Latest / Deep Values: Value Investing Deep Dives / Alibaba (BABA) Business, Value, Growth, and Risk Analysis
Transcript
- 0:00Have you ever really stopped to think about the sheer size of a
- 0:03company like Alibaba Group? I mean, it's influence.
- 0:06It's not just e-commerce, it's global.
- 0:08Tech. Daily life for billions.
- 0:10It's kind of mind boggling. Welcome to the Dick dive.
- 0:13Today we are definitely plunging deep into yeah, the really
- 0:16fascinating and, let's be honest, incredibly complex world
- 0:19of. Alibaba.
- 0:20Group, you probably know it as Barber.
- 0:21Our mission here for you is to sift through all the noise, all
- 0:24the data out there and pull out the really critical insights
- 0:26from the sources we've got. We're talking it's called
- 0:28business year, but also the big risks, the financials.
- 0:31What it might actually be worth. Basically, we want to give you a
- 0:34shortcut, you know, a way to get properly informed about this
- 0:36company that's always in the news.
- 0:38So what are we unpacking? First, we'll try and get our
- 0:40heads around Alibaba's huge business model.
- 0:42Just how many things do they do? Then we'll look straight at the
- 0:45challenges, the headwinds, the geopolitical stuff.
- 0:47It's pretty serious. After that, we'll shift to the
- 0:49people who's actually running the show and maybe more
- 0:52importantly, what are the big shareholders, the smart money.
- 0:54Telling us with their actions and finally the numbers.
- 0:57We'll dig into the financial history, the latest earnings,
- 0:59and try to figure out what a solid valuation analysis
- 1:02suggests about its real value. OK.
- 1:04But before we jump in, it's really important we get this out
- 1:06there, a crucial disclaimer. Everything we talked about
- 1:09today, all the analysis is based strictly on publicly available
- 1:12sources. And like any financial data,
- 1:13especially for a company this complex, it could be subject to
- 1:17different interpretations, maybe even revisions down the line.
- 1:20So Please remember, this is purely for educational purposes.
- 1:23It is absolutely not investment advice.
- 1:25We really encourage you to do your own homework, your own
- 1:27thorough due diligence before making any investment decisions.
- 1:31Always, always check the figures against official company
- 1:33filings. And keep in mind Alibaba is a
- 1:36global player, so it's financials involve currency
- 1:38translation. Those reported numbers can shift
- 1:40a bit depending on exchange rates and the usual reminder
- 1:43past performance analyst views. None of that guarantees future
- 1:46results. OK, got it.
- 1:48Crucial stuff. All right, let's unpack this
- 1:49then. When people hear Alibaba, I
- 1:52think most just picture, you know, online shopping like
- 1:54Amazon, but in China. But what is Alibaba Group
- 1:56really, beyond just the shopping part?
- 1:58Yeah, that's the common perception, but it's so much
- 2:00bigger. Alibaba Group is, well, it's a
- 2:03massive Chinese tech conglomerate.
- 2:05Ecommerce and cloud services are the big money makers, Yes.
- 2:08And its core, the foundation, is absolutely domestic retail in
- 2:11Shiner, specifically Taobao and Tmall, those two platforms where
- 2:16hundreds of millions of Chinese consumers shop every day.
- 2:19They brought in nearly half of Alibaba's total revenue in
- 2:21fiscal 2023. Just those two.
- 2:23Wow, nearly half. Yeah, but then you've got all
- 2:25the other arms, big international e-commerce
- 2:27operations, think Aliexpress, Lazada, Trendual reaching people
- 2:31globally. Then there's Caminio, their
- 2:33logistics powerhouse, local services like a La dot me for
- 2:36food delivery, fresh Shippo for groceries, even digital media
- 2:39and entertainment. It's it's like this sprawling
- 2:42digital octopus, really. A digital octopus.
- 2:45I like that. So it's not just a website.
- 2:46It's like a whole digital economy they've built.
- 2:48Can you give us some numbers? Just help wrap our heads around
- 2:50the scale? How many people are we talking
- 2:51about using these platforms? The numbers are pretty
- 2:54staggering, frankly. In fiscal 2023, Alibaba reported
- 2:581.31 billion annual active customers, billion with AB1
- 3:02core, 3 billion across all their different platforms.
- 3:04And just look at their premium loyalty program, 88 VIP.
- 3:08That alone had something like 49 million members by the end of
- 3:102024. That's a huge, highly engaged
- 3:12group. And then the ecosystem players
- 3:14brought from the reach Kainiao handling immense logistics
- 3:17volumes, Alipay part of Ant financial handling payments,
- 3:20even though Ant's IPO is still, you know, on old.
- 3:23Right, the Ant IPO saga. Exactly.
- 3:24And the volume flowing through the core platforms, Taobao and
- 3:27team, all together they handle over CN¥1 trillion in gross
- 3:30merchandise value GMV annually. That's the total value of stuff
- 3:33sold. A trillion yuan.
- 3:34Yeah. And Alibaba Cloud serves over
- 3:363,000,000 customers worldwide. So yes, the scale is just
- 3:39monumental, way beyond just online shopping, OK.
- 3:41This is where it gets really, really interesting for me.
- 3:44How does a company that big, with all these different pieces
- 3:47operating globally, how do they navigate the current world
- 3:50stage, esecially with, you know, all the geopolitical tension,
- 3:54which brings us right to the risks, doesn't it?
- 3:55It's like they're constantly walking this tightrope.
- 3:57What are the major headwinds you see them facing right now?
- 4:00Yeah, you've nailed it. It's a kind of dual pressure
- 4:02cooker. Political and regulatory risks
- 4:05are huge. On one side you have the US,
- 4:07China tensions that's a constant background noise, sometimes
- 4:09lighter than others. There's a very real threat to
- 4:12their US listing their 80 years, right, the American depositary
- 4:15receipts. US lawmakers are pushing the SEC
- 4:18quite hard actually to potentially D list Chinese
- 4:20companies, Alibaba included, citing national security
- 4:23concerns that could it happened as soon as 2025.
- 4:25That's a massive uncertainty hanging over them.
- 4:28Huge. Then on the other side, within
- 4:30China itself, they've faced well intense government scrutiny.
- 4:33We all remember that huge anti monopoly fine, right, $2.75
- 4:37billion back in 2021. Yeah, forget that. 1.
- 4:40And it's not just fines. There are ongoing new
- 4:43regulations around data around tech platforms, often
- 4:47implemented with very little notice.
- 4:48So it's pressure from both sides.
- 4:50And beyond the politics, there are major economic and industry
- 4:53risks, too. The Chinese economy, oh, it's
- 4:56been slowing down, consumer spending, incomes, they're
- 4:58weaker. And that hits Alibaba directly.
- 5:00You saw it in their Q2 2024 results.
- 5:03Revenue growth was only what, 3.9% year over year?
- 5:06Only 3.9% wow compared to. Compared to like 30% growth just
- 5:10three years before that, it's a dramatic slowdown plus fierce
- 5:13competition. Pinduoduo especially has been
- 5:16incredibly aggressive and successful in grabbing market
- 5:18share, often targeting different consumer segments.
- 5:20Right, Pinduoduo's rise has been something else.
- 5:22And then there are those other geopolitical risks like the US
- 5:24export controls on advanced AI chips that's already directly
- 5:27impacted Alibaba. It caused delays for their
- 5:29planned cloud spin off. Wow, OK.
- 5:31So a minefield of risks. What does all this turbulence
- 5:34mean for their actual business operations, their bottom line?
- 5:37How do they manage costs when things are so uncertain and
- 5:40they're so diversified? That's the $1,000,000 question,
- 5:42isn't it? Or maybe billion dollars for
- 5:44Alibaba. They have a really significant
- 5:46cost structure. Think about the fixed costs,
- 5:48enormous data Centers for the cloud business, sprawling
- 5:51warehouses for kineologistics, huge investment and R&D across
- 5:55the board and a massive workforce, around 250,000
- 5:59employees quarter. Of 1,000,000.
- 6:00People, yeah. Then the variable costs
- 6:02marketing promotions, especially for those big shopping festivals
- 6:06like Singles Day, that costs a fortune.
- 6:08Order of film, it adds up too. Just as an example, back in mid
- 6:112022, their marketing spend was about 12% of their revenue.
- 6:14That's substantial. 12%, OK. But here's what's interesting,
- 6:17and it speaks to their operational agility.
- 6:19They adapt their spending when the economy is good.
- 6:22They push marketing hard to grab growth, but in downturns like we
- 6:25saw in 2022, they were pretty quick to slash costs, protect
- 6:28those profit margins. Smart so they can tighten the
- 6:30belt when needed. Exactly.
- 6:32And we've actually seen their operating margins expand
- 6:34recently. Gross margin is solid around
- 6:3637%. Operating margins now ticking up
- 6:38maybe 13% to 15%. This suggests something
- 6:41important. Strong operating.
- 6:43Leverage, Operating leverage. Meaning because those fixed
- 6:46costs are so large, once revenue growth does return, even
- 6:50modestly, a much bigger chunk of that extra revenue can drop
- 6:53straight to the bottom line to profit.
- 6:56I see. So a small revenue bump could
- 6:58mean a big profit jump. Potentially, yes.
- 7:00It shows underlying efficiency despite the scale and
- 7:02complexity. It's a key thing to watch.
- 7:03That is a crucial insight. OK, so with all these powerful
- 7:07forces at play, who is actually steering this massive ship?
- 7:10And maybe just as vital, what are the signals from the big
- 7:12owners, the people with the most skin in the game?
- 7:14Well, the leadership has seen some changes.
- 7:16The founder is Jack Ma, who's retired from day-to-day stuff
- 7:19now, and Joseph Tsai. They're still key figures, still
- 7:21big shareholders, but the current setup as of 2025 has Joe
- 7:25Tsai as chairman and Eddie Wu as the CEO.
- 7:28You've also got key execs like President J Michael Evans, CFO
- 7:31Toby Zhu. This team has deep, deep roots
- 7:34in e-commerce. They've got a history of
- 7:36innovation, you know, from launching Tabo way back when to
- 7:39expanding globally. And crucially, their interests
- 7:42seem pretty aligned with shareholders.
- 7:43Josiah, for instance, he's been buying shares personally.
- 7:46That's a statement. Buying his own company stock.
- 7:47Yes. And he's been spearheading that
- 7:49huge share buyback program we mentioned.
- 7:51Right. And governance wise, any major
- 7:53red flags beyond the Jack Ma situation in 2020?
- 7:57Not really. Major corporate governance
- 7:58scandals know. The Jack Ma incident was, you
- 8:01know, more political, a clash with regulators rather than
- 8:03internal fraud or something like that.
- 8:05OK. Now that buyback program you
- 8:07mentioned, it sounds huge, but sometimes companies buy back
- 8:10shares just to boost the stock price, right?
- 8:12Or because they don't see better places to invest.
- 8:14Why is this buyback seen as such a strong signal of confidence?
- 8:18That's a fairpoint, but I think the sheer scale of Alibaba's
- 8:21buyback makes it stand out. First, ownership context.
- 8:24SoftBank Group is still the biggest institutional holder,
- 8:26about 14.2%, though they've sold down quite a bit from their peak
- 8:29of around 25%. Still significant though.
- 8:31Oh yeah, and the founders PSI and MA hold about 1.4% and 4.8%
- 8:36respectively. Meaningful stakes, but the
- 8:38buyback itself, they authorized $25 billion back in 20/21/22.
- 8:42That was the largest buyback authorization ever by a Chinese
- 8:45tech company. $25 billion. Yes.
- 8:47And by May 2025, they had already used about $11.9 billion
- 8:52of that to repurchase roughly 150 million Adss, which is over
- 8:555% of their shares. Importantly, a lot of these
- 8:58buybacks happened when the price was around 80 to $100 per ADS.
- 9:01So spending that much cash at those prices under such a large
- 9:05authorization, it's a pretty clear signal for management
- 9:07saying we think our stock is significantly undervalued right
- 9:10now. They're betting on themselves,
- 9:12basically. Putting their money where their
- 9:13mouth is indeed. OK, so management seems
- 9:15confident. What about the big name
- 9:17investors, the value investing crowd?
- 9:19Are they seeing opportunity here or are they maybe spooked by the
- 9:22risks we talked about? It's a it's definitely a mixed
- 9:25bag, which is interesting in itself.
- 9:26It shows genuine disagreement among the pros about the current
- 9:29value proposition. On one hand, you have someone
- 9:31like Ray Dalio's Bridgewater Associates making a massive
- 9:33move. They dramatically ramped up
- 9:35their stake from around $21 million in early 2024 to over
- 9:38$700 million, like $727 million by Q 1/20/20.
- 9:42Five whoa from. 21 to over 700 million, That's a huge
- 9:45conviction bet. Absolutely huge.
- 9:47Then you have Michael Burke, the big short guy.
- 9:49His fund Sign Asset Management, held about 150,000 ADS in late
- 9:542024, though admittedly he did trim that position by about 25%
- 9:57recently. Still, he's involved and others
- 10:00like Prem Watson's Fairfax linked Pinnacle Associates were
- 10:03adding shares in Q 12025 too. So some heavy hitters are
- 10:06definitely seeing value. Yes, but it's not universal.
- 10:09Some other well regarded value funds like Sanders Capital
- 10:12actually cut their stakes significantly.
- 10:14OK, so divided opinions. Exactly.
- 10:16It highlights the tension potential deep value versus
- 10:19significant undeniable risks. Different smart people are
- 10:21weighing that balance differently right now.
- 10:23Fascinating. OK, let's get to the brass
- 10:25tacks, then the numbers. How has Alibaba's financial
- 10:27journey actually looked over the past, say, decade?
- 10:30And what does that story tell us about its value today,
- 10:32especially with all this recent choppiness?
- 10:34Yeah, Looking back over 10 years, the financial story is,
- 10:37well, it's dramatic. Revenue growth was just
- 10:39phenomenal for a long time. They went from about $8.5
- 10:42billion in fiscal 2014 to over $126 billion in fiscal 2023.
- 10:48That's roughly a 25% compound annual growth rate over a
- 10:51decade. Incredible scaling. 25% a year
- 10:53for 10 years. Yeah, that's staggering growth.
- 10:55It really was. But as we discussed, that growth
- 10:57engine has definitely sputtered more recently, market
- 10:59saturation, the economy revenue actually dipped about 6% in the
- 11:0220/22/23 period. That signaled a major shift.
- 11:05Margin wise. The gross margin has been pretty
- 11:07stable actually, usually in the 36% to 38% range.
- 11:10Operating margins, as I mentioned, have improved a bit
- 11:11lately, around 11.9% in FY23, maybe closer to 13% in FY24.
- 11:16But net income, that's been a real roller coaster.
- 11:18Yeah, you mentioned volatility earlier.
- 11:20Huge volatility, like they made almost $23 billion in net income
- 11:23in 2021, then it plummeted to under $10 billion, nine point
- 11:2777B in 2022 before recovering slightly to $10.56 billion in
- 11:312023. The Net margin now sits around
- 11:338% or 9% and that volatility combined with slowing growth has
- 11:37crushed their valuation multiples.
- 11:39The PE ratio price to earnings used to be well over 20X, now
- 11:42it's more like the mid teens. So the market is paying much
- 11:44less for each dollar of earnings now?
- 11:46Precisely. And return on equity Roe,
- 11:48another key metric showing profitability relative to
- 11:51shareholder investment, that's also fallen down to around six,
- 11:537% in 2023. That kind of net income swing
- 11:56and the multiple compression, it really underscores the
- 11:59uncertainty, doesn't it? The market's struggling to
- 12:01predict their earnings power in this environment.
- 12:03Absolutely. It reflects that complex mix of
- 12:04macro headwinds and regulatory pressures we talked about.
- 12:07But, and this is a big but, Despite that earnings
- 12:09volatility, their balance sheet is incredibly strong.
- 12:11They have very little net debt. In fiscal 2024, they had
- 12:14something like $84.4 billion in cash sitting there against only
- 12:18about $19.6 billion in long term debt.
- 12:20That's very low leverage. Loads of cash, little debt that
- 12:23gives them. Flexibility, huge flexibility
- 12:25and shareholder equity. It's ballooned from about $6.6
- 12:28billion back in 2014 to over $152 billion in 2024.
- 12:33So the underlying financial foundation is rock solid.
- 12:35Looking at the very latest snapshot, Q4 fiscal 2024, which
- 12:39ended December 2024, revenue was about $38.4 billion RMB 280.2 B,
- 12:44up just 4% year over year, modest growth.
- 12:47Only 4%, OK. Operational efficiency really
- 12:49came through. Operating profit jumped 17% and
- 12:52net income soared 163% year over year A. 163%.
- 12:56Partly due to someone time items fair enough, but also better
- 12:58cost control. Key metrics looked OK too. 1.315
- 13:01billion active consumers in China, better results in local
- 13:04services and smaller losses in the Kineo Logistics arm.
- 13:07It shows a company may be shifting focus slightly from
- 13:09pure growth at all costs to more efficient operations.
- 13:11Right, optimizing the massive machine they've built.
- 13:13OK, so let's try to put all these pieces together.
- 13:15The scale, the risks, management confidence, investor activity,
- 13:18the financial trends. If you run a discounted cash
- 13:21flow analysis trying to estimate the intrinsic value, what does
- 13:25that tell you? Where does the value potentially
- 13:26lie compared to the current stock price?
- 13:29OK. So using a discounted cash flow
- 13:32or specifically a discounted owner earnings approach where
- 13:34you project the future cash profits available to
- 13:36shareholders and discount them back to today's value, you get a
- 13:38range. Naturally, if you assume let's
- 13:40say modest growth going forward and you apply no margin of
- 13:43safety, the estimate for the intrinsic value per ADS per
- 13:46share basically lands somewhere in the 60 to $90.00 range
- 13:51roughly. 60 to $90.00 with no safety margin.
- 13:54Correct. Now, value investors like Warren
- 13:55Buffett often insist on a margin of safety right to account for
- 13:58errors in estimation or unexpected bad news if you apply
- 14:01a typical 30% to 50% margin of safety to that range.
- 14:04Then the target buy range gets much lower.
- 14:06It's much lower. You're looking at an intrinsic
- 14:08value range of roughly $20 to maybe $45 per ADS.
- 14:12So a very conservative DCF, maybe assuming slower growth or
- 14:15applying a large discount rate for the risks might point to a
- 14:18value around 20-30 dollars per ADSA.
- 14:21More optimistic DCF maybe assuming they successfully pivot
- 14:24to AI and cloud growth accelerates could get you closer
- 14:27to that $90.00 before you apply any safety margin.
- 14:29And the stock is currently trading around $84 as of.
- 14:32June 2025. Exactly.
- 14:34So based on this DCF framework, the current price near $84
- 14:37suggests, well, maybe modest upside, but only if you lean
- 14:40towards the more optimistic growth assumptions and use
- 14:43little to no margin of safety. It doesn't scream deep value
- 14:46based purely on a conservative DCF.
- 14:47Interesting. Depends heavily on future growth
- 14:49assumptions then. Absolutely.
- 14:50And management is talking a lot about pushing into cloud and AI
- 14:53as the new growth drivers. If they succeed there, that
- 14:56could boost future free cash flow growth beyond what recent
- 14:58history suggests potentially lifting that intrinsic value
- 15:00calculation. That's a big if.
- 15:02Wow, what a deep dive. Seriously, we've gone from the
- 15:05sheer, almost unimaginable scale of Alibaba's empire through the
- 15:09very real storms. It's navigating political,
- 15:12economic otters, then seeing the confidence signals from
- 15:15management buybacks and some big investors, and finally digging
- 15:18into the numbers that tell this really complex, nuanced story.
- 15:22It's definitely not just an e-commerce play anymore.
- 15:24It really isn't. You've got this core tension
- 15:26right? A company with incredible reach.
- 15:28A fortress balance sheet. But facing these profound, maybe
- 15:31even existential, challenges from geopolitics, regulation and
- 15:34the economy, it makes forecasting its future path
- 15:37incredibly difficult, even for the experts.
- 15:39Yeah, which leads us to a final, maybe provocative thought for
- 15:42you, our listener, to chew on. Given the strategic pivot
- 15:45they're attempting towards cloud and AI, how much of Alibaba's
- 15:48future success will really hinge on their own innovation, their
- 15:50ability to execute in these new fields?
- 15:52And how much will just be dictated by these massive
- 15:54geopolitical currents, things totally outside their control?
- 15:57It really makes you question what value even means in today's
- 16:00interconnected, rapidly changing world, doesn't it?
- 16:02It certainly does. And just one final time,
- 16:04remember our goal here is knowledge and insight.
- 16:06This is absolutely not financial advice.
- 16:08Please always your own thorough research.
- 16:10And hey, if you found this deep dive useful, we'd really
- 16:12appreciate it. If you'd like and subscribe, you
- 16:14can find us on Apple podcast, Spotify podcast or our YouTube
- 16:18channel. Just search deep value
- 16:19investing. Oh, and don't forget to check
- 16:21out the book list on value and Vista we've got on our main
- 16:24page. Lots of great resources there.