Latest / Honey Badger Radio / The Problem with Lesbian Romance Novels! | Red Chill Cinema
Transcript
- 0:00Hi, and welcome to Honey Badgery Radio. I'll be your host, Alison,
- 0:05and with me today as always is Brian and we are going to be
- 0:09covering the problem with lesbian romance novels, which I know is a bit of
- 0:13a digression from our usual affair. Well is it really? I mean,
- 0:16because we do media quite a bit and this is a red chill cinema,
- 0:20so well media, there you go. It could work. Yeah, we'll
- 0:27do it. We'll figure it all out. So we're responding to a individual
- 0:32who apparently is not fond of lesbian or at least how lesbian. How it's
- 0:39written. One wonders how you could really write lesbian romance in a way that
- 0:45isn't boring as hell. But regardless, perhaps she can enlighten us. The
- 0:50channel is a sunny booknook. I don't know, does she seem really ideologically
- 0:55uh hunter postual to us? Well, she's not, like so I looked
- 1:03through the opus clips and you don't get the sense that she's an angry person.
- 1:10You know, that's like like walking around with a chip on her shoulder.
- 1:15But I do think that she's certainly like got the woke mind virus at
- 1:21least, so far as how it applies to LEB women and lesbians and women
- 1:26and queer theory and feminism, et cetera. So there's definitely that, But
- 1:32she's kind of like, I don't know, like my my ingreied on the
- 1:37surface is that she is an unfortunate casualty of a feminist dogma. Essentially,
- 1:45she learned how to be a woman from her you know, university professors,
- 1:49her English teachers, whatever, and she's just following through on it, and
- 1:55I don't know, you know, it's a little bit sad because she probably
- 1:57didn't have any other options. So yeah, it's, uh, well,
- 2:01she's doing she's doing the womanhood the way she's taught essentially, So there you
- 2:07go. She's she is. She is a product of the system, so
- 2:10exactly that's exactly right. She's a product of the system. So great.
- 2:15Okay, well let's let's see let's see the just sort of the put is
- 2:21now basically the factory standard. Yep, all right, yeah, sure,
- 2:28sure, yeah, sure, Okay, So if you enjoyed this actually,
- 2:31you know what, I haven't done that yet, so let's let's delay that
- 2:35for a moment. I was gonna say, if you enjoy this content,
- 2:37support it Feed the badgery dot com slash support. But our current fundraiser is
- 2:40last month's fundraiser. But you know, if in the future you go there,
- 2:46I might have the current fundraiser up, So just keep it in mind.
- 2:49Put you know, put a little pin in it. We'll get there.
- 2:52But if you want to send us a message at anytime throughout the show,
- 2:54you can do so at feed the Badger dot com slash just the tip.
- 2:58That is, feed the Badger dot com slash just the tip. We
- 3:00get the full benefit of whatever funds you send us, and you get the
- 3:04benefit of not sending your comment through YouTube's comment enhancement system, which is a
- 3:07euphemism yes her censorship. All right, So feed the Badger dot com slash
- 3:16just the tip to send us those comments. And of course Twitter, I
- 3:19don't think they have a way for you to send us comments yet, or
- 3:22at least not to tip us and send us comments, So you can do
- 3:24so on Twitter if you're watching us on Twitter at Feedbadger dot com slash just
- 3:29the tip. All right, So I guess we just get started, eh
- 3:32yeah, get the party, get the party rolling, all right. Let's
- 3:38uh, so this is the first so we put the video through opus clip,
- 3:42and it like sort of like looked for highlights or what it thought were
- 3:46highlights. I think, And so this is the first one, which is
- 3:50kind of an introductory thing, or at least it sets up her conversation.
- 3:54So we'll play it as to why I think being romance novels specifically are not
- 4:03that good, why the genre doesn't really lend itself to good good writing,
- 4:11looking at some of the specific lesbian romances that I've read over the years,
- 4:15and how I think they just fall short and fail at doing the thing that
- 4:21romance novels are supposed to do and that I have gotten from romance novels of
- 4:26other sorts. Oh man, I wonder if she got total shit for this.
- 4:30I mean, this is this is actually like slightly controversial, you know
- 4:34what. She's saying that she's not totally fulfilled by romance novels that are all
- 4:41about the informed consent or never ending consent or like confirming consent, you know,
- 4:48like always taking the temperature every like thirty seconds? Right? Are you
- 4:53okay with this? Are you okay with this? Now? Are you okay
- 4:55with this now? Which also is a high pressure sales technique, is constantly
- 4:59asking questions to essentially erode people's ability to say no. So what you do
- 5:03is you just keep asking questions and then eventually you just exhaust people and then
- 5:09they just do whatever you want. And I'm guessing that feminists aren't intend you
- 5:14know what. I was about to say that feminists aren't intending to promote something
- 5:16that's actually occult, sort of like a little sexually abusive. But then I
- 5:21thought about it, and I'm like, of course they are. I'm done
- 5:28giving them the benefit of the doubt. Yeah, be talking about let me
- 5:33see here. I just wanted to make sure. So it is playing here,
- 5:40but the people watching on see the people watching on vertical, I want
- 5:46to make sure they can hear it because it is a separate set of frightens.
- 5:51So I'm just double check. I'm sorry, guys, No, no,
- 5:55no, I think it's okay. I'm just making our sound is fine.
- 6:00Yeah, our sound is fine. Let me just go and I want
- 6:06to go ahead, Okay, I apologize. I wanted to just say what
- 6:13romance is usually supposed to do, and with the Roman romance genre, and
- 6:17that includes also, for example, buddy cop films. So with romance,
- 6:23you're supposed to have. And I don't mean that in like a sexual way.
- 6:26It's it's basically two people who function as each other's biggest antagonists. And
- 6:30what I mean by that is they're the ones who are forcing the biggest amount
- 6:33of change in the other. And with with a buddy we'll use a buddy
- 6:39Buddy Cops for for an example. Each of the two cops changes the other
- 6:45in a significant way, and that is what is the central pillar of romance.
- 6:49And of course, a traditional romance, as acceptable to the romance writers
- 6:54of America, is that it has to end in a happy manner, so
- 6:57they have to get together in the end. So for a buddy cop romance,
- 7:00romance friends they become friends, they understand each other, and the idea
- 7:08is that it's two people who are coming together and learning to let go of
- 7:13an aspect of their individuality in order to put the relationship first right, in
- 7:17order to make room for that relationship in their life. And with the buddy
- 7:21cops, they have to learn to work together. With the traditional romance,
- 7:25the man and the woman have to let go of something in order to gain
- 7:30the relationship. And the first thing that all right, off the bat and
- 7:33I don't know if she's going to address it is with the new romance I've
- 7:38been seeing, they seem to have more of an emphasis on the man just
- 7:43changing for the woman. That's not actually traditional romance. Both are supposed to
- 7:46change put the relationship first. But what I've seen, and I'm there was
- 7:51a recent romance that I watched that it's just awful. It was it was
- 7:57just so destroyingly awful, and the entire ten things I Hate about you know,
- 8:03what was it ten things about I Hate about? Yeah, yeah,
- 8:07it was, it was. It was. It was not that one.
- 8:09It was it was one that was almost completely forgettable. I'm sorry I can't
- 8:13remember the title, but it was something about hate and it was supposedly enemies
- 8:18to lovers scenario, except of course the man was always secretly you know,
- 8:24in love with her, and of course he's also like a you know,
- 8:28high powered executive type. But the premise is that he is part of a
- 8:33publishing empire, and he goes and works at her little book nook kind of
- 8:37publishing, uh, indie publisher kind of thing, and and he's he's bringing
- 8:43all that kind of corporate behavior, and throughout the course of the movie,
- 8:48she does absolutely nothing to earn him, nothing like less than nothing, and
- 8:56he just basically turns into a completely spineless simpy. For some reason, falls
- 9:07for her, for some reason, he does everything for her, He sacrifices
- 9:11his job for her. But but but but but he gets a better job,
- 9:13so still got that higher or be going, you know. And she
- 9:18does not extend herself at all, She does not change a damn whisker of
- 9:22herself, and he just conforms to her ass like a man shaped leech.
- 9:30And I mean, I don't mean I could probably get it. This is
- 9:37not romance. The essential component of romance is both characters are each other's antagonists.
- 9:43But I was thinking, like, in this kind of modern take on
- 9:46non mance, because I'm not gonna call it romance where the man just completely
- 9:52conforms to the woman, how do you actually how do you actually extrapolate that
- 9:58to lesbians? Which one's going to be the man, which one's going to
- 10:03be like totally debasing herself to conform to the other. I don't know.
- 10:07Yeah, it's it's a real question, isn't it. Yeah, I don't
- 10:11know what it's about. I mean, like, I mean, I don't
- 10:13know how and I don't know that this girl answers that question. This is
- 10:20the end of that clip, so it cuts off there. This is like
- 10:24one of the later clips. Maybe. Yeah, it's the last one on
- 10:28the list, but it sounds like it's early in the video. Okay,
- 10:31so you know what I mean. Like, it doesn't it's not putting them
- 10:35in chronological order when it selects the clips. It's kind of like setting up
- 10:39a set of I guess priorities. Yeah, the scores get higher as you
- 10:43go up. So all right, but anyway, do you do you want
- 10:48me to go to another another one? Sure? All right? Okay,
- 10:52so they have titles. So there's the last one is why romance not was
- 11:00fall short? Analyzing the genre's writing. That was the clip we just played.
- 11:03Then there's exploring adult queerness, navigating romance and identity. Then there's escape
- 11:09into the world of romance novels, a level of literary escapism. Yeah,
- 11:15fascinating, diving a historical young adult female female romance. Let's go for number
- 11:20two, number two on the list. Yeah, let's number two on the
- 11:24list. Looks good. Let me just go to the top. Mm hmm,
- 11:31what the what what happened? No? Nothing, it's just it's the
- 11:35the whole screen moved over, and I don't know why I did that,
- 11:39and I don't see how I can just yeah, all right, So this
- 11:43is number two. Is Last Night at the Telegraph Club a compelling historical lesbian
- 11:50romance. Let's go for it. Yeah, sure, oh, because it
- 11:56is a I mean, I think the peak example that combined all of the
- 12:00things that I'm talking about, that is it comminds all the things I'm talking
- 12:05about in the sense of being good against all the ways that I think things
- 12:09are not good and are part of the genres that I think like lend themselves
- 12:13better to that aspect of female. A romance, historical A young adult is
- 12:20fuck is last Night at the Time Technical Difficulties by Transitive Property a historical fiction
- 12:28novel, and it's a romance novel at the heart of it, but it's
- 12:31also like a young adult story about the coming of age of our main character,
- 12:35Lily, who is Chinese American, lives in San Francisco's Chinatown during the
- 12:41nineteen fifties, and it's like the Heighth of the Red Scare. She is
- 12:46studying like Stem and the only other girl in her math class is this girl
- 12:52named Catherine who's this Italian and they both as not that unlikely though. I
- 12:56mean it's the fifties. Women were more likely to go into STEM at the
- 13:00time, get involved with the butchfem subculture there, and I think, like,
- 13:03that's so beautiful and amazing, and their romance is so compelling and sweet.
- 13:07We also talked about this book actually on the podcast, so you should
- 13:11check that out if you would be interested as well. That's I guess,
- 13:15like an example of something that I found really compelling. I mean, so
- 13:20she's that's like an example of something that she thinks is good. Why because
- 13:24it checks boxes? Like what it sounds like? It checks boxes? Yes,
- 13:28that's what it sounds like. Do you want to listen to it again?
- 13:33No, I'm just like, maybe we should just go to the red
- 13:37to the main move show video. Yeah, because it's almost sounds like there's
- 13:43nothing like it. There isn't like a an organized like a skeleton to this,
- 13:48like a a spine, you know what I mean. Maybe maybe it's
- 13:54more in the Yeah, maybe it's more in the actual videos. All all
- 14:01right, Well, I mean we could go me to go to the beginning
- 14:03of this. There are some there are no chapters, but there are there
- 14:07are peaks and valleys. Okay, yes, so we could try that.
- 14:11Okay, let's give that a go. I'm not feeling Just make sure we're
- 14:16not missing any chick. Yeah. The opus is like it would be good
- 14:20if it was about hooking you in, like hooking somebody in to watch the
- 14:26content. But that means it's probably because most of the clips are not making
- 14:31a direct point, but they're hinting that there is a point. And so
- 14:35what what works is that people are like, oh, I want to watch
- 14:37the video now and find out what this is about, you know exactly anyway,
- 14:41So we'll just play it from the beginning here, and I'm I'm actually
- 14:46really concerned about the one where she says, well, this does it right?
- 14:50Yeah? What was the I mean, does it? Yeah? It
- 14:54doesn't? Like is it just checking boxes? There is the ultimate conclusion of
- 14:58this is if it's sallacious, it's bad like last night at the Telegraph Club
- 15:03is what the name of it is? All right book that she was recommending.
- 15:07Okay, Hello, welcome to the Sonny Book Nook. My name is
- 15:11Sunny, and I have a problem with lesbian romances. I have a problem
- 15:18with I also have a problem with romance, like lesbian romance novels. If
- 15:26I sought them out, I might have a problem, but I I really
- 15:30have very little interest in it. Although I did change my video, So
- 15:33did I screw anything up? Nope? Well no, it looks fine.
- 15:37No, okay, good, Okay. I read a variety of genres.
- 15:41I read basically every genre. I will admit that the majority of what I
- 15:46read is literary fiction and a lot of speculative fiction as well. Lesbian literary
- 15:50fiction is often not always, but it's often pretty good in my in my
- 15:56opinion, Do you really read it though, like honestly literary thing? Do
- 16:00you read it? Or do you read like the first pack paragraph of every
- 16:03chapter and then tell everybody you read it, look at the cliff notes.
- 16:07I don't know how anybody can read literary fiction. It's a total direk well
- 16:12literary fiction or something modern literary fiction, modern literary Let me, let me
- 16:17qualify that modern literary fiction, because I actually understand the appeal of like older
- 16:22literary fiction, but modern literary fiction. I mean it's basically people sucking farts
- 16:30out of each other's butts butts buttholes. Yeah, I mean you can read
- 16:40literary fiction if it's What I've found is, if it's written by somebody who
- 16:44went through a war, it's very readable. But if it isn't, it's
- 16:48it's a lot of It usually amounts to a lot of fart sniffing. So
- 16:55went through a war or ran a homestead on the prairies. Those are the
- 17:00two options. Everything else is huff fart huffing. All right, Okay,
- 17:07yep, Okay. The thing is, I have a couple reasons as to
- 17:12why I think lesbian romance novels specifically are not that good, why the genre
- 17:21doesn't really lend itself to good good writing, looking at some of the specific
- 17:27lesbian romances that I've read over the years, and how I think they just
- 17:33fall short and fail at doing the thing that romance novels are supposed to do
- 17:38and that I have gotten from romance. Okay, I'm curious what she thinks
- 17:42romance novels are supposed to do, because I know, technically i'm talking about
- 17:49possibly like one percent, romance is something that's very easy to do very badly.
- 17:56So you know Sturgeon's law, ninety percent of shit, everything is crap.
- 18:00Well with romance novels. It's like ninety nine point nine percent of everything
- 18:03and in the genre is utter crap. But that's because there are the people
- 18:08who are attempting to write a romance in the traditional form, which includes things
- 18:15like pride and prejudice and stuff like that, which is actually pretty good reading.
- 18:18And then there are people who are simply making something to slick to.
- 18:23Yeah right, I don't know what she means by that. Yeah, so
- 18:26it's it's it's like because this could just be like, you know, like
- 18:32gooner material in the where in the Veneer of like literature. That's why she's
- 18:37exactly and sipping tea with makeup. But she's really so really you have to
- 18:41ask yourself, what is it? What is it you're saying that lesbian romance
- 18:47needs to do? Does it need to I don't know check boxes in your
- 18:52how you know how bad writing. You know how bad writing has gotten.
- 18:56And I know this even though I don't read. Sometimes I see ads on
- 19:03YouTube, Okay, sometimes they see ads on YouTube where there'll be like an
- 19:07ad before a video that's trying to sell a book, and they're like the
- 19:11worst tumblr bloggie plots ever. Like there was one of a of a.
- 19:17It even has animation to go along with it to sort of sell you in
- 19:19the book. And it was like I was the only wolf in my pack
- 19:22that couldn't transform and I was in heat and I had this and no one
- 19:29could tell it was a girl, right, And it was like it was
- 19:32an ad on YouTube and I was like, what is going on? And
- 19:34yeah it was. It was total like borderline lesbian furry smut, but disguised
- 19:44as literature, and it was a book. It was they were trying to
- 19:45sell a book. I'm yeah, it's basically pornography and there's some seriously screwed
- 19:53up in So what right off the bat, what are you trying to say
- 19:59that you're you want from this? Because most what most people want is an
- 20:07encouragement to you know, like just to start gooning. Yeah, like,
- 20:15what is it about? Well, let's see, let's I guess we'll listen
- 20:18to more novels of other sorts. I have read straight romance novels and male
- 20:23male gay romance novels. I've read historical romance novels and contemporary romance novels.
- 20:29I haven't read any fantasy romance novels. Really, I mean I think I
- 20:34read like a quatar once, like years ago, and I thought it was
- 20:37fine, and I read what was Court of Thorns and Roses? I read
- 20:44like a quatar, Sarah J. Mass Court a Court of Thorns and Roses.
- 20:51I actually attempted to read some of her. Right, it looks bad.
- 20:55It looks bad, just based on that, because technically I can say
- 20:59that I write fantasy romance in a technical sense. At least, my editors
- 21:08encouraged me to lean into the romance because the romance readers will tolerate all the
- 21:14weird time shenanigans to get their hit. But so I was researching romance in
- 21:22the fantasy genre, so I read some attempted to read some Sarah J.
- 21:26Mass. Let me see what this one is, Court of Thrones and Thorns
- 21:30and Roses. Oh yeah, this is the one that was sort of like,
- 21:33you know how fifty Shades of Gray is like a is a fan fic?
- 21:40Yeah, oh yeah yeah. Court of Thorns and Roses reminded me very
- 21:45strongly of the Hunger Games? Is it a super sexy Hunger Games? I
- 21:56didn't get to that point. It was just okay, the first chapter was
- 22:00really interesting, but then the protagonists martyrdom and whining got a little bit annoying,
- 22:07I think, is what happened. And I was just like, I'm
- 22:08done, I'm done, goodbye. I did read some of the Uh,
- 22:17I did read some of the the one star reviews. I really love that.
- 22:21I like going to read one star reviews from books. I'm pretty sure
- 22:26that ya novels are totally trash. Pretty sure. I'm not sure that the
- 22:32because pretty sure this has too much sexual content to be ya. Okay,
- 22:37well, I don't know. I mean I think that they they're moving in
- 22:41on that. Yeah, go ahead. Uh, well, you know,
- 22:47I'm done. I think we should just continue once like years ago, and
- 22:52I thought it was fine, and I read What's the Fairy one that everyone
- 22:55likes Holly Holly Black, Yeah, that one. I read the first book
- 22:59to that as well, and I thought it was fine as well. But
- 23:02I am a lesbian reader who reads lesbian books what I identify as lesbian books,
- 23:08and a lesbian novel. Okay, I'm just plausive for the veno.
- 23:14Okay, I never thought you'd be like, I'm a lesbian reader. Well,
- 23:17here's the book section for you. I guess I don't know a lesbian
- 23:22reader. Weird, it's weird. It is weird. It is weird.
- 23:25Latino reader, But are you though, Yeah, yes, I'm Latino and
- 23:30I read so, I'm a Latino reader. Yeah read dragon Mary. I'm
- 23:41being an asshole. Let's keep going. That's all right, all right,
- 23:44Well, lesbian literature, a lesbian romance novel is obviously at the center of
- 23:48it are two female characters who get together, or a lesbian relationship that is
- 23:53at the center of the novel, or lesbian dynamics and themes that are really
- 23:56present. That to me, is what makes a lesbian novel a lesbian novel.
- 24:03Of course, with romance novels FF, romance is its own thing,
- 24:07and like that is lesbian fiction, that is lesbian romance. That's the lesbian
- 24:11romance genre oftentimes. And this gets into my first point. I've noticed that
- 24:19I'm pausing for the banana. We'll listen to her first point. What's f
- 24:23F stand for f F? What do was the context that she said it?
- 24:30Novels. It's like a novel, type of lesbian book or something novel.
- 24:37I have a female female sorry female on female. Okay, it's the
- 24:42obvious sorry, weird, Like that's like a porn genre. F fm mmf
- 24:48whatever. So you're saying that, No, I know, But so what
- 24:52you're saying is is that what it sounds like she's saying is that lesbian novels
- 24:57are like there are no, oh, lesbian novels that don't become sexual because
- 25:04like how else? How else do they exist? You know what I'm saying,
- 25:10Like, yeah, yeah, it just seems it seems like these are
- 25:14all just smut, Like I mean, they kind of have to be on
- 25:18some level. Okay, anyway, wait what happened to my sources? Oh
- 25:23there it is. There is Okay, many ff romance novels. The two
- 25:27feel main characters that get together are not lesbians. That's fine, Okay,
- 25:33that's fine. But I just don't think it is necessarily a good representation of
- 25:38reality, if that makes sense. Like from what I understand, romance novels
- 25:45are of course a level of escapism and a way of inserting yourself into something
- 25:52that is appealing or experiencing. It's like all other forms of literature, right
- 25:56form of escapism and is immersive. Something that I find is kind of takes
- 26:02me out of a lot of the romance novels that I read is that most
- 26:07of these love interests and main characters are both bisexual or pansexual women who have
- 26:11male exes who sort of feature in the stories as well. Some example.
- 26:17Oh no, that's interesting. Mmm yeah, well, what a surprise,
- 26:22you're basically the genre is basically just fantasy for the main amount of readers,
- 26:30which are women who do have relationships with men. I mean, that's that's
- 26:37who it's really marketed for. It's not really marketed for lesbians, so yes,
- 26:44or so for lesbians who have always been lesbian, these books are not
- 26:48for you. But if you're a woman who has who's angry at an X
- 26:53or is just angry at men or whatever, then maybe this book is for
- 26:57you, yeah. Or if you just want to explore the scenario, yeah,
- 27:03or you just want to explode a scenario. Sure yet, all right,
- 27:07rules that I'm going to bring up are actually let me, I'm gonna
- 27:11look on my phone for this, because I have screenshots of like twenty five
- 27:14different romance novels that I've read over the last two years or three years ish
- 27:19that I would identify as like having some of these things that I think are
- 27:26some of my problems, I guess with lesbian romance, The lesbian romance Sean,
- 27:32I'm gonna say one thing. I will say one thing for this person.
- 27:37She doesn't make me hate my life like manifest though, I don't hate
- 27:44you. I don't feel the onset of cellular death. When I'm listening to
- 27:51you. I think, Yeah, you're right, she's pretty. She's just
- 27:53pretty much bog standard factory setting. I am what I've been taught, and
- 28:00uh like, I think she's a bit delulu about freaking lesbian novels because they're
- 28:07never going to really feature I guess, the pure lesbian It's just it's unlikely
- 28:15because it because the biggest part of the genre is going to be again women
- 28:22who do have relationships with men exploring the other side. Strangely, there's not
- 28:26a huge amount of that, you know for men. No, not a
- 28:33lot. Okay, let's keep going Temple. In the book Something to Talk
- 28:41About by Merril Wolsner, which follows this, it's like a fake dating Hollywood
- 28:48assistant and an older woman who is a really famous actress or actress who's like,
- 28:56you know, pretty pretty well known in the Hollywood circles, and they
- 29:00stint is definitely like I think she has male exes from what I remember,
- 29:04I read this a while ago, and Joe the Hollywood actress, she just
- 29:11like vaguely does not have any exes or like no one knows her sexuality,
- 29:18and that feels to me that's not really how lesbian romances are in real life,
- 29:26and I think, like that's what makes it different from male male romances.
- 29:32And I just, you know, felt like he was going for long.
- 29:36I don't know, so I think we need to get to a point
- 29:42like yeah, yeah, pausing for the banana. Hopefully there'll be like is
- 29:47that Oftentimes for those books like I haven't read any Emily Henry for example,
- 29:52but like for other contemporary romances that I've read that aren't lesbian, these characters
- 29:59are coming from positions that make sense, are realistic, and that I encounter,
- 30:03you know, like people who are out and proud in a way that
- 30:10their identities are like really central to their life. And I think that a
- 30:15lot of the sexualities of characters and female female romances that's not really necessarily the
- 30:21case I've noticed, which I think, like doesn't really doesn't make sense.
- 30:26Every lesbian I know is really proud to be a lesbian. And also every
- 30:30lesbian couple I know is usually comprised of two lesbians, not to by women.
- 30:36Sometimes it's one by woman and one lesbian. But to be honest,
- 30:40like, I just feel like it seems like a lot of these romance novels
- 30:45are kind of even while being lesbian. Point, she's just just waffling as
- 30:55pophobic in the way that it's phobic because the characters are not full on,
- 31:00super proud, hardcore militant butch lesbians like you. No, she likes the
- 31:10butcher stuff. It comes up the cliffs. There's a lot of mention of
- 31:14that, although she doesn't appear to be butch, but then she does have
- 31:17that the nose ring. I don't know, but yeah, I mean,
- 31:22I don't like. I guess what I'm what I'm wondering about is, uh,
- 31:27how do you how do you even like? How do you even write?
- 31:33Like when you write, let's okay, when you write a heterosexual romance
- 31:37and not like this the Penguin book smut stuff that the women like where it's
- 31:42because they're all formulaic, right, It's like the say, you could turn
- 31:45to a certain page in the book and that's when the sex is happening,
- 31:48and it's it's basically just porn for women. But if you want to write
- 31:52a real like a real story that has romance in it, like that has
- 31:56a romantic theme that runs through it, I don't know, whatever it is
- 31:59the boss Estonians or you know, some and some Shakespeare or some you know,
- 32:08I don't know, just something like like you mentioned Bride and Prejudice,
- 32:12Like it's not smut, it's it's you know, it involves like let's say,
- 32:17for the example, it involves a man and a woman. And why
- 32:22do those work? And can you take that template and simply apply it to
- 32:27either two men or two women? And I don't think that lesbian, but
- 32:30I think that lesbian romance novels and maybe also gay romance novels, if they
- 32:36exist, I'm sure they do. I think they are written explicitly to kind
- 32:43of not be of let's say, formulaic in a heterosexual sense. Okay,
- 32:52so you think that lesbian novels are not okay, First of all, one
- 32:54of the problems is, yes, you can apply it to men, but
- 32:57no, you cannot apply it to women. And the reason why is because
- 33:00women's characters are extremely limited in this particular orthodoxy that we exist within and the
- 33:07range of stories. And it's even more limited when you're talking about lesbians,
- 33:12because each of these characters is going to have to contend with being a lesbian
- 33:17and what that means in the society and smashing the patriarchy, and that is
- 33:22going to end up consuming their individual personalities. With the heterosexual romance, the
- 33:28important thing is you got two individuals who are contending with themselves and contending with
- 33:32the relationship. When you take away a man, or often if you have
- 33:37a man paired with a woman, you may end up with just one person,
- 33:42one individual contending with himself and contending with the relationship, and the woman
- 33:45is just basically a metric by which she measures his ability to Like when I
- 33:52was talking about that woman who was part of the I guess the small publisher
- 33:57and then this guy came in from a more professional publishing outlet. When I
- 34:02talked about that that there is two sides to that. On the one hand,
- 34:07he becomes entirely defined by her needs. But on the other hand,
- 34:12she becomes entirely defined by her needs, you know, and whether or not
- 34:17he is meeting them. So there's no sense of development of herself. There's
- 34:22no going inside herself and becoming stronger, being able to effect change in the
- 34:29greater world, being able to manage herself and her own bullshit. There's none
- 34:32of that, So there's no real development of the individual female like the individual
- 34:37woman now there was in past romances like Pride and Prejudice. Not only did
- 34:44the main female character have to overcome her prejudice towards the main male character and
- 34:49actually see beyond the surface level, she also had to stand up to his
- 34:52very class conscious aunt who did not want him marrying a squire's daw. Basically,
- 35:00when she was based like redescended from nobility or royal blood, it's it's
- 35:06it's last stuff. But but she had to develop the chops to stand up
- 35:12for herself. She had to develop the chops to question herself and all of
- 35:15that, or she wasn't going to be worthy of the relationship. You don't
- 35:19see that, You get see less and less and less the closer you get
- 35:21to the modern time of that of that recognition of women's individual moral development in
- 35:25romance. Now, so with with modern romance, you can have a situation
- 35:31where a man is the only one doing any kind of developing, and only
- 35:36one developing himself as an individual and the woman is basically just a blob of
- 35:40needs that he has to accommodate. And but but that starts to like that,
- 35:47the whole concept and the whole enjoyability of it starts to deteriorate. Then
- 35:53you have two women, Well you got two women who are blobs of needs,
- 36:00and who's going to attend to those needs? So even that tension is
- 36:02gone, right, and then it's all about the victimhood because they have to
- 36:08somewhere. The movement has to come. So it comes from the persecution by
- 36:13a horrible patriarchal society, the hatred of men towards women, whatever, that
- 36:19something kind of external force. It's the only place where you're going to find
- 36:22tension because you can't start to explore the individuality of these women and how they
- 36:27develop themselves because you're not really recognizing that. So a classical romance between two
- 36:34men is doable, although there's some horrendous crap going on there, just because
- 36:38you have you don't get away from recognizing the individuality. Although to be fair,
- 36:46women can screw that up really badly by simply a over identifying one of
- 36:51the men with like a thirteen year old girl, or making them both thirteen
- 36:54year old girls. But but you see what I'm getting at. It's like,
- 36:58yeah, when you have two women, the tension just drains out of
- 37:01everything because now it's no longer about who they are as individuals, and there's
- 37:07nobody actually being an individual, so there's no real tension. It's just a
- 37:12mess. And the other thing is that it's going to be even worse.
- 37:15When she's talking about, oh, I want this to be like pure lesbians,
- 37:19Well, you're just going to make that twenty times worse because on top
- 37:22of being women, they are now lesbians, which means they have no agency
- 37:27whatsoever, and they cannot develop individually because that would be lesbianist. I think.
- 37:36Okay, she said lesbophobic is actually lesbophobic phobic. You need to understand
- 37:40any recognition of individual moral worth is the intersectionalists have a word for it for
- 37:47any particular group except for men. Men can continue to be interesting individuals who
- 37:52develop, who deal with their own bullshit, who becomes stronger, whose stories
- 37:58are fascinating and compelling, and everybody wants to read, which is why male
- 38:01authors have a huge female viewership readership, whereas female reader authors do not have
- 38:09a huge male readership, you know, so we're we're going to continue to
- 38:13make men the best characters in fiction by constantly erasing the individuality of every other
- 38:21group. But you know, and ultimately, like this is this is this
- 38:28complaint is ridiculous because she's essentially saying, oh, because this is a genre
- 38:35that appeals to a subset of straight and bisexual women, and they are much
- 38:39larger in number than lesbians. I have a whole bunch of options that I
- 38:45wouldn't have if that weren't the case. Plus, you also have the classical
- 38:50lesbian romance, which you know, you read one of them, and you
- 38:54probably have read every single one of them, let's be honest. Yeah,
- 38:59But like, the truth is that lesbian romance as a sub genre of romance
- 39:06is the size that it is because of bisexual and straight women's interests. The
- 39:12end, if they didn't have an interest, you would probably have three options.
- 39:20So there you go, you don't, okay, all right? They
- 39:28exclude lesbian experiences and are very still centered on previous relationships that women have with
- 39:37men in the aftermath of those things, which that is also a true experience
- 39:42of many people, and many by women. And lesbians even in like my
- 39:47life, but I think that that a man turned them into lesbians or I
- 39:54just want aftermath being with a man. Yeah, especially for the female female
- 40:01like romance genre. I'm actually curious that it is really because you know,
- 40:07every time there's a shooting, there's some guy who throws himself in front of
- 40:10a bullet for his female partner. I notice that or or tries to take
- 40:15down the shooter. I'm wondering, let's be a relationship which one of you
- 40:17throws themselves in front of the bullet, like you do you have to?
- 40:22Does it? Do you toss a coin like because it seems like there's something
- 40:29going on? Yeah, you know, but we're and actually, honestly,
- 40:31that's a more interesting that's more that makes a more interesting premise for romance too.
- 40:37And I know I don't want to over encourage like men's sacrifice for women,
- 40:42but men sacrifice for women, women sacrifice for each other, and that
- 40:47makes that challenging a challenge, yeah, like if you well, challenging for
- 40:55by the standards today. But okay, let's keep going. You know what
- 41:01I'm just well, what I'm what I'm saying is, uh, it would
- 41:06be like if you if you wanted to explore lesbian romance, you could do
- 41:09it and involve a sacrifice, right, Yeah, So I'm just saying like
- 41:15you could do that. I don't know, like you like that's why I
- 41:22said. But in the beginning I said that, like you know, if
- 41:23you if you look at the way that good heterosexual romance stories are written,
- 41:30then look at what elements, what are the elements in them that work,
- 41:34and then see if you can translate will that translate over to a lesbian relationship?
- 41:39And I think you're right. I don't think it will as well.
- 41:44And it's almost like that's why maybe there they just turn out to be.
- 41:51It sounds like they're just kind of political to me, like they're just kind
- 41:54of political screeds like, oh, well, well we got nothing else,
- 41:58so let's make it about the patriarch. You know, well, like I
- 42:00said, there's no other tension. So yeah, because again, like that
- 42:07bechel test I suppose maybe specifically for like lesbian romances, when I feel like
- 42:15that's not really the case for gay romances, and for straight romances, your
- 42:20ex oftentimes like the ex'es and gay romances are like also men or in straight
- 42:27romances it's not like, obviously there's not that issue of having to contend with
- 42:30your identity. And I don't know, I find it a little disingenuous at
- 42:36a certain point, I suppose, But I can sort of sympathize with this
- 42:40because I can see what's probably happening. They're using a straight and maybe bisexual
- 42:46women are using lesbian romance as a maybe catharsis to their romantic relationships with men
- 42:55and their their gripes about that, and they bring that in and I can
- 43:00see why that would be annoying if you have a genuine interest in the romance
- 43:04between women that it's not a statement about men, you know what I mean.
- 43:08Yeah, But also she says that it's also gay men have, at
- 43:14least the way they're written, apparently also are like, you know, they
- 43:19have men in their history, and I wonder if that's not, like,
- 43:22if that's not basically the constant throughout is that there has to be a background
- 43:29where there was a man and that man hurt them or broke them or did
- 43:35them wrong or something, and can't do that with a woman exactly. Like
- 43:39That's that makes me wonder, And that's the funny thing, is that how
- 43:43come all of these How many of these lesbian romance books end up in a
- 43:47fistfight? Like, I don't know how many fight scenes there are. These
- 43:51lesbians are so big on the domestic violence now, But seriously, I think
- 43:54that that might be the reason. I think that, And it goes back
- 43:58to what I was saying about it possible being political, because there has to
- 44:02be like, Okay, we're gonna make this. Like if you create any
- 44:07piece of media and you're trying to include a kind of identity in the story
- 44:15that is superficially intersectional, like I'm gonna make this about an Asian girl,
- 44:21I'm gonna make this about a you know, a trans Muslim, I'm gonna
- 44:24make this about whatever. In nine times out of ten, that identity takes
- 44:30the front row seat in all of the story choices you make. Because now
- 44:35all of that every choice you want to make in the story, you have
- 44:38to consider how it impacts this political purse puppy that you've created for your story.
- 44:45So lesbian romance stories are going to run into that problem because I'm betting
- 44:52that most of the people who write them are doing it. From that,
- 44:55I'm gonna write a story about a lesbian woman because no one's ever done it
- 44:59before, and I'm gonna do it. And then they sit down and they're
- 45:02doing it, and they're like, well, she's she's got a history.
- 45:06It can't be another woman because that's not good for the sisterhood. So we're
- 45:08gonna put We're gonna make it like some you know guy used to beat her
- 45:13and he drank all the time and all of the usual Like, let's just
- 45:15cross off all the stereotypes, right. He was a redneck, he wore
- 45:19a maga hat, you know, he liked beer and watching sports and all
- 45:23this other stuff. And she couldn't take it anymore. And so she fled
- 45:28to the arms of another woman who listened to her, who you know,
- 45:31heard her problems. Whatever. She's like, she runs up to an animal
- 45:37shelter. She's got like you know, you know, all of that stuff,
- 45:42and I think that it is like that. I think that's her issue,
- 45:46but she's not gonna be able to identify it if she's concerned about the
- 45:53way that lesbianism is represented and not exploring the possibility that a woman who leaves
- 46:00another woman someone was in the wrong. There there was some problem and a
- 46:05good story with that kind of back story to it, like where there was
- 46:08an old relationship and it went sour. That can't be like something simple like
- 46:15well, we just didn't see eye to eye. It has to be something
- 46:17kind of dramatic because it adds to whatever the tensions are, right, Like
- 46:22if they were controlling, Let's say, and you you do like a relationship
- 46:28where lesbian's breakup because one of them is like really controlling and always plays the
- 46:34victim and uses it to control the behavior or the other and the other one's
- 46:37like, I gotta get out of this. This is toxic. Whatever reminds
- 46:39me of my mother, you know, And and they leave and then like
- 46:43she meets the new girl. The new girl's kind of you know, like
- 46:45the opposite of that whatever. She's like more I don't know, like not
- 46:51not as controlling, a better listener, whatever. And then the controlling woman
- 46:54comes back into the you know, into the picture, and then it creates
- 46:58all but like you need that otherwise it doesn't work or like a rival boring,
- 47:02Yeah, otherwise it's boring, right, So that's I'm just making that
- 47:07up. But I'm I'm thinking, like this is what she's she sees that
- 47:12there's a problem with it. But what she doesn't seem to get is it
- 47:15is not an accident. It is it is kind of by design because the
- 47:21people who write this kind of stuff, if people create this content, especially
- 47:23today, whether it's literature or television or film or video games or music,
- 47:29even they're doing it from a specific kind of identity like oriented angle and that,
- 47:37and there are things associated with that that take precedent, so it will
- 47:40affect the storytelling, but they think it's worth it. That's how you get
- 47:43lesbian space witches. That's how you get them. Oh, I'm gonna I'm
- 47:46thinking of watching that and maybe covering it. I've never watched it. I
- 47:52I no interest, no interest. Okay, no, Star Wars is dead,
- 48:00so damn. But but uh but yeah, I mean like I know
- 48:04about it. I know what the plot points are and stuff. So all
- 48:08right, let's play some more of the video. I don't know, maybe
- 48:12I'm wrong for that. This is just a general trend that I'm noticing,
- 48:15like even in lesbian literary fiction, and this is just for lesbian fiction in
- 48:20general. So much of what is published and what is on the market and
- 48:27the books that are out there feature characters who are not lesbians, but get
- 48:34involved in lesbian relationships. Okay, all right, how many times is she
- 48:37gonna say this? I don't know, you jump to one of these humps,
- 48:43these spikes. Sure, let's jump to a spike. And also like
- 48:49yeah, I think you I think you're on point there, Brian. The
- 48:52reason why they do that is because they don't want to have a woman ex
- 48:55who is a nutcase. And you can do anything with a MALEX, right.
- 49:00You can make it a serial killer. You can make them a stalker,
- 49:01you can make them a rapist, a rapist, you can make them
- 49:04a freaking genocide er. You, I mean, the sky is a limit
- 49:07With a male X, like, you can make them any shades of evil.
- 49:12What can the hell can you do with a female X? Well,
- 49:15she just she just me or you don't even have to make it evil,
- 49:20like you can just have like say a scenario where in a heterosexual romance where
- 49:27there is a girl and there's a love triangle, there are two men they're
- 49:30interested in the same woman and there's a rivalry. It's like you know,
- 49:34Team Edward or team whatever his name is, like from Twilight, Right,
- 49:38and that is enough to get like readers and gross because they like, start
- 49:43picking their favorites and then and a good writer will probably make both of them
- 49:46appealing right to the point where you don't know which one is good for her
- 49:50or whatever, as long as the woman is not a pain in the ass,
- 49:52because if the woman is unlikable, then you're just gonna want them to
- 49:57be a lot like what these guys they shouldn't be with her, she's not
- 50:00worth it. But if you make all of them appealing and you keep people
- 50:04on the edge of the seat, you can make a rivalry look good.
- 50:07It's another thing that they don't want to do. And I think it's because
- 50:08they don't want Lesbie. They don't want women in competition with women. They
- 50:13don't even though women are always in competition with women. Yeah, and the
- 50:16problem with the female ex is even if you make a female ex, if
- 50:22you don't make them evil, then why did they leave? Then then it's
- 50:25bad on the on the person, like you know, it looks bad on
- 50:29the on the person who did it, or it's just dull. You just
- 50:32say, well, we just grew apart, you know, and then that's
- 50:36it, right, And then why are you even including them? Like why
- 50:38would you include an ex unless they're the the inclusion of the X actually increases
- 50:44the tension. Yeah, that's really interesting, isn't it. Like a male
- 50:50ex can add so much to a story that a female ex just can't because
- 50:55they thinks so much with the characterization of a male ex and you can also
- 51:00have it, well, you can blame him, and you can also you
- 51:02don't don't have to blame the female character who left him as much, you
- 51:07know what I mean, Like you can you can have her leave him for
- 51:12superficial reasons and people will still buy her as a sympathetic character, you know,
- 51:16but if if she leaves another woman, she becomes less and less sympathetic,
- 51:21right, yeah, okay, Well one other thing too that they could
- 51:24do with arrival. This is what they would likely do even if they did
- 51:29have something like where they need to figure out, like, you know,
- 51:31what happened with a past female partner, is that she could have gone to
- 51:37a man which would make her a traitor in a way or something like that,
- 51:40right, or go back to her old man, her old ex boyfriend
- 51:45who was not good for her or whatever, and she didn't know, you
- 51:49know, what she was doing. I don't know, something like that.
- 51:50There there there are ways, there are new ways, novel ways to make
- 51:53men in fiction more and more unsympathetic and so all right, yeah, but
- 52:01that's why the male ex will always be more pervasive and always be more likely
- 52:07to be part of the fiction. Like I said, he can add so
- 52:09much more tension without sacrificing the sympathy of the female protagonists. So sorry,
- 52:17lady, Like, if you want to do if you want that to change,
- 52:21then you're gonna have to accept portrayals of women that you probably wouldn't accept
- 52:29dark feminine. Man, Yeah, you're gonna have to explore the dark feminine.
- 52:31You're gonna have to accept fiction like that other than and like I talked
- 52:36about how when you when you have the women, you have two women,
- 52:42you limit how much you can do with those women for the same reason that
- 52:46when you have a female ex you're limited in what they can bling to the
- 52:50story for exactly the same reason, because the women cease to be interesting individuals
- 52:55and they become ciphers for a morality. Play can't do certain things with women
- 53:00because otherwise it's it's sexist, right, you can't do things with women because
- 53:06I just I guess the the idea of women being totally evil. I mean,
- 53:10how's this for a lesbian romance one half or a woman who gets involved
- 53:16with an incredibly abusive lesbian partner who tries to suck her into a cult that
- 53:22kills boys, and then she has to escape that and overcome it, and
- 53:30then with her new FBI girlfriend she goes back and she there. That sounds
- 53:38like it would be actually interesting to listen. But you can't do that.
- 53:43Can you do that? Could you even consider publishing that something like that in
- 53:46today's publishing industry? Absolutely not. So you're stuck with male axes for the
- 53:52same reason as every time the woke writers attempt to make male characters less interesting,
- 54:00they make them more interesting because are the only ones who have any flaws.
- 54:05They're the only ones who have to strive. They're the only ones whose
- 54:07individual moral actions matter in a way that the others don't. And they keep
- 54:13doing this over and over again. They don't understand why. Oh man,
- 54:19we should call this the we should call this the interesting male ex theory hypothesis.
- 54:27Yeah, male characters are interesting for the reason why your so many romance
- 54:32novels have ex boyfriends, Because you can just do so much with them and
- 54:37add and they add so much to the story. All right, possibilities are
- 54:40endless. All right. Couple of like the dozens that I know that are
- 54:46like two bisexual women or two bisexual feminine women, which is what is seems
- 54:52like to be the majority of these books, like most of Alexandra Bellaflir's books.
- 54:58And she is a ma So I think she's saying they're not writing enough
- 55:01butch lesbian stories. They're all like feminine, lipstick lesbian stories. And I
- 55:07think it's because, again, they're not for butch lesbians. They're four like
- 55:14regular women. They just want to like explore the material. They like the
- 55:17idea of you know, it's like Yuri. Isn't that what Yuri is?
- 55:21I don't know. Yeah, yeah, so the girl girls in Uri are
- 55:24very feminine and like that, Like they're not and they're not explicitly lesbian,
- 55:30but lesbian things happen, I guess, I don't know. So they're hetero
- 55:36flexible. Yeah yeah, Well, honestly, I think she's just repeating herself.
- 55:42But let's let's see, I mean, does she make another point.
- 55:45I don't know. I don't know. I got a super I mean,
- 55:47a rumble rant. So I want to read that really quick. Nova Fan
- 55:52twenty one Thank you, NOBA Fan says for a dollar, does she not
- 55:55know that even when her diversity fantasy is realistic, it's triggering to others,
- 56:00and when it's presented as empowering that the reader base still complain because real life
- 56:06still sucks. M Yeah, I don't know, thank you. I probably
- 56:13not. I'll just say that she probably does not know that. All right,
- 56:15there is another peak coming. So let's see where Alexander Bellaflour is a
- 56:20major female female conemporary romance author, and that's basically all of all of her
- 56:25characters, and then with Ashley Herring Blake in the first book of her Bright
- 56:32Fall series, Dalilah Green doesn't care. I mean she does a similar thing
- 56:38again, like it's two by women who get together, I think, or
- 56:43it might be one lesbian and one by woman. It varies between all of
- 56:46her books, but it's always like two feminine women or two Yeah. See,
- 56:52so I knew that she was going to get into the Delilah is the
- 56:57woman who was sent in to destroy Samson something about like I'm gonna assume this
- 57:05is a feminist writer. Okay, so you can put me on a stake
- 57:07if it's not true. But there's something about feminist writers that they love to
- 57:15take the names of really evil women from like fairy tales and mythology and religion,
- 57:24and then take that name like they love Delilah and you know, Jezebel
- 57:30and Lilith and kali Ma and they love them. I don't know what it
- 57:36is, but feminist women they love to embrace that, like that dark feminine,
- 57:39and then they Medusa they celebrate it like I there was a sculpture.
- 57:45You guys probably remember this was like years ago that someone made a sculpture.
- 57:50It was like that. There was a sculpture. I think it was Perseus
- 57:53holding the head of Medusa. Do you remember that. It's an old classical
- 57:57sculpture Greek mythology. Money created a reversal of that where it was Medusa holding
- 58:02the head of Perseus and all the women were like, oh, get it
- 58:07girl, And I'm like, do you know what the do you know who
- 58:09Medusa is? Like? Why are you you know, putting these women on
- 58:13a pedestal. They're always doing that anyway. Sorry, I just had to
- 58:16say that, Yeah, more feminine than masculine women, I guess getting together
- 58:22and I think that it's it's kind of again, it's strangely, it's it's
- 58:29lesbophobic in some way because it feeds into this idea of like, oh,
- 58:34we're not like those ugly, mannish, Harry fat bull dykes. We are
- 58:39We're like pretty women, just like everyone else. Like that's when a lot
- 58:44of these covers and I'm going to put some examples on here really give off.
- 58:49I guess this is more of this kind of surface level criticism, like,
- 58:57Oh, I don't like that they're pretty. Why aren't they like you
- 59:00know, bull dye carry flannel, wearing short haircut, hairy legs, birkenstocks,
- 59:09Like, why aren't they those lesbians? It's like, I don't know,
- 59:15maybe it's the same reason why the men in romance stories don't have washboard
- 59:19abs. I mean, they do have washboard as was regular men mostly,
- 59:23don't you know. Yeah, yeah, it seems pretty superficial. It's finished
- 59:27off the peak. Okay, I don't really have anything. I don't know
- 59:31that doesn't sit right with me. And I think like this really encompasses the
- 59:36vast majority of the genre, and I think it has to do with the
- 59:39publishing industry itself, and it has to do with what people are writing and
- 59:43comfortable with writing. In the Actually Herring Blake books, I also noticed that,
- 59:50and actually, on my podcast Lavender Metas, where we talk a lot
- 59:52about lesbian media and critically examining a lot of that, one of our listeners
- 59:58emailed us and mentioned how and Jilah Green doesn't care. The first book in
- 1:00:00the series, Actually Hearing Blake never uses the word lesbian. Ever. One
- 1:00:07of the love interests is a bisexual woman who has I know, you have
- 1:00:12a banana. Are we through the peak yet? Yeah, there's another one
- 1:00:16right here though. Yeah, this is like the biggest one. Let's just
- 1:00:20teleport over here. Okay, So, like, do you watch a lot
- 1:00:23of like if you had a podcast and all your podcast was focused on lesbian
- 1:00:30fiction, how much of that is there to get out? Are you just
- 1:00:35looking at like fan fiction, because I know there's a lot of fan fiction
- 1:00:38probably covers that. Are you looking at like editorials? Like I don't,
- 1:00:44like, I don't know, I just feel like you're limiting yourself a little
- 1:00:46bit, you know, Like do you just do you just like turn your
- 1:00:51nose up at like regular stories talk about it. She says that she does
- 1:00:57read it though. I'm just really astounded because this represents an explosion in romance
- 1:01:07related to lesbian themes gay themes. But it's all written by women. So
- 1:01:12but you know, like I bet, yes, yes, which is why
- 1:01:22a lot of it is just awful. But twenty years ago you wouldn't see
- 1:01:25any of this. And you're complaining for Chuck Tingle, he's a genius.
- 1:01:30Yeah, you're complaining about having this much choice, because let's be frank,
- 1:01:38the actual representation of people who have women who have an interest in sexuality with
- 1:01:45other women is not right here like a gigantic blob on lesbian it's actually a
- 1:01:52bell curve with their straight women. There's bisexual women who are interested, and
- 1:01:57there are a lot more of them. So you you are upset that women
- 1:02:02interested who have sexual interest in women the fiction that aimed towards them reflects what
- 1:02:10they look like and what they want and how they are. Right, You
- 1:02:15cannot, you cannot. You are unbelievably entitled. Yes, you want this
- 1:02:23to resemble your interests, and no doubt you think you have the self righteousness
- 1:02:30belief that if they don't resemble your interests, that there's something wrong with them.
- 1:02:36Well, one you. Once you get rid of the male ax,
- 1:02:38you have severely restricted your plot potentials because the male ax represents such a variety
- 1:02:45in terms of stakes and tension and different things that he's bringing to the plot
- 1:02:52that a female ax just won't. And if you want to change that,
- 1:02:55then you have to challenge missonry and the soogyny of low expectations. But you're
- 1:03:01not gonna do that. So you are gonna look at this entire gigantic genre
- 1:03:10of romantic fiction and you're gonna say this resembles the people who are interested in
- 1:03:15it too much. It should resemble me. And you're gonna say that you
- 1:03:20are entitled to do that because why because you're a lesbian. You don't own
- 1:03:24sexual interest in women. That's your problem. You think you own that,
- 1:03:29you don't. There are straight women, women who identify as straight, who
- 1:03:34have a sexual interest in women. There are bisexual women who obviously have a
- 1:03:37sexual interest in women, and they outnumber you. So the fact that the
- 1:03:42the genre of women with a sexual interest in women looks like the majority of
- 1:03:47the women who have a sexual interest in women, get over it. Yeah,
- 1:03:54it's not gonna look like you. It's not an echo chamber to make
- 1:03:58you feel good, good Lord, And like twenty years ago, I go
- 1:04:04into a bookstore and there would be five books on lesbian romance or anything related
- 1:04:11to that, and most of the the genre of women with a sexual interest
- 1:04:18in women, Because it's not the lesbian genre. It is. This is
- 1:04:21she's trying to own something that isn't hers. It is the genre of women
- 1:04:27who have a sexual interest in women. It includes straight women, it includes
- 1:04:30bisexual women, it includes lesbian women. But if you think when you look
- 1:04:34at the demographics, the largest demographic of women with a sexual interest in women
- 1:04:41probably is straight. And that doesn't mean they don't identify as straight. I
- 1:04:45know that sounds weird, but they just they don't want to identify with that
- 1:04:48particular aspect of their sexuality. They just want to explore it. Fine,
- 1:04:51and then you have bisexual women, and then you have a smaller proportion which
- 1:04:56is lesbian. So the fact that the genre resembles the majority of the people
- 1:05:01in it who consume it and who write for it, that is not discrimination
- 1:05:06against lesbians. Your problem is you think you own the genre and you don't.
- 1:05:13Exactly. You are a small part of it. And if you want
- 1:05:15to go back to owning the genre. Then you can get rid of all
- 1:05:19of the bookcases full and we can all go back to twenty five years ago
- 1:05:25when you had five books and all of them were short stories. Right No,
- 1:05:29like we're compilations of short stories. Right Yeah. Otherwise, just enjoy
- 1:05:34the fact that you have choice. And also again, if you want to
- 1:05:39get rid of the male ex then that the number of the types of stories
- 1:05:43are gonna be slashed by ninety nine percent. They're all going to be the
- 1:05:46same damn coming out story of smashing the patriarchy like it's in. You won't
- 1:05:53even be able to put a face to the patriarchy because that's going to be
- 1:05:56having an X. Right, you get rid of the mailexes, you get
- 1:05:59rid of X everything they add to a story, tension, stakes, questions,
- 1:06:04other aspects. I mean, I guarantee in each one of these stories,
- 1:06:10the male ex is probably bringing most of everything to it, and that's
- 1:06:14probably why she's complaining about it. Well, you want to change that.
- 1:06:16Challenge, challenge miss Injry, recognize men's issues and challenge the misogyny of low
- 1:06:25expectations, and demand that your female characters have every bit as much moral individuality
- 1:06:30as men, which means that their consequences, they can be just as evil
- 1:06:34as men. And do not soft pedal it with bullshit about patriarchy. Okay,
- 1:06:41if that's what you want, but this is the consequence of living in
- 1:06:44the system that we do. Women's moral choices are boring, they add nothing
- 1:06:49to a story, and you make it worse by saying, well, it's
- 1:06:53the patriarchy, the patriarchy is responsible. Well, you're just blanding women out
- 1:06:58more. You're making them more worthless as human beings, more just just blobs
- 1:07:03that are posted or pushed around by the miasma of evil men's thinking and actions.
- 1:07:09What do you think is gonna happen that's gonna come out in storytelling?
- 1:07:13People are gonna add a malex because they need a bit of tention, They
- 1:07:16need a bit of a heavy you know. Okay, Yep, there you
- 1:07:21go. There's the best I can do. That's good bunge of annoyance.
- 1:07:26Again when like the characters are another yet another sort of representation of something that,
- 1:07:30like I've seen a million times before that doesn't feel realistic to like how
- 1:07:35people actually engage in like lesbian community. But I will say you freaking and
- 1:07:45I'm like, I'm like, okay, how far until we get the biphobia?
- 1:07:47Well, we were already well passed. I didn't say anything. It's
- 1:07:51just like, I'm not gonna I'm not gonna turn my freaking experience into a
- 1:07:55sword. But honestly, how dare you say you speak for the entire community?
- 1:08:01You are a part of it. You don't own it. Okay,
- 1:08:06you don't own it. Get off your high horse, and if you want
- 1:08:12to own it once again, we go back to twenty five years ago.
- 1:08:15Five books on a shelf, all of them short story anthologies. All right,
- 1:08:24shut up, enjoy the plenty. Think specifically about like adult romances here,
- 1:08:30because young adult romance novels I have a lot more leeway. I feel
- 1:08:36like they are often a better written and be much more compelling because they're dealing
- 1:08:43with other themes besides the core of like just romance. Like oftentimes they're dealing
- 1:08:46with like family and loss and growing up and being in an environment of like
- 1:08:51school or you know, working, Like oftentimes, that's what a lot of
- 1:08:55these young adult female female romance novels are doing. I think a lot of
- 1:08:59times they're done really compellingly and really well, but pausing for the banana.
- 1:09:05But I think this is almost the end of this hump, so I don't
- 1:09:08know if she's gonna say anything. I don't think that that is the case
- 1:09:12for a lot of adult contemporary female female romances, for example. I mean,
- 1:09:15I think young adult romances that are done really well are by Kelly Quinslan.
- 1:09:20And perhaps some of the things that I'm identifying as I think are like
- 1:09:26problematic a little or that I find concerned trend within lesbian romance might be identifiable
- 1:09:32in some of Kelly Quinlan's work, But I think that as a whole,
- 1:09:36the writing and the characters like kind of make up for it, whereas a
- 1:09:40lot of these other books, like there's no redemption for that in that regard,
- 1:09:44Like in Kelly Quinlan's books Late to the Party and Her Name in the
- 1:09:47Sky, and there's another one about the basketball player and the Cheerleader, like
- 1:09:54all of them feature characters who are even if they're not grappling with her sexualities
- 1:10:00within the context of these books, they are in environments that are like restrictive
- 1:10:05of like you're in high school. Some of these girls are like out and
- 1:10:10or out to certain people and trying to navigate that, and I think all
- 1:10:13of that is really interesting, whereas uhhhhh, I don't know if this gets
- 1:10:20a lot deeper. I mean, you know what, this is the end
- 1:10:25of this hump, by the way. You know what I think is funny
- 1:10:29about this. I think these are all like these are essentially queer feminists criticizing
- 1:10:41the work of other queer feminists, and they're just you know, because like,
- 1:10:45I don't know, I feel like this has nothing to do with me,
- 1:10:47Like this is all like, you know, it's like the people who
- 1:10:53were on Tumblr have become and we're writing fan fiction, are now writing books,
- 1:10:58and now the people who read those books that are fan fiction are criticizing
- 1:11:01them. And it's like a competition for who is the most inclusive and who
- 1:11:06is the least problematic amongst this small subset of writers that are trying to make
- 1:11:14you know, content that's apparently, you know, just lesbian friendly enough.
- 1:11:19Yeah, and uh yeah, it's like it's just becoming another competition. Mm
- 1:11:26hmm. Although I do appreciate I'm about to ruin this woman's whole career.
- 1:11:30I do appreciate the shout out to Angel Reese there. Although I don't know
- 1:11:33if she'd appreciate being cast as a lesbian. Oh really, well, white
- 1:11:39basketball player right there up in the Yeah, yeah, no, I oh,
- 1:11:44oh, are you referring to the basketball player? Yes, yes,
- 1:11:47Angel, isn't it Angel rees no talking about the really popular one right now?
- 1:11:51Yes, that's upsetting all the other female basketball players. Lindsay's a big
- 1:11:57Lindsay's a yeah. Well, actually she's not good. I can't remember her
- 1:12:00name now that you say it, now that you said that, it's not
- 1:12:02it's not what you said though, But not only no, it's not,
- 1:12:11it's a different I'll get the I'll get the name, get the Clark.
- 1:12:16Yes, that's right, Kaitlyn Clark. The thing I was gonna say about
- 1:12:19Caitlyn Clark is that not only is she a really great basketball player that happens
- 1:12:25to be white, which is woof that's a problem, but she's also very
- 1:12:29sportsman like. She's very like. The reason why her team kills is because
- 1:12:33she cooperates with the other players. She comes up with plays and like,
- 1:12:39you know, like they works with the team to to score. This is
- 1:12:43what professional you know, uh, sports teams are supposed to do. They're
- 1:12:48supposed to come up with a plan they're supposed to like. I think sports
- 1:12:51is actually more about it's actually more tactical than people think, and it's less
- 1:13:00athletic. I mean, athletics are important obviously, but it's less of a
- 1:13:03focus, you know, than like being a good part of the of the
- 1:13:09team. So yeah, and I think Katelyn Clark recognizes that. But yeah,
- 1:13:13it is it is funny that that's when I saw that cover we got
- 1:13:17we got a Caitlin Clark Angel Reese story. Is that what that is?
- 1:13:24No? No, absolutely not, absolutely do not. I know I'm taking
- 1:13:29the piss utterly. Okay, this is this is a bunch of wintering and
- 1:13:34basically an object demonstration and why stories are only interesting if men are involved.
- 1:13:39So let's keep going. Well, I want that to be the case,
- 1:13:43but it seems to be. Do you want me to jump to another hump?
- 1:13:45Yeah, jump to another hump? The humps day it's the same time.
- 1:13:54Guess what day it is? Oh, I got a super child super
- 1:13:57chow from Richard Pierre is five bucks and says she has yet to bring up
- 1:14:02whether the author is authentically lesbian enough. This stream has been sponsored by and
- 1:14:09The Minotaur as well. Burger King and Fries, Burger King and Fries and
- 1:14:14the minotaur. You know what this is? This seems this is this is
- 1:14:20deep lore from the discord. Incidentally, if you want to join the discord,
- 1:14:24you can do so at Badger Nation dot online. You can help us
- 1:14:28with or you can enjoy our resources and all that other stuff that we give
- 1:14:31and I put together. If you're interested in any of the statistics that I
- 1:14:36talk about on the stream, the best place to go to get them would
- 1:14:40be the Discord. So Badger Nation dot online and uh Badger or sorry,
- 1:14:45Burger King and Fries was one of the craziest posters I have ever met,
- 1:14:53one of the craziest, craziest people in the discord. Yes, I actually
- 1:14:58made a labor the center of the discord. And yeah, and the minitary
- 1:15:04lesbians. Yeah no, no, he he used to constantly talk about the
- 1:15:09lesbian You know how some people talk about certain noticers, you know, like
- 1:15:14particular Yeah. Uh. That kind of his conspiracy was the lesbians. The
- 1:15:19lesbians are at the center of it all. So he'd go on and on
- 1:15:24and on about it, among other things, and he'd also challenge He's just
- 1:15:28really obnoxious. So I constructed a special role for him that left him at
- 1:15:32the center of the maze, and amusingly, at one point we had I
- 1:15:38don't know, like I think it was Rose Wrist or Rose Wrist, that
- 1:15:43guy who kept wanting me to identify as an intersectional. Remember we got into
- 1:15:48that fight with him about him. Did he end up in the Minotaur?
- 1:15:55I think it was him. I think or was one other feminist who ended
- 1:15:59up in the actual And then he's I'm like, you gotta be careful because
- 1:16:03he'll release the minatar, and then they do, and then the minuitar got
- 1:16:08into their discord and it was hilarious because you could just see them like trying
- 1:16:13to crawl out of their discord, like this is your fault. I'm like,
- 1:16:15I warned you, I warned you. You you're the one who went
- 1:16:21into my discord and then crashed it and then released the minatar and then you
- 1:16:27had the minotaur on your ass. That was all on you. Nothing new
- 1:16:30with me, all right? So as well as also I recall several audio
- 1:16:35book apps that were advertising their app with these cookie cuttery young adult novels but
- 1:16:41about either the werewolf romance genre or the husband struggling at work and people propositioning
- 1:16:45his wife. But he's connected with a powerful mafia family, but he's trying
- 1:16:48to make his own way without using his connections to establish himself. It's awfully
- 1:16:54specific. Yeah, right, but I could see how that could become its
- 1:16:57own trope. Yeah, the werewolf thing, I don't know, it's just
- 1:17:01it's so it's cringe man, all right, So should we play some more?
- 1:17:09Yeah, let's see if there's any anything left of these humps. Yeah,
- 1:17:15I don't know that there's a there's like a little one right here,
- 1:17:19so I'm gonna jump here. Well, let's see romance and whatever. Like,
- 1:17:25I know it can get bad, but there's some things that I'm like,
- 1:17:29this is not how is this being published? I feel like I'm reading
- 1:17:32fan fiction that is better than this, you know, and me and Renaissance
- 1:17:35talked about this in terms of reading Mel Wilson something to talk about, and
- 1:17:40Merl Wilson recently came out with us, is your pornography is so bad?
- 1:17:48Yes, because it's porn? Like, do you not know what the genre
- 1:17:55is about? Okay, this is dumb? What's another hump? Is there
- 1:17:57any other further humps? Uh? There's like little ones over here I'm looking
- 1:18:03at These are some pathetic cumps. Yeah they are. They're more like a
- 1:18:10mild rise really into like the bo lesbian subculture. In a way, it's
- 1:18:15about as stimulating as the books that she is critiquing. There's no erections because
- 1:18:21this is all lesbian stuff. That's why there's so few that most a lot
- 1:18:28of lesbians and a lot of people in lesbian communities aren't necessarily but I think
- 1:18:30like the fact that this the huge swathes of like this genre, or just
- 1:18:35have no acknowledgement of even the existence of like gender non like truly gender not
- 1:18:43conforming women write it and gender not conforming lesbians. Okay, who is this
- 1:18:46person? Did she have a sunny book something sunny something booknook? Let me
- 1:18:54let me, let me take a look, because these people always write take
- 1:18:58a look. It's in a book. My name is Sonny, Sonny Lushoe.
- 1:19:03I mean, I'm guessing that she's got a huge following on Twitter or
- 1:19:08something, Sonny Shoe. I never heard of them, Uh no, I
- 1:19:16mean, because you know they this is book talk. Oh, incidentally,
- 1:19:19there's a big controversy with book talk. They're drooling over Wade Wilson not the
- 1:19:24Deadpool actor, the guy who murdered two women. Did you know that?
- 1:19:30What book talk? Book Talk. It's all the female It's a whole bunch
- 1:19:35of women who are fans, usually of dark romance. They're on a place
- 1:19:42called book talk, which is like a community on TikTok, and a lot
- 1:19:45of them are drooling over Wade Wilson, not the guy who plays Deadpool,
- 1:19:50a man who was recently condemned to death for murdering two women. Oh yeah,
- 1:20:01I mean not got surprised. Okay, all right, booknook. Now
- 1:20:12I'm trying to find literary reviews for children's books, workbooks and get okay,
- 1:20:15that must be her general or somebody else's. Yeah, this might be some
- 1:20:20This might be somebody who has absolutely nothing to do with the evils. Here
- 1:20:26we go, good Reads. Let's see do you actually write? Is what
- 1:20:30I'm trying to get at. Uh read currently reading doesn't look like she writes
- 1:20:38best anti capitalist fiction, because of course this is one of her list's best
- 1:20:45anti capitalist fiction. Yeah, it's like I said, it's political in nature.
- 1:20:49I knew it was from the get When she said lesbian romance, I
- 1:20:54was like, this is political and I knew it, like I I So,
- 1:20:57I'm not surprised. I'm sure that. And that's and by the way,
- 1:21:00that's why it sucks, you know, that's why it sucks. That's
- 1:21:05why like all of these, all of this like woke garbage sucks because the
- 1:21:11political is the precedent on which or it's the foundation of whatever the product is,
- 1:21:18whatever the art is, and so it undermines it because it's a weak
- 1:21:25foundation. Anti capitalist books. Do you pay for these books? You've already
- 1:21:30lost? You know, how much are these anti capitalist books? Allison?
- 1:21:38How much do they cost? Is it's going to make who's going to make
- 1:21:44the products in your anti capitalist utopia? Oh? Well, who's going to
- 1:21:47pay the taxes? Let's face it, Like yeah, well, And the
- 1:21:55the problem is that, I mean, I honestly, I think today's verse
- 1:22:00version of capitalism is so it's it's well, I mean it's it's not exactly
- 1:22:05real because it's all like the money is printed, so they're manipulating everything.
- 1:22:12But but I'm not against the idea the necessity of a meritocracy in society.
- 1:22:17People need to get what they earn. God damn, do these people ever
- 1:22:24bore themselves to death like they don't want any kind of strife in their life
- 1:22:30despite constantly creating it. No doubt that's probably why they. Yeah, but
- 1:22:36okay, so I got another super child from Richard Beierre. He gives us
- 1:22:40five bucks and says, Wade Wilson's swastika face tattoo just put those women over
- 1:22:45the edge and makes them absolutely irresistible to those women. To be fair,
- 1:22:50he didn't have the facial tattoos when he was murdering the women, but he
- 1:22:56did have neck tattoos. It's like, there you go, there's a big,
- 1:23:01big, big red flag. Yeah, like he's uh, and there's
- 1:23:09a lot of women drooling over him right after the man versus bear meme.
- 1:23:15Yep, I guess people are too boring or sorry, men are too boring.
- 1:23:19Okay, let's let's uh is there any because she's just back on the
- 1:23:24same topic there. I don't think. I don't think that this really gets
- 1:23:28I don't I don't think there's anything else to this. I think we've done
- 1:23:30it, Like I think we we squeezed everything out of this, out of
- 1:23:33this lemon. Yeah, we've squeezed all the things. We've got it all.
- 1:23:39Yeah. Oh so In short, lesbian fiction, sucks because they can
- 1:23:46only write men in an honest way. And so if you can't, if
- 1:23:51you can't write women as compelling as you can write men, then your lesbian
- 1:23:57fiction will always have male ex boyfriends or male antagonists or whatever the conflict is,
- 1:24:05because that's what I'm wondering about too, like, what is the conflict
- 1:24:08in a romance? In the lesbian romance, Without the conflict, then you
- 1:24:13got nothing. So yeah, and of course you're also limiting your potential.
- 1:24:17That's why what stories remain probably all look the same because there's only so many
- 1:24:24ways to skin a cat. So well, I think ultimately what I'm getting
- 1:24:29from this is she believes that the genre of women with the sexual interest of
- 1:24:33women, it's not lesbian fiction, that genre should resemble her, should just
- 1:24:40be a gigantic echo chamber determined by her interests. Well, no, and
- 1:24:46you don't. I mean, you have every right to say that because you
- 1:24:49know no censorship, but everybody has an equal right to completely ignore you and
- 1:24:57say, yeah, but we also exist in the space. Yes, unless
- 1:25:00you're gonna talk about some kind of purity or you're the pure woman who wants
- 1:25:04to have sex with women. Therefore you get to define the entire genre and
- 1:25:09everybody, even women who don't want to write what you want them to write,
- 1:25:13they have to write what they Well, they're not going to do it,
- 1:25:15right, no wonder an anti capitalist wants slavery or thinks that she's entitled
- 1:25:20to it to enforce norms on other people, to enforce things on us,
- 1:25:28or ask for things from others that they have to labor to create. Let
- 1:25:31me put it that way, Yeah, entitlement to others labor. Okay,
- 1:25:38all right, So what's gonna happen now is we're gonna move over to my
- 1:25:43channel, which I believe you can find at It's at gender attic on YouTube.
- 1:25:46I did check that out gender attic. Uh, it's erratic with two
- 1:25:53rs. Not too te's two rs erratic gender ratic Okay, but you might
- 1:25:59also be able to do it with a search on Typhoon Blue. And we
- 1:26:01are going to talk about more House of the Dragon, because it's almost the
- 1:26:06same as this, Like really it's almost the same problems as we got here,
- 1:26:13Like the women just cannot be characters. They just they're functionally non existent
- 1:26:17as moral agents. But anyway, if you want to join us for that,
- 1:26:21go over to my channel and if you want to send us a message
- 1:26:25at any time after this show is over, feed the badger dot com slash
- 1:26:28just the tip is the very best way to send us that message and to
- 1:26:30send us whatever funds you'd like to give us as a tip to tell us
- 1:26:34we're not screaming into the void, because it often feels like we are.
- 1:26:39Once again, Feed the badger dot com slash just the tip to send us
- 1:26:42a message in a tip and back to you. Brian. All right,
- 1:26:45I did get one last super child before we wrap it up from grading doors
- 1:26:49for five bucks and he says you will own no lesbian books and you'll be
- 1:26:53happy. Some old German misogynists posing seductively. All right, a right,
- 1:27:00Well, if you guys liked this video, please don't like subscribe if you're
- 1:27:01not already subscribe to the bellflonifications, leave us a comment, let us know
- 1:27:04what you guys think about what we discussed on the show today, and please
- 1:27:08please please share this video because sharing is caring. Thank you so much for
- 1:27:11coming on today's episode of Red Chill Cinema, and we'll talk to you all
- 1:27:15in the next one.