Latest / Legally Speaking with Michael Mulligan / Informer Privilege vs. Fair Public Trials and Damages for a Puck Injury
Transcript
- 0:00Adam Stirling: It's time for our regular segment with Michael Mulligan, barrister and solicitor.
- 0:03Adam Stirling: With Mulligan Defense Lawyers, legally speaking on CFAX 1070.
- 0:07Adam Stirling: Morning Michael, how we doing.
- 0:08Adam Stirling: Hey, good morning, I'm doing great.
- 0:10Adam Stirling: Always good to be here.
- 0:11Adam Stirling: Couple of really interesting stories on the agenda today.
- 0:13Adam Stirling: Where shall we begin?
- 0:16Michael Mulligan: Well, I think we can start with the Supreme Court of Canada declaring that there was no secret trial, which is an interesting declaration to be making.
- 0:24Michael Mulligan: And so the background of this case.
- 0:28Michael Mulligan: It comes out of Quebec originally, and it involves these competing legal concepts.
- 0:35Michael Mulligan: One is a concept of what's called informer privilege, and that runs squarely up against the right to a fair and public trial, freedom of the press and all of those values.
- 0:46Michael Mulligan: Now, I should say that, first of all, that concept of having a sort of a fair and public trial is really sort of central to our justice system and, living in a democratic society with freedom of the press and so forth, it's constitutionally protected.
- 1:05Michael Mulligan: Section 11D of the Charter provides that a person's presumed innocent until proven guilty according to law in a fair and public hearing by an independent and impartial tribunal.
- 1:17Michael Mulligan: And so you would think, on the face of it, well, we can't have secret trials.
- 1:21Michael Mulligan: We're not in China, where you go behind a closed door and five minutes later they take you out back and shoot you.
- 1:27Michael Mulligan: But that constitutional principle is at odds with a judicially created rule of public policy, which is informer privilege.
- 1:41Michael Mulligan: And the Supreme Court of Canada confirms that that concept of informer privilege is judicially created.
- 1:47Michael Mulligan: It's not a statutory thing.
- 1:49Michael Mulligan: The Supreme Court of Canada has created it many years ago and they've repeatedly found it to be very, very important.
- 1:58Michael Mulligan: And the concept of informer privilege is that where a person provides information to the police with the promise from the police of confidentiality whether that's explicit, the police says we won't, you know, we'll keep your identity secret or even when that's by implication that it would be kept secret, the person gets the benefit of informer privilege.
- 2:21Michael Mulligan: And the informer privilege means that the person cannot be identified.
- 2:27Michael Mulligan: And the Supreme Court of Canada and the jurisprudence surrounding it, including this most recent case about this secret trial, finds that informer privilege has been characterized as absolute or near absolute and does not depend on any balancing of interests, which is very interesting.
- 2:47Michael Mulligan: Most legal concepts aren't absolute because of course, we live in a gray world where sometimes, you know, competing interests have to be balanced against one another, what the courts do.
- 2:58Michael Mulligan: But this privilege, the Supreme Court of Canada is saying that it's near absolute.
- 3:03Michael Mulligan: It applies to civil, administrative and criminal proceedings.
- 3:08Michael Mulligan: There is only one exception.
- 3:09Michael Mulligan: The exception is an extremely narrow one and it's an exception that can only apply in criminal cases referred to as the innocence at stake exception, which is very narrow.
- 3:20Michael Mulligan: It means that in order for the identity of an informer to be revealed, the judge would need to be persuaded that it was necessary to do so.
- 3:32Michael Mulligan: For a person to establish their innocence of a criminal charge Not desirable, not might do that might buttress the defense but necessary right, which is very narrow, otherwise the person's identity is kept secret.
- 3:48Michael Mulligan: Now you put those principles together and this case from Quebec involved a person who was a police informant, who was then charged with an offense, we don't know what, relating, according to what we do know, the person's status of being a police informant.
- 4:11Michael Mulligan: So they're charged with a crime of some kind, and the person's defense is a claim of an abusive process, claiming that somehow what the state did was, you know, really very unfair in terms of how they dealt with them, such so unfair that the charges should be stayed.
- 4:32Michael Mulligan: And so, with those competing.
- 4:34Michael Mulligan: So imagine that, okay, you've got this person who's a police informer, everyone agrees that they're a police informer, informant who is now charged with a crime, and that's what they want to argue.
- 4:45Michael Mulligan: Well, the judge hearing the case decides that nothing can be known about this or the person's identity might be revealed, because the entire case involves the fact that the person's a police informant and the abuse of process issue relates to that.
- 5:02Michael Mulligan: And so the judge the trial judge decides to conduct a trial in camera, like doors locked, gives no notice to the media or anyone else, does not put a court file number on it and there's just nothing.
- 5:23Michael Mulligan: There's no sign of this thing ever happening.
- 5:25Michael Mulligan: There's no file number made public, the doors are sealed, nobody's told about this and this trial occurs, wow.
- 5:32Michael Mulligan: And the judge rejects the abuse of process argument and convicts the man.
- 5:37Michael Mulligan: Now the case then goes the man appeals to the Court of Appeal in Quebec.
- 5:44Michael Mulligan: The Court of Appeal in Quebec is critical of what the judge did, saying that the judge conducted a secret trial and, moreover, finds that the abuse of process argument was meritorious and so overturns the conviction.
- 6:02Michael Mulligan: But again, we have no idea what the charge was, what the abusive process was, who this person was or anything else.
- 6:09Adam Stirling: Wow.
- 6:11Michael Mulligan: Now, of course, the media and others get wind of the court of appeal.
- 6:14Michael Mulligan: They sort of release this decision with no reasons, referring to a secret trial, which of course causes everyone to be what on earth is going on?
- 6:22Michael Mulligan: Have we turned into China, right?
- 6:25Michael Mulligan: And what about this fair and public hearing?
- 6:27Michael Mulligan: And what about the freedom of the press?
- 6:29Michael Mulligan: And, should this so off, the case goes to the Supreme Court of Canada.
- 6:34Michael Mulligan: And so the Supreme Court of Canada is then dealing with those competing interests, this judge-made public policy about informer privilege being virtually absolute, and that it goes further.
- 6:51Michael Mulligan: They say that privilege it's more than just something which could directly identify the person, but also any information that could lead to the person being identified, and in this case, the information that was kept secret included, where this was what the charge was.
- 7:07Michael Mulligan: We have no idea what was going on Now.
- 7:09Michael Mulligan: The Supreme Court of Canada.
- 7:11Michael Mulligan: First of all and this is an interesting thing they have been a little defensive lately.
- 7:17Michael Mulligan: They saw the Chief Justice complaining that politicians were complaining about the court's decisions, criticizing them without having read them.
- 7:27Michael Mulligan: That was one of their complaints.
- 7:29Michael Mulligan: Fair enough, that's, I think, a fair criticism.
- 7:31Michael Mulligan: You should probably read and understand the decision before you criticize it.
- 7:34Michael Mulligan: Now, in this particular case, the Supreme Court of Canada declared that there was no secret trial.
- 7:41Michael Mulligan: Now you have to you do need to read the whole decision.
- 7:45Michael Mulligan: I've read it.
- 7:46Michael Mulligan: I've read it carefully, right, and they distinguish between the concepts of a sort of a secret trial, which I guess they take to mean a trial where there's no record of it at all and they say, well, this wasn't, there was no record of it, you could somehow sniff it out.
- 8:02Michael Mulligan: But when you have a trial which is conducted in camera so nobody can go in the room, when you have an order that bans any publication of it, and when you do things like you don't notify the press that anything's going on or anyone else, it's a pretty thin line between an in-camera proceeding with no file number and locked doors and a secret trial.
- 8:28Michael Mulligan: Now the Supreme Court of Canada goes on to analyze all of that and they confirm that principle of informer privilege being very important.
- 8:39Michael Mulligan: And I should say this this is something I think people should think about, because this isn't something in the Charter, it's not something in the Criminal Code.
- 8:46Michael Mulligan: Judges have just made this up and they've created this concept of informer privilege and the justification for it has been over the years and, in this case, the justification that that is necessary, that concept of informer privilege.
- 9:03Michael Mulligan: It is necessary in order to ensure public order and effective policing.
- 9:12Michael Mulligan: Now, I think that's something which we should at least consider right, that is a policy decision, right?
- 9:19Michael Mulligan: Do we want to live in a country where we have, you know, secret informers providing information to the police?
- 9:24Michael Mulligan: It does have kind of a stazzy, you know East German, you know Cold War element to it and you know this goes back to that sort of era.
- 9:35Michael Mulligan: You know, is that something we want?
- 9:37Michael Mulligan: Do we want to live in a place where there's no doubt that if you didn't have that, more crimes would go undetected?
- 9:44Michael Mulligan: Right, you might have people saying I'm not going to go, you know, provide information if I can't be assured that my information will be kept secret.
- 9:53Michael Mulligan: But the entire criminal justice system in Canada and in other Western countries weighs a desire to detect crime with other things that we consider to be more important.
- 10:05Michael Mulligan: Right, like, for example, we require police to obtain search warrants before they go into your home and rummage around looking for evidence.
- 10:12Michael Mulligan: If we and that's just a decision that we've made that sort of privacy trumps crime solving, you know, if you got rid of that you would solve more crime, but at the cost of the police might be in your bedroom when you come home, going through your underwear drawer looking for something.
- 10:28Michael Mulligan: Well, we just decided that we don't want that.
- 10:31Michael Mulligan: And so we're agreeing that some crimes were, the evidence of which, you know the bag of drugs or whatever, when that was illegal, was in your underwear drawer.
- 10:40Michael Mulligan: We're not going to solve that one Now.
- 10:42Michael Mulligan: This is the same thing, and so there could be a reasonable public policy decision made to say, look, you know, yes, we want to detect crimes, but we weigh things like having public hearings, public trials, and not having things whether you call it a secret trial or an in-camera proceeding with no file number, that nobody knows about.
- 11:01Michael Mulligan: If you say, look, you know the principle of having things done in public so people can be aware of, like well, what did the government do to this person?
- 11:10Michael Mulligan: What happened there?
- 11:12Michael Mulligan: Was that so bad and abusive that it overrode?
- 11:15Michael Mulligan: What crime did they commit?
- 11:17Michael Mulligan: Did they murder somebody?
- 11:18Michael Mulligan: Did they steal a chocolate bar?
- 11:20Michael Mulligan: We have no idea.
- 11:20Michael Mulligan: That's pretty important stuff, right?
- 11:24Michael Mulligan: You know you've had a finding here for the Court of Appeal that whatever abusive conduct the state engaged in was so abusive that the charges against this person, whatever they were, had to be stayed, and wherever they occurred.
- 11:35Michael Mulligan: We don't know that either that's been kept secret and it might reveal who the person is.
- 11:39Michael Mulligan: That either that's been kept secret, it might reveal who the person is, and so that's just, I think, something people should think about.
- 11:48Michael Mulligan: Is that degree of informer privilege something that we still want post-charter in 2024?
- 11:52Michael Mulligan: Or is the importance of knowing those kinds of things?
- 11:55Michael Mulligan: Does that outweigh the idea of having an absolute form of informer privilege?
- 11:59Michael Mulligan: Should there be some weighing there right?
- 12:01Michael Mulligan: Should a judge be able to weigh that up, listen to the arguments in a particular case and make a decision about it, or should it be kept as well?
- 12:09Michael Mulligan: It's just absolute.
- 12:10Michael Mulligan: It doesn't matter whether the you know premier of a province went and threatened to kill somebody, causing their murder trial to be stayed.
- 12:18Michael Mulligan: You know that could be what went on.
- 12:20Michael Mulligan: We have no idea.
- 12:21Michael Mulligan: Or maybe the person didn't get I don't know right to counsel after they were arrested for shoplifting.
- 12:26Michael Mulligan: We just have no earthly idea what went on here, and so you know.
- 12:32Michael Mulligan: I think that's something we should think about and you know, there, I think, is legitimate room for criticism about maintaining an absolutist position, even if you think we want to live in a place where informers secret informers should be part of our criminal justice investigative system.
- 12:49Michael Mulligan: I'm not persuaded that without secret informers all of the wheels come off the bus, any more than I would be persuaded that if we got rid of a person's right to be free from unreasonable search and seizure, all of the wheels would come off the bus either.
- 13:04Michael Mulligan: But you know, that's for people to reasonably debate and consider, although there is no debate or consideration of it, even by judges trial judges, court of appeal judges here's the Supreme Court of Canada.
- 13:15Michael Mulligan: It's a hierarchy right.
- 13:16Michael Mulligan: So, no matter what a particular judge thinks about it.
- 13:18Michael Mulligan: Well, that's the law, that's the law of the land.
- 13:21Michael Mulligan: I guess, subject to, there could be a legislative response to that Right If a government decided look, we don't like thumbs up to continued operation of this absolute and former privilege.
- 13:31Michael Mulligan: They did say that.
- 13:46Michael Mulligan: What was?
- 13:47Michael Mulligan: They did criticize the Court of Appeal for calling it a secret trial, which seems a little harsh.
- 13:52Michael Mulligan: I don't know how else you would fairly describe that thing, but they did say that more should have been done to at least allow some information about what was going on so that we don't have a genuinely secret trial in the future.
- 14:05Michael Mulligan: And so they talked about various ways like, for example, they said the Court of Appeal could have issued a heavily redacted reasons for judgment that removed all information that had any possibility of identifying this person, that had any possibility of identifying this person.
- 14:19Michael Mulligan: You know, maybe we could know, for example, what the charge was, or maybe we could know what the state did that was so bad that caused the charge to be stayed.
- 14:28Michael Mulligan: We don't know that.
- 14:29Michael Mulligan: Maybe that couldn't be revealed without possibly identifying the person.
- 14:33Michael Mulligan: So the Supreme Court of Canada did say that there should have been further information, at least that they talked about, as they have in a previous case from BC involving the Vancouver Sun.
- 14:43Michael Mulligan: You know there could be approaches taken by a trial judge to do things in some cases like create a parallel proceeding which would have a file number and maybe at least give the media knowledge that this kind of a ban on publication is occurring so they can show up and oppose it.
- 15:02Michael Mulligan: But you know it's pretty hard to oppose something when you have no idea what is it, what is the charge, what's going on.
- 15:08Michael Mulligan: I'm not quite sure what that submission would look like in the absolute dark.
- 15:11Adam Stirling: Yeah.
- 15:12Michael Mulligan: But you know they have said, just in case.
- 15:16Adam Stirling: Just in case there's a proceeding right now that we don't know about, we want you to know.
- 15:19Adam Stirling: We oppose being excluded.
- 15:21Michael Mulligan: Yes, whatever it is.
- 15:22Michael Mulligan: Do you have anything to say about that, sir?
- 15:24Michael Mulligan: I can't say.
- 15:25Michael Mulligan: Well, I'm not sure what I'm supposed to tell you.
- 15:27Michael Mulligan: I don't know anything about it, but they've talked about that with the idea to, I guess, draw a distinction between a completely secret trial and an in-camera trial which you may get to know absolutely nothing about.
- 15:40Michael Mulligan: They have said that judges should take that approach of at least notifying potentially interested people, whatever that means, maybe some selected members of the media, so that they could show up and make some kind of a submission about the importance of a free press or something, I guess.
- 15:59Michael Mulligan: When they know nothing about it, I'm not quite sure how they're supposed to contribute to that legal debate.
- 16:03Michael Mulligan: And so that's the recent Supreme Court of Canada case dealing with a secret trial or, as they've ordered, declared not a secret trial, just an in-camera trial that we knew nothing about, and so we still don't know any of the details of it.
- 16:18Michael Mulligan: We'll have to wait and see whether the Court of Appeal there, what they do in response to the Supreme Court of Canada decision, whether they issue some additional information on some heavily redacted version.
- 16:28Michael Mulligan: So at least we could in this particular case.
- 16:31Michael Mulligan: If they do, maybe we'll find out what the charge was or what happened or why this occurred.
- 16:35Michael Mulligan: Maybe, but that's the latest on informer privilege and, uh, not a secret trial.
- 16:42Adam Stirling: So says the supreme court of canada all right, we'll take a break legally speaking.
- 16:46Adam Stirling: We'll continue right after this.
- 16:47Adam Stirling: All right, we return to Legally Speaking here on CFAX 1070, joined by Michael Mulligan from Mulligan Defense Lawyers.
- 16:53Adam Stirling: We've got a couple of interesting stories left on the agenda, michael.
- 16:56Adam Stirling: Five and a half minutes remaining.
- 16:57Adam Stirling: Can we do them?
- 16:59Michael Mulligan: All right, well, we can start.
- 17:01Michael Mulligan: Perhaps the local one might be a place to go Sure.
- 17:04Michael Mulligan: So this was a decision just released by the BC Court of Appeal and it involved an appeal from a jury award for a local case that originated at the Eagle Ridge Community Centre in Langford, and it was a very unfortunate case that occurred a number of years ago there, where the plaintiff was watching a roller hockey game and a puck I guess there's a puck in a roller hockey game managed to go through a gap in the sounds like the boards, and through a gap in a net.
- 17:41Michael Mulligan: They were there to protect people and hit this poor woman in the head, just above the eye, causing very serious injuries.
- 17:51Michael Mulligan: And my goodness, you'd be on your toes if you're watching a hockey game, make sure there's no holes in the netting.
- 17:57Michael Mulligan: And the case eventually turned into a jury trial where the woman was suing people, including the city of Langford, the hockey arena, some individuals maybe somebody who shot the puck and the Eagle Ridge roller hockey team.
- 18:14Michael Mulligan: All got sued and all of the defendants acknowledged liability for what happened.
- 18:21Michael Mulligan: This woman was just sitting there and she got hit by a hole in the net, hit in the head, and so the issue for the jury was how much compensation she should receive, as in many cases, the large portion of compensation a person can receive in Canada when they're seriously injured as a result of negligence is for lost wages and income.
- 18:48Michael Mulligan: And this woman, who was apparently an excellent salesperson she had been a salesperson for some period of time selling credit card terminals and when you read the decision, that seems like a pretty good area of sales to be in.
- 19:03Michael Mulligan: She had, for a few months before all of this, been earning about $10,000 a month selling these terminals.
- 19:09Michael Mulligan: Wow.
- 19:09Michael Mulligan: And interestingly, just before the accident she wound up with a new contract with a new company that would pay her much more.
- 19:17Michael Mulligan: Per terminal she sold $800, as well as receiving residuals, so I guess an ongoing amount of the business kept using the terminals.
- 19:25Michael Mulligan: And the person who was the former director of the company that hired her testified, described her as an excellent salesperson, one of the top 30 or 50 salespeople he'd ever come across, and indicated the top salespeople selling those things could earn between $300,000 and $400,000 annually.
- 19:45Michael Mulligan: So again, if you're a good salesperson, that might be a pretty good area to be in.
- 19:50Michael Mulligan: So that's what went before the jury.
- 19:54Michael Mulligan: The evidence was that, as a result of the puck hitting her, she had severe headaches, breathing problems, cognitive difficulties.
- 20:01Michael Mulligan: There was expert evidence from a neurologist that she suffered a traumatic brain injury as a result of being hit in the head in that way, and so she wasn't able to continue selling these things, and so the jury was tasked with sorting out what's the proper compensation.
- 20:19Michael Mulligan: She was, I think, 60 at the time.
- 20:21Michael Mulligan: Her evidence was she planned to work for about another 10 years, and the jury accepted what she had to say.
- 20:28Michael Mulligan: That's what the essence of it was.
- 20:30Michael Mulligan: The case was about these defendants arguing that she was not a believable witness and they should reject what she had to say.
- 20:35Michael Mulligan: But they clearly believed her, and they awarded her a total of just over $1 million, including $804,000 for lost earning capacity, what she'd already lost in future earnings until when she would have retired, already lost in future earnings until when she would have retired, and $175,000 for non-pecuniary losses.
- 20:57Michael Mulligan: That's like pain and suffering, and the appellants appealed all of that, and they were arguing that the jury shouldn't have found that.
- 21:03Michael Mulligan: They didn't argue.
- 21:03Michael Mulligan: The judge made any mistakes in giving the jury instructions, which is unusual.
- 21:08Michael Mulligan: Most appeals of jury decisions are revolving how the judge told them to do their job.
- 21:14Michael Mulligan: Here.
- 21:14Michael Mulligan: The defendants agreed the judge gave a flawless instructions to them, but they argued that first of all, there was just no basis upon which the jury could have come to its conclusion.
- 21:23Michael Mulligan: The Court of Appeal analyzed it and said well, yes, there was.
- 21:26Michael Mulligan: Even though she'd only been making only $10,000 plus a month, the evidence was clear that her expected income would have gone way up with this new contract.
- 21:36Michael Mulligan: She had being such a good salesperson and so clearly the jury accepted that and did the calculation and awarded her that amount.
- 21:42Michael Mulligan: And with respect to the non-pecuniary damages we've talked about this before juries aren't given any instructions about how they're to come up with that figure.
- 21:50Michael Mulligan: But here, where you've got a $175,000 award, even though that might be slightly above what other judge set awards would be for people of similar serious long-term injuries, the test on an appeal is whether the award is wholly disproportionate or shockingly unreasonable, and on that test remembering of course, juries don't provide reasons for their decision, they just make the decision.
- 22:18Michael Mulligan: The Court of Appeal found that the $175,000, well higher than the $100,000 roughly that judges have awarded for similar injuries wasn't wholly disproportionate to what happened here and it wasn't shockingly unreasonable, and so the appeal was dismissed, and so that's the outcome for what happened at the Eagle Ridge Community Center, and the takeaway is watch out for pucks, because, boy, your life could turn around in an instant.
- 22:47Michael Mulligan: So that's the case from Langford.
- 22:49Adam Stirling: Michael Mulligan from Mulligan Defense Lawyers, with Legally Speaking every Thursday.
- 22:53Adam Stirling: Michael, thank you.
- 22:54Adam Stirling: Pleasure as always.
- 22:55Michael Mulligan: Thanks so much.
- 22:56Adam Stirling: Have a great day All right, you too, we'll take a quick break.