Latest / The Health Care Preview / Special Edition: Pre-Election Breakdown
Transcript
- speaker-1: Hello, and welcome back to the Healthcare Preview, a weekly podcast from Cozen O'Connor Public Strategies, where we break down what's happening in health policy in Washington DC. I'm your host, Matty News, and I'm here with my colleagues Debbie Curtis and Rodney Whitlock for a special pre election episode. So how are you guys doing? speaker-0: Two weeks, fourteen days, Debbie, can you just I I I'm just it's only two weeks away. It seems like it's been forever and now it's almost here. speaker-2: I know it is shocking. And what's even more shocking is just that we're almost in 2027, not to blow past the election, because the election is what we're here to talk about, but I am overwhelmed by the speed of time writ large. And I want to raise one more thing. Just Maddie said we're a weekly podcast. And we are when Congress is in session, but this is a special edition since Congress has been gone. speaker-1: So where are we at heading into the upcoming election? speaker-0: So we've been talking about it here in Washington, about something called the blue wave and the red undertow. Blue wave means rising fortunes on the Democratic side. And the red undertow particularly speaks to how in many places it almost feels as that Republicans are being pulled over, frankly, from the top. And so that theme remains dominant. It has us leaning towards believing the House is. Clearly breaking to the Democrats and the Senate certainly starts to feel that way. But the one pause I want to give that I'm not certain I believe, but at least think it's a pause worth having, which is that if pollsters sometime in September got a vibe and started oversampling Democratic intensity, then the polls could be consistently directionally wrong in one way. I actually don't know that I believe that. But I at least want to give it that as an excuse to say, okay, if it doesn't turn out like everybody feels like is conventional wisdom at this point, that might be why. speaker-2: So I totally hear you on that, Rodney. And it's always nice to raise things to think about, totally relevant. But I think the things that argue against that is you if you look at the primaries and the level of democratic turnout in those primaries, where across the country turnout was up about forty-five percent at the primary level. So what that and that's for democratic candidates. So that to me says there's a motivation issue. That is really out there for Democrats. And I think that tends to enhance what we're also hearing from the polls with regard to the way it looks like this election will go. And I think the early voting data that we've seen certainly indicates enthusiasm, where we've seen early voting percentages much higher than they have been in past cycles. And if that has to do with enthusiasm from one side of voting. It just further substantiates that this may be a red undertow slash blue wave scenario. Though I think for both of us, we would say, like, don't overread into this and think there's going to be a tidal wave, because the Congress is going to end up pretty close, no matter who is in control on both sides of the Capitol. We are still going to have a very divided Congress. speaker-1: So let's talk specifics then. What are your guys' thoughts on the house? speaker-2: On the House, it certainly appears that the Democrats will take the House of Representatives. Remember, we have got something like 75 members who aren't returning already. So in the open seats in particular, that is a more even fight when candidates are running. And when you look across the country at the way that polling is showing where folks are going. If it's showing where folks are going. And you look at analysts who who we have looked at for decades, Rodney and I, just showing our age. But I mean, Cook Political Report is no liberal set of analysts who willy-nilly change their perspective on the direction that races are going. They are pretty darn conservative in making their predictions and they hold out longer than lots of others. And yet what we are seeing is them continue to push races in the direction of Democrats. So, you know, we can continue talking about this as much as we want, but the reality is two weeks out, we're gonna know pretty soon which way it goes. And it to me, I will be surprised if it's not the Democrats in control of the House and with more of a margin than the Republicans have had in this last session. speaker-0: Debbie, it'll be absolutely gobsmacking if the Democrats don't take the House. This is not 24 where we thought it was going to flip and it was close. This one doesn't feel close at all. But what's going to be interesting here is two years after watching this redistricting cycle, which has been challenging to try to figure out who's on first with the states going in and redrawing maps. What will be interesting is what's the floor? Particularly on the Republican side, because six weeks ago, two months ago, I would have said that you can find Republicans that would have told you the floor is 210. They cannot go below 10, 210. I don't think anybody believes that anymore. But why? What's changed? And that's, I think, the that's going to be the really fascinating thing to watch, which is if you believed that you had this base that was so high that the districts were drawn in such a way that you couldn't lose, well, then what has happened? And that may be part of the red undertow. And what Debbie you spoke to previously, which is the idea of okay, democratic intensity is so high and Republicans feel the undertow of what is clearly economic issues that are dragging them down, lack of Republican intensity. So it is where is that floor now in the House for Republicans? speaker-2: Yeah, and I would actually say bigger picture of Rodney. A hope I have, and you know me, I always have to insert some hope. A hope that I have after this election is maybe this starts to temper the constant, feels constant today, attempts to change lines to draw advantage to whoever is in control. Redistricting it it it is entirely possible after this election that redistricting ends up with only Republicans gaining one or two seats and overall still being very much in the minority. And the problem with this redistricting all the time is that you're redistricting based on what you think matters. And they did this without thinking through, I believe, some of the changing dynamics with regard to the economy. And you know, you have a longstanding statement in campaigning, it's the economy stupid. That that Is ringing true right now in a big way. Affordability is the major issue. But also the demographics of America are playing into this and immigration and the tactics used by this administration. So there is going to be a lot we learn from this election. And if one of the outcomes is less redistricting mid-cycle, I think that's actually a really positive thing. speaker-1: So what about the Senate then? speaker-0: Senate could go either way. It it's fascinating, again, particularly towards my earlier comment, which is if you look at some of the states that are in play, that is Kansas in play, is South Carolina in play. These are gonna be again, it's either gonna be the polls are capturing what is Democratic intensity, reduced Republican intensity, and more states are in play than we were expecting. And it could be 54. It could be 55. I can punch them, you know, states and change colors to get to 55 if I want to. But again, we won't know until election day, but it could, we would not be completely blown away if it actually doesn't flip, much unlike the house, where we feel like it's a near certainty. If they all break the same way, they could break the same way blue, clearly. But what if they don't? Then we could end up looking something more like status quo. speaker-2: Yeah, and I mean a reminder for as someone who worked in the House all my career is that no matter which way the Senate goes, it's going to be below 60. So you're still gonna have the obstacle of the Senate in legislating. Let's not kid ourselves about that. But I will say on election night, a race I'm really gonna be watching just because it's an early race and because I can't think of anybody who is more of a survivor in the US Senate than Susan Collins. But if Susan Collins loses, that to me is going to be a sign that things are going the Democrats' way because it's just surprising to see that she would lose, in particular given the turmoil of that race in Maine and all that has come up during it. And if she s goes down, my instinct is going to be that that means a very good night for Democrats in the Senate. We'll see if I'm right or wrong about that. speaker-1: So in addition to the Collins Senate race, Rodney are there other indicator races you'll be looking at on election night? speaker-0: So I'll cheat a little bit. I was hanging out with a couple of polling professionals yesterday. And so I'm bringing in a ringer here. Kentucky Six, it will come out. We'll hear that one early. That's an indicator race. It's an open seat. It's the one Andy Barr is leaving. And if that one is a lot closer than it should be, it should be red. That may be your indicator for the rest of the evening. You and I don't always agree on the main one. I believe that the only Republican in New England losing is no more indicative than Tester losing in Montana was. I look at Ohio, which has been reliably red for a number of cycles. If that starts to go, if that one is pretty obviously going blue, not to say that there aren't good candidates there, but if that one's going blue, again, that's one that is, I think, indicative of the night. speaker-2: Well, and I'll just add a couple others, just because we're doing if you want to look on the Democratic side, what to watch. Davis in North Carolina is an interesting one. He he was redistricted and is not supposed to be able to win. And so if he wins, that may be saying something. And for those of us in the healthcare space, watching the Kathy Castor race in Florida as well, again, a redistricting target by Republicans to have her not able to win. If she's able to pull that out. that's pretty meaningful. And then we can take that across the country and look at other races from those. But I agree with you, the Kentucky one is also a very interesting one to watch. speaker-1: So looking past November third a little bit, what races in this cycle do you have do you think will have the biggest impact on the next cycle? speaker-2: I mean, my answer to that is let's see what happens. Because what matters with that is not only who gets elected, but who else gets elected and what that means for what Washington may be focused on, what Congress may be focused on for the next couple of years. So I am gonna take a pause button on that one and say that is a topic for another podcast, in my opinion. speaker-0: I'll take that on. What the heck? For Republicans, they need to watch Iowa, Kansas, and Texas. Those are three states they're supposed to win by just saying, Yeah, but that person's a Democrat, so I win. If they lose those three states, they've got some serious soul searching to do. And I'll throw out for the Democrats, Michigan, El Sayyed wins. They've got some internals they're gonna have to deal with. We'll see how they play out, but it's gonna matter. speaker-1: Bigger picture what's next for health care? speaker-0: So we will start here. We got to get through lame duck. Now we're going to get too early into our lame duck preview. We're not going to do the whole thing here, but hey, there are three tracks for healthcare next year. One is the regular legislating on whatever's left over, whatever does not get done that we call extenders and other policies they want to accomplish. Track two, there's going to be a huge political fight over HR one, the Medicaid cuts, and the policies in there. And three, there's gonna be a healthcare battle going on in the Democratic presidential primary. All three of those will be things we'll be hearing out throughout twenty seven. Debbie? speaker-2: Totally agree. I would just add that in addition to Medicaid, the ACA will be part of that conversation. So we'll be watching that as well. And in the short term on the lame duck, the wild card here is when they come back in November, how many of them come back? Because if Republican members don't come back, they may not have a functional majority. We hear Republicans continuing to talk about doing reconciliation. They obviously cannot do that if they don't have a functional majority. Many of us don't think they can do that in any way, shape, or form. But if they s regardless, but if if they start out there, that doesn't bode well for the lame duck getting much done on healthcare. And I think what we all have to be prepared for is the likelihood that there's a short term kick the can into twenty seven. And we start off healthcare battles earlier rather than later in the hundred and twentieth Congress. speaker-1: Well, Debbie and Rodney, thank you both so much for joining and thank you for tuning in to this special pre-election episode of the healthcare preview. The preview will be on hiatus until after the election, when we will return on Monday, November 9th to discuss what is on Congress's agenda in the aftermath of the election. We will also be hosting a webinar on November 10th to debrief the election. So keep an eye out for more information on that and to register for that event. For more information on health policy and to subscribe to the healthcare preview, go to copublicstrategies.com. And until next time, I hope you have a great week and a great end of your October card.