Latest / Serial Killer Documentary Show / True Crime Documentary - Delphi Murders The Case Against Richard Allen
Transcript
- 0:01Speaker 1: That's okay.
- 0:03Speaker 2: Having Joyce Williams getting scared. Now it's getting a cold.
- 0:08Speaker 3: Liberty rose Lynn.
- 0:10Speaker 4: German missing abducted.
- 0:12Speaker 5: We don't know for sure.
- 0:15Speaker 6: At the high Bridge in Delphi, Indiana.
- 0:18Speaker 7: Delphi is just not one of those places where any
- 0:22Speaker 7: of us ever thought that something like.
- 0:24Speaker 2: This would happen.
- 0:29Speaker 5: Despite that video, despite that audio, nothing happens seemingly for
- 0:34Speaker 5: six years.
- 0:35Speaker 8: That just did find probable cause for arrest of Richard Allen.
- 0:39Speaker 8: He's been charged with two counts of murder for the
- 0:41Speaker 8: murder of Abba Williams and Liberty German.
- 0:44Speaker 9: Richard down murder.
- 0:46Speaker 2: Why would you do it? They got the wrong guy
- 0:51Speaker 2: in no way.
- 0:52Speaker 1: There are other people who were looked at for this.
- 0:55Speaker 10: Yeah, it's some sort of a religious sect slash holder
- 1:02Speaker 10: that follow od.
- 1:06Speaker 11: I believe they sacrificed a girl and killed another one, and.
- 1:11Speaker 12: Law enforcement insists no one's ever been cleared.
- 1:14Speaker 13: When can you provide any kind of journalism?
- 1:16Speaker 5: It's time for you guys to start being journalists. Delphi
- 1:46Speaker 5: is a small town. The downtown is two blocks. It
- 1:56Speaker 5: has a main street literally a main street, old courthouse,
- 2:00Speaker 5: wonderful restaurants called the Stonehouse Girl, which has amazing breakfasts,
- 2:05Speaker 5: and it just has a regular America small town cliche,
- 2:08Speaker 5: almost flavor and field.
- 2:16Speaker 1: Downtown is surrounded by lots of fields, corn and soybean,
- 2:20Speaker 1: and lots of farmland.
- 2:24Speaker 5: The Historic Trails of Delphi is a popular spot in
- 2:26Speaker 5: town for people to go to. It's a little bit
- 2:29Speaker 5: outside of town. It's just a beautiful place filled with trees.
- 2:34Speaker 5: You could hear nature, you could hear the birds chirping.
- 2:36Speaker 5: It's a very serene place.
- 2:39Speaker 2: I live pretty close to the trails.
- 2:42Speaker 7: Dropping your kids off at the trails was just something
- 2:44Speaker 7: that you did.
- 2:45Speaker 2: It was just what kents did.
- 2:47Speaker 1: And just off the trail, there's an abandoned railroad bridge,
- 2:50Speaker 1: the Monon high Bridge, sixty three feet above Deer Creek.
- 2:55Speaker 5: The Monon high Bridge is not that serene. It's this
- 2:59Speaker 5: old rickety bridge, or it was at the time, right
- 3:03Speaker 5: the rail ties are falling apart. It's you know, you
- 3:06Speaker 5: could look down, take a step, a couple steps and
- 3:09Speaker 5: look down and see one hundred foot drop below you.
- 3:12Speaker 7: I mean, it was a very high bridge. The name
- 3:14Speaker 7: definitely applies. I grew up watching people post on their
- 3:20Speaker 7: Snapchat stories like going to the bridge to like read
- 3:24Speaker 7: a book or things like that, and they'd have their
- 3:25Speaker 7: feet like swinging over the edge. My name is synth
- 3:30Speaker 7: Rossi and I was best friends with Abby and Libby.
- 3:35Speaker 7: I first met Abby when we were in preschool together.
- 3:39Speaker 7: I spent my entire childhood basically at her grandparents' home.
- 3:46Speaker 7: We just loved being little girls and just sitting on
- 3:50Speaker 7: my bed reading magazines, playing with makeup.
- 3:54Speaker 2: She loved playing dress up. That was one of our
- 3:57Speaker 2: favorite things to do together.
- 4:00Speaker 7: I first met Libby when we were in classes together
- 4:03Speaker 7: in elementary school. She just had such a spunky personality.
- 4:10Speaker 7: She was constantly saying the funniest things I've ever heard
- 4:14Speaker 7: in my entire life. I've seen this picture a lot.
- 4:18Speaker 7: It was during one of her swim meets. She loved
- 4:22Speaker 7: swimming and how much she was such an active kid.
- 4:26Speaker 2: She seemed to never run out of energy. She was
- 4:28Speaker 2: constantly going.
- 4:30Speaker 7: Oh, the picture that I'm often cropped out of. So
- 4:35Speaker 7: this was our solo and ensemble competition with the song
- 4:38Speaker 7: Home on the Range that we could not agree how
- 4:41Speaker 7: to play. And Abby's actually wearing a dress that my
- 4:43Speaker 7: mom had gotten her for Christmas. I'll never forget that day,
- 4:50Speaker 7: February thirteenth.
- 4:52Speaker 2: It was around two pm.
- 4:54Speaker 7: I saw the picture of Abby on the bridge on
- 4:57Speaker 7: their Snapchat stories, and I immediately just knew that.
- 5:01Speaker 2: Something was wrong. Taken by Liberty.
- 5:04Speaker 7: It should have just been them being kids on a
- 5:07Speaker 7: day off from school, but unfortunately turned.
- 5:10Speaker 2: Into a lot Why.
- 5:13Speaker 6: Until okay two minute in juveniles Liberty Rose Lynn German,
- 5:19Speaker 6: but being at a high bridge in Delphi, Indiana, A
- 5:24Speaker 6: personally thirteen hundred hours second juno, I would you know
- 5:28Speaker 6: Joyce Williams last name? Where I've braved it up to
- 5:33Speaker 6: twit shirt and a rich shirt with the rich or
- 5:36Speaker 6: under his engine.
- 5:38Speaker 5: On the afternoon of February thirteenth, twenty seventeen, Abby and
- 5:42Speaker 5: Libby were dropped off at the trails that lead to
- 5:45Speaker 5: the Monon Highbridge. They're supposed to be picked up by
- 5:48Speaker 5: Libby's father at three pm. They never turned up. The
- 5:51Speaker 5: search started around five point thirty.
- 5:53Speaker 2: Well upset, confused, obviously, very de strong, just worried.
- 5:59Speaker 7: All I want to do is have the girls get.
- 6:00Speaker 14: Home safe, missing, abducted.
- 6:03Speaker 5: We don't know for sure.
- 6:04Speaker 3: There's a cell phone tower, but the pain was last
- 6:06Speaker 3: noted about five or six hours ago.
- 6:08Speaker 2: I say the phone's now dead.
- 6:10Speaker 5: Words spread quickly that help was needed, that these girls
- 6:13Speaker 5: needed to be found. Hundreds of people turned out and
- 6:16Speaker 5: searched through the night. Becky Patty, Leeby's grandmother would say
- 6:20Speaker 5: that you could see flashlights everywhere, like stars in the sky,
- 6:24Speaker 5: like fireflies. It was a full town effort.
- 6:27Speaker 15: Ravin's ditches, trash cans for phones, any sign of the girls.
- 6:34Speaker 7: I was like, I think one of them just like
- 6:36Speaker 7: fell off the bridge and maybe broke their leg, and
- 6:39Speaker 7: then the other one went down to help them, and
- 6:41Speaker 7: maybe they got hurt.
- 6:42Speaker 5: All options around the table. Did they run away, did
- 6:45Speaker 5: they go to a party, did they fall off the bridge,
- 6:48Speaker 5: did they get injured? No one had any idea what
- 6:51Speaker 5: had happened to them, but the official search was halted
- 6:53Speaker 5: that night and picked up the next morning.
- 6:56Speaker 7: The next day, I went to school and it was
- 7:00Speaker 7: just gloomy.
- 7:01Speaker 5: Hundreds of people showed up searching all over the place.
- 7:04Speaker 5: Hope was high, and then the word came.
- 7:09Speaker 7: I learned that Abby and Libby had been found. When
- 7:14Speaker 7: I saw everybody in the hallway just crying. No one
- 7:19Speaker 7: said the exact words to me, and we just sat
- 7:22Speaker 7: on our phones and watched the news headlines start to
- 7:26Speaker 7: come in.
- 7:30Speaker 3: We have found two bodies about a mile east of town.
- 7:36Speaker 3: We are investigating this as a crime scene. We suspect
- 7:41Speaker 3: bout play.
- 7:44Speaker 5: They didn't identify them as Abby and Libby, but everyone.
- 7:48Speaker 7: Do I knew it was them.
- 7:53Speaker 2: I wasn't in a position to hear it.
- 7:54Speaker 7: I just was truly traumatized, like my body was just
- 7:58Speaker 7: in fight or flight. Didn't know exactly what all foul
- 8:02Speaker 7: play entailed.
- 8:03Speaker 2: But when my.
- 8:05Speaker 7: Mom started to tell me someone hurt them and someone
- 8:08Speaker 7: wanted them to die for me, it was so difficult
- 8:12Speaker 7: to process. New stations started showing up to my house.
- 8:17Speaker 7: I couldn't enter my home without someone asking what happened?
- 8:21Speaker 2: Do you have any information?
- 8:23Speaker 7: And I'm just trying to process the fact that my
- 8:27Speaker 7: two best friends were just murdered, let alone trying to
- 8:31Speaker 7: balance a media presence at thirteen like it was so terrifying.
- 8:38Speaker 3: Basically, we have identified the bodies of the two females
- 8:43Speaker 3: that were found out yesterday, Epicgail J. Williams, thirteen of
- 8:47Speaker 3: the Delphi area and Liberty rose Land German, fourteen at
- 8:52Speaker 3: the Delphi Area. Family has been notified. This is considered
- 8:57Speaker 3: a double homicide investigation.
- 9:00Speaker 7: Yeah, I had known that Abby and Libby were active
- 9:07Speaker 7: on some kind of sites where you could meet new people,
- 9:11Speaker 7: and part of me thought that that might have something
- 9:15Speaker 7: to do with it, that maybe they had met someone online.
- 9:19Speaker 3: We have nobody in custody at this time.
- 9:25Speaker 5: The next day, police released a picture of a man
- 9:29Speaker 5: on the bridge. He appears to be wearing a blue coat,
- 9:32Speaker 5: blue pants, and boots. They don't say where this picture
- 9:36Speaker 5: comes from, but they do say that they are looking
- 9:39Speaker 5: for this person and they want to.
- 9:40Speaker 2: Talk to him.
- 9:42Speaker 7: When I first saw that image, I just wanted to
- 9:47Speaker 7: solve it.
- 9:48Speaker 2: Immediately.
- 9:48Speaker 7: I was flipping through every single person I'd ever seen
- 9:53Speaker 7: in my entire life, who might walk like that, who
- 9:55Speaker 7: might appear like that? And the first thing that I
- 10:01Speaker 7: noticed when I saw it was the pockets, that they
- 10:07Speaker 7: were filled, that there was something along like the waste
- 10:11Speaker 7: area into me. I just immediately was like, that's either
- 10:17Speaker 7: a knife set or a gun.
- 10:19Speaker 5: At this point, no one knows where this picture had
- 10:21Speaker 5: come from, so speculation was rampant. Was he caught on
- 10:24Speaker 5: a trail cap and if they had that image, what
- 10:26Speaker 5: else did they have? This picture had actually come from
- 10:32Speaker 5: Libby's phone. She had captured that image. Not only that,
- 10:36Speaker 5: she had also captured his voice, and.
- 10:42Speaker 12: For the first time we hear that this man is
- 10:45Speaker 12: the prime suspect in the murders of Abby and Libby.
- 10:49Speaker 7: Finding out that Libby had recorded him, I felt proud
- 10:53Speaker 7: of her.
- 10:54Speaker 5: And then in July twenty seventeen, police release a composite sketch.
- 10:58Speaker 5: They say that the man they're looking for. The sketches
- 11:00Speaker 5: between five six and five ten, weighs between one hundred
- 11:04Speaker 5: eighty and two hundred and twenty pounds, and has reddish
- 11:06Speaker 5: brown hair.
- 11:07Speaker 7: I couldn't think of anyone that I thought looked like that,
- 11:14Speaker 7: But then again, I thought of everyone who looked like that,
- 11:16Speaker 7: Like he just looked like every other guy I'd ever
- 11:20Speaker 7: seen in this town. I couldn't place anyone specific to
- 11:27Speaker 7: the sketch, and that was frustrating.
- 11:32Speaker 5: Who was this person? Was he a trucker passing through?
- 11:35Speaker 5: Could he have been a drifter? Was he a serial killer?
- 11:39Speaker 5: This is really when the people in town started to
- 11:41Speaker 5: pay attention and start to look around.
- 11:46Speaker 7: I've done numerous interviews with police officers, FBI investigators, and
- 11:52Speaker 7: they all, I mean, when you get asked, do you
- 11:55Speaker 7: have any answers?
- 11:56Speaker 2: You just want to have an answer.
- 11:58Speaker 1: But I didn't and then two years into the investigation,
- 12:02Speaker 1: a whole new direction.
- 12:07Speaker 15: To the killer, who may be in this room. We
- 12:11Speaker 15: believe you were hiding in plain sight. We likely have
- 12:16Speaker 15: interviewed you or someone close to you, and you want
- 12:21Speaker 15: to know what we know. One day you will.
- 12:28Speaker 12: A couple of new things come out of that pressor
- 12:30Speaker 12: they add one word to the audio from Libby's phone.
- 12:39Speaker 1: They also released this much younger sketch, saying that he
- 12:42Speaker 1: could be as young as sixteen at the time of
- 12:44Speaker 1: the murders.
- 12:45Speaker 7: I thought to myself, Oh my gosh, they have no
- 12:49Speaker 7: clue who did it. And I was like, if they
- 12:54Speaker 7: don't know if the age range is from sixteen to
- 12:57Speaker 7: forty like, I was like, do they know anything about him?
- 13:01Speaker 2: Do they have anything at all?
- 13:05Speaker 7: I was hopeless, and that, to me was my worst fear,
- 13:10Speaker 7: that they wouldn't end up arresting anyone and they would
- 13:14Speaker 7: just become another case.
- 13:18Speaker 5: Despite both of those faces, despite that video, despite that audio,
- 13:22Speaker 5: despite the fact that Indiana State Police Superintendent Doug Carter said,
- 13:25Speaker 5: this person probably lives here, he's probably a neighbor of yours.
- 13:29Speaker 5: No arrests are made for six years coming up.
- 13:33Speaker 15: I am proud to report to you an arrest has
- 13:36Speaker 15: been made.
- 13:37Speaker 5: I think everyone's first reaction was, who.
- 13:56Speaker 16: Here we are guys on Ron Loggan's property Steer Creek.
- 14:01Speaker 16: I'm on on high bridges over that way, and over
- 14:09Speaker 16: here is where the bodies were.
- 14:15Speaker 5: This case has been going on for a long time
- 14:18Speaker 5: and a lot of names have come up over those
- 14:21Speaker 5: years as potential people who could have been involved in
- 14:23Speaker 5: this crime, and none of them have been cleared. Ron
- 14:26Speaker 5: Logan was one of the first people that police took
- 14:28Speaker 5: an interest in for many reasons. One guest, the girl's
- 14:31Speaker 5: bodies were found on his property, that's going to raise questions.
- 14:34Speaker 5: But also he was out there on TV early doing interviews,
- 14:37Speaker 5: giving tours of the crime scene, telling people where he
- 14:40Speaker 5: was and when.
- 14:42Speaker 14: Who would have thought they let their children out to
- 14:44Speaker 14: do something spatial that day, take a trip down and
- 14:49Speaker 14: turn out a disaster like this.
- 14:51Speaker 12: Within weeks of the murders, there were two search warrants
- 14:55Speaker 12: executed ron Logan's property. The first one was just looking
- 14:58Speaker 12: for guns and they found a hundred and fifty six.
- 15:01Speaker 12: The second search was directly related to the murders. Ron
- 15:05Speaker 12: Logan gave me a copy of the probable cause that
- 15:09Speaker 12: was used to get that second search warrant for the
- 15:12Speaker 12: search of his property, and in it the FBI writes
- 15:16Speaker 12: that they believe he is responsible for the murders.
- 15:20Speaker 5: There are a couple key pieces of the ron logan
- 15:22Speaker 5: probable cause EFFI David. Perhaps the most compelling part of
- 15:26Speaker 5: it is that he constructed an alibi for a crime
- 15:30Speaker 5: that had not yet been discovered.
- 15:32Speaker 1: He lied about when he left his house to go
- 15:35Speaker 1: by Tropical Fish. He had a suspended license. He shouldn't
- 15:39Speaker 1: have been driving at all.
- 15:43Speaker 17: Detectives with the Carroll County Sheriff's Office and then Danta
- 15:46Speaker 17: State Police have uncovered an online profile named Anthony Shotts.
- 15:50Speaker 17: The fictitious Anthony shots profile used images of a known
- 15:54Speaker 17: male model and portrayed himself as being extremely wealthy and
- 15:58Speaker 17: owning numerous sports cards.
- 16:01Speaker 2: The creator and the.
- 16:02Speaker 17: Fictitious profile used this information while communicating with juvenile females
- 16:06Speaker 17: to solicit nude images.
- 16:09Speaker 12: We know that Libby was at least friends on social
- 16:12Speaker 12: media with the Anthony Schottz profile, and that he at
- 16:15Speaker 12: least liked or commented on some of her posts. Kegn
- 16:19Speaker 12: Klein from Peru, Indiana, about forty minutes away, admitted he
- 16:24Speaker 12: created that fake profile, and I spoke to him from jail.
- 16:28Speaker 12: Are you aware whether you may have talked to Libby
- 16:32Speaker 12: on the thirteenth.
- 16:34Speaker 7: That's what they said, and that's what the police tell
- 16:36Speaker 7: me that you did.
- 16:39Speaker 12: Yeah, And do you have any recollection of that?
- 16:43Speaker 8: Not atlone.
- 16:45Speaker 12: Did you have anything to do with the murders of
- 16:47Speaker 12: Abby or Libby?
- 16:49Speaker 7: Not at all.
- 16:49Speaker 18: And I've gave up my DNA a hair follical test.
- 16:52Speaker 8: I've done everything they wanted me to.
- 17:04Speaker 5: In October of twenty twenty two, surprisingly we got word
- 17:07Speaker 5: that there was an arrest.
- 17:10Speaker 2: What you know, disbelieve Like, Okay, I'm hearing this.
- 17:17Speaker 15: But.
- 17:20Speaker 2: It's a process.
- 17:22Speaker 5: Like the rest of national media, I showed up to
- 17:24Speaker 5: watch that press conference to announce the arrest, not knowing
- 17:26Speaker 5: what to expect.
- 17:28Speaker 15: Today is not a day to celebrate, but the arrest
- 17:31Speaker 15: of Richard m Allen of Delphi on two counts of
- 17:35Speaker 15: murder is sure a major steppard leading the conclusion of
- 17:40Speaker 15: this long term and complex investigation.
- 17:43Speaker 19: We expected to be excited and happy and like overjoyed
- 17:47Speaker 19: that he's arrested, but now we're we're dealing with understanding
- 17:53Speaker 19: that there's a lot of reopening wounds that's.
- 17:55Speaker 2: Coming with that.
- 17:58Speaker 5: My name's Dan Simtobe which I'm the producer and co
- 18:01Speaker 5: host of Down the Hill, the Delphi Murders podcast. My
- 18:04Speaker 5: first reaction, I think everyone's first reaction was who. We
- 18:08Speaker 5: had no idea who this was.
- 18:10Speaker 6: Richard?
- 18:10Speaker 4: Now you job murder? Why did you do it? Same
- 18:14Speaker 4: on you.
- 18:16Speaker 8: My name is Nicholas Mclearlin. I'm the Carroll County prosecutor.
- 18:20Speaker 8: Mister Allen has had his initial hearing. He's in an
- 18:22Speaker 8: a preliminary plea of not guilty, and he is in custody.
- 18:25Speaker 8: He's being held currently without bond.
- 18:28Speaker 14: Here comes a guy that has never ever been announced there.
- 18:33Speaker 9: He was nobody's radar.
- 18:35Speaker 2: It was like, where did this guy come from?
- 18:37Speaker 1: Richard Matthew Allen was fifty years old, had no criminal history,
- 18:42Speaker 1: and worked as a farm tech over at the local
- 18:44Speaker 1: CBS in Delphi.
- 18:46Speaker 12: I was surprised because he seemed like a real nice
- 18:48Speaker 12: guy and everything waiting on us in the drive through
- 18:50Speaker 12: and everything.
- 18:52Speaker 7: I had not interacted with him, but I everyone knew
- 18:56Speaker 7: who he was.
- 18:57Speaker 2: I mean, he worked there for so long and I
- 19:00Speaker 2: when I.
- 19:00Speaker 7: Found out who it was, I never in a million
- 19:03Speaker 7: years thought that it would have been him, not someone
- 19:08Speaker 7: so integral to the community and to the Delphi experience.
- 19:14Speaker 1: Richard Allen has been married to Kathy for thirty years.
- 19:18Speaker 5: They have one daughter. Ellen was raised in Mexico, Indiana,
- 19:22Speaker 5: about forty miles from Delphi.
- 19:24Speaker 12: Mexico is a very small town, smaller than Delphi, with
- 19:27Speaker 12: the population of about twelve hundred people.
- 19:36Speaker 4: That's where Ricky Ellen lived there in that yellow house
- 19:39Speaker 4: early on, and I think when he first.
- 19:44Speaker 5: Got married they moved in there, if I remember right.
- 19:48Speaker 4: Very very nice, very respectable young man. He always has been.
- 19:54Speaker 2: Yeah, my name is David Yoda, and when I knew
- 19:57Speaker 2: Ricky his.
- 19:58Speaker 4: Entire life, very loyal to dog. He's a quiet kind
- 20:03Speaker 4: of He's very polite, always has been respectful to me
- 20:07Speaker 4: and all. He'll go out of his way and say hi,
- 20:10Speaker 4: you know, just to say hello to me. Very friendly, sociable.
- 20:15Speaker 3: Hey.
- 20:15Speaker 4: I really can't speak highly enough about the man. I
- 20:18Speaker 4: just can't believe it this that he did this, and
- 20:21Speaker 4: I don't believe it for a minute.
- 20:24Speaker 12: People who have talked to who shopped at the CVS
- 20:26Speaker 12: and dealt with Richard Allen described him as friendly. In fact,
- 20:30Speaker 12: after the murders, Libby's aunt went in there to have
- 20:32Speaker 12: some pictures printed for Libby's memorial. She said Richard Allen
- 20:36Speaker 12: helped her and at the time she thought he was
- 20:39Speaker 12: helpful and kind.
- 20:42Speaker 7: I just wanted to ask him, why would you do
- 20:46Speaker 7: something like that? Why would you take such too innocent
- 20:51Speaker 7: people from this world?
- 20:52Speaker 2: Why?
- 20:53Speaker 7: What was your motive? What did you want to do?
- 20:55Speaker 7: What were your intentions? Did you know all along if
- 20:57Speaker 7: that's what you were going to do?
- 20:58Speaker 5: But we still didn't know why he had been arrested,
- 21:01Speaker 5: and they said in that press conference that everything about
- 21:04Speaker 5: that was still under seal. This is really important.
- 21:09Speaker 15: While I know you are all expecting final details today,
- 21:14Speaker 15: it's sending this arrest today is not that day.
- 21:18Speaker 20: It's very unusual for what happened in this case to happen,
- 21:23Speaker 20: and especially a case of this magnitude, which is why
- 21:27Speaker 20: that's the reason why when a case is so high profile,
- 21:31Speaker 20: a case that's gone cold for so many years, and
- 21:33Speaker 20: there are obviously things that for some good reason we
- 21:37Speaker 20: as members of the public just shouldn't be privy to prosecutor.
- 21:41Speaker 12: Nicholas mcleland also said there could be other actors involved
- 21:45Speaker 12: in this crime.
- 21:46Speaker 5: Where are those people? Where's that second person? Why haven't
- 21:49Speaker 5: we heard anything about it.
- 21:52Speaker 12: Then Sheriff Tobe Lesanbie of Carroll County asked the court
- 21:55Speaker 12: to move Richard Allen out of the Carroll County Jail,
- 21:59Speaker 12: saying they couldn't ensure his safety. So the judge agrees,
- 22:03Speaker 12: signs off on that and sends him to the Department
- 22:05Speaker 12: of Corrections. And then the judge immediately steps down from
- 22:09Speaker 12: the case.
- 22:11Speaker 14: And what happens is he's moved without a judge who
- 22:14Speaker 14: had accused himself, claiming that the blood lost of the
- 22:17Speaker 14: case was just too much for him to handle and
- 22:21Speaker 14: he didn't think that he'd be able to sit on it.
- 22:24Speaker 1: Allan has moved to the Westville Maximum Security Prison. That's
- 22:27Speaker 1: pretty unusual because usually suspects are held at the county jail.
- 22:33Speaker 12: With Allan in prison without defense attorneys and now no
- 22:37Speaker 12: judge on the case, the Indiana Supreme Court steps in
- 22:40Speaker 12: and they appoint Special Judge Francis Gull, who's from Allen County,
- 22:45Speaker 12: about two hours away.
- 22:48Speaker 10: Coming up.
- 22:49Speaker 9: Richard Allen has a message for the judge.
- 22:52Speaker 5: He writes a letter to Judge Gull, throwing himself on
- 22:55Speaker 5: the mercy of the court.
- 23:12Speaker 12: Richard Allen is in custody without bond after being charged
- 23:15Speaker 12: with the murders of best friends Abigail Williams and Liberty German.
- 23:27Speaker 5: So in November of twenty twenty two, we finally hear
- 23:29Speaker 5: from Richard Allen. He writes a handwritten letter gives it
- 23:33Speaker 5: to Judge Gall throwing himself on the mercy of the court,
- 23:36Speaker 5: asking for help paying for his defense.
- 23:39Speaker 14: Allen had originally when he made his first appearance and
- 23:42Speaker 14: told the judge that he was going to try to
- 23:44Speaker 14: get private counsel. I don't think, realizing how much a
- 23:47Speaker 14: case like this would cost in terms of hiring private counsel.
- 23:52Speaker 1: Carroll County is too small to have its own public defenders,
- 23:55Speaker 1: So Judge fran Gall she appoints two private attorneys, Brad
- 23:59Speaker 1: Rosie and A Andrew Baldwin.
- 24:01Speaker 14: Both of these guys have vast experience, I mean collectively
- 24:04Speaker 14: they've been trying cases for fifty years, both very experienced
- 24:07Speaker 14: trial lawyers.
- 24:08Speaker 5: His new defense attorneys, Baldwin and Rosie, immediately release a
- 24:12Speaker 5: statement saying he is not guilty, he has nothing to hide,
- 24:15Speaker 5: is one hunch percent innocent.
- 24:17Speaker 1: We also learn more about why Richard Allen was arrested
- 24:20Speaker 1: in the first place when the probable cause affidavit is
- 24:23Speaker 1: released to the public.
- 24:25Speaker 14: That is what the public is going to be basing
- 24:27Speaker 14: their initial opinion as to innocence are killed on.
- 24:31Speaker 12: We learn that the evidence shows that Abby and Libby
- 24:34Speaker 12: are dropped off at the trails at one forty nine PM,
- 24:38Speaker 12: and we already knew that Libby's video recording that man
- 24:42Speaker 12: on the bridge happened at two thirteen. Just twenty four
- 24:46Speaker 12: minutes later.
- 24:47Speaker 5: We learned that the video has one of the girls
- 24:50Speaker 5: saying the word gun. We also find out about some
- 24:52Speaker 5: physical evidence. An unspent, unfired forty caliber round is found
- 24:57Speaker 5: in between the bodies.
- 24:59Speaker 14: They then brought or had examined by Indiana State trooper
- 25:04Speaker 14: who had some training with tool markings. He gave a
- 25:07Speaker 14: subjective opinion that he thought that the gun that they
- 25:10Speaker 14: recovered in Richard Allen's home pursuant of the search was
- 25:13Speaker 14: a match.
- 25:15Speaker 20: To me, the most damaging piece of evidence that the
- 25:19Speaker 20: State of Indiana has against Richard Allen is the unspent
- 25:22Speaker 20: round that cycled through his gun found just two feet
- 25:26Speaker 20: away from Libby Jerman. He is either the unluckiest guy
- 25:31Speaker 20: in the world or he was there at the scene
- 25:35Speaker 20: when those two girls were murdered.
- 25:37Speaker 5: The probable Cause reveals at least four witnesses, three teenage
- 25:41Speaker 5: girls and one adult woman saw someone generally matching the
- 25:45Speaker 5: description of the person in Libby's video between one twenty
- 25:48Speaker 5: six pm at two thirteen pm, the time that Abby
- 25:52Speaker 5: and Libby were encountering that man on the bridge.
- 25:54Speaker 12: And one of those witnesses is seen on surveillance video
- 25:57Speaker 12: arriving a brown one for six peter and she says
- 26:01Speaker 12: she parked her car and then walked out to the
- 26:04Speaker 12: bridge where she saw a man standing on the bridge
- 26:07Speaker 12: about fifty feet away. She didn't walk onto the bridge,
- 26:10Speaker 12: she turned around and walked back in the direction she
- 26:13Speaker 12: came and when she did that, she passed two young
- 26:16Speaker 12: girls who were walking towards the bridge, and she believes
- 26:21Speaker 12: that was Abby and Libby.
- 26:22Speaker 1: Another witness says that she was driving north of the
- 26:25Speaker 1: trails that day and about two hours after the abduction,
- 26:28Speaker 1: she saw a man in a blue jacket walking in
- 26:31Speaker 1: the opposite direction quote muddy and bloody.
- 26:35Speaker 5: Just before Richard Allen was arrested in October of twenty
- 26:38Speaker 5: twenty two, he met with investigators again after they had
- 26:41Speaker 5: resurfaced his name and he said, yes, I was there.
- 26:44Speaker 5: I was wearing a blue jacket, I was wearing a
- 26:46Speaker 5: blue pants, may have been wearing a hat.
- 26:48Speaker 20: One of the other most damaging pieces of evidence came
- 26:51Speaker 20: from Richard Allen in him admitting to being on the
- 26:55Speaker 20: trail that day.
- 26:56Speaker 2: Think about it.
- 26:57Speaker 20: He's admitting to being there from one thirty three and
- 27:01Speaker 20: he claims he went there to watch the fish. So
- 27:04Speaker 20: how unlucky is this guy that he admits to being
- 27:08Speaker 20: present and his window encompasses the window of time that
- 27:12Speaker 20: investigators believe those beautiful girls were murdered.
- 27:16Speaker 1: About eight months after his arrest, a slew of documents
- 27:19Speaker 1: are released, and that's when we find out that Richard
- 27:22Speaker 1: Allen has confessed.
- 27:25Speaker 20: His confessions are going to be a major problem for
- 27:29Speaker 20: this defense team.
- 27:32Speaker 2: We need to have more than that.
- 27:33Speaker 20: Whenever we have a criminal case, a confession alone is
- 27:35Speaker 20: not enough.
- 27:36Speaker 12: So the state is mounting this case.
- 27:38Speaker 20: With other pieces of evidence that corroborate what he's admitting to.
- 27:43Speaker 20: We haven't heard the confessions yet, We're just aware that
- 27:47Speaker 20: prosecutors have alerted the court to the fact that he
- 27:50Speaker 20: has made admissions made them to his wife by way
- 27:53Speaker 20: of a jail phone call. And that they plan to
- 27:55Speaker 20: introduce that evidence.
- 27:57Speaker 5: So everything we've been hearing up to this point is
- 27:59Speaker 5: the theory of the case from the prosecution, from law enforcement,
- 28:03Speaker 5: and then via filings we start to hear from the defense,
- 28:08Speaker 5: and the details that they lay out are like nothing
- 28:12Speaker 5: we could possibly have imagined today.
- 28:15Speaker 10: Like I said, unexpected, out of left field. One hundred
- 28:20Speaker 10: and thirty pages worth of information in just one of
- 28:23Speaker 10: the filings that was released. They are pointing the finger
- 28:27Speaker 10: in a very specific direction as to who's responsible for this.
- 28:30Speaker 5: And it's not Richard Allen.
- 28:32Speaker 10: It's some sort of a religious sect slash cult that
- 28:38Speaker 10: follow Odinism and it was a sacrifice.
- 28:44Speaker 14: Wow, when that thing dropped he was a defense attorney.
- 28:49Speaker 9: It blew my mind. I had never seen a filing
- 28:52Speaker 9: like that. My name is Mark pitt Cavage. I'm a
- 28:56Speaker 9: senior research fellow with the Anti Defamation League Center on Extremism.
- 29:02Speaker 9: The defense argument that Odinism was involved in the murder
- 29:06Speaker 9: is largely based on the idea that there were Norse
- 29:16Speaker 9: pagan symbols left at the scene of the crime in
- 29:20Speaker 9: the form of sticks or branches or blood patterns, and
- 29:29Speaker 9: it's not clear to me that any such symbols were
- 29:32Speaker 9: actually left at the scene in the first place. Odinism
- 29:36Speaker 9: is one of the branches of white supremacy. There are
- 29:38Speaker 9: a number of different types of white supremacy, and it's
- 29:42Speaker 9: derived from a religion that is the easiest way to
- 29:47Speaker 9: put is modern Norse paganism. Modern Norse paganism is the
- 29:52Speaker 9: revival of some of the old Scandinavian myths and religious
- 29:56Speaker 9: beliefs centered around the ancient Norse gods like Odin and
- 30:02Speaker 9: Thor and Freya. Most modern Norse pagans are not racists,
- 30:07Speaker 9: they're not white supremacists. The religion as a whole is innocuous,
- 30:10Speaker 9: but this one part of it is not so innocuous.
- 30:14Speaker 9: It's much more problematic. So at the Center on Extremism
- 30:18Speaker 9: we try and track extremism in a lot of different ways.
- 30:21Speaker 9: One of the things that we started doing in two
- 30:23Speaker 9: thousand and eight was to track extremist related murders, where
- 30:27Speaker 9: we created a database to track extremists domestic extremist related murders.
- 30:33Speaker 9: Because those allegations were raised, we have been tracking the
- 30:36Speaker 9: progress of the case to see if any of them
- 30:39Speaker 9: are ever at some point substantiated with evidence. If and
- 30:43Speaker 9: that's a big. If any of the allegations were actually substantiated,
- 30:48Speaker 9: then we would certainly add it to our database.
- 30:51Speaker 12: At that point, the defense says this theory of the
- 30:56Speaker 12: crime was never fully explored by law enforcement and that
- 31:00Speaker 12: men they've identified as potential suspects were cleared too easily, and.
- 31:06Speaker 1: After making those bombshell claims, the defense is off the case.
- 31:12Speaker 10: Coming up, graphic crime scene photos make their way to YouTube.
- 31:17Speaker 14: Pictures like that are just going to incite and enrage people,
- 31:20Speaker 14: and they are going to blame the person that's under arrest.
- 31:40Speaker 5: In October of twenty twenty three, work gets out that
- 31:44Speaker 5: crime scene photos have leaked, apparently from the office of Baldwin,
- 31:48Speaker 5: and what it turns out had happened was that someone
- 31:50Speaker 5: who was in his office had taken pictures of the
- 31:53Speaker 5: evidence and shared them.
- 31:55Speaker 14: Thankfully, these things didn't make it out to the public
- 31:57Speaker 14: and mass for number one. For the families, like the
- 32:01Speaker 14: nightmare of them getting online one day and opening up
- 32:04Speaker 14: a picture of their daughter is like beyond words. The
- 32:07Speaker 14: other thing is you worry about is if they get out,
- 32:10Speaker 14: it destroys Rick Allen's opportunity to have a fair trial.
- 32:13Speaker 14: Just does because pictures like that are just going to
- 32:16Speaker 14: incite and enrage people, and they are going to blame
- 32:19Speaker 14: the person that's under arrest.
- 32:21Speaker 12: Defense attorney Andrew Baldwin says he's essentially the victim of
- 32:25Speaker 12: a theft. But the judge is furious and she accuses
- 32:28Speaker 12: the defense team of being incompetent and negligent.
- 32:33Speaker 18: We've had an unexpected turn of events, Ladies and gentlemen.
- 32:38Speaker 18: Mister Baldwin made an oral motion to withdraw. I granted
- 32:42Speaker 18: that oral motion to withdraw, and mister Rosie will be
- 32:45Speaker 18: submitting a written motion to withdraw. I'm assuming within the
- 32:49Speaker 18: next couple of days.
- 32:52Speaker 5: With Baldwin and Rosie off the case, Richard Allen still
- 32:54Speaker 5: needs a defense, so Judge Gull appoints two attorneys from
- 32:58Speaker 5: her home county of Allen County.
- 33:00Speaker 12: She picks Allen County's chief public defender, William Lobrado and
- 33:04Speaker 12: Robert Screman. But that's not the last that we hear
- 33:07Speaker 12: of Rosie and Baldwin. They say they were coursed into
- 33:11Speaker 12: leaving the case and they fight to get back on.
- 33:14Speaker 1: So that issue goes to the Indiana Supreme Court, who
- 33:17Speaker 1: quickly rule that the original defense team should have never
- 33:20Speaker 1: been removed.
- 33:21Speaker 12: Seventy nine days after they were appointed. Librado and Scremmen
- 33:26Speaker 12: are off the case, and Rosie and Baldwin are back.
- 33:31Speaker 11: I was asked to do a job. I did my job.
- 33:34Speaker 11: I was then told two gentlemen are going to take over.
- 33:37Speaker 11: It is what it is. My name's William Labrado. I
- 33:41Speaker 11: am now Richard Allen's former lead counselor. I don't think
- 33:46Speaker 11: mister Allen had anything to do with this.
- 33:49Speaker 12: You're a defense attorney, so that's your job to sort
- 33:53Speaker 12: of say your client is innocent, and.
- 33:56Speaker 11: Rarely do I believe it. But in this particular case,
- 34:01Speaker 11: I believe it. And what convinced you conversations with him,
- 34:09Speaker 11: the fact that he lived in this very small community
- 34:13Speaker 11: that's not much bigger than a high school. He worked
- 34:18Speaker 11: at the CVS in Delphi. The police sketches are hung
- 34:24Speaker 11: up in the CVS. The bridge guy picture is in
- 34:28Speaker 11: the CVS, and in five and a half years, no
- 34:32Speaker 11: one comes into that store and says that kind of
- 34:35Speaker 11: looks like you. I don't know if this has any relevance,
- 34:39Speaker 11: and you know I'm not a conspiracy theorist, but arrest
- 34:43Speaker 11: was made twenty four, twenty seven days before a sheriff election.
- 34:51Speaker 12: How would you characterize the case as you know it
- 34:54Speaker 12: against Richard.
- 34:55Speaker 11: Allen Well, it's obviously circumstantial. I haven't seen a direct
- 35:00Speaker 11: evidence that other than he admitted that he was on
- 35:04Speaker 11: the bridge that day and we think during the same
- 35:08Speaker 11: timeframe as the girls were.
- 35:12Speaker 20: There's technically both direct evidence and circumstantial evidence. For example,
- 35:17Speaker 20: his confession, that's direct evidence. Witnesses eyewitnesses seeing it Goby direct.
- 35:22Speaker 11: Evidence eyewitness haestimony inherently unreliable in my opinion. They all
- 35:28Speaker 11: say saw the same person, and you have that many
- 35:31Speaker 11: different descriptions. That's a problem.
- 35:36Speaker 1: Rosie and Baldwin, in a filing, claimed the descriptions attributed
- 35:40Speaker 1: to witnesses and the probable cause affidavit are wrong.
- 35:44Speaker 12: So remember the witness who said that she walked out
- 35:47Speaker 12: to the bridge and saw a man standing on it,
- 35:49Speaker 12: and then she passed what she believes Rabby and Libby
- 35:52Speaker 12: as she was walking back to her car. Well, the
- 35:54Speaker 12: defense says that the state left out that woman's description
- 35:59Speaker 12: the man she saw. She described a young man, possibly
- 36:03Speaker 12: in his twenties, clean shaven, with a boyish look.
- 36:08Speaker 5: That description is actually what led to the second sketch
- 36:10Speaker 5: which was made in February of twenty seventeen but not
- 36:13Speaker 5: released until April of twenty nineteen.
- 36:16Speaker 1: And the witness who saw a man walking on the
- 36:18Speaker 1: road both muddy and bloody, actually just saw a man
- 36:22Speaker 1: who was muddy. According to the defense.
- 36:25Speaker 14: Richard Allen's five to four. So when you're talking about
- 36:29Speaker 14: the witness statements, okay, in none of them that would
- 36:33Speaker 14: have been the first descriptive thing that I would have
- 36:36Speaker 14: said is that he's really short. Not one of them
- 36:38Speaker 14: said that he was a really short guy, And that
- 36:40Speaker 14: would have been, like to me, the first descriptor, you know,
- 36:44Speaker 14: and it just didn't happen.
- 36:47Speaker 12: Bradley Rosie and Andrew Baldwin also said there's no electronic
- 36:51Speaker 12: evidence linking him to the crime scene or the girls,
- 36:55Speaker 12: and that there's no DNA of his at the scene.
- 37:00Speaker 11: Yes, as far as I can tell, yes, nothing forensically
- 37:06Speaker 11: other than this bullet that they claimed that they found
- 37:10Speaker 11: that they shot through a barrel. That there's no way
- 37:14Speaker 11: to compare the markings a bullet projectile shell casing would
- 37:20Speaker 11: have fired through a barrel compared to ejection marks. And
- 37:26Speaker 11: it was to my knowledge about two inches underground.
- 37:31Speaker 12: What do you think is the biggest piece of evidence
- 37:34Speaker 12: in this case.
- 37:36Speaker 11: There's an alleged confession. That's it to me.
- 37:41Speaker 12: You had not heard of Odonism when it first was
- 37:45Speaker 12: floated with regard to this case.
- 37:47Speaker 11: I honestly thought I thought it was hocus pocus. I
- 37:50Speaker 11: honestly didn't.
- 37:51Speaker 5: I'd never heard of it.
- 37:53Speaker 11: And the more I got into it, that's a real thing.
- 37:59Speaker 11: It is a real thing, and it's scary. I believe
- 38:02Speaker 11: they sacrificed a girl and killed another one.
- 38:07Speaker 1: In addition to pointing the finger at several men who
- 38:09Speaker 1: allegedly practice Odinism, the defense says that several of the
- 38:13Speaker 1: prison guards in charge of Richard Allen were wearing Odinism
- 38:17Speaker 1: patches on their uniform.
- 38:20Speaker 12: You described one of those officers. It's mentioned in one
- 38:26Speaker 12: of Rosie and Baldwin's filings, Sergeant Jones, who was wearing
- 38:32Speaker 12: patches that said in Odin we trust on his Department
- 38:35Speaker 12: of Corrections uniform. The judge ordered the warden to make
- 38:39Speaker 12: them stop.
- 38:41Speaker 2: And then what did.
- 38:42Speaker 11: You notice that mister Jones had a tattooed under his
- 38:47Speaker 11: right eye. From the bus, we can tell it looks
- 38:51Speaker 11: a lot like Odin's spear.
- 38:54Speaker 1: Both sets of Richard Allen's defense attorneys have raised issues
- 38:58Speaker 1: about what they call harsh conditions behind bars. Rosie and
- 39:02Speaker 1: Baldwin also alleged that Richard Allen's family was threatened if
- 39:06Speaker 1: he didn't confess.
- 39:08Speaker 11: There's no ties to this oldness to call whatsoever. He
- 39:12Speaker 11: didn't even know that there was oldness in Delfa. He
- 39:15Speaker 11: had never heard of it.
- 39:18Speaker 6: Up.
- 39:18Speaker 9: Next, did Abby and Libby's killer have help?
- 39:22Speaker 5: One of the major things hanging out there right now
- 39:25Speaker 5: about this story is the fact that there are likely
- 39:28Speaker 5: other people involved in this crime.
- 39:47Speaker 13: Hopefully justice for Abby and Libby Bill means some closure
- 39:51Speaker 13: for their family members. I always see you never get
- 39:54Speaker 13: complete closure in a homicide case because there is a
- 39:57Speaker 13: void left in your heart that can never if would
- 39:59Speaker 13: be still but some bit of closure, some bit of
- 40:03Speaker 13: justice and peace knowing that the right person has been
- 40:06Speaker 13: help responsible and can't hurt anyone ever again.
- 40:10Speaker 2: All that being said, the State.
- 40:11Speaker 20: Of Indiana has mounted quite a case to prove that
- 40:16Speaker 20: Richard Allen is that person.
- 40:19Speaker 7: As sees in Bloom at the side of you, oh
- 40:25Speaker 7: so priceless. So this was a song that actually played
- 40:30Speaker 7: at her funeral, and just the way that it describes
- 40:35Speaker 7: I see you dressed in why Every wrong Made right?
- 40:38Speaker 7: Or it really makes me think of Abby as angelic.
- 40:44Speaker 7: I feel connected to her. It just really makes me
- 40:48Speaker 7: think that she's an angel by my side. Rather than
- 40:52Speaker 7: the things that she went through and how she died,
- 40:57Speaker 7: there are a lot of things that make me think
- 41:00Speaker 7: of her. I got this tattoo of butterflies on my arm,
- 41:06Speaker 7: and that was just a huge part of her.
- 41:10Speaker 2: She loved butterflies.
- 41:28Speaker 7: I think what is important is talking about who they
- 41:32Speaker 7: were while they were living, and that's what's most important
- 41:36Speaker 7: to me. I really want to make sure that people
- 41:39Speaker 7: know that they were good people and that their lives
- 41:46Speaker 7: are constantly part.
- 41:49Speaker 2: Of everyone who knew them's lives.
- 41:55Speaker 7: True justice would be that there would be no need
- 41:58Speaker 7: for justice at all, that it never would have happened,
- 42:02Speaker 7: that they never would have been taken from us, that
- 42:05Speaker 7: they never would have been treated.
- 42:08Speaker 2: In that way.
- 42:10Speaker 7: For me, there's a piece that really never will reach justice.
- 42:21Speaker 5: One of the major things hanging out there right now
- 42:23Speaker 5: about this story is the fact that there are likely
- 42:26Speaker 5: other people involved in this crime. Prosecutor Nick McCleland said
- 42:30Speaker 5: that himself there could be other actors involved. Former Sheriff
- 42:33Speaker 5: tob Blesenbie saying under oath that he believes it would
- 42:36Speaker 5: have taken at least two people to commit this crime.
- 42:39Speaker 14: And you just have to hope that law enforcement is
- 42:41Speaker 14: up to the task because they're putting all the cards
- 42:45Speaker 14: on the table with Rick Allen at this point. You know,
- 42:48Speaker 14: but we still have that thing, don't we sitting there
- 42:52Speaker 14: saying we think that they were more involved. So we
- 42:55Speaker 14: have to hope that they're continuing to investigate it.
- 43:18Speaker 5: It's easing all this back and forth and debate about
- 43:22Speaker 5: this case. Who did it, who didn't do it, who
- 43:26Speaker 5: might have done it. It's easy to lose the victims,
- 43:29Speaker 5: Abby and Libby. I learned early on and throughout that
- 43:34Speaker 5: these girls were the absolute lights in the lives of
- 43:37Speaker 5: those who loved them. Abby and Libby were loved. Justice
- 43:43Speaker 5: in this case is going to mean different things to
- 43:45Speaker 5: different people. I'm not going to presume to define that
- 43:48Speaker 5: for those who love them. My definition is a little
- 43:50Speaker 5: more traditional. It's arresting and punishing the person or people
- 43:54Speaker 5: responsible for this, whoever that may be, and however long
- 43:57Speaker 5: that takes.