Latest / Office Hours with Fexingo: Daily Career Q&A, Workplace Questions, and Professional Advice / How to Ask for a Raise When Your Boss Changed
Transcript
- Lucas: Okay, listener question today that I think hits a lot of people. Email from Jenna in Chicago. She's a marketing manager at a mid-size B2B software company. Her original boss — the one who hired her two years ago, who knew her work inside out — left in March. She now reports to someone new, hired externally, who's been there about six weeks. She wants to ask for a raise. Her question: how do you ask for a raise from a boss who doesn't know your track record yet? Luna: Oh, that's such a common spot. I bet half the people listening have been in that exact situation at some point. Lucas: Right. And Jenna's case is even trickier because her company does annual reviews in November. So she's looking at a window where her new boss will have been there maybe eight months by then — but she doesn't want to wait that long. Luna: So she's thinking about bringing it up earlier. But how early is too early? Lucas: Exactly. My first reaction is: do not ask in the first month. You need to give the new boss time to see your output firsthand. But I'd say four to six weeks in is fair game to start the conversation — not the ask itself, but the groundwork. Luna: So stage one is credibility building, not negotiation. Lucas: Yes. Jenna's new boss has performance data from the old boss's era — but that data doesn't have the same weight because it's not her data. There's a term for this: the 'speed-bump reset.' When a new manager comes in, your track record partially resets. They have to see it themselves before they'll advocate for you. Luna: That's tough. So how does Jenna accelerate that without seeming like she's campaigning? Lucas: Couple of things. First, she should schedule a weekly one-on-one that's purely about current work — no agenda items about her career yet. Use those to show competence, ask smart questions, deliver consistently. Second, after about three or four of those, she can introduce a document I call a 'performance snapshot.' Luna: A performance snapshot — what's in it? Lucas: A one-page summary of her top three wins from the past year, with specific numbers. For example: 'Led the email campaign that increased trial sign-ups by 34 percent quarter-over-quarter.' And then a section on current priorities and goals. Not a brag sheet — more like a strategic alignment tool. It helps the new boss connect Jenna's work to the team's objectives. Luna: And she can just hand that over in a one-on-one? 'Hey, I put together a snapshot of my recent work'? Lucas: Yeah, exactly. Frame it as helpful context. Say something like, 'I know you're still getting up to speed on the team, so I wanted to share a quick overview of what I've been working on and the results we've seen. Let me know if you'd like more detail on any of it.' That's a collaborative tone, not demanding. Luna: That also gives the new boss an easy way to ask follow-up questions and see Jenna's communication style. Lucas: Right. Then, after the boss has had that document for a couple weeks, Jenna can schedule a separate conversation — not during the one-on-one — to talk about her compensation. She should say something like, 'I'd like to set aside 20 minutes to discuss my career trajectory and compensation. I've been thinking about how I can grow here, and I want to make sure we're aligned.' Luna: Keeping it separate from the regular check-in is smart. It signals that this is a distinct topic, not an afterthought. Lucas: Exactly. And in that meeting, she leads with the same data — but now she can frame it around market value. She can say, 'Based on my contributions and comparable roles in the market, I believe my compensation should be at X. I'd like to work together on a plan to get there.' Luna: One thing I'd add: Jenna should also ask her new boss what she needs to see — what milestones or outcomes — to feel comfortable supporting a raise. That turns it from a demand into a collaborative goal. Lucas: That's a great tactic. And it gives the boss a clear path to say yes later. If the boss says, 'I need to see you lead a cross-functional project,' then Jenna knows exactly what to do. And she can follow up in a month and say, 'I led that project — here are the results. Can we revisit compensation now?' Luna: Right. So the whole process is: build credibility, share a snapshot, then ask for a separate meeting, and finally get clear on what success looks like. Lucas: One more nuance: if the new boss says, 'I need to wait until the annual review cycle,' Jenna shouldn't just accept that. She can ask, 'Is there any flexibility for off-cycle adjustments based on performance? I'd love to make the case now so we don't lose momentum.' Some companies do have mid-year merit pools, and the boss might not even know about them unless someone asks. Luna: Yeah, and if the boss says no, at least Jenna has a concrete plan for the review. She's not starting from zero in November. Lucas: And speaking of plans — if you're listening and you've found this kind of career strategy helpful, we keep this show ad-free thanks to listener support. If you'd like to help us keep doing that, you can find us at buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. No pressure at all, but every bit helps us keep answering questions like Jenna's. Luna: Yeah, and we really appreciate it. Okay, so back to Jenna — one thing I want to flag is the emotional side. It can feel awkward asking a new boss for more money. How do you handle that discomfort? Lucas: It is awkward. But remember: your new boss has a boss too. They understand that compensation is part of the job. If you frame it professionally — with data, with a collaborative tone — you're not being pushy. You're being a competent professional who knows her worth. Luna: And if the boss reacts badly — say, gets defensive — that's actually useful information about the company culture. Lucas: Exactly. A good boss will respect the conversation even if they can't say yes immediately. So don't let the fear of awkwardness stop you from having it. You've got nothing to lose, and potentially a lot to gain. Luna: Alright, so to recap for Jenna: four steps. One, build credibility in your one-on-ones. Two, share a performance snapshot. Three, schedule a separate compensation conversation. Four, ask for specific milestones. And if you hit them, follow up. Lucas: That's the playbook. And if you have a career question you'd like us to tackle, send it in. We read every one. Luna: Thanks, Jenna, and good luck. We'll be back tomorrow with another episode.