Latest / The Jeremy Ryan Slate Show / Rome Didn't Fall — Here's What Actually Happened
Transcript
- 0:00Rome didn't fall, it contracted. We have a picture of this.
- 0:04Barbarians at the gates fire a civilization at its absolute
- 0:09peak and then silence. This picture is structurally
- 0:13wrong. What destroyed Rome wasn't
- 0:15invasion, it was hollowing. Power didn't vanish, It
- 0:19fragmented, localized, and quietly changed hands.
- 0:23The institution stayed, the authority drained out of it by
- 0:27550. ADA merchant, sailing from
- 0:30Constantinople to Massilia still found ports.
- 0:33The ships were smaller, the ports were emptier.
- 0:36The customs official wore a Roman uniform, but the coins in
- 0:40his hand bore A barbarian King's face.
- 0:44Not fire, not screaming. Just smaller, slower, and more
- 0:48local, until the system you thought you were living inside
- 0:52had already been replaced. This isn't just Rome.
- 0:55This pattern is running again. If you're new here, I'm Jeremy
- 1:17Ryan Slate, and this channel is called the Roman Pattern.
- 1:20And what we do is honestly pretty simple.
- 1:23We take a civilization that spent 500 years coming apart,
- 1:27and we ask what actually killed it.
- 1:29Not the myth, not the version you got in the textbook if you
- 1:33did it all, but how the thing really worked and where it
- 1:36really broke. For about a year now, we've been
- 1:38going through that piece by piece.
- 1:41The way the currency got debased, the way the borders
- 1:43gave out, the emperors who basically auctioned off the
- 1:46state to whoever would pay the most.
- 1:49It's all sitting there in the back catalog.
- 1:51If you want to watch it, the last episode ended on a single
- 1:54date, 476, the day the last emperor in the West handed over
- 1:58his crown and just walked away from it.
- 2:00That's the day historians decided to call the end of the
- 2:04Roman Empire. If you haven't watched that one,
- 2:06the links in the description, because what I want to show you
- 2:09today really only lands if you understand how we got to that
- 2:13point. That episode was us working out
- 2:16what went wrong. This one is about what came
- 2:18after, what actually happened next.
- 2:21So here's the question I want to answer in this one.
- 2:23Not why Rome fell, because he already spent a lot of time on
- 2:27that. The question is what it felt
- 2:28like from the inside while it was happening.
- 2:31What did a merchant actually see when he sailed into a port in
- 2:35550 that he wouldn't have seen in 350?
- 2:38What would a peasant have picked up on?
- 2:40Or a soldier? And the part I find most
- 2:42interesting, what did none of them notice at all?
- 2:45Because the dangerous thing about a civilization changing
- 2:48shape isn't the dramatic collapse, it's how normal
- 2:52everything feels while it's going on.
- 2:55I want to go through this in order.
- 2:56So we'll start with the cities, then move into trade, then daily
- 3:00life. And what actually changed there
- 3:03versus what stayed the same after that.
- 3:05The one institution that quietly absorbed everything the empire
- 3:09left behind. And then at the end, I'll show
- 3:12you what this same pattern looks like when you find it running in
- 3:16a completely different century. So let's start with the cities.
- 3:19Because the first thing, everybody is zooms, mostly
- 3:22because that's what movies show you, is that cities burned.
- 3:26And some of them did, but most of them didn't.
- 3:29Rome itself came through it. By 5:50, it was a much smaller
- 3:32place. Around the year 300, the city
- 3:35was holding somewhere between half a million and a million
- 3:37people. And by 350, you're looking at
- 3:40something closer to 50,000. That's roughly a 90% drop in
- 3:44under 200 years, but the city was still there.
- 3:47It's worth pausing on why that number fell off a Cliff right in
- 3:51that window. Procopius, who actually rode
- 3:54along with the Eastern army during Justinians campaign to
- 3:57take back Italy, describes Rome getting besieged and changing
- 4:01hands over and over through the five 30s and five 40s.
- 4:05So the population didn't really trickle away over centuries.
- 4:08It got beaten out of the place in a couple of genuinely brutal
- 4:11decades. And even after that, the
- 4:13Coliseum was still standing, some of the aqueducts were still
- 4:17running, and the Bishop of Rome was still holding court inside
- 4:21the old government buildings. The physical empire was still
- 4:25there. The one thing missing was the
- 4:27empire itself. Constantinople, by contrast,
- 4:30didn't shrink at all. And 5:50, it was the most
- 4:33powerful city in the Western world.
- 4:36And the Eastern Roman Empire, the thing we call Byzantium, was
- 4:39completely intact, still collecting its taxes, still
- 4:42putting armies in the field, and still writing law.
- 4:45This part really matters. When we say Rome fell, what we
- 4:49actually mean is the western half of it.
- 4:52The eastern half just kept going for another 1000 years.
- 4:55And that one fact pretty much takes apart the idea that this
- 4:59was some total collapse of civilization.
- 5:02What you're really looking at is a political reorganization that
- 5:06was devastating in the West and barely registered in the East.
- 5:10You could see the same thing in other big cities.
- 5:13Alexandria came through, Antioch came through, Massilia which is
- 5:17modern Marseille came through. These were the anchor points of
- 5:21the Mediterranean economy, and as long as the Mediterranean
- 5:24itself was holding together, so were they.
- 5:27And look at what actually died. Take Trier and 300.
- 5:31Trier was the most important city in the Western Roman world.
- 5:35It was the seat of Western emperors for most of the 3rd and
- 5:384th centuries with a palace. A circus bath complex is bigger
- 5:42than anything in Rome. By 5:50 it had shrunk to a small
- 5:46town. The palace had become a church,
- 5:49the baths had been turned into a quarry, and the circus was
- 5:53somebody's farmland. Britain had it even worse.
- 5:56The Romans pulled out in 410, and it wasn't really an invasion
- 6:00that drove them out so much as the plain fact that they could
- 6:03no longer afford to keep the Garrison there.
- 6:06Within 50 years, the villas were sitting abandoned.
- 6:09The roads were still there, but nobody was bothering to repair
- 6:13them. The town shrank back to
- 6:15fortified hilltops. Literacy fell apart and in under
- 6:18a century Britain went from a Roman province to something
- 6:22closer to an Iron Age tribal center.
- 6:25So what's the actual difference between Rome and Trier, or
- 6:28between Alexandria and Britain? It comes down to power, And not
- 6:32military power either. Administrative power.
- 6:35The cities that made it with the ones that stay plugged in to the
- 6:38working administrative network. Constantinople was running on
- 6:42the eastern one. Rome was becoming the seat of
- 6:45the Papacy, which was a brand new administrative network
- 6:49growing right on top of the old imperial one.
- 6:52Alexandria and Antioch were still wired into Eastern trade
- 6:55and governance. Trier had lost its emperor, and
- 6:59Britain had lost its Garrison. And once that connection was
- 7:02gone, the city just stopped functioning as a city and slid
- 7:06back into being a big village. That's the real fault line.
- 7:10And it isn't fire and it isn't Barbarians.
- 7:12It's organized power pulling out.
- 7:15Now let's get into the economy. Back in a book that came out in
- 7:181937, a Belgian historian named Andre Peren made an argument
- 7:23that most people outside the academic world would just never
- 7:26have come across. What he says was that Rome
- 7:29didn't really end in 476 at all. The Roman economic world,
- 7:33meaning the whole Mediterranean trade system, actually kept
- 7:37running for another 200 years after that.
- 7:39What finally killed it, in his telling was the Arab conquest of
- 7:43North Africa and the Levant in the 7th century, because that
- 7:47cut the Mediterranean clean in half, and once it was cut, the
- 7:50Western economy finally dropped down into real subsistence.
- 7:54I think Paren was partly right. The trade clearly didn't stop in
- 7:58476, but it did contract, and that contraction is the thing
- 8:03that you want to be watching. Think about what was possible in
- 8:06300. A jar of olive oil could move
- 8:08from North Africa all the way to the Rhine frontier without
- 8:12changing hands more than a couple times because the
- 8:15infrastructure was that dense. You had the roads, the ports,
- 8:20the customs houses, the warehouses, all of it
- 8:23coordinated by an administrative system running on Roman law.
- 8:26By 5:50, that same jar of oil might still have made it as far
- 8:31as Massilia, but getting up the Rhine now meant that three more
- 8:34transactions, a couple more middle men, and a road that
- 8:38hadn't seen any maintenance in 40 years.
- 8:41This is where the money problem turns into something physical.
- 8:44The debase currency didn't just wipe out people's savings, it
- 8:48killed off the reason to trade over long distances in the first
- 8:51place. Once you stop trusting the coin,
- 8:54you stop extending credit. And once nobody's extending
- 8:57credit, nobody's shipping. And when the shipping dries up,
- 9:01the ports get smaller. And when the ports get smaller,
- 9:04the city around it gets smaller as well.
- 9:06That's the chain reaction. And every Lincoln, it snaps from
- 9:10the same original failure, which is that the state could no
- 9:12longer afford to stand behind its own money.
- 9:15So by 5:50 the Mediterranean economy was still up and
- 9:18running, just at a fraction of what it used to be, and it was
- 9:21falling back on barter in places that had never needed barter
- 9:24before. The merchants were still out
- 9:26there, the ships were just smaller, the routes were
- 9:29shorter, and there was a lot less money in it.
- 9:32That's not a collapse, it's a contraction.
- 9:35And a contraction is a much harder thing to see.
- 9:38Which is exactly my most people don't catch it until it's
- 9:40already finished. Now let's shrink it down
- 9:42further, past the cities and the trade routes, all the way down
- 9:46to one person, say a Craftsman in a mid sized town in southern
- 9:50Gulf in the year 550. What does his actual life look
- 9:53like? He wakes up in a house that's
- 9:55still recognizably Roman in the way it's built, and not because
- 9:59somebody just put it up. It's because the house his great
- 10:02grandfather built simply hasn't fallen down yet.
- 10:05Roman construction was that good.
- 10:08He speaks a kind of Latin, too, not the classical Latin of
- 10:11textbooks that's already breaking up into regional
- 10:14dialects, but it's clearly still Latin.
- 10:17If you dropped him in front of a Roman citizen from 300, he could
- 10:21more or less make himself understood about the way a
- 10:24modern American could work things out with someone from the
- 10:271790s. So it's tricky, but it's
- 10:30suitable. The market, though, is a
- 10:32different story. Back in 300, his town would have
- 10:35had a weekly market carrying goods all over the empire,
- 10:39pottery coming up from North Africa, glass from Syria, and
- 10:43grain out of Egypt. By 5:50, that market has gone
- 10:46local. The North African pottery has
- 10:48thinned right out since the high end decorated workshops fell
- 10:52apart after the Vandals took Carthage, and even the ordinary
- 10:55everyday stuff is showing up less reliably and costing more.
- 10:59The Syrian glass still turns up, just not as often or not as
- 11:03cheap. The Egyptian grain now gets
- 11:05routed through Constantinople before it ever reaches.
- 11:09The market's still there, it's just smaller and a narrower
- 11:13version of itself. Then there's the services side
- 11:16of things. And 300, if you had a legal
- 11:18dispute, it went in front of a Roman magistrate, somebody
- 11:22trained in law, appointed by the state, and working from Roman
- 11:26law. By 5:50, that magistrate is just
- 11:29gone. What you got in his place is a
- 11:31Bishop, or maybe the agent of some Visigothic king who picked
- 11:35up his Roman law from a manuscript that got copied out
- 11:38of a monastery by men who never laid eyes on a Roman emperor.
- 11:42So the law itself is still mostly Roman, but the person
- 11:45handing it down to you isn't. And that shift turns out to
- 11:49matter a lot because the Bishop isn't only settling your
- 11:52disputes, he's the one handing out grain when there's a famine,
- 11:56running whatever passes for a local hospital, organizing
- 11:59whatever Rd. repair actually gets done.
- 12:02He's basically the welfare officer and the courthouse and
- 12:05the town council rolled into one man.
- 12:08And all of it is being paid for by the church rather than the
- 12:10Empire. This is the last stage of that
- 12:13power handover. The Empire's authority was
- 12:15draining out of imperial hands, slowly at 1st and then
- 12:19completely, and the thing it drained into was the Catholic
- 12:22Church, not one of the barbarian kingdoms.
- 12:25Now flip it over and look at the other side, the things that
- 12:28didn't change, because this is where the standard story really
- 12:32falls apart. The peasant out in southern Gaul
- 12:34is still farming the same land his family always farmed, same
- 12:38crop rotations, same irrigation channels, and a lot of cases the
- 12:42same tax bill. Except now it's being paid to a
- 12:45Visigothic king instead of a Roman emperor.
- 12:48And it's structured in exactly the same way, because the
- 12:51Visigoth simply took over the existing Roman tax records and
- 12:55kept using them. He didn't sit down and redesign
- 12:57the system, he just stepped straight into it.
- 13:00Roman law survived too. Not everywhere, and not in
- 13:04perfect shape, but the Visigoths and the Ostrogoths and the
- 13:07Burgundians all produced their own law codes, and every one of
- 13:11these codes is built on Roman models.
- 13:14They held on to Roman law for the simple reason that it
- 13:17worked, because tribal custom was never going to be able to
- 13:20run a complicated urban economy. Even with everything coming
- 13:24apart, the old system was still worth copying.
- 13:27The shape of the household didn't change either.
- 13:30You still got the family unit, the parents and the children and
- 13:33the wider kin around them holding steady.
- 13:36The old feast days got folded into the Christian calendar.
- 13:39Instead of being thrown out, the local gods quietly turned into
- 13:42Saints, the temples turned into churches, the forum became the
- 13:46marketplace, and the government building down the street became
- 13:50a cathedral. Same stones, just a different
- 13:53name over the door. This is what one of these
- 13:55transformations actually looks like when you're standing at the
- 13:58street level. There's no fire and no sudden
- 14:01silence, just the slow pile up of small substitutions, each one
- 14:05basically invisible by itself and all of them quietly pointing
- 14:09the same way. Now bring geography into it,
- 14:12because none of this happened evenly.
- 14:14It was wildly different from one region to the next.
- 14:18Italy under the Ostrogoths was, by the standards of the day,
- 14:22remarkably well run. Theodore kept the Roman Senate
- 14:25where it was, kept the Roman civil service intact, governed
- 14:29through Roman law, put Romans into administrative posts, and
- 14:33kept the infrastructure going at the same level that genuinely
- 14:36startled people watching at the time.
- 14:38And we know this in real detail because of a man named
- 14:41Cassiodorus, a Roman senator who worked for Theodoric and wrote
- 14:45the King's official correspondence in a style you'd
- 14:48swear came straight from Augustus.
- 14:51We're not guessing here, either. The whole collection of his
- 14:54letters, The very Eye, actually survive.
- 14:57You can sit and read the Ostrogothic government talking
- 15:00in flawless Roman bureaucratic Latin, arranging grain shipments
- 15:05and aqueduct repairs as though Augustus himself were still
- 15:08signing off on the paperwork. Same titles, same formulas, same
- 15:14basic assumption that Roman order was simply how things were
- 15:17done. Theodoric had grasped something
- 15:19that a lot of conquerors never do, which is that the system was
- 15:22worth far more than the territory.
- 15:25You don't burn the whole thing down that you've just inherited,
- 15:28you keep it running. Southern Gaul went most the same
- 15:31way. The Rhone and the Sawn were
- 15:33still working as trade highways, Basilia was still alive port,
- 15:37and the bishops were still keeping civic life going through
- 15:41the Roman administrative networks they'd inherited.
- 15:44The infrastructure was scaled down, but it was still genuinely
- 15:47infrastructure. Northern Gaul is where it starts
- 15:50to look different. The Rhine frontier had been the
- 15:53very edge of the Empire, so when the Empire pulled inward, the
- 15:56frontier pulled in right along with it.
- 15:58The Franks who'd moved into Northern Gaul were a good deal
- 16:02less Romanized than the Visigoths were.
- 16:04Their law codes leaned more tribal, their way of governing
- 16:07was far more personal, and a King's authority basically came
- 16:11down to whatever he could enforce in person rather than
- 16:14anything written into a legal framework run by trained
- 16:17officials. Britain is the extreme of the
- 16:20whole spectrum. The cultural collapse there was
- 16:22unlike anything else in the post Roman W Latin died out as a
- 16:26spoken language within two generations of the Romans
- 16:29leaving. And the pottery tells the same
- 16:31story in an even starker way. Because the mass produced Roman
- 16:35wheel throne pottery that you find that every single Romano
- 16:38British site just stops dead around 4:50.
- 16:42There's no gradual decline and no switch to something else.
- 16:45The whole production base simply ceases to exist.
- 16:48And this is the one spot where the Catastrophe school of
- 16:51historians really has the goods. Ryan Ward Perkins, who by the
- 16:55way, I read a lot in grad school, built an entire book
- 16:58around exactly this point, that when you can watch cheap, good,
- 17:02mass produced pottery vanish from the record, what you're
- 17:05really watching is a genuine collapse in people's standard of
- 17:08living, not some polite transformation.
- 17:11And on Britain, he's dead right. The Potter's wheel and the kiln
- 17:15actually disappear and people go back to making pots by hand.
- 17:19I just like to add that Ward Perkins would argue with a
- 17:21gentler contradiction reading that I'm giving you.
- 17:24For the rest of the empire, Britain is the place where even
- 17:27the optimists admit the bottom dropped out completely.
- 17:31This is the border problem showing its teeth.
- 17:33The empire held a perimeter, and when that perimeter moved, the
- 17:37symbolization sitting behind it didn't always come through at
- 17:40the same level. The further you were from the
- 17:42new centers of power, from Constantinople, from Rome, from
- 17:46the Church's network, the harder and faster you slid backwards.
- 17:50Being a long way from the center was basically a death sentence
- 17:54for any kind of Roman complexity.
- 17:56The center was doing a lot more than just handing down
- 17:58governance, it was creating the conditions that let the
- 18:02complexity exist at all. Take the center away, and the
- 18:05complexity can't hold itself up, so it falls back toward whatever
- 18:09people can keep going at a local level.
- 18:11Now we get to the institution that soaked all this up, and
- 18:15this is much more than a religious story.
- 18:18It's probably the most successful handover of
- 18:20institutional power in the whole history of the West.
- 18:23By 5:50, the Catholic Church was carrying out basically every
- 18:26function the imperial administration had been handling
- 18:30since back in 350. The tax collection was still
- 18:32happening, it was just called tithes now.
- 18:34Dispute resolution was still happening under the name of
- 18:37Canon Law. Welfare had become charity, the
- 18:40upkeep of infrastructure had become the work of the
- 18:42monasteries, record keeping moved into the scriptoria and
- 18:46education ran through the cathedral.
- 18:48Control schools, same jobs, new labels.
- 18:51I went deeper on the Vatican's particular role in taking over
- 18:54these state functions in a companion video, and that links
- 18:57in the description. But the point I want to make
- 18:58here is about actually how it happened.
- 19:02The Church stepped into the Empire and it took it over.
- 19:05And it could do that because it was the one institution with the
- 19:08geographic reach, the administrative skill, and the
- 19:11genuine authority to fill the gap the Empire had left.
- 19:15The bishops were using the Roman Rd. network.
- 19:17They were writing in Latin. They organized their own
- 19:19authority along the old Roman provincial boundaries.
- 19:22They even took over the Roman title pontifex, the words Romans
- 19:26used for their chief priests, which literally means bridge
- 19:29builder. And the Bishop of Rome picked up
- 19:31that title and simply never let go of it.
- 19:34This is what power looks like when the handover goes smoothly.
- 19:38It doesn't make any announcement, it just moves into
- 19:40the empty spaces, the old power left behind.
- 19:42It borrows the language of the system it's replacing.
- 19:45It keeps all the familiar forms in place and quietly swaps out
- 19:48what's inside them. By the time anybody notices that
- 19:51the switch has happened, the new institution has already been
- 19:54doing the old jobs for a generation.
- 19:56The whole thing finishes before it ever becomes visible.
- 19:59By 600, the Catholic Church was the single most powerful
- 20:02institution in the Western world, and it got there without
- 20:06conquering anyone. It just outlasted everything
- 20:08else around it. So that's what life actually
- 20:11looked like once Rome had fallen.
- 20:13The cities got smaller, but they didn't vanish.
- 20:15The trade routes pulled in, but they kept running.
- 20:18The Latin broke apart, and what it broke into was French,
- 20:21Spanish, Portuguese, Italian, and Romanian. 5 living languages
- 20:25that more than a billion people speak today.
- 20:28Roman law got rewritten by barbarian kings and it still
- 20:31ended up as a foundation under every western legal system that
- 20:35came after. The Roman infrastructure
- 20:37crumbled and the church just kept enough of it patched
- 20:40together to keep the network breathing.
- 20:42The story most people grew up with is that Rome fell and the
- 20:46lights went out. The truth is harder than that.
- 20:48Rome shrank down into something smaller, and that smaller thing
- 20:51turned out to be the seed of everything that came next.
- 20:54So medieval Europe was really Rome carrying on at reduced
- 20:58capacity. Now the part that actually
- 21:00matters here is less about history and more about learning
- 21:03to spot a pattern. What does one of these
- 21:05transformations look like from the inside?
- 21:08It looks like the institution is still taking over.
- 21:11The ceremony is still being held, the old title still in
- 21:13use, all the familiar forms kept carefully in place long after
- 21:17the thing inside them has changed.
- 21:19This is more or less the argument that Peter Heather has
- 21:22spent his career making, that Rome didn't just quietly rot
- 21:25from the inside on some schedule of its own.
- 21:27The forms held in the paperwork held, but the thing that was
- 21:30actually funding and defending the whole apparatus got eaten
- 21:33away underneath. And once that was gone, the
- 21:36inheritance got carved up by whoever happened to be standing
- 21:39closest. Think about that merchant in 550
- 21:42again. He paid his customs duty, He
- 21:44just had no idea whether the empire behind that customs
- 21:46office still existed. The peasant paid his taxes to a
- 21:49man in a Visigothic uniform reading off a Roman tax Ledger.
- 21:53The Bishop handed down Roman law, only now he did it in the
- 21:56name of God instead of the emperor.
- 21:58The same system underneath, different names on top.
- 22:01And that's the thing that most people miss.
- 22:03What looks like a civilization ending is really a civilization
- 22:07changing hands, and the moment it changes hands stays invisible
- 22:11right up until it's finished, and by then the new system has
- 22:14been running long enough that everyone just assumes it was
- 22:17always there. None of this is unique to Rome.
- 22:20It happens anytime the center loses its grip on holding the
- 22:24system together. The system gets inherited rather
- 22:26than destroyed, picked up by whoever's organized and
- 22:29legitimate enough to take over the jobs that the center can't
- 22:32manage anymore. The money fails, the borders
- 22:35thin out, the power moves on, and whatever fills that empty
- 22:38space becomes the next civilization.
- 22:40In the next video, we're going to follow that same pattern
- 22:42forward into what the church actually built on top of the
- 22:45ruins of the Western Empire, and what it stripped out of those
- 22:48ruins to build with. That link's going to be in the
- 22:50description once it's actually live, so if you're watching this
- 22:52later on, you're going to get to see it and it's already there.
- 22:54If not, you can wait for it. And if the series is new to you,
- 22:57there's a Start Here playlist down in the description that
- 23:00lays out the whole thing in order because it honestly makes
- 23:03a lot more sense if you watch everything.
- 23:05This has been the Roman pattern. I'm Jeremy Ryan Slate, do me a
- 23:08favor and like this video. Leave us a comment and hit that
- 23:11subscribe button if you want more of the Roman pattern.