Latest / The Team House / Reacting to the Taiwan War Game Video by the WSJ | EYES ON | Ep. 20
Transcript
- 0:00Hello, Welcome to another episode of Aizon. I'm Andy Mulban, I'm Jason
- 0:05Lyons, I'm a Dimitri Contakos. I'm the producer of Izon. In the
- 0:09team house, we have a weird not a weird one, but off beat
- 0:14episode today about China and Taiwan. I came across this video from the Wall
- 0:18Street Journal about a war game of what it would look like if China were
- 0:22to invade Taiwan and the next steps, and I figured I have a military
- 0:26strategist to here. Supposedly, h we could take a look at this video
- 0:32and react to it, add to it, and you know, see where
- 0:35it goes. So thank you guys. Yeah, as they say, it's
- 0:39money Python, it's the money Python line goes now and now for something completely
- 0:44different, and you know, obviously Taiwan and China not just looking in the
- 0:49background, but send a stage and perhaps increasingly so as the wall tunes to
- 0:55shit elsewhere and the topic close to my heart. It's just a very quick
- 1:00comment before we begin this. You know, let's say this is a certainly
- 1:03a credible wargame run by the run by CSIS and Mark Hansion, the guy
- 1:11presenting it, not just because he is a retired marine, is a you
- 1:17know, credible expert. He would probably push against that title. But as
- 1:22as close as it comes on on China, and I think we should welcome
- 1:27any wargame scenario, even if we don't agree with the assumptions or the outcome,
- 1:36simply because it has great minds such as ours and focusing on this problem.
- 1:42So yeah, let it roll, all right? Great? What would
- 1:46happen if China invaded Taiwan? What you're seeing are training drills performed by the
- 1:53Chinese and Taiwanese militaries. Both sides are preparing for a conflict, which,
- 2:00if it took place, would likely include the US in some capacity. Analysts
- 2:05say there are two causes for concern. One is China's long standing position the
- 2:09Taiwan is a part of China and that it would seek re unification by force
- 2:14if necessary. The other is its military build up. The gravity of a
- 2:25potential war has now become a commonplace discussion in the US national security community and
- 2:31raise questions about how a conflict would unfold. To answer those questions, I
- 2:36have a question here, do you guys when you're at the War College or
- 2:39wherever, this is what you guys, do this is how it looks usually?
- 2:44No, this is uh I'm pausing yet, I mean they were at
- 2:50the beginning of my career. Yet you're talking about the board game type approach.
- 2:53Maybe you know, the the the old school roach is I think quite
- 3:01quite unusual. But yes, war games we play them all the time at
- 3:07the war colleges, and they run from just kind of scenarios, talk through
- 3:13of scenarios in faculty groups to full blown war games either you know, with
- 3:20the whole communications networks set up and all of that, involving the entire you
- 3:27know, student body. And in fact, there are a couple of war
- 3:30games that involve all the war colleges simultaneously. Interest So war games vary very
- 3:38much in scale and and intended outcome. We're gonna talk about that, you
- 3:45know, at at the end of this one, all right, but yeah,
- 3:49experts, I'm gonna run it. Look to war games. This was
- 3:57a brilliant movie. Unlike in the movies, in real life wargames board games
- 4:08two. The think tank, the Center for Strategic and International Studies developed a
- 4:12wargame for a Chinese amphibious invasion of Taiwan. Most of the war games that
- 4:16have been done about a conflict between the US and China have been classified.
- 4:20Rumors indicate very adverse outcomes, but the assumptions and the mechanics are not well
- 4:28known because they're classified. We wanted to do something that was entirely unclassified,
- 4:33so we could talk to a very broad audience separated from China. How do
- 4:39we get the classified one? Well, you know, I think Monk's got
- 4:43a good point. Hey, we don't have to necessarily get into you know,
- 4:47to run a decent wargame, you don't necessarily have to it doesn't have
- 4:53to be classified, but you do need to note capabilities to the various involved.
- 4:57Right, so you don't have to name the weapons, systems and all
- 5:00of that. But you know, with through open source information you can get
- 5:03all the critical information to run a walk game. You don't. It doesn't
- 5:06need to be classified. You don't need to know that, you know,
- 5:10the the X blah blah counter ship or counter countership missile has arranged a blah
- 5:20blah blah. You just need to know generally that the US has the capability
- 5:25to do X sort of things. Right, all right, But the good
- 5:30thing here is, you know, Cancin says, up front. Hey,
- 5:33look, this is you know we we are. We're pitching for a wider
- 5:39audience, much wider audience. Yeah, southeastern coast by one hundred miles of
- 5:44sea. Taiwan is a self ruled island the China claims as its own.
- 5:48The Central Intelligence Agency estimates the Chinese leader Shijinping has set twenty twenty seven as
- 5:55the deadline for his military to be ready to take the island. CSIS based
- 6:00it's war games and a hypothetical Chinese invasion of Taiwan taking place in twenty twenty
- 6:03six. Csis's wargame is a turn based strategy simulation after each turn is played,
- 6:11Eddie, Yeah, I've so this is where I think things go a
- 6:15little awry. A turn based wargame. Now, that's not bad as long
- 6:24as people understand that that's not the way wars are fought. But there are
- 6:29a couple of things wrong with this approach. It with several weaknesses. One
- 6:32is, as we get into the turns, they're starting from Chinese boots on
- 6:39the ground in Taiwan almost right. I mean they're talking about the amphibious the
- 6:44landing craft already been in the straight close to it. So My point is
- 6:48they're missing out a ton of shaping actions. And as we as we progress,
- 6:55you know, we have to ask ourselves, Hey, wouldn't the Chinese
- 6:58have thought about this already? Right? You know, capturing a port,
- 7:03suppressing you know, ADA threats, you name it, doing something to counter
- 7:11US submarine the US submarine threat in the Straits. I mean, if we're
- 7:15undoubtedly the Chinese have done this. My point is simply this. Wargames are
- 7:21a great indicator, but the human element is all important. And you know,
- 7:26and that's number one. Number two is you can't stop with you can't
- 7:30start with Taiwan because the war, arguably the whole scenario is one or lost
- 7:38in actions leading up to the actual amphibious assault. To begin with actions now,
- 7:44you know, shaping actions for instance, you know, the US having
- 7:49a strong logistics base and in a method for dissemination, for distribution, sorry,
- 7:57of logistics in the Pacific is our biggest chance lunch, right, and
- 8:01preparations that needs to begin now as it has started to do. You know,
- 8:05we started, we set up stocks in Australia and you know, various
- 8:09other Asian countries I'm sure we will follow and trying to do the same.
- 8:16But you see what I'm saying that that all of this preparation, all of
- 8:20this stuff that's shaping is all important. The starter board game, a turn
- 8:24based war game. I move, you move once the war has already started,
- 8:30kind of misses the point, I think. And there are certain things
- 8:33that you can't really war games, such as the diplomatic side of it,
- 8:37the intelligence side of it. You can make assumptions, you know, or
- 8:41you can whole cloth make things up and say, China is we've discovered through
- 8:46you know, sean human and sources that China tends to do this, blah
- 8:50blah blah. Because like you said, Andy, those things can make or
- 8:54break the outcome. They could actually prevent it from even happening in the first
- 8:58place. You know, we send a diplomatic note that says, you know,
- 9:01hey, this is what we know, and then all of a sudden
- 9:03they roll up the pieces and say we're going home. We're not doing this.
- 9:07So it's I mean, we're recognizing for everybody out there that this is
- 9:11a manufactured scenario because there is certain things that probably in this game itself they
- 9:20can't talk about and they just won't on camera. So something to keep in
- 9:24mind, you know, one other point on this day and the importance of
- 9:26shaping actions undoubtedly, not undoubtedly, but I mean, well, look they
- 9:35you know, they've chosen to begin with this scenario, and I know that
- 9:39with the structure of the wargame as such, they can start with many a
- 9:41seria's I would suggest that if you're not going to underestimate or wish away or
- 9:48assume away an adversaries capabilities, then you have to assume he's going to begin
- 9:54by establishing a blockade over time on unless he's pushing for surprise. But China,
- 10:00those it's got very little you know, they have very little chance of
- 10:03launching a surprise attack. So the blockade is important because it doesn't reach that
- 10:07threshold of armed conflict. But it's putting, you know, pressure on Taiwan
- 10:13to begin with very heavy pressure. I mean, if you think that a
- 10:18blockade it can be carried out not by surface ships, by by submarines,
- 10:22even unmanned vehicles, you name it. I think that is a very dangerous
- 10:28start to the conflict and kind of puts the US in the position again of
- 10:33having to respond from a distance. Right, players turn to combat result tables
- 10:41and computer programs to calculate combat outcomes. Today, CSIS Research assistant Chris Park
- 10:46will be helping facilitate gameplay. Players are divided into two sides. The Red
- 10:52team represents China, the Blue Team represents the US and its allies. Of
- 10:56the twenty four scenarios played, the version you were about to see is the
- 11:00most likely. As the game begins, the Chinese are moving their ships around
- 11:07Taiwan, and they're aircraft over Taiwan. The United States is responding with its
- 11:13own So I guess they're moving the ships. That's the blockade. I would
- 11:16assume that they would start with. No. I think, I mean,
- 11:20he's launching right in the attack here. It's but you know, the biggest
- 11:26one of the biggest controversies about defending Taiwan is getting there right, getting that
- 11:33getting a footing within an area that is covered by uh you know, I
- 11:39always forget the acronym area and anti access area denial right weapons systems, and
- 11:48getting out platforms mainly aircraft carriers within within range to support Taiwan. That's a
- 11:56that's a big issue here, any kind of skirts around it. But the
- 12:01point about landing on the on the south of the island yeah, I mean
- 12:03absolutely, that's legitimate. Uh maybe not. I mean it's it's worth a
- 12:09discussion because all of the critical infrastructure in Taiwan's in the north, you know,
- 12:13to include the capital, but of course that's where Taiwan's ring of defenses
- 12:18are. So you know, Mark uses the the metaphor, I mean the
- 12:24some way of Italy. I'm not sure that's useful, but I I his
- 12:30point, and he's right, is that this is going to be a long,
- 12:35hard, attritional ground slog fest because Taiwan and it who's visited there will
- 12:41tell you that, you know, inland away from the roads, you know,
- 12:45that area is all it's rocky, mountainous pine forests. It's it's not
- 12:54it's not designed for mechanized warfare. It's certainly designed for defense. But you
- 13:01know, there are there are so many other things going on, as we
- 13:03talked about at this time, a massive massive cyber attacks on Taiwanese command and
- 13:09control capabilities, which I don't think Mark mentions in this would certainly have a
- 13:13player. So the ground fight and talking in terms of World War two is
- 13:18not I don't think it's a helpful analogy. All right, let's continue,
- 13:24But yeah, well with its bombers to attack the Chinese naval forces, and
- 13:31also with its surface ships that have been sent forward as part of the US
- 13:37effort to deter the conflict. The United States also has submarines in the streets.
- 13:43Csis's war game is played with three maps. Two operational maps represent the
- 13:48regional operations of the US and its allies and the Chinese forces, respectively.
- 13:54Another ground map is used for the operations on the island. The Chinese have
- 13:58now invaded the island. They've landed forces in the south. Strategically it'd be
- 14:03better and the north that's where the capital is, that's where much of the
- 14:09industry is. The problem is that most of the Taiwanese military capabilities also in
- 14:15the north. That makes it very difficult to invade there. Several of our
- 14:18teams tried to do that in some of the iterations, it was just too
- 14:22difficult. There were too many defending forces, So most of the Chinese teams
- 14:26decided to land in the south. The challenge there is to occupy the country
- 14:31and to take the capital. They have to fight their way up the entire
- 14:35island. The campaign looks much like the Allied campaign in Italy during the Second
- 14:41World War, bit by bit, very difficult terrain. Here we see that
- 14:46the Chinese have landed. First, we have troops landing on the beach.
- 14:52They're only a handful of good beaches on Taiwan for landing troops. These are
- 14:56indicated on the map. And then around the airfield we have Chinese parachute and
- 15:03airmobile troops as troops coming in by helicopter. And the purpose of doing that
- 15:09would they would they be able to get like a lot of enough airborne guys
- 15:13in through helicopter. The really tricky part about this is, you know,
- 15:20I think that's a Pintung airfield in the south. You know, imagine how
- 15:26that figures in Chinese wargames, right. So the problem with this particular wargame,
- 15:33the way it's talked through, is that they are trying to seize these
- 15:35places, you know, after the conflict has started, and they're trying to
- 15:39do it in a very conventional way. You know, We've got to give
- 15:43the Chinese credit to being a little more innovative. But yeah, they certainly
- 15:48they will want to seize control of that airfield, and I would think,
- 15:52you know, and also a port whether they're going to set up their own
- 15:56temporary port, or try and seize the port at al Shun, which is
- 16:02you know, obviously a massive, massive port would really help them out.
- 16:04But but it's you know, it's going to be is going to be defended.
- 16:10Now they've got to do something about cal Shun anyway, some major metropolis,
- 16:15uh, you know, so they only contain it as they advance.
- 16:18All they do, indeed go in and seize key terrain there and sort of
- 16:23the port. There's nothing more keytering than that port. But yeah, tricky
- 16:29move. You know, you just have to look at history of airborne operations
- 16:32and in conjunction with an amphibious assault from crete onwards, you know, at
- 16:37best the Chinese is going to suffer very high attrition. But I just you
- 16:42know, I cannot imagine. I don't want to minimize the threat, but
- 16:47I cannot imagine a successful assault conducted in you know, on a on on
- 16:53that airfield and that has been that is so coveted by both sides and for
- 17:03which the Taiwanese have had a long time to practice how to defense. But
- 17:08could be wrong. It will be an objective in them if they can capture
- 17:14the airfield intact, then they can fly in troops and supplies are not dependent
- 17:18on ships and craft bringing troops and supplies across the beach. After both science
- 17:26play their turns, the game is paused for an adjudication in which the losses
- 17:30for each side are calculated. What we see is that the Chinese amphibious units
- 17:36have successfully gone ashore, They've moved ten kilometers inland, and they eliminated one
- 17:45Taiwanese battalion out of the defenders. The air mobile and parachute games were less
- 17:49successful. This still hit that for a moment. All right, Hey,
- 17:55guys, it's Jack. I just wanted to talk to you today about a
- 17:57way that you can help support the podcast. If you're not already, we
- 18:00would really appreciate it if you guys went and reviewed us on Apple or Spotify.
- 18:06Those reviews really help people find the podcast and help it get recognized,
- 18:10and you know, if you've been enjoying the show, we really appreciate your
- 18:12support. Another thing that you can do to support the channel is to become
- 18:18a Patreon member. So we have Patreon memberships that started just five dollars a
- 18:22month, and when you sign up, you get access to all of our
- 18:26episodes add free. That's the big bonus for that. I mean, we
- 18:30also do some Patreon bonus episodes for our subscribers, but this is the biggest
- 18:37and best way that you can support the Teamhouse channel and podcast if you'd like
- 18:41to, and we really appreciate that, So go and check us out at
- 18:45Patreon dot com slash the Teamhouse. This is where I started to get a
- 18:49little irritated because it seems as though the whole game has gravit take it down
- 18:56to just kind of a hey, this is, you know, a game
- 19:02when we talk about the kind of casualty intensive fighting here, you know,
- 19:07Mark removes a battalion from from the board. I think either side of this
- 19:14stage would be lucky to avoid to to lose only a few battalions. And
- 19:18remember, you know what's the battalion? I mean, I forget in PLA,
- 19:22it's quite small. Someone's going to contradict me, but I believe it's
- 19:25three to four hundred guys. What they are we doing a war game where
- 19:30we're accounting, you know, casualties like that. It just seems a little
- 19:34arcade because that's not what's going to sway the course of events here. It's
- 19:41going to be it's going to be major moves like the Chinese destroying or denying
- 19:48our ability to use Japan as a base. That is a game changer,
- 19:55you know, that's the sort of thing that we should be talking about,
- 19:59not one, one or two battalions being a Trindad hero there. We're not
- 20:03learning that way, it's my view, all right, that's a much more
- 20:07difficult operation. They landed around the airfield, eliminated one defending Taiwanese battalion,
- 20:15but they lost three of their own battalions. This is a very risky operation
- 20:19and they have not captured the airfield yet. Once the losses for the last
- 20:23turn are calculated, the second turn is played with dramatic results. There's not
- 20:27much change on the US side, tremendous change on the Chinese side. Let's
- 20:32take a look. So you got to assume like even in this initial like
- 20:37amphibious landing, they got to be looking at hitting a carrier strike group,
- 20:44like you know, things are spinning up. We're probably sending more strike groups
- 20:48in well. Yeah, this is why kind of movement to the objective is
- 20:52all important, right to really talk through in the wargame time space, things
- 20:59involved the role of for instance, the marine littoral regiment who's supposed to be
- 21:03already in place here mostly in you know, an islands, particularly Japanese islands.
- 21:11Southwest is one that's less than one hundred miles from from Taiwan. It's
- 21:17southwest of Okanawa, so you know, and they are in their role is
- 21:22to a try it the not just the amphibious fleet, but the you know,
- 21:29the main surface vessels to supporting or that that assault. So there's and
- 21:38and also I mean think about what is already in the area. Undoubtedly US
- 21:44submarines in the Strait, and you can imagine even one or two would wreck
- 21:52a huge amount of data. And that's the Chinese biggest, biggest fear.
- 21:56Undoubtedly the US is continuing to focus on attacking the Chinese ships around Taiwan,
- 22:03trying to get through the picket screen there to get at the amphibious ships.
- 22:07The submarines are still in the Straits. The one that was in the Straits
- 22:12last trend has moved back to base in Japan Yukushka to reload. The squadron
- 22:19that was outside the Straits has moved in, and a new squadron has moved
- 22:23forward. Now looking at the Chinese side, here we have a lot of
- 22:26change, and the big thing is that the Chinese have decided to strike Japan,
- 22:32and they've decided to strike in a major way rather than just strike one
- 22:36basica, decided to strike all of the Japanese bases with Japanese aircraft and US
- 22:41aircraft. What you're seeing here is the flow. So that's a huge partying.
- 22:49Denying Japan as a base for US forces is going to be a Jampanese
- 22:59goal, you know, and initially maybe even in shaping operations. But what
- 23:04Mark's talking about is quite ambitious. You know, he's talking about massive attacks.
- 23:10Yes, certainly airfields would be a target, but they but at the
- 23:12same time, the Chinese have to focus on critical infrastructure because the weight of
- 23:17their I mean these are yes, they this is going to be a role
- 23:19for their There are mid to long range rockets and missiles, not just US
- 23:29aircraft. Though. The big thing is going to be logistics supplies, taking
- 23:32out those, particularly things like jet fuel or just gasoline all together. I
- 23:37mean that that is China knows again that are one of our perhaps olf biggest
- 23:44vulnerability is going to be our logistics. Gene genes Oh of Taiwanese forces from
- 23:51the north where they let me ask you, Jason, like, what's going
- 23:55on now? If this is happening and this is kicking off, like where's
- 23:57the CIA in this? Like what are they doing? What's their role?
- 24:03Well, from my low level point of view, it would seem that focusing
- 24:07on Chinese leadership, what is what are their thought process? Right now?
- 24:11We know that what their end goal is, but how far are they willing
- 24:17to take this? You know, they're talking, they're listening to singing,
- 24:19they're talking to what few probably human sources they have. Hey, what are
- 24:25they thinking? How far are they willing to push this? You know,
- 24:29is there any kind of dissension in the ranks, because if this was a
- 24:32right now scenario, there's corruption in the PLA, there's questions of loyalty within
- 24:40the PLA. So those are the kind of things that intel officers would want
- 24:44to be finding out. Is everyone on board with this and if not,
- 24:47who isn't and how far are they willing to go to stop this kind of
- 24:49thing? Cool they were initially stationed protecting the capital. Now they're coming down
- 24:56both coasts to engage the Chines. These landing troops in the south, there
- 25:03are more amphibious units that have come across the beach. Here they are attacking
- 25:07the Taiwanese defenders. There are a few more air mobile parachute units that have
- 25:14landed around the airfield. They've surrounded the Taiwanese which are holding out on the
- 25:19airfield. But both of these Chinese forces are attacking the Taiwanese. After the
- 25:26second turn is played, the second adjudication round takes stock of the losses on
- 25:30both sides. This has been a massive term. Both sides have taken very
- 25:34heavy casualties. The results are that the Chinese lose one battalion over here and
- 25:41the Taiwanese also lose one defending battalion around the airfield. The Taiwanese lose one
- 25:48defending battalion and the Chinese lose attacking battalion. We now fast forward about three
- 25:56weeks eight, feel like there'd be way more casualties in that. I'm just
- 26:03an idiot, so I don't know. I mean, this is the problem
- 26:07with this particular war game. It's kind of evolved into, you know,
- 26:10the kind of war game we played as kids. We threw dice and decided
- 26:12how many casualties and each side had taken and it's really not you know,
- 26:17I don't think they're talking about the major actions of every phase. Mark did
- 26:21touch on it with the submarines and Japan, but we need to talk to
- 26:26you know, if you talked about three boards and this one on Taiwan is
- 26:30just one board. All right. There's also stuff going on potentially a career,
- 26:34right, China's influenced North Korea and so diverting our attention there. There's
- 26:42there's things happening on the biggest stage that have a bearing on what is happening
- 26:48in Taiwan and vice versa. You know. Lastly, we're talking about kind
- 26:52of wishing away and adversaries capabilities. You know, we have to be careful
- 27:00to wish away his ability to innovate and imagine, especially imagine. Right,
- 27:06So give you an example. This was a kind of single axis amphibious assault
- 27:11followed by a two axis you know, kind of advance up the coast.
- 27:17Why would the Chinese be you know, kind of approach that way. There's
- 27:22many disadvantages without without trying to put the Taiwan Taiwanese on the horns of a
- 27:29dilemma. I didn't say that very well, on the horns of a dilemma.
- 27:33I trotted that cliche out. Well, you know the point, a
- 27:37faint demonstration, a massive you know, towards Taipei, a landing on the
- 27:45north coast, either the main or subsidiary landing. I mean, there's there's
- 27:52we've got to when when you have when you have a piece of terrain that
- 27:56both sides have looked at and prepared for for a long time, you have
- 28:00to use deception and you have to employ your imagination, you know. And
- 28:06I think for just like I think Mark knows that obviously being a Marine colonel
- 28:10and you know, doing this this whole life. I think it's just you
- 28:14know, for the Wall Street Journal, they kind of want to like probably
- 28:17make it. Yeah, but I think someone should make that point editorially.
- 28:19You're right. And the other point is they did mention that there are three
- 28:25boards, So why not talk about what's happening on the other boards. That's
- 28:27my point because it's so important and I'm not you know, just throwing darts.
- 28:32As I said, I welcome this. We're talking about this war game,
- 28:36so it is substantive, uh, and it starts the discussion cooling.
- 28:47The Chinese have moved up the East coast, but they've bumped into Taiwanese units
- 28:52that they're coming down the east coast. That movement has been slowed by the
- 28:57Chinese aircraft which have been attacking the transportation system. But eventually those troops get
- 29:03there and they've formed a pretty solid line on the east coast. The Chinese
- 29:07were able to clear the airport where the Taiwanese have been holding out and have
- 29:14moved forward. Here in the center. They've bumped into a Taiwanese defensive line
- 29:22and that has been reinforced by fortifications. They've moved into the city down here
- 29:30in the south. The reason for moving into the city is to capture the
- 29:34port. Finally, we're rocking hey, So he says that almost cashally they
- 29:41moved into the city, right, I would say, I mean Kelshun,
- 29:45that's Taiwan's major port. They wouldn't you know the purpose of moving that,
- 29:49you know, they would launch I think a very determined attack on Klshun,
- 29:55as I said before, either to seize the port or to isolate the city,
- 30:00or both. Last adjudication and the end of the game. This scenario
- 30:07concludes with the Chinese established ashore but unable to expand their forces there. Much
- 30:14of the Chinese amphibious fleet has been destroyed. The United States and its partners
- 30:18have been attacking those ships relentlessly, so their ability to bring troops and supplies
- 30:25onto the island has declined. Over time, those forces will weaken, the
- 30:30Taiwanese will push them back, most of them will end up as prisoners of
- 30:34war. When we ran this game, we considered it a minor US coalition
- 30:41victory. It was a minor victory because it was going to take a lot
- 30:45of time and there was going to be a lot of damage to Taiwan.
- 30:48But it was a US and coalition victory because the Chinese were unable to establish
- 30:52themselves on Taiwan and Taiwan endured as an autonomous and democrat entity. All right,
- 31:00let me just so in the beginning, I want to give Mark a
- 31:03little bit of credit. In the beginning, they mentioned that they ran it
- 31:07twenty plus times and stuff like that, So I really do think, like
- 31:11the Wallstreet Journal like this probably took them like nine hours to film and they
- 31:15cut it down to ten minutes. So like, I want to give Mark
- 31:18a little bit of credit in terms of that, right, because I'm sure
- 31:21they do good work at yes, I yeah, one hundred percent. But
- 31:25that but you know, and this isn't about criticizing markam World. But but
- 31:29again, the methodology, it isn't just scale, it's the methodology of turn
- 31:33turn turn, and and he didn't cover shaping actions in any you know,
- 31:37at all during the war game, regardless of length, and if he did,
- 31:42he should. So yeah, absolutely absolutely distilled. And it's a it's
- 31:48an absolutely wonderful thing to have done because it has five million views, people
- 31:55who are thinking through this problem. But yeah, don't I mean, hey,
- 32:00you wants me to criticize this. You're right, You're right. No,
- 32:04you're not wrong, You're definitely not wrong. You know, it's just
- 32:07that people need to understand, like you said, this is the base,
- 32:12This is a baseline warging. This is not all encompassing at all, you
- 32:16know, exactly. But I think to make it a really good one,
- 32:20you'd have to change some of your assumptions and the methodology of how it's conducted.
- 32:24Absolutely, And I mean like you got to assume the casualties will be
- 32:29enormous, right, especially for China, for every side. Yeah, I
- 32:32mean politically, how did like because you know, CCP wants to stay the
- 32:37ruling party of China. If they losing, if they lose fifty thousand guys
- 32:43or more, which they've never had before, no one cares. What do
- 32:47you mean, no one cares? No one cares. I mean they You
- 32:51know, China's pretty even less sensitive to casualties than Russia, because you think
- 32:59it's only in functioning democracies where there is a feedback loops helping opinion to the
- 33:04government through the government's survival, where casualties matter at all. So we shouldn't
- 33:08mirror image. The Chinese could lose a million people here and if you know,
- 33:14if they could continue fighting and it was still a political objective, they
- 33:16would continue pursuing it. And nothing says that this has happens as a singleton.
- 33:22You know, nothing says that China can't take their beating withdraw, learn
- 33:28your lessons, and then come back again. You know, it's the question
- 33:31is how long can we hold out or how long are we willing to do
- 33:36this? In the Taiwanese So is there in a CIA or NSA or whoever
- 33:42army, Siap, whoever like is there There's got to be a strategy in
- 33:45place to if they did take a beating or if it's ongoing and they're losing
- 33:50tens of thousands of guys a month, how do we get the Chinese public
- 33:54to turn on the CCP that's going to be I think that's there's got to
- 34:00a strategy though. I mean, I'm sure, yeah, I'm sure there's
- 34:04something on the books, but like Andy's saying, there's that's small, that's
- 34:07way down on the list. Tell you what, though, when we're talking
- 34:12about not solving this problem, but taking a clear eyed approach top to preventing
- 34:19this scenario unraveling war, I think strack com is an important issue and it
- 34:24comes down specifically to the United States policy towards defensive Taiwan. Right. So
- 34:30you know, to this point we say strategic ambiguity, which is one of
- 34:34those wonderful meaningless phrases, right, but it was born in the Cold War
- 34:38when it was you know, it's a very simple fact that the US enjoyed
- 34:42overwhelming military dominance against China and the waters and airways you know of the Western
- 34:46Pacific. And you know, so although Taiwan's only one hundred miles from China,
- 34:52thousands of miles you know from the US, the US US dominance I'm
- 34:57trying to avoid saying our us and it's was so clearly pronounced for five decades
- 35:06that there was no doubt that we would have come to Taiwan's defense and won.
- 35:14But strategic ambiguity, now when China could have the upper hand in such
- 35:20a conflict, counts against us. Right. We should be saying, Look,
- 35:24it's gonna really be painful for both of us if you do attack Taiwan.
- 35:29But you should know that it is US policy to go to the defense
- 35:32of Taiwan. So if you initiate conflict, you know it's going to be
- 35:37a wider war. Just saying, you know, so we raised the calculus
- 35:42for China going to war. Now, strategic ambiguity is a danger. Strategic
- 35:47ambiguity, arguably is what it got us into the First Golf War, you
- 35:52know, I mean not messaging clearly to Sadam before he rolled into Quaint that
- 35:57we would crush him if he tried if he did some. I mean we
- 35:59had warnings of plenty. I mean, our US ambassador was almost briefed on
- 36:04the plan. Right, So we've got to get over thinking that we're being
- 36:08coined because other countries don't appreciate the recognized, don't understand our coinness. We
- 36:15should simply say hey, if you invade Taiwan, games on, you know,
- 36:20and say it publicly, and that way, maybe we don't have to
- 36:23deal with these step by step war games where we're losing a battalion, you
- 36:30know, h every few seconds. So I feel like the only way we'd
- 36:35be game on one hundred percent is if we lost a carrier and like,
- 36:38you know, thousands of sailors died, and then the US populace is outraged,
- 36:45right, Oh you mean on that, yeah, the US. I
- 36:47mean, look, it's hard to it's really hard to gauge the US public's
- 36:53capacity for torrance for war with China. I mean, I can't gauge the
- 37:00US public's tolerance for anything twenty four hours in advance because it shifts so quickly.
- 37:07Right, yeah, I mean we're going to see you know. I
- 37:09mean, any estimates are meaningless because they depend on what scenarios you've set up.
- 37:15But every scenario expects to lose at least a carrier. You I mean,
- 37:20that would be realistic, right, you know, one or two of
- 37:23those thousands of missiles are likely to get through. So yes, we're going
- 37:29to see We're not going to lose guys so much in ground fighting except for
- 37:36you know, perhaps the Marines out there, but with the MLA, but
- 37:40who cares about them, right their Marines? You know? Do all of
- 37:47our casualties are going to be either nable or aviation. And when they were
- 37:53talking about they will be significant, I'm sorry, I'm sorry. When they
- 37:57were talking about hitting the China, make the decision to hit bases in Japan.
- 38:00Those aren't just Japanese bases, you know those You're not just gonna lose
- 38:06Japanese personnel. So yeah, he was talking about us basis and that's a
- 38:10great point, chase, And I'm sorry, Yeah, totally totally forguxistly Yeah,
- 38:15thousands, i mean dependents, Yeah, yeah, because and then what
- 38:20does it become like what was never addressed was because I'm sure for time and
- 38:25classification, what is our response to that as far as hitting inside of China?
- 38:30Do we go after their leadership? Are we just focusing on Taiwan?
- 38:36You know, because now it becomes a bigger issue. Yeah, what are
- 38:39the rules of the game? How does it's Yeah, this was a great
- 38:49exercise. Yeah, I mean, it was a great not It was a
- 38:52great exercise that they did in the sense again that they went through these steps
- 38:57and look at all the questions from asking, right, I mean yeah,
- 39:00undoubtedly we'ren't. I mean, I we've learned from it, so kudos.
- 39:05So I just like I'd like to see more of these Yeah, no,
- 39:07this is super interesting. Yeah, but most of them. I'd like to
- 39:10see the United States just say, hey, yes, we're going to defend
- 39:15Taiwan any questions. Yeah, you know, come on. That would certainly
- 39:21that's why the Chinese would understand that. Right, Yeah, let's wrap this
- 39:24one. All the US and its allies came out on top of this scenario.
- 39:29The US was not always successful. There were some scenarios where the United
- 39:32States did lose the conflict. A key requirement is the use of bases in
- 39:37Japan. The United States has many bases there. If it cannot use those
- 39:43bases, then it has no way of getting its fight or in attack aircraft
- 39:47into the fight, regardless of the scenario is there, Like, those bases
- 39:52have to be heavily defended. Right, Having been a base that one I
- 39:58don't know about heavily, Uh you the one that I was at Ikuni.
- 40:02Uh, it just relied on it's on the aircraft. I never saw any
- 40:10strategic air defenses there or anything like that. Not saying that they're not there,
- 40:14I'm just saying that that wasn't something that was readily seen. So,
- 40:19yeah, the air defense is the key thing. And the answer is there
- 40:22is never enough, you know, A number two. The answer is what
- 40:27even if we could defend them, now, the chances are in a few
- 40:30years they are the defenses to be overwhelmed. Just it's it's battlefield calculus,
- 40:36right that. Yeah, Chinese are just generating more and more sophisticated precision,
- 40:44long range precision missiles, and you have to assume even if it hits an
- 40:47American base in Japan, Japan is gonna spin up, right, like,
- 40:53yeah, but what does that do for us? I mean, be ready,
- 40:55I mean listen, I mean it's gonna I know you're right. So
- 40:59it's a full Japan's in the war, you know, I mean, there's
- 41:04no doubt about it. And Japan knows that and and has started to prepare
- 41:10in its own way for a war with China, which is kind of interesting.
- 41:15In the last five years in particular, part of it is sadly kind
- 41:20of a perhaps a show of lack of confidence in the US and but but
- 41:25also a positive thing, you know, because Japan could be a really strong
- 41:30regional player again you know, historically probably wary of having a large military force.
- 41:37But but my opinion something that we should strongly encourage because what other ally
- 41:44do we have that combines loyalty to the United States with military with with technical
- 41:51capability. And you know, there, I say, at Western values democracy,
- 41:57there are very few right in the world in Southeast Asia, Australia,
- 42:02New Zealand with its massive military are you any iterations found that the cost for
- 42:12all sides would be devastating. The big takeaway from the project is that the
- 42:15United States is coalition partners can sustain an autonomous and democratic Taiwan, but it
- 42:22comes at great cost to the Taiwanese economy. The US and its partners lose
- 42:27very heavily, but so do the Chinese, enough so that the grip of
- 42:30the Chinese Communist Party might be endangered. All right, that's the end of
- 42:35it. M It's just hard to imagine the grip of the Chinese Communist Party
- 42:40being endangered in China. You know. That's I don't know, that's like,
- 42:46that's like saying the grip of God over the the you know, Catholic
- 42:52Church. I mean, what else is there? Spot? Yeah, thank
- 43:00you d that was good. That was awesome. Don't forget to like and
- 43:04subscribe. If you're listening to us on audio rate and review at five stars,
- 43:07that helps just as well. Patreon dot com slash the teamhouse to help
- 43:10support the show. Andy Milburn's book When the Tempest Gathers link is in the
- 43:15description. All the links will be in the description. H yes, thank
- 43:19you and Andy, welcome back from the man. Hey, it's an award
- 43:22winning put now. Oh yeah, congratulations. Congratulations man, it's awesome.
- 43:30The expensive oount lay I believe of around eighteen dollars, but if you get
- 43:34it audible you can get it free. And Kindle has a really good knockdown.
- 43:39Right and follow Jason on Twitter. Yeah good on Twitter? No,
- 43:46good luck? All right, thanks guys, take care of Jents later