Latest / Journey to the Fringe / The first UFO casualty
Transcript
- 0:00From the unexplained to the mundane, come join us on a journey to the fringe.
- 0:12Hello and welcome to Journey to the Fringe, here today reminding you that fringe topics
- 0:17aren't always fun and games.
- 0:19Sometimes people get hurt, other times they lose a penis.
- 0:22Or even dare I say die?
- 0:25We are your podcast host, Taylor and Chelsea, here today covering a more graphic topic that
- 0:32viewer discretion is advised for.
- 0:34It is the topic of alien human mutilation, Chelsea.
- 0:38But I need to specifically say it's not the entire topic of alien human mutilation.
- 0:47It is but one account of it.
- 0:50And this account has come up on the podcast before.
- 0:54It came in the form of one John Lear's manifesto.
- 0:59And I got super interested in this because I was like, yes, we got it added to the list
- 1:04and it immediately got picked up because I said, my God, I need to know more about this
- 1:08and more about this I got for I have, I think what accounts to the whole story.
- 1:14Now I do have to warn you this will be a shorter episode likely just because with dead people,
- 1:20there's less eyewitness account of what happened.
- 1:25But people can I witness anything, especially if there's multiple dead people.
- 1:28But if you're in a graveyard, there's all these dead people.
- 1:32I'm just going to say dead people can I witness so long as you talk to them before they die,
- 1:38but not in this case because they died very or they died beforehand.
- 1:41Then anyhow, that's a whole other thing in the story.
- 1:44We are covering the story of Jonathan P. Love It, which happens in 1956.
- 1:51And my God, Chelsea, you're in for a treat because there's so much of the story.
- 1:55There are twists and there are turns and there are names that we have heard before that come
- 2:00up and I already feel like that's a red flag in your mind, but we're just going to go about.
- 2:05I am so excited.
- 2:07Can I just ask one piece of information before we start?
- 2:11Yes.
- 2:12Mr. Levin.
- 2:13Is he going to be okay?
- 2:14Is he alive or dead?
- 2:15I have no idea.
- 2:17I would say no.
- 2:18Okay, fair enough.
- 2:19That's a good answer.
- 2:20I think a reasonable answer is no.
- 2:24But you're going to understand once we get to it why I have to say it in that weird way.
- 2:28Okay, we're going to start with an account of this story.
- 2:31We're going to go right into it here.
- 2:33And this is a live person accounting this.
- 2:36These are live people.
- 2:37I have some late questions already.
- 2:39It's based on your starting of this episode.
- 2:42Yeah, I know.
- 2:43But this is where it goes.
- 2:45I'd like to witness this.
- 2:46And yeah, actually that one's going to get answered fairly quickly.
- 2:49So we're on a military base and a search crew of two pilots was sent out to the fields
- 2:55south of the central White Sands testing region on one chilly morning on March of 1956
- 3:01to look for any debris that might have fallen from a missile test conducted the previous
- 3:05evening.
- 3:06Major William Cunningham and Sergeant Jonathan Lovett were the men in question.
- 3:10Those men were affiliated with the adjacent Holloman Air Force Base's Air Force missile
- 3:15command at around 300.
- 3:17The two men arrived at the place and they got out of their Jeep and lived drowsily into
- 3:21the search area with flashlights.
- 3:24They had completed the same work numerous times before with varying degrees of success
- 3:28and boredom.
- 3:29Following a few minutes of pacing next to one another, the two men eventually parted
- 3:33ways with Cunningham continuing to move forward while Lovett vanished over the top of a nearby
- 3:38sand dune.
- 3:39Cunningham had no idea where the sergeant was going because he still needed to tell
- 3:43him and his superior assumed it was probably a bathroom break.
- 3:46But after waiting for a few minutes, Lovett still hadn't shown up so Cunningham halted
- 3:51what he was doing and began to go back to where the two men had split off.
- 3:55The high pitched scream of his subordinate suddenly pierced the darkness and he heard
- 4:00something that would send shivers down his spine.
- 4:02A scream of pure agony echoed throughout the black desert fields surrounding him.
- 4:07Cunningham ran over to the crest of the sand dune fully aware that Lovett must be in distress
- 4:11and presuming it was consequence of a snake bite or some other kind of animal attack only
- 4:15to be faced with a unique, albeit horrifying, scene.
- 4:19Cunningham has maintained that he had witnessed Jonathan Lovett being transported to an alien
- 4:23aircraft.
- 4:24Cunningham could see a curious metallic disk hovering about 15-20 feet above the ground,
- 4:31about 30 feet from where he stood.
- 4:33The craft reflected in the weak beam of the flashlight held tightly in his right hand.
- 4:38The major had never seen anything like it, completely silent resembling neither a vehicle
- 4:42nor a piece of military equipment.
- 4:46Cunningham directed his torch beam towards something, slithering and flexing like a snake
- 4:50at the base of the device and he could see that it was a strong steel cable of some sort.
- 4:55The officer was shocked to discover that the cable was wrapped around one of Lovett's
- 5:00legs when he pointed his torch at the end of the cable after being startled back into
- 5:04reality by another horrifying screen.
- 5:06The Air Force Sergeant made a valiant effort to release himself from the heavy metal flex
- 5:11wrapped around his leg by kicking and slashing with his hands, but it appeared that his efforts
- 5:15were in vain and as Cunningham watched an increasing terror, the cable retracted quickly, pulling
- 5:21the trapped airman through the rocky terrain and then upwards towards the disk space.
- 5:25Paralyzed by fear, Cunningham watched helplessly as Lovett was relentlessly drawn up into the
- 5:30base of the puffing craft.
- 5:32Before he vanished from view, the sergeant's pharantic eyes briefly locked with his own
- 5:37while pleading for assistance.
- 5:38The disk rose silently into the overcast skies with a faint click and Cunningham stumbled
- 5:43and tripped his way back to the waiting jeep as he tried to comprehend what he had just
- 5:48seen.
- 5:49He yelled into the radio that Lovett had been stolen and an airplane was leaving the scene.
- 5:52Within minutes, every unit and resource of the Air Force was swarming in that direction
- 5:56but all they discovered was the major slumped over on the ground and wobbling in shock.
- 6:01In the days that followed, airmen searched every square inch of the area around the suspected
- 6:05kidnapping site but in vain.
- 6:07On the evening of the event, the crew on duty at the site control tower verified that
- 6:12unknown radar contact had shown up on their equipment.
- 6:15Still, it was moving too swiftly for any potential counteractions to be taken and a search group
- 6:21operating about 10 miles down range from where Lovett had vanished had been questioning Cunningham
- 6:25for three days when Jonathan Lovett's body was found or what remained of it.
- 6:30Nobody participating in the later investigation had ever seen the horrifying mutilation done
- 6:34to Lovett's remains.
- 6:35There was tongue, eyes, and a sizable section of jaw were now missing and a clean incision
- 6:40had been created from the point of his jaw around to the back of his larynx.
- 6:45With what appeared to be exceptional surgical expertise, the penis had been removed and
- 6:50the anus seemed to have been plucked out.
- 6:52The coroner's report also mentioned the absence of any signs of organ failure or vascular
- 6:57collapse elsewhere in the body, which was troublesome given that the body had no blood
- 7:02at all.
- 7:03The report the officer tasked with investigating the case contained further peculiarities.
- 7:08Several paratory birds were also discovered dead at the scene where the remains were found,
- 7:12having perished while attempting to feast on the carcass.
- 7:15Go ahead.
- 7:16Oh no question.
- 7:17Okay.
- 7:18Just statement.
- 7:19I just couldn't help but getting hung up on the fact that his anus seemed to have been
- 7:24plucked out.
- 7:26I don't know how you pluck an anus.
- 7:27That is what appeared like that.
- 7:28If they said plucked a penis, I would understand what they meant.
- 7:33Yeah.
- 7:34You can pluck a penis.
- 7:35You can't pluck an anus.
- 7:36You gotta think that if you're seeing it, it would clearly be like, oh, that's been
- 7:40plucked.
- 7:41That's the only way to describe it.
- 7:42Yeah.
- 7:43That's the only way you could describe it if it's been plucked, it's been plucked.
- 7:45That was the only thing that's been plucked on his body.
- 7:49The verbs that they're using, verbs is the word that I'm looking for, right?
- 7:54Adjectives.
- 7:55Adjectives.
- 7:56I think verb, if you're talking about plucked, is correct.
- 7:58But overall, adjectives I think is correct.
- 8:00Yeah.
- 8:01That are being used to describe this are plentiful.
- 8:05Yes.
- 8:06Almost as if they're the parts that are being added to the story.
- 8:09Okay.
- 8:10Interesting thing to say.
- 8:12Yes.
- 8:13Okay.
- 8:14I can't imagine that's foreshadowing at all.
- 8:16No, not at all.
- 8:17Oh no.
- 8:18It was also in surprisingly decent shape despite being discovered in the open in one of the
- 8:22country's warmest and harshest climates.
- 8:25Now that love is body had been found, Cunningham was taken into custody in the case of killing
- 8:28him.
- 8:29Military prosecutors claim that the major had killed his subordinate, made up the tale
- 8:33of the kidnapping and mutilated the body to make the lies seem more credible when the
- 8:37matter was brought before a tribunal.
- 8:39It did cross my mind.
- 8:41Wouldn't it be fun if something else happened and you're just like, oh, I saw like this
- 8:46craft came down and like, I'm just going to go.
- 8:48I'm going to say that it was a human mutilation.
- 8:51There is a UFO.
- 8:52I'm just going to do it.
- 8:53And I'm just going to murder this guy?
- 8:55Yeah.
- 8:56Like it crossed my mind.
- 8:57Like at what point.
- 8:58I don't like him anyways.
- 9:00Yeah.
- 9:01At what point are you just like, I'm just going to fucking see if they believe it.
- 9:04Maybe.
- 9:05I don't want to admit what I did.
- 9:06Okay.
- 9:07Fair enough.
- 9:08Yeah.
- 9:09Human mutilation.
- 9:10Yeah.
- 9:11Aliens.
- 9:12I've heard about these cattle things.
- 9:13So like humans, that's not that far away.
- 9:16No one's ever heard of this.
- 9:17This is, I'm a guard and I'm just going to try it and see where it lands me.
- 9:22Not a bad plan.
- 9:23Yeah.
- 9:24Just a thought.
- 9:25Just a thought.
- 9:26I'm just thinking here.
- 9:27Just a thought.
- 9:28Okay.
- 9:29I'm not going to be alone with you in like deep forest anytime soon or anywhere where
- 9:32this could present itself on a hike per se in the dark.
- 9:35Yes.
- 9:36I mean, okay.
- 9:37But that's fair enough statement.
- 9:40It should come as no surprise that the court quickly rejected this argument and after being
- 9:44freed without being charged, Cunningham was permitted to quit the Air Force with an honorable
- 9:48discharge.
- 9:49Honorable.
- 9:50Jonathan Lovett's death has never been fully addressed.
- 9:52The US government has a solid and longstanding policy of not publicly commenting on reports
- 9:58of encounters between military and UFOs and as we have learned from earlier tales.
- 10:03We should note where this story comes to light is in the grudge reports, which Chelsea, I
- 10:09don't expect you to remember fully.
- 10:11We covered this, I think in our second episode ever project grudge, which leads into project
- 10:16blue book.
- 10:17Now project grudge had, I should say 14 reports, one through 14.
- 10:23I do remember this.
- 10:25Most of them are public record.
- 10:26Allegedly, report 13 doesn't exist.
- 10:29And this is the report from which this story comes from.
- 10:32This is 13.
- 10:33This is from report 13 of project grudge.
- 10:37We got it here exclusively.
- 10:39Sure.
- 10:40Absolutely.
- 10:43So what basically happens is this man by the name of William English alleges that he read
- 10:50project grudges report 13, which this story comes from and he tells the story.
- 10:55And this is where all of the later accounts come from is William English's account of
- 11:01this story, which he read in project grudges report 13.
- 11:05It should be noted, despite the fact that there are project grudge one through 14 and
- 11:11one through 12 fully exist and 14 fully exist.
- 11:15It's not that report 13 is top secret.
- 11:18There's no account of it.
- 11:20Usually if something is top secret, they'll say like, if you do a FOIA request that this
- 11:24there's information that we cannot disclose.
- 11:26That doesn't happen.
- 11:27The government's position is report 13 doesn't exist.
- 11:30I don't know how I feel about that.
- 11:32I found an interesting follow up to this, which Chelsea, you're going to get some really
- 11:36good information from this.
- 11:38How does it, how does it exist with project grudge if the government says it doesn't
- 11:42exist?
- 11:43Project grudge does exist.
- 11:45Project grudge reports do exist.
- 11:48They fully admit it.
- 11:49There were 13 reports numbered one to 12 and then 14.
- 11:54And there's just nothing about report 13.
- 11:57But how come they have it?
- 11:59The government says it.
- 12:00Same English alleges that he read report 13 as well as someone else, which we'll get
- 12:05to later in this story.
- 12:07Everybody's in agreement.
- 12:08Project grudge exists.
- 12:09No question about that.
- 12:10Yeah, I know.
- 12:11I know.
- 12:12Project grudge reports exist.
- 12:14However, there's no evidence that there's a report 13 despite there being weirdly enough
- 12:19a report 14.
- 12:20Okay.
- 12:21Does that make sense?
- 12:22Are we on the same page?
- 12:23No, it completely makes sense, but I don't understand.
- 12:26It's still weird.
- 12:27I agree.
- 12:28Why it's happening this way.
- 12:29Like why?
- 12:30Like where are we getting the story from if it doesn't exist?
- 12:34Yeah.
- 12:35And we're going to get to that.
- 12:36Yeah.
- 12:37Well, it's not here saying what's his face isn't it?
- 12:39Is it?
- 12:40Hey, don't go speculating yet.
- 12:42This is a true story from a William English, which is a name that has not come up yet.
- 12:47Oh, no.
- 12:48Okay.
- 12:49So my confusion and where the fuck did the story come from is going to go somewhere.
- 12:54So anyhow, I found this great breakdown on a skeptical forum online of this entire story,
- 13:01which I think just reading it in full fully encapsulates the entire idea behind it and
- 13:05brings it back so much to what we've been talking about.
- 13:08So there is no mention or record of a report 13 ever being produced.
- 13:12If it were to exist, it is unclear whether it would have been a continuation of the
- 13:16regular monthly summary reports or another special report as with report 14.
- 13:21The existence of reports one through 12 and then 14 was well known.
- 13:24In fact, a book was published about report 14 in 1956 entitled Flying Saucers and Analysis
- 13:30of the Air Force Project Blue Book Special Report number 14 by Leon Davidson.
- 13:35So to look at this origin of the story, it comes from William English who stated in 1977
- 13:41he was given a document to analyze labeled grudge slash blue book report number 13.
- 13:47He recorded his memories of the report onto two cassette tapes and these were transcribed
- 13:52into letters which were circulated among the UFO community in the 1980s.
- 14:06It is really weird.
- 14:07No matter what at the end of the day, I agree it is weird.
- 14:11There's not a 13.
- 14:12However, Chelsea, I'm just going to say this now it's going to come up later.
- 14:1613 is not a weird number to skip in Western culture.
- 14:20I was just going to say that places don't have 13 floors.
- 14:24That's generally it.
- 14:25That's generally it.
- 14:27But when I'm counting generally I don't just skip numbers and then just move on with life,
- 14:32especially when it's like a project for the government that I'm working on.
- 14:36Usually I want to include all the numbers.
- 14:39Professionally speaking, I agree.
- 14:41But at the same time, I don't think this is a realm ruled by logic either.
- 14:45I mean mostly, but no.
- 14:48Okay, let's keep seeing where this goes.
- 14:50Not liking where it's going, like usual.
- 14:53Text file typed in by UFO net one.
- 14:55Original document is eight neatly handwritten pages of which photocopies have been circulated
- 15:00in the UFO research community.
- 15:02Note, what follows is purportedly the recollection of an intelligence analyst who was given an
- 15:06assignment to prepare an analysis of the Grudge 13 report.
- 15:10The timeframe in which this occurred was July 1977 with the original Grudge report having
- 15:15been published in 1953.
- 15:17The Grudge 13 report was made up of 624 typed pages on white paper with gray cover.
- 15:24This memorandum as it has become known was first circulated in early 1981.
- 15:29It seems the letters were then typed up and uploaded to the internet.
- 15:33The uploader from the first website being William Cooper, also known as Bill Cooper,
- 15:39also known as very good friend of John Lear, who became Proto Alex Jones and dies in a
- 15:45gunfight with the friends.
- 15:47I remember him from behind the bastard.
- 15:49It's not a journey to the friend.
- 15:51Well, actually he did come up in the journey to the friend type.
- 15:54Yeah, he did.
- 15:55But anyhow, the most important part in this story is William English, whose description
- 16:01of the report is this.
- 16:02Publication was withdrawn from pouch.
- 16:04It measured approximately eight inches by 11 inches with gray cover.
- 16:08Basically bound paperback style similar to technical manuals.
- 16:12Across the center front, it read Grudge slash Blue Book Report number 13.
- 16:17It was dated 1953 to 1963.
- 16:20In the lower right hand corner was AFSN 2246-3.
- 16:25An upper left hand corner was the word annotated.
- 16:29Across the front upper right hand corner to lower left hand corner was red tape indicating
- 16:33code red security measures.
- 16:35Across the front was stamped in red ink, top secret need to know only crypto clearance
- 16:4014 required.
- 16:41Inside front cover upper left hand corner were handwritten notations in ink, which were
- 16:46blacked out by black felt pen.
- 16:48Now that's a subscription of this document when he first got it.
- 16:52It should be noted this is clearly different from the other 12 reports.
- 16:58So he says it was titled Grudge slash Blue Book Report number 13.
- 17:02I'd call my attention.
- 17:04The other reports all say it's Project Blue Book Report number and then the report number
- 17:09formerly Project Grudge.
- 17:11That's how they're all titled.
- 17:13Except this one.
- 17:14That's actually one thing that stood out to me.
- 17:16It wouldn't have been like Grudge slash Project Blue Book because it was one or the other
- 17:21at the time.
- 17:22Well, it was one or the other and then it transferred into the other.
- 17:24There was never a time where it was both, which is a great point.
- 17:28I mean, it doesn't make sense for it to be both at one time.
- 17:31No, exactly.
- 17:32That right there is a big flag.
- 17:34The original person who brings up the story mistitles it or at least this one is significantly
- 17:40differently titled from the ones coming before and after it.
- 17:43Next up, very strange thing.
- 17:45English said this document is 624 pages, which is significantly different than the other
- 17:5213 reports, which are roughly 20 pages.
- 17:57Maybe that's why they excluded it.
- 17:59Two don't.
- 18:00Yeah.
- 18:01Yeah.
- 18:02I mean, both the juices.
- 18:03We put it in 13.
- 18:04Yeah.
- 18:05Because surely nobody's going to notice we skipped a number.
- 18:08Yeah, exactly.
- 18:09So he also, he gives a full table of concepts of this.
- 18:13I'm just going to go through what he says is in this entire document.
- 18:16Part one on the design of generators to accomplish strain free molecular translation.
- 18:20Part two, the generation of space time continuums closed open and folded.
- 18:25Part three on the generation of temporary pseudo acceleration locus.
- 18:30Part one chapter one.
- 18:32One criteria for a simple generator and control system referring to equation 17 appendix a
- 18:37part two chapter one continuation of Einstein's theory of relativity to final conclusion.
- 18:42Part three chapter one possible application of Einstein's theory of relativity at conclusion
- 18:47part one chapter two reports of UFO encounters classifications close encounters of the first
- 18:52kind subtitle sightings and witnesses part two chapter two close encounters of the second
- 18:57kind subtitle UFO sightings witness within close proximity.
- 19:01Part three chapter two close encounters of the third kind subtitle to UFO encounters
- 19:05and extraterrestrial life forms witnessed and personal encounters subtitles slash colonies
- 19:11relocations thereof case histories chapter three part one military encounters with UFOs
- 19:17chapter three part two military reports concerning sightings on radar and electronic surveillance
- 19:23of UFOs subsection two analysis report J.L. and Heineck lieutenant colonel friend.
- 19:28So there's a lot going on in this and anybody who's listened to our episodes and has some
- 19:34sort of weird memory thing which is good we need you on our side and please tell us when
- 19:40we're doing these things that we need to be linking but it should be noted that this
- 19:45support came out in 1963.
- 19:48The idea of close encounters of the first second and third kind don't exist at this
- 19:52time J.L. and Heineck does create it but he never actually formally talks about it in
- 19:57any way until 1972 in his book the UFO experience the scientific inquiry which is much later
- 20:03that's a pretty big gap but but before this guy is talking about it in 1977 importantly
- 20:10which is pretty well around the time that he came out with it.
- 20:13So whilst Heineck was a scientific consultant for Project Blue Book in the 50s the scale
- 20:17wasn't created until two decades later by Heineck and the U.S. Air Force certainly wasn't
- 20:22categorizing according to the system which didn't exist yet and particularly in only
- 20:27this one report too it would be weird for this to just show up in one report and then
- 20:31not appear again for 19 years.
- 20:34There's quite a few things that are showing up who lean in this report not other reports.
- 20:38And in fact in his follow-up book the Heineck UFO report which followed the Blue Book reports
- 20:44he didn't use these terms anywhere so he actually wrote books prior to 1972 about these reports
- 20:51without using these terms at all.
- 20:53But in any event English does recount what he remembers of this Jonathan Love It story
- 20:59in his own words and this is his version of the story.
- 21:02The report gave a clear indication of reports of human mediation most notably was a case
- 21:06witnessed by Air Force personnel in which an Air Force Sergeant E6 by the name of Jonathan
- 21:11P. Love It was observed being taken captive aboard what appeared to be a UFO at White
- 21:15Sands Missile Test Range in New Mexico.
- 21:18This abduction took place in March of 1956 at about 0300 local and was witnessed by Major
- 21:23William Cunningham of the United States Air Force Missile Test Command near Hallamon Air
- 21:27Force Base.
- 21:28Major Cunningham and Sergeant Love It were out in a field downrange from launch sites
- 21:32looking for debris from a missile test when Sergeant Love It went over the ridge of a
- 21:37small dune and was out of sight for a time.
- 21:40Major Cunningham heard Sergeant Love It scream and what was described as a terror of agony
- 21:44and the Major thinking the Sergeant had been bitten by a snake or something ran over the
- 21:48crest of the dune and saw Sergeant Love It being dragged into what appeared to him as
- 21:52silvery disc-like object which hovered in the air approximately 15-20 feet.
- 21:57Major Cunningham described what appeared to be a long snake-like object which was wrapped
- 22:02around the Sergeant's leg and was dragging him to the craft.
- 22:05Major Cunningham admittedly froze as the Sergeant was dragged inside the disc and observed the
- 22:09disc going up into the sky very quickly.
- 22:12Major Cunningham got to the Jeep radio and reported the incident to missile control whereupon
- 22:17Mollilé Control confirmed a radar sighting.
- 22:21Search parties went out into the field looking for Sergeant Love It.
- 22:24Major Cunningham's report was taken and he was admitted to the White Sands Base Disciplinary
- 22:28for observation.
- 22:29The search for Sergeant Love It was continued for three days at the end of which his nude
- 22:32body was found approximately 10 miles downrange.
- 22:35The body had been mutilated, the tongue had been removed from lower portions of the jaw,
- 22:39an incision had been made just under the tip of his chin and extended all the way down
- 22:43to his esophagus and larynx, he had been emasculated and his eyes had been removed.
- 22:48Also his anus had been removed and there was comments in the report on the apparent surgical
- 23:01skill in the removal of these items including the genitalia.
- 23:04The reports commented that the anus and genitalia had been removed as though a plug which in
- 23:09the case of the anus extended all the way to the colon.
- 23:18Pulled out like a plug or plucked in my mind are the same thing.
- 23:25Too much.
- 23:28There was no sign of blood within the system.
- 23:30The initial autopsy report confirmed that the system had been completely drained of
- 23:33blood and that there was no vascular collapse due to death by bleeding.
- 23:37Some comment added that this was an unusual event because anybody who dies or has complete
- 23:42loss of blood there is vascular collapse.
- 23:45Also noted when the body was found there were a number of dead predatory type birds within
- 23:50the area who apparently had died after trying to partake of the sergeant's body.
- 23:53There were a number of extremely grisly black and white photos from all indications the
- 23:58body had been exposed to the elements for at least a day or two.
- 24:01The new Mexico sun in the desert is extremely hot and debilitating under the normal circumstances.
- 24:06So that's his original story.
- 24:08That's so funny.
- 24:10One that we have such differing opinions of plug and plug.
- 24:14Number two, a plug and plug danis.
- 24:16Well pulled out like a plug removed as though a plug in my mind is plucking.
- 24:21Okay when you put it that way.
- 24:23Because that's the term had been removed as though a plug.
- 24:26So I don't like that as much as I like hearing that it was plucked out.
- 24:30Yeah.
- 24:31Makes it a little bit more disturbed.
- 24:32I already said it right off the bat.
- 24:34That gives me the shudder.
- 24:35The only real difference between that first story which is the more recent, it's from
- 24:39one of the more recent conspiracy sites.
- 24:42There's no difference except plug.
- 24:44Except for the adjectives and verbs.
- 24:46Yeah.
- 24:47Oh you're right.
- 24:48Other than that it was exactly the same.
- 24:49I was like that.
- 24:50They added some flowery words.
- 24:52And that's why I wanted to read that first one off the bat and then come back to this
- 24:55and this is the original story.
- 24:57Anyhow English added a few extra details in an interview he gave with a man named John
- 25:02Lear.
- 25:03Namely that quote Major Cunningham was initially accused of murdering Jonathan Lovett.
- 25:09But charges were later dropped.
- 25:10Why?
- 25:11Because they thought the alien.
- 25:12Because this guy had no way of draining his blood.
- 25:15Okay.
- 25:16I can see it.
- 25:17One more sentence.
- 25:18But anyhow that's where the John Lear part of it comes in.
- 25:21Okay.
- 25:22The White Sands missile range.
- 25:23No.
- 25:24I'm just saying okay.
- 25:26Okay.
- 25:27The White Sands missile range is a real place and does border hall in an air force base.
- 25:31However there appear to be no records that people named Major William Cunningham or Air
- 25:36Force Sergeant E6 Jonathan P. Lovett ever existed.
- 25:40Great.
- 25:41The only Major General William Cunningham from this time period was stationed in the
- 25:46Pacific during the 50s.
- 25:48Was Army not Air Force and was promoted to Major in the 60s.
- 25:52Ultimately it should be concluded that the incident never happened.
- 25:55The only source for it is that of William English.
- 25:58But considering his recounting of the report, has it not matched legitimate reports and
- 26:03used terms that did not exist at the time, it's likely to be a fake.
- 26:07Is William English?
- 26:08William English worked for the British Air Force I believe.
- 26:13It's gonna come up a little later.
- 26:14It should be noted however Bill Cooper saw the same report 13.
- 26:18Weird how he sees these reports that are all fake.
- 26:21Is it in hypnosis?
- 26:22However in Cooper's report he only states that he saw a document entitled Project Grudge.
- 26:27He makes no mention if it had been labeled for report 13 or mentioning Project Blue Book
- 26:31and no mention of it containing the story about Lovett.
- 26:35Eventually the writer here found himself in possession of two documents, one called Project
- 26:38Grudge and another called Operation Majority.
- 26:41Project Grudge contained the history of alien involvement since about 1936 and it began
- 26:46talking about Germany's involvement with the crashed discs that they had recovered in
- 26:501936.
- 26:51And we're attempting to duplicate technology.
- 26:52When Project Grudge, William Cooper, saw photographs of the dead aliens and of the craft.
- 26:57I saw photographs of live aliens.
- 26:59I saw photographs of off-top seas of our internal organs is what he says.
- 27:03I saw photographs of aliens designated EB which is a term that just keeps coming up.
- 27:09Who was held in captivity from 1949 to 1952 when he died.
- 27:13I saw the history of what had been able to put together at that time from incidents from
- 27:17the 1800s that involved aliens and their crafts.
- 27:21As detailed, Bill Cooper was then one of the people who typed up online John Lear and William
- 27:26English's account of Grudge 13 and their interviews.
- 27:29He stated, this report was typed onto disc verbatim from the original document which
- 27:34was sent by John Lear via Federal Express and arrived on October 8th, 1988 by Bill Cooper.
- 27:41I Bill Cooper, do swear that no changes were made and do swear that this is an exact verbatim
- 27:46copy of the original.
- 27:48No idea who he's swearing to.
- 27:50It doesn't seem clear.
- 27:53And just so that everybody's aware, this is not legal advice, but if you just state that,
- 27:59that has no legal ramifications.
- 28:01Is it like those people on Facebook sharing like I don't agree to let Facebook share?
- 28:07I do not consent, yes.
- 28:09Because you've already agreed to the exact same impact.
- 28:14It seems that after Bill Cooper saw Bill English's report, the two got in touch and at that point
- 28:20Bill Cooper claimed that what he had seen was in fact the same report 13 that Bill English
- 28:25had seen.
- 28:27Once again, time has proven to be an ally in that evidence has come to light over the
- 28:31past several years that substantiated everything that was initially said about reviewing report
- 28:3613.
- 28:37In addition, one other person, Bill Cooper, formerly of the United States Naval Intelligence
- 28:40section, CINCPAC, has come forward and admitted viewing an earlier version of the Grudge Blue
- 28:48Book Report 13.
- 28:50This Bill Cooper's original claims were just to have seen something called Project Grudge,
- 28:54it was only after he read Bill English's report that he switched to claiming they saw
- 28:59the same Blue Book Report 13.
- 29:01I think it's reasonable to dismiss Bill Cooper's claims as absolutely false, particularly when
- 29:06everything we know about Bill Cooper is he just lies about what he was briefed on in
- 29:10red while he was in military, which again leads back to Bill English as being the sole
- 29:15source of the story.
- 29:16English himself is known something of a grifter in the UFO community as well.
- 29:21In his book Fact, Fiction, and Flying Saucers, the truth behind the misinformation, distortion,
- 29:27and derision by debunkers, government agencies, and government con men noted UFO researcher
- 29:31Stanton Friedman recalls English's involvement in the 1981 Cash Lundrum UFO incident.
- 29:38The Cash Lundrum incident is one of the few incidents to have left forensic evidence in
- 29:43the form of burns and psych-physiological effects suffered by witnesses, which led to
- 29:47a $20 million lawsuit against the US government.
- 29:51It was one of the more credible sightings of the decade.
- 29:54But unfortunately, according to Friedman, English, who was an initial investigator of
- 29:58the incident as a member of the aerial phenomena research organization APRO, quote, sold his
- 30:03story to a tabloid and was expelled from ACRO for violating confidentiality, end quote.
- 30:08The Cash Lundrum story first appeared in public on the cover of the Weekly World News, a less
- 30:13than credible weekly tabloid.
- 30:15In the late 80s, English's story of his experiences with the alleged captain in the Army Special
- 30:21Forces during Vietnam and later as an alleged intelligence analyst at RAF, Chick Sands,
- 30:26began to gain attention with the UFO researchers.
- 30:28Cooper's support of English's claims bolstered his credibility.
- 30:32Cooper and English both gained prominence around the same time.
- 30:37Around the same time, John Lear began making inroads to the UFO community and promoting
- 30:41the story of Bob Bazar.
- 30:42One of the more atlandish and questionable conspiracy theories in the late 1980s was
- 30:46a document uploaded to the UFO bulletin boards called Krill Papers, which came up in our
- 30:51John Lear episodes.
- 30:52He just made them up.
- 30:53They were just a fun fanfic.
- 30:56Cooper drew to his forum, claimed that he had seen copies of the Krill Papers during
- 30:59his time in the Navy, and in 1990, Don Ecker, director of research for UFO magazines wrote
- 31:05an expose about Cooper calling him a fraud and questioning his business practices and
- 31:09research methods.
- 31:10In 1991, English made what was essentially an early internet call out post claiming that
- 31:15the Krill Papers were a fraud perpetrated by Lear to expose the gullibility of the UFO
- 31:19community.
- 31:20Cooper lash out at English claiming that he was the real fraud and that his claim of service
- 31:25in special forces were exaggerated.
- 31:27Given that English was born in 52, making him 18 when he claimed to be a special force
- 31:33captain in Vietnam in the 70s, there may be some merit to Cooper's claims of stolen
- 31:37valor.
- 31:38Cooper also accused everyone who disagreed with him, including John Lear, George Knapp,
- 31:41Staten Freeman, and other notable members of the UFO community of being government agents
- 31:45and or Freemasons.
- 31:48English largely disappears at this point from the UFO community.
- 31:51He did have a short-lived campaign for a New Mexico Senate and in 2018, started a GoFundMe
- 31:57to raise $10,000 to write a book about his Vietnam experience.
- 32:00The secret history of Cooper English debacle is largely forgotten as the story is one of
- 32:14unpleasant community infighting and of course complete fabrication.
- 32:18Much of the debate took place on bulletin board systems, early predecessors of modern
- 32:22internet and many of those threads that formed on the online UFO communities in the 80s had
- 32:26been lost to history.
- 32:27Though there are a number of sites that have archived these discussions, the fact that
- 32:30much of the UFO community history has been lost is troubling because now outlets like
- 32:35the History Channel are uncritically repeating accounts of some of these dubious figures
- 32:39from the fields.
- 32:41And guess what?
- 32:42History Channel is one of those ones that has an in-depth story about Jonathan Lovett.
- 32:47Although that's not the one I chose to read, they do actually have a fairly balanced story
- 32:51on it.
- 32:52And they do that does include like four sides that nobody can okay.
- 32:57Yeah, there's nothing to validate that this is promising.
- 33:01I am surprised that this guy has not come up for us before and until this point as he
- 33:07seems kind of tied in with everybody.
- 33:09But this is it for him.
- 33:11Yes, but it's really just for this one story.
- 33:13This is it for him.
- 33:14Yes, he just kind of says this, which makes me think that he probably did really murder
- 33:19this person.
- 33:20But he wasn't involved in the UFO community at all.
- 33:23I do just want to come to his defense a little bit here.
- 33:26He was born in 52.
- 33:28So at the time of the murder, he was one.
- 33:31I don't think he was the one who did it.
- 33:33But wait, who was supposed to do the murder?
- 33:36Cuttingham.
- 33:37Then what the fuck's he doing?
- 33:38He was the guy who read the grudge report.
- 33:39Why?
- 33:40Just cuz.
- 33:41Okay, I got my wires crossed there for a second.
- 33:43So if he didn't do the murder, he just came in for a second and then left.
- 33:49He's the only one who recounts the story.
- 33:52This is where all of the original stories come from.
- 33:54And it should be noted that neither Cunningham nor Love It seemed to actually have existed.
- 34:00This is weird.
- 34:01Why?
- 34:02Like why?
- 34:03I have no idea, but it just seems to kind of go in line with things that we learned about
- 34:07John Lear and Bill Cooper.
- 34:09Right, it comes back up.
- 34:10From the last few episodes.
- 34:11This is messed up.
- 34:12Yeah.
- 34:13It's just kind of right in line with all that.
- 34:16But then I forgot that John Lear was in there.
- 34:19Yeah.
- 34:20Okay.
- 34:21Then especially everything going around with the animal mediation at the time.
- 34:24Like it fits in perfectly with that.
- 34:26It's just an elaboration on that story.
- 34:28Do we know this guy actually existed?
- 34:30English definitely did exist.
- 34:32I was wondering because it got tied back to Lear.
- 34:34He ran for Senate.
- 34:36Oh, oh.
- 34:37And he had ego fund me.
- 34:39And he also wrote a book.
- 34:40So he appears to at least have some evidence that he existed.
- 34:43What a weird thing.
- 34:44Okay.
- 34:45He did serve in the military.
- 34:46That is true.
- 34:47However, there is questions about.
- 34:49Like what his actual role is.
- 34:51I don't know what to make of this.
- 34:52What do you make of it?
- 34:54I make of everything that I've learned about John Lear and Bill Cooper and that they get
- 34:58a lot of stories to change the view of aliens come forward during their time.
- 35:04This being one of them.
- 35:05Because before they really came along, it was just this question of like these mysterious
- 35:09people and it was more so fearful things and somebody dying to aliens and being cored
- 35:14and plucked from their anus.
- 35:17It's worrisome.
- 35:18You're a weird choice there.
- 35:19That would be my choice to.
- 35:21I don't like plug.
- 35:22Chelsea, what do you think of the story?
- 35:23I'm still trying to process it to be honest with you.
- 35:27Okay.
- 35:28As you can tell, I'm trying to work through my thoughts on it.
- 35:31But in the end comes back to John Lear and Bill Cooper.
- 35:35It's obviously made up, but I'm just trying to like the why doesn't is not there for me.
- 35:40It just kind of seems pointless.
- 35:43That's a fair point.
- 35:44I don't know as soon as Bill Cooper gets a hold of it and he just like, yeah, of course,
- 35:49if he says he read it is probably a lot.
- 35:53From everything I'm learning about this guy, I mean, good story.
- 35:56Nonetheless, I'm just trying to process the why because it's the why and everything.
- 36:01That is the weird thing, but he also tried to sell UFO stories to the press prior to
- 36:05this.
- 36:06So I think he could have just been trying to make it.
- 36:08I was trying like it didn't make sense to me why he just shows up and then he seems to
- 36:12have a very minimal mark and then leaves.
- 36:15I know it's weird and I don't think we're going to get any more things from him, honestly.
- 36:19It doesn't seem like he does a very short flash in the pan.
- 36:22Okay.
- 36:23But yeah, that's I mean, I enjoyed it.
- 36:25That was a great story connected back to the usual players that we find popping up now
- 36:30that I surprisingly did not know about before doing this podcast.
- 36:36And they really do play so much of what the average person knows about UFOs.
- 36:41I wouldn't say the average person.
- 36:43What the average UFO enthusiast knows.
- 36:46I don't know if you were like, what do you know about UFOs?
- 36:50I bet you it would tie back to aliens being found at Roswell.
- 36:54Maybe at least something the average person would know.
- 36:58See I don't.
- 36:59Hmm.
- 37:00That's a good question.
- 37:01We can put this on as a poll.
- 37:03You know, it's not a spotify.
- 37:04That's going to be a bias poll though.
- 37:07It is going to be a bias poll.
- 37:08But also I said my viewpoint is UFO enthusiasts and I actually have no idea what fan base
- 37:14is.
- 37:15Who's listening?
- 37:16Yeah.
- 37:17How do you pull that even?
- 37:18Didn't we realize at some point it was all nothing but engineers or something like that?
- 37:22It came up in a previous episode like a while back.
- 37:25I would say that's probably one of the most renowned.
- 37:30If you were to ask any Jobwell in the street, what do you know about UFOs?
- 37:34Roswell, Area 51.
- 37:35Yes, but that's not aliens.
- 37:37I think Bill Moore, John Lear and Bill Cooper specifically here who comes out of it, they
- 37:43really have the negative viewpoint of aliens and not necessarily UFOs on the community.
- 37:49Yeah.
- 37:50Like everything that's like people being killed by aliens comes from this group, which is
- 37:55just so mind boggling.
- 37:56That is weird.
- 37:58But that makes me wonder what Linda Moltenhouse up to.
- 38:02Yeah.
- 38:03I feel like we're really alluding to her episode coming up in the next three to five years.
- 38:07I'm really, really scared to do her.
- 38:11Yeah.
- 38:12These guys just keep coming up to these guys that I never knew about before doing this
- 38:16podcast.
- 38:17Yeah.
- 38:18Way before this episode.
- 38:19We are again.
- 38:20And I should say this is not the only alleged case of human mutilation.
- 38:24There are other cases we will likely cover in the future.
- 38:27I will not speculate at this time as to the validity of those cases, mostly because when
- 38:33I do speculate, I always get disappointed when I actually get to the story.
- 38:37So I'm just going to leave it at that.
- 38:39There definitely are other cases.
- 38:40I am aware of them.
- 38:42I will be researching them and they will come up in future episodes.
- 38:45Can you speculate on the state that their anus is, whether they were plucked?
- 38:50You know what?
- 38:51I know they're removed, but I am unwilling.
- 38:53Oh, you don't know the ad.
- 38:54I am unwilling to use any verb at this point other than removed.
- 38:59Okay.
- 39:00Fair enough.
- 39:01Or missing.
- 39:02Sorry.
- 39:03Missing is a better one because that doesn't even connote a verb.
- 39:06Yeah.
- 39:07It doesn't even let us know what you would think.
- 39:09It's just missing.
- 39:10They are missing though.
- 39:11Yeah.
- 39:12So the state of how it became missing, we'll find, no, just leave it at that.
- 39:17Yeah.
- 39:18And I would like to leave this on something anus related, but that also seems a little
- 39:21off for an end up in episode.
- 39:23So I have been Taylor here with Chelsea.
- 39:25We are Journey to the Fringe.
- 39:26Thank you all for listening and we'll see you next week.
- 39:28That was good enough.
- 39:29Bye.
- 39:30Thank you for listening to Journey to the Fringe.
- 39:34If you have liked what you have listened to, please like, share, subscribe, or follow
- 39:40depending on what venue you are listening to us through.
- 39:44Also please, if possible, leave a five star review as that really helps us in the algorithms.
- 39:50If you wish to interact with us, please check us out on your social media of choice.
- 39:55I bet you we are there.
- 39:56And if you really want to communicate with us and give us ideas for new episodes or tell
- 40:01us that we're wrong and terrible, either way, please send us an email at journeytothefringe.com.
- 40:08For now, I'll see you in the next episode.