the coolest thing. How's everyone else gonna do?
- 0:31[laughs] Well, pretty much when you, when you drive around right now, and you look around at the driver, the driver looks like this. Honk. Right. [laughs] Right. Right in, right in their lap.
- 0:39So maybe it'd be better if they had VR goggles on while they were driving if it gave them an accurate representation of what's in the road. Let's bring Steve Greenfield into the show. Let's not wait till his segment.
- 0:49What is going on, my friend? There we go. Hey, guys. Howdy. Howdy. So- Howdy... How's, hey, so Steve, b- before, before we got on, we, you gotta let the people know what you did yesterday, because I think- [laughs]...
- 1:00this is, like, you know, every once in a while you do s- one of those things that you didn't realize was on your bucket list, but all of a sudden you just throw it on there because you did it yesterday. Ugh.
- 1:09[laughs] You did s- s- something kinda crazy in the flight pattern yesterday. Crazy, but it wasn't on my bucket list, and I, I don't recommend it for anyone else's bucket list.
- 1:16[laughs] But for the record, for the record. No, I, I, uh, as Kyle said, I, I flew into Las Vegas for a dinner. So I literally got off the plane and took a taxi to the Bellagio Prime Steak.
- 1:28And then when I was finished, I hopped into a taxi, got, went back to the airport, hopped on a flight, and flew home. And, and he- Right. That's disgusting... didn't even have dinner with anybody.
- 1:36He just really wanted to go eat there. [laughs] Yeah. He's- Dinner by myself. [laughs] Hey, look, that's a good dinner to go to. At least you weren't like, "Ah, we're gonna go to In-N-Out Burger and just- [laughs]...
- 1:48you know, do business," you know? [laughs] This is true. This is true. Uh, s- so here's what we're gonna do today.
- 1:53We're gonna go through, usually we bring you in when it's time for you to talk about the intel report, but we wanted to keep you involved in the story. We only have one story, and then we'll talk about the intel report.
- 2:02So, uh, feel free to interrupt and do all the things that we- [laughs]... Kyle and I usually do with one another. So here it is.
- 2:07The tech entertainment company founded by Audi named Holoride has since spun off as its own company. It is now planning a 2023 rollout for its in-vehicle entertainment system, according to Automotive News.
- 2:19Audi announced their partnership to create Holoride-ready vehicles at South by Southwest this year, and the system will be available, uh, by 2023 in Europe.
- 2:27If you're just listening to the podcast, basically you put this headset on, like a VR headset, and it follows the dynamics of the car.
- 2:33The car is feeding it information as far as how fast it's going, which way it's turning, and so as you look around in the VR world, you actually feel the motion, and you feel the interaction, and you can, like, you know, in some of the videos that you probably saw if you're watching, but if you're not, you can, like, shoot these little sticks.
- 2:50Hold on. Wasn't she in the driver's seat? She was not in the driver's seat. Wasn't she in the driver's seat? No. She was in the driver's seat. Oh, she's gotta be in the passenger seat. No, passenger seat. No way.
- 2:56Actually- That's right... [laughs] in the back seat. Uh, Porsche- Oh, man... so here's the deal. Porsche is also developing experiences around the tech.
- 3:04Um, and if you go to their LA Experience Center, you can actually be n- taken for a spin around a track while you kind of, like, are playing a first-person shooter game, shooting, uh, I think it's bugs.
- 3:14You shoot some bugs. Pedestrians, pedestrians. No shooting pedestrians. [laughs] Uh, you can turn them from birds into skeletons according to one of the videos that we saw. And, and then- And then shoot them.
- 3:24Uh, well, it, it always ends that way. Just pick 'em off. Right? You need the points. [laughs] That's gotta be weird. Like, you just look over, right? You look over and someone's like, doink, doink, doink.
- 3:33Oh, it's- Just like duck hunting in a car... Look, I don't know if- That's gonna work in public really well, really well... Have, have any of you- Oh...
- 3:38have either of you ever, like, put a VR, like PlayStation VR and, and played? I haven't done it. Okay. Yeah, I get dizzy. Have, have you ever done that, though? Oh, man, I could, I don't think I could do it. Yeah.
- 3:49It's- I get dizzy... it, [laughs] it's surprisingly immersive when you put it on. I can't imagine doing it in a car.
- 3:57But on one of the videos, like, we linked them up in the show notes, and one of the videos, the, I think it was the developer from Porsche said, "And it helps to alleviate symptoms of motion sickness."
- 4:09And I was thinking- No way. Yeah. [laughs]... it's just the opposite. Get outta here. It's the opposite. When he said it, I was like, "I don't think he really believes what he [laughs] just said."
- 4:17There is no way, like, anyone with vertigo is literally chunking their cookies. It's over. Maybe it alleviates road rage, 'cause I can shoot the other cars. No. [laughs] There you go. Oh, see?
- 4:28[laughs] Now, now that, now we're talking augmented reality. It just, the whole world- [laughs]... turns into some Grand Theft Auto, um, playback. Yeah.
- 4:34It really, honestly, it feels very, like, as I'm watching the videos and as I'm thinking about it, like, y- if you've been to Disney World, and you've gone through, like, you know, the, the, the, the things where you go through and you got the little gun, and you're playing- Yeah...
- 4:48Buzz Lightyear or whatever, like, that's kinda what it feels like to me. So it's not, like, an altogether departure from, like, game mode of, of the way that you would expect it, but I just- Feels weird, right?
- 4:59I just can't imagine. It's hard enough for me, like, when we throw in a DVD, like pop in a DVD for the kids, we go on vacation, right?
- 5:07It's hard enough not, like, getting them to ask to do that every time we hit the road. [laughs] Oh, yeah. Right? Let alone- [laughs]...
- 5:14them knowing the potential of, like, throwing one of those guys on on the way to Walmart on Tuesday is an option. That would just destroy their, you know- Well, look-... every car ride. Gone...
- 5:24maybe if you deploy the technology at the right time, and don't let the kids know what it is, and you go on a big two-hour drive, maybe you could actually convince them they went to Disney, and then you're just home.
- 5:35Ooh. Like, there you go. You just went to Disney- [laughs]... and now you're home. Cheaper vacations. Very cheap. I like it. Uh, you know, remember what was happening- I mean, I, I-...
- 5:41with the Wii remotes when people were doing the bowling, and they were throwing remotes- Yeah... and breaking the TV? You know? Or springing their, their arms. Yeah. I'm just wondering. Yeah.
- 5:50Like, I know these do come- It'd happen... with a, a, the, the, the safety tether strap, but I, I just, I have kids, and I can just imagine people only have one. No, someone straight up breaking through a glass.
- 5:58It's done. [laughs] Someone's trying to break through a glass. It's done. Someone's, like, punching stuff. It's done.
- 6:01And the riders- I just, I, I, you know-I get this convergence, you know, it's South by Southwest is the, the relaunch, like the convergence of pop culture and automotive and trying to make the car, like, an extension of an experience.
- 6:14It just, to me, like, I just think there's so many more things that could be done with technology right now. [sighs] It's, it's a struggle to me. So it's an entertainment company.
- 6:22And if you look at the Porsche video, the Porsche video, they were... The person was kind of, like, moving through, like, what looked kind of like a space city as he's in the car. And it was all, it was Porsche branded.
- 6:34It was pretty cool. Like, I was like, "Oh, okay. Maybe there's an element." One thing that you can also do, you can also, uh, send media, view media from your phone on the device with the perceived 180-degree screen.
- 6:44Um, I don't know if it's gonna work or not, but it's coming out, and we'll see what people think about it, uh, not too long. Talking, speaking of think- speaking of hearing what people think about things. Stop. Segway.
- 6:57Time. [upbeat music] Oh, the n- no- November edition of the Auto Intel Report, authored by our very own Steve Greenfield here on the screen, uh, just came out.
- 7:10And you have a few announcements to make that I think I got personally, Kyle and I got excited when we read it this morning.
- 7:15Um, but, but tell us about what the big deal is in the November issue and, and what you're really excited about. Yeah. I think this is a, more of an evolution than anything.
- 7:24But, you know, it struck me really, you know, at your conference here, when was that? Like a month, month and a half ago- Yeah...
- 7:29where, you know, first, first time back with a bunch of industry folks, and folks come up and say, "You know, I really like this idea of you raising money from dealers and investing in early stage automotive technology companies, but how do I, how do I participate?"
- 7:42Mm. You know, "How do I participate?" And, you know, so we're, we're focusing on what I would call, like, democratizing the ability for people in the industry to invest in early stage auto tech.
- 7:53That's really it, you know?
- 7:54So it's, um, you know, getting away from the, the core fund, which we still have, but also, you know, on a deal by deal basis, when we find hot companies that the fund's gonna invest in, um, circulate those if we've got availabil- ability, and let, let, let, let people in the industry step up and invest directly into individual companies.
- 8:14Well, it's huge for... This is something that real estate has done really, really well at, kinda democratize investment opportunities for low level investors, um, people- Mm...
- 8:23that are just kinda, like, dipping their toe in.
- 8:26But I think this actually does two things for the industry, in my opinion, from, from my read, is one, like, if you are that, "Hey, I wanna tiptoe into investment," you also get the advantage of knowing what's on the horizon a lot better.
- 8:41Like, you get that deep level learning of going, "Okay, what, what are they doing? Why are they doing it? What problem are they solving?"
- 8:47And seeing it from, like, the ground level and not some sales pitch three years after they raised three rounds of funding, and you finally saw them at, at Digital Dealer, right? Mm-hmm.
- 8:56And so it's, I think it actually does two pieces. One, it allows people to get in and invest in auto, which keeps them more sticky in auto career pathing.
- 9:05And two, it allows auto to innovate faster because more people start to see early stage tech. So kudos, snaps all the way. Well, you know, I mean, it, it's, so I, I can't really take credit for it.
- 9:16You, look, look what's happening with fractional ownership and- Yeah... fractional participation right now.
- 9:21You've got, you know, everything from Masterworks, where I can buy a fraction of a Van Gogh, to, you know, Rally Road, which allows me to buy a fraction of a Porsche.
- 9:30Um, there's collectibles, Batman comics, you know, Kobe Bryant rookie cards, et cetera. So same sort of notion. It's like, you know, let's lean into this and see what the audience wants to do.
- 9:39But I've heard anecdotally, and I'm inter- very interested to, to hear sort of what your viewers think. But, uh, I've heard anecdotally that, um, people, like, love, you know, the, the taste of red meat, right?
- 9:50They- [laughs]... they fa- they fancy themselves gunslingers, right? Let me tick off the ones I think are gonna be the winners. Mm-hmm. And then let me get a taste of this. I think we can build a community around this.
- 9:58I think it'll be great for folks to, you know, figure out who else is invested in this early stage company, and I think it's gonna be really energizing to the industry.
- 10:06I think it's already energizing to the industry what you've been doing, and people are seeing... Like, you're just seeing more and more, um, dealers becoming investors, right?
- 10:15And I think, like you said, like, there's this, the, the next layer is looking at them being like, "Oh, wow, that looks like a lot of fun." Right?
- 10:24Especially when, like, some of these companies now are moving forward, right? And you're reporting on it so well. So you see even, like, I always look at Robo Tire, and that gets me really excited.
- 10:32It's, it's a company- Yeah [laughs]... you haven't seen. I wish we had a clip, and it's, like, these robot arms remove tires, and they put them back on.
- 10:38Because, you know, my background at the wheel repair, I'm like, "Oh, if only we had that thing." And so I think there's- [laughs]...
- 10:43another layer of people looking at the, the early movers and shakers and saying, like, just, "How can I move closer?" You're providing them an opportunity to move closer.
- 10:51And so now what I think is gonna happen is you're gonna kind of, like, make the circle bigger, and there's gonna be this third layer, right?
- 10:58That maybe consider being, and you're just broadening, and just every time that circle gets bigger, just proportionally more people come into the ecosystem.
- 11:05And, and look, everybody, with auto changing as much as it is, and as much money as there is floating around automotive right now, like, you giving it a channel to run into that's productive not only for the individuals but for the industry as a whole, um, man, you, you know how we roll at a SoDo.
- 11:22Like, we're all, we're all about dealer funded, dealer backed, you know, dealer, dealer, uh, you know, priorit- priorities being pushed to the front. So I'm excited with that as well. And holograms. And holograms.
- 11:35And holograms.
- 11:36And hey, I'd like to- Yeah, one of the things that we haven't talked about actually in your intel report that's kinda been in there, and it's a little bit toward the back half, but, um, I think you did, uh, it was probably, like, seven or eight months ago that you initially started doing this, but you indexed a lot of, um, uh, of, like, mobility type companies or third party marketplaces back to, was it something in, it was, like, back to 2019, is that right?
- 12:00Yep. Right. That you inve- uh, indexed them to a zero.
- 12:03Yeah.You know, for me, there, I, I'd love to hear kind of like what you're seeing in the trend data on companies that are more stable and how auto is reacting to the broader market.
- 12:17Um, because I, uh, there's, I, I'm sure there's some insights. 'Cause for me, they, they sometimes just kinda sit there. But, um, and it's just like you've gotta perceive.
- 12:25But what, what are your perceptions out of those indexes that, that people might wanna be looking at and paying, paying attention to as they see these publicly traded companies indexed against broader markets?
- 12:37No, it's great. Yeah. I mean, it started off with your, if you remember, um, I think we, we, we shared...
- 12:42I, I used to show this, um, proportional, what they call a tree map, of the market cap of Carvana versus all the other dealer groups, right? Which a year ago- Oh... Carvana was sitting at- [laughs]... 50 or $60 billion.
- 12:54And, you know, they, they've really f- um, you know, been down 95% or something. So that, that chart has changed.
- 12:59But also the other one that always resonates is if you look at all the publicly traded companies in the world, uh, that are in mobility, right?
- 13:06Automotive, dealer groups, uh, parts suppliers, whatever, and you look at all of them versus Tesla, T- Tesla's sitting over here at one point, like at $1.2 trillion.
- 13:15It was kind of almost the same, um, um, um, um, um, d- distribution.
- 13:19You had Tesla over here on the left with, you know, a market cap that, you know, it could have vacuumed up effectively every single other publicly traded mobility company in, in, on the face of the earth.
- 13:29Which, you know, after I built those, and people always like had this interesting reaction to it, just to put that proportional scale.
- 13:35I was like, "Okay, well let me start tracking," uh, to Kyle's point, "how these sh- shares have, have p- um, um, performed over, over the last, like, you know, uh, 15 years, 10 to 15 years.
- 13:45And, like, how has that performed, those baskets and sub-indices versus the S&P 500?" S- some benchmark, right, that all of us could invest in. And it's very interesting.
- 13:55You look at some of the indices, like autonomy and electrification. Many of these companies went, went public through SPACs. They've entirely fallen from grace, right? Yeah. They've entirely fallen.
- 14:05If you wanted to go buy, you know, any, any of the public companies in electrification infrastructure and, and, um, and autonomy, you can do it pennies on the dollar compared to what they were worth.
- 14:15But, you know, you look at so- some of the segments have stood up really, really well. The, the manufacturers.
- 14:19Up until very recently, the, the publicly traded dealer groups were doing very well compared to the S&P 500 over the last 10 or 15 years. So it's, it's interesting for me to watch.
- 14:28What, what I've thought about is, like, is there a, a future for us to think about building a derivative product? Meaning if I only wanna buy dealer groups, I could buy them all with one s- stock, right? An E- ETF. Yeah.
- 14:40Exchange Traded Fund. And then you could either go long or short on dealer groups- Mm-hmm... B2B marketplaces. Mm. Uh, you could go short on OEMs, right?
- 14:49If you, if you really believe, like, you know, the, the OEMs were gonna come under pressure, then you could, like, go short.
- 14:54If you believe that they were gonna make all this new money off of subscription services, it's all gonna be 100% profit margins- Yeah... you can go long on the- Yeah... OEMs. But- Oh, boy...
- 15:02so that's, that, that, that's the idea. I, I don't know quite what to do with it. I, I report on it every month. I, I wanna eventually make it interactive, like a stock tracker. Mm-hmm.
- 15:10And then people can build their portfolios. But I, I don't, I don't quite know what... So if, if an- any of your, the viewers have ideas about what I should do with this thing, I'm, I'm all ears. Yeah. I'm all ears.
- 15:18You heard it here first. [laughs] All right, now they know. Yeah. Thanks for giving us another thing- Let's do something with it... to think about. Yeah. [laughs] Right. [laughs] One more thing.
- 15:25Hey, before, before we go today, I wanna get your thoughts on some, two current issues. Um, first, rate increase. Yeah. What do you think the rate increase is, is going to do for us this n- last quarter?
- 15:37Uh, well, I mean, just continue to slow down the economy, right? That's the idea is, like, inflation is, like, out of control.
- 15:44Um, you know, the, the Fed has said and, and signaled that they're gonna con- continue to, to increase rates until they get inflation, um, u- under control. And, uh, we'll see how successful they are.
- 15:53Right now it just doesn't seem like it's slowing down at all. Prices keep increasing for a multitude of reasons. But I mean, I'm not an economist, but I don't know that they have any choice.
- 16:02I mean, you know, when goods are increasing by, by, you know, 10% year over year, everything from, you know, Big Macs to homes to cars are increasing at this rate that, you know, is squeezing out the average consumer from affordability.
- 16:14And then the consumer has to, like, tap on the brakes and they stop buying used cars, and we see what happens. Yeah. Okay. Last question. Yeah. Not, don't wanna get political. Stomp the chump, baby. Stomp the chump.
- 16:26Stomp the chump. Well, well what are your thoughts- Sure... on Elon Musk buying Twitter a- now that, that whole shenani- [laughs] What do... Because, like, how...
- 16:33[laughs] Well, 'cause you don't wanna put him in the spotlight. There you go. No, no, it's, it's good. Listen, so, so for, for... L- listen, I'll tell you what.
- 16:40So, so go online and read the last earnings call transcript, uh, Tesla's earnings call transcript. And, um, I just wanna, like, wa- watch my words here. Just, just read, read an earnings call transcript.
- 16:52I mean, the guy is just, like, not, not normal. [laughs] I'll just say that. [laughs] The guy is not normal. And, you know, I don't know how someone... You know, I know he has, he doesn't sleep.
- 17:01And he, he has unlimited bandwidth it seems. So, but he's trying to get m- rockets to go to Mars, electrify the US with wall chargers and, and, you know, solar panels and cars.
- 17:13And now he's gonna also be able to have 20 direct reports at Twitter and turn that business around? It just seems like at some point- I don't know, yeah... there's gotta be a day of reckoning. It's- Mm...
- 17:22the stock market, the Wall Street analysts have to say, "Well, hold on, dude. You're stretching yourself too thin." And it's just like, I just think it's a battle that he doesn't need to fight.
- 17:31I, I wonder about the bandwidth himself. I couldn't... Um, that's so well said. [laughs] So well said. Now, however- I feel it seems like Twitter's a philosophical thing for him, right? And he's even said it.
- 17:41Like, the, "I didn't, I didn't buy it to make money," right? "I didn't expect it to be easy. I didn't buy it to make money."
- 17:47But to your point, I don't understand what magic potion there is where you can have all these things going at once and still be moving forward. And look, i- it's hard to argue. Like, the rockets are doing their thing.
- 18:00Starlink's doing their thing, right? It's like Tesla's doing its thing. And, like, they all have bumps and bruises, but I mean, like- Th- th- but there's one thing, though, to keep in mind, though.
- 18:09So, so Tesla has zero marketing budget. Mm. Yes. That's what they- Tes- Te- Te- Yeah... Tesla's awareness has been built on the back of the crazy man tweeting. Yep. So there's something to it.
- 18:21I mean, he knows that his channel of acquisition- Mm-hmm... his channel of awareness, has been built on Twitter, and therefore, so there, there may be bigger things afoot here. Mm. Yeah. Well, I, I would say that, that,
- 18:33uh, that your customer acquisition costs have to be spread out over those separate, o- over all of the companies.
- 18:40And their brand attention that you get from building those companies across verticals, and then pushing that back to each company and see what now your customer acquisition cost is.
- 18:50Because it, I know it's not associated with a line item on marketing, but there's definitely a lot of marketing being done. No doubt. Exactly. Well, there you go.
- 18:57We've gone from holographs, or in the car hologram- [laughs]... to the auto intel report, everyone can invest in tech, now to Elon Musk buying Twitter. If that is not a Thursday, I don't know what is.
- 19:07Steve Greenfield, thank you so much. [upbeat music]