Latest / The Philanthropists / Omidyar Network’s Former CEO Mike Kubzansky: AI Is Rewriting Philanthropy. What Happens Next?
Transcript
- meredith: Today's guest is Mike Kubzansky, my friend and mentor and former CEO of Amidiar Network, the philanthropic and impact investing organization founded by Pierre and Pam Omidiar to help shape the digital revolution towards shared power, prosperity, and possibility. Mike joined Omidiar Network in 2013, became CEO in 2018, and led the organization through a period when technology, economic power, democracy, and human agency became central philanthropic questions. In twenty twenty six, he stepped down after more than eight years of CEO and handed the reins over to the lovely and unstoppable Michelle Jawando. Quanda: He is now building Andaris AI, a new platform at the intersection of AI, investment, and policy. Mike, welcome to the Philanthropists. Mike K: Thanks so much. it is fabulous to be with you. Quanda: So Mike, before we talk about AI or a MidyR network, I want to start with you. So tell us where you grew up, tell us about your family. You studied at Brown and then earned an MBA at Kellogg. How did all of those experience shape who you are today? Mike K: I'll take the rest of the full hour on this question alone. I grew up I grew up I grew up Quanda: Ha ha ha meredith: Sit back, ladies and gentlemen. Mike K: yeah, exactly. get a popcorn. The I grew up just outside of Boston, in the suburbs, with with parents who were in deeply committed to social justice, actively protesting the Vietnam War from my father's perch at Boston University. centers for low income residents in the Boston area in immigrant communities from Haitians to Armenians to speakers as well. and so and you grow up in Massachusetts with the Kennedy aura and it is tough to it is tough to escape. And so my first foray in life was I was went into elected politics. I worked in high school for the late great Barney Frank. may his memory be a blessing. He was truly one of a kind. and then got out of college and worked on the Michael Dukakis for President campaign, where I proudly like to say we came in second. meredith: Mm-hmm. Mike K: so the but it was a good experience to understand and see different parts of the the country. I moved immediately to Atumba, Iowa, population twenty-four thousand. and it was very different way to understand the universe than sitting in suburban Boston for obvious reasons. So that was an invaluable experience of seeing that. And then when I went back to the work in the Massachusetts state legislature right after that, that was a very disillusioning time. We were in the middle of a recession. And I got firsthand knowledge in terms of the legislative process. And I felt like I have a high premium efficaciousness and it didn't seem so easy to be efficacious in a in a legislative setting. That's what sent me to business school is to try to figure out a new set of cut in points. If you still wanna make a difference, but you're not gonna do it from sitting as a legislator, that was the point on getting the MBA. and so went out and then promptly got a job doing low income housing tax credits indication and places like and this was great. I did I graduated in the nine and so by the way, my MBA is totally out of date. It's pre internet, let alone pre AI. Quanda: Yeah. Mike K: and so meredith: Ha ha. Mike K: I often tell people who are asking for career advice, you shouldn't listen to me. my I have the most outdated, educational credential on the planet. But it was fun to go, I lived in Chicago and, would see my business school classmates at O'Hare who are working for McKinsey or BCG or Goldman, they'd be on their way to New York or San Francisco or LA. And I'd be on my way to Flint, North Philadelphia, Grand Rapids, and some of the other garden spots of low-income housing community development, which I was very proud of, and we did great work there. But and so that kicked off a career and and I would say the signal influence there was a summer internship I did at Shorebank, which your older listeners will remember as the icon of the CDFI, what became the CDFI movement. meredith: Mm. Mike K: and the first place that really tried to take a commercial enterprise like a bank and turn it towards turn it towards not just making a profit off of the lending, but actually community development in in a in a pretty impoverished community on the south side of Chicago. and so and that was a very formative experience in terms of the power of taking market instruments and seeing what you can do in the service of social impact. And by the way, when I first met Darren Walker at the Ford Foundation, I said, Darren, I've been waiting 25 years to thank the Ford Foundation because you guys were the ones who actually funded the CDFI movement and f and entities like Shorebank and Lisk meredith: Interesting. Huh. Mike K: and Enterprise and that sort of thing. And if it wasn't for some far-sighted philanthropic work. in the eighties and nineties, I would never have gotten my start. meredith: Yeah. that actually dovetails perfectly I've always admired that the way that you approach problems is very systems oriented, mark markets, technology, capital governance. Were you always wired that way to think about the world? Or yes, just came out of the womb. Yeah. Mike K: Yes. Yes. in college, to Quanda's question, the other formative thing in college is I actually, I I was a strange beast when I showed up at business school. I, I was I was a history major. I was a meredith: Mm. Mike K: I had worked in politics, I had to be told what P and L stood for, and meredith: Yeah. Mike K: that sort of thing at the at the opening keynote speaker. and God bless Angela Comstock who told me. I'll never I'll meredith: Yeah. Mike K: never Be more grateful to somebody who didn't embarrass me when I asked the question, what's PL? So that was good. The but yeah, I in in college I studied history of science in particular. And that one of the things that most stuck with me is is Thomas Kuhn's observation about how science that science proceeds in terms of paradigms, right? That science meredith: Mm. Mike K: itself is a series of paradigms that hold for a while and then eventually break. But the paradigms themselves are a social construct. It is what does the scientific community believe the evidence is strong enough about. And it's actually a consensus method, not a truth method, right? In terms of the we don't actually, figuring out what is actually truth is hard. So we're getting some really weird epistemological territory here, which I'll get out of in a second. And so yeah, I've always thought about what is shaping the broader set of ideas and efforts. in the say what are the incentives, what are the mindsets, what are the what are the hidden steering mechanisms, whether it's beliefs and paradigms, in addition to the actual actions on the ground. But in particular, what is economics, what is business? It's it's the study of incentives, right? Quanda: But Mike, it's so interesting. So you talked about the intellectual perspective, but you also mentioned that you had an opportunity to do microcredit in Zimbabwe. So you've had the human experience of the systems at work. And so I'm really curious when you look back at all of those experiences in addition to the intellectual framework. when did you begin to truly understand that markets can create opportunity? But then leave so many people out. And then you said you're thinking a lot about systems right now and have been over the last five years. And and we've all obviously talked about that a lot, even in our short time together. what are some big insights that are coming out of of that work for you right now? Mike K: there's something about going out with the loan officer and doing collections in Mutare, Zimbabwe, Quanda: Right. Mike K: at microcredit that gives you a real sense as to how this lands on the ground. There's a lot of at both Monitor and at Monitor and our Inclusive Markets Project, we interviewed over, a thousand either, small businesses, entrepreneurs, social entrepreneurs operating in Africa and India, who are trying to build something on the ground, going out with them, seeing their customers, seeing their, seeing their engagement with everything from students to teachers to f smallholder farmers and that sort of thing. So I think you need both, right? the theory without being grounded in the lived human reality, and and particularly the, particularly in the early days of market based solutions, there was a little bit too much theorizing and there's not enough of actually when this gets onto the ground. And so, to to get into your question, Kwanda, the where do you start to realize the limits of these market-based solutions? Credit is a great place to see the limits on that sort of thing. So credit on the one hand, absolutely vital lifeline for any number of, small individual entrepreneurs and that sort of thing. On the other hand, you run into people who are both necessity entrepreneurs and opportunity entrepreneurs. The opportunity entrepreneurs, it's great. They're trying to build a business. There's a bunch of people who are entrepreneurs because it's necessity. They would much prefer to have a call center job or a factory job. Sort of thing, but this is the only thing that was available to them. So one, without getting on the ground, you don't see that difference, right? Credit is a great place where it's the absolute double edged sword. Most people don't have enough access to credit, but Quanda: Right. meredith: Mm. Mike K: it can be either too expensive, it can be too too it can become a debt trap, and it can become and so credits, micro credit is the perfect case for both the great things about market based solutions and all the things you really need to look out for. And so that was a strong thread was always anchored in like, hey, let's treat these folks as, as what they are. People with dignity, people with purchasing meredith: Mm. Mike K: power, even though it's limited, understand what they need and and and tailor from there rather than coming in with a top down approach that takes their voices as secondary to the to the enterprise. meredith: Yeah, we always just say Quanda: Yeah, and it it meredith: build with not for, right? Yeah. Right. Mike K: Exactly. Exactly. And treat them as customers, right? Don't treat Quanda: Yeah, I really love that. Mike K: them as passive passive recipients, right? these people are customers with dignity, agency, and their own set of choices and trade offs. You need to respect that and treat them accordingly. Quanda: Yeah, a real a real people centric approach. And for me, that really feels like the first bridge, right, in the story where, you weren't just interested in helping people after the harm happened. you're really interested in thinking about the systems overall and what created the harm in the first place. And, I think that's a good transition for us to begin talking, about the work that you've done at Omidia Network. meredith: So Mike, when that opportunity to work with Pam and Pierre came about, did you see the proposition as an extension of your previous work or an opportunity to leverage philanthropy as a counterweight or conscience for market forces or something completely different? Mike K: The so ON was a was positioned already as a leading edge organization. I knew them well. It wasn't a hard sell. But it was clear that ON was a great platform thinking differently about it. And the the obvious appeal to ON was not just the philanthropy, but was that Pierre had already made the choice, and this is gonna be I hope a theme of the second half of the conversation, had already made the choice to set up differently. So the real appeal was one, Pierre was willing to take risks, obviously. as he had already shown. and two, and underneath that, Matt Bannock, who is my predecessor running ON, was was really pushing the envelope on that on that set of things. But two, the unique setup, right? That you the massive flexibility you get from being an LLC and a C3 meredith: Mm-hmm. Mike K: was the actual the most aside from the amazing people and the great work I knew they had done, the the flexibility of the platform and Amy Clement, whom you've probably run into, who now runs Imaginable Futures, always used to say problem first, tool second. Right. And I just let your listeners sit with that for a bit, because that is actually those are those are words to live by. And that is how, and so that is how philanthropy should be done. Quanda: So, Mike, before we go on to talk a little bit more about ON, Omidia Network was structured with both an LLC and a C three. and we have some broader questions about that, but very specifically, can you give us maybe one example of how you were able to leverage both vehicles in order to address a specific problem? Mike K: yeah, of course. let's talk let's talk about AI, right? Which is in in our most recent, in our most recent ethos. and the thing to know is so an LLC, if you have an LLC, you'd actually don't need a C four. Because LLCs, as Mitt Romney famously said, companies are people too. They have all the rights to lobby, make campaign contributions, and that sort of thing that that anybody else has, as a private individual or as a or as a C4. now I just want to for the record say we never made political contributions. That was never part of a the ON toolkit and never would be. I'll come back to that later as I give my advice to your to your audience. But the but just to say so, but the LLC toolkit affords an immense amount of flexibility, which is if you're not in it for the tax deduction, you can do a lot of things. And so a good example is on AI. Our our our North Star on AI is to make sure there's some intentional societal governance of the AI revolution, the same way. We have put into place for every other technology in modern history, whether it's electricity or biomedicine, or cars. and I would commend if you want to put in the show notes, I I did a great piece, if I say so myself, in Fast Company, comparing the automobile revolution to the AI revolution and how we might want to think about the guardrails around that. So would commend that to your readers. But the but just to say, so if your goal is the intentional is the intentional governance of AI. And and and just to say, in coming back to this in particular, right, we would never let Merck or Pfizer check their own homework, but somehow we let Meta and and and and OpenAI check their own homework. Why do we do that? we set up regimes and other, and other things. And they're doing as consequential things as Merck and Pfizer and Roach and that sort of thing. So the so if that's where you're trying to go, then yeah, the toolkit rolls out in a bunch of different ways. One, we invested in anthropic with for-profit money as in the B-round shares that came out of the the SBF estate sale so that we could be engaging directly with one of the what one of the what we es estimated would be one of the better governed and major players in the space to get some insight from the insight and to provide some ballast, and to be a voice on their cap table with Ford Foundation, Nathan Cummings and others to meredith: Mm. Mike K: help them push back against the growth at all costs pressure that they would be getting from the rest of their investors and to be and to engage them with and to help engage them with our grantees on the civil society side. We have we had at least two convenings with anthropic leadership and our civil society grantees, many of whom were critical of anthropic, but we put those together as a way of so as an example quanda on how the toolkit works. On the Quanda: You're right. Mike K: grant side we're funding groups like Tech Equity and AI Now. And these folks and on the investment side we're funding, we've invested in Anthropic to open a channel to have a conversation with them on their policies and their and their own growth issues. and then on the third side, we are also using our LLC status to actively lobby for bills that would put that into place. So ON last year came out for seventeen bills in California, which you can't do as a C three. You're not allowed to meredith: Mm. Mike K: lobby. As a f as a foundation, no None of our peer foundations could do that because they're 501c3s, and you're not allowed to lobby on specific legislation. So it's a it just opens up a much broader toolkit, a much richer toolkit that you can use across many more dimensions of the problem than if you could only write C three checks. Quanda: percent. I think that does a great job of showing how you can leverage each of those entities to make a positive impact on something you care about. So no, that was a great example. meredith: So I I was gonna dig in on that a little bit, but but maybe shift it to your personal sort of view. So you and I've had many conversations about big philanthropy and intentions versus practice over the years. And I wanna be Mike K: Yeah. Uh-huh. meredith: very careful about asking this question because it goes to the heart of the show. So how has working, how has working, you working so close to this level of we'll call it strategic philanthropic capital? Change the way that you think about your own resources, your time, your voice, your relationships, your own investments in philanthropy, and and then your willingness to take risks. Mike K: I've developed at this point a theory of how social change needs to happen. And I'm gonna shorthand it with four cities, which ha sadly, as somebody who lived in Iowa and lived in Chicago and loves loves the Midwest, are all coastal cities. So I'm gonna talk about Washington, San Francisco, Los Angeles, and New York. Any any cogent approach to social change needs to take into account policy, right, which is Washington, right? so that's the Washington piece. Los Angeles culture, right? There are lots of steering narratives that we have, which we're not even aware of, right? but we live with several narratives and these narratives, they they used to say culture eats strategy for breakfast. Narrative and culture eat strategy for breakfast for sure. And so, if you're not paying attention to what is the overall narrative and what's going on, that's a problem, right? the third piece is New York, which is capital, right? And particularly, and there's some pieces where philanthropy works where the capital is a little less important or it's all state. if you're working on criminal justice, there's a lot less private sector involvement. Yes, there's private prisons and that thing, but it's basically a topic for the state, for advocates, for legal, for the legal community meredith: Mm-hmm. Mike K: and that sort of thing. There's some private money running around, certainly, but that's basically a public sector, at its essence it's a public and civil society sector topic. whereas if you're working on AI and the governance of AI, or if you're working on climate, Or if you're working on other things, there's massive amounts of capital at risk and people behave but defending the capital that's at risk, say the oil companies on the climate movement, for instance, meredith: Mm. Mike K: or in AI, where just the sheer amount of money being spent is just so massive that, if you're not paying attention to the private sector money in the space, you're missing very important levers. And so any any action you do needs to take into account the financial, the financial setup, the investing dollars, that how the investing community is behaving. and there's a lot of other topic, microcredit obviously is a very private sector inflected, access to finance and financial inclusion is a very private sector inflected topic. Education is much more of a mixed bag and that sort of thing. So and then the fourth is the technology itself, which is driving a lot of change, which was the San Francisco shorthand. There needs to be a fifth, and maybe we'll put it in Kansas City in honor of the World Cup, which is just communities, right? In terms of like that's the fifth piece of it, which is what are You what are the communities on the ground having to say? grounding everything you do and what consumers want and what actual citizens and members of communities need and want and that sort of thing. But just to say, so any strategy needs to take into account those five points on the compass. meredith: Mm. Mike K: and and so that's what's informed how I think about both ON and Doris and everything else is that. you would wanna have the tools and a comprehensive strategy to be able to address ideally each of those. And if you're not addressing each of those, and this will get into philanthropic fragmentation, meredith: Mm-hmm. Mike K: then you need to be working in concert with people who are addressing the other missing aspects of the system. But my other observation about philanthropy is it's hyper fragmentation. So I think meredith: Mm. Mike K: you've heard me use this statistic before, but for your listeners, there are at last check 108,000 registered philanthropies in the United States. meredith: Mm. Mike K: Spending about $117 billion a year of institutional philanthropy. There's another $350 milli billion being spent in church plate, much more community-based kinds of things. But institutional meredith: All right. Mike K: philanthropy in this country is less than $120 billion a year, which sounds like a lot, but then just to scale the problem back. Google net profit in 2024 under mean regulatory Joe Biden was $110 billion or $100 billion, somewhere between $100 and $110 billion. Dollars alone. One company earned enough net profit to be the entire size of institutional philanthropy. meredith: Right. Mike K: And so if you take a a dispassionate lens to the industry structure of philanthropy, it's profoundly fragmented and punching below its weight And so one of my biggest vexations with philanthropy was getting philanthropy to row in the same direction. And so meredith: Mm-hmm. Mike K: If you're going to take a truly systemic approach, then philanthropy needs to be much better coordinated and has has has historically failed this miserably. with meredith: Mm. Mike K: a few shining exceptions, like Gavi, I think has been a terrific, initiative meredith: Right. Mike K: where philanthropy has gotten it together. So the exceptions are notable and very promising, but just to say, in general, American philanthropy is way too fragmented, too idiosyncratic, too wedded to its own individual theories of change. and up again and particularly in the private sector facing stuff where you're up against the two trillion dollars that have been just invested meredith: Right. Mike K: in data centers in this country, meredith: Right. Mike K: a hundred and ten billion dollars doesn't go that far. So you better use it wisely and meredith: Right. Mike K: But this notion that everybody's doing their own thing and it's not adding up and there's no incentive because of philanthropy's uniquely philanthropy's greatest asset is also its greatest Achilles heel, its lack of accountability. the ideal form of philanthropy today would not be what we have. It meredith: Mm-hmm. Mike K: would be a hedge fund. with a C three pocket that is not motivated by the tax deduction. So if I had one piece of advice for your listeners, it's don't be in it for the tax deduction. So meredith: Mm-hmm. Mike K: back to the Amy Clement mantra of problem first, tool second. If you really care about impact, then you should be okay with squ with losing a possible tax deduction because the right contribution is a C4. The right action is getting on a cap table of a company that actually matters. The right meredith: Mm-hmm. Mike K: action is actually lobbying and that sort of thing. And too much of philanthropy still is driven or constrained by the C3 constraint. And there's a lot of these problems where absolutely the right answer is is to give, is to give civil society groups the the ballast and the and the general operating support to go out and do their thing. Absolutely. meredith: Right. Right. Mike K: Absolutely has to be a key part of the toolkit. But also, if we care about evidence, the evidence is clear from our friends at Give Directly. Giving direct Giving people money cash directly is a winning strategy. We saw this in the pandemic, we've seen this in the RCTs out of the UBI movement, we've seen this out of the give directly work. There's not a tax deduction for that, but that is potentially the most effective thing people could do. meredith: So you recently argued that philanthropy is completely underestimating AI. And let's make Mike K: Mm-hmm. meredith: that very plain. What is the sector missing? Because I I really want to dive into the heart of this this urgency around the intersection of philanthropy and AI and what philanth individual philanthropists too should be thinking about in terms of what's missing at this moment. Mike K: Yep. So I think one one it's pretty clear that AI is gonna remake society in profound ways. meredith: Mm-hmm. Mike K: as is climate, as are other things, but AI is gonna actually do it faster, right? As we've seen already. Look at the crisis in American education with just how do you write a term paper, right? And that sort of thing. that's here right now. meredith: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Mike K: if you talk to anybody who's teaching. so one, it's gonna be profoundly it's gonna be as profound as electricity, I have no doubt about it. And it might take longer than people are saying to get there. and the installation period on these on these new technologies is longer than the proponents would say, but it's gonna get there and it's gonna get there quicker than we've all already the models are way more capable than anybody predicted two years ago and that sort of thing. And so eventually this will get adopted. We'll probably have a a a crash a la the dot com crash in 2001 before we get there. but meredith: Right. Mike K: we will get there and we will get there soon. So one, I think it's gonna reorder everything. Education, what's the role of the university, right? now the university was already in crisis, and AI is gonna push that over the tipping point between that and what Trump is doing to research funding. what is it going to mean for mental health, right? And companionship? What is it going to mean for the climate, obviously, with all these data center constructions? What is it gonna mean for epistemology itself and liberal institutions, right? If you know. and that thing. So it's gonna have effects both profound and mundane. and obviously we're already seeing effects in the labor markets for entry level jobs, although that is the the attribution on that is quite contested. But just to say, irrespective of whether it's from AI, there is a problem with entry level white collar jobs at the moment, It's gonna creep into everything you care about, whether it's farming or education or universities or science or fill in the blank. and so one, that's the call. And so, anyone who's working on jobs and labor markets or anyone who's working on this sort of thing is gonna have to contend with this piece. And I think it is it is fundamentally destabilizing. We saw this in Egypt in twenty eleven. When you have a bunch of college educated folks with no jobs and no job prospects, that is profoundly destabilizing to society. And by the way, the f and the first people who are going to get affected are the people who philanthropy really cares about. So the fact that philanthropy isn't doing more. Center left philanthropy really cares about entry level kids, women of color, who are the ones who are the bank tellers and the postal workers and the ones who are in the first line of defense in terms of facing the job on insecurity. And so the other call in that is to draw a direct connection from the topics you care about to AI, which is the populations you really are worried about are the first ones who are gonna be in the in the in the front lines on this sort of thing, in the at least in the labor market side of this. And so, come on in, you all the water is fine, we need you, Quanda: Ha ha ha. Mike K: would be my would be my invitation. Quanda: Mike, it's it's so interesting as I listen to you talk about AI as not just a technology issue. It does remind me of Nick Canner's characterization that all funders, all organizations should be minoring in AI. if you major in education Mike K: Absolutely. Quanda: or healthcare, and again Meredith's characterization that AI is the horizontal. sounds like one of your guiding principles as to how people should ultimately think about that, Mike K: and just to be clear, right, a lot of people have interpreted that as well, you should use AI in your operations. Like that I'm agnostic about. If people want to do that, great. That's not what I'm calling for though. It it is Quanda: Okay. Mike K: more exactly in your programming decisions, think about what AI is gonna mean for healthcare, for labor markets, for early childcare, for science, right. Quanda: Right. And you seem to have a lot of urgency, around this as well because of the speed of the evolution of the technology. some of these decisions that people are making today may not be easily reversed. what are you most worried about right now as it relates to AI? Mike K: I am worried about our federal government's resolute refusal to set some guideposts and policy. AI could be AI, just to say it's not just a threat, it could be massively useful. We need the economic productivity growth. We could really develop precision weather forecasting, meredith: Mm. Mike K: capabilities that would avoid, predict everything from earthquakes to floods and that sort of thing. There's a lot of great promise in it. I'm in that kind of middle camp between the sort of the doomers and the boomers, but the but just to say. In the absence of a framework that says even the basics, who's liable, right? if McDonald's uses open AI and makes a discriminatory decision in hiring, is OpenAI liable? Is McDonald's liable? Is anybody liable? Right now it's a free-for-all on a regulatory position. it's a free-for-all race to the bottom and it doesn't have to be, right? We could structure this the way we structured cars, where American cars with some basic common sense regulations were the envy of the world until the nineteen seventies. even though we introduced things like automobile insurance and DMVs and the requirement to have taillights or, Buick famously lost a suit in nineteen fifteen when the wheels fell off and a woman sued her, sued them saying, You hurt me and Buick said, I didn't I didn't sell you the car, the dealer did. He's liable. And the court saw through that and said, No, you're liable, Buick. Well, guess what? Buick started making safer cars and that and the incentives were aligned and And Buick was hugely competitive through the 30s, 40s, 50s, 60s, and that sort of thing. And and the the rules apply to everybody, not just to Buick. And so, in the absence of any kind of framework, it's gonna be chaotic. This bizarre competitive dynamic where the a the leaders in AI are all saying, This is the most dangerous technology in the history of the world. Therefore I must build it, and I alone must build it. Quanda: Mm-hmm. Mike K: and it's a bizarre so it's ON spent a lot of time thinking about competition policy and how you encourage healthy competition. But I think we also need to think about the downsides of competition. There's a there's a premise out there that this is a winner-take-all market. and that somebody has to get there first. And so there's gonna be no hold bars competing to get there. And I think that is a dangerous premise that needs to be inspected closely. I don't think this is gonna be like Uber where there was really a a winner-take-all kind of thing. But people are behaving that way, and that is creating a dangerous dynamic of racing to the bottom on capabilities before they are governed, Quanda: So Mike, is this a wake up call for philanthropy's unfinished work around concentrated power, or is there a risk that AI becomes a new shiny distraction from legacy fights around inequality, labor, quality education and supporting families, not to mention advancing democracy and checking corporate power? Mike K: Aside from that, no. all all business as usual. The meredith: Just yeah. Mike K: so I look, I would say the way to think about it is not an either or, but this is an accelerant of all the, this could be an accelerant of some of the better trends, but if on current trajectory it could also be an accelerant of all the worse trends around, higher education is already in crisis, the financial model is broken, the administration is coming for universities, AI is now creating, real questions as to what is the role of the university. university and these kinds of institutions. So it's forcing acceleration of a question that was already on the table. Same thing. We already have a problem with concentration of power and concentration of wealth, AI could actually turbocharge that if we don't put some better guardrails in place and could exacerbate it worse, or could by the way, become ambassad means for gain sharing and improving jobs, if we take it in that direction. So I think we need to view AI as both a threat and an opportunity because if we leave it unchecked on current trajectory, chances are in most cases it will accelerate the things that are already, on philanthropy's agenda that need to be addressed. the first place. Quanda: Right. Mike K: And that's why I wrote my Inside Philanthropy piece was to say, look, if you care about education, you care about healthcare, you need to care about AI. Because it's coming for your if you care about economic mobility, obviously, AI is gonna have a lot to say about economic mobility or cutting off economic mobility. And so meredith: Right. Mike K: that's why the call to action for philanthropy is don't ignore this, you need to think about, but don't think of this as separate either, right? This is this is in most everything people care about. in ph in philanthropic terms and even something that seems as unrelated as criminal justice that's used in sentencing, is actually an application there that could exacerbate criminal justice sentencing or not, even though you would think, well gosh, the criminal justice system has not much to do with AI, but it does. So the there's some aspect of AI that's going to touch into everything that all of our friends in philanthropy are diligently trying hard to work on. And so I think that the question is where is it both a threat that you need to tamp down and where's an opportunity to change the conversation. meredith: I completely agree with you. And shameless plug for Georgetown's McCord School of Public Policy. We have a professor that's specifically looking at the impacts of AI on the criminal justice system. And at first I was like, what is what is that? I didn't even think about the intersection or the impacts there. But you just sit sit for more if if you can suspend your gut reaction about AI will never touch philanthropy or never touch third world monetary policy or whatever your thing is, you start to think about it a little bit deeper and you're like, wow, actually. Housing right. Mike K: Yeah, housing right. Housing policy, mortgage lending decisions are gonna get made with AI. So how are we making sure meredith: Right. Mike K: that the AI is doing it on a on a merit basis as opposed to a some kind of discriminatory algorithm that gets programmed in in first place. So every meredith: Right. Mike K: every issue that the rest of philanthropy cares about, this is coming for in one way or the other. And in some cases it will eat the meredith: So yeah. Mike K: issue and in other cases it could be the the way to finally get it addressed. meredith: Right. So, and AI is enormous, well capitalized, moving quickly. So if you could take off your Mike Kubzangski, former head of a major philanthropy hat, and then put on your what do individual philanthropists think about and how do they interact and invest and engage in a way that actually matters? what would you say about that? Because I want to dig into that a little bit. Mike K: So the great Yeah. Yeah, the great the great news is one, we're gonna be minting a lot of new individual philanthropists and so I think there's meredith: Mm-hmm. Mike K: gonna be a lot of momentum for and so one would just be to say individual philanthropies should not feel com compelled or bound by doing it the way the philanthropy has been doing things. usually in fact the arrival of new philanthropists helps to upend the conventional wisdom in philanthropy and that is really healthy. The same way when Pierre came in twenty years ago we invented this kind of L L C and C three model, which nobody had tried before and now we're seeing other variations on that, structure and that theme and so one I would just say my advice would be don't just because the Ford Foundation, the Gates Foundation or Midear Network does something in one way, don't feel like you have to do it that way. Quanda: Right. Mike K: And in particular my call out to individual philanthropists would be think about using your full toolkit, your investing toolkit and your advocacy toolkit and your political check writing toolkit, which you have much more freedom to do than the Ford Foundation. The Ford Foundation can't write political checks and won't. shouldn't, but you as an individual philanthropist, this is going to be as this is gonna be a process that's going to be both economic and political, meredith: Mm-hmm. Mike K: and justice oriented and that sort of thing. So my second advice would be, think of all the tools you have at your disposal, not simply your charitable giving as the tool with which to make a difference. Quanda: So Mike K: And then I'd say that, sorry, one last third thing would be think about doing it together. We have 108,000 registered philanthropies in this country, we don't need 109. and so Quanda: Ha ha ha. Mike K: join a club like a Forward Global or an iconic or there's a lot of organizations that are helping individual philanthropists make sense of things together, P150, meredith: Yeah. Mike K: I can keep naming them Confluence, right? There's a bunch of groups that are help there to help the newly interested philanthropists make sense of this moment and act together. Because the meredith: Right. Mike K: danger in philanthropy is you can be fragmented. And everybody Quanda: Right. meredith: Yes. Mike K: going off in their own direction. This is a moment there's so much money capital arrayed on the private sector rollout side of things meredith: Mm-hmm. Mike K: that some kind of coordinated action is going to be really important. So don't go it alone, please. If you need help, call me. I will help you find a partner for you who can do it with you. But just to say the the the danger of newly minted philanthropists coming in is they've got to get onto their journey, they've got to figure out what motivalizes them, they pick a theory of change that's three degrees off the person next to them, and then the stuff doesn't add up. And so meredith: Right. Mike K: philanthropy needs to be a team sport and not and not an individual. meredith: my gosh, I love that. That's like the that right there, that's the heading for the podcast. Yeah. Right. elegantly. So elegantly. Mike K: Exactly. Play like Spain. Play the way Spain did in the World Cup, About team about team excellence passing the ball, working together, not simply meredith: Yeah. Yeah. Mike K: about one superstar banging in the goals. meredith: Right. And cute too. Very cute. Quanda: Yeah. It's it's interesting. Mike K: Yeah, that's a good looking team. Quanda: Mike, you talk a lot about funders using their full toolkit. And so we're talking about grants, endowments, their voice. You just talked about convening as being really important. Investment capital is another one. So lots of tools in the toolbox, but what is the tool that philanthropy is most afraid to use and the tool that you feel like really needs to be deployed right now? Mike K: I would say the advocacy and political tool, the stuff, and which is why if you're only oriented around the tax deduction, it prevents you from using it. So the problem is there is a strong interest in social impact, and particularly, society loves to hear from people who have been successful otherwise, including financially. Right? And so these f individual philanthropists actually have voice that society wants to hear from, their point of view. They few they figure that you've been successful enough to be able to make this money, you probably have something useful to contribute. That's whether that's That's deserve it salience or not is a different question. But the the fact of it is that they have voice. If they're unwilling to get involved in using that voice in addition to making that sort of thing, we're leaving interests on the sidelines that are which not should which should not definitely, and by the way, not as a substitute. Civil society needs to be out there, particularly groups that are on the ground, on the front lines, representing citizens and communities. That's a set of voices that has to be empowered in doing that sort of thing. So I'm not saying this instead of. saying this in addition to those voices from the community have certain salience and will get people's attention. but the sad truth of it is politicians will take calls from people with money before meredith: Mm. Mike K: they take calls from people with with community. status. That's an unfortunate and dreadful inversion of how it should be. But as long as that's the case, then not putting those voices to work in addition to and alongside the voices from the community is a is a mistake. And so I do think when you're organized only around the C three tax deduction and the C three status, you lose the ability to both influence the politics and you lose the ability to use your voice because as a C three you're not supposed to lobby on and has made it very clear that they will have very specific enforcement actions if they think you're doing something that looks to them to be partisan meredith: so Mike, you are now building an Andaris. Am I saying how am I saying it properly? Andaris, Andaris, Ondaris, AI. So congratulations. tell us briefly what it is about. And then what do you think you can do with this new platform that you could not do from inside Omidiar Network? Mike K: the idea being that a lot of interest needs to have a seat at the table, and this is following on the the conversation we just had about individual philanthropists, that meredith: Right. Mike K: we hear a lot So there needs civil society needs a seat at the table on the AI revolution and their voice needs to be heard. Communities need a seat at the table. The technologists need a seat at the table, obviously. So the basic idea on Andaris is to help meredith: Okay. Mike K: bring the voice of investors in for a common sense AI policies, both in terms of public policy, but even more so in terms of how they manage their own investments. So how do they have visibility of the full set of risk? Nine institutional investor magazine surveyed their readers. Nine percent of their in membership felt like they understood the risks from AI in their portfolio. And if you're sufficiently broad base, yeah, nine. meredith: Nine nine percent. Mike K: zero nine, nine percent, not nineteen, not ninety, nine. So the meredith: Whoa. Mike K: so there they understand that they're sitting on a lot of the risks, whether it's from unemployment or from concentration of power or from simply, what this is gonna mean for their other holdings in the electricity sector or their other holdings. in GM or that sort of thing. And so really helping them get smart on AI, helping them make sense of AI, and therefore helping that using that to help them then figure out where they plug in both through their practice, their investing, the questions they're asking of their holdings and the, and their engagement on policy. That's the point of Andaris, is to bring that same level of attention to the important role, outsized role of investors who both are stand to profit from it, but also stand to be holding the bag if the thing goes south. and if if the thing goes south, obviously financially, but also socially, right? The investors meredith: Right. Mike K: are the ones who are gonna be coming in and that's gonna affect the philanthropic endowments and that's gonna affect the the pension fund holdings and that's gonna affect the the family wealth and that sort of thing. So trying to get the folks who own both the benef so the alignment's good, they own both the upside and the risk. How do you then help them, how do you equip them to be smarter players on this? and that's the piece. So to your second part of your question, Meredith. I I'm not sure it couldn't have been done from a Mid Your Network, but I think it helps to have a separate entity that is simply about by and for the investors, including philanthropic endowments, but also, meredith: Right. Yeah. Mike K: other lots of other categories of investors. Quanda: Mm-hmm. Mike K: whether it's a an insurance company or a or a sovereign wealth fund or or or simply a but really trying to get to those folks to help them both understand and manage the risks that they're facing and bring those voices into the conversation, as well. And they sit on the most risk of all because if the data center thing pops, they're the ones holding the back. meredith: Right. And so many of those the pension funds in particular haven't really been coming from a place of strength over the last few years. in some in some ways. Calpers and a bunch of those folks have have made are in a risky position, more risk than not. So that's good that they're having Mike K: Yeah, they have and they have ex and they have exposure through their real estate holdings to data centers. And they meredith: Right. Mike K: have holding exposure through their venture holdings to OpenAI meredith: Yeah. Mike K: and Anthropic and They have exposure through their private equity holdings to the utilities and the electricity industry. And so they're meredith: Mm. Mike K: they're exposed up and down the chain, as are, by the way, well-diversified family offices or university endowments or that sort of thing. So but that's a set of voices who have not, who are only the conversation has strictly been about the alpha. And they have a broader set of interests besides the alpha. And that's what we're trying to do is help them both navigate their need and demand for returns to be able to fund retirements for their pension holders, in the case of a pension fund, and think through how do they manage the risk of the downside. Particularly early in most technological revolutions, there typically comes a at some point comes a pop in the bubble. meredith: Mm. Mike K: And money is lost and money is made. and we have not hit that point in AI yet, but I guarantee we will at some point meredith: No, it's comin'. Mike K: hit that point too. meredith: Okay, so we ask, we're gonna transition to our signature question. We ask every guest one question that gets underneath the public story and into a full the philosophy of giving. So what is one belief you hold about capital or giving or power that most people would disagree with? And why are you so sure about it? And this goes back to conversations you and I have had over the last two years. That I based my capstone from the NBA Georgetown program on. So I'm interested to see how your ideas have evolved. Mike K: Yeah, so I've I've hit on this, I've hit on both themes that I want to pick up already. Right. One is this is not an individual sport. We are not doing pole vaulting alone. This is a team sport, this is a relay race, do it together. Right? And I think philanthropy often the conventional wisdom is I've got my own thing, I've got my own interests, and that sort of thing, I'm just gonna pursue what's of interest to me. And I think that is a losing strategy for philanthropy. And that's why we're on it's one of the reasons why I'm back. Don't operate enough together. That's hard. It is functionally quite difficult to do, so I understand why it doesn't happen. But the fact that everyone's pursuing their own theory of change three degrees off of somebody else's, I think, dissipates the impact that philanthropy could be having, even given the limited resources that philanthropy has vis-a-vis the broadside with the And then I'd say the second thing, which I don't know if it's conventional wisdom or that sort of thing, but there's a general assumption in this country that you're doing philanthropy and you're getting a tax deduction. And if you're being motivated by the tax deduction, you're missing the story. And meredith: Mm. Mike K: so if you care about social impact, it's not about the tax deduction, it's about social impact. And so this is a this is a belief I strongly believe. Amy Clement, my dear friend, who recruited me into Omidar Network all these years ago and is now meredith: Mm. Mike K: running Imaginable Futures, who should be a guest of yours. meredith: Okay. Mike K: Amy always used to talk about problem first, tool second. So yeah, in some case, in some case the answer is a C three grant and that is the appropriate thing. But in some case, by the way, it could be a give directly direct contribution if you care about poverty. In some case it could be supporting mutual aid at the community level, which has no tax deduction consequence to it at all, and helping communities build their own self-sufficiency. And in some cases it should be a private sector investment or or signing onto a policy level. And so, meredith: Right. Mike K: but I think we tend to get skewed, particularly big institutional philanthropy skews by the tax deduction, and you miss a lot of tools that are at your disposal to drive impact, that if you if you're willing to give up that core belief, a lot of new things become possible. Quanda: Thanks for sharing that perspective. Now we end every episode the same way. We have three questions and a tip. So I'll ask you three questions in a lightning round. So, you answer in a sentence or two and then we'll go to the next one, and then we will end with your parting advice to our listeners. So the first question is: What's the most unexpected act of generosity you've ever witnessed, and what did it reveal to you? Mike K: Kenzie Scott, when she first came out, and it revealed to me that women should be in charge of philanthropy. Quanda: That's a good one. We agree with that, by the way. meredith: Amen. That could also be the title of the podcast. Quanda: All right, Mike K: Feel free. Yeah. Quanda: question number two. What's something people do in the name of generosity that may look meaningful on the surface but often misses the deeper point? Mike K: Chase the tax deduction, instead of chasing the impact. Quanda: Love that. And then final question of the three, what's a belief that you hold about giving that you wish that people felt more comfortable saying out loud? Mike K: most of it's gonna fail. Social change is hard and taking a venture capital attitude towards that is a much better frame on it than expecting 80% of my stuff to make a difference and that sort of thing. We are aiming at the hardest problems that if they were easily solved, they would have been solved. And so You're gonna have to try and try again. A lot of this stuff isn't gonna pan out. That's okay. Your your philanthropy is risk capital for social change, and risk capital needs to be risk tolerant and okay with not getting it right. So the real impetus there is spending the time to learn why did it fail? How do I do it differently next time? And to stick with it. Quanda: That's awesome. Thank meredith: Love that. Quanda: you. And then finally our tip, if someone listening to our conversation today wants to be more intentional, with their personal giving, but they feel unsure as to where to start, what would you offer them? Mike K: I think there's a bunch of great resources for the philanthropic sector who are geared up both by subject and just more generally. So the Center for Effective Philanthropy does amazing work and have Quanda: Yeah, they do. Mike K: really a lot of good guides. Candid. has got some amazing resources and guides for the thing. But I would say again, as an individual, join one of these clubs. That's meredith: Mm-hmm. Mike K: also a source of places where you can actually do it together. Phil Buchanan and his whole team at CEP are terrific. And they would be delighted, I'm sure, to advise anybody. But just to say, again, think of this as a team sport. Who can I do this with? Who can I learn it with, you'll have more fun anyway. Quanda: Ha. Mike K: Right. Or if if you're an extrovert like me, you'll have more fun. So that's the Quanda: That's awesome. Thank you so meredith: Love that. Quanda: much. Thank you for joining us for this episode of The Philanthropist, Personal Journeys of Giving with Purpose. You can also watch full episodes and exclusive content on our YouTube channel and follow us on LinkedIn and Instagram for behind-the-scenes reflections and upcoming conversations. And if this podcast is meaningful to you, please subscribe, review, and share. It really does help us grow this community. We would like to extend a special thanks to Lumina Foundation for their support and our good friends Jack Pompey and Connor Ellis of Goodpoint NYC for producing this episode. Meredith Hanley: To continue the conversation with us directly, email us at hello at the philanthropistpodcast.org. We generally want to hear what these stories are stirring in you. You can also watch full episodes and exclusive content on our YouTube channel and follow us on LinkedIn and Instagram for behind the scenes reflections and upcoming conversations. Quanda: And if this podcast is meaningful to you, please subscribe, review, and share. It really does help us to grow this community. I'm Quanda Allen. meredith: And I'm Meredith Hanley. Thanks for listening and remember everyone has something to give.