Latest / Credit Union Exam Solutions Presents With Flying Colors / Why Does NCUA Ask to Meet with CU Board without CU Staff Present??
Transcript
- 0:03Do you want to maximize your success with NCUA?
- 0:06Join Mark Treichel as he shares with you the insider's view on passing
- 0:09your exam with Flying Colors.
- 0:12The With Flying Colors podcast is sponsored by Credit Union
- 0:15Exam Solutions by Mark Treichel.
- 0:17If you would like to work directly with the Credit Union Exam Solutions
- 0:20team and receive support to optimize your results with NCUA so you save time
- 0:25and money, visit us at marktreichel.
- 0:27com to find out more.
- 0:35Treichel: Hey everyone, this is Mark Treichel with another
- 0:37episode of With Flying Colors.
- 0:38I'm back with Steve Farr and Todd Miller of my team here at Credit Union Exam
- 0:44Solutions and also formerly of NCUA.
- 0:46Guys, how you doing today?
- 0:49Farrar: Very good.
- 0:50Very good.
- 0:51Treichel: Very good.
- 0:51All right.
- 0:52And we have folks who listen to every episode and we have folks
- 0:57that listen to episodes based on what we, what the topic is, and we
- 1:02might have some new listeners today.
- 1:04So if you guys could give a little bit of your background at NCUA before you change
- 1:09teams with me and started helping credit unions what was your your journey at NCUA?
- 1:14And let's start with Steve today.
- 1:16Farrar: I welcome everybody.
- 1:19I always refer to my career.
- 1:21It was 2 parts.
- 1:231st, part in the field.
- 1:25With the credit unions, 2nd, part in the central office in the division
- 1:29of risk management, but while in the field, I got to do is just
- 1:33a big variety of examinations.
- 1:36Most of that career was as a problem case officer and got to be involved in problem
- 1:42credit unions and their resolution.
- 1:47Then I second sent another 15 of my 30 some years in the
- 1:51central office and division risk management working on many project.
- 1:55And 1 that will come into place here was I worked on the training that was provided
- 2:00to examiners on problem resolution.
- 2:03And in that was we'd hired a person that taught conflict resolution
- 2:09specifically, and that training session was one day for each examiner.
- 2:13And that was one of the things that they said it was one of the best things.
- 2:16So examiners are trained and to be able to listen well and to deal with conflict.
- 2:24And I think that was important, but so I'll just end it right
- 2:26there for going into this podcast.
- 2:29Treichel: Very good.
- 2:30And Todd.
- 2:32Miller: So I spent 34 years within CUA, I can break my career into three
- 2:36parts, probably the first third from 87 to 2000 or so, I was an examiner
- 2:42problem case officer in the western region, that middle third from 2000 to
- 2:472010 I was a capital market specialist.
- 2:51Dealt with your larger complex credit gains in the Western region.
- 2:55And then the last decade of my career, I was the director of special
- 2:58actions in the Western region, supervising problem case officers.
- 3:03So throughout my career, most of it was actually spent in larger complex
- 3:07credit gains or what you would, NCA would call troubled credit unions.
- 3:13Treichel: Troubled credit unions.
- 3:15And that kind of dovetails into, we talked about problem
- 3:18resolution, we talked about conflict resolution, troubled credit unions.
- 3:23We have experienced with our discussions with credit unions recently.
- 3:30An uptick maybe is the right word of N.
- 3:33C.
- 3:33U.
- 3:33A.
- 3:34Gathering the board of directors or some subset of the board of
- 3:38directors and asking to speak with the credit union's board of directors
- 3:43without credit union staff present.
- 3:46And, we've seen that an uptick in that in our conversations.
- 3:51And I thought it would be a good topic to walk through the nuances of why
- 3:57NCUA might ask for that to happen.
- 3:59So with that open-ended statement there, guys, what let's talk about situations
- 4:05where a board member, if a board member's listening, or a CEO or staff member
- 4:10is listening, where they might go here for the first time from NCA that they
- 4:15would like to meet with the board.
- 4:17separately from staff being present.
- 4:22Miller: I think we need to break this into a couple pieces.
- 4:26NCOA examiners asking to meet with just the board chair as part of
- 4:31an exam or part of their ongoing supervision is not that uncommon.
- 4:36And Steve and I, our first boss that we ever had when we started, he often asked
- 4:42us, He said, go to lunch with the board chairman, figure out their points of view.
- 4:46It's a very different equation when NCUA asked to meet with the full
- 4:52board without management present.
- 4:54That's a whole different
- 4:57Treichel: scenario.
- 4:58Okay.
- 4:59And so why don't we, and Steve, you can add something here, but
- 5:02so if we're going to break it into Board chair versus full board.
- 5:06We can maybe talk about board chair first, but Steve, anything before
- 5:09we jump into that, you want to add?
- 5:11Farrar: No, I think that's a good process for this discussion.
- 5:14Treichel: Okay, great.
- 5:15So scenario a NCOA asked to talk with the board chair.
- 5:23Miller: Steve talked about problem resolution and conflict resolution.
- 5:29A lot of times with meeting with board chairs and like I said, our first boss had
- 5:34us do it routinely when I was a director of special actions, I told my PCOs to
- 5:40meet with their board chairs at least once a quarter, a lot of that is just.
- 5:44Opening the doors to further communication and building trust.
- 5:49It's not nefarious.
- 5:50It's here's the board's view.
- 5:52It's gathering information, but part of it is just the examiner wants to
- 5:58meet with the board and open doors of communication and build trust.
- 6:02There's usually nothing nefarious in it.
- 6:05It happens quite often.
- 6:08It probably should happen more often than it does.
- 6:12So in those situations.
- 6:14I think just as a board chair, take it as an opportunity to learn a little bit more
- 6:19about your examiner what concerns them and take it as an opportunity to educate
- 6:24your examiner what you as a board want from your credit union, what your focus
- 6:29is, how you focus on serving the members.
- 6:32Use it as an opportunity to open doors and exchange.
- 6:37Information about your credit union and your board.
- 6:42Farrar: Yeah, I think that's the real key is that regular
- 6:45dialogue can be extremely helpful.
- 6:47And, unfortunately, that regular dialogue really occurs.
- 6:52Once the credit union is dealing with the emergence of problems, cause they'll
- 6:57tend to spend more time with, when you get to code three and stuff that regular
- 7:01dialogue will really start to kick up.
- 7:06Treichel: And there also could be a fear like it's a gotcha moment.
- 7:09It's examiners are not police officers, but they are regulators, right?
- 7:13Examiner is not the IRS, but.
- 7:15Getting a, getting an envelope from the IRS, peach makes your eyebrows
- 7:19stand up and getting a call from into a saying, Hey, I'd like to talk to you.
- 7:23They the volunteer could go, Oh gosh, did I do something wrong.
- 7:27Is there something I should I get talking points from the CEO before I,
- 7:31I call them but if it hasn't happened to the board, it's a new board chair.
- 7:36Or it's a board chair where they haven't done that.
- 7:38It could make them, get a little bit anxious or get a little bit
- 7:42worried about the fact that NCUA is considering, having that conversation.
- 7:48And then I also, I'm remembered of a quote that I say on here quite a
- 7:51bit, former NCWA board member who said, familiarity breeds consent.
- 7:55It's, it goes back to that communication.
- 7:57If I know you, and how you tick, and you know me, and how I tick if we should run
- 8:03into problems, like it's someone who has some issues that we have to deal with, If
- 8:08it ever gets to that point, we're going to under, we're going to have a little
- 8:11bit more trust as one of you mentioned.
- 8:14So that we can maybe figure things out that work both for
- 8:17NCUA and for the credit union.
- 8:19Any thoughts on anything I added there?
- 8:23Miller: I think you summed it up fairly well, Mark.
- 8:25Farrar: Yeah.
- 8:25And occasionally, I know me, I met with other board members apart from
- 8:31that, and they usually dealt with it.
- 8:34There was some specific issue there that I didn't think needed to be
- 8:36brought up to the entire board.
- 8:39I know one case that dealt with it had a board member that was
- 8:42pretty seriously delinquent on an agriculture loan and wanted to just
- 8:46get the sense of what was going on there, but and what the other board
- 8:50members would be thinking about that.
- 8:52The other ones dealt with when I would find or be informed of
- 8:56potential conflicts of interest.
- 8:58I would see, when they start using board members, firms for architecture and other
- 9:06professional services that might lead to the need for a conversation to make sure
- 9:12that was completely on the up and up.
- 9:14But those are examples of when I would meet with not just the board
- 9:19chairman, but specific board members.
- 9:23Treichel: And in those instances, making sure on the up and up that
- 9:26the votes that, you know, that the individual recused himself from the
- 9:30vote, that they did a competitive bid.
- 9:32And I'm also, as you were explaining that I'm going to date myself here again, but
- 9:36I was, I pictured you in a like Peter Falk in Colombo, asking and asking open ended
- 9:44questions to try and get to the truth.
- 9:48Farrar: Yeah, they do that.
- 9:49Oh, 1 more thing.
- 9:52Just 1 more thing.
- 9:53Yeah.
- 9:54Yeah.
- 9:54But the other thing is, we're also interested in as examiners is.
- 9:59The powers within the board, some boards are overwhelmed by 1 member
- 10:03of the board, and it really helps if the examiner is aware of who that
- 10:08is and why that situation exists.
- 10:11And is it creating a problem or not?
- 10:16Treichel: That's a good, that's a good point.
- 10:17We had, when I was at NCA we had training by an author of a
- 10:21book called the loudest duck.
- 10:23And the concept was whoever the loudest duck is in a group of ducks what a gaggle?
- 10:28What's no giggles geese.
- 10:29I don't know what a group of ducks is.
- 10:31Whatever the loudest duck is, that's who you hear, right?
- 10:34And so you can have these dynamics of group dynamics of a board or.
- 10:38Or at NCOA executives where there's someone who dominates
- 10:43those conversations which can have positive and negative effects.
- 10:49Farrar: And on those 1 on 1 meetings it's important when it's less of a group
- 10:55is is if the examiner asks a question and it's just you and the examiner, and
- 11:00you don't know the answer, just admit that, I don't know the answer to that
- 11:031, but I can get back to you on that and don't ever try to, make anything
- 11:08up, but don't be afraid to admit.
- 11:09I don't know.
- 11:10Treichel: That's great.
- 11:11Yeah, saying you don't know expresses the confidence that you don't
- 11:15feel that you maybe you should.
- 11:16And I would even say sometimes, I should know that.
- 11:18I think I know that, but let me double check to make sure
- 11:21I give you the right answer.
- 11:22And we hadn't mentioned a supervisory committee, but it's not uncommon
- 11:26or actually probably is as common or maybe even more common that
- 11:32they'll reach out to the supervisory committee and touch base with them.
- 11:35Anything you want to add on NC way talking to the supervisory committee.
- 11:41Miller: That probably happens on most exams.
- 11:44Yes.
- 11:44Supposed to happen on most exams.
- 11:47So supervisory committee chairs are probably used to talking
- 11:50to their examiners and a lot of that's just logistical.
- 11:54The agency is trying to figure out, how active the committee is and
- 11:58are they aware of their duties?
- 12:00And, what's the extent of their supervision over the credit union in terms
- 12:04of internal audit and external auditors?
- 12:07And so that's an information gathering one, too, on the part of the examiner.
- 12:11It's just a routine check in with the committee.
- 12:14It's part of their scope.
- 12:15It's something that examiners are expected to do.
- 12:20Treichel: Yeah.
- 12:20And as you were, as I was framing the question, my recollection is that
- 12:24is a required call as opposed to the others that are a, maybe regionally
- 12:30or supervisory examiner based type setups with the board and things.
- 12:33But.
- 12:34I think that reaching out to the Supervisory Committee Chair
- 12:37may actually be on the checklist of things they have to do, but
- 12:42Farrar: It's a good way, like Todd talked about measuring their engagement
- 12:46in in, in what they're doing.
- 12:49The other thing is that one's always good.
- 12:50'cause a lot of times supervisory committee is a developmental
- 12:54committee for potential board members.
- 12:57So that's never hurts to get that dialogue going with the potential board members.
- 13:03Treichel: Yep.
- 13:04No, that makes sense.
- 13:05That makes sense.
- 13:06All right, so that kind of I think we've talked through the
- 13:09talking to one board member and or talking to the chair of the board.
- 13:12Let's pivot to N.
- 13:15C.
- 13:15U.
- 13:15A.
- 13:15Has asked to speak to the entire board or the executive committee,
- 13:22but we'll focus on the entire board.
- 13:23N.
- 13:23C.
- 13:23U.
- 13:23A.
- 13:24Asked.
- 13:25to speak with the entire board without credit union staff present.
- 13:32Thoughts on that?
- 13:34Miller: Now you're getting into the realm of not such a common action.
- 13:38In my 35 years, as I was going through notes last night, I think I did this
- 13:42maybe five times as all in my career.
- 13:45So in 35 years, so it doesn't happen very often.
- 13:49In two of those five times, it was state regulators that actually
- 13:53said board, we want to talk to you without your management present.
- 13:58So it doesn't happen a lot.
- 14:01And so when it does happen, It's an unusual circumstance.
- 14:07The regulators usually have concerns of one kind or another.
- 14:11I would just say in the times I've done it, different reasons is you
- 14:16have a dominant CEO, so you're trying to figure out just where the
- 14:20board stands because the CEO has dominated all the conversations.
- 14:24It doesn't really let the board speak to the regulator at all.
- 14:29Oftentimes, while in another case, it came down to the board was just totally
- 14:35misinformed about the credit union's risk position in every way, shape, or form.
- 14:39You can say the CEO or management team was either intentionally or
- 14:44unintentionally not keeping the board informed about the whole risk position
- 14:49of what was going on in the credit union.
- 14:52Other instances, we've done it.
- 14:54In those five things is you have a board that's not holding management
- 14:59accountable for doing their job.
- 15:00And from a board governance position, hiring the CEO and holding
- 15:04them accountable is one of the primary functions of the board.
- 15:09And so we had a case where, that wasn't happening.
- 15:12And in one of the cases, it was a prelude in a way to maybe prevent NCOA from having
- 15:19to take other administrative actions.
- 15:21And it's to inform the board.
- 15:23This is what needs to happen.
- 15:25It wasn't a pleasant conversation.
- 15:27It's you're going to do A or B or NCOA is going to take the
- 15:31next administrative action.
- 15:35So in my cases, those were the reasons where I was personally involved in it.
- 15:41But boards should be aware it's not A usual practice and in fact, it's happens
- 15:50very rarely, but as we're seeing with our clients, it's happening more frequently.
- 15:55And today with like code two credit unions and it's wait, that's never
- 16:00happened in my career in the past.
- 16:02So there's some other things potentially going on.
- 16:08Farrar: And I think is that if you're a chairman and you get that, phone
- 16:11call that and see who he wants to meet without a management president.
- 16:16That I would probably ask is are you able to provide me with a just brief agenda
- 16:21that I can share with the other board members so that we can be, if we need to
- 16:25do any preparation for that meeting, they may not they may say no, this is item
- 16:30we're going to talk and that kind of would tell you a lot if they say, I'm hesitant
- 16:34to provide you a agenda ahead of time.
- 16:37Keep in mind, you should have a good idea of what the trajectory
- 16:40of your credit union is.
- 16:42Okay.
- 16:42And I doubt that you'd be real surprised.
- 16:46That that was a request that was made to meet without senior management.
- 16:49And I can't overemphasize Todd's good point about, the bar, the
- 16:53board is responsible for holding professional management accountable
- 16:58for obtaining the results of which they have put into the strategic plan.
- 17:03And that absolutely needs to happen.
- 17:08Treichel: And
- 17:10which is the kind of conversation that you'd see in a credit union that
- 17:16has complex document resolutions, and maybe not not the code too, right?
- 17:20That Todd said, we're starting to see some situations where
- 17:23well cameled credit unions are asked to have such conversations.
- 17:27And I don't know if that's a change in policy.
- 17:30At NCUA, or as you and I know that, regions do things a little bit different,
- 17:36there might be a rhythm to what's going on, and of course there's a National
- 17:39Supervision Policy Manual, but regional directors can influence how things are
- 17:44done ARDs, Associate Regional Directors of Operations can influence it, Supervisory
- 17:49Examiners, Directors of Special Actions can influence how their group of 10,
- 17:5515 examiners are handling things.
- 17:58So it, but we've seen also some things in different in all of the
- 18:03regions and all of the organizations that touch credit unions.
- 18:06So it's, yeah, it's an, it's a very interesting trend.
- 18:09And you talk about, importance of responsibility and accountability with
- 18:12staff ultimately who NCUA, Who the credit union employs, as long as they're bondable
- 18:19is up to the credit union, it's really important that the credit union operate in
- 18:24a safe and sound manner but who's employed is the responsibility of the credit union.
- 18:29And so it can get into a delicate situation there if you're, if
- 18:33they're trying to point out, issues that could go into that arena.
- 18:38I don't know if we want to talk, go down that path in this podcast here today, or
- 18:42that might be a story for another day.
- 18:46Farrar: I go through 1 I want to bring up is, 1 of the questions that you
- 18:49might have is a board member based on that trajectory of your credit union.
- 18:53And what you know what's going on is, do you feel like you need to have
- 18:58legal representation at that meeting?
- 19:01I know it's always a joke that I had.
- 19:03I used to get called into.
- 19:05When I was just an examiner and a PCO that the regional director just
- 19:08usually wanted to catch up with me.
- 19:09And I would always ask jokingly, Oh, do I need to bring my lawyer?
- 19:13And everybody's laughing.
- 19:14And then one time there was a meeting, it was like I don't know.
- 19:16You might want to think about it today.
- 19:18But I think that's important that that you can question that you can ask even
- 19:22the numbers you think would be appropriate for us to have counsel at that one.
- 19:26And then you can ask that, but it is your decision.
- 19:28If you need counsel, then.
- 19:29It's really needs to be clear that if you bring counsel to that
- 19:33meeting who they're representing, because that would be the question.
- 19:37I would always ask if counsel is there.
- 19:39It's do you represent the board?
- 19:41Are you representing an individual board member?
- 19:44But they wouldn't, you wouldn't have somebody that's representing the CEO.
- 19:49So I think those are issues that you have to clearly consider.
- 19:53You guys's thoughts on that.
- 19:56Miller: I've asked that question of attorneys a few times
- 19:59when they've been present.
- 20:00I want to circle back to your whole comment about the board asking the
- 20:07regulators if they have an agenda and are willing to share with it because
- 20:11the simple fact of the matter is The regulator and see you a state regulator.
- 20:17They don't ask to meet with the board unless they have an agenda.
- 20:22Now they might not want to share it in writing but be
- 20:24assured they have an agenda.
- 20:27So I think, along with the General Counsel recommendation that Steve brought up.
- 20:33I think there's a couple things that boards need to keep in mind
- 20:37when they're asked for this one I'd recommend you don't refuse them.
- 20:43Refusing to meet with the regulator is just inviting additional
- 20:47actions or administrative actions on their part, and you probably
- 20:50don't want to go down with that.
- 20:51That path.
- 20:52So if N.
- 20:54C.
- 20:54U.
- 20:55A.
- 20:55or state regulator asked to meet with the board without management
- 20:58present as a board, you should probably agree to do that.
- 21:02Refusing is probably not in the credit unions interest.
- 21:06But in terms of the meeting itself like Steve had mentioned earlier, asking
- 21:11for an agenda ahead of time is good.
- 21:14Whether they'll give you one or not is a different thing, or they might give
- 21:17you a verbal one and not a written one.
- 21:20It is good to perhaps have your attorney present.
- 21:24I think as a board, one thing you have to be very careful about
- 21:28during these meetings is that you don't agree to anything.
- 21:33Go there and listen, have questions back and forth.
- 21:37But as a board in a pressured meeting where you might not have an Clear
- 21:42agenda on the part of the regulators.
- 21:44I think it's important as a board, you go and listen and you keep an open mind.
- 21:49But at that specific meeting, don't agree to anything with
- 21:53the regulators at that meeting.
- 21:55You need a chance to talk that over with your fellow board
- 21:58members away from the regulators.
- 22:01You need a chance to involve your executives.
- 22:04You need a chance to potentially involve your credit union's counsel.
- 22:09So be careful that you don't agree to anything, to agree to take any actions.
- 22:15You might agree that a problem exists or something that they bring
- 22:18up, but don't agree to take any actions at a meeting of that nature.
- 22:23You might even consider asking to record the meeting.
- 22:26If it's within CUA, they generally have to allow you to do that.
- 22:32There are certain state regulators that will not allow you to
- 22:35record meetings with them.
- 22:37So that answer to that question can go either way.
- 22:41I've been in meetings like this sometimes state regulators are present in a state
- 22:44chartered credit union and sometimes it's been just with federal credit
- 22:48unions, but there are some states out there that will not allow you to record
- 22:52meetings, but you might think about asking if you can record the meeting.
- 22:57Take notes.
- 22:58But the big thing is listen attentively speak truthfully.
- 23:03If you don't know the answer to something, like we talked about
- 23:06earlier with an individual if you don't know the answer, tell them you
- 23:09don't know the answer or just say it.
- 23:11And keep your mouth closed in this situation, but be honest with them
- 23:16and anything you do say But in the big scheme of things This is not the
- 23:22meeting to make agreements with them
- 23:25Farrar: That's a really good point because we actually recently did deal
- 23:27with a credit union where the board and the examiner had met together and agreed
- 23:33on doing something and the Examiner thought the board was going to tell
- 23:37senior management about it You and the other 1, 5 and 2, 8 was going to partner.
- 23:41Nobody told senior management would have been agreed to in that meeting.
- 23:44And, it was, weeks later, and everybody starts asking him, it was like.
- 23:47Nice to know, so that's just following up on those recapping those meetings is
- 23:54something that usually should be done.
- 23:57If the NCOA doesn't do it, you should do it as your organization.
- 24:02That's always important.
- 24:03Here's what we understand in our conclusions of our meeting.
- 24:08That's a great
- 24:09Treichel: point.
- 24:09Yeah, as Todd was walking through that, the situation of not making commitments,
- 24:14if you don't have the people, there may be unintended consequences and
- 24:19NCOA should, A, NCOA should not expect you to make decisions like that.
- 24:23And B, there may be unintended consequences that both the people
- 24:27at NCUA and the board might not be aware of if they were to take
- 24:31some sort of action similar to the situation you're referring to.
- 24:36And then the taping concept, that's something NCUA's vice chairman, Kyle
- 24:40Houtman talks about at NCUA board meetings, NCUA actually in their closed
- 24:45section of their exam report, they have to check a box that says whether
- 24:49or not the meeting was tape recorded.
- 24:53And so NCOA current regime is pushing people to do that so
- 24:59that they've got a good record.
- 25:00And the reality is anything that NCOA says in a meeting with the board they should be
- 25:05comfortable that there be a record of it.
- 25:0740 years ago, that might not have been the case, but today in the world we're
- 25:11living in that is indeed the case.
- 25:13So very good.
- 25:14What else?
- 25:15What else we got on this topic guys?
- 25:17Anything you can think of?
- 25:18I
- 25:20Farrar: think at times you may get, emotional.
- 25:23And that occurs in some of these meetings.
- 25:26And it's okay to disagree with the examiner, but you have
- 25:29to do it in a respectful way.
- 25:32And you may have to just say, we need that.
- 25:34We need a break right now.
- 25:36If you can feel like you're triggered and might not be.
- 25:39In the best of shape to continue the conversation right at that minute.
- 25:43So it's just all of that, good listening and conflict resolution type skills.
- 25:51Treichel: As my mom said, you got two ears and one mouth for a reason, go into
- 25:54those meetings planning on listening and not using your mouth so much.
- 26:00Miller: He speaks about emotional stuff in the big scheme of things in my career.
- 26:04It never bothered me when boards got emotional, especially if you were giving
- 26:08them news that was unexpected to them or they perhaps didn't want to hear.
- 26:13I found quite often if they got emotional, it was helpful in the long run because
- 26:18They would go back later and they would rethink their whole position and go
- 26:22over everything that they were told.
- 26:25And quite often it was a catalyst to moving forward.
- 26:30Treichel: Yeah.
- 26:30The seven stages of grief, you gave them maybe some bad news about
- 26:33something that they weren't aware of, and they're going to, they're
- 26:36going to have some emotions there.
- 26:37Yeah, this is an interesting topic guys.
- 26:39Again, we're seeing it.
- 26:41More frequently taught in the front end.
- 26:42You had mentioned you saw it less than five times.
- 26:45And I'm recalling three in particular.
- 26:47And two of those three were actually state exams where they called
- 26:50them into the office and said, you're coming to the office and
- 26:54you can leave your staff at home.
- 26:56And states tend to.
- 26:58Be a little bit more aggressive in that maneuver, at least they did back
- 27:01when you and I and Steve were at NCUA.
- 27:03Miller: Like I said, out of my five, it was state commissioners twice, once on
- 27:08the Canadian border and once at a state on the Mexican border, so extreme North
- 27:12and South, and in those cases, Both times the commissioners, the highest
- 27:17level at the state, they went to the credit union, but it was pretty clear
- 27:22that state commissioner was in charge of the meeting and they had very specific
- 27:26reasons for meeting with those credit unions without their management present.
- 27:30Treichel: Same in my, in the one I was involved with.
- 27:33Very good.
- 27:34It's happening more frequently.
- 27:36If it happens consider having your attorney present, consider tape recording
- 27:40listen more than committing to actions.
- 27:44If it should happen and any last thoughts again, before we wrap up here, guys, I'm
- 27:50Miller: reemphasize Steve's point, ask them if they have an agenda.
- 27:56Farrar: Yeah.
- 27:57Miller: And exam.
- 27:58Farrar: Examiners are people and they're usually, after the, the
- 28:02best interest of your institution.
- 28:04So just keep that in mind.
- 28:07Treichel: Great point.
- 28:08Great point.
- 28:08As always, this is fun.
- 28:10It's fun chatting with you guys about these topics.
- 28:12I think we all probably sparked a synapse in our brain of a story
- 28:17that we hadn't thought of for a while, which makes us smile.
- 28:20And I appreciate your time, Steve and Todd.
- 28:24Miller: Have a great day, Mark.
- 28:25Treichel: You too.
- 28:26And listeners, I want to thank you for listening as always.
- 28:29I hope you'll listen again soon.
- 28:31This is Mark Treichel signing off with Flying Colors.
- 28:39Thank you for joining us on this episode of with flying colors, subscribe on
- 28:44your favorite podcast app to hear future episodes where subject matter experts
- 28:47of all varieties will provide tips on how to achieve success with NCUA.
- 28:52If you would like to learn more about how we assist credit unions, check
- 28:55out our services at marktreichel.
- 28:57com.