Latest / I Love You Keep Going with George Haas / Finding Meaning In Exploration
Transcript
- 0:01You're listening to the I Love You Keep Going podcast with
- 0:04George Haas. For more information, please
- 0:06visit our website at www.medigroup.org.
- 0:10That's www.m ETTAGROU p.org. So welcome everybody.
- 0:19This is I Love You. Keep Going.
- 0:21It is February 1st, 2024 at 7:37 PM Pacific Standard Time.
- 0:30And I was touching on exploration last time and I
- 0:35thought that I would continue on that, maybe focus a little bit
- 0:39on meaning. I think that in in the West, and
- 0:43particularly with our sort of lopsided, incredibly unequal
- 0:50society, where meaning is often associated with legacy and
- 0:56making an impression on the culture, I don't think that
- 1:00that's actually what we mean by finding meaning, finding
- 1:07fulfilment in your life. From the Buddhist perspective,
- 1:11of course we're we're narrowing down to the experience of the
- 1:15present moment and engaging in the experience of the present
- 1:19moment. So really, when we talk about
- 1:21meaning and fulfilment, we're we're still talking about that
- 1:28moment by moment experience rather than something different
- 1:33than that. What is an engaged, fulfilling
- 1:41moment? I was talking earlier today
- 1:46about that. I like symphonic music, and I
- 1:50have a a favorite conductor who's maybe for 15 years, the
- 1:55same one whose name is Vasily Pachenko and he is the musical
- 2:01director of the Royal Philharmonic, and they came
- 2:05through Los Angeles on a tour and played at the Performing
- 2:11Arts Center on the Northridge campus.
- 2:15I drove out there to see the performance and in the
- 2:20experience of the orchestra playing and him conducting
- 2:25Tchaikovsky's Sixth Symphony, the the way that the the the
- 2:32third movement unfolded was absolutely mesmerizing.
- 2:38This is not an experience I have that often.
- 2:41Hold on, Lucy wants to come in. I was talking about it at the
- 2:55Northridge Center where this concert happened.
- 2:58I was on the young side of the audience, but I was sitting next
- 3:09to this couple. They were quite fun and at a
- 3:14certain point she looked at me and she said would you like a
- 3:17butterscotch? And she then dug in her purse
- 3:21and pulled out this butterscotch.
- 3:24Now, what does a butterscotch mean to you and how did you
- 3:34assign that meaning to it? I find butterscotches attached
- 3:42to the meaning of my grandmother, us, my father's
- 3:48mother, because when we went over to her house she had a big
- 3:52dish of hard candy and we were allowed to pick one.
- 3:57And I liked the butterscotch. Now the butterscotch is that she
- 4:01had were you may have seen them. They were sort of a disc, sort
- 4:07of a yellowy disc with the yellow cellophane around them
- 4:10and solid all the way through. But this was not the
- 4:13butterscotch of the woman sitting next to me, pulling it
- 4:17out of her Louis Vuitton bag. It was.
- 4:23It had a soft center, but in that moment, of course, the
- 4:32taste of the butterscotch elicited the whole thread of
- 4:37meaning that I have associated with butterscotch.
- 4:40It's when we were kids, we would go to the diner, which was
- 4:47called B and GS, and we would get butterscotch sundaes.
- 4:51So vanilla ice cream with butterscotch.
- 4:56But in in each moment, because of the way that the human
- 4:59condition operates, meanings are assigned to the sensing
- 5:03experience, and what we want to be able to do is mentalize fast
- 5:10enough to recognize how the meaning of the present moment is
- 5:14being shaped by the definitions that we assign.
- 5:23Maybe sitting there, Well, if you don't like symphonic music,
- 5:29you probably wouldn't have been sitting there.
- 5:31But if you did, and you were, and you had no history of
- 5:33butterscotch, maybe it would be a a curiosity and not something
- 5:37that had a richness to it. I quite enjoyed the experiences
- 5:42of my grandmother and it was a pleasant to have that richness
- 5:48of filling part of the moment, of being there and and
- 5:53understanding that in each moment we have the capacity to
- 6:00sense the object that can be sensed.
- 6:03When there's contact, the sensing experience comes into
- 6:09consciousness. Consciousness is not the self
- 6:12experience in this sense. This precedes the self
- 6:16experience. It's then evaluated for urgency.
- 6:20Does it need immediate attention?
- 6:22Does it not matter whether we give it attention?
- 6:25Is there time for something pleasant?
- 6:28And then there's a queue of sensing experiences formed.
- 6:33Urgent material always cuts to the head of the line, and then
- 6:37it's compared to the perceptual database and the threads of
- 6:41meaning. All of the previously
- 6:42experienced sensing moments that were defined in the way we are
- 6:48about to define this sensing moment happens and that whole
- 6:53thread of meaning attaches and it rolls from ultimate reality,
- 6:58that pure sensi experience, into conceptual reality which has all
- 7:04of those meanings assigned to it.
- 7:07We don't take a complete inventory, a neutral inventory
- 7:14of everything that's around us and then form a depiction of
- 7:18that. We really select what has
- 7:22meaning to us. So it's a highly curated
- 7:25experience picking the things that matter to us and then
- 7:29forming the the perception of the meaning of the moment.
- 7:36So we live not in what's happening, but in what is
- 7:40happening means to us. And so when we talk about
- 7:45finding meaning or finding fulfilment in the present
- 7:48moment, what we're really talking about is engaging in
- 7:51activity that activates that whole system in a way that it is
- 7:57fulfilling. That matters to us.
- 8:02Course, when we find ourselves in environments where we don't
- 8:05have a lot of choice about the things that are meaningful to
- 8:08us, then we think of it as a sort of desert like environment,
- 8:16absence of what's meaningful, that making sense so far.
- 8:24So that there isn't a way of discovering the meaning of the
- 8:27present moment without of course understanding that it's made-up
- 8:32of the the conditioned experience that you have in
- 8:38addition to the actual experience that you have.
- 8:42There's the capacity to imagine and make meaning.
- 8:47Now this is an important feature to understand because if we are
- 8:52in a novel situation where we haven't had the experience
- 8:56before, we can then create a a a definition of meaning of it and
- 9:05assign it and then begin this thread.
- 9:09So what you notice is that some threads are old and they go way
- 9:13back. The the taste of butterscotch
- 9:18goes all the way back practically to the beginning of
- 9:22my memory of myself and the world, which has a kind of
- 9:29richness to it. There's a lot of positive
- 9:33associations with that, but but it's impossible really I think
- 9:42to have every experience and have a history of every
- 9:46experience. And so the imagination plays a a
- 9:50vital role in this. One of the things that happens
- 9:55in an adverse childhood experiences of course is that we
- 9:57begin to limit the capacity to imagine things.
- 10:00We pinch them off, I like to say because the imagining something
- 10:07that we can't have is too painful.
- 10:08And so we restrict the capacity to pay attention to understand
- 10:16what's actually happening. And so part of this exploration
- 10:22of how do you make meaning, what the database is like and also
- 10:28the capacity to imagine is part of this process of of exploring
- 10:35what is meaningful just in this moment, that small moment by
- 10:43moment experience. Then what would we say is
- 10:52fulfilling, and this is so idiosyncratic, so individual,
- 10:59that really we can use descriptions of exploring as
- 11:05guidelines, but we have to begin this process ourselves and what
- 11:10what resonates for us in the experience of learning to
- 11:20explore, which really starts about one year old.
- 11:25A part of this is also going to be the way in which your
- 11:29caregivers valued what was meaningful to you and reflected
- 11:35back to you its value. This may not be what actually
- 11:41happened. You may have grown up in an
- 11:44environment where what the caregivers thought was valuable
- 11:48was what was reflected back to you as valuable.
- 11:51And if your past it is, your sense of meaning interest was
- 11:59not in that group, and you may have had the experience of that
- 12:04authentic interest and exploration was devalued or
- 12:10restricted in some way. And so the associations with
- 12:14that process of finding meaning will carry that restriction.
- 12:23And you may find that your capacity to explore was blocked.
- 12:28And so you didn't really learn to do it.
- 12:30And this is what is more the territory of preoccupied people
- 12:38dismissing people really are are more organized around the kinds
- 12:44of things that their caregivers wanted from them and they they
- 12:48can also quite oriented to the things that are valuable
- 12:52culturally. Whether or not that corresponds
- 12:55to what's interesting on an individual level.
- 13:04Disorganized people of course don't have the capacity to
- 13:09emotionally regulate well enough to go into a deep exploratory
- 13:16way path and it's constantly disrupted by the the
- 13:24dysregulation and fearfully avoided.
- 13:29People of course withdraw from social interaction into
- 13:35themselves to try and auto regulate and fearfully
- 13:39preoccupied it. It becomes so chaotic that that
- 13:44there isn't the capacity for follow through.
- 13:50Preoccupied people who have their exploration limited in
- 13:53childhood really depend on other people's exploration to carry
- 13:59them, and also they tend to look for the meaningfulness of life
- 14:03in relationships, not in exploration, not in finding
- 14:07meaning. And usually there's a sense of
- 14:11dissatisfaction in doing that, because relationships are really
- 14:14meant to support the exploration and not not provide the sense of
- 14:18meaning. Dismissing people look for
- 14:22culturally valuable activities because they tend to transact
- 14:30care rather than collaborate and reciprocate care.
- 14:35It's the really the realm of secure people who in childhood
- 14:41experienced the interest of the caregivers in what mattered to
- 14:45them and then the support in being able to explore that, find
- 14:51out what works and what doesn't. And they have a real advantage
- 14:56in terms of exploration and they come out of childhood with a
- 15:02sense of value in in pursuing things that are meaningful to
- 15:05them. And they have had the support to
- 15:08learn how to explore, to understand what that is.
- 15:15Is that making sense in terms of the the experience of
- 15:19meaningfulness in engaging in the activity and the fulfilment
- 15:25of of doing that? Another one of the passions I
- 15:29have in exploration and finding meaning is photography and that
- 15:36that also goes back to my mother.
- 15:39So in that early childhood experience, in seeing and
- 15:44watching the things that my caregivers engaged in, that was
- 15:52one of the things that had real interest for her.
- 15:54And in my ability to engage with her while she was engaging, that
- 16:00also had meaning for me in terms of that connection.
- 16:03So there's that association, but the the way in which she
- 16:08explored photography in the way that I do are are vastly
- 16:11different. She was a pictorialist, if you
- 16:17know your photographic history. And I am really more engaged in
- 16:23the narrative of things. And So what I like to make are
- 16:31these these visually illustrated narratives that are very
- 16:36prosaic, very subtle, not the the high drama that we're used
- 16:42to. Nothing blows up 10,000 people
- 16:48are not machine gun, just the ordinariness of life.
- 16:53I really think that coming into the the moment by moment rhythm
- 17:01of your life and the the typical ordinariness of most of our
- 17:07lives. Getting up, eating, working in
- 17:12some way at something. Eating, working at something,
- 17:17eating, socializing, going to sleep, this rhythm of life that
- 17:24we have. The slow process of ageing, the
- 17:29slow process of gaining experience and integrating that
- 17:33into these narratives of of what our lives are are like and
- 17:42finding in that a richness that gets you out of bed in the
- 17:47morning. Of course, if you can't find the
- 17:49richness in what you're doing, it's hard to get up.
- 17:52It's hard to engage in things. We get bogged down by the
- 17:57senselessness of it. This is a conversation really
- 18:04around meditation practice. And so we use the meditation
- 18:10practice to explore the nature of how all of this unfolds, in
- 18:17some sense, making sense of the meaning of it.
- 18:21And as your practice deepens and you get closer to the direct
- 18:28experience of the nature of this human condition, I often think
- 18:32what arises are these experiences of sacredness in all
- 18:37of this. And then each moment takes on
- 18:42that character sacredness. I remember when I was first
- 18:54practicing, there was a lot of conversation around the
- 18:57preciousness of this human life and the preciousness of finding
- 19:02the teaching of the Buddha and the unusual nature of that
- 19:10combination. It was described as if you were
- 19:16the sea turtle and you just had random popped up to the surface
- 19:21for a breath of air and you happened to get pop up in the
- 19:26center of a life ring that had fallen off of a passing ship.
- 19:31That unique quality. I've had a lot of trouble
- 19:37imagining the unique quality of it because I have trouble
- 19:47connecting directly with the whole cosmology of 31 levels of
- 19:53existence and what really feels almost like a competition for
- 19:58higher birth In the Theravada school.
- 20:02Of course, you gain liberation. You take the third path of
- 20:08liberation and you you're a non returner.
- 20:11You're not reincarnated in the the Mahayana Vow, the
- 20:15Bodhisattva vow to be. To do something that guarantees
- 20:20your reincarnation and the commitment to reincarnate until
- 20:26all beings are enlightened. The conversation around
- 20:32thousands of lifetimes. None of that really makes so
- 20:39much sense to me from a this orientation around the George
- 20:48Ness of things around here. But I also don't mind the
- 20:57confusion and I don't need a certainty.
- 21:01So maybe that's the way this particular view works.
- 21:13Early on in in my practice there was a conversation around Bodhi
- 21:19Cheetah. Bodhi is awakened Cheetah's
- 21:23heart, the awakened heart, and that the meaningfulness of life
- 21:30comes from that. The heart opening and then the
- 21:34heart moves into a direction of service in it and without really
- 21:39needing to do anything in particular, just the practice,
- 21:44just the seeing of the human condition, just coming into a
- 21:48relationship to it that matches it and the heart breaks open and
- 21:55you reorient towards surf service.
- 22:00I might say in my life I've done.
- 22:05I've done that because I do a lot of the service for different
- 22:09people and it happened all on its own without me having to
- 22:16really make much of A decision or have having much resistance
- 22:20to doing it. It just seems fulfilling to
- 22:25help. I think of it more as I needed
- 22:31so much help and I was so ineffective in terms of being
- 22:34able to persuade people to do it that that I'm quite grateful for
- 22:39the people that did help and it was really hard to find that I
- 22:43and and so I'd like to to pay that back in a way that sense of
- 22:54helping people. But I do find culturally in the
- 23:03way that we operate the there's not much sense of that.
- 23:14How do I put it? I was talking to somebody about
- 23:22it and they were describing what I was describing in this sort of
- 23:25culture that we have of. I really think of it as a
- 23:29culture of appropriation where we just take whatever it is that
- 23:37we think it's a good thing to take and we don't really assign
- 23:45a lineage to it. And we have then, out of all of
- 23:51these pieces, constructed a culture.
- 23:56I was talking to a Chinese woman who grew up in China and she
- 24:03laughingly said yes, our 200 year old culture that's been
- 24:09assembled from everyone else's culture without regard the
- 24:13origins of anything. And and we think of it as the
- 24:17the, the, the true path of meaning.
- 24:23And So what we find is the the discarding of older experience,
- 24:29older people and the experience that they gather and the urgency
- 24:33of the youthfulness of finding something out as you get older.
- 24:38Of course, what you see is that each generation comes up not
- 24:44knowing anything and make the same decisions around what's
- 24:50happening that each generation has made, except that it's on
- 24:54the back of the generations before and what they've
- 24:57developed. But because there's no
- 24:59understanding of that and no real value to that, it's just
- 25:04what this generation has discovered, not understanding
- 25:08the that trajectory. I was talking to someone else.
- 25:22I talked to a lot of people as you might imagine in in in the
- 25:25role that I have. I I carry on these
- 25:28conversations. And he said that actually the
- 25:31word for what I'm describing, which is the abandonment of the
- 25:34wisdom of older people and an understanding of how, and this
- 25:40moment was dependent on the moment before it in that
- 25:44Buddhist frame, is colonialism, which made me laugh really hard.
- 25:51If you look at it in contrast, say, to the native understanding
- 25:57of things, whereas these traditions, these ways of being
- 26:01in the world, are handed down and they're valued.
- 26:04And there's an the understanding of the relationship to what is
- 26:10gone before it's built into the education.
- 26:17We don't really have that so much.
- 26:31How do we change that? I would like to change that.
- 26:47One of the ways in which we understand all of these things
- 26:51and it's encapsulated, is in learning the nature of culture
- 26:56as we're growing up. So all of that stuff, we don't
- 27:00have to learn all of that stuff. That part isn't necessary.
- 27:06The culture hands it to us how everything works and it's useful
- 27:16that that indoctrination into the to the culture in which
- 27:21you're born, because it allows you then to function in the, in
- 27:25the, in the social group. But with that disconnection from
- 27:32how we got here, the the values seem off.
- 27:45So in the Buddha sense, of course what we're talking about
- 27:47is karma and the that understanding that the
- 27:52conditions of the present moment are are dependent on the
- 27:56conditions of the moment before this happened.
- 27:59And the the conditions of the next moment will be dependent on
- 28:04the conditions of this moment. That in each moment, what opens
- 28:09up are the entire range of possibilities that you could
- 28:12pick, and then as soon as you pick one, all of the
- 28:15possibilities drop away except for the one that you picked.
- 28:19Then in the next moment, opens up all of the possibilities that
- 28:24are linked to the choice that you made in the moment before.
- 28:28And this runs all the way back, each moment, the seating
- 28:34containing that range of choices which were dependent on the
- 28:39moment before to begin to see that what happens.
- 28:51You know, I describe these things, butterscotches and
- 28:54symphonic music and and photography, and I'm also
- 29:00describing privilege in a way. What happens if you didn't have
- 29:06that? My grandmother saw it on my
- 29:10mother's side, grew up in poverty.
- 29:14She had no food security, no housing security, no a great
- 29:19drive to not have that for her children.
- 29:23And so she managed to accomplish that in in her lifetime.
- 29:29That her children didn't didn't have food insecurity.
- 29:33Her children did not have housing insecurity.
- 29:39But there was no sense of that really in in the way that she
- 29:43described it. When I was 16, growing up in the
- 29:54Midwest, where I did, how was the age that you got your
- 29:57driver's license? Because the distances were too
- 30:00big and the public transportation wasn't good
- 30:02enough. And so all of us kids, all of us
- 30:07teenagers who who could, Again, this is a expression of
- 30:12affluence, learning to drive. And I liked to to drive.
- 30:18And so I was happy to take people wherever they wanted to
- 30:21go. And my grandmother asked me if I
- 30:24would take her to a wedding in Indiana.
- 30:30We grew up in Chicago and she wanted to go to a wedding of one
- 30:44of her cousins, kids. And so I drove her down there
- 30:51and when we got there and entered into the church, it was
- 30:55clear that this was a Catholic ceremony.
- 31:00And I grew up in a fairly non religious Protestant family.
- 31:04So it was quite unusual. And I said to my grandmother
- 31:09sitting in the church, we have Catholics in the family.
- 31:12And she said I'll tell you later.
- 31:15And so as we were driving home, she said, growing up the way
- 31:20that you did, you'll never understand the way that I grew
- 31:23up, which was in a log cabin, the sod roof on the wheat on the
- 31:29plains of Alberta in the middle of a wheat field.
- 31:35She was about 4:10, so a little Irish woman.
- 31:40And she said the the doorway to the the house was so low that
- 31:47she had to stoop to get out of it.
- 31:49And I grew up in this big house. She said that when she was 17,
- 31:58she stood in the front yard, turned 360° and all she could
- 32:04see were wheat fields. And the voice inside her head
- 32:07said, you got to get the hell out of here.
- 32:11And she said she spent a year talking her mother into talking
- 32:16her father into sending her to college.
- 32:18And so they would look at the magazines and look for schools
- 32:22where rich people would go to so that she could go and make a
- 32:28good marriage. When they were putting her on
- 32:31the train, her dad said you have one year to get married,
- 32:37otherwise you have to come back to the farm.
- 32:40And as her mother was putting her on the train, mother said to
- 32:44her now is not a good time to be an Irish Catholic.
- 32:47Better. You were a British Protestant,
- 32:50but she said she got on the train in Irish Catholic and she
- 32:53got off British Protestant. So.
- 33:02And she was right. I have no concept of what that
- 33:04would be like, really, the the harshness, the difficulty of
- 33:11that. And then to transform herself
- 33:15from a kid grew up on a farm into somebody who could manage a
- 33:25Chicago society. But still she found meaning that
- 33:40was embedded in that same flow of experience that we all have.
- 33:45And she was able to organize her life in a way that a lot of it
- 33:49was spent in those activities. And so each of us will have the
- 33:57things that happened to us and the meanings that we've
- 34:00associated. And the exploration really then
- 34:02is to to figure out what is the things that when we engage in
- 34:08them in the present moment, it the experience of doing it is
- 34:15fulfilling that we're we're engaged in the experience of the
- 34:26moment completely. You notice sometimes when you're
- 34:32engaged in the moment of something that you don't really
- 34:34want to do, there's a constant reflection and self of
- 34:38irritation and having to do it. And that when you find yourself
- 34:42in, in a fulfilling, engaging moment that that alarm system of
- 34:47the self is absent, simply absorbed and doing it.
- 34:56But all of that is tied into those that whole process of of
- 35:03filling that perceptual database with experiences and that
- 35:08preferences or versions that arise from it.
- 35:12And so part of this practice, of course, is, is pulling that all
- 35:16open, pulling that all apart and seeing what's actually there,
- 35:21and then orienting the present moment experience in valuing
- 35:29what there is. This is the way that we change
- 35:34the experiences of the past, that changing of the meaning of
- 35:39it, finding that a sense of fulfilment in it.
- 35:48Maybe it's the that opening of the heart that leads us into
- 35:56this connection to other people that's useful in supporting that
- 36:05deeper exploration, the human being or is it the human doing
- 36:18actually engagement. The constant engagement
- 36:25equanimity, the fully engaged and perfectly balanced.
- 36:30But not still. Have you ever seen those surfers
- 36:38who like to surf the giant waves?
- 36:42So you have this huge wall of water and then stuck somewhere
- 36:45in the middle of it is this little surfboard sticking out
- 36:48with a surfer on top of it. And it and it looks so dangerous
- 36:54and amazing and the stillness of the of the that concentrated
- 37:02surfer, a tiny little thing, the vastness of the ocean.
- 37:09But when you look closer, of course they're not.
- 37:12So they're just constantly adjusting, constantly moving to
- 37:15keep the balance. And so that's that idea of
- 37:18equity, fully engaged and at the same time balancing as an
- 37:25activity and an active stands. And at at the same time
- 37:32understanding the direction that it feels more fulfilling and
- 37:35more meaningful and the direction that it feels less
- 37:39fulfilling and less meaningful and really orienting toward that
- 37:44sense of fulfilment. So what are you going to do?
- 37:57What match is that for you, and can you begin to see the
- 38:04obstacles that arise so you don't do it a lot of times?
- 38:09That's again, touching into that early conditioning of this isn't
- 38:13for you, this isn't worthwhile. You can't have that and setting
- 38:24that aside and really listening deeply with the things that
- 38:30matter to you, whether or not they have cultural relevance or
- 38:38not. Of course keeping your non
- 38:46harming stance right? There's no permission to be an
- 38:54asshole in in what I'm saying. How's that?
- 39:12So why don't we do some vipassana tonight?
- 39:16We'll start with a little bit of concentration practice and then
- 39:20go into Vipassana. All right, Let go of the
- 39:23meditation. Any comments or questions about
- 39:29that? That was really nice.
- 39:34Thank you for the guidance. Good, thanks.
- 39:40So not this weekend, but the following weekend we're starting
- 39:44meditation and addiction series of half day long.
- 39:48So for the three Saturdays starting on the 9th I think or
- 39:5710th look. Saturday the 10th, the three
- 40:19Saturdays. This month, the workshop is
- 40:25going to be how to date like a secure person, even if you're
- 40:31not yet secure. So come along to that, if you
- 40:34want to talk about relational dynamics and secure functioning
- 40:38and how to navigate all of that, it's in May.
- 40:47We're doing a two week retreat, which is a meta Vipassana
- 40:50retreat. So the first week is meta
- 40:53practice and the second week is Vipassana practice.
- 40:57I think that you could come either to the meta only or the
- 41:01Vipassana only, but or consider coming to both the meta and the
- 41:05Vipassana it's going to be outside of, that's in Poland.
- 41:12What I'm going to do in at the end of May, in the beginning of
- 41:15June, a short four day intensive on level one in Utrecht for the
- 41:25last week of May. There we will be doing another
- 41:35level one series in March and then starting another level 2 in
- 41:42April. That will appear variously on
- 41:45the website. So that's what's coming up.
- 41:47Take a look at it, see if you can find interest in it and
- 41:52attend. Ioffer the teaching freely.
- 41:57But I do hope that you'll consider making a donation to
- 42:01Medigroup if you can. You have the resources, it helps
- 42:06support me and also the work Medigroup is doing.
- 42:08There's a link on the website for that.
- 42:11Thank you for your practice. Good to see you and we'll see
- 42:14you soon. Bye.