Latest / Bloomberg Law / Supreme Court Seems Ready to Okay GOP South Carolina Map
Transcript
- 0:03Speaker 1: This is Bloomberg Law with June Brusso from Bloomberg Radio.
- 0:09Speaker 1: It's a case over South Carolina's congressional map that could
- 0:13Speaker 1: help determine which party controls the House after next year's election,
- 0:18Speaker 1: and if the Supreme Court arguments were any indication the
- 0:22Speaker 1: Republicans won. A three judge panel had concluded that for
- 0:25Speaker 1: South Carolina's first district, GOP lawmakers established a target of
- 0:30Speaker 1: seventeen percent black voters, shifting thirty thousand African Americans out
- 0:36Speaker 1: of the district to hit the goal and engaging in
- 0:39Speaker 1: unconstitutional racial gerrymandering in drawing what is now a Republican
- 0:43Speaker 1: held district. But today the conservative majority of the Supreme
- 0:47Speaker 1: Court voice skepticism about that. The Republicans say they were
- 0:51Speaker 1: motivated by politics, not race, and the Supreme Court ruled
- 0:56Speaker 1: in twenty nineteen that voting maps can't be challenged and
- 0:59Speaker 1: fed court as excessively partisan. But a line of cases
- 1:03Speaker 1: says the Constitution's equal protection clause bars people who draw
- 1:07Speaker 1: maps from making race the predominant factor. Joining me is
- 1:11Speaker 1: Bloomberg News Supreme Court reporter Greg Store. An important redistricting
- 1:16Speaker 1: case came before the Court today.
- 1:18Speaker 2: Tell us about that, Yeah, this is a case involving
- 1:21Speaker 2: South Carolina and a lower court, a three judge panel
- 1:26Speaker 2: said that when South Carolina drew its congressional map, it
- 1:30Speaker 2: used race more than it should have, engaged in a
- 1:33Speaker 2: racial jerry mandering. And the evidence that the lower court
- 1:36Speaker 2: pointed to was that in drawing the first district in
- 1:39Speaker 2: South Carolina, which is now a Republican health district, first
- 1:42Speaker 2: map drawers added a number of African American voters, about
- 1:47Speaker 2: thirty thousand people into the district. And then the lower
- 1:51Speaker 2: court found because that number of black voters in the
- 1:54Speaker 2: district might have caused it to go democratic, they moved
- 1:59Speaker 2: a different thirty thousand voters out of the district. And
- 2:02Speaker 2: the lower court said that is unconstitutional racial jerry mannering,
- 2:06Speaker 2: use race too much in that process, and therefore we
- 2:10Speaker 2: are striking down those congressional districts.
- 2:12Speaker 1: And so what did you hear from the justices?
- 2:15Speaker 2: The justices, at least the conservative justices didn't seem to
- 2:18Speaker 2: be buying that. It was an argument that seemed like
- 2:21Speaker 2: it might divide the court along ideological lines. And the
- 2:26Speaker 2: backdrop of this is the court a few years ago
- 2:28Speaker 2: said that partisan jerry mandering can't be challenged. So it
- 2:32Speaker 2: would have been perfectly fine for Republicans to say, we're
- 2:36Speaker 2: drawing the first congressional district this way because we wanted
- 2:38Speaker 2: to keep it, keep it Republican. And the issue is
- 2:42Speaker 2: that race and politics overlap so much that sometimes it's
- 2:46Speaker 2: hard to sort of disentangle them and figure out what's.
- 2:49Speaker 3: Really going on.
- 2:51Speaker 2: And the conservative justices suggest that they didn't see clear
- 2:55Speaker 2: enough evidence that what was going on here was race
- 2:59Speaker 2: rather than politics, even though they.
- 3:01Speaker 1: Shifted thirty thousand blacks out of the district.
- 3:05Speaker 3: Yes, and of course when they did that, they also
- 3:07Speaker 3: shifted some white voters as well.
- 3:09Speaker 2: That was one of the points that Justice Kavanaugh made
- 3:12Speaker 2: over the course of the argument. One of the points
- 3:14Speaker 2: that both Justice Courses and Chief Justice Roberts pointed to
- 3:18Speaker 2: was that the challengers to this map didn't come up
- 3:21Speaker 2: with an alternative that would have let the state meet
- 3:24Speaker 2: its political goals without using race quite so much. So
- 3:27Speaker 2: there was some skepticism there as to whether it was
- 3:31Speaker 2: even possible to draw the kind of map that Republicans
- 3:35Speaker 2: wanted without having race seem like it played a significant role.
- 3:39Speaker 1: So it doesn't seem as if the justices are going
- 3:42Speaker 1: to have a surprise ruling like they did in the
- 3:45Speaker 1: Alabama case, were they ruled against the map by Republicans,
- 3:49Speaker 1: So it seems like that was just a one shot deal.
- 3:52Speaker 1: The issues are different.
- 3:54Speaker 2: So two things June. First of all, I can't remember
- 3:57Speaker 2: if we had a conversation after the Alabama argument, but
- 4:00Speaker 2: I would have said at the time it seemed like
- 4:02Speaker 2: they were going to back Republican in that case as well.
- 4:06Speaker 2: That one turned out to be a surprise. Who knows,
- 4:08Speaker 2: maybe this one will be a surprise too. The second
- 4:10Speaker 2: thing to say is these are very different legal issues.
- 4:13Speaker 2: That was a matter under the Voting Rights Act of
- 4:16Speaker 2: whether the states should be required to draw a second
- 4:20Speaker 2: majority black or nearly majority black district.
- 4:23Speaker 3: There because there were so many black voters.
- 4:25Speaker 2: Who were so concentrated in a few parts of the state. Here,
- 4:29Speaker 2: it's not a matter of drawing an additional majority black district.
- 4:32Speaker 2: This is a separate line of Supreme Court cases where
- 4:34Speaker 2: they say you just can't use race too much in redistricting.
- 4:38Speaker 2: It can't be the predominant factor.
- 4:40Speaker 3: And so the fact that they ruled one way in
- 4:43Speaker 3: the Alabama case doesn't really, at least as a doctrinal
- 4:47Speaker 3: matter dictate what they would do in this case.
- 4:49Speaker 1: Let's turn now greg to a case a Supreme Court
- 4:53Speaker 1: heard on Tuesday where the Court considered reinstating a nine
- 4:57Speaker 1: hundred thousand dollars jury verdict won by a fired UBS
- 5:02Speaker 1: research strategist in a case that could make it easier
- 5:05Speaker 1: for whistleblowers to win suits claiming retaliation under a federal
- 5:09Speaker 1: investor protection law. Tell us more about that case.
- 5:14Speaker 2: This is the case about a man named Trevor Murray
- 5:16Speaker 2: who worked as a research strategist for UBS in the
- 5:20Speaker 2: commercial mortgage backed securities market, and he says he was
- 5:26Speaker 2: fired because he refused to skew his reports to back
- 5:31Speaker 2: the company's mortgage backed securities trading business. And the question
- 5:35Speaker 2: that the Supreme Court is basically, what does he have
- 5:38Speaker 2: to show in order to win his lawsuit? And what
- 5:40Speaker 2: do other whistleblowers have to show to win lawsuits under
- 5:44Speaker 2: a law known as Starbin's Oxley Act.
- 5:46Speaker 1: What were the arguments? Let's start with the arguments for UBS.
- 5:51Speaker 1: And the lawyer for UBS has a last name we're
- 5:56Speaker 1: all familiar with.
- 5:58Speaker 2: Yes, it's Eugene scale Yea. He is the son of
- 6:01Speaker 2: the late Justice antonin Scalia. This is his first Supreme
- 6:05Speaker 2: Court argument for obvious reasons. He didn't argue while his
- 6:09Speaker 2: father was on the court. And he represented UBS, and
- 6:13Speaker 2: he argued that what Murray has to show is intentional
- 6:18Speaker 2: discrimination or maybe even intentional retaliation. And he says it's
- 6:23Speaker 2: because the law says that what is prohibited is discrimination,
- 6:28Speaker 2: and because of that, that is part of what a
- 6:32Speaker 2: plaintiff has to show has to convince a jury of.
- 6:36Speaker 1: And it seemed like several of the justices were confused
- 6:41Speaker 1: by his argument and said so liberals and conservatives, yeah.
- 6:46Speaker 2: Yeah, he got a bit of a rough reception, even
- 6:49Speaker 2: from some of the more conservative justices. So Justice Brett Kavanaf,
- 6:53Speaker 2: for example, looked at the case and he thought that
- 6:56Speaker 2: all that was really required was that UBS has to
- 7:00Speaker 2: argue to the jury that it didn't fire Murray in
- 7:03Speaker 2: retaliation for his alleged whistle blowing, but that it fired
- 7:08Speaker 2: him for other reasons than the UBS says it was
- 7:10Speaker 2: because of overall staffing reductions. And so Justice Kavanaugh asked,
- 7:14Speaker 2: mister Scalia, didn't that defense get to the jury. And
- 7:17Speaker 2: there are some other conservatives as well, just as Neil
- 7:20Speaker 2: Gorsuch said, you know, he didn't see the word retaliation
- 7:24Speaker 2: in the statute and therefore suggests the plaintiff shouldn't be
- 7:28Speaker 2: required to explicitly show intentional retaliation was the cause of
- 7:32Speaker 2: his dismissal.
- 7:34Speaker 1: So it's intentional retaliation because to me, retaliation implies intent.
- 7:40Speaker 2: It does. Let me back up just a little, and
- 7:42Speaker 2: maybe this will help explain things. One thing both sides
- 7:45Speaker 2: agree on is that the law kind of separately, that's
- 7:49Speaker 2: up a burden shifting system. And what that means is
- 7:53Speaker 2: a plaintiff first has to show that his or her
- 7:57Speaker 2: whistle blowing was a contributing factor in being fired or
- 8:02Speaker 2: something like that, and if they can do that, then
- 8:04Speaker 2: it's up to the employer to show that by clear
- 8:09Speaker 2: and convincing evidence, that they would have taken the same
- 8:11Speaker 2: action even if it weren't for the whistle blowing. And
- 8:14Speaker 2: so that's sort of a system that is set up
- 8:16Speaker 2: that some justices said that's actually a way of kind
- 8:20Speaker 2: of figuring out whether this was intentional or not. That
- 8:23Speaker 2: if an employer can't show that there was some other
- 8:26Speaker 2: reason that they would have fired the employee for, then
- 8:29Speaker 2: that suggests that it was intentional, it was done for
- 8:33Speaker 2: the reason of retaliation, and that it was intentional.
- 8:36Speaker 1: So what was the argument on behalf of the whistle blower?
- 8:41Speaker 2: So the argument we have the whistleblower was basically that
- 8:44Speaker 2: that burden shifting is all that is required under the law,
- 8:48Speaker 2: and that if an employer is not able to show
- 8:51Speaker 2: that it would have taken the action even without the
- 8:54Speaker 2: whistle blowing, then the employer is liable that that essentially
- 8:59Speaker 2: is a showing that they did intentionally retaliate. And what
- 9:03Speaker 2: they were saying is, we don't have to show, kind
- 9:06Speaker 2: of as a whole separate line of argument, somehow get
- 9:11Speaker 2: inside the minds of an employer and show this is
- 9:14Speaker 2: what they were thinking when they made this decision. It's
- 9:18Speaker 2: enough that if they can't show that there was some
- 9:21Speaker 2: other reason, if that happens, that's enough and we should
- 9:23Speaker 2: win our case.
- 9:24Speaker 1: Did the Biden administration take a position.
- 9:27Speaker 2: The Biden administration did weigh in in this case. They
- 9:30Speaker 2: were on the side of the whistleblower.
- 9:33Speaker 1: This was an appeal from the Second Circuit. Is the
- 9:36Speaker 1: Second Circuit the only circuit that's ruled this way?
- 9:40Speaker 2: I believe it's the only circuit that has ruled this way.
- 9:43Speaker 2: There are other circuits that have ruled the other way.
- 9:47Speaker 2: In other words, they have said that you don't have
- 9:49Speaker 2: to show intentional retaliation to win your suit. That's actually
- 9:53Speaker 2: the reason, most likely the Supreme Court agreed to take
- 9:56Speaker 2: up this case to clear up that lower court disagreement.
- 10:00Speaker 1: Course it didn't want to get into the particulars of
- 10:02Speaker 1: the statute, which he saw us complicating the Justice's task.
- 10:07Speaker 1: But some of the other justices seem to disagree with that.
- 10:11Speaker 2: So Trevor Murray is asking the Supreme Court to reinstate
- 10:14Speaker 2: a jury that he wanted. Justice Gorsuch was suggesting a
- 10:18Speaker 2: ruling favoring mister Murray, but short of that, he was suggesting,
- 10:23Speaker 2: we just say the Second Circuit was wrong to say
- 10:26Speaker 2: that there's a requirement of intentional retaliation because the word
- 10:30Speaker 2: retaliation isn't in the statute. We just say the Second
- 10:34Speaker 2: Circuit was wrong to insist on that, and then we
- 10:37Speaker 2: kick it back to the Second Circuit and let it
- 10:39Speaker 2: figure out what to do next. And some of the
- 10:42Speaker 2: other justices and some of the advocates suggest that that
- 10:45Speaker 2: would leave open an awful lot of questions about what
- 10:48Speaker 2: exactly is required under this law, and that would eventually
- 10:52Speaker 2: lead to another Supreme Court case.
- 10:54Speaker 1: So This is important because this is an element in
- 11:00Speaker 1: whistleblower suits under the Sarbinez Oxley Act.
- 11:03Speaker 2: It is and employees are filed up words of seven
- 11:06Speaker 2: hundred and fifty claims with the Labor Department over the
- 11:09Speaker 2: past six years or so, so a significant number of
- 11:13Speaker 2: cases and all of them sort of by definition, are
- 11:16Speaker 2: affecting publicly traded companies.
- 11:18Speaker 1: And was this a two hour argument? So an hour
- 11:22Speaker 1: longer than necessary or your scheduled?
- 11:25Speaker 2: It lasted about an hour and a half, which is
- 11:28Speaker 2: about par for the course of these days. They schedule
- 11:31Speaker 2: an hour for an argument. But what ends up happening
- 11:34Speaker 2: is that there's even at the end of the lawyers
- 11:37Speaker 2: a lot of time, there's an additional period where they
- 11:40Speaker 2: go justice by justice to ask additional questions.
- 11:43Speaker 1: A COVID left over. Remember the days when they stuck
- 11:46Speaker 1: to that hour and those lights went on and it
- 11:49Speaker 1: meant business. So there is disagreement, I take it over
- 11:52Speaker 1: where the court should land exactly. But did it appear
- 11:55Speaker 1: like there were a majority of justices that were in
- 11:58Speaker 1: favor of you know, it can get easier for whistleblowers.
- 12:02Speaker 2: It did seem like there was a majority of justices
- 12:05Speaker 2: at least for the narrow ruling that Justice Gorsich was suggesting.
- 12:09Speaker 2: There wasn't a whole lot of support for the second
- 12:12Speaker 2: Circuit ruling and UBS's arguments in support of it. It's
- 12:18Speaker 2: not one hundred percent clear, but that seemed like the
- 12:21Speaker 2: leaning of the court was to give the employee at
- 12:24Speaker 2: least a partial victory.
- 12:25Speaker 1: And I have to ask, did Eugene Scalia do a
- 12:29Speaker 1: textual argument in honor of his father?
- 12:33Speaker 2: Everybody does a textual argument nowadays, in large part because
- 12:37Speaker 2: of his father and the influence that he had.
- 12:40Speaker 1: Justice Scalia certainly left his mark on the court. Thanks
- 12:43Speaker 1: so much, Greg. That's Bloomberg New Supreme Court reporter Greg's store.
- 12:48Speaker 4: Israel is a war.
- 12:50Speaker 1: We didn't want this war.
- 12:52Speaker 4: It was forced upon us in the most brutal and
- 12:54Speaker 4: savage way. But though Israel didn't start this war, Israel
- 12:59Speaker 4: will finish it.
- 13:00Speaker 1: Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu promised punishing retaliation for the
- 13:05Speaker 1: shocking attack by Hamas on Saturday, where militants stormed into
- 13:10Speaker 1: border communities and massacred hundreds of Israelis in their homes,
- 13:14Speaker 1: on the streets and at an outdoor music festival, taking
- 13:18Speaker 1: more than one hundred people hostage, including women, children, and
- 13:21Speaker 1: the elderly. So far, Israel has unleashed intense air strikes
- 13:26Speaker 1: in Gaza, flattening entire city blocks, and has cut off
- 13:29Speaker 1: essentials like food, fuel, and electricity, while Hamas militants in
- 13:34Speaker 1: Gaza continue to fire rockets at Israel. My guest is
- 13:38Speaker 1: international law expert Mary Ellen O'Connor, a professor at Notre
- 13:41Speaker 1: Dame Law School. The Hamas attack, the deliberate targeting of civilians,
- 13:47Speaker 1: hundreds massacred, taking hostages are those actions war crimes that
- 13:52Speaker 1: can be prosecuted June.
- 13:55Speaker 4: Let's start with a preliminary question of whether they even
- 13:57Speaker 4: had the right to resort to this kind of major
- 14:01Speaker 4: armed violence. It is a hotly contested question. I take
- 14:06Speaker 4: a more progressive view and understand new scholarship and new research,
- 14:13Speaker 4: including my own, suggests that people living under long term
- 14:17Speaker 4: occupation must use nonviolent resistance, so that from the get
- 14:22Speaker 4: go there was no right to resort to this military force.
- 14:26Speaker 4: But even if Hamas or other Palestinians have the right
- 14:30Speaker 4: to take up arms to try to remove Israelis from
- 14:35Speaker 4: their territory, there's another principle at stake here, and it
- 14:40Speaker 4: really applies to both sides in this terrible conflict. And
- 14:43Speaker 4: that's called the principle of necessity, and it applies to
- 14:46Speaker 4: any decision to resort to major armed violence of the coiner.
- 14:50Speaker 4: Seeing here, if a party has no reasonable chance of
- 14:54Speaker 4: succeeding and using military force, then every death they cause,
- 14:59Speaker 4: even of their opponents soldiers troops, will be unlawful. You
- 15:04Speaker 4: can't kill people in a vain effort. And let's face it,
- 15:08Speaker 4: after all these decades, what Hamas was trying to do
- 15:12Speaker 4: had nothing to do with accomplishing a legitimate military objective
- 15:16Speaker 4: of removing Israelis from Gaza. They knew they had no
- 15:20Speaker 4: chance of accomplishing that, so what were they doing. I'm
- 15:23Speaker 4: with those who believe Hamas's efforts were nothing more than terrorism,
- 15:28Speaker 4: the infliction of terrible violence for the purpose of trying
- 15:33Speaker 4: to get political concessions. It may not have even been that,
- 15:37Speaker 4: because Hamas has tried that particular tactic terrorist tactics clearly
- 15:42Speaker 4: criminal actions for so long with no result. So was
- 15:46Speaker 4: it just a mass suicide attempt by truly desperate people.
- 15:51Speaker 4: At any rate, even if there was some legal basis
- 15:54Speaker 4: for Hamas taking action, it is never ever legitimate it
- 15:59Speaker 4: is an absolute ambition to target civilians, those not taking
- 16:03Speaker 4: direct part in hostilities, those who are not members of
- 16:07Speaker 4: the Israeli armed forces, and hostages. Even worse, to take
- 16:11Speaker 4: people and to bargain for them, and to use them
- 16:14Speaker 4: as bargaining chips, terrifying them in children. This is beyond
- 16:18Speaker 4: the pale. And then, of course, I assume your next
- 16:20Speaker 4: question will be what about Israel's response.
- 16:23Speaker 1: Yes, so Israeli Prime Minister of Benjamin Yahoo declared war
- 16:28Speaker 1: and said he had ordered the israel Defense forces to
- 16:31Speaker 1: prepare for a mass offensive against Hamas, and they've started
- 16:35Speaker 1: with these airstrikes.
- 16:36Speaker 4: So jessics Hamas, in my view, had no legal right
- 16:40Speaker 4: to resort to this kind of armed, significant armed violence
- 16:44Speaker 4: against Israeli's The Israeli government also has clear limits on
- 16:50Speaker 4: its right to respond even to this kind of major
- 16:53Speaker 4: terrorist violence. Of course, every state has the right to
- 16:57Speaker 4: take all defensive measures on their own tares, territory or
- 17:01Speaker 4: in defense of their own communities, their own civilian populations
- 17:06Speaker 4: living peacefully, They may take defensive measures. There's a huge
- 17:12Speaker 4: difference between defending, protecting, preventing incoming violence, and offensively responding,
- 17:21Speaker 4: especially in a situation like that of Gaza. This is
- 17:24Speaker 4: not an area where you can easily defeat, as on
- 17:28Speaker 4: an old fashioned battlefield, a formation of enemy military combatants.
- 17:33Speaker 4: We just don't have that situation. We have a heavily populated,
- 17:37Speaker 4: densely populated, a group of people who had nothing to
- 17:40Speaker 4: do with what Hamas has carried out or very tangential
- 17:45Speaker 4: just as israelis civilians cannot be the target of violence,
- 17:49Speaker 4: nor can the Palestinians who are not participating in the
- 17:52Speaker 4: Hamas armed action. It is very questionable whether this kind
- 17:56Speaker 4: of major military offensive on the territory of another people
- 18:00Speaker 4: is first lawful, but second that same rule, that same
- 18:04Speaker 4: principle of necessity, which would prevent Palestinians from trying to
- 18:09Speaker 4: use military force to take back Palestinian territory. Israel has
- 18:13Speaker 4: tried this kind of tactic again and again, and it
- 18:16Speaker 4: has not worked to defend Israel to create security. We
- 18:20Speaker 4: just see an escalation to this current tragic moment. Israel,
- 18:24Speaker 4: under the principle of necessity, needs to try other means.
- 18:28Speaker 4: It needs to work cooperatively in law enforcement. It needs
- 18:32Speaker 4: to finally address the roots of ongoing violence, among other things.
- 18:37Speaker 1: Israel might say, well, the Palestinians are launching rockets into Israel,
- 18:43Speaker 1: so why don't we have the right to launch rockets
- 18:47Speaker 1: at Gaza?
- 18:49Speaker 3: Right?
- 18:49Speaker 4: We never say in the law that because somebody has
- 18:53Speaker 4: committed a criminal action, we have a right of a
- 18:56Speaker 4: criminal response. That's just not how the law works. It
- 18:59Speaker 4: can't work that way. When criminals carry out criminal actions,
- 19:05Speaker 4: we respond with law enforcement. And the great thing about
- 19:08Speaker 4: our ancient principles prohibiting resort to military force, demanding respect
- 19:14Speaker 4: for the principle of necessity and proportionality and distinction. All
- 19:17Speaker 4: these ancient principles have been honed over time to be effective.
- 19:23Speaker 4: And those who comply with the law in how they
- 19:26Speaker 4: respond to criminal and other kinds of violent action military action,
- 19:31Speaker 4: they are the ones who succeed. If you follow the
- 19:34Speaker 4: strict rule, you will succeed. So we know this exactly.
- 19:38Speaker 4: An example of Palestinians and israelis Hamas has been shooting
- 19:43Speaker 4: rockets into southern Israel for decades. Israel has not found
- 19:48Speaker 4: a way effectively to stop them because Israel is not
- 19:52Speaker 4: following the path of the law, and it has constantly
- 19:55Speaker 4: tried with more and more force. Yes, if the devastation
- 19:58Speaker 4: could lead to a law and violence for a while,
- 20:01Speaker 4: but the seeds of the next tragedy I'm so fearful
- 20:05Speaker 4: are being planted when there is an alternative, and that
- 20:09Speaker 4: is to strictly follow the rule of law, enhance defenses
- 20:13Speaker 4: for Israeli communities, make sure that all Hamas fighters who
- 20:17Speaker 4: may still be in those communities are removed.
- 20:21Speaker 2: Now.
- 20:21Speaker 4: This is something Israel can do right now. It can
- 20:25Speaker 4: use careful law enforcement methods, the kinds of methods that
- 20:29Speaker 4: the US has perfected in rescuing hostages who are being
- 20:34Speaker 4: held by armed militant groups. The US has done so successfully,
- 20:38Speaker 4: for example in Somalia, with no loss of US military
- 20:43Speaker 4: lives or the lives of hostages. That is what Israel
- 20:46Speaker 4: should be planning right now. It would be such a
- 20:48Speaker 4: major victory for Israel to bring its one hundred plus
- 20:52Speaker 4: people safely out of the hands of these militants.
- 20:56Speaker 1: Coming up next on the Bloomberg Law Show, I'll continue
- 20:58Speaker 1: this conversation with yes Or Mary Ellen O'Connor of Notre
- 21:01Speaker 1: Dame Law School and we'll talk about the international law
- 21:05Speaker 1: involving the rescue of hostages. I've been talking to Notre
- 21:08Speaker 1: Dame Law School professor Mary Ellen O'Connor about international law
- 21:12Speaker 1: regarding the deadly conflict between Israel and Hamas. Hamas is
- 21:16Speaker 1: holding hostages, including women, children, and elderly people, and no
- 21:22Speaker 1: one knows where they're being held. Does Israel have the
- 21:24Speaker 1: right under international law to go into Gaza to rescue
- 21:28Speaker 1: the hostages.
- 21:30Speaker 4: Yes. Absolutely, Israel can take means to military means. Law
- 21:35Speaker 4: enforcement means are really the better message to rescue any
- 21:40Speaker 4: of its nationals that are being held. That absolutely is right.
- 21:44Speaker 4: There's an old, old principle of rescue of nationals being permissible.
- 21:48Speaker 4: This is often carried out with using your military forces
- 21:53Speaker 4: because they have this kind of clandestine foreign territory experience.
- 21:59Speaker 4: We used commit and force when we carry out this
- 22:02Speaker 4: brilliant rescue operation in Somalia some years ago. That is
- 22:07Speaker 4: definitely there's no doubt in my mind about that. There's
- 22:10Speaker 4: some debate about what the legal theory is. Some people
- 22:13Speaker 4: say it's self defense under Article fifty one or the
- 22:16Speaker 4: UN Charter. I think there's no basis for that. Rescue
- 22:20Speaker 4: of nationals is a countermeasure. It is the right to
- 22:25Speaker 4: violate a state's sovereign territory for the express and limited
- 22:28Speaker 4: purpose of bringing your people out alive, and you can
- 22:32Speaker 4: use limited armed force to protect the mission and succeed
- 22:39Speaker 4: in bringing people out, just as police would do in
- 22:42Speaker 4: a hostage lockdown situation in the US, so that no doubt.
- 22:47Speaker 4: And then the other end of the spectrum I think
- 22:50Speaker 4: is equally clear. Bombing a population, a civilian population packed
- 22:55Speaker 4: into this tight area of Gaza cannot be permitted under
- 23:00Speaker 4: or international law. There's no right to resort to that
- 23:02Speaker 4: kind of level of force under the laws on resort
- 23:06Speaker 4: to force. And it's a clear violation of the Inbello
- 23:10Speaker 4: rules because you cannot make a distinction between fighters and
- 23:13Speaker 4: non fighters. So what about the interim between sending some
- 23:17Speaker 4: forces for the clear purpose of rescue and bombing indiscriminately.
- 23:22Speaker 4: The middle level is more difficult to judge. Even if
- 23:28Speaker 4: Israel could make out the claim that they were sending
- 23:31Speaker 4: military forces, highly trained, focused only on Hamas fighters and
- 23:36Speaker 4: rooting them out of the populated area of Gaza, those
- 23:39Speaker 4: are all very big ists. Even if they could succeed
- 23:43Speaker 4: in doing that, I do not believe the principle of
- 23:46Speaker 4: necessity will be met. Given this is the fifth Gaza war.
- 23:50Speaker 4: The past four did not succeed. They just brought us
- 23:53Speaker 4: to this current crisis. The way to succeed now is
- 23:57Speaker 4: rescue hostages, protect your people at home, begin the hard,
- 24:02Speaker 4: hard work of creating a situation where we never again
- 24:07Speaker 4: have this kind of violence. And the only way to
- 24:10Speaker 4: do that is to use nonviolent measures. There's a huge
- 24:14Speaker 4: toolbox that will lead to a better outcome, but it
- 24:17Speaker 4: really takes statesmanship, it really takes humanity now on both sides.
- 24:22Speaker 1: I mean, do you really think that that's possible. You
- 24:25Speaker 1: have decades of hostility between the Palestinians and the Israelis.
- 24:31Speaker 1: What would change that now?
- 24:33Speaker 4: Well, I think one thing that should be changing things
- 24:36Speaker 4: now is Russia's invasion of Ukraine. We've come to the
- 24:40Speaker 4: point where we have this dramatic example of a country
- 24:43Speaker 4: that has completely dismissed any of this law we're talking
- 24:47Speaker 4: about with absolute disregard. We've got to get this law back.
- 24:51Speaker 4: We are creating such a lawless world with weak governance.
- 24:55Speaker 4: We're heading into this unending spiral of violence with strong men, authoritarians.
- 25:03Speaker 4: The whole world has an interest in putting a stop
- 25:05Speaker 4: to that. The situation between the Israelis and Palestinians is
- 25:09Speaker 4: so much more complicated, and it needs a much more
- 25:12Speaker 4: nuanced and complicated answer. But we can start with if
- 25:16Speaker 4: we're interested in defending the prohibition on the use of
- 25:19Speaker 4: force for Ukraine, we've got to be interested in that
- 25:22Speaker 4: between Israelis and Palestinians and apply it now. The United
- 25:27Speaker 4: States has a huge role to play. President Biden made
- 25:31Speaker 4: clear that the United States condemns what Hamas did. He however,
- 25:36Speaker 4: also emphasized the need for democracies to stand by the
- 25:41Speaker 4: rule of law. And that's exactly what I'm talking about.
- 25:44Speaker 4: So if people like President Biden, the leaders of the
- 25:47Speaker 4: European Union countries around the world who are so heartbroken
- 25:51Speaker 4: at this loss of life, need to close ranks, stand
- 25:56Speaker 4: tall and insist to both Palestinians and Israeli that war
- 26:01Speaker 4: and violence is just never going to bring the flourishing
- 26:06Speaker 4: communities that they both want. It really comes down so
- 26:10Speaker 4: often to this lack of governance. Israel can make a
- 26:13Speaker 4: huge impact on the terrible state of governance in the
- 26:19Speaker 4: occupied Palestinian territories that has led to Hamas being in
- 26:23Speaker 4: a position where they could organize weapons and bring people together.
- 26:28Speaker 4: Israel can be part of a true multilateral effort to
- 26:32Speaker 4: help Palestinians create the governance institutions that will respond, but
- 26:37Speaker 4: it requires generosity in economics and commitment to the rule
- 26:42Speaker 4: of law in so many other ways. It's a difficult time.
- 26:45Speaker 4: But Israelis themselves are struggling with good governance and commitment
- 26:49Speaker 4: to the rule of law as they look at policies
- 26:52Speaker 4: to weaken their own exemplary judicial system. So two levels
- 26:57Speaker 4: have to work here. We need to start suspecting globally
- 27:02Speaker 4: the prohibition on the use of force, restricting force to
- 27:05Speaker 4: true situations that Ukraine is in of needing to use
- 27:09Speaker 4: force in self defense. This is a message that has
- 27:12Speaker 4: to go out to China, to India, to South Africa.
- 27:15Speaker 4: Everyone should be supporting Ukraine and in Israel Palestine. Everyone
- 27:21Speaker 4: needs to be supporting the rule of law and understanding
- 27:23Speaker 4: what it requires in this situation. It will not be
- 27:27Speaker 4: easy in the next days and weeks, but I would
- 27:30Speaker 4: just reiterate we have a solution in the law and
- 27:33Speaker 4: that's what needs to be observed.
- 27:35Speaker 1: So talking about defensive measures, Israel has stopped the entry
- 27:40Speaker 1: of food, water, fuel and medicine into Gaza. Is that
- 27:45Speaker 1: a defensive measure that's considered legal under international law?
- 27:49Speaker 4: Just as with the high aerial bombing or using military
- 27:53Speaker 4: planes to bomb. It is absolutely forbidden to cut off food, fuel,
- 27:59Speaker 4: medicine and water to a civilian population. That is a
- 28:04Speaker 4: black letter rule in the law of armed conflict. When
- 28:07Speaker 4: armed conflict is ongoing as it is here now because
- 28:11Speaker 4: of mutual violations of the principle on resort to force
- 28:14Speaker 4: and the principle of necessity, then the rules i'm the
- 28:18Speaker 4: conduct of armed conflict takeover. The clear principle is never
- 28:23Speaker 4: to deny food, fuel, water, and medicine to a civilian population.
- 28:28Speaker 1: Do you know if there's any effort by the Red
- 28:31Speaker 1: Cross or the World Health Organization to get food and
- 28:36Speaker 1: medicine in there.
- 28:37Speaker 4: I assume that one of the goals of Secretary Blincoln,
- 28:41Speaker 4: who's in Israel right now, is to discuss exactly that point.
- 28:47Speaker 4: There may be a lot of debate on some of
- 28:49Speaker 4: the international law you and I've been discussing. I've never
- 28:52Speaker 4: heard a contrary view to the requirement to allow these
- 28:57Speaker 4: necessities of life to reach a civilian population. So the
- 29:01Speaker 4: International Committee, the Red Cross, definitely, they always work quietly
- 29:05Speaker 4: behind the scenes diplomatically, but this would have been one
- 29:08Speaker 4: of their foremost messages.
- 29:10Speaker 1: And when this conflict is over is there any accountability
- 29:14Speaker 1: for things that were done in violation of international law?
- 29:18Speaker 3: June.
- 29:19Speaker 4: We speak so much about accountability. There's been a major
- 29:22Speaker 4: effort by international lawyers to construct an international criminal court,
- 29:26Speaker 4: and all during the tragedy of Russia's invasion of Ukraine,
- 29:30Speaker 4: there's been discussion of accountability. We focus so much on
- 29:33Speaker 4: accountability and how difficult it is and how problematic we
- 29:37Speaker 4: fail to say in the first instance, these tragedies could
- 29:40Speaker 4: have been prevented if we'd focused on the prohibition on
- 29:44Speaker 4: resort to force. That's where I put my focus really,
- 29:48Speaker 4: the construction of international courts, the attempts to hold these trials.
- 29:51Speaker 4: All we're seeing is that it's had no positive impact
- 29:55Speaker 4: on prevention. I don't work on those topics for that
- 29:59Speaker 4: very reason. I work on disseminating information on respect for
- 30:04Speaker 4: the principle of necessity, proportionality, and the use of non violence.
- 30:09Speaker 1: Thanks for being on the show. That's Professor Mary Ellen
- 30:12Speaker 1: O'Connell of Notre Dame Law School, and that's it for
- 30:15Speaker 1: this edition of The Bloomberg Law Show. Remember you can
- 30:18Speaker 1: always get the latest legal news on our Bloomberg Law podcast.
- 30:21Speaker 1: You can find them on Apple Podcasts, Spotify and at
- 30:25Speaker 1: www dot bloomberg dot com. Slash podcast Slash Law, and
- 30:30Speaker 1: remember to tune into The Bloomberg Law Show every weeknight
- 30:33Speaker 1: at ten pm Wall Street Time. I'm June Grosso and
- 30:36Speaker 1: you're listening to Bloomberg