Latest / Newcomer Pod / Elon Musk’s Boisterous OpenAI Bid
Transcript
- 0:00Hi, I'm Eric Newcomer. And I am Madeline Rinbarger.
- 0:04And this is the newcomer podcast.
- 0:10Each week, Eric and I discuss the VC deals and the drama that
- 0:14went down. Let's do it.
- 0:16Here we go. Oh, a loyal supporter of the
- 0:22Newcomer podcast. I, I think our first advertiser
- 0:25and Christina the CEO has been on the show.
- 0:27Anyway, without further ado, you're a start up founder.
- 0:30Finding product market fit is probably your number one
- 0:33priority, but to land bigger customers you also need security
- 0:37compliance and obtaining your SoC 2 or ISO 27.
- 0:41OO One certification can open those big doors, but they take
- 0:45time and energy pulling you away from building and shipping.
- 0:49That's where Vanta comes in. Vanta is the all in one
- 0:53compliance solution, helping startups like yours get audit
- 0:56ready and build a strong security foundation quickly and
- 0:59painlessly. How?
- 1:01Vanta automates the manual security tasks that slow you
- 1:04down, helping you streamline your audit.
- 1:07And the platform connects you with trusted experts to build
- 1:10your program, auditors to get you through audits quickly, and
- 1:14a marketplace for essentials like pen testing.
- 1:17So whether you're closing your first deal or gearing up for
- 1:20growth, Phantom makes compliance easy.
- 1:23Join over 9000 companies including Mini, Y Combinator and
- 1:26Techstar. Startups who trust Vanta.
- 1:29Simplify compliance and get $1000 off at vanta.com/newcomer.
- 1:35That's V anta.com/newcomer for $1000 off.
- 1:41Welcome back to the show. I feel like all of the news is
- 1:44really front loaded this week. Monday kicked off with Elon
- 1:47Musks bid to purchase the nonprofit wing of.
- 1:50Open AI Elon has the capacity to be in every headline.
- 1:54You know, it's just like, he's the guy running the country.
- 1:57His company Tesla, is the one getting government contracts.
- 2:02He can't just be the one suing open AI.
- 2:04Now he has to be the one trying to buy open AI, too.
- 2:06It's like, is it one saying it absolutely needs to remain a
- 2:09nonprofit? And, oh, wait, if it's not going
- 2:12to be a nonprofit, I would like to own it.
- 2:14And of course, this is a man who accidentally bought a company in
- 2:17the past, you know, sort of put out what seems like a not quite
- 2:21serious offer to Twitter only to end up buying it.
- 2:25So you'd think he'd have learned his lesson about acquisitions
- 2:28that are messaging because they they can become reality.
- 2:32And potentially he's maybe learned a lesson or two about
- 2:35overpaying for acquisitions because this price point, 97.4
- 2:39billion for the nonprofit wing is much higher than what this
- 2:43was valued and imported deal talks and even the last closed
- 2:46round for open AI is. I don't understand that.
- 2:48Doesn't the nonprofit owns the overall company?
- 2:51The overall company's valuation is higher.
- 2:53Why isn't the nonprofit worth more than the overall company?
- 2:58I'm not sure about that actually.
- 3:01I don't understand how it could be this valuation math is just,
- 3:05I read a take that it was basically also kind of like
- 3:08calling the bluff on the nonprofit because it's like, if
- 3:11it's valued so high, then over the round, then they have to say
- 3:15like, no, why are we rejecting so much money?
- 3:18And that's like making this case, that's like, OK, you know,
- 3:21where do you think the valuation really is, you know?
- 3:24I think he's just trying to make open AIS life as difficult as
- 3:28possible. I mean though I'm I imagine he
- 3:31set a price that he thinks if I got it for that it'd be worth
- 3:34it. I mean he's already learned that
- 3:36there are plenty of non monetary value in controlling the world's
- 3:40new social network. And I'm sure there's plenty of
- 3:45value to Elon and controlling the most popular AI company in
- 3:50the world. So if you think of him as
- 3:52someone who has plenty of money and an insatiable appetite for
- 3:57influence, then there could be some credibility to the
- 4:00acquisition. But I do think mostly it's meant
- 4:02just to frustrate open AI, make it difficult for Sam Altman to
- 4:06turn this thing into a for profit.
- 4:09I mean, Sam is just kind of outright rejecting this offer.
- 4:12I mean, he's, you know, quipped back.
- 4:15Like. Yeah, he's going to buy Twitter
- 4:17for $9.7 billion, right? Yeah.
- 4:19Which is the offer with the decibel point moved over 1
- 4:22section. So you know, that's just like a
- 4:24trolley reply. He's clearly not taking this
- 4:26seriously. I told Axios later this week
- 4:28that Open AI is not for sales. So today, as we're recording,
- 4:32the news breaks that Musk is saying, you know, he'll withdraw
- 4:35the bid if. Never.
- 4:36Mind cancels its conversion to for profit.
- 4:39Never mind, we'll stop. So I think that makes it
- 4:42abundantly clear what this move is about.
- 4:44Though he might have given Altman ammunition that Musk is
- 4:48being disingenuous here. It's like, oh if Musk says it
- 4:51really should never be anything but a non profit then why is he
- 4:53open to buying it anyway? It's it's another like trolley
- 4:57move. Well, another open AI news
- 5:00thrives. Joshua Kushner has been, you
- 5:01know, making the pitch to Opening Eyes staff to not leave,
- 5:04per the information. Time honored tradition of the
- 5:08mega Unicorn being like, this thing's going to be a trillion
- 5:11dollar company and if you look at our evaluation, this is what
- 5:15we're going to be worth. I mean, and they're not always
- 5:16wrong. You know, Uber did go on to
- 5:19become a super valuable company. Maybe not on the timeline that
- 5:22some people imagine when they got their equity.
- 5:25I think Joe Lonsdale was just reflecting on how Palantir had
- 5:28modeled out comp. So certainly not unprecedented.
- 5:32A funny situation. I mean, you know, all these
- 5:36highly talented AI software engineers are, they're like,
- 5:39man, I have a once in a generational skill that I don't
- 5:43even need to create a company to become extremely wealthy and I
- 5:47need to maximize that. You have all these former Open
- 5:51AI founders and executives recruiting people away.
- 5:55You've got Mira Marati starting thinking machines, clearly
- 5:59drawing a lot of Open AI people away, and that's on Open AI's
- 6:02mind. You have Ilia with safe super
- 6:04intelligence also pulling on the same people.
- 6:07Basically the entire legion of open AI Co founders that have
- 6:11since gone on to bigger brighter things.
- 6:14And anthropic, you know. I mean, that's the original 1.
- 6:17Right, the beauty of, you know, mirrors right now is it's like,
- 6:20oh, well, it's, it's a new company, so you're going to have
- 6:23more upside. And so I think, you know, Thrive
- 6:26is trying to answer, well, we, you know, if, if you think about
- 6:30how unlikely their success is versus the trajectory we're on,
- 6:35you know, it's, it's just a, it's a funny exercise.
- 6:38And of course, there is overall a sort of collective action
- 6:43problem, which is open AI valuation sort of depends on all
- 6:46those employees staying. It might be in your rational
- 6:50interest to defect and join Mira, because then you get a
- 6:54larger share of the potential upside if some of the momentum
- 6:57shifts. But that undermines open AI.
- 7:00So there's a classic like we could all just stay at the same
- 7:03place. We could get rich, but we're all
- 7:06going to like go everywhere. And maybe we hurt the valuations
- 7:09of the collective companies or we create more value, but
- 7:13they're they're getting paid plenty of money.
- 7:15I don't feel too bad. Yeah, sounds like they're
- 7:17getting paid regardless. And they, you know, it's just
- 7:20how much, how much of A better deal I could get.
- 7:23Plus all these engineers staying at Open AI.
- 7:26We'll get to work on GPT 5, as Sam Altman announced this week.
- 7:30This was very confusing thread, Eric, of how it was.
- 7:33Let's clear the air on what GPT 5 is and then explained perhaps
- 7:36the most complicated product bundle I've seen in an
- 7:39announcement. He's a once he's isn't he like
- 7:42sort of swearing that they're going to stop having all these
- 7:45confusing different labels. And then even the explanation of
- 7:48what models there will be remains confusing.
- 7:51Like, I mean, I'm paying for the top tier.
- 7:54I have no idea which one I'm supposed to use on.
- 7:57Like when do you use the pro? the Super pro version versus O3
- 8:02is very I'm and like some of them have access to the web and
- 8:06some you can have PDFs. So it's it's very confusing.
- 8:09I also don't understand like when you change on a thread, how
- 8:13much the memory it's, it's just like it's not a very good user
- 8:17experience as a hardcore user for the hardcore podcast fans on
- 8:21the Cerebral Valley podcast with Max and James, we had a lengthy
- 8:25debate over whether they would actually call this GPT 5 and
- 8:29that our predictions about what would happen in our sort of
- 8:33forecasting episode. An important data point that
- 8:35they are going to use the name GTG PT5 apparently.
- 8:38Yes, but what GPT 5 is in this transition maybe looks a little
- 8:42different. And Anthropic is doing a similar
- 8:44thing too with its next cloud release to incorporate reasoning
- 8:48models in with the larger package suite.
- 8:50And so it seems like now everyone is just productizing
- 8:54these models in a way and trying to find a best way to get it to
- 8:57stick with this new compute power and really testing what
- 9:00people will pay for at these different tiers.
- 9:03I mean, Eric, what do you as a as a pro user, do you select?
- 9:07Different models. The end result we want here is
- 9:12the models to sort of be smart enough to pick for themselves
- 9:15how it should be routed. And I think that's clearly on
- 9:20the horizon where it's like, OK, you ask a question and if it's
- 9:26like practically a Google search, you get sort of the
- 9:28classic model. And if it's a very creative
- 9:31philosophical question or math problem, you get reasoning
- 9:34model. I do think there's an element
- 9:37which I can understand is these are all very engineer driven
- 9:41products who want a lot of optimization and are like, I can
- 9:45decide whether time is a preference or thinking is a
- 9:49preference or, you know, and so you get, and they come up with
- 9:53weird names and you know, they, they could use a little bit of a
- 9:57Steve Jobs product centric, like we're building this for a big
- 10:01customer, but it's working, you know, it's, it's working.
- 10:04And I think, you know, open AI in particular, a foundational
- 10:08experience for them is like, oh, we have released something
- 10:10called ChatGPT, and it's one of the most popular products in
- 10:14America. So like, it's often the case
- 10:17that everything you think you know about brand isn't true.
- 10:20And if you have a great product, people figure out how to make it
- 10:23work. And so it's sort of funny.
- 10:25And I do think they should come up with clear names though, but
- 10:29it'll be fine. You got to peek behind the
- 10:31curtain at Lightspeed's venture return.
- 10:33What did you make of these numbers?
- 10:36Yeah, I mean, I think Lightspeed is doing a good job.
- 10:39I think that was number one. We haven't really seen mega fun
- 10:43performance besides the actual LP class.
- 10:45So this is a rare, very exhaustive to pat myself on the
- 10:51back window into how one of these mega funds is doing.
- 10:54You know, I just done General Catalysts, but that one was sort
- 10:57of old. This is fresh.
- 10:58This is like compared with Cambridge performance.
- 11:01So we're seeing it benchmarked, so it's super useful.
- 11:05And I mean basically the early Lightspeed funds are very good.
- 11:09There's mostly 1st and 2nd quartile funds.
- 11:11There's one depending how or two depending how you measure it,
- 11:15third quartile funds. So Lightspeed, you know, super
- 11:18strong player. But what we're seeing with all
- 11:21these funds is their recent humongous funds just haven't
- 11:24returned a lot to investors. Obviously, you know, it takes
- 11:28time, but I do think it's amazing that we're seeing these
- 11:32the sort of private equitification of venture
- 11:35capital firms. They're becoming so large when
- 11:37they haven't even really proved to LP's that the multibillion
- 11:42dollar funds work. You know, they're they're proof
- 11:44is based on a $500 million fund. But you know, Lightspeed is
- 11:48clearly getting in the right companies.
- 11:49If you want to bet on tech and ventures getting bigger,
- 11:53Lightspeed seems to make a lot of sense.
- 11:55They have good portfolio companies.
- 11:58Beyond even, you know, they had their initial wins, you know,
- 12:00when Jeremy Lou was there with Snap.
- 12:02But recently they've been getting into some really good
- 12:04deals. They're in the straw well.
- 12:05Like Glean is super important. I mean, I actually have this is
- 12:09the level of depth. I have the most important
- 12:12companies by net asset value to Lightspeed.
- 12:15It's Wiz #1, Grafana labs #2 navon #3 Clean Anthropic.
- 12:21Anthropic is going to go up in the their most recent things.
- 12:24So yeah, time, time to open your wallet expense subscription.
- 12:30Read, read our report and understand finally how venture
- 12:34capital works. I think it's super interesting.
- 12:36Now, someone please just send me Andreessen Horowitz's returns,
- 12:42please. That's all I want.
- 12:44Eric and newcomer Deca, I'll protect you.
- 12:46And then we, we want Sequoia. We, we've done things around
- 12:49Sequoia over the years, but we take Sequoia too.
- 12:52Any, any returns. But those are the big, big ones.
- 12:56Meanwhile, while I've been in Lightspeed Land, you've been
- 12:59actually listening to what the news of the week JD Vance gave
- 13:03his speech in Europe. Like what's what's tell us
- 13:06what's going on in Paris? What's your read on that
- 13:08situation? Paris was interesting, the AI
- 13:11Action Summit. This isn't the first version of
- 13:13the summit that they've had, but it definitely was the 1st that
- 13:16strayed from the initial mission of AI safety in the past.
- 13:20If this had been an AI safety focused event before, it is just
- 13:24all tech leaders. Sundar Dario, Sam Altman
- 13:29mingling with Narendra Modi, Emmanuel Macron, JD Vance was
- 13:33there, gave an opening speech on Monday.
- 13:36That was the America first of AI speech, if you will.
- 13:39He had this one quote. The Trump administration will
- 13:41ensure that the most powerful AI systems are built in the US with
- 13:44American design and manufactured chips, which is quite the
- 13:47statement to make at a World Summit on AI.
- 13:50There's a funny dynamic in that America sort of wants where
- 13:54Europe to get it shit together. It's like, oh, if you're such a
- 13:57great ally to us, like deliver pay, pay for some of the defense
- 14:01stuff, like build good companies, don't just extract
- 14:04from our our companies. Like, you know, I don't, I'm no
- 14:08Trumper, but I'm sympathetic to that message that you're it does
- 14:13feel like we go on vacation in Europe.
- 14:15It's like, oh, it's chill over here, but like, I'm like,
- 14:18where's everybody? I'm always like, where are
- 14:20people working? You know, like, whereas you go
- 14:22to New York and, you know, people are working and you can
- 14:25see the results with the companies.
- 14:27So. So what was Europe's response to
- 14:30all this goading from JD Vance? After all the taunting, European
- 14:34leaders did make some sizable announcements this week that
- 14:37showed that they want to get in the game and are taking this
- 14:40seriously, even if it's, you know, on the later side, Macron
- 14:43and France are announcing billions of dollars in nuclear
- 14:47power that will be allotted to building data Centers for AI.
- 14:51And French banner AI Lab Mr. All is announced a partnership with
- 14:55the defense company Helsing to build defense focused models,
- 14:59which is very American dynamism of them I must say.
- 15:03It sounds like safety's dead. That's basically what everyone
- 15:05told me. I mean, what Adario and
- 15:07Anthropic who put out, I mean, I like Dario's writing, but I
- 15:11thought it was sort of a weird note in this classic.
- 15:13Like, I'm trying to be positive, but I'm sort of negative here.
- 15:16I mean, he seemed a little worried that, you know, people
- 15:18weren't talking enough about safety.
- 15:20It certainly seemed like he was holding back, maybe a stronger
- 15:23opinion than what was published, but his essay was really
- 15:26critiquing, in some ways a soft, backhanded critique of the lack
- 15:30of safety in the geopolitical discussions around AI.
- 15:33Now it seems like everyone is looking for their national
- 15:36advantage. And in a polarized world, that
- 15:39certainly makes sense. Kind of going almost Cold War
- 15:42industrialization of this technology where if we don't do
- 15:46it, deep seek and China will. And there was also quite a bit
- 15:50of hush over the conference around Deep Seek's ability and
- 15:54Western leaders, you know, saying, oh, we need to really
- 15:57focus on this as a threat and. Of course, the unique fear with
- 16:00AI, unlike nuclear weapons, is that maybe someday they will
- 16:03figure out how to fire themselves.
- 16:05You know, that is that's why it's like, oh, we need to be
- 16:08very mindful because one day you could accidentally come up with
- 16:11the AI that is too smart for its own good.
- 16:14But yeah, I don't we are not going to necessarily be keeping
- 16:18them in a box. I floated on this podcast in the
- 16:20past that it is very possible that we look back at the Trump
- 16:23years and say, man, we were so worried about democratic norms
- 16:27and immigration, things I'm very concerned about.
- 16:30But we actually say, oh, man, it was tech.
- 16:33It was, you know, AI policy that mattered the most because we
- 16:35were at a true inflection point and AI, and honestly, this is a
- 16:40data point that at least the Trump administration is somewhat
- 16:42aware of that If the vice president's first speeches on AI
- 16:46seems like, you know, JD Vance is someone of Silicon Valley,
- 16:50even if he's like, you know, throw caution of the wind.
- 16:53They're clearly very mindful that they're living in an AI era
- 16:56that could be swamp some of the other historical trends that
- 17:00they're involved in. Moving on to the deal of the
- 17:02week, Legal Tech Harvey, the darling of all legal tech, has
- 17:06raised 300 million at a 3 billion valuation led by Sequoia
- 17:10and is including COTU, Kleiner Perkins, Opening Eyes, Startup
- 17:14Fund, TV conviction, Ilad Gill, Rev LexisNexis had to get in
- 17:19there too because legal industry.
- 17:21But yeah, they're an AI legal assistant effectively.
- 17:24So they build tools to help with drafting briefings, really a lot
- 17:29of content generation and summarizing themes and leads.
- 17:33So tools that things AI is very good at, you know, parsing
- 17:37through text based data for certain points and pulling those
- 17:41out and summarizing them and then subsequently drafting them
- 17:44for lawyers, which is the next step.
- 17:46So they offer a suite of tools along those lines of what you
- 17:50know a legal assistant or a junior paralegal would do for a
- 17:55lawyer. Hopefully the days of minding
- 17:57every comma in your legal briefing will soon be over and
- 18:01AI will solve some of the monotony of lawyers.
- 18:05Lawyers are corporate lawyers are back.
- 18:06You know, they're, they're making a lot of money these
- 18:08days. So, and now they've got software
- 18:10to automate the whole thing. It's like good, good time to be
- 18:12a lawyer. There's no shortage of copyright
- 18:14cases these days, I'll say that too.
- 18:16And our AI focused episode, the honorable invention.
- 18:20Other deal that we have to shout out is that Sequoia once again
- 18:23is in talks to lead an investment in Mercury, the
- 18:27digital banking company, at a valuation of more than 3
- 18:29billion, which is a big step up. All newcomers, not all, but much
- 18:34of newcomers bank is on mercury. So as a customer, it's always
- 18:37nice, OK, Sequoia is culpable for this one.
- 18:40And they're, they're getting more money.
- 18:42You know, it's, and part of what you want is a banking startup is
- 18:46to give people confidence that you're, you're going to be
- 18:49around. And this is certainly one of
- 18:51those confidence inspiring moments.
- 18:53That's our show. See you next week and subscribe
- 18:56to the newsletter to read the Lightspeed posts if you haven't
- 18:58yet. Get Eric's insights into mega
- 19:01fund returns. Only a newcomer.
- 19:05All right, see ya.