Latest / Bitcoin And | Bitcoin & Economic News / Build The Invisible Future
Transcript
- 0:00Good morning. This is David Bennett, and this is Bitcoin and, a podcast where I try to find the edge effect between the worlds of Bitcoin, gaming, permaculture,
- 0:08podcasting, and education to gain a better understanding of all. Edge effect is a concept from ecology describing a greater diversity of life where the edges of 2 systems overlap. While species from either system can be found at the edge, it is important to note there are species in the overlap that exist in neither system, and that is what I seek to uncover. So join me in discovering the variety of things being created as Bitcoin rubs up against other systems.
- 0:44It is 10:17
- 0:45AM Pacific Daylight Time. It's the 6th day of September
- 0:502024,
- 0:51and this is episode
- 0:53I just had it. I think it's 648.
- 0:56Is it? Yeah. No.
- 0:58648, my ass.
- 1:00948. We're damn near
- 1:02to 50 away
- 1:04from the 1000th show of the Bitcoin and podcast.
- 1:09Wow, man. That's a that's a hell of a run, right? So
- 1:13what do we got?
- 1:16Dharav has made a statement. Dharav is the Telegram's founder, and we've got a little bit more than that going on with the,
- 1:23with Dharav. We got a couple of things to talk about with Jirov.
- 1:28I'm gonna talk a little bit about
- 1:31one of Ripple co founder because you need to know what side of the fence
- 1:35the people that
- 1:38do the whole Ripple thing. You need to know what side of this what side of the fence that they are truly
- 1:43truly sitting on. You don't want to have anything to do with these guys and you don't want to have anything to do with Ripple either.
- 1:49Jobs
- 1:51numbers
- 1:52came in. You might have noticed that there's a bit of a red dildo going on. Well, we'll we'll talk a little bit about that.
- 2:01There's also a couple of things that I wanna talk about. Actually, there's at least one thing that I wanna talk about with the, feds,
- 2:08Waller. He had a Q and A and he made it a statement
- 2:11that I think is rather chilling
- 2:13when you read it more than once. And then we'll do a little bit of market stuff and then we're gonna talk a bit about the tornado
- 2:20cash
- 2:21court case that's going on because they're
- 2:24railroading these poor dudes from tornado cash.
- 2:27And then I want to get into a little bit
- 2:30of Reply Guy. But first,
- 2:33Durov
- 2:34has announced
- 2:35that he is disabling
- 2:37personal
- 2:38geolocation
- 2:39from Telegram
- 2:41and I guess he can do that because he's, I guess, out on bail.
- 2:45Vince Quill, Cointelegraph,
- 2:47let's crank this son of a bitch up.
- 2:49Telegram founder Pavel Durov revealed that Telegram is cutting certain features
- 2:54from the platform,
- 2:56including
- 2:57media uploads to the platform's
- 2:59telegraph
- 3:00blog
- 3:01and disabling the people nearby feature in a September 6th announcement.
- 3:07Durov told his followers that media uploads to the blogging platform were misused
- 3:12by malicious actors,
- 3:14explaining
- 3:15that the vast majority of the Telegram community was not abusing these features. However,
- 3:21Durov made it clear
- 3:23that the 0.001%
- 3:27involved in illicit activities
- 3:29pose a disproportionate
- 3:30risk to the vast majority of law abiding users on Telegram.
- 3:35The Telegram co founder also announced that the individual geolocation
- 3:40tracking
- 3:41would be ditched
- 3:42for a businesses
- 3:44nearby
- 3:45option. Durov likewise claimed that this personal geolocation
- 3:49feature was only used by a tiny minority of Telegram users. Okay, so I guess that means that you had to turn it on and that it was off by default.
- 3:58Let's hope that that is indeed the case.
- 4:01This
- 4:02year, we're committed
- 4:04to turning moderation on Telegram from an area of criticism
- 4:08into one of praise,
- 4:10Durov concluded.
- 4:13Pausing for effect.
- 4:16Let's read that again.
- 4:18This year,
- 4:20we are committed
- 4:21to turning moderation on Telegram from an area of criticism
- 4:26into one of praise.
- 4:29I'm gonna tell you right now they got to him.
- 4:32They got to him.
- 4:35We all know how they got to him.
- 4:37But if there's any question in your mind that he is know that he is uncompromised,
- 4:43that should be swept under the rug
- 4:45right now.
- 4:46And I'm not saying anything bad about him. He's a human being. He has a life to live.
- 4:52He has 1,000,000,000 of dollars.
- 4:54He has a lot to lose.
- 4:57But make no mistake,
- 5:00they have successfully compromised
- 5:02Durov.
- 5:04French prosecutors have alleged that the Telegram founder and the platform were complicit in the spread of, of course, child pornography
- 5:12by not enforcing stricter content moderation policies.
- 5:15On August 28, 2024, French authorities charged Durov with money laundering, criminal association,
- 5:22and providing cryptology
- 5:24services without a license.
- 5:26French authorities issued arrest warrants for Pavel
- 5:29Durov
- 5:30and his brother, Nikolai,
- 5:32in March of 2024.
- 5:35French law enforcement officials claimed that the Telegram founders
- 5:39refused to cooperate with an earlier investigation by failing to identify
- 5:43a specific Telegram user who was allegedly spreading child abuse materials.
- 5:49According to French officials, the probe started after cybercrime investigators from the Paris prosecutor's office uncovered an illicit Telegram chat room
- 5:57attempting to lure underage girls into the room and exploit them.
- 6:02On September 5th,
- 6:04Durov broke his silence for the first time since his arrest and took to his Telegram channel to clarify the events since his arrest. And since that time,
- 6:14Telegram has signaled a shift in content moderation policies
- 6:17by changing the language surrounding the moderation
- 6:20of private chats in the Telegram frequently asked questions section and trimming certain features.
- 6:27Okay, so first
- 6:29I'm not an advocate
- 6:31of illicit materials being exchanged on any platform.
- 6:35But I'm also not an advocate
- 6:39of threatening somebody with their life,
- 6:42their security,
- 6:44their future,
- 6:45their possessions,
- 6:46and everything about them
- 6:48to immediately affect a change that you want to see that I guarantee has nothing to do with child pornography.
- 6:56They don't give a
- 6:57shit. It's like everything else. Hey, do we want to wrap it in terrorism or do we want to wrap this little gift box with child pornography and child exploitation?
- 7:07It's a meme if you haven't seen it, right? The
- 7:11picture like it's a cartoon of uncle Sam with a box and he's coming up to, like, a gift wrapping place and the other dude's like, do you want this wrapped in child pornography or do you want it wrapped in, you know, terrorism?
- 7:23Because that's the only two choices the United States government
- 7:27and the rest of the Western governments have. That that's it. It's a is a mind manipulation
- 7:34to get you to think that
- 7:36everybody is a criminal,
- 7:38except, of course, for the United States and Western governments, of which they are all criminals. They should all be put on trial. They should all be drugged out in the street and at least hard and feathered and run out on a rail. I've said it before. I'll say it again.
- 7:51But Dharov is fully compromised.
- 7:54And it was very quickly done, which makes me wonder what those discussions were.
- 8:00And I doubt very seriously that we're gonna find out anything more
- 8:04when I read
- 8:06you
- 8:08Durov's
- 8:09statement. And this is from his direct telegram.
- 8:13It says, Thanks, everyone, for your support and love.
- 8:16Last month I got interviewed by police for 4 days after arriving in Paris.
- 8:21I was told I may be personally responsible for other people's illegal use of Telegram because the French authorities
- 8:28didn't receive responses from Telegram.
- 8:31This was surprising for several reasons.
- 8:331.
- 8:34Telegram has an official representative
- 8:36in the European Union that accepts and replies to EU requests.
- 8:41Its email address has been publicly available for anyone in the EU who Googles Telegram EU address for law enforcement.
- 8:51I gotta stop there.
- 8:53Because even though that that the way he said it is like, well, all you had to do was Google Telegram EU address for law enforcement there, mister officer.
- 9:03No.
- 9:04That's sort of not the way you do it. What you do is you build you build and write a memorandum
- 9:10on Telegram stationery,
- 9:12and you give the exact
- 9:15email address
- 9:16and the reason for that email address's existence and you send it to every authority
- 9:22under the sun.
- 9:23Alright? And I'm not saying that because I love the authorities. I just said that I don't.
- 9:29But this, honestly, this is a little bit of 6th grader logic.
- 9:34Oh, well, all you had to do was email Telegram EU address for law enforcement.
- 9:41Oh,
- 9:42that I that's not gonna wash. Okay? So number 2, the French authorities had numerous ways to reach me to request assistance. As a French citizen, I was a frequent guest at the French consulate in Dubai.
- 9:54A while ago,
- 9:55when asked, I personally helped them establish a hotline with Telegram to deal with the threat of terrorism in France.
- 10:033. If a country is unhappy with an internet service,
- 10:07the established practice is to start a legal action against the service itself.
- 10:11Using laws from the pre smartphone era to charge a CEO with crimes committed by third parties on the platform he manages,
- 10:19is a rather misguided approach.
- 10:22Building technology is hard enough as it is.
- 10:24No innovator will ever build new tools if they know they can be personally held responsible
- 10:30for potential abuse of those tools. And in there is the seed of the future.
- 10:37No innovator
- 10:38will ever build new tools if they know they can be personally held responsible for potential abuse of those tools.
- 10:46This is why
- 10:48everybody in Bitcoin, everybody in Lightning,
- 10:51everybody in eCash, everybody in Nostr, everybody in Fedimint,
- 10:55all of this
- 10:58was we
- 10:59jumped
- 11:00the gun of creating companies.
- 11:03Maybe that's what Satoshi was talking about so long ago
- 11:06when Julian Assange
- 11:08and WikiLeaks started accepting donations in bitcoin.
- 11:12You know, I think that the seed of what what was just said by Durov is there.
- 11:18That
- 11:19no longer are we allowed to build tools
- 11:22and have companies
- 11:23if we're going to be thrown in prison and have all our shit taken from us. Which is why it's so incredibly important
- 11:31that free and open source software
- 11:33and freedom technology
- 11:36be done in a way that is not done the way it is now. I mean,
- 11:41how to make money from a thing without having a company.
- 11:46How to get support financial
- 11:49honest to God pay the bills pay the rent pay the stuff buy the food get the gas.
- 11:56How can we do that
- 11:57without having a company?
- 12:00I think this is a major question that needs to be examined and answered
- 12:07for us to thrive in the rest of this century.
- 12:10Because it is very clear to me
- 12:13that the governments, especially of the Western
- 12:16world, view everybody else in the world as well as their own citizens
- 12:22as criminal
- 12:24and as somebody that they would rather not see walking around.
- 12:29It's
- 12:29sad. I shouldn't be that much of a cynic, but I cannot help it.
- 12:34They are giving me nothing else to look at.
- 12:37Let's continue. Establishing
- 12:40the right balance between privacy and security is not easy.
- 12:43You have to reconcile privacy laws with law enforcement
- 12:48requirements and local laws with EU laws. You have to take into account technological limitations.
- 12:53As a platform,
- 12:54you want to process
- 12:56or you want your process to be consistent globally
- 12:59while also ensuring
- 13:01that they are not abused in countries with weak rule of law. We've been committed to engaging with regulators to find the right balance. Yes,
- 13:09we stand by our principles.
- 13:11Our experience is shaped by our mission to protect
- 13:16our users
- 13:17in authoritarian
- 13:18regimes, but we've always been open to dialogue and sometimes we can't agree
- 13:23with a country's regulator on the right balance between privacy and security. And in those cases,
- 13:29we are ready to leave that country. We've done it many times.
- 13:33When Russia demanded we hand over encryption keys to enable surveillance, we refused, and Telegram got banned in Russia. When Iran demanded we block channels
- 13:43of peaceful protesters, we refused and Telegram got banned in Iran.
- 13:48We are prepared to leave markets that aren't compatible with our principles,
- 13:52because we're not doing this for money. We're driven by the intention to bring good and defend the basic rights of people,
- 13:59particularly in places where these rights are violated.
- 14:03All of that does not mean Telegram is perfect. Even the fact that authorities could be confused by where to send requests is something that we should improve.
- 14:13But the claims in some media that Telegram is some sort
- 14:16of anarchic paradise are absolutely untrue.
- 14:20We take down millions of harmful posts and channels every day. We publish daily transparency reports.
- 14:27We have direct hotlines with NGOs to process urgent moderation requests faster.
- 14:32However, we hear voices saying that it's not enough.
- 14:36Telegram's abrupt increase in user count to
- 14:40950,000,000
- 14:41caused growing pains that made it easier for criminals to abuse our platform.
- 14:45That's why I made it my personal goal to ensure we significantly improve things in this regard.
- 14:52We've already stated that process internally, and I will share more details
- 14:57on our progress with you very soon. Yeah, and he did. I hope that the events of August will result in making Telegram
- 15:06and the social networking industry as a whole safer and stronger.
- 15:10Thanks again for your love and memes.
- 15:14Man, I mean, there's a lot honestly, this is kind of creeping me out. His tone
- 15:20is playful,
- 15:22yet there's 6th grade logic
- 15:25in this whole thing about all they had to do was email or Google how to get a hold of Telegram by EU authorities or whatever it was. Right? And this this sign off,
- 15:36thanks again for your love and memes,
- 15:39The fuck is this? We're we're we're literally talking about the lives of people being absolutely hammered and destroyed
- 15:46because they went to Telegram
- 15:48to figure out how they could communicate with each other in authoritarian regimes.
- 15:53He talks about how he's, like, perfectly happy to say, fuck you, and pull out of Russia and pull out of Iran and just, you know, let the authoritarian regimes do what they may. Because we're not in it for the money, but yet we're
- 16:06what?
- 16:08Look,
- 16:10I don't want
- 16:11Durov to go to prison.
- 16:13I don't want him to lose any of his money. I really don't.
- 16:17But no one's taking a stand
- 16:20because no one can.
- 16:23Because we've been lured by money and riches and wealth. It's like for the for the United States, that shit started in earnest in the very early 19 eighties with Robin Leach's
- 16:34lifestyles of the rich and famous, where they showed you how much of a schmo you were
- 16:39every single week.
- 16:40How you didn't have the mansion, how you didn't have the jet, how you didn't have all of the stuff that these beautiful people have.
- 16:48And it's not done us any good.
- 16:51Durov, I think, is just a victim of the same shit.
- 16:54He's got he's a billionaire. He doesn't want to lose it, and he will do whatever it takes to keep it. That's
- 17:01the carrot
- 17:03and the stick
- 17:04all in one. It's not the carrot then the stick, it's the carrot and the stick all at one. The carrot is the fucking stick. This is a carrot that if you get walked upside the head with, you're going to
- 17:17writhe on the ground like a baby and then go feed them.
- 17:21It's the wealth that we were promised, the wealth that we were shown that we could get, but we don't have and until you do you're a schmo
- 17:30that keeps us under the thumb. That's the real prison. And I'm not saying sell everything and wear sackcloth
- 17:37and go out and hunt squirrels in the forest for the rest of your life. I'm not saying that. I'm saying that it is imperative
- 17:44for all of us to start really
- 17:47endeavoring on how to build a system
- 17:51that somehow or another
- 17:53creates wealth
- 17:55for the people that build it,
- 17:57but somehow
- 17:59is completely untraceable
- 18:01that nobody knows who built it.
- 18:04This goes back to this thing that was said a long time ago by very wealthy people.
- 18:09I don't own anything,
- 18:12but I control
- 18:14everything.
- 18:16You don't really want to own anything because they can take it away from you.
- 18:21Why would you want to when you can simply control a thing?
- 18:25Now, there's a lot of
- 18:28I just unloaded a lot of baggage on you and I understand that. And do I have all the answers? Hell, no.
- 18:34I don't.
- 18:36But
- 18:37what I've seen
- 18:38after being in Bitcoin for long enough
- 18:41I started really looking at free and open source software as something that I'd never looked at before,
- 18:47something vitally important.
- 18:49But you know what really happened to make me really move into that direction?
- 18:54A direction that many other people in this space had already seen, but I was it hadn't clicked just yet. I saw it as important.
- 19:01I saw it as critical.
- 19:02But the light bulb didn't go off until
- 19:06Noster.
- 19:08And that's when I realized
- 19:10that's when I realized
- 19:13that we can build our way out of this with these Freedom Tech tools,
- 19:18but it's not enough.
- 19:21We have to figure out a way to build
- 19:24what would be considered
- 19:26in modern times as in today
- 19:29brand new legal structures
- 19:32except that it's not
- 19:34not a legal structure. It's a logic structure. I think that that's what it should be. We should be building businesses
- 19:41and companies
- 19:43and have value exchange that is a has a logical
- 19:47structure,
- 19:49but it's not technically
- 19:51something to do with the legal
- 19:53lay of the land because it is clear that that is being used as a weapon against us.
- 19:58If they don't like what we're doing they'll just build a new law and all of a sudden what we've been doing for 10 years is now illegal. Do you see what I'm saying?
- 20:05How do we build something that looks like a company that we can have a product that is sold that does not look like a company and has no product to sell?
- 20:16I know I'm probably confusing
- 20:19you. But I don't see any other way out except to build our way out Bitcoin
- 20:25e cash Lightning Network Fedimint's
- 20:27Gnoster
- 20:30I'm missing something. This is a this is a good start.
- 20:33Free and open source software,
- 20:35the extension of what that that I just mentioned, the Bitcoin and all that, free and open source software needs to extend amongst
- 20:43well beyond that. And it has been for decades and I wasn't seeing what it was doing.
- 20:48Now I can see it plainly.
- 20:52Watching Durov basically roll over
- 20:56after 6 days
- 20:58or 7 or however whatever it was that he was arrested in Paris. He rolled over within 2 weeks,
- 21:04and Telegram is no longer going to be what Telegram was.
- 21:10That's all it took.
- 21:12And there's more.
- 21:14Because Ripple's co founder
- 21:17is among Kamala Harris's new corporate endorsers.
- 21:22CoinDesk,
- 21:23Jesse Hamilton,
- 21:25Chamomile Shamba is writing this one, and I'm not gonna read all of it. Ripple cofounder and executive chairman, Chris Larsen,
- 21:32is among the 88 corporate leaders who endorsed vice president Kamala Harris to be the next United States president in a letter on Friday, revealing potential differences among company leaders.
- 21:44While while
- 21:45Larson joined, other high profile CEOs
- 21:48come from the likes of review site Yelp,
- 21:52cloud storage company Box,
- 21:54social media platform Snapchat's
- 21:57snap, and more. According to the letter
- 22:00CNBC was first to report on, Ripple and CEO Brad Garlinghouse
- 22:06has targeted prominent Democrats in their campaign contributions.
- 22:10The majority of the company's contributions have gone to pro crypto super political
- 22:15action committees or PACs,
- 22:17like the Fair Shake political action committee,
- 22:21which is focused on getting crypto friendly candidates
- 22:24elected from both major parties.
- 22:26Ripple Labs
- 22:28has been among the chief backers of Fairshake and its affiliates,
- 22:31giving about $48,000,000
- 22:33to influence
- 22:34the 2024
- 22:35elections.
- 22:37While the industry's combined efforts has tried to walk a tight rope between the 2 major political parties, Ripple's giving has leaned into the Republican side in one key situation,
- 22:48trying to defeat crypto critic senator Elizabeth Warren
- 22:52Garlinghouse, the company's CEO,
- 22:54has also reportedly given 50,000 to a super PAC aimed at building a Republican majority in the senate according to disclosures to the Federal Elections Commission.
- 23:04So his political sympathies may be at odds with the letter Larson signed which favors a Democratic administration under Harris.
- 23:13The letter argued that Harris
- 23:15would continue to advance fair and predictable policies that support the rule of law, stability, and the sound business environment.
- 23:23Ripple has been in a protracted fight with the United States Securities and Exchange Commission
- 23:28over accusations
- 23:29that the company violated securities law in its,
- 23:33in its sale of the token XRP.
- 23:35We don't need to know anymore here.
- 23:39Chris Larsen
- 23:40and Brad Garlinghouse
- 23:45are not diametrically opposed
- 23:47at all.
- 23:49They're not.
- 23:51They're playing both sides of the fence
- 23:53because they've they know how to do this.
- 23:57That's why they're not in jail.
- 23:59They know how to do this. They know how to buy them off.
- 24:06This is the kind of chicanery
- 24:10that is going has plagued,
- 24:12is plaguing,
- 24:13and will continue to plague
- 24:16this industry. And it's not just this industry. It plagues it plagues our freedom.
- 24:22It causes people like Durov to be plucked off of his private plane in Paris and then rolled over in a week
- 24:29to where his platform is not going to look anything like it used to look like.
- 24:35Anybody who was depending on Telegram, you can kiss that shit goodbye.
- 24:40Now these assholes
- 24:42are putting themselves
- 24:44squarely
- 24:46up the butts of these politicians.
- 24:48And if you don't think it's not going to have an effect,
- 24:51then you're wrong.
- 24:54So this shit now gets worse and it becomes even more imperative
- 24:58that we build our way
- 25:01out of these people's view to become invisible,
- 25:06but visible only to ourselves.
- 25:09And now, Ayn Rand comes back to mind.
- 25:13Galt's Gulch
- 25:15The whole shield around Galt's Gulch that made it invisible.
- 25:19I don't see any other way out. She saw it in the fifties or forties or whatever the hell. Was it the thirties? It may have been the thirties when she wrote that shit. But it's somewhere around there,
- 25:30when she's writing
- 25:32Atlas Shrugged,
- 25:33she knew.
- 25:35It was just going to be this shit storm forever and ever and ever. We have
- 25:41so many talented people in this space
- 25:44and it's attracting more every day.
- 25:48And they are it's chewing riches and fame and
- 25:51glory and whatever, you know, they're they're they don't seem to care
- 25:56because they know if they
- 25:58if if they do care about the the legacy world, that their children are gonna have to live in one that's even worse than today.
- 26:06And
- 26:07while you think it can't get any worse, believe me, it can.
- 26:13Because you know how many jobs we added?
- 26:16Because the jobs report dropped.
- 26:18We added a 142,000
- 26:21jobs in August.
- 26:23And that likely sets the stage for a 25
- 26:26basis point rate cut by the Federal Reserve, CoinDesk.
- 26:31Steven Alpher is writing US job growth was slightly less than expectations
- 26:36in August, but probably not weak enough to prompt the Federal Reserve to begin its rate cutting cycle later this month with a 50 basis point move as people want.
- 26:46According to Friday's
- 26:48morning's nonfarm payroll report from the government, which we can't trust, by the way, the US added a 142,000
- 26:55jobs in August versus The Economist forecast for a 160,000.
- 26:59And July's
- 27:0189,000
- 27:02jobs, which was revised from a previously reported
- 27:06114,000.
- 27:08Now, the unemployment rate edged down to 4.2 percent
- 27:11in line with expectations
- 27:13and from a 4.3%
- 27:15print in July.
- 27:17Down sizably in the days leading up to the report, the price of Bitcoin rose about a well, 1% to 56,500.
- 27:24In the minutes following the report,
- 27:27the price remains lower by 5% from week ago levels. And now we've seen an even sharper dip. We'll get to that.
- 27:35A check of traditional market shows US stock index futures trimming
- 27:41early large losses with the Nasdaq now lower by just 0.5%.
- 27:45And now all these numbers
- 27:47that I'm about to read, which I'm not going to read anymore, they're all out of date by about a couple of hours. So here's the main question. Will the Fed cut 25 or 50 basis points?
- 27:58Always a key data point. The jobs numbers for August had taken on extra importance
- 28:04given that the Federal Reserve is set to begin cutting rates at its mid September meeting. That's this month.
- 28:10The conventional thinking believed
- 28:12the US central bank would enter this monetary easing cycle cautiously by lowering its benchmark Fed funds by a mere 25 basis points.
- 28:22The Fed, though, might be swayed by a weak August employment report to instead slash rates a full 50 basis points at that meeting.
- 28:30The headline numbers from this report
- 28:33doesn't appear to make the case for a 50 basis point move.
- 28:37I'm pausing to let you know that's why the markets are in the red today.
- 28:42Everybody wanted 50.
- 28:44Everybody wanted 50, but the jobs report wasn't weak enough.
- 28:49We didn't have enough people in bread lines to make money. We didn't have enough people
- 28:55not going to be able to pay their fucking rent
- 28:59so that we could make some money.
- 29:01So everybody's fleeing to the dollar.
- 29:03This is why.
- 29:05The downward revisions
- 29:07to not just July
- 29:09but also June
- 29:10are somewhat troublesome, though. Taken together,
- 29:14the 3 month average job growth is just
- 29:17116,000
- 29:19and that is sure to come up in the Fed's discussions.
- 29:21See, they're they're still hoping. They're they're they're they're hoping for it. It's hopium. It's hopium. They're smoking a big old bong of it. A check of the other report details show a somewhat stronger picture. However,
- 29:33average hourly earnings rose 0.4% in August.
- 29:37In July's
- 29:38well, sorry. I'm sorry. On a year over year basis, average hourly earnings were higher by 3.8 percent versus expectations of 3.7
- 29:46in July's 3.6.
- 29:47Quote,
- 29:48it's a solid, if unspectacular
- 29:51report, that largely confirms
- 29:53the cooling trend in place, wrote economist
- 29:56Joe Bresalis,
- 29:58minutes following the release.
- 30:00The details, he said, support a 25 basis point rate cut from the Fed.
- 30:05Alright. So that's why everything is freaking red. It's why it's all red
- 30:10But there's this little note that I caught early this morning when I woke up
- 30:16and I saw that we were going to dump
- 30:21The Federal Reserve's Waller,
- 30:24at a Q and A,
- 30:26said that the Fed probably waited too long to stop buying MBS
- 30:31as the housing market was on fire.
- 30:35What is MBS?
- 30:37Mortgage
- 30:38backed
- 30:40securities. You remember
- 30:422,008?
- 30:43Do you remember 2,008?
- 30:46Every institution
- 30:48was buying mortgage backed securities,
- 30:50like
- 30:51like fireman's pension funds, and teachers pension funds, and banks, and
- 30:56brokerage houses, and exchanges, and like massive
- 31:00massive institutions.
- 31:01And bank you know, the banks themselves were so exposed
- 31:06to mortgage backed securities
- 31:08that the second that shit started to unravel,
- 31:11so did the banks.
- 31:13Now it's the government
- 31:15of the United States.
- 31:18And even the Federal Reserve's own I think he's the New York chair of the or the the chair of the New York Fed.
- 31:25Even he's like, yeah, we probably waited just a bit too long to stop buying this garbage
- 31:31because the housing market was on fire. They
- 31:34bought into the bullshit just like everybody did in, you know, prior 2,008.
- 31:40And now we've got these dismal job numbers,
- 31:44right? All the markets are in the red.
- 31:46Bitcoin is completely correlated to all of it because everybody's running to
- 31:52dollars.
- 31:54Hence, why the dollar strengthened to something like
- 31:57103
- 31:58on the dollar strength chart.
- 32:01And somebody speculated earlier today
- 32:04that this might have to do still
- 32:08with the yen carry trade
- 32:11being
- 32:11torpedoed
- 32:12on August 5th.
- 32:14Right? And I remember we dumped all the way down to 49,000?
- 32:19Do you remember
- 32:20we actually went down to 49,000
- 32:22on August 5th on the price of Bitcoin, and then we came right the hell back up
- 32:28to what, like, 60 I can't remember what it was. 60 something. It doesn't really matter
- 32:33because we're not there right now.
- 32:35Because everybody is is getting out and they're getting into the dollar.
- 32:40Because everybody is terrified. It doesn't matter what market you're in.
- 32:44In fact, let's run the numbers.
- 32:57Oil, energy markets
- 32:59are all down.
- 33:01West Texas Intermediate is down over 2 points to 67
- 33:05dollars
- 33:0667¢ a barrel. Brent, North Sea is down exactly the same, about 2.14
- 33:12percent
- 33:13to oh, no. It just flipped over. 2.23
- 33:15percent to $71.07
- 33:18a barrel.
- 33:20Natural gas is the only thing making a gain, but not much. Just 2 thirds of a point
- 33:24to $2.6
- 33:26no. $2.26
- 33:28per 1,000 cubic feet. Gasoline is down 1 and a half, so enjoy your dollar 89
- 33:33a gallon gasoline
- 33:35even though you're not going to find that price, guaranteed.
- 33:38Gold and silver, all the metal rocks are dying.
- 33:42Well, not dying, but they definitely got they got raked over the coals. Gold is down 3 quarters of a point to 2523.
- 33:49Silver is down 3 points.
- 33:51Platinum is down almost a point. Copper is down 1.6.
- 33:55Palladium is down over 3 points.
- 33:58Ag, is it any better today?
- 34:00No. The only thing is that's a winner today is cocoa.
- 34:040.06 percent to the upside.
- 34:07The biggest loser?
- 34:08Let's see if I can find
- 34:10it. 3.4%
- 34:12down for coffee.
- 34:13Yay. Cheap coffee.
- 34:15Live cattle is down almost a point. Lean hogs are down just over a point. Feeder cattle are down 1.41%.
- 34:22Now the legacy equity market, surely, surely somebody's buying the blood. Nope. They're still bleeding them out because the Dow is down a full point. S and p is down 1.69%.
- 34:34Nasdaq is down 2a half.
- 34:36The S and P mini,
- 34:38down 1 a quarter.
- 34:39What's Bitcoin doing?
- 34:41$53,840
- 34:44per coin. We have now gone down to a $1,060,000,000,000
- 34:49market cap and we can only get 21.5
- 34:52ounces of shiny metal rocks with that one Bitcoin of which there are
- 34:5619,750,342.99
- 35:00of
- 35:01and yet these still remain low.
- 35:050.06
- 35:06BTC on average
- 35:08on a per block basis.
- 35:11How many blocks but a 131?
- 35:14Carrying
- 35:15262,678
- 35:18transactions waiting to clear
- 35:20at high priority rates of
- 35:224
- 35:23satoshis per vbyte.
- 35:25Low priorities are 4
- 35:27satoshis per vbyte.
- 35:30Doesn't make any sense, does it?
- 35:32I saw a spike earlier today went all the way up to 8 satoshis per vbyte.
- 35:38So
- 35:40what's
- 35:41what's selling? Did anybody see? I I mean, I've been scanning the news, like, for the last well, I've been bringing you news since I've been home from Colorado and I look at these markets every single day for you.
- 35:53You know what I haven't seen? I'm not just the markets but the news. I haven't seen very many or any at all in fact
- 36:00news articles
- 36:01about people putting their Bitcoin back on exchanges.
- 36:05Like, I haven't seen headlines like like bitcoin hodlers rush to put bitcoin back on exchanges.
- 36:11$100,000,000
- 36:12inflows per day to coinbase in bitcoin. I haven't seen anything like that.
- 36:18Yet,
- 36:19it's it doesn't seem to be, you know, retail, the the people like us that actually use the Bitcoin network, this seems to be all book
- 36:27value.
- 36:29It's like exchanges
- 36:30or or or trades on exchanges
- 36:33of Bitcoin that was already there, but I had seen nothing but Bitcoin coming off exchanges
- 36:38pre August 5th.
- 36:40And I haven't seen very many stories at all. Actually, like I said, none at all about great gobs of Bitcoin going rushing to exchanges. So what the hell is going on? I don't know. If you can tell me, if you know, if you've got the intelligence on that, please let me know what that intelligence is because I'm confused. But, you know, it's okay. It's not like we haven't been here before. We've been in here or I've been here since 2015.
- 37:04I've seen this many many times.
- 37:07It's just it's but now that institutions are involved,
- 37:11it's a little has a little bit of a different flavor.
- 37:14But maybe you can just get Uncle Jim'd.
- 37:17That was episode
- 37:18947
- 37:20of Bitcoin and Dovrovko with 2,290
- 37:24sat says apologies.
- 37:26I am not more timely with my boosts. Fountain probably counts the 1st day the most heavily. I'll work on that. That's okay, Dabravco. I appreciate it though. The federalis like to f with Texas.
- 37:37Department of Transportation
- 37:39even made a rule tied to money, go figure, that electronic road signs can't be funny after TxDOT kept becoming viral for their funny quips promoting safe traveling habits.
- 37:50How effing
- 37:51petty can you be?
- 37:55Pretty petty.
- 37:56I'm so I'm I'm actually disappointed with TxDOT, but it doesn't surprise me. Dark with 2121
- 38:02says, awesome episode. Thanks, man. God's death with 537 says, thank you, sir. No. Thank you. The bird the bird. I don't know if that's actually it. The bird the and then a whole bunch of underline hashes. 500 says,
- 38:15BlackRock is going to do what you said, but only after they buy up more BTC on the cheap.
- 38:22Gin, sue the government so they
- 38:25so then they win on both sides. Maybe it's meant then.
- 38:29Then sue the government so then they win on both sides. Good show, by the way. Oh, thanks dude. I hope this one is as good too. Anyway, where else? Oh, Hugh Janice with 200 says, shout out to my missus
- 38:41Eun.
- 38:42Love the show. Oh, thanks, man. I appreciate that. S w bratcher says nothing well, he actually says, Mastercard to allow spins from your own wallets in the EU. And I don't know if that was something that I wrote or not, but Dabravco comes back with another 100.
- 38:57The Mastercard is a good notch in the belt of adoption.
- 39:01With f and f, let me know how that goes. Not sure what that means, Dabravco.
- 39:07It's probably because my brain cells aren't working all that well. Also, does the new fountain take, more phone data?
- 39:13The possibility has kept me from updating.
- 39:16I don't know.
- 39:17I've had fountain on my phone for so long
- 39:20that I can't remember
- 39:22if I what it takes. I'm I'm not sure, man.
- 39:27Oscar Mayer is your guy. On Noster, just type, you know, at symbol Oscar and see if Oscar Mayer populates.
- 39:35He's the guy behind fountain, that might be a good question to ask him. Stacy with a 100 says great show.
- 39:40Xplbzx,
- 39:43says I appreciate
- 39:44the 947
- 39:45shows,
- 39:47wait, I I
- 39:49hold on. I appreciate that 947
- 39:51shows later.
- 39:53There are still 0 dads or 0 ads on this show. Alright. Well, yeah. I'm I'm trying to do that,
- 40:01probably because I don't want meetings. I don't know.
- 40:06That's the weather report.
- 40:18Welcome to part 2 of the news that you can use.
- 40:21Only 3.
- 40:22Count them. 3. 1, 2, 3 examples
- 40:26of, quote, illicit tornado cash use
- 40:29cited by the United States Treasury
- 40:31in the sanctions case.
- 40:33A 5th Circuit panel questioned the United States Treasury's classification
- 40:38of Tornado Cash as a corporation, calling its reasoning slippery
- 40:42during oral arguments on Tuesday.
- 40:45Tornado
- 40:46Cash users appealed
- 40:47a Texas federal court's decision upholding
- 40:50the treasury sanctions.
- 40:52The treasury sanctioned Tornado Cash after discovering,
- 40:56quote, North Korean hackers used it at least 3 times,
- 41:00you know, out of 1,000,000 of transactions
- 41:03to launder 100 of 1,000,000 of dollars worth of cryptocurrency.
- 41:09Users argue Tornado Cash is an open source privacy tool and not a sanctionable entity.
- 41:15That's right. Build yourself to invisibility,
- 41:17ladies and gentlemen.
- 41:18The Treasury Department argues it can sanction Tornado Cash
- 41:22for saying the crypto project acts like a corporation
- 41:26rather than ownerless code.
- 41:29Bradley Henslewood
- 41:30of the United States Department of Justice noted that users
- 41:34own torn, t o r n, a token similar to corporate stock. That's not a very good sentence.
- 41:42US circuit Judge Court Engelhardt
- 41:45noted that out of 1,000,000 of transactions,
- 41:48the agency found only 3 instances of money laundering using Tornado Cash asking why the existing designations for North Korea were insufficient
- 41:58to achieve the agency's purpose, reports Law 360, quote, you're a solution in search of an entity
- 42:05in a way, she added.
- 42:07United States Circuit Judge Edith Jones also expressed skepticism
- 42:12of the Treasury's categorization,
- 42:14noting that North Korea could still use the protocol
- 42:17regardless if the sanctions were in place or not.
- 42:20In fact, just earlier this week, there were reports that a hacker entity, which stole over $230,000,000
- 42:26in user assets
- 42:27from an Indian crypto exchange, Wazirix,
- 42:30started to move funds through Tornado Cash in attempt
- 42:34to obfuscate
- 42:35obfuscate
- 42:36the trail of funds. Quote,
- 42:38but the 3 transactions that we're talking about are instances where, oh my god, North Korea stole 100 of 1,000,000 of dollars of cryptocurrency.
- 42:47DOJ's
- 42:48Hensalwood
- 42:49said, adding that it's important
- 42:52because by sanctioning
- 42:53entities that aid North Korea, their ability to help the rogue state is lessened. Do you can you smell the bullshit?
- 43:01Can you smell it?
- 43:03US circuit judge Don Willett
- 43:06also asked if it mattered that the people who made tornado cash made a profit.
- 43:11Plaintiff's representative Cannon
- 43:13k Shamgan, I can't pronounce the name, said anyone making money from tornado cash was doing so through a service besides the protocol itself. I'm not sure if I agree with that. Property includes rights like possession and use and enjoyment.
- 43:27None of those rights are implicated here.
- 43:30This application
- 43:31exists on the internet. It's not even controlled in any meaningful way through the Tornado Cash website,
- 43:37he added.
- 43:38Separately from this appeal,
- 43:40the United States government is criminally prosecuting the cofounders
- 43:44of Tornado Cash, Roman Seminov
- 43:47and Roman Storm.
- 43:48Seminov is fighting the charges while Storm remains at large.
- 43:52Another cofounder of Tornado Cash, Alexei Pertsev, has already been sentenced
- 43:57into a 64
- 43:58months or in the for
- 44:01sentenced to 64 months in the Netherlands and is currently in the process of appealing that decision.
- 44:08In another related case,
- 44:10the United States government also went after the founders of Bitcoin privacy tool, samurai wallet. The next hearing in the samurai developers case is expected to take place on September 17th.
- 44:22All
- 44:23of the Department of Justice's
- 44:25arguments
- 44:27are bullshit.
- 44:29Re remember what I what I was telling you about was either yesterday or the day before, the FBI
- 44:34dropped their warning that North Korea, oh my God, it's always North Korea,
- 44:39is trying to abscond
- 44:41and hack funds out of the Bitcoin
- 44:44exchange traded funds like Fidelity and Ark and BlackRock.
- 44:49And now here's North Korea, it's North Korea.
- 44:52I'm surprised that they haven't just done nothing but Russians.
- 44:56I mean, that would I mean, that that that would seem to to wash
- 45:00with the theme that the United States has had for, I don't know, since
- 45:05the elections before actually, the 2016
- 45:08elections.
- 45:09Russia Russia Russia. It's a it's a Russian disinformation operation. It's Russia this and Russia that. And now we're just gonna use North Korea.
- 45:18Why? I I I don't know. I I wish I did, but I just this is nothing but bullshit.
- 45:24Every argument here is all bullshit.
- 45:27And if the Texas court if the 5th actually, it's not it's the court's in Texas, but it's the 5th Circuit Court of Appeals.
- 45:34They really need to eviscerate the DOJ on this one. And just I don't know if they can vacate this thing or not, but they basically need to tell the DOJ to go sit and spin. Go pound sand, brother.
- 45:47But it doesn't matter which way this rolls out.
- 45:50It doesn't like, if we were to breathe breathe a huge sigh of relief and think that we're all going to be safe because the 5th Circuit's Court of Appeal tells the DOJ to go pound sand,
- 46:01it won't
- 46:04matter. The only way
- 46:07to get out of this mess is to build our way out of it.
- 46:11I wish I could program. I really wish I do. I wish I could be one of the developers for Noster.
- 46:16I really wish I do. I'd apply for an open sats grant
- 46:20or or Human Rights Foundation grant. I would just do that.
- 46:26Because
- 46:27I cannot leave my children
- 46:30in this place.
- 46:31We have to build
- 46:33ourselves the invisibility
- 46:35cloak that we need. We need to build the companies that cannot be seen.
- 46:40We need to build the routes that are blinded.
- 46:45It's not just building Nostr and e cash and Bitcoin and Lightning Network. No. It's way more than that. It's entire logic structures that we have to build.
- 46:56What does a company? What does an invisible company look like?
- 47:02How do you sell products? How do you pay employees?
- 47:07You can't you can't do it through any of
- 47:10what we have already.
- 47:12There can be no payroll tax. And it's not because well, I'm tax is theft. Let's get that clear. But it's not because I want to evade the tax.
- 47:20And it's not because I don't want there to be a tax. This is different. There needs to be no trail
- 47:25at all.
- 47:26Everybody working for company x or, well, let's say company y because x is a destroyed letter because of e Elon Musk,
- 47:35like the retirement accounts. What is what do those look like in a in a blinded company,
- 47:40Which doesn't exist, by the way. I mean, the the structure I'm talking about doesn't exist.
- 47:46Nobody's ever had to think of it before.
- 47:49Now we better start thinking about how to do this shit.
- 47:52How how how do we take on completely new identities that do not have a social security number? And they're they're what does health care look like?
- 48:00What what the hell does insurance look like? How do you insure your house?
- 48:05How do you do any of this? And you know what? What we should probably do?
- 48:10We should probably look at how the drug lords of Colombia did their shit.
- 48:15But it won't matter because a lot of them got caught.
- 48:18And I'm not saying I wanna be a Colombian drug lord. I don't wanna destroy people's lives. I'm not in this
- 48:24to figure out a way
- 48:27to
- 48:28cheat people out of their money or destroy their lives. I am in this to destroy
- 48:33governments of the west at this point.
- 48:37That's a horrible thing to say. I know. You're anti American. What
- 48:42under what circumstances
- 48:43do you think the United States government is in this for you?
- 48:47What have they done in the last
- 48:4925 years
- 48:51that is good for you?
- 48:53Do you think they're working for you?
- 48:56Do you think they want to keep you safe?
- 48:58Have
- 48:59they? Have they demonstrated
- 49:01any competency
- 49:02whatsoever
- 49:03that they can do that? And even beyond the competency,
- 49:06have they demonstrated
- 49:08any
- 49:10any actual plan
- 49:12that doesn't do something other than take more of your money, more of your time,
- 49:17and more of your good feelings.
- 49:20You know how hard it is for people to be in a good mood nowadays?
- 49:25It's
- 49:26not because
- 49:27this is all an accident. This is because a very small group of people have basically decided
- 49:33about
- 49:34think about 25 years ago,
- 49:36we've had enough of you people.
- 49:39We don't care about you anymore. We'll
- 49:42we'll say that we do, but we don't.
- 49:44Because all of their actions
- 49:47lead me to believe that. It's more more than a gut feeling. So I come back to the question,
- 49:53What structures aside from free and open source software, which I believe is the underpinning of the new technology for where we're going.
- 50:01How do we build on top of that non technological
- 50:05logic structures that are basically like businesses
- 50:08but cannot be seen
- 50:11by any government in the world because all of them are corrupt.
- 50:14Every single one of them. I have no respect for a single government whether they're west, east, south, whatever.
- 50:21Don't give a shit. I automatically assume that they're all corrupt, they are all evil,
- 50:26and they either don't care about you or they actually hate you.
- 50:32This is where I've come to.
- 50:35And it's not because I'm in a bad mood because I got a red dildo. I've seen those before. Okay? I've seen them many, many times. That's not it.
- 50:42But this Dharav thing,
- 50:44he rolled over inside of 2 weeks,
- 50:47and Telegram is now destroyed.
- 50:49Well, actually, it will be. You just haven't seen it yet. You haven't seen it yet. But it will be.
- 50:56We're left with the very things
- 50:59that most of the people that so many people in Bitcoin
- 51:02that so many other people listen to
- 51:05refuse.
- 51:06Even Parker Lewis, one of my favorite people in the space,
- 51:10looks at seems to have an attitude of Noster that is just thumbing his nose at it or or turning his nose up at it, and I don't get it.
- 51:20I don't how easy is it to make people roll over? Is it their influence?
- 51:25Is it their 1,000,000,000 of dollars in their yacht?
- 51:28Is Michael Saylor possibly going to be absconded with in that same way that Durov just woke up and said, hey, by the way, we're gonna strip out all this shit and we're gonna we are gonna moderate the living crap out of you guys from now on because you can't be trusted.
- 51:45Is that what it is?
- 51:50Well,
- 51:52we can soften the mood as we go into this weekend
- 51:55because God only knows what happens this weekend. I almost have a gut feeling
- 52:00that this entire week
- 52:02because I told you I told you guys on Tuesday
- 52:04that it was gonna be a week of bad news
- 52:07to hold fast.
- 52:09You know? Don't freak out. If you got hey. If you gotta pay a bill,
- 52:12I don't mind that with, you know, with your Bitcoin. But for those people that are just gonna like, you know what? I'm done. I'm out. And you're gonna see it.
- 52:19You're gonna see that shit in droves. It always happens. Right? The the weak the people that said that they were strong hands get really weak,
- 52:28and they sell everything. Yeah. Don't do that. If you need to make rent, sell a little bit. Keep most of it. Right? If you gotta do that, that I mean, I there's no problem with that. I'm not gonna look down at you. And even if I did, you can just look up at me and say, fuck you. I don't care about you. But in either event,
- 52:45I told you that this was going to happen. Right?
- 52:48So
- 52:48this week, if I was somebody sitting on a boatload of Bitcoin
- 52:53and
- 52:54I really wanted to make more Bitcoin,
- 52:56I would continuously sell,
- 52:59especially after every single one of these reports, which as we've seen has happened, which is exactly what I told you was going to happen. And then over the weekend when the markets can't aren't open,
- 53:11the people that sold their positions in the BlackRock Bitcoin ETF can't do anything when they see a green candle over the weekend.
- 53:19Do I do I know that that's going to happen? No. It could go the other way. It could still go south. We could see
- 53:2652. We could see 50. People are calling for 49.
- 53:30Some asshole out there is calling for 40. I don't know what it's gonna do.
- 53:34Right?
- 53:35But if I was the guy
- 53:37that could actually do that kind of shit, had enough Bitcoin that if I throw it on an exchange and I start market selling
- 53:45and start buying, you know, buying it back at the bottom and then market sell some more and then buy it back at that local bottom and then rinse and repeat for the entire week to the point that by the time you get into Friday, everybody that was going to sell their institutional positions
- 53:59is basically out and then
- 54:01buy it all back.
- 54:03So wouldn't surprise me.
- 54:05I'm not gonna swear by it, but it would not surprise me. Okay, so let's get into the weekend
- 54:11with a little bit
- 54:12of fun.
- 54:14Reply guy
- 54:15on Nostr.
- 54:16Dude
- 54:17is pissing
- 54:19people
- 54:19off left and right.
- 54:21If you're not on Nostr,
- 54:23why?
- 54:25Bring your talent,
- 54:26bring your thoughts,
- 54:28bring your energy
- 54:30to Nostr.
- 54:31Not to Telegram, which is gonna be eviscerated,
- 54:34not to Twitter, which has already been eviscerated,
- 54:36not to any of the other legacy
- 54:38media stuff
- 54:39Bring it to Nostra because Nostra is more than media
- 54:44It really is
- 54:45If you haven't tried it, it doesn't cost you nothing
- 54:48And you will if you stay around long enough and you experiment long enough and you ask me questions, you can ask me questions, I'm none your business on on Nostr,
- 54:58right? Just just look me up, ask me a question.
- 55:01I'll answer or if I don't know, I'll send you somewhere there is. But there's but one of the things that I love about Nostr is that every once in a while you get these weird things that start occurring.
- 55:11Right? And meant like, people like maybe like Parker Lewis might say, see that's why Nostra will fail. Uh-uh. No. No.
- 55:19So reply guy.
- 55:21What is reply guy?
- 55:23Reply guy
- 55:25is a bot
- 55:27that is
- 55:28replying to almost
- 55:30every note that there is.
- 55:32And it says it says something like, good morning from
- 55:35reply guy. But what's interesting is that it actually gives
- 55:40the
- 55:41relay that it's coming from,
- 55:43right? So it's like WSS.
- 55:46And for those of you who don't know what nostril is, relays is the way that we're propagating
- 55:52and storing notes around the nostril network. Right? So I write a note I say, hi, good morning,
- 55:58and then it goes to like a relay that I'm or several relays that I'm subscribed to and they all start with wsscolonforward/forward/likenoster.snort.social.
- 56:09Right? It's like a server. It's just an open server. It's out there.
- 56:12It takes in notes if you're subscribed to it. If it's got, you know, read and write capabilities,
- 56:18it'll save your note and then it will like if so like it like if somebody else is subscribed to that same, same,
- 56:25relay,
- 56:25they'll be able to read that note. The relays start talking to each other and, it takes a while, but, you know, the the notes start getting propagated around.
- 56:34But these this bot
- 56:36has a particular server or a particular relay that it's writing from and or writing to and reading from.
- 56:43And it's causing some problems. Because all like like somebody said earlier this morning, the noster is almost unusable now.
- 56:50Okay. Yeah. Because I write a note and I get a reply guy and it's just this all it says is g m and then, like, exclamation point, couple of emojis,
- 57:00and the relay.
- 57:02Except this. Here's the here's the biggest problem.
- 57:05It's not just one reply guy.
- 57:08It's thousands of
- 57:09them or at least 100 at this point.
- 57:12And they all have the same emblem,
- 57:14right? Or the the same PFP, your profile picture.
- 57:19It's the same ones like reply guy and it's like blue and yellow. Right?
- 57:23But they all have different in pubs.
- 57:25And now I'm starting to see multiple different relays that these in pubs these reply guy in pubs are coming from.
- 57:32And they're replying, like, I will now I can write a note, and I'll get 15 different in pub reply guys all saying good morning emoji emoji emoji and then whatever relay that they're writing from.
- 57:45And this has caused consternation that started happening yesterday.
- 57:49So, like, that way, you know, when you write a note and 15 to 25 different reply guys, you know, reply to it, you think your note got, like, oh my god. Look at this. I got 25 replies, but only one of them is from a human.
- 58:02You can see how that might piss some people off. You can see why somebody like, I don't know, Parker Lewis might say, see, that's why Nostra is going to be unusable.
- 58:12Now before I tell you what I think is happening
- 58:16I want to take you back
- 58:17back the way Sherman set the way back machine for, like, 4 months ago.
- 58:23I was getting
- 58:25followed
- 58:26by a new like several new account it just started happening one day.
- 58:31And for about 2 months, I would write I would write something like a note and then, like, I'd go away and I'd come back to my notifications and I'd see that, you know, a whole bunch of people, like, you know, hearted my or,
- 58:45thumbed up my note. But what I was really noticing was the fact that I was getting, like, 55 followers
- 58:52a day.
- 58:53Sometimes I would get as many as a 100 followers a day.
- 58:57Most of the time, however, it was, like, between 5 and 10.
- 59:01But the PFP, remember I told you that the reply guy PFP is like this little
- 59:06robot looking thing is blue and yellow or whatever it is.
- 59:10This one was a whole bunch of concentric
- 59:13concentric
- 59:14circles
- 59:15of different colors, but, like, actually of 2 different colors. It was like red and yellow or orange and yellow or something like that. But they
- 59:23they had it to where, like, there was like 5 circles and they would all be broken
- 59:28like, like a little gap in the circle and they'd all be rotated in a different position.
- 59:33And each one of those was a different in pub,
- 59:37but it was relentless.
- 59:39I think I gained
- 59:41like 400 followers
- 59:42if not
- 59:44if not a couple actually, I probably gained more like 3,000 followers off this thing. They're all fake, right? They're all like it's a bot and it's just this it's not a bot these are all bots, but these bots are being constructed
- 59:56autonomously
- 59:57by some kind of compute automated computer program or something like that script, right? It's just like a script kitty.
- 1:00:03And
- 1:00:05it's annoying when you get all these followers and you think oh, well, I get like some like thing people are listening to what I say and then it's just garbage.
- 1:00:14Right? Well, that
- 1:00:15went on for about 2 full months and then it just stopped.
- 1:00:19And I've never seen him again
- 1:00:21ever.
- 1:00:22And now we have this reply guy. He's not following anybody,
- 1:00:26but he's liking all the posts
- 1:00:28and, like, well, they're like
- 1:00:32like they because there's hundreds of them now. They like all the posts
- 1:00:37and then they say good morning and then they reply reply to the post saying good morning emoji emoji emoji and then whatever it's relay is. So this has prompted several people,
- 1:00:46to,
- 1:00:47hold on.
- 1:00:48I'm looking at something here.
- 1:00:51So
- 1:00:54actually wait wait wait wait wait. Yeah, I'm not gonna do that one.
- 1:00:57So I'm about here.
- 1:00:59Here's my thought of what this is. Now keep in mind both these stories.
- 1:01:04A bunch of fake in pubs
- 1:01:07interacting with real human accounts,
- 1:01:10making life kind of miserable. Reply guy is actually more miserable
- 1:01:15than the follow guy the the the guy that happened about, like, you know, 4 months ago.
- 1:01:20So
- 1:01:21I wrote a note on Nostr earlier this morning that said hear me out.
- 1:01:25Reply guy is a developer
- 1:01:27antagonizing
- 1:01:28Nostr
- 1:01:29so they can see how to fix it.
- 1:01:31Hashtag
- 1:01:32adversarial
- 1:01:33thinking is back?
- 1:01:37That's what I thought that was my gut feeling
- 1:01:39with the follow
- 1:01:41bots.
- 1:01:43Now with the reply guy bots,
- 1:01:45I'm thinking the same thing.
- 1:01:47I'm thinking that there is a Nostra developer out there that is savaging
- 1:01:52the Nostra network and that developer is indeed
- 1:01:56savaging the network.
- 1:01:57This is a lot of,
- 1:01:59like, wasted data. It's all crap. It doesn't mean anything. It's all bullshit.
- 1:02:04And it's dust. It's noise.
- 1:02:07We don't need it.
- 1:02:09And yet I believe
- 1:02:11that the developer that is doing this is doing this because the developer loves Nostr
- 1:02:17and is trying to figure out ways to break Nostr
- 1:02:20so that other developers,
- 1:02:22including the developer himself or herself,
- 1:02:25can fix it
- 1:02:27against state actors
- 1:02:29or institutional actors or people like Elon Musk's how do we screw with these guys so that we can have Twitter and we can be the town square forever and ever and Nostra will just die.
- 1:02:38That's what I believe is happening. I think they're actually doing it out of love for the network.
- 1:02:44So please,
- 1:02:46instead of intake antagonizing
- 1:02:48the reply guy thing,
- 1:02:50think
- 1:02:52about what I was saying
- 1:02:53when we have to build ourselves out of these situations.
- 1:02:57It starts right here with reply guy.
- 1:03:00How do we guard against that shit happening?
- 1:03:04And keep the platform open.
- 1:03:06And make it to where if somebody like, oh, I'm not even gonna give a name. So some major developer, Nostr,
- 1:03:13is picked off a plane in, you know, London
- 1:03:17and said, hey, you're gonna you're gonna fix Nostr the way we want and have that developer say, I don't know what to do. I I can't help you on that.
- 1:03:25Because they can't.
- 1:03:27And meanwhile, we're down here in the trenches
- 1:03:31thinking about how how do we stop Reply Guy without stopping me posting a picture of my cat?
- 1:03:39These are the ways that we build our way out and everybody can do this.
- 1:03:45You can think about, you know, given what you know about how things work,
- 1:03:50what would you do?
- 1:03:51And maybe, just maybe, give that idea to a developer.
- 1:03:55So when stuff like reply guy happens
- 1:03:59don't fret
- 1:04:00don't freak out
- 1:04:02use it as a way to help build ourselves
- 1:04:06an invisibility
- 1:04:07cloak
- 1:04:08against those people that are truly brutal to us
- 1:04:12You do that
- 1:04:13over the weekend and I will see you on the other side.
- 1:04:17This has been Bitcoin and and I'm your host, David Bennett. I hope you enjoyed today's episode and hope to see you again real soon.
- 1:04:25Have a great day.