Latest / Politics with Paul / Politics with Paul #17: Why Incumbents Win Reelection So Often
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome back to the best podcast around as long as you don't count any other podcasts that are
- 0:07around.
- 0:08Welcome back to the politics with Paul podcast with your host, me, Paul Reeder.
- 0:14Today, we're gonna talk about incumbent reelection rates.
- 0:19So another election has come and gone, and there is some considerable change coming.
- 0:26But at the same time, there are lots and lots of familiar faces that are still at office and
- 0:33in the same seats they were in before.
- 0:36In some ways, the more things change, the more they stay the same.
- 0:40Lots of incumbents ran in 2024, and lots of them won, and that's typically what you see in
- 0:46elections these days.
- 0:48But why do we see them win so often?
- 0:52We seem to hate politicians so much, and we seem to be perpetually frustrated with them and
- 0:58their performance, but we still reelect them at very high rates.
- 1:03What's behind this apparent disconnect, and just how many incumbents did we see reelected
- 1:10in the 2024 election?
- 1:12Well, that's what we're gonna talk about today.
- 1:14So let's dive in.
- 1:17So first of all, what exactly is an incumbent?
- 1:21That might seem like a straightforward question, but just in case, let's go over it
- 1:24real quick.
- 1:25An incumbent is somebody who is already in office and is running for election again to
- 1:31that same exact office.
- 1:32Now a little bit of a slight exception here is if a candidate is running again for a
- 1:38districted office, districted office, excuse me, like congress where there's a 1st
- 1:45congressional district, 2nd congressional district, or state legislature where there's
- 1:501st, 2nd, 3rd state senate districts or state house districts, and redistricting changes the
- 1:56district they are in.
- 1:57They are still considered an incumbent.
- 1:59So if you're the 3rd house district representative in Georgia and redistricting
- 2:07happens and it puts you in the 4th district.
- 2:10You're still technically an incumbent, so a little bit of a difference there.
- 2:14But it's not someone who is in an elected office already, and then they run for a
- 2:19different office.
- 2:21One common stepping stone is from US house to US senate.
- 2:25They're not considered an incumbent because they're not in the US senate yet, and they're
- 2:29leaving their current seat.
- 2:30So that is an open seat, and those open seats are when incumbents decide to retire or to run
- 2:36for a different office.
- 2:37So incumbent versus open seat.
- 2:41And generally speaking, you can expect incumbent reelection rates to be pretty high in
- 2:46the 80 to 90% range depending on the type of office and where it happens.
- 2:53Sometimes can fluctuate a little bit, but you tend to see a large advantage that incumbents
- 3:02have when they run for reelection.
- 3:05Again, we reelect people so often, but we're so perpetually frustrated with them.
- 3:11What's behind this apparent disconnect?
- 3:14Well, this is mostly a reference to an observation regarding congress, but you can
- 3:21somewhat extend it to other political offices.
- 3:25And this is what we call the theno paradox.
- 3:27Simply put, it's the observation that congress has considerably low levels of approval, but
- 3:34incumbents experience high rates of reelection.
- 3:36You see approval rates of congress in the t tens, teens, however you say it, even in single
- 3:45digit range a lot of times, but they see massive reelection rates for congressional
- 3:52incumbents well into the nineties.
- 3:54And it's been that way for quite a while, at least 50, 60 years.
- 3:58A little that's a little a little bit of fluctuation here and there, but generally
- 4:01speaking, it's very high reelection rates.
- 4:04Everybody hates congress, but they tend to love their congressperson.
- 4:09And this is called, again, it's called the Fenno paradox, which is f e n n o.
- 4:13It's named after the late great political scientist, Richard f Fenno junior.
- 4:19He wrote 19 books on congress, was a distinguished university professor emeritus at
- 4:24the University of Rochester.
- 4:26Sadly, he passed away at 93 years old in 2020, but he was really the first to directly observe
- 4:34members of congress in the field instead of taking a broad institutional view.
- 4:40He was much more of a hands on guy as opposed to just bird's eye view kinda deal.
- 4:47Thanos paradox, though, goes back to at least a 1975 essay titled, if, as Ralph Nader says,
- 4:56congress is the broken branch, how come we love our congressmen so much?
- 5:00And, specifically, a quote from there, we do, it appears, love our congressmen.
- 5:05On the other hand, it seems equally clear that we do not love our congress.
- 5:09But Fenno's paradox is more synonymous with his 1978 book, homestyle house members and their
- 5:16districts.
- 5:16And, again, that's it was where Fenno spends a lot of time with members of congress both on
- 5:23Capitol Hill and in their home districts on the campaign trail, noting differences in how they
- 5:29did in both environments.
- 5:31So members of congress, while they were in their home districts, they would distance
- 5:35themselves from the overall body of congress.
- 5:38And then no no.
- 5:38It's it's those guys, they have the problem, not me.
- 5:41I I quite frankly, I think congress sucks too, and I'm just trying to fix things.
- 5:46It's it's it's not it's my fault.
- 5:48It's always the other guys.
- 5:50And you know what?
- 5:51That's what the rest of Congress tends to say too.
- 5:53It's not it's not fashionable to say that, well, you know, Congress is actually yeah.
- 5:58Things are they're having a hard it's a hard job, and and they're doing their best.
- 6:03No.
- 6:03You tend to distance yourself from congress because everybody hates congress.
- 6:07Again, you even see single digit level approvals of congress where only, like, 8, 9%
- 6:14of people say congress is doing a good job.
- 6:17Basic reason we see this disconnect, though, of why we see people hate congress but love their
- 6:24congressperson, reelect the congressperson is, well, we only elect the congresspeople
- 6:29representing our specific slice of America, and we often separate them from the rest of
- 6:33congress.
- 6:34So if we have a u if your state has a US senate election in a given year, not always gonna
- 6:40happen.
- 6:41But if your US senator is for your states or your US congressperson for your district,
- 6:49you're only voting on those people.
- 6:50You're not voting on all of the US senate or all of the US house.
- 6:54That'd be way too many, races to keep track of.
- 6:57But we often like our congressperson because they're bringing home projects to our
- 7:03congressional district.
- 7:04But a lot of times, we also see these projects that are happening in other districts.
- 7:09Those tend to be considered wasteful.
- 7:11That's not how helping our district.
- 7:12Well, that's yeah.
- 7:14I mean, why why are they doing this this thing?
- 7:16We're we're also doing it, but why are they doing this exact thing?
- 7:20Not necessarily the exact same kind of project, but it's a lot easier to think a project
- 7:26happening elsewhere is wasteful when you and people around you are not directly benefiting
- 7:34from it.
- 7:34So oftentimes see the rest of congress as wasteful, but our congressperson's bringing
- 7:40home the bacon, so to speak.
- 7:43Now as for extending this paradox to other nonfederal officials like governors and state
- 7:53legislatures or even local officials.
- 7:56There's a lot less public opinion data that is available on these officials, but Fidos paradox
- 8:02might extend to them to varying degrees as well.
- 8:05But in any case, we see high incumbent reelection rates like congress shows regardless
- 8:11of political, public opinion on these local institutions like governorships and state
- 8:19legislatures and so on.
- 8:21The historical data on incumbents, though, is a little bit more mixed, however, as you'll see
- 8:27later.
- 8:27We'll talk a little bit about it, but just as a little bit of a preview, presidential
- 8:31reelection bids have a more mixed history.
- 8:35They win more.
- 8:36When they run for reelection, they win more often than not, but not by a whole lot.
- 8:40Not not the kinds of reelection rates you see in congress, for example.
- 8:44And, to dobernatorial election rates have mostly gone up since the 19 sixties, but back
- 8:50then, it wasn't happening a ton either.
- 8:54So why is it that these incumbents have such an advantage?
- 8:58It's a very well documented advantage that incumbents have.
- 9:02Regardless of, Fenno's paradox.
- 9:05Incumbents have a very strong advantage a lot of the time, but what are some of the reasons
- 9:12for that?
- 9:13Well, some reasons, and this is not by any means a comprehensive list and specific cases
- 9:21of elections will have unique factors that benefit that specific incumbents.
- 9:25But these are general examples of boons that incumbents have.
- 9:30For example, name recognition.
- 9:32Simply by virtue of already having that office, you have the name recognition.
- 9:37A lot of times, challengers usually have to work harder to get people to learn about them.
- 9:42And when you don't really know somebody, usually, you're not gonna support them.
- 9:49And you also see these incumbents' names all over the place even outside of campaign
- 9:55context.
- 9:56If they're, for example, I'll use Florida as an example, the Department of Agriculture and
- 10:02Consumer Services, usually just Department of Agriculture for short, but the commissioner
- 10:08there, currently Wilton Simpson, was previously Nikki Fried.
- 10:12Their names are on gas station or whoever is the incumbent for that, their name is on gas
- 10:17station pumps to certify that they have or their office has inspected these gas station
- 10:22pumps and that they're good to go.
- 10:24So used you happen to see their names all over the place in that regard.
- 10:28And you'll see a similar case for other state executives, state executives being things like
- 10:36governor, attorney general, secretary of state.
- 10:39You'll see their names all over the place simply because they're already in the office,
- 10:42and they are certifying all sorts of different things going on.
- 10:46Right.
- 10:46Let's say you'll see them on paperwork all the time, so you tend to know who they are already.
- 10:51Obviously, challengers don't get that luxury.
- 10:55Some challengers will come in with a lot more name recognition, but generally speaking, the
- 11:00incumbents will have the advantage when it comes to people already knowing who they are.
- 11:07Another advantage that incumbents have is they tend to have more solidified personal and
- 11:14monetary connections.
- 11:15You're already in the office.
- 11:17Other people who have a similar office, for example, if you're a state house representative
- 11:21and you become buddy buddy with a lot of other state house representatives, you have them, as
- 11:28endorsements, for example, for your campaign as long as you guys are getting along.
- 11:34You also get the party campaign arms.
- 11:38They usually make their resources more available to you.
- 11:42So the parties, they have their party apparatuses have specific organizations that
- 11:50deal with giving campaign resources to these campaigns.
- 11:53For example, the d triple c, which is the Democratic Congressional Campaign Committee,
- 11:58they help out Democrats that are running for congressional elections, especially if they're
- 12:04running for reelection.
- 12:05The NRSC, which is the National Republican Senatorial Committee, they help out Republicans
- 12:12running for US Senate, and you'll see similar kinds of party campaign arms and organizations
- 12:18that do the same thing at the state and local levels as well.
- 12:24Incumbents are also seeing fewer and fewer competitive elections because more and more
- 12:29districts are becoming distinctively Democrat or Republican.
- 12:33And so you tend to see the primary the primary being what what determines who makes it to the
- 12:40general election.
- 12:42These primaries are especially if they're partisan primaries, they're effectively
- 12:46becoming the general election because the other party has little to no chance of winning.
- 12:51If you have a district that is in Maryland, for example, that is just so overwhelmingly
- 12:57Democrat or you have a district in Texas that is so overwhelmingly Republican, the
- 13:04disadvantaged party just really doesn't even have a chance.
- 13:07And a lot of times, if they don't even have a chance, they won't even run a candidate.
- 13:11Or there might be a candidate for that disadvantaged party, but they get minimal
- 13:15support from their party's apparatus, their campaign, apparatus because they just can't
- 13:23afford to put resources into an election that their candidate has no chance of winning.
- 13:28They can put those resources toward other elections that they have a better chance of
- 13:33winning.
- 13:34So you see a lot of these fewer and fewer competitive districts over time, which
- 13:43regardless of your opinions on politics, political competitive the lack of political
- 13:48competitiveness is a very serious issue.
- 13:51And especially for local level offices, some races won't have a challenger at all.
- 13:56Like, not even just this race has a Democrat, but not a Republican.
- 14:00This race has a Republican, but not a Democrat.
- 14:02They won't even have, like, a third party or nonpartisan challenger sometimes.
- 14:08So that's become a bigger issue for local level races like school boards.
- 14:15And then some and some of this lack of competitiveness is due to gerrymandering, but
- 14:19it's not necessarily as wide spread as you might expect, though the threshold for genuine
- 14:24gerrymandering is not clear cut.
- 14:27You can look at some districts and be like, okay.
- 14:30That's clearly drawn in a way that's trying to benefit 1 party or the other.
- 14:35But a lot of times, it's not a this is the criteria that needs to be met to be considered
- 14:42gerrymandering.
- 14:43There's not really you don't really have that kind of checklist to say that a district is
- 14:50gerrymandered.
- 14:50But gerrymandering does happen or at the very least, maybe not necessarily full on
- 14:55gerrymandered, but definitely drawn in a way to try to benefit another party one party or the
- 15:00other a little bit more than what might be considered fair.
- 15:06Incumbents also have the experience of already winning the office.
- 15:11Experience is is a big deal in, oh, really, in in basically any job that you do and especially
- 15:18for politics.
- 15:18You have more data on what it takes to win that seat.
- 15:22And a lot of times for person candidates, because they already won in the first place,
- 15:29that's sometimes signals that their campaign or their party is more powerful and or capable of
- 15:36campaigning well.
- 15:37Maybe that already signifies that you are very well resourced or that the party is putting a
- 15:43lot of resources into helping you in the first place.
- 15:46Regular voters don't realize the power of talented campaigners.
- 15:52You might just have real people that are really good at knocking on doors, reaching out to
- 15:57voters, that other campaigns just don't have, and that's I mean, that's how you won in the
- 16:03first place.
- 16:04So that experience of winning the office already is incredibly valuable to trying to win
- 16:11that seat again.
- 16:13There's also just a general reluctance to change officials once they are already in in
- 16:19office.
- 16:20Sometimes it's a bit of an as a fear of the unknown.
- 16:25Usually, you're not gonna see a whole lot change unless dissatisfaction with the
- 16:29incumbent is strong enough.
- 16:30There's not there's not enough motivation for somebody to vote against the incumbent unless
- 16:35they really feel like their the incumbent has their their policies have directly hurt that
- 16:43person.
- 16:44Yours usually not gonna see a whole lot of change there.
- 16:47And some elected offices are obscure enough that people find it too difficult to find ample
- 16:54information on candidates, and thus thus they just stick with what they know, or they just
- 16:58don't even bother getting involved.
- 17:00But the people who elected that person in the 1st place, they do, and so that person gets
- 17:06reelected again.
- 17:07And and the and a valid information issue really hits everybody.
- 17:11Even those of us who are heavily involved in politics, we have trouble with it a lot of
- 17:18times too.
- 17:18There's when you get really, really local, it's sometimes a lot harder to find information on
- 17:26who your local local officials are.
- 17:30Now some of the factors that can actually hurt incumbents, again, not a comprehensive list,
- 17:36and specific elections will have their own unique circumstances that can potentially hurt
- 17:42incumbents where it's actually not helpful for them to have an incumbency advantage.
- 17:48Generally speaking, being an incumbent is an advantage, but every so often, you'll have
- 17:53obviously factors that actually hinder an incumbent in particular, not necessarily
- 18:00because of their party or any scandal, but simply because they're an incumbent.
- 18:04So general dissatisfaction with the incumbent president's party.
- 18:08And this is more so an issue for incumbents in congress being for example, if you're
- 18:14dissatisfied with Donald Trump, you're go you might be more inclined to vote against
- 18:19Republican congressional candidates.
- 18:21Or if you're dissatisfied with Joe Biden, you might be more inclined to vote against
- 18:28Democrats in congress.
- 18:30But this can also trickle further down the ballot, and we're starting to see not starting.
- 18:35We've been seeing it for a while, but it's starting to happen more and more where you see
- 18:40a nationalization of politics where even state and local politics are not necessarily
- 18:47considered so much separate from federal politics where what's happening at the federal
- 18:53level is being considered at the state and local level.
- 18:58So, for example, a Republican county commissioner, there's for some people, there's
- 19:05a litmus test of how much they support Donald Trump.
- 19:07Even if the local issues have nothing to do with anything Donald Trump's doing, voters
- 19:14might vote on that county commissioner based on how they feel about Donald Trump or how they
- 19:20feel about Joe Biden.
- 19:22So what's happening at the national level is mattering for voters more and more at the state
- 19:27and local levels and, hence, nationalization of state and local politics.
- 19:35An economic downturn, economics is a very powerful motivator for people.
- 19:41Yeah.
- 19:41And you saw it in this election.
- 19:43Regardless of whose fault it is, doesn't matter whether it's Republicans' or Democrats' fault,
- 19:48it's Donald Trump's, it's Joe Biden's.
- 19:50That's not the point.
- 19:52Point is who is perceived to be at fault, and economic issues tend to be reflected on the
- 19:59incumbent's party, at least for federal elections.
- 20:02Again, can happen further down the ballot as well because of that nationalization of
- 20:06politics, and other incumbents of the same party are considered guilty by association.
- 20:12But Republicans have felt that hit before.
- 20:16Democrats have felt that hit before of is it an economic downturn?
- 20:20Who's in office right now?
- 20:22Who is mostly in charge?
- 20:24Oh, it's this party or, oh, it's this person of this party.
- 20:28Other people of that party must also be guilty.
- 20:31It's obviously a more complex issue than simply, oh, that one person, it's because of
- 20:38them.
- 20:39But it matters more in terms of who's winning these elections.
- 20:44It matters more about what voters perceive, who they perceive to be at fault.
- 20:50And, again, I'm not saying that one party or the other is more responsible.
- 20:55That's just just about how these voters who these voters think are at fault.
- 21:02Emotional reactions, obviously, anger and anxiety are powerful motivators for voters to
- 21:09come out and vote.
- 21:11But if you're angry and or anxious about current events, you may be more inclined to
- 21:18vote against an incumbent.
- 21:20We talked about just a little bit ago how usually people are reluctant to change unless
- 21:27there's a powerful enough stimulus to persuade them to vote against somebody.
- 21:33If you are terrified of somebody's policies, you might, they're an incumbent and their
- 21:39policies and what they've done in office already.
- 21:42You may be more inclined to come out to vote against them as opposed to if you were just
- 21:48kind of lukewarm on them or even if you didn't like them, but you weren't anxious about
- 21:52something that they were doing.
- 21:54So all else equal, usually, you're not gonna act out against an incumbent if you aren't too
- 22:01perturbed about what's happening at a given level of office.
- 22:06Then there are cases when name recognition actually becomes a bane instead of a boon.
- 22:11For some incumbents, they might find that they get too much negative publicity simply by being
- 22:15more known as an elected official.
- 22:18There are also there's also a potential of more sources of scandals because you are in office
- 22:24as opposed to if you are a challenger.
- 22:26So name recognition in that regard can be an issue.
- 22:30You you might people might know who you are, but they don't necessarily have an opinion
- 22:35about you.
- 22:37When you if you look at polling data, sometimes pea you'll see questions basically asking, do
- 22:43you know who this person is?
- 22:45What do you think of this person?
- 22:46And they'll say favorable opinion, unfavorable opinion, or not sure.
- 22:52Sometimes you'll see that not sure be a lot higher than for another person.
- 22:59So sometimes you might want people to be more unsure about the what they think of that
- 23:04incumbent as opposed to with, oh, a lot of people know them, and a lot of people don't
- 23:07like them.
- 23:09Onto more about how we actually study incumbent win rates and how they can vary depending on
- 23:15the office.
- 23:15So we can compare win rates by several several categories including by the type of office.
- 23:21How often do congressional incumbents get reelected versus state executive incumbents
- 23:27versus state center, state house, or local judges.
- 23:31Several examples of categories that you can consider.
- 23:36And then by state, states will vary in how often their incumbents win.
- 23:41And cat comparisons of those categories depend on several factors that can inflate or deflate
- 23:47win rates of a particular category.
- 23:49So, for example, some offices that are elected in one state are appointed in another state.
- 23:54And if they're appointed positions, doesn't really count in terms of how often an incumbent
- 24:00wins because there's no election for them to run-in, so voters aren't voting on them.
- 24:05For example, attorney general is elected by voters in 43 states.
- 24:09So those 7 states where it's not being voted on can't really compare because income the whole
- 24:16incumbent win rate thing doesn't really apply to them because they're being appointed by
- 24:22governor or state legislature or whoever's doing the appointing.
- 24:25And then some states have much fewer elections or, excuse me, fewer elected state executives
- 24:32overall than others.
- 24:33For example, Alaska just votes on governor and lieutenant governor, but it doesn't vote on
- 24:39attorney general and secretary of state.
- 24:41But North Carolina has 10 state executives that they vote on, including a labor commissioner
- 24:45and an agriculture commissioner.
- 24:48So some of them just aren't up for election by voters, and so you can't compare them as easily
- 24:57to, other states and how they vote.
- 25:01And some offices have far more officials up for reelection at a time than others.
- 25:07For example, if you're talking about state legislative seats, especially in New Hampshire,
- 25:10where there's 400 state house representatives versus state executives where you're never
- 25:15gonna have nearly as many state executives up for election as you will state legislators.
- 25:21So if or talking about how often do state executives win, incumbents win reelection
- 25:27versus state legislative incumbents running for reelection.
- 25:31Well, there's a lot more state legislative incumbents running for reelection than there
- 25:35are state executive incumbents, so smaller sample size can skew the incumbent win rates a
- 25:42little bit or by a lot.
- 25:46And then some states might have relatively few elections in a given year compared to others.
- 25:51For example, New Jersey and Virginia have a lot of their elections in in odd numbered years, so
- 25:56there's a small sample size for them in 2024 versus, Florida or Georgia or California that
- 26:05have a lot more even numbered gear elections, such as this one in 20 24th.
- 26:13And then you have also the timing of elections.
- 26:17Some states have a lot more elections in a midterm year versus a presidential election
- 26:23year or versus an odd numbered year, or they have a general election that's held in a
- 26:29different month.
- 26:30And an incumbent might have been defeated in a primary, and that potentially influences what
- 26:36happens in the general.
- 26:37Maybe that incumbent actually had a better shot at weighing the whole thing than the person who
- 26:41beat them because the primary voters wanted somebody who was a, quote, unquote, stronger
- 26:48Republican or a stronger Democrat.
- 26:52And when they get to the general election, more voters see them as too extreme as an just as an
- 26:58example.
- 26:59Not necessarily gonna be the case, but sometimes it is.
- 27:03So just a few caveats to keep in mind there.
- 27:07But that being said, let's look at some incumbent win rates in recent years.
- 27:14So a lot of this data is coming from Allopedia, at least this overall data for 2018, 2020,
- 27:212022, and 2024.
- 27:24And this data does not account for every single race that occurred across the US.
- 27:30That's basically an impossible task to document all of the local races like I talked about
- 27:35before.
- 27:36A lot of this a lot of this information is is very difficult, if not impossible to find.
- 27:41But I can tell you both from just observing ballot PDIA now now and previously when I
- 27:47worked at Ballopedia.
- 27:49Ballopedia's scope, especially now, is incredibly expansive.
- 27:53There are a lot of elections under their umbrella.
- 27:57They've got all the federal elections, and they've got all the state level elections.
- 28:01And they'd have a ton of the local level races as well.
- 28:06And Ballopedia still has all the win incumbent win rates for congress, state executives, state
- 28:11legislatures, and state level judges, which is what we're using here.
- 28:17And, of course, this data does not include incumbents who ran for a different office or
- 28:22retired because then that's considered an open seat.
- 28:27So a general overview of 2018 to 2024 according to Ballopedia.
- 28:33There is a 92% win rate in 2018.
- 28:37Overall, 93% win rate in 2020, 94% in 2022, and 95% in 2024.
- 28:45So already, again, very, very high incumbent reelection rates, and it started to trickle.
- 28:54I guess not trickle, but it started creep up and up and up and up.
- 28:59As for incumbent win rates over time by type of office, couple of examples, we'll talk about
- 29:06presidents.
- 29:07And this is what I referenced earlier on in the podcast about there being a little bit of
- 29:12variation in incumbent win rates.
- 29:15You typically see very, very high win rates.
- 29:18In the case of president, it's incumbents tend to win, but it's actually not an enormous
- 29:25advantage like you see for congress.
- 29:28So we've had a total of 33 presidential elections where the incumbent ran for
- 29:33reelection, and 20 incumbents have won 22 reelection bids.
- 29:39Franklin Roosevelt won 3 of them.
- 29:41He's the only president we've had that has won more than 2 terms because the u, US
- 29:48constitutional amendment that instituted the 2 term limit was not applied until post Harry
- 29:54Truman or Harry it was it was ratified to the constitution during Harry Truman's presidency,
- 30:00but Harry Truman was exempt from the amendment, and every president since him has been subject
- 30:06to that 2 term limit.
- 30:08So you won't see ever see a president win multiple reelection bids.
- 30:14They'll only win 1 of them at most.
- 30:16So 20 incumbents have won 22 reelection bids.
- 30:2011 presidents have run for reelection but lost, and that includes the 2 presidents that have
- 30:27won nonconsecutive terms, Grover Cleveland being the first one in the latter 19th century,
- 30:33and now Donald Trump winning in 2024.
- 30:35He has now joined Grover Cleveland as the only presidents who have served nonconsecutive terms
- 30:41or at least Donald Trump will soon be doing that at when the new presidential term actually
- 30:47starts.
- 30:49But before Donald Trump lost in 2020, incumbents had won 3 straight reelection bids.
- 30:55So it had been more common lately for presidents running for reelection to win their
- 31:02reelection bids.
- 31:04And then governor, this is via Rutgers University's center on the American governor.
- 31:11For the most part, the rate has increased since the 19 sixties.
- 31:15So in the 19 sixties, governors, incumbent governors won reelection 64% of the time.
- 31:22In the 19 seventies, went up a little bit to 69%, 19 eighties, 74%, 19 nineties, 81%.
- 31:30Very slight dip in the 2000 where it went to 80%, then back up 85% in the 20 tens or 20
- 31:39teens, however you say it.
- 31:40And then 2020 to 2023, 98%.
- 31:45The only incumbent who lost in that time frame there's 39 of 40 incumbents won reelection in
- 31:51that time frame.
- 31:52The only one who lost was Steve Sisolak to Joe Lombardo in Nevada in 2022.
- 32:00Now as for the final section before we close this episode out, let's talk about 2024
- 32:05incumbent win statistics specifically.
- 32:07Now keep in mind, there are still some undecided races here and there at the state and
- 32:12local levels.
- 32:12Not many of them left, but there are a few.
- 32:15And for federal elections, we still have 2 US house races in California that are too close to
- 32:23call still.
- 32:25Yeah.
- 32:25As is usually the case, though, 2024 saw extremely high win rates regardless of
- 32:30category.
- 32:32Obviously, president doesn't apply here because Joe Biden didn't well, he initially ran for
- 32:36reelection, but then dropped out, and then Kamala Harris ran.
- 32:39So incumbency didn't really at least in this context, didn't really apply here.
- 32:46But of the 7,412 incumbents covered by Ballotpedia this year, 95% of them won
- 32:52reelection.
- 32:53And if we go by office type, 98% of congress, congressional incumbents won reelection.
- 32:59Again, still a couple of US house races in California that are undecided, so that might
- 33:04slightly change the percentage, but not by a lot.
- 33:08It's gonna be somewhere of 97, 98, 99%.
- 33:1396% of state executives won reelection, 93% of state judicial, that being state supreme courts
- 33:20and intermediate public courts, 97% of state legislative incumbents, and there are a lot of
- 33:26those this year as there tend to be.
- 33:3093% of local executives, so for example, mayors of cities, and then 98% of local judicial
- 33:39elections, so those local level judges, like a county judge, for example, and then 90% of
- 33:45local legislative incumbents that ran for reelection won.
- 33:48So city council, for example, there.
- 33:54Comparing specific states, whether they had high versus low incumbent win rates.
- 34:00Again, gotta keep in mind that some states have a lot more elections had a lot more elections
- 34:06this year than other states did, but putting that aside, states that saw particularly high
- 34:12rates of incumbent wins include West Virginia, Tennessee, Delaware, Washington, Rhode Island.
- 34:19States where incumbent wins were bit lower were Virginia, New Jersey, Alaska, Arizona, and
- 34:27Mississippi.
- 34:28As for specific types of offices, in congress, 42 states elected 100% of their incumbents who
- 34:35ran for reelection.
- 34:36Again, keep in mind the wide disparity in, US house delegations by state.
- 34:44The exceptions here include Alaska, California, Colorado, Montana, a few other states, and,
- 34:52once again, account for those far fewer US house members.
- 34:56For example, California has the most, and it's there's a lot of them to account for while
- 35:01whereas Alaska only has one US house race.
- 35:07And as for state legislature, 6 states had no state legislative elections this year, so
- 35:13they're excluded here.
- 35:14And those were Alabama, Louisiana, Maryland, Mississippi, New Jersey, and Virginia.
- 35:20But the other 4 44 states had at least 80% of their incumbents reelected.
- 35:2711 states reelected a 100% of their incumbents.
- 35:3139 states reelected 95% or more.
- 35:35As there were a few states that were below 95%, but weren't many.
- 35:40Those 5 states were Nebraska, which had 80%, Vermont, 87% of state legislative incumbents,
- 35:48Alaska, 88%, New Hampshire, 93%, and Wisconsin, 93%.
- 35:53So that does it for this episode of the podcast.
- 35:57As always, thank you so much for listening.
- 36:00Random question of the daytime.
- 36:02And as when this episode comes out, this is gonna be this is relevant to the day after this
- 36:09podcast episode comes out.
- 36:11Today's random question is, what's your ideal Thanksgiving meal?
- 36:17I'm gonna tell you right now.
- 36:20Turkey, dark meat.
- 36:21It has to be dark meat.
- 36:22White meat is usually way too dry.
- 36:24Stuffing, it's not dressing.
- 36:26I know I don't care if it was made in the turkey or not.
- 36:30It's stuffing.
- 36:31Mashed potatoes with gravy, corn pudding, and and I'm not I'm not including, dessert here.
- 36:41And, oh, King's Hawaiian rolls.
- 36:45Absolutely.
- 36:45So I mean, how can you not have rolls?
- 36:47And then you can make basically make sandwiches with Thanksgiving leftovers.
- 36:51And I actually just tried out the other day some cranberry sauce.
- 36:55I had it in my head that I didn't like cranberry sauce, and then I tried it.
- 36:59It was like, okay.
- 37:00I have to add this.
- 37:01So any other combination of Thanksgiving dinners, vastly inferior.
- 37:10Don't tell me green bean casserole because green bean casserole is gross.
- 37:14It does not matter who made it.
- 37:17I despise green beans.
- 37:21My sister loves them, and I I I just I don't understand how anybody likes green beans.
- 37:28So green bean casserole is absolutely out the window.
- 37:32Corn pudding, though, love me some corn pudding.
- 37:36That's my ideal Thanksgiving meal, and, let me know what what yours is.
- 37:42But other than that, we're gonna close this out.
- 37:45So once again, as always, thank you so much for listening.
- 37:49Got my social media and and other stuff in my show notes, including my book, why independents
- 37:57rarely win elections and how they could become more competitive on Amazon and ebook and paper
- 38:01book format, my Facebook, LinkedIn, Medium, Matchmaker FM profile.
- 38:08If you wanna have me on your podcast or possibly you'd be on my podcast.
- 38:15And my email, paulraderwrites@gmail.com.
- 38:19But other than that, I'll see you or talk to you in the next episode.
- 38:24Until then, take care.