Latest / Bloomberg Law / How the Warhol Ruling will Impact Copyright Law
Transcript
- 0:03Speaker 1: This is Bloomberg Law with June Brusso from Bloomberg Radio.
- 0:09Speaker 1: With dueling opinions from two liberal justices, the Supreme Court
- 0:14Speaker 1: ruled that Andy Warhol violated the copyright of photographer Lynn
- 0:18Speaker 1: Goldsmith by using her work to create sixteen images of Prince.
- 0:23Speaker 1: In a seven to two vote. The Justice has rejected
- 0:26Speaker 1: the arguments that the late artists transformed the photograph of Prince,
- 0:31Speaker 1: making it fair use under federal copyright law. In the
- 0:35Speaker 1: majority opinion, Justice Sonya Sotomayor pointed to the commercial use
- 0:39Speaker 1: as a key factor in determining that Warhol hadn't engaged
- 0:43Speaker 1: in fair use, something that echoed her questions in the
- 0:46Speaker 1: oral arguments.
- 0:48Speaker 2: That's up to what was made, What use was made
- 0:52Speaker 2: of Orange Prince. It was a highly commercial use. Goldsmith's
- 0:57Speaker 2: also licensed her photographs to magaz means just as warholtz
- 1:02Speaker 2: a state did so, how is it that your two
- 1:06Speaker 2: thousand and six license and Goldsmith's photographs do not share
- 1:10Speaker 2: the same commercial purpose.
- 1:12Speaker 1: In dissent, Justice Elena Kagan, joined by Chief Justice John Roberts, said, quote,
- 1:18Speaker 1: if Warhol doesn't get credit for transformative copying, who will?
- 1:23Speaker 1: Something the Chief had expressed during the arguments.
- 1:26Speaker 3: It's not just that Warhol has a different style, is it.
- 1:30Speaker 1: Unlike Goldsmith's photograph, warl sends a message about the depersonalization
- 1:36Speaker 1: of modern culture and celebrity status. Joining me is intellectual
- 1:40Speaker 1: property litigator Terrence Ross, a partner at Caton Much and Rosenman.
- 1:44Speaker 1: We've talked about this case many times, and I have
- 1:47Speaker 1: to say that I was surprised by the verdict. Were
- 1:50Speaker 1: you surprised?
- 1:52Speaker 4: I was not surprised by the outcome. I was surprised
- 1:54Speaker 4: by the seven to two vote. During oral argument, you
- 1:58Speaker 4: knew exactly how the Chief Justice was going to vote.
- 2:01Speaker 4: He on a couple occasions made statements in the form
- 2:04Speaker 4: of the question, but they weren't questions. They were simply
- 2:06Speaker 4: expressing his views. How could you possibly not think this
- 2:09Speaker 4: is a fair use? And I'm paraphrasing. And after each
- 2:12Speaker 4: of those instances you could hear crickets. The rest of
- 2:16Speaker 4: the court was dead sign it. Several of the justices
- 2:19Speaker 4: looked at their papers and shuffled their papers like they
- 2:21Speaker 4: were embarrassed that their old uncle had said something. And
- 2:25Speaker 4: one of the justices pointedly leaned over looked down the
- 2:28Speaker 4: panel with that look on his faces, what is it
- 2:30Speaker 4: that you're smoking? So you sort of got a sense
- 2:33Speaker 4: that you knew exactly what the Chief Justice was going
- 2:35Speaker 4: to do, and you also sort of knew that his
- 2:38Speaker 4: view was not going to prevail. He had a very
- 2:41Speaker 4: very deferential view, which is expressed in part Justice Kagan's dissent,
- 2:46Speaker 4: essentially that if an artist says I'm doing something different,
- 2:49Speaker 4: then fair use applies, which is of course nonsense. So
- 2:52Speaker 4: I wasn't surprised by the outcome, but I was surprised
- 2:55Speaker 4: that the majority cobbled together seven votes, which makes this
- 2:58Speaker 4: opinion all the more significant because it was not a
- 3:01Speaker 4: close call.
- 3:02Speaker 1: So Terry for the majority, was the key factor in
- 3:05Speaker 1: determining fair use, the purpose of the works, the commercial
- 3:09Speaker 1: use of Warhol's image, and the fact that both were
- 3:13Speaker 1: used as magazine illustrations.
- 3:15Speaker 4: That is certainly what the majority decision says. If you
- 3:21Speaker 4: read a little bit more closely, there's this very interesting
- 3:26Speaker 4: discussion of derivative works. One of the rights that copyright
- 3:31Speaker 4: gives an artist is the exclusive right to prepare derivative
- 3:35Speaker 4: works based on the original work, And what Justice Somayor
- 3:39Speaker 4: said was that the way that the law transformative use
- 3:43Speaker 4: has evolved, it has virtually swallowed up the concept and
- 3:48Speaker 4: the exclusive right to prepare derivative works. And indeed, at
- 3:52Speaker 4: one point she says, we have to protect this exclusive
- 3:56Speaker 4: right to prepare derivative works and prevent this transformative use
- 4:03Speaker 4: test from swallowing this exclusive right to derivative works. So
- 4:07Speaker 4: I think there was an element of concern about that,
- 4:10Speaker 4: and that clearly comes through in several places. But the
- 4:14Speaker 4: way it's expressed in the most part in the decision
- 4:17Speaker 4: is through this notion of the textual words. Is there
- 4:20Speaker 4: a different purpose or character to the secondary use?
- 4:23Speaker 1: So what's the test?
- 4:25Speaker 4: Now, that's a great question. So keep in mind that
- 4:29Speaker 4: we're talking about batcheatory language, the fair use Statute, which
- 4:32Speaker 4: has a four factor test. The only part of that
- 4:37Speaker 4: test that is at issue in this case is the
- 4:40Speaker 4: first factor. Although the courts toss off these words that
- 4:43Speaker 4: all factors have to be considered, no one factor is
- 4:45Speaker 4: more important than the other, the reality is that the
- 4:48Speaker 4: first factor is always the most important factor. The first
- 4:50Speaker 4: factor says, you know, in considering whether there's a fair use,
- 4:54Speaker 4: you have to consider, and I'm quoting here the purpose
- 4:56Speaker 4: and character of the use, including whether such use is
- 5:00Speaker 4: of a commercial nature or is for nonprofit educational purposes.
- 5:03Speaker 4: And so the battleground has been on this purpose and
- 5:07Speaker 4: character of the use. And I see this case really
- 5:10Speaker 4: as not a radical shift, but as a clarification of
- 5:13Speaker 4: what that purpose and character of the secondary use means.
- 5:17Speaker 4: And just so to major starts a trope that will
- 5:20Speaker 4: continue throughout the decision. She talks about the matter of degree.
- 5:24Speaker 4: She says, specifically, the larger the difference, you know, the
- 5:28Speaker 4: greater the degree, the more likely the first factor weighs
- 5:31Speaker 4: in fair use. So the greater the change in purpose
- 5:34Speaker 4: or character of use, the more likely it is going
- 5:38Speaker 4: to be a fair use, and the smaller the difference
- 5:40Speaker 4: in purpose or character, the less likely. And so what
- 5:43Speaker 4: she has done, in my view, is set up a
- 5:46Speaker 4: balancing test of sorts. First, you look at what is
- 5:49Speaker 4: the difference in purpose, what is the difference in use?
- 5:52Speaker 4: You consider how much of a difference that is from
- 5:55Speaker 4: the original work, and then you have to do another thing.
- 5:58Speaker 4: She says, if it's a commercial use, then you have
- 6:01Speaker 4: to have even more significant of a difference than if
- 6:04Speaker 4: it's a nonprofit educational used. To our criticism, something the
- 6:08Speaker 4: other you don't have to have as great a difference
- 6:11Speaker 4: in purpose or character of the secondary use. And so
- 6:14Speaker 4: I think that's what the test on the first factor is.
- 6:17Speaker 4: And again she says this, I'm not pausing out this
- 6:19Speaker 4: transformative use concept, but and she says transformativeness is a
- 6:25Speaker 4: matter of degree. She again keeps coming back to this
- 6:27Speaker 4: notion that it's not all or nothing. A district court
- 6:30Speaker 4: judge has to look at the degree to which the
- 6:33Speaker 4: purported difference and whether that is significant to overcome what
- 6:37Speaker 4: is a straightforward commercial usage. Was what was going on here.
- 6:40Speaker 1: Justices Sotomayor and Kagan are both liberals, usually allies, but
- 6:47Speaker 1: there was an unusually sharp tone in their opinions here.
- 6:52Speaker 1: Justice Elena Kagan, joined by the Chief Justice, wrote the dissent.
- 6:56Speaker 1: Justice Kagan wrote, the majority does not see it, and
- 7:00Speaker 1: I mean that literally, And she gave this example. If
- 7:03Speaker 1: a magazine editor publishing an article about Prince and an
- 7:06Speaker 1: employee asks whether you want to use the Goldsmith photo
- 7:10Speaker 1: or the Warhol portrait, and she says, quote, would you
- 7:14Speaker 1: say that you don't really care that the employee is
- 7:16Speaker 1: free to flip a coin? In the majority's view, you
- 7:19Speaker 1: apparently would. What do you think of her analysis?
- 7:22Speaker 4: Oh, I've always thought, as a practicing lawyer advising clients
- 7:27Speaker 4: with serious and significant mondary issues here that it's a
- 7:31Speaker 4: challenging role for us to decide what's fair use and
- 7:34Speaker 4: what is not. It's just the nature of the concept
- 7:37Speaker 4: has to be somewhat flexible, somewhat plastic to allow the
- 7:42Speaker 4: cover odd situations that come up. And so yes, there
- 7:45Speaker 4: are a handful of black letter cases where you can
- 7:50Speaker 4: say one way or the other, you know that this
- 7:52Speaker 4: is fair use is not fair use. But the vast
- 7:55Speaker 4: majority fall in the middle ground. And it's a very
- 7:58Speaker 4: nuanced analysis. So that's always been true. And again you
- 8:02Speaker 4: have here Justice Kagan never practiced law in any real sense.
- 8:06Speaker 4: She wes Solicitor General and she's only peering court as
- 8:08Speaker 4: a practier six times, all of them in the Supring Court.
- 8:11Speaker 4: I might add, for which you want, but prior to
- 8:14Speaker 4: becoming a solicity to general, it never been at court room.
- 8:16Speaker 4: It was an academic and I think that is something
- 8:19Speaker 4: that's missing often from the court, this real world practice component.
- 8:24Speaker 4: And this is hard. Ears you said it's unfair to
- 8:26Speaker 4: say there's a flip of the coin. I mean, it's
- 8:28Speaker 4: just not right. More to the point, I think her
- 8:31Speaker 4: decision in many ways very intemperate and unfortunately draws them
- 8:35Speaker 4: and in temperate responds backs from the majority decision. I mean,
- 8:39Speaker 4: sort of unheard of, And I think you make a
- 8:41Speaker 4: very good point, Jennie Bryant. They're usually allies and from
- 8:44Speaker 4: the liberal wing of the court. You and I have
- 8:46Speaker 4: discussed this in past copyright cases. Copyright doesn't seem to
- 8:50Speaker 4: break down on some sort of partisan division lawns. Here
- 8:53Speaker 4: you have the Chief Justice who's a moderate Republican appointee,
- 8:57Speaker 4: and Justice Kagan perceived to be a liberal vote the
- 9:00Speaker 4: other and just so to major writing majority supported by
- 9:04Speaker 4: all of the other conservatives on the Court, including arguably
- 9:08Speaker 4: the most liberal Judge Jackson. I mean, for years, copyright
- 9:12Speaker 4: case or are dominated by Justice Ginsberg and Justice Bryer,
- 9:15Speaker 4: who are opposite ends of the spectrum on copyright law.
- 9:18Speaker 4: Justice Briar believing in a very robust fair use and
- 9:22Speaker 4: Justice Ginsburg believing in very robust protection for copyright. Yeah,
- 9:26Speaker 4: arguably they were kindred cousins on most other cases. So
- 9:31Speaker 4: copyright really you can't analyze in sort of a liberal
- 9:34Speaker 4: versus conservative way. But what is interesting here is you
- 9:37Speaker 4: have two of the justices who arguably are a slightly
- 9:40Speaker 4: different socioeconomic situation throughout their lives versus all the others
- 9:44Speaker 4: who are different, and some of the tone of Justice
- 9:47Speaker 4: Kaigan reflects that I think this knee jerk reaction that
- 9:51Speaker 4: Chief Justice had, and then Justice Kagan reflects that we've
- 9:54Speaker 4: got to protect artists, we've got to protect creativity without
- 9:57Speaker 4: actually thinking about what's going on in in this case.
- 10:00Speaker 4: You know, you saw this with Justice Ginsberg often and
- 10:03Speaker 4: Justice Bryer, who were clearly too wealthiest of the justices
- 10:07Speaker 4: went to the opera or patrons of the art, And
- 10:09Speaker 4: here you have a distinct group of justices who did
- 10:11Speaker 4: not grow up that way and did not live their
- 10:13Speaker 4: lives that way and taking a different approach, which is,
- 10:16Speaker 4: you know, you've got a photographer here trying to earn
- 10:18Speaker 4: a living, and you're cheating her out of that. And
- 10:21Speaker 4: there's even a line where she says, you could have
- 10:24Speaker 4: taken a few dollars and sent it to Lynn Goldsmith's
- 10:28Speaker 4: Planet photographer out of all the money you're making off
- 10:31Speaker 4: of publishing these Warhol prints. And I thought that one
- 10:36Speaker 4: was very revealing of sort of behind the scenes the
- 10:39Speaker 4: way they were thinking of it. And I think that's
- 10:41Speaker 4: really important subrosa narrative that's going on here.
- 10:46Speaker 1: Well, do you agree with Justice Kagan and the Chief
- 10:50Speaker 1: that this decision will stifle creativity of every sort?
- 10:55Speaker 4: Now, absolutely not, it won't. I think this is a
- 10:58Speaker 4: decision that's well ground it in fair use principles, exactly
- 11:02Speaker 4: the opposite of what Justice Kagan says. I sort of
- 11:04Speaker 4: expected it to come out this way. I didn't think
- 11:06Speaker 4: there would be as strong as support for it. But
- 11:09Speaker 4: we have seen this fair use first factor analysis run
- 11:14Speaker 4: amock the Carew case in the Second Circuit where a
- 11:17Speaker 4: photographer took some very creative photographs of Rastafarians in Jamaica
- 11:22Speaker 4: and so called artists done up putting air quotes around.
- 11:24Speaker 4: Artists came along, doodled on them, You drew sunglasses on
- 11:28Speaker 4: one hand and drew guitar and the other and sold them.
- 11:31Speaker 4: And the Second Circuits that those doodles were transformative and
- 11:34Speaker 4: that was an abomination of a fairy And that case
- 11:38Speaker 4: is dead. Now you want to know what the Warhol
- 11:41Speaker 4: case does. That case is dead. That whole type of
- 11:43Speaker 4: approach is dead. What we've done is get back to
- 11:47Speaker 4: the textual analysis of what the words say which is
- 11:51Speaker 4: very important and most important to what we haven't talked
- 11:53Speaker 4: about yet is this reasserted objective test with respect to
- 12:00Speaker 4: purpose of use, which just rings so clearly here. It
- 12:04Speaker 4: is the part that I think district quot judges have
- 12:06Speaker 4: to pay most attention to. What Justice Soda Mayor says
- 12:08Speaker 4: is quote here, a court should not attempt to evaluate
- 12:11Speaker 4: the artistic significance of a particular work, which is exactly
- 12:14Speaker 4: what Justice Kane does. She goes on and on and
- 12:16Speaker 4: on about how great Andy Warhol is, and I would
- 12:19Speaker 4: have loved to see the first draft majority opinion because
- 12:21Speaker 4: Justice Soda Myyer, I'm convinced in a subseqan draft goes
- 12:25Speaker 4: in and rewrites the beginning of her decision to talk
- 12:27Speaker 4: about how great Lynn Goldsmith is photographer, and from a
- 12:30Speaker 4: feminist approach, there were no women's photographers doing rock and
- 12:34Speaker 4: roll back in the sixties and seventies. She created a
- 12:37Speaker 4: whole new genre of rock and roll photography and deserves
- 12:40Speaker 4: credit for that. And it was an interesting, again dueling
- 12:43Speaker 4: approach to this case. But to get back to the
- 12:45Speaker 4: subjective test, Justice Soda Myer goes on to say, nor
- 12:49Speaker 4: does the subjective intent of the user the artist determine
- 12:53Speaker 4: the purpose of the use. And this is the critical
- 12:55Speaker 4: sentence that will get quoted over and over again in
- 12:57Speaker 4: district of poor opinions whether the purpose and character of
- 13:00Speaker 4: a use ways in favor of fair uses, an objective
- 13:03Speaker 4: inquiry into what use was made, and what she's saying
- 13:07Speaker 4: there is I don't care what the artist says. I
- 13:09Speaker 4: don't care that the artist says that it is transformed.
- 13:12Speaker 4: I don't care what the judge thinks. Judges shouldn't be
- 13:14Speaker 4: art critics in the first place. That goes back to
- 13:17Speaker 4: the nineteen twenties that doctorate and what we had seen
- 13:19Speaker 4: in the Crew case was reflective of This is artists
- 13:23Speaker 4: coming in after the fact and concocting some story as
- 13:27Speaker 4: to how they were trying to do something different and
- 13:29Speaker 4: therefore was a transformative use. And what just as Sodoma
- 13:32Speaker 4: are in the overwhelming majority say, here's no, that's not
- 13:35Speaker 4: the way. Let's look at this from a reasonable person
- 13:37Speaker 4: perspective and what is the objective purpose here? And in
- 13:41Speaker 4: this case they said, the objective purpose of Lynn Goldsmith's
- 13:45Speaker 4: photograph was to illustrate a magazine article about Prince's life.
- 13:50Speaker 4: What was the objective purpose of the Warhol print. It
- 13:53Speaker 4: was to illustrate a magazine article about Prince's life. Therefore
- 13:58Speaker 4: the purpose was the same, and therefore you lose on
- 14:01Speaker 4: factor one. And if there's anything that makes fair use
- 14:05Speaker 4: analysis simpler here in this decision, that's it, because now
- 14:09Speaker 4: we know exactly how to perform the analysis of what
- 14:12Speaker 4: is the secondary purpose? What is the secondary use? What's
- 14:15Speaker 4: the purpose of the secondary use? We now know how
- 14:17Speaker 4: to do that. And once we have that, the test
- 14:20Speaker 4: really kicks in just the same as it always has
- 14:23Speaker 4: in past cases. Is that the same purpose and character
- 14:27Speaker 4: of use as the original And if so, you lose
- 14:30Speaker 4: no fair use. So I think that's really really important here.
- 14:34Speaker 1: So in a concurring opinion by Justice Neil Gorsich joined
- 14:38Speaker 1: by Justice Katanji Brown Jackson, again an unusual duo left
- 14:43Speaker 1: open the possibility that the princes images could claim fair
- 14:46Speaker 1: use protection in other contexts.
- 14:49Speaker 4: It's absolutely true. I mean, what happened here, end of
- 14:52Speaker 4: the day. You know, the client always does where do
- 14:54Speaker 4: I stand? And the answer for the Warhol Foundation is
- 14:57Speaker 4: you lost this case on appeal. They waived any challenge
- 15:01Speaker 4: to factor two, three and four, which they lost below
- 15:04Speaker 4: and had bet the farm on factor one, they've now
- 15:07Speaker 4: lost factor one. And oh, by the way, they early
- 15:10Speaker 4: on conceded substantial similarity. So in the majority opinion says,
- 15:15Speaker 4: we affirmed the decision by the second Circuit, the Court
- 15:17Speaker 4: of Appeals. Here the way the second Circuit it approached
- 15:20Speaker 4: this was we're gring a grands summary judgment to Lynn Goldsmith.
- 15:23Speaker 4: The plane of it still has to go back to
- 15:25Speaker 4: the district court for determination of damages and attorney's fees
- 15:28Speaker 4: and the like, but the Andy Warhol Foundation has now lost.
- 15:32Speaker 4: What the concurring decision by Justice Gorswitz says, is this
- 15:37Speaker 4: all the hyperbole in the descent by Justice Kagan can
- 15:41Speaker 4: be ignored. At one point in her descent, Justice Kagan,
- 15:44Speaker 4: and she puts in illustrations of various artists through history
- 15:49Speaker 4: painting reclining nude women. They're all in the public domain,
- 15:53Speaker 4: so it's not a copyright issue. And she says, so
- 15:55Speaker 4: going forward, is no one allowed to paint a woman
- 15:59Speaker 4: in a reclining position because of this decision? And that's
- 16:02Speaker 4: pure hyperbole. In a justice corsition, Justice Jackson call her
- 16:06Speaker 4: out and they say a quote worried about the fate
- 16:09Speaker 4: of artists seeking to portray reclining nudes or papal authorities
- 16:13Speaker 4: or authors hoping to build on classic literary themes. Worry not,
- 16:17Speaker 4: the case does not call us on us to strike
- 16:19Speaker 4: a balance between rewarding creators and enabling others to build
- 16:22Speaker 4: on their work. And again, this is just a reiteration
- 16:27Speaker 4: that the decision is in line with pre existing fair
- 16:32Speaker 4: use analysis. It simply clarifies how we make the determination
- 16:37Speaker 4: as to what the purpose and character of the secondary
- 16:39Speaker 4: use is and make it very hard for an artist
- 16:45Speaker 4: whoever is creating the secondary work to make up some
- 16:50Speaker 4: theory that they claim that is it transformed its use. Instead,
- 16:53Speaker 4: we look at taking an objective approach. And therefore that's
- 16:56Speaker 4: why I think this is not a radical change, but
- 16:59Speaker 4: it is a very significant clarification, and I would go
- 17:02Speaker 4: so far as say this is arguably the most important
- 17:04Speaker 4: copyright case of the twenty first century. Keeping mind that
- 17:07Speaker 4: Supreme Court has not looked at fair use now since
- 17:10Speaker 4: nineteen ninety four, almost going on thirty years.
- 17:12Speaker 1: What happens next in this case, So.
- 17:15Speaker 4: We'll go back to the district court and the district
- 17:17Speaker 4: court will have to determine how much Lynn Goldsmith should
- 17:21Speaker 4: get by way of the infringement and whether or not
- 17:24Speaker 4: she should get attorney's fees, which could be very significant.
- 17:28Speaker 4: My guess is that because this is a really important
- 17:32Speaker 4: case and there was a lot of confusion as to
- 17:37Speaker 4: what the law is, the district court was saying, now
- 17:39Speaker 4: you don't get attorney's fees. This wasn't that sort of case.
- 17:43Speaker 4: There were real doubts. Now we've got those doubts clarified,
- 17:46Speaker 4: and so that the Andy Warhol Foundation actually did all
- 17:49Speaker 4: of us a favor by forcing us to litigate this through.
- 17:51Speaker 4: And I'll also say that based on the evidence I
- 17:54Speaker 4: saw in the record on damages, I don't think she's
- 17:57Speaker 4: going to get a lot of money either. I mean
- 17:59Speaker 4: in the neighborhood between one and ten thousand dollars. Really, yeah,
- 18:03Speaker 4: because that's what these licenses were going for. There's a
- 18:05Speaker 4: lot of evidence of record here. I mean, that's one
- 18:08Speaker 4: of the points Justice Soda Mayor was making is why
- 18:11Speaker 4: didn't you just toss her a few bucks to get
- 18:14Speaker 4: the rights to this when you're making all this money
- 18:16Speaker 4: on it. It's a fair point. And you know what,
- 18:19Speaker 4: you talk about creativity. Justice Kagan talks about creativity and
- 18:22Speaker 4: the damage to creativity The real damage has been this
- 18:25Speaker 4: overbroad interpretation of fair use, which is preventing photographers and
- 18:30Speaker 4: other original artists from getting their fair due and having
- 18:35Speaker 4: that money siphoned off by secondary uses. This being a
- 18:39Speaker 4: classic example of this. And I think this was necessary,
- 18:42Speaker 4: and I think remedies the flaw of the types of
- 18:45Speaker 4: cases like crew that had gone overboard.
- 18:47Speaker 1: We'll see how the district courts do with the test
- 18:49Speaker 1: Thanks so much, Terry. That's Terrence Ross of Catain, Mutchen Rosenman.
- 18:54Speaker 3: Thank tot ver remain a place for free expression and
- 18:57Speaker 3: we're not be manipulated by government.
- 19:01Speaker 1: And TikTok backed up the testimony of its CEO So
- 19:04Speaker 1: Shoe by suing Montana, the first state to ban the
- 19:08Speaker 1: popular app. The company says it doesn't share US user
- 19:12Speaker 1: data with the Chinese government and has taken substantial steps
- 19:16Speaker 1: to protect the privacy and security of TikTok users.
- 19:20Speaker 3: That's what we've been doing for the last two years,
- 19:22Speaker 3: building what amounts to a firewall this use of protected
- 19:27Speaker 3: US user data from unauthorized foreign access.
- 19:30Speaker 1: TikTok has been here before, and one federal courts bloc.
- 19:34Speaker 1: Former President Donald Trump's executive order banning TikTok and the
- 19:38Speaker 1: Chinese app we chat back in twenty twenty. Joining me
- 19:42Speaker 1: is Jorge Marquez of the Warren Law Group. So one
- 19:45Speaker 1: of the arguments that TikTok is making is that the
- 19:48Speaker 1: ban violates free speech rights.
- 19:51Speaker 5: So basically, the argument goes that the ban goes to
- 19:56Speaker 5: not just the users, because you're eliminating TikTok at a
- 20:00Speaker 5: medium for the users to be able to post and
- 20:03Speaker 5: express themselves pursuant to the First Amendment, but also TikTok.
- 20:07Speaker 5: TikTok even makes the argument that they themselves have their
- 20:09Speaker 5: own account, So you're removing TikTok as a forum, but
- 20:13Speaker 5: you're also removing TikTok as a content provider. And because
- 20:18Speaker 5: you're actually focusing on the speaker, and because you're focusing
- 20:22Speaker 5: on the content, you get to these questions of is
- 20:25Speaker 5: strict scrutiny going to apply.
- 20:28Speaker 1: Strict scrutiny being the toughest form of judicial review, and
- 20:31Speaker 1: does it sound like a prior restraint.
- 20:34Speaker 5: Absolutely, there's definitely prior restraint with the way in which
- 20:37Speaker 5: the ban is taking effect. So the ban is trying
- 20:40Speaker 5: to definitely make sure that none of this content can
- 20:43Speaker 5: even be provided and you have a chilling effect from
- 20:47Speaker 5: the Montana law.
- 20:49Speaker 1: Another argument is that the ban is preempted by federal law.
- 20:53Speaker 5: Now, in terms of the preemption, the federal government has
- 20:56Speaker 5: the Department of Homeland Security and it has its own
- 21:00Speaker 5: cyber agencies. Right now, I think that Montana does not
- 21:04Speaker 5: have the winning side of that question. However, is they
- 21:08Speaker 5: are able to articulate a much more specific argument to
- 21:13Speaker 5: their own state needs. They may be able to craft
- 21:17Speaker 5: an argument as to how they may be able to
- 21:19Speaker 5: be involved in that. Now, that still segues into the
- 21:23Speaker 5: commerce clause issue and those state laws that are directed
- 21:26Speaker 5: to legitimate local concerns such as the cyber security of
- 21:31Speaker 5: your residence, but have incidental effects on interstate commerce. You're
- 21:35Speaker 5: trying to apply a local solution. But at the end
- 21:39Speaker 5: of the day, TikTok has a national exposure. It is
- 21:43Speaker 5: broad based. If someone is in Montana, they can cross
- 21:46Speaker 5: state lines and what happens with the APPS usage, so
- 21:49Speaker 5: both of those issues are there. I do think that
- 21:52Speaker 5: the preemption argument TikTok makes us very valid points.
- 21:56Speaker 1: There's a really interesting argument around the prohibition of a
- 22:00Speaker 1: bill of attainder, not something that often comes up in
- 22:04Speaker 1: ordinary conversation. But where a law punishes a party without
- 22:08Speaker 1: a trial. So here there's been no proof, no proceeding
- 22:13Speaker 1: showing that TikTok violates the privacy of Montana residents.
- 22:19Speaker 5: So what you're raising is a very valid point. So
- 22:23Speaker 5: number one, this bill of attainer, it is not that common.
- 22:26Speaker 5: I think there's a reason why TikTok put that. At
- 22:29Speaker 5: the fourth point, TikTok makes the point of and even
- 22:32Speaker 5: cites to language from the governor about how there was
- 22:35Speaker 5: an initial interest of including other social media companies and
- 22:39Speaker 5: however they got singled out and a lot of the
- 22:42Speaker 5: concerns that the law brings. So for example, the law
- 22:46Speaker 5: mentions issues on the contents of the video and they
- 22:49Speaker 5: promulgate violence. Well that's not just on TikTok. You could
- 22:52Speaker 5: say that about many other social media platforms. So it
- 22:55Speaker 5: still goes to the First Amendment issue. But TikTok does
- 22:59Speaker 5: have a point. Why are you focusing on my platform
- 23:03Speaker 5: when all these other social media platforms have many the
- 23:06Speaker 5: same issues, And TikTok in the complaint makes the point.
- 23:09Speaker 5: And by the way, even if you included these other
- 23:12Speaker 5: social media companies, you would still run into problems. I
- 23:15Speaker 5: tend to agree with that unless the state can articulate
- 23:18Speaker 5: why TikTok is so different. And this brings up a
- 23:22Speaker 5: very crucial point. Right now, there is no evidence that
- 23:26Speaker 5: TikTok is actually providing data and any information to the
- 23:31Speaker 5: Chinese Communist Party, but that doesn't eliminate the concern that TikTok,
- 23:35Speaker 5: if push comes to shove, may have to eventually give
- 23:38Speaker 5: any data to the CCP. It is not enough for
- 23:42Speaker 5: Montana to have a suspicion. The US has a system
- 23:47Speaker 5: of independent judicial courts that must take into account the
- 23:50Speaker 5: evidence and standards, and that is a fundamental difference between
- 23:54Speaker 5: the Chinese system and the US system. There's a reason
- 23:57Speaker 5: why Spacebook and other companies cannot rate China. But nevertheless,
- 24:02Speaker 5: you have a Chinese company taking advantage of the legal
- 24:05Speaker 5: framework in the US to basically argue for the system
- 24:09Speaker 5: in the US. It's an underlying theme as to what's
- 24:12Speaker 5: happening with respect to this band.
- 24:15Speaker 1: How would Montana enforce the ban? Would they have people
- 24:19Speaker 1: monitoring TikTok so Jun?
- 24:21Speaker 5: As you know, I'm a lawyer, I'm not a technician
- 24:23Speaker 5: or an engineer, right, but from what I understand, the
- 24:27Speaker 5: app store is able to look at the IP address
- 24:30Speaker 5: and basically limit the download from the state. Another in theory,
- 24:35Speaker 5: you could have someone that goes to the telecommunication towers
- 24:38Speaker 5: in Montana and they're able to limit the access to
- 24:41Speaker 5: those towers, so you don't have to be policing the
- 24:44Speaker 5: individuals on TikTok. Of course, you get to questions about
- 24:47Speaker 5: VPN right, and those are services that allow someone to
- 24:51Speaker 5: bypass some of the restrictions that are in place. But again,
- 24:56Speaker 5: is it practical can they actually coordinate all all these
- 25:00Speaker 5: different pieces together? Law is only as good as your
- 25:03Speaker 5: enforcement mechanism. Does Montana have the infrastructure the personnel to
- 25:07Speaker 5: actually follow through with that? And the answer you know
- 25:10Speaker 5: from minus standing is no. You require a coordinated effort
- 25:15Speaker 5: among multiple parties, particularly at the federal level, to really
- 25:20Speaker 5: be able to achieve those objectives.
- 25:22Speaker 1: Senate Intelligence Committee Chair Mark Warners talked about the likelihood
- 25:26Speaker 1: of federal courts overturning Montana's ban and that's why it
- 25:30Speaker 1: was essential for Congress to pass legislation. So what do
- 25:33Speaker 1: you think about the likelihood of Montana's ban actually going
- 25:37Speaker 1: into effect in January?
- 25:39Speaker 5: The fact that the affected data is January one, twenty
- 25:42Speaker 5: twenty four sort of indicates that they can see the
- 25:45Speaker 5: writing on the wall that this will most likely be
- 25:48Speaker 5: struck down. So I do think that there was definitely
- 25:51Speaker 5: some political posturing because of the acceptance that this was
- 25:55Speaker 5: preempted by the federal government. You know, the state wants
- 25:59Speaker 5: to make it seen. State politicians, they want their constituents
- 26:03Speaker 5: to see that they're trying to do something about it.
- 26:05Speaker 5: You know. Right now, from what I'm seeing, I do
- 26:08Speaker 5: think that the First Amendment issue by itself is sufficient.
- 26:12Speaker 5: They talks to prevail on this lawsuit.
- 26:14Speaker 1: As long as the parent of a data company like
- 26:17Speaker 1: this is Chinese, isn't there always going to.
- 26:20Speaker 5: Be a problem in the US, And let's not be naive.
- 26:24Speaker 5: Companies work alongside the US government, and sometimes the US
- 26:27Speaker 5: government is on top of companies, knowing full well what's happening. However,
- 26:32Speaker 5: the government has a limited role that is part of
- 26:34Speaker 5: the US culture. You go to China, the Chinese government,
- 26:38Speaker 5: the CCP is in control, the military response to the CCP,
- 26:43Speaker 5: not to the country, and you have a fundamental problem
- 26:46Speaker 5: of what data sharing with the country is. With China,
- 26:50Speaker 5: you have a law that says that if you are
- 26:52Speaker 5: a Chinese company you must share information. And there is
- 26:57Speaker 5: a fundamental problem that manisfests itself in this TikTok issue
- 27:03Speaker 5: that is just pervasive throughout the relationships. And when you
- 27:07Speaker 5: have a US company saying I am limited in the
- 27:10Speaker 5: way that I can interact in China, I don't have
- 27:14Speaker 5: the backing of the US government to the same level
- 27:17Speaker 5: that this Chinese company does. And by the way, not
- 27:20Speaker 5: only that the Chinese company actually has tools to go
- 27:24Speaker 5: against the governments in the US that I would not
- 27:27Speaker 5: have within China, and that I think is the crucial
- 27:31Speaker 5: problem at the origin the fundamental distinction of having a
- 27:36Speaker 5: communist party force companies doing multiple things, including providing data
- 27:41Speaker 5: as it is built into the system, versus the US system,
- 27:44Speaker 5: which is much more apprehensive towards government's involvement. At the
- 27:48Speaker 5: end of the day, it does seem to be a
- 27:50Speaker 5: problem that may not have any solution that's reconcilable.
- 27:54Speaker 1: Thanks Orge. That's Hore Marquez of the Warren Law Group,
- 27:58Speaker 1: and that's it for this edition of The Bloomberg Remember
- 28:01Speaker 1: you can always get the latest legal news on our
- 28:03Speaker 1: Bloomberg Law podcasts. You can find them on Apple Podcasts, Spotify,
- 28:07Speaker 1: and at www Dot Bloomberg dot com, slash podcast Slash Law,
- 28:13Speaker 1: and remember to tune into The Bloomberg Law Show every
- 28:15Speaker 1: weeknight at ten pm Wall Street Time. I'm June Grosso
- 28:19Speaker 1: and you're listening to Bloomberg