Latest / eMotors: Electric Revolution / Mustang Mach-E versus Tesla Model Y Comparison
Transcript
- 0:09Welcome back to the Deep Dive. OK, so we've gone through all
- 0:12the sources you sent us, car and Driver, Consumer Reports, the
- 0:16lot, trying to cut through the the usual brand noise.
- 0:19Yeah, get straight to the facts. Exactly.
- 0:22And today we're tackling a big one, the electric crossover
- 0:26fight. It's the Ford Mustang Mach E,
- 0:29taking on the Tesla Model Y. Two heavyweights in this
- 0:33segment, really. For sure, and both have had some
- 0:35pretty big updates for the 2025, maybe even bleeding into 2026
- 0:39models, right? So this rivalry, it feels
- 0:42sharper than ever. It's definitely moved past the
- 0:45legacy automaker tries to catch the EV startup.
- 0:48Oh, completely. Now it feels like like two
- 0:51different ways of thinking about an EV.
- 0:52You've got Ford leaning into that Mustang heritage, that
- 0:56design, that driving feel. Even in an electric car.
- 0:59I have to admit, there's something about the Mustang
- 1:01name. It has that pull, doesn't it,
- 1:03That history. Ford knows exactly what they're
- 1:05doing, playing that card. And then you've got Tesla
- 1:07sticking to what they do best. Yeah, sleek design, efficiency
- 1:11and that massive charging network advantage, right?
- 1:14So our mission here for you, the listener, is pretty
- 1:17straightforward. We're boiling down all these new
- 1:19comparison tests, all the reviews, to figure out where
- 1:21each car really shines now with these updates.
- 1:24Is the Mackey actually making a play for the top spot or is
- 1:28Tesla still just dominant because of the tech and the
- 1:32superchargers? That's the core question and
- 1:34we'll look at it through a few lenses.
- 1:35Comfort, value, those are huge. Then performance technology
- 1:40inside the cabin and of course the whole charging and range
- 1:44situation. OK, let's dive in.
- 1:46The first big take away, and this popped up in several
- 1:48sources, was kind of a surprise, wasn't?
- 1:49It it was the 2025 Mac E actually came out on top in some
- 1:54head to head test against the Model Y and.
- 1:56Not because it was necessarily faster, no.
- 1:58Not primarily speed. The big wins for the Mac E were
- 2:01value and comfort. Mostly comfort, actually.
- 2:04Value first, though. How did Ford manage that?
- 2:06Prices have been all over the place for EVs.
- 2:08Well, Ford got pretty aggressive with the 2025 pricing.
- 2:11They dropped the price on the base Select trim quite a bit.
- 2:14It now starts around $37,995, which is down from what, almost
- 2:19$42,000 a year before. That's a serious cut.
- 2:22It is, and when reviewers factor that in, plus maybe some
- 2:26standard features, they found the Maki had like a an overall
- 2:29value edge. One source put it around $3600
- 2:33better value compared to a similar Model Y.
- 2:36OK so cheaper entry point that definitely gets your attention
- 2:39but the comfort thing that feels like old school car making
- 2:43winning out. I think that's exactly it.
- 2:45It's Ford leveraging what they've always been good at.
- 2:47The reviews consistently said the Maki just rides better.
- 2:50It's more comfortable, especially on longer trips.
- 2:52How so? Like the suspension?
- 2:54Yes, suspension tuning, but also the seats themselves.
- 2:57Softer, apparently more supportive in the Maki, and it
- 3:00just soaked up bumps and rough roads better than the Model Y,
- 3:02which tends to be, you know, stiffer.
- 3:05More sporty, maybe, but less forgiving.
- 3:07And Ford made some small interior tweaks too, right?
- 3:10I saw something about the gear selector.
- 3:12Yeah, they moved it to the steering column like like you
- 3:14see in some Mercedes or well, older American cars even.
- 3:18Frees up space in the center console.
- 3:20Exactly little practical touches that improve the day-to-day
- 3:23usability. Now, it's worth noting the Model
- 3:26Y still generally offers a bit more rear leg room and the door
- 3:29openings are wider, so getting in and out of the back might be
- 3:31easier in the Tesla. OK, so Maki wins on value and
- 3:35comfort, which is huge for a daily driver crossover.
- 3:39But performance? I mean Mustang implies
- 3:41performance and Tesla implies speed.
- 3:44Right. That's the traditional trade off
- 3:45people think of and generally first straight line
- 3:47acceleration. The Model Y often is quicker
- 3:50across the different trim levels.
- 3:52Tesla really engineers for that instant punch, but Ford has
- 3:56seriously closed the gap, especially at the high end.
- 3:59If you look at the Maki GT, the top performance version,
- 4:01particularly with the the optional performance upgrade, it
- 4:05does zero to 60 in 3.3 seconds, which is exactly the same as the
- 4:09Tesla Model Y performance. So top trim versus top trim to
- 4:13dead heat now in pure acceleration. 3.3 seconds in a
- 4:16family SUV. I'm like, it's just nuts, isn't
- 4:19it? Like, are we even impressed by
- 4:21these numbers anymore? It's.
- 4:22Kind of normalized, yeah. But the reviewers made a key
- 4:24distinction. It wasn't just about the raw
- 4:26speed. It was about the feel of the
- 4:28drive. The subjective stuff.
- 4:30Exactly. The McKee was consistently
- 4:33called more enjoyable to drive, more balanced handling, better
- 4:38steering feedback. The driving flair Ford aims for.
- 4:42It feels sporty, maybe a bit stiff, but reviewers noted it
- 4:46still handles bumps better than the Model Y somehow.
- 4:48So Tesla is maybe clinically fast, while the Mucky is more
- 4:52engagingly fast. That seems to be the consensus,
- 4:55yeah. Tesla's about efficient speed.
- 4:57Ford's aiming for the driver. Who actually enjoys, you know,
- 5:00driving? OK, driving feels great, but the
- 5:02EV elephant in the room is always charging in range.
- 5:04That's Tesla's Kingdom, right? The Supercharger network?
- 5:07Has Ford made any real inroads there with the 25 updates?
- 5:11Not enough to claim victory? No.
- 5:13Tesla still holds pretty significant advantages here.
- 5:15Let's talk charging speed first. The Model Y can handle up to 250
- 5:19kilowatts at ADC fast charger peak speed.
- 5:23The Maki. Even the newest ones Max out at
- 5:26150 kilowatts. And what does that mean in real
- 5:28world waiting time if I pull up low on battery?
- 5:30It means the Tesla driver is likely done charging maybe 10,
- 5:33even 12 minutes faster for a typical say 10% to 80% charge.
- 5:38OK, that adds up on a road trip. It definitely does.
- 5:41The Maki, even with the bigger battery, takes around 43 minutes
- 5:44for that 10 to 80% charge. It's not bad, but the Tesla is
- 5:49noticeably quicker at the fastest chargers.
- 5:51And the network itself? Still no contest.
- 5:53The Supercharger network is still, well, it's a Supercharger
- 5:56network. It's bigger, often more
- 5:57reliable, just seamlessly integrated into the Tesla
- 6:00experience. That's their huge mode.
- 6:01But. Aren't other EVs getting access
- 6:03now? They are slowly Maki drivers can
- 6:06use some superchargers now with an adapter, and Ford says
- 6:09broader, easier access is coming.
- 6:10Supposed to be out properly through 2025, so that gap will
- 6:14shrink. But today, Tesla's network is
- 6:16still a major, major plus. In raw range, who goes further
- 6:20on a single charge? Tesla still takes the crown
- 6:22there to the Model Y Long range rear wheel drive version gets an
- 6:27EPA estimate of I think 357 miles.
- 6:31Yeah. The longest range Machi, the
- 6:33premium rear wheel drive, gets about 320 miles, which is good
- 6:38plenty for most people most of the time.
- 6:40But if maximum possible range is your absolute top priority,
- 6:45Tesla still leads the segment. So the story on infrastructure
- 6:48is Tesla leads, but Ford is closing the gap, especially with
- 6:53charging network access coming. That's a fair summary, yeah.
- 6:55OK, let's move inside the car, the cabin.
- 6:57This feels like a real clash of styles.
- 6:59Ford versus Tesla minimalism. Totally different philosophies.
- 7:03Ford is, well, it's less stark. The Maki still has some physical
- 7:07buttons and knobs, particularly for climate control, which
- 7:10honestly a lot of reviewers and I suspect drivers really
- 7:12appreciate. Yeah, not having to tap through
- 7:15three menus just to turn on the heated seats.
- 7:17Exactly. Plus you get the big vertical SY
- 7:19and C screen, which has been updated.
- 7:21And importantly, Ford added a standard heat pump across the
- 7:24board. That's actually a big deal for
- 7:26preserving range in cold weather.
- 7:27And Tesla still screen centric. Oh yeah, ultra minimalists.
- 7:31Almost everything runs through that big central horizontal
- 7:34screen, but the newer model wise are getting some upgrades based
- 7:38on feedback. There's talk of a new little
- 7:41screen for rear passengers, optional ventilated front seats,
- 7:44finally, and they've apparently improved sound insulation.
- 7:48That was a common complaint, the road noise.
- 7:50Yeah, they use some redesigned body castings, apparently fewer
- 7:53parts, which helps make it quieter.
- 7:55So Tesla's iterating, but the core minimalist approach
- 7:58remains. What about the driver assistance
- 8:01tech, Ford's Blue Cruise versus Tesla's Full Self Driving, or
- 8:04FSD supervised as they call it now?
- 8:07This is a really interesting comparison.
- 8:08The sources we looked at actually seem to prefer Blue
- 8:11Cruise for regular highway driving.
- 8:13Really why FSD sounds more advanced?
- 8:15FSD is arguably more advanced in its ambitions.
- 8:18It tries to handle more complex situations like city streets,
- 8:21though it still requires constant supervision.
- 8:24But Blue Cruise, which is primarily for hands free highway
- 8:27driving, was described as steadier, more consistent, more
- 8:31reassuring. So less capable maybe, but more
- 8:34trustworthy for what it does do. That seems to be the take away.
- 8:37Blue Cruise doesn't try to do as much, but what it does, it does
- 8:40very reliably, giving drivers more confidence.
- 8:43FSD feels more like a beta test, sometimes incredibly capable in
- 8:48moments, but potentially less predictable.
- 8:50That predictability matters a lot for trust.
- 8:53Makes sense. OK, one last practical point.
- 8:56Cargo space if you need to haul stuff.
- 8:58Model Y wins there. With the back seats folded down,
- 9:01you get about 71, maybe 72 cubic feet in the Tesla.
- 9:05The Mach E is closer to 60 cubic feet.
- 9:07So for pure hauling capacity, Model Y has the edge.
- 9:11Got it. Now before we wrap this up, you
- 9:12mentioned a financial point, something time sensitive.
- 9:15Yes, absolutely critical for anyone listening who might be
- 9:17considering buying either of these cars.
- 9:19Like soon. It's about the federal EV tax
- 9:22credit. That $7500 potential discount,
- 9:25OK. What's the catch?
- 9:26The rules are changing, specifically related to where
- 9:28the battery components come from.
- 9:29It's part of the Inflation Reduction Act, the IRA, and the
- 9:32deadline is looming September 30th.
- 9:34So after September 30th? After September 30th, because of
- 9:38these stricter battery sourcing rules, it's very likely that
- 9:42many trims of both the Model Y and the Mach E might lose
- 9:45eligibility for the full 70,000 half $100.
- 9:48It could drop to half 3007 for and $50 or even 0 for some
- 9:53configurations depending on their specific battery chemistry
- 9:56in origin. Wow.
- 9:57OK. So that $38,000 starting price
- 9:59for the Mach E we talked about, it might effectively become much
- 10:02higher if you wait too long? Exactly that potential $7500
- 10:06makes a huge difference in the final cost.
- 10:08So there's a real a short term incentive to potentially buy or
- 10:12before that deadline if you want to maximize your chances of
- 10:15getting the full credit. Good to know, definitely
- 10:17something buyers need to factor in, right?
- 10:18Now creates a bit of market urgency for sure.
- 10:20OK, so let's bring it all together.
- 10:21We've got the Maki winning on comfort and value, maybe driving
- 10:24feel. We've got Tesla still leading on
- 10:27range, charging speed and the network, plus cargo space.
- 10:30It really isn't a simple this one's better anymore, is it?
- 10:33Not at all. It's genuinely about priorities
- 10:35now. This is a mature rivalry.
- 10:37The choice really, truly depends on what you value most.
- 10:41So let's break it down for the listener who should choose the
- 10:43maki. OK, choose the Maki if you
- 10:46prioritize #1 ride comfort if you want a smoother daily drive.
- 10:51Also if the lower starting price and overall value proposition
- 10:55are key for you. If you love that distinctive
- 10:58sporty Mustang look. Which I admit looks fantastic.
- 11:01It does if you prefer having some physical buttons inside,
- 11:04and if you value that engaging, enjoyable handling, that fun to
- 11:07drive factor, That's the monkey profile.
- 11:10And the model Y who's that for? Choose the Model Y if your
- 11:13absolute top priorities are maximum possible range and the
- 11:16fastest charging speeds. If you rely heavily on public
- 11:18charging and want the Peace of Mind of the supercharger
- 11:20network. If you want the most advanced
- 11:23alt, be it still evolving driver assistance tech with FSD, and if
- 11:27you need that slightly larger maximum cargo space.
- 11:30Speed, range, network, tech, Edge.
- 11:33That's Tesla. Comfort, Value, driving, fun,
- 11:35Traditional controls? That's Ford.
- 11:37That sums it up pretty well, and you see this reflected in honor
- 11:40satisfaction too. My key owners rave about the
- 11:42looks and the drive. Tesla owners rave about the
- 11:45range and the seamless charging. Different priorities.
- 11:47You really do need to test drive them both, feel the difference
- 11:50yourself. But it's fascinating that Ford
- 11:52has managed to shift the conversation, hasn't it?
- 11:55It's not just about EV metrics anymore.
- 11:57It really is. And that leads to maybe the
- 12:00final thought here, the provocative question for you to
- 12:02consider. Go on.
- 12:04Given that the Machis recent wins in these comparisons were
- 12:07based on things like comfort, value, driving, enjoyment, you
- 12:11know the stuffed traditional car companies have honed for
- 12:14decades, does this signal a real shift?
- 12:17Meaning. Meaning is the EV market kind of
- 12:19growing up, moving past the initial wow, it's electric
- 12:23phase, the pure tech novelty and starting to value those
- 12:26traditional automotive strengths more like ride quality, interior
- 12:30usability, just how pleasant the car is to live with day-to-day?
- 12:35When does nicer ride become more important than charges 10
- 12:38minutes faster for the average person?
- 12:40Exactly. That's the question.
- 12:43When does comfort truly outweigh convenience for the mainstream
- 12:46buyer? Something to think.
- 12:48About definitely something to Mull over.
- 12:51All right, that's our deep dive for today.
- 12:53Thanks for joining us. Keep digging into your own
- 12:55sources. Keep asking questions.
- 12:57And happy driving whatever you choose.