Latest / Dark Murder: True Crime Cases / Episode 107
Transcript
- 0:06Dark murder true crime cases five four, three, two one one one one
- 0:22one one. Welcome back. I'm your host, Jordan Lee. I'm sure
- 0:30you are all ready to dive into some dark, creepy stories, So let's
- 0:34get started. The Murder of Zona Shue. When Erasmus Shoe moved to the
- 0:44small town of Livesay's Mill, Virginia in the summer of eighteen ninety six,
- 0:49he didn't know that he'd be meeting the woman he'd marry shortly after his arrival.
- 0:54Another thing he wasn't aware of was that he'd be facing a charge of
- 0:58murder less than a year later. Erasmus may have been his given name,
- 1:02but he always introduced himself as Edward, but for whatever reason, the name
- 1:07Trout seems to be what everyone referred to him, as he was tall,
- 1:11handsome, and covered in muscles. Pretty soon, Trout found himself a job
- 1:17working at the local blacksmith shop, owned by a man named James Crookshank.
- 1:22It wasn't long before Trout came to know Elva Hester. She was a daughter
- 1:26of a local farmer. The two fell instantly in love with one another.
- 1:30After a short courtship, the two decided to tie the knot in October eighteen
- 1:36ninety six. For all intents and purposes, the couple put on a good
- 1:40show out in public. The truth, however, was much darker. Almost
- 1:45three months to the day after they were married, Edward had stopped by the
- 1:49house of Martha Jones, her son Anderson had at times done shores for the
- 1:53couple in the past, and with Zona sick at home, he wanted the
- 1:57lad to see if she needed anything picked up from the door. Anderson readily
- 2:01agreed, and when he went inside to check on the alien twenty three year
- 2:06old, he found her lifeless corpse lying face down at the bottom of the
- 2:08stairs. News of the tragic death quickly spread, and doctor J. N.
- 2:14Knapp was summoned to the Shoe home. It was customary for the time
- 2:19for the female friends and family to wash and prepare the body for her funeral
- 2:23after the doctor had given an official cause of death. When he arrived,
- 2:27though, he found that Trout had already dressed his wife in a long gown
- 2:30that had a high collar. He also added a scarf that didn't match the
- 2:35outfit she was wearing, but the traumatized husband swore that it was her favorite
- 2:39and insisted that it be kept on. The doctor did what would be called
- 2:44a cursory inspection of Zona's body. This was primarily attributed to Edward loudly crying
- 2:51the entire time the doctor conducted the post mortem. In the end, he
- 2:54concluded the death was caused by a heart attack, though the term at the
- 2:58time was everlasting faint. This determination would be later changed by the doctor claiming
- 3:05childbirth had been the reason for her passing, though no one was aware of
- 3:08her pregnancy. During the wake, which was held in the widower's home,
- 3:14Trout refused to let any of the attending guests anywhere near the casket. Now
- 3:19she not only wore the dress and the scarf, but he'd added a veil
- 3:23to her ensemble, further obscuring the mourner's view. He continued to openly cry
- 3:29and pace the area in front of the coffin, essentially playing the part of
- 3:32security guard, until Zona was put to rest in the cemetery. Most everyone
- 3:38attributed Edward's strange behavior to grief, but didn't find it overly suspicious. Maybe
- 3:46the one person who didn't believe the over the top display of emotion was Zona's
- 3:51mother Mary. She hadn't ever really liked her daughter's husband from the beginning.
- 3:55The two had been very close since she gave birth to her only female Check,
- 4:00and they'd become more like best friends than mother and daughter. As Zona
- 4:03aged, something about her death didn't sit well with her, and she was
- 4:09almost sure Trout had something to do with it. Mary was a very devout
- 4:14believer in what the Bible said, and she took a literal translation when it
- 4:17came to say goodbye. Thessalonians five seventeen instructed her to pray without ceasing,
- 4:25and if that was what it would take in order to hear what Zona had
- 4:28to say, the lost sleep would be a price she was willing to pay.
- 4:32For several nights. This went on without a sign from her daughter,
- 4:35and she was exhausted. Mary went to lie down for a moment, when
- 4:41she claims, a light came into her bedroom, where it had begun to
- 4:45morph into a human figure. Her exhausted mind didn't comprehend what was happening until
- 4:50she saw Zona standing right before her. Her faith had been rewarded by the
- 4:56spirit of her daughter coming to visit her, but she there to do more.
- 5:01She had a tale to tell. She claims that her daughter's spirit told
- 5:05her of the day she died. Edward had come home from work and took
- 5:10one look at the meal Zona had prepared for them and flew into a fit
- 5:15of rage. This was all because his wife hadn't included some sort of meat
- 5:19in the meal. The spirit told her mother he had grabbed her by both
- 5:25sides of her head and with a quick jerking motion, broken her neck.
- 5:30She also informed Mary the trout possessed a bad temper and had struck her on
- 5:33multiple occasions. Zona's spirit would continue to visit her mother for four days in
- 5:40a row. Each night, she would drive the point home that Edward had
- 5:44been the cause of her death. The visions became more detailed in their description,
- 5:48including the exact location of the break between the first and second vertebrae,
- 5:55the positions of her hands, and the final night, Zona's spirit actually turned
- 5:59head in the complete opposite direction to demonstrate the severity of the break. Her
- 6:05daughter's spirit had given Mary enough she believed that the prosecuting attorney, John Preston
- 6:11would look into the matter. When she started spewing tales of ghosts telling her
- 6:15that a murder had occurred, he chalked the matter up to grief. It
- 6:19wasn't until he saw the post mortem that he finally ordered Zona's body disinterred.
- 6:26The second examination was conducted by doctors Knapp, Rupert, and mcclun. Edward
- 6:32was present for this as well, and managed to remain calm until they reached
- 6:36the area around her neck and head. The doctors were shocked to find bruises
- 6:42in the shape of fingers on Zona's neck, as well as what appeared to
- 6:46be a break between the first and second vertebrae. In March eighteen ninety seven,
- 6:50the evidence against Trout went in front of a jury to debate whether there
- 6:55was enough proof to pursue the charge of murder. Despite most of the finding
- 7:00against him being circumstantial, they decided to proceed. The trial would begin four
- 7:05months later. Trout himself would take the stand in his own defense, claiming
- 7:11the entire thing was a fabrication cooked up by a hateful woman in Mary.
- 7:16Prosecutors, on the other hand, brought up Edward's past in an attempt to
- 7:20show the type of man he was. Not only had he been a horse
- 7:25thief, but Zona in fact was his third wife. The first woman had
- 7:28left him because of abuse, and the second had up and died without explanation.
- 7:33The prosecution hesitated on the idea of bringing Mary herself to the stand,
- 7:40knowing how it would sound that she'd gotten her information from Zona's spirit. In
- 7:45the end, the defense thought that her testimony would provide enough reasonable doubt to
- 7:49gain an acquittal. The strategy backfired, however, there was no way to
- 7:55explain how she knew intimate details about the nature of her daughter's injury, where
- 8:00she'd been killed, and even the clothes she'd had on when it had happened.
- 8:05Despite what some might call a weak case by the prosecution, it took
- 8:07the jury only seventy minutes to return a verdict of guilty against Edward schu The
- 8:13judge didn't hold back either, and sentenced Trout to life in prison. He
- 8:18wouldn't spend much time in prison, however, since he passed away less than
- 8:22three years after his conviction in West Virginia State Penitentiary at the ripe old age
- 8:28of thirty nine.