Latest / Film And Whiskey / The Prestige / Quarter Horse Bourbon (feat. Bilge Ebiri)
Transcript
- 0:00So here's the deal everybody. We just absolutely love
- 0:03producing as much content as possible for film and Whiskey
- 0:07Nation. But if our regular episodes
- 0:09aren't enough for you, then you can head on over to
- 0:11patreon.com/film Whiskey. Sign up for one of our
- 0:15memberships and you will get a slew of extra content for your
- 0:18listening pleasure. Check us out on
- 0:21patreon.com/filmwhiskey. In 2006, director Christopher
- 0:27Nolan and stars Christian Bale and Hugh Jackman gave the world
- 0:30a mysterious thriller that had role reversals galore.
- 0:35In 2023, we make a return trip to Kentucky to try a brand of
- 0:40mysterious origin. The film is the prestige.
- 0:44The whiskey is Quarter Horse Bourbon.
- 0:46We'll review them both. This is the.
- 0:49Film and Whiskey Podcast. Welcome to the Film and Whiskey
- 1:10Podcast, where each week we review a classic movie and a
- 1:13glass of whiskey. I'm Bob Book.
- 1:15I'm Brad Gee. And this week we are continuing
- 1:18the Christopher Nolan retrospective.
- 1:21With his 2006 film The Prestige. Bob, doesn't retrospective mean
- 1:25like they are no longer with us? Isn't that what it's called at
- 1:30the Oscars? No, that's like in memoriam.
- 1:33Oh, OK. Yeah.
- 1:34Yeah, well, regardless, we're looking back on some Christopher
- 1:38Nolan films. He is very much not dead at the
- 1:40time of recording, so. I'm glad to hear that also at
- 1:44the time of recording, like, do you expect him to just?
- 1:47Listen man, you got to, you got to prepare, you got to be
- 1:50prepared for these kind of things.
- 1:51So man, Brad's a new world record.
- 1:55We have gone off the rails in 32 seconds on this podcast.
- 1:59Today it's it's quite impressive, Bob.
- 2:02All right, so Brad let me set the stage a little bit with The
- 2:04Prestige. This is a movie like Memento
- 2:07that I have not watched in a long time, partially because I
- 2:10remember when I first watched it, I was not the world's
- 2:13biggest fan of it, and I know that it has since become.
- 2:17One of Nolan's best loved films. And there are people who will,
- 2:21like, fight you to the death about The Prestige.
- 2:23And I did not want to come in here and crap all over The
- 2:26Prestige. And I was trying to kind of
- 2:28hedge a little bit and make sure that there was somebody to
- 2:30balance me out. Luckily, Brad, we have a guest
- 2:33on this show today. He is a film critic, one of the
- 2:36nation's preeminent film critics, Writer for Vulture in
- 2:40New York magazine. Bilga Abiri, Bilga, how are you
- 2:42doing today? I'm good.
- 2:44How are you? I'm doing great and I feel like
- 2:47I can already sense in your voice that you don't know where
- 2:50I'm going to go with my thoughts on The Prestige.
- 2:52So let me just say upfront, Brad Bilga, this is a damn good
- 2:57movie. It sure is now, now so, so that
- 3:02you are one of the people who has changed their opinion of the
- 3:06Prestige, because there are a lot of those people.
- 3:08Very much so, yeah. Yeah, Bob, I am so glad that
- 3:12you've come around on this film because it's a movie I remember
- 3:15seeing when it came out in the theaters.
- 3:17I believe I went with my dad and my brother to see it, and I I
- 3:21just remember being blown away by how cool it was.
- 3:23The problem that I had with The Prestige, if I could say that I
- 3:27had a problem, was that I watched it when it came out, and
- 3:30then I didn't watch it for probably a decade, and I would
- 3:33always forget because it came out at the exact same time as
- 3:36another magic movie. And I would always be like,
- 3:39wait, was which one was it? Was it the the prestige or the
- 3:43illusion? I don't remember which one I
- 3:45liked because I saw them both in theater and for the longest
- 3:48time, they both stuck in my brain as as kind of the same
- 3:52movie. Well, let's get this out of the
- 3:54way now. Let's talk about this the the
- 3:55double bill of magic movies we had in 2006, Brad, we didn't
- 3:59know what we had at the time. What what a time to be alive to
- 4:02get these two movies. I really liked The Illusionist
- 4:05when that movie came out, and I was really hoping to be able to
- 4:08go back and revisit it before today because I was the guy that
- 4:11was like, you guys are dead wrong.
- 4:13The Illusionist is a much better film than The Prestige.
- 4:16I really loved it when it came out.
- 4:18I'm bummed I didn't get to revisit it, but I think that my
- 4:23big problem with The Prestige that I didn't have with The
- 4:25Illusionist was that we were in like Peak Shyamalan.
- 4:32The wake of M Night Shyamalan on Hollywood and how every movie at
- 4:36the time was being marketed as if the twist was the key to the
- 4:41whole film. And I remember with The Prestige
- 4:44being like, I don't think that that was the way to market this
- 4:48movie because, you know, they don't give you all the cards
- 4:51until the end of the film. But if you're paying attention,
- 4:55like, no one's really not trying to hide the twist of the movie
- 4:59from you. And I remember kind of holding
- 5:02Nolan accountable for what the marketing of the movie had done.
- 5:05And I think that really kind of tainted my appreciation of the
- 5:09movie at the time. So I don't know, man.
- 5:11All that to say, I don't know how The Illusionist holds up,
- 5:14but The Prestige divorced from that context, really good movie.
- 5:20Yeah, Like I said, I'm, I'm glad that you say that, Bob, because
- 5:23it's coming back to it now. I believe I watched it again in
- 5:26the late, you know, 20 tweens. Watching it again, probably my
- 5:31third or fourth time. I love this movie, man.
- 5:34It just, it hits all the boxes of a really suspenseful, fun
- 5:40thriller. And I I'm, I'm excited to talk
- 5:42about it. Bill Good, Can you help us set
- 5:45the stage for, I mean, like just, I don't want to say
- 5:47historically, like this movie is not that old, but 2006 Nolan's
- 5:52coming off of Batman Begins and he has this relationship.
- 5:56Where it's almost like a, you know, one for them, one for me
- 5:59film that he toggles throughout the Batman trilogy.
- 6:03What do you remember the initial kind of reception to this film
- 6:07being? With The Prestige, you know.
- 6:10But part of it was the 1-2 punch of the fact that Nolan released
- 6:14both of these both Batman Begins and The Prestige in the same
- 6:17year, if I remember correctly. And and Batman Begins was a hit,
- 6:21but Batman Begins, you know, was was was a.
- 6:25Fairly modest hit it wasn't. It wasn't in a huge hit.
- 6:29It was I think it out of making like $200 million some some
- 6:32something thereabouts. Which was good which was which
- 6:36was you know which was good and and it had decent legs but it
- 6:39wasn't like you know, it it it didn't like blow a hole in the
- 6:43box office. It did however get great reviews
- 6:47and I remember, you know I was kind of Issy on Nolan before
- 6:50Batman Begins. I I liked Memento.
- 6:52I found Memento very clever. I did not like insomnia.
- 6:57I didn't quite know what to make of him.
- 6:59And then Batman Begins, I had zero interest in a new Batman
- 7:03movie. But, you know, then friends of
- 7:04mine were like, oh, you got to go see it, you know?
- 7:06And and I went and saw it and I loved it.
- 7:08And and then when The Prestige came out, I was like, all right,
- 7:10this, this, this is a major dude.
- 7:13This this guy's making money, you know, this guy's churning
- 7:16them out. And and ironically enough, it's
- 7:18the last time he churned them out.
- 7:20But. You know, and the films contain
- 7:25a number of elements that are that are similar.
- 7:27I mean, obviously, you know, there are themes that run
- 7:29throughout Nolan's films and stylistic, you know, flourishes
- 7:33and things like that, but the stories are very different.
- 7:39I I will say I I also saw The Illusionist around that time.
- 7:42I hated The Illusionist. I have revisited it, but I
- 7:46thought that movie was absolute. Garbage.
- 7:49You mean Jessica Biel as the the main female over Scarlett
- 7:52Johansson didn't intrigue you? I will say this, I am a Jessica
- 7:56Biel fan. There you go.
- 7:59And it's got Giamatti. I mean, it's a yeah, nothing
- 8:01wrong with the cast of that movie, but I just found it so
- 8:04ludicrous and. You know, I mean think about a
- 8:08magic movie, that's tough is it has to, it has to dazzle you in
- 8:13some way. But it's like cinematically it's
- 8:15it's hard to dazzle you with magic tricks because it's like,
- 8:18I mean it's movies you can, you can do whatever, like, you know,
- 8:23the idea of a magic trick is is you know and ask them at the
- 8:27movies, even though movies share qualities with magic and and
- 8:31many qualities with sort of the way magic evolved.
- 8:36But what I love about The Prestige is it does kind of
- 8:40through its twists and through its use of distraction and red
- 8:46herrings and things like that, it actually does kind of make
- 8:49you feel like you've seen a magic trick.
- 8:52That's that's the thing that I loved about it and the other
- 8:55thing about it and and and you know it's it's interesting to
- 8:57hear you guys talk about revisiting it.
- 9:01You know Nolan has made movies that.
- 9:05Sometimes they're sometimes people think of them as puzzle
- 9:08movies and sometimes people think of them as twist movies.
- 9:11I mean this is 1. Obviously the Inception is
- 9:13another. And sometimes people use that as
- 9:18kind of a knock against them. But what I would say is you know
- 9:22the class puzzle movie or twist movie.
- 9:26You know the the twist or the puzzle or the solution of the
- 9:29puzzle or whatever or like you know the.
- 9:32The mind F at the end of the movie, like those are often kind
- 9:35of the raison debt true of the film, right?
- 9:37That's that's like the film is basically almost an excuse to
- 9:42have the twist or the puzzle or whatever.
- 9:46I don't find that to be the thing with Nolan movies.
- 9:49I mean, I return to them over and over and over.
- 9:51I've seen The Prestige like, you know, 1015 times at this point.
- 9:54You know, I've seen the Inception even more.
- 9:58The puzzle is not. The puzzle is not the thing.
- 10:02The puzzle is the thing that that maybe creates some level of
- 10:05interest and excitement and engagement with the film.
- 10:08But but the film stand on their own without that.
- 10:11And same with the and what I love about the prestige, you
- 10:14know that that idea of misdirection which is kind of
- 10:16the the heart of magic. He does that here, right?
- 10:20I mean because he because he because he sets up one twist,
- 10:22right. And then at a certain point, you
- 10:25kind of realize, you kind of understand where the movie is
- 10:28going and what that twist is. And that's interesting and it's
- 10:32exciting, but it's not actually the final twist.
- 10:35Like, exactly missurrection. And then and then he brings the
- 10:39hammer down in the very final shot of the movie and you're
- 10:41like, whoa, wait a minute. And then he just fades out, you
- 10:46know? Which is which I think is
- 10:48beautiful, interestingly. I mean, I I don't know if you
- 10:51guys have read the book, but the book is quite different from the
- 10:53film. But yeah, I know.
- 10:55So just to say, I was a big fan of The Prestige then I found it
- 10:59interesting some, some I had a couple of friends who disliked
- 11:02it when they first saw it because they thought, oh, you
- 11:05know, this is like a fantasy or like it's science fiction or
- 11:10something like that. Like like like they they they
- 11:12felt like it, it changed genres. But really it didn't.
- 11:15I mean it it. It it adheres to that old Arthur
- 11:19C Clarke saying, which is like, you know, a great, I can't
- 11:24remember the exact saying, but it's like a great scientific
- 11:26discovery is is basically the the feels no different than a
- 11:32magic trick, you know. Well, and I agree with you, I
- 11:35think that yes, he gives, he brings the hammer down at the
- 11:38end of the film, but also he gives you enough of the twist
- 11:41throughout the movie that watching it through this time.
- 11:45I was so much more impressed with this movie than I was with
- 11:47Memento, a movie that I also like, but that I feel is much
- 11:51more about the twist than this movie is about the twist.
- 11:54This movie is so much more about the deeper themes of obsession
- 11:58and artistic integrity and sacrifice to make art.
- 12:03And I think because of that, it plays much more like a great
- 12:06tragedy than anything else. And.
- 12:09Brad, I think we've kind of beat around the Bush a little bit
- 12:11here because I have been waiting with bated breath to get into
- 12:16our first segment of the day, which we call, Brad explains.
- 12:19Brad's going to give us the movie plots with only 60 seconds
- 12:22ticking on the clock, so let's go ahead and do your take with
- 12:26this little segment that we call.
- 12:27Brad explains. Brad Explains is the part of the
- 12:30show where Brad breaks down the plot of the film that he has
- 12:33just seen, often for the first time.
- 12:36I think you've already said this was like your third or fourth
- 12:38time seeing the film, so hopefully that will help you as
- 12:41we put 60 seconds on the clock here.
- 12:43Brad, do you think that like and not to spoil or step on your
- 12:48thing here, but like this is another sort of Nolan fractured
- 12:51timeline thing. Do you think that plays into the
- 12:55explanation of the movie at all or not really?
- 12:58Honestly, not really, because I don't think he's like, out of
- 13:03all of his films. I mean, Dunkirk is probably up
- 13:06there, but he's the least clever about the time stuff here.
- 13:12Like he never tries to trick you into thinking that one timeline
- 13:15is a different one. Like, I don't, I like, I don't
- 13:18know about you guys. It seemed pretty obvious when we
- 13:20were going to the past versus the present, and I don't know.
- 13:25So, no, I don't think so. All right, great.
- 13:27Well then, that makes it a much more straightforward task for
- 13:29you, Brad. You've got one minute on the
- 13:31clock. Spoil this movie as you go and.
- 13:35The Prestige is a film about two magicians in Victorian England,
- 13:40one of whom was married to a woman who gets drowned in a
- 13:43magic trick gone wrong because the other magician tied the
- 13:48knots too tight on the rope she's unable to escape, and this
- 13:52sets off a decades long rivalry between the two that becomes, as
- 13:57you said earlier, Bob, obsessive, bitter and to the
- 14:01point of almost evil. The two men fall in love with
- 14:05the same woman played by Scarlett Johansson, who works
- 14:08for both of them at different times, and the movie ends with
- 14:13one framing the other for murder.
- 14:16And it turns out that he is unable to truly pull that off,
- 14:20as the final reveal is that the man framed for murder has a twin
- 14:26brother who has been playing him the entire time.
- 14:30And not to bury the lead too much, but.
- 14:33Nikola Tesla is also going to say.
- 14:35Yeah, 1900s cloning. Yeah, am I right?
- 14:39Yeah, no, no big deal. All right, guys.
- 14:43Where do you want to start today, Brad?
- 14:45I'll let you kind of steer us here.
- 14:46Do you want to jump right into performances?
- 14:48Do you want to keep talking about the Nolan of it all?
- 14:51Where should we begin? I I'm.
- 14:53Just fascinated by the fact that David Bowie was in this movie,
- 14:56right? I don't know about you guys, but
- 14:58he he walks on screen and you're like, huh, that he looks kind of
- 15:02familiar. And then you look on IMDb and
- 15:03you're like, oh, why is David Bowie in this movie?
- 15:07And why isn't he in every movie? He's great, He's great and
- 15:10everything he's doing. Incredible in this.
- 15:13He's doing a preposterous accent and I am all for it because, you
- 15:17know, Nolan really chased after Bowie to get him in this movie.
- 15:20Apparently Bowie declined a number of times and Nolan kind
- 15:23of really pressured him into being in the film.
- 15:26And I think that it's such a stroke of genius in terms of the
- 15:29casting of it, because like, what is Bowie associated with,
- 15:32right? Like his first big stage persona
- 15:35is Ziggy Stardust this like. Maybe futuristic alien that
- 15:39comes down as like a as like a savior motif.
- 15:42Bowie always had this sort of otherness to him and like, what
- 15:47better way to introduce the themes of science and progress
- 15:50and the science fiction elements than to put somebody like Bowie
- 15:54in that role. I think it's just a stroke of
- 15:57genius just to put him in the film.
- 15:59Yeah, the science being indistinguishable for magic.
- 16:01That feels like a Bowie concept. But I I want to say, you know,
- 16:07in in your summary of the film you said the final reveal is, is
- 16:10the fact that you know that that Christian Bale's character is a
- 16:14twin. That's not the final reveal of
- 16:16course, right. I mean the final reveal is that
- 16:20you know, Hugh Jackman has been killing himself every single
- 16:23night and and and you know, burying his, his doppelganger
- 16:30in, you know, tubs of tubs of water, I mean.
- 16:34That's the part that that that's the that that to me is the is
- 16:38the great reveal of the movie. Because I think at a certain
- 16:40point, there's a certain point in the film where you realize
- 16:43the the twin thing, I think where where yeah, it starts to
- 16:47dawn on you around the time when when Hugh Jackman takes one of
- 16:55them hostage at that point. I remember starting to think,
- 17:00oh, wait, I I see what's going on here. 1 guy's a twin.
- 17:03I'm like, I I got it. I figured out the movie.
- 17:05And of course, of course like it.
- 17:07It builds to that. But then the real, the real
- 17:11reveal is what Hugh Jackman has been doing every night.
- 17:14Can I say, though? I actually think that I'm.
- 17:18I don't know if I'm just being that guy here.
- 17:20I actually think that the final reveal of the movie is that
- 17:24Michael Caine ended up helping Christian Bale.
- 17:29Because that that's like literally the last shot of the
- 17:31film when they're with the daughter and and like Michael
- 17:34Caine is helping him. And I I think that for me, you
- 17:38know, you were talking earlier, Bilga, about how this film
- 17:42endures because it's not just about the twist.
- 17:47And I think that that's why this movie works, is that it's more
- 17:50about the dark levels to which obsession can take you.
- 17:57And it's about the human drama between Bale and Jackman.
- 18:01And like the the idea that that Kane's character, who once
- 18:08nailed a guy into a coffin box for Hugh Jackman, would then
- 18:13switch sides once he saw how dark he went is like, that's
- 18:17like, that's like the twist that you don't expect.
- 18:19I I don't know. No, I love that.
- 18:22It's fair. Yeah.
- 18:23No. And and and you're absolutely
- 18:24right. I mean, it really is about the
- 18:26characters. I mean, and I think, you know, I
- 18:28I would say the reason why this movie and I, I, I would agree
- 18:36with you, it resonates for me much more than Memento, which is
- 18:40a Memento is like a perfectly put together film.
- 18:42No knock against it. But there's a certain to me,
- 18:47there's a certain human drama missing from it.
- 18:50Not because of what's happening on screen is actually what's
- 18:53happening on screen is is very sad.
- 18:55But because weirdly, because of the perspective of the film, for
- 18:58some reason it's hard to. I mean, you feel for that
- 19:03character, but for me, I feel, I feel in the abstract, in an
- 19:06abstract way for him, he doesn't move me the way, yeah.
- 19:11Bail does in this particularly. I mean, his face has to look
- 19:15like a computer that's resetting every 10 minutes.
- 19:17Yeah, it's hard to connect with that.
- 19:19Yeah, yeah, right, right. Because you know something about
- 19:23something about memory is is is is what's, you know what's so
- 19:27moving and and you know, there's a there's a very sort of, I
- 19:30mean, you know, refined almost existential aspect to the story
- 19:37which is the idea that. You know, Christian Bale or
- 19:43Borden has been living. You know, it's not a double
- 19:46life, It's like a half life, right.
- 19:48I mean the idea that these two men, these, these two, these
- 19:51twins have basically been sharing the same life and the
- 19:55same identity. And it's funny when you read the
- 19:59book, it's it's more almost more vivid in the book because it's
- 20:03like Borden narrates part of the book.
- 20:06But it's like the two of them. So it's like he's constantly,
- 20:09it's almost, it's actually a bit like Memento because he keeps
- 20:11forgetting or he keeps reminding himself of something he said or
- 20:14did and sometimes speaks about himself in the third person.
- 20:20And and later on you realize, oh, it's because it's actually
- 20:23two people narrating. So it's like this, this idea of
- 20:25the divide itself, but not just divided, but literally living
- 20:28half lives, right. It's not, it's not a twin that's
- 20:32hiding. It's not a twin that's like.
- 20:36Sometimes filling in for one person like they they are kind
- 20:39of they are literally living one life to the point where their
- 20:45identities have been subsumed into one another And that's you
- 20:49know that's a thing that that is very, you know it's it's an
- 20:53abstract notion But somehow no one in that cast they they make
- 20:58it very vivid in the film and and and very moving I find.
- 21:01And you know that's one of the things that I every time I
- 21:04return to the film. I'm really struck by the beauty
- 21:08and the power of of Christian Bale's performance and and his
- 21:11character. I really don't think that you
- 21:13can divorce this film either from like where it falls in the
- 21:16Nolan catalog. This is smack dab between 2
- 21:19Batman movies and Brad. We talked last week about how
- 21:22you you just really can't underestimate what those Batman
- 21:26films did for Nolan as he continued to hone his craft, but
- 21:29also to develop the themes that he would continually return to.
- 21:33And I think that with this film, and to the point you're both
- 21:36making, the reason this movie works for me better than it
- 21:39worked, better than Memento worked, is because you have
- 21:42characters grappling with their own humanity and with how far
- 21:47they are willing to go to either maintain an illusion or to, you
- 21:53know, sacrifice themselves in service of that illusion.
- 21:57And I think with Memento, because for that character
- 21:59Leonard, every moment is new. He doesn't really have to weigh
- 22:02those options very much. Like you get one scene at the
- 22:04end where he decides to self sabotage, right.
- 22:07And that's the key to the whole movie.
- 22:09But you never see him really grappling with that and to kind
- 22:13of tie all these things together.
- 22:14I think this is best embodied in Michael Caine's performance and
- 22:19character of Cutter in this movie, because to your point,
- 22:22Brad, he is the person that at the end of the movie.
- 22:25Has kind of made the biggest. He is the biggest character arc
- 22:28from defending one of these rivals to completely being in
- 22:31the other's camp. And it's because he's not
- 22:34allowing himself to go to those extremes that he saw Hugh
- 22:37Jackman go. And I wanted to talk about
- 22:40Michael Caine's performance here.
- 22:42This is the second movie that he makes with Nolan.
- 22:45He makes 6 films in a row with Nolan before Dunkirk breaks that
- 22:50streak. I think that his performance
- 22:52here is just pitch perfect. And really does influence how
- 22:57much Nolan expands the character of Alfred in the latter 2
- 23:02Batman. Like the story he tells in this
- 23:04one Brad about the guy drowning and it being very peaceful and
- 23:08then he comes back later and says that was a lie.
- 23:10Like that's that's the exact same function that the some men
- 23:15just want to watch the world burn Speech has in the dark
- 23:18Night. But you know what He can give
- 23:20that speech or something that's like functionally equivalent to
- 23:23that speech in every movie. And I will still sign off on
- 23:26that as a choice because it's it's freaking great.
- 23:28I'm. Just going to eat it up, man.
- 23:30Michael Caine is a international treasure like he's he's just
- 23:36such an incredible actor. And honestly, like as he was,
- 23:40you know, giving the second-half of that speech about drowning,
- 23:43you know, at the end of the film, I thought that Hugh
- 23:46Jackman was acting his butt off man.
- 23:49Like the the horror on his face as he, as he's hearing him, like
- 23:55confirm what his fears are and even like, you know, watching it
- 24:00this time through, you catch. Or at least I caught how.
- 24:05Hard. He has his eyes closed while the
- 24:08people are inspecting the cloning machine because he knows
- 24:12that he's about to drown and like that.
- 24:14Like that hit me this time where I was just like, man, Hugh
- 24:19Jackman was killer in this movie, yeah.
- 24:23Brad, I like, I have so many thoughts on Hugh Jackman, like
- 24:25let's let's hold on Hugh Jackman, we'll do Jackman and
- 24:28Bale at the same time. But I really Bill Guy, I'd love
- 24:30to hear your thoughts on Michael Caine in particular.
- 24:34I mean, Kane is wonderful in this film.
- 24:35I've actually, over the course of the past year, I've been,
- 24:38I've been in the midst of a Michael Caine rewatch.
- 24:42I'm watching everything he's done.
- 24:44Wow. So.
- 24:45So where do The Muppets fall in for you?
- 24:47I mean that he well he's he's he's great.
- 24:49And that one he's so great. I actually, I actually have not
- 24:53revisited that one yet because. Because.
- 24:56I think in the end it's all going to result in the ranking,
- 24:59you know, in those rankings it's going to be like 200,000 words.
- 25:03So I haven't even been younger yet, but but he is, you know,
- 25:12he's he's, he's able to bring such humanity to a part with
- 25:17just, you know, I mean just a few few lines of dialogue and
- 25:20just a few minutes of screen time.
- 25:22I mean how much of this movie is he in?
- 25:24He narrates part of it. But he's also the audience
- 25:27surrogate, right? I mean he's he's with Hugh
- 25:31Jackman when we're with Hugh Jackman and then he's and then
- 25:35he turns on Hugh Jackman around the point when we turn on Hugh
- 25:38Jackman right. I mean he aligns himself with
- 25:40Christian Bale when when we start to align ourselves with.
- 25:43I mean it's not like they're it's not like they're totally
- 25:46antagonistic to us while watching the movie.
- 25:48But you know Hugh Jackman has he has a legitimate cripe.
- 25:52His wife was killed. You know, like.
- 25:56And there's a something very cocky about Christian Bale at
- 26:00first, right. But then later later the the the
- 26:04tables turn the emotional tables turn and and and Michael King
- 26:10kind of rides that and as a result you know he his presence
- 26:14sort of. Helps propel us towards that
- 26:18character as well towards, you know, towards one or the other
- 26:21characters. So he's used very, very cleverly
- 26:24in the film. His character is, I mean his
- 26:27character is like an afterthought in the novel, like
- 26:29that character is is just kind of mentioned in the background.
- 26:32He becomes a much more pronounced character and noble
- 26:34one's telling of it. All right, let's talk about the.
- 26:38I guess the, what I would say are like the the two female
- 26:41leads of the movie. I mean, we could talk about
- 26:43Piper Perabo as. Julia, Hugh Jackman's wife in
- 26:47the early scenes. But really, we need to talk
- 26:49about Rebecca Hall and Scarlett Johansson and I will say just
- 26:55forever, like, you know, from here on after Rebecca Hall is
- 26:59great and everything she does, she is a freaking treasure.
- 27:01She's great in this movie, in a very tortured performance.
- 27:06And I think that in the wrong hands, that role could really
- 27:08tip into kind of overdramatic acting.
- 27:12But she really, really nails. The slip into alcoholism and
- 27:18depression and that characters kind of tragic arc is just
- 27:21played so beautifully by her. Yeah, I I really felt like as I
- 27:26was watching her this time that Anne Hathaway in Les Mis had to
- 27:32have based some of her performance off of Rebecca Hall
- 27:35here. Interesting.
- 27:37Like they like they had so many SIM.
- 27:39There was just something about her by the end of her arc,
- 27:42right? Like when when she is finally.
- 27:45At the lowest of the low that I don't know.
- 27:48There's just something about it that felt really similar to me.
- 27:51And part of it's the era, you know, the Victorian era and
- 27:54that, but it that it made me think of her in Les Mis quite a
- 27:58bit. I yeah, I can't say I thought
- 28:01the same, Brad, but I'm I'm not going to discount your
- 28:04experience. Bob, I know that you're, you
- 28:06know. Film history isn't quite as
- 28:08extensive as mine, and so I draw on a lot of difference.
- 28:12For a noted lame is hater. I am just I'm very happy to hear
- 28:17you at least mention the movie here on this podcast.
- 28:19Hey I liked like the 1st 45 minutes of lame is it was the
- 28:24the other 3 1/2 hours that I didn't like.
- 28:26I mean, Lame is is a terrible movie, but but she's very good
- 28:29in it, and might I add. She's in that movie The same
- 28:32year she's in The Dark Knight Rises there.
- 28:36You. Go might have been, might have
- 28:39been doing some research into previous Nolan films for I
- 28:43actually I said the reason I know this is because I know or
- 28:45not that I know this. The reason I remember this is
- 28:48because I remember in New York Film Critics Circle that year we
- 28:52voted her best supporting actress.
- 28:56But the way we vote is we we. We only put the name of the
- 29:00actor on the ballot. We don't beat in the film and I
- 29:04was voting for her for The Dark Knight Rises not for Les Mis
- 29:08although she's very good in Les Mis.
- 29:10And then at the end when I when an actor wins if they've been in
- 29:13other movies that could potentially qualify.
- 29:16We take a vote on whether to include those other movies and
- 29:19and of course because. New Film Critics Circle is full
- 29:24of snobs. You know, they they struck down
- 29:28the idea of including The Dark Knight Rises, your award
- 29:32citation. But this, this was my early
- 29:35years in the Circle. So in future years I became a
- 29:37little more aware of this, the way this phenomenon worked.
- 29:41But at the time, I felt so angry because I was like, but wait a
- 29:43minute, she got my vote for that movie.
- 29:45Like I was voting for her in that movie.
- 29:49It's kind of. Bogus that like, we can't then
- 29:52include that in the citation because you know, my vote help
- 29:54put her over the top, whatever. But I think she's great by the
- 29:58way, but. If you need to keep talking this
- 30:03through like we're happy to listen.
- 30:05We can help you work through this trauma.
- 30:08But the but the thing about Rebecca Hall in The Prestige is
- 30:11that, you know, she has to like you said.
- 30:14I mean, what she has to do is really difficult.
- 30:17One, she doesn't get a ton of screen time, but also she has to
- 30:23express an emotional reality that we at that point do not
- 30:28have access to. Right.
- 30:30So it almost feels like a flaw in the film's design at first,
- 30:34right? Because we're like, and she's
- 30:36like, do you love me? Yes, I do Not today.
- 30:40You know, or today you mean it, you know that whole thing, which
- 30:43we don't yet know what's going on.
- 30:45Right. So it feels like this weird sort
- 30:48of emotional situation that she's in.
- 30:52Like it's it feels like a problem that she has, but
- 30:56because we're not seeing enough of their relationship at that
- 30:59point And you know, I mean and and Dale is a very good actor.
- 31:03I I mean I think Dale was like, you know, possibly the greatest
- 31:06actor of his generation, but he's not.
- 31:09That nuanced an actor because at that point we're not aware of
- 31:11like the fact that it's two different guys right And and
- 31:16it's it's funny because it's this delayed emotional reaction
- 31:20to her. So by the end of the film fog
- 31:23performance the gains a kind of retrospective gravity but while
- 31:31she's while her character is alive.
- 31:34We might sort of be wondering like, what's what's what's going
- 31:37on here? Like, what's what's her problem
- 31:38here? And there's a way to do that.
- 31:42I mean, she could have done that in such a way that it just came
- 31:45off as laughable and completely old.
- 31:48But she doesn't like, like, we buy it.
- 31:50Like we understand that she's we understand that she's unhappy
- 31:54and that she's conflicted and that she doesn't really know
- 31:56what's going on. And that feels very sincere.
- 32:00Even though we don't have the full picture yet and I think
- 32:03that's that's actually very high degree of difficulty both for
- 32:06the filmmaker and for the for the actor And this idea of
- 32:10delayed reactions and kind of delayed knowledge, I mean it's
- 32:14an idea that runs throughout Nolan's films, you know, I mean
- 32:18he I interviewed him recently and he said, you know delayed
- 32:21reaction is just kind of like what all my movies are about,
- 32:24you know, and. And if you watch him, I mean
- 32:28that's that's exactly, you know that.
- 32:30I mean if you watch him with that eye, it's like that's the
- 32:32structure of every one of his films.
- 32:35So. So in that sense, I mean I think
- 32:37The Prestige works beautifully and and it is really, you know,
- 32:41it's like a magic trick. I mean there are all these
- 32:42things that he's, he's like he's all these balls he's got up in
- 32:45the air and all these things he's juggling and you kind of
- 32:48don't know where it's going. And then by the end it all, I
- 32:51mean it all just comes together so beautifully for me at least.
- 32:55Yeah, I think that's what's so beautiful about her performance
- 32:57is that she is getting gas lit, right?
- 33:00Like, like super hardcore by the man who loves her and by the man
- 33:06who is pretending to be the man who loves her.
- 33:08Like they're both gaslighting the heck out of her.
- 33:10But the crazy thing that he pulls off is like we as the
- 33:15audience think that she's the crazy one.
- 33:18Like and and and. I just don't know how you pull
- 33:21that off as a performer to be able to.
- 33:24Show what it's like to get gas lit and you, the audience
- 33:27member, don't even realize that you're partaking in the gas
- 33:30lighting until it's like, way too far gone.
- 33:35Yeah. Yeah.
- 33:37On the other hand, let's talk about Scarlett Johansson.
- 33:39And I don't know that we need to spend a ton of time on this, but
- 33:42I think this is the movie where I realized that Scarlett
- 33:45Johansson was like like a capital letters movie star.
- 33:49And I'm gonna say this in the nicest way I can.
- 33:51It's cuz I think this is probably one of her weakest
- 33:53performances. Like she's just she doesn't do
- 33:55the accent well. She doesn't have a ton to do in
- 33:57this movie. And yet when someone is a star
- 34:03of the caliber of Scarlett Johansson, it's almost like.
- 34:07I don't know how to explain it, Brad.
- 34:08It's like you forgive them because even when they're off as
- 34:11a character, they still succeed at being Scarlett Johansson.
- 34:15Do you know what I'm saying? Like, it's like when when Tom
- 34:18Hanks every once in a while you're like, I don't know, he
- 34:20seems miscast in Road to Perdition or whatever.
- 34:22But then it's like, oh, but it's Tom Hanks and I still will watch
- 34:25Tom Hanks do anything I want. You know what I mean?
- 34:27Like, and this is, I think that kind of Scarlett Johansson
- 34:31performance for me, where I certainly wouldn't rank it among
- 34:34her best, but like. She's she's very enjoyable to
- 34:39watch in everything she does. Yeah, I I guess I would agree
- 34:44with you just from the sense that out of all the actors in
- 34:48this film, I think I probably would have the least notes on
- 34:51Scar Joe. I just think she's incredible
- 34:54and everything that she does. She is truly one of my favorite
- 34:58actresses. So I I really like her here.
- 35:01I think she does a great job. Particularly in the scene where
- 35:05she goes to Borden, Christian Bale's character, and like tells
- 35:10him the quote UN quote truth, but then the actual truth.
- 35:14And then when they return to that scene later in the film,
- 35:16like that whole scene between her and Christian Bale, you can
- 35:21feel the raw energy within her. And I think that's probably her
- 35:25best scene in the movie. She doesn't.
- 35:30I mean, you're right in that she doesn't ultimately have.
- 35:33That much to do in the film. I mean, I think she's very good,
- 35:37but she is, you know, she kind of has almost like a dimension
- 35:41removed because she's not conflicted in the way that the
- 35:44other characters are. I mean, she's conflicted in the
- 35:46way that she has the changing loyalties from one to the other.
- 35:49In that sense, she almost foreshadows Michael Caine,
- 35:52right? I mean she's kind of a, you
- 35:55know, when he's not on screen, she's kind of an audience
- 35:57surrogate as well, I guess. But but I'm all, I'm, I'm with
- 36:01you. Brad and in the sense that I
- 36:03mean she can do no wrong. I I think she's an incredible
- 36:06actor and you know the year that I mean I thought that was just
- 36:11an incredible year she had with marriage story and JoJo Rabbit
- 36:16and yet so many people just like dunked on her and I was just
- 36:19like you are all going to regret this one day.
- 36:23I mean this is this is a person working with the highest level
- 36:26of of their art form. Yeah, I was going to say
- 36:28Marriage Story and JoJo Rabbit A2.
- 36:32Incredible movies, but be two incredible performances from
- 36:35Scarlet. Incredible performances, yeah.
- 36:39And you know, it's just, it's so weird because because she kind
- 36:43of got on the Marvel train and got on the Marvel train in a way
- 36:47that I mean. Belatedly, she got her own
- 36:51movie. But for a long time she was the
- 36:54one who didn't get her own movie, right.
- 36:55And so she she never quite got the, I don't know, it's like she
- 37:00never quite got the the respect or the, you know, the the box
- 37:04office sort of that's that. Maybe some of the others did.
- 37:09Yeah, yeah, it was almost like she.
- 37:11Was she? She was in every single.
- 37:13And then she got killed. Right.
- 37:19I was going to say it, it was almost like she was undermined
- 37:21from from both sides, right? Like she lost the respect of
- 37:24certain people who wanted her to avoid Marvel films.
- 37:28But then she never quite gained the Marvel fans respect either
- 37:31for the reason you're saying. Like she was never headlining a
- 37:34movie for them. And so yeah, kind of easy to
- 37:36forget about in some of those movies.
- 37:37Yeah. And she was, you know, I mean,
- 37:39you remember. I mean, she was, she was in art
- 37:41house darling, right. I mean, she was in, you know,
- 37:43she was in, you know, Ghost World.
- 37:46And I mean, it was, it was. Well, okay, let's talk about the
- 37:51two leads before we go to break, because, you know, we've already
- 37:53talked about Christian Bale a little bit.
- 37:55I've been kind of chomping at the bit to talk about Hugh
- 37:57Jackman because my, my hottest take on this movie is that I
- 38:01think this is Hugh Jackman's performance in this film is one
- 38:04of the best performances in any Nolan film.
- 38:06And I'm quite honestly shocked that Jackman and Nolan never
- 38:10worked together again after this Hugh Jackman.
- 38:16Brad, we've talked a lot about, like Jack Nicholson and how we
- 38:19always mentioned that the key to Jack Nicholson is that he's
- 38:22really good at portraying anger. Like when when Jack gets angry,
- 38:25it's just something that is. And I think with with Hugh
- 38:28Jackman, it's even more specific than that.
- 38:30It's not just like blind rage, which he does have, but it is
- 38:35exuding, like bitterness, like deepseeded bitterness.
- 38:39And I think about. The look he gives Christian Bale
- 38:43when he shows up at the like mausoleum and and man it's the
- 38:47same look that he is giving throughout Prisoners.
- 38:51I don't know if you've ever got around to seeing Prisoners.
- 38:53Brad might be my favorite Hugh Jackman performance.
- 38:56He is just he's and that's why he works as Wolverine, right.
- 38:59I hate to keep bringing this back to comic book movies but it
- 39:01seems kind of unavoidable today. The reason he works is Wolverine
- 39:06is like he's able to channel this deep seated bitterness and
- 39:09anger towards everything around him and it this is the perfect
- 39:12combination of him being sleazy, him being a showman, and him
- 39:17channeling that sort of rage that made him famous.
- 39:21I think this is like the Platonic ideal of a Hugh Jackman
- 39:25performance. Yeah, I was.
- 39:27I was going to come in today and say the same thing, Bob.
- 39:29I like, I think Hugh Jackman steals the show here and I
- 39:33freaking love Christian Bale in this movie.
- 39:35But Hugh Jackman, I I think the reason I love his performance so
- 39:40much is because he starts off so optimistic.
- 39:45Right. Like the the kiss that he gives
- 39:47to his wife on her leg while he's tying up her feet and and
- 39:50the way they interact and the way, you know, they have that
- 39:53banter when she gives him the name, the great Danton like
- 39:57that. There's just so much in that
- 39:58that is lighthearted and fun and and honestly like just cutesy
- 40:04and you don't really get a lot of that and Nolan films and so
- 40:07to see him move from that. To someone who is willing to
- 40:11clone and kill himself night after night for 100 nights
- 40:15straight so that he can, you know, ruin the life of his
- 40:20enemy, it's it's a descent unlike many we've seen in Cinema
- 40:25Bob. Yeah, the thing about Hugh
- 40:27Jackman that that I think he's really good at is is a kind of
- 40:32like righteous anger, right? He's got justified rage.
- 40:34I mean, I know I would. I would contrast him with Jack
- 40:38Nicholson, who is. It was just like who came out of
- 40:43the womb angry at the world. And that's that's always Jack's
- 40:47thing is he's just angry at the world.
- 40:49Which is why he became such a star in the late 60s, early 70s,
- 40:53when like everybody was just angry at the world.
- 40:56I mean, he, he captured that quality.
- 40:58And then later as the 70s wore on and then the 80s came about,
- 41:03you know, his his anger, there was a kind of distanced, almost
- 41:06snarkiness to it, which was. So perfectly, which so perfectly
- 41:11encapsulated the way that the Boomer generation just like
- 41:15checked out a kind of any kind of sense of, you know, social
- 41:22justice or, you know, world betterment or anything like
- 41:27that. I mean, it was, it became sort
- 41:28of a perfect, even though he's much older than the yuppies, but
- 41:31he became kind of a perfect yuppie icon as a result.
- 41:35Whereas Hugh Jackman, I mean, Hugh Jackman is in that sense,
- 41:38he's kind of a perfect superhero because the superhero is always
- 41:41angry about something right there.
- 41:42He would have actually made a great Batman, but but you know,
- 41:47he's got justified anger. There's always something that
- 41:49sets him off and and once it does, you know it, it it makes
- 41:54perfect sense. I mean you can really sort of,
- 41:57you know, click into his anger and that's I think what makes
- 42:00him special and why, why I think he's so good here.
- 42:04I mean, you really buy him as a man.
- 42:05Just completely obsessed. Yeah.
- 42:08All right. Bill, you you have just said a
- 42:10minute ago that you think Christian Bale might be the best
- 42:12actor of his generation. I'd like to just hear.
- 42:16I hate to pit the two of them against each other, but if you
- 42:18had to pick the better performance in this movie, who
- 42:21would you go with? In this movie?
- 42:23Yeah. I mean, I think it's Bale.
- 42:29I think they're both great. I mean they're both, they're
- 42:30both really great. Sorry.
- 42:31There's like fireworks going off here.
- 42:34They're they're both great. I think they all because he has
- 42:40to. I mean they both have secrets,
- 42:42right. Like each character has a secret
- 42:45that is sort of haunting them and that is that is driving us
- 42:49and and also feels like you know as we watch their performance
- 42:53like we can tell that there's something they're keeping from
- 42:55us that we're going to find out about I think with.
- 42:58With bail, there's a bit more of it.
- 42:59There is a bit more of a an unreadability to him, but but
- 43:04not a, you know, not a not an unreadability that works against
- 43:09the performance and unreadability that makes us more
- 43:12interested in in what's going on with him.
- 43:14But I mean it's very close. I mean I probably, you know,
- 43:18they're probably. You know, every time I see the
- 43:21movie, I might change my opinion on who's who's better, right?
- 43:24Because because Jackman also, you know, in the second-half of
- 43:26the film especially, you know Jack, Jackman is also hiding
- 43:29something from us and he's haunted in a way that that he
- 43:34isn't early on, right. I mean, the the scene that I
- 43:37always think about with this film, I can't remember the exact
- 43:40line, but you know, it's after Jackman goes to see The
- 43:46Transported Man for the first time.
- 43:49And before we see the actual act, there was just like, I
- 43:54can't remember if it's like a zoom in on his face or not.
- 43:56But before, like he says, you know, I went to see an act today
- 44:01and he was like it was the greatest magic trick I've.
- 44:02Ever seen he? Says that before we see it and
- 44:05we totally believe it. Like at that point, I mean that
- 44:08does such a great job of setting up The Transported Man and we
- 44:13kind of need that, even though they even though it's an
- 44:15incredible magic trick, but we need somebody to say.
- 44:18This is a whole other level. Of Well, it's somebody that we
- 44:22trust knows magic, right? You know what I mean?
- 44:26Well, that was that was the other thing I was going to say
- 44:27is like this structurally this script does such a good job of
- 44:32putting its thumb on the scale of either of these guys at
- 44:35different times so that the audience is sympathizing with
- 44:37each of them and root kind of actively rooting against the
- 44:41other at other parts of the movie.
- 44:42And I'm thinking in particular about the fact that like.
- 44:45When Tesla leaves the machine to him and is warning him and
- 44:49warning him and he says, you know, Tesla knew that his
- 44:52warnings would go unheeded. You get this great scene of
- 44:55Jackman, like literally rolling up his sleeves and getting to
- 44:58work tinkering on the machine. And it's this great picture of
- 45:01like, you know, America versus Britain and like the American
- 45:05ingenuity and the the hardworking guy who's going to
- 45:08pull himself up and make something of himself and and win
- 45:12this battle. And as that's happening, they're
- 45:14intercutting it with essentially like the end of Christian Bale's
- 45:17marriage, where he seems to be at his most villainous as a
- 45:21character. And so I just love the way that
- 45:24Nolan makes the, I guess I would call the downfall of Jackman's
- 45:29character all the more tragic because at certain points of the
- 45:32movie, you're actively rooting for him.
- 45:35Yeah, I agree. I mean, and and, and that, you
- 45:38know, his obsessive journey into the, you know, into America.
- 45:44You know, the performance has to drive that to such an extent.
- 45:47I mean it's such a, I mean if you think with this story turns
- 45:51on a die, the guy writes Tesla on a piece of paper and the
- 45:55other guy goes to America and this is like what the 1870s.
- 46:00I mean this is not, this is not an easy trip.
- 46:03This isn't like, you know, I booked the flight.
- 46:05I mean this is like. He changes his life, right.
- 46:09I mean, you know, to to go into the American heartland in the
- 46:131870s from the UK, even though he is American, which is kind of
- 46:18funny, you know, that's a huge deal especially for someone who
- 46:22was who was fled from his background, right.
- 46:24I mean it's like and it's just like because Christian Bale
- 46:27wrote Tesla on a piece of paper like and to to sell that to us
- 46:33is, you know, that's that's again.
- 46:36It's a high high degree of difficulty situation there and
- 46:40and he does it you know we we totally buy that that this man
- 46:43would go to was effectively the ends of the earth in that age
- 46:49for this. Brad, I think this is a good
- 46:51place for us to hit pause. What do you say we tried this
- 46:54quarter Horse Bourbon, then we'll come back and keep
- 46:57chatting about The Prestige. Let's get to it.
- 47:06All right, everybody. Today we are looking at Quarter
- 47:09Horse Kentucky Bourbon Whiskey. They did not market the full
- 47:13horse, only one quarter of the horse.
- 47:15Brad, when you go to your horse butcher, you can ask them for a
- 47:19quarter horse. That's a great joke for people
- 47:24from Kentucky. I'm sure they love it.
- 47:27All right, so here's the thing about Quarter horse.
- 47:29I picked this up for us, Brad, when we made a trip to Kentucky
- 47:32and I stopped at one of my favorite stores in the world,
- 47:34Party Source. And up towards the front of
- 47:37Party Source, they have a huge section of little 50ML sample
- 47:41size bottles. You know, we used to call them
- 47:43airplane bottles, but you don't get them anymore.
- 47:46And it was all the major brands. It was like Maker's Mark and
- 47:49Jack Daniels. And then they had Quarter Horse.
- 47:52And I thought to myself like, well, I've never heard of this
- 47:54brand, but for them to be carried at such a major retailer
- 47:58and to have invested so much money in making these little
- 48:01tiny bottles. Like they must have a big
- 48:04conglomerate behind them. Maybe this is like a Heaven Hill
- 48:06brand or something that I've never heard of.
- 48:08So I picked a couple up for us. They were a dollar a piece.
- 48:11And I have come to find out that I know very little about this
- 48:14brand because they are not what I thought they were.
- 48:17Like, they're they're an Owensboro, KY distillery from my
- 48:20understanding, and I think that they're aging their bourbon more
- 48:25now than they were when we bought these samples about a
- 48:28year ago. I'm looking at their website.
- 48:30It says that their bourbon is now considered a straight
- 48:32bourbon, which would mean at least two years old.
- 48:35And the ones that we have in our hands do not say that.
- 48:37And in fact on the side and very small print it says aged a
- 48:41minimum of one year. So this is very young whiskey.
- 48:45Very excited to pair this with the Prestige.
- 48:48See if they can pull off a magic.
- 48:50Trick here. Oh man.
- 48:51Well we'll see about that. I don't have any mash bill info.
- 48:54I know that it says it's 46% ABV, so 92 proof.
- 48:58That's all we have to go with, Brad.
- 49:00That's about it, man. Yeah, I'm, I am not excited to
- 49:03get into this with you. I have been letting this kind of
- 49:06air out in my glass for a little while now.
- 49:08When I first poured it out, it had.
- 49:11I mean, I'm just going to be frank here and almost
- 49:14offensively young smell to it a like a a craft whiskey smell and
- 49:20also a young whiskey smell where it reminds me of some of those
- 49:25like, really bad whiskeys we've had.
- 49:27I will say that this one it had that it didn't quite have that
- 49:31like chemical Tarnex smell I've gotten before, but it smelled
- 49:35almost like artificial, like coconut hand lotion or
- 49:41something. It almost smelled like
- 49:42artificially sweet to to like mask how young and grainy it is.
- 49:48Yeah, yeah, I'm, I'm with you 100% and like every time I think
- 49:52about coconut hand oil. All I can think about is eating
- 49:55it, so this is going to be a great.
- 49:58Great experience and. I can already tell.
- 50:01Yeah, I don't like this on the nose, man.
- 50:02I'm sorry. I don't mean to cut you off, but
- 50:04I forgot to give it a score. I'm going to give it a 4 1/2 out
- 50:08of 10 on the nose. Yeah, I give it a 5 out of 10.
- 50:12It smelled like cherry Robitussin to me.
- 50:16There's the corn, there's the ethanol, and then this is a note
- 50:19that I've never given before, and it's a note that like.
- 50:23If you if you know, you know, you know it's it's it smells
- 50:29like barn. I just love that you described
- 50:33it as if you know, you know, you know.
- 50:35Yeah, yeah, it smells like barn Bob.
- 50:38Yeah. It does.
- 50:40That's all I'm going to say about that.
- 50:43Yeah, I think that's kind of what I mean when I call it grain
- 50:45forward, it's not Even so much grain forward.
- 50:46It's like, hey, forward. You know what I mean?
- 50:49Like what there is that, hey, yeah, 100%, man.
- 50:53Not great, and I'm sipping this live.
- 50:55I know you've tried it already, so I'm going to give it a sip
- 50:57while you influence me with your tasting notes.
- 51:01Yeah, honestly, the taste is not good.
- 51:04It tasted kind of like cheap red wine.
- 51:08Like like if you bought like a $4.00 bottle of red wine, it was
- 51:13it was kind of fruity. It tasted like sweet corn that
- 51:17didn't have any, like seasoning or butter on it, and it tasted
- 51:21like ethanol. So 4 1/2 great, great score for
- 51:26a one year aged whiskey. I don't know how to explain what
- 51:30just happened on my palate. It's almost like this whiskey
- 51:37rushed itself down my esophagus like it was the fastest tasting
- 51:42experience I've ever had. It was like sweet, sweet, sweet
- 51:45honey, vanilla. You swallow it, It's like a
- 51:48little bit of oak and then like, midway down my esophagus.
- 51:53It like detonated a bomb of like really, really prickly alcohol
- 51:59to the point where I was like, oh, the if like it mimicked the
- 52:02feel of like, acid reflux. You can hear me over here.
- 52:07I'm like struggling through it. I wouldn't call it a harsh
- 52:09whiskey, but it's like not complex at all.
- 52:13And then you don't notice what you've drank until like midway
- 52:17through the finish of it and then it like.
- 52:19Reignites this really prickly alcohol burn.
- 52:23I don't think this is a poor whiskey on the pallet, but it's
- 52:26nothing to write home about. I'll give that as six.
- 52:28The finish again, like I'm struggling through it.
- 52:32It doesn't taste bad, but the alcohol burn doesn't feel
- 52:36balanced out with the rest of the experience.
- 52:39It is a little bit harsh, so I'm going to give it a, I don't
- 52:43know, a 5 out of 10. Yeah, I actually gave it a 5 out
- 52:46of 10 as well in the finish. It's it's short, it's grainy,
- 52:49it's generically sweet. It does.
- 52:53It's not the most offensive part of the whiskey, but it's not
- 52:57good for balance. I give it a four out of 10.
- 53:01I actually think this is well balanced in the sense that it's
- 53:03all bad, but I'm not going to give it a good score because
- 53:08it's the the, the the well balanced experience all the way
- 53:13through. I don't know if we're just like
- 53:15finally living into our truest selves.
- 53:17Brad, we're usually not this curt with our comments on a
- 53:21whiskey. But like folks, I really am
- 53:24enjoying our conversation with Bill good today and I really
- 53:27want to get back to that. And I just don't like this
- 53:29whiskey. It's not it's not great.
- 53:32I will give it a 5 out of 10. On the balance, I think that
- 53:35with some time, this actually could be a pretty good whiskey.
- 53:38Like, it doesn't taste like offensively young or anything.
- 53:42It's just a really young whiskey that tastes harsh right now
- 53:45because it needs time to mellow out.
- 53:46At four years, this might be good at one year, which we have
- 53:50it at, Not great. So it's a 5 out of 10 for me,
- 53:53and that brings us to value. Now, like I said, we were
- 53:56drinking one dollar's worth of this.
- 53:58Brad, how much is a 750ML bottle of this?
- 54:03It is. $30 Bob. It's hard to give it a a true
- 54:07value score because I know that they're releasing a more aged
- 54:11version of it now. Yeah.
- 54:13If this what we have was magnified up to 750, I would not
- 54:19pay $30.00 for this. I I mean if this was like 15
- 54:21bucks, I'd be like all right, cool, give it a shot.
- 54:24I know it's a craft distiller and honestly $30.00 for a craft
- 54:27whiskey is not bad at all, but the whiskey itself is not good,
- 54:32so I'm going to give it. I don't know.
- 54:35I'll be generous. I'll give it a six out of 10 on
- 54:37value. Bob, this is a one out of 10 on
- 54:42value bro. $30.00 for this. Come on, come on I.
- 54:47Guess what I'm saying? That their two year product is
- 54:49better? Yeah.
- 54:50But I'm going to give it fine. I'll give it a 1 1/2 out of 10.
- 54:55I think the only reason I'm giving it, you know we it's our
- 54:57our classic thing of like how we consider value.
- 55:00I don't know that a craft distiller, well, I don't know
- 55:02that a craft distiller. Can make it can produce a
- 55:07bourbon for less than like a $30 price point.
- 55:10Like this is pretty you got to admit, when you think about like
- 55:13all the craft distillers we've ever sampled from their bourbons
- 55:16are always like $45.00 because it's it's really hard for them
- 55:19to make a profit off of this. So like this is already like
- 55:22bottom, bottom, bottom tier pricing for a craft whiskey and
- 55:27I'm trying to at least give him credit for that because it's not
- 55:29like they're trying to upcharge people too much.
- 55:32But you're right, I don't think it's worth $30.
- 55:35I'm coming out to a Go ahead. I have 3 words for them make
- 55:41better whiskey. Man, you are like you're on one
- 55:44today, dude. Jeez.
- 55:46Well, there goes the possibility of us ever working with the
- 55:49quarter horse whiskey folks. I am not going to be quite as
- 55:53harsh. I'm coming out to a 26.5 out of
- 55:5650. What are you coming out to,
- 55:57Brad? I came out to on the dot a 20
- 56:02out of 50. So we're at a 46 1/2 out of 100.
- 56:06This is, folks, one of the lowest rated whiskeys we have
- 56:10ever had on film and whiskey. And I it feels weird to say
- 56:14that, Brad, because I know for a fact we've had significantly
- 56:17worse whiskey than this one. But I mean, there's nothing to
- 56:21write home about with this whiskey.
- 56:23It's, you know, it needs more time.
- 56:25It just does. Bottom line, end of story.
- 56:28Yeah, this is a whiskey that needs more time and a lot of
- 56:32things, Bob. It's not good.
- 56:35You know what is good? What's?
- 56:36That the prestige. The Prestige is so good, man.
- 56:40It's such a it's just so entertaining.
- 56:43Let's get back into talking about that.
- 56:44What do you say, Brad? Let's get to it.
- 56:52All right, everybody. That was Quarter Horse a whiskey
- 56:54that I refuse to say another word about.
- 56:58All right, There it is. Man.
- 57:00I'll, I'll say a couple more words.
- 57:02Not great whiskey, Brad. No, you didn't have to say.
- 57:06Yep, Yep, I see what you're doing.
- 57:08All right, on that note, I will segue us into our next segment,
- 57:11which we call 2 facts and a falsehood.
- 57:14Brad is gonna try to stumpy ball.
- 57:19You are right and what is wrong? 2 facts and a falsehood. 2 Facts
- 57:24and a Falsehood is the part of the show where Brad presents
- 57:27three items to me as fact about the making of this movie, one of
- 57:30which is a total lie and it is my job to suss out which one is
- 57:34the fabrication. I thankfully have a big fan of
- 57:38the movie here today that seems to have some inside knowledge
- 57:41about this movie, so Bilga will be my phone, a friend on the day
- 57:45if I need some help. Brad, I am sitting right around
- 57:47500 on the season. You've been doing a pretty good
- 57:50job keeping me in check this time around, man.
- 57:53Yeah, I I think that we are like evenly matched at this point and
- 57:58honestly that makes it a little more enjoyable for me, I think.
- 58:00It's like it truly is a microcosm of the Prestige.
- 58:04Like I you have metaphorically shot off two of my fingers and
- 58:08and I'm coming for you at this point.
- 58:11Is is this podcast just going to end with us murdering each other
- 58:14somehow? Do you have a twin brother out
- 58:16there? Little do you know, man, can we?
- 58:21Just like they don't talk about this at all.
- 58:24But like, was this really just a plot for the twin brothers to
- 58:27both have sex with multiple women?
- 58:31Christopher Nolan and his brother writing this screenplay,
- 58:33or like, you know, it would be awesome.
- 58:36Because if we could tell our life story same time, I'm sorry,
- 58:41I can't. Be the only person that thought
- 58:44about that. This is this is basically
- 58:46Christopher Nolan's version of Vicky Cristina Barcelona.
- 58:49Exactly. Exactly.
- 58:50Like we can get very Freudian with this movie.
- 58:53And I feel like we will before the day is over, Brad, but at
- 58:56the moment. You have a task ahead of you,
- 58:59and that is to lie to me and I hopefully will be able to figure
- 59:03out which one is the lie. Hit me with your two facts in a
- 59:05falsehood. Fact #1 Chung Ling Su was a
- 59:09stage character in real life created by William Ellsworth
- 59:13Robinson, a white man who disguised himself as a Chinese
- 59:16man to cash in on audiences enthusiasm for the exotic.
- 59:20He lived as Chung, never breaking character while in
- 59:22public. But he died in 1918 when a
- 59:26bullet catch trick went wrong, saying my God, I've been shot,
- 59:31which were both his last words on the on the stage and the
- 59:34first English he had spoken in 19 years.
- 59:37That's a heck of a that's a good one.
- 59:39That's a good one. Man, yeah, even if you made that
- 59:41up, I got to say that. Nicely done.
- 59:44Fact #2. Ridley Scott was initially
- 59:47attached to direct this film in the early 2000s and had hired
- 59:51Jonathan Nolan to write the film.
- 59:53He chose, however, to work on other projects, and Jonathan
- 59:56suggested the project to his brother Fact #3.
- 1:00:00When Alfred is in prison, his inmate number is D23.
- 1:00:05The movie was released by Touchstone Pictures, a Disney
- 1:00:08subsidiary, and D 23 is the official Disney fan club 23,
- 1:00:13referring to 1923, the year Walt Disney opened the studio.
- 1:00:18So. Are you saying that it's an
- 1:00:20intentional reference or just like something fun?
- 1:00:23I believe it is an intentional reference.
- 1:00:25Got it, got it. But the person on IMDb who wrote
- 1:00:28that, you know, I I don't know what was going on in their mind.
- 1:00:31Sure, sure, sure. OK, Bilga, I think #1 is true.
- 1:00:37It at least sounds true. It is dense enough that I don't
- 1:00:40think Brad took the time to write all that down.
- 1:00:42That is rude. One sounds true to me too.
- 1:00:46Yes, Not having not having met you before, Brad.
- 1:00:51Just going to stay. You know that the, the, the.
- 1:00:55I don't see that intelligent. Is that what you're saying?
- 1:00:57You seem like a guy that cuts a lot of corners, That's what he
- 1:00:59said. I'm saying, you know what I'm
- 1:01:03saying. This doesn't seem like a thing
- 1:01:04that he would have put that much effort into.
- 1:01:07Believe me, you are you are correct.
- 1:01:09It does feel right, but it also feels it does feel like a piece
- 1:01:12of like great Magic lore, like it feels it feels true in that
- 1:01:17sense. #2 is one that I'm kind of circling here because I know
- 1:01:22just from skimming the Wikipedia page before we press record that
- 1:01:26there were other filmmakers attached to this project.
- 1:01:28The one that I saw was Sam Mendes, which I think would have
- 1:01:31been made for really interesting and and probably not as great
- 1:01:34movie. But I did not see Ridley Scott
- 1:01:37attached, and so I'm kind of circling that as a potential
- 1:01:40okay. Maybe not #3.
- 1:01:44I'm struggling to figure out, like, how it even applies to
- 1:01:47this movie. Like like, oh cool.
- 1:01:49The letters D23 sometimes mean something else, so Bill got I'm
- 1:01:54really waffling back and forth between 2:00 and 3:00, but I'm
- 1:01:58I'm kind of leaning towards 2. Do you have a sense in your mind
- 1:02:02of which one is the falsehood? I'm I think.
- 1:02:06I think 2 is the falsehood. And I say that despite the fact
- 1:02:11that I know that Ridley Scott is a is a serial developer and
- 1:02:15serial attacher of himself to things.
- 1:02:19So it feels like it it could very well be trained.
- 1:02:23But that's also why I think it might be false, Whereas the
- 1:02:28other thing is just to to it's it's it's too stupid to not
- 1:02:33like, it's too stupid to not be a thing that people talk about
- 1:02:36like I'm. Like so.
- 1:02:37So what? You're saying Bilga is?
- 1:02:40Either the facts are too smart for me to write or too stupid
- 1:02:43for me to write. No, no, it's not that.
- 1:02:47It's it's it's it's it feels like the kind I you know what it
- 1:02:50is. I'm what I'm saying is you're
- 1:02:52too smart to have come up with a falsehood like 3.
- 1:02:56Ah, thanks. I'm like if you are going to
- 1:02:58come up with a falsehood, you would have come up with a better
- 1:03:01like a more intelligent falsehood than three, which just
- 1:03:04sounds like some random thing that some idiot on the Internet
- 1:03:07said. I am half inclined to just say
- 1:03:10three's the falsehood just so we can stop stroking Brad's ego
- 1:03:13here for a minute. Let's see.
- 1:03:16I'm going to say Two's the falsehood, Brad.
- 1:03:18I'm going to lock it in as my final answer.
- 1:03:21I think that this is the happiest I've been to say that
- 1:03:24you're right. Hey.
- 1:03:27This I will say normally 2 facts in a falsehood is a roller
- 1:03:31coaster for Bob. That was a roller coaster for
- 1:03:34me. Guys.
- 1:03:34I I'm feeling, I'm feeling emotionally drained right now.
- 1:03:40It was. It was a combo of getting beat
- 1:03:42up emotionally and then getting affirmed at the end, you know?
- 1:03:45Yeah, I really got you. Yeah, you guys.
- 1:03:47Pulled the rug out from under me and then helped me up.
- 1:03:50Yeah, it's like we delivered a little prestige there at the
- 1:03:53end. Exactly.
- 1:03:56All right, here's here's the thing I want to talk about.
- 1:03:59Here's my question for you. So I was reading Roger Ebert's
- 1:04:04review on this because at this point, if the movie has a review
- 1:04:07by Ebert, I have to read it. And he he gave it three stars.
- 1:04:12And the final part of his his commentary I thought was
- 1:04:15fascinating because he basically docked this movie a star because
- 1:04:21at the end of the day, it wasn't.
- 1:04:26How do I want to say it? There was actual magic involved,
- 1:04:31right? Like he like, he is getting
- 1:04:33cloned. And I I think that the way Roger
- 1:04:36presented it was like I wanted it all to be a trick at the end
- 1:04:41that, you know, was manufactured because that's the whole point
- 1:04:43of magic tricks. Like we're not in the 1800s
- 1:04:46anymore. We don't think that these things
- 1:04:48are, you know, truly supernatural magic.
- 1:04:52And I thought that that was a fascinating point and it it it
- 1:04:56took me to this point. Where I'm wondering, like at the
- 1:05:00end of the film there's a clear villain, right?
- 1:05:02Like Hugh Jackman is the villain of this movie and Christian Bale
- 1:05:06is is cast upon with a A merciful light by the end of the
- 1:05:11film. Is this movie a commentary on
- 1:05:15CGI? Yes, it is that Brad, thank you
- 1:05:19for that. This was going to be my big
- 1:05:22think piece pitch to Bilga and Vulture for the end of this.
- 1:05:26No, but I I really do think that there is a particular reason.
- 1:05:30And and Ebert was not alone in this, in his criticism of the
- 1:05:33movie, he basically argues that Nolan stops playing by his own
- 1:05:38rules, the rules of the world that he's created by introducing
- 1:05:41A literal like Deus Ex machina. At the end of the like there's a
- 1:05:45machine that clones somebody. We did not know that that this
- 1:05:47universe operated it within this set of rules.
- 1:05:51Right. I mean, it's almost like a
- 1:05:52Tarantino, like, oh, by the way, we killed Hitler, right?
- 1:05:55Like, oh, I didn't realize that this was a.
- 1:05:56Historical fix, we can do that, Yeah.
- 1:05:59And and I was reading another review that basically the poll
- 1:06:02quote from it was like, I don't mind science fiction.
- 1:06:05I just want to know that that's what I'm watching.
- 1:06:08And so there were a number of critics that felt kind of duped
- 1:06:11by the end of this movie. I think that's intentional.
- 1:06:14And I think that like, if you're going to take the Freudian O
- 1:06:18tourist reading of this movie. The person that breaks the
- 1:06:23rules, the person that can't get one up on Christian Bale by
- 1:06:27playing fair, is the guy who introduces new technology into
- 1:06:32the mix. And Christian Bale and
- 1:06:34Christopher Nolan has gone on record and become one of the
- 1:06:38biggest champions for filming movies on film and preserving
- 1:06:42movies that are shot on film like he he has become.
- 1:06:47I think probably more than anybody else, except maybe
- 1:06:50Scorsese, like the champion of the analog as opposed to the
- 1:06:54digital and this movie. If you want to take that
- 1:06:57reading, I think you could look at that Hugh Jackman character
- 1:07:00and say that's exactly what what Nolan was trying to do, was to
- 1:07:04present this guy as you're cheating by trying to introduce
- 1:07:09this entire new system. You can't do it better than
- 1:07:13somebody, and so you cheat, and the cheating is the introduction
- 1:07:16of these. Computer, you know, facsimile
- 1:07:20movies that are being churned out from the time this movie is
- 1:07:24made to now. I really do think that's a
- 1:07:25legitimate reading of the movie, Brad.
- 1:07:29I'm just gonna, I'm just gonna soak in that for a minute.
- 1:07:31Watch Bill go, come in and be like, yeah, that's not a that's
- 1:07:33not a legitimate. Are idiots.
- 1:07:37I think that's a really interesting reading.
- 1:07:39I mean, I I think I I don't know that that's what he was thinking
- 1:07:44of. Like in the moment.
- 1:07:47Like in the moment, but, but, but I mean, I think, I think you
- 1:07:51know having watched his films and and you know having read
- 1:07:55interviews with him and things like that.
- 1:07:56I mean there is a kind of how do I say this without without
- 1:08:03sounding like a criticism but there is a kind of you know
- 1:08:05almost a Burkean conservative quality to Nolan, a sense of
- 1:08:10like. You know, preserving the past,
- 1:08:14they're preserving aspects of the past and and being, you
- 1:08:17know, somewhat skeptical of of technology.
- 1:08:21I mean, it's not, I mean it's in, it's in all his movies,
- 1:08:25right. The idea that that knowledge can
- 1:08:28be a dangerous thing or the idea of the machine that must not be
- 1:08:32used, right. I mean, I think he's fascinated
- 1:08:35by the stuff. I think he's fascinated by the
- 1:08:37idea of. You know, science and the idea
- 1:08:41of progress and the idea of, you know, can we build this thing?
- 1:08:47Can we can we do this thing? Like, these are all ideas that
- 1:08:51that I think he's, he's engaged with throughout his career.
- 1:08:54But then there's also this like, Oh my God, what have we done?
- 1:08:57Right. I mean, you see it in the, you
- 1:08:58see it in the dark night, right, with with Batman's like the
- 1:09:01citywide sonar that he creates at the end of the film, which,
- 1:09:04you know, a lot of people. We're critical of the film for
- 1:09:08that because they were like, oh, this is a justification for Bush
- 1:09:11era surveillance. I was like, no, it's actually
- 1:09:13like a criticism of Bush era surve.
- 1:09:14Yeah, exactly. Like it's it's a thing that in
- 1:09:17many ways it's it's that man's moral downfall that he uses that
- 1:09:21thing and he and he and you know he asks that it be destroyed.
- 1:09:25And in many ways it's one of the reasons why he exiles himself
- 1:09:30from Gotham at the end of the film.
- 1:09:32You know it's kind of. You know, allows himself to be
- 1:09:34punished and and thought of as a murderer because because of the
- 1:09:38the guilt that he feels over this thing.
- 1:09:41So and you know, I mean you know people will see, I mean anybody
- 1:09:45that knows the story of Robert Oppenheimer is like that.
- 1:09:49I mean the machine that must not be used, the ultimate machine
- 1:09:52that must not be used in atom bomb you know and so I mean it's
- 1:09:57an idea that runs throughout no one's filmography and.
- 1:10:02And so there is that, there's that kind of fascination with
- 1:10:07and skepticism of that type of sort of quote UN quote
- 1:10:12scientific progress. I mean, it's not like it's not
- 1:10:14really scientific progress, but the idea that, you know, there
- 1:10:17are things we can do. And and if we take our knowledge
- 1:10:21and our research to their logical conclusion, like are we
- 1:10:25sure we're going to be happy with what we find, you know?
- 1:10:29Brad I I really do love the idea of these characters as sort of
- 1:10:34representative of Nolan in a way, though, And I think that
- 1:10:36there there are elements of the themes that we see throughout
- 1:10:40Nolan. So, like, if you want to read
- 1:10:41Nolan on to these characters, I think that final confrontation
- 1:10:45between the two, between Bale and Jackman, has such
- 1:10:48fascinating implications because they're both right and they're
- 1:10:51both wrong, and it's really. Jackman in a way that gets the
- 1:10:56last laugh, even though he's dying.
- 1:10:58And he he basically tells Christian Bale, like, you never
- 1:11:02understood why we do this. Like you're obsessed with the
- 1:11:06craft, you're obsessed with getting better, but you get no
- 1:11:10pleasure out of it, you get no enjoyment out of it.
- 1:11:12And he says, like I, I have a much more pessimistic outlook on
- 1:11:16the world, but what I get joy from is being able to fool these
- 1:11:21people for one second and seeing the look on their faces.
- 1:11:24And I've. I've been really struggling to
- 1:11:26figure out like, is does Nolan believe that, like is Nolan
- 1:11:29inserting himself into a character that he may not
- 1:11:33actually agree with his motivations on?
- 1:11:35Like, because I think I can't tell if he's associating himself
- 1:11:40more with bail or more with Jackman.
- 1:11:41Right. And it seems in a way, like
- 1:11:43Nolan's almost trying to teach himself something at the end of
- 1:11:46this movie. And I find it to be, you know,
- 1:11:49we have these movies every now and then, Brad, where we you and
- 1:11:51I just. You know, we had a field day
- 1:11:53with Spielberg. Like, every every movie with
- 1:11:55Spielberg is like, you could psychoanalyze the hell out of
- 1:11:57this, right? Yeah, I feel like this might.
- 1:11:59This movie in particular seems the most like a window into
- 1:12:05Nolan's psyche, but it's not always 100% clear what he's
- 1:12:11implicating himself in. Yeah, I mean, in in a certain
- 1:12:15sense, this is a movie about putting on performances, right?
- 1:12:18Like getting up on a stage and putting on a show for people
- 1:12:22where they suspend their disbelief.
- 1:12:24So like in a weird way, this is a movie about making movies.
- 1:12:27And I I think that with that in mind, you can definitely point
- 1:12:31to certain things and say like, yeah, Nolan is is most likely
- 1:12:35inserting himself into these places.
- 1:12:38I I think the fascinating thing for me is the idea of like.
- 1:12:41Jonathan and him as a as a duo like to me it's just fascinating
- 1:12:48that Jonathan continues to write these movies for him and the
- 1:12:52idea that they are a pair here like that is fascinating to me.
- 1:12:56To see played out in the prestige that these two brothers
- 1:12:59are so close that they're able to work together in such a
- 1:13:03capacity. Right.
- 1:13:05Like there's got to be something there, right?
- 1:13:06And to, you know, and to share a woman, you know, like, very
- 1:13:10crucially that is we, we cannot emphasize enough.
- 1:13:13That is the key to this whole Christopher had to like, sit
- 1:13:16down with his wife one night and be like, alright honey, like
- 1:13:19this isn't actually about please, please don't read too
- 1:13:22much into this movie, Brad, before we get into our last
- 1:13:26couple segments. I feel like I'm going to be the
- 1:13:30guy that I always hate hearing from.
- 1:13:33And that's the guy that's like, well, actually, I found some
- 1:13:36plot holes in this. I hate the plot hole guy, right?
- 1:13:38But I do think that the reason I will not give this movie like a
- 1:13:42perfect score and that I don't think it works perfectly is that
- 1:13:46while it's not reliant on the twist, there are implications of
- 1:13:50the twist that are kind of like, hold on a second, you know what
- 1:13:54I mean? Like.
- 1:13:55Why did Hugh Jackman just hold on to all of these bodies in the
- 1:13:59basement? Like, you know, you can't like,
- 1:14:01dump them in the river, like tie a brick to them or something.
- 1:14:04Like there are there's just a few unanswered questions that if
- 1:14:08you think about it for more than two seconds, it really does kind
- 1:14:11of harm the twist of the movie. I think that's ultimately why,
- 1:14:16like, the fact that the movie's not relying on the twist is a
- 1:14:18good thing. Because if it was relying on the
- 1:14:20twist, I think people could really, like, eviscerate this
- 1:14:23movie if they wanted to. But there's just something
- 1:14:25about, like, was the makeup on on the Twin really that
- 1:14:30convincing that they could kidnap him and bury him alive
- 1:14:35after, I'm assuming, roughing him up And, like, his false
- 1:14:38mustache never came off. Like, and they never noticed
- 1:14:41that he looked exactly like Christian Bale with a mustache.
- 1:14:44You know what I mean? Like, there are elements of the
- 1:14:46movie that it's you really got us stretch the limits of your
- 1:14:51belief. For me, the one thing that
- 1:14:53really stretched my belief was the fact that he just had made
- 1:14:59millions and millions of dollars off of his magic show so that he
- 1:15:04could go live in Colorado for six to 10 months and finance all
- 1:15:09of Nikola Tesla's stuff. Like that was the one thing
- 1:15:12where I was like, man, where did he get all this money?
- 1:15:14And then he comes back and he's able to establish himself as an
- 1:15:18English Lord. With like a castle and grounds
- 1:15:22and servants, I was just like, where did all this money come
- 1:15:26from? But isn't isn't his whole thing
- 1:15:29that, that, that that's actually like that he is actually he
- 1:15:34comes from money, right? Isn't that I thought that was
- 1:15:36the whole thing like. Yeah, like there's definitely
- 1:15:38class elements to it. That's because he does have that
- 1:15:41line where he says, like, you know, my family thought that
- 1:15:45this was too, you know, low for me.
- 1:15:47Yeah, like he's running from his his family well.
- 1:15:51No, you're probably right. I honestly didn't think about
- 1:15:53that. Yeah, but but you know that's
- 1:15:55that's fair. One thing that really pulls me
- 1:15:59out of the movie, and this is a complete aside, guys, is like
- 1:16:03when he's dressed up as the Twin, what's what's the guy's
- 1:16:06name that he calls himself as the Twin?
- 1:16:10Oh God, I forgot. Yeah, OK, whatever.
- 1:16:13You know, we'll call him Jeff when he's when he's dressed up
- 1:16:15as Jeff. They get, you know, he has these
- 1:16:18kind of like little pudgy chipmunk cheeks a little bit.
- 1:16:20He looks exactly like Charlie Day from It's Always Sunny in
- 1:16:24Philadelphia, like in Victorian garb.
- 1:16:28And there were a couple times that I was like how much better
- 1:16:31would this movie be with like a Day Man song inserted into it.
- 1:16:35You know, like I I could not get over, go back and watch it
- 1:16:38again. It's it's uncanny how much he
- 1:16:41looks like Charlie Day. Oh man, we need to get away from
- 1:16:44day man real quick, Bob. So I I actually have a a a plot
- 1:16:50hole as well. And it it, I think it only
- 1:16:53really dawned on me the last time I saw the film.
- 1:16:56Possibly it dawned on me before too and I just forgot about it.
- 1:16:58But so I mean, as we see in the opening scene of the film,
- 1:17:03Christian Bale, he's his character like it's, you know,
- 1:17:07Hugh Jackman is doing The Transported Man, Christian Bale.
- 1:17:12Goes down there, sees Hugh Jackman in the in the tub of
- 1:17:16water drowning. And he, you know, he tries to,
- 1:17:24you know bust through and he doesn't.
- 1:17:26And you know is is accused of killing Hugh Jackman.
- 1:17:33But like, given how quickly the the magic trick works, by that
- 1:17:37point Hugh Jackman would have been.
- 1:17:40Replicated already in the audience.
- 1:17:42And like, reemerged. Yeah. 100% emerged, right.
- 1:17:45So at that point, you can't blame it, like you can't accuse
- 1:17:48him of murdering the guy. After you have to reveal that
- 1:17:53there is another Hugh Jackman, right?
- 1:17:55I mean, it's it's that doesn't quite work for me.
- 1:17:58I think the implication there is that, like with most times where
- 1:18:02they're both undercover, the magician figures it at like.
- 1:18:07He I think he sees Christian Bale come up on stage and makes
- 1:18:10the split second decision of like I am not going to come out
- 1:18:14and reveal myself after I get cloned.
- 1:18:16I'm going to run off and start this new life because this is my
- 1:18:19opportunity to frame Christian Bale like that was at least my
- 1:18:24reading of it, right Like he made he made the decision
- 1:18:26because I I think the the cloning machine he recalibrates
- 1:18:31it so that instead of cloning him in place.
- 1:18:35The clone is the one that stays behind in place and gets dropped
- 1:18:37into the the water, and then the real Hugh Jackman is the one
- 1:18:40that gets shot into the back of the theater, right?
- 1:18:43Oh, see, I never thought that. They're both real.
- 1:18:46That's the thing. It's like, cuz, he says.
- 1:18:48I never knew if I was going to be the one to drown or not.
- 1:18:51Like that's that's the thing that's that's tearing him apart.
- 1:18:54Is that it? I mean, it's a it's a if you
- 1:18:56think about it, it's kind of an elegant counterpoint to the fact
- 1:19:00that. Christian Bale is living 2 lives
- 1:19:05like he's he's like dying a death.
- 1:19:08Like he's he's he's he's dying 2 deaths in a way.
- 1:19:11Like not two deaths, but like it's a kind of like, but it's
- 1:19:15like a mirror image of that, right?
- 1:19:18Because you know, Christian Bale never knows who's going to,
- 1:19:21who's living his life at any given moment.
- 1:19:23And then Christie Hugh Jackman doesn't know who's dying his
- 1:19:25death at any given moment. Yeah.
- 1:19:29So that's the thing. It's like she doesn't know
- 1:19:31because his consciousness is being fractured essentially.
- 1:19:35And there are two of them, but one dies.
- 1:19:39And that's, I mean that's fascinating because he doesn't
- 1:19:42know. He doesn't know like when he
- 1:19:43goes into the thing, that particular consciousness.
- 1:19:49Am I? Am I the one that's going to end
- 1:19:50up in the drink, or am I the one that's going to end up in the
- 1:19:53thing? Got it, got it.
- 1:19:54Honestly, it it almost feels like getting into a time travel
- 1:19:57conversation with your friends about like how time travel
- 1:20:01works, where you're like, well, if he if he's splitting, like is
- 1:20:04he an exact copy at the back of the at the back of the theater
- 1:20:08that like. Not only is an exact copy of
- 1:20:11knowing everything that the original knows, but also feeling
- 1:20:15everything that the original feels like, feeling the depth of
- 1:20:18hatred towards Christian Bale and and like, like, there's so
- 1:20:22many questions that I had coming out of the theater when I first
- 1:20:25watched this of like and it was all about the cloning.
- 1:20:28Like, I didn't, I didn't care about anything else in the film.
- 1:20:31I was like, I need to know how this cloning works.
- 1:20:34And now 15 years later, I'm like, oh, the movie's a lot more
- 1:20:37than that. Well, I mean it is, but it also
- 1:20:40it's like it ties directly into that, right.
- 1:20:42It it ties into this idea of the fractured self and and what that
- 1:20:47means for cloning and which is actually, you know, which I
- 1:20:50guess is a question if, you know, if cloning were to be
- 1:20:53possible, like that's that's the thing that we would have to be
- 1:20:55wrestling with. And but The Fractured Self is
- 1:20:57also this idea that runs throughout Nolan's movie.
- 1:20:59I mean the superhero movie is like Bruce Wayne and Batman.
- 1:21:03I'm talking about a fractured self and a guy who can't live.
- 1:21:06One full life, one fully realized life.
- 1:21:11I mean, you see a variation of it Inception.
- 1:21:13You see a variation of it in Interstellar, you see it in
- 1:21:17tenant, right? I mean, you know, the most
- 1:21:19powerful moment of tenant for me is, you know, at the end when
- 1:21:23they go back to the airport and we suddenly realized, oh, he was
- 1:21:26fighting himself in that scene. That scene is so powerful to me
- 1:21:31because it's like. Obviously within the context of
- 1:21:33the movie, it's about a specific thing and you know it's an
- 1:21:36action movie and whatnot. But like there's such a such
- 1:21:38great metaphorical power in that, you know and and I think
- 1:21:42Nolan is very much aware of it because he's been, he's been
- 1:21:45playing with this idea his whole life, right?
- 1:21:48And even even Memento. Oh yeah.
- 1:21:51Like who killed my wife? Oh, I did.
- 1:21:54You know, like. But I can't live with that.
- 1:21:57So let me Yeah, exactly right. So yeah, I mean it's just this
- 1:22:02thing in in in all his movies and I find that really powerful.
- 1:22:07But yeah, you know it's in the book.
- 1:22:08It's it really is it's it's a really great book.
- 1:22:12But it is so much more a novel than a film.
- 1:22:14And and and I actually, I gained even more respect for Nolan and
- 1:22:21and for Jonathan Nolan after I read the novel because I I just
- 1:22:24kept thinking to myself. There's so many changes they've
- 1:22:29made to the novel while sort of maintaining its spirit.
- 1:22:33Like the changes that they've made make it so much more
- 1:22:38effective as a film. But the novel, you could not
- 1:22:40adapt that novel straight into a movie.
- 1:22:43It just wouldn't work at all. It works beautifully as a novel.
- 1:22:48And it's so different like the film is so different in so many
- 1:22:51ways but but they've streamlined it and simplified it but then it
- 1:22:54expanded on certain other elements in the in the novel
- 1:22:57that are just briefly mentioned and and it really it's just it's
- 1:23:02a it's a wonderful adaptation in that sense.
- 1:23:04I mean if I ever like taught a class about you know adapting
- 1:23:08books to film, I would assign this one.
- 1:23:10Man, I'm really regretting not picking the book up before we
- 1:23:12recorded this one, Brad. Like.
- 1:23:14Yeah, you know, every once in a while I think you can get away
- 1:23:16with it. Like, yeah, I didn't really need
- 1:23:18to read the book because the movie's so good, but it sounds
- 1:23:20like they really, you know, it. It is.
- 1:23:23It's really interesting when it's a true adaptation, when
- 1:23:26it's not just lifted from page to screen.
- 1:23:28And they they do find ways to make it more cinematic.
- 1:23:32It sounds like that was the case here.
- 1:23:34Yeah, yeah, yeah. I mean, you don't have to read
- 1:23:35the book to to be able to appreciate the movie.
- 1:23:37So. So don't worry about the fact
- 1:23:38that you haven't read the book. But it is like if you do read
- 1:23:41the book, you gain a newfound, a different appreciation of it
- 1:23:44because it's like, oh wow, like what possessed them to to do
- 1:23:48this with this story element? You know, it's you'll, you'll
- 1:23:51read the book. I mean it's it's honestly, I
- 1:23:53read it in like 2 days and I'm not a fast reader at all and
- 1:23:56it's like 350 pages. It just breezes by.
- 1:24:00Well, guys, I think this is like a perfect segue into talking
- 1:24:02about a perfect movie to pair this up with.
- 1:24:05So Brad, let's get into our final segment of the day, which
- 1:24:08we call, let's make it a double. We're near the end of the
- 1:24:11episode, so thanks for listening to the film and whiskey show.
- 1:24:14Let's pair another film with this one.
- 1:24:16Even if it's struggle, it's a final segment of the day.
- 1:24:18Now let's make it a double. Like I said, let's make it a
- 1:24:21double is the part of the show where we paired this movie up
- 1:24:24with a second film to make the perfect double feature.
- 1:24:27Brad, as we have a guest with us today, I think we should let him
- 1:24:30go first. Bilga, we've been giving you
- 1:24:32some time to to ruminate, to marinate on this.
- 1:24:35What would you pair the Prestige with?
- 1:24:38You know, I went back and forth on this one.
- 1:24:42Obviously there are two sort of obvious examples that that I
- 1:24:45need that are not going to be my choice.
- 1:24:47But you know, we've talked about the illusionist.
- 1:24:49I mean it. The movie effectively was a
- 1:24:51double feature in that sense. You know Illusionist, which is
- 1:24:55the other period magic drama thriller that about obsession
- 1:25:00that that came out around the same time and which I think.
- 1:25:03Lows but. Haven't revisited since then,
- 1:25:08but was also seen by a lot of people as because Prestige was
- 1:25:11kind of like the studio movie and the illusionist was like the
- 1:25:13Sundance movie. So no, the Illusionist is like
- 1:25:16the real real good movie and Prestige is just.
- 1:25:20You know, studio fluff with movie stars and so.
- 1:25:26And then of course there's the, the obvious, also obvious double
- 1:25:29feature of Batman Begins, which was Christopher Nolan's other
- 1:25:32film this year, which is also about a fracture itself and
- 1:25:35about obsession and about trauma and, you know, righteous rage
- 1:25:44that. Kurdles into something worse.
- 1:25:47And I mean there's there's so many themes that are in both
- 1:25:50movies that you could create a great double feature of the two
- 1:25:53films. But the movie I'm going to go
- 1:25:55with is a movie made by a gentleman with whom I just
- 1:26:00published an interview that I think also makes movies about
- 1:26:05two opposing strong opposing personalities who in some ways.
- 1:26:10Can't live without each other, but are often trying to destroy
- 1:26:13one another, and that movie is John Woo's face off.
- 1:26:16Yes. Which is which is another movie
- 1:26:20that turns on like a scientific invention that seems utterly
- 1:26:25absurd and yet the film just kind of takes it as a matter of
- 1:26:28fact. But also is about like, I mean
- 1:26:32in in its own completely demented, entirely unknown like
- 1:26:36way, but is about like 2 characters.
- 1:26:39Who are kind of unable to live their their real lives because
- 1:26:44of their obsession with one another and that becomes, you
- 1:26:49know, physically manifested in like the fractured cells in so
- 1:26:54far as in this case, they trade each other's faces, yes, face
- 1:27:01off and the prestige I think would make a fantastic bell
- 1:27:03feature. Brad, I don't think we're going
- 1:27:05to top this. I'm so mad that we didn't say
- 1:27:07that for last because that's what I mean.
- 1:27:09Anytime you can suggest a Travolta Cage pairing with any
- 1:27:13movie we do, you you win. Yeah.
- 1:27:16All right, Brad, you want to go next?
- 1:27:18Sure. I, you know, I usually try to
- 1:27:21pick my double feature based on the theme of the film.
- 1:27:25And so I started thinking of my brand.
- 1:27:26I was like, what are some great movies about, like
- 1:27:29obsessiveness? And I realized there will be
- 1:27:33blood. I think would be just an
- 1:27:35incredible double feature and I so yeah, that's my pick.
- 1:27:40There will be Blood. I think it would be a really
- 1:27:43depressing evening but I think you would watch some great
- 1:27:46cinema. There you go.
- 1:27:48In reading a little bit about this movie and some of the
- 1:27:51reviews that came out, one of the films that continually came
- 1:27:54up as a comparison point to this was Amadeus in terms of, you
- 1:27:58know, a a diabolical and deadly rivalry.
- 1:28:02And I think that that's a fantastic pairing, but it's not
- 1:28:05original to me, so I'm not going to claim it, but I do think
- 1:28:08that's probably one of the better ones you could do.
- 1:28:10I started thinking back through movies about obsession as well,
- 1:28:13Brad, and I'm going to come out with a pretty, you know, a
- 1:28:16pretty milquetoast 1 here. But like, it's Vertigo, man.
- 1:28:20Like a movie about a man who's the, the, the blonde love of his
- 1:28:26life is taken from him by a lie that is being told around him.
- 1:28:31And that he obsessively tries to recreate a time in his life by
- 1:28:35making it again in his own image, only to his utter ruin.
- 1:28:39Like if it does not get more similar thematically than to
- 1:28:42pair this movie for me at least, with Vertigo.
- 1:28:45And I think that like any chance I get to recommend Vertigo to
- 1:28:48people, I'm going to do it. Yeah, that that's a that is a
- 1:28:52perfect recommendation, Bob. It's not as good as face off,
- 1:28:55but I had. I did my best.
- 1:28:57No, it's a good one. Both.
- 1:28:58Both of you came up with great ones, I think.
- 1:29:01I will say that the, the, the Vertigo thing makes me think,
- 1:29:03you know there's probably a really great like Brian De Palma
- 1:29:06film that prestige would we could also like hire Brian De
- 1:29:09Palma to remake the prestige and which would probably result in
- 1:29:13the just the sickest movie ever. But but yeah, you know like like
- 1:29:18I mean body double or femme fatale or you know there's so
- 1:29:22many films that you know that that take the ideas that are in
- 1:29:25the prestige and just that are late in the prestige and just
- 1:29:28make them over. You know, I was thinking about
- 1:29:31this, actually. It's a, it's a great point that
- 1:29:33you make like in in the current IP wasteland that we're in,
- 1:29:37where every filmmaker just has to get, you know, a Mattel
- 1:29:40product handed to them or something.
- 1:29:41Like, I've been trying to think of, if Nolan were to do a
- 1:29:45recognizable IP again outside of Batman, like what would be a
- 1:29:48great one? Thematically, they've been
- 1:29:51thinking about Frankenstein and like.
- 1:29:54No one's made a good Frankenstein movie in a long
- 1:29:56time, and I really think this idea of like, trying to
- 1:29:59resurrect the past and creating a freakish creature out of it
- 1:30:03and the ruination of everybody as a result, like that's a
- 1:30:07Christopher Nolan movie if I've ever heard of 1.
- 1:30:11So this is my official. Pitch like.
- 1:30:13Yeah, exactly. Now if you could tell it in like
- 1:30:174 different story like timelines then it it's definitely a
- 1:30:20perfect. Well, you'd have to tell like,
- 1:30:22like the the story of the bride and then, yeah, Frankenstein.
- 1:30:27And then you'd have to tell the story of.
- 1:30:29Like Dr. Frankenstein. And then you'd have to tell the
- 1:30:31story of, like, Mary Shelley, and then you'd have to
- 1:30:33interweave them. But which, by the way, like, why
- 1:30:37are we even talking about this in public?
- 1:30:39We should just, like, write that treatment and send it to him A.
- 1:30:41100%. But yes, and then you know Nolan
- 1:30:45is a is a big fan of of Stanley Kubrick obviously.
- 1:30:48And every Kubrick movie is, is on some level of Frankenstein
- 1:30:51story. You know like it's no, you're
- 1:30:53right, you're absolutely right. And Frankenstein like all those
- 1:30:55ideas that are in his movies. You know, the idea of, you know,
- 1:31:00the monstrousness of scientific knowledge and and the machine
- 1:31:03that was not be used. And I mean there's so many great
- 1:31:06great ideas there. Wow, that's a great idea.
- 1:31:09I will leave it at that. I was complimented by Bill
- 1:31:11Gabiri and my day has been made. Guys, let's give this movie some
- 1:31:16final scores. Brad, I'll just get mine out of
- 1:31:18the way real quick. I think this is a really, really
- 1:31:20good movie. My enjoyment level of the movie
- 1:31:23was probably like a nine out of 10 and I was not expecting that.
- 1:31:27I think I'm going to come to an 8.5 on this movie just because I
- 1:31:31do think there are some plot holes in the movie.
- 1:31:34There are some flaws to the film.
- 1:31:35It's not a perfect movie, but this has pretty rapidly risen up
- 1:31:40my ranking of Nolan films. I think this is a great movie
- 1:31:43and definitely fodder for some really good double features as
- 1:31:46well. So it's an 8.5 for me.
- 1:31:50Yeah, I think for me, I I came into this curious, you know,
- 1:31:54this is his fourth film. Fifth maybe?
- 1:31:575th movie. 5th movie and I I feel like watching Memento, we
- 1:32:01mentioned that there was one or two moments, especially in the
- 1:32:03flashback scenes, where I was like, oh, there's Nolan, like,
- 1:32:08like I can feel him in this scene and I feel like prestige,
- 1:32:12you know, you get some of that and Batman Begins there.
- 1:32:14There's there are things from that movie that feel very
- 1:32:17Nolanesque. I feel like this is the first
- 1:32:20movie where I am fully immersed and I feel like I am watching a
- 1:32:25Capital C Christopher Nolan film, right?
- 1:32:29And so I think that that goes a long way towards showing what an
- 1:32:34incredible director he is, that that he is getting his grip on
- 1:32:37what his movies are going to feel like.
- 1:32:41And on top of all that, it's an incredible story about two men.
- 1:32:44And their obsessive nature that just spirals into insanity.
- 1:32:49And I I really, really love this movie.
- 1:32:51It's going to keep me coming back for years to come.
- 1:32:53So yeah, it's a nine out of 10 for me.
- 1:32:57I think I I mean, I I'm terrible with ratings because the movies
- 1:33:01I love are the ones I love and and I can't, you know, clearly,
- 1:33:05like it's a 10 out of 10 for me. I just, I revisited so many
- 1:33:10times. I I have a an ongoing null and
- 1:33:13ranking at Vulture. I think it's #3 there, number
- 1:33:17three or four. But it's also like every single
- 1:33:19one of those movies is great like except for like maybe the
- 1:33:22bottom two which are following in insomnia, you know.
- 1:33:26So it's like I can't I can't give it less than a 10 even
- 1:33:31though you know it's it's not quite on the level of Dark
- 1:33:34Knight or Dunkirk for me. But you know what is?
- 1:33:38All right, so there you have it. I gave it an 8 1/2.
- 1:33:40Brad gave it a nine. Builder gives it A10.
- 1:33:42I love it when our scores ascend as we give them.
- 1:33:45That's always nice. It's always nice when a guest
- 1:33:48comes on the show and is like, man, I love this movie and
- 1:33:53here's why. And I'm have zero shame.
- 1:33:55It's a 10 out of 10. That like that just warms my
- 1:33:57heart. Me too.
- 1:33:59And that's like, my expectation because when we when we send out
- 1:34:02invites to guests, like, we let them pick the movie.
- 1:34:04And I'm always shocked when someone's like, yeah, this is a
- 1:34:06solid 7. Like, what are you talking
- 1:34:08about? Like, you, you picked this
- 1:34:09movie, man. So.
- 1:34:11So Bilga, thank you for doing what you're supposed to do and
- 1:34:14giving this movie a 10 out of 10.
- 1:34:16I appreciate it. Oh yeah.
- 1:34:18All right, as we wind down today, Bilga, please plug
- 1:34:22yourself. Where can we find you?
- 1:34:23What are you working on that you're allowed to divulge to us
- 1:34:26now? I you can always find my stuff
- 1:34:29at vulture.com, that's, you know, that's my employer.
- 1:34:32So that's really kind of where my stuff is for New York
- 1:34:35Magazine. And these days, well, I'm
- 1:34:38working on an Oppenheimer piece that that will be dropping soon,
- 1:34:45hopefully at the time of writing at the time of at the time that
- 1:34:50we are talking, it has not been filed yet.
- 1:34:54Hopefully it's not killed before this run set.
- 1:34:58But you know I'm always, I'm always, you know every week I
- 1:35:01review something. So we always got something in
- 1:35:04the works. I love it.
- 1:35:06Is there like a is there a code of ethics around saying that
- 1:35:09your piece on Oppenheimer is dropping sometime soon?
- 1:35:11Like are we, are we allowed to to lean into the double entendre
- 1:35:15of that one or not so much with Oppenheimer?
- 1:35:20Yes, somehow I suspect my piece will have less of an impact on
- 1:35:25world history. That is fair, that is.
- 1:35:27Fair to assume. Than the other one that dropped,
- 1:35:29but yes. Well Bilga, we cannot thank you
- 1:35:31enough for joining us today everybody.
- 1:35:33This has been Bilga Ibiri, one of our favorite film critics and
- 1:35:37lovers of the movie face off Brad.
- 1:35:40We will be back next week as we finish out our little miniseries
- 1:35:44on Christopher Nolan with his 2017 film Dunkirk.
- 1:35:48I'm pretty excited for that one. Is that going to be a first time
- 1:35:50watch for you. It sure will, Bob.
- 1:35:52No, that's exciting. Cool.
- 1:35:54Yeah. All right.
- 1:35:55So join us next week for Dunkirk.
- 1:35:57But until then, I'm Bob Book. I'm Brad Gee.
- 1:36:00And we'll see you next time.